AUTUMN / WINTER 2012-13 Where does our food come from? Why do 1 in 7 people go hungry? Is there enough food for everyone? We report on the global food system. 5 million producers now benefit from fair trade. What next for the global movement? Find out what it’s like to be a small holder farmer in the global food system. Our Land, Our Storyline: using drama to explore controversial global issues. Resources Activity packs which focus on food, farming and fair trade. All featured resources are available to buy or loan from www.seedsforlearning.org.uk Our Food, Our World Failte Malawi Choc- a- Lot Told through the lives of five engaging children and their stories, the pack features a huge range of activities to explore food, healthy eating, transport and trade issues. It emphasises common needs and diversity across the world, encourages pupils to empathise with others, and helps teachers challenge prejudice and stereotypes. It includes a 32 A4 full-colour photo cards, featuring images from South Africa, Thailand, France, Mexico and India; A1 display poster and CD-ROM including all photographs for use on PC or interactive whiteboard. Age 5 - 9 Oxfam Special offer for this issue £12.50 Designed to support the Scottish curriculum, Failte Malawi encourages teachers and pupils to explore the links and commonalities that are shared between Scotland and Malawi. With a focus on children’s rights, the pack covers four topics: water, food and farming, homes and toys. By exploring how these needs key needs are met in Malawi, pupils will learn more about themselves and their won commonalities. The booklet provides sample activities while the full resource, activity sheets and images are available on the CD ROM. Age 5-11 Scotdec Cost £25 This useful collection of activities based on chocolate allows teachers and youth leaders to explore all aspects of the cocoa trade, from exploitation and child labour to branding and spin. It enables pupils to find out the facts, develop a wide range of skills and have confidence to take action for change. Age 11 - 19 RISC Cost £5.00 Bananas and Cocoa Beans Pupils are introduced to fair trade theory and practice in this thought provoking resource. It starts by raising awareness of our global links and then goes on to look at the negative impact these links can have. Fair trade is introduced as a positive alternative, with suggestions of how we can all take action for change. It includes teacher information, pupil activities and photocopiable materials and has been designed for minimum teacher preparation and maximum pupil participation. Age 7 - 14 RISC Cost £5.00 2 Stride Go Bananas! The journey of a banana from the Caribbean to the UK is illustrated through a sequence of colour photographs in the new edition of this popular resource. It provides a range of activities suitable for whole class, small group and independent work, which make use of photographs, maps and up-to-date information on banana production. It includes a teachers’ booklet and 18 A4 colour photographs. Age 5-11 Oxfam Special offer for this issue £10.00 Food and Farming Local and Global How does the food we eat tie us in to lives and places in our own country and all over the globe? How can we effectively engage children in the everyday complexity of live issues about food and farming? This pack has been devised by teachers to share ideas about this debate, including practical examples of classroom practice. Case studies include strawberry growing in the Vale of Evesham, a Gambian school garden and banana production in the Windward Islands This resource encourages teachers of all age groups to think about engaging their students in questions around food, farming and interdependence. Age 7 - 14 TIDE Cost £8.75 Charlotte Dwyer, Editor Editorial There is no simple solution to world hunger. Hunger is not just the result of drought, flood or failed harvest. It is a result of the way the global food system works - how food is traded between countries and how the farmers, consumers and business within them interact. favour of unsustainable cash crops. In Scotland, Anthony Baxter, outraged with the ease with which one man, effectively, took away the land and property from a small community in Aberdeenshire, made a film about it which is now set to be broadcast on BBC2 this autumn. He shares his story on page 12. Angela Higgins – IDEAS Brenna Nyznik – IDEAS Charlotte Dwyer – Scotdec Della Rea – Scotdec Diana Ellis – WOSDEC John Dornan – Conforti Institiute Lynn Baxendale – WOSDEC Richard Nicodème – Context Silvia Sabino-Hunt – British Red Cross Nick Morgan – Education Scotland We would love to hear your ideas, comments and feedback. Get in touch! [email protected] Food for Thought 4-5 Can you beat the system? 6-7 Fair trade 8-9 Activity pages In this issue we consider the changes that need to be made to the way the The accompanying education material global food system works, in order to reminds us that at the heart of these support a world where everyone has conflicts lie the broader issues of power enough to eat and is paid a fair wage and who ultimately for the work they do. As makes decisions. consumers, our pupils ‘As educators it is It is often the case need to be aware of their our responsibility that economics role within this system to facilitate and takes precedence and to reflect on how encourage our pupils over environmental their actions impact on to research and form sustainability and the people round the world. wishes of the local their own opinions community. Many schools in Scotland and critical responses have successfully gained to these global issues the status of Fairtrade within the classroom.’ As educators it is our responsibility School, we hear from to facilitate and one on page 16 while encourage our pupils to research and Sally Romilly explores the history of form their own opinions and critical this movement and evaluates the responses to these global issues within impact it has had so far. The Fairtrade the classroom. Developing the attitudes movement has tried to address some and skills of young global citizens of the big inequalities that exist in enables our pupils to see personal the world trading system, which pit connections with issues such as global powerful multinationals against small hunger and empowers them to take holder farmers resulting in the loss of informed actions. productive subsistence farmland in Stride team Inside 10-11 We are the 99% 12 Grow Island 13 My Story 14 Forum Theatre 15 Fairtrade Schools 16 Our Crop, Our Land 17 In the Loop 18-19 © IDEAS, Autmn / Winter 2012-13 Stride magazine is printed using vegetable inks on 100% recycled uncoated stock, a product with FSC certification. Design by www.contextdesigns.co.uk Front cover picture © Aly Wight – www.alywight.com Stride 3 THEBIGDEBATE Food for thought Anne Kane, Education Advisor for Oxfam Scotland, reflects on what role education can play in creating a world where everyone has enough to eat. W hat’s for tea? It’s a question we ask ourselves every day. But the truth is, beyond deciding what we will eat each night; most of us take the availability of our food for granted. We do so because we have never really had to question where our next meal is coming from. The fact is: no-one should. Right now the world produces enough food to feed everyone and yet one in seven people still go hungry every day. That must change. But delivering food for everyone won’t be easy. By 2050 the world’s population is predicted to grow from seven to nine billion and that means many more mouths to feed. ‘Right now the world produces enough food to feed everyone and yet one in seven people still go hungry every day.’ Oxfam International has launched a campaign called GROW which, by fixing the broken food system, aims to create a world where everyone always has enough to eat. www.oxfam.org/en/grow/reports/growingbetter-future The GROW campaign focuses on four major issues and puts forward possible solutions. Land Grabs Finding space to grow food in developing countries has always been tough, but now the situation is getting out of control. Land used by families to grow crops is being taken over in secretive land deals by wealthy companies and foreign governments looking for cheap agricultural space. Families are often evicted with little or no warning and no compensation. Such ‘land grabs’ are happening on a huge scale. In the last decade, an area 29 times the size of Scotland has changed hands in developing countries. Rules must be put in place to govern the behaviour and actions of local, national and international investors in relation to land and natural resources. If land is to be taken away, transparency and consultation with communities is crucial to ensure they benefit from any investment, and receive appropriate compensation. Committee for Campesino Unity Rising Food Prices Indigenous smallholder farmers in Guatemala are being violently evicted as companies move in to satisfy Europe’s hunger for biofuel for cars. 4 Stride After decades of progress, the number of people without enough to eat is increasing. Food spikes are a big part of the problem and they’re hitting the poorest hardest. When you spend up to 75% of your weekly income on food, as many families in the developing world are forced to do, sudden price rises have a particularly destructive effect. Even here in Scotland, price rises are having a major impact on some of our most vulnerable people because they are least able to respond to surging prices at the checkout. “For with the land comes the right to withdraw the water linked to it, in most countries essentially a freebie that increasingly could be the most valuable part of the deal” Peter BrabeckLethmath, CEO, Nestle. Price spikes have many causes – the changing climate, oil prices, dysfunctional commodity markets where food is treated like stocks and shares, biofuel subsidies that mean crops end up in cars and not on plates - but what’s clear is that we are facing a whole new challenge. It’s time for governments to come together to address long term problems with the way food is produced and distributed globally. The cruel irony is around half of those going hungry in the world are small-scale farmers (see the GROW ‘Where are the Hungry People’ chart). In part this is because crop yields are flatlining following a century of increase. Billions of pounds of public money is now being ploughed into unsustainable industrial farming in the Global North. Yet, given the right support and investment, small-scale farmers, many of them women, have huge potential to grow more food potentially increasing production by as much as 30%. In Vietnam, for example, the number of hungry people has been halved in just 12 years - a transformation kick-started by government investment in small farmers. Climate Change The formula is pretty simple: as global temperatures rise, crop yields will fall. According to some predictions, yields could be cut in half in some African countries. At the same time, extreme weather events, like heat waves, droughts and floods, are becoming ever more frequent and severe, and the seasons people rely on to grow crops are becoming even more unpredictable. Rich, developed countries, including Scotland, did much to cause climate change. We now have a responsibility to both cut our emission levels and help those already most affected by climate change to adapt their lives. The Role of Education The separation of consumers from sources of food has become wider with every generation. Food comes from the supermarket, out of season and shiny. A report to Scottish Government in2009, noted that the four big supermarkets (Tesco, Asda, Sainsbury’s and Morrison’s) accounted for 71.5% share of the food retail market in Scotland. (Food Affordability, Access and Security: Their implications for Scotland’s Food Policy, June 2009.) Teachers have an opportunity to explore Global Citizenship questions about ‘Food and Land’ issues, both local and global, and looking at the human cost of Climate Change. How does the food we eat tie us into lives and places in our own country and all over the world? What choices do we make as consumers? ‘Given the right support and investment, small-scale farmers have huge potential to grow more food.’ Whose rights and whose responsibilities are affected by these choices? It matters more than ever that we understand about our food, what is in it, where it comes from, how it grows and who grows it. It matters because it affects all of us. Look out for the new CPD workshop, Food For Thought: investigating the Global Food System, offered by Scotland’s six Global Learning Centres. (See page 19) Oxfam has also produced an online resource around these themes which can be found at www.oxfam.org.uk/education See next page for a simulation game from the resource. Leyla Kayere selling her tomatoes. The farming village of Mnembo in Malawi is totally self-sustainable. Picture: Abbie Traylor- Smith Small Scale Farming Stride 5 Activity ideas Can you beat the System? This is a simulation game to introduce pupils to the idea of a global food system by putting pupils in the position of a small holder farmer producing food which goes into this system. It highlights some of the inequalities in the system and helps them to think about the challenges small holder farmers face. What you need Crop templates and scenario cards (see facing page), 1 pencil per pupil, sheets of A4 paper, 2 pairs of scissors, 2 colouring pencils and 1 crop template per group. What to do Show pupils the crop template. Explain it is called maize and is grown across the world. Have they eaten it? (Sweet corn is a type of maize). Do they eat beef? Maize is used as feed for cows. Draw out the idea that there are connections between people who grow and people who buy food. They are going to find out what it is like for farmers growing things like maize. Split the class into groups of 4 and give out materials. Explain that they are now farmers living in a less economically developed country, making a living by growing food (maize) to sell at a local market. Each group must create as many completed ‘crops’ as they can in 10 minutes using the materials provided. The group who produces the most crops wins the game. However they may have to cope with a change in circumstances… Give each group one of the scenario cards, run the game for another 5-10 minutes. Then give them an additional scenario and run it again for another 5 – 10 minutes. Repeat again if you wish. At the end declare the winning team. This should be the group who experienced scenario 4. Reflection and evaluation Debrief with the pupils what it was like being a small farmer as part of this global system. Include the following points: What was it like being a small holder farmer in the global system? What was challenging? Why? How did each group manage after the scenarios were introduced? How did this make them feel? What was fair about the game, and what was unfair? Explain that the game illustrates some of the challenges and inequalities small farmers face within the global food system. Draw out the different experiences of being supported (by the government) or not supported (other scenarios). What would the impact be on the wider global food system of farmers? Would the system be fairer if small farmers were supported? Adapted from Oxfam www.oxfam.org.uk/foodforthought 6 Stride Simulation game Level 2 / 3 SCENARIO CARDS & CROP TEMPLATE Scenario 1: Climate change Background Global temperatures are rising due to climate change. This means some of your crops will die. Also extreme weather like heat waves, droughts and floods will get worse and happen more often. The seasons will become unpredictable. This means the amount of food (yield) you can grow will go down. Action Your farmland is flooded and your crops are destroyed. When the floods recede, it takes months to repair the damage and start producing again. What you must do Any crops you’ve completed in the game so far will be destroyed. You must sit on your hands for 30 seconds once the game re-starts. Scenario 2: Your land is bought by a wealthy company Background Wealthy companies buy cheap land in poor countries. But sometimes the land they buy is actually being used by poor families to grow food. These families are often told to go (evicted) with little or no warning, and they are often not given much money to make up for this. Sometimes the land is used to grow biofuels and sometimes the land is left so the buyer can keep it to use later. Action Half of the land you farm has been bought by a large global food company and you are no longer allowed to farm it. What you must do Half of your remaining paper will be removed re-starts. Scenario 3: Food prices rise Scenario 4: Investment Background Background Up until a few years ago the number of people in the world who didn’t have enough food to eat was going down. Now however that number is going up. A big reason for this is because the cost of food is going up. This means many families have to spend 75% of their money every week just on food. If food prices change suddenly families cannot cope. Farmers who grow food to sell also have to buy food, so this affects them too. Action As a farmer you can no longer afford to buy essential food you cannot grow yourself. You don’t have any savings so you have to sell things you need to farm, such as farming equipment, to have enough money to buy food. The 500 million small farms across the world grow enough food for 2 billion people – or 1 in 3 people on earth. This shows the impact that small farmers have in the global food system. However they can grow more food. With support from their government and help to improve farming methods their yields (amount grown) can go up. Action The government spends money to support your farm. What you must do You will receive additional scissors, pencils and paper. What you must do Half of your scissors and pencils will be removed. p Cro te la mp te Stride 7 Fair trade A drop in the ocean? Sally Romilley, from the One World Centre Dundee, explores the extent to which the fair trade movement has changed the way we shop. Picture: Simon Rowles However, the Fairtrade Foundation has been criticised for enabling companies to use the FAIRTRADE Mark on flagship brands to effectively ‘greenwash’ their overall image, as the Mark is awarded to a product, not a company. Conversely, iconic brands switching to Fairtrade standards, means a huge number of farmers and their communities are now reaping the benefits and helping to raise the profile of the movement. Very often co-operatives which meet the Fairtrade standards can only sell a fraction of their crop at the Fairtrade price because consumer demand is too low. Olive farmer, Palestine. (Fair Trade Producers Company) T his summer saw UK dairy farmers hit the headlines. Their rallies and protests highlighted that a further cut in the price paid for their milk would mean they earned less than it cost them to produce it. Clearly this is not a sustainable situation. Yet this is often precisely the situation for thousands of farmers across the world growing and harvesting crops we rely on here, from coffee to cotton. Fair trade is about much more than an extra couple of pence on a banana or a bar of chocolate. It’s about turning the whole trading system as we know it on its head, and starting from the perspective of the farmer or producer, and what she or he needs to receive to earn a decent living. It’s an alternative model of trade, set up to meet the basic needs and rights of those who would normally be at the bottom of the chain. It is unique in being the only trading system to have poverty reduction at its core. A successful movement The Fairtrade Foundation licences the use of the FAIRTRADE Mark in the UK, to products containing certain 8 Stride crops or ingredients for which there are internationally agreed criteria, as monitored by Fairtrade International (FLO). There are now nearly 5000 such products available, bringing direct benefits to over 5 million producers and their families. No-one twenty years ago could have foreseen the enormous growth and indeed popularity of the movement. Sales ‘It’s about turning the whole trading system as we know it on its head, and starting from the perspective of the farmer or producer, and what she or he needs to receive to earn a decent living. ’ of food products with the FAIRTRADE Mark reached a billion pounds last year, representing 1% of the UK shopping basket spend. This is down in no small way to the fact that supermarkets responded to consumer demand and all now stock a range of Fairtrade products. Best-selling brands of confectionery now proudly sport the familiar blue and green symbol. Fairtrade has gone mainstream! A further criticism comes from an environmental perspective. A desire to support local producers and reduce our carbon footprint is seemingly at odds with buying food from countries thousands of miles away. Yet it is these very countries which are bearing the brunt of the current crisis in the world’s food system and environmental degradation brought on through climate change. It is a difficult balancing act but one we should all be responsible for as global citizens and consumers. A fair model in an unfair world While Fairtrade aims to create equal partnership between Southern producers and Northern importers and consumers, it is still a movement dominated by the Global North. Despite the involvement of producers’ representatives in decision making, labelling organisations dominate the process of setting criteria and monitoring, they have the power to choose which producers to work with and are closer to the consumer. A truly just trading system can only develop when there is a radical shift in the balance of power so Southern countries can develop their own economies to suit their own needs. Of course this needs an overhaul of the rules which govern international trade, rules which are designed by Global North regarding tariffs Picture: Annette Kay Tea picking Malawi. and subsidies to favour their own interests at the expense of the Global South. The current system of fair trade is a stage in the process of forcing such a shift. It is an example of trading which attempts to balance the desire of the consumer for ‘value for money’ with the wish of the producers to earn a living wage. Changing the current dominate system requires political action, which will hopefully be inspired by what the consumer-driven fair trade model has managed to achieve. The future of the Fair Trade movement As Scotland gears up to become a Fair Trade Nation* this autumn, we should ask what is the future for the fair trade movement? I believe we need to look to the fair trade pioneers, those 100% fair trade companies like Traidcraft, Equal Exchange, Cafedirect and Divine Chocolate, who have proved that a different way of trading is possible. Without their wholehearted commitment, and perseverance, laying the foundations and working longterm with producer groups to reach the Fairtrade standards, there would be no mainstream market. Traidcraft believes the wide availability of fair trade products has “eroded the points of difference” between what the big players do and they do. So this autumn, they are launching a new ‘more than just’ range, supporting and trading with new, ‘A truly just trading system can only develop when there is a radical shift in the balance of power so Southern countries can develop their own economies to suit their own needs.’ as the world’s food system as a whole needs a micro approach, so does the fair trade movement. Our role as educators Many schools across Scotland have been successful in becoming Fairtrade schools and the curriculum provides many opportunities to explore the issue. As with so many global issues, teaching about fair trade is not about giving easy answers or suggesting simple solutions but equipping children and young people with the skills to think, to question and to explore viewpoints and values. It’s about giving them an education which enables them to develop open-minded attitudes and the skills to weigh up arguments and make up their own minds. And above all, nurturing in them the values which will lead us all to respect and cherish our common humanity, and act accordingly. Useful websites Picture: Simon Rowles small-scale farmer groups from the most marginalised communities, producers who would otherwise never be able to export their products. They will also be supported to help find local markets. Some of the products will be packaged in the country of origin, a major step forward in overcoming trade barriers. Coffee farmer, Uganda Divine would like to see more, “support for social-enterprise models, for co-operatives and for employee-ownership – a future where money and decision-making is in the hands of the many, not the few.” Just Fairtrade Foundation: www.fairtrade.org.uk Fairtrade International: www.fairtrade.net Traidcraft: www.traidcraft.co.uk Equal Exchange: www.equalexchange.co.uk Cafedirect: www.cafedirect.co.uk Divine Chocolate: www.divinechocolate.com * For details of the campaign to make Scotland a Fair Trade Nation, see the website of the Scottish Fair Trade Forum, www.sftf.org.uk Stride 9 LEVELS 1 & 2 Activity ideas 1. What is fair? In these activities pupils explore the things in our personal lives and as a society that are ‘unfair’ and reflect on the concepts of unfair treatment and prejudice. What you need Reflection and evaluation Small prizes, coloured stickers (2 colours) Hold a class debrief on what happened. Include the following points: What do you think the difference is between the groups? Were groups treated fairly? Was this fair? Can they think of other situations where this happens? Do we sometimes do things which are unfair? Whose responsibility is it to make sure things are fair? Can they think of any examples beyond the personal level? Whose responsibility is it to make communities or society fair? Can we do anything to make the world a fairer place? What to do Stick a coloured sticker on each child, either randomly or follow a factor such as blue eyes / not blue eyes. If the pupils ask what the stickers mean tell them they will find out later. Invite one group to sit at the desks, while the other group remain standing. Offer the seated pupils a choice of activity. Once selected all the class do the activity. The seated pupils should always be asked the questions, praised, rewarded and selected in place of the standing group. 2. What do we want from our food? This activity places fair trade within the context of a number of choices we make when we buy our food. Pupils need to prioritise those choices and decide which are the most important. What you need What do we want from our food? cards (see below) 1 set per group cut up. Kind to animals Good for wildlife Cheap Locally produced Fairly traded Good quality Healthy Ethical Fresh What to do Organise pupils into groups and ask them to brainstorm what things we need to think about when buying food. Give each group a set of cards and ask them to ‘diamond rank’ (see diagram right) the cards in order of importance. Share group decisions with the class. Can the whole class reach a consensus about 2 or 3 things that mattered most when choosing our food? Was fair trade one of those? Why / why not? Reflection and evaluation Do all the groups agree on what is most important when choosing our food? What did you find easy or difficult to agree on? Are there other matters we should take into consideration when choosing our food? How important is fair trade when choosing food? 10 Stride 1 – highest 2 2 3 3 3 4 4 5 – lowest LEVELS 2 & 4 What is trade? This activity gets pupils thinking about what ‘trade’ means and how at times it might be fair or unfair. There is also an option to reflect more closely on pupils own involvement in the issues involved in one product, in this example, bananas. What to do Reflection and evaluation Designate 3 areas in the room; 1 for agree, 1 for disagree and 1 for not sure. Once you have finished the activity hold a discussion with class which raises the following points. Explain that you will read a series of statements about trade and or /banana trade. Pupils must move to the area of the room which indicates their response. What came up that they had not considered before? For each statement, once pupils have moved into position, ask a few of them why they chose their response and what they feel about the statement. Did the activity make them change their views on anything? Are there any issues that they are still unable to make their mind up about? Does the answer change depending on the context? S n trade o s t n e m e t a t ❱ All trade involves money. ntries ❱ All cou al u have eq nities to oppor tu other h trade wit s. countrie be dn’ t s at l u o ana e sh ❱ W sell ban ake to To m s a able heaply. get so c veryone hould s e s u r e e a l t h ey u c h . m d fair twice as co s t ❱ It is bett er to grow all our own food here in the UK than trade with other countries t o get it. de sing tra s a e r c n I ❱ ntrie h e r co u t o t o h t i w est way is the b overty p r educe a. A in fric ❱ Trade is about a fair exchange. banana n o s t n e m e t a St trade ❱ Bananas should be cheap as we need access to affordable fru it. If farmers cannot produce the m at competitive prices our superm arkets should just find other produ cers that can grow them more che aply. nana industry really ❱ The issues in the ba only concerned do not worry me. I am a reasonable price. about fresh fruit at ❱ Trade is selling about h i g h e s fo r t h e t can an price you d buyin gf the che apest p or rice you ca n. ❱ It is important ho w bananas look. I will always choose the healthiest looking fruit. y my responsibilit ❱ It’s really not d. owers are treate how bananas gr workers’ rights We have enough ry about. in the UK to wor ❱ Subsides for farmers, whether in the Caribbean or in Europe, are vital for their survival in today’s global economy. Stride 11 from ‘Funny Island’ by Craig Maclachlan, Iochdar Primary School,South Uist. Activity ideas Grow Island debate LEVELS 2 & 3 Pupils will find out about land rights and how decisions about resources are linked to the power of different people. They will think about fairness and future sustainability. Warmer Give pupils a large piece of paper and tell them it represents their land. They must write or draw 5 uses for the land for things they would like to do. (E.g. playground, swimming pool, cinema) Next ask them to draw or write 5 ways to use the land to get things they need (e.g. food and shelter). In groups of 8 give pairs of pupils one of the 4 role cards below. Give them 5-10 minutes to prepare their argument. Remind them to think about how they can influence people to get what they want. Groups have a debate and the government representative must decide who to sell the land to. Share the ideas and create a list on the board. Ask the class “Is there enough land for all the things?” Discuss which things on the list are the most important. As a class, make a list of the 5 basic needs which they consider most important. At the end of the debate ask the government representatives who they sold the land to and why. Role play Tell the class that they own a small island. Most people living on the island grow their own food on the land to eat, or to sell to buy food from elsewhere. However, there are different groups of people on the island who all want to use the land. Pupils will pretend to be those people and have a debate, in role, to decide who will get the land. Hold a plenary and include the following points: • Who will be better or worse of now? Why? • Will food production for the islanders be a problem? • Will they be able to meet all their basic needs now and in the future? • Is it a fair situation? Prompt pupils to think about ownership, power, and money and why resources like land are contested in this way. Role cards You work for the government. You think that: • No one else has papers saying they own the land, so you think it belongs to you • You have the power to decide what happens to it • You can make lots of money if you sell it • As long as you make money you don’t mind what happens to it. You are a farmer who is farming the land. You think that: • It is your land because your family has been farming on it for many years • But you have no papers to prove this • You grow crops to sell at the local market to make money • 50 local people work with you on the land • You have very little money. You are a rich business person. You think that: • The price of the land is very cheap • You don’t want to use the land right now or let anyone else use it • The land will be worth more in the future, so you will sell it then to make money • You do not want to employ local people • You have lots of money to persuade some to sell it to you. You work for a multinational business. You think that: • You will grow crops on the land to turn into biofuels, to send to a rich country • You will use machines so will only need to employ 20 people to work on the land • You have lots of money to persuade someone to sell. Adapted from activities in the GROW resource. See the full range of activities at www.oxfam.org.uk/education 12 Stride We are the 99% W hen the Occupy movement in New York gathered on Fifth Avenue to beam the trailer of You’ve Been Trumped onto Trump Tower, they came equipped with ‘The Illuminator’ – a van emblazoned with the logo ‘We are the 99%’. Moments later, the vehicle’s roof-top projector flashed a cartoon image of Donald Trump across the façade of the 60 storey skyscraper accompanied by the message, ‘Wanted for Crimes Against Environment’. The voices of the residents of the Menie Estate in Aberdeenshire were heard echoing in the shadow of Manhattan’s most famous street, as yellow cabs rushed by. Aberdeenshire fisherman Michael Forbes was first. ‘It’s my home. I’ve stayed here for 33 years. And he won’t put me out of it.’ Minutes later, Justin Wedes, Occupy Wall Street’s Organizer leapt on top of ‘the Illuminator’, and addressed the gathering crowd: “It’s a story that has to be told, an exemplary case of the 99% against the 1% corrupting the political process, destroying our land, destroying the earth, and we have to speak out or we’ll have no more earth to speak out for.” It was a defining moment. You’ve Been Trumped, which captures the confrontation between Donald Trump’s golf course project and a proud group of homeowners in Balmedie, north of Aberdeen, had just been held over for a second week in New York City, after a successful theatrical release in the UK. And what started as Picture: David McCue Anthony Baxter took action against the environmental vandalism he saw happening on the Aberdeenshire coast which resulted in the film You’ve Been Trumped. Here he explains how his low budget movie became a powerful symbol for activists globally. a no-budget attempt to document the environmental impact and get to the truth, was now being adopted by the very movement that had given the 99% a voice. The film which the First Minister Alex Salmond has refused to publically watch, was now making headlines in The New York Times which splashed across its Weekend Arts section ‘Billionaire versus The Little Guy’. Bill Moyers, one of America’s most respected journalists and ‘You’ve Been Trumped was made during a time when the world was becoming more attuned to the consequences of unfettered power and money. ’ broadcasters was hailing You’ve Been Trumped as a ‘remarkable, moving and important film’. Donald Trump meanwhile had taken to the airwaves to dismiss the film as “third rate” whilst his organization issued a statement branding the residents “a national embarrassment for Scotland.” That’s not what New Yorkers were saying in post screening Q&As. The dignified, funny and exquisitely perceptive residents, who quite by accident have ended up spending a fairly significant chunk of their adult lives defending our shared natural heritage, were being lavished with praise for the way in which they had stood up for their homes and land, the ridicule from Aberdeen’s newspapers and persistent harassment. I had always felt the film’s subject was an important one for the United Kingdom. And I knew there was a universal theme that the gorgeous music of Jónsi and Scottish singer songwriter Karine Polwart helps to underline. But I wasn’t prepared for how deeply You’ve Been Trumped would resonate in places seemingly far removed from the shores of the North East of Scotland. You’ve Been Trumped was made during a time when the world was becoming more attuned to the consequences of unfettered power and money. The painful global financial crisis, and the Occupy movement it spawned, has been the real-life backdrop for the many film festivals that asked to show You’ve Been Trumped before its theatrical release. Whether in Alabama or Zagreb, it was obvious that the events that unfold in You’ve Been Trumped were somehow encapsulating the widespread anger about the actions of what all were now calling ‘the 1%’. For that we can credit the residents of the Menie Estate who are not impressed or blinded by celebrity, and for whom Donald Trump is, in Susan Munro’s immortal words, just a man with “a bit of a name” and “a few pounds they reckon in his pocket.” Stride 13 My story Martine Leitch from Swinton PS, Glasgow, explains why she is so passionate about taking a rights based approach to teaching and learning. F rom a very young age, I was encouraged to ask questions at home. However, I can recall very few opportunities that allowed me to truly question within the classroom. A very vivid memory from my own school days was being asked to leave a maths class because I was asking too many questions. I still remember the frustration of being reprimanded for questioning theories that I wasn’t expected to understand but just accept. As I began my own teaching career, I made a commitment to ensure that the learners in my class did not experience this same frustration. Ironically, several years after qualifying as a primary teacher, I undertook a postgraduate certificate in Philosophy for Children, and very quickly realised that I thrived on the challenge of trying to answer ‘big questions’. I was thinking much more critically about the world around me and wanted to encourage my pupils to do the same. I began seeking CPD opportunities that would support me to do this. After a business placement at SCIAF, I decided to explore issues such as fairness and equity through a Fair Trade topic. This project had a great impact not only on the pupils but also on my colleagues, 14 Stride who were impressed by the motivation and engagement of my pupils. Fair trade became a context for learning across the school, involving all teachers. Such was the success that I was inspired to further my own knowledge and understanding of Global Citizenship. It was at this point that I was introduced to WOSDEC. ‘I became increasingly aware that many of the issues and topics I was exploring with pupils in the classroom encompassed the theme of rights...’ I was attracted to a CPD opportunity that aimed to facilitate critical thinking using the context of global issues. I left the session feeling more motivated and inspired than ever. Working with WOSDEC has provided me with a network of ‘like minded’ teachers, who were keen to share ideas and support others in developing Global Citizenship. I joined one of their funded projects and was invited to attend informal network meetings which allow teachers to share ideas and learning. Through developing a greater understanding of Global Citizenship and exploring key issues, I became involved with the promotion of children’s rights. I became increasingly aware that many of the issues and topics I was exploring with pupils in the classroom encompassed the theme of rights, and I am now responsible for a whole school approach to rights education. I work with pupils, parents and staff to develop their knowledge and understanding of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC). A rights based approach has become integral to the ethos of our school. In recent years, I have been greatly involved in developing classroom approaches to Human Rights Education and am extremely passionate about supporting others in doing so. This has contributed greatly to me recently receiving GTC professional recognition for my work in this area. Global Citizenship has not only amplified my love of teaching and learning, but has inspired and motivated the young people that I work with to become active citizens. There is nothing more rewarding for a teacher than to observe pupils developing the necessary skills and qualities to inspire change and influence others around them. FROMSCHOOLS Exploring HIV through theatre Deans Community High School, Livingston T heatre can be a powerful tool for education. With World AIDS Day (1st December) on the horizon, last winter the British Red Cross decided to put theatre to work, using it to explore the complexities of the global HIV crisis with S6 students in West Lothian.’ A small, extracurricular group of pupils at Deans Community High School, Livingston volunteered to pilot new British Red Cross education work, which combines peer education drama techniques such as role play to develop empathy and public awareness around the issue of HIV. Drawing on the theatre’s young, but rich, history of application to education, social change and citizenship (based largely on Augusto Boal’s Theatre of the Oppressed), the workshops were designed with Curriculum for Excellence in mind, and its many overlaps with the British Red Cross’ humanitarian education programme. One of the highlights was an exploration of the stigma and misinformation that surrounds HIV using Forum Theatre. Forum Theatre is a ‘rehearsal for real life,’ typically an allegorical scene that challenges the audience to actually intervene in the action onstage and change the scene’s outcome. Pupils interacted with the scene through ‘thought-tracking’, where a hand on the shoulder of any character commands a monologue of his or her thoughts at that exact moment in the conflict. Once comfortable moving about the performance space and involving ‘These are theatrical scenes or spectacles performed in public spaces, designed to raise awareness or provoke thought about social issues.’ themselves in the drama, students had the opportunity to replace actors mid-scene and try alternative approaches of conflict resolution and responsible dialogue. Witnessing one character discriminating against another, for example, students would step into the action, standing up to the antagonist as either a third party or as the victim themselves. Forum Theatre proved a stimulating and engaging way to help pupils build on their knowledge of the HIV crisis at home and abroad, while providing them with the tools and leadership skills to educate others. The pupils also enjoyed brainstorming their own ‘Guerrilla Theatre’ action projects (also known as ‘Street Theatre’ – flash mobs being a popular example). These are theatrical scenes or spectacles performed in public spaces, designed to raise awareness or provoke thought about social issues. Pupils were challenged to plan their own vignettes that communicated important aspects of the global HIV crisis, from its impact on health to its implications for families, economies, and food security. One group thought to stage a ‘die-in’, where in the middle of the lunch period pupils would drop to the floor at the same rate that people die of HIV globally, one every fifteen seconds. Another group donned props and costumes and portrayed the revolving door of a developing world doctor’s office, where the physician could hand out diagnoses, but no treatment. Pupils were excited to learn new and engaging forms of Expressive Art, and creatively applied these practices to the communication of global issues to their peers. Individual and group evaluations and reflections were recorded weekly, and provided a valuable, visual means of tracking pupils’ learning throughout. For more information on British Red Cross humanitarian education workshops, please contact Sarah Cassidy, Youth & Schools Manager – Fife, Lothian and Borders, at [email protected] Students attempt to put in order the 'vicious cycle' of HIV and its impact on families and economies. Stride 15 FROMSCHOOLS An enterprising approach to Fair trade Holyrood HS, Glasgow, have a long standing link with Lomola Primary School and Stella Maris Girls School in Malawi. H olyrood HS, Glasgow, have a long standing link with Lomola Primary School and Stella Maris Girls School in Malawi. Both schools have been working on rights and have developed their own Charter of Rights. The girls in Stella Maris focussed particularly on rights for women and girls and established the Empowering Girls Group at Lomola PS. Holyrood HS fair trade group. The group makes and sells various craft items in order to help support themselves and their future education. Supported by the Thyolo papermakers, an artisanal group committed to sustainable craft methods, the girls make cards, jewellery, pictures and other items using recycled materials and paper. Fairtrade schools The Fairtrade School Award gives recognition to pupils and teachers who show commitment to raising awareness of fair trade in their school and local community. Sally Romilley spoke to pupils Qasim Aslam and Shona Ellis and DHT Fiona Low at Morgan Academy, Dundee. What does it mean to you to have Fairtrade School status? Fiona: It shows we demonstrate responsible Global Citizenship throughout the school and it puts into practice our aims and values; to treat everyone fairly, not just those within the school building. Shona: We are doing something collectively – it’s not just the pupils, but the canteen and the staffroom are supporting it as well. Qasim: As a school, I feel we’re making a difference. 16 Stride How easy was it to achieve the award? What were the challenges? Fiona: We were building on existing practice. Renewing it annually will probably be more of a challenge; increasing what we do and keeping it fresh. Many of our ideas are led by the pupils. Qasim: It is important that the teachers supported our ideas. What changes have you noticed as a result of working on fair trade? Fiona: In general, our pupils are quite compassionate and want to see a fairer world. They are aware of unfair conditions and they know what Fairtrade means. For the pupils on the Fairtrade committee, they are developing their organisational and decision making skills, and growing in confidence. Shona: It was a great experience to have a sugar producer from Malawi visit the school. I didn’t realise how much money from Fairtrade was going into community projects. That really reminded us what we were working for. In order to establish new markets for the products, the group works in partnership with Holyrood HS pupils, who buy their products and sell them in their school and local community. This has enabled the girls to buy more materials and to make an income from their crafts. The pupils are involved in selling, planning and marketing the items. This includes leading for assemblies, informing their peers of the project and writing an information leaflet for parents. This innovative project illustrates fair trade on a micro level and is a good example of how school partnerships can work to the benefit of both partners. To become a Fairtrade School you need to meet 5 goals • Set up a Fairtrade School Steering Group with at least half pupils and which meets at least once a term. • Write and adopt a Fairtrade Policy which has the support of the board of Governors and is signed by the Head teacher. • Use and sell Fairtrade products as much as possible. • Learn about Fairtrade in at least three subjects in two year groups. • Take action for Fairtrade at least once a term in the school and once a year in the community. To find our more visit: www. fairtrade.org.uk/schools/how_to_ become_a_fairtrade_school Our Land, Our Storyline Sandra Lyon from Oakgrove PS and Frances Boyle from Notre Dame PS explain how taking part in an innovative project linking Global Citizenship and drama impacted positively not only on their classes but across their schools. Pictures on this page: Pupils from Oakgrove primary school stage a protest against land grabs. “I recommend this topic for every school in the world,” says one of the boys who took part in this innovative approach to the primary topic of ‘Farming’. The Global Storylines project uses the methodology of storylines to explore global issues; this enables learners to become more directly involved with a social or environmental issue thus prompting deeper and more critical reflection. Supported, by WOSDEC, Glasgow City Council and Strathclyde University who have developed the project, the schools used the Our Crop, Our Land Storyline, which explores the complex issues of food security and land grabbing. The pupils begin by exploring food as a human right and a commodity; investigating farms around the world and food journeys from harvest to consumption. The stories take place on imaginary farms where everyone grows the same imaginary crop. They create the environment needed to grow their crop, and then the family groups and characters who farm the crop. In this storyline a developer arrives on the farm and they find out that the government has sold the farmland as it sits within a wider area being developed. The pupils had to respond and they decided to stage a protest. ‘The pupils begin by exploring food as a human right and a commodity; investigating farms around the world and food journeys from harvest to consumption.’ Both teachers agree that the project has really motivated pupils. “The impact on the children is amazing,” says Sandra, “they are reflecting on everything they do and say and how they work together.” Frances adds: “It really gave them the enquiry skills and communication skills to be effective learners and made them realise that if you want to know the answer to a question you can find out.” For the teachers involved in the project it meant moving away from the traditional role of a teacher and handing over to the pupils; in effect, “stepping out of the comfort zone”. Sandra goes on: “I’ve been teaching for 26 years and it is not easy to let go. If things started to go too far you can stop the drama and ask everyone to reflect on what is happening, empowering the pupils to resolve the problems themselves. “ The relationship has changed between the children and the teacher for the better, with both children and teachers developing as reflective learners alongside each other. It has also had a positive impact on the relationships between pupils and their behaviour. Both teachers agree that the support from Wosdec throughout the project was invaluable. Frances says: “It was a different way of working and they have given us teaching strategies that can be used in every area of the curriculum, it’s about developing an ethos in your class. Global Citizenship is not a subject, it permeates every area of the curriculum. It is about an approach and asking questions is a big part of that. It gets away from the idea that you have to have the right answer and that the children are trying to give you that right answer.” Both teachers are firmly committed to taking this work forward in their schools where it has generated a buzz of interest and keenness from other staff to get in on the action! For more information about the project email [email protected] Stride 17 A round-up of Global Citizenship events, competitions & CPD from IDEAS members. In the loop World development Movement Scotland Malawi Partnership Growing Change... in our High schools? Wednesday 7 November 4.30 – 6.30pm, Central Glasgow This free CPD event for teachers of Social Studies, Science, English and RMPS in and around Glasgow will focus on Interdisciplinary Learning through Global Citizenship. Growing Change is a documentary about the global food crisis. Documenting what is happening in Venezuela, it shows what is possible when communities, not corporations, start to take control of food based on the principles of social justice and sustainability. Gender Equality Forum Meeting 19 November, Central Library, Edinburgh, 5-7pm The next Gender Equality Forum meeting will provide the opportunity to begin to explore the first in our “Gender Matters” series looking at Gender Matters in Education. If you would like to showcase your partnership at the meeting, or attend to find our more, please email charlie@ scotland-malawipartnership.org. All are very welcome to attend. This is an opportunity to join other teachers to review and discuss the documentary and how it might be used to meet the CfE Experiences and Outcomes within Scotland’s new National Qualifications. Fairly traded refreshments will help the discussions along! Contact [email protected] to register your interest in joining us. Yewo! A Celebration of Scotland-Malawi Youth Links On the 7 November 2012 (from 6-8pm), the Scotland Malawi Partnership are hosting a youth event at the Scottish Parliament, celebrating youth links between Scotland and Malawi. The event will be aimed at 5th and 6th year pupils, and those at college and university. The event will provide the opportunity to showcase current youth engagement between the 2 countries and explore the potential for new partnerships. We’re also really looking forward to welcoming a number of young Malawians to the event, who will be visiting Scotland at the time. For further information visit: http://tinyurl.com/SMPYouth12 Youth Steering Group The Scotland Malawi Partnership Youth Steering Group (YSG) is made up of 5th and 6th year pupils, college, and university students, with an interest in, and commitment to, strengthening youth links between Scotland and Malawi. The YSG is always looking for new members to join the group, helping to shape the SMP’s youth strategy and plan youth events. The group meets every 3 months or so with SMP staff. If you would be interested in joining the group, or would like to recommend someone, please email [email protected] for further information. Amnesty International Young Human Rights Reporter Competition 2013 The competition aims to inspire young people to become human rights reporters, to investigate what’s going on in the world and bring human rights abuses to light. This year there is also a photojournalism category looking for powerful photos on a human rights theme. The competition is open to pupils aged between 7-18 and the deadline for entries is 18 February 2013. For more information visit www.amnesty.org.uk Red Cross Picture: Brian, Morrison (BRC) Humanitarian Education Course This course helps teachers develop a detailed understanding of a range of humanitarian issues and how to explore those in the classroom. It is open to secondary teachers of all subjects. There will be an opportunity to engage with topical issues such as conflict, child soldiers, disasters and emergencies as well as the chance to design innovative action projects to use in your school and home. The course takes place over four Saturdays; 3 Nov, 1 Dec, 26 Jan and 1 June in Edinburgh. For more information and to register contact Silvia at ssabinohunt@ redcross.org.uk Queens University, Belfast – teacher training – December 2009 18 Stride Picture: Ridgway, Simon (UNP) Refugee Week: British Red Cross workshops with children at Barton Hill Primary School, June 2012. Global Citizenship CPD programme Awareness Days October Black History Month 16 October World Food Day 12 November International Education Week The Global Learning Project has developed a new CPD programme available for 2012/13. 1 December World Aids Day Sessions available will include: 10 December Human Rights Day • Climate Change: an interdisciplinary approach • Rights Across the Curriculum: an active learning approach • Global Thinking: practical ideas for developing thinking skills through Global Citizenship • Food for Thought: investigating the global food system • Dhaka to Dundee: linking local history to global issues • A Global Approach: primary topic planning • Comparing localities: using place as a context for Global Citizenship learning • A’ Adams Bairns: equality and diversity in Scotland past and present • Fàilte Malawi: a country focussed approach to Global Citizenship 12 February Red Hand Day For more information on where these courses are available, contact your local Global Learning Centre (see back cover). 2 December International Day for the Abolition of Slavery 25 February start of Fairtrade Fortnight 4 March Climate Week 8 March International Women’s Day Global Citizenship Events The IDEAS Global Learning Project (GLP) will be organising a number of events over this academic year. • CPD and Global Citizenship co-ordinators training days. This will focus on planning for Global Citizenship across the school. • National Secondary Schools Global Citizenship event. • Global Citizenship Symposium for teachers who have worked on the project so far. For details about any of the above please contact the GLP Schools co-ordinator [email protected] Stride 19 IDEAS & its members IDEAS (the International Development Education Association of Scotland) is a network of organisations involved in Development Education and Education for Global Citizenship across Scotland. Amnesty International 0131 313 7010 www.amnesty.org.uk/ scotlandeducation Save the Children 0131 527 8200 www.savethechildren.org.uk/ scotland British Red Cross 0131 338 5700 www.redcross.org.uk/education SCIAF 0141 354 5555 www.sciaf.org.uk Christian Aid 0141 241 6137 www.christianaid.org.uk/learn Scotland Malawi Partnership 0131 529 3164 www.scotland-malawi partnership.org Global School Partnerships 0131 524 5780 www.dfid.org.uk/gsp Hand Up Media 0131 226 2674 www.handupmedia.co.uk Mercy Corps 0131 662 5160 www.mercycorps.org.uk Woodcraft Folk Scotland 0141 304 5552 www.woodcraft.org.uk ‘The world has enough for everyone’s need but not enough for everyone’s greed.’ Gandhi World Peace Prayer Society 01387 740642 www.worldpeace-uk.org WWF Scotland 01350 728200 www.wwfscotland.org.uk Seeds for Learning Oxfam Scotland 0141 285 8887 www.oxfam.org.uk/education including Global Learning Centres Conforti Institute 01236 607120 www.confortiinstitute.org Highland One World Group 01381 621265 www.globaldimension. highlandschools.org.uk Montgomery Development Education Centre 01224 620111 www.montgomerydec.org.uk One World Centre Dundee 01382 454603 www.oneworldcentredundee. org.uk This essential one stop website gives you local and national access to Global Citizenship resources. Scotdec 0131 226 1499 www.scotdec.org.uk A wide variety of materials for all ages can be borrowed from your local Global Learning Centre or purchased directly from: West of Scotland DEC 0141 243 2800 www.wosdec.org www.ideas-forum.org.uk www.seedsforlearning.org.uk In the next issue: Gender and equality Active global citizens IDEAS’ work in Scotland is funded by: o subscribe free of charge to this T magazine: [email protected]
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz