Swapan Wanegee
C
Wpsidence eZ Chamher :
4 A LLB , Advocate
HIGH COURT, CALCUTTA
Office :
G.T. ROAD, THANAPARA,
MEMARI, P.O. MEMARI,
DIST. BURDWAN, 713146.
MOBILE NO. 9332120646.
HIGH COURT, CALCUTTA,
BAR ASSOCIATION,ROOM NO.10,
PHONE NOS.-2248.3190,2248-3169,
EXT. ROOM NO.: 10
FAX : (033) 2248-2313.
To
1J The Ld. Govt. Pleader, High Court at Calcutta.
17/05/ 2016
Dated :-
2J The District Magistrate, Burdwan, having its Office at Court
Compound, P.O. & District - Burdwan, PIN. 713141.
3] The. Director of Panchayet and Rural Development Department,
Government of West Bengal, having its Office at Panchayet Bhawan, Salt
Lake City, Kolkata - 91.
4; The Block Development Officer, Raina - II Block having its Office at Raina,
Dist. Burdwan, PIN. 713423.
5] The Health Supervisor, Raina H Gram Panchayet Samity having its Office
at Raina, District - Burdwan, PIN. 713423.
6] The Chief Medical Officer at Health Burdwan, having its Office at Burdwan
Medical College & Hospital, P.O. & Dist. Burdwan, PIN. 713141.
7] The Secretary to the State Mission Director(NRHM), Govt. of West Bengal,
Health & Family Welfare. Department, Swastha Bhawan, 4th floor, Wing B, GN - 29, Sector - V, Salt Lake City, Kolkata - 700 091.
81 The Three(3) Men Committee, service through the Block Development
Officer, Raina - II Block, District - Burdwan, PIN. 713141.
Ref.:- W.P. No.9l ccrOJW) of 2016;
iNnyv_at_a_
PETITIONER
-VersusState of West Bengal & Others
RESPONDENTS
Dear Sir(s),
Please find herewith a copy of the Writ application along with all
annexures which to be moved before the Hon'ble Justice I.P. Mukerji on
.6.2016 on any date thereafter as per business of I he Hon'ble Court as a
`Listed Motion'.
Please attend at the time of hearing.
With thanks,
Enclo: As stated above.
Yours faithfully,
[MR.SWAPAN NERAJEE]
/ Advocate
DISTRICT : BURDWAN
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
W.P. No.
95'65
(W) of 2016;
Subject matter relating to:- Under the West Bengal Panchayet Act,
1973 and the rules relating thereto in respect of appointment of Asha
Employees' in different Gram Panchayets under the Raina - II
Par Lchayet Saintly.
head :- k of the classification list.
Group :- V
CAUSE-TITLE
Nirmola San
.... PETITIONER
(Malik)
-versu 5...RESPONDENTS
State of West Bengal & Others
Advocate on Record:Mr. Swapan Banerjee,
Ad-Irk:mate
High Court at Calcutta,
Bar Association,
Room No. 10.
INDEX
1)
The Copy of the Writ application.
Page - 1 - 32;
2)
Affidavit.
Page - 33;
3)
Annexure - `11'
Page - 34
4)
Annexure -11/
Page -
Annexure - P72'
Page -
6) Anne e - P73'
Page -
Annexure - `111/4'
Page -
Annexure -
Page -
Vakalatnama
o-
LIST OF DATES
DATE & FACTS:
Earlier Writ application being W.P. No. 12511 (W) of 2012 was
disposed of on 9.9.2015.
2)
On 26.3.2012 by the Order of the Chief Medical Officer and also
Order dated 22.3.2012 issued by the District Magistrate and the
Panel has been cancelled.
the month of April, 2010 advertisement was published by the
authorities for appointment of Asha employees.
4)
Admit Card for the interview was issued by the authoritie
the month of May, 2010.
The appointment letter as issued on. 8.9.2011.
The petitioners made several representations since 2011 for
sending her in training.
POINTS OF LAW
That the Scheme has been framed by the Central Govt. and as per the
Scheme the Govt. of West Bengal has also adopted the Scheme for
engagement of Asha employees in different Gram Panchayets at Raina
- it Block according to the Scheme so many candidates have been
applied in different Gram Panchayets and interview was taken up and
appointment letter has been issued to the petitioner medical
examination has been taken on the basis of the Samity two(2)
candidates selected by the authorities as per the regulation and that
the authorities without hearing the petitioner, without mentioning the
specific objection has taken a plea a panel has cancelled though there
is no whisper regarding such cancellation of panel by the three (3)
Men Committee and a person was a judge of a case cannot be a
member of the Committee and also taken the plea to cancel the panel
and by violating the natural justice everything has been done by way
of a political reason and the action of the authorities are violative of
Article 14,16, 21 and 39d of the Constitution of India and also
violative of the regulation of the appointment for Asha employees.
DISTRICT : BURDWAN
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
IN THE MATTER OF:
(W) of 2016;
W.P. No.
An application under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India.
-And-
IN THE MATTER OF:
A Writ in the nature of Mandamus
and/or in the nature of Certiorari
and/or in the nature of Prohibition
and/or any other Writ or Writs as
will be deemed fit proper and
equitable and for the ends of
justice.
-And-
IN THE MATTER OF:
Order or orders, direction or
directions as will be deemed fit and
proper.
2
-And-
IN THE MATTER OF:
Purported and illegal arbitrary
action on the part of the respondent
authorities by withholding for
sending training and actual
appointment in the post of Asha
Prakalpa in spite of the authorities
have given the appointment letter
and recommendation to the
petitioner and thereby medical
examination has already been
completed but the authorities have
not sent the petitioners to the
training for Asha Prakalpa under
the Scheme of the Central Govt.
-And —
IN THE MATTER OF:
If there is no objection in respect of
interview of the Asha employees in
different Cram Panchayets a flimsy
ground has been set-up that the
advertisement in respect of
3
engagement of Asha employees has
not been properly pronounced in
the Village concerned though in the
Gram Panchayet Office as well as in
the Office/House of the members of
the Gram Panchayet and in the:
Library and in different places of
the Village the advertisement has
been made and thereby upon
perusing the same the petitioner
has completed all formalities for
engagement in the said post
according her qualification.
-And-
[N THE MATTER OF:
Order dated 26.3.2012 issued by
the Chief Medical. Officer of Health
under Memo No.P/CON, dated Nil
intimating the State Mission
Director (NRHM) and the Secretary
of the Govt. of Health and. Family
Welfare.
-And-
4
IN THE MATTER OF:
The District Magistrate, Burdwan
regarding illegality of engagement of
Asha employees of Raina - II Block
a Committee has been formed
under memo No.113/ CON/ Health,
dated 22.3.2012 by appointing
three(3) Men Committee to place
the repo n respect of engagement
of Asha employees at Raina - 11
Block the Committee has been
placed the report but after receiving
the report the District Magistrate,
Burdwan as well as the Mission.
Director/Chief Medical Officer of
Health has not cancelled the panel
as such the panel is valid and the
petitioner is entitled to get the
actual engagement by way of
training
5
-And —
IN THE MATTER OF:
The earlier Writ application being
W.P. No. 12511 (W) of 2012 Nan.dita
Paramanik(Das) and. Others Versus- State of West Bengal &
Others wherein fifty three (53) Asha.
Candidates was filed the aforesaid
Writ application and that matter
came up for final hearing before the
Hon'ble Justice Dr. Sambuddha
Chakrabarti wherein by the order
dated 9.9.2015 His Lordship has
been pleased to pass an order that
as the panel is defective and in
procedural irregularity as such
fresh cause of action is arisen and
the liberty is given to the petitioner
but challenge as a totality of the
new cause of action as arisen, in
view of the circumstances and
liberty was given to file a fresh
proceeding.
-And —
IN THE MATTER OF:
The authorities have not cancelled
the panel of the Asha employees to
whom
the
appointment/
engagement was given and thereby
sent them for medical examination
before the Block Level Health
Centre after completion of the
medical.examination the petitioner
in spite of undertaking by the
authorities the petitioner was not
sent for training for a indefinite
period as such earlier WriL
application being W.P. No. 12511
(W) of 2012 was filed but that Writ
application was dismissed upon
7
giving liberty to file the present
petition challenging the cause of
action in totality.
-And-
IN THE MATTER OF:
The authorities who have approved
the panel and who have verified the
panel ave no power to cancel the
panel (though the panel has not
been cancelled as yet as per report
of the District Magistrate) but no
actual posting has been made by
sending the petitioner for Asha.
Training and no payment has been
made as such the petitioners
entitled to get the entire galaxy from
the date of issuance of the
engagement letter.
-And.-
8
IN THE MATTER OF:
The authorities cannot be a judge of
his own case because the
authorities who have taken
interview and approved the panel
and sent to the Higher authorities
for
recommendation
and
recommendation has been made
and engagement letter has been
issued and medical examination
has been held and that authorities
i.e. actually the Mission Director
himself being a judge of his own
case cannot take the plea the panel
has been. cancelled.
-And-
IN THE MATTER OF:
Purported and illegal violation of
the regulation. of the Asha Prakalpa
9
a Scheme of the Central Govt. and
violation of the Panchayet Act and
Rules and also Rules for
appointment of the Asha
employees.
-And-
IN THE MATTER OF:
Purported and illegal violation of
the Article 14,16 and 21 of the
Constitution of India.
--AndIN THE MATTER OF:
Purported and illegal violation of
the natural justice by not giving
hearing to the petitioner o whom
the engagement letter has been
issued and medical examination
has already been completed but
before the Court in respect of earlier
10
Writ application being W.P. No.
12511 (W) of 2012 the Govt.
Advocate submitted.the panel has
been cancelled though the panel
has not been cancelled in the report
as has been handed over at the
time of hearing of the application so
the action of the authorities is
totally arbitrary, illegal and violative
of Constitutional provision of law as
well as rules of the Asha. Prakalpa.
-And-
IN THE MATTER OF:
Nirmola Santra (Malik), Wife of Dilip
Kumar Malik, residing at VllageMadhabd ihi, P.O. Madh andthi , Police
Station - Mad h ab dih
D ict-
Burdwan, PIN. 713424.
PETITIONER
11
-Versus-
1)
The State of West Bengal,
service through the Secretary,
Department of Panchayet and Rural
Development Department, having
its Office at 1, Kiran Sh.ankar Roy
Road, Kolkata - 700 001.
2)
The District Magistrate,
Burdwan, having its Office at Court
Compound, P.O. & District Burdwan, PIN. 713141.
3)
The
Additional
District
Magistrate (Z.P.) Burdwan, having
its Office at Court Compound, P.O.
& Dist. Burdwan, PIN. 713141.
4)
The Director of Panchayet and
Rural Development Department,
12
Governmentof West Bengal, having
its Office at Panchayet Bhawan,
Salt Lake City, Kolkata - 91.
5)
The Block Development Officer,
Raina -- II Block having its Office at
Raina, Dist. Burdwan, PIN. 71.3423.
6)
The Secretary, Raina- II
Panchayet Samity having its Office
at Raina, Dist. Burdwan, PIN.
713423.
kvti
7)
The Prodhan,
Gram
Panchayet, having its Office at
Kuili, Dist. Burdwan, PIN. 713421
PN
8)
The Health Supervisor, Raina II
Gram Panchayet Samity having its
Office at Raina, Dist. Burdwan,
PIN .713423.
13
9) The Chief Medical Officer at
Health Burdwan, having its Office
at Burdwan Medical College or,
Hospital, P.O. & Dist. Burdwan..
Burdwan, PIN. 713191.
10) The Secretary to the State
Mission Director (NRHM), Govt. of
West Bengal, Health & Family
Welfare Department, Swastha
Bhawan, 4th floor, Wing - B, GN 29, Sector - V, Salt Lake City,
Kolkata - 700 091.
11) The Three(3) Men Committee,
service, through the Block
Development Officer, Raina.
Block, District - Burdwan,
PIN .7131.41.
... RESPONDENTS
14
The 1-ion'ble Miss. Manjula Chellur, Chief Justice
And Irter Companion Justices of this Hon'ble Court.
The Humble petition of the
petitioner abovenamed most
respectfully Shcweth:
1)
That, the petitioner is the citizen of India and resides in the
address as mentioned in the cause-title and entitled to file this
ap plication .
2.1
That, the Respondent Authorities are the Authorities who come
under the purviewof the Article 12 of the Constitution of India so the
Writ application is maintainable against the Respondents.
3)
That, challenging the illegal action of the authorities by not
sending the petitioner in training for Asha Prakalpa employees in
spite of giving appointment letter n spite of making medical
cxmaination the petitioner and 53 others moved the Writ application
being W.P. No. 2511 (W) of 2012 and that matter came up for final
15
hearing before the Hon ble Justice Sambuddha Chakrabarti on
9.9.2015 and upon hearing the matter His Lordship has been pleased
to observe on the basis of the submission of the Govt. Advocate that
the recruitment of Asha Prakalpa employees, Raina — II Block stood
cancel, as such, there is a new cause of action and the same to be
challenged in totality in view of such the Writ application is disposed
of as an infractuous with a liberty to file fresh Writ Petition
challenging the new cause of action accordingly the present Writ
application is being filed.
Xerox copy of the order dated 9.9.2015 is annexed hereto and
marked as Annexure —
4)
That, the main grievance of the petitioner are very much legal
and fair and the authorities have no right to make an enquiry on the
basis of the objection without disclosing the same the authorities
conducted the enquiry of the three (3) men Committee and District
Magistrate was issued the order of enquiry by appointing three (3)
men Committee who is approving and recommending authority of the
pancl to send the same before the State Mission Director (NM-1M) as
such entire process has been done a authority who is a party to the
1. 6
proceeding as such no man can judge of his own case who has signed
and approved the panel of Asha Prakalpa employees of Raina - II
Block
The copy of the report of the enquiry and also the forwarding
letter dated 26.3.2012 of the Chief Medical Officer of the authority
and the letter dated 22.3.2012 issued by the District Magistrate have
been deposited and disclosed before the Hon'ble High Court at the
time of hearing of W.P. No. 12511 (W) of 2012, dated 9.9.2015 is
annexed hereto and marked as Annexure - P/1'.
5)
That, a guideline has been framed by the Govt. of West Bengal,
Department of Health & Family Welfare for engagement of Asha.
Prakalpa employees for implementation of the Central. Govt. Scheme
wherein 800-1200 vacant posts to be filled up in 135 blocks and the
borough rules and regulations of such engagement has been
ecl in such notification on the basis of such different Gram
Panchayets in the year April, 2010 in different dates made an
advertisement n the Panchayet Office and at the wall of the library of
the Village and also accessible place of the Village for engagement of
17
the Asha employees with. the rules and regulations for engagement
under Raina -- II Block.
The Xerox copy of the regulation of the Govt. of West Bengal,
Department of Health & Family Welfare and also the specific
advertisement of the Gram Panchayet which was wall up in different
places in every Village of the respective Gram Panchayet is collectively
ar (mod hereto and marked as Annexure `P/2'.
6)
That, on the basis of the advertisement of the. Gram Panchayet
in the year 2010 in specific and specimen format of the application
for appointment in different Gram Panchayets under Raina - II Block
was Lilted up by the Candidate/Petitioner and thereby deposited the
same in due time.
Xerox copy of such specimen copy of the application will
produce at the time of hearing of the application.
7)
That, on the basis of such application for engagement of Asha
emt~ioyees at Gram Panchayet Arui, Sub-centre -- Madhabdihi
B.P.H.C. - V the authorities issued the AdmitCard to he petitioner
18
for interview specifying the date, time of such interview in respect of
the petitionerwhich has been mentioned in the Admit Card itself as
the petitioner^ has requisite qualification as per the advertisement and
the rules. The Admit Card was issued by the authorities, so, there is
no dispute regarding academic qualification and if required the
petitioner will refer and produce the certificate of academic and other
qualification at the time of hearing of the application.
Xerox copy of the Admit Card is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure -'P/3'.
That, after completion of nterview in different Gram Panchayets
under Raina -.II Block for filled up the post of Asha employees
whereas lfairly and properly advertised the vacancy and also the
engagement of Asha employees in the accessible place of every village,
library in. a reputed wall of the shop, the Gram Panchayet Office etc.
and accordingly after eceiving the application from the Candidates
interview was completed and thereby a panel was prepared by the
authorities on the bas's of the regulation as made as stipulated being
Anr.e.ture - P/2 of the application and thereby issued the
appointment letter to the petitioner on 8.9.2011 by the Block Health
1.9
and Family Welfare, Raina II Block Madhabdihi, Burdwan by
requesting to report to the Secretary, Block Health and Fa y
Welfare Sanity of the Block between 12.10.2011 to 18.10.2011 at any
working days between 1 a.m. to 4 p.m. for reporting of medical
examination and bring medical certificate from a registered Medical
Practitioner.
Xerox copy of the appointment letter is annexed hereto and
marked as Annexure - `P/4'.
9)
That, in the appointment letter the authorities have been
directed the petitioner to appear before the Block Medical Officer for
Nleyical Examination in specific date and time and the petitioner have
appeared and thereby fit for appointment but no fit certificate has
been given and thereby said the petitioner that he will send for
training in the training centre very soon.
10) l.t is stated by the petitioner that the authorities who have
advertised the post in wide circulation in the Village concerncd and
many candidates have been applied in the said post and upon taking
the interview by the respondent authorities prepared the panel and
20
recommended the panel and sento the State Mission.Director for
final approval of panel and thereby issued the appointment letter to
the selected candidates upon preparation of panel and thereby the
said Officer without specifying an objection which has not been
mentioned by the District Magistrate as well as the three(3) men
committee, without canceling the appointment letter kept the matter
pending for indefinite period and thereby before the Hon'ble High
rn the earlier Writ application being W.P. No. 12511 (W) of 2012
the Govt. Advocate submitted, the panel has been cancelled and
thereby submitted a bunch of paper wherein there isno whisper
regarding the cancellation of panel and the respondents have mislead
the Court. Considering such situation the petitioners are entitled to
get the actual training and posting the said post and they are also
entitled to get the salary, allowances and benefits month by month.
11) :t is stated by the petitioner that as per the scheme of the
Central. Govt., the Govt. of West Bengal implemented. the Scheme and
thereby tried to give appointment of Asha employees in other blocks
except Raina - II as per the advertisement the Asha employees have
bean en aged earlier but in respect of Raina - II Block no one has been
21
given actual posting and training as such local people are suffering to
a great extent.
12 it is stated by the petitioner that no man can judge of his own
case the authorities who have prepared the panel, recommended the
panel, and given an appointment and medical examination has been
made to the petitioner the said authorities cannot by making a false
three(3) men Committee cannot stop the panel.
13) It is stated by the petitioner that it is case of judicial review
because no cancellation of the panel has been made in the report
being Annexure - P/1 of the Writ application which has been
prat ed before the Court a connection with the hearing of the
earlier Writ application being W.P. No. 12511 (W) of 2012.
1/'' It is stated by the 'petitioner that after the medical ex-
atoll
and getting the appointment letter the petitioner along with others
made the representation to the authorities but nothing has been done
and in the hearing of the Writ application being W.P. No. 1251.1 (W) of
2012 in the year 2015 they have produced a report that panel has
22
been cancelled. In such report there is no whisper regarding the
cancellation of the panel.
Xeroxcopy of the representations are annexed hereto and
marked as Annexure - `P/5'.
15)
It is stated by the petitioner that the authorities have violated
the provisions of the Scheme for appointment of Asha employees and
also violated the provision of Article 14, 16 and 21 and 39d of the
Constitution of India and also the provision of judicial review and
without giving a hearing to the petitioner who have been appointed in
the post, the cancellation of panel is arbitrary, illegal and
dis:rirninatory and it is required to be set aside and quashed and
thereby pass an order to send the petitioner in training for Asha
employees under Raina
II Block in the respective Gram.
Pa n ehayets / Vill ages.
16)
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the inaction on the part
of the respondent authorities by not sending the petitioner in training
as an Asha employees and not allowed actual posting in the
respective Gram Panchayets/Villages as an Asha employees and
23
cha.'lenging the illegal engagement of three (3) men Committee for
enquiry without any specific basis without notice to the empanel
candidate stopping for such engagement by not sending the petitioner
in training and by submitting before the Court that panel has been
cancelled and taking the plea for cancellation of panel as stipulated in
Annexure - PR of the Writ Application, the petitioner is filing this
application under Article 226 of the Coinstitution of India on the
following amongst other grounds:-
GROUNDS
1)
FOR THAT that the authorities who have advertised the post in
wide circulation in the Village concerned and many candidates
have been applied in the said post and upon taking the
interview by the respondent authorities prepared the panel and
recommended the panel and sent to the State Mission Director
for final approval of panel and thereby issued the appointment
letter to the selected candidates upon preparation of panel and
thereby the said Officer without specifying an objection which
has not been mentioned by the District Magistrate as well as the
three(3) rnen committee, without canceling the appointment
21
letter kept the matter pending for definite period and thereby
before the Hon'ble High Court in the earlier Writ application
being W.P. No. 12511 (W) of 2012 the Govt. Advocate submitted,
the panel has been cancelled and thereby submitted a bunch of
paper wherein there is no whisper regarding the cancellation of
panel and the respondents have mislead the Court. Considering
such situation the petitioners are entitled to get the actual
training and posting the said post and they are also entitled to
get the salary, allowances and benefits month by month.
FOR THAT as per the Scheme of the Central Govt., the Govt. of
West Bengal implemented the Scheme and thereby tried to give
appointment of Asha employees in other blocks except Raina II as per the advertisement the Asha employees have been
engaged earlier but in respect of Raina - II Block no one has
been given actual posting and training as such local people are
suffering to a great extent.
11-1) FOR THAT that no man can judge of his own case the
authorities who have prepared the panel, recommended the
panel and given an appointment and medical examination has
25
been made to the petitioner the said authorities cannot by
making a false three(3) men Committee cannot stop the panel.
IV)
FOR THAT it is case of judicial review because no cancellation of
the panel has been made in the report being Annexure - P/1 of
the Writ application which has been produced before the Court
in connection with the hearing of the earlier Writ application
being W.P. No. 12511 (W) of 2012.
V)
FOR THAT after the medical examination and getting the
appointment letter the petitioner made the representation to the
authorities but nothing has been done and in the hearing of the
Writ application being W.P. No. 12511 (W) of 2012 in the year
2015 they have produced a report that panel has been
cancelled. In such report there is no whisper regarding the
cancellation of he panel.
FOR THAT the authorities have violated the provisions of he
Scheme for appointment of Asha employees and also violated
the provision of Article 14, 16 and 21 and 39d of the
Constitution of India and also the provision of judicial review
26
and without giving a hearing to the petitioner who have been
appointed in the post, the cancellation of panel is arbitrary,
illegal and discriminatory and it is required to be set aside and
quashed and thereby pass an order to send the petitioner in
training for Asha employees under Raina - II Block in the
respective Gram Panchayets/Villages.
VII) FOR THAT the authorities who have been taken interview,
prepared the panel, recommended the panel and send before
the Higher authorities for final approval those officers cannot
take the plea that the panel has been prepared illegally without
proper advertisement and in spite of issuance of the
--Appointment letter the training facilities has not been given to
the petitioner as such which is arbitrary, illegal and violative of
Article 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
VIII.) FOR THAT without giving any notice to the petitioner without
allowing to the petitioner in three(3) men Committee though the
panel has not been cancelled cannot deprive the petitioner from
their employment of Asha employees and such action is violative
of principle of natural justice.
27
IX) FOR THAT the report which has been placed before the Hon'ble
Court at the time of hearing being W.P. No. 12511 (VV) of 2012
and the copy has been handed over o the Advocate of the
petitioners in that case, there is no whisper regarding the
cancellation of panel so the authorities have mislead the court
by making submission which is arbitraryand illegal.
FOR THAT the action of the authorities are otherwise bad and
illegal.
17) That, challenging the illegal action of the respondent authorities
TIC>
other application has been filed before this Hon'ble Court or any
other Court of law.
1.8) That, relevant records in connection with this application is
lying in the Office of the respondent authorities which is within the
jtar .;fiction of the Appellate Side of this Hon'ble Court.
28
9) That, the petitioner along with others made representations to
the respondent authorities but nothing has been done as yet so the
justice has been denied.
20) This application is made bonafide and for the ends of justice.
Under the aforesaid facts and
circumstances it is most humbly
prays that Your Lordship will
graciously be pleased to pass Rule,
Order, Direction as follows:-
a) A Rule do issue out and under
the Seal of this Hon'ble Court
asking the Respondents and each
one of them to show-cause as to
why a Writ in the nature of
Mandamus shall not be issued
commanding them thereby to send
the petitioner in training under the
Raina - II Block under the
29
respective Gram Panchayct as per
the interview and selection and
issuance of the appointment letter
and thereby allow them to send
training and to work in th.e
respective Gram Panchayets and
release the salary, allowances and
benefits month by month as per the
rules upon quashing and setting
aside the impugned report of the
three (3) Men Committee and also
the submission regarding th.e
cancellation of the panel.
b) A Rule do issue out and under
the Seal of this Hon'ble Court
asking the Respondents and each
one of them to show cause as ie
why a Writ in the nature of
Certiorari shall not be issued
commanding them thereby to
30
produce all relevant records in
connection with this application
and thereby to send the petitioner
in training under the Raina - II
Block under the respective Gram.
Panchayet as per the interview and
selection and issuance of the
appointment letter and. thereby
allow them to send training and to
work in the respective Gram
Panchayets and release the salary,
allowances and benefits month by
month as per the rules upon
quashing and setting aside the
impugned report of the three (3)
Men Committee and also the
submission
regarding
cancellation of the panel.
the
31
Rule NISI in terms of prayer a)
c)
and b) and make the rule absolute
upon hearing the parties.
d)
Ad interim order directing the
Respondents to send the petitioner
in training as per the appointment
letter issued by the authorities
the respective candidates and
thereby give actual posting in the
respective Gram Panchayets
/Villages as per appointment letter
and thereby release the salary,
allowances benefits month by
month till the final hearing of the
Writ petition.
e)
Ad interim order restraining the
respondents
not
to
give
appointment and/or not to process
further interview in respect of Asha
32
Employees under Raina - II Block
till the final hearing of the Writ
applica o
f) Such other order or orders,
direction or directions as will be
deemed fit proper and equitable
and for the ends of justice.
And Your petitioner, as in duty bound, shall ever pray.
33
AFFIDAVIT
I, Nirmola Santra (Malik), Wife of Dilip Kumar Malik, aged about 46
years, by faith Hindu, by Occupation House wife, residing at Village Mutlhabclihi, P.O. Madhabdihi, P.S. Madhabdihi, Dist. Burdwan, PIN.
713424, do hereby solemnly anal and say as follows:-
1)
That, I am the petitioner of the instant case and I am well
acquainted with the facts and circumstances of the case.
2)
That, the statements as made in paragraphs I., 2; 4 to 1.5, 17 to
19 are true to my knowledge and paragraph 3 is matter on records
and rests are my humble submission before this Hon'ble Court.
\17111in 010k &k41:\
Deponent is known to me
Prepared in my Office
)
C\l-Pq
P CVO-CDC-1"blClerk to: Mr. Swapan Banerjee
Advocate
Advocate
Solemnly afirmed before me
on this th1,3, day of May,
2016.
COMMISSIONER
I Cartify that all annexures
are legible.
Advocate
1
10 09.9.201
5
WP 12511(w) of 2012
Nandita Pramanik (Das) & Ors.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
ar
Mr. Rabi Shankar Chattopadhyay
Ms. Snigdha Saha
... For the Petitioners
Mr. Amrittal Chatterjee
... For the State Respondents
Mr. Atnritlal Chatterjee, the learned advocate
for the State respondents has produced -rater
dated August 31, 2015 written by the Mission
Director, National Health, Mission, to the Chief
Medical Officer of Health, Burdwan intimating
him that the approval of recruitment of ASI-IA in
respect of 12aina-II Block stood cancelled on the
basis of the report of enquiry committee
constituted by the District Magistrate, Burdwan,
on receipt of complaints of procedural
irregularities and lapses in preparation of the
panel and selection of ASHA.
By the present writ petition the petitioners
have, inter alia, prayed for approval of their
appointment and to engage them as ASI IA in
different sub-centers.
In view of what has been produced in Court
today to the writ petition the petitioners are given
2
liberty to challenge the same as a totally new
cause of action has arisen and since in view of
this communication, the prayer made in the writ
petition cannot be acceded to, I dispose of the
writ petition as infructuous with the liberty as
mentioned above.
Mr. Chatterjee is directed to submit the
copies of the records produced in Court today to
Mr. Chattopadhyay in course of today.
There shad be no order as to costs.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order,
if applied for, be given to the parties on usual
undertaking.
(Dr. Sarnbuddha Chakrabarti, J.)
Government of West Bengal
Office of the Chief Medical Officer of I iealth, Burdwan,
Khoshagan, Shyam Sayer East, 3urdwan
Memo No. P/CONC
Dated:
To
The State Mission Director (NRHM)
\istri
& Secretary to Govt. of West Bengal,
Health & Family Welfare Department,
Swasthya Bhaban, 4 th Floor, Wing-B,
GN-29, Sector-V, Balt Lake, Kolkata-91
Clr
.f'il'th reference to allegation regarding solution of ASHA in different Grain Pendia yet Linder horny
Ir
6 of Burdwan district, a 3 (three) Men Committee was constituted by the Distort Magistrate
per avian
The report alongwith direction of District Magistrate duly forwarded to this end vide no
113(Con)/Health dated 22 thl
March, 2012 is enclosed herewith which will speak for itself.
Now the matter is being forwarded to his end for information and necessary action towards re
examination of approval of the panel in view of irregularities & shortcoming noted in the enquiry
ratbort
is earliest response is solicited.
Chief Medical Officer 01 Health,
Burdwan
io P/CON/ 2
A (1_)
Dated 'LC C
Copy forwarded for information & necessary action.
isaltril The District Magistrate, Burdwan,
2) The Dy.CMOH-11.1, Burdwan.
Chief Medical Officer of Health,
Burdwan
jl
Government of West Bengal
Office of the District Magistrate, Burdwan
Health Section
4th Floor, New Administrative Building
Phone No. & Fax No. 0342-2567260, e-mail address- oc_health@rediffmail corn
Memo No.
yea 7‘/ /Health
Dated. lard
cl(2012
To
The Chief Medical Officer of Health
& Secretary, DR & SWS,
Burdwan
Sub: - Report of 3 (three) Men. Conlin ittee in respect of engagement of
ASHA under Raina —II Block.
Sir.
A copy of the note-sheet containing order of the District Magistrate, Burdwan in
connection with the matter as under subject is sent along with a copy of the report of the 3 (three)
Men Committee herewith for favour of your kind information and taking necessary action as per
order of the District Magistrate, Burdwan.
In this connection a copy of
the list of ASHA as approved by the Health Department a
copy of the Block Level Panel of ASHA of Raina — 11 Block and a copy of the order on formation
of 3 (three) Men Committee are also sent herewith for ready reference.
En clot- I) Report of 3 Men Committee —
4 Slice:a:
2) Approved list of ASHA —
4 Sheets.
3) Block Level Panel of ASHA —
13 Sheets.
4) Order on formation of 3 Men Committee — I Sheet.
Total .:-22 Sheets
Memo No.
iVem/Health
Yours Faithfully,
---gre VL2
14 District Magi trate,
Burdwan
Dated, Burdwan, •' jivlarch'2012
Copy forwarded for information to:I) CA to ADM (ZP), Burdwan
For District Magistrate.
Burdwan
l_IOVernIlIelli al
rf
Office of the District Magistrate, Burclwan
(Health Section)
Memo No.
/17
)
/ Health
Dated, Burdwan!BliiFcbru
2012
To
1) The Officer — in — Charge,
Health Section, Burdwan
2) The ACMOH, Sadar Burdwan
3) The BDO, Raina — II, Burdwan
Ref: - This Office Memo No. 8(6)/Health. dated — 05/01/2012
In reference to above you are requested to verify all original documents and records in
connection with engagement of ASHA of Raina — II Block for confirmation if there is any
irregularity in the engagement process and submit report immediately.
i
,l,Irtf:A
Additional Dist
agis rate (Z1-1),
Burdwan
Government of West Bengal
Office of the District Magistrate, Burdwan
(Health Section)
ORDER
A committee headed by 0/C, Health, Burdwan is hereby constituted, comprising of
ACMOH, Burdwan & BDO, Raina - II, Burdwan to examine all the original documents to
ascertain irregularities if any, in respect of engagement of ASHA under Raina - 11 Block. The
Committee will submit report by 15/01/2012,
District magistrate,
Burdwan
Memo No. 0
/Health
Dated, 13 urdwanyqamiary'2012
Copy forwarded for ind information and necessary action to:
ADM (ZP), Burdwan
2) CMOH, Burdwan
3) ACMOH, Burdwan
4) BDO, Raina - a, Burdwan
5) BMOH, Madha),Iihi BPHC, Burdwan
6) CA to DM, Burdwan
\---District Magistrate,
Burdwan
Government of West Bengal
Office of the District Magistrate, Burdwan
Health Section
4th Floor, New Administrative Building
Phone No. & Fax No. - 0342-2567260, e-mail address- oc_health r;7rediffinad.com
Memo No.
krt
/Health -Thr
e11-7
Dated, Burdwan
,Bt February'2012
To
The Officer- in- Charge,
RTC Meeting Hall,
Burdwan
Sub: - Booking of RTC Meeting Hall, Court Compound, Burdwan on
04/03/201245/03/2012 and 06/03/2012 from 11:00 AM to 5:00 PM
Hearing in connection with engagement of ASHA under Raina - 11 Block will be held on
04/03/2012, 05/03/2012 and 06/03/2012 at the RTC Meeting Hall, Court Compound, Burdwan.
You are requested to please arrange for booking the RTC Meeting Hall, Court Compound,
Burdwan on the said date and time.
For *net Magistrat 1 \,1 A-Burdwan
Memo No.
$
/Health-671ft
t-
Dated, Burdwan
tv,liebruary- 20 2
,
Dopy forwarded for information to:I) CA to ADM (ZP), Burdwan
For Dislriet Magisti
l.)64,1\-1 —
Burdwan
Report in
respect of verification of all original records per
12 nal
ement of ASHA under [Edna — 11 Block.
tainii
As per order of District Magistrate Burdwan, a thorough vedification is made in respect of all
original records including Advertisement Notice inviting applications, original applications, the relevant
register of the applications, application details, interview marks, compilation sheet and the panel — all in
connection with engagement of ASHA under Raina — Il Block.
The verification ofthe original records as aforesaid is made on 3 (three) different dates on and
from 04/03/2 012 to 06/0
3/2
012 at RTC Meeting Hall in presence of the Panehayat Level Selection
Committee Members called for the said purpose and the facts revealed in the course of verification of
records are stated in the Paras noted Panehayatwise below.
•
Poi
— Tr CP
') The G.P failed to show the original of the notice inviting application for ASHA, The Xerox copy
shown lacks any memo number and thus it has no record in GP's issue register. The GP also
failed to Produce any proof that this notice had actually been circulated.
2)
Original application form received for only 8 (eight) candidates who were rejected but for 18
(Eighteen) candidates who were called for interview, no original was submitted.
3) No Individual Score Sheets were found.
4)
Attendance sheet on date of interview was not found.
5)
Scrutiny of applications before interview was not done by all Members of Selection Com
but by the Prodhan only.
ntincc
6)
The GP Level Panel included one under aged candidate namely Sarama Kiska (Hanscia) vide
approved list SI. No. - 48, who is not eligible to be engaged in the post of ASHA.
Arui GP
I) The G.P failed to show the original of the notice inviting application for ASHA. The Xerox
copy shown lacks any memo number and thus it has no record in GP's issue register. The OP
also failed to put up any proof that this notice had actually been circulated.
,
2)
22 (Twenty Two) Applicants appeared in interview but out
of
these only 17 (Seventeen) original
applications were found. Rest 5 (five) applications are missing. No Register was maintained
entering details of applications.
3)
No intimation was sent to Applicants shortlisted for interview. Prodhan claimed that a general
notice having list of such applicants were walled up at GP Office only. Candidates collected the
call letter from GP Office only after seeing the list. Thus it is very clear that some candidates
who did not appear for interview were actually unaware of the fact that they were actually short
listed for inmrview, since they did not see the notice and did not come to GP Orrice to milk
their interviews call letter. Further no attendance sheet was found on interview due
4) Scrutiny of applications before interview was not done by all Members of Selection Ci
but by the Prodhan only.
tee
Knit)/ GP
I) Individual copy of the advertisement notice is not available except a receipted copy of the notice
served upon Mrigendra Prasad Library .
2) Register was submitted by Prodhan entering application details but it was not authenticated by
Prodhan nor it is signed by any Member of the Selection Committee.
3) In the original score sheet, whitener was found to have been used.
4) No proof of issuance oilcan letter was found.
5) Scrutiny of applications before interview was not done by all Members of Selection Committee
but by the Prodhan only.
Painta — I GP
1) A notice inviting application for ASHA was issued but the copy initially submitted to the BM01-1
did not have any memo number, but during hearing Prodhan produce anther notice bearing
memo number. But Prodhan failed to show any proof that this notice was actually circulated.
2) GP failed to submit any original applications Prodhan claimed that the original applications were
sent to the 13D0 earlier but failed to show sufficient proof.
3) Scrutiny of applications before interview was not done by all Members of Selection Committee
but by the Prodhan only.
4) Two Selection Committee Members namely (i) Suprava De, ANM Chotobainan Sub -- Centre
and (ii) Sipra Chandra, ANM Sherpur Sub — Centre have deposed to the effect that they have
signed the interview sheet but not allowed to put any marks thereon. It is also deposed that notice
in respect of ASHA engagement was not published in the respective area. As a result many
eligible candidates could not submit any application.
5) The CP Level Panel included 3 (three) under aged candidates namely Mithu Chaietjee
(Mukherjee), Rine Chakrabarty (Bhattacharjee), Tumpa. Samanta (Nandi) vide approved list SF
No, — 58, 59, 60 and anon—resident candidate Tapasi Rana vide approved list SI. No. - 63. who
are not eligible to be engaged in the post of ASHA.
Barabairmn G•P
1 The G.P failed to show the original of the notice inviting appfication for ASHA. The Xerox copy
shown lacks any memo number and thus it has no record in GP's issue register. The GP also
failed to produce any proof that this notice had actually been circulated.
2. 32 (Thirty Two) number of original application submitted by GP but no register was maintained
for entering the application details.
Ci. P
thiled lo
4. Score
show any proof chat call letters were issued Kr
IIILCIVICW.
sheets were prepared GP wise, not Sub-Centre wise. Also ANM of Barabainan Sub- centre
who should have been a member of the selection committee for her Sub-centre did
not
this
score sheet however she claimed that she did put marks in the individual score sheet 61sign
Health
Supervisor but did hot sign it.
5. Scrutiny of applications before intervie
but by the Prodhan only.
s not done by all Members of Selection Committee
Gotan C P
Pradhan of Gotan did not comply with the instruction of 131).0 to submit all original documents
and also did not appear for hearing before enquiry committee.
Based on some original documents which were available With BMOH till the date of hearing as
well as hearing of other member of Selection Committee following findings are made.
I No notice was made inviting application for ASHA.
2. No call letter was issued for interview.
3. No original individual score sheets were found.
4.
No register entering applications were shown to the committee. However 74 (Seventy Four)
original applications were sent to the EMOH.
Scrutiny of applications before interview was not done by all Members of Selection Comm ir
but by the Prodhan only.
ICC
•
Uchalan GP
I) The G.P failed to show the original of the notice
inviting application for ASHA. The Xerox copy
shown lacks any Memo number and thus it has no record in GP's issue register. The GP also •
failed to any proof that this notice had actually been circulated.
2)
Scrutiny of applications before interview was not done by all Members of Selection Committee
but by the Prodhan only. As a result two candidates Moynabati De (Nandi) and Ruma Medda
(Nandi) vide approved list SI. No. — 109 and 116, although actually under aged were called for
interview among others and even selected in
the final paiiel.
3)
Except EDO's representative, a different trend is generally observed in giving marks to
candidates for interview by the other Selection Committee Members. In case of BDO
representative the higher academic marks holder got higher marks in interview whereas in case
of
Other Selection Committee Members, the lower academic marks holder got higher marks in
interview.
4)
The Selection Committee Members namely (1) Sujata Chatterjee (Banerjee), HA (F), ANM
Aklakhi Sub — Centre, (ii) Maya Kundu, HA(F), ANM Keunta Sub — Centre, (iii) Purnima
Banerjee, HA (F), ANM Uchalan Sub —
Centre and (iv) Arpana Chowdhury, Health Supervisor
(F), lichalan
GP -- have given deposition that they have signed the interview mark sheet in which
marks
were already
given.
Pahalanpur GP
)
1) The ('3.P failed to show the original of the notice inviting application for ASHA. The Xerox cop
*dOn lacks any memo number and thus it has no record in GP's issue register. The GP also
failed to any proof that this notice had actually been circulated.
2) Scrutiny of applications before interview was not done by all Members of Selection Committee
but by the•Prodhan only.
3) No Register was maintainedtntering details of applications.
4) Attendance sheet on date of interview was not found.
In the sequence of the facts as stated above, it is evident that the Panchayat Level Panels in
respect of engagement of ASHA under Raina — II Block contain procedural irregularities and lapses.
And the Block Level Panel prepared by accepting all such Panchayat Level Panels, therefore,
automatically comes to be termed as equally irregular from the point of view of the procedures ought to
be followed in the engagement process as per the Govt. guidelines.
Submitted
\ .c
BOO,
Raina — II Dev. Block,
Burdwan
ACMOR,
Burdwan Sadar,
Burdwan
I
Ofificerif- — Charge,
Health Section.
Burdwan
opytiiiii n' a .
Paina 1i Kant
Burdwan Rama II
Burdwan Raffia II kaira
: 3• N. Distil r t
:.`,!''.' :.e...)..t.
Black
: Purdwan
_
3
F4., : mon
Borojoata
4 Burdwan Raina II Kaity
5
Burdwan Raina II Kaity
6
Burdwan Raina II Kait)
7
Burdwan Raffia II Kairy
8
Burdwan Raffia II Kaity
9
10
Burdwan Raina H Kaitv
Burdwan Raina II Kaity
Burdwan Raffia II Kaity
Burdwan Rana II Kaity
I l'
12
3
14
.15
16
10 18
19
20
21
22
t_23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
Burdwan Rama 12 Kaity
Raina il Kaity
Raina II Kalty
Raina II Ka),
Raina II Kaity
Burdwan Raffia II Kaity
Burdwan 'Raina 11: Barabainan
Burdwan Raina II Barabainan
Burdwan Raina II Barabainan
Chandana Karmakar
Jasoda Ray (blandol
Chant pa Begam
PriHknn q.
Kaity
Sarathi Mandl (Soren)
Kaity
Kai
Shahan( Ray rehatterjeC
Rita Konar
Chalkchandan
Chaitali Biswas (Sarkar)
Hafiza Begam
Maim Begam
Subaldaha
Subaldaha
1 Subaldaha
Subaldaha
Kamargoria
Kamargoria
Kamargoria
Deno
Deno
/
. Nandita Pronlimik (Dat ,
Kaity
1< ifv
Barabainan
Barabainan
Barabahran
Barabainan
Burdwan Raina [I Barabainan
Burdwan Raina II Arui
Burdwan Raina II Arui
Burdwan • Raina II Arui
Burdwan Raina II Arui
Burdwan Raina II Arui
Burdwan Raina II Arul
Burdwan Raina II Arui
Burdwan Raina II Arai
Burdwan , Raina Il Painta H
Burdwan Raina II Paints II
Boroipota
Kaitm
Chalkchandan
Chalkchandan
Chalkchandan
Barabaina'n
•
Barabainan
Burdwan Raina 1
Burdwan • Raffia II Barabainan
IBurdwan Raina II Barabainan
Burdwan Raina II Barabainan
Burdwan Raina II Barabainan
Burdwan Raffia II Barabainah
Burdwan Raina II Barabainan
Burdwan Raffia II Barabainan
Burdwan Rama Ii Barabainan
......
Plyall Pal tEtarn :
Riziva Khatun
Chalkehandan
Chalkchandan
Burdwan Raffia II Barabainan
.
.
iBurdwan Raina II Barabainan
Burdwan Rana II Barabainan
Burdwan Raina II Barabainan
I3urdwari Raffia II Barabainan
•
hivr: a El rgit(
Boroipota
Kairy
Buadwan
Burdwan
Burdwan
Burdwan
.1..'u ..
Manu Misra
Mausumi Nandi (Mandal)
Sabari Das () Sin all)
Chli'ancla Ghosh
Ruparani Hati
Abhaya Ghosh
Bharati MAI-Jerk
Bibha Dutta
Rita Pal
Sonali Dey
Usha Malik (Dolui)
Gulsonara Khatun
Nistarani Bag (Karak)
Anjana Ghosh
Jamuna Chauli
Deno
Radharani Malik
Madhunfala Korey
Tanuja Karmokan
Anima Pal
Deno
Rama Gor
Deno
Sum itra Ghost]
Madhabdihi
Aniuma Begam (Khatun)
Madhabdihi
Madhabdihi
Madhabdihi
Madhabdihi
(
- Pasanda
Pasanda
Nirmala Santa (Malik)
Tapasi Ruidas (Pramanik)
Kalpana Choudhury (Das)
Dipali Ghosh
Pasanda
Parma
Sankari Ghosh (Rana)
Bangni Pal-(Royt)
Tanuja Saha (PoreD
Dipali Nandi
Painta
Kakoli Nandi (Kundu)
Page 1 of 3
-
—I
LIST OF ASHA.-RA/NA El BLOCK
Block Gram Psnefiava Sub centre
N rue of ASli A
Palma II
Paint
,,,
1252111Painta II
nu Si a
Raina II Paints fl
ma sku (Hansday
Burdwan
Bulchand
d IL
MilPainta If
u,
Buis
Pain ra ft
Du /chandra nv
Inall1111
Burdwan
aulehand raper M S
ane
Burdwan
Buichandra ur
I./Zara Koley (De)
Burdwan
Bulchandra ur
anchita Manch)/
Burdwan
Buichandim ur
llama D
Burdwan
Chotobainan
N ibedita D e
Burdwan
Chotobainan
Suohitra Chakr bai
Burdwan
Chotobainan
Mi hu Chatter'
Burdwan
Chotobaintin
m a Chakraba
Burdwan
Chotobainan
Tu
Sam
Burdwan
Chotobainan
Sabi Ba
Burdwan
Sher ur
Mon k Ba
Burdwan
Painta I
Rana
Burdwan
Painta I
~Saima Bectim
Burdwan
Gotan
ha
bMi Hui (Dan)
Gotan
Rune
Kundu (Handi)
Burdwan Raina
II Gotan
oilers Khatun (Be• am)
Burdwan Raina II
Gotan
anika Sarkar (Das).
Burdwan
Gotan
S kba Pramanik M
Burdwan
Kamarliati
Manika Pakhira Paine )
Gotan
Kamarhati
Afroh..Khatun
Kamarhati
Mahabuda Khatun (Be am)
Burdwan Raina
Kamarhati
11
arida Khatun (Be am)
Burdvvan Raina
Soma Ghos/ D
Burdwan Raina E
utta
Ch
Ch
ee
Burdwan
Anuva Partra (Sineha)
Burdwan
Soma
Saha
Burdwan Raina II
Sauli Chatterice (CliakraboiV)
Burdwan Raina
II
Sabitraa
Ruidas (Malik)
Burdwan Raina II
Gotan
AnitaE3a• (Malik)
Burdwan
Gotan
T an Nandi (Kundu)
Damin a
Sk Sakila Hazari
enu a Si
(Ban)
Darin a
Burdwan
Burdwan
Burdwan
Burdwan
Burdwan
Dam in a
Damin
Susmita Bhaumik ebi th)
Sabina Yasmin
Sabita Paul D
Babita Pal Kundu
Bamali Karmakar
Rains II
Bandanaand(
beclita Pal
ahalan u
rood ur
Page 2 of M
ma Mondal
nara Pe rya
1.1ST OE .1611d. HAIN:). II rd GCS.
INoll
t
C"1111111,11l1221-1)u11LLijSS
NOLIO: OC ASUA
of jihudyan Rama 11 Paha lan au
[13 inodou r
Hire,
Des (Ba: kl
) I Windy. an Raina 11 fradgiln."---- HTdirr
ior 77— - Baru Saikar
P Fiala »ur
Binsacluiu
riga Bank
Butd1VH11 Rains 11 Pahnlu
Binodlrur
Maluku
Malik
Burdwan Raina 11 Pal ala )1,1r
hum 1,1 13OO.1111
98 Burdwan Raina II
Pahalan ur
B lekumar ur Iona Mondal
99 Burdwan Raina II
Pahalan ur
028=31 hhanda Ghosh
100 Burdwan Raina I/
Pahalan ur
Bajekuniar stir
Ialata Roy
101 Burdwan
Biekulnar ur
fa B a n
Bundwan Raina II
Ba'ekumar. ur Panchi Das
Burdwan Raina II Pahalanour
Ba ekuna Su ta Mondal
Raina
Pahalan. ur
IraUchalan
Burdwan Raina II
114
15
116
119
120
121
122
124
125
BurdWan Raina 11 Uchalan
Burdwan Raina II Uchalan
Burdwan Raina 11 Uchalan
Burdwan Raina II
Burdwan Raina II Uchalan
Burdwan Raina II
Burdwan Raina II
Burdwan Raina H
Burdwan Raina II
Burdwan Raina II
Burdwan Raina II Uchalan
Burdwan Raina II Uchalan
Burdwan Raina H
Burdwan Raina II
Burdvvan Rahn H
Burdwan Raina II
Burdwan Raina Il
Burdwan Raina H
Burdwan Raina II
Burdwan Raina H Uchalan
Burdwan Raina II Uchalan
_
Ba ekulnar ur
UchaIan
Suchitra Kundu Sarkar)
Uchalan
Lakhi Mahato
Ucl alan
Lakh is Ha ldar (Kundu)
a
Uchalan
Uchalan
Uchalan
Uchalan
Uchalan
Keunta
AklakIn
AkISkni
r ka Khatun Be.
oynabaoti De (Nandi)
Subhra Kundu (Nandi)
shun Kundu (Puma)
lannista Biswas (Duna)
Krishna Handal (Dhara)
Kalani Malik
Maenoka Mandal
Rams Medda (Nandi)
Hena Pandit Dhabok
Priti Das
Chintamoni Pandit
Indrani Ghosh
Lata Ghosh Pal
unp Chakraborti (Bhanac h
Pampa Duct Pa'
Reh
2
Siena Saha Kahan_
Kalidasi Saunas MaNk
Kal.ana Hemrom Mandl
Page 3 of 3
H
•
IFF;41 7crair 3W11:4
Thle'3 113 c-n";7:1-si 4 TM Fla
7G-141
t18 - rd,
C
TYk Cm <? F.51 - qoo c)87
-
RIM
cat8e,
'f,`I
.cFt
1,
ASHA
11./1
j.roc, ;SH
)1171,1 1,1-81
71.Cgit—c,
1 ,71;.1
)4
81
78e,-1,51
t-71
ikTtm
4=W
.,:c5.•
boo
>!),11-Gi
'1
L1- 1(
•9121771
c.,
ASHA
117;
11)--7,i 1^Tal 1,1(?9 Ut883-V kr!
ei11.1)( \15/
R74
Vmr
rr„,rsf
CrIsfiFFQ-1
50
..8
7Sc
<19,8
5)
11r•A
-I
-7d
7t7WITIT ()A. e
80 a•
%Al
759t
7;w-cc!
,INE-r=7
-c
r}tam- c-cr
i 11,.;„/
1A17-4-1 7171
AL Aic
— 117111447/1
72
171
1.7r;17
m?));
»)
1(.1). W7177/7 14CA-w 1C)-T2
II ZTh Tq3I1f; 1I7C-Accw W1,14CA 1c
17%0)11 1
8) WITN9w 714417
1111121)3 / T1'511 °t vie „' fA1
11W1 1•7I
- 2C\t 7/51 *71
(t)11CAW/-w- /774J.Wrw
., -7 WWI TC
7;17.- 11trir5t L77)11I‘c €1-M w!:,
di/A 1) A111-r) AA,*
1K
15:27,..3 ,?R17.7
e, W11 1 kATA/1
L117,17R -CWIn
FrV
i
- bo
CrlThW
In7C -o %
\) 5153* t;,-Wrf
t‘rcT
y4r
witFime
T(t)cc5 virk7:4.)1 c!Fr71,
51**tX',r
. 5m,
111-)73
I4-A)Wil)/31
`K-N1194
47711WIRE5 3711): 4-11e1e/.7.1Th 1,7,1117,1,
.AR s
(1/WQ,
I
74W73pw-c
ciI)vdc, 1S1A 7)4; CWICA)A1 WIC71
t1)11;71 \11r4ICIACI-7/q
\n) 11711k - •q11:41711
. ITTC.
17.7AM 51111r
7,Z7ri
) (7\
117:-A144c't7A1 511C4:
-17://, s)ZCA)
h̀all 7C
40
ti 8) 771217
(111)1IA / 1 9furlftk. 1E1171R W17.74)W
tit; ?WI?"
I75517411
117 3
P4716/4 44;17.75 v1.•tA1
914<ric?,1(..9
414.11‘
311AR v7A/C5 7A-t:C41
Ii<R"
c.
7
.a/11-1 71%
3:
TrIt 1
"( ..717111?.
itc: 14Ft1 %ITN 9i437
P
v„1\ 51(.\.n
,3k^1
9
ft) g17 91c(.<[
-4C\-, C11
DO -4
91'7
-9&7
-
citWt< c'M
5_• \51D11-1”= 7174711
(...117,9 circ4 tHifti 4tai
Wiq 7511 7121 ti—
.C711:PrVi6 k4ZT -
VT ‘.9 90-4M ‘"1.(1.i 51 11, \D
9
"TRTFS- ktr -
PV
\5•11.
ctaltr•-)
G-G7GI1 "Trief1 \e 9124•M- G111.-{
citsaltcn
WW
7ra
V--11:6''mei5H,M
t
Ter,;\
-
aiJ FfN
14115
1 .3
7.7nc;ii
.‘e
4;01-ck`,T
`?1"< V,Ft
`ict
car
Y:3Qi Cy-i
(1`5•1) ?D`trl
au '04541 ‘%ifal il -T3 INT' C1 ?tr:1tD3- .*:41 11W 9.r41C<Lc5
<7f1:1 Cs517,1
9fSr; '2"1-TD D') 5
f,_1517
;:cl
.7f7•(,
yff:•1? c:77•1-, (37;1
2j3 I
50) cirsTI
Viii 9t8vm
gS.) ,-DDS' '051 tl"--sCcl A4
`T -rair :citiNciczt...
"11 411\ D kC' 1;114
"d[51-1 ID<N,
.42:101 4fikl-CDD
L.:n(1Z
551f*K1
4.15-NtIGTh
5"1 13G>1•W3,
.2;,`-, 2vc,,r0m)
-11Q1C<D6
`1
N-4, AZ<
otr ADri•
7,M;
`111SH:
crICc5 '2'1(511 3 T qTc01.-i
_
)f V4
r<71 ,A
1211 717
( \D)
!
\s, Ht2<17.
IN-frtiTift7 12711V1 ;IV= 2i".(71- C7,571 T.V5111
4)Rtn
ataliz.
i cr
crr
(8) .9
'')74 1a-1
\n3
koob-
as
-R7V-<fi.
LiRt
\=\14:141=e <P,
t(IT 7,
7-qt
ti c5-f1',r-Hzi-cr
t
71Qca-titces!
)1514
3 V'-31 5117-1; \t,';
tt.7.71
c.! v<reim
'1E'uf
<PkG•tjt,t
61. Ue., Ts1
(
-nitnnn
Ce7G1
I
75191.5t`t7
nb nal:1;
1nn
tin
Ca!
w;tif
GT•7 L.,:CD TM.g\
4.-
22!91
4raT
fr
rt.
v.
- PS
ifts5n
rgit-
, r)
k)
: ( C‘I-Mfer t--- -5
NM
'Yr-- CrI14
,,,---
a)
a)
Wit it.-ti (ftrafU 'Tk)
:
e1.--i,
_ r_c2
ri-t(o(134-4727;),(2,
: 02_1 (3i
wlqt
t)
owowkrao wArAt -49-1
s).
mixt 9maict, ‘5.
:
a3 2R
D'c, C
'g c '4V: (360)
61
.a
Ztif WR 9
b)
, 734r-77-%
,
Blur tctc-4.tiN
9rawt* yr:4.4 "14 711
111 -
thiocr '2-4°
tra---1
I 2 <II
6-4 Cc?: Cot; •rfu5-1\r-
f
re1410SO
[C€4ft
M8be
dta, 5aidwa
urmm
BR.SzEWS.
. hi..
Mri( I
LI, unr1
AIN ntlIttLk}'
Welfare Samity
... 5?4!.
.Distrlet
Governittell( of West Bengal
No.
To,
4111--nnaNta,
Snut./Mst
Village
Gram Panehayat
District
....
Sub: Selection for engagement as ASHA
Madam,
This
is
‘i
\`
to
inform
Cp. t
Smt./Mst.
Wife of or Widow of
01‘1,...eaystl cliAL
-A
Gram Panchayat,
Village,
Block,
District, that you have been selected for
engagement as ASHA for ...ftesgs
,cs&loA1.
-Pry.
Subcentre, under
Gram Panehayat to serve as a link between Me Government
- Health Systems, Panehayati Raj Institutions, ANMs and the Community of your
resident village.
You are therefore requested to report to the Secretary, Block Health arid Family
Welfare Samity of your Block between .
It t 0 ^ tt.
A
1,9f: M
Rtnt
and
261-1. on working days between 10 A.M. and 4 P.M. At the time of
reporting you shall have to bring Medical Certificate in the enclosed format, from a
registered Medical Practitioner having at least MBBS degree, along with original
documents/ certificate in support of your age, educational qualification, residential
status and marital status for verification, Your appointment is. provisional subject to
production of original documents as to proof of age, residence, educational
qualification, marital status and medical fitness. It may be reiterated that selection will
stand summarily rejected if any one of the documents produced by you are found to
be ingenuine.
On engagement as ASHA you will be imparted a compulsory residential training of
23 days in five phases, spread over a period of one year after engagement. You will be
reimbursed TA (based on annals) subject to provision of necessary proof by the
MNGO for attending the training. Your fooding and lodging will be arranged by the
MNGO during the training period(s).
You have to compulsorily attend the five phase training to be conducted by the
MNGO of your district failing ivbieh the engagement sdall stand automatically
cancelled. You will have to report to the ANM of your respective Subcentre and the
PRI of your village and perform your duties in close coordination with the ANM,
AWW and other health system functionaries at the village level,
Note: ft may be noted that ,ASHA will be entitled for performance based
:
t ,compensation only after completion of second round 4 days training. She will also be
eligible for payment for conducting household survey in her area. This will be
provided as per approved guideline.
Yours faithfully,
—7->"‘"SCt
ecre* ite4e14Sallti
gloolc
BHFW Salinity
No.
Health
C 4174caltiry
soxfanDi
Dated:
Copy forwarded for information/ necessary action to the:I. BDO,
Block
2. Pradhan
Gram Panchayat
3. Health Supervisor
4. ANM,
Subcentre
5. CDPO,
Block
Secretary
STEW Samity
Block
cs hidit;t,1- Ha-t-ittAalZ
t, I/
1
t -tr; (-Lc t A Cal
r2) t.li Cit)- a \ I
01\
" 7-67?-
C
e'lrl
d-4‘49Intra'Cnif.f,APrus-QT,e
-F
-47.01
4? c.Writ‘Cc?,
5O`carcri-
747
tvirmEt-rzt
-F
2.--741\-Q)
a- clord
i tv-KFT.5•16.
c-"A`rdr 5'674
--SQL 913_R c
e
-2,3'n
,-{\--n-s-r.,5,-,7 -77
my-Cidy-c-S-TiX5V'n -15t4; C°4rgS .""kKt
`i
c-Turrvr.-aS" 5-1-cr,7
qsa-strn.
'iV tc l3 .1,4, 0.14 va-(1-s-c\--91t213.
(kr6fttcp-i-74
lid
r-F
a I
57U-3
iKs ''Th‘
r„
C94‘75-PCM
\--47S" c`iW Pc- D
ccccr
a
::CZZ
t), tvl
4,(\s-a-cr
'
01%2
D\R'sR107
zfiiPS 7kCiitrro
`71-7
eiccil,
Z.
RIALF \M
bc,17,1
r-?1a•rs--
.21V
fcizSTC_T POT `C.C.TYTT .x\- 1
-
ciipcoFt ,
cj
i
7;\
C9,1
17r7PC
F(C--TC\-c2+-
I Al)
frcirth.
G‘5
\-!_4
(617VITS.
LhfcrOF
--251;71Q.2_74
ccct-)
?C'e <5‘C\--b-CCQ16 ')N-arin-z)
-Thrh-lter
c„lcv-.5,(727
.\Qtr.!si- j'A
a. Lystig-s
63 415-
sa
0, I
'AD
j
Zl
c--cv-FC
-6:- 5-47
-Tptn-Q.sd
2,
6J ef'\ ?,
r, ‘
C'S_
iv? zry..c--6
•
cc
4
\--3)-• r7:
T.
-17+1) zcl
• ).•.ti.
-
1
'
OCZSILANN--0›,_
14-, / 204
Roy ,
A."0. 6)_;
1. 51123.tr
2, GA-am 0AD cc ki\Woot.
cr31-cr(4-191)
Oal
cLekifes? 4fee
'
6Aro-\% WS a
C9-04(34)
,,
CavEk
Qc505
cl\trclvf
4
Osiar,
(---;_m5-1-)
(en/
T:ril9:19
y.
(01)
S;CS
-
ckg-2.1)
-6 4A#V
rr
7A-- •
L_c 4)
1-4-04:4
3,ff
/
To
The C2, •
p
^0.-17\0., 2- NO !C bcis
-Madka,6 clih;
,rdw an
W1.,
k 27 zrz”
__c
am
-Cl•Nrr.-C17
Yx(74177 "faiV?,
71-Arrcilb )M\ acra
11714-'S-5
FaZ‘4F-
\-M-a sTen 'c,
i3. 1;1 • 0' 1+ -Znb
-Fat-Lira-Apr-A •Ocrey,1 4-To
c)4
xsr
-`,PSCCZ-(P,
97B- I ‘'-'67V67S
11' I`#1, • Pr - re1 -261-(YL
‘..rt-7.11;a
err, eA•G.Ar-
ip
-fra-L.77-
c-ci-10•2•2
M;
R M, 0, 4
asa (,),,fccnicfaso
6° 4r6
A :_;`
,D5r-ae•G
--rPb1L5'
')41-(P1-61Z
4 0 L9
cm
C,S7Z6.1?'"CA
M L'n"1-re.“136-'66-Q7
'FK4
,v4 co‘
6 Fr
gra R-1-b
-16-rrelno
b_a
Cfp-W21
-767-(71671 -SF ; 13.
;T
o•
-22A2
\nty a}1,gFws norrdos• k 20
--c-rcWCz
c-->
-(L'ATLX-.z7Nrz5m-a- Th-V'SeAkt \-'6)-rzi
R=2:s_
wera
‘b-ii--Fa
3-6,cc
fst-ex-
u‘-eNk\-Avc-c'h-
gx~i
20
-Ne`K°1Z^7%-cl `-airs-I 115N
‘I Aypc \
eyt? "z5swS- -&-9-0•6-211
s.)?-a-c-e-c,„-c,,_
-ctAA cw(cli-c
batrA
9-11
or, to--
OA\
o.c`° --e
\\*3)9*
1
)
air3G-i - cx_
-•e/ Z5
oc is-101)
`5 ) I KrAl y51
c4,.)
r)
2) --000n c4 (qsi,)
%
0'
erft
..•••
,)
sif(Th
,)
tick
cr\
cc
6„)
) ?)-47
gui--4-RrEccicrbyt
(5( -534- -sfizr(9W
11-ae\A)
rertrry-Th '
3-el
>-(t
c\07‘CaCt5Y
7`"Y <41 .
Pair\ G
fl7Thi CciTh
kL
-;%>i
--&Y---51\24\1- gCtk
v 0)) rstt'- xvimaz+
vxicciaTt
23 I
as
,NNtri-c,
z2-
/
-ThSrs!19 arts) Cpl )
&yell c2:
(
Q, 3t,
-
CA0,5Qc3q,‘L
4co--024-
vA
-Lot° -aaCrb--9
cak(W- cif-C;7
C
r1-.6
--r-oNta?trac-Wbecs
3
1
atnag-
Cataq-c n a --CArtrsAt'67)
C.9;"Atr
‘634"P-L,
StC
C;9
'
--,Zrisgrtrtir
-72g,,Sttra agra-6-WZ,
t/. 41A
Z4r
-CDri7Z-C44 471CW? tS\
oc4.
(
ncf
-"P
tsCn{Wte,
%z-G, ta
t\
*67 Rr
-\-6
cnkci.p
liCkebr "3e 'elf—CZ
r) G
c_tet-zp t_3‘ pyg,-Ta
°a-\MCC
co-c-cts\ls?
C2- \
CS'SV
—835-qt6v.
-1
5nce" ‘6717
Thl>
etkepar NA) CtkA,6 ieS tnyc
rev*\ -Lc otcr624'1(0, 2, 2.4)5) &I; L.5-fr4c -1
o4-:(-67>e<
c/A tsf-%1 ‘47<`L :
Ca-a0tealet
<ra-
\Jae - c1-4344-a`11-11 Co
WAS - cr-orLoti 2kr;
cv?P
(
DISTRICT: BURDWAN
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
IN THE MATTER OF:
(W) of 2016;
W.P. No.
An application under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
-And IN THE MATTER OF:
Nirmola Santra (Malik)
...Petitioner
-V e r S U s -
State of West Bengal & Others
...Respondents
WRIT A P P L I C A T 1 ON
Advocate on Record:Mr. Swapan Banerjee,
Advocate
High Court at Calcutta,
Bar Association,
Room. No. 10.