Georgetown University Law Center
Scholarship @ GEORGETOWN LAW
2010
Constitutionalism: A Skeptical View
Jeremy Waldron
New York University School of Law, [email protected]
This paper can be downloaded free of charge from:
http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/hartlecture/4
This open-access article is brought to you by the Georgetown Law Library. Posted with permission of the author.
Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/hartlecture
Part of the Constitutional Law Commons, and the Jurisprudence Commons
!
"
#"
$
$
$%
&'"
"$
(
""
""
)
!
"
*
"
"+
,
*-"..
*
+
$.
/#,
0
%*.
.$)112'$)34%
5!
'
)
,
$
$.0,
%
$!
$263'$78
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1722771
9
$
$(8:
#
##
$7
;,
.*"
"".
"
<
,(
=
"
"
6$
""
""
3&4>
$&
""
""
8*9?.:@,**;*:@#A,:B#?C.#@,*#*?,%-"?..
9)11D';E$)11D
7#
C#$ $64,FC#.;,?AC?0)34
%)114')32
6A!,
$!"#$$18@;AC2)8
%)112'$GG
3%-
'
4.,
)114)1169
)
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1722771
"
$5
"%'
#
$
,H
(
,
$
/5/
"
.
"$
D
*%&$
$"
"$/IJ
2#
.
"
,
&$
D.
&D4*+AC818
*+AC$)112,H$#"$KL#
.
K"<*.
K"K?,-@@-#.:@,**;*:@H
:B#C.9*?.*,#@K!;AK?C,
BA
"
81D
2%&$
$*"D4K
*
)@$
*L".
DD2*2B
2M)*""
.
8
($("
%&'
,"H%'
%'
"
$
""
?"
&
"#&
(
"
1:$$
$
5
"C",&
$
+
%'H
"$"
"
:$
""N"
1#0K.?F$@*C:K;.*:@*:*9?,*;KF:B*9?A#:B*9?.:@,**;*:@$?"
26%
HA.
$2D)'$8D3$
#
O
;,$O
;
?"
C:-?C,.C;*:@$#K.*:@#CF:BE:A*.#A*9:;-9*%AH
2D)'$27
7
$+
$
%
'$)
"
"""
K%'?"
#
$"
"
",
%
' %
+(
"
;,'!"
"
$$$
?"
"
/@$
/
$$
"
()*
)#$*
*
9!$C*%."H.";E$223'$.D
)3
6
!
E"
"$
"
"
+$+$
($
"$8
,!
(
##
(+
:$ " 7
#"
"$"
"
$
""
$!
""
$&
#
+9
""'
8.#
$$!0HIJ"N$
""O
7!E
"
$*..
A
?$ (! $81%227'612$61H!$$
$/
"
"
"
O
"
P
"
$
$
Q
$&
Q&
3
$
OO
"""
$
6
"
"
+
<
5
%'
"
<*;L
"+$!
C"3D2$#;414$?
.#24$9C"#22D$
CE
#2D)111
"
$
""&
"
"
6#
+9
$$$'$-"
.A
%
HAB$)11'$
4
$"
(*
)
!)*
I#J
"
$>
"$
"
"
*
O3
:$
"*5
"
"
$
@R
.#2D3:
"
$
"
$
,.283:
$(
"
"
"
"
,?."+,4
#
?"
36;,84%D18'$44
4"+,D.C7%..E
I31J'H#O
$
$("
H
""$"$
$
$("
O
D
"
"
"
:
9
&
H.
"
"
"D:
"#
"
#
+9
"
2! "
!$
5:
H
5
9#$#$
."
$
D
99
[email protected]:E?K#:B*9?,:.#A,.?@.?,)66
%?,
"#
$28'$C,L$
$.:@,**;*:@#A,HE9A:,:E9.#AB:;@K#*:@,3%A#
+
$22D'3
2B$B?K?C#A,*S7DH
$$
$"$
""<*
#!
+$"
>
$"
$
"B9
$B?K?C#A,*S48H*
"
"$$
$
"" $
"
$,
B?K?C#A,*S)1$
!
"
2
("$$$
"
$O
($
)1
*
""#
"
"
*&
""
;L$$
$$"
H(5
"
&"N
"(
>K
+
%
'/+$$
")
>
!
)19#$(!%9HE"!$248'$64
)"+
"
$ $
%:+H.
E$222'$325D4
1
B$5
$
+
:+$
"
$
"5+"
"
))#
$
$
("
5"
$
">
$$$
"
,
$(
+
"$
$!
$@
""B
5
$
#$
$
>/B
:
))%B+
$"#
"
$
"""
<'
B$
+
""5
*
"5*
"
%';L"
$
$"
"
"
"$""$
%&'AL"
55#
#
+
""&
B&+
"
,
";
$$C
A$
(
)
")8
"$
"$"
@
,-&(
$*
#T,(V
$-!*
.)7,(V&$
,9
IJ""
*
"
)6*
.,
"(
)3!"
""
$"
.9
$
>
H
"
")4
)8.AAB
$)
$C?%@9HF
;E$
232'$23
)7,-$$*
%."H9;E$222'#T,(V$$-!*
.%!H.
?E$222'
)6,(V$$+
)3.C,$.
@K
$#! (! $1%2D4'$
7)$787583
)4.9
$)%H.
;E$
271'$)7%>-$$6'B$
>
*
&N.
B$
W"
NW".
B$
-!
*
&86583
%723D'
8
,H
$
$
"
.
%
"',
)D*
5"$
5
"$5"
"
#
$"<#&
$
<.
*
"$
%,-&
.
",'@$
/
"$"$
"/*
"
&
"
*
"
""
$
&"$
)D@,
$*A
B$
$$ /$,
9%."H;."E$22D'$8
7
""
"
$+
$
<&
C$$
"H
""""#
$
"
"
,
"/"$"
"
$*
"
$
"
"
!
&
+
B$
$
*
("
6
.
"
(
$
"/
"/
"*"
"
$
$*
"&!
(
$
"
"
"
$
""E
N5
$
(+
"$
"
$"
)2
)2.A!$.
.N"E#
"$
0$38%)11)'$)D6$)D4,
K"
,$#E0
!
:C"H*@.
$0 ($$8%2235D')4$
)2581HI.J
$
"$
"#+$
NO
3
#"+
$
$<,
$
$
"
!
$H
"
5
$
N
$">
(+
$$
"
"
&
("
"
&
"
"$
$>
$"$
E
$
"
"$ "$
A"
"$("
5"
+"".+
4
)3.,#$>
"
"
N">"
"
"
$"
" "
>+"
"" ,#
-81F
C
A
"%)3'$
"
>
C
AC
A
"
"$
"$
""+
"
"#"
"C
A
"
BM
!"$"
"+
"
"
"
(
"
C
A$
"
81-!(!-1223%',#73%..'
D
>"""
"
"
$
.
(+
8EH&!
"5
$
H$
$>*
$@"
"
"/>$/
,$/
/
$$> (
>
"*;
,/
>
/
> 0/!"
046B))11%2D8'$"E
"IJ!
C"
""
"8)"E
8L$$2
8)EH
2
"
$
"
"
>
-)
$
%
"
'
<BH
(
*,9
,!88
"
"
$
"
$87%
'
#
"N
$"
88,#!$
.74568%)118'
87.$A"A"
)1
"$
$
*
$
$
(
""
"">
*
!
"+,(V&$IJ IJ"
86
!
"
$
$>
"
#
N
""
$"
"%'
5"
86,(V$$)
)
"
$
>+$
"
$"
+$
B
$
H(
/
5"$
""
$
"
"
?>
%'
"
$+$(
""
+?""
!
"H
"
"
"
N "
"
/K/"
"+
"
))
"
+83"
$
$
$
"5
$
"
"
"
5"5"$
*
84
""
8D
./
$0)
1
$
"
"
83.K&
"
HK$$)3D548*
"
#(
"%"
"
(
'$" ""
"
!
"
&
$
("
#
"
"
"
84B+
$
"$
""$,
$B"
K$9AC$)1%)114'GGG
8D*
9# $#&.
E
K0
%'
$#%."H.";E$)11'
)8
$
"H9""
(<
$
$
+
<
!>
$>9
<
<
>
%
+$+
$
"
("'<9"
"<#
$
"
>H9
4
$$
<
55
"$
N$$
$$
"*
)7
$$
" $
("
*
.
C"
?"
$"
82
$
"
"
#
$"$!
$>
$
>
"
$
>
>
"
$
"
%
'
#>
"
$
$
82".
C"&+
374EHI*J
?"
" $$
&
""
"&&%*K-
.
#$E$
)2:374$#,%'&$!%."H."
;E$22D'$18'
)6
>
(
"
"
+
/
"
%&
>
'H
E
>
H*
>
$
"
"%
"$+$$
'$"
"
>
$
71
#"5!'7.
""">
$
B#
$
,.&$
(+
#
"B#
+
$
>
$
71%*
"
#
0%7'
"$
"/B&"5
/"!"+$7D;,
%D72'
781,.D43%)11'
)3
"
""#
%)'$
7#$
6$4$2$)3#$
$
""
"
"+
"
"$*
(
"
"
"
:
"
"
$
!""
$6
$"
,$
+
$
"
&
)4
(
7)"
$">(78
"
"
H
77""
"$"
""@
+""@
"%#
>"
"'!"
5"$
+
"
"
&2$
7)C#,$E
B
H,.B
.$
(! $D4%222'$76$78D
78,,
N@K
$9
:
,
E;,H?
,E
;(<
7! (! $72%)117'$3
77,$"$AKL$!*0
(! %@FH:+;E$)117'B
$%#"'
E"5A
K.
< $7%222'$D
,
*$/$ %EHE
;E$)111'
)D
:
#
$
$
"/E
O
./"
,$+
$;,,.)
!")
"
"
"
$"$
$
$
"
(
"
""
76
@
C!"">"
"
%'73#$
(
76)
!")6;,84%D18'$43
73,$"$C?!$*E
,<.
-"E
,"$280AC4)2%)114'
)2
(74#$
"
"
""
"
"
>
5
7DB#$
"B+
/
5
/
"
"*
">""
"
!
"
$
"/
5#
$""
""
.
5 5
74A#
+$.
C
$.
,$.
,
H.
,$
$)1%)118'$832$848
7D,A$""$8)258186753$*9$!*&$7$
9%:+H.
E$2D8'$848
81
!3"
,
O(
$
$(
"
5N
$&
""&"
"*
""
"
$>$
F&+
$&
"H
"$
N""$
$"%"$
'
*
$
$
"H"
>
"
8
"
"
72
#
$
"
%'*
$
"/
/
%':
"
$
"
",$@
R
$"
@R
!
C"
#/
"
(221$(
@R
$
"E
$
#+
;L9C"#22D$"
72C
K""#
$"
"
$"
"
4 5
67%*&
#
-
"/.$
+
$;L"'!""$
"
#$
"
""
8)
"
"H?.
9C"%'
$
;,$
"
B$
"
>$
"
("
%*
$"
',
$
"
$+
$"(
"
"
(
$
(
X
%'#
$
5
$
"
(&
"
"
(
*
!$
#
0K$""
88
"
%I
J"
$"
"'
(
""
". "%
'""
$
$"
O:
$$("5$
$"$("5
"
"$
""K
;,!"$"
"!
C"$
"
#
$
/
"
#5
!
C".
?
$"
!
61
61"
$
"
"
$$"
$"
"
87
:L=
H
"
*
$
%'@
H
"
:$
"
"
$
5
..
E
C"%..EC'
-.$
."
*!"$
"
"
"
"
*""
$$
..EC$
31
"
B$
"
"
*
"""$"
"
%*;,$
86
+
$..EC&
""'6!
"
"$"
"N
*
$(
H"
""
5
"6):$
/$/
"($
"
@$
"
"
9"
>
"
#
)%)'..EC$+
$>
"
"
H
6#
)1%)'
..
E
C">IJ
$
"$
*;,
""$+.
;,
6)%&+""*
$$..EC
%#
)'&*
&"
#
7%' ..EC $
74"
#A,*:@#@K,*?@?C$@*?C@#*:@#A9;#@C-9*,@.:@*?Y*
%)111'$482
83
+"
"
$,E.
$
O
""
"N.
, #
)%)'
""
$
"
","5"!
C"$
,"
H+
$;,&5
"
"
.#"*
*
"/
N/"
5
9&
+
#
"
*>
"$
$
"
N
84
"
@
"
*
"
"X#$
5
N
>
5
"
,"
5
$
$
+
.
"$-
@9C".
C"H9
K68!
""
"
"5
!#""
67+
"
*$
"5
/$;,$
""
68-
A@$9C".
C"H9K$66
,ACD38%)11)5)118',
,E
#
$#B.
#
!
C"$#
%'EC::*@-9;#@C-9*,*9C:;-9!AA,:B
C-9*,H.:E#C#*0?E?C,E?.*0?,%:;E$222'
67!#$*C
.
$D80AC44$4425D1%224'
8D
#$$
@F;
"E
#
$
"
"+"
5
$
$(
"
"
66.
/
/
!&
/"
"/
$
B
#
"$
//
&
5
"
$
#"
/
/
!"
*
#"
$"
66%#
$'.,?-9#C*$*9?@*?C@#*:@#AA#:B9;#@C-9*,$++
82
"
@
"
/%
'"/
B+
$#?"
#..C"B
$
+
$?"
!
C"3D2+$
,
..EC
"%
@R
&,#&'
*"
B"$
"
N"
"
N.
" +5"""
"
+
5 "
N
(
",
71
!
"
/"/"
"$
""5
$"
"$
5"
=
5
$$
5"
*;,
"
"
(
5?$
5
"
"
"" ""
"
B
"
$"
#
"
"
"
""
*
""""
$
7
"
"
!!"""
!
"?""
"
$
"&5
"H$#"
,
&!/$"$
$"
IJ"
.;,#
+"63#"
,.&(!)116$
(
$L
"
$
221;,
"
+"
64?
$.QIJ
"
63*:
$7D4;,D6%2DD'$D815%,$.'$D32
%,
$"'
64*$E$,#$F$@"$KC
."$
.
7)
""
"
(
,
H
.P"/#
/"(
#$
$"($
"
$
"
."
"
"
?"
443,X/
""
"
"
,
"
+
%
.9
"B
"
+$%
8 !$
"
.("
".
78
"
E
6D
#$
"
"
+
"$
$
"$
$
$
&$$
H&
"&%
+
'
%
'9
<=&$
*
#
#
$
!
"
C$
5
6D#"
""/
/"
$
""
"$"
77
#
$H
/
"
($
&
"
"
5%
"'
"
"
"
>
">
""
*
$
$$"$
<$(
$
$"
<&
<
76