ISSN 0208-7774 T R I B O L O G I A 1/2017 p. 35–43 Majid Habeeb Faidh-Allah* Numerical and Finite Element Contact Temperature Analysis of Friction Material’s Type Effect on a Thermal Transient Behavior of a Single-Disc Dry Clutch Analiza numeryczna i elementów skończonych temperatury styku jako efektu rodzaju materiału trącego i jej wpływ na zachowanie termiczne suchych sprzęgieł jednotarczowych Key words: dry friction clutch, thermoelastic problem, Friction materials. Abstract: The sliding period is considered a critical period in the lifetime of friction clutches, because most failures occur during this period. High temperatures due to sliding velocity will appear on the contacting surfaces of the friction clutch system (e.g., in single -disc clutch are pressure plate, clutch discs and flywheel). The finite element technique has been developed to investigate the effect of the type of friction material (material properties) on the transient thermoelastic behaviour of a single-disc dry clutch. Two types of friction materials are used in this work: organic and sintered friction materials. Axisymmetric models are developed to simulate a friction clutch system (single disc with two effective sides). The results represent the comparisons between organic and sintered friction discs, behaviours during slipping periods in clutches. Słowa kluczowe: suche sprzęgło tarciowe, termosprężystość, materiały tarciowe. Streszczenie: Stan poślizgu tarciowego ze względu na występowanie największej ilości uszkodzeń jest krytycznym stanem pracy sprzęgieł tarciowych. Wysoka temperatura pracy występująca na powierzchniach trących elementów sprzęgieł spowodowana jest poślizgiem (np. w sprzęgłach jednotarczowych na klockach, tarczach i kole zamachowym). Metoda elementów skończonych została wykorzystana do zbadania wpływu rodzaju materiału (właściwości materiału) na zagadnienie termosprężystości w suchych sprzęgłach tarciowych. W pracy wykorzystano dwa rodzaje materiałów tarciowych: organiczny i spiekany. Opracowano osiowosymetryczne modele symulujące sprzęgło tarciowe (pojedyncza tarcza z dwoma okładzinami). Wynikiem pracy jest porównanie cyklów poślizgu pomiędzy dyskami wykonanymi z materiału organicznego oraz spiekanego. Introduction Automotive friction clutches are considered a crucial part in the torque transmission system, and it is also responsible for the performance of the vehicle. The friction clutches are also used in a wide range of different applications, i.e. industrial applications. The engagement cycle of clutches consists of two stages. The first stage occurs when the clutch starts to engage and consequently a high amount of heat is generated in this period due to sliding between contacting parts. On the contrary, in the second stage, all contact elements rotate together with the same speed of rotation. The first period (slipping period) is considered the most * important period, because the most failures that occur on the surfaces of the contacting parts take place precisely during this period. Pisaturo and Senatore [L. 1] studied the heat transfer problem of the surfaces of friction clutches under sliding condition. They studied the temperature field of a friction clutch after repeated engagement, and they found that the surface temperature increases dramatically and reach, in some cases, the peak value (300°C). Furthermore, they investigated the frictional behaviour of the friction clutches at high temperatures (250–300°C). They found that the temperatures affect the cushion spring load-deflection characteristic and the subsequent transmitted clutch torque. A control algorithm to calculate the heat flux during vehicle Department of Mechanical Eng. /College of Engineering / University of Baghdad, Baghdad-Aljadria 47024, Iraq, e-mail: [email protected]. 36 T R I B O L O G I A 1/2017 launch and up-shift manoeuvres was presented as well in this work. They used the finite element method to compute the temperature field during repeated engagement of a clutch system. The results showed that only few repeated engagements of a clutch lead the temperature to reach values near the critical point of 300 °C. Yang et al [L. 2] conducted the transient thermal problem of a multi-disc friction clutch to study the deformation due to the thermal effect and distribution of contact pressure of the contact surfaces. They used the finite volume method (FVM) and the finite element method (FEM) to compute the temperature field and the distribution of the contact pressure. The couplings between temperature, displacement, and contact pressure were investigated using Matlab. In the contact analysis, a penalty method was used to find the contact pressure distribution of the contacting parts of clutch system. The results showed that the distributions of the contact pressure on the surfaces that exist near the pressure plate are more smooth than those which exist near the opposite plate, and non-uniformity will increase when the temperatures increases. Moreover, their results showed that the maximum contact pressure will decreases due to the effect of heat transfer by conduction and convection that occurred between the parts of the clutch system when the engagement period reach the end. Marklund et al [L. 3] developed a new model based on a simple technique to measure the friction coefficient under wet conditions then calculated the temperature and torque transmit for a wet clutch that are working under limited slip conditions. This model can be used to investigate the torque behaviour of the wet clutches and to find the optimal values of the design parameters that improve the performance of a clutch system. Their model takes into consideration the fluid dynamics, the contact mechanics, and the temperature calculations in the fluid film between the friction disc and the separator disc. The calculations of the fluid dynamics use homogenized flow factors to facilitate simulations of the flow on a coarser grid and also contain the surface roughness effects. The results showed that the temperature distribution in the film of the sliding interface is approximately represented as a polynomial of the second order. The results of their model were validated with experimental work, and it showed a good agreement between the measured and the simulations. Zhuo et al [L. 4] conducted a numerical analysis to study the thermal buckling of annular rings using a reduced Fourier method. They derived the stress stiffness matrix from the geometric nonlinearity in the Green strains with a predefined circumferential wave number. Their results were validated with commercial software, Abaqus, assuming that the model annular ring is axisymmetric. They also found the solutions of non-axisymmetric problems with multiple waves along the circumference. The results showed that there exists ISSN 0208-7774 a specific wave number for the buckling temperature that reaches a minimum value. Marklund et al [L. 5] studied the behaviour of wet clutches under low speed and heavy-duty load. They developed new models to estimate the torque transfer under lubricated boundary conditions. Their models take into consideration the effect of temperature, speed, and nominal pressure on the behaviour of a wet clutch that is working in boundary lubrication regime. The results of the torque and the temperatures that were obtained from the numerical work have acceptable agreement with the experimental results. Awrejcewicz and Grzelczyk [L. 6] built a mathematical model that illustrated the processes of the heat generated and how this heat generated will affect the friction clutch system behaviour. They assumed that the heat flux is an unequal distribution over the contacting surfaces. They solved a set of algebraic linear homogeneous and heterogeneous equations and then simulated it using a numerical method. The results of the torque and the temperatures that were obtained from the numerical work have acceptable agreement with experimental data. Zhao et al [L. 7] investigated the stability issue of the thermal buckling that occurred in automotive clutches using the finite element method. Two- and three-dimensional models were built using commercial software ABAQUS. They found that the radial variation of the temperature will significantly affect the critical buckling temperature. They also obtained numerical solutions assuming the variation of the temperature is periodic with multiple waves along the circumference direction. They concluded that the buckling can happen in the case when the temperature is uniform in the circumference, but it will be non-uniform in the radial direction. The other important conclusion is that the patterns of the radial temperature distribution strongly affect the critical value of buckling load and the mode shapes of the dominant buckling. Chao et al [L. 8] proposed a new model of pressure plate that have channels in the radial direction and holes on the traditional pressure plates to increase the amount of heat that transfers to the surrounding. The finite element method was applied to achieve numerical work in this analysis using commercial software Ansys. They studied the boundary conditions such as environment temperature, and the heat transfer coefficient for convection of the friction and steel surfaces. They also investigated the effect of design parameters such as dimensions of the radial cooling channels, the diameter of the holes that used for cooling on the temperature field and deformation of the proposed model of pressure plate. Based on the obtained results, they found that the thermal behaviour of a new pressure plate model is better than the classical one. Pisaturo et al [L. 9] estimated the error due to the neglect the effective spatial distribution of the heat ISSN 0208-7774 T R I B O L O G I A 1/2017 generated in the dry friction clutches during a vehicle launch manoeuvre. The finite element technique was used to assess the effect of the spatial distribution of the heat flux on the surface temperature. Axisymmetric models were built to obtain the thermal behaviour of a friction clutch system. Their analysis covered different assumptions. The first one supposed that the heat flux function of disc radius and the second one supposed the heat flux is uniform over the contacting area. The results showed that the surface temperature was increased very quickly after a few repeated engagements. Pica et al [L. 10] studied the thermal behaviour of dry dual clutches in the case when the sliding speed and the temperature were the function of the transmitted torque. The results from their model showed how the temperature affects the torque transmitted via clutch. They used a driveline model to prove that the temperature variation can determine the critical degradations of the clutch engagement performances. The aim of this analysis is to develop a new mathematical model that able to test different kinds of friction material especially the new one. In this work, the thermoelastic problem of dry friction clutches has been solved using two kinds of friction material (organic and sintered). The results are presented with the full details of the temperature distribution, contact pressure, and the heat generated during the slipping period. Thermoelastic problem in Friction Clutches The main parts of a typical friction clutch system (single disc) include a pressure plate, clutch disc, and a flywheel as shown in Fig. 1. The working process of a friction clutch consists of three stages (Fig. 2): the first stage (disengaged) is when the engine is working but there is 37 Fig. 2. The stages of lifecycle of a friction clutch system Rys. 2. Etapy pracy sprzęgła no torque transmitted to the driven shaft because of the friction clutch disconnect; the second stage (engaging phase / slipping period) is when the main elements of clutch system will press together (flywheel, clutch disc and pressure plate) and the torque will start to transfer to the driven shaft; and, the last stage (engaged) is when all elements of clutch system rotate together and there is no slipping between the contacting elements. The most critical phase is the second one (slipping period), because of in this phase, a huge amount of heat will generate due to the high kinetic energy that absorbed by the clutch system. In order to obtain a successful design, one should calculate the highest working temperature during this phase. Figure 3 illustrates the common failures that occurred in the surfaces of friction clutches [L. 11]. It can be seen that the most problems occur due to the high temperatures that appeared during the slipping period. Fig. 1. The elements of a single-disc friction clutch Rys. 1. Elementy sprzęgła jednotarczowego 38 T R I B O L O G I A 1/2017 ISSN 0208-7774 a) b) Fig. 4. Mathematical model for the (a) contact and (b) thermal problem for two bodies in contact Rys. 4. Model matematyczny styku (a) oraz kierunek przepływu się ciepła dla dwóch stykających się powierzchni (b) contact, the surfaces are assumed to be in an adiabatic state (separated) as follows: = q= 0= qn1 q= if P 0 n2 , Fig. 3. Typical types of failures that occur in the friction material surfaces Rys. 3. Typowe rodzaje uszkodzeń występujących na powierzchniach trących Problem Statement The thermoelastic problem can be solved in friction clutches using two different models. The first model (contact model) will be used to compute the contact pressure of the contacting parts of a clutch system, while the second model will be used to find the temperature distribution of a clutch system. The boundary conditions for two bodies (1 and 2) when pressed together (contact problem) can be written as follows [Fig. 4(a)]: w1 = w2 , if P>0 (1) w1 ≤ w2 , if P=0, (2) where P and w are the contact pressure between the contacting bodies. The thermal boundary conditions for two bodies (1 and 2) when they are contact together and there is heat flux at the interface is shown in Fig. 4(b). There are two anonymous variables, qn1 and qn2, that appear on the surfaces of contact. In order to describe the heat conduction problem, two added conditions are needed on every interface of contact. The energy balance and continuity in the temperature conditions are assumed on every interface as follows: T1 = T2 , if P > 0 q = µ P ω r = − ∑ qn = − (qn1 + qn 2 ), (3) if P > 0 , (4) where μ is the coefficients of friction and ω is the angular sliding velocity. In the case when the bodies are not in (5) In this work, the sliding angular velocity is assumed to be decreases linearly with time as in the following equation: t ω (t ) = ωo (1 − ), 0 ≤ t ≤ ts . (6) ts The magnitude of the contact pressure P that is needed to find the heat generated due to friction [Equation (4)] can be obtained when one finds the solution of the contact problem that occurs in the friction clutch system. In order to find the solution of the thermoelastic problem of a friction clutch, one should solve the coupling problem (structural and thermal) instantaneously at each time step during the slipping period. In order to find the values of the contact pressure p(r,t), the temperature distribution T(r,z,t) is given. Then, Hook’s law can be used to solve the equation, including the thermal strain relations as follows: εij = (1 + ν ) E ν σij − σmm + αT δij E (7) when the equilibrium equation is ∂σij ∂x j =0. (8) The transient heat conduction problem needs to be solve, and then the new temperature distribution T (r , z , t + δt ) can be estimated as follows: ∇ 2T = 1 ∂T k ∂t (9) Finite element Formulation In this section, the procedure of the numerical analysis using finite element method will be explained. The following equation can be used to find the solution of the T R I B O L O G I A 1/2017 ISSN 0208-7774 39 transient thermal problem of axisymmetric model based on Galerkin’s method [L. 12]. ∂T + [ K (T ) ]{T } = {R} , ∂t [C (T )] (10) where C(T), K(T) and {R} are the matrix of heat capacity, the matrix of heat conductivity and the vector of thermal force. The differential equation (10) can be solved using the direct integration method. Assuming that temperature {T}t occurs at time t and {T}t+∆t occurs at t+∆t, then the solution can be written as follows: dT dT +β ∆t , (11) dt t dt t + ∆t {T }t + ∆t = {T }t + (1 − β ) where β is the factor that used to find the accuracy of the integration and the stability of the scheme, and the range of the values of this factor is between 0.5 and 1. The implicit equation can be obtained by substituting Equation (11) into Equation (10) ( C (T ) + β ∆t K (T ) ){T }t + ∆t = = ( C (T ) − (1 − β ) K (T ) ∆t ) {T }t + (12) + (1 − β ) ∆t {R}t + β ∆t {R}t + ∆t The equation that is used to find the solution of the contact problem can be written as follows: Ku=F (13) where K, F and u are the matrix of stiffness of the complete model, the force vector that applied to the model and the displacement vector of nodes. Owing to the initial strain that occurs in the system, the formulas of the stiffness matrix K and the force vector F are K =2π ∫∫ B A F =2π T D Br dr dz T ∫∫ B D εor dr dz (14) Fig. 5. Flowchart of solving thermoelastic problem in dry friction clutch using finite element method Rys. 5. Przyjęty schemat postępowania przy rozwiązywaniu zagadnienia termosprężystości dla sprzęgła tarciowego wykorzystujący metodę elementów skończonych Table 1. The properties of materials Tabela 1. Właściwości materiałów Friction materials (15) A The integrations of Equations (14 and 15) should be calculated for the complete surface area A where the tractions exist. Figure 5 demonstrates the flowchart of the processes that are used to find the solution of the thermoelastic problem using the finite element method. Tables 1 and 2 list the properties of materials, the dimensions, and the operational factors of a clutch system that were used in this analysis. The axisymmetric finite element models that were used to solve the thermoelastic problem in a dry friction clutch system are shown in Fig. 6. Material properties Steel (Flywheel, pressure plate Organic Sintered & axial cushion) Coefficient of friction, μ 0.3 0.3 0.3 Young’s modulus, E [GPa] 0.2 1 200 Poisson’s ratio, ν 0.3 0.25 0.25 Density, ρ [kg/m3] 1800 4500 7800 Specific heat, c [J/kg K] 1000 500 532 Conductivity, K [W/mK ] 0.65 20 54 30 12 12 Thermal expansion, α [10-6 K-1] 40 T R I B O L O G I A 1/2017 Table 2. The dimensions of a clutch system and operational factors Tabela 2. Wymiary sprzęgła oraz jego cechy Dimensions / operational factors Values Inner radius of clutch disc, [m] 0.06 Outer radius of clutch disc, [m] 0.085 Thickness of friction layer in clutch disc, [m] 0.00275 Thickness of axial cushion, [m] 0.00135 Inner radius of the pressure plate, [m] 0.0580 Outer radius of the pressure plate, [m] 0.0920 Thickness of pressure plate, [m] 0.00965 Inner radius of the flywheel, [m] 0.0485 Outer radius of the flywheel, [m] 0.0975 Thickness of flywheel, [m] 0.0195 Applied pressure, pa [MPa] ISSN 0208-7774 (a) Contact model 0.1 Heat transfer coefficient, h [W/m K] 40 No. of friction surfaces, n 2 Time of slipping, t [s] 0.4 2 Numerical Analysis In this work, a typical friction clutch (single plate with two effective sides of contact) that consists of pressure plate, clutch disc, and a flywheel, using two kinds of friction materials (organic and sintered) during the slipping period was studied. The results covered the thermal and structural behaviours of a friction clutch system when it starts to engage. Figures 7–9 show the distribution of the contact pressure with a dimensionless radius of clutch on the pressure plate side at different time intervals (t = 0.12, 0.24 and 0.4s). The results showed that the values of the contact pressure will increase with time for both kinds of friction materials. During the entire slipping period, the contact pressure values that are obtained when using organic friction material are higher than those obtained using sintered friction material. The peaks of the contact pressure occurred in the position that is located between the inner and mean disc radii of organic clutch disc, while for sintered clutch disc occurred at inner disc radius. Owing to the increase in the thermal deformation that occurred in the contact elements of friction clutch (pressure plate, clutch disc, and flywheel), the contact area will be decreased with slipping time for both cases. The highest magnitude of contact pressure is 0.36Mpa at t = 0.4 s when an organic clutch disc is used. The variations of the surface temperature with disc radius on the pressure plate surface for different times are presented in Figures 10 and 11. It is obvious that the maximum values of temperature corresponding to the organic clutch disc are higher than are those of (b) Transient thermal model Fig. 6. Finite element models for friction clutch system Rys. 6. Modele elementów skończonych sprzęgła tarciowego ISSN 0208-7774 T R I B O L O G I A 1/2017 Fig. 7. The distribution of contact pressure at t = 0.12 s Rys. 7. Rozkład nacisku powierzchniowego dla t = 0,12 s Fig. 8. The distribution of contact pressure at t = 0.24 s Rys. 8. Rozkład nacisku powierzchniowego dla t = 0,24 s 41 Fig. 10. The distribution of surface temperature at t = 0.24 s Rys. 10. Rozkład temperatury na powierzchni dla t = 0,24 s Fig. 11. The distribution of surface temperature at t = 0.4 s Rys. 11. Rozkład temperatury na powierzchni dla t = 0,4 s Fig. 9. The distribution of contact pressure at t = 0.4 s Rys. 9. Rozkład nacisku powierzchniowego dla t = 0,4 s 42 T R I B O L O G I A 1/2017 sintered clutch disc. It can also be distinguished that the behaviours of each kind of friction material is different during the entire slipping time. The values of surface temperatures of the organic clutch disc increase from the inner disc radius to the peak values near the point that is located between the inner and mean disc radii and then decreases to the minimum values at the outer disc radius. On the other hand, for a sintered clutch disc, the maximum values of surface temperature occurred at the inner disc radius and then the values of surface temperatures are decreased to the minimum values at the outer disc radius. Figures 12 and 13 illustrate the variation of the heat flux at the pressure plate side with the radius of clutch disc at different times during the slipping. It can be observed that the heat flux is semi-uniform over the contact area for both kinds of friction materials at the beginning of engagement (t = 0.04s), because the contact pressure is still semi-uniform over the contact area at the same time. In the other words, the thermoelastic phenomenon has no effect at this time (values of thermal deformations are very small). The heat generated is from the function of slipping speed; therefore, at the beginning of the slipping time, the maximum amount of heat generated will occur, but later it can noticed that the behaviour of the heat generated is changed, and the heat generated is focused one specific area of the entire contact area. The reason for these results is the change that occurred in the distributions of contact pressure, where the contact pressure will be focused on some specific area of the nominal contact area that leads to the increase in the magnitude of the heat generated on this specific area. Figure 14 exhibits the variation of maximum surface temperature with an initial angular velocity of 300 rad/s using organic and sintered clutch discs. It is clear from the figure that the values of the temperature increased dramatically at the beginning of slipping to the peak values that occurred approximately at the middle of the slipping phase. Finally, the temperature decreases to the final values at the end of the slipping phase. The highest temperature values are 335K and 331 K corresponding to the organic clutch disc and sintered clutch disc, respectively. It is obvious that the values of temperature that appeared on the organic clutch disc are greater than those that appeared on the sintered clutch disc during the whole slipping stage. ISSN 0208-7774 Fig. 12. The distribution of the heat flux at t = 0.04 s Rys. 12. Rozkład przepływu ciepła dla t = 0,04 s Fig. 13. The distribution of the heat flux at t = 0.12 s Rys. 13. Rozkład przepływu ciepła dla t = 0,12 s Conclusions In this work, new mathematical models have been developed to find the solution to the transient thermoelastic problem of the dry friction clutches during the slipping period. The analysis examined the thermal and structural behaviours of the friction clutch system using two kinds of friction materials (organic and sintered). The results Fig. 14.The maximum surface temperature evolution with time Rys. 14.Przebieg maksymalnej temperatury powierzchni w funkcji czasu ISSN 0208-7774 T R I B O L O G I A 1/2017 showed that the thermal behaviour of a friction clutch was improved when a sintered friction material was used instead of organic friction material. The reduction of the maximum temperature was found to be approximately 11% when organic friction material was replaced by sintered material. It can also be concluded that the 43 maximum surface temperature occurred approximately during the middle of the slipping period for both cases. This analysis is considered the basis for subsequent research to investigate the effect of design parameters on the thermal stresses and stability of dry friction clutch systems. References 1. Pisaturo Mario, and Adolfo Senatore, “Simulation of Engagement Control in Automotive Dry-Clutch and Temperature Field Analysis Through Finite Element Model”, Applied Thermal Engineering, 93, (2016): 958-966. 2. Yang Likun, Biao Ma, Mehdi Ahmadian, Heyan Li, and Brian Vick, “Pressure Distribution of a Multidisc Clutch Suffering Frictionally Induced Thermal Load”, Tribology Transactions, 59.6 (2016): 1-6. 3. Marklund P., F. Sahlin, and R. Larsson, “Modelling and Simulation of Thermal Effects in Wet Clutches Operating Under Boundary Lubrication Conditions”, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part J: Journal of Engineering Tribology, 223.8 (2009): 1129-1141. 4. Chen Zhuo, Yun-Bo Yi, and Jiaxin Zhao, “Fourier Finite Element Model for Prediction of Thermal Buckling in Disc Clutches and Brakes”, Journal of Thermal Stresses, 39.10 (2016): 1-11. 5. Marklund P., Mäki R., Larsson R., Höglund E., Khonsari M. M., and Jang J., “Thermal Influence on Torque Transfer of Wet Clutches in Limited Slip Differential Applications”, Tribology international, 40.5 (2007): 876-884. 6. Awrejcewicz Jan, and Dariusz Grzelczyk, “Modeling and Analysis of Thermal Processes in Mechanical Friction Clutch-Numerical and Experimental Investigations”, International Journal of Structural Stability and Dynamics, 13.07 (2013): 1340004. 7. Jiaxin Zhao, Zhuo Chen, Huizhou Yang, and Yun-Bo Yi, “Finite Element Analysis of Thermal Buckling in Automotive Clutch Plates”, Journal of Thermal Stresses 39.1 (2016): 77-89. 8. Jin Chao, Gong Yu-Bing, Pan Shun-Ying and Zhang De-Feng, “Influence of the Thermal Parameters and the Structural Parameters on the Performance of Clutch Pressure Plate”, In the Proceedings of 2nd International Forum on Electrical Engineering and Automation (IFEEA), Guangzhou, China, December 2015. 9. Pisaturo Mario, Adolfo Senatore, and Vincenzo D’Agostino, “Influence of Spatial Heat Flux Distribution on Temperature Field in a Dry Clutch During A Launch Manoeuvre”, In the Proceedings of 5° Workshop AIT (Tribologia e Industria) - University of Salerno, Italy, April 2016. 10. Pica G., Cervone C., Senatore A., Lupo M., and Vasca F., “Dry Dual Clutch Torque Model with Temperature and Slip Speed Effects”, Intelligent Industrial Systems, 2.2 (2016): 133-147. 11. Neale Michael J., “The tribology handbook”, Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, 1995. 12. Lewis R. W., Nithiarasu P., Seetharamu K. N. (2004), Fundamentals of the finite element method for Heat and Fluid Flow, John Wiley & Sons.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz