C Black Death and HIV/AIDS Critical Challenge Critical question Overview Which is worse: Black Death or HIV/AIDS? In this challenge, students compare the effects of the Black Death of the Middle Ages to the HIV/AIDS epidemic. Students begin by studying the preventive measures and treatment attempted, and the physical, social and economic effects of the bubonic plague. As an introduction to the growth potential of diseases, including modern diseases, students take part in a scientific experiment where one student “infects” almost the entire class simply by having everyone exchange liquids with three others. This experiment on exponential growth leads to the study of HIV/AIDS. Supplementing supplied briefing materials with independent print and electronic research, students learn about the nature and effects of HIV/AIDS. In the critical challenge, students decide which disease is more devastating— the Black Death or HIV/AIDS. As an extension, students create a poster representing one lesson they have learned about the disease(s). Objectives Broad understanding Requisite tools Readily transmittable diseases, such as the bubonic plague during the Middle Ages and HIV/AIDS in modern times, can have devastating human, economic, political and social effects. Background knowledge • basic knowledge of Black Death and HIV/AIDS (origins, causes, physical effects, treatments, preventive measures, social and economic effects) • understanding of exponential growth Criteria for judgment • criteria for destructive effects (e.g., difficulties in control, physical, social and economic effects) Critical thinking vocabulary Thinking strategies Habits of mind • empathy Joan of Arc and the Hundred Years’ War 107 The Critical Thinking Consortium Suggested Activities Pre-planning Assemble materials for experiment ➤ In Session Two, we propose a demonstration of how quickly diseases can spread—even those requiring exchange of fluids. This requires providing one glass for every student—all but one of which are halffilled with water; the remaining glass is half-filled with a clear low concentrate acid. This acid can easily be obtained from the chemistry teacher. In addition, you will need red cabbage juice to serve as an acid indicator. This can be made by boiling some red cabbage in a non-metallic vessel (e.g., glass, Corning ware). Alternatively, let red cabbage soak in hot water overnight. The red cabbage juice should look dark purple (Source: http://www.cheminst.ca/ncw/experiments/ eredcabb.html). Study about HIV/AIDS ➤ It is likely that students will have many questions, and perhaps also misconceptions, about HIV/AIDS. You may want to familiarize yourself with the briefing sheets we provided and with some of the interest sources listed in References, to help you respond to students’ comments. ➤ Decide in advance whether you will allocate roles or allow students to select their own. We have assumed that students will work in pairs on this project. Encourage those students who want to focus on the same role to work together. Although it is not optimal, consider allowing more than one pair of students to research the same role. A significant limitation on students’ choices may be availability of resources—especially if an interview is planned. Session One Blackline Masters #1–5 Introduce catastrophic diseases ➤ Ask students to brainstorm some of the world’s worst diseases. Students’ response will likely include HIV/AIDS, cancer, small pox and influenza. Generate a list of their responses. Discuss why students believe these diseases are among the worst. Typically, students will not think of the Black Death because it is a disease that has little effect on their lives. Some students may have had friends or family members die from HIV/AIDS or cancer, but not Black Death. Discuss the Black Death ➤ On an overhead projector place depictions of the victims of the Black Death. Locate these in student textbooks or search http:// images.google.com/ for “Black Death.” Briefly explain the origin of the term “Black Death.” During the Middle Ages, people termed the illness black death because of the black spots that appeared on their skin. These spots were caused when dried blood under the skin turned a blackish colour. Explain to students that, during the Middle Ages, Asia and Europe were struck by a deadly disease known as the bubonic plague. Between 1347 and 1352, over 25 million people were killed in Europe as a result of the plague. Draw the comparison between the death toll of this plague and Canada’s current population. Joan of Arc and the Hundred Years’ War 108 The Critical Thinking Consortium Create base groups ➤ Divide students into groups of four (base groups). Distribute a different briefing sheet to each student in the group on one of the following aspects of the Black Death in Europe: • Physical effects (Blackline Master #1A–B); • Prevention and treatment (Blackline Master #2); • Social and cultural effects (Blackline Master #3A–B); • Economic and political effects (Blackline Master #4). Acquire information in expert groups ➤ Phys ical e ffect s of Form s of th e dise Moder ase n actual scientists Black ly bu believe bo line wild Maste rodent nic plague that the Bla r #1A s. The — “Yersi cause a disease ck Death ni unde was whi scient a pestis” of the rm (n is plague ch afflic arms ined. Then ts agains t who isol amed afte is so m a a r Ale ated it there t xandre bacterium e calle boil abou de in 18 fleas it). The di ve d “bur t th lo calle 94 which Y se n boil. e size of ped on th penetr pestis live on ase can be and deve ersin, a Sw d e a lent ” This lo ated is exist tr il whi thighs or it so This in Nor the rats. T ansferred ped a seru s close up that th infected ch th vo m he ra en th e peop per the w e ts and to humans three miting of bacter ough to hu America ho le blood patient vi by days, fleas today ia mans olently le body, an an co th th bu is calle —and, of d ere be fo nt e patie d vomite course r the flea t they rare Yersinia ing no inued with d “bub nt di d bloo s lymph ed. , we ha ly ge to tran out in onic” means t d. te nodes ve sf be rm of er N ca th ot healin is the de “buboe use th e seru and th only g it, an sion for ad e m all also plague s,” in the gr ere create bacteria m . The dise ly d then those those who eg as ove in oi who had sp When the w has, over th n or arm g-shaped to the e had ee th pits of orld. lu e cent sudden e inhabita touched or ch with th It its vi mps, calle now em di nts of call “E is believe uries, occu ctims. us de d ed at ed hurrie h M any of d by Bubon , but ur from some rred in m dly or emanated essina di th Kaffa ope” abou ic ei an r th that scov the ev dered fr y , t bubo il them om the Gen ered that ings. nic pl a city on th 1345, carr it reache places in As th remained ou d ague e num and ca t of the ha oese ship this occurr e Black Se ied by a G what we s they be desire enoese a. A re ed in rb us Bubon d to co r of deaths ed a fear our and India ic plag town. in 19 cent recurr ship their ful ou drugs 94. last w nfess thei increased ence tb that ca ue usually re ak of But r of ill an in Mes peop How results n cure death. d test sins to the le], la ever sina amen wye of the malnu , if the vi it, if they in death. T t. But priests an many diseas rs and no ar ct oday tr d to dr eccles , we ha taries ed. plenty ition or ot im is alre e adminis aw up ia st te ad re he ve ic re of pe y at ri fused r illne s [rel Soon ople so, hi sk, th d in time. igious to en ss, it th in the e storia ter th corpse ro is mor eccles ns are 1340 1348 e hous e dead ugh sw ia sw pu ou es enter, stic, no so ere lying one va tbreak. O zzled why ho were at ly. There forsak n, no but th ur were such ri so man en in dead fa ri other ety of plag best gues th . The ey hired se ther and s is th y died du sk. Even va ue at houses no re e houses. rvants their at ther ring th the ot rieties of work la va of w tio e was plague her w e in Eur n dare No had re luables, go the dece ith high w hich m dang op : d on or as e. to ag e ached e attack ld an ed re erous T es to d emig s the which atta here are than as seem rate [m its climax jewels… mained op bury the two lung ck s likel it can be .W en the M vineya ov transm s. The la s the bloo y work essini hen the ca with all rds an e away]. d, an tter is itted alongs that some ans re tastro d in the One d field thro espe fo ide th po so phe to e bubo rm of pneu ugh the ai cially and ac wn of Cat s, but a la rtion of th lved to Histo m r. ni onic c plag rg em se ania. compa rical plague It ue in ttled The di er portion of accoun ni he ed in the those lp. was at sease sought This them t of th awfu ac dragge Many of ev cl e plag l year the fle erywhere ung to th refuge the ar count is fr ue s. e fugi eing Thos d themselv om th rival th ey fell do tives ew turned and in es e w itial pr city of M hospita ho reache into the fields n by the ro in search essi At th d ogress e begi and bu adside the bu ls there. Th Catania of the na, and it nning br galle sh ry and descri e diseas ys of and so ing of fugi terrified eathed thei es to die. bes e. they …entered October, citizen r last tives they bore in th th fr w s in … e om M would ere al e wal harb 1347 the so viru who ls. es l thro on lent [d or of Mes , twelve wn in sina with not permit Genoe ange sina. and in ly spoke to to de in the ro In Th se ep them us] a no m tow their us th trench anne spread es ou n, r coul was seized disease th bones island e people of tside at d by a diseas to everyo of Sici Messi morta anyone ne who evade deat innum ed. Th na di ly an l illne h. d sp er pain ss throug ose infect had any co The infe inhabi able peop with them ersed ov ed fe ction er the le died ntact hout tants, the di lt whole their th with When sease, and ul . The whole emselves the th to tim so e w th pl at n penetr bodies at patria ag el of Cat Joan at rch en ue had at y sank in and, of Ar to co ania lost so to ed by a tained with dowed c and mpl all its all say, its he the Hu himse priestly po all eccles ight in ete oblivio ndre iast lf d Ye n. w ars’ pestile possessed ers for th ics, even Catania, War the e abso the yo as bi nce ra shop unge ged fr and pa lution of st , om O sin w tria ctober 115 1347 rch. But th hich he to Apr e il 1348 . The Rearrange students into new groups based on their assigned topics (expert groups). In their expert groups, students are responsible for taking notes or highlighting the important ideas of the material provided in the briefing sheets. These students will be expected to teach this material to the members of their base groups. To help them prepare, encourage students to ask questions for clarification and discuss the material with their base group members. The Nam Teach other students ➤ Direct students to return to their base groups where each student will teach the other group members his/her topic. Distribute Summary of key facts (Master #5) for students’ use in recording the main points on all four aspects of the Black Death. ➤ Once students have been introduced to the four topics, invite them to share their reactions to this disaster. Encourage students to imagine the feelings of people at the time— losing so much to a disease they did not understand and were unable to control. Prev Joan of Arc and the Hundred Years’ War 109 enti on a nd Wha Wha Othe c and ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ inking Coop erativ e knowledge of Black Death __ Sum mary of ❑ Term of Ar ____ cal Th key f acts Black Sum m Death inform arize im ation portan t info obta rm ined from ation fr ❑ H om re othe cal e IV/A r so ffect IDS urce ports by s (e.g s ., bo groups on oks, each web of th sites) e topi . cs be Econ Joan e(s): Criti Black line Maste r #5 Physi Soci Discuss student reactions the B lack Deat h omic r im port inolog the Hu al eff e ndre y and d Ye ars’ effe ant basic t peop t is kn trea le firs own toda tme low. Add impo rtan t rele vant nt t knew or be lieve d y cts cts effe cts o r info rma tion facts War 121 The Criti cal Th inking Coop erativ e empathy The Critical Thinking Consortium Session Two Conduct transmission experiment Test results Explain exponential mathematics Introduce study of HIV/AIDS Blackline Masters #5–7 ➤ As a powerful way of demonstrating how quickly diseases can spread—even those that require exchange of fluids—ask students to imagine that they have been invited to a party. Distribute half-full glasses of water to all but one student in the class (only you should know this person’s identity). The one student unknowingly is to receive a half-full glass of the low concentrate acid. The idea is that the student with the acid is infected with a communicable disease such as HIV/AIDS. This student will spread the disease to the rest of the class. Be emphatic with students that all the glasses contain a liquid that they are NOT to drink, touch or spill. Explain to students that they must share their liquid with three other students by pouring the contents of their glass into another and then pouring half of that liquid back into their own glass. ➤ When everyone has exchanged fluids with three others, test their glasses with an acid indicator (i.e. cabbage juice) to determine which students have been infected. Most of the students will have been infected—their liquids will colour. Explain that only one student’s glass contained an acid mixture while the rest of the glasses contained water. Tell students which student had the acid mixture. Ask students how they think they were infected. ➤ On an overhead projector, use a diagram to demonstrate how easily one person can infect up to 27 people. (One person infects three people; those three people each infect three people, and these nine people infect three people each.) Students should begin to see how easily HIV/AIDS can be spread. Explain to students that this concept is called “exponential growth.” ➤ Invite students to volunteer what they already know about HIV/AIDS—its transmission, prevention, symptoms and so on. Brainstorm with students similarities between what they already know about HIV/AIDS and Black Death. Generate a list of the similarities and differences on the overhead. Although the actual diseases are different, their effects are quite similar. Some similarities may include the vast scope of death, the destruction of families, and the destruction of economies. Distribute the two background sheets, HIV/ AIDS—a modern plague (Blackline Master #6) HIV/ AIDS –a m oder n pla gue HIV stands subm for hu ic m reprod roscopic pa an immun od uc rasite Black stands e inside that ca eficiency th line virus. fo n only Maste weake r acquired e cells of It is a surv a r #6 ning of the immunod host organi ive and HIV Sympt ge ef bo sm. A oms develo ts into a pe dy’s abili iciency sy IDS associ ndrom ty to rson’s p HIV/A at fi Accor AIDS. T e. ed gh bl It is a ood t off with IDS is hu di HIV/A diseas un Preven ng to the s, the epid system, th diseases. lik e IDS Centr If e pers emic tion: body itself and e Black D es fo eath of a pe m r Dis is called “H on may in that ease peop rson ore like a “HIV IV/A Contr le it to a ra ga IDS.” is ol an nge of tekeeper acts less lik preven these infe person spread by d ctions which ted by infect ea , sexual w of open io (prim by sharin ou th ns. In illne contac e bo ld prev s the g ar heal io person sses and sy dy’s imm infect ily for drug needles an t with an une sy usly have thy mptom ed or d/or sy has H infect in je be so st , ct IV/A ed coun many tries less comm ion) with ringes IDS. s can be in em. A grea en di ff w B be on di so ering t va here ecause antib ca fore th meone ly (and bloo od sy it can tions that riety who now recogn e existenc mptoms, or bloo ies), throug d is scre a be as is very it ened ized. e h tran rarely been for As of of HIV/A took rese sociated w HIV-i d clotting sfusio in fo archer 1999 IDS w ith fa nf ns of HIV s as stro und to be abou or du ected wom ctors. Bab infect t two as genera years “AID ng ring bi ie ed en s in bo lly blood do Smay dicato rn to HIV/A rth or rs of defining”– zen diseas throug become IDS is the pr es weake infe h brea Physi esence that is, they have n or de a sexually st-fee cted befo ca of HIV are ta tr ding stroy HIV/A l and psyc ken Com after re /AID the bo ansmitted hologi bine IDS birth. S. di dy’s cal pr cockta d antivir ability sease (ST Peop oblem al ther il” D); it le to figh treatm ) is one s asso apy (a ca t off discom with HIV of ciated lso ca en diseas n /AID fo No pe t of HIV the more lled th rt S w es. s: ith suffer /AID impo rs e “dru a grea S, rtant • pain succes on, once t rang recent g infect but the tr ful in sf e of ea ad ed, ha fectio cockta ully elim • failu s had tment is no vances in in ns, il HIV/A t a cu re of no kn for HIV/A ated from re. body own IDS his or ID • S cu sy is expe vaccin her bo eye in re for stems, dy es are fectio ns H ns an curren IV/AIDS. ive. There . The drug • diff The C d sigh tly be E is, at icul en t failu ing co xperimen pr the fo ter for D res, failing ties in sw tal tria esent, nduc isease allow llowin ted. s, ls of ing, in Contr g wor • ol an testin blood ldwid • By d al pa e stat vessel the ins an istics: Preventio tumor • rash d n repo were end of 20 s, es, 02 rts liv are ch ing with , an estim • pain ated HIV/A ildren ful sw 42 ID un m • App S. Of ill der 15 elling • dem these, ion peop . roxim of ly le entia mph 3.2 m ately 2002 organs illion 5 mill functio (Alzheim . , ion pe ns), er-lik • Dur ople e decl • canc acquir ing ine in ers, ed H peop 2002, AID mind IV in le, S kille • loss child including d of wei an es ren un 1. gh der 15 2 million timated t, • grea streng 3. . wom th an t men en an 1 million d ener tal st d 610, • stig ress gy, 000 ma, the di when peop sease. le ap pear to be visibl y ill w ith Joan Joan of Arc and the Hundred Years’ War understanding of exponential growth 110 of Ar c and the Hu ndre d Ye ars’ War 122 The Criti cal Th inking Coop erativ e The Critical Thinking Consortium and HIV/AIDS in East-central Africa (Blackline Master #7) to every student. Also distribute a copy of Blackline Master #5 for student use in summarizing the key facts. Ask students to learn more about the parallels between HIV/AIDS and Black Death by reading the two briefing sheets and recording the key facts on Blackline Master #5 for each of the four aspects of the epidemic: • • • • knowledge of HIV/AIDS physical effects; prevention and treatment; social and cultural effects; economic and political effects. Session Three Blackline Masters #6–7 provide an introduction to HIV/AIDS, but students will need to supplement these sources with independent research. Provide students with time in the library and the computer lab to research HIV/AIDS. Check that the websites listed in the References are still accessible, and provide these and others as starting points for students’ research. If needed, arrange for an introductory lesson in the library where students can learn to use the Internet more effectively. Remind students to locate and record sufficient information about each of the four aspects of the epidemic. Session Four r #8 criteria for devastating disease Maste h is WOR Black SE a nd Death ❑ why HIV/A erativ Whic ❑ e Com parin g Bla Black ck D Dea th eath and HIV/ AIDS HIV/A IDS ? IDS Criti The ____ ____ ____ ____ So cult cial and ural imp act ____ ____ ____ Black Death ❑ HIV/A IDS ____ ❑ 124 HIV/A IDS War Death ❑ ❑ HIV/A ars’ Black Death IDS of Ar c and the Hu ndre ❑ Black d Ye ❑ Joan ____ ____ ____ Nam Econ poli omic an tical d imp act ____ Distribute Comparing Black Death and HIV/ AIDS (Blackline Master #8) to every student. You may want to enlarge this chart to ledger size (11 x 17). Present the critical question: ____ ➤ e: Present the critical challenge Coop line act Black cal im p Physi When students have completed their research, invite them to share their main facts with the rest of the class. Again discuss the similarities and differences between the Black Death and HIV/ AIDS. Diffi prev culty in enti trea on and tme nt ➤ __ Discuss the main findings Blackline Master #8 inking ➤ cal Th Carry out additional research Which is worse: Black Death or HIV/AIDS? Joan of Arc and the Hundred Years’ War 111 The Critical Thinking Consortium Ask students to use the information gathered on the Black Death and HIV/AIDS to help them answer the critical challenge. Explain that the criteria for determining which disease is worse are the extent of impact on each of the four aspects they have been researching. For each of the four criteria, students must rate which disease is worse. Debrief the results ➤ Invite students to share each of their four conclusions. Encourage students to debate those conclusions upon which they disagree. Create a poster ➤ OPTIONAL: As a final project, ask students to create a poster that reflects one lesson they have learned while studying Black Death and HIV/AIDS. The posters should not state the lesson learned, but instead imply the lesson through visual representation. For example, instead of simply stating that the spread of the disease is exponential, students would create an image that vividly depicts this phenomenon. A search for Black Death on Google http://images.google.com/ leads to many contemporary posters and images on the theme. Display the completed posters in the classroom or school hallway. Ask students to determine the lesson represented in each poster. Evaluation Assess information and conclusions ➤ Blackline Master #9 Assess students’ assembled information about the Black Death and HIV/AIDS as recorded on Summary of key facts (Blackline Master #5) and their conclusions about the worst disease as recorded on Comparing Black Death and HIV/AIDS (Blackline Master #8). Use the rubric found in Assessing the effects (Blackline Master #9). The assignments are worth 10 marks and are assessed on two criteria: Nam e: ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ __ Use th interm e follow in edia te m g rubric to arks for ev assess th iden Black ce fa e studen line ts lling Maste betw ’ summar een r #9 the de ies of ke Cove script y facts and ors. Und key rage of conc erdev idea lusion s elop Inform s abou ed t the key po ation is worse vagu ints e an are re diseas d fe Com pres e. Aw peten ente w ard Ther d. t e Wel inform is some l de concl support are m ation bu tailed Wel ed usio issing t l ke d evel 1 ns The in ea y points oped Ther conc ch e ca lu unre tego sions inform is much as ry. seem de supp onable poin ation an tailed and orte ts in d are no evid each d the ke repr 3 ence with re The esen y levant t . co ted. category reason nclusion are s with able an are gene d ar some ra releva e supp lly 5 All of nt ev orted Com 1 th men id e en very conc ts: ce. re lu supp asonab sions se le an orte em d d are evid ence with re levant . 3 Asse ssing the effec ts 5 TOTA L / 10 • coverage of main ideas, • support for conclusions. Joan of Ar c and the Hu ndre d Ye ars’ War 125 Extension ➤ The Criti cal Th inking Coop erativ e Invite students to plan and implement an HIV/AIDS awareness week campaign. Students can teach their peers about the dangers of HIV/AIDS as well as preventive measures. Encourage students to develop and distribute informational brochures and posters as well as speak at a school assembly or pep rally. Joan of Arc and the Hundred Years’ War 112 The Critical Thinking Consortium References Print resources Huppert, George (1986). After the Black Death: A Social History of Early Modern Europe. Bloomington, IN; Indiana University Press. Nardo, Don (Editor) (1999). The Black Death. San Diego, CA: Greenhaven Press. Picard, Andre (1995). The Gift of Death: Confronting Canada’s Tainted Blood Tragedy. Toronto: Harper Collins. Smith, Raymond A. (Ed) (2001). Encyclopedia of AIDS: A Social, Political, Cultural and Scientific Record of the HIV Epidemic. London: Penguin Books. Internet sites Black Death http://www.encarta.msn.com.find.Concise.aspx http://www.orb.rhodes.edu/textbooks/westciv/blackdeath.html http://www.brown.edu/Departments/Italian_Studies/dweb/plague/ Images of the Black Death can be found at: http://www.bnf.fr/enluminures/themes/t_3/ast_3_04.htm http://www.brown.edu/Departments/Italian_Studies/dweb/images/ plague/plague_motif.gif http://images.google.com/ (Search for “Black Death”) HIV/AIDS There are numerous Internet sites which focus on HIV/AIDS. Here are the addresses of some: http://www.cdcnpin.org/hiv/start.htm http://www.unaids.org/ http://www.apa.org.pi/aids/resource.html http://www.aidsinfo.nih.goc/drugs/ http://www.pbs.org/newshour/health/aids/index.html http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/1679619.stm http://www.pbs.org/newshour/health/aids/index.html http://www.newint.org The New Internationalist on-line back issue on HIV/AIDS (June 2002). Search “Back Issues” for #346. Joan of Arc and the Hundred Years’ War 113 The Critical Thinking Consortium
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz