2/19/2015
Limitations of VSEPR - Chemwiki
Ashley Robison
My Preferences
Site Tools
Popular pages
MindTouch User Guide
FAQ
Sign Out
If you like us, please share us on social media.
The latest UCD Hyperlibrary newsletter is now complete, check it out.
ChemWiki
BioWiki
Periodic Table of the Elements
GeoWiki
Reference Tables
StatWiki
Physical Constants
PhysWiki
MathWiki
SolarWiki
Units & Conversions
Lab Techniques
ChemWiki: The Dynamic Chemistry E-textbook > Inorganic Chemistry > Molecular Geometry > Limitations of VSEPR
Limitations of VSEPR
Athough the VSEPR model is useful in predicting molecular geometry, it fails to predict the shapes of isoelectronic species and transition metal
compounds. This model does not take relative sizes of substituents and stereochemically inactive lone pairs into account. As a result, VSEPR cannot
be applied to heavy d-block species that experience the stereochemical inert pair effect.
Introduction
The VSEPR model is a powerful tool used by chemists to predict the shapes of molecules; yet like many other theories, it has exceptions and
limitations. This article discusses in detail the various limitations of VSEPR and gives explanations for these exceptions. VSEPR fails for isoelectronic species
Isoelectronic species are elements, ions and molecules that share the same number of electrons. According to the VSEPR model, chemists determine
the shape of the molecules based on numbers of valence electrons (i.e. bond pairs and lone pairs). However, two isoelectronic species, can differ in
geometry despite the fact that they have the same numbers of valence electrons. For example, both IF7and [TeF7]- have 56 valence electrons;
VSEPR theory predicts both to be pentagonal bipyramidal. However, electron diffraction and X-ray diffraction data indicate that the equatorial F
atoms of [TeF7]- are not coplanar. Moreover, the bond lengths of equatorial I-F and Te-F bonds are different. The VSEPR model fails to
accommodate the correct shape for [TeF7]- and other species because it does not account for such irregularities. VSEPR fails for transition metal compounds
The VSEPR model also fails to predict the structure of certain compounds because it does not take relative sizes of the substituents and
stereochemically inactive lone pairs into account. Elements in the d-block have relatively high atomic masses and they tend to have stereochemically
inactive electron pairs. In other words, valence shell s-electrons in these elements tend to adopt a non-bonding role. This is known as the inert pair
effect. As a result, VSEPR does not give correct geometries for these transitional metal complex compounds.. For example, [SeCl6]2- , [TeCl6]2- ,and
[BrF6]- are predicted to adopt pentagonal bipyramidal geometries according to VSEPR since the central atom can have seven electron pairs.
However, due to the stereochemical inert pair effect, these molecules are found to be regular octahedral because one of the electron pairs is
stereochemically inactive. http://chemwiki.ucdavis.edu/Inorganic_Chemistry/Molecular_Geometry/Limitations_of_VSEPR
1/3
2/19/2015
Limitations of VSEPR - Chemwiki
R
e
References
1. Cotton, F. Albert, and Geoffrey Wilkinson. Advanced Inorganic Chemistry; a Comprehensive Text. [New York]: Interscience, 1962. Print.
2. Housecroft, Catherine E., and A. G. Sharpe. Inorganic Chemistry. Harlow, England: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2008. Print.
Problems
http://chemwiki.ucdavis.edu/Inorganic_Chemistry/Molecular_Geometry/Limitations_of_VSEPR
2/3
2/19/2015
Limitations of VSEPR - Chemwiki
]2- ?(Hint: Xenon
1. What is the shape of [XeF8
contains one pair of stereochemically inactive lone pair)
2. Give some examples of isoelectronic species.
3. Why are d-block elements exceptions to VSEPR? Answers
1. Antiprismatic
2. IF7 and [TeF7]3. Because of stereochemical inert pair effect
© Copyright 2015 Chemwiki
Powered by MindTouch ®
Unless otherwise noted, content in the UC Davis ChemWiki is licensed under a Creative
Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License. Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at [email protected].
Questions and concerns can be directed toward Prof. Delmar Larsen ([email protected]), Founder and Director. Terms of Use
http://chemwiki.ucdavis.edu/Inorganic_Chemistry/Molecular_Geometry/Limitations_of_VSEPR
3/3