ROTAVATOR THE MAGAZINE OF THE ROTARY CLUB OF PORTSMOUTH & SOUTHSEA 1916 - 2017 Issue no 144 April 2017 Edited by Greg Russell; sponsored by Addison Law & printed by Portsmouth Rotary Housing Association Ltd. In this issue…. Message from the President A Presidential Plea Centenary Dinner Youth Speaks 2017 Global Grant for the Philippines Vocational Training Team in Manila International & Foundation Report A Rotary Club Three Centuries Ago! Famous Speakers at our Club And Finally…..A Poem from David What’s On Our Team President David Collins Imm. Past President Nigel Brown President Elect Carey Bowker Hon. Secretary David Marshall Hon. Treasurer Barrie Davies Hon. Charities Treasurer Des O’Keeffe Administration David Collins International & Foundation John Bishop Community & Youth Bernard Parsons Membership John Cogley Fellowship Rob Cottee Fund Raising Tony Palmer Public Relations Caroline Gwatkin FROM THE PRESIDENT How time flies. We are already three quarters of the way through our Centenary Year. Many of our projects have already been completed, with the help of our hardworking Centenary Committee and tremendous support from the various committees of the Club. The £20,000 allocated for Youth charities has been distributed, the Tonda School project in Manila has been completed with the remaining funds entrusted to the British Council who work locally, and we have enjoyed two of our three Local Celebrity Dinners. Our Archivist Reg Gardner has completed and distributed our impressive Centenary booklet. marketing purposes. I am grateful to those who sponsored the publication, resulting in no cost to the club. The News has also given excellent coverage to many of our other projects as well. With Caroline and her newly reconstituted PR committee, hopefully we can continue to ensure promotion of Rotary within the local community. We have yet to achieve a lasting project to commemorate the one hundred years of service this Club has given to the community of Portsmouth. We have had several false starts which have collapsed along the way. I am hopeful that the latest project involving a tree planting at a peaceful leisure area on the western side of Portsea Island will come to fruition, although it will not be within the Centenary Year. We were privileged to have the use of the Lord Mayor's Banquetting Suite for our Centenary Dinner in November. Our distinguished guests, including our National President, "Essex Girl" Joy as she likes to be known, were entertained by the Lord Mayor to pre-dinner drinks in his parlour. Other guests included six from our "parent club" Edinburgh and many from our daughter clubs. We have just entertained the Lord Mayor on a return visit where he was presented with a cheque for £500 for his local charities. Finally, my thanks to all our members for the support throughout this year so far. Without that, we could not have achieved so much. Please keep it up! David Collins Centenary President ______________________________________ I am trying to visit as many of our daughter clubs as possible during the year. Some of us have already been to Portsmouth North and Gosport. Only yesterday we went to Southampton and I hope to fit in the others including Winchester, Guildford and Chichester at some time. At all these clubs, we have been well received. With some of them having their own Centenary Year coming up soon, they have been interested to learn what we have been up to. AN URGENT PLEA Our hardworking Secretary, David Marshall, has not been in the best of health recently, and has also had to cope with looking after Eileen following her hip operation and other health problems. Even before the start of this Centenary Year he had indicated that he wished to retire from his position as club secretary after undertaking this for us for many years. He WILL be retiring in June. After many year's struggling to get publicity for Rotary with the local press, we have managed to achieve a breakthrough with the Portsmouth News. With their help our Centenary Newsheet was published in September as a supplement to the edition published on September 15th. We have also been given a further 1,400 copies for future Earlier this year, I said that the job could be broken down into several parts. Reg Gardner 2 has kindly volunteered to take over responsibility for notifying attendance numbers to the Mountbatten, and for some months now, John Bishop has acted as Minute Secretary at the Council Meetings. the President of our Mother Club Edinburgh, John Williams and their other halves. In total, there were 106 attending which involved a substantial amount of However, we do still need to appoint someone to the role of Secretary in July. I have asked David to prepare a list of the functions still remaining under the role of Secretary. When this is available, I would ask all members to seriously consider whether this is something they could undertake. Without a Secretary to coordinate things, we cannot function. Honoured guests organisation for which many thanks to all of those who so kindly gave of their time to ensure that the event went off so smoothly. Although we have a President elect (Vice President) in Carey, taking over as President in July, and a presidential nominee (junior Vice President) in John Bishop, we do not have a president elect (senior Vice President) to support Carey, and then to take the Chair the following year, before John Bishop takes over. It is important that we do have seamless succession if Carey is to have full support to build upon the progress we have been able to make in our Centenary Year. Whilst I will be happy to stand in for him when necessary and give support, that is not the same. Perhaps I could ask you all to consider whether this is a gap you may be able to fill Attendees were greeted on arrival (or at least those who climbed the 50 steps up to the first floor of the Guildhall) by a steel band, the distinguished guests then making their way to the Lord Mayor’s Parlour for a welcome drink and the hoi polloi assembling in the Circle Bar below. The Dinner took place in The Lord Mayor’s Banqueting Suite with a three-course meal followed by several speeches, the principal Speaker, Max Craft giving a most amusing speech. All concerned felt that the event was a fitting tribute to David Collins Centenary President ______________________________________ CENTENARY DINNER the first 100 Rotarians and guests enjoy years of our the meal Club and could form the basis of a similar event in 100 years’ time! The formal Dinner to celebrate the Centenary was held by kind permission of The Lord Mayor Councillor David Fuller, at the Guildhall on 18 November 2016. Apart from the Lord Mayor and the Lady Mayoress, distinguished guests also included in particular the RIBI President, Eve Conway, District Governor, Chris Slocock Chris Halliwell ______________________________________ 3 We have never made the National Final before so good luck to both our teams for a wonderful day out at All eyes on you, David! Southampton and they go with our good wishes for a happy day and who knows what might happen! YOUTH SPEAKS 2017 Since November we have concentrated on the Youth Speaks competition which was held at Portsmouth High School on 23rd January 2017. We had entries from Portsmouth High School, both Intermediate and Senior sections, and Mayville High School, Senior section. We Well done, ladies had a new panel of judges comprised of Rotarians Caroline Gwatkin, Chair and Nigel Brown and Des O’Keefe in support. All teams presented well and the winners of the Intermediate section were: Bernard Parsons Community & Youth ______________________________________ VOCATIONAL TRAINING TEAM IN MANILA A series of articles on the progress made in providing training to teachers at the Tondo School in the Philippines. It includes an article on the provision of a global grant by Dennis Meadus, events in Manila from Caroline Gwatkin who is head of the training team, and a follow up report from John Bishop of the International and Foundation Committee. PORTSMOUTH HIGH SCHOOL Chair: Madelaine Oliver. Speaker: Annallee Macfarlane Vote of Thanks: Evie Thomas Subject: “In their search for profits companies are disregarding their ethical responsibilities” The winners of the Senior section were: GLOBAL GRANT FOR THE PHILIPPINES PORTSMOUTH HIGH SCHOOL Chair: Florence Smith Speaker: Francesca McBride Vote of Thanks: Milly Giles Subject: “Everyone has a right to offend! The primary objective was to provide students from very low income households with an education at the Tondo School in Manila, a new Secondary School. To achieve this end, all of the educational materials required and approved as part of this grant have been purchased. The winners went on to present at Bay House School Gosport and I am pleased to report that both teams were successful! They move on to the District Final to be held on Saturday 11th March 2017 at Richard Taunton Sixth Form College in Southampton. A condition of the grant was that a Vocational Training Team (VTT) of three 4 trainers, experienced in teacher training and working internationally, attend the Tondo School for two weeks to provide concentrated training, having devised lesson plans based on the results of a needs analysis from all of their teachers, and also to evaluate and organise future help. Introduction The feeling of deja vu was strong - the same freezing cold morning, the controlled chaos of Heathrow airport, and filling up with the last full English breakfast for a fortnight. The Portsmouth and Southsea Rotary VTT (Vocational Training Team), made New uniforms for all up of Caroline Gwatkin, Joanna Glos and Richard Shaw were off to Manila again, this time to evaluate the Teacher Training Project they had started in 2016 at the Purple Centers School in the Tondo area of Manila. The VTT worked at the Tondo School throughout the second and third weeks of January, 2016. At a de-briefing and subsequent presentation on their return, it was most apparent that apart from the continued assistance it would be most advantageous to the teachers and students for the three members of the VTT to return after one year to the Tondo School to provide another two weeks concentrated training and to carry out a full evaluation. The VTR will be travelling again to Manila on 6th January, 2017 for this purpose. They will also be using £2,500 obtained from the St James’ Place Charity to equip a Teachers’ Resource Centre. Voluntary Training Team, Second Visit It has to be said, that it was with some feelings of foreboding that the VTT team set out again for Manila. Based on the limited response to the online course offered to them during 2016, would some of those in positions of responsibility continue to see them as a threat? Dennis Meadus International Primary Contact ______________________________________ Welcomed Back The teachers welcomed the VTT team with open arms, proving that all their fears were baseless! Iris Gokeelao (Education Manager) together with Rocelle Malvar (Education Director) and Melvin Soriano (Head), all new in their posts, also seemed to be delighted at the team's return. It was evident at once that this new academic team is professional and experienced. In the short time they have been working in the school they have made considerable changes, not only in the teaching staff, but also revamping the school's image. TEACHER DEVELOPMENT PROJECT AT THE PURPLE CENTERS FOUNDATION SCHOOL IN MANILA A full-length report from Caroline Gwatkin on the Voluntary Training Team’s second and final visit to the Tondo school in Manila. Making Changes In order to encourage a sense of being part of an up-to-date learning community the Who said that teachers have an easy life? 5 school uniform has been changed. Where, in 2016, the girls were dressed in below-theknee skirts and white shirts with Peter Pan collars, now all the children have purple Tshirts with the school logo printed on them. This renewed sense of identity has included both the teaching and administrative staff, with all of them sporting a deep purple polo shirt with the school logo. The effect of this small, but important change is evident in a closer sense of community. expected to prepare classes in cramped conditions with no designated work place, they now have individual work stations, That's my new work station! each equipped with a computer linked to a printer bought with the monies donated in 2015/16. This set-up is essential in order to facilitate the major educational change that has been made - the scrapping of slavish adherence to course books, most of which did not serve the children well. Teachers are now encouraged to extend from these course books by devising their own worksheets tailored to their class's needs. Melvin Soriano is working towards paperless administration, so teachers now upload all student results, attendance sheets and other information directly onto the centralised directory which is accessible to all concerned. However, it is the change in vision in the pupil selection policy that will have far reaching consequences. Up until this reorganization, the school took just one child from each family. When this approach was evaluated it was found to lack the desired effect, that is to say, by educating just one child per family did not necessarily make any difference to their siblings. Not only that, but the parents and other adults did not feel included. Now the policy is to take not just one child, but to work holistically by educating the whole family. All the children in a family are enrolled and assessed. The older adolescents and young adults, including those who may have fallen behind with their education, are tested and join groups according to their age and level. This new approach to grouping, plus the reduction in the number of pupils per class, have gone a long way to solving discipline problems and other disruptive behavioural problems stemming from mixed age-groups that had been so evident during the 2016 visit. As a direct result of this change, the VTT team decided to drop the programmed sessions on classroom discipline. An adult literacy programme has also been included to support the parents. In an effort to support teachers in their personal professional development, the small methodology library has been moved from almost unreachable low shelves in the library to bookshelves incorporated into the furniture near the individual workplaces. The finishing touch to the new layout is that each teacher now has a locker nearby where their personal belongings can be kept. In 2016 the VTT team had been concerned that the school had been too focussed on the extra curricula arts activities to the detriment of the pupils' academic studies. Funds had been used to equip ballet classes, an art club and music groups. While these activities are part of a balanced curriculum the team felt that the standard core subjects for education of language arts, writing, reading Changes based on the VTT 2016 Report The VTT team were delighted to hear that where previously the teachers had been 6 comprehension, mathematics, science, geography, social studies and history had been somewhat neglected. There had been very little IT usage, both in the teaching methodol ogy and in the learning strategies as evidence d by the produce them at different levels and in different subjects. To provide more personalised support the VTT team decided to include more individual classroom observations followed by non-judgmental feedback discussions. These observation sessions were originally scheduled for the teachers who had attended the 2016 course but, as only 50% were in this category, and at Iris Gokeelao's request, some of the new teachers were also included. Unfortunately, it proved to be impossible to include all 23 teachers, but in general these observation sessions proved to be extremely helpful, and many commented that they were the highlight of the programme. under Joanna inspires use of the (permanently) locked computer room. This situation has been completely changed the refocus is very much on the academic skills, slowly reintroducing the extra curricula activities to support them. Based on the fact that the teachers had found the online Training Programme intimidating due to their lack of experience with online distance learning and to ensure sustainability, the British Council was approached with the idea of continuing the Teacher Training/Development Programme face to face. The VTT team visited Mike Cabigon at the BC offices in downtown Manila and arranged for him to visit the school with the view of giving a presentation to all the staff. The resulting visit was a great success, the school hosting the meeting in typically Filipino fashion, with plenty to eat and lots of enthusiasm. Luckily Charlie Jorge from the Makati Uptown Rotary Club (Portsmouth and Southsea's sister club) was also able to attend, which strengthened the bond between the school and their local club. It has to be said that it is a shame that due to the fact that an extremely large open-plan church has been built across the road, the school has lost vital play areas. The VTT 2017 Project. Based on the 2016 Needs Analysis (online SurveyMonkey), the experience and results of the 2016 Training Programme and the difficulties of running the 2016 online Edmodo course, the VTT team focussed Hard at work their efforts in the second course on providing support in Classroom Management, CLIL (Content and Language Integrated Learning) and practical material writing skills. After learning about the extensive use of worksheets extra sessions were added to help the teachers create and Making the Project Sustainable After the teachers had given their final presentations on how they now see their Personal Development Paths and collecting feedback forms and comments from everyone involved in the Teacher Development Project, the VTT team 7 page” to raise money for their own professional development. unanimously decided that the funds for the development of the teachers of the Purple Centers Foundation school should be spent on continued training from the British Council. The monies donated for the second part of this project together with the sum left over from the original donation should ensure that all the members of the teaching staff will benefit from the British Council course. Should there be any funds remaining these will be used to buy methodology and teaching skills books and journals to add to their admittedly rather limited Teachers' Resources. With the inclusion of the British Council in the Philippines, money left over from this and the previous visits make this project sustainable. The VTT is now writing their final report and Dennis is writing the reports to the Rotary Foundation, District and St James’s Place (which kindly provided £2500 to the fund). We look forward to the team’s presentation to the Club in the near future. Saying Goodbye. And so it was with heavy hearts that the VTT team took their leave, this time feeling that they achieved what they had set out to do - to make a difference. Meanwhile, we have recently awarded a sponsorship of £200 to a local student reading Business Studies at Loughborough University so that he can go to Uganda with the registered charity ‘East African Playgrounds’ to build playgrounds suitable for the children there. Caroline Gwatkin Vocational Training Team & Public Relations ______________________________________ John Bishop International & Foundation ______________________________________ INTERNATIONAL AND FOUNDATION COMMITTEE REPORT A ROTARY CLUB THREE CENTURIES AGO! Since our last copy of Rotavator was published, our intrepid Vocational Training Team (VTT) has returned from their trip to the school built on a rubbish dump in Tondo, Manila. The team was impressed by how well the School had put into practice the items highlighted in the report from their first visit. An example of this is the provision of individual work stations, with computers and lockers for each teacher. A small library is currently being developed for the teachers to use. In a 1711 publication known as the Spectator (not related to the magazine of today which bears the same name), one of its characters, “Sir Roger de Coverley” lists a set of rules for a club made up of artisans and mechanics. I think you will enjoy reading them. “I cannot forbear concluding this paper with a scheme of laws that I met with upon a wall in a little alehouse. How I came thither I may inform my readers at a more convenient time. These laws were enacted by a knot of Amongst many other things, the VTT taught the teachers there how to set up a “giving 8 artisans and mechanics, who used to meet every night; and, as there is something in them which gives us a pretty picture of low life, I shall transcribe them word for word. FAMOUS SPEAKERS AT OUR CLUB As part of our centenary celebrations, our club archivist, Reg Gardner, looks back at a couple of notable speakers who addressed our club almost a century ago. “RULES TO BE OBSERVED IN THE TWOPENNY CLUB, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Erected in this Place for the Preservation of Friendship and good Neighbourhood. 1. Every member at his first coming shall 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. lay down his 2d. Every member shall fill his pipe out of his own box. If any member absent himself, he shall forfeit a penny for the use of the Club, unless in case of sickness or imprisonment. If any member swears or curses, his neighbour may give him a kick upon the shin. If any member tells stories in the Club that are not true, he shall forfeit for every third lie a halfpenny. If any member strikes another wrongfully, he shall pay his Club for him. If any member brings his wife into the Club, he shall pay for whatever she drinks or smokes. If any member’s wife comes to fetch him home from the Club, she shall speak to him without the door. If any member calls another a cuckold, he shall be turned out of the Club. None shall be admitted into the Club that is of the same trade with any member of it. None of the club shall have his clothes or shoes mended, but by a brother member. No non-juror shall be capable of being a member.” Arthur Conan Doyle visited us in September of 1918. A Scotsman born in 1859, he studied medicine at Edinburgh University and after first working in Plymouth moved to Portsmouth at the age of 23 to set up a Doctor’s practice in Elm Grove, Southsea. This was not a success and he found the lack of patients gave him ample time to write fiction, so perhaps the apparently excellent health of Portmuthians indirectly gave the world Sherlock Holmes, who first featured in “A Study in Scarlet” in 1886. As Conan Doyle did not leave Portsmouth until 1890, he may well have written this whilst a resident. It is as the author of the Sherlock Holmes mysteries that we know him best. All in all, with short stories as well as novels, Sherlock Holmes appears in sixty of Conan Doyle’s writings. He was a prolific writer of other works, non-fiction as well as his novels, perhaps the next most wellknown being the short stories about the Napoleonic wars featuring Brigadier Gerard. Contrary to what you may have thought, his knighthood, awarded in 1902, was not for his literary prowess. He had served in his medical capacity with some distinction in the Boer War and had written an important Reg Gardner ______________________________________ 9 “adventures” being a huge understatement, as the talk would have encompassed his heroics in rescuing his crew when their polar expedition vessel “Endurance” was trapped in ice in the Weddell Sea in the Antarctic for the winter of 1915. It had been hoped that the thaw of the ice in the following spring would free it and allow the expedition to sail for civilisation, but the ship broke up from the pressure of the ice. The 28 members of the expedition were marooned on ice floes until April, and when the floes began to break up they were forced to row 350 miles in the ship’s three lifeboats before arriving exhausted at the inhospitable and uninhabited Elephant Island. Here they remained until Shackleton decided that an attempt to get help was essential. He, and five others, then rowed 800 miles in an open lifeboat, the strongest of the three carried by Endurance, for fifteen days in stormy seas to reach South Georgia where there was a whaling station. The storm reached hurricane force and forced the little boat to land on the opposite side of South Georgia to the whaling station. Rather than risk another sea journey in the atrocious conditions, Shackleton with two of his men traversed the 30 miles of frozen mountains with their only climbing aids being a carpenter’s axe and fifty feet of rope, finally reaching help at the whaling station. After going back to pick up the three men left on the other side of South Georgia, he tried to get a vessel through the ice to Elephant Island to pick up the remaining 22 men he had left there. Three attempts failed until, with the help of the Chilean navy, he succeeded. The Elephant Island men had been there for over four months. Imagine, if you will, hearing this gripping story from the man himself, as our predecessors were able to do a century ago. A few words on Shackleton the man. He was an Irishman, born in County Kildare in 1874, and at the age of 27 had been Third Officer on Robert Falcon Scott’s Discovery and widely translated work justifying the British role in that campaign and it was for those activities he was knighted. He was a very competent sportsman. Whilst in Portsmouth he played in goal for Portsmouth Football Club, under the name of Smith. Later, whilst in London, he played first class cricket for M.C.C. as a batsman. As an occasional bowler, he only took one first class wicket, but that was that of the legendary W.G. Grace. The war took a severe personal toll on him. Shortly after he visited our Club he lost his son who had been two years convalescing from wounds received at the Somme, and his brother-in-law, the creator of “Raffles”, and two nephews also died in the conflict. Some feel the huge number of soldier’s deaths led him to spiritualism, in which he was a great believer, and even in fairies. To a degree his credulous acceptance of what were obvious frauds might well have ruined his wellearned reputation. At his funeral, a séance was held, but he did not appear. What did he speak to our Club about? It was a rather mundane subject. His talk was “War debt and how to meet it”. We can only guess that with the end of the First World War approaching, thoughts of what it had cost were exercising the minds of prominent people. Conan Doyle was then nearly sixty and deeply into spiritualism and to promote it he travelled to Australia not long after his visit to us. Sir Ernest Shackleton In October 1920, the Club organised a dinner in aid of the British Red Cross Society to hear Sir Ernest Shackleton speak of his “Adventures in the Antarctic”, his title 10 Expedition. He led the Nimrod Expedition in 1907-09, which got to within 100 miles of the South Pole and for which he received his knighthood. His third foray was the Imperial Trans-Antarctic Expedition in 1914-17, the one which suffered such heroic failure. He died in January 1922 from a heart attack whilst at South Georgia when commencing a fourth expedition. He had a bad heart throughout all his Antarctic days, and it is astonishing that he could achieve so much with such a disability. With his reputation and the magnificent tale he had to tell, Sir Ernest Shackleton might be regarded as the finest speaker we have had in our hundred years. It lists the vehicles just in front, and all those to the rear. And taking this into account, it specifies my gear. I'm sure no other driver, has so helpful a device. For when we leave and lock the car, it still gives its advice. It fills me up with counselling, each journey's pretty fraught. So why don't I exchange it, and get a quieter sort? Ah well, you see, it cleans the house, makes sure I'm properly fed. It washes all my shirts and things, and keeps me warm in bed! Despite all these advantages, and my tendency to scoff, I only wish that now and then, I could turn the dratted thing off. Reg Gardner Club Archivist ______________________________________ AND FINALLY…..A POEM FROM DAVID David Thomson ______________________________________ A Satnav is a driver's friend it tells you where you are. I have a little Satnav, I've had it all my life. It's better than the normal ones, my Satnav is my wife. It gives me full instructions, especially how to drive. "It's sixty miles an hour", it says, "You're doing sixty five". It tells me when to stop and start, and when to use the brake. And tells me that it's never ever, safe to overtake. It tells me when a light is red, and when it goes to green. It seems to know instinctively, just when to intervene. 11 WHAT’S ON 2017 APRIL Tue 4th 13.00 – Lunchtime meeting: Presentation ‘Operation Smile’ ! 2017 JUNE Tues 6th 13.00 – Lunchtime meeting 17.30 – Club Council meeting at Portsmouth Water, Havant 17.30 – Club Council meeting at Portsmouth Water, Havant Tue 11th Wed 12th Tue 18th Tue 25th Tue 13th 18.30 – Evening meeting: Speaker - Thea Noli 17.00 – PRHA Board Meeting at Rotary House NO MEETING 19.30 – Centenary Celebratory Event at the Naval Club Wed 14th Tue 20th Tue 27th MAY Tue 2nd Tue 9th Wed 10th Tue 16th Tue 23rd Tue 30th 18.30 – Evening meeting: Elizabeth Foundation Presentation 10.00 – 14.00 – Kids Out at Marwell Zoo NO MEETING 18.50 – Club Assembly. Presentation of club plans and aims for the next year JULY 13.00 – Lunchtime Meeting Sat 1st 17.30 – Club Council meeting at Portsmouth Water, Havant 18.30 – Evening Meeting: Speaker – Reg Gardner “A Day in Virginia” 12.00 – PRHA Annual General Meeting at Harrison House, Stamshaw NO MEETING 18.30 – Evening meeting: Rowan House Presentation 18.30 – Evening Meeting and Centenary Quiz Tue 4th Fri 14th Wed 19th 12 START OF NEW ROTARY YEAR (20172018) 13.00 – Lunchtime meeting: INSTALLATION OF NEW PRESIDENT CENTENARY SAFARI SUPPER – details to follow 17.00 – PRHA Board Meeting at Rotary House
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz