Metabolism of Resistant Mutants of Streptococcus faecalis II. Incorporation of Exogenous Purines*t M. EARI.BALIS,VALIAHYLIN, M. KATHARINE COULTAS ANDDORRISJ. HUTCHISON (Laboratories of the Sloan-Kettering Institute, New York, N.Y.) Several agents which inhibit neoplastic growth in man and in experimental animals appear to exert their effects at least partially by interference with nucleic acid purine metabolism. The clinical usefulness of such compounds is severely limited by the fact that, after a period of treatment, re sistance develops to the agent employed. The availability of mutant strains of Streptococcus faecalis1 resistant to the action of certain agents (13) has presented an avenue of approach to the mechanism of the development of such resistance and to the problem of the action of these agents. This work represents an attempt to compare the information derived from tracer studies with that which is known about the growth require ments of these bacteria. The organisms were grown in the presence of labeled purines, and the conver sion of these compounds to nucleic acid adenine and guanine was measured. MATERIALS AND METHODS Reagents.—Theadenine-8-C1* and the guanine-8-C14 were synthesized, as has been previously described (2, 8). The xanthine-8-C14 and hypoxanthine-8-C14 were purchased from the Southern Research Institute. The adenosine-8-Cu and guanosine-8-C14were prepared by Dr. B. Lowy and synthesized from adenine-8-C" and guanine-8-C14 (10). * A preliminary report of this work has been presented (4). t This investigation was supported by funds from the Na tional Cancer Institute, National Institutes of Health, Public Health Service (Grant No. Cy 3190, C-2699), and from the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission (Contract No. AT(8001)810). 1The strains studied have been designated as follows: SF/O = parent (ATCC No. 8043). SF/MP = resistant to 6-mercaptopurine. SF/MP/A = double mutant, resistant to 6-MP and Amethopterin. SF/MPcc = resistant to 6-MP, isolated independently of SF/MP. SF/DAP = resistant to 2,6-diaminopurine. SF/A = resistant to A-methopterin. SF/A/O = partial revert of SF/A. SF/A/MP = double mutant, resistant to A-methopterin and 6-MP. Received for publication September 19, 1957. Bacteria and media.—Theisolation and maintenance of the strains of S. faecalis have been described elsewhere (11, 13). The standardized inocula used in these experiments were grown and prepared according to the following regimen: Two successive transfers were made into 5 ml. of liquid medium identical with that on which the culture is carried. The third transfer with saline-washed inoculum was then made into 5 ml. of an unlabeled equivalent of the medium which was to be used in the labeled experiment. The inoculum used was one which gave approximately 8 X IO5cells/ml. In each experiment 400 ml. of a folie acid (1 m^g/ml) or thymine (1 ;ug/ml) supple mented purine and pyrimidine-free medium (F-PP) was further supplemented with the labeled purine at a concentration of 3.7 X 10-» M.This medium was sterilized at 121° C. for 15 min utes; if the labeled compound was heat-labile it was omitted from the medium, sterilized by filtration through an ultrafine sintered glass filter, and added aseptically to the cooled me dium. Just prior to inoculation, a 12-ml. aliquant was removed aseptically from each flask to serve as a titration blank. The flasks were then inoculated so that there were approximately 8 X IO5cells/ml and incubated at 35°C. for 18 hours. At the termination of the incubation period, 19 ml. was removed from each flask, and the rest of the cells were harvested by centrifugation. A 5-ml. aliquot was handled aseptically, since it was to be used as the inoculum for a series of controls to determine the resistance and purine requirement for the mutants after the above growth conditions had been carried out. A 2-ml. sample was used to determine the amount of growth by turbidity measurement on a Coleman Junior Spectrophotometer, and a 12-ml. sample was used for titer determination. Controls on A-methopterin and 6-mercaptopurine resist ance and purine requirements were made on each culture for each experiment, with the use of the saline-washed suspension, prepared from the 5-ml. aliquot removed from the experimen tal flasks, as seed. The basal medium for the resistance controls was the one supplemented with PGA at 1 mMg/ml, while the response to adenine, guanine, hypoxanthine, and xanthine was determined in this medium and also in one supplemented with thymine at 1 fig/ml rather than with the PGA. The controls were set up in 13 X 100-mm. tubes which con tained 2 ml. of medium; these tubes were sterilized at 121° C. for 8 minutes and, after being cooled, were inoculated with a saline-washed suspension diluted so that each inoculated tube contained 8 X IO6 cells/ml. Turbidity measurements were made after incubation for 18 hours at 35°C. Isolation of nucleic acid purines.—Theharvested cells were washed successively with cold trichloroacetic acid, alcohol, and ether. The washed cells were hydrolyzed at 37°C. for 24 hours with 1 ml. of l N sodium hydroxide per 180 mg. of bacteria (16). The degraded pentosenucleic acid (PNA) was separated from the deoxypentosenucleic acid (DNA) by acidification with HC1, followed by the addition of 1.5 volumes of ethanol. 220 Downloaded from cancerres.aacrjournals.org on June 15, 2017. © 1958 American Association for Cancer Research. BALIS et al.—Metabolism of S. faecalis Mutants. The DNA was collected by centrifugation. The individual purines were isolated, as has been previously described (7), by hydrolysis of the nucleic acids, precipitation of silver purines, regeneration of the purines as hydrochlorides, and separation of the individual purines by paper chromatography. The radio activities were determined as has been previously described (6). Infinitely thin films on aluminum planchéiswere measured in a Geiger-Müllerflow counter, with helium-isobutane gas. All the planchéiscontained sufficient radioactivily lo result in counts of at leasl twice Ihe background, and Ihe aclivities were determined to within slandard errors of less lhan 5 per cent (15) except where noted. Aclivilies are reported as relalive specific activity (RSA), defined as ESA counts/min/^mole isolated compound X 100. counls/min/Mmole supplemenl RESULTS The capacity of the eight strains1 to use adenine as a precursor of the nucleic acid adenine and guanine was determined (Table 1). With the ex- II 221 cursor and the amount of DNA purines which were derived from the same source. The capacity of these eight mutants to utilize exogenously supplied adenosine was determined (Table 1), and the results were similar to those obtained with the free base, with the exception of those found with SF/MP, which used exogenous adenosine even more poorly than it did exogenous adenine for the synthesis of nucleic acid adenine. The degree of conversion of the adenine moiety to guanine was about the same when the free base or when the ribosides were used. A similar series of experiments was carried out with guanine and guanosine used as precursors. The results of these studies are shown in Table 2. Again it can be seen that all the mutants except SF/MP could convert the exogenous purine and the exogenously supplied riboside to both the TABLE 1 UTILIZATION OFEXOGENOUS ADENINEANDADENOSINE IN FOLICACID-CONTAINING MEDIA STHAIN EXP. 1: ADENINE* Adenine Guanine PNA DNA PNA DNA Exp. RSAt SF/0 SF/MP SF/MP/A SF/MPcc SF/DAP SF/A SF/A/O SF/A/MP 48 1» SO SS 45 58 47 47 36 80 37 84 SS 41 80 2: ADENOSINEf Adenine PNA DNA Guanine PNA DNA RSAt 44 4 51 38 40 65 47 50 50 5 41 SO 9 31 31 56 47 40 41 40 54 43 34 11 26 31 37 31 26 28 29 6 28 29 47 41 86 36 28 4 26 27 35 28 27 28 * Experimenl 1 medium contained 3.7 X 10 6 moles/liter of adenine-8-C14. t Experiment 2 medium contained 3.7 X 10~6moles/liler of adenosine-8-C14. __. _ counls/min/Atmole iVSA —: -. isolated compound : : - counls/mm/^mole supplemenl X 100. ception of SF/MP, all were able to synthesize a nucleic acid purines. SF-/MP was again inefficient considerable portion of both of their nucleic acid in the conversion of the purine from the supplied purines from adenine. This one exception was able compound to adenine, and again it can be seen to derive its polynucleotide adenine from the exog that the mutant SF/A converted the exogenously enously supplied adenine to about one-half the supplied purine to nucleic acid purines to a greater extent that the other mutants were able to do, but extent than did the other strains. In the experi it was extremely inefficient in converting this exog ments listed in Table 2, it is evident that there was enous precursor to guanine. This is consistent no significant difference in the incorporation of the with the fact that all the strains except SF/MP exogenously supplied purine into the PNA as were able to grow in a folie acid-free medium with compared with that into the DNA. adenine as the sole source of purines. Mutant The capacity of these eight strains to use SF/A incorporated the exogenous purine to a xanthine as a precursor of the two nucleic acid greater extent than did the other strains; this is purines was determined, and the results are pre consistent with the growth studies which would sented in Table 3. Here again, there was no exten seem to indicate that this mutant is less efficient sive difference in the relative amount of the purine at synthesis de novo than are the other strains. It that was converted into the PNA as compared will further be noted that there is no significant with that into the DNA. In contrast to the results difference between the relative amount of PNA obtained when adenine and guanine were the pre purines that have been synthesized from this pre- cursors, mutant SF/MP was able to use xanthine, Downloaded from cancerres.aacrjournals.org on June 15, 2017. © 1958 American Association for Cancer Research. 222 Vol. 18, February, 1958 Cancer Research particularly for guanine synthesis, to about the same degree as did the wild strain or the other mutants. Xanthine, in contrast to guanine and adenine, was used to a greater extent for the syn thesis of nucleic acid guanine than it was for the synthesis of nucleic acid adenine by all strains which were studied. The capacity of these micro organisms to utilize xanthine in a folie acid-free for several strains. With the exception of the mu tant which is resistant to 2,6-diaminopurine, about three-fourths of the adenine was synthesized from the exogenously supplied adenine, and SF/DAP made only hah' its adenine from this source. All the mutants synthesized more of their nucleic acid guanine from the exogenously supplied adenine than did the mutant SF/DAP. In Table 3, results TABLE 2 UTILIZATION OFEXOGENOUS GUANINEANDGUANOSINE IN FOLICACID-CONTAINING MEDIA EXP. 3* STRAIN Adenine PNA DNA HSAt ÕÕ4 41 12 2 SO SF/O EXP. 4t Guanine PNA DNA SF/MP 1 30 SF/MP/A 45 39 :u 40 SF/MPcc 35 49 38 40 SF/DAP 38 50 SF/A 66 33 SF/A/O 45 43 SF/A/MP 38 41 * Experiment 3 medium contained 3.7 X t Experiment 4 medium contained 3.7 X Adenine PNA DNA Guanine PNA DNA RSAÃŽ 43 38 l 18 28 42 47 41 62 32 40 42 82 52 4(î 37 «7 34 4* 52 38 4(¡ 38 40 Vf 10 ' moles/liter of guanine-8-C14. 10~5moles/liter of guanosine-8-C14. 34 40 2 SS S« 41 39 31 68 38 48 42 43 ÃŒ See footnote t Table 1. TABLE 3 UTILIZATION OFEXOGENOUS PURINES EXP. 5* 6 + DAPf 7 + DAPÃŽ 8} (A-8-C»)AdeninePNARSA34393834fil606685512972807166637867646694503976727254777505658158827874DNARSA487682Guani (X-8-C»)AdeninePNADNAGuaninePNADNAEXP. (X-8-C»)AdeninePNA2816302145482935GUIDNA (H-8-C»)AdeninePNA214235250412932DNA234103923252 STRAIN PNA27182724343823RSA#4348484045684748nineDNAEXP. SF/O SF/MP SF/MP/A SF/MPcc SF/DAP SF/A SF/A/O SF/A/MP The following abbreviations have been used: X, xanthine; DAP, 2,6-diaminopurine; A, adenine and H, hypoxanthine. * Experiment 5 medium contained 3.7 X 10~*moles/liter of xanthine-8-C" and 1 m/ig/ml of folie acid. t Experiment 6 medium contained 3.7 X 10~6 moles/liter each of xanthine-8-C1* and of 2,6-diaminopurine, and 8 X 10~* moles/liter of thymine. ÃŽ Experiment 7 medium contained 3.7 X 10~6 moles/liter each of adenine-8-C" and of 2,6-diaminopurine, and 8 X 10~6 moles/liter of thymine. §Experiment 8 medium contained 3.7 X 10~5moles/liter of hypoxanthine-8-C" and 1 m/xg/ml of folie acid. # See footnote J, Table 1. medium, but in the presence of 2,6-diaminopurine, was also determined and is shown in Table 3. With the exception of mutant SF/MPcc, all the strains studied synthesized a larger fraction of the nucleic acid purines from xanthine than they did from the 2,6-diaminopurine. Indeed, mutant SF/MP syn thesized only a very small amount of its adenine and guanine from the 2,6-diaminopurine. The utilization of adenine in a folie acid-free medium containing 2,6-diaminopurine was also determined are also shown from an experiment in which the capacity of the organisms to use hypoxanthine as a purine precursor was determined. It can be seen that the mutant SF/MP used hypoxanthine ex tremely poorly, and it synthesized just as little nucleic acid adenine as it did nucleic acid guanine from this precursor. Most of the mutants, with the exception of SF/MP, used hypoxanthine more readily than did the parent strain, SF/O. In gen eral, the mutants synthesized a little more nucleic Downloaded from cancerres.aacrjournals.org on June 15, 2017. © 1958 American Association for Cancer Research. BALISet al.—Metabolism of S. faecalis Mutants. II 223 this compound. These observations are consistent with the postulated mechanism of action for 6-MP (5) which proposes that 6-MP, in the course of be coming inhibitory, is converted to a nucleotide de rivative that antagonizes the interconversion of DISCUSSION the natural purine ribotides involved in the syn Several strains of S. faecalis have been studied, thesis of nucleic acid purines. If we imagine that strains which are resistant to purine antagonists the organism cannot use the exogenous adenine, or to substances implicated in the synthesis of guanine, or hypoxanthine, because it lacks en purines, and yet with the exception of the one zymes necessary for the conversion of these exog mutant, SF/MP, there is no definitive change in enous purines to the biologically active nucleothe pattern of purine utilization that would in any tides, and if we further postulate that the enzymes way explain the resistance of these bacteria to which are responsible for this conversion are also the ones which convert 6-MP to the nucleotide these particular inhibitors. The one mutant, SF/MP, shows that it lacks the ability to convert (the true inhibitor), then it can be seen that the exogenous adenine or exogenous guanine into the absence of these enzymes would result both in the corresponding nucleic acid purine, and thus it is inability of the organism to use adenine, hypoxan logical that this organism should be unable to grow thine, or guanine as a purine source for growth and in a folie acid-deficient medium with adenine or in the organism's being resistant to 6-MP. It was further noted that the mutant did not interconguanine as a source of purines for growth. How ever, it is not immediately apparent how loss of vert exogenous adenine and guanine. If the bac synthetic ability should result in resistance to an terium possesses very limited ability to convert exogenous adenine and guanine to the active ribo antagonist. The double mutants are particularly enigmatic. tides, then in effect only trace amounts are avail A mutant which was isolated from SF/MP on the able to the cell. Such a situation was studied with basis of A-methopterin resistance was able to Escherichia coli, and it was found that small con convert adenine from the medium into nucleic acid centrations of adenine or guanine resulted in a guanine and could convert guanine from the me very limited interconversion of the exogenous pre dium into nucleic acid adenine; this ability is lack cursor, though higher concentrations resulted in ing in the parent SF/MP. If the inability of the extensive interconversion (14). mutant SF/MP to utilize exogenously supplied In view of the fact that neither adenine nor adenine for this synthesis of nucleic acid guanine guanine is extensively converted to the other by is fundamentally associated with the mutant's re the mutant SF/MP and the fact that this organ sistance to the action of 6-MP, it is difficult to ism is able to convert xanthine into both nucleic understand how the biochemical changes con acid adenine and nucleic acid guanine, this or comitant with the second mutation could restore ganism offers evidence again of the fact that there the synthetic ability and yet not restore sensitivity must be more than one pathway leading from to the action of 6-MP. In essence, the conversion adenine to guanine. It has also been noted that of the mutant SF/MP into SF/MP/A has resulted this organism, when grown on suboptimal amounts in the resistance to 6-MP being manifested in a of xanthine in a folie acid-free medium, is stimu manner more similar to that observed with SF/ lated in its growth by the addition of mixtures of MPcc, and perhaps this is merely evidence of a adenine and guanine. The bacterium derives a suf very close relationship between the two routes to ficient quantity of nucleic acid purines from these resistance—one exhibited by SF/MP and the two (adenine and guanine) together to spare the other by SF/MPcc. Certainly, the data presented requirement for xanthine. Thus, it appears that have shown the complexity of the mechanisms adenine and guanine in combination should be that lead to the development of resistance to anti- able to supply all the nucleic acid purines re metabolites, and they have shown an interrelation quired for growth; yet no growth results (13). This ship between these actions. is another example of a situation in which a quan The mutant SF/MP, is, for all practical pur titative reduction in the ability of an organism to poses, unable to utilize exogenously supplied hy carry out a necessary biological process has resulted poxanthine as a precursor of nucleic acid purines. in a qualitative alteration in growth response. If This mutant can synthesize nucleic acid purines the organism cannot make a quantity of nucleic de novo. Therefore, it must be able to utilize ino- acid purines above some threshold level, there is sinic acid, and the mutation cannot involve any not a reduction in growth proportional to the re metabolic steps subsequent to the formation of duction in this synthetic process, but no growth at acid adenine than guanine from this precursor. When hypoxanthine was used as a precursor, there was definitely less utilization of the precursor for DNA synthesis than for PNA synthesis. Downloaded from cancerres.aacrjournals.org on June 15, 2017. © 1958 American Association for Cancer Research. 224 Cancer Research all. A similar situation was observed with a purineless mutant of Aerobacter aerogenes (1), which was able to synthesize nucleic acid purines from 2,6diaminopurine but was able to do so only at a level of about one-third that of the parent; as a result of this quantitative reduction in ability to use 2,6diaminopurine, there was no growth whatsoever on this substrate. The mutant SF/A, when studied with regard to its folie acid requirements, was found to have a lower requirement for this growth factor in the presence of purines than did the parent strain for optimal growth (13). However, the growth was less extensive in the absence of purines, and under these conditions the organism had a much higher requirement for folie acid than did the parent. These findings are made clearer in view of the in corporation studies. This mutant utilizes the exogenously supplied purine to a greater extent than do the other strains which were studied. This we have interpreted to mean that the organism has a lessened de novosynthetic ability as compared with its parent, and, hence, in the medium which is free of purines more folie acid is required to give the optimal amount of growth than is required with those organisms which are more capable of carry ing out the de novo synthesis of purines. Further more, this organism has apparently compensated to some extent for this lessened de novo path by a greater ability to utilize exogenously supplied purines. This shift in metabolic pattern is remi niscent of that which was indicated for an A-methopterin-resistant leukemia in which the capacity to synthesize nucleic acid purines and thymine from formate appeared to be reduced (3). The ability of this organism to survive in the presence of A-methopterin is perhaps most consistent with the concept that this inhibitor acts, to some extent at least, by causing unbalanced growth (3, 9). Therefore, a reduction in the rate of synthesis of nucleic acid purines via the affected routes would make the organism less susceptible to the in hibitor. The second mutant that is resistant to the ac tion of 6-MP, SF/MPcc, possesses no definite metabolic trait, discernible by the methods of in vestigation used, which would indicate in any way the mechanism by which this organism has become resistant to the action of 6-MP. The only differ ence that this organism manifested was a lessened utilization of xanthine in the presence of 2,6-diaminopurine. In view of the fact that, under the conditions of this experiment, there was no folie acid present, the lessened utilization of xanthine is equivalent to an increased utilization of 2,6-diaminopurine. Other than that, the organism uti Vol. 18, February, 1958 lized the purines which were studied in a manner quite similar to the other strains and to the parent strain. Two different mutants have been studied which arose in response to what appeared to be identical treatment. These two organisms have different folie acid requirements (12) and are distinct indi viduals in response to exogenous purines. They are one example of the variety of alterations which can lead to the same end—resistance to an in hibitor. It is undoubtedly true that many tissues in response to a variety of agents will develop re sistance in several independent fashions. SUMMARY Several strains of S. faecalis which are resistant to agents which suppress the growth of some tu mors have been studied with respect to their ability to utilize certain purines and purine ribosides for nucleic acid synthesis. In those instances in which more than one mutant resistant to the same agents has been obtained, the mutants dif fered in other respects. This was most strikingly demonstrated by two strains resistant to 6-mercaptopurine, which differed in their growth re quirements and in their ability to utilize various purines for nucleic acid synthesis. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors wish to thank Dr. George Bosworth Brown for his continued interest and very helpful discussions of the prob lem. REFERENCES 1. BALIS,M. E.; BROOKE,M. S.; BROWN,G. B.; and MAGA8ANIK,B. The Utilization of Purines by Purineless Mutants of Aerobacter aerogenes. J. Biol. Chem., 219:917-26,1956. 2. BALIS,M. E.; BROWN,G. B.; ELION, G. B.; HITCHINGS, G. H.; and VANDERWERFF, H. On the Interconversion of Purines by L. casei. J. Biol. Chem., 188:217-19, 1951. 8. BALIS,M. E., and DANOIS,J. Effects of A-Methopterin on Nucleic Acid Synthesis in Leukemic Spleen Breis. Cancer Research, 15:603-8, 1955. 4. BALIS,M. E., and HUTCHISON, D. J. Purine Metabolism of Resistant Strains of Streptococcus faecalis. Bact. Proc., p. 135, 1955. 5. BALIS,M. E.; LEVIN,D. H.; BROWN,G. B.; ELION,G. B.; NATHAN,H. C.; and HITCHINGS,G. H. The Effects of 6Mereaptopurine on Lactobacillus casei. Arch. Biochem. & Biophys. 71:355-66, 1957. 6. BALIS,M. E.; LEVIN,D. H.; BROWN,G. B.; ELION,G. B.; VANDERWERFF, H.; and HITCHINGS,G. H. The Incorpora tion of Exogenous Purines into Pentose Nucleic Acid by Lactobacillus casei. 3. Biol. Chem., 196:729-47, 1952. 7. BALIS,M. E.; LEVIN,D. H.; and LUZZATI,D. A PurineHistidine Relationship in E. coli. 3. Biol. Chem., 216:9-16, 1955. 8. CLARK,V. M., and KALCKAR,H. M. A Synthesis of Adenine Labeled with C14.J. Chem. Soc., pp. 1029-30, 1950. 9. COHEN,S. S. Thymine Deficiency and the Death of Bac teria. Texas Reps. Biol. & Med., 16:154-30, 1957. Downloaded from cancerres.aacrjournals.org on June 15, 2017. © 1958 American Association for Cancer Research. BALISet al.—Metabolism of S. faecalis Mutants. II 225 faecalis. I. Isolation and Characterization of the Mutants. 10. DAVOLL,J., and LOWT,B. A. A New Synthesis of Furine Cancer Research, 18:214-19, 1958. Nucleosides. The Synthesis of Adenosine, Guanosine, and 2,6-Diamino-9-0-D-ribofuranosylpurine. J. Am. Chem. 14. KOCH,A. L.; PUTNAM,F. W.; and EVANS,E. A., JB. The Soc., 73:1650-55, 1951. Furine Metabolism of Escherichia coli. J. Biol. Chem., 197:105-12, 1952. 11. HUTCHISON,D. J. Biological Activities of 6-Mercapto15. LOEVINGEH,R., and BEBMAN,M. Efficiency Criteria in purine: Effects on Streptococcusfaecalis. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Radioactivity Counting. Nucleonics, 9 (1): 26, 1951. Sc., 60:212, 1954. S. J. A Method for the 12. . In: J. W. REBUCK,P. BETHEIX,and R. MONTO, 16. SCHMIDT,G., and THANNHAUSEB, The Leukemias, pp. 605-15. New York: Academic Press, Determination of Deoxyribonucleic Acid, Ribonucleic Acid and Phosphoproteins in Animal Tissues. J. Biol. Inc., 1957. Chem., 161:83-89, 1945. 13. . Metabolism of Resistant Mutants of Streptococcus Downloaded from cancerres.aacrjournals.org on June 15, 2017. © 1958 American Association for Cancer Research. Metabolism of Resistant Mutants of Streptococcus faecalis: II. Incorporation of Exogenous Purines M. Earl Balis, Valia Hylin, M. Katharine Coultas, et al. Cancer Res 1958;18:220-225. Updated version E-mail alerts Reprints and Subscriptions Permissions Access the most recent version of this article at: http://cancerres.aacrjournals.org/content/18/2/220 Sign up to receive free email-alerts related to this article or journal. To order reprints of this article or to subscribe to the journal, contact the AACR Publications Department at [email protected]. To request permission to re-use all or part of this article, contact the AACR Publications Department at [email protected]. Downloaded from cancerres.aacrjournals.org on June 15, 2017. © 1958 American Association for Cancer Research.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz