Renewable
Energy Development in the California Desert
!
UM School of Natural Resources & Environment Report 2010
!""#$%&'()(*(+,&-&,./01!-#(02-!3("324#1,0(&$(1!-&523$&!(
+678769/0:;8<("=>?<:6@(7A(1;87B>=A7;
=*>*$,6*-
.-,/*("+?)@*
A$*("-#(#"%+.B-(C)0*-
D,()"#,1
D)17+E%6* E*(C1,$,F%
.C)0*
G1$#1*+=)"* 2)6)(#"%+HIJK
Concentrating Solar Power (including Concentrating Photovoltaics)
5B0-)
L#@M*-$#1)
2)$#3,-1#)N0+OC,$*0)$*+@)-P*"
9)P*-03#*$7
D#1*)-+Q-*01*$ G6*-)"#,1
:RR;
<
*0,$)-
'#*--)+'B1+E,O*-
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
51F*$,6*+S)$$*%T+25
E,O*-
:RRU
<
DBV+
',$)-+A1*-F%+W*1*-)"#1F+'%0"*@0+H'AW'K+X
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
=)FF*""
E-,BFC
G6*-)"#,1
YU;<
YZ
DBV+
',$)-+A1*-F%+W*1*-)"#1F+'%0"*@0+H'AW'K+XX
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
=)FF*""
E-,BFC
G6*-)"#,1
YU;[
\R
DBV+
',$)-+A1*-F%+W*1*-)"#1F+'%0"*@0+H'AW'K+XXX
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
L-)@*-+]B1("#,1
E-,BFC
G6*-)"#,1
YU;^
\R
DBV+
',$)-+A1*-F%+W*1*-)"#1F+'%0"*@0+H'AW'K+XS
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
L-)@*-+]B1("#,1
E-,BFC
G6*-)"#,1
YU;;
\R
DBV+
',$)-+A1*-F%+W*1*-)"#1F+'%0"*@0+H'AW'K+S
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
L-)@*-+]B1("#,1
E-,BFC
G6*-)"#,1
YU;U
\R
DBV+
',$)-+A1*-F%+W*1*-)"#1F+'%0"*@0+H'AW'K+SX
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
L-)@*-+]B1("#,1
E-,BFC
G6*-)"#,1
YU;U
\R
DBV+
',$)-+A1*-F%+W*1*-)"#1F+'%0"*@0+H'AW'K+SXX
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
L-)@*-+]B1("#,1
E-,BFC
G6*-)"#,1
YUUR
;R
YUUY
;R
G6*-)"#,1
DBV+
',$)-+A1*-F%+W*1*-)"#1F+'%0"*@0+H'AW'K+X_
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
L-)@*-+]B1("#,1
E-,BFC
G6*-)"#,1
W-**1S,$"0T+X1(`
WSY
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
9%-,1
2.S
2,10"-B("#,1
:
5M*1F,)+',$)-++
I,/)>*+',$)-
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
')1+9*-1)7#1,+2,B1"%
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
:<R
5((#,1)+',$)-+.,O*-++
Q"`+X-O#1+',$)-+.,O*-+.-,/*("
!`'`+5-@%b0B--,B17#1F+B"#$#"#*0
Q"`+X-O#1
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
U;R
9-#FC"',B-(*+A1*-F%+
X>)16)C+',$)-+A$*("-#(+W*1*-)"#1F+'%0"*@+H'AW'K+X
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
9)-0",O
E,O*-
=*>*$,6@*1"
Y:[
9-#FC"',B-(*+A1*-F%+
#>)16)C+',$)-+A$*("-#(+W*1*-)"#1F+'%0"*@+H'AW'K+XX
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
9)-0",O
E,O*-
=*>*$,6@*1"
Y\\
9-#FC"',B-(*+A1*-F%+
#>)16)C+',$)-+A$*("-#(+W*1*-)"#1F+'%0"*@+H'AW'K+XXX
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
9)-0",O
E,O*-
=*>*$,6@*1"
Y\\
*',$)-
W)0P*$$+'B1+E,O*-+H.C)0*+XK
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
L*-1+2,B1"%
E,O*-
=*>*$,6@*1"
YR<
*',$)-
W)0P*$$+'B1+E,O*-+H.C)0*+XXK
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
L*-1+2,B1"%
E,O*-
=*>*$,6@*1"
YZR
*',$)-
5$6#1*+'B1E,O*-
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
D)1()0"*-
E,O*-
=*>*$,6@*1"
U:
c)-6*-+D)P*T+DD2
c)-6*-+D)P*+',$)-+.$)1"
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
:<R
X1$)17+A1*-F%T+X1(`
.)$@7)$*+c%M-#7+W)0&',$)-
.)$@7)$*
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
<R
X1$)17+A1*-F%T+X1(`
S#(",->#$$*+c%M-#7+W)0&',$)-
S#(",->#$$*
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
<R
L*-1+2,B1"%
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
:<R
d#>*-0#7*+2,B1"%
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
:<R
?*8"A-)+A1*-F%+d*0,B-(*0
9*)(,1+',$)-+A1*-F%+.-,/*("
?*8"A-)+A1*-F%+d*0,B-(*0
W*1*0#0+',$)-+A1*-F%+.-,/*("
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
')1+],)eB#1+',$)-T+DD2
')1+],)eB#1+',$)-+Y
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
2,)$#1F)
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
<\
')1+],)eB#1+',$)-T+DD2
')1+],)eB#1+',$)-+:
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
2,)$#1F)
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
<\
'P%QB*$++
'P%E-,BFC+7*@,10"-)"#,1
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
=)FF*""
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
Z\
',$)-+I#$$*11#B@
9$%"C*+',$)-+.,O*-+.-,/*("
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
9$%"C*
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
YRRR
',$)-+I#$$*11#B@
d#7F*(-*0"+',$)-+.,O*-+.-,/*("
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
d#7F*(-*0"
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
:<R
',$)-+I#$$*11#B@
.)$*1+',$)-+.,O*-+.-,/*("
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
=*0*-"+2*1"*-
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
:<R
',$)-d*0*->*
d#(*+',$)-+A1*-F%+.-,/*("
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
d#>*-0#7*+2,B1"%
E,O*-
=*>*$,6@*1"
Y<R
',$*$
I,/)>*+',$)-+.)-P
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
I,/)>*+=*0*-"
E-,BFC
=*>*$,6@*1"
<<\
E*00*-)+',$)-
'A'+',$)-+G1*
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
S#(",->#$$*
=#0C&*1F#1*
=*>*$,6@*1"
;<R
E*00*-)+',$)-
'A'+',$)-+EO,
')1+=#*F,+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
X@6*-#)$+2,B1"%
=#0C&*1F#1*
=*>*$,6@*1"
^<R
E*00*-)+',$)-
'A'+',$)-+EC-**
X@6*-#)$+2,B1"%
=#0C&*1F#1*
=*>*$,6@*1"
<<R
!
!"#$#"%&'()$*+',$)-+.-,/*("0+#1+2)$#3,-1#)+4+566*17#8+9+
:;<+
!
Renewable Energy Development in the California Desert
UM School of Natural Resources & Environment Report 2010
+678769/0:;8<("=>?<:6@(7A(1;87B>=A7;
=*>*$,6*-
.-,/*("+?)@*
A$*("-#(#"%+.B-(C)0*-
D,()"#,1
D)17+E%6* E*(C1,$,F%
.C)0*
G1$#1*+=)"* 2)6)(#"%+HIJK
Photovoltaics (excluting Concentrating Photovoltaics)
Q#-0"+',$)-+
Q'A
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
9$%"C*
EC#1&3#$@
G6*-)"#,1
2$*)1"*(C+5@*-#()T+X1(`
2)$dA?AJ&Y
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
I*17,")
EC#1&3#$@
2,10"-B("#,1
<
5((#,1)+',$)-+.,O*-+
Q"`+X-O#1+',$)-+.,O*-+.-,/*("
!`'`+5-@%b0B--,B17#1F+B"#$#"#*0
Q"`+X-O#1
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
:R
9)-0",O
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
YU
DB(*-1*+S)$$*%+',$)-+.-,/*("
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
')1+9*-1)7#1,+2,B1"%
EC#1&3#$@
=*>*$,6@*1"
Z<
2)1"#$
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
[
Q#-0"+',$)-+
E,6)V+',$)-+Q)-@
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
2)-#00)+.$)#10
EC#1&3#$@
=*>*$,6@*1"
<<R
Q#-0"+',$)-+
=*0*-"+'B1$#FC"
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
=*0*-"+2*1"*-
EC#1&3#$@
=*>*$,6@*1"
\RR
Q#-0"+',$)-+
=*0*-"+'B1$#FC"
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
=*0*-"+2*1"*-
EC#1&3#$@
=*>*$,6@*1"
:<R
!`'`+5#-+Q,-(*
D)1()0"*-
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
<RR
D)P*+c)>)0B+2#"%
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
Y:RR
^R
2`Q`+.-,6*-"#*0
2C*>-,1+A1*-F%+',$B"#,10
2$*)-+'P#*0+',$)-T+X1(`
Q,",O)"#,+d*1*O)M$*+S*1"B-*0++
?**7$*+I,B1")#1+.,O*-T+DD2++
'"*-$#1F+.-,@*("
.,O*-J,-P0
W,$7*1+c#$$0
:RRU
:Y
5$@*7)+2,B1"%
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
d*(B--*1"+A1*-F%
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
L*-1+2,B1"%
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
[
d*(B--*1"+A1*-F%
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
L*-1+2,B1"%
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
::
',B"C*-1+2)$#3,-1#)+A7#0,1
')1+9*-1)7#1,+2,B1"%
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
::
')1+Q-)1(#0(,+.BM$#(+!"#$#"#*0+2,@@#00#,1
')1+Q-)1(#0(,
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
<
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
YRR
d*(B--*1"+A1*-F%
d*(B--*1"+A1*-F%
')1+Q-)1(#0(,+'B10*"+d*0->,#-+',$)-+.-,/*("
',$)-+A1*-F%+X1#"#)"#>*0T+X1(`
2)$#3,-1#)+',$)-+.)-P
',$)-F*1+A1*-F%
')1+9*1#",+2,B1"%
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
Z:R
',$)-+.-,/*("+',$B"#,10
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
EB$)-*+2,B1"%
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
:R
',$)-+.-,/*("+',$B"#,10
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
EB$)-*+2,B1"%
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
:R
',$)-+.-,/*("+',$B"#,10
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
EB$)-*+2,B1"%
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
:R
',$)-+.-,/*("+',$B"#,10
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
L#1F0+2,B1"%
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
:R
',$)-+.-,/*("+',$B"#,10
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
EB$)-*+2,B1"%
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
<R
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
:
2)$#3,-1#)+'")"*+!1#>*-0#"#*0
EC#1&3#$@
=*>*$,6@*1"
;
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
:<R
.S
=*>*$,6@*1"
YR
',$,1+2,-6,-)"#,1
.WaA+',$,1+.-,/*("
'B1A7#0,1
'B1.,O*-
2)$#3,-1#)+S)$$*%+',$)-+d)1F*
.)(#3#(+W)0+a+A$*("-#(
')1+DB#0+GM#06,+2,B1"%
D,0+51F*$*0+=*6)-"@*1"+,3+J)"*-+a+.,O*- GO*10+D)P*
!
:;[+
+
566*17#8+9+4+!"#$#"%&'()$*+',$)-+.-,/*("0+#1+2)$#3,-1#)+
!