HERITAGE Professor Stanley D. Beck: Outstanding Scientist and Hero of the Human Spirit Gene R. DeFoliart I n1968, the Department of Entomology at the University of Wisconsin submitted Stan Beck's name in nomination for a named professorship in recognition of his many scientific achievements. In 1969, he was named the W. A. Henry Distinguished Professor. One of the outside scholars who had been asked to submit a letter in support of this nomination was Reginald H. Painter of Kansas State University. In his letter, Dr. Painter stated: "Ever since he went back to his research [after being stricken with polio in 1952], with its outstanding contributions, I have considered that beyond his scientific contribution he is one of the heroes of the human spirit and as such has been an inspiration to his older colleagues as well as the younger ones." That statement probably sums up as well as one statement can why Stan Beck has been such an inspiration to a generation of entomologists. Although Stan was physically confined to a wheelchair the last 45 years of his life, his spirit and his intellect continued to roam free. And his scientific accomplishments continued to build. Stanley D. Beck was born October 17, 1919, in Portland, Oregon, and died July 8, 1997, of post-polio syndrome in Madison, Wisconsin. Isabel Beck, Stan's wife of 54 years, said that it became very hard for him near the end, but he never gave up. Isabel was, undoubtedly, one reason why he never gave up. To many people who knew the Becks, Isabel also qualified as one of the heroes of the human spirit. She worked tirelessly to make sure he was able to travel and work, and that he had a loving, caring family. In fact, about a year after the onset of Stan's illness, which came within one degree of being fatal, Wallace Wikoff, well-known writer for the Madison-published newspaper, Wisconsin State journal, wrote an article entitled "The Becks: Heroes Without Medals": AMERICAN ENTm10LOGIST • Volume 46, Number 3 correspondence (Chippendale and Reese 1998). The "SDB/me" at the end of a letter meant literally "Stanley D. Beck, me." His hospital quarters began to look like an office with stacks of books and notes strewn all around the bed. Between naps and therapy sessions, Stan met with graduate students and worked on papers for publication. "Had to earn my salt," he said. It helped facilitate his work when the university loaned him a dictating machine. Wikoff quoted Stan as follows: Once you have adjusted yourself to the realization that you are-slightly incapacitated, then the road back is lessdifficult.For,sooner or later, you wake up to the realization that there are not many alternatives. You either must readjust your life or give up completely. Professor Stanley D. Beck, 1970. In the service you get medals for displaying courage. At home there are no medals ... But if medals were struck for what StanleyBeckdid in conqueringalmost total paralysisand at the same time continuing his work for the University of Wisconsin of which he is a faculty member, a duplicate should be struck for his pretty redhaired wife, Isabelle [sic],who refused to let her husband get despondent and showed a devotion in his darkest hours that should be a challengeto any married couple. During the long months of therapy and convalescence, as his stricken limbs and muscles gradually became stronger, Stan taught himself to stab at a typewriter with a pencil gripped in his partly usable left hand and to type with one finger. He attained such a high degree of typing proficiency that he prepared all of his own manuscripts and Stan Beck grew up in the State of Washington, living in several towns near Mt. Ranier. He loved hiking and fishing in the mountains. Former students say that some of his funnier stories dealt with out-witting the wildlife agents in order to hike back to some of the best fishing spots in the Cascades. His interest in insects developed during a biology course in high school. After high school he worked for a year in a lumber mill to earn money for college, and he worked for two summers in the apple orchards of an experiment station in Wenatchee, Washington. Stan graduated in 1942 from Washington State College (now Washington State University) as a Phi Beta Kappa and magna cum laude. He served in the Navy from 1942 to 1945 as a lieutenant on a mine sweeper. He gained a master's degree and a doctorate, both in zoology from the University of Wisconsin in 1947 and 1950, respectively. He also served as an instructor of entomology from 1948 to 1950 and then received an appointment as Assistant Professor of Entomology. 141 A Stanley Beck Photo Album Clockwise from upper left. A young Stanley Beck with his dog, Jinx. Isabel Beck shortly before her marriage to Stan in 1943. Stanley Beck, Ensign, U.S. Navy, Chicago, IL, 1943. This photograph of Isabel and Stan accompanied a Madison newspaper article, "The Becks: Heroes Without Medals; published in the "Wisconsin State Journal," June 7, 1953. Portrait of Stan and Isabel on their 35th wedding anniversary in 1978, with their grown children. From left, Bruce, Diana, Stan, Marianne, Isabel, Karen. 142 AMERICAN ENTO~10I.OGIST • Fal/2000 not last long, but will give rise to other ideas. In the same way, although he would probably like knowing that he is missed, it would please him far more to know that his contributions to his family, his science, and his professional society have stimulated others to continue to make these kinds of contributions. These continuing contributions may be the greatest tribute we can pay to the memory of Stanley D. Beck. That Stan emerged from his illness with his sense of humor intact is shown in a thankyou note written to his colleagues in the Department of Entomology, which was at that time located in old King Hall; the note was addressed to Dwellers of King Hall: Dear Dwellers, Just a left-handed note to thank you for the radio and birthday cards. The radio is a lovely instrument, and I am looking forward to many hours of enjoyable music, quiz programs, and murder miseries [intentional; not a misspelling of mysteries]. I can now reckon time by FM as well as AM and PM. The feature I particularly like is the exclusive memory circuit, which operarcs on a feed-back principle and is used to cut out singing commercials and to edit repititious material out of political speeches-Stevenson's don't come through at all. Thank you for the fudge, Norma-it was very good. Beck was a pioneer in researching the relationships between insects, their host plants, nutritional requirements, feeding behavior, orientational behavior, and developmental characteristics as well as their responses to plant-borne factors such as allelochemics. His research career boasted many firsts. He developed the first meridic dietary medium on which a plant-chewing insect could be cultured through successive generations under aseptic conditions. He was the first to formulate an artificial diet on which a plantsucking bug could be reared successfully. He was the first to elucidate the roles and relative importance of nutritional, chemosensory, contact sensory, and allelochemic factors in the establishment and survival of an insect larva [the European corn borer, Ostrinia nubilalis (Hiibner)) on its host plant. He was the first to demonstrate the role of growthinhibiting allelochemics in plant resistance (i.e., the involvement of the benzoxazolinone family of compounds in the resistance of maize to the corn borer). Further development of his original findings by other workers led to significant improvements in the breeding of borer-resistant genetic lines of maize. Beck's contributions had significant impact on the development and perfection of mass-rearing methods used in pest management programs and improvements in the development of insect-resistant plant lines. As John Reese noted in his "Tribute" and others also have pointed out, all of the rearing of lepidopterous insects started with Beck's 1949 and 1950 papers on artificial diets for successfully rearing the European corn borer (Beck et a!. 1949, Beck 1950, Beck and Stauffer 1950). States Reese, "Those agar-based diets, utilizing both crude plant materials and specific nutrients, laid the foundation for countless projects across the country." Reese adds: The kindness you all have extended to me and my family during my illness has been deeply appreciated. Stan Beck The "Stevenson" referred to was presidential candidate Adlai Stevenson; and "Norma" was Norma Itten, who for many years was the head secretary of the Department of Entomology. During his long professional career, Dr. Beck authored or co-authored 138 research papers (Wedberg 1998) plus a variety of books, monographs, and reviews on scientific, theological, and even fictional subjects. He was not merely a researcher; he was a man of many dimensions. Two of his former graduate students, Michael Chippendale and John Reese (1998), attempted a concise characterization, saying: It is difficult to capture the multifaceted contributions of this remarkable scientist and man. For those who knew Dr. Beck, his legacy extends far beyond the written record of his accomplishments, his cutting edge research, and his exemplary teaching. He taught us a lot about life and how to persist in the face of seemingly insurmountable difficulties. [n 1980 he wrote: 'Research may be characterized as the process of opening an infinite regression of black boxes.' He helped those around h\m to open their eyes to the full potential life has to offer... We were fortunate to be advised by Dr. Beck in our doctoral programs ... and learned much of lasting value from observing his analytical approach to research problems, his skill in formulating hypotheses, designing and interpreting experiments, and from his philosophy of life. One of those projects was in his own [Beck's] lab and used the diet as a way to bioassay plant compounds as possible resistance factors [Beck and Smissman 1961]. Once again, his approach served as the model for the systematic bioassay of resistance factors by testing fractions extracted serially, as opposed to a more empirical testing of compounds known to be in a plant. Similarly, in an unpublished "Tribute to Stanley D. Beck" presented at the 1997 Entomological Society of America (ESA) meetings in Nashville, Tennessee, Reese stated: Beck's 1965 paper, "Resistance of plants to insects," was an excellent synthesis of the existing state of knowledge on the subject. Dr. Beck used to talk about the bionomics of ideas and how a good idea or hypothesis may A~H~I\ICAN ENTtnlOLOGlST • Volllme 46, NlImber 3 Insect seasonal development is determined in part by its host-plant relationships but also in part by the insects' adaptations to environmental factors such as temperature and day-length. Beck (1963, 1968, 1980) was fascinated with the effect of daylength (photoperiodism) on insect development. In addition to studying its role in determination of diapause in the European corn borer, Beck and coworkers demonstrated the existence of geographical populations of the species in North America. Their results were of great significance, leading to the establishment of an important regional project (NC 20) by the U.S. Department of Agriculture and several state experiment stations in the Corn Belt. This cooperative project contributed greatly to understanding local differences in the behavior and seasonal development of the insect. Chippendale and Reese (1998) mention that while Beck was working on insect photoperiodism, he immersed himself in the theory and experimental protocols for doing seasonal-time-measurement research: He worked on a mathematical model for the production, and subsequent breakdown, of two purely hypothetical substances thought to be involved in insect time-measurement. The required mathematics quickly outgrew his 128step programmable calculator, and he enrolled in a course in Fortran, becoming one of the first faculty members at [UW-Madison] to connect to the main-frame computer from his office. This work led to a large number of experiments with real European corn borers and a series of publications on what he called the Dual System Theory (Beck 1985). Another area that Beck investigated was retrogression, or when, in certain beetle species, individuals get smaller with each molt (Beck 1973). According to John Reese, in this project Stan weighed the Trogoderma beetle larvae and adults himself rather than asking his technician to do it. He explained that he needed a project of his own so he wouldn't "bug" his students too much about the details of their projects. Stan's main teaching assignment was a course in the histology and physiology of insects, which he taught from 1949 onward. In 1965, he introduced "Proseminar," a graduate level course in the preparation and presentation of oral scientific reports, and in 1977 he introduced "Theory and Practice of Biological Research," also a graduate level course. The latter course started with philosophical discussions and ended with the preparation of a grant proposal. He also did occasional teaching in the University's Biocore Curriculum. Professor Beck was considered an excellent teacher and mentor, witty and cogent, and one who challenged his students to think critically. According to John Reese, 143 no matter how many times he had taught a topic, he always reviewed and revised his notes one more time immediately before giving his lecture. Considering the wide impact of Beck's research program, it is not surprising that he was invited to be a participant in many conferences, symposia, public lectures, and other professional activities. Considering his disability and the difficulty of traveling, however, it is amazing that he had the energy and strength to actually be a participant in such a great magnitude of professional activity. Some major participations, more or less chronologically, included the following: • Oregon State University Biology Colloquium Series, 1962; • AAAS Symposium on Biological Time Measurement, 1964; • Working Conference on Radiation, Ra- dioisotopes, and Rearing Methods in the Control of Insect Pests, Tel Aviv,Israel, 1966; • Peabody Symposium on Evolution and Environment, Yale University, 1966; • All Campus Lecturer, Coe College, Cedar Rapids, Iowa, 1967, 1968; • Invitational Lectures Series, Kansas State University, 1967; • International Biological Program, International Conference on Insect-Plant Relationships, Santa Barbara, California, 1968; • Summer Institute on Biological Control, Mississippi State University, 1971; • Member, Organizing Committee and Executive Committee of the NSFrrRP Project "Principles, Strategies, and Tactics of Pest Population Regulation" (Huffaker Project), 1971-1973; • Chairman, Cotton Study Team, National Academy of Sciences Study Panel on Pest Control Strategies, 1973-1975; • Conference on Host Plant Resistance to Insects, Academy of Science of Hungary, Tihany, Hungary, 1974; • Conference on Plant Resistance, Tucson, Arizona, 1975; • North American Phytochemical Society, Conference and Symposium on InsectPlant Relationships, Tampa, Florida, 1975; • Member, Editorial Committee, Annual Review of Entomology, 1975-1979; • Entomological Society of Canada, Symposium on Overwintering Strategies, Quebec City, 1980; • Sigma Xi Lecturer, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 1981; • Provost's Invitational Lecturer, University of Notre Dame, 1981; • Keynote Speaker, Pennsylvania Association of State College and University Biologists, 1984; • Hatfield Lecturer, Georgetown College, Georgetown, Kentucky, 1986. In one of his first extracurricular endeavors, Stan served 144 from 1957 to 1960 as Editor of the Transactions of the Wisconsin Academy of Sciences, Arts and Letters. Stan's physical disability did not prevent him from rendering outstanding service to the Entomological Society of America, including serving as its president in 1982. Throughout his career, he was active in Section B matters (Section of Physiology and Biochemistry) and served as secretary, vice-chair, and chair of the Section in 1973, 1974, and 1975, respectively. He served as a member of the Board of Directors of ESA's Thomas Say Foundation, 1974-1976; on the ESA Governing Board, 1976-1978, 1981-1983; on the Executive Committee, 1981-1983; and as president-elect and past-president in 1981 and 1983, respectively. After his presidency, Stan served on the Editorial Board of the Advancement of Science in 1964. He received an honorary degree (D.Sc.) from Luther College, Decorah, Iowa, in 1972 and the Distinguished Achievement Award from Washington State University Alumni Association in 1981. In 1988, he was elected to the National Academy of Sciences. Stan Beck had a good, often subtle, sense of humor. I believe it also would be accurate to say that he did not suffer fools lightly. John Reese noted in his "Tribute" that Dr. Beck was thought to be a little on the stern side by some graduate students and faculty colleagues. Reese relates a humorous incident, however, showing Beck's tolerance for the antics of other people's children. Reese's five-year-old son, Andy, equated Professor Beck's W. A. Henry Distinguished Professor Chair with his wheelchair. Andy proudly in- Bulletin of the Entomological Society of formed Dr. Beck that as soon as his dad fin- America, 1983-1985; on the Honorary Membership Committee, 1983-1988; and on the Committee on Endowments, 19861988. Dr. Beck was the 1962 recipient of the Founders' Memorial Award of the Entomological Society of America and delivered the Founders' Memorial Lecture, discussing the physiology and ecology of insect photoperiodism and honoring S. A. Forbes, a pioneer in insect ecology. The Founders' Award is bestowed by the ESA in recognition of excellence in research, and Professor Beck was the fifth person to be so honored by the society. An honor bestowed on Beck posthumously in 1997 was establishment by the ESA Foundation of the Stanley D. Beck Fellowship to benefit disabled students. A dinner/dance fundraiser is held each year as part of the society's annual meeting. The Founders' Memorial Award came full circle in 1999 when Beck was chosen as the honoree. The ESA meeting this past year was in Atlanta in December and the Memorial Lecturer was Dr. David Denlinger (Denlinger 2000), professor and chair of the Department of Entomology at Ohio State University. In addition, at this meeting, there was an ESA Symposium entitled "Insect Photoperiodism: A Tribute to Stanley D. Beck." A poster session was associated with the six-speaker symposium, and it was followed by a wine and cheese reception sponsored by the Journal of Insect Physiology (which is not an ESA publication). It added greatly to these events honoring Stan that Isabel and daughter Marianne were in attendance. They also attended the Stan Beck Fellowship Dinner Dance and were able to meet the 1999 recipient of the fellowship, a young man who had sustained injuries in an automobile accident. There were other major honors in addition to those already mentioned. He became a Fellow of the American Association for the ished his degree, he too would get a chair like that. After several exchanges of, "Your dad probably doesn't need a chair like this," and "Yes, my dad is going to get a chair like yours," Dr. Beck finally told Andy that he was "full of prunes," and they both gave up the futile exchange. Reese slowly came from behind the laboratory bench and tried to whisk Andy out of there. Another former graduate student of Beck's, Arthur Retnakaran, recounts that (personal communication 1999): Stan always whistled while he was wheeling himself from lab to lab, which was a way to announce his impending arrival. When I look back at all the pranks that we used to pull as grad students in the lab, that whistle served as an alarm bell and many a caper came to a premature end! Retnakaran, in reminiscing about several humorous incidents involving Stan and students, noted that Stan has always been perceived as an intimidating intellectual, while his lighter side is often overlooked. The author has noticed in this connection that people who were more closely associated with Stan are more likely to mention his humorous side. Don Swinton, for example, who was Beck's laboratory assistant for many years and accompanied and assisted him on many of his travels, stated (personal communication 1999) that "In the 28 years I worked for Dr. Beck we never had a disagreement and I admired his humor and humility." Stan was devoted to his family and spoke of them often. Reading, listening to music (he played a trumpet in high school), attending plays, traveling, playing games, and having theological discussions were all part of a very active family life. The Becks had four children, a son, Bruce, and three daughters, Diana, Marianne, and Karen. Tragically, Karen preceded her father in death. She had AMERICAN ENTOMOLOGIST • Fa1l2000 received a Ph.D. in theoretical mathematics at the University of Iowa and then served on the faculty as an instructor at the University of Utah; shortly before her death she had accepted an assistant professor position at the University of Texas, Arlington. Understandably, Stan never stopped grieving over this tragic loss. As noted by two of his students, Chippendale and Reese (1998), Dr. Beck had a life-long interest in the philosophy of science and devoted much effort to the communication of science to non-scientists. His first book, The Simplicity of Science, was nontechnical, written after he came home from the hospital, and published in 1959. He believed, as noted by Chippendale and Reese, that scientists should vigorously counter anti science, anti-intellectual groups, which are becoming increasingly vocal in our society. He made his concern for academic and scientific freedom a major theme of his 1982 presidency of the ESA. His presidential address, Science and Politics (Beck 1983), addressed the problem and cited examples of legislative and partisan political interference in science, which led to passage of a resolution by the ESA membership expressing "its conviction that scientific judgement remain free of political bias and that the selection of individuals charged with making these decisions be based solely upon their scientific competence. " Beck also had strong interest in theological matters, authoring the book Modern Science and Christian Life published in 1970. As an active member of his church, Bethel Lutheran, in Madison, Stan served on task forces dealing with ethical and disability issues. In 1982, he authored an article in BioScience titled "Natural Science and Creationist Theology." Here, he forcefully makes the case that creationism is merely pseudoscience. Following reasoned discussion of both the scientific and theological premises of creationism, Beck, typically, wastes few words in conclusion: "Since it has neither scientific nor theological credibility, the continued survival of creationism is dependent on its appeal to the scientifically uninformed and theologically naive, combined with a great deal of fanatic politiclli activity." After his retirement in 1989, Stan was able to realize a lifelong dream, writing fiction. His novel, Two in the Game, was published in 1993. It is about a two-career married couple in academic li·e, deating with love, tenure, publish or perish, and the joy of teaching. He had just completed a mystery novel prior to his death, but it has not been published. AMERICAN ENTOMOLOGIST • Voillme 46, Number 3 I was asked to say a few words at Professor Beck's funeral service. I began by noting that Stan was much more than just an outstanding scientist-he was a man of many dimensions and wherever he was and whatever the situation, Stan Beck was always a "presence" that could be felt. One instance I remember well that illustrates this was at an annual meeting of the ESA, probably 20 years ago more or less. The annual dinner is held on the second or third evening of these meetings. On this particular occasion, seated to my right was a young professor from, if memory serves me correctly, Stanford University. I had not met him before, but it took only a few minutes of conversation to discern that he was a very sharp young man, very articulate, and brimming with enthusiasm for science and with confidence in his own capabilities as an up-and-coming young researcher. As the dinner was about to begin, the M.e. asked for all to rise for the invocation, which would be delivered by Professor Stanley Beck. I still remember Stan's vibrant voice in that great hall. As we resumed our seats, there was a long moment of silence, finally broken by the young professor who said, with a bit of awe in his voice, "So far, that was the high point of these meetings." Stan always had that kind of impact. Or, as stated so eloquently by John Wedberg of the U. W. Department of Entomology faculty (unpublished manuscript 1999), "Those of us who shared Stan's professional life will never forget the sheer force of his will, determination, and intellect." • Acknowledgments I am indebted to the following individuals for reading the first draft of the manuscript and offering suggestions for improvement: John Reese (Kansas State University, Manhattan, Kansas), Michael Chippendale (University of Missouri, Columbia, Missouri), Arthur Retnakaran (Great Lakes Forestry Center, Canadian Forest Service, Sault Ste. Marie, Canada), David L. Denlinger (Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio), John Wed berg and David Hogg (University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin), and Don Swinton (formerly Department of Entomology, now retired). I am grateful to Isabel Beck for discussions concerning various aspects of Stan's life, especially pertaining to his illness, family, and early life. Isabel also made available and helped choose the photographs that accompany this article. I thank the Wisconsin State Journal for permission to reproduce a photograph that appeared in that newspaper June 7, 1953, u.w. and I thank Walter Goodman (U.W. Department of Entomology) for computer-enhancing the photograph. Finally, my thanks go to Edward H. Smith for suggesting that a tribute to Stan Beck should be a part of ESA's Heritage Series. References Cited Beck, S. D. 1950. Nutrition of the European corn borer, Pyrausta nubilalis (Hiibn.). II. Some effects of diet on larval growth characteristics. Physiol. Zool. 23: 353-361. 1959. The simplicity of science. Doubleday, New York. 1963. Animal photoperiodism. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York .. 1965. Resistance of plants to insects. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 10: 207-232. 1968. Insect photoperiodism. Academic Press, New York. 1970. Modern science and Christian life. Augsburg Publishing House, Minneapolis, MN. 1973. Growth and retrogression in larvae of Trogoderma glabrum (Coleoptera: Dermestidae). 5. Effects of repeated retrogressions. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 66: 10511054. 1980. Insect photoperiodism, 2nd ed. Academic Press, New York .. 1982. Natural science and creationist theology. BioScience 32: 738-742. 1983. Science and politics. Bull. Entomol. Soc. Am. 29: 21-24. 1985. Dual system theory of the biological clock. J. Theor. BioI. 113: 93-115. 1993. Two in the game. Publishers Group, Los Angeles, CA. Beck, S. D., and J. F. Stauffer. 1950. An aseptic method for rearing European corn borer larvae. J. Econ. Entomol. 43: 4-6. Beck, S. D., and E. E. Smissman. 1961. The European corn borer, Pyrausta nubilalis, and its principal host plant. IX. Biological activity of chemical analogs of corn resistance factor A (6-methoxybenzoxazolinone). Ann. Entomol. Soc Am. 54: 53-61. Beck, S. D., J. H. Lilly, and J. F. Stauffer. 1949. Nutrition of the European corn borer, Pyrausta nubilalis (Hiibn.). I. Development of a satisfactory purified diet for larval growth. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 42: 483496. Chippendale, M., and J. Reese. 1998. Obituary. .. Stanley D. Beck (1919-1997). J. Insect Physiol. 44: 361-363. Denlinger, D. 1. 2000. Confronting adversity: a tribute to Stanley D. Beck. Am. Entomol. (in press). Wedbetg, J. 1. 1998. Stanley D. Beck [obituary]. Am. Entomol. 44: 127. Gene R. DeFoliart is a professor emeritus of the Department of Entomology, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706. 145
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz