Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2009). The Politics of Mother-hatred in Elleke Boehmer's Screens Against The Sky Eva Hunter On the outside back cover of the Penguin edition of Elleke Boehmer's Screens Against the Sky, Wendy Woods (whose husband Donald was Steve Biko's ally) is quoted as saying that this "closely focused account of a stifling relationship between a mother and daughter in white middle-class South Africa" will give its readers "a beautifully authentic insight into a society turned in on itself in the face of black deprivation."} But, the ignorant woman who is the protagonist's mother has a subjectivity so cramped that she seems an extreme, rather than a representative, manifestation of what the white housebound female can become. Does such a character merit the burden of the novel's animosity? Further, Boehmer's novel, published in 1990, appeared at a time when South African feminist critics had begun to note the growth of maternal discourses in writing by black women who were articulating feminist goals. Is this matrophobic novel not regressive, out of touch both with developments in South Africa and with recent changes in attitudes towards mothering and motherhood in Western feminist writing? I will discuss these two critical problems raised by Screens in the context of other feminist South African texts, assessing Boehmer's intervention and its challenges and implications. Screens is another in a line of novels of education, all markedly autobiographical, all with implications for feminism, written by white Southern African women. Predecessors to Boehmer'S novel include: Doris Lessing's Martha Quest (1952) and A Proper Marriage (1965), Nadine Gordimer's The Lying Days (1953), Jillian Becker's The Virgins (1976), Carolyn Slaughter's Dreams of the Kalahari (1981), Menan du Plessis's A State of Fear (1983), Lynn Freed's Home Ground (1986), and E. M. Macphail's Phoebe and Nio (1987). A way of understanding the journey traced in such works is as a response, within imperial-colonial culture, to the unsettled nature of the frontier mentality. Such novels are a kind of border fiction, in which to explore possibilities lying beyond the moral and social (and, English in Africa 23 No. I (May 1996) Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2009). 106 EVA HUNTER frequently, geographical) boundaries that orthodox racist policies would have the writers honour. A decision all these writers and their protagonists must make, once the point of acknowledging one's complicity in racist society has been reached, is whether to embrace the possibility of achieving, and justifying, a sense of locatedness, or not. Boehmer envisages no possibility of belonging for Annemarie Rudolph, and perhaps it is not coincidental that the author herself voluntarily left the subcontinent. But then, so have Lessing, Becker, Slaughter, and Freed. What distinguishes Screens from the other novels of education I have mentioned is the fact that never has a female adolescent been so betrayed as is Annemarie Rudolph by those close to her, especially by her mother. Macphail's Phoebe and Nio rely on the advice of Phoebe's tough, practical, and wise (even if racist) Gran. Freed's adolescent mocks her fallible parents, but she also loves them. In Gordimer's Lying Days, Helen's parents may be selfish and obtuse, but their faults seem motes when set alongside Sylvie Rudolph's machinations. Sylvie Rudolph is, in fact, the most appalling mother produced by a Southern African white woman writer. Even May Quest's sins pale by comparison: Martha's mother encouraged her daughter to sleep; Sylvie gives her daughter Valium. Martha was free to wander through the veld; Sylvie discourages her daughter not only from going to university, but even from going out at all. I suggest that the phenomena of maternal betrayal and Annemarie's failure to find any sort of satisfactory South African identity are linked: so attenuated is the experience of the white female, and so strong is her dislike of herself and her role model, her mother, that all that remains for Annemarie to do is to leave the country, as Boehmer herself has done. The 'position' of white South African women has, however, never been so hopeless and compromised that self-expulsion has ever been the sole option. Beyond the pages of Screens there are many white women who have worked for and with black South Africans, some at the cost of their lives (Ruth First), others to suffer exile (Ray Alexander), yet others to defy harrassment by security police in order to reveal the truth (Janet Cherry). Besides the well-known instances, there are hundreds of other women, who remain unknown (and,largely, unsung), who have, often without financial security, worked devotedly in such fields as education, literacy programmes, advice offices. Boehmer's Bad Mother has her cultural origins outside South Africa, in feminist thought of the United States and Europe. The Western feminist writer and critic has, typically, spoken as a daughter (often a rebellious daughter) or a sister. Absent, silenced or dead mothers feature in the careers Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2009). ELLEKE BOEHMER'S SCREENS AGA/NSTTHE SKY 107 of many nineteenth-century characters fabricated by women writers with feminist ideals, of whom Jane Eyre and Gwendolen Harleth are two of the best-known. In the second half of this century, Lessing, for one, has notably augmented the matrophobic legacy of Western feminism. Lessing's early works were set in this subcontinent; Boehmer uses an extract from The Golden Notebook as one of the two epigraphs to Screens Against the Sky, and has said she is "comfortable" with the idea of Lessing as a "precursor." Possibly Lessing has influenced Boehmer's matrophobic depiction of the mother-daughter relationship in Screens. 2 Carolyn G. Heilbrun said in 1987 that, while the "oedipal drama, certainly since Freud but perhaps ever since the inheritance of property first passed from father to son," had been "the primary, controHing plot" in literature about the 'Western' family, another plot was present but obscured from view, even when written about (as in Virginia Woolf's To the Lighthouse); this plot traced the "mother-daughter struggle," a struggle that involves "the love," as Heilbrun pointed out, "that threatens, not murder, as between father and son, but engulfment" (12). Boehmer has Sylvie threaten her daughter with, precisely. engulfment. Sylvie is happiest when Annemarie mirrors her own behaviour exactly, as when the two of them bake cakes or sit knitting together in front ofthe TV set. After her husband's death Sylvie tells Annemarie '''You are my life'" (32). She feeds her daughter cakes, fudge, "rich and milky treats," "viscous messes"; "Around the time of [Annemarie's] first menstruation," her mother feeds her "egg-nog, big mugfuls that would slip down in one glutinous swallow" (24). The girl is compelled to become bulimic in order to maintain control over her body size. (Boehmer is excellent at conveying nausea: for Annemarie, lipstick is "red fat" [155].) However, since the 1980s, attitudes toward textual representations of the mother in British and American feminist fiction and theory have begun to change. So, in a collection of poems called In the Gold of Flesh (1990), American and British women celebrate metaphorical (that is, creative) and biological birth and motherhood, and Michele Roberts (half-English, half-French), in Flesh and Blood (1994), her most recent novel, creates a protagonist who, having symbolically 'killed' her mother as Bad Mother by shedding emotional attachment to her, moves toward a climax in which, simultaneously, she integrates her early memories of her mother, who, as her Good Mother, was her "paradise garden" and she begins to sing a "love song" for her own (as yet unborn) daughter. The cycle of destructiveness is shattered. Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2009). 108 EV A HUNTER Meanwhile, in this country, black women have been shaping their sense of identity in positive fictional and autobiographical form, through discourses that incorporate the maternal. This these black women have done in the face, on the one hand, of resistance rhetoric that glorifies black women as mothers only to marginalise them from important power structures, and, on the other, of the apartheid state's depredations upon the black family and upon black self-esteem. Margaret Daymond notes tentative validation of motherhood in Bessie Head's fiction (Daymond, 1990); Dorothy Driver traces Ellen Kuzwayo's assertion (in Call Me Woman [1985]) of maternal authority in the face of the youth's uprising in 1976 (Driver 1990). Miriam Tlali, in her most recent collection, Footprints in the Quag (1989), has certain characters and narrators protest against black men's treatment of their womenfolk, and voice their protest as women speaking as mothers (Hunter 1993). It seems it is precisely as women speaking as mothers and on behalf of other mothers that Kuzwayo and Tlali can defy the cultural imperative that excludes them from public life and from voicing criticism of their menfolk. Indeed, Driver goes so far as to say that "it is only by passing through" the "assertion" that the strength of women is their strength as mothers "that the possibilities for an African feminism begin to emerge" (237). South Africa's black women writers are, then, confirming what the Western reappraisal of motherhood has only recently extended to women, the exhilarating, liberating realisation that, in order to be faithful to feminist goals, it is necessary neither to ignore nor depreciate the biological fact of motherhood or the practical ways in which women raise their children. We may (and I probably do not speak for black women here, since they it seems have never had such doubts), without ignoring such social and cultural realities as the poverty of black mothers left to raise children alone or the stigma attached to those women who do not have children, may speak as feminists and speak as mothers, as well as sisters or daughters. So, I am resistant to Boehmer's fabrication, in the Nineties, of another mother who is weak, clinging, terrible, witch-like (as Sylvie snoops among her sleeping daughter's books, the reader, sharing the point of view of the narrator, sees that her "sickle of chin brackets that of nose" [4]). Perhaps the tardiness of Boehmer's materialization of a Bad Mother is due to the fact that in the colonies and ex-colonies the political and social attitudes of white populations have tended to lag behind those of the metropolitan centres. If there is a tendency amongst South Africa's black women writers to idealise mothers (cf. Driver on Kuzwayo in Driver 239-43) - a tendency stimulated by the mystique of Mama Afrika in popular and resistance culture - Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2009). ELLEKE BOEHMER'S SCREENS AGAINST THE SKY 109 perhaps there has lingered, in our white women writers, a contrary tendency to demonise white mothers. My second point of resistance to Boehmer's fictional mother-daughter relationship, besides its regressive, limiting nature, is related to Woods's statement that it offers "authentic insight" into white "society." Given both the patriarchal nature of white apartheid society and Sylvie's feebleness of character as Boehmer depicts her, Boehmer is scapegoating an inappropriate target. Especially after the death of her husband, Sylvie feels embattled, hardly fit to face life alone. She is alienated from her own sexuality, protects herself against intrusions from outside her snug home by avoiding television news, and finds a comforting role for herself, as countless middle-class women have done - we need think only of the Misses Mann and Ainley in Charlotte Bronte's Shirley - in knitting for the needy. All this despite the wealth that accrues to her when her dead husband's share portfolio begins to flourish. Where ought contempt for such a person to end and pity to begin? Is Boehmer not, as Lessing did in her characterisation of Mary Turner in The Grass is Singing (1950), creating a character the reader can hardly conceive of as able to comprehend the privileges her class and ethnic origins bring her, a character whom, nevertheless. the author's techniques urge readers to dislike and to judge as guilty? Judged as complicit, Sylvie is. Her lethal nurturing is not idiosyncratic; instead, it is part of a poison so pervasive it infects the very air in Hoopstad. The atmosphere is "filled with sweetness" (194). There is an objective origin for this smell in the sugar-growing area of Natal, and this is a chocolate factory. But the odour functions, too, as a correlative for forces that spread throughout the social fabric. The suburban good life, and the civilities of white culture, are in reality toxic, because sustained at the cost of the terrible poverty of the proletariat. Like the sweet smell in the air, the names of the places where the Rudolphs live - Merrydale and Hoopstad - resonate satirically, as Boehmer exposes the falseness of the belief, which is defined by Steve Biko in the second of the novel's epigraphs, the belief of the black "man" that, while he is inferior, "completeness goes with whiteness." The Rudolph family suffer what the second epigraph, from Lessing's The Golden Notebook, warns against: "an inability or a refusal to fit conflicting things together" means "ultimately either death or impoverishment of the individual." The novel's focus is white consciousness and conscience. The Rudolphs, refusing to see beyond the cluster of attitudes they have allowed into their home, bequeath their daughter a legacy of impoverished understanding. Mr Rudolph puts up hailscreens that blur the view to the Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2009). 110 EVA HUNTER outside. More of the "screens" of the title are raised by Sylvie: she enjoys watching mobiles hung in the window. They help her avoid looking beyond them to a sky that is, for Annemarie too, frequently "blank." The domesticated woman is a product of pervasive social and cultural forces, the history df whose formation has been traced by, for instance, Nancy Armstrong, in Desire and Domestic Fiction: A Political History of the Novel (1987), and the ideology surrounding this figure is class-bound, as Virginia Woolf saw (Woolf 1923). Like the oedipal dynamic that Freud traced, the ideology of domesticated woman has a central relationship to dominant middle-class culture. Sylvie's aJJegiance is clearly with the dominant class grouping in South Africa, who assert their superiority also by virtue of race: as Woolf understood, the ideology that constructs the image of the An~el in the House is the ideology of imperialism as we)) as of class hegemony. Sylvie sees herself as living in a land of barbarians, and so plays her part in keeping them from the gate. She betrays her daughter's confidence to a security policeman, so ensuring Annemarie, too, is complicit, as child of her class and race, in helping to convict a white doctor who is doing what Annemarie wishes to do, help the resistance. There is, however, a possible way of deflecting the objection that Boehmer is laying too much blame on this pathetic, even if destructive, woman, Sylvie Rudolph. This is to argue that when Wendy Woods encourages the reader to view Screens as an "authentic" account of growing up white under apartheid she is misreading the author's style and intent. To read the book Woods's way entails understanding it as depicting experience that was already constituted, experience that remained only to be shaped by the selections of the author. Yet Boehmer herself, through formal strategies, signals her wish to forestall the notion that she is presenting realistic fiction or a closed, perfected vision. (She has said she has "problems with" the "self-sufficiency" and "completeness" of Gordimer's kind of "realism" [1992: 94].) Instead, through techniques commonly termed postmodemist, Boehmer points to fiction as a fabricated collage, and to the philosophical point that 'truth' and any representation thereof are fickle entities. For instance, the voice that begins the tale is uncoloured by emotion or judgement; it is the voice of a recording eye, recounting what it sees, while it sees, and referring at this stage only to "the girl" and "the woman." It refutes any claim to omniscience, and, along with such refutation, challenges the white masculinist values of liberal humanism which have predominated in European realist fiction, with what Kenneth Parker calls its "aggrandizing self-perception" of a "subjectivity [that is] assumed in the twin disguises of authorial percipience and of the reader as unproblematic centre of a particular and 'natural' sensibility" (Parker 39). An omniscient narrator would supply the names of the characters, and would usually use Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2009). ELLEKE BOEHMER'S SCREENS AGAINST THE SKY III the past instead of the present tense. The past perfect implies actions already completed, a world already structured, finished. Boehmer not only ruptures the implicit compact conventional to the relationship between a fictional narrative's implied reader and its thirdperson narrator (or its implied author), she also, after three paragraphs, changes to an "I" -narrator. And, as the reader continues, it is to realise that, quite possibly, the voice previously heard waS, in fact, a device of the protagonist, who has since decided to take over her story in her own voice. Perhaps the reader never stops sharing Annemarie's perspective. The reaqer cannot be certain of this. This uncertainty, in a postmodernist text, is precisely the point, as may be further read from the fact that, in the opening three paragraphs, the narrator sees, at "night-time," and from outside, only whatever can be s~en through the windows of the Rudolph house and where the Jightsare .on. This narrator must assume, guess, surmise: "At the far end of the house Jies what must be the livingroom" (3). Boehmer's postmodemist play is used to make the usual philosophical point that meaning is unsettled. Annemarie, who is inside and, it may well be, also at times (attempting to place herself) outside her own story, refutes, frolll both perspectives her ability to convey the truth. Even her keeping of a journal becoI1!es, instead of a guarantee of veracity and verisimilitude, its opposite: the journal was one of her "ventures" intended to "bring about an entirely new kind of existence"(5); like J. M. Coetzee's Magda in In the Heart of the Country (1977), she turns to shaping her life into a fiction so as to avoid !>oredom. . [W]hat follows may in part be drawn from the memory not only of what happened, but of what 1 once wrote happened. 1 do not set out to re-create those fictions [of the journal]; but as 1 have no way now of reviewing them, as 1 no longer have the journal books in my possession and cannot check up on my memories, 1 can never be sure that my present account did not in part begin on the pages of my journal. If 1 spent so much time on the journal, it is possible that details of what 1 remember of those last school years did not in fact happen ... [I am] writing off, you could say - the fabricated facts. (5-6) If the past constructs the present, so, too, does the present construct the past. Boehmer is, then, writing a tale that deconstructs its own authority yet has a didactic purpose (Fay Weldon's technique has similar effects). Even if any knowledge Annemarie may convey is called into question, yet the novel still makes its critiques, of, for instance, white ignorance of the black world, an ignorance more marked in women because of the split between the home and the public world. Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2009). 112 EV A HUNTER Do I betray that I was concerned, almost obsessively concerned, with nothing so much as with my own self. Yet this is, I suppose, my intention. I believe my preoccupation at that time was in itself telling. I believe that my life then - in its confinement, its littleness, its negligible engagement with external matters - shows up, precisely by virtue of exclusion, how very much was left out: the entire history of a long struggle, the endurance of that struggle, its effort and its pain. (7) There is an internal tension between the novel's emphasis on its didactic purposes and its ludic, reflexive strategies. And, in both its internal tensions and its choice of scapegoat for white culpability - an unhappy, white woman - Boehmer's novel recalls Lessing's first novel, The Grass is Singing (1950). In Lessing's novel, the analytical discourse (of formal realism) carried by the narrator casts blame for the cruelty of Southern Rhodesia's racist society on broad social forces, which are controlled by white men, but the author's animus is, in the novel's climax, directed, in a surge of melodramatic language and metaphor, against sick, pathetic Mary Turner. Boehmer, using not realism but postmodernist techniques, would counter a sense of finality and infallibility, but her didactic purpose draws the reader to focus on the referentiality of the novel, and the emotional weight of the author's dislike of her creature Sylvie works against the detachment called for by Boehmer's deconstructive techniques. The ignorance of the privileged comes in varying degrees, ranging from the state of genuinely not knowing (as among children, for instance) to a condition in which one refuses either to know or to acknowledge that one knows. Mrs Rudolph clearly does not wish to know; furthermore, the effects such a woman may have upon a young psyche are terrible (and may be hard to forgive). But, the intensity of the bitterness seems misdirected (with Annemarie's father dead, all blame may be attributed to her mother). The novel's targets, white mother and daughter, are those most like herself in class, gender, and ethnic identity; this does not make them the targets that most deserve to be attacked. My objection here is not merely an academic one, since South Africans face together a future in which some will face demands for redress, while others will be deciding in what circumstances, who, and how much to punish for the past. The story potentially obscures where ultimate power has been located, in white men; it could also add fuel to attacks upon white women by their black sisters. In the struggle for resources and power, white women are next in the firing line to black women. If they are berated more than white men - and, in some circumstances, black men - deserve to be, this could dilute the power of all the women of South Africa to press for their own interests. Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2009). ELLEKE BOEHMER'S SCREENS AGAINST THE SKY 113 NOTES I. All page references are to the Penguin edition, 1992. An earlier version of this article was presented at the annual conference ofthe Association for University English Teachers of South Africa, Wild Coast, July 1994. 2. Paradoxically, Lessing must herself be counted among the 'good.' nurturing mothers of post-World War II feminism. along with thinkers such as Simone de Beauvoir. Furthermore. Lorna Sage. in her study of post-war novelists entitled Womi!n in thi! HOWi! of Fiction. notes the existence of a group of "women realists in the nurturing. matriarchal mould." amongst whom Sage counts Iris Murdoch and Margaret Drabble (154). Lessing. too. for all her experimentation with form in Thi! Goldi!n Noti!book and her space fiction, has impressed her readers as a realistic, and sage-like chronicler of the experience of modern women. 3. Boehmer's setting is clearly South Africa. yet. just as her formal choices are influenced by transcontinental fictional practices. so the lives she depicts unsurprisingly. given both the original transplanting of metropolitan cultures to the colonies and the contemporary forces of mass communication and trade - exhibit characteristics that are widespread. For instance. Lorna Sage. writing of Fay Weldon. says. "As Praxis [The main character in Praxis (1978)] points out. most women are left alone with themselves. or other women. in the end (if not a lot sooner)" (Sage 156). and "In Thi! Lifi! and Lovi!S of a Shi!-Di!vil" [1983]. women are, as it were. the suburbanites of the human race. The opening setting. 'Eden Grove.' with its brand-new houses. half-grown trees. domestic seclusion and large-scale consumption of tranquillisers and Mary Fisher novels. is a lUXUry ghetto where wives are insulated (for the moment) from material pressures and opportunities. It could be anywhere in the developed world ... a haven ofinsecurity" (Sage 159). Simply alter the name of the favoured novelist, and the statement would apply as appropriately to the lives of wives in South Africa's suburbs. (Not all of South Africa's suburbs are inhabited only by whites: the Indian and 'coloured' communities and some amongst the black communities also have their suburbs. the women who inhabit their houses. 11ali depicts a black woman emulating white. suburban ways in "Masechaba's Erring ·Child· ... in Footprints in thi! Quag.) WORKS CITED Armstrong. Nancy. 1987. Di!siri! and Domi!stic Fiction: A Political History of thi! Novd New York: Oxford UP. Becker, Jillian. 1986 (1976). Thi! Virgins. Cape Town: David Philip. Boehmer. Elleke. 1992. Screens Againstthi! Sky. London: Penguin. - - - . 1992. "Talking about 'Muted Responses' in South African Literature and Reading from her Novel Screens Against the Sky." Interview with Caroline Rooney. Aspects of Commonwealth Lituaturi!. Vol 2. 90-94. Coetzee. J. M. 1977. In the Heart of the Country. London: Secker & Warburg. Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2009). 114 EVA HUNTER Daymond, M. 1. 1990. "Sources and Resources: A Reflexive Reading of the Short Stories of Bessie Head and Miriam Tlali." Yale U, USA. Paper presented at Commonwealth Letters Conference, "Tradition and Transition in African Letters," 19-21 April. Driver, Dorothy. 1990. "M'a-Ngoana 0 Tsoare Thipa ka Bohaleng - The Child's Mother Grabs the Sharp End of the Knife: Women as Mothers, Women as Writers." Rendering Things Visible: Essays on South African Literary Culture. Ed. Martin Trump. Johannesburg: Ravan. Du Plessis, Memin. 1983. A State of Fear. Cape Town: David Philip. Freed, Lynn. 1986. Home Ground. Hannondsworth: Penguin. Gordimer, Nadine. 1978 (1953). The Lying Days. London: Jonathan Cape. Heilbrun, Carolyn G. 1987. "To the Lighthouse: The New Story of Mother and Daughter." ADEBulletin 87: 12-14. Hunter, Eva. 1990. "A Sense of Place in Selected African Works by Doris Lessing Read in Conjunction with Novels of Education by Contemporary White Southern African Women Writers." Diss. U of Cape Town. - - - . 1993. "A Mother is Nothing but a Backbone"; Women, Tradition and Change in Miriam Tla/i's Footprints In the Quag. Current Writing 5. I: 60-75. Kuzwayo, Ellen. 1985. Call Me Woman. Johannesburg: Ravan Press. Lessing, Doris. 1950. The Grass is Singing. London: Michael Joseph. - - - . 1951. "The Old Chief Mshlanga." This was the Old Chief's Country: Collected African Stories. (Volume One). London: Michael Joseph. - - - . 1952. Manha Quest. London: Michael Joseph. - - - . 1954. A Proper Marriage. London: Michael Joseph. - - - . 1962. The Golden Notebook. London: Michael Joseph. Macphail, E. M. 1987. Phoebe & Nio. Johannesburg: Hippogriff Press. Palmeira, Rosemary, ed. 1990. In the Gold of Flesh: Poems of Birth & Motherhood. London: Women's Press. Parker, Kenneth. 1993. '''Traditionalism' vs 'Modernism': Culture, Ideology. Writing." The African Past and Contemporary Culture. Ed. Erhard Reckwitz, Lucia Vennarini, and Cornelia Wegener. Papers on Africa Delivered at the Annual Conference of the Association for the Study of the New Literatures in English, Essen, 12-15 June 1991. Essen: Die Blaue Eule. Roberts, Michele. 1994. Flesh and Blood. London: Virago. Sage, Lorna. 1992. Women in the House of Fiction: Post-War Women Novelists. London: Macmillan. Slaughter, Carolyn. 1981. Dreams of (he Kalahari. London: Granada. Steedman, Carolyn. 1986. Landscape for a Good Woman: A Story o/Two Lives. London: Virago. nali, Miriam. 1989. Footprints in the Quag: Stories and Dialogues from Soweto. Intro. by Lauretta Ngcobo. Cape Town, David Philip. First published 1989 under the title Soweto Stories. London: Pandora Press. Weldon, Fay. 1983. The Life and Loves of a She-Devil. London: Coronet. Woolf, Virginia. 1923. "Speech to the London Working-Women's Club." The Death of the Moth and Other Essays. London: Hogarth Press, 1945.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz