What is MI?

What is MI?
Stephen Rollnick, Ph.D., & William R. Miller, Ph.D.
Reprinted with permission from Rollnick S., & Miller, W.R. (1995). What is motivational interviewing? Behavioural and
Cognitive Psychotherapy, 23, 325-334.
Introduction
The concept of motivational interviewing evolved from experience in the treatment of problem drinkers, and
was first described by Miller (1983) in an article published in Behavioural Psychotherapy. These
fundamental concepts and approaches were later elaborated by Miller and Rollnick (1991) in a more detailed
description of clinical procedures. A noteworthy omission from both of these documents, however, was a
clear definition of motivational interviewing.
We thought it timely to describe our own conceptions of the essential nature of motivational interviewing.
Any innovation tends to be diluted and changed with diffusion (Rogers, 1994). Furthermore, some
approaches being delivered under the name of motivational interviewing (c.g., Kuchipudi, Hobein,
Fleckinger and Iber, 1990) bear little resemblance to our understanding of its essence, and indeed in some
cases directly violate what we regard to be central characteristics. For these reasons, we have prepared this
description of: (1) a definition of motivational interviewing, (2) a terse account of what we regard to be the
essential spirit of the approach; (3) differentiation of motivational interviewing from related methods with
which it tends to be confused; (4) a brief update on outcome research evaluating its efficacy; and (5) a
discussion of new applications that are emerging.
Definition
Our best current definition is this: Motivational interviewing is a directive, client-centered counseling style
for eliciting behavior change by helping clients to explore and resolve ambivalence. Compared with
nondirective counselling, it is more focused and goal-directed. The examination and resolution of
ambivalence is its central purpose, and the counselor is intentionally directive in pursuing this goal.
The spirit of motivational interviewing
We believe it is vital to distinguish between the spirit of motivational interviewing and techniques that we
have recommended to manifest that spirit. Clinicians and trainers who become too focused on matters of
technique can lose sight of the spirit and style that are central to the approach. There are as many variations
in technique there are clinical encounters. The spirit of the method, however, is move enduring and can be
characterized in a few key points.
1. Motivation to change is elicited from the client, and not imposed from without. Other motivational
approaches have emphasized coercion, persuasion, constructive confrontation, and the use of
external contingencies (e.g., the threatened loss of job or family). Such strategies may have their
place in evoking change, but they are quite different in spirit from motivational interviewing which
relies upon identifying and mobilizing the client's intrinsic values and goals to stimulate behaviour
change.
2. It is the client's task, not the counsellor's, to articulate and resolve his or her ambivalence.
Ambivalence takes the form of a conflict between two courses of action (e.g., indulgence versus
restraint), each of which has perceived benefits and costs associated with it. Many clients have never
had the opportunity of expressing the often confusing, contradictory and uniquely personal elements
of this conflict, for example, "If I stop smoking I will feel better about myself, but I may also put on
weight, which will make me feel unhappy and unattractive." The counsellor's task is to facilitate
Page 1 of 21
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
expression of both sides of the ambivalence impasse, and guide the client toward an acceptable
resolution that triggers change.
Direct persuasion is not an effective method for resolving ambivalence. It is tempting to try to be
"helpful" by persuading the client of the urgency of the problem about the benefits of change. It is
fairly clear, however, that these tactics generally increase client resistance and diminish the
probability of change (Miller, Benefield and Tonigan, 1993, Miller and Rollnick, 1991).
The counselling style is generally a quiet and eliciting one. Direct persuasion, aggressive
confrontation, and argumentation are the conceptual opposite of motivational interviewing and are
explicitly proscribed in this approach. To a counsellor accustomed to confronting and giving advice,
motivational interviewing can appear to be a hopelessly slow and passive process. The proof is in the
outcome. More aggressive strategies, sometimes guided by a desire to "confront client denial," easily
slip into pushing clients to make changes for which they are not ready.
The counsellor is directive in helping the client to examine and resolve ambivalence. Motivational
interviewing involves no training of clients in behavioural coping skills, although the two approaches
not incompatible. The operational assumption in motivational interviewing is that ambivalence or
lack of resolve is the principal obstacle to be overcome in triggering change. Once that has been
accomplished, there may or may not be a need for further intervention such as skill training. The
specific strategies of motivational interviewing are designed to elicit, clarify, and resolve
ambivalence in a client-centred and respectful counselling atmosphere.
Readiness to change is not a client trait, but a fluctuating product of interpersonal interaction. The
therapist is therefore highly attentive and responsive to the client's motivational signs. Resistance and
"denial" are seen not as client traits, but as feedback regarding therapist behaviour. Client resistance
is often a signal that the counsellor is assuming greater readiness to change than is the case, and it is
a cue that the therapist needs to modify motivational strategies.
The therapeutic relationship is more like a partnership or companionship than expert/recipient roles.
The therapist respects the client's autonomy and freedom of choice (and consequences) regarding his
or her own behaviour.
Viewed in this way, it is inappropriate to think of motivational interviewing as a technique or set of
techniques that are applied to or (worse) "used on" people. Rather, it is an interpersonal style, not at all
restricted to formal counselling settings. It is a subtle balance of directive and client-centred components.
shaped by a guiding philosophy and understanding of what triggers change. If it becomes a trick or a
manipulative technique, its essence has been lost (Miller, 1994).
There are, nevertheless, specific and trainable therapist behaviours that are characteristic of a motivational
interviewing style. Foremost among these are:





Seeking to understand the person's frame of reference, particularly via reflective listening
Expressing acceptance and affirmation
Eliciting and selectively reinforcing the client's own self motivational statements expressions of
problem recognition, concern, desire and intention to change, and ability to change
Monitoring the client's degree of readiness to change, and ensuring that resistance is not generated by
jumping ahead of the client.
Affirming the client's freedom of choice and self-direction
The point is that it is the spirit of motivational interviewing that gives rise to these and other specific
strategies, and informs their use. A more complete description of the clinical style has been provided by
Miller and Rollnick (1991).
Differences From Related Methods
The check-up
Page 2 of 21
A number of specific intervention methods have been derived from motivational interviewing. The Drinker's
Check-up (Miller and Sovereign, 1989; Schippers, Brokken and Otten, 1994) is an assessment-based
strategy developed as a brief contact intervention with problem drinkers. It involves a comprehensive
assessment of the client's drinking and related behaviours, followed by systematic feedback to the client of
findings. (The check-up strategy can be and has been adapted to other problem areas as well. The key is to
provide meaningful personal feedback that can be compared with some normative reference.) Motivational
interviewing is the style with which this feedback is delivered. It is quite possible, however, to offer
motivational interviewing without formal assessment of any kind. It is also possible to provide assessment
feedback without any interpersonal interaction such as motivational interviewing (e.g., by mail), and there is
evidence that even such feedback can itself trigger behaviour change (Agostinelli, Brown and Miller, 1995).
Motivational Enhancement Therapy (MET)
MET is a four-session adaptation of the check-up intervention (Miller, Zweben, DiClemente and Rychtarik,
1992). It was developed specifically as one of three interventions tested in Project MATCH (1993), a
multisite clinical trial of treatments for alcohol abuse and dependence. Two follow-up sessions (at weeks 6
and 12) were added to the traditional two-session check-up format to parallel the 12-week (and 12 session)
format of two more intensive treatments in the trial. Motivational interviewing is the predominant style used
by counsellors throughout MET.
Brief motivational interviewing
A menu of concrete strategies formed the basis for "Brief Motivational Interviewing", which was developed
for use in a single session (around 40 minutes) in primary care settings with non-help-seeking excessive
drinkers (Rollnick, Bell and Heather, 1992). We found that it was not immediately apparent to primary care
workers how to apply the generic style of motivational interviewing during brief medical contacts. Therefore
Rollnick and Bell designed this set of quick, concrete techniques meant to manifest the spirit and practice of
motivational interviewing in brief contact settings. An unresolved issue is whether the spirit of motivational
interviewing can be captured in still briefer encounters of as little as 5-10 minutes. Numerous attempts to do
this are underway, although only one method has been published to date (Stott, Rollnick, Rees and Pill,
1995).
Brief intervention
This raises a fourth common confusion. Brief intervention in general has been confused with motivational
interviewing, helped perhaps by the introduction of more generic terms such as "brief motivational
counselling" (Holder, Longabaugh, Miller and Rubonis, 1991). Such brief interventions, as focused on
drinking, have been offered to two broad client groups: heavy drinkers in general medical settings who have
not asked for help, and help-seeking problem drinkers in specialist settings (Bien, Miller and Tonigan,
1993).
Attempts to understand the generally demonstrated effectiveness of brief intervention, have pointed to
common underlying ingredients, one expression of which is found in the acronym FRAMES originally
devised by Miller and Sanchez (1994). The letters of FRAMES refer to the use of Feedback, Responsibility
for change lying with the individual, Advice-giving, providing a Menu of change options, an Empathic
counselling style, and the enhancement of Self-efficacy (see Bien et al., 1993; Miller and Rollnick, 1991).
Although many of these ingredients are clearly congruent with a motivational interviewing style, some
applications (e.g., of advice-giving) are not (Rollnick, Kinnersley and Stott 1993). Therefore motivational
interviewing ought not be confused with brief interventions in general. We suggest that the word
"motivational" be used only when there is a primary intentional focus on increasing readiness for change.
Further, "motivational interviewing" should be used only when careful attention has been paid to the
definition and characteristic spirit described above. Put simply, if direct persuasion, appeals to professional
authority, and directive advice-giving are part of the (brief) intervention, a description of the approach as
Page 3 of 21
"motivational interviewing" is inappropriate. We are concerned to prevent an ever-widening variety of
methods from being erroneously presented (and tested) as motivational interviewing. It should also be useful
to distinguish between explanations of the mechanisms by which brief interventions work (which might or
might not involve motivational processes) and specific methods, derived from motivational interviewing,
which are designed to encourage behaviour change.
Differences From More Confrontational Approaches
Although motivational interviewing does, in one sense, seek to "confront" clients with reality, this method
differs substantially from more aggressive styles of confrontation. More specifically, we would regard
motivational interviewing as not being offered when a therapist;






argues that the person has a problem and needs to change
offers direct advice or prescribes solutions to the problem without the person's permission or without
actively encouraging the person to make his or her own choices
uses an authoritative/expert stance leaving the client in a passive role
does most of the talking, or functions as a unidirectional information delivery system
imposes a diagnostic label
behaves in a punitive or coercive manner
Such techniques violate the essential spirit of motivational interviewing.
How It Began...
William R. Miller, Ph.D.
Reprinted from Addictive Behaviors, Vol 21, No 6, “Motivational Interviewing: Research, Practice, and Puzzles,” pgs 835-842,
with permission from Elsevier Science.
Motivational interviewing began in a barber shop in Norway. Actually, the haircutter for
the Hjellestad Clinic outside Bergen had vacated the room to make space for a visiting
professor from the United States, and I found myself in a lovely corner office looking out
into the dense forest above a fjord.
Among my tasks that semester in 1982 was weekly supervision of a group of bright young
psychologists, most of them newly trained, who had been hired to treat alcohol and other
drug problems at Hjellestadklinikken. Because even toddlers quickly grew impatient with
my Norwegian, these meetings were conducted mostly in English, and one devise that we
used was role-play enactment of therapeutic methods. As I demonstrated how I might work
with clients in a variety of settings, I soon found that these psychologists had learned in the
course of their training to ask excellent and challenging questions: "What are you thinking
as you say that? Why have you taken this line of approach rather than another? Why that
particular word? What underlying model is guiding your methods?" They required me to
make explicit the approach I had learned from my clients.
One result of these discussions was a concept paper entitled, "Motivational Interviewing
with Problem Drinkers." I had not intended to publish it, but a copy fell into the hands of
Ray Hodgson who urged me to do so. He published the edited-down version in Behavioural
Psychotherapy (Miller, 1983), and I rather expected that to be the end of it, in part because
the article contained not a scrap of empirical data.
To my surprise, I found in the ensuing years that the concepts and methods of motivational
interviewing were quite appealing to practitioners, and in some countries were catching on
Page 4 of 21
to the extent of approaching common practice. Out of curiosity and, if nothing else, sheer
embarrassment, I was compelled to begin studying the processes and outcomes of this
approach that I had inadvertently introduced.
Reference
Miller, W.R. (1983). Motivational interviewing with problem drinkers. Behavioural Psychotherapy, 11, 147172.
The Philosophy Behind Motivational Interviewing
There are several important elements of the philosophy behind motivational interviewing.
1. Client resistance typically is a behavior evoked by environmental conditions.
MI views denial and resistance as behaviors evoked by environmental conditions, not as traits characteristic
of substance abusers. Resistance is primarily viewed as a reaction to the in-session behavior of the
counselor. A client's resistance may also be raised before meeting the counselor by other elements of the
situation, such as directives from a spouse, employer or judge to seek treatment. In any case, the counselor
is advised to disengage from the emotional pulls of the client's negative communications (e.g. anger,
silence); continue to communicate respect and empathy for the client; and ultimately judge the client's
motivation level, not by what he or she says to the counselor, but instead by what behavior is performed
over the course of treatment.
Additionally, the client's behavior over the course of treatment is affected in part by the counselor's reactions
to the early, negative communications of the client. It is important for the counselor using the MI approach
to remember that agreeing with the counselor's views does not indicate motivation on the client's part, and,
more importantly, disagreeing with the counselor's views does not indicate a lack of motivation on the
client's part.
2. The client/counselor relationship should be collaborative and friendly.
The MI framework fits best with a view that client change is best enhanced through positive reinforcement.
Through positive reinforcement, a client's environment rewards him or her for trying new things, such as
opening up to another person about his or her difficulties, or trying new behaviors that fit with the client's
long term goals rather than continuing behaviors that provide short-term gain at the cost of long-term loss,
etc.
Recognizing that a client's fears and sense of comfort with current habits and surroundings create strong
ambivalent feelings about change, the MI model contends that ambivalence must be fully addressed and
truly resolved in order to achieve long-term success. Essentially, the willingness of a client to open up and
express concerns, hesitations, fears, frustrations, anger, and feelings of loss, is likely to be increased by a
positive, friendly, collaborative relationship and to be decreased by an evaluative, hierarchical, or coercive
relationship. In the MI model, the counselor remains a friendly consultant, never criticizing the client's
effort or difficulties, always attempting to provide empathy and support, yet also willing and able to provide
feedback and helpful suggestions to the client as the client becomes ready to consider them. The MI
counselor is persuasive, but not coercive; at times challenging, but never argumentative.
3. Motivational Interviewing gives priority to resolving ambivalence.
As mentioned above, in the MI approach, clients are generally viewed as feeling highly ambivalent about
changing. Miller and Rollnick believe that resolving clients' ambivalence generally has been given less
attention in traditional approaches than is optimal. They see most traditional SA treatment approaches as
Page 5 of 21
being too action-oriented, or at least too quick to press clients into focusing primarily on making changes in
their lives. The concern about this is that clients often have mixed feelings about making changes, and
counselor who presses a client to make changes immediately risks (a) evoking client resistance, (b)
promoting premature termination from counseling, and (c) encouraging clients to overlook the internal and
external factors that may promote relapse even following initial success in change attempts.
4. The counselor does not prescribe specific methods or techniques.
MI counselors educate clients about the variety of therapeutic options available to them and, at times, the
research support for particular options. These include treatment options, as well as other means of support.
Clients are free to choose the elements that they believe will be most helpful to them in their efforts. Miller
and Rollnick remind us that, despite our best attempts to convince clients to do as we wish, they are always
free to make their own choices and we shouldn't get too obsessed with the idea that we are "letting" clients
do things we believe are not in their best interests. They believe that allowing clients to pursue their own
means of change increases the likelihood of long-term success, even if clients choose goals or means that do
not lead to immediate success.
5. Clients are responsible for their progress.
Although MI counselors help clients make positive changes in their lives, counselors never assume
responsibility for their clients' change. Just as MI counselors emphasize the freedom clients have to choose
their behaviors, MI/MET counselors also emphasize the responsibility that lies with clients to make those
changes.
6. MI focuses on clients' sense of self-efficacy.
The MI approach increases the clients' hope that they can make substantial changes related to their substance
abuse. Clients who perceive that they have substance problems in need of change may still "resist" change if
they believe they cannot successfully complete the change process. The Project MATCH MET manual
cautions counselors that, without a sense of self-efficacy regarding change, clients are likely to use defense
mechanisms such as rationalization or denial in order to protect themselves from emotional pain.
Motivational Interviewing Principles
There are four general principles behind Motivational Interviewing.
Express Empathy
Empathy involves seeing the world through the client's eyes, thinking about things as the client thinks about
them, feeling things as the client feels them, sharing in the client's experiences. Expression of empathy is
critical to the MI approach. When clients feel that they are understood, they are more able to open up to
their own experiences and share those experiences with others. Having clients share their experiences with
you in depth allows you to assess when and where they need support, and what potential pitfalls may need
focused on in the change planning process. Importantly, when clients perceive empathy on a counselor's
part, they become more open to gentle challenges by the counselor about lifestyle issues and beliefs about
substance use. Clients become more comfortable fully examining their ambivalence about change and less
likely to defend ideas like their denial of problems, reducing use vs. abstaining, etc. In short, the counselor's
accurate understanding of the client's experience facilitates change.
Support Self-Efficacy
As noted above, a client's belief that change is possible is an important motivator to succeeding in making a
change. As clients are held responsible for choosing and carrying out actions to change in the MI approach,
counselors focus their efforts on helping the clients stay motivated, and supporting clients' sense of selfefficacy is a great way to do that. One source of hope for clients using the MI approach is that there is no
"right way" to change, and if a given plan for change does not work, clients are only limited by their own
creativity as to the number of other plans that might be tried.
Page 6 of 21
The client can be helped to develop a belief that he or she can make a change. For example, the clinician
might inquire about other healthy changes the client has made in their life, highlighting skills the client
already has. Sharing brief clinical examples of other, similar clients' successes at changing the same habit or
problem can sometimes be helpful. In a group setting, the power of having other people who have changed
a variety of behaviors during their lifetime gives the clinician enormous assistance in showing that people
can change,
Roll with Resistance
In MI, the counselor does not fight client resistance, but "rolls with it." Statements demonstrating resistance
are not challenged. Instead the counselor uses the client's "momentum" to further explore the client's views.
Using this approach, resistance tends to be decreased rather than increased, as clients are not reinforced for
becoming argumentative and playing "devil's advocate" to the counselor's suggestions. MI encourages
clients to develop their own solutions to the problems that they themselves have defined. Thus, there is no
real hierarchy in the client-counselor relationship for the client to fight against. In exploring client concerns,
counselors may invite clients to examine new perspectives, but counselors do not impose new ways of
thinking on clients.
Develop Discrepancy
"Motivation for change occurs when people perceive a discrepancy between where they are and where they
want to be" (Miller, Zweben, DiClemente, & Rychtarik, 1992, p. 8). MI counselors work to develop this
situation through helping clients examine the discrepancies between their current behavior and future goals.
When clients perceive that their current behaviors are not leading toward some important future goal, they
become more motivated to make important life changes. Of course, MI counselors do not develop
discrepancy at the expense of the other MI principles, but gently and gradually help clients to see how some
of their current ways of being may lead them away from, rather than toward, their eventual goals.
Reference: Miller, W. R., Zweben, A., DiClemente, C. C., & Rychtarik, R. G. (1992). Motivational
Enhancement Therapy manual: A clinical research guide for therapists treating individuals with alcohol
abuse and dependence. Rockville, MD: National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism.
Visit the NIAAA web site to learn more about Project MATCH or to obtain this treatment manual:
http://silk.nih.gov/silk/niaaa1/publication/match.htm
Some MI "Traps"
The following includes some of the "Traps" that counselors may fall into when attempting to work with
clients, particularly when those clients have motivations that lead them away from positive change in their
problematic behaviors.
Recognizing and Working with Resistance
Much of the focus in the Motivational Interviewing model is on working with clients' counter-motivations;
that is, any motivations that lead individuals away from a decrease in substance-related problems or other
problematic behaviors. Although these behaviors have traditionally been referred to as resistance, some
counselors familiar with the MI model prefer the term counter-motivation. This seems more fitting with the
MI model, for a few reasons. First, "resistance" is perhaps just one type of counter-motivation. In fact, there
are many reasons why a person might choose to continue using substances or engaging in other problematic
behaviors, including hopelessness, low self-efficacy, excitement about parts of the lifestyle surrounding the
problematic behaviors, and so on. Second, the term "resistance" seems to have a pejorative quality to it, as if
the individual is refusing to do "what is best" for himself or herself in an intentional, stubborn manner.
Labeling counter-motivations as "resistance" may tend to promote urges on the part of the counselor to
confront or argue with the client about the client's "resistance," when an approach that is more consistent
Page 7 of 21
with MI might be for the counselor to take these other motivations as serious viewpoints or alternatives for
the client to fully consider and to approach this consideration in a non-threatening manner.
Signs of client counter-motivation might include interrupting, ignoring, arguing, denying, talking about
seemingly unimportant matters, daydreaming, reminiscing, "wondering aloud" and so on. If you see these
behaviors in your client, consider them a cue to check your own current behaviors, plans, and expectations.
Have you moved ahead to working toward the implementation of change plans without first checking the
client's level of readiness? If so, you may be in a "trap," or inducing the client to argue, interrupt you, deny
the problem, or ignore you. These are signs that the client is not feeling heard, respected, or taken seriously,
or that the client is simply not yet ready to consider implementing what may seem to you like an obviously
needed change in behavior.
Using the MI approach, when a counselor notices counter-motivations in a client, he or she attempts to first
avoid avoid certain "traps," then help the client consider change by using certain therapeutic strategies.
Below is brief coverage of some of these traps and strategies. They are covered in greater detail in the
Motivational Interviewing book.
Traps to Avoid
Question/Answer Trap
In this "trap" the counselor and client fall into a pattern of question/answer, question/answer, and so on. The
problem with this pattern is that it tends to elicit passivity and closes off access to deeper levels of
experience. Thus, clients are not encouraged to explore issues in depth, and the client-counselor relationship
becomes increasingly hierarchical.
Confrontation/Denial Trap
Most counselors have had the experience of interviewing a client who is not yet ready to change, and who
provides a reasonable argument in response to every statement the counselor makes. The counselor and
client then engage in an argumentative, confrontation/denial trap, in which the client counters each argument
for change with an argument for remaining the same. An example of a mild confrontation/denial trap is
illustrated in the following conversation:
Dr.: Have you thought about trying to lose weight so your blood pressure comes down?
Pt.: Well yes, but it's not so easy, and I must say, I really like my food.
Dr.: But it's not a matter of depriving yourself of food. You just need to eat different, healthier foods, if you
see what I mean.
Pt.: Yes, I know, I did try to eat less meat and more fruit and that sort of thing, but I never keep going for
too long. I always have these binges when I break all my rules, and I just get fat.
Dr.: What about....?
Pt.: Yes, but....
(From Rollnick, Heather, & Bell, 1992, p. 25-26)
One of the benefits to the counselor of adapting a motivational approach is the avoidance of such
discouraging interchanges. Rather than engaging in futile attempts to convince the client to change, the MI
approach encourages the client to voice the reasons for change, with just a little questioning and guidance
supplied by the therapist. Remember that if a person feels backed into a corner, or one point of view, the
person will usually defend that point of view more strongly. If you leave your client with no other option
than to argue with you, that is what you will get. MI-style approaches may help the client and the counselor
avoid the inevitable frustration of two people working at odds.
Expert Trap
In the "expert trap," counselors fall into providing direction to the client without first helping the client to
determine his or her own goals, direction and plans. The problem with this approach is that clients may tend
to passively accept the counselor's suggestions, and may only halfheartedly commit to the difficult work
Page 8 of 21
involved in changing. A counselor using the MI approach is not non-directive, that is, he or she will offer
suggestions for change. However, this is done after the client's motivation is high, after initial exploration of
multiple pathways to change, and only upon client's request, or when the counselor perceives that the client
is in immediate danger if not given advice.
Labeling Trap
The labeling trap happens when a counselor attempts to convince a client that he or she is an "alcoholic,"
"addict," or some other label. As Miller and Rollnick state, "because such labels often carry a certain stigma
in the public mind, it is not surprising that people with reasonable self-esteem resist them" (1992, p. 68).
They also point out that "the Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) philosophy specifically recommends against such
labeling of others" (p. 68). Despite this, some counselors believe that clients must accept a label or
diagnosis in order to change their behavior. MI theory disagrees with this view, and suggests that counselors
de-emphasize labels whenever possible.
Premature Focus Trap
Although the MI does not suggest that counselors simply "follow" the clients' lead as is done in Rogerian or
Person-Centered therapy, MI also cautions counselors against focusing too quickly on a specific problem or
aspect of a problem. Difficulties with premature focus include raising client resistance and focusing on an
unimportant or secondary problem.
Blaming Trap
Clients may wish to blame others for their problems. Counselors may feel compelled to show the client how
he or she is at fault for the difficulties encountered. In the MI approach, neither of these urges are seen as
useful. Blame is irrelevant. Miller and Rollnick suggest establishing a "no-fault" policy when counseling a
person, and commenting, "I'm not interested in looking for who's responsible, but rather what's troubling
you, and what you might be able to do about it" (1991, p. 70).
References:
Miller, W. R., & Rollnick, S. (1991). Motivational interviewing: Preparing people for change. New York: Guilford Press.
Miller, W. R., Zweben, A., DiClemente, C. C., & Rychtarik, R. G. (1992). Motivational Enhancement Therapy manual: A clinical
research guide for therapists treating individuals with alcohol abuse and dependence. Rockville, MD: National Institute on
Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism.
Rollnick, S., Heather, N., & Bell, A. (1992). Negotiating behaviour change in medical settings: The development of brief
motivational interviewing. Journal of Mental Health, 1, 25-37.
Visit the NIAAA web site to learn more about Project MATCH or to obtain the MET treatment manual:
http://silk.nih.gov/silk/niaaa1/publication/match.htm
Interaction Techniques
Following are some of the techniques described in Miller and Rollnick's Motivational Interviewing book and
NIAAA's Project MATCH Motivational Enhancement Therapy Manual.
Interaction Techniques
The following section focuses on interaction techniques for motivational interviewing counselors.
Interaction Techniques
The basic approach to interactions in motivational interviewing is captured by the acronym OARS: (1)
Open-ended questions, (2) Affirmations, (3) Reflective listening and (4) Summaries. The acronym is a nice
Page 9 of 21
image. It gives us power to move, yet it is not a powerboat. We don't zip from one place to another, yet with
sustained effort OARS can take us a long way.
Open-ended questions are those therapist utterances that client's cannot answer with a "yes", "no" or "three
times in the last week". Most people begin treatment sessions with an open-ended question - "What brings
you here today?" or "Tell me about what's been happening since we last met?" An open-ended question
allows the client to create the impetus for forward movement. Although close-ended questions have their
place - indeed are necessary and quite valuable at times - the open-ended question creates a forward
momentum that we wish to use in helping the client explore change. For example, "So what makes you feel
that it might be time for a change?"
Affirmations are statements of recognition about client strengths. We side firmly with Carlo DiClemente
that many people who come for our assistance are failed self-changers. That is, they tried to alter their
behavior and it didn't work. As a result, clients come to us demoralized or at least suspicious of the assertion
that change is possible. This condition means that as therapists, we must help clients feel that change is
possible and that they are capable of implementing that change. One method of doing this is to point out
client strengths, particularly in areas where they observe only failure. We often explore prior attempts at
change. For example, "So you stayed sober for a week after treatment. How were you able to stay sober for
that week?" We also use resistance as a source for affirmations. For example, "You didn't want to come
today, but you did it anyway. I'm not sure, but it seems like that if you decide something is important
enough, you are willing to put up with a lot just to do it."
Affirmations can be wonderful rapport builders. For clients suffering from addictions, affirmations can be a
rare commodity. However, they must be congruent and genuine. If the client thinks you are insincere, then
rapport can be damaged rather than built.
Reflective listening is the key to this work. The best motivational advice we can give you is to listen
carefully to your clients. They will tell you what has worked and what hasn't. What moved them forward and
shifted them backward. Whenever you are in doubt about what to do, listen. But remember this is a directive
approach. Unlike Rogerian therapists, you will actively guide the client towards certain materials. You will
focus on their change talk and provide less attention to non-change talk. For example, "You are not quite
sure you are ready to make a change, but you are quite aware that your drug use has caused concerns in your
relationships, effected your work and that your doctor is worried about your health."
You will also want to vary your level of reflection. Keeping reflections at the surface level may lead to that
feeling that the interaction is moving in circles. Reflections of affect, especially those that are unstated but
likely, can be powerful motivators. For example, "Your children aren't living with you anymore; that seems
painful for you." If you are right, the emotional intensity of the session deepens. If you are wrong or the
client is unready to deal with this material, the client corrects you and the conversation moves forward.
The goal in MI is to create forward momentum and to then harness that momentum to create change.
Reflective listening keeps that momentum moving forward. This is why Bill and Steve recommend a ratio of
three reflections for every question asked. Questions tend to cause a shift in momentum and can stop it
entirely. Although there are times you will want to create a shift or stop momentum, most times you will
want to keep it flowing.
Finally, there are summaries. This is really just a specialized form of reflective listening where you reflect
back to the client what he or she has been telling you. Summaries are an effective way to communicate your
interest in a client, build rapport, call attention to salient elements of the discussion and to shift attention or
direction. Personal preference will determine how often you do these, but we recommend doing them
relatively frequently as too much information from the client can bc unwieldy for the therapist to digest and
feedback. Also, if the interaction is going in an unproductive or problematic direction (e.g., reinforcing
status quo talk, encountering resistance), the summary can be used to shift the focus of the intervention.
Page 10 of 21
The structure of the summary is straightforward. It begins with an announcement that you are about to
summarize, a listing of selected elements, an invitation to correct anything missed and then usually an openended question. If ambivalence was evident in the interaction that proceeded the summary, this should be
included in the summary. Here's an example,
"Let me stop and summarize what we've just talked about. Your not sure that you want to be here today and
you really only came because your partner insisted on it. At the same time, you've had some nagging
thoughts of your own about what's been happening, including how much you've been using recently, the
change in your physical health and your missed work. Did I miss anything? I'm wondering what you make of
all those things."
The goal is not acquire ammunition, which is then turned on the client in a defense-overwhelming manner,
but instead is a reflection of what the client has said and where the client is encouraged to supply the
meaning. This is an area where you need to watch that your wisdom and experience doesn't keep you from
listening to your client's understanding of the problem. It is this understanding that will guide their efforts at
change or maintaining the status quo.
The goal is using the OARS is to move the person forward by eliciting change talk, or self-motivational
statements. Change talk involves statements or affective communications that indicate the client may be
considering the possibility of change. Miller and Rollnick organize this talk into four categories: problem
recognition, concern about the problem, commitment to change and belief that change is possible.
Essentially, any statement oriented toward the present or future, either in the cognitive or emotional realm,
may represent a self-motivational statement. For example,:"I think that using may be causing problems"
(present-cognitive); "I'm kind of worried that things may be getting out of hand" (present-emotional); "I'm
definitely going to do something about that" (future-cognitive); "You know, I'm starting to feel like this just
might work out" (future-emotional).
More on Reflections, Rolling with Resistance, Reframing
The following section focuses more on specific interaction techniques for counselors to try in order to
reduce client resistance once it occurs.
Simple Reflection
One way to reduce resistance is simply to repeat or rephrase what the client has said. This communicates
that you have heard the person, and that it is not your intention to get into an argument with the person.
Client: But I can't quit drinking. I mean, all of my friends drink!
Counselor: Quitting drinking seems nearly impossible because you spend so much time with others who
drink.
Client: Right, although maybe I should.
Amplified Reflection
This is similar to a simple reflection, only the counselor amplifies or exaggerates the point to the point
where the client may disavow or disagree with it. It is important that the counselor not overdo it, because if
the client feels mocked or patronized, he or she is likely to respond with anger.
Client: But I can't quit using. I mean, all of my friends use!
Counselor: Oh, I see. So you really couldn't quit using because then you'd be too different to fit in with your
friends.
Client: Well, that would make me different from them, although they might not really care as long as I
didn't try to get them to quit.
Double-sided Reflection
With a double-sided reflection, the counselor reflects both the current, resistant statement, and a previous,
contradictory statement that the client has made.
Page 11 of 21
Client: But I can't quit drinking. I mean, all of my friends drink!
Counselor: You can't imagine how you could not drink with your friends, and at the same time you're
worried about how it's affecting you.
Client: Yes. I guess I have mixed feelings.
Shifting Focus
Another way to reduce resistance is simply to shift topics. It is often not motivational to address resistant or
counter-motivational statements, and counseling goals are better achieved by simply not responding to the
resistant statement.
Client: But I can't quit drinking. I mean, all of my friends drink!
Counselor: You're getting way ahead of things here. I'm not talking about your quitting drinking here, and I
don't think you should get stuck on that concern right now. Let's just stay with what we're doing here talking through the issues - and later on we can worry about what, if anything, you want to do about it.
Client: Well I just wanted you to know.
Rolling with Resistance
Resistance can also be met by rolling with it instead of opposing it. There is a paradoxical element in this,
which often will bring the client back to a balanced or opposite perspective. This strategy can be particularly
useful with clients who present in a highly oppositional manner and who seem to reject every idea or
suggestion.
Client: But I can't quit using. I mean, all of my friends use!
Counselor: And it may very well be that when we're through, you'll decide that it's worth it to keep on
drinking as you have been. It may be too difficult to make a change. That will be up to you.
Client: Okay.
Reframing
Reframing is a strategy in which you invite clients to examine their perceptions in a new light or a
reorganized form. In this way, new meaning is given to what has been said. For example, if a client reports a
spouse or loved one as saying, "You really need to get in treatment and deal with these problems," the client
may view this as "she's such a nag" or "he is always telling me what to do." The counselor can reframe this
as "this person must care a lot about you to tell you something he (or she) feels is important to you, knowing
that you will likely get angry with him (or her)."
Reframing can also be used to discuss the issue of tolerance. Clients may report that they are especially good
at holding their liquor, or may view their substance use as non-problematic because they don't "even really
get high anymore." This gives the counselor the opportunity to discuss notions about tolerance, and reframe
it to the client as not having a built-in warning system to indicate when he or she has "had enough." Thus,
what originally appears to support the concept that there is no problem ("I can hold it") now supports the
concept that there may be a problem ("I'm at risk for overdoing it without knowing it until it's too late").
Material adapted from Ingersoll, Wagner & Gharib, 2000; NIAAA Project MATCH Motivational Enhancement Therapy
manual (Miller, Zweben, DiClemente, & Rychtarik, 1992; Rosengren & Wagner, 2001.
References:
Miller, W. R., & Rollnick, S. (1991). Motivational interviewing: Preparing people for change. New York: Guilford Press.
Miller, W. R., Zweben, A., DiClemente, C. C., & Rychtarik, R. G. (1992). Motivational Enhancement Therapy manual: A clinical
research guide for therapists treating individuals with alcohol abuse and dependence. Rockville, MD: National Institute on
Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism.
Rollnick, S., Heather, N., & Bell, A. (1992). Negotiating behaviour change in medical settings: The development of brief
motivational interviewing. Journal of Mental Health, 1, 25-37.
Page 12 of 21
MI Counseling Strategies
The following includes some of the strategies used in motivational interviewing. This text is adapted and
excerpted from Ingersoll, Wagner & Gharib (2000) and Rosengren & Wagner, (2001).
Motivational Counseling Strategies
Reviewing a Typical Day
Here, the counselor builds rapport while gathering information. The counselor avoids a focus on "problem
behaviors," focusing instead on how substance use fits in to the person's life. Rollnick et al. (1992) suggest
starting with, "Can we spend the next 5-10 minutes going through a day from beginning to end. What
happened, how did you feel, and where did your use of xxx fit in? Let's start at the beginning." (P. 30).
Proceed to help the client tell a story of the day, focusing on feelings and behaviors. If the client is receptive,
summarize, then move to the next strategy.
Looking Back
This strategy simply involves engaging in a conversation with the client about what life was like "before."
Before substance use problems, before legal, work or relationship difficulties, etc. What does the client
remember? What good memories, hopes, dreams or plans did the person once have? What successes,
achievements did the person have? If the person's history is very negative, it may still be useful to explore
"what it was like," not necessarily in an attempt to process or resolve issues from that time, but primarily to
establish the situation that existed before substance problems.
These techniques can be spurred by a client comment such as, "I used to have it all" or "I wasn't always this
way." This is a natural segue for a therapist comment and question, "So things have really changed. Tell me
a little bit about what life was like back then." Then the therapist uses OARS to keep momentum going and
to elicit how the problem behavior fit into this circumstance and/or how it changed over time. For example,
if drinking is the client issue, then, "So I'm wondering how your drinking fit in back then." Then later, the
therapist might ask, "It sounds like your drinking changed over time. Tell me about that."
Then, you can explore how the client's path went from those previous dreams, plans successes or stressors
into occasional, regular or chronic substance use. Again, the goal is not "insight" into deep psychological
processes, just an establishment of some history to help "ground" the client as those with substance
problems often seem caught in the "here and now" and sometimes seem to have lost a deep sense of self, of
who they feel they are. The goal is for the client to obtain some perspective from the immediacy of his or her
circumstance and to observe either how things have changed over time.
Good Things and Less Good Things
This strategy is simply to review what is "good" about substance use alongside a review of what is "not-sogood" about the use of substances. Steve Rollnick developed this phrasing for a particular purpose; namely,
he wanted to avoid labeling a behavior as a problem when the client was not using that language. Failure to
do this may lead to arguments with clients where they state adamantly the behavior is not a problem.
Conversely, clients are often willing to acknowledge that there are less good things about a behavior.
behavior. The technique also provides the therapist an opportunity to explore what "positives" may be
sustaining a behavior. This is often a very fruitful inquiry and typically quite surprising to clients. They are
often confronted with why they need to change a behavior, but only rarely asked what benefits they are
receiving. This often serves to reduce resistance and allows inquiry into the Less Good things to be more
acceptable to the client. We start this technique with a prefacing comment, then follow with a qu estion about
the Good Things. We follow up until all the Good Things have been exhausted. We summarize, then ask
about the Less Good Things. These are then explored in more detail with requests made for examples of
Less Good behavior. For example, "You said that your use had affected your children. Tell me about a time
Page 13 of 21
that happened." Once this area is fully explored, we summarize, emphasize any change talk that emerged,
and then ask the client what their take on this material might be. The most important part of this strategy is
to avoid labeling things as a problem.
Some counselors have begun using an alternate focus for the exploration of "good things and not-so-good
things" - asking clients to talk about their experiences at AA or NA meetings and considering both "pros" of
attending as well as "cons." The goal is to engage the client in sharing both likes and dislikes with the
intention of reducing resistance or unhappiness about attending these meetings by "getting things out in the
air." Often, people are more willing to accept the "good things" about meetings if their counselor explores
and gives respect to what clients see as the "not-so-good" things.
Discussing the Stages of Change
Below is an example of how a counselor might talk with a client about the stages of change. After an
explanation such as the one below (or something briefer!), the counselor might ask the client to react to the
explanation just given about the stages of change. The counselor might ask the client to think about things
they have changed in the past, and examples of when they were in the various stages of change during this
process. If a client previously got stuck in a stage, ask the person to think about what methods they were
using during that stage, if he or she can identify any. Write these down as well. Spend some time discussing
the client's experiences with change, and consider focusing more on "less threatening" changes such as diet,
adhering to medical advice, cigarette smoking, work habits, exercise, rather than on drug and alcohol abuse.
This can reduce defensiveness about drug and alcohol in later sessions and help to teach how changing
addictive behaviors is similar to making other changes.
One way a counselor might introduce the topic:
In or out of treatment, people seem to pass through similar stages as they work on making changes. This
goes for many kinds of changes. The same stages seem to apply to people who want to lose weight as they do
to people who want to cut down or stop their drinking or drugging.
The first stage of change is called the "Pre-contemplation Stage". During this stage people are not thinking
about making a change. This may be because they have never thought much about their situation or they
have already thought things through and decided not to change their behavior. Sometimes people may want
to change, but not feel as if they could successfully make the change they desire. People in this stage might
find it useful to get more information about their situation.
When people start thinking about their situation, they begin the second stage called the "Contemplation
Stage." During this stage, people are "unsure" about what to do. There are both good and not-so-good
things about their present situation. People in this stage also struggles with the good and not-so-good things
that might come with change. During this stage people often both want change and yet want to stay the same
at the same time. This can be a bit confusing for people as they feel torn between these options.
At some point, when people have been thinking through whether or not to change, they may come to feel that
the reasons for change outweigh the reasons not to change. As this weight increases on the side of change,
the person becomes more determined to do something. This is the beginning of the next stage, called the
"Preparation Stage." During this stage, poeple begin thinking about how they can go about making the
change they desire, making plans, and then taking some action toward stopping old behaviors and/or
starting new, more productive behaviors. People often become more and more "ready" and committed to
making changes.
During the next stage of change called the "Action Stage" people begin to implement their "change plans"
and trying out new ways of being. Often, during this stage people let others know what's happening and look
for support from them in making these changes.
Page 14 of 21
Once people have succeeded in making and keeping some changes over a period of time they enter the
"Maintenance Stage." During this stage, people try to sustain the changes that have been made and to
prevent returning to their old ways. This is why this stage is also known as the "Holding Stage." Many times
the person is able to keep up the changes made and then makes a permanent exit from the wheel (or spiral)
of change. During this stage it is also common for people to have some "slips" or "lapses" where old habits
return for a short time.
Sometimes people also have "relapses" which may last a longer period of time. When a person has a
relapse, he or she typically returns to the precontemplation or contemplation stages. the person's task is to
start around the wheel of change again rather than getting stuck. Keep in mind that relapses, slips, and
lapses are normal as a person tries to change any long-standing habit. Often times people go around the
wheel of change 3 or 4 (or more) times before permanent change takes hold.
There is some pretty good evidence that people shouldn't skip stages. Someone that jumps right into the
action stage may not spend enough time preparing for change. The result is they have trouble in keeping the
changes they've made. For this reason, it is important for you to know which stage you're in and what things
you need to do to move to the next stage.
Assessment Feedback
Another strategy involves providing feedback to the client about their behavior. This can be formalized, as
in the Drinker's Check-up discussed below, or informal based on information elicited during the course of
the intervention. Normative feedback can include information about levels of use, consequences of use or
comparison to others. Standardized instruments like the ASI, SASSI, AUDIT or DrInC or InDUC provide
ready resources for this type of feedback. The comparison can be to others or within themselves on scales.
For example, a therapist could use the DrInC scales to convey where the client acknowledges experiencing
problems and where they seem to be doing fine. An informal feedback opportunity that frequent arises is
tolerance. Clients often point to their ability to "hold" alcohol as a sign there is not a problem. This statement
allows the therapist to offer information about how tolerance operates, including the potential detrimental
effects of circumventing this early warning system. Feedback can also be from locally used instruments or
information gathered in the session. For example, in exploring HIV risk behavior, on emight elicit
information about values, goals and sexual practices and then review with clients the information they
shared, including any inconsistencies observed. They then explore together these inconsistencies. The most
important point here is the therapist acts simply as a conduit for information. The client is given the job of
ascribing meaning. An example of informal feedback might go like this:
Mary, would it be okay if I offered a little information to you based on what we've talked about so far?
Correct me if I'm wrong about anything. To begin, it sounds like you've noticed an escalating pattern in your
cocaine use. This is a source of some concern to you both because of your parents' history of substance
misuse and because you've begun to drop away from your old friends. You're spending a lot more time
recovering from the use and the financial drain has begun to create some issues with your husband. You've
also noticed the high has changed and your using more to get to that place you want. Finally, you are
concerned about your relationship with your kids. You swore that you were going to be a better mom to your
kids than your mom was to you, but now your not so sure how you've done with that. I'm wondering what
you make of all this?
Values Exploration
A values focus can help a person define his or her "ideal self" by exploring those behavioral ideals to which
the person resonates. Sometimes, individuals have forgotten about these values or have rejected them as
naive or unachievable. Simply focusing on these ideals can help open a person detect actual behaviors
inconsistent with the ideal.
A focus on values may stimulate motivation for change. Focusing on discrepancies between ideal life
conditions and actual conditions may induce a desire to "recalibrate" daily behaviors to be more congruent
with deeply held beliefs. Awakened to a deeper sense of self and values, the person may become
Page 15 of 21
increasingly aware that the problematic behaviors meet certain short-term needs but do not lead to
fulfillment of higher values or long-term satisfaction. Focusing on ideals can help decrease clients'
defensiveness and increase desire for change by shifting the focus away from consideration of "bad"
behaviors or lifestyle, toward a focus on a more deeply satisfying lifestyle that can be pursued and enjoyed.
Clients may come to perceive that they do not necessarily have to purge valued aspects of their current self;
instead they need to restrain certain tendencies in order to develop a deeper, more aware self and live with a
greater sense of purpose (importance) and power (confidence).
Ambivalence about various possibilities can be viewed in part as the experiential result of multiple
conflicting values. While ambivalence may be resolved from concluding that longer-term values (for
example, stable job, good family and friend relationships, ownership of property) take precedence over
short-term values (for example, fun, relief from stress or anxiety, excitement), there are other paths to its
resolution. Sometimes, it is not so much a conflict between the long- and short-term values themselves but
an issue that the strategies for fulfilling short-term values are precisely those strategies that prevent fulfilling
the longer-term values. There are other ways to gain excitement other than using cocaine and living a fast
lifestyle. By seeking with the client the positive motivations behind the problem behaviors, we can open the
door to consideration of alternative behaviors that address short-term needs without unduly interfering with
the pursuit of long-term goals.
In addition to a general discussion of the client's values, counselors can use a set of valu es cards and have
the client sort through the cards and order them in accordance with his or her priorities. Topics discussed
may include the meaning of the various values statements, evaluation of current consistency between values
and behavior, perceived barriers to and opportunities for increasing value-behavior consistency, and
personal evaluation of the extent to which the use of substances plays a role in achieving or preventing
consistency. Counselors sometimes report that this technique increased the ease of practice as well as client
engagement.
One study of individuals who have made "quantum" changes shows the dramatic shifts in values that
individuals can undergo in a very brief timeframe. See the table in this link for an example of the types of
value changes individuals can undergo.
Looking Forward
Looking Forward has a similar focus to Looking Back. It has the client envision two futures. The first is if
they continue on the same path without any changes where they might be five or ten years from now. The
second future is if - and the emphasis is on if - they decided to make a change in their behavior, what that
future might look like. The therapist's job is not argue one position or another, but rather just elicit the
information and then ask the client to comment on these imaginings.
Exploring Importance and Confidence
A recent strategy developed by Rollnick and colleagues (Rollnick, Mason, & Butler, 1999) involves the
dimensions of importance and confidence. This strategy essentially explores the client's impressions of how
important is to make a change and how confident he or she is that he or she can succeed in changing. The
therapist explores the client's impressions of what it is that makes the change important, how this change fits
in with other aspects of his or her life, and what events may transpire to make this change seem more
important than it currently does. The issues around a person's confidence in changing are explored in a
similar way, and the therapist may guide the client to review past change attempts and determine how the
therapist and significant others could help the person succeed in making a change.
Decisional Balance
The decisional balance exercise is a values exercise similar to good things/less good things, except with a
focus on future behavior. Counselors ask clients to identify the anticipated "pros" and "cons" of changing a
behavior, then compare this with the pros and cons of not changing the behavior. Once the pros and cons
have been identified, counselors may ask clients to consider which of these options best meet clients' ideals
Page 16 of 21
while also tending to their preferences for experiences. Counselors may reflect that clients have the
opportunity to create different lifestyles and to choose in part who they will become in the future through the
course of action they choose.
As with a number of these strategies, this one can be done on paper as preparation for or a supplement to a
conversational approach. See a Decisional Balance worksheet here (PDF file).
Change Planning
A change plan is a technique that can be quite helpful with clients that are ready to do this type of work. To
avoid a premature focus on action plans, some have taken to calling these forms, "The Next 90 days." This
form can then be used to record any number of actions including simply thinking more about an issue. This
form typically includes just a few simple questions (Fill in), which the therapist and client fill in conjointly.
See a Change Plan worksheet form and completed sample here (PDF file)
Do it All in a Moment or Two
One counselor, Chris Dunn, has offered what he calls the 20-second MI intervention. Apparently, there are
also colleagues at Kaiser-Permanente in Portland who are doing similar work. The basic premise is you have
a very brief amount of time and a potentially thorny issue to solve. Chris simply clicks through an acronymbased model called FRAMES and leaves the client with the responsibility for making a choice. For example:
So, Bill you are in your third week of treatment and your feeling like you've accomplished everything you
need to (FEEDBACK). My sense is you've begun exploring what's led to your drinking (FEEDBACK). I am
concerned that you've not spent much time thinking about how you'll handle your homelife (FEEDBACK). If
you asked for my advice, I would recommend you stick with treatment a little longer and work on this area
(ADVICE). However, there may be other ways to do this (MENU OF OPTIONS) and the choice is really
yours to make (RESPONSIBILITY). I know you've been feeling antsy (EMPATHY) and I have faith that you
can make a good decision (SELF-EFFICACY). What do you think?
Monitoring the effectiveness of your use of MI Strategies
Although formal research methods for client outcomes are a worthwhile goal, this is unlikely to be available
for many clinicians. A much more practical method is available for practitioners: observe your clients. If
during the session they are constantly arguing, disagreeing or ignoring you, then what you are doing is not
working. It's a signal that you should shift methods. Even if you convince them of the folly of their ways,
change is unlikely to be sustained under these circumstances. If clients agree to do something between
sessions, then fail to do it, this does not necessarily mean there is a problem. It may simply be ambivalence.
However, if it happens consistently, then you may be arguing for change and the client is simply
acquiescing. It is time to focus on listening to your client. Finally, if your client's don't return for sessions, it
may be a sign that they are giving up you rather than the problem behavior. You may have pressed too hard
for a change the client was not ready to make. Our advice: pay attention to your clients, they tell you one
way or another how you are doing.
Toward a Theory of Motivational Interviewing
William Miller, Ph.D.
Reprinted with permission from the Motivational Interviewing Newsletter: Updates, Education and Training (MINUET; 1999;
Vol 6, No. 3; p. 2-4)
Much of my career I've run afoul of colleagues for being too atheoretical - a pragmatic dustbowl empiricist.
When pressed I can usually come up with a reasonable theoretical rationale, but the truth is that I usually
Page 17 of 21
start from curiosity and experience, and from a general interest in finding what works best for people in
pain. With enough experience, I start coming around to theory development.
Thus I have devoted perhaps too little time and attention to developing the theoretical underpinnings of
motivational interviewing. As you know, MI did not evolve from a theory. It was drawn out of me. In a style
much like that which I would be writing about, my Bergen colleagues had me demonstrate what my clients
had taught me, and then helped me to unpack the unspoken assumptions and decision rules behind the
method so that it could be communicated to others. As I wrote the resulting descriptive article that was
published in 1983, I tried to ground the method to behavioral science findings and constructs, as well as a
few metaphors. (This was long before Jeff Allison's elegant dancing-versus-wrestling.) I drew on Festinger's
concept of cognitive dissonance, which eventually gave way to the broader and less baggage-encumbered
concept of discrepancy. I used what Hal Arkowitz had taught me about Daryl Bem's self-perception theory.
There was a natural fit with the then-new transtheoretical model of change, and with health belief models. I
even threw in a wacky electrical wiring diagram that with a little tweaking could now grow up to be a
structural equation model, complete with mediating and suppressor variables.
Since then I have been busy doing, developing, testing, and teaching MI, and haven't contributed any further
steps toward a theory to understand it. I may not even be the right person to wrest (or dance) a theory from
the data. I am getting curious, though. We seem to have a method that works with surprising consistency
across problem areas, contexts, therapists, and cultures. Two decades ago it would have been hard to
convince me that a single session of anything could reliably trigger a change in stubborn addictive
behaviors. Yet it seems to happen - not always, of course, but with enough statistical reliability to be
replicated by numerous investigators in reasonably small samples, with effect sizes averaging somewhere
around six tenths of a standard deviation. We seem to be able to show other therapists how to practice MI, so
that they can replicate its effectiveness. We're even training trainers!
Yet with all of that we do not have, in my view, a satisfactory explanation of why and how motivational
interviewing works. I've taken to asking MINTies how they explain it. Perhaps that's the nominal group
brainstorm topic with which we will start off MINT-7 this year. If we stick to our style, what we will do is
eventually elicit the theory from each other, and I hope that MINT -7 will be just such an opportunity. As a
small step forward, I offer the following findings, which I think, need to be accounted for and incorporated
into any theory of motivational interviewing.
1. MI seems to work. Behavior patterns that have been stuck for some time seem to get unstuck. How/where
was behavior "stuck" before MI (this is where Steve and I have speculated about ambivalence), and what
unsticks it?
2. It works in relatively small doses. There are numerous demonstrations of single session interventions (not
all of them explicitly MI) being a reliable catalyst for change. Whatever it is that happens, it doesn't take
much.
3. The effect is relatively large. It's enough to produce large effect sizes from a single session added to an
outpatient program or a 21-day inpatient program. In Project MATCH, MET held its own against two 12session outpatient treatment methods. Whatever is happening in MI, it seems to be enough to produce
change.
4. The efficacy of MI seems to be enhanced by (or at least is most evident in the presence of) negativity. If
anything, its relative advantage is with less ready, less motivated people. In MATCH, it worked better with
angry people. Client attributes often regarded to be markers of poor prognosis seem to be less serious
obstacles with MI.
5. It seems to work by reducing negativity. In Miller, Benefield and Tonigan (1993), we found that what
predicted change was not a high level of clients saying the right thing (though that did happen with MI), but
Page 18 of 21
rather a low level of client resistance. If the therapist behaved in a way that did not elicit resistance, change
followed. It is also noteworthy that client resistance was a relatively low frequency behavior; small numbers
of occurrences predicted a lack of change.
6. If Paul Amrhein's reported psycholinguistic findings in MIDAS hold up to replication, self-motivational
statements (SMS) do make a difference. What he is finding, and what may have eluded us before, is that it is
not the absolute level of SMS that predicts outcome, but rather the slope of commitment language during an
MI session. If commitment language (what we call SMS) is going up over the course of the session, the
client is likely to show behavior change. If the slope is flat or negative, the client is unlikely to change.
7. Therapists differ in their efficacy using MI. Even under intensive training and monitoring conditions in
Project MATCH, designed to minimize therapist differences, therapist effects on outcome persisted after
removing variance accounted for by sites, treatments, and client characteristics. MET was the one condition
where we could not account for such differences by eliminating outlier therapists.
8. Accurate empathy, defined as reflective listening, seems to be a strong predictor of therapist efficacy. I
am enthusiastic that in MISC we have a research tool with finer resolution, which may let us get closer to
identifying process determinants of change. Straying further from the data, I would add these intuitive
observations.
9. There is something about this Menschenbild, the underlying positive assumptions about human nature, the
living-as-if seeing of possibilities in the other. This may be harder to measure, but I believe that the efficacy
of MI has something to do with communicating - even taking for granted - hope, profound respect, esteem,
possibilities, faith in the person, freedom to change. "Other-efficacy," perhaps.
10. There is something about self-esteem. The literature doesn't show up self-esteem, as usually measured,
to be a strong determinant of outcomes, and perhaps it's because it involves interactions. In my original
wiring diagram, self-esteem has the potential to drain off motivational juice at the point where both
discrepancy (importance) and efficacy (confidence) are present. If I am doing myself in with my behavior,
and there is something I could do about it, I still might not take action if I think I'm not worth saving. Selfesteem in itself doesn't seem to drive change; it may even do the opposite in some circumstances. Yet I think
there are conditions under which it is the missing ingredient. Lacking self-esteem, our clients borrow our
esteem for them.
11. There is something about acceptance. The paradox that Rogers highlighted is that when one feels
unacceptable in one's present discrepant state, one cannot change. When one feels accepted or acceptable,
then it becomes possible to change. Against the reflexes of the heart, the motivational interviewer does not
insist or even believe that a client must change. I also agree with Rogers that this is a reciprocal process - not
that the client accepts the therapist (although I think it happens, and that Monty Roberts is onto something
here) - but that one's ability to extend such acceptance to others is related to and enhanced (or limited) by the
extent to which one experiences that same forgiving acceptance of self. The good news is that practicing one
seems to enhance the other. The very act of listening reflectively to another also changes the listener.
12. There is something about love. In America it is out of fashion for psychologists and researchers to talk
about love. We also mix up its multiple meanings. I have found particularly helpful a little C.S. Lewis book
called The Four Loves in which he distinguishes among four ancient Greek nouns, all of which are rendered
in English as "love." One (eros) is erotic, sexual love. One (storge) is attraction love, like my own love for
chocolate. One (philia) is familial, close-bond loving. All three of these are things that therapists are not
supposed to do with their clients. Then there is agape, a kind of selfless, other-directed, encompassing but
nonpossessive love, likened to God's love. Its sole interest is in the well-being and growth of the other.
There is a mystical sense of oneness with the other, as though at least for this moment we were not separate
beings.
Twelve. That's a good number, a good place to stop for now. You take it from here.
Page 19 of 21
Motivational Interviewing for Eating Disorders
Dr Janet Treasure, Dr Ulrike Schmidt and Gill Todd, Eating Disorder South London & Maudsley
NHS Trust
One of the consistent aspects of anorexia nervosa is the denial that there is any problem in the face of an
overt signal of disease i.e. starvation. This clash of perceptions frequently leads to confrontation and
coercion. It is possible that these factors contribute to the maintenance of his problem once it has begun.
(The average duration of illness is 6 years)
What do we know about the readiness to change in Anorexia Nervosa?
The transtheoretical model has been applied to patients with eating disorders (Ward et al 1996; Blake et al
1997, Stanton et al 1986). Less than 50% of patients with anorexia nervosa referred to a specialised eating
disorder clinic were in action; twenty percent were in precontemplation and thirty percent in contemplation
(Blake et al 1997). The majority of patients with anorexia nervosa on an inpatient unit were in
precontemplation or contemplation (Ward et al 1996). The decisional balance and the processes of change
showed similar stage matched profiles to those found in other conditions.
What do we know about readiness to change in bulimia nervosa?
Using the same measures many more of the patients with bulimia nervosa were in action. However, the
situation in bulimia nervosa is more complex and fluid because people want to stop their binges but they are
much less willing to change their weight control strategies (Blake et al 1997).
The use of motivational Interviewing for eating disorders
The ambivalence and overt negative reaction to treatment in anorexia nervosa means that it is a suitable case
for motivational interviewing treatment. There are some case reports (Treasure & Ward, 1997). Motivational
enhancement therapy for bulimia nervosa has been manualised (Schmidt & Treasure 1997) and is in the
process of evaluation (Treasure et al 1999). The concepts of a motivational approach for parents are
introduced in a Self/Career help guide for anorexia nervosa (Treasure 1997, Treasure -in progress). A
metaphor that we use to convey the spirit of motivational interviewing when we are introducing the concepts
to the parents is one of Aesop's fables. "The sun and the wind were having a dispute as to who was the most
powerful. They saw a man walking along and they challenged each other about which of them would be
most successful at getting the man to remove his coat. The wind started first and blew up a huge gale; the
coat flapped but the man only closed all his buttons and tightened up his belt. The sun tried next and shone
brightly making the man sweat. He proceeded to take off his coat."
Limitations and difficulties of motivational strategies for patients with eating disorders
We have successfully introduced a motivational style of approach to all our service setting, inpatient, day
patient and out patient in our National Health Service Unit in South London. Nevertheless, there are some
difficulties working with this patient group. The style of motivational interviewing sits most comfortably
when there is an equal balance of power between client and therapist. Children and adolescents find this
assumption somewhat alien and threatening. These patients often have very low self-esteem. They have
dismissive attachment styles and avoid revealing themselves to others. Adults are not seen as peers. In this
context the therapist may need to give more structure to the session. Commonly adolescents with anorexia
nervosa are wary and suspicious. During the information exchange process the person with anorexia nervosa
will form a judgement as to whether the therapist understands the problem. Thus the therapist needs to
subtly reveal his or her expertise Thus in the initial phase you needs to open up avenues of eating disorder
Page 20 of 21
specific problems to break the ice. One of the tenets of motivational interviewing is that the client is able to
choose whether he or she will decide to change. In the case of anorexia nervosa this freedom is limited. It is
physiologically impossible to choose not to eat for longer than 2-3 months. In most countries mental heath
legislation can override an individual's decision. It is still possible to work in a motivational way if these
limits are conceptualised as part of a higher power or authority, constraining the actions of both therapist and
patients. The therapist does not have to use confrontation or coercion directly but can be an indirect conduit
of society's rules.
Theoretical Considerations
Patents with anorexia nervosa have poor reflective functioning (a conceptual measure, which is thought to
represent metacognitive ability and is derived from the adult attachment interview). Motivational
interviewing may work by modelling this capacity by the therapist.
References
Blake W, Turnbull S & Treasure JL (1997) Stages and processes of change in eating disorders. Implications for therapy Clin
Psychol & Psychotherapy 4: 186-191
Schmidt UH & Treasure (1997) A clinicians guide to management of bulimia nervosa (Motivational Enhancement Therapy for
Bulimia Nervosa) Psychology Press Stanton AL Robert WM & Zinn LM 1986. Self change in bulimia : A preliminary study
International J Eating Disorders 5: 917-914
Treasure, J. (1997). Anorexia Nervosa. A Survival Guide for Sufferers and Those Caring for Someone with an Eating Disorder.
Psychology Press, Hove, Sussex. Treasure, J.L. (200?). Motivational enhancement therapy for Anorexia Nervosa. A companion
version to escaping from anorexia nervosa. Psychology Press. Hove, East Sussex.
Treasure, J.L. and Schmidt, U. (1997). A Clinician's Guide to Management of Bulimia Nervosa (Motivational Enhancement
Therapy for Bulimia Nervosa). Psychology Press, Hove, Sussex. Treasure, J.L. and Ward, A. (1997). A practical guide to the use
of motivational interviewing in anorexia nervosa. European Eating Disorders Review 5: 102-114
Ward A, Troop N, Todd G, Treasure JL (1996) To change or not to change-How is the question Brit J Med Psychol 69:139-146
Page 21 of 21