Minutes
Development Assessment Panel
Minutes of the meeting of the Development Assessment Panel
held in the Council Chamber, 172 Montacute Road, Rostrevor on
Wednesday 26 April 2017
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
26 April 2017
Chairperson:
Mr S Smith
Members Present:
Mr N Grigg
Mr J Kennedy
Ms A Leombruno
Mr D Starr
Mr P Johnson
Mr J Rutt
Council Staff Present:
Manager Planning Services
Planning Officer
Meeting Commenced: 6.30 pm
1.
Meeting Concluded: 10.01 pm
Apologies
Nil.
2.
Minutes
Mr Kennedy moved and Mr Johnson seconded that the minutes of the meeting of the
Development Assessment Panel held on Tuesday 21 March 2017 as printed and
circulated be taken as read and confirmed.
Carried
3.
Category 2
3.1
Development Number 170/0709/16
Applicant:
D'Andrea & Associates
Owner:
Ken Wong (WP Property Group)
Date Registered:
07/07/2016
Development Plan:
Consolidated - 28 April 2016
Subject Site:
48 & 50 Jervois Street, Magill
Existing Use:
2 detached dwellings and associated detached
outbuildings
Reference: 17/26527
Page 1
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
26 April 2017
Proposed Development:
To erect 3 double storey row dwellings and a
residential flat building comprising 4 double storey
dwellings (7 dwellings in total) with associated
landscaping and a common driveway.
Zone:
Residential - Regeneration Policy Area 3
Public Notification:
Category 2 - representation received from:






Qingguo Li and Wenhong Zhou of 52 Jervois
Avenue, Magill
Louise A Blackwell of 53 Jervois Avenue,
Magill
Brett W White and Pihui Kim of 52 Windsor
Avenue, Magill
Daniel Sorrel (owner of 50 Windsor Avenue,
Magill)
Roy L Jordan of 54 Windsor Avenue, Magill
Douglas J Rudd (owner of 59 Jervois Avenue,
Magill)
(Representors in bold wish to be heard by the Panel in
support of their representation.)
Assessing Officer:
Darren Adams
Recommendation:
The grant development plan consent
The following persons were heard and asked questions by the Development Assessment
Panel:

Louise A Blackwell of 53 Jervois Avenue, Magill
Mr Rutt moved and Mr Starr seconded that using the powers delegated to it, the
Development Assessment Panel grant Development Plan Consent to the application by
D'Andrea & Associates to erect 3 double storey row dwellings and a residential flat
building comprising 4 double storey dwellings (7 dwellings in total) with associated
landscaping and a common driveway at 48 and 50 Jervois Avenue, Magill subject to the
following conditions:
1.
That except where minor amendments may be required by other relevant Acts, or
by conditions imposed by this application, the development is to be established in
strict accordance with the endorsed stamped details and plans submitted in
Development Application number 170/0709/16 and all works shall be completed to
the reasonable satisfaction of Council prior to the occupation and/or use of the
development.
Reason:
Reference: 17/26527
To ensure that the development is conducted in accordance with the
approval.
Page 2
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
2.
All stormwater from the whole site is to be drained to the street watertable or
Council underground stormwater system including rear allotment drainage if
available. Discharge from the site shall be limited to a maximum of 3 litres/second
unless otherwise advised by Council Engineering staff.
Reason:
3.
To minimise overlooking of adjoining properties.
All planting and landscaping must be completed in the first planting season
concurrent with or following commencement of the use of this development and
must be maintained in good condition. Any plants which become diseased or die
must be replaced by suitable species.
Reason:
8.
To ensure useable and safe carparking.
All upper level windows of the dwellings (with the exception of the front windows of
dwellings 1-3 facing Jervois Avenue) will be fitted with manufactured obscure glass
to a minimum height of 1.7 metres above the upper floor level, such windows to be
permanently fixed shut other than by a wind out mechanism (opening to no greater
than 150mm) and hinged at the top or bottom of the window panel. The obscure
glass must be fitted prior to commencement of use of the dwellings and is to be
maintained at all times.
Reason:
7.
To ensure visitors to the site can access designated parking areas.
All driveways, parking and manoeuvring areas must be formed, sealed with textured
or patterned concrete or paving, and be properly drained. They must be maintained
in good condition thereafter.
Reason:
6.
To illuminate the common areas to make safe at night.
The driveway shall remain clear and unrestricted at all times to allow for visitors to
the site to access visitor parking areas. At no time shall a gate or other barrier be
installed across the driveway without the prior consent of the relevant authority.
Reason:
5.
To protect council's underground stormwater drainage system.
Low level energy efficient lighting is to be installed throughout the common areas as
per the approved plans and maintained in good condition at all times. The subject
lights shall be of a suitable luminance so as to not cause impacts to adjoining
properties by way of light overspill.
Reason:
4.
26 April 2017
To maintain amenity and site of locality.
The vehicular arrangements for the development shall be adjusted to avoid any
need to trim or remove the existing Jacaranda street tree adjacent to the subject
land and in particular the footpath crossover shall be located at least 2.0 metres
from that tree.
Reason:
Reference: 17/26527
To ensure safe and convenient access and protect Council's
infrastructure.
Page 3
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
9.
26 April 2017
Rubbish bins shall be removed from the bin storage location within the common
driveway area as soon as practicable after pick up, to the reasonable satisfaction of
Council.
Reason:
To maintain the amenity of the site and locality.
10. The applicant shall submit and receive an approval via a Section 221 form which
facilitates the removal of the two (2) street trees that conflict with the common driveway
and the driveway to proposed dwelling 3 prior to
development approval being
granted.
Reason:
To enable appropriate vehicular access to the site.
Carried
3.2
Development Number 170/1000/16
Applicant:
Anthony Donato Architects
Owner:
Arthur Street (SA) Pty Ltd
Date Registered:
21 September 2016
Development Plan:
Consolidated - 28 April 2016
Subject Site:
131 & 133 Arthur Street Magill
Existing Use:
Residential
Proposed Development:
To erect two double storey residential flat
buildings comprising a total of 10 dwellings with
common driveway and associated landscaping
Zone:
Residential - Regeneration Policy Area 3
Public Notification:
Category 2 - 2 representations received


Roger James of 122C Arthur Street Magill
Michael Bull of 124A Arthur Street Magill
Representors in bold wish to be heard by the
Panel
Assessing Officer:
Matthew O'Dwyer
Recommendation:
To grant Development Plan Consent
Subject Land Attributes
The following person was heard and asked questions by the Development Assessment
Panel:


Michael Bull of 124A Arthur Street Magill
Mr Anthony Donato (Applicant)
Reference: 17/26527
Page 4
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
26 April 2017
Mr Starr moved and Mr Johnson seconded that using the powers delegated to it, the
Development Assessment Panel grant Development Plan Consent to the application by
Anthony Donato Architects to erect two double storey residential flat buildings comprising
a total of 10 dwellings with common driveway and associated landscaping at 131-133
Arthur Street Magill subject to the following conditions:
1.
That except where minor amendments may be required by other relevant Acts, or
by conditions imposed by this application, the development is to be established in
strict accordance with the endorsed stamped details and plans submitted in
Development Application number 170/1000/16 and all works shall be completed to
the reasonable satisfaction of Council prior to the occupation and/or use of the
development.
Reason:
2.
To ensure that the development is built in accordance with the
approval
The control and disposal of all stormwater from the building(s) and the subject land
shall be to the reasonable satisfaction of the Council and all paving shall be
installed so as to drain to the street watertable in a manner to the reasonable
satisfaction of the Council.
For all rainfall events up to a 20 year storm (ARI) the rate of discharge of
stormwater from the land shall not exceed that for a 5 year storm and the drainage
system shall be designed to retain or detain the difference.
Reason:
3.
All upper level windows of the dwellings, with the exception of the windows facing
onto Arthur Street, must be fitted with manufactured obscure glass to a minimum
height of 1.8 metres above the upper floor level, such windows to be permanently
fixed shut other than by a wind out mechanism (opening to no greater than 150mm)
and hinged at the top or bottom of the window panel. The obscure glass must be
fitted prior to commencement of use of the dwellings.
Reason:
4.
To minimise overlooking of adjoining properties.
All planting and landscaping must be completed in the first planting season
concurrent with or following commencement of the use of this development and
must be maintained in good condition. Any plants which become diseased or die
must be replaced by suitable species.
Reason:
5.
To reduce the flow of stormwater off the subject land to a rate which
does not exceed the system’s capacity.
To maintain amenity of the site and locality.
The driveway shall remain clear and unrestricted at all times to allow for visitors to
the site to access visitor parking areas. At no time shall a gate or other barrier be
installed across the driveway without the prior consent of the relevant authority.
Reason:
Reference: 17/26527
To ensure visitors to the site can access designated parking areas.
Page 5
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
6.
All driveways, parking and maneuvering areas must be formed, sealed with
concrete, bitumen or paving, and be properly drained. They must be maintained in
good condition thereafter.
Reason:
7.
To maintain safety for users.
The shared driveway and on-site manoeuvring areas shall remain clear of any
impediments (such as meters, vegetation, parked vehicles).
Reason:
9.
To ensure useable and safe carparking.
All visitor carparking spaces must be linemarked, in accordance with the approved
plans and in accordance with Australian Standards AS 2890.1:2004, Off Street
carparking. The linemarking must be clearly visible at all times.
Reason:
8.
26 April 2017
To ensure safe and convenient vehicle access to the site.
Low level energy efficient lighting is to be installed throughout the common areas as
per the approved plans and maintained in good condition at all times. The subject
lights shall be of a suitable luminance so as to not cause impacts to adjoining
properties by way of light overspill.
Reason:
To illuminate the common areas to make safe at night.
10. An amended landscaping plan shall be provided to Council prior to full Development
Approval being granted showing amended mature species in the common driveway
areas to the reasonable satisfaction of Council.
Reason:
To enhance the amenity of the site and reduce the visual bulk and
scale of the dwellings.
Carried
3.3
Development Number 170/0024/17
Applicant:
Gavin Pinksterboer
Owner:
Gavin Pinksterboer
Date Registered:
10/01/2017
Development Plan:
Consolidated - 28 April 2016
Subject Site:
48 Darley Road, Paradise
Existing Use:
Residential
Proposed Development:
To erect a double storey residential flat building
containing two dwellings and a double storey
residential flat building containing four
dwellings (6 dwellings in total)
Reference: 17/26527
Page 6
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
26 April 2017
Zone:
Residential Zone Regeneration Policy Area 3
Public Notification:
Category 2 - 2 representations (bold to address
panel)


Paul Burnes of 52 Darley Road, Paradise
Prikshat Verma and Gurjeet Kaur of
46B Darley Road, Paradise
Assessing Officer:
Nick Legoe
Recommendation:
To grant development plan consent
The following person was heard and asked questions by the Development Assessment
Panel:

Prikshat Verma on behalf of himself and Gurjeet Kaur of 46B Darley Road, Paradise
Ms Leombruno moved and Mr Kennedy seconded that using the powers delegated to it,
the Development Assessment Panel deferred consideration of the application by Gavin
Pinksterboer to erect a double storey residential flat building containing two dwellings and
a double storey residential flat building containing four dwellings (6 dwellings in total) at
48 Darley Road, Paradise subject to enable the applicant to consider:





amended overshadowing diagrams which depict 3 dimensional objects and
structures on adjoining properties
amendments which increase the provision of POS associated with dwellings 1 and
2
amendments which increase the rear setback to 4 metres for dwellings 3 and 4
amendments to increase allotment sizes
amended plans which depict the storage of utilities such as bins, rainwater tanks
and clotheslines.
Carried
3.4
Development Number 170/1194/16
Applicant:
Lemonia Vavaroutsos
Owner:
Lemonia Vavaroutsos
Date Registered:
7/11/2016
Development Plan:
Consolidated - April 2016
Subject Site:
6 Alton Avenue, Magill
Existing Use:
Residential
Reference: 17/26527
Page 7
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
26 April 2017
Proposed Development:
To erect two double storey residential flat
buildings each containing 2 dwellings (4
dwellings in total) and divide land by Community
Title into 4 Allotments
Zone:
Residential Zone Regeneration Policy Area 3
Public Notification:
Category 2 - 7 representations (Bold to address
panel)







Belinda Clarke of 3 Altone Avenue, Magill
Kathleen Lewis of 7 Alton Avenue, Magill
Dean Francis of 5 Alton Avenue, Magill
Robert Noack of 9 Alton Avenue, Magill
Michael Nies, Laurel Gillan, Marcus Browne
of 8 Alton Avenue, Magill
Anestis Pouferas of 139 Arthur street, Magill
The resident of 9 Alton Avenue, Magill
Assessing Officer:
Nick Legoe
Recommendation:
To grant development plan consent
The following persons were heard and asked questions by the Development Assessment
Panel:




Ian Rice on behalf of Kathleen Lewis and Dean Francis of 5 and 7 Alton Avenue,
Magill
Robert Noack of 9 Alton Avenue, Magill
Michael Nies on behalf of himself, Laurel Gillan, Marcus Browne of 8 Alton Avenue,
Magill
Marcus Rolfe of URPS on behalf of the applicant.
Ms Leombruno moved and Mr Starr seconded that using the powers delegated to it, the
Development Assessment Panel deferred consideration of the application by Lemonia
Vavaroutsos to erect two double storey residential flat buildings each containing 2
dwellings (4 dwellings in total) and divide land by Community Title into 4 Allotments at 6
Alton Avenue, Magill to enable the applicant to consider:




amended plans which increase the rear setback to dwellings 3 and 4
amended plans which increase the provision of onsite car parking
amended plans which better demonstrate privacy to the private open space areas
forward of dwellings 1 and 2 (ie alternate fencing details)
amended streetscape elevations which depict the proposed development alongside
existing dwellings.
Carried
Reference: 17/26527
Page 8
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
3.5
26 April 2017
Development Number 170/1341/16
Applicant:
Onassis Developments
Owner:
Onassis Projects Pty Ltd
Date Registered:
08/12/2016
Development Plan:
Consolidated - April 2016
Subject Site:
7 New Cut Street Hectorville
Existing Use:
Residential
Proposed Development:
To erect a two storey residential flat building
containing two dwellings and a two storey
residential flat building containing three
dwellings (five dwellings in total)
Zone:
Residential Zone Regeneration Policy Area 3
Public Notification:
Category 2 - 2 representations received (bold to
address panel)


Shane Berketa of 33 North Street
Hectorville
Susie Pansini of 35 North Street Hectorville
Assessing Officer:
Nick Legoe
Recommendation:
To grant development plan consent
The following person was heard and asked questions by the Development Assessment
Panel:


Tony Pansini spoke on behalf of Susie Pansini of 35 North Street Hectorville
Matthew Faulkner on behalf of the applicant.
Mr Rutt moved and Mr Johnson seconded that using the powers delegated to it, the
Development Assessment Panel grant Development Plan Consent to the application by
Onassis Developments to erect To erect a two storey residential flat building containing
two dwellings and a two storey residential flat building containing three dwellings (five
dwellings in total) at 7 New Cut Street, Hectorville subject to the following conditions:
1.
That except where minor amendments may be required by other relevant Acts, or
by conditions imposed by this application, the development is to be established in
strict accordance with the endorsed stamped details and plans submitted in
Development Application number 170/1341/16 and all works shall be completed to
the reasonable satisfaction of Council prior to the occupation and/or use of the
development.
Reason:
Reference: 17/26527
To ensure that the development is conducted in accordance with the
approval
Page 9
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
2.
All stormwater from the whole site is to be drained to the street watertable or
Council underground stormwater system including rear allotment drainage if
available. Discharge from the site shall be limited to a maximum of 3 litres/second
unless otherwise advised by Council Engineering staff.
Reason:
3.
To minimise overlooking of adjoining properties.
All planting and landscaping must be completed within 3 months of the buildings
being occupied and must be maintained in good condition. Any plants which
become diseased or die must be replaced by suitable species.
Reason:
8.
To ensure useable and safe carparking.
All upper level windows of the dwellings (with the exception of the front windows of
dwellings 1 facing New Cut Street) will be fitted with manufactured obscure glass to
a minimum height of 1.7 metres above the upper floor level, such windows to be
permanently fixed shut other than by a wind out mechanism (opening to no greater
than 150mm) and hinged at the top or bottom of the window panel. The obscure
glass must be fitted prior to commencement of use of the dwellings and is to be
maintained at all times.
Reason:
7.
To ensure visitors to the site can access designated parking areas.
All driveways, parking and manoeuvring areas must be formed, sealed with textured
or patterned concrete or paving, and be properly drained. They must be maintained
in good condition thereafter.
Reason:
6.
To illuminate the common areas to make safe at night.
The driveway shall remain clear and unrestricted at all times to allow for visitors to
the site to access visitor parking areas. At no time shall a gate or other barrier be
installed across the driveway without the prior consent of the relevant authority.
Reason:
5.
To protect council's underground stormwater drainage system.
Low level energy efficient lighting is to be installed throughout the common areas
and maintained in good condition at all times. The subject lights shall be of a
suitable luminance so as to not cause impacts to adjoining properties by way of light
overspill.
Reason:
4.
26 April 2017
To maintain amenity and site of locality.
The recessed landscaping area parallel to the front fence of dwelling 1 and facing
the street shall be extended the entire length of the front fence, to the reasonable
satisfaction of the Council.
Reason:
To maintain amenity and site of locality.
Carried
Reference: 17/26527
Page 10
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
3.6
26 April 2017
Development Number 170/1361/16
Applicant:
Ferrone Architects
Owner:
Freecity Pty Ltd
Date Registered:
13/12/2016
Development Plan:
Consolidated - April 2016
Subject Site:
31 & 31A Cresdee Road, Campbelltown
Existing Use:
Residential
Proposed Development:
To erect two double storey residential flat
buildings each containing four dwellings (8
dwellings in total)
Zone:
Residential Zone Regeneration Policy Area 3
Public Notification:
Category 2 - 1 representation (bold to address
panel)

Peter Crescitelli of 28B Wyn Street,
Campbelltown
Assessing Officer:
Nick Legoe
Recommendation:
To Grant Development Plan Consent
The following person was heard and asked questions by the Development Assessment
Panel:

Don Ferrone (applicant)
Mr Grigg moved and Mr Johnson seconded that using the powers delegated to it, the
Development Assessment Panel grant Development Plan Consent to the application by
Ferrone Architects to erect two double storey residential flat buildings each containing
four dwellings (8 dwellings in total) at 31 and 31A Cresdee Road, Campbelltown subject
to the following conditions:
1.
That except where minor amendments may be required by other relevant Acts, or
by conditions imposed by this application, the development is to be established in
strict accordance with the endorsed stamped details and plans submitted in
Development Application number 170/1361/16 and all works shall be completed to
the reasonable satisfaction of Council prior to the occupation and/or use of the
development.
Reason:
Reference: 17/26527
To ensure that the development is conducted in accordance with the
approval
Page 11
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
2.
All stormwater from the whole site is to be drained to the street watertable or
Council underground stormwater system including rear allotment drainage if
available. Discharge from the site shall be limited to a maximum of 3 litres/second
unless otherwise advised by Council Engineering staff.
Reason:
3.
To minimise overlooking of adjoining properties.
All planting and landscaping must be completed in the first planting season
concurrent with or following commencement of the use of this development and
must be maintained in good condition. Any plants which become diseased or die
must be replaced by suitable species.
Reason:
8.
To ensure useable and safe carparking.
The western elevation upper level windows of the dwellings 1-4, the eastern
elevation upper level windows of dwelling 5-8 and the northern elevation upper level
windows of dwellings 4 and 5 will be fitted with manufactured obscure glass to a
minimum height of 1.7 metres above the upper floor level, such windows to be
permanently fixed shut other than by a wind out mechanism (opening to no greater
than 150mm) and hinged at the top or bottom of the window panel. The obscure
glass must be fitted prior to commencement of use of the dwellings and is to be
maintained at all times.
Reason:
7.
To ensure visitors to the site can access designated parking areas.
All driveways, parking and manoeuvring areas must be formed, sealed with textured
or patterned concrete or paving, and be properly drained. They must be maintained
in good condition thereafter.
Reason:
6.
To illuminate the common areas to make safe at night.
The driveway shall remain clear and unrestricted at all times to allow for visitors to
the site to access visitor parking areas. At no time shall a gate or other barrier be
installed across the driveway without the prior consent of the relevant authority.
Reason:
5.
To protect council's underground stormwater drainage system.
Low level energy efficient lighting is to be installed throughout the common areas
and maintained in good condition at all times. The subject lights shall be of a
suitable luminance so as to not cause impacts to adjoining properties by way of light
overspill.
Reason:
4.
26 April 2017
To maintain amenity and site of locality.
The timber privacy screening as approved on dwellings 3-6, shall be of a suitable
density to prevent overlooking and established prior to commencement of the use of
the dwellings, and be maintained thereafter at all times to the Council's reasonable
satisfaction.
Reason:
To minimise overlooking of adjoining properties.
Carried
Reference: 17/26527
Page 12
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
3.7
26 April 2017
Development Number 170/1364/16
Applicant:
D'Andrea & Associates
Owner:
Iconic Property Ventures Pty Ltd
Date Registered:
13/12/2016
Development Plan:
Consolidated - April 2016
Subject Site:
47 Acacia Avenue North, Campbelltown
Existing Use:
Vacant Land
Proposed Development:
To erect a two storey residential flat building
containing 2 dwelling and a two storey
residential flat building containing 3 dwellings
(5 dwellings in total) (LOT 53 - Future 47 Acacia
Avenue North)
Zone:
Residential Zone Regeneration Zone 3
Public Notification:
Category 2 - 1 representation received (bold to
address panel)

The property owner of 33 Lennox Street
Campbelltown
Assessing Officer:
Nick Legoe
Recommendation:
To grant development plan consent
Mr Rutt moved and Mr Johnson seconded that using the powers delegated to it, the
Development Assessment Panel grant Development Plan Consent to the application by
D'Andrea and Associates to erect a two storey residential flat building containing 2
dwellings and a two storey residential flat building containing 3 dwellings (5 dwellings in
total)at 47 Acacia Avenue North subject to the following conditions:
1.
That except where minor amendments may be required by other relevant Acts, or
by conditions imposed by this application, the development is to be established in
strict accordance with the endorsed stamped details and plans submitted in
Development Application number 170/1364/16 and all works shall be completed to
the reasonable satisfaction of Council prior to the occupation and/or use of the
development.
Reason:
2.
To ensure that the development is conducted in accordance with the
approval
All stormwater from the whole site is to be drained to the street watertable or
Council underground stormwater system including rear allotment drainage if
available. Discharge from the site shall be limited to a maximum of 3 litres/second
unless otherwise advised by Council Engineering staff.
Reason:
Reference: 17/26527
To protect council's underground stormwater drainage system.
Page 13
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
3.
Low level energy efficient lighting is to be installed throughout the common areas
and maintained in good condition at all times. The subject lights shall be of a
suitable luminance so as to not cause impacts to adjoining properties by way of light
overspill.
Reason:
4.
To ensure useable and safe car parking.
All upper level windows of the dwellings (with the exception of the front windows of
dwellings 1 and 2 facing Acacia Avenue North) will be fitted with manufactured
obscure glass to a minimum height of 1.7 metres above the upper floor level, such
windows to be permanently fixed shut other than by a wind out mechanism (opening
to no greater than 150mm) and hinged at the top or bottom of the window panel.
The obscure glass must be fitted prior to commencement of use of the dwellings
and is to be maintained at all times.
Reason:
7.
To ensure visitors to the site can access designated parking areas.
All driveways, parking and maneuvering areas must be formed, sealed with textured
or patterned concrete or paving, and be properly drained. They must be maintained
in good condition thereafter.
Reason:
6.
To illuminate the common areas to make safe at night.
The driveway shall remain clear and unrestricted at all times to allow for visitors to
the site to access visitor parking areas. At no time shall a gate or other barrier be
installed across the driveway without the prior consent of the relevant authority.
Reason:
5.
26 April 2017
To minimise overlooking of adjoining properties.
All planting and landscaping must be completed in the first planting season
concurrent with or following commencement of the use of this development and
must be maintained in good condition. Any plants which become diseased or die
must be replaced by suitable species.
Reason:
To maintain amenity and site of locality.
Carried
4.
Category 1
4.1
Development Number 170/1252/16
Applicant:
Russo Design & Construction
Owner:
Ilario Dichiera & Angela Patricia Dichiera
Date Registered:
17/11/2016
Development Plan:
Consolidated - 28 April 2016
Reference: 17/26527
Page 14
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
26 April 2017
Subject Site:
30 Sparks Terrace Rostrevor
Existing Use:
Residential
Proposed
Development:
To remove a significant (River Red gum, Eucalyptus
camaldulensis) tree in the rear yard
Zone:
Residential Zone – Suburban Policy Area 4
Public Notification:
Category 1
Assessing Officer:
Amelia Thiele
Recommendation:
To refuse development plan consent
Mr Rutt moved and Mr Johnson seconded that using the powers delegated to it, the
Development Assessment Panel Refuse Development Plan Consent and Development
Approval to the application by Russo Design & Construction to remove a significant River
Red Gum tree, Eucalyptus camaldulensis at 30 Sparks Terrace, Rostrevor as the
application fails to satisfy Council Wide General Section Significant Trees Objective 1, 2
and Principles 1 and 3 more specifically, the subject tree:

significantly contributes to the character and visual amenity of the local area

forms a notable visual element in the local area

Is not diseased and does not have a short life expectancy.

does not represent an unacceptable risk to private open space or private safety and
if pruning is undertaken it would further reduce the risk associated as outlined in the
arborist report by Sam Cassar

Is not shown to be causing or threatening to cause substantial damage to a
substantial building or structure of value.

all other reasonable remedial treatments and measures have not been determined
to be ineffective and

it has not been demonstrated that all reasonable alternative development options
and design solutions have been considered to prevent substantial tree-damaging
activity occurring.
Carried
5.
Policy Issues
Container Reference: B730
The Policy Issues were carried by consensus.
Reference: 17/26527
Page 15
Minutes - Development Assessment Panel
6.
26 April 2017
Dwelling Approval Report
Container Reference: B730
The Dwelling Approval Report was carried by consensus.
Certified a true record
............................................. CHAIRPERSON
Taken as read and confirmed this
day of
............................................. CHAIRPERSON
Reference: 17/26527
Page 16