Financing Startup and Early-Stage Companies in the Kansas City Region: June 2015 WE CREATE CAPITAL WHERE WILL KANSAS CITY FIND JOBS? Kansas City has a proud tradition of economic and entrepreneurial success, spanning several generations. The community, however, has been slow to replace jobs lost during the recent Great Recession. PERCENT CHANGE IN EMPLOYMENT Kansas City has one of the lowest percentages of employment growth since November 2013 when compared to the 12 peer metropolitan areas typically used to benchmark our region. November 2013 - November 2014 4 3 3.2 2.9 2.8 2.7 2.7 2.6 2.5 2.3 2 2.2 2.1 1.3 1 1 0.4 a Omah City Kansa s is St. Lo u -St. P aul Minne apolis nati Cincin apolis Indian ukee Milwa mento Sacra le Nashv il r Denve ma Cit y Oklah o Charlo t te 0 Austin 1 Research by the Kauffman Foundation shows that of the 12 million new U.S. jobs added in 2007 alone, young firms (up to age five) were responsible for creating nearly 8 million of those jobs. Fully leveraging and sustaining the emerging entrepreneurial movement is critical to increasing job growth in Kansas City. WE CREATE CAPITAL The Kansas City region can increase regional growth rates, job creation and wealth creation by increasing access to capital for growth-oriented startup and early-stage businesses. FUNDING BY THE NUMBERS THE COMMUNITY NEEDS TO: 1 build capacity in organizations that can provide capital, 2 encourage the formation of new microloan programs, angel investor groups, seed capital funds and venture capital funds and To accomplish these strategies, regional investors, community leaders, corporations, nonprofit organizations, entrepreneurs, educators and public policymakers need to work collaboratively to set objectives. 3 build capacity in existing nonprofit organizations that provide assistance to entrepreneurs seeking capital. WHAT WILL IT TAKE TO FUEL THE FIRE FOR EARLY-STAGE COMPANIES? + WE NEED more experience and connectivity to take advantage of tens of millions of dollars in both federal and private funding that could be supporting our businesses. + WE NEED to take a step today, or our tomorrow will look the same. + WE NEED to make that step impactful. $10,000 typical startup capital for small businesses $80,000 typical startup capital for high-tech companies, with financing usually coming from a combination of debt and equity 51% of funding for small businesses comes from loans 7% of funding financed by credit cards 4% of funding comes from angel or venture capital $0 amount of startup capital for about one-third of new non-employer and 12% of employer startups Source: U.S. Small Business Administration This report outlines specific steps that can drive early-stage funding for Kansas City’s future. > + WE NEED TO DO IT TOGETHER. 2 WE CREATE CAPITAL LOANS WHAT’S THE GAP? Businesses that can’t qualify for bank loans can build credit through credit-building loans, access alternative loan funds or take advantage of SBA loan guarantees. Moving businesses along this path sets them up to be “bankable,” where they can be good bank customers and build their businesses. BUILDING A CONTINUUM FOR s en cy Us Im e pro Cr v ed e it S co re Im pro Cr v ed e it S co re Ide a D an e d S ve tar lop tup me nt Ac ce ler ati on Ea rly an O d E pe xp rati an on sio s On n g o & E in xp g O an pe sio rat n ion erg BANKABLE Bank Loans BANKABLE with guarantees SBA Bank Loan Guarantees Lower risk <5M UNBANKABLE Community Advantage High risk <50-250K Microloans High risk <50K High risk <2500 High risk <1000 A cohesive infrastructure for loans less than $250,000 for non-bankable entities did not exist in Kansas City in 2009. A partnership between many organizations has been working diligently to build solutions. Kansas City’s largest microloan program is the KC Regional Microloan Fund operated by Justine PETERSEN in partnership with OneKC for Women, the KCMO CDE, the city of Kansas City, MO KC BizCare and other partners including a number of financial institutions. KC REGIONAL MICROLOAN PROGRAM EARLY-STAGE LOAN INFRASTRUCTURE Em 3 Credit-Building Loans Secured Credit Cards Personal Emergency Loans BY THE NUMBERS 2012 $3 million Launched in in lending 262 loans with an average loan size of $11,000 59% to women 45% to minorities Approximately 800 jobs Default rate less than 3% This highly successful microloan program benefits less than 2% of the microenterprises in Kansas City. High risk <500 ? Bankable companies have the collateral, track record and/or cash flow to qualify for conventional bank small business financing. “Non-bankable” companies typically need access to alternative loans or bank guarantees. as their primary mission. While many CDFIs serve as community development banks, they can offer microenterprise funds which provide small amounts of business capital to small scale entrepreneurs. Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFI) are private-sector financial intermediaries with community development The Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) of 1977 is intended to encourage depository institutions to help meet the credit needs of the communities in which they operate, including low- and moderate-income neighborhoods. Lending institutions can receive favorable CRA consideration for investments in a pool that would be used to make microloans to promote economic development in a regional area that includes the institution’s assessment area. WE CREATE CAPITAL Increase the availability of alternative loans to $10 million by 2020. n The Kansas City Regional Microloan Fund has demonstrated the value of microloans to support “unbankable” companies. n Underutilized federal programs through the SBA and U.S. Treasury could rapidly introduce more alternative loan funding to Kansas City. n Kansas City needs to build microloan servicing experience to qualify for additional federal funds. n OneKC for Women and KCMO CDE have agreed to pursue needed federal certification. Next Increase Kansas City Regional Microloan Establish a $5 million SBA-backed microloan Use CDFI funds to create $2 million loan pool NOW $3M $5M + NOW $0M $5M + NOW $0M $2M + Maximize use of revolving loan funds NOW $?M Explore U.S. Treasury New Market Tax Credit options $3M + NOW $0M TOTAL $3M $2M $10 TO $17M WHAT’S IT GOING TO TAKE? INCREASE LOAN CAPITAL INCREASE ACCESS TO LOANS + ally CRA funding to support early-stage loan funding R mechanisms and programs. + Convene an ad hoc committee to review existing alternative loan funds for activity and available funds. + dd additional capacity and support fundraising for an A initial microloan pool for OneKC for Women to achieve the experience necessary to garner the $5 million SBA-backed microloan program. + Increase community support for programs that provide entrepreneurial and business development training to develop a pipeline of borrowers for the various loan products offered by traditional and non-traditional lenders. + ssist OneKC for Women and KCMO CDE in applying for A and achieving CDFI certification, accessing funds for loan pools and expanding capacity to administer loans and provide technical assistance. + Create a strong marketing program that raises awareness of existing loan products and services to appropriate audiences. + + onvene an ad hoc group to explore U.S. Treasury New C Market Tax Credits (NTMC) and work with existing CDEs to promote NMTC Program to businesses and support additional allocation requests to the region. Develop a “train the trainer” module to educate service providers and entrepreneurs in the Kansas City region about available alternative loan programs and application procedures to get alternative loans. + FURTHER STUDY: Convene an ad hoc committee to review small business lending practices by banks and identify hurdles banks face in deploying more capital in the community. 4 5 WE CREATE CAPITAL GRANTS Business plan competitions, reward-based crowdfunding and other contests have given rise to grant funds that often move concepts to a point where they can be validated in the market. Digital Sandbox KC was established in 2013 to provide support for proof-ofconcept projects. LaunchKC grants of $50,000 each will become available in 2015 to attract companies to Kansas City, Missouri. Additionally, federal agencies with extramural research and development budgets that exceed $100 million are required to set aside annually a portion of that funding to the Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) and Small Business Technology Transfer (STTR) programs. These programs provide some of the very few federal grants available for small companies. SBIR and STTR programs can assist very earlystage and established companies. WHAT’S THE GAP? Originally launched through a federal grant from the U.S. Department of Commerce Economic Development Administration, Digital Sandbox KC provides about $20,000 per company in proof-of-concept resources for market validation, prototyping and beta testing of digital technologies within new and existing businesses. In addition to this support, Digital Sandbox links companies to a variety of resources to help with business development and follow-on funding. KS/MO SBIR GRANTS AWARDS, 5-YEAR AVERAGE DIGITAL SANDBOX KC 2010-2014 BY THE NUMBERS Launched in 226 total applicants 46 proof-of-concept projects $8,000,000 6.1M $6,000,000 funded for area startups 23 new KC-based companies created $4,000,000 $2,000,000 2013 2.1M 33 companies have secured 3.5M 3.4M follow-on investment $17.7 million in follow-on funding 0 HE OT Nearly R R HE OT S SA I UR SO IS N KA M KC S UI RO ET O .L ST M 181 new jobs created Missouri and Kansas generally do not take full advantage of SBIR funding. Missouri ranks 28 and Kansas 39 in the number of SBIR grants received since 1982. The Kansas City metro region also lags behind other Missouri and Kansas regions in total dollars. From 2010-2014, Kansas City was awarded $10,890,619 in SBIR grants, averaging slightly more than $2 million per year. The St. Louis region garnered almost three times that amount at $30,692,854. Even the regions outside the two major metros outperformed the KC area. $5.5 million in total salaries Digital Sandbox KC was able to fund only 20.4% of applications. WE CREATE CAPITAL Increase local, state and federal grant funding to early-stage and R&D focused businesses in the Kansas City region to $6 million by 2020. Next n Fledgling companies need community support to be positioned for later funding and success. It is critical that we fill the pipeline at the early stage. n Few private investors provide capital at this stage. n Digital Sandbox KC has been very successful, but is one of the few sources of capital for this stage. Raise awareness of Small Business Innovation Research grants Maintain Digital Sandbox KC funding at current levels Support investment in emerging grant programs NOW $2M $5M + NOW $600K $600K + NOW $0K TOTAL $2.6M $400K $6M We need more experience and connectedness... WHAT’S IT GOING TO TAKE? INCREASE GRANT CAPITAL + upport public and private investment in emerging and S existing grant programs. + M onitor, assess and apply for all state and federal resources that add additional funding pools to the region. Examples include Regional Innovation Strategies grants from the U.S. Department of Commerce Economic Development Administration. + B etter position the community to access public funding, especially state and federal innovation grants, by creating a pool of matching funds that can be rapidly allocated to special projects. ...so that we can take advantage of tens of millions of dollars in federal funding that could be supporting our businesses. INCREASE ACCESS TO GRANTS + reate and implement a strong awareness campaign for C SBIR and STTR grants that drives people to existing SBIR/ STTR training seminars. + D evelop a “train the trainer” module to educate entrepreneurs and resource partners in the Kansas City region about available grant programs and how to apply for and win grants. 6 WE CREATE CAPITAL EQUITY CAPITAL BUILDING A CONTINUUM FOR SERIES A Expansion Maturity + IPO, Acquisition RE VE NU E SEED EARLY-STAGE VENTURE CAPITAL INFRASTRUCTURE MEZZANINE SERIES B Equity investment in emerging companies usually comes in stages. Defining these stages is somewhat arbitrary, and they can differ based on industry type and individual company characteristics. The chart below shows the typical types of investors found at each stage as a company goes from inception to profitability. SERIES C Young companies with large market potential often turn to equity investors for capital. Investors provide capital to these startup and early-stage businesses, generally in exchange for convertible debt or ownership equity. Investors seek companies developing differentiated products that address large global markets, offer an exceptional exit potential in a reasonable period of time and promise high return on the invested capital. PRESEED 7 Rapid Growth + Banks Gestation + Inception + + BREAK EVEN Roll Out Prototype Venture Capital Firms & Corporate Investors Angel Financing Founders, Friends & Family For purposes of this report, investments with series not stated directly were categorized by deal size as shown. WE CREATE CAPITAL The Kansas City region garnered $668,310,000 in equity investments from 2009–2014. Compared to other peer cities, Kansas City ranked only 11. Source: CB Insights TOTAL EQUITY INVESTMENTS PER METRO (IN THOUSANDS) 2009-2014 Denver $9,029,190 Austin $4,908,720 Raleigh $3,194,740 Portland $3,117,490 Minneapolis $2,524,000 Indianapolis $1,484,070 Nashville $1,386,540 Pittsburgh $1,375,130 St. Louis $1,077,250 Charlotte $943,130 Kansas City $668,310 Milwaukee $411,100 San Antonio $310,430 Louisville $309,280 Columbus $252,487 $0 $2,000,000 $4,000,000 $6,000,000 $8,000,000 $10,000,000 NUMBER OF DEALS BY SERIES, BY YEAR 2009-2014 How many equity deals does Kansas City have? 100 The number of deals in the Kansas City region has increased since 2009. IPOs included QTS Realty, AMC Theatres and Aratana Therapeutics. Proteon Therapeutics, Inc., founded in Kansas City, completed an IPO in 2014 but by then had moved its headquarters to Massachusetts. The increase in the preseed funds in 2013-2014 is due to the entrance of accelerators in the community and the establishment of the Digital Sandbox KC proof-ofconcept center. 75 50 25 0 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014* n Preseed n Seed (<$1M) n Series A ($1-3M) n Series B ($3-7.5M) n Series C ($7.5-10M) n Mezzanine ($10-20M) n IPO *2014 data is underreported due to delays in reporting. 8 9 WE CREATE CAPITAL SEED CAPITAL Plotting the location of companies that received funding in 2014 shows many of the companies receiving seed investment are located on the Kansas side of the state line. Kansas has traditionally had a strong seed capital system. The combination of Kansas Technology Enterprise Corporation (KTEC), the Kansas Bioscience Authority (KBA) and the Kansas Capital Multiplier Venture Fund 2014 FUNDED COMPANIES Seed and Series A through NetWork Kansas, coupled with Kansas Angel Tax Credits, provided support to many early-stage businesses. WHAT’S THE GAP? KTEC was dissolved in 2011, and as of January 2015, KBA is no longer funding seed rounds and Kansas angel tax credits are scheduled to sunset in 2016. In Missouri, seed funding is currently available through the Missouri Technology Corporation’s IDEA Fund TechLaunch and Seed Capital CoInvestment programs. Most of MTC funding goes to companies outside of the Kansas City area. The Kansas City region has two strong angel groups, MidAmerica Angels and Women’s Capital Connection. Started in 2006 and 2008 respectively, these groups are composed of approximately 140 angels and have averaged $1.7 million in investment each year. Value of Investment in Kansas City Region Companies by Missouri Technology Corporation 435 In 2014, 47 companies used $6.1 million in Kansas angel tax credits. Thirty-six of those companies were in the Kansas City metro area. There is a strong correlation between companies receiving angel tax credits and receiving funding from MidAmerica Angels and Women’s Capital Connection. 5,000,000 435 3,750,000 2,500,000 1,250,000 0 MTC FY13 n KC Region Kansas MTC FY14 n Outside KC Missouri ? Seed Investments help take a company from proof of concept to market, build a user base and begin scaling. Investment ranges from $250,000 to $1 million. Angel investors are high net worth individuals who provide capital to high growth potential startup and early-stage businesses, usually in exchange for equity or convertible debt. Angels generally invest their own money, often making investments in the range of $5,000 to $100,000. Super Angels are experienced investors with greater means than angels that either invest their own capital or invest larger amounts cooperatively with other like-minded individuals. They often fill the $250,000-$1 million funding gap. . WE CREATE CAPITAL 10 Increase seed capital investments to more than $10 million per year by 2020. Next n We are losing sources of seed capital in the region. n Policy makers will be important in helping to fill this gap. n Angel tax credits work. Companies with access have been successful in securing funding. n Missouri Technology Corporation funds are underutilized. Double number of angel investors; double investment Establish a new $5 million seed capital fund Establish a new “super angel” investor group Increase investment in local accelerators Increase access to MTC, NetWork Kansas and KBA funds NOW $1.7M $5M + NOW $0M $5M + NOW $0M $1M + NOW $180K $500K + NOW $1M TOTAL $2.9M $2M $10 TO $13.5M WHAT’S IT GOING TO TAKE? INCREASE SEED CAPITAL INCREASE ACCESS TO SEED CAPITAL + ork with emerging and existing angel capital groups to W increase membership. + C onduct networking events that increase the interconnectedness and contributions of local investors. + xtend the angel investor tax credit program in Kansas at E the current funding level; establish an angel investor tax credit program in Missouri. + + Add capacity to organizations that support angel groups. + C onvene an ad hoc group of attorneys, investors and resource partners to provide insight on angel investment terms and obstacles to closing angel investment deals in the region and educate the community on angel investment deal structures. rge ultra high net worth individuals to come together as a U super angel network with a visible gatekeeper. + D evelop a “train the trainer” module to educate investors, service providers and entrepreneurs in the Kansas City region about angel investing and how to seek and obtain angel investments. + everage the qualified early-stage evaluation teams at local L organizations to vet deals. + oalesce early-stage investors into a new $5 million seed C fund to be located at an existing organization. + aintain and increase seed stage investment funds that exist M at the Missouri Technology Corporation, Kansas Bioscience Authority and NetWork Kansas. 11 WE CREATE CAPITAL VENTURE CAPITAL In Kansas City during the past five years, most preseed investments for which investors were reported came from the Kansas City area. Nebraska shows up prominently in the early rounds, as do other Midwestern cities. East and West Coast investment sources are more prevalent in later rounds. A variety of efforts have attempted to bring more local, later-stage dollars to area startups to help keep companies in our region. For example, Kansas Bioscience Authority (KBA) in 2009 established a “fund-of-funds” program that made limited partner investments in venture capital funds located outside the region in exchange for a pledge to establish a regional office. This encouraged several firms to establish regional offices. However, this program was ended and most offices have closed. Recently Flyover Capital, a new venture capital firm, closed a $43 million fund that seeks to make investments of $500,000 to $3,000,000 and is an important step in addressing this regional funding gap. To be competitive, the region needs additional funds of this size or larger headquartered in the region. WHAT’S THE GAP? The Kansas City region is far below national and regional peer regions in venture capital (VC) investment. This lack of capital can lead to the relocation of promising young companies to other regions. NUMBER OF INVESTORS IN KC COMPANIES By Location of Investors, 2009-2014 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 KC AREA MO/KS NEBRASKA OUTSIDE REGION n Preseed n Seed (<$1M) n Series A ($1-3M) n Series B ($3-7.5M) n Series C ($7.5-10M) n Mezzanine ($10-20M) ? Venture Capital Firms comprise “general partners” who invest funds provided by other “limited partner” investors. Examples of limited partners include pension funds, insurance companies, foundations and ultra high net worth individuals. Venture capitalists generally make larger investments than angels, usually from $1 million to $10 million. Discussions with investors indicate that additional venture capital may be forthcoming if more assistance with due diligence were available from others with experience in selecting, managing and reporting on investments. Additional early-stage capital could be developed if experienced managers could be identified and agree to take on the management of additional funds. WE CREATE CAPITAL 12 Double the number of venture capital investments of $1 million-$10 million in the Kansas City region by 2020. Next n Corporate, foundation and individual investors need to understand investing at this level to coalesce around Flyover Capital and a new fund. n Experienced fund management will be needed for a new fund. n Underutilized federal programs through the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA) could provide growth capital. n Kansas City needs an experienced investment firm to take advantage of SBA funding. n Flyover Capital is currently building an investment portfolio and provides opportunity for developing needed experience for federal funding. Increase investment in Flyover Capital I and add Flyover Capital II Establish a new $50 million venture capital investment fund Maintain offices for at least two venture capital firms headquartered outside of region NOW $43M $80M + NOW $0M $50M + NOW $20M $0M + Position to apply for matching U.S. SBA SBIC Early Stage License NOW $0M TOTAL $43M $50M $180 TO $200M WHAT’S IT GOING TO TAKE? INCREASE VENTURE CAPITAL + oalesce individual, corporate and foundation investors into C Flyover Capital and a new fund of $50 million with trusted due diligence. + romote entrepreneurs and regional deals to regional, P national and international venture capital firms to drive investment in the Kansas City region resulting in increased capital access and the presence of a regional office for a fund headquartered outside of Kansas City. + upport round two of Flyover Capital or other fund to S position the community with the necessary experience to apply for SBIC Early Stage License funding. + Increase the amount of capital available for regional investment by Kansas Bioscience Authority, NetWork Kansas and Missouri Technology Corporation. Increase the success of regional companies in accessing these statewide capital sources. INCREASE ACCESS TO VENTURE CAPITAL + Convene an ad hoc group of attorneys, investors, entrepreneurs and resource partners to provide insight on venture capital investment terms and obstacles to closing venture capital deals in the region and educate the community on venture capital deal structures. 13 WE CREATE CAPITAL INCREASE ACCESS TO EXISTING CAPITAL WHAT ELSE IS IT GOING TO TAKE? The reach of an entrepreneur’s social network in Kansas City is an important asset when raising funds as many connections are made through trusted referrals. A well-connected community can improve the success of both the entrepreneur in accessing funds and the investor in finding the right deals. In the Kansas City region, market fragmentation makes it difficult for entrepreneurs to identify and access appropriate funding sources. According to research by Ted Zollar, professor at the University of North Carolina and Kauffman Foundation Fellow, Kansas City’s entrepreneurial nodes are not as connected as in more established entrepreneurial hubs in the country. In Kansas City, entrepreneurs are not connected to investors and investors are not connected to other investors. In this inefficient market, pathways to equity investments pass through a set of gatekeepers. These individuals and organizations have knowledge of who invests at what stage, what types of opportunities certain investors look for and how a company needs to prepare for the “pitch.” Ways to improve the efficiency of this market include better connecting investors to enhance deal sharing, encouraging more seed investors to join angel groups and investing in accelerators. Education for both entrepreneurs and investors can increase the understanding of the types of deals certain investors prefer and their desired stage of investment. The formation of additional angel investor groups, seed funds and venture capital funds that are publicly “open for business” could increase the amount of capital available. WHAT CAN WE DO? + ncourage regional investors to “put out their shingle” and publicize investment E approaches, portfolios and investment levels. + valuate the use of technology to make deals more visible to individual investors E and entrepreneurs in the region providing better visibility of who is being funded by whom to larger audience. + Create a systematic deal-tracking method to validate the yearly level of investments. + repare a comprehensive set of resource materials on raising capital in the P Kansas City region and make it available to entrepreneurs, investors and support organizations. Promulgate best practices on deal structure and terms. + ork with existing organizations that provide specialized education programs that W support access to capital and increase referrals to those programs through a strong awareness campaign. WE CREATE CAPITAL 14 W e need to take a step today or our tomorrow will look the same. — MATT CONDON, CEO and Founder ARC Physical Therapy+ and Bardavon Health Innovations LLC & Champion of the Greater Kansas City Chamber’s Big 5 Entrepreneurship Initiative Next Increase the availability of alternative loans NOW $3M $10 to $17M + Increase local, state and federal grant funding to early-stage and R&D-focused businesses NOW $2.6M $6M + Increase seed capital investments NOW $2.9M Double the number of venture capital investments of $1 million-$10 million $10 to 13.5M + NOW $43M $180 to $200M This report was developed through a collaborative effort of the KCSourceLink network over 12 months. Many people contributed data and feedback. We thank them all. The data included is incomplete — we continue to find new information daily. For the complete report and references, please go to wecreatekc.com. with support from “This Report was Prepared under an Award from the US. Department of Commerce Economic Development Administration” “This publication was prepared by the University of Missouri-Kansas City Innovation Center. The statements, findings, conclusions, and recommendations are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Economic Development Administration.” June 2015 Download the full report at wecreatekc.com
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz