NEWSPAPER LOGO Children in an Agrarian Age A I B Tools Match the letters next to the drawing of each tool with its name below. What do you think these tools were used for? Four-finger “Bow” cradle C Scythe Drill TABLE OF CONTENTS Children in an Agrarian Age 2-3 Apprentices 4 Cabin Boys 5 Mill Girls 6 Canal Boys 7 Upon their Bended Backs 8 Child Stars 9 When Childhood Became a Cause 10 The Orphan Trains 11 Shedding Light on Child Labor 12-13 The Child Labor Debate 14-15 Free the Children 16 As you study Children Who Built America, read the newspaper each day and clip and collect in a folder all news articles, opinion columns and advertisements that relate to children. Teachers! To order the newspaper for your classroom, copies of the Children Who Built America student supplement, or for more information about the supplement and accompanying Teacher's Guide, contact (insert name and contact info here) t’s a beautiful afternoon in the summer of 1745. You’re sweeping the porch of your family home in Saratoga, N.Y., when suddenly your old broom’s binding breaks and it falls apart, scattering straw everywhere. When you drop the broom handle to gather up the straw, the old wood snaps in two. You need a new broom, but where will you get it? There are no shopping malls or supermarkets in preindustrial America, so you’re going to have to make that A woman sweeps snow off her front steps in a 1909 photo. Before the 1800’s, brooms were all homemade, using tree branches wound together with twine. A broommaking machine was invented in 1810. When All Work Was Homework From colonial times until the early 1800’s, children worked growing crops, producing goods, and doing whatever else was necessary to help their families survive. In preindustrial America, families made or grew almost everything that they used or consumed. If your house needed fixing, you used your own tools and did your own repairs. If you needed a new shirt, you made one by hand. Child labor wasn’t thought of as a problem: It was expected that everyone in the family would contribute. Boys in rural areas In this family-based worked as farm hands economic system, child and were kept particularly care, schooling and job busy at harvest time. training were handled by friends, relatives and the community. In fact, one of the reasons people had children was to have help around the house and farm. Churches and the government supported this system. Preachers warned, “The devil makes work for idle hands,” and some of the colonies had laws mandating that children work. It is said that understanding the past helps people to better understand the present. Some things stay the same and some things change. Make a Venn diagram that compares the lives of children on colonial farms and the lives of children in America today. Read the newspaper every day for a week and clip and save all articles relating to the lives of 2 broom yourself. You’ll need to find the wood and strip, sand and polish it, and then collect the thatch and bind it onto the handle you’ve made. And you do, without giving any of it a second thought. What would you do today if your broom fell apart? What’s different about the world today that makes this possible? NEWSPAPER LOGO In this rural-agrarian time, there were few public schools. By working at home or in a neighbor’s home, children learned the skills they would need as adults. Older children watched the younger ones, but even young children were expected to perform simple chores, and they mastered specialized tasks as they grew older. Girls learned the skills needed to run a home and keep a family fed and clothed. Boys were taught to work with farm, construction or trade tools, and were trained to take over their father’s business or trade. A difficult job for girls working at home was churning butter. Slightly soured cream was put in the churn and girls would have to turn the plunger, sometimes for hours, until the cream turned to butter. children in the United States and abroad. At the end of the week, create a Venn diagram that compares the lives of two children featured in the articles you’ve collected. NOTE: The Teacher Guide has a reproducible Activity Worksheet with an explanation of VENN diagrams. “Bound Out” I f a family was poor, they might hire out their children to reduce their household expenses and bring in extra income. Conversely, if a couple were childless, they might take in other people’s children to work for them, housing them, feeding them, and possibly giving them instruction in a skill or craft. Many poor and orphaned children were legally “bound out” to work for and live with other families. These children and orphans provided services in exchange for room and board, an arrangement communities liked because they didn’t have to pay to support indigent children. However, this system wasn’t a good one for all the children involved: Some “bound out” children were treated like slaves. Asa Sheldon Asa Sheldon was a successful farmer and teamster (someone who transports goods). In his autobiography, what he remembered most about growing up on a farm in Massachusetts was work. Like most American Before pipes boys at the turn and pumps, water had to be of the 19th century, Asa was carried to wherever it was expected to help support his needed. family. As his family was poor, he was “bound out” to live with and work for another family. Asa’s wages were part cash, and part cow. Sheldon wrote: “On April 14th, 1797, being still in my ninth year, Mr. Daniel Parker came to my father’s house to get a boy to live with him. … I commenced my servitude here without time or remuneration This illustration of an apple orchard at harvest time looks idyllic, but very often the children performing this kind of manual labor were poor and were “bound out” to other families: In return for food and a bed, “bound out” children worked in other people’s homes or on their farms, sometimes for as much as 10 years. (1788 – 1870) being stated, which … is a circumstance liable to produce difficulty. … Mrs. Parker told me to call her ‘mother’. … She fed me when hungry; dried my clothes when wet; cared for my every want; and when troubles assailed that she could not alleviate, pitied and sympathized with me. … “The second year, in hoeing time, I was able to keep up with the hands, unless the ground was very tough. … My father needing a cow, he agreed with Mr. Parker to take one for $22, and I was to work for him another year … to pay for her. … “Mr. Parker … was unwilling to let me slide on the ice, because it wore my shoes out; but thanks to mother Parker’s adroit management, I found frequent opportunities to enjoy an hour of glee on the ponds. … “At the commencement of my third year, Mr. Parker frequently urged that I should be bound to him, telling my father that he would give him $20 in cash, and me on becoming twenty-one. To this my father agreed, and the necessary documents were signed without mother’s knowledge.” Noah Blake’s Diary (1805) Eric Sloane’s “Diary of an Early American Boy: Noah Blake 1805” (New York: NY, W. Funk, 1962) incorporates the diary that 15-yearold Noah Blake wrote in 1805. Sloane later used the original woodbacked, leather bound diary as a guide for building a small cabin, as he imagined Blake’s cabin to be, next to The Sloan-Stanley Museum in Kent, Conn., which houses his collection of early American tools. Eric Sloane (1905-1985) painted the murals at the National Air and Space Museum. new bridge beams are seasoned and ready. When the waters subside, he shall begin to erect it. We are shaping up the abutments.” “A P R I L 1 0 - 1 1 : Worked on the bridge abutments.” “A P R I L 1 2 : Good Friday. It rained all day.” Blake wrote: “A P R I L 1 - 6 : Robert Adams came by in his Father’s sleigh to take me to the Adams place. I shall help them for the week with maple sugaring.” “A P R I L 7 : Palm Sunday … returned home with Mother and Father. I earned a tub of sweetening [maple sugar] for my week’s work. It is good to be home again.” “A P R I L 8 : … seasonable weather for Spring business has arrived. I finished the winter’s lot of nailmaking and put the forge to rights.” “A P R I L 9 : Flooding all but washed our bridge away. Father says the NEWSPAPER LOGO Historians piece together the puzzles of history by studying various types of primary source documents, including written materials, images and artifacts. This supplement offers a selection of excerpts from rare primary source documents that together tell the history of child labor in America. As you read this supplement, study the images for artifacts that you might not find in other time periods. Think about how each artifact was made, and then discuss what that tells us about the technology of the time. Select three artifacts described in words or pictures in today’s newspaper to include in a time capsule. Write a paragraph to go with each artifact, explaining what these items will tell future historians about today’s technology. 3 Apprentices B y the early 1800’s, American families and communities were able to produce not only enough goods to survive, but also surplus goods, which could be sold or bartered for other goods. For the first time in American history, it started to make economic sense for boys to leave the farm to work in town as apprentices to master tradesmen such as coppersmiths or printers. Instead of following in their fathers’ footsteps as farmers, these boys were breaking with tradition by learning skills they could never have learned at home. Printer’s Devils Boys usually began their apprenticeships between the ages of 10 and 14. Working conditions under a master craftsman, prosperous farmer or sea captain could be quite different from those on the family farm. Apprentices and bound-out children often worked under restrictive, longterm contracts. If they were unhappy in their situation, mistreated or abused, they had no recourse but to run away, which was illegal, and hope to find work someplace else. After the Revolutionary War, Americans took great pride in American-made goods. No American-made product was more commonplace or highly valued than the printed word. Every town had a print shop that produced books, newspapers, handbills and business forms. And every print shop had its “devil,” an apprentice whose job included cleaning the ink-covered type and printing press. Because their hands and faces were always inkstained, these kids were nicknamed “printer’s devils.” Many famous Americans started out as printer’s devils, among them Benjamin Franklin. starting for the wide West in quest of a future home; so, not needing at (1811 – 1872) the moment my services, Born on a hardscrabble he readily acceded to my farm in New Hampshire, wishes. I walked over to Horace Greeley became a Poultney, saw the printer’s devil at age 15. It Ben Franklin dreamed of going to sea. His older brother, Josiah, went to sea and drowned. publishers, came to an proved to be the start of a When Ben expressed a desire to head to sea, his father found him a safe, land-based job understanding with great career. At age 30, he them, and returned; and as a printer’s devil. founded The New York a few days afterward— Tribune, which became the most widely read newspaper in America. April 18, 1826—my father took me down, and verbally agreed with them The following is excerpted from “Recollections of a Busy Life.” for my services. I was to remain till twenty years of age, be allowed my board only for six months, and thereafter $40 per annum in addition for my clothing.” Horace Greeley Greely wrote: “Having loved and devoured newspapers … from childhood, I early resolved to be a printer if I could. When but eleven years old, hearing that an apprentice was wanted in the newspaper office at Whitehall [Vermont], I accompanied my father to that office, and tried hard to find favor in the printer’s eyes; but he promptly and properly rejected me as too young, and would not relent; so I went home downcast and sorrowful. No new opportunity was presented till the Spring of 1826, when an apprentice was advertised for by the publishers of The Northern Spectator, at East Poultney, Vt. … The village, though larger and more active then than now, was not adequate to the support of a newspaper; but the citizens thought otherwise, and resolved to maintain one, under the management of committee … there was room for a new apprentice, and I wanted the place. My father was about Adolph S. Ochs (1858 – 1935) of The New York Times Ochs started in the newspaper business at age 11. He got his start at a newspaper in Cincinnati, sweeping floors and running errands for 25 cents a day to support his family. A quick learner, he soon became a skillful printer’s devil. At age 20, Ochs became a part-owner of the Chattanooga Times in Tennessee, which he turned into one of the most respected and profitable papers in the region. At 38, Ochs purchased The New York Times. He believed that a newspaper should be “clean, dignified, and trustworthy,” and he adopted the motto “All the news that’s fit to print” for The Times. (It still appears every day at the top of the front page.) Historians learn about the past from clues found in primary source documents such as Horace Greeley’s autobiography. Read the excerpt and underline all clues that tell you when and where this story took place. Then select a news article from the newspaper and underline the clues that 4 NEWSPAPER LOGO tell you when and where the news event being reported took place. NOTE: The Teacher’s Guide expands on this activity with additional practice exercises analyzing primary source documents. Cabin Boys B oys might also leave the farm for a life at sea. The great cities of the colonies — Boston, New York, Philadelphia and Charleston, S.C. — were all ports, and 9 out of 10 settlers in the 13 colonies lived within 50 miles of the ocean. The way history is presented often depends on who tells the story. Select one of the stories on these pages and identify the different people connected to the story, both those telling the story and those in the story. Retell the incident from the point of view of one of the other people. Find an article in the newspaper about child labor today. Identify the different people or groups of people involved in the news event being reported. Rewrite the article as a memoir from the point of view of one of the people in the article. From Melville’s book, “Redburn”: “As I was standing looking round me, the chief mate approached in a great hurry about something, and seeing me NOTE: The Teacher’s Guide provides a reproducible Activity Worksheet for in his way, cried out ‘Ashore with you, this activity. you young loafer! There’s no stealing here; sail Cabin boy was the away, I tell entry-level job for you, with young men 12-to-16 that shooting (1819 –1891) years of age who jacket!’ Herman Melville, author of “Moby dreamed of going to “Upon this Dick; or, The Whale” (1851) and other sea and becoming I retreated, novels of the seafaring life, wrote ship’s saying that I captains. from personal Some were was going experience. out in the sons, sons “Redburn” of friends, ship as a (1849), based or nephews sailor. on his time as a of the “‘A sailor!’ cabin boy on a captains. he cried. ‘A whaling ship, Their life at barber’s was the first sea was as clerk, you American book a privileged mean; you to deal with the At the beginning of the 19th century, America’s roads were terrible: apprentice going out in dust-choked ruts in the summer and virtually impassable in the challenges of a to the the ship? winter. The trip from Boston to New York, a distance of 250 miles, boy becoming ship’s What, in that might take a week or more by coach, but with good winds, a sailing a man. officers. Other cabin jacket? Hang ship could make it in under two days. boys came from poor families who couldn’t me, I hope pig-pen in the long-boat; it has not been cleaned out since last voyage. afford to keep them at the old man hasn’t been shipping any And bear a hand about it, d’ye hear; there’s them pigs there waiting to be home. Still other boys more greenhorns like you — he’ll make might have had a judge a shipwreck of it if he has. But this is the way put in; come, be off about it, now.’ suggest they go to sea nowadays; to save a few “Was this then the beginning of my sea-career? Set to cleaning out when they ran afoul of a pig-pen, the very first thing?” dollars in seamen’s wages, the law. These boys they think nothing of got the dirty jobs, like shipping a parcel of cleaning the pigsties farmers and clodhoppers and chicken coops, and baby-boys. What’s your and life under a cruel Life was often name, Pillgarlic?’ captain or with an harsh for cabin unkind crew could be “‘Redburn,’ said I. boys, who very hard indeed. ‘A pretty handle to a man, worked as that; scorch you to take servants for the hold of it; haven’t you got any other?’ captain and ‘Wellingborough,’ said I. everyone else on “‘Worse yet. Who had the baptizing of ye? Why board. Beatings didn’t they call you Jack, or Jill, or something were common short and handy? But I’ll baptize you over again. and there was D’ye hear, sir, henceforth your name is Buttons. seldom any time off. And now do you go, Buttons, and clean out that Herman Melville NEWSPAPER LOGO 5 Mill Girls F rom the mid-18th through the early 20th century, technological innovations (like the cotton gin and the steam engine) occurred at such a rapid rate that this period is often referred to as “the Industrial Revolution” or “the Industrial Age.” Many products that had been made at home by hand could now be produced in factories by machines. As the Industrial Revolution advanced, children — some as young as age five — tended these machines in increasing numbers, especially in the textile industry. Long viewed as assets in a primarily agricultural economy, children were now seen as factory workers for an industrialized society. Mill Girls Young children started working in 16 and 25. Harriet was only 10 when she began working at one of the textile mills in the early 19th century factories as a “doffer”: removing the when mill owners hired entire families full bobbins from the spinning frames who worked and lived at mill sites. The and replacing them with empty ones. job of “factory girl” was considered a While she and the other young girls lowly occupation. However, the textile working as doffers might work for only mill in Lowell, Mass., was different. In 15 minutes of every hour, they still had Lowell, company owners offered young to be on the job for the full 14-hour day. women top wages to work in their The Lowell experiment was shortfactories, and built lived. The company owners cut wages, boarding houses for and then cut them again. In 1836, when them to live in. In an age Harriet was only 11, she joined with in which women had Lewis Wickes Hine’s photographs helped change child-labor laws. other Lowell mill girls and walked off virtually no economic A Hine photo from 1910 shows Addie Laird, who was somewhere the job in protest — one of the first rights or status in between 10- and 12-years-old at the time, working as a spinner in labor actions in American history. The society, the Lowell a cotton mill in North Pownal, Vt. This photo was later reproduced mills found replacement workers and on a stamp to commemorate child-labor reform. mills offered them the strike was broken. Within the next respectable few years, boatloads of Irish employment, a decent income, and educational, cultural immigrants began arriving in New York, followed by immigrants from southern and eastern Europe. These immigrants provided America’s and social opportunities. In exchange, they gave the textile industry with masses of women and children who would work for mills 14 hours of work a day, 73 less money and under the worst working conditions. hours a week. The first group of women Robinson wrote of the strike of 1836: working at “My own recollection of this first strike (or ‘turn out’ as it was called) Lowell learned … is very vivid … When the day came on which the girls were to turn new skills, formed the (1825-1911) out, those in the upper rooms started first, and so many of them left that first-ever Women’s Club and Harriet Robinson came to Lowell our mill was at once shut down. Then, when the girls in my room stood produced a literary magazine when her mother moved there to irresolute, uncertain what to do … and not one of them having the called the “Lowell Offering.” run one of the boarding houses. courage to lead off, I … became impatient, and started on ahead, saying, Published between 1840 and According to Harriet, in the early with childish bravado, ‘I don’t care what you do, I am going to turn out, 1849, the magazine was written days of Lowell Mills, the working whether any one else does or not;’ and I marched out, and was followed by mill girls, or as Harriet girls were mostly between the ages of by the others. …” Robinson called Harriet Hanson Robinson them, “poets of the loom, spinners of verse, artists of factory life.” 6 While expanding options for young women, the Industrial Revolution also created problems for them. Create a chart that compares the life of a girl working in a textile mill with that of a girl working on a farm. Search current issues of the newspaper for stories that feature women. Create a chart that NEWSPAPER LOGO compares women’s roles today with women’s roles in the early years of the Industrial Revolution. Write an essay explaining what has changed and what has stayed the same. NOTE: The Teacher’s Guide provides an Activity Worksheet for this project. .L St aw eR nc re ive r Canal Boys Oswego anal Whitehall Oswego Canal Erie Canal Tonawanda Buffalo Utica Syracuse Erie C anal Waterford Schenectady Troy Albany e Eri Montour Falls Montour Falls ive r Watkins Hudson R e Lak Cayuga-Seneca Canal C Cha lain mp Lake Ontario T he Erie Canal’s completion in 1825 changed America forever. Connecting New York and the Hudson River with the Great Lakes, the Canal opened lands west of the Allegheny Mountains for settlement, significantly lowered the shipping cost of goods and established New York’s harbor as the center of American commerce. One of the jobs of a canal boy was to drive the mules that pulled the 100-ton canal boats. They would walk along the towpath and also help open and close the lock gates. Canal Lingo Poughkeepsie Muleskinner: Mule driver Towpath: Path where mules walk when pulling boats Whiffletree: Bar that linked mules with the boats New York Flying light: Boat traveling empty Hoggee: Young boy mule driver Hoodledasher: Train of boats with empty boats tied to full boats Mud-larked: A boat stuck in mud Snubbing post: Post for tying up boats. The Life of a Canal Boy Canal boys drove Others overworked the boys, beat them and and cared for the denied them food and mules that towed even medicine — canal boats, often trying to force them walking 20 miles a day. A canal boy’s typical to run away so the captain did not have workday began to pay them. around three in the Search the Help Most families lived morning and ended Wanted ads in the on their boat all year. about 10 at night. newspaper for jobs that There were two Boating season lasted would and would not from April to types of canal boys: a have existed in the early November. During son of the boat-owner 1800’s. Study how Help the winter, hundreds and a “bound-out” Wanted ads are written. Rewrite the Mule Driver of canal boats were child from a poor job posting as a modern family that could not tied together, Help Wanted ad. afford to keep him. forming floating communities in Mothers on boats major harbors like New York’s. minded the young children, cooked, Children labored on canals cleaned and — when needed — until the last canal was closed steered the boat and led the mule. Fathers were usually the captains. in 1932. Without their help, “Bound-out” boys drove the mules canals would not have been the mass transit system that for captains who didn’t have helped America become an children. Many captains treated industrial giant. these kids well and paid them fairly. This is a reproduction of what an old ad for a mule driver might have looked like. NEWSPAPER LOGO 7 Upon Their Bended Backs I help on plantations because n the South, slave most of the men were away children contributed to fighting, with many the American economy returning home wounded. before the Civil War by Slave children began working on the working at about the age plantations that of five, looking after provided cotton for small animals in the textile mills such as farmyard and helping those in Lowell. Many with small jobs in the of these children had fields. Around been separated their master’s from their homes they families or were carried firewood, orphans. polished brass Slave children doorknobs, born on Some children worked in the fields, while others were sent to scrubbed plantations the master’s house to attend floors, and were forced to the family. fanned and to work for bathed their masters. Many most of their lives, and, of children of slave owners had course, without pay. During the Civil War, children were their own child-slave to dress and attend to them. needed more than ever to Booker T. Washington Henry Bibb (1815 – 1854) (1856–1915) Washington, born a slave, grew up to become one of America’s foremost black educators and leaders. In his autobiography, Washington said, “From the time that I can remember anything, almost every day of my life has been occupied in some kind of labor.” He wrote: Henry Bibb was one of a handful of escaped slaves who wrote an autobiography. As a child, Bibb lived on a Tennessee plantation and worked as a servant to the plantation owner’s daughter. He wrote: “During the period that I spent in slavery I was not large enough to be of much service, still I was occupied most of the time in cleaning the yards, carrying water to men in the fields, or going to the mill to which I used to take the corn, once a week, to be ground. … This work I always dreaded. The heavy bag of corn would be thrown across the back of the horse, and the corn divided about evenly on each side; but in some way … the corn would shift as to become unbalanced and would fall off the horse, and I would fall with it. As I was not strong enough to reload the corn upon the horse, I would have to wait, sometimes for many hours, till a chance passer-by came along who would help me out of my trouble. The hours while waiting for someone were usually spent in crying. The time consumed in this “She was too lazy to scratch her own head and would often make me scratch and comb it for her. She would at times lie on the bed, in warm weather, and make me fan her while she slept, scratch and rub her feet, but after a while she got sick of me and preferred a maiden servant to do such business.” way made me late in reaching the mill, and by the time I got my corn ground and reached home it would be far into the night. The road was a lonely one, and … I was always frightened. The woods were said to be full of soldiers who had deserted from the army, and I had been told that the first thing a deserter did to a Negro boy when he found him alone was to cut off his ears. Besides, when I was late in getting home I knew I would always get a severe scolding or a flogging.” History books often overlook the experiences of children in general. As for slave children, their experiences are largely unrecorded due to the fact that most never learned to read or write. Find an article in a current issue of the newspaper reporting on an event that will have an impact on the lives of children. List the points of view of the children 8 NEWSPAPER LOGO affected. Using facts in the article, write a first-person account of the news event from the point of view of a child. NOTE: The Teacher’s Guide provides a reproducible Activity Worksheet for this activity. Child Stars T he second half of the 19th century witnessed enormous change in the American theater. As cities grew larger and Americans had more leisure time, many of them turned to the theater for entertainment. Some performances, however, were more informal: Dancing, singing and playing instruments (usually home-made) on city street corners, young performers put on their own shows, and then “passed the hat.” While entertainment was not a very lucrative occupation for most child performers, two had great success. These excerpts from their obituaries tell the stories of the fortunes they amassed as child stars of their day. The obituaries of child stars on this page and the autobiographies of slave children on the previous page provide facts and opinions about the very different experiences of a number of children in the 19th century. Underline the facts and circle the opinions in the passages you’ve just read. Discuss the value each provides to an understanding of American history. Find entertainment reviews and ads in the newspaper featuring young movie, theater and TV stars. Underline the facts and circle the opinions. Select one star and write a newspaper-style obituary for that star reflecting on his or her career. What would the obituary you’ve written tell people in the future about life in presentday America? NOTE: The Teacher’s Guide provides a reproducible Activity Worksheet for this project. Lotta Crabtree Cordelia Howard (1847-1924) (1848-1941) From her obituary: From her obituary: “[Cordelia’s father, George C.] Howard presented the play, [‘Uncle Tom’s Cabin’] for eight years in this country and abroad and retired to Cambridge with a fortune. Mrs. MacDonald [Cordelia’s married name] continued the role of Little Eva for those eight years, and retired from the stage with her family when they came to Cambridge to live. She was then 12 years old. … “She had always, since her retirement from the role she created, remained a keen student of everything that transpired in connection with Uncle Tom. … Many times since her retirement she had declared her preference for obscurity, but so universal was the appeal of Harriet Beecher Stowe’s old play that any one connected with its production could hardly achieve anonymity. “For decades demands had been made on Mrs. MacDonald to give her presence to this and to that version of the epic, but on each occasion she gently, but firmly refused her petitioners. “‘I’m afraid I couldn’t have much to contribute to the stage,’ she would smilingly protest. ‘I have never had a desire to return to the theatre except as a member of the audience.’” “Starred as ‘Lotta,’ Charlotte Mignon Crabtree sang, danced and played herself into the hearts of the theatergoers of a generation ago all over the United States, and in 1891 retired, at the height of her success, with a fortune estimated at more than $2,000,000. “Over the bookshop which her father, John Ashworth Crabtree, kept in Broadway, New York, the little comedienne was born Nov. 7, 1847. The bookseller was one of those who followed the gold rush to California, taking his family with him, and it was on the Pacific Coast that Lotta scored her first childish triumphs. She made her debut as an actress when only 6 years old at Petaluma, Calif., when she played Gertrude in: ‘The Loan of a Lover.’ “At the head of her own company, at the age of 7, ‘La Petite Lotta’ played one-night stands throughout the mining region and in those days scored her biggest night at a rough Nevada camp where, after a rather hostile reception, she finally so won the hearts of the miners that they pitched bags of gold dust and nuggets at her feet.” NEWSPAPER LOGO 9 When Childhood Became a Cause F rom the 1840’s through the 1880’s, waves of immigrants poured into America’s Atlantic Coast cities. As they struggled to get settled in their new country, some families abandoned their children, either because they didn’t have enough money to support them or could not supervise them because of the long hours they worked. The Children’s From the “Life of the Street Rats” Children’s Champion: Charles Loring Brace (1826-1938) A Methodist minister, Charles Loring Brace saw the problems the Industrial Revolution inflicted upon children in the slums of New York City. During the Industrial Revolution, children played an important role in America’s economy, but they faced serious problems as a result. Factories were often located in slum buildings, cellars or attics. Hours were long, pay was low, and working conditions were dangerous and often unhealthy. Because of the way children (and many adults) were exploited, these factories became known as “sweatshops.” Many factories hired children because they could Aid Society was established in New York in 1853 to help these children. The Society estimated that more than 30,000 children lived on New York City streets in 1855. These abandoned children — known as “urchins,” “street Arabs” or “street rats” — sold newspapers, sewed clothes, collected rags and worked in sweatshops to survive. perform some types of detail work better than adults. In addition, they could be paid lower wages than adults, were more easily intimidated than adults, and were difficult for unions to organize. In 1853, Brace helped establish the Children’s Aid Society. Today, the Children’s Aid Society helps more than 100,000 New York City children and their families every year with health, education and counseling programs, along with summer camps, job training, and adoption and foster-care services. “Seventeen years ago, my attention had been called to the extraordinarily degraded condition of the children in a district lying on the west side of the city. … A Certain block, called, ‘Misery Row’ … was the main seed-bed of crime and poverty in the quarter … Here the poor obtained wretched rooms at a comparatively low rent … The parents were invariably given to hard drinking, and the children were sent out to beg or to steal. Besides them, other children, History is a sequence of events. By understanding what happened in the past, it may be possible to avoid repeating the problems of the past. Using the information in this guide, create a timeline that shows the sequence of events that led to the formation of the Children’s Aid Society. Then, from your collection of newspaper reports on 10 NEWSPAPER LOGO who were orphans, or who had run away from drunkards’ homes, or had been discharged on the docks nearby, drifted into the quarter, as if attracted by the atmosphere of crime and laziness that prevailed in the neighborhood … They were mere children, and kept life together by all sorts of street-jobs— helping the brewery laborers, blackening boots, sweeping sidewalks, and the like.” child labor today, select one country you’ve read about. Place the working children of that country along the timeline of the evolution of an economy from agrarian to industrial. NOTE: The Teacher’s Guide expands this activity into a writing assignment. The Orphan Trains T he Children’s process at the next Aid Society town. Caring families used “Orphan took in some of the Trains” to rescue children. Other homeless kids who children were treated worked in sweatshops like slave laborers. in the big cities of the Between 1853 and East Coast. Society 1929 the Orphan agents gathered Trains carried as Some records say homeless children many as 200,000 kids that William H. and put them on west for adoption. Bonney, better trains bound for the The goal was to mold known as Billy West. Agents traveled the Kid, rode an the youngsters into orphan train. ahead of the trains, productive adults visiting towns along through hard work, the route and advertising clean living and moral that children were available family life. It worked for for adoption. When an Andrew Burke and John Orphan Train pulled into a Brady, who later became the station, the children were governors of North Dakota questioned and examined to and Alaska. It did not see if they would make good work for the outlaw Billy farm hands or shop clerks. the Kid, who, according Strong, attractive, healthy to some accounts, also kids usually found homes. rode an orphan The others returned to the train. train and repeated the Betty Lou Wade (née Gladys Marie King*) Remembers: “An old man and woman had their arms around the shoulders of my brother and sister. ‘We’ll take these two,’ they said. ‘What about my little sister?’ my big sister asked them. ‘She’s too little to milk a cow,’ the old man replied. Then they were all gone. … “I was three years old with no one. Then the tall, dark, nicelooking man who had made the remark about me at the train station stepped up to me and said, ‘Do you want to be my little girl?’ “That’s all I remember about that episode, but I do remember living in the hotel, having a nursemaid to take care of me and getting anything and everything I wanted, for the man was the manager of the hotel, and he and his wife had never had any children. “I was brought around to reality a couple of times a year by being taken out to the farm to visit my By the middle of brother and sister the 19th century, for the weekend in it was estimated Petit, Kentucky, a that as many as few miles from 30,000 children Owensboro. They lived on the were only a few streets of years older than I New York. was, but they had to do many chores. They chopped tobacco, killed tobacco worms, milked 24 cows, and did chores around the house, barn and garden. I can remember trying to help them, but I only seemed to get in the way.” *Betty Lou Wade’s adoptive parents changed her name to Gladys Marie King. From the streets of New York City, children were sent west on Orphan Trains to find new families. NEWSPAPER LOGO 11 Shedding Light on Child Labor A round the turn of the 20th century, attitudes toward child labor began to change. The National Child Labor Committee, the women’s suffrage movement, labor unions, the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (N.A.A.C.P.) and other social reform groups worked to get children off the streets and into settlement houses. They also tried to reduce the demand for child workers by arguing that children should not be viewed as simply economic assets: They are children, and should be going to school while they’re children, to get the education they will need as adults and citizens. These advocates pioneered techniques of mass Jacob Riis political action we (1849-1914) are familiar with With his 1890 book, today, including “How the Other Half investigations by Lives,” Jacob Riis experts, the use used photos and of photography evocative descriptions to take readers into to dramatize parts of New York children’s working City they had long conditions, ignored. What they leafleting, and mass saw was a shocking mailings to reach the portrait of people’s American public. desperate lives, Journalist Jacob especially the children who lived in New York Riis helped reshape City’s tenements. On American attitudes this page and the toward child following page, you’ll labor. Once an find examples of Riis’ impoverished images and words— immigrant (from images and words so Denmark) powerful that they inspired many people himself, Riis to fight for the reform spent time as a of child-labor laws. police reporter for The New York Tribune — experiences that gave him a special understanding of the plight of children. He became an activist for the reform of child labor laws and advocated for better housing, lighting, sanitation, parks and playgrounds in the nation’s cities. “I Scrubs” “Katie, Who Keeps House in West Forty-ninth Street. ‘What kind of work do you do?’ I asked. ‘I scrubs,’ she replied promptly, and her look guaranteed that what she scrubbed came out clean.” 12 NEWSPAPER LOGO “Minding the Baby” “Of Susie’s hundred little companions in the alley — playmates they could scarcely be called — some made artificial flowers, some paper boxes, while the boys earned money at ‘shinin’, or selling newspapers. The smaller girls ‘minded the baby,’ leaving mother free to work …” Susie “Little at Her Work” “Little Susie ... Every morning she drags down to her Cherry Street Court heavy bundles of the little tin boxes much too heavy for her twelve years, and when she has finished … earning a few pennies that way, takes her place at the bench and pastes two hundred before it is time for evening school.” “Night School in the Seventh Avenue Lodging House” The Numbers Jacob Riis gave the world a glimpse into the lives of the millions of children who spent their days struggling to earn a meager living. The 1900 census showed that 1.8 million children between the ages of 10 and 15 were working in the United States — about 18% of the country’s children. Ten years later, that number increased to more than 1.9 million children. Many younger children who worked in mills, factories and on the streets Average Salaries for were not counted. If child workers in 1873 they had been Children working in tobacco counted, experts factories earned $1 per week. estimate that more Children working in envelope than two million of factories earned $3 per week. America’s children (Run by The Children’s Aid Society) “One night I took the picture of my little vegetable peddling friend, Edward, asleep on the front bench in evening school. Edward was nine years old and an orphan, but hard at work every day earning his own living by shouting from a peddler’s cart. He could not be made to sit for his picture, and I took him at a disadvantage …” were employed. Girls who worked at cutting feathers earned $3.50 per week. Although most child workers had someone dependent on them, such as a sick mother or an elderly father, it wasn’t easy for them to support their families. Children were paid less than adults. They received few vacations and no sick days. In addition, they were often fined for mistakes and had to pay for their transportation and in many cases, their room and board, which could cost as much as $4 per week. “Tenement Yard” “I counted the other day the little ones, up to ten years or so, in a Bayard Street tenement … yard … There was about as much light in the ‘yard’ as in the average cellar … I had counted one hundred and twenty-eight in forty families.” “‘The Five Points House of Industry’ accomplished what no machinery of government availed to do. Sixty thousand children have been rescued by them from the streets. ... It is one of the most touching sights to see a score of babies, rescued from homes of brutality and desolation ... saying their prayers in the nursery at bedtime.” Historians interpret the past using visual as well as text documents. Study the photographs by Jacob Riis and write a paragraph with as many details as you can. Describe the people, the setting, the event and any artifacts that you see. Think about what is happening beyond the edges of the photograph. Select a news photograph in the newspaper. Describe NEWSPAPER LOGO it in detail, just as you described the photographs above. Then write a paragraph explaining what it tells you about the situation it is reporting. NOTE: The Teacher’s Guide provides additional background and ideas for extending this assignment. 13 The Child Labor Debate C hild labor wasn’t seen as a problem before the Industrial Revolution. Families and communities were largely selfsufficient in agrarian economies, and everyone contributed by working. As local economies grew, children were still an essential part of the work force. Some were able to hold a job and complete their education at home with the support of their families. Others learned to become independent when they left home for jobs as apprentices, cabin boys or mill workers. Even after the abuses that resulted from industrialization became well known, many people didn’t see child labor as a problem that needed regulation. Although we take childlabor laws for granted today, the debate over these laws lasted for more than 30 years — well into the first half of the 20th century. Some experts believe that industrialization itself ultimately put an end to the very problems it created. Rising standards of living and technical innovations The arguments on the next page are representative of those voiced during America’s long debate over child labor. Look for examples of similar arguments being made today in articles from the newspapers that you’ve collected. Write an editorial supporting one side of the debate. Use information 14 NEWSPAPER LOGO reduced the need for child workers. Automation replaced, and continues to replace, many workers. The Great Depression of the 1930’s also played a role in reducing the demand for child labor: With unemployment so high, jobs once scorned and left to children were suddenly coveted by adults. After decades of debate on the subject, the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 became the first federal law to place limitations on child labor. (It also established the first national minimum-wage standards.) It effectively prohibited the employment of children under age 16 in manufacturing and mining. The Act was amended in 1949 to include prohibitions on children working in agriculture, textiles and other industries. Was it social concern for the welfare of children that eventually resulted in the passage of these laws, or the changing nature of a more modern industrialized economy? What do you think? What other factors might have played a role in the passage of these laws? from both these historical documents and the contemporary reports from the newspaper. NOTE: The Teacher’s Guide provides additional historical information and critical-thinking activities. Voices Against Child Labor “ “ Those industries which coin into profits the vitality of childhood — and leave to the world, for its mercy and support, wrecks of manhood — rob the country of something which they can never return.” —Robert Hunter, “Poverty,” 1904 We have no right to the labor of children … It is one of the worst evils of the present day and should be corrected. If children are driven to toil before they have received a sound education and before their bodies are grown, where are we to look for the future citizens of the country?” W hile child labor laws were adopted in the United States in the 1930’s and 1940’s, child labor continues to exist around the world. These contemporary images from the United Nations photo archives dramatize the ongoing debate between the idea that childhood should be a time of play and learning, and the view of children as economic assets. How do each of these pictures support the arguments of both sides of the childlabor debate? “ “ “ “ In some less developed countries children may have to work for family economic survival. Better that they work and eat than starve.” —Richard B. Freeman, Harvard economist, “A Hard-Headed Look at Labor Standards,” 1994 If a child is not trained to useful work before the age of 18, we shall have a nation of paupers and thieves.” —Letter to the New York Chamber of Commerce Bulletin, Bulletin XVI, No. 5 (December 1924) The mills of Georgia are dependent for their labor upon poor white people who were, as a rule, tenants on farms. Children are brought to the mills by their parents because the work is lighter, the pay is better, and they have better opportunities for improvement and enjoyment than on the farms. I appeal to the legislature and to the state on behalf of these people not to interfere with their privilege to work when and where they will.” —William Jennings Bryan, Democratic candidate for President, 1896, 1900 and 1908 Chicago Record-Herald (Sept. 7, 1906) If you continue to use the labor of children as the treatment for the social disease of poverty, you will have both poverty and child labor to the end of time.” Voices In Favor of Child Labor A boy sifts through trash for items of value to sell in Columbia. —Mary Applewhite Bacon, “Child Labor in the Cotton Mills of Georgia,” Charities (July 18, 1903) —Grace Abbott, testimony to the U.S. House of Representatives on the proposed Child Labor Constitutional Amendment, 1924 “ “ The work of the world has to be done; and these children have their share … We don’t want to rear up a generation of nonworkers, what we want is workers and more workers.” “ If we continue to sanction premature child labor, we not only degrade and lower the standard of citizenship, but we prevent that future growth, that development of American civilization … we must give to the world in order to contribute to the world’s riches.” —Elizabeth Fraser, “Children and Work” Saturday Evening Post (April 4, 1925) Young boys carrying bricks at a construction site in New Delhi, India. —Felix Adler, philosopher, social activist and educational pioneer. Speech to Third Annual Meeting of the National Child Labor Committee, 1906 A boy from the Solomon Islands plays with a homemade truck. It’s as easy to teach a boy to love work with the result of capability as it is to let him drift into habits of idleness with the result of incapability.” —Daniel Augustus Tompkins, cotton-mill owner, Quoted in “A Builder of the New South,” 1920 Child Labor Today “Today, child labor has been virtually eliminated from the American workplace. Or has it? “Violations of the child-labor laws continue in the economically impoverished sectors of the nation, notably among the migrant agricultural workers. Employers in New York’s garment industry employ the children of illegal immigrants in an effort to compete with imported low-wage goods from other countries. Recently, the laws pertaining to work done at home have been liberalized, increasing the possibility of child labor law infringement. Many school children work beyond the allowed number of hours or hold prohibited jobs. One study has shown that proportionally nearly as many children in America work today as at the turn of the 20th century, reminding us that child Throughout history and today, the news media has shed light on the conditions of the living and working conditions children experience. From your collection of newspaper articles, select one country to profile. Make a chart listing reasons why children in that particular country should be utilized as workers and reasons why they should not. The United States led the world in the transition from an agrarian to industrial economy. Use your study of NEWSPAPER LOGO labor hasn’t disappeared.” [Hugh D Hindman, “Child Labor: An American History,” 2002] In addition to the thousands of children who work in the United States, millions of children around the world work in agriculture, as domestics, and in trades, manufacturing and services. Most of these children overseas have few rights and protections because of weak laws and lax enforcement. the impact of this transition in U.S. history to write an editorial describing the situation of children in the country you’ve chosen and what history suggests could happen there in the future. Include recommendations of possible steps to take in your editorial. NOTE: The Teacher’s Guide provides a timeline on child-labor reform and suggestions for holding a class debate on the topic of child labor. 15 Free the Children T he International Labor Organization (ILO) has estimated that 250 million children between the ages of five and 14 work in developing countries — at least 120 million on a full-time basis. Sixtyone percent of these are in Asia, 32 percent in Africa, and seven percent in Latin America. Most working children in rural areas are found in agriculture; many children work as domestics; urban children work in trade and services, with fewer in manufacturing and construction. — Human Rights Watch For more information on the topic of child labor issues: Fr e e t h e C h i l d re n Toronto, Ontario, Canada http://www.freethechildren.org H u m a n R i g h t s Wa t ch New York, New York http://www.hrw.org/children/ labor.htm I n t e r n a t i o n a l I n i t i a t iv e t o E n d C h i l d L ab o r Arlington, Virginia http://www.endchildlabor.org/ G l o b a l M a r ch A g a i n s t C h i l d L ab o r New Delhi, India http://globalmarch.org/index.php Supplement Credits This student supplement was developed for The New York Times Knowledge Network by Kid Scoop. Editor: Vicki Whiting Contributing writers: Jim Silverman, Risa Aratyr and Don Kaplan Production Manager: Vivien Whittington Design: Dawn Armato-Brehm Special thanks to Ellen Doukoullos for her contribution to this project. This student supplement is an educational resource from The New York Times Knowledge Network. It did not involve the editing or reporting staff of The New York Times. 16 leadership and action. Its goal In 1995, 12-year-old Craig is to help children escape Kielburger became a from poverty and exploitation spokesman for children’s — and to free them from the rights. He was searching for idea that they are powerless the comics in to bring about positive change the local in their lives and the lives of paper when a their peers. front-page Free the Children is article caught unlike any other children’s his attention. charity in that it is an It told the organization by, of, and story of a for children young boy that fully from Pakistan embodies the who was sold notion that Craig Kielburger addresses heads of state and into bondage children and civic leaders at the State of the World Forum. as a carpet young people weaver, themselves escaped and was murdered can be leaders in creating a more, for speaking out against child labor. Kielburger equitable and sustainable world. gathered a group of friends and started the organization Free the Children. Today, Free the Children is an international Craig Kielburger receives the network of children helping children at local, national Roosevelt Freedom Award, 1998, and international levels through representation, with Archbishop Desmond Tutu. Text Citations: Cover: Poem by Elizabeth Watson, published in the magazine The Survey 28 (Sept. 28, 1912) Page 3: Asa Sheldon, “The Life of Asa G. Sheldon: Wilmington Farmer. In two arrangements.” Woburn, Mass.: E.T. Moody, printer, 1862. Eric Sloane, “Diary of an Early American Boy, Noah Blake, 1805.” New York, NY: W. Funk, 1962. Page 4: John Tebbel, “The Compact History of the American Newspaper.” New York: Hawthorn Books, Inc., 1963. Horace Greeley, “Recollections of a Busy Life.” New York: J.B. Ford & Company, 1869. Doris Raber, “Printer’s Devil to Publisher, Adolph S. Ochs of The New York Times.” Hensonville, N.Y.: Black Dome Press, 1963. Page 5: Herman Melville, “Redburn: His First Voyage. Being the Sailor-boy Confessions and Reminiscences of the Son-of-a-Gentleman, in the Merchant Service.” New York: Harper & Brothers, 1849. Lotta Crabtree’s obituary. The New York Times, Sept. 26, 1924. Page 6: Harriet Hanson Robinson, “Look and Spindle or Life Among the Early Mill Girls,” New York: T.Y. Crowell, 1898. Page 10: Charles Loring Brace, “The Dangerous Classes of New York and Twenty Years’ Work Among Them.” New York: Wynkoop & Hallenbeck, 1872. “The Lowell Offering,” New England Magazine, Dec. 7, 1889. Page 11: “The Orphan Train Collection,” edited by D. Bruce Ayler of the Orphan Train Heritage Society of America, Inc/ (http://www.orphantrainriders.com/) Page 7: Lance E. Metz, historian, National Canal Museum, Easton, Pa. Page 8: Henry Bibb, “Narrative of the Life and Adventures of Henry Bibb, an American Slave.” New York: Published by the author, 1849. Booker T. Washington, “Up From Slavery: An Autobiography.” New York: Doubleday, Page & Co., 1901. Page 12-13:Jacob A. Riis, “The Children of the Poor,” New York; Scribner’s Sons, 1892. Jacob A. Riis, “How the Other Half Lives: Studies Among the Tenements of New York,” New York; Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1890. “Little Laborers of New York.” Harper’s New Monthly Magazine 47.279 (August 1873). Page 9: Cordelia Howard’s obituary. The New York Times, Aug 11. 1941. Page 15: Hugh D Hindman, “Child Labor: An American History.” Armonk, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe, 2002. Cover: (center, bottom left) Lewis Wickes Hine/CORBIS. (bottom) Russell Lee/CORBIS. right) Berkshire Athenaeum, Pittsfield, Massachusettes. (bottom right) Ex-classics.com. Page 2: (top) Wisconsin Historical Society, photo by Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, WHi2280. (top left) Dawn Brehm. (bottom right) Picture Copyright 1953 by Garth Williams, Copyright renewed 1981 by Garth Williams. Used by permission of Harper Collins Publishers. (bottom left) CORBIS. Page 6: (center) Bettmann/CORBIS. (top right) Lowell Historical Society. (bottom left) Bettmann/CORBIS. Page 10: (center) WIGenWeb Project, a part of the USGenWeb Project Orphan Train. (bottom) Kansas Historical Society. Picture Credits: Page 3: (top right) Bettmann/CORBIS. (left) Colonial Williamsburg Foundation. Page 4: (center) Lake County Museum/CORBIS. (bottom left) The New Castle Historical Society. (bottom right) Bettmann/CORBIS. Page 5: (center) Bettmann/CORBIS. (left) National Maritime Museum, London. (center Page 7: (center) Paul A. Souders/CORBIS. (center right) Courtesy of Minisink Historical Society. (bottom) Jeff Schinkel. Page 8: (top left) Picture History. (top right) Picture History. (bottom left) Library of Congress, LC-USZ62-25624. (bottom right) Used with the permission of The University Library, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Page 9: (center) Brown University Library. (bottom left) Harvard Theatre Collection. (bottom right) www.historichwy49.com. Page 11: (top right) Bettmann/CORBIS. (top left) Bettmann/CORBIS. Page 12: Jacob Riis Portrait: CORBIS. (center, top right, bottom) Museum of the City of New York. Page 13: (all ) Museum of the City of New York. Page 14: (top left, top center, top right) Lewis Wickes Hine/CORBIS. (bottom) Courtesy of BoondocksNet.com. Page 15: (all) UN Photo Page 16: (all) Free the Children. NEWSPAPERS & CHILDREN: a formula for action Craig Kielburger learned about modernday exploitation of children when he was searching through the newspaper for the comics. A newspaper article brought the world beyond his neighborhood into his living room. And, at 12 years old, he discovered that he could make a difference in places thousands of miles from his home. NEWSPAPER LOGO Comparing the role of children in American history and the lives of children today offers insight into both the past and the present. Now that you are armed with information about the lives of children around the world today and lessons from the past, create a plan of action to educate others about child labor.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz