2016 FIRST HALF GREATER SALT LAKE AREA MULTIFAMILY MARKET REPORT Salt Lake • Utah • Davis • Weber CBRE is pleased to introduce the H1 2016 (first half of 2016) Greater Salt Lake Area Multifamily Market Report—the most current and comprehensive multifamily data available for the Salt Lake area/Wasatch Front market. Produced by Patrick Bodnar and Eli Mills of CBRE, this report has been assembled to empower multifamily investors interested in the Utah market. This report has been prepared with current data sourced from a comprehensive survey of over 50,000 units along the Wasatch Front area inclusive of Salt Lake, Utah, Davis and Weber Counties. Minimum reporting requirements were identified for each city and county by class, type and size. As the global leader in commercial real estate, CBRE understands the critical nature of transparency in a marketplace. This Wasatch Front Market Report was created to fill the void of reliable and detailed data formally provided to the market by Equimark Properties prior to its business closing in 2015. To represent vacancy and rents for 2015 in this report, the average between 2014 Equimark and 2016 CBRE numbers were utilized. For 2016 H1 rent increases, Yardi Matrix data was used. Historic numbers shown in this report are from previous Equimark reports. Additionally, the data collected was compared to—and validated by—the most trusted national data sources. Data contributions and validations to this publication were made by: •CBRE Research •CBRE Econometric Advisors •Yardi Matrix •Axiometrics •Western States Multifamily •Utah Department of Economics •University of Utah Bureau of Economics and Business Research •Equimark Properties (Historical Data) •Construction Monitor Whatever your multifamily data needs may be, please feel free to reach out to us. We have the most comprehensive data on the market and can provide information on a macro or micro level based on class, city, submarket, zip code, location, age, size, proximity to rail stops, and many other variations. We welcome your inquiries into the Utah multifamily market and look forward to working with you. Best Regards, TABLE OF CONTENTS PREFACE TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY................................ 4 FORWARD MARKET ECONOMIC SUMMARY.......... 5 SALT LAKE COUNTY Rent/Vacancy/Concessions Greater Salt Lake Area............................................. 6 Multifamily Construction Activity Supply vs. Demand and Absorption.......................... 7 Wasatch .......................................... 8 100+Front UnitSummary. Properties Historical RentalExpenses Rates & Vacancy.............................. 9 Operating SALT LAKE/WASATCH FRONT 1. SALT LAKECOUNTY COUNTY DAVIS Vacancy and Rent Growth...................................... 10 Rental Rate Comparison Rental Rate Review................................................. 10 Vacancy&and Rent Growth Downtown Sugarhouse Spotlight......................... 11 Concessions Historical Rental Rates............................................ 12 Multifamily Housing Maps.................................13-15 UTAH COUNTY Rental Rate Comparison 2. UTAH COUNTY Vacancy andand Rent Growth...................................... 16 Vacancy Rent Growth Rental Rate Review................................................. 16 Concessions Multifamily Housing Pipeline Map........................... 17 WEBER COUNTY 3. DAVIS COUNTY Rental Rate Comparison Vacancy andand Rent Growth...................................... 18 Vacancy Rent Growth Rental Rate Review................................................. 18 Concessions Multifamily Housing Pipeline Map........................... 19 WASATCH FRONT Patrick BodnarEli Mills 4. WEBER COUNTY Unemployment/Job Growth Vacancy and Rent Growth...................................... 20 Concessions Rental Rate Review................................................. 20 WasatchHousing Front Rents Unit Type Multifamily Pipelineby Map........................... 21 Wasatch Front Rent/Vacancy by County DEBT & CAPITAL MARKETS.................... 22 CBRE MULTIFAMILY.................................... 23 For a market analysis on your property or more information contact: Patrick Bodnar Senior Associate +1 801 869 8053 [email protected] Eli Mills Senior Vice President +1 801 869 8029 [email protected] 2016 FIRST HALF GREATER SALT LAKE AREA MULTIFAMILY REPORT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY MARKET ECONOMIC SUMMARY HEADLINES •Wasatch Front overall vacancy is 4.5% For the seven years following 2009, the multifamily market in Utah has seen significant year-over-year improvement with falling vacancy rates and climbing rental rates. Coupled with continued growth of new construction projects, the Greater Salt Lake area has increased its total unit count by 16,673 since 2011. With almost 9,000 units under construction, and potential starts over the next 12 months of over 10,500 units, developers in Utah have continued to introduce apartment communities to the market, outpacing typical expectations. •Rents increased in Salt Lake County by 26% since 2011, while vacancies reduced by 60 basis points from 5.2% to 4.6% Utah typically absorbs approximately 2,500 units per year, a growth rate of about 2%. Careful and thoughtful review of multifamily market data suggests that over the years, demand has outpaced supply and Utah is now “catching up,” providing the overdue supply Utah has been lacking. Investors and developers will continue to enjoy a healthy multifamily business climate with relatively minimal change over the next 12 months while it continues to “catch up” with demand. •Davis County showed the lowest vacancy rate out of all four counties along the Wasatch Front at 2.9% •Wasatch Front rent reaches all-time average high of $1.15 per square foot •Along the Wasatch Front, new projects have absorbed units at a rate of approximately 18 per month with Salt Lake County absorbing units at approximately 20 per month •Downtown and Sugarhouse lead the multifamily market, driving rental rates to new levels •Permits for 3,278 multifamily units in Salt Lake County were issued in the past 12 months from June 2016, up 639 units from the prior year The Greater Salt Lake market is as active as ever and looking forward, is expected to remain vibrant. LOOKING FORWARD •The market vacancy rate is expected to stay below 5% through the balance of 2016 and well into 2017, but is projected to be above 7% by 2019 •Demand is anticipated to remain robust in the near term, although some overbuilding will delay stabilization periods in the latter part of 2017 ECONOMIC DRIVERS OF DEMAND Utah’s economy has performed well in recent years. With job growth near its historical average—in the low three percent range—Utah has easily outpaced the nation as a whole. A continuation of growth near historical averages was observed during the first half of 2016 and looking ahead—barring any major external shocks—healthy growth is expected during coming quarters. Population, personal income, and most importantly, total employment are the primary economic drivers of apartment demand. The graph below shows the annual growth rates of these variables from 2004 through year-end 2017. TOTAL EMPLOYMENT, POPULATION & REAL PERSONAL INCOME GROWTH Consistent strong job growth has underpinned positive dynamics playing out in the state’s commercial real estate markets. This will continue to be the case and will be supportive of demand for multifamily housing. The area’s positive performance is not the only characteristic that should be noted in terms of economic trends interacting with commercial real estate markets; the diversity of Utah’s economy is also an important factor to consider, providing economic stability and less volatile demand for commercial real estate. 8.0% 6.0% 4.0% 2.0% There are many factors that will continue to support growth; Utah’s business friendly culture and lower cost of doing business will continue to attract and support business expansion. In addition, strategic investments such as the terminal redevelopment program at the Salt Lake City International Airport—a $2.5 billion project—will inject investment dollars into the regional economy and pay dividends for years to come. 0.0% -2.0% -4.0% -6.0% 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 TOTAL EMPLOYMENT Generally speaking, Utah’s economy is strong. Moving forward, its diverse economy, growing population, business friendly culture and continued investment in infrastructure all support a positive outlook. 20% NAICS CATEGORY •Over the next 12 months, financial markets will continue to be eager to invest in multifamily projects FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES 12% 7% 11% •8,894 units are currently under construction along the Wasatch Front and will be brought to market within the next 18 months— 6,226 are located in Salt Lake County 17% RETAIL TRADE GOVT. 16% •Wasatch Front potential starts over the next 12 months or later total 10,627 units PROF. & BUSINESS SERVICES 9% MFG. 8% HOSP. & LEISURE Source: CBRE EA © 2016 CBRE, Inc. 4 © 2016 CBRE, Inc. REAL PERSONAL INCOME EMPLOYMENT LEVELS AND GROWTH RATES: SALT LAKE AREA VS. U.S. EDUCATION & HEALTH OTHER POPULATION Source: CBRE EA LARGEST EMPLOYMENT SECTORS IN THE GREATER SALT LAKE AREA •Annual effective rent growth will slow to approximately 3% in 2017 TOC TOC The multifamily market in the Greater Salt Lake area—Salt Lake, Utah, Davis and Weber Counties—is experiencing strong construction and rental growth due to pent up demand that is now beginning to be met. LEVEL (X 1000) LOCATION QUOTIENT Agriculture & Mining 3 0.67 0.6 Construction 54 1.25 5.1 4.0 Manufacturing 87 1.08 1.9 1.1 1.5 -0.3 Wholesale Trade 39 1.01 1.3 Retail Trade 101 0.98 3.0 1.8 Transportation & Warehousing 40 1.26 3.8 2.7 Information 20 1.12 1.8 0.7 Financial Activities 65 1.22 3.7 1.4 Prof. & Business Srvcs. 148 1.14 4.5 3.2 Education & Health 109 0.75 3.3 2.2 Hospitality & Leisure 81 0.81 3.7 3.2 Other Services 27 0.74 2.6 1.2 Government 156 1.09 1.4 -0.1 Total 931 n/a 3.0 1.8 Source: Moody’s Economy.com, CBRE EA 5 LAST 5 YEARS METRO U.S. 2016 FIRST HALF GREATER SALT LAKE AREA MULTIFAMILY REPORT GREATER SALT LAKE AREA (WASATCH FRONT) SUPPLY VS. DEMAND AND ABSORPTION The Greater Salt Lake area, also known as the Wasatch Front, consists of four counties—Salt Lake, Utah, Davis and Weber. Ogden City is located on the north end of the Wasatch Front, Salt Lake City sits in the middle, and Provo is on the south end in Utah County. Ogden City is located 40 minutes to the north of Salt Lake City, while Provo is located 45 minutes to the south of Salt Lake City. Approximately 2,262,207 people (80% of Utah’s population) live within this four-county area. The counties are connected via Interstate 15, the primary north-south freeway through Utah around which the majority of development occurs. The Wasatch Front, from Weber County to Utah County, is connected by FrontRunner—a high speed passenger train line that also connects with a lightrail system (TRAX) that runs throughout Salt Lake County. The Greater Salt Lake Metro population is growing by more than 200% of the national average. For many years there was a lack of rental supply in the Greater Salt Lake market. Class A projects with amenities renters desired weren’t being constructed and pent up demand existed. From 2011-July 2016, approximately 16,602 units were added to the Wasatch Front. During this same time period, rents went up by 26% in Salt Lake County from $791 to $996 per month, while vacancies decreased by 60 basis points from 5.2% to 4.6%. THE WASATCH FRONT COUNTY OGDEN GREAT SALT LAKE DAV IS COUNTY 80 215 SALT LAKE CITY COUNTY POPULATION Salt Lake 2015 GROWTH 1,107,314 14,426 1.3% 575,205 13,671 2.4% Davis 336,043 6,349 1.9% Weber 243,645 3,145 1.3% Totals 2,262,207 37,591 1.7% 1.7% UTAH LAKE 2015 GREATER SALT LAKE POPULATION GROWTH RATE Source: U.S. Census Bureau UTAH TRANSIT AUTHORITY TRAX LINE 6 SALT LAKE COUNTY 3 YEAR PROJECTED SUPPLY ADDITIONS PROJECT STATUS CONSTRUCTION SUMMARY # OF PROJECTS TOTAL UNITS COUNTY COMPLETED 2011 - CURRENT UNDER CONSTRUCTION POTENTIAL STARTS Under construction - not leased - to complete next 18 months 32 6,320 Salt Lake 9,457 6,720 7,127 Likely starts next six months 21 2,312 Utah 3,959 1,492 3,128 50% of potential starts 2017 or later* 13 2,510 Davis 2,448 538 1,222 Estimated new deliveries over next 3 years 80 11,142 Weber 738 780 742 Totals 16,602 9,530 12,219 *There are currently 27 properties containing 5,020 units that are potential starts beginning 2017 in Salt Lake County. This analysis assumes that 50% of those projects begin construction in the next 18 months and are completed within 3 years. Source: Western States Multifamily Source: Western States Multifamily If the assumptions shown on the graph above hold true there will be 11,142 units added to the market over the next 3 years. Absorption from 2010-2014 has averaged approximately 2,500 units per year. If absorption continues at 2,500 units per year for the next 3 years, 7,500 units will be absorbed leaving 3,548 units unabsorbed. This will increase the vacancy rate in Salt Lake County from 4.6% to approximately 7.4% by the end of 2019. © 2016 CBRE, Inc. 7 TOC 0.8% 2015 U.S. POPULATION GROWTH RATE UTAH PROVO PROVO COUNTY % INCREASE Utah Source: Utah Population Estimates Committee, Governor’s Office SALT LAKE COUNTY TOC 80 © 2016 CBRE, Inc. Jeff Neese, MAI of Western States Multifamily, has projected future supply additions in Salt Lake County as follows: GREATER SALT LAKE METRO 2015 POPULATION GROWTH WEBER Significant construction is underway along the Wasatch Front; 9,530 units are currently under construction, 6,720 of which are in Salt Lake County. Another 12,219 units have been identified as potential starts along the Wasatch Front, 7,127 of which are in Salt Lake County. 2016 FIRST HALF GREATER SALT LAKE AREA MULTIFAMILY REPORT WASATCH FRONT HISTORICAL RENTAL RATES & VACANCY: SUMMARY TABLES BY COUNTY AND CITY WASATCH FRONT SUMMARY The multifamily market along the Wasatch Front continues to be vibrant, with overall low vacancy and strong rent growth. This supports a strong trend toward renting in Utah; people are getting married later, starting families later and desire to be mobile, enabling them to move away to pursue additional schooling or a new career path. Lifestyle is a top priority, and living in downtown areas or walkable communities has become more desirable. Coupled with favorable financing, this trend is promoting the development of many new apartment communities. Developers are eager to get projects off the ground, securing long-term, low-cost debt while possible. VACANY BY COUNTY SF RENT SF RENT SF SF $/SF VACANCY 954 $0.93 5.9% $938 901 $1.04 4.5% $961 918 $1.05 4.5% $1,011 910 $1.11 4.8% $1,061 901 $1.18 5.1% Draper $993 983 $1.01 6.2% $980 964 $1.02 6.9% $978 964 $1.01 2.2% $1,023 903 $1.14 3.4% $1,068 842 $1.27 4.5% Midvale $815 860 $0.95 5.6% $860 860 $1.00 4.8% $888 876 $1.01 4.8% $969 848 $1.15 5.4% $1,051 821 $1.28 5.9% Murray $804 838 $0.96 5.5% $839 894 $0.94 5.2% $863 888 $0.97 4.0% $936 861 $1.09 3.3% $1,008 834 $1.21 2.6% Riverton $916 1,005 $0.91 3.1% $921 1,043 $0.88 6.7% $918 1,043 $0.88 7.2% $962 971 $1.00 3.6% $1,005 898 $1.12 0.0% Salt Lake City $772 728 $1.06 3.5% $865 793 $1.09 5.4% $886 782 $1.13 4.9% $960 748 $1.29 5.2% $1,035 715 $1.45 5.5% Sandy $932 904 $1.03 4.7% $943 846 $1.11 6.0% $975 884 $1.10 5.5% $1,061 889 $1.19 4.8% $1,148 893 $1.28 4.1% South Jordan $1,152 1,117 $1.03 9.8% $1,140 1,094 $1.04 9.2% $1,137 1,034 $1.10 6.9% $1,115 984 $1.14 5.3% $1,093 934 $1.17 3.7% South Salt Lake $638 708 $0.95 4.1% $709 656 $1.08 4.2% $725 673 $1.08 6.0% $761 705 $1.08 4.1% $798 738 $1.08 2.1% Taylorsville $749 823 $0.91 5.6% $787 814 $0.97 4.6% $817 812 $1.01 6.1% $855 811 $1.06 6.0% $892 809 $1.10 5.8% West Jordan $837 888 $0.94 6.7% $866 923 $0.94 4.7% $861 832 $1.04 4.9% $921 884 $1.04 3.7% $980 936 $1.05 2.6% West Valley City N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A $750 791 $0.95 4.2% $828 775 $1.07 4.3% $907 760 $1.19 4.4% $400 Downtown N/A N/A N/A N/A $941 797 $1.18 3.7% $757 783 $1.26 5.4% $968 779 $1.39 5.3% $200 Overall $1,200 $1,000 6.0% $800 $600 4.0% 0.0% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 SALT LAKE 2010 2011 2012 2013 UTAH 2014 2015 DAVIS $0 2016 1 BED 1 BATH 2 BED 1 BATH SALT LAKE 2 BED 2 BATH UTAH 3 BED 2 BATH DAVIS OVERALL WEBER Source: CBRE, Inc. HISTORICAL RENTAL & VACANCY RATES 2012 WASATCH FRONT RENT SF 2013 $/SF VACANCY RENT SF 2014 $/SF VACANCY RENT SF $/SF VACANCY N/A 2015 $/SF VACANCY RENT SF MID - 2016 $/SF VACANCY RENT SF $/SF VACANCY 2012 UTAH COUNTY RENT SF Orem $925 953 $0.97 Pleasant Grove $863 973 $0.89 Provo $863 973 $0.91 2013 $/SF VACANCY RENT SF 3.8% $883 958 $0.92 3.1% $922 946 $0.97 2.9% $633 714 $0.89 853 $0.95 5.0% $850 867 $0.98 5.1% $892 851 $1.06 4.9% $944 837 $1.13 4.7% $996 823 $1.19 4.6% $788 857 $0.92 6.1% $678 929 $0.73 6.9% $698 845 $0.75 4.2% $740 899 $0.79 5.1% $950 952 $1.08 3.2% Davis $720 837 $0.86 6.6% $756 889 $0.85 4.6% $796 846 $0.88 4.7% $802 800 $0.98 3.8% $871 755 $1.07 2.9% DAVIS COUNTY RENT SF Weber $684 912 $0.75 3.2% $807 887 $0.91 4.4% $868 900 $0.99 6.0% $956 902 $1.07 4.7% $783 904 $0.82 3.4% Bountiful $783 942 $0.83 5.1% $840 1,012 $0.83 Wasatch Front $790 849 $0.93 5.1% $830 874 $0.95 5.2% $854 862 $1.00 4.9% $912 848 $1.08 4.69% $970 834 $1.15 4.5% Clearfield $731 890 $0.83 6.0% $748 857 $0.87 Layton $669 751 $0.89 8.0% $749 North Salt Lake $874 934 $0.94 8.9% Source: CBRE, Inc. OTHER INDICATORS CLASS A CLASS B CLASS C CATEGORY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY LOCATION RESIDENTS 5YR AVG. INCREASE Studio $844 $1.54 $647 $1.65 $641 $1.81 Salt Lake 1,107,314 1.50% 1 Bed 1 Bath $1,060 $1.51 $813 $1.28 $717 $1.28 Davis 336,043 1.92% 2 Bed 1 Bath $1,063 $1.21 $902 $1.03 $842 $1.02 Utah 575,205 2012 POPULATION SF 2.26% Ogden $633 827 $0.77 $769 990 $0.78 $613 875 $0.70 $1,039 $1.09 $1,000 $0.85 Weber 243,645 1.08% $1,162 $0.99 $1,204 $0.93 Wasatch Front 2,262,207 1.69% West Haven State of Utah 3,000,000 1.68% Overall 7.1% Source: CBRE, Inc. © 2016 CBRE, Inc. Source: U.S. Census Bureau 8 RENT SF $/SF VACANCY 4.7% $946 913 $1.04 5.3% 3.2% $921 946 $0.97 3.2% 5.2% $685 714 $0.96 2.8% $1.52 5.3% $1.19 4.6% $996 823 RENT SF $/SF VACANCY $970 942 $1.03 2.9% $1,124 995 $1.13 3.1% MID - 2016 RENT SF $958 928 $1.03 4.1% $1,023 970 $1.05 3.1% $722 $/SF VACANCY 708 $1.02 2014 RENT SF 3.9% $839 960 $0.87 5.4% $723 898 $0.80 898 $0.83 3.9% $789 $815 1,063 $0.77 3.6% $907 2012 RENT 3 Bed 2 Bath $1,469 $1.21 $773 $1.12 SF 2013 $/SF VACANCY WEBER COUNTY 2 Bed 2 Bath $1,286 $1.27 4.1% $1,178 774 3.0% $759 702 $1.08 3.1% $950 881 $1.08 3.19% $/SF VACANCY RENT SF MID - 2016 2015 $/SF VACANCY $/SF VACANCY $/SF VACANCY RENT SF 6.0% $862 909 $0.95 4.9% $886 857 $1.03 3.8% 3.7% $797 873 $0.91 3.0% $871 849 $1.03 2.4% 898 $0.88 4.8% $792 821 $0.98 4.1% $794 743 $1.07 3.4% 924 $0.98 5.5% $942 908 $1.04 3.7% $976 893 $1.09 1.9% $871 755 $1.07 2.91% RENT SF $/SF Source: CBRE, Inc. Roy $946 $1.11 RENT 2015 RENT Overall BY CLASS 4.5% $/SF VACANCY Overall $810 $1,126 $1.29 SF Source: CBRE, Inc. Utah Overall RENT 2014 $/SF VACANCY Salt Lake WASATCH FRONT CURRENT RENTAL & VACANCY RATES $/SF VACANCY Source: CBRE, Inc. STUDIO WEBER Source: CBRE, Inc. $/SF VACANCY TOC TOC 2.0% MID - 2016 2015 2014 Cottonwood Heights $891 $1,400 8.0% 2013 SALT LAKE COUNTY RENT CURRENT RENTAL RATES BY UNIT TYPE 10.0% 2012 2013 RENT SF 8.3% $622 833 $0.75 6.0% $783 1,105 $0.71 3.4% $756 $/SF VACANCY 2014 $/SF VACANCY 885 $0.85 RENT SF 7.4% $622 790 $0.79 6.1% $812 1,106 $0.73 3.9% $756 885 $0.85 Source: CBRE, Inc. © 2016 CBRE, Inc. 9 MID - 2016 2015 $/SF VACANCY $/SF VACANCY VACANCY RENT SF 5.6% $682 830 $0.82 4.0% $742 870 $0.85 2.5% 3.3% $852 1,161 $0.73 2.8% $892 1215 $0.73 2.2% 3.9% $829 2.2% 922 $0.90 $903 958 $0.94 0.5% $783 952 $0.82 3.5% 2016 FIRST HALF GREATER SALT LAKE AREA MULTIFAMILY REPORT SALT LAKE COUNTY SPOTLIGHT: Salt Lake County reached new heights with its overall average monthly rental rate, topping out at $996/month and achieving mid-year rent growth of 2.7%. Vacancy in suburban markets was the highest at 4.6%; these markets also reported the lowest rental rate with an average of $1.14/sq. ft. Overall, newer communities built after 2010 carried the lowest vacancy of 2.8%. This data validates that current market trends are holding steady. Newer product located downtown or in select communities such as Sugarhouse commanded the highest rents. Suburban markets tend to be more affordable alternatives. DOWNTOWN & SUGARHOUSE MULTIFAMILY STATS VACANCY 4.6% RENT $996 RENT GROWTH (H1 2016) 2.7% OVERALL VACANCY AND RENT 10.0% $1,100 RENT ($) VACANCY (%) 9.0% $1,000 8.0% $900 7.0% $800 5.0% $700 4.0% $600 3.0% $500 2.0% $400 1.0% 0.0% 2005 Source: CBRE, Inc. 2006 2008 2007 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 MID-2016 $300 RENTAL RATE & VACANCY SUMMARY TABLES BY YEAR BY UNIT TYPE CATEGORY VACANCY 1990 - 1999 2000 - 2009 BUILT AFTER 2010 RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY $625 $1.14 $765 $1.65 CATEGORY RENT SF $/SF Studio $715 398 $1.79 Studio 1 Bed 1 Bath $879 666 $1.32 1 Bed 1 Bath $973 $1.30 $967 $1.32 $970 $1.27 2 Bed 1 Bath $939 880 $1.07 2 Bed 1 Bath $989 $1.04 $949 $1.07 $1,125 $1.31 2 Bed 2 Bath $1,159 1,016 $1.14 2 Bed 2 Bath $1,225 $1.18 $1,152 $1.13 $1,152 $1.13 3 Bed 2 Bath $1,288 1,227 $1.05 3 Bed 2 Bath $1,286 $1.04 $1,210 $1.03 Overall $1,012 868 $1.19 Overall 4.6% Source: CBRE, Inc. n/a n/a $1,126 $1.15 3.8% $1,071 $1.16 BY LOCATION DOWNTOWN SUGARHOUSE SUBURBAN CATEGORY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY Studio $668 $1.90 $978 $1.23 $747 $1.78 1 Bed 1 Bath $1,043 $1.50 $1,152 $1.52 $869 $1.31 2 Bed 1 Bath $1,011 $1.15 $1,211 $1.59 $932 $1.06 2 Bed 2 Bath $1,614 $1.63 $1,655 $1.36 $1,132 $1.11 3 Bed 2 Bath $1,653 $1.36 Overall $1,178 $1.52 N/A 5.3% $1,143 $1.26 50 - 99 UNITS 100+ UNITS VACANCY 880 Average rents for both the Downtown and Sugarhouse locations are $1.52 and $1.48/sq. ft., respectively. For all Class A communities with more than 50 units, Downtown rents are higher than Sugarhouse. Some Class A Downtown units are reporting rents as high as $2.15/ sq. ft. Downtown’s studio and 2 bed/2 bath units have achieved higher rents than Sugarhouse, while Sugarhouse has higher rents in the 1 bed/1 bath and 2 bed/1 bath units. This is primarily due to Downtown having a greater quantity of older units leased at lower rates which drops the downtown average rents. 860 Both submarkets will continue to be of great interest to Salt Lake County’s renters. 720 SIZE (SF) CLASS A CLASS B CLASS C RENT $/SF RENT $/SF CATEGORY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY Studio $625 $1.19 $714 $1.83 Studio $844 $1.54 $676 $1.71 $781 $2.32 1 Bed 1 Bath $679 $1.12 $884 $1.38 1 Bed 1 Bath $1,070 $1.50 $833 $1.33 $742 $1.33 2 Bed 1 Bath $822 $0.91 $947 $1.11 2 Bed 1 Bath $1,058 $1.15 $936 $1.08 $936 $1.08 2 Bed 2 Bath $1,063 $0.99 $1,159 $1.16 2 Bed 2 Bath $1,319 $1.25 $1,064 $1.14 $1,000 $0.85 3 Bed 2 Bath $1,118 $0.91 $1,303 $1.09 $842 $0.95 $1,008 $1.23 3 Bed 2 Bath $1,520 $1.16 4.6% Overall $901 $1.15 3.7% $956 $1.17 $1,223 $0.92 4.4% $815 $1.20 5.10% SUGARHOUSE APARTMENTS BY URBANA 10 © 2016 CBRE, Inc. 4.5% 8.0% 820 800 6.0% 5.3% 4.5% 780 3.1% 760 4.0% 2.0% 740 Source: CBRE, Inc. DOWNTOWN 4TH WEST APARTMENTS Source: CBRE, Inc. Source: CBRE, Inc. © 2016 CBRE, Inc. $1,182 $1.31 $1,001 $1.15 10.0% VACANCY (%) 840 2.8% CATEGORY 3.3% VACANCY BY CLASS $1,279 $1.04 3.1% SQUARE FOOT & VACANCY COMPARISON BY LOCATION $1,390 $1.12 5.3% N/A $1,249 $1.48 Source: CBRE, Inc. Source: CBRE, Inc. BY SIZE Overall RENTAL RATE COMPARISON BY LOCATION 11 SUGARHOUSE SUBURBAN 0.0% TOC TOC 6.0% The Downtown and Sugarhouse submarkets have been the center of attention for multifamily development in Salt Lake County. Cranes have dominated the skyline in both areas. Over the past few years, these two locations have undergone significant redevelopment of several infill parcels for both commercial and multifamily development. New approaches to construction and design have elevated competition and attracted renters of all demographics to these locations. These submarkets offer walkability to amenities that are simply unavailable in most suburban markets—everything from trendy eateries and shopping districts to public services such as parks, libraries and post offices. These communities, coupled with lifestyle amenities, have driven rental rates to new heights. 2016 FIRST HALF GREATER SALT LAKE AREA MULTIFAMILY REPORT SALT LAKE COUNTY: COMPLETED MULTIFAMILY PROJECTS 2011 - AUGUST 2016 SALT LAKE COUNTY HISTORICAL RENTAL RATES BY UNIT TYPE (AVERAGE MONTHLY AND PER SF RATES) # NAME $1.80 $1,400 $1.79 $1,288 $1,200 $1,159 $1.60 $1,000 $800 $600 $1.43 $739 $715 $800 $781 $1.37 $996 $850 $844 $1.60 $1.50 $892 $1.40 $632 $599 $1.30 $1.21 $1.09 $0.99 $0.97 $1.02 $0.91 1 BED 1 BATH $0.97 $1.10 $1.06 $1.05 $0.98 $1.00 $0.91 2 BED 1 BATH 2 BED 2 BATH 2013 2014 $1.20 $0.90 3 BED 2 BATH OVERALL 2016 Source: CBRE, Inc. As displayed in the bar chart above, monthly rents have been on the rise. Most significant were the increase in monthly rental rates for studio, 1 bed/1 bath and 2 bed/2 bath units, each at—or just over— 19% rent growth since end-of-year 2013. Following close behind are the 2 bed/1 bath and 3 bed/2 bath units, realizing monthly rental rate increases at 17% and 16%, respectively. The overall monthly rental rate increase is over 17% between 2013 and 2016 across all unit types. This validates the insatiable appetite of Salt Lake County’s renter base. They have shown a continued willingness to pay the increase in monthly rental rates. OTHER INDICATORS POPULATION SINGLE FAMILY HOUSING LOCATION RESIDENTS 5YR AVG. INCREASE YEAR AVERAGE HOME PRICE Salt Lake County 1,107,314 1.30% 2013 $240,000 Salt Lake City 192,672 0.66% 2014 $273,000 West Valley 136,208 1.04% 2015 $287,000 State of Utah 3,000,000 1.68% 2016 $306,000 Source: U.S. Census Bureau © 2016 CBRE, Inc. VIA APARTMENTS Source: WFR Multiple Listing Service UNITS 36 ViA 80 1 West Station 2 Rendon Terrace 70 37 Bud Bailey 136 3 644 City Station 132 38 Birkhill 202 4 Seasons at City Creek 130 39 Lionsgate at Fireclay 400 5 North Sixth 115 40 Birkhill Seniors 105 6 Bridges at Citifront - Phase 2 91 41 Brickgate 268 7 Liberty Gateway 160 42 Silvercrest 186 8 City Creek Landing 105 43 Lotus Madrona 37 9 The Lotus 84 44 Canyon Crossing at Riverwalk 180 10 Providence Place 125 45 Tuscany Villas 76 11 Cityscape 122 46 Talavera at the Junction 252 12 Mercer 73 47 Florentine Villas 214 13 Eastside Apartments 173 48 Lofts at 7800 192 14 Encore 189 49 Jordan Valley Seniors 72 15 Seasons on the Boulevard 99 50 Victoria Woods - Sandy 100 16 Newhouse 61 51 Rosegate 159 17 SEG028 28 52 Willow Cove VII 72 18 Seasons at Library Square 119 53 Hills at Sandy Station 55 19 Prana Townhomes 21 54 Drycreek at East Village 282 20 Aire Condominiums 30 55 Legacy Cottages 186 21 Enclave 210 56 Jordan Station 302 22 Lotus Bluekoi 20 57 South Ridge 145 23 Taylor Springs 95 58 The Gardens 60 24 Sugarhouse Apartments 70 59 District Heights 258 25 21st and View 29 60 Promenade at the District 170 26 Liberty Village 171 61 San Tropez - Phase II 84 27 The Vue at Sugarhouse Crossing 211 62 Victoria Woods - Draper 42 28 Wilmington Gardens 105 63 Parc at Day Dairy 228 29 Sage Gate at Haynes Landing 278 64 Terrameer 174 30 2550 South Main 112 65 Solameer at Harriman Towne Center 134 31 Pinnacle Highbury 290 66 Rosegate in Draper 277 32 Element 31 at Brickyard 208 67 Beacon Hill 168 33 Millcreek 9 27 68 Ballpark Apartments 62 34 Residence at Fairbourne Station 225 69 Meadows at Park Avenue 121 35 Millcreek Towers 38 70 Triton Terrace 177 9,817 Total Units Source: Western States Multifamily. Maps as of June 2016. 12 145 # NAME © 2016 CBRE, Inc. 13 TOC TOC $200 STUDIO $1.19 $1.14 $1.12 $400 $0 $1,157 $1,017 $970 $939 $879 $1,113 $1.70 UNITS 2016 FIRST HALF GREATER SALT LAKE AREA MULTIFAMILY REPORT SALT LAKE COUNTY: POTENTIAL MULTIFAMILY STARTS AS OF AUGUST 2016 SALT LAKE COUNTY: MULTIFAMILY DEVELOPMENT UNDER CONSTRUCTION - AUGUST 2016 1 4th West Apartments 493 2 Liberty Crest 177 3 Alta Gateway 264 4 Laporte* 180 5 The Bonneville 158 6 360 Apartments 151 7 Liberty Boulevard 266 8 9th East Lofts 68 9 616 South State 274 10 Ball Park Apartments* 61 11 Taylor Gardens 112 12 Zeller Beach 292 13 Oquirrh Hills 288 14 Riverfront 288 15 Artesian Springs 118 16 Metro at Fireclay 175 17 The Ridge 261 18 The Station at Midvale 102 19 Kimpton Square 97 20 Pinnacle Sandy 332 21 Novi at Jordan Valley Station 267 22 Cobblegate at Quarry Bend 416 23 Park at City Center* 330 24 Hills at Sandy Station - Phase 2 146 25 East Village 271 26 Rosegate in Herriman 298 27 Draper Village 181 28 Sagegate at Anthem* 422 29 Meadows at Park Avenue 14 30 Draper Lofts 249 31 Triton Terrace* 177 32 Independence 60 33 Bodhi Salt Lake City 80 34 Paragon Station Lofts 38 35 S-Line Townhomes 32 36 Park at City Center 330 37 Sagegate at Anthem # NAME UNITS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 422 6,720 Total Units Source: Western States Multifamily. Maps as of June 2016. *Construction has since been completed. © 2016 CBRE, Inc. Source: Western States Multifamily. Maps as of June 2016. 14 © 2016 CBRE, Inc. 15 Marmalade Flats North 4th Apartments West Station - Phase II North Temple Micro North Temple Flats Sharon Gardens Hardison PEG The Morton Artspace Macaroni Flats 4th and 4th Liberty Square Granary Place Central 9th Studios 965 Central Central Ninth TenFifteen The East Village Phase 2 1701 South 1100 East Liberty on Main 21 By Urbana Liberty Place Sugarmont Liberty Crossing NW Pipeline 2265 South State Rockwell Lofts Highland 40 Townhomes Via Lotus Tapestry Artesian Springs - Phases 2 & 3 Flats at the District Spring Run Townhomes Murray Crossing Canyon Centre Station at Midvale - Phase 2 Station at Gardner Mill The View at 5600 Little Cottonwood The Prestige Cliffs at Jordan Station Daybreak Condos Liberty Pointe Veranda Draper Vista Station Independence Triton Terrace UNITS 300 110 145 350 168 58 77 182 136 13 210 138 134 12 50 43 54 65 19 120 126 200 435 157 248 300 21 40 58 43 260 120 54 280 123 84 272 192 264 350 237 180 100 239 250 244 320 7,332 Total Units TOC TOC # NAME 2016 FIRST HALF GREATER SALT LAKE AREA MULTIFAMILY REPORT UTAH COUNTY: MULTIFAMILY COMPLETED/PIPELINE - 2011-2016 UTAH COUNTY VACANCY 3.2% # NAME RENT $950 RENT GROWTH (H1 2016) 4.3% OVERALL VACANCY AND RENT 8.0% $1,000 7.0% $900 6.0% $800 5.0% $700 4.0% $600 3.0% $500 2.0% $400 TOC 1.0% 0.0% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 VACANCY (%) Source: CBRE, Inc. 2012 2013 2013 2014 2015 MID-2016 $300 RENT ($) HISTORICAL RENTAL & VACANCY RATES BY YEAR 2012 OTHER INDICATORS 2014 2015 MID - 2016 POPULATION SINGLE FAMILY HOUSING RENT $/SF RENT $/SF RENT $/SF RENT $/SF RENT $/SF LOCATION RESIDENTS 5YR AVG. INCREASE YEAR AVERAGE HOME PRICE N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Orem 93,130 1.38% 2013 $243,000 1 Bed 1 Bath $672 $1.06 $693 $1.02 $755 $1.15 $779 $1.18 $804 $1.20 Provo 118,148 0.50% 2014 $259,000 2 Bed 1 Bath $720 $0.86 $685 $0.81 $756 $0.88 $799 $0.93 $843 $0.98 Utah County 551,891 2.26% 2015 $275,000 2 Bed 2 Bath $899 $0.92 $953 $0.96 $959 $0.93 $985 $1.01 $1,011 $1.10 State of Utah 3,000,000 1.68% 2016 $284,000 3 Bed 2 Bath $952 $0.83 $975 $0.88 $1,014 $0.92 $1,092 $0.96 $1,170 $1.01 Overall $0.92 $807 $0.91 CATEGORY Studio $788 $820 $1.00 $885 $1.04 $950 Source: U.S. Census Bureau Source: WFR Multiple Listing Service $1.08 Source: CBRE, Inc. CURRENT RENTAL & VACANCY RATES BY SIZE 50 - 99 UNITS 100+ UNITS OVERALL CATEGORY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY Studio $409 $0.89 $709 $1.36 $592 $1.19 1 Bed 1 Bath $688 $1.06 $815 $1.22 $826 $1.27 2 Bed 1 Bath $889 $0.89 $836 $1.00 $843 $1.03 2 Bed 2 Bath $955 $0.95 $1,011 $1.10 $1,138 $1.20 $1,182 $1.01 3 Bed 2 Bath $1,057 $0.97 Overall $811 $0.97 1.3% $961 $1.09 $1,209 $1.07 3.3% $950 $1.08 THE ALLOY AT GENEVA 3.2% Source: Western States Multifamily. Maps as of June 2016. Source: CBRE, Inc. © 2016 CBRE, Inc. 16 © 2016 CBRE, Inc. 17 Aldara Saratoga Springs Seasons at Traverse Mountain Cresthaven Lofts at Ivory Ridge Traverse Towns American Fork Vintaro Meadows Millpond Bella Grace Viewpointe Residences at Mayfield Grove Crest Villas Avalon Senior Living Lincoln Square Waters Edge Concord at Geneva Mill Pointe at Geneva Alloy at Geneva Siena Villas The Boulevard Cherry Hill Residences at Montveal Canyon View Crossing Sun Canyon Villas The Aston at University Place Midtown 360 Parkway Lofts Parc on Center The Aston at University Place - Ph 2 Midtown Village Ridgeline Townhomes Arbors on the Avenue Riverview Lakeview Court Rowland Heights Village at South Campus Woodland Heights The Old Chapel St. Francis Eighty East 63 Center Savoy Liberty Center 200 Cityview Central Park Station Startup Crossing Outlook Springville Seniors on Main The Depot UNITS 240 252 440 344 45 92 270 252 142 213 24 288 214 162 90 239 227 304 468 324 81 110 74 132 180 84 237 286 332 168 241 225 85 68 48 44 128 236 71 15 42 77 41 121 120 139 59 100 260 25 120 STATUS Completed Potential Start Completed Completed Completed Under Construction Potential Start Potential Start Potential Start Potential Start Under Construction Completed Completed Completed Completed Potential Start Potential Start Completed Potential Start Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed Under Construction Under Construction Under Construction Under Construction Completed Potential Start Potential Start Potential Start Potential Start Under Construction Completed Potential Start Completed Under Construction Completed Completed Potential Start Completed Potential Start Under Construction Under Construction Under Construction Completed Completed Completed Potential Start 8,579 Total Units Completed (24) 3,959 Units Under Construction (11) 1,492 Units Potential Start (16) 3,128 Units TOC 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 2016 FIRST HALF GREATER SALT LAKE AREA MULTIFAMILY REPORT DAVIS COUNTY DAVIS COUNTY: MULTIFAMILY COMPLETED 2011 - 2016/PIPELINE VACANCY 2.9% # NAME RENT $871 RENT GROWTH (H1 2016) 4.3% OVERALL VACANCY AND RENT $900 9.0% 8.0% $800 7.0% $700 6.0% 5.0% $600 4.0% $500 3.0% 2.0% $400 0.0% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 VACANCY (%) Source: CBRE, Inc. 2012 2014 2015 MID-2016 OTHER INDICATORS 2013 2014 2015 POPULATION MID - 2016 CATEGORY RENT $/SF RENT $/SF RENT $/SF RENT $/SF RENT $/SF LOCATION Studio $437 $1.19 $437 $1.05 $439 $1.05 $563 $1.54 $551 $1.49 Bountiful City 1 Bed 1 Bath $625 $1.05 $666 $0.98 $721 $1.09 $707 $1.16 $740 $1.22 2 Bed 1 Bath $677 $0.78 $717 $0.82 $769 $0.83 $818 $0.92 $895 $1.01 2 Bed 2 Bath $830 $0.88 $868 $0.91 $827 $0.94 $903 $1.00 $954 $1.05 3 Bed 2 Bath $915 $0.79 $887 $0.76 $970 $0.82 $1,016 $0.89 $1,123 $0.98 Overall $0.86 $756 $0.85 $796 $0.92 $720 2013 RENT ($) RENTAL & VACANCY RATES BY YEAR 2012 $300 $793 $1.00 $871 SINGLE FAMILY HOUSING Under Construction 2 Clearfield Station 216 Potential Start 3 West Square 149 Potential Start 4 Greyhawk Homes 114 Under Construction 5 Eastgate at Greyhawk 108 Completed 6 Seasons at Layton 164 Completed 7 Villas Apartments 144 Completed 8 Angels Landing Townhomes 24 Completed 9 Fernwood Place 74 Completed 10 Village at Church & Main 56 Completed 11 Legacy Cottages 150 Completed 12 Kay’s Crossing 156 Completed 13 Creekside Oaks 24 Completed 14 Orchard Farms 80 Completed 15 Farmington Crossing 93 Completed 16 Park Lane Village 324 Completed 17 Farmington Station 140 Under Construction 18 Residences at Station Park 431 Potential Start 19 Legacy Crossing 206 Completed 20 The Park at Legacy Trails 162 Under Construction 5YR AVG. INCREASE YEAR AVERAGE HOME PRICE 43,784 0.56% 2013 $237,000 21 Huntington 70 Completed Layton City 74,143 1.96% 2014 $238,000 22 Olson Apartments 112 Potential Start Davis County 336,043 1.92% 2015 $263,000 23 Hills at Renaissance 107 Completed State of Utah 3,000,000 1.68% 2016 $281,000 24 Woods Cross 242 Potential Start 25 Woods Cross Townhomes 72 Potential Start 26 Hampton Place 210 Completed 27 Ridgeview 122 Completed 28 Eaglewood Lofts 122 Completed Source: U.S. Census Bureau Source: WFR Multiple Listing Service $1.07 CURRENT RENTAL & VACANCY RATES CATEGORY 122 RESIDENTS Source: CBRE, Inc. BY SIZE STATUS Sand Ridge 4,208 Total Units 50 - 99 UNITS 100+ UNITS OVERALL RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY Studio $450 $1.25 $571 $1.54 $551 $1.49 1 Bed 1 Bath $680 $1.09 $745 $1.23 $729 $1.21 2 Bed 1 Bath $793 $0.86 $898 $1.01 $895 $1.01 2 Bed 2 Bath $831 $0.90 $968 $1.06 $961 $1.07 3 Bed 2 Bath $947 $0.88 Overall $739 $0.95 $1,134 $0.98 1.47% $882 $1.08 $1,086 $0.95 3.03% $871 $1.07 EAGLEWOOD LOFTS 2.9% Source: CBRE, Inc. © 2016 CBRE, Inc. Source: Western States Multifamily. Maps as of June 2016. 18 © 2016 CBRE, Inc. 19 Completed (18) 2,448 Units Under Construction (4) 538 Units Potential Start (6) 1,222 Units TOC TOC 1.0% UNITS 1 2016 FIRST HALF GREATER SALT LAKE AREA MULTIFAMILY REPORT WEBER COUNTY: MULTIFAMILY COMPLETED/PIPELINE - 2011-2016 WEBER COUNTY VACANCY 3.5% # NAME RENT $783 RENT GROWTH (H1 2016) 5.4% OVERALL VACANCY AND RENT 10.0% $900 9.0% $800 8.0% 7.0% $700 6.0% $600 5.0% 4.0% $500 3.0% 2.0% 1 Station at Pleasant View 144 Completed 2 Station at Pleasant View - Phase 3 128 Completed 3 The Cove at Pleasant View 88 Completed 4 Mountain View Townhomes 58 Completed 5 Mountain View Townhomes Ph 2&3 87 Under Construction 6 North Ogden Townhomes 79 Potential Start 7 Village at Prominence Point 339 Potential Start 8 Lomond View 38 Under Construction 9 The View on 20th 148 Completed 10 Colonial Court 73 Completed 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 VACANCY (%) Source: CBRE, Inc. 2012 2013 2014 2015 MID-2016 $300 RENT ($) RENTAL & VACANCY RATES BY YEAR 2012 11 View at the Junction 40 Completed 12 Tower View Apartments 144 Under Construction OTHER INDICATORS 13 Imagine Jefferson 59 Completed 2013 2014 2015 MID - 2016 SINGLE FAMILY HOUSING POPULATION 14 Imagine Jefferson - Phase 2 113 Under Construction 15 Garden City 61 Under Construction CATEGORY RENT $/SF RENT $/SF RENT $/SF RENT $/SF RENT $/SF LOCATION RESIDENTS 5YR AVG. INCREASE YEAR AVERAGE HOME PRICE Studio $460 $1.15 $429 $1.11 $432 $1.11 $482 $1.28 $532 $1.45 Ogden City 84,444 0.64% 2013 $243,000 1 Bed 1 Bath $587 $0.82 $638 $0.82 $653 $0.80 $679 $0.88 $705 $0.96 Riverdale 41,900 1.08% 2014 $168,000 16 Bouwhuis Apartments 216 Potential Start 2 Bed 1 Bath $681 $0.73 $662 $0.71 $710 $0.76 $728 $0.77 $747 $0.79 Weber County 243,645 1.68% 2015 $182,000 17 Claradon Village 192 Under Construction 2 Bed 2 Bath $774 $0.72 $820 $0.71 $826 $0.68 $856 $0.75 $885 $0.81 State of Utah 3,000,000 1.58% 2016 $213,000 3 Bed 2 Bath $837 $0.73 $869 $0.64 $897 $0.66 $924 $0.69 $950 $0.72 18 Claradon Village - Phase 2 108 Potential Start Overall $0.75 $678 $0.73 $698 $0.75 $740 $0.79 $783 $0.82 19 Station Square 31 Under Construction 20 Aderra 114 Under Construction $655 Source: U.S. Census Bureau Source: WFR Multiple Listing Service Source: CBRE, Inc. CURRENT RENTAL & VACANCY RATES BY SIZE 2,260 Total Units 50 - 99 UNITS 100+ UNITS OVERALL CATEGORY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY RENT $/SF VACANCY Studio $469 $1.23 $532 $1.45 $532 $1.42 1 Bed 1 Bath $652 $0.85 $710 $0.97 $701 $0.95 2 Bed 1 Bath $799 $0.83 $737 $0.78 $738 $0.78 2 Bed 2 Bath $870 $0.84 $887 $0.80 $885 $0.81 $952 $0.73 3 Bed 2 Bath $928 $0.63 Overall $791 $0.78 9.8% $783 $0.83 $926 $0.72 2.6% $783 $0.82 CLARADON VILLAGE 3.5% Source: CBRE, Inc. © 2016 CBRE, Inc. Source: Western States Multifamily. Maps as of June 2016. 20 © 2016 CBRE, Inc. 21 Completed (8) 738 Units Under Construction (8) 780 Units Potential Start (4) 742 Units TOC TOC STATUS $400 1.0% 0.0% UNITS 2016 FIRST HALF GREATER SALT LAKE AREA MULTIFAMILY REPORT DEBT MARKETS CBRE’S UNPARALLELED MULTIFAMILY RESOURCES ARE NOW IN UTAH As depicted in the graph below, overall multifamily finance volume has risen for six consecutive years, increasing by 335% between 2009-2015. Agency lenders (Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and HUD) represented 88% of overall volume in 2009 vs. 51% in 2015, as the full range of capital sources has become increasingly active and competitive for multifamily assets. CBRE welcomes Patrick Bodnar as a multifamily specialist. Patrick has been selling multifamily properties for over 15 years and joins Eli Mills, who has been advising clients in commercial real estate investment for over 20 years. Throughout their careers Patrick and Eli have closed over 500 transactions and sold or advised on several billion dollars of investment real estate for private and institutional clients. To create the most comprehensive multifamily market data available for the Greater Salt Lake marketplace, CBRE has also added a local market research team. ESTIMATED MULTIFAMILY FINANCE VOLUME BY LENDER TYPE (BILLIONS) $250 $213 $225 $200 $169 $175 $149 $150 $101 $100 2015 U.S. APARTMENT RANKINGS (BILLIONS) $124 $119 $125 25.0 $88 $75 $64 $56 $49 $50 20.0 TOC TOC Nationally, CBRE’s multifamily investment sales totaled $24.69 billion in 2015 with the nearest competitor closing less than half as much sales volume. With 65 locations and over 300 multifamily professionals, including direct lending services, CBRE’s unparalleled multifamily platform now has a presence in Utah, providing clients with the greatest market exposure available. $25 $0 2006 (% Change YoY) 2007 Up 18% Fannie Mae 2008 Down 46% 2009 Down 23% Freddie Mac 2010 Up 14% HUD 2011 Up 57% 2012 Up 41% 2013 Up 20% Banks & Credit Unions Other 2014 Up 13% 2015 Up 26% Life Companies 15.0 CMBS Source: CBRE, Inc. CURRENT LENDING PARAMETERS LENDER TYPE MAX LTV AMORTIZATION TERM Fannie Mae 75-80% 30 years 10-YR PRICING* PREPAYMENT PENALTY 5-12 years up to 30/30 1-5 years 3.75 - 4.00% Yield Maintenance (YM) No • Favorable interest rate environment continues Freddie Mac 75-80% 30 years 5-10 years up to 30/30 1-5 years 3.75 - 4.00% Defeasance or YM No HUD 85-90% 35 years 35/35 years None 3.50 - 3.75% Stepdown (10-1%) No • Diminishing lender appetite for new construction projects Banks 70-75% 25 years 5-10 years None (typically) 4.00 - 4.25% Stepdown (3-1%) Yes • Agency emphasis on deal types that don’t count against their lending cap: Credit Unions 70-75% 25 years 5-10 years None (typically) 4.00 - 4.25% None Yes o Life Companies 65-70% 25-30 years 5-10 years up to 25/25 At lower leverage 3.25 - 3.50% YM No CMBS 5-10 years Defeasance or YM No 70-75% 30 years INTEREST ONLY 2-4 years 4.00 - 4.25% RECOURSE MULTIFAMILY FINANCE MARKET: HIGHLIGHTS/TRENDS • 2016 year-to-date volume on pace with 2015 levels Source: Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac 10-Ks, American Council of Life Insurers (ACLI), FDIC, Trepp, Mortgage Bankers Association & Fannie Mae Multifamily Economic Research Group *Approximate pricing as of September 2016; Credit Union pricing assumes 5-year rate resets Small: Fewer than 50 units Affordable: More than 50% of units at or below 80% AMI 10.0 5.0 0.0 CBRE o Green: Qualifies for recognized green building certification HFF MARCUS & MILLICHAP NEWMARK GRUBB KNIGHT FRANK EASTDIL SECURED 22 BERKADIA CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD Source: Real Capital Analytics o With the powerful resources of CBRE’s national multifamily platform, along with the most comprehensive local market research, CBRE Multifamily in Salt Lake City is ready to help investors maximize the value of their assets. Disclaimers: Terms represent typical parameters by lender type; actual loan terms are deal-specific; will vary based on leverage, term, quality, location, etc. Terms assume standard permanent loans for each lender type additional options available on floating rate and/or shorter term (bridge) options. © 2016 CBRE, Inc. JLL © 2016 CBRE, Inc. 23 For a market analysis on your property or more information contact: CAPITAL MARKETS Patrick Bodnar Senior Associate +1 801 869 8053 [email protected] Eli Mills Senior Vice President +1 801 869 8029 [email protected] DEBT & STRUCTURED FINANCE Doug Birrell First Vice President +1 801 869 8029 [email protected]
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz