Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in

!
!"#$ %&'()*+,(-$.',/0($
"#$! !
!
"%&'()*+&+),(-+%*)!./-!$*0(1,2!34,%-)56%,7!%&'!8(49,:-+)56(-6(+,!;<(-*4&=>!
?@#ABC?! !
?(&,-41!C.-+54&!B:-(),)!?:**+))+:&!
<DE! !
!
<-:))!D:*(),+5!E-:'%5,!
<FB! !
!
<1:G41!F&H+-:&*(&,!B45+1+,=!
<AI! !
!
D(%,)56(!<()(11)564.,!./-!A&,(-&4,+:&41(!I%)4**(&4-G(+,!;<(-*4&=>!
$3DE!!
!
$&+,('!34,+:&)!D(H(1:J*(&,!E-:K-4**(!
$3B???!
!
$&+,('!34,+:&)!B-4*(0:-9!?:&H(&,+:&!:&!?1+*4,(!?64&K(!
$3BEC!
!
$&+,('!34,+:&)!E:J%14,+:&!B%&'!
$LDL! !
!
$&+,('!L,4,()!D(J4-,*(&,!:.!L,4,(!
!
!
?:H(-+&K!4&!4-(4!:.!4G:%,!MN2OPO!)Q%4-(!9+1:*(,(-)!;$LDL2!MORO>2!,6(!8(J%G1+5!:.!FQ%4,:-+41!<%+&(4!+)!:&(!:.!,6(!)*411(),!5:%&,-+()!+&!
5:&,+&(&,41!C.-+54S!T6(!5:%&,-=!5:&)+),)!:.!*4+&14&'!J-:H+&5()!:&!C.-+54·)!0(),(-&!5:4),!,64,!4-(!G:-'(-('!G=!?4*(-::&!,:!,6(!&:-,6!
4&'!<4G:&!,:!,6(!(4),2!4&'!.+H(!+&64G+,('!+)14&')³+&51%'+&K!,6(!H:154&+5!+)14&'!:.!"+:9:!:&!06+56!,6(!)(4,!:.!K:H(-&*(&,!+)!1:54,('!
;$LDL2!MORO>S!?:&)+),(&,!0+,6!+,)!)*411!)+7(2!FQ%4,:-+41!<%+&(4!+)!:&(!:.!,6(!1(4),!J:J%14,('!5:%&,-+()!+&!C.-+542!64H+&K!4&! (),+*4,('!
J:J%14,+:&!;+&!MORO>!:.!OSU!*+11+:&!;$3BEC2!MORO>SRRV!!
!
T6(!(5:&:*=!:.!FQ%4,:-+41!<%+&(4!64)!K-:0&!-4J+'1=!+&!-(5(&,!=(4-)2!.%(11('!G=!,6(!(WJ1:+,4,+:&!:.!14-K(!:..)6:-(!:+1!'(J:)+,)SRRX!T6(!
5:%&,-=·)! <DE! J(-! 54J+,4! :.! $LYVU2ZOO! ;MORO! (),S>! -4&9)! MN,6! +&! ,6(! 0:-1'! ;?AC2! MORRK>S! [:0(H(-2! ,6(! 5:%&,-=! 64)! 4! 6+K6! 1(H(1! :.!
+&5:*(!'+)J4-+,=\!*%56!:.!,6(!5:%&,-=·)!J:J%14,+:&!5:&,+&%()!,:!1+H(!+&!J:H(-,=SRRP!C)!)%562!,6(!5:%&,-=!-4&9)!RRU!:%,!:.!R]Z!5:%&,-+()!
:&!,6(!$3DE![%*4&!D(H(1:J*(&,!A&'(W!;$3DE2!MORO>S!!
!
!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
RRV!7KHFRXQWU\·VSRSXODWLRQLVH[SHFWHGWRUHDFKRSX!*+11+:&!+&!MOPO!;$3BEC2!MORO>S!!
RRX!,QGXVWU\LVWKHVRXUFHRISHUFHQWRIWKHFRXQWU\·VHFRQRPLFDFWLYLW\DQGLQFOXGHVSHWUROHXPQDWXUDOJDVWLPEHUDQGIL)6+&K!;$LDL2!MORO6>S!!
RRP!""?!3(0)2!6,,J^__&(0)SGG5S5:S%9_M_6+_4.-+54_5:%&,-=`J-:.+1()_ROMVRPRS),*\!4&'!?AC2!6,,J)^__000S5+4SK:H_1+G-4-=_J%G1+54,+:&)_,6(a0:-1'a
.45,G::9_K(:)_(9S6,*1!!
$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8'113%#4*-'60!
!""#
!
!"#!$%&'%'()*#+,,$-#%*$#./()/('(,-#
"#$%#&'()*! ('+! %,&-'(,)! ./+'! ),0'1! ,$! '1#! #2/-',03! '1#! &%(4-'#! ,$! 52/-',0(-%! 6/()#-! (+! '0,7(&-%! 8('1! 9(+'0(&'! 8#'! -)9! 90:! +#-+,)+;!
<#47#0-'/0#+!'10,/*1,/'!'1#!:#-0!0-)*#!$0,4!=>,!',!=?,@3!8('1!'1#!8#'!+#-+,)!,&&/00()*!A#'8##)!B70(%!',!C&',A#03!9#7#)9()*!/7,)!
'1#!D#+'!B$0(&-)!E,)+,,);!<1#!&,-+'-%!0#*(,)+!-0#!8#''#0!'1-)!'1#!()'#0(,0!FE&G8##)#:! #'!-%;3!=HHIJ;!G()&#!KLMH3!'#47#0-'/0#+!1-N#!
A##)!,A+#0N#9!',!()&0#-+#!A:!H;M,@!-)9!0-()$-%%!',!9#&0#-+#!A:!>;O44!7#0!4,)'1!F,0!=;K!7#0!&#)'J!7#0!9#&-9#;!!
!
@%(4-'#! 9-'-! $,0! 52/-',0(-%! 6/()#-! (+! *#)#0-%%:! 8#-P3! 81(&1! 4-P#+! '1#! 9#N#%,74#)'! ,$! &%(4-'#! 70,.#&'(,)+! &1-%%#)*()*;! BN-(%-A%#!
70,.#&'(,)+!+/**#+'!'1-'!4,9#0-'#!()&0#-+#!()!'#47#0-'/0#!FK!',!=;?,@J!&,/%9!,&&/0!A:!=HMH3!()&0#-+#!',!K;>!',!Q;K,@!A:!=HLH+;!R,++(A%#!
&1-)*#+!()!4#-)!-))/-%!0-()$-%%!-0#!%#++!&%#-03!0-)*()*!$0,4!-!9#&%()#!,$!M!7#0!&#)'!',!-)!()&0#-+#!,$!=H!7#0!&#)'!A:!=HLH;!@%(4-'#!4,9#%+!
A0,-9%:!#S7#&'!-!+%(*1'!()&0#-+#!F$0,4!TK!7#0!&#)'!',!UK=!7#0!&#)'J!()!'1#!70,7,0'(,)!,$!','-%!0-()$-%%!'1-'!$-%%+!()!1#-N:!#N#)'+;!G#-!%#N#%!
0(+#! #+'(4-'#+! 0-)*#! $0,4! H;K>! 4#'#0+! ',! H;?M! 4#'#0+! A:! =HLH3! 9#7#)9()*! ,)! '1#! #4(++(,)+! +&#)-0(,! FE&G8##)#:! #'! -%;3! =HHIV! D,0%9!
W-)P3!);9;J;!!
!
52/-',0(-%!6/()#-!1-+!),'!:#'!&,47%#'#9!-!X-'(,)-%!@,44/)(&-'(,)!,0!,'1#0!-++#++4#)'!,$!('+!N/%)#0-A(%(':!',!&%(4-'#!&1-)*#;!Y)!'1#!
-A+#)&#!,$!'1#+#!#$$,0'+3!'1#!N/%)#0-A(%(':!,$!52/-',0(-%!6/()#-!',!&%(4-'#!&1-)*#3!,0!,$!-770,70(-'#!-9-7'-'(,)!4#-+/0#+3!1-+!),'!:#'!
A##)!(9#)'($(#9!A:!'1#!&,/)'0:;!
!
0"#+%'()*%1#2,3,1#.)1(4(,-#%*$#5'/%',6(4#7)489,*'-#
Z#+7('#! A#()*! -! 7-0':! ',! '1#! [)('#9! X-'(,)+! \0-4#8,0P! @,)N#)'(,)! ,)! @%(4-'#! @1-)*#! F[X\@@@J3! -)9! 1-N()*! 0-'($(#9! '1#! ]:,',!
R0,',&,%!F=HHIJ3!52/-',0(-%!6/()#-!1-+!),'!:#'!-77%(#9!$,0!-!*0-)'!',!$()-)&#!'1#!70#7-0-'(,)!,$!('+!()('(-%!X-'(,)-%!@,44/)(&-'(,)!',!
'1#![X\@@@;!B+!8#%%3!+()&#!'1#!&,/)'0:!(+!),'!-)!^Z@3!('!8(%%!),'!A#!70,9/&()*!-!X-'(,)-%!B9-7'-'(,)!R0,*0-44#!,$!B&'(,);!@%(4-'#!
&1-)*#!-%+,!9,#+!),'!-77#-0!()!'1#!&,/)'0:·+!Z#N#%,74#)'!B++(+'-)&#!\0-4#8,0P!F=HHOJ;!!
!
:"#:8//,*'#!$%&'%'()*#!4'()*#
CN#0-%%3! N#0:! %(''%#! (+! /)9#08-:! ,)! &%(4-'#! &1-)*#! -9-7'-'(,)! ()! 52/-',0(-%! 6/()#-V! '1#! &,/)'0:! (+! &/00#)'%:! ,)%:! ()N,%N#9³',! -)!
/)&#0'-()!9#*0##³()!,)#!0#*(,)-%!()('(-'(N#;!B+!-!4#4A#0!,$!'1#!@#)'0-%!B$0(&-)!\,0#+'+!@,44(++(,)!F@CEY\B@J3!52/-',0(-%!6/()#-!
8(%%!A#)#$('!$0,4!'1#(0!&/00#)'!70,.#&'!,)!&%(4-'#!&1-)*#!+&#)-0(,+!$,0!'1#!@,)*,!W-+();!!<1#!#S'#)'!,$!-&'(N('(#+!A#()*!&-00(#9!,/'!()!
52/-',0(-%! 6/()#-! /)9#0! '1#! 70,.#&'! (+! /)P),8)3! A/'! ('! (+! 1,7#9! '1-'! '1#+#! +&#)-0(,+! 8(%%! #)-A%#! 9#&(+(,)! 4-P#0+! '10,/*1,/'! '1#!
@CEY\B@!0#*(,)!',!-9-7'!-)9!70#7-0#!'1#(0!)-'/0-%!0#+,/0&#!4-)-*#4#)'!+'0-'#*(#+!',!4##'!'1#!0#*(,)-%!&1-%%#)*#+!,$!&%(4-'#!&1-)*#!
$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8'113%#4*-'60!
!"!#
!
"#$%&!'()(*+!,-./012&!345/.-67/1!8579:/!7;!9-.!</6.!-=!.>:!<6-?:@.!´A1.:679B!.>:!C17D/.:!-=!E-F:6.2!59G:6!C17D/.:!C>/9B:H!I>:!=-6:;.;!
-=!C-9B-!#/;79µ))J!G:;<7.:!0:79B!-9:!-=!;7K!C-9B-!#/;[email protected]:;+!!
!
!"#$%&'(&)*++%,-&./"0-"-12,&3+24%5-6&",/&3+27+"86&"5-19%&1,&:;*"-2+1"$&<*1,%"&
="8%&
>#4%5-19%6&
?*,/%+@6A&
B80$%8%,-1,7& !C0%&2D&
.7%,5C@6A&
0+24%5-&
E*+"-12,&
3+12+1-C&
F%5-2+@6A&
<%27+"0G15&
D25*6&@1D&",CA&
3"+-1510"-12,&1,&H%712,"$&",/&<$2#"$&.5-12,6&
!:
,$ 4(;10&$,<1/=&$>7&/1.(*?$
+*.$0<&$,*/=*$@1?(/!!A$
B<&$6.*C&70$1(;?$0*$6.*'(2&$/10(*/14$1/2$ @9I$JK&2&.14$ NPQ$1/2$
.&=(*/14$2&7(?(*/D;1E&.?$)(0<$74(;10&$
9(/(?0.G$+*.$0<&$ ,R9PK5,$
7<1/=&$?7&/1.(*?$0<10$<1'&$F&&/$
L/'(.*/;&/0H$
7147-410&2$?6&7(+(7144G$+*.$0<&$,*/=*$@1?(/H$ M10-.&$
1/2$)<(7<$)(44$&/1F4&$0<&;$0*$12160$
,*/?&.'10(*/$
/10-.14$.&?*-.7&$;1/1=&;&/0$?0.10&=(&?$ 1/2$M-74&1.$
0*$74(;10&$7<1/=&:$
>1+&0GH$
N&.;1/GO$
%&?&1.7<$
#""S$Ȃ$#"!!$ ,4(;10&$
(/+*.;10(*/$
?&.'(7&?$
!"#$%&'($
,R9PK5,$
[email protected]/2(H$
,1;&.**/H$
,5%H$,<12H$
,*/=*H$T%,H$
LU-10*.(14$
N-(/&1H$
N1F*/H$
%)1/21H$>1*$
B*;&$1/2$
3.(/7(6&O$
)'*+,-&./#$&0*1-$'2&($9*.&$(/+*.;10(*/$.&U-(.&2*
!
!"#$%&'&()*#+*,'-,-.&/#+0-.&/#
87F:9! .>/.! 345/.-67/1! 8579:/! >/;! 2:.! 0::9! /@.7F:12! :9B/B:G! -9! /GG6:;;79B! .>:! 7D</@.;! -=! @17D/.:! @>/9B:&! .>:! @-59.62! >/;! 9-.! 2:.!
G:F:1-<:G!/92!=-6D/1&!<6-<-;:G!/G/<./.7-9!/@.7-9;+!
!
1"#+(()((2)/-#
L:62!17..1:!M-6N!-9!@17D/.:!@>/9B:!/G/<./.7-9!7;!59G:6M/2!79!345/.-67/1!8579:/+!$-;.!-=!.>:!B-F:69D:9.·;!:9:6B2!-9!@17D/.:!@>/9B:!7;!
0:79B!<5.!.-M/6G;!=-6:;.62O0/;:G!D7.7B/.7-9!<6-?:@.;+!I-!D/N:!<6-B6:;;!-9!.>7;!7;;5:&!/!=76;.!;.:<!=-6!.>:[email protected]!@-51G!0:!.-!<6:</6:!7.;!
P76;.!,/.7-9/1!C-DD597@/.7-9!.-!.>:!%,PCCC+!A;!</6.!-=!.>7;!:K:6@7;:&!/!@17D/.:!F519:6/0717.2!/;;:;;D:9.!D5;.!0:!@-9G5@.:G!02!.>:!
B-F:69D:9.&! /9G! /<<6-<67/.:! 6:;<-9;:! ;.6/.:B7:;! /6:! .-! 0:! 7G:9.7=7:G+! 87F:9! .>:! 6:B7-9/1! <6-?:@.7-9;! -=! @17D/.:! @>/9B:! /9G! .6:9G;! 79!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
))J!QRSC&!>..<HTTMMM+7G6@+@/T@@//T:FO)'UVW'O'()X)(YZ[VO)OQRSCXAR$XQ,P\+>.D1!!
))U!#$%&!>..<HTTMMM+0D5ON17D/;@>5.]797.7/.7F:+G:T:9T<6-?:@.;^<_)`G_VV(!!
%&'(&)$*+$,-..&/0$1/2$341//&2$5216010(*/$570(*/8$9(224&$5+.(71!
!"#$
!
"#$%&'()$"%! *(+",)$#-! ./0'("1! 203#)(("! 0"4! 56(! 7(38! #! 9)$"*$:#;1! $,! *0"! '#! #<:#*,#4! ,&0,! =>+0,()$0?! /+$"#0! @$??! A0*#! -$3$?0)!
*&0??#"%#-!$"!&#0?,&1!0%)$*+?,+)#1!*(0-,0?!B("#!30"0%#3#",1!A)#-&@0,#)!)#-(+)*#-!0"4!#"#)%CD!7&#-#!*&0??#"%#-!"##4!,(!'#!$4#",$A$#4!'C!
,&#!%(E#)"3#",!0"4!$",#%)0,#4!$",(!"0,$("0?!4#*$-$("F!0"4!:(?$*CF30G$"%D!7&#!0'-#"*#!(A!"0,$("0?!*?$30,#!$"A()30,$("!0?-(!$"4$*0,#-!,&#!
"##4!A()!$3:)(E#4!*?$30,#!40,0!*(??#*,$("!0"4!@#0,&#)!3("$,()$"%!
!
!
!"#"$"%&"'()
H+"4#-3$"$-,#)$+3-!AI)!J3@#?,1!K0,+)-*&+,B!+"4!L#0G,()$-*&#)&#$,!MHNJO!.PQRQ;D!2?$30,#!2&0"%#!5*#"0)$(-!A()!,&#!2("%(!H0-$"D!
L#,)$#E#4!A)(3!&,,:STT@@@D'3+FG?$30-*&+,B$"$,$0,$E#D4#T#"T:)(U#*,-V:WRX4WYYQ!!
!
2#",)0?!Z",#??$%#"*#![%#"*C!M2Z[O!.PQRR%;D!\()?4!]0*,'((GS!=>+0,()$0?!/+$"#0D!^0-,!+:40,#4!RR!]#')+0)C!PQRRD!L#,)$#E#4!A)(3S!
&,,:-STT@@@D*$0D%(ET?$')0)CT:+'?$*0,$("-T,&#F@()?4FA0*,'((GT%#(-T#GD&,3?D!!
)
N*5@##"#C1!2D1!ND!K#@!0"4!/D!^$B*0"(!.PQQ_;D!JK`9!2?$30,#!2&0"%#!2(+",)C!9)(A$?#-S!=>+0,()$0?!/+$"#0D!J"$,#4!K0,$("-!
`#E#?(:3#",!9)(%)033#!0"4!J"$E#)-$,C!(A!a<A()4S!a<A()4D!
)
J"$,#4!K0,$("-!`#E#?(:3#",!9)(%)033#!MJK`9O!.PQRQ;D!!"#$%&'()(*+,#(%-&.(,+/-&01213&45(&.($*&6($*-5&+7&8$-9+%:3&;$-5<$=:&-+&!"#$%&
'()(*+,#(%-D!JK`9S!K#@!b()GD!
)
J"$,#4!K0,$("-!9(:+?0,$("!]+"4!MJK]9[O!.PQRQ;D!>-$-(&+7&6+/*?&;+,"*$-9+%&01213&@/+#&A+%7*9B-&$%?&A/9:9:&-+&.(%(<$*3&C(%(/$-9+%:&+7&A5$%D(D!
JK9]S!K#@!b()GD!!
!
J"$,#4!5,0,#-!`#:0),3#",!(A!5,0,#!MJ5`5O!.PQRQ;D!H0*G%)(+"4!K(,#S!=>+0,()$0?!/+$"#0D!L#,)$#E#4!A)(3!
&,,:STT@@@D-,0,#D%(ET)T:0T#$T'%"TcPPRD&,3!
!
\()?4!H0"G!.+"40,#4;D!2?$30,#!2&0"%#!d"(@?#4%#!9(),0?D!L#,)$#E#4!A)(3!&,,:STT-4@#'<D@()?4'0"GD()%T*?$30,#:(),0?T&
!
!
%&'(&)$*+$,-..&/0$1/2$341//&2$5216010(*/$570(*/8$9(224&$5+.(71!
!"#$