1 Running Head: Using Young Adult Literature in the Classroom-Connecting to Classics Using Young Adult Literature in the Classroom-Connecting to Classics Amanda Viau The University of Akron 2 It is no surprise that students are not as interested in reading when they are constantly faced with video games, television shows, movies, and computers. They are so full of technology that reading seems to become a chore, something they are forced to do by their English teachers. However, students who read develop better writing, spelling, and speaking skills so it is necessary as teachers to try and interest them in reading. The best opportunity to help them become readers is by introducing them to the world of young adult literature. Young adult literature can help students learn more about themselves, other cultures or people, current events, or simply learn to enjoy reading. For a novel to be considered young adult literature it needs to meet a number of criteria, according to Sarah K. Herz and Donald A. Gallo (2005) in their book From Hinton to Hamlet. The novels need to have main characters who are teenagers, most often a first person point of view, be told in the voice of a teenager, have language typical of teenagers and vocabulary for average readers, have a setting that is most often contemporary and in the United States, possess characters and issues that are relatable, have parents who play a minor role, have a plot and literary style that is uncomplicated but not simplistic, have an outcome that is usually dependent on decisions and actions of main characters, and the tone and outcome are usually upbeat (10). Herz and Gallo also write that all traditional literary elements are present and the very best young adult novels are appealing to adults too. Sarah K. Herz and Donald A. Gallo write ―According to recent research, young adult literature has proven to be an effective means to motivate adolescents to read all kinds of literature, including the classics‖ (14). In the book From Hinton to Hamlet, Herz and Gallo suggest pairing young adult novels with classic novels that have similar themes. Students read the young adult book first and then read the 3 classic. The young adult novel serves as an excellent springboard into the classic and the students are more familiar with the context and content of the classic. Many students in elementary school enjoy reading. They continue this love of reading into middle school and junior high where they are beginning to read the classics. Most students continue to like to read in sixth and seventh grades. However, when they reach eighth grade and beyond, they lose interest in reading because they are forced to only read books they feel cannot be understood or are boring. John H. Bushman (1997) found that ―Sixth and seventh graders were more likely to read young adult literature as assigned reading‖ (36). As the students became older, they were less and less likely to read for pleasure. Many students felt overwhelmed by the assigned reading that they had no time for any other reading. However, Bushman writes, ―In order to help young adults through the difficult time of being adolescents, teachers must provide literature that speaks to the issues facing our students: problems in their physical, intellectual, moral, and reading development‖ (35). For students to enjoy reading, they need to connect to the material. They need to relate to the characters. Many urban students cannot relate to Mr. Darcy in Pride and Prejudice but they can relate to Ponyboy in The Outsiders by S.E. Hinton or Andy in Tears of a Tiger by Sharon Draper. These characters may seem silly to adults but they are real to students. Herz and Gallo write, ―Young adult literature contains many universal themes, including the eternal questions ‗Who am I?‘ and ‗Where do I fit in?‘‖ (14). Young adult literature authors help students answer these questions by presenting real situations that students face such as breaking up with a boyfriend or witnessing their parents go through a divorce. Bushman writes, ―Another task so very important to middle and senior high school students is the struggle for that personal 4 ideology or value system that confronts the adolescent almost everyday. Students just cannot read about this issue when asked to limit their reading to the classics‖ (39). When students are given the option to choose a book to read, they almost never pick a classic. Bushman writes, ―They‘re never going to read Dickens when they get out of school. You need to introduce them to authors they will read‖ (38). During my student teaching, the students had to complete a major writing assignment. I chose to have them write a literary analysis where they analyzed a novel‘s themes, characterization, style, and plot. The students were taken to the university library where they were allowed to choose any book as long as it was at or above their reading level. Herz and Gallo write, ―Choice and self-selection are an important component of reading development‖ (5). Out of 90 students only one chose a classic, Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen. Most of the students chose young adult authors such as Walter Dean Meyers and Sharon Draper. For some of the students, these were the only books they completed all year. When I read their papers, it was clear they enjoyed the novel and identified with the characters. I have a group of African-American boys that are at a sixth-eighth grade reading level and never appear interested when reading Brave New World by Aldous Huxley or Othello by William Shakespeare. They struggle with the readings assigned in class and have a hard time understanding the meaning. However, almost all of this subset enjoyed their independent reading novels. They enjoyed talking about the novels with the rest of the class and talked about the characters as if they were real people. Herz and Gallo write, ―Book discussions with peers is crucial to teen readers; it makes reading a part of the socialization process‖ (6). Students need time to discuss the novels they are reading on their own and also to write about them and reflect. As teachers, we need to realize that 5 many times the only place they are reading is in our classrooms so we need to set aside time where they can read at least a couple times per week. Chris Crowe (2000) writes, ―Give your students time to read in class. Find at least 30 minutes each week when your students can sit and read silently. For many of your kids this will be the only time they have for reading‖ (151). At first, it can be difficult for teachers to give up instructional time but it is vital to give students these opportunities to read. It was truly inspiring to see these students enjoy reading when they seemed to struggle so much in class. Many teachers do not want to teach young adult literature because they still feel it is only for struggling readers. They want to teach the classics because it was what they were taught and what they know. It is true that the reason many books become classics is because they are excellent novels with complex characters, beautiful imagery, and a strong plot. However, young students have a hard time relating to the characters in these novels, Ophelia in Hamlet and Nick in The Great Gatsby. These characters are facing situations that most students have never dealt with. At their basic levels, teachers can help students understand Ophelia by relating it back to relationships that students might be in. However, it is much easier to have them connect with a character like Hiram in Mississippi Trial, 1955 by Chris Crowe. Even though the novel is set in 1955, it was written in 2003. Hiram faces many situations that seem very real to the students, such as his rocky relationship with his father throughout the novel. The novel Mississippi Trial, 1955 has many themes in common with To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee such as the injustice of courts and the attitude of a community. The young adult novel by Chris Crowe can be used to help students better understand Harper Lee‘s novel. Chris Crowe‘s novel possesses many literary elements that are normally found in classics such as 6 imagery, symbolism, figurative language, and foreshadowing. Susan P. Santoli and Mary Elaine Wagner (2004) write, ―Young adult literature can be a vehicle that allows teachers to present the same literary elements found in the classics while engaging students in stimulating classroom discussions and assignments‖ (66). They also write, ―The literary elements and devices that are found in the classics can also be taught through young adult fiction‖ (71). Many English teachers seem to think of young adult literature as ―lesser‖ reading, almost as if they were Harlequin Romances. However, the best young adult novels have all the complexities of a classic but they are more relatable to the students most teachers have in their classrooms. As students begin to read more, they can better appreciate the classics but they need to enjoy reading before they can enjoy reading a classic. I participated in a reading workshop with eleventh graders at Barberton High School in the fall of 2010. The students were given book talks about five different books. The books included The Five People You Meet in Heaven, The Glass Castle, If I Should Die Before I Wake, Ironman, and Make Lemonade. The students then ranked the books they would most like to read and were assigned a group. All five books are contemporary and three of the five are considered young adult literature. Every day the class would start with a mini literature lesson about a literary element such as symbolism or foreshadowing. During that day‘s class, the students would read and find examples of the literary element that had been discussed that day. The students were able to enjoy reading a novel they could relate to and still were learning about literary elements and the complexity they add to a novel. Many people think that because the language in young 7 adult literature is easy to read and understand that the novel itself is very simple. However, this is not the case. Young adult novels are complex and enjoyable. Bushman (1997) writes, ―Statistics from the 1993 National Adult Literacy Survey show that students are not carrying the reading habit into adulthood‖ (38). As mentioned previously, students are not going to graduate high school and continue reading Charles Dickens, Jane Austen, and D.H. Lawrence. As adults, they may choose to read these authors, but if they are readers they are going to also read authors like Stephen King, John Grisham, and James Patterson. It is vital that teachers help students find pleasure in reading not only classics but also more contemporary novels so students realize there are vast amounts of literature they will enjoy. There are many different categories of young adult literature such as fantasy, mystery, romance, drama, historical fiction, and the list goes on and on. Teachers need to get to know their students on a personal level so they can help the students find books they will enjoy. Teachers need to be familiar with a wide variety of young adult authors and novels and should assemble a classroom library as well as receiving help from the school library. Teachers can make surveys that will help identify what novels a student might be interested in reading. They can also give book talks about certain books and have students recommend books. Some teachers keep a Rolex of very short book reviews that students have written to help other students find a novel that might interest them. It is no surprise that the students who are the best writers and speakers also enjoy reading so it is paramount that teachers find a way for students to read more. Another reason to include young adult literature in the classroom is because it opens up the possibility to discuss events that are occurring in modern society. Students 8 can make connections between Brave New World by Aldous Huxley and modern society but they can truly analyze modern society when reading Purple Heart by Patricia Mccormick, which is about the Iraq war. It is simply impossible for students to read about current events in books that are 200 years old. While connections can be made, it is more imperative that students read first hand accounts written by people who have witnessed some of the worst and greatest events of the 21 st century. Thomas Philion (2009) writes, ―I believe that literature opens up windows on the world just as clear and powerful as the vantage points provided by statistics, interviews, polls, journalism, and even science‖ (47). There is an old adage that writers write what they know. In today‘s society, most writers are writing in a global economy and post-9/11 world. This is the world that the students are living in and it is the world that they will eventually take over one day so it is important they understand the world. They can gain understanding through young adult novels that are based on current events. Students can be taught social responsibility through young adult literature. They can also be taught acceptance of other nationalities and ethnicities. There are young adult novels that cover every topic imaginable from racism to homosexuality to teen violence and on and on. Steven Wolk (2009) writes, ―The time is urgent for all schools and teachers to awaken their students‘ consciousness to the world and help them develop the knowledge and inspiration to make a better world, from local to global‖ (665). Students can learn about current problems by reading young adult literature. They will find characters who are facing decisions about the war on terrorism, protecting the environment, and functioning in a bad economy. These characters can make students recognize that they can help make a difference. Many times students feel that they are too 9 young and that adults do not respect them so they do not try to help their communities. However, these novels can show them other young adults who are making a difference in the world. It can also introduce students to people who come from completely different lives. For example, students who live in a very rural area can read about issues affecting children who live in inner city New York or vice versa. Young adult literature can awaken in students the need for social change. It can bring to life a homosexual student‘s struggles with his family or an anorexic girl‘s struggle with her body. These are issues that appeal to young adults and make them want to take an active role in their school, community, or government. When my students chose novels for their independent reading assignments, they read books about Iraq and Afghanistan, modern technology and its harmful effects, body image issues, underage drinking, trying to provide for a family at seventeen, and many other issues that affect our students everyday. Just because a teacher includes young adult literature in his or her classroom, does not mean he or she is ―dumbing down‖ the curriculum. The young adult novels can be used to teach the same literary elements that are found in classic novels. The young adult novels can also introduce students to issues their peers are facing, as well as issues they are facing at home and in school. Students who read are better writers and speakers so it is imperative to help students find an interest in reading. Many times, the only place a student is reading is in his or her English classroom. Teachers must set aside time each week for their students to read and allow them the choice of what to read. Self-selection is an important part of developing strong readers. Reading young adult literature can help students connect to classic novels more and make connections between the young adult novel they read and the classic they are reading. Students are faced with many other types 10 of entertainment including television, video games, and movies so it is important to help them establish a love of reading by having them read books that interest them. These can often be found in the young adult literature genre and can help create lifelong readers. 11 Bushman, J.H. (1997). Young adult literature in the classroom--or is it?. The English Journal, 86 (3), 35-40. Crowe, C. (2001). Young adult literature: sports literature for young adults. The English Journal, 90(6), 129-133. Crowe, C. (2000). Young adult literature: dear knucklehead: wise up. The English Journal, 90(1), 149-152. Crowe, C. (2001). Young adult literature: ap and ya?. The English Journal, 91(1), 123128. Herz, S.K., & Gallo, D.R. (2005). From Hinton to Hamlet. New York: Greenwood. Philion, T. (2009). the age of----?: using young adult literature to make sense of the contemporary world. Young Adult Library Services, 7(4), 46-49. Santoli, S.P., & Wagner, M.E. (2004). Promoting young adult literature: the other "real" literature. American Secondary Education, 33(1), 65-75. Wolk, S. (2009). Reading for a better world: teaching for social responsibility with young adult literature. Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 52(8), 664-673. 12 Prejudice and Social Injustice Unit Plan Overview Mississippi Trial, 1955 and To Kill a Mockingbird This is a six-week unit plan designed for ninth grade students as part of a thematic unit on prejudice, social injustice, and racism. The major part of this unit plan will be reading To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee. To prepare the students to read To Kill a Mockingbird, they will spend two weeks reading Mississippi Trial, 1955 by Chris Crowe. This is a young adult fictional novel based on the murder of Emmett Till. Reading this novel first will allow the students a glimpse of the time period Harper Lee was writing during. It will also give them a brief introduction to racism and prejudice. Like To Kill a Mockingbird it is also a coming of age story in the south. The students will be asked to evaluate the prejudices and social injustices throughout the novels and decide if they still occur today. It is the hope that the students will become more sensitive to these issues in their own lives. This unit will focus on connecting the students‘ lives to the material. The students will learn better if they actively take part in the learning. Students will be encouraged to share their own ideas, opinions, and experiences. The students will be drawing comparisons between their lives and the lives of the main characters. There will be many types of activities that range from whole class to group work to individual work. Students will be responsible for a variety of assignments throughout the unit. They will have one test, four quizzes, one paper, a collage activity, a reenactment, journal entries, and class discussions and debates as well as other informal assignments and assessments. Unit Assessment Journal Quizzes Test Papers Collage Reenactment Participation 20% 10% 15% 20% 15% 15% 20% 13 Objectives and Standards By the end of this unit it is expected the students will: Better understand the views and conflictions regarding education, prejudice, courage, and respect of individuals Define their own views on prejudice, social injustice, racism, courage, and respect Demonstrate their understanding and knowledge of the main events and characters as it relates to the authors‘ themes Interpret the main ideas, events, and themes of the novels Identify and explain connections between what they have read and their personal opinions Demonstrate respect for different cultures Recognize the importance and function of figurative language Apply reading comprehension strategies to understand grade-appropriate texts Analyze interactions between characters in a literary text and how the interactions affect the plot Explain and analyze how the context of setting and the author‘s choice of point of view impact a literary text Identify the structural elements of the plot and explain how the author develops conflicts and plot to pace the events in a literary text Identify similar recurring themes across different works Identify and analyze how an author uses figurative language, sound devices, and literary techniques to shape plot, set meaning, and develop tone Write responses to literature that extend beyond the summary and support references to the text, other works, other authors, or to personal knowledge Use documented textual evidence to justify interpretations of literature or to support a research topic 14 Overview of Assessment Journal: Journal entries will be made throughout the unit on assigned topics. This is intended to give the students a chance to reflect on the readings. Most topics will ask students to relate the reading to their own lives and their own personal experiences or opinions. This assignment is to be graded on ideas and creativity only, not on grammar or spelling. This will hopefully encourage students to write and not be worried about making a mistake. The journals will be collected periodically throughout the six weeks. The journal entries will often act as a springboard to discussion. 20% Quizzes: There will be four quizzes throughout the unit. These will be used to objectively assess the students‘ comprehension of what they have been reading. The quizzes will consist of mostly factual questions. They will be spread throughout the unit with two quizzes for each unit. Each quiz will have approximately 15-20 questions and will take 10-15 minutes to complete. 10% Test: There will be one comprehensive test over both novels. This test will take one full class period. It will consist of matching, multiple choice, short answer, quotations, and extended response questions. It will include factual questions and will also ask students to make inferences about the novels. 15% Papers: The students will write one short paper during the unit. One paper will be an opinion paper. At the beginning of Mississippi Trial, 1955 they will be asked to give their own definition of courage and how they see it. They will also write about who has courage in their opinion. At the end of the novel, they will write a short paper discussing whether their definition of courage has changed and who demonstrated courage throughout the novel. 20% Collage: This will be a partner project and the students will be given class time to work on it. Students will be asked to create a collage of a character, theme, or scene from Mississippi Trial, 1955. The purpose of this project is to allow students to demonstrate their knowledge in an alternative way. The students will be asked to bring in magazines and newspapers and the teacher will provide some as well. The students will also write a short paragraph explaining the collage. The collage will be graded on creativity as well as how it demonstrates understanding of the novel. 15% Reenactment of Tom’s Trial: The students will have the opportunity to reenact Tom‘s trial. They will read the chapters on the trial for homework and will come to class prepared to choose a role. Students will play Atticus, Tom, Mayella, Mr. Ewell, the judge, Heck Tate, and jurors. The students will receive a partial script for the trial, however, they will be required to finish the script during one class period in groups (defense, prosecution, jurors, and witnesses). The trial will be performed the next two days in class. After the trial is over, the jurors will need to make a ruling that can be different than the one in the novel, however, they must base it on evidence from the trial. 15 Students will be graded on participation as well as understanding their roles and not changing their characters‘ attitudes or beliefs. 15% Participation: It is vital that all students participate in discussions and have the opportunity to share their opinions. Therefore, it is expected that students will come to class prepared to actively participate everyday. This means bringing all materials and completing the assigned reading. Students will be respectful to everyone‘s opinions. 20% 16 Lesson #1: Introduction to Mississippi Trial, 1955 Objective(s) Students will be able to define the NAACP and Jim Crow Laws Students will demonstrate comprehension of the word courage and how it relates to them Students will demonstrate an understanding of how to create journal entries Materials: Powerpoint (Attachment A) Study guide Books Procedure 1. Pass out the journal guidelines, explain journal entries 2. Journal prompt: ―What does courage mean to you? Define courage in your own words. Who do you know that has courage?‖ 3. Discuss the meaning of courage as a class, share journal entries (volunteers only) 4. Civil rights overview-powerpoint. Ask students what they already know about the south in the 1950s. What was happening during that time? It is important students understand the NAACP and Jim Crow laws to better understand the novel. 5. Pass out the novels 6. Pass out the study guides. Explain that the purpose of the study guides is to help make sure the students understand all the important events throughout the novel. 7. Begin chapter 1 in class. The teacher will read aloud to help set the tone of the novel. The teacher will stop as necessary to point out important information. 8. Assign homework Homework Finish reading chapter one, read chapter two Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation points Journal 17 Journal Writing Guidelines This journal will be worth 20% of your final grade for this unit. The journals will be collected approximately three times throughout the unit. These collections will be unannounced so you need to stay up to date. If you miss a class it is your responsibility to get the prompt from the teacher or a classmate. This journal is intended to allow you to express your opinions on important issues and events throughout the novels. This journal will not be graded on grammar or spelling, but rather on the ideas you discuss. Most topics will be assigned. General Guidelines: Each entry should be at least one page. If you do not finish in class, you may bring it home and finish. You are strongly encouraged to write as much as you can and your points for the journal will reflect that. You must put all your entries into the same journal. I do not want 10 different sheets of loose paper. I will not accept that! Do not give me a ―good‖ copy. I want whatever your first thoughts were! You will lose points if you hand in anything typed or edited. The journals should come with you to class everyday. If you would like to leave them in the classroom, you may leave them in the bin marked with your period. 18 Name__________________________________ Period_______ Date_______________ Mississippi Trial, 1955 Study Guide Directions: Answer the questions as best you can while reading. If you are unsure of any leave them blank and we will go over them in class the next day. This will be collected at the end of the unit on the test day for part of your participation points. Chapter 1: 1. Why does Hiram get angry with his dad? What does he say starts to change his mind about his dad? 2. What does his Grampa own? Who has he never seen working there? 3. Why does his Grampa get angry when they’re out in the fields? 4. What does his Grampa say about the African-Americans? Chapter 2: 1. Who is RC? Give a brief description of his attitude. 2. Who are the Remington brothers? What makes them unique? 3. What does RC do to the fish? How does Hiram feel about it? Chapter 3: 1. Who dies? 2. What do the Remingtons say about Florence? 3. Compare and contrast what you know about Gramma and Grampa. 4. Where does Hiram move to at nine years old? Where does he want to stay? Chapter 4: 1. When was the last time Hiram’s Grampa and Dad talked? 2. Why won’t his Dad let him visit his Grampa? 3. Why does Hiram’s Dad finally allow him to go back to visit his Grampa? Chapter 5: 1. Who is introduced in chapter 5? Describe his general attitude so far. 2. What does Ruthanne say about RC? 3. How does Hiram feel to be back? Chapter 6: 1. Who does Ralph say Hiram looks like? How does that make him feel? 2. What does Hiram decide to do for the day? 3. Who does Hiram see while he’s out on the river? What does he do to him? 4. When Hiram and his Grampa go out to lunch what does Hiram learn about? 5. How does Hiram’s Grampa feel about desegregation? Chapter 7: 1. How does Mr. Paul describe the African-American schools? 2. What does Hiram say his Grampa said about desegregation? What is Mr. Paul’s response? 3. What does Hiram realize about the Jim Crow laws? 4. How does Hiram feel about his Dad towards the end of the chapter? Chapter 8: 1. Where do Hiram and RC go? 2. Why won’t RC eat the food Ruthanne made for them? 3. What does RC say Ruthanne is doing with Hiram’s Grampa? 4. What does RC say he once did to Ralph Remington? 19 5. How does Hiram feel about RC? 6. Who do Hiram and RC run into while fishing? 7. What does RC do to Emmett? How did it make Hiram feel? Chapter 9: 1. What is Grampa’s response when Hiram tells him what happened? 2. What does Hiram say his Dad realized? 3. What does Naomi say to Hiram? What does she want to do? 4. What does RC tell Hiram about the sheriff? Why does he ask Hiram to lie? (Other than so he won’t get in trouble!!!) 5. Where does RC say he’s going that night? What happened to the white woman and who supposedly did it to her? Chapter 10: 1. Why does Hiram feel helpless? Who is he worrying about? 2. Who comes to get Grampa late at night? 3. What happened to Emmett? 4. Who does Hiram think is the third man? Why? 5. What does Hiram tell the sheriff? Chapter 11: 1. What does Hiram tell his Mom? 2. Where do they find Emmett? 3. Who is being charged with murder? 4. Why does Grampa seem upset? Why does this make Hiram angry? Chapter 12: 1. Does Hiram want to testify or not? Does he feel like he has to? Why or why not? 2. What does his Grampa say about him testifying? 3. What does Grampa say could have saved Emmett? 4. What does Naomi say about Hiram testifying? Chapter 13: 1. What does Mr. Paul say he would do if he had to testify? 2. What does Hiram decide to do? How does he make his decision? Chapter 14: 1. Who makes up the jury? What type of people? 2. Who donates to the defense fund? How much money is in the jar? 3. What does Emmett’s uncle testify to? How does Mr. Breland cast doubt on his testimony? 4. Who’s testimony gets thrown out? Why? 5. What does Sheriff Strider say about the body? 6. Who testifies that the body was Emmett’s? How did she know? 7. What does Mrs. Bryant say happened at the store? How does the courtroom feel about it? Hiram? Chapter 15: 1. How long was the jury out for? What was the verdict? 2. How does the verdict make Hiram feel? 3. What does Milam do at the end of the chapter? Chapter 16: 1. What does his Grampa say about the trial? 2. What does RC do to this father? What does the sheriff tell him? 3. Why couldn’t RC be the third man? 4. What is Hiram’s Grampa trying to get rid of? 20 5. What does Ronnie Remington tell Hiram about his Grampa and the truck? 6. What does Hiram’s Grampa say about that night and about Emmett? Chapter 17: 1. What happens to Naomi? 2. Who picks Hiram up at the train station? 3. How does he feel about his father compared to the beginning of the book? Lesson #2: MT Chapters 1 and 2 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of the first two chapters Students will compare and contrast Grampa and Dad and RC and Hiram to more clearly understand their similarities and differences 21 Materials Compare and Contrast handout Study guide Novels Procedure 1. Bell Work-Journal Prompt: ―Do you know people like RC? Should Hiram stay friends with him?‖ RC acts as a bully during the first two chapters of Mississippi Trial, 1955. Bullies still exist in today‘s culture and the students should be able to list a few people who act like bullies. 2. Discussion about bullies. Do they exist in our school? What do they do today that is different from how RC acts? 3. Answer any confusing questions about the novel. At this time students can ask questions about the study guide or about the reading in general. It is an open forum. 4. Break into groups of no more than 4 in each group. 5. Complete the compare and contrast handout. Compare and contrast Grampa and Dad. Then compare and contrast Hiram and RC. Students should have three similarities and three differences for each. 6. Share the handout answers. Discuss what influences may make the characters act the way they do. The students should discuss their backgrounds and the type of environment they grew up in. Tell students to keep the handout because it will be used later. 7. Assign homework 8. If any time is left over, students may silently begin the homework Homework: -Read chapters 3 and 4 -Complete study guide questions Evaluation: -Participation in group work -Participation in class discussion Compare and Contrast: Write the similarities and differences between Grampa and Dad and between Hiram and RC. You should have 3 similarities and 3 differences for each. Grampa Dad 22 Hiram RC Lesson #3 MT Chapters 3 and 4 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 3 and 4 23 Students will demonstrate understanding and respect for cultural differences from 2011 and 1955 Materials Study guide Novel Procedure 1. Answer any confusing questions. Open forum. 2. Discussion as a whole class about the town‘s treatment of Ralph and Ronnie compared to the treatment of African-Americans. Who is treated better? How would this be different if the novel was set in Chicago in 1955? In New York in 2011? Chapter 3 deals with the sensitive issues of race and homosexuality. The students need to understand the cultural differences between 1955 and today. It would be best to have a whole class discussion on the issue. In the novel the homosexual men are treated better than the African-Americans, which could prompt an interesting discussion. 3. Break into small groups of no more than 4 4. Brief discussion of Gramma and Grampa. How are they similar? How are they different? What do Ralph and Ronnie think of Gramma? 5. Begin reading chapter 5 aloud 6. Assign homework Homework Finish chapter 5, read chapter 6 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation during discussion Participation during group work Lesson #4 MT Chapters 5 and 6 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 5 and 6 24 Students will define the differences between how Emmett acts and how he ―should‖ act in accordance with Jim Crow Laws Students will apply prior knowledge to list things they already know about desegregation Materials KWL chart Study guides Novels Procedure 1. Bell Work-Journal Prompt: ―What are your first impressions of Emmett? Would you be friends with him?‖ 2. Discuss first impressions of Emmett. Do you like him? Why or why not? Do you think Hiram likes him? Why or why not? How does Emmett act compared to how African-Americans are ―supposed‖ to act according to Jim Crow laws? 3. Answer any questions about the reading 4. Individual work: Complete a KWL chart about desegregation. What do you think you know about desegregation of schools in the south in 1955? What do you want to learn about desegregation? 5. Share what students already know about desegregation from their own experiences and the reading. Ask for opinions about what Grampa thinks about desegregation. The students will learn more about African-American schools and desegregation in chapter 7. 6. Assign homework Homework Read chapters 7 and 8 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation in class discussions Participation in creating a KWL chart about desegregation Desegregation KWL Chart Name_____________________________ Date___________ Period________ 25 What you think you know about desegregation What you want to learn about desegregation What you learned about desegregation Lesson #5 MT Chapters 7 and 8 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 7 and 8 26 Students will use critical thinking skills to list three things Hiram could have done differently at the river Students will list what they learned about desegregation Materials KWL chart Study guide Novel Procedure 1. Complete KWL chart from yesterday. Students will fill out what they learned about desegregation from last night‘s reading. 2. Answer any questions about the reading. 3. Whole class discussion: Students will share their opinions on Mr. Paul and the African-American schools. What does Hiram‘s Grampa think about AfricanAmericans? What does Mr. Paul say in response? Discussion of the fact that Mr. Paul is blind but he may be the only one in Greenwood who can truly see what is going on around him. What does this tell you about the conflicts so far? 4. Discussion of RC‘s treatment of Emmett when he seems him by the river. Ask the students to share how it made them feel to hear about how badly RC treated Emmett. Ask the students what they would have done. 5. Break into small groups of no more than 4 students in each group 6. Small group: Come up with a list of at least 3 things Hiram could have done differently at the river. How could he have protected Emmett? 7. Each group will share at least one thing from their list to compile a class list of things Hiram could have done differently. 8. Assign homework Homework Read chapters 9 and 10 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation in class discussion Participation in group work Lesson #6 MT Chapters 9 and 10 Objectives 27 Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 9 and 10, as well as the entire first half of the novel Students will define soliloquy Students will create their own soliloquy for Hiram Materials Soliloquy instructional sheet Study guide Novel Quiz #1 Procedure 1. Bell Work-Journal Prompt: ―What do you think happened to Emmett and who is the supposed third man?‖ 2. Quiz #1. Students will take a quiz over the first half of the novel. 3. Discuss journal prompt. What happened to Emmett? What does this tell you about the south during this time? What do you think the outcome will be? Why does it seem possible RC could be the third man? What happened at the end of chapter 9 to make you think that? Who else could it be? 4. Answer any questions 5. Create a soliloquy for Hiram after RC confronts him about the sheriff in chapter nine. What would Hiram be thinking after he hears the sheriff was asking about the river incident? Pass out soliloquy instructions. 6. Assign homework Homework Finish soliloquy if you didn‘t finish in class Read chapters 11 and 12 Complete study guide Evaluation Participation in discussion Quiz #1 Soliloquy assignment (due tomorrow) Soliloquy Instructions You should be familiar with a soliloquy after reading Romeo and Juliet earlier this year. Today you will be creating a soliloquy that could be added to the novel. 28 Soliloquy: an utterance or discourse by a person who is talking to himself or herself or is disregardful of or oblivious to any hearers present 1. Brainstorm: What did RC tell Hiram? How would you react? What might Hiram be thinking? You already know some of it since the novel is written from Hiram’s point of view. 2. Come up with a list of AT LEAST 5 different things Hiram might be thinking. 3. Write a ¾-1 page soliloquy of Hiram’s thoughts after his visit from RC. This should include all the things from your list. 4. You should write this as if Hiram were actually speaking so it should be in first person present. Remember not to use slang or colloquial modern English as the story is set in 1955. Points-This will count towards your participation points Possibility of 25 points 10 points for stating at least 5 things Hiram is thinking about RC comes over 5 points for writing in the same dialect Hiram uses 5 points for writing from Hiram’s point of view 5 points for grammar and mechanics Mississippi Trial, 1955 Quiz 1 Chapters 1-10 Name____________________________________ Date____________ Period_______ 29 Directions: Short answer. You must answer in complete sentences or else the answer is WRONG! 1. Why does Grampa get angry with Hiram? 2. Why is Hiram finally allowed to go visit his Grampa? 3. Who does Hiram save at the river? 4. What does Hiram’s Grampa say about desegregation? 5. Tell me one aspect of an African-American school according to Mr. Paul. 6. Why does Mr. Paul say we were all put here? 7. What does Hiram realize about Jim Crow laws? 8. What is one thing RC did to Emmett at the river? 9. How does Hiram feel after seeing what RC did to Emmett? 10. Who is RC going to teach a lesson? What did that person do? 11. What happened to Emmett? 12. Who does Hiram think is the third man? Lesson #7 Chapters 11 and 12 Objectives 30 Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 11 and 12 Materials Study guide Novel Procedure 1. Discussion: Would you testify? Why or why not? What decision do you think Hiram will ultimately make? 2. Silent conversation: Students will sit in a u-shape. Each student will take out a piece of paper and write their opinion about one thing from the novel. They could ask a question, write something that bothers them about the novel, or write something they enjoy. The only thing that is off limits is a summary of the novel. They will then pass the paper to the person on their right. They will read what the previous person wrote and then respond with their own opinion. They will have one minute with each paper and they will keep passing the papers until they get their own paper back. 3. Discussion: Students will have the opportunity to discuss or debate anything about the novel with little input from the teacher (ie the teacher will not influence the students‘ opinions). 4. Assign homework Homework Read chapters 13, 14, and 15 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation in class Silent conversation participation Lesson #8 MT Chapters 13, 14, and 15 Objectives 31 Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 13, 14, and 15 Students will read and comprehend Gwendolyn Brooks‘ poem Students will compare and contrast the poem to the novel Materials Study guide Novel Poem handout Procedure 1. Bell Work-Journal Prompt: ―Were you surprised by the outcome of the trial? Why or why not? Do you think it was fair? Do you think they were guilty?‖ 2. Discussion: Allow students the opportunity to have an open discussion about the trial. 3. Poetry connection: ―A Bronzeville Mother Loiters in Mississippi. Meanwhile, a Mississippi Mother Burns Bacon.‖ Read aloud in class. Gwendolyn Brooks wrote this about the Emmett Till trial. What are the connections between the poem and the novel? How might the woman have felt while watching the trial? How do you think the woman really feels? 4. Begin reading chapter 16 Homework Read chapters 16 and 17 (finish the novel) Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation in discussion ―A Bronzeville Mother Loiters in Mississippi. Meanwhile, a Mississippi Mother Burns Bacon‖ (1960) by Gwendolyn Brooks From the first it had been like a Ballad. It had the beat inevitable. It had the 32 blood. A wildness cut up, and tied in little bunches, Like the four-line stanzas of the ballads she had never quite Understood—the ballads they had set her to, in school. breadth, undisputed height, And a harsh kind of vice. And best of all, when his history was cluttered With the bones of many eaten knights and princesses. Herself: the milk-white maid, the ―maid mild‖ Of the ballad. Pursued By the Dark Villain. Rescued by the Fine Prince. The Happiness-EverAfter. That was worth anything. It was good to be a ―maid mild.‖ That made the breath go fast. Her bacon burned. She Hastened to hide it in the step-on-can, and Drew more strips from the meat case. The eggs and sour-milk biscuits Did well. She set out a jar Of her new quince preserve. The fun was disturbed, then all but nullified When the Dark Villain was a blackish child Of fourteen, with eyes still too young to be dirty, And a mouth too young to have lost every reminder Of its infant softness. That boy must have been surprised! For These were grown-ups. Grown-ups were supposed to be wise. And the Fine Prince— and that other—so tall, so broad, so Grown! Perhaps the boy had never guessed That the trouble with grown-ups was that under the magnificent shell of adulthood, just under, Waited the baby full of tantrums. It occurred to her that there may have been something Ridiculous in the picture of the Fine Prince Rushing (rich with the breadth and height and Mature solidness whose …But there was a something about the matter of the Dark Villain. He should have been older, perhaps. The hacking down of a villain was more fun to think about When his menace possessed undisputed lack, in the Dark Villain, was impressing her, Confronting her more and more as this first day after the trial And acquittal wore on) rushing With his heavy companion to hack down (unhorsed) That little foe. So much had happened, she could not remember now what that foe had done Against her, or if anything had been done. The one thing in the world that she did now and knew With terrifying clarity was that her composition Had disintegrated. That, although the pattern prevailed, The breaks were everywhere. That she could think Of no thread capable of the necessary Sew-work. She made the babies sit in their places at the table. Then, before calling Him, she hurried To the mirror with her comb and lipstick. It was necessary To be more beautiful than ever. The beautiful wife. For sometimes she fancied he looked at her 33 as though Measuring her. As if he considered, Had she been worth It? Had she been worth the blood, the cramped cries, the little stuttering bravado, The gradual dulling of those Negro eyes, The sudden, overwhelming littleboyness in that barn? Whatever she might feel or half-feel, the lipstick necessity was something apart. He must never conclude That she had not been worth It. He sat down, the Fine Prince, and Began buttering a biscuit. He looked at his hands. He twisted in his chair, he scratched his nose. He glanced again, almost secretly, at his hands. More papers were in from the North, he mumbled. More meddling headlines. With their pepperwords, ―beastiality,‖ and ―barbarism,‖ and ―Shocking.‖ The half-sneers he had mastered for the trial worked across His sweet and pretty face. What he‘d like to do, he explained, was kill them all. The time lost, The unwanted fame. Still, it had been fun to show those intruders A thing or two. To show that snappy-eyed mother, That sassy, Northern, brown-black— Nothing could stop Mississippi. He knew that. Big Fella Knew that. And, what was so good, Mississippi knew that. Nothing and nothing could stop Mississippi. They could send in their petitions, and scar Their newspapers with bleeding headlines. Their governors Could appeal to Washington…. ―What I want,‖ the older baby said, ―is lasses on my jam.‖ Whereupon the younger baby Picked up the molasses pitcher and threw The molasses in his brother‘s face. Instantly The Fine Prince leaned across the table and slapped The small and smiling criminal. She did not speak. When the Hand Came down and away, and she could look at her child, At her baby-child, She could think only of blood. Surely her baby‘s cheek Had disappeared, and in its place, surely, Hung a heaviness, a lengthening red, a red that had no end. She shook her head. It was not true, of course. It was not true at all. The Child‘s face was as always, the Color of the paste in her paste-jar. She left the table, to the tune of the children‘s lamentations, which were shriller Than ever. She Looked out of a window. She said not a word. That Was one of the new Somethings— The fear, Tying her as with iron. Suddenly she felt his hands upon her. He had followed her To the window. The children were whimpering now. Such bits of tots. And she, their mother, Could not protect them. She looked at her shoulders, still Gripped in the claim of 34 his hands. She tried, but could not resist the idea Over her white shoulders, her own shoulders, And over all of Earth and Mars. He whispered something to her, did the Fine Prince, something About love, something about love and night and intention. She heard no hoof-beat of the horse and saw no flash of the shining steel. He pulled her face around to meet His, and there it was, close close, For the first time in all those days and nights. His mouth, wet and red, So very, very, very red, Closed over hers. Then a sickness heaved within her. The courtroom Coca-Cola, The courtroom beer and hate and sweat and drone, Pushed like a wall against her. She wanted to bear it. But his mouth would not go away and neither would the Lesson #9 Chapters 16 and 17 Decapitated exclamation points in that Other Woman‘s eyes. She did not scream. She stood there. But a hatred for him burst into glorious flower, And its perfume enclasped them—big, Bigger than all magnolias. The last bleak news of the ballad. The rest of the rugged music. The last quatrain. 35 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 16 and 17, as well as the second half of the novel Students will demonstrate comprehension of the Look magazine article and compare it to the novel Materials Study guide Novel Look magazine article Paper assignment handout Quiz #2 Procedure 1. Quiz #2 over the last half of the novel. 2. Discussion: What role do you think Grampa played? Would you still love Grampa if he were your grandfather? What did you learn about Hiram? How have your opinions about RC changed from before? 3. Read the article from Look magazine where Milam and Bryant confess to murdering Emmett. 4. Discussion: How do you feel now knowing the truth? Brief definition of double jeopardy. What were Emmett‘s ―crimes‖ and why was he punished for them? Does this still happen? Are people ever convicted for something they didn‘t do? Do people ever confess after they‘re acquitted? 5. Pass out paper assignment. Homework Paper #1 due Monday Bring magazines and newspapers to class tomorrow Evaluation Paper Participation in discussion Quiz #2 36 The Shocking Story of Approved Killing in Mississippi This article is the infamous confession of J. W. Milam and Roy Bryant to the kidnapping and killing of Emmett Till. Reporter William Bradford Huie reportedly paid the men $4000 for their story. It appeared in Look 20 (24 January 1956): 46–50. Each section is divided and numbered with the original pagination. ________________________ ________________________ ________________________ ______ [46] The Shocking Story of APPROVED KILLING IN MISSISSIPPI EDITOR‘S NOTE: In the long history of man‘s inhumanity to man, racial conflict has produced some of the most horrible examples of brutality. The recent slaying of Emmett Till in Mississippi is a case in point. The editors of LOOK are convinced that they are presenting here, for the first time, the real story of that killing – the story no jury heard and no newspaper reader saw. By WILLIAM BRADFORD HUIE Disclosed here is the true account of the slaying in Mississippi of a Negro youth named Emmett Till. Last September in Sumner, Miss., a petit jury found the youth's admitted abductors not guilty of murder. In November, in Greenwood, a grand jury declined to indict them for kidnapping. Of the murder trial, the Memphis Commercial Appeal said: "Evidence necessary for convicting on a murder charge was lacking." But with truth absent, hypocrisy and myth have flourished. Now, hypocrisy can be exposed; myth dispelled. Here are the facts. Carolyn Holloway Bryant is 21, five feet tall, weighs 103 pounds. An Irish girl, with black hair and black eyes, she is a small farmer's daughter who, at 17, quit high school at Indianola, Miss., to marry a soldier, Roy Bryant, then 20, now 24. The couple have two boys, three and two; and they operate a store at a dusty crossroads called Money: post office, filling station and three stores clustered around a school and a gin, and set in the vast, lonely cotton patch that is the Mississippi Delta. Carolyn and Roy Bryant are poor: no car, no TV. They live in the back of the store which Roy's brothers helped set up when he got out of the 82nd Airborne in 1953. They sell "snuff-and-fatback" to Negro field hands on credit: and they earn little because, for one reason, the government has been giving the Negroes food they formerly bought. Carolyn and Roy Bryant's social life is visits to their families, to the Baptist church and, whenever they can borrow a car, to a drivein, with the kids sleeping in the back seat. They call Shane the best picture they ever saw. For extra money, Carolyn tends store when Roy works outside -- like truck driving for a brother. And he has many brothers. His mother had two husbands, 11 children. The first five -- all boys -- were "Milam children"; the next six -- three boys, three girls -- were "Bryant children." This is a lusty and devoted clan. They work, fight, vote and play as a family. The "half" in their fraternity is forgotten. For years, they have operated a chain of cottonfield stores, as well as trucks and mechanical cotton pickers. In relation to the Negroes, they are somewhat like white traders in portions of Africa today; and they are determined to resist the revolt of colored men against white rule. On Wednesday evening, August 24, 1955, Roy was in Texas, on a brother's truck. He had carted shrimp from New Orleans to San Antonio, proceeded to Brownsville. Carolyn was alone in the store. But back in the living quarters was her sister-in-law Juanita Milam, 27, with her two small sons and Carolyn's two. The store was kept open till 9 on week nights, 11 on Saturday. When her husband was away, Carolyn Bryant never slept in the store, never stayed there alone after dark. Moreover, in the Delta, no white woman or group of white women ever travels country roads after dark unattended by a man. This meant that during Roy's absences -- particularly since 37 he had no car -- there was family inconvenience. Each afternoon, a sister-in-law arrived to stay with Carolyn until closing time. Then, the two women, with their children, waited for a brother-in-law to convoy them to his home. Next morning, the sister-in-law drove Carolyn back. Juanita Milam had driven from her home in Glendora. She had parked in front of the store to the left; and under the front seat of this car was Roy Bryant's pistol, a .38 Colt automatic. Carolyn knew it was there. After 9, Juanita's husband, J. W. Milam, would arrive in his pickup to shepherd them to his home for the night. About 7:30 p.m., eight young Negroes -- seven boys and a girl -- in a '46 Ford had stopped outside. They included sons, grandsons and a nephew of Moses (Preacher) Wright, 64, a 'cropper. They were between 13 and 19 years old. Four were natives of the Delta, and others, including the nephew, Emmett (Bobo) Till, were visiting from the Chicago area. Bobo bragged about his white girl. He showed the boys a picture of a white girl in his wallet; and to their jeers of disbelief, he boasted of his success with her. "You talkin' mighty big, Bo," one youth said. "There's a pretty little white woman in the store. Since you know how to handle white girls, let's see you go in and get a date with her?" "You ain't chicken, are yuh, Bo?" another youth taunted him. Bobo had to fire or fall back. He entered the store, alone, stopped at the candy case. Carolyn was behind the counter; Bobo in front. He asked for two cents' worth of bubble gum. She handed it to him. He squeezed her hand and said: "How about a date, Baby?" She jerked away and started for Juanita Milam. At the break between counters, Bobo jumped in front of her, perhaps caught her at the waist, and said: "You needn't be afraid o' me, Baby. I been with white girls before." Bobo Till was 14 years old: born on July 25, 1941. He was stocky, muscular, weighing about 160, five feet four or five. Preacher later testified: "He looked like a man." At this point, a cousin ran in, grabbed Bobo and began pulling him out of the store. Carolyn now ran, not for Juanita, but out the front, and got the pistol from the Milam car. Bobo's party joined a dozen other young Negroes, including two other girls, in front of the store. Bryant had built checkerboards there. Some were playing checkers, others were wrestling and "kiddin' about girls." Outside, with Bobo being ushered off by his cousins, and with Carolyn getting the gun, Bobo executed the "wolf whistle" which gave the case its name: [47] THE WOLF-WHISTLE MURDER: A NEGRO "CHILD" OR "BOY" WHISTLED AT HER AND THEY KILLED HIM. That was the sum of the facts on which most newspaper readers based an opinion. The Negroes drove away; and Carolyn, shaken, told Juanita. The two women determined to keep the incident from their "men-folks." They didn't tell J. W. Milam when he came to escort them home. By Thursday afternoon, Carolyn Bryant could see the story was getting around. She spent Thursday night at the Milams, where at 4 a.m. (Friday) Roy got back from Texas. Since he had slept little for five nights, he went to bed at the Milams' while Carolyn returned to the store. During Friday afternoon, Roy reached the store, and shortly thereafter a Negro told him what "the talk" was, and told him that the "Chicago boy" was "visitin' Preacher." Carolyn then told Roy what had happened. Once Roy Bryant knew, in his environment, in the opinion of most white people around him, for him to have done nothing would have marked him for a coward and a fool. On Friday night, he couldn't do anything. He and Carolyn were alone, and he had no car. Saturday was collection day, their busy day in the store. About 10:30 Saturday night, J. W. Milam drove by. Roy took him aside. "I want you to come over 38 early in the morning," he said. "I need a little transportation." J.W. protested: "Sunday's the only morning I can sleep. Can't we make it around noon?" Roy then told him. "I'll be there," he said. "Early." J. W. drove to another brother's store at Minter City, where he was working. He closed that store about 12:30 a.m., drove home to Glendora. Juanita was away, visiting her folks at Greenville. J. W. had been thinking. He decided not to go to bed. He pumped the pickup -- a half-ton '55 Chevrolet -- full of gas and headed for Money. J. W. "Big Milam" is 36; six feet two, 235 pounds; an extrovert. Short boots accentuate his height; khaki trousers; red sports shirt; sun helmet. Dark-visaged; his lower lip curls when he chuckles; and though bald, his remaining hair is jetblack. He is slavery's plantation overseer. Today, he rents Negro-driven mechanical cotton pickers to plantation owners. Those who know him say that he can handle Negroes better than anybody in the country. Big Milam soldiered in the Patton manner. With a ninthgrade education, he was commissioned in battle by the 75th Division. He was an expert platoon leader, expert street fighter, expert in night patrol, expert with the "grease gun," with every device for close-range killing. A German bullet tore clear through his chest; his body bears "multiple shrapnel wounds." Of his medals, he cherishes one: combat infantryman's badge. Big Milam, like many soldiers, brought home his favorite gun: the .45 Colt automatic pistol. "Best weapon the Army's got," he says. "Either for shootin' or sluggin'." Two hours after Big Milam got the word -- the instant minute he could close the store -- he was looking for the Chicago Negro. [48] Big Milam reached Money a few minutes shy of 2 a.m., Sunday, August 28. The Bryants were asleep; the store was dark but for the all-night light. He rapped at the back door, and when Roy came, he said: "Let's go. Let's make that trip now." Roy dressed, brought a gun: this one was a .45 Colt. Both men were -- and remained -cold sober. Big Milam had drunk a beer at Minter City around 9; Roy had had nothing. There was no moon as they drove to Preacher's house: 2.8 miles east of Money. Preacher's house stands 50 feet right of the gravel road, with cedar and persimmon trees in the yard. Big Milam drove the pickup in under the trees. He was bareheaded, carrying a five-cell flashlight in his left hand, the .45 in the right. Roy Bryant pounded on the door. Preacher: "Who's that?" Bryant: "Mr. Bryant, from Money, Preacher." Preacher: "All right, sir. Just a minute." Preacher came out of the screened-in porch. Bryant: "Preacher, you got a boy from Chicago here?" Preacher: "Yessir." Bryant: "I want to talk to him." Preacher: "Yessir. I'll get him." Preacher led them to a back bedroom where four youths were sleeping in two beds. In one was Bobo Till and Simeon Wright, Preacher's youngest son. Bryant had told Preacher to turn on the lights; Preacher had said they were out of order. So only the flashlight was used. The visit was not a complete surprise. Preacher testified that he had heard of the "trouble," that he "sho' had" talked to his nephew about it. Bobo himself had been afraid; he had wanted to go home the day after the incident. The Negro girl in the party urged that he leave. "They'll kill him," she had warned. But Preacher's wife, Elizabeth Wright, had decided that the danger was being magnified; she had urged Bobo to "finish yo' visit." 39 "I thought they might say something to him, but I didn't think they'd kill a boy," Preacher said. Big Milam shined the light in Bobo's face, said: "You the nigger who did the talking?" "Yeah," Bobo replied. Milam: "Don't say, 'Yeah' to me: I'll blow your head off. Get your clothes on." Bobo had been sleeping in his shorts. He pulled on a shirt and trousers, then reached for his socks. "Just the shoes," Milam hurried him "I don't wear shoes without socks," Bobo said; and he kept the gun-bearers waiting while he put on his socks, then a pair of canvas shoes with thick crepe soles. Preacher and his wife tried two arguments in the boy's behalf. "He ain't got good sense," Preacher begged. "He didn't know what he was doing. Don't take him." "I'll pay you gentlemen for the damages," Elizabeth Wright said. "You niggers go back to sleep," Milam replied. They marched him into the yard, told him to get in the back of the pickup and lie down. He obeyed. They drove toward Money. Elizabeth Wright rushed to the home of a white neighbor, who got up, looked around, but decided he could do nothing. Then, she and Preacher drove to the home of her brother, Crosby Smith, at Sumner; and Crosby Smith, on Sunday morning, went to the sheriff's office at Greenwood. The other young Negroes stayed at Preacher's house until daylight, when Wheeler Parker telephoned his mother in Chicago, who in turn notified Bobo's mother, Mamie Bradley, 33, 6427 S. St. Lawrence. Had there been any doubt as to the identity of the "Chicago boy who done the talking," Milam and Bryant would have stopped at the store for Carolyn to identify him. But there had been no denial. So they didn't stop at the store. At Money, they crossed the Tallahatchie River and drove west. Their intention was to "just whip him... and scare some sense into him." And for this chore, Big Milam knew "the scariest place in the Delta." He had come upon it last year hunting wild geese. Over close to Rosedale, the Big [50] River bends around under a bluff. "Brother, she's a 100foot sheer drop, and she's a 100 feet deep after you hit." Big Milam's idea was to stand him up there on that bluff, "whip" him with the .45, and then shine the light on down there toward that water and make him think you're gonna knock him in. "Brother, if that won't scare the Chicago -------, hell won't." Searching for this bluff, they drove close to 75 miles. Through Shellmound, Schlater, Doddsville, Ruleville, Cleveland, to the intersection south of Rosedale. There they turned south on Mississippi No. 1, toward the entrance to Beulah Lake. They tried several dirt and gravel roads, drove along the levee. Finally, they gave up: in the darkness, Big Milam couldn't find his bluff. They drove back to Milam's house at Glendora, and by now it was 5 a.m.. They had been driving nearly three hours, with Milam and Bryant in the cab and Bobo lying in the back. At some point when the truck slowed down, why hadn't Bobo jumped and run? He wasn't tied; nobody was holding him. A partial answer is that those Chevrolet pickups have a wraparound rear window the size of a windshield. Bryant could watch him. But the real answer is the remarkable part of the story. Bobo wasn't afraid of them! He was tough as they were. He didn't think they had the guts to kill him. Milam: "We were never able to scare him. They had just filled him so full of that poison that he was hopeless." Back of Milam's home is a tool house, with two rooms each about 12 feet square. They took him in there and began "whipping" him, first Milam, then Bryant smashing him across the head with those .45's. Pistol-whipping: 40 a court-martial offense in the Army... but MP's have been known to do it.... And Milam got information out of German prisoners this way. But under these blows Bobo never hollered -- and he kept making the perfect speeches to insure martyrdom. Bobo: "You bastards, I'm not afraid of you. I'm as good as you are. I've 'had' white women. My grandmother was a white woman." Milam: "Well, what else could we do? He was hopeless. I'm no bully; I never hurt a nigger in my life. I like niggers -- in their place -- I know how to work 'em. But I just decided it was time a few people got put on notice. As long as I live and can do anything about it, niggers are gonna stay in their place. Niggers ain't gonna vote where I live. If they did, they'd control the government. They ain't gonna go to school with my kids. And when a nigger gets close to mentioning sex with a white woman, he's tired o' livin'. I'm likely to kill him. Me and my folks fought for this country, and we‘ve got some rights. I stood there in that shed and listened to that nigger throw that poison at me, and I just made up my mind. 'Chicago boy,' I said, 'I'm tired of 'em sending your kind down here to stir up trouble. Goddam you, I'm going to make an example of you -- just so everybody can know how me and my folks stand.'" So big Milam decided to act. He needed a weight. He tried to think of where he could get an anvil. Then he remembered a gin which had installed new equipment. He had seen two men lifting a discarded fan, a metal fan three feet high and circular, used in ginning cotton. Bobo wasn't bleeding much. Pistol-whipping bruises more than it cuts. They ordered him back in the truck and headed west again. They passed through Doddsville, went to the Progressive Ginning Company. This gin is 3.4 miles east of Boyle: Boyle is two miles south of Cleveland. The road to this gin turns left off U.S. 61, after you cross the bayou bridge south of Boyle. Milam: "When we got to that gin, it was daylight, and I was worried for the first time. Somebody might see us and accuse us of stealing the fan." He staggered under its weight... carried it to the river bank. They stood silently... just hating one another. Milam: "Take off your clothes." Slowly, Bobo pulled off his shoes, his socks. He stood up, unbuttoned his shirt, dropped his pants, his shorts. He stood there naked. It was Sunday morning, a little before 7. Milam: "You still as good as I am?" Bobo: "Yeah." Milam: "You still 'had' white women?" Bobo: "Yeah." Bryant and Big Milam stood aside while Bobo loaded the fan. Weight: 74 pounds. The youth still thought they were bluffing. They drove back to Glendora, then north toward Swan Lake and crossed the "new bridge" over the Tallahatchie. At the east end of this bridge, they turned right, along a dirt road which parallels the river. After about two miles, they crossed the property of L.W. Boyce, passing near his house. About 1.5 miles southeast of the Boyce home is a lonely spot where Big Milam has hunted squirrels. The river bank is steep. The truck stopped 30 yards from the water. Big Milam ordered Bobo to pick up the fan. That big .45 jumped in Big Milam's hand. The youth turned to catch that big, expanding bullet at his right ear. He dropped. They barb-wired the gin fan to his neck, rolled him into 20 feet of water. For three hours that morning, there was a fire in Big Milam's back yard: Bobo's crepe-soled shoes were hard to burn. Seventy-two hours later -eight miles downstream -boys were fishing. They saw feet sticking out of the water. Bobo. The majority -- by no means all, but the majority -- of the white people in Mississippi 1) either approve Big Milam's action or else 2) they 41 don't disapprove enough to risk giving their "enemies" the satisfaction of a conviction. END Mississippi Trial, 1955 Opinion Paper At the beginning of the novel you wrote a journal entry about the definition of courage in your own words and who you thought had courage. I want you to look back at that journal entry and reread it. Decide whether you agree with it still or not. If you do 42 not, write a new definition of courage. Then choose one person in the novel who you thought had courage based on your definition. This will be a 5 paragraph paper. Introduction: Give your definition of courage Identify the character you think possessed character throughout the novel Thesis statement about courage and your character; why does your character have courage Body Paragraphs (each body paragraph should have): One action that your character took that you believe demonstrated courage Why you think this action took courage Whether the character struggled with his or her action or not Conclusion Why your character has courage How your character demonstrated courage (brief summary) Insightful statement about your character and his or her courage Grading: Introduction Definition of courage _____/5 Character that possessed courage _____/5 Thesis statement _____/10 Body Paragraphs Three different courageous actions _____/15 Why the action was courageous _____/30 Did the character struggle _____/15 Conclusion Why you think your character has courage _____/10 Brief summary of how your character demonstrated courage _____/10 Insightful comment _____/10 Grammar Grammatical conventions, spelling _____/10 Mississippi Trial, 1955 Quiz #2 Chapters 11-17 Name________________________________ Date_______________ Period________ 43 Directions: Fill in the blank and short answer. Write in complete sentences or else the answer is WRONG. 1. Emmett’s body is found in the _________________________. He was ______________. 2. Why doesn’t Hiram’s Grampa want him to testify? 3. What does Grampa say Emmett did wrong? What should he have done? 4. Hiram decides ___________ testify. 5. Who donates to Milam and Bryant’s defense? 6. What did Emmett supposedly do to Bryant’s wife? 7. The jury’s verdict is ________________________. 8. Give ONE possibility of who the third man could be according to the novel? 9. Hiram’s Grampa is trying to get rid of the __________________________. 10. What does Ronnie say Ralph saw? 11. Hiram’s Grampa says _______________________ was ____________________ when he left. Lesson #10 Collage Project Objectives 44 Students will demonstrate comprehension of one aspect of the novel from their choosing Materials Magazines and newspapers Scissors Glue/tape Collage instruction sheet Procedure 1. Explain collage project, pass out instruction sheet 2. Get into groups of two 3. Choose from one of the topics on the list 4. Work in groups for the rest of the period. You will have one more class period to work on it and then it will be due. 5. Reminder that papers are due on Monday Homework Paper Evaluation Participation in groups Collage (due at end of class on Monday) Mississippi Trial, 1955 Collage Project 45 You will be creating a collage to represent a character, scene, or theme from Mississippi Trial, 1955. You should choose a topic from the list below. Once you choose a topic you will look through the magazines and newspapers to find images or words that represent your topic. You will glue these onto your poster. We should be able to tell what your topic is simply by looking at your collage. You probably won’t find any images from 1955 so you will need to be creative! Think about the characteristics of the novel! You should have AT LEAST 10 pictures or words. You must have pictures, you cannot just have words! When you are finished you need to write one paragraph explaining your collage. Glue this to the back of your poster. Characters: Emmett Hiram RC Grampa Mr. Paul Ralph and Ronnie Dad Themes: Prejudice Racisim Coming of age Social injustice Scenes: You may choose any scene from the novel Points: Creativity _____/30 At least 10 pictures or words _____/30 Paragraph _____/20 Ease of identifying topic from collage _______/20 46 Lesson #11 Collage Project Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of one aspect of the novel of their choosing Students will write an opinion paper about one character from the novel Materials Magazines and newspapers Scissors Glue/tape Collage instruction sheet Procedure 1. Finish working on project 2. Opportunity to share collages with class 3. Hand in collages 4. Collect papers Homework None! Day off! Evaluation Collage Participation Paper Lesson #12 Introduction to To Kill a Mockingbird 47 Objectives Students will be able to summarize Harper Lee‘s background Students will be able to summarize the setting of TKAM Students will create and share a story with the class Students will display oral reading skills Materials Novel Study guide Handout on Harper Lee and TKAM Procedure 1. Write a brief, interesting story of something that happened to you but tell us the ending first without giving anything away! Example: ―And that‘s how I learned to never stick my tongue to any frozen metal.‖ Teacher will share a full example. ―When I was 8 years old I learned to never stick my tongue to any frozen metal. My mother always froze the metal candleholders to get the wax off. One day we had just finished watching A Christmas Story and she wanted to know if her tongue would really stick. She took the candlestick out of the freezer and sure enough her tongue stuck. She ran around the kitchen panicking until my Dad and I could stop laughing enough to run her tongue under hot water. And that‘s how I learned to never stick my tongue to any frozen metal.‖ 2. Share some of the backwards stories. Explain that TKAM starts with the end but tells nothing about the whole story. 3. Introduction to Harper Lee and the 1930s 4. Pass out the novels 5. Pass out study guide 6. Begin reading chapter 1 7. Assign homework Homework Finish reading chapter 1 Read chapters 2, 3 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation Harper Lee Background Born April 28, 1926 in Alabama 48 It is often said that Maycomb has many similarities with Lee‘s hometown of Monroeville In 1949 she moved to NYC with the goal of becoming a writer By 1957 she had finished a draft of To Kill a Mockingbird Scottsboro Nine Happened in the 1930s, Lee would have read about it in the newspapers In March 1931, nine African-American youths were charged with raping two white women Over a five-year period, a series of trials were held. In spite of evidence of the men‘s innocence, eight of the nine men were found guilty and sentenced to death By 1937 after appealing all the way to the Supreme Court, four defendants were freed and the others were sentenced to long prison terms Scottsboro Nine v. Tom Robinson Charged with raping a white woman Atticus Finch and Judge James E. Horton both acted in the interest of justice when an African American was wrongly accused Both had all white juries It is likely that Lee used her knowledge of the Scottsboro Nine as well as her knowledge of living through the Emmett Till trial while writing her novel Name______________________________ Date________________ Period_________ 49 To Kill a Mockingbird Study Guide Questions Directions: Answer these questions to the best of your abilities in COMPLETE SENTENCES as you read at night. If you have trouble answering a question do your best but ask in class the next day. Chapter 1 1. Who is the narrator of the novel? How old is she when the story takes place? 2. Describe the town of Maycomb. 3. Who is Dill? Why does he come to Maycomb? 4. What was summertime for? 5. Who is Boo? What does Dill want to do to him? 6. What does Dill dare Jem to do? Chapter 2 1. What is Scout‘s ―crime‖ on her first day of school? 2. What is the teacher confused about? How does Scout try to help her? 3. How do the Cunninghams pay Atticus? Chapter 3 1. Why does Scout attack Walter? Who makes her stop? 2. Why don‘t the Ewells have to go to school? 3. What does Atticus say about the Ewells? Chapter 4 1. What does Scout find in an oak tree? 2. What else do they find in the tree? 3. Who do you think may be leaving things in the tree? Chapter 5 1. What does Jem say they‘re going to write to Boo? 2. Who catches them? What does he tell them? Chapter 6 1. What are Dill and Jem planning to do now? 2. What do Dill and Jem see? 3. Who does Nathan Radley think he saw? Chapter 7 1. Why do Scout and Jem now consider everything in the knothole their property? 2. What do they find in the tree? 3. What happens to the knothole? Who does it? Chapter 8 1. What happens to Miss Maudie‘s house? 50 2. What happens to Scout while she‘s standing outside? Chapter 9 1. Who is Atticus defending? 2. Atticus says they won‘t win because they were beat 100 years before. What does he mean by this? 3. Why is Atticus worried about the case? Chapter 10 1. What does Atticus say it‘s a sin to do? Why? 2. What does Atticus do when he hears about the mad dog? 3. Why does Jem think Atticus tell them about his skill? Chapter 11 1. What does Jem do to get back at Mrs. Dubose? 2. What is Jem‘s punishment? 3. Why does Mrs. Dubose have Jem do his penance? Chapter 12 1. What makes Scout upset? 2. Where does Cal take Scout and Jem? 3. What is the church collecting for? 4. What is Tom Robinson accused of? 5. Who is waiting on the porch? Chapter 13 1. Why does Aunt Alexandra come to visit? 2. What does Aunt Alexandra want the kids to know? Chapter 14 1. What does Aunt Alexandra try to get Atticus to do? 2. Who is found in Scout‘s room? 3. Why is that person there? Chapter 15 1. Why does Atticus go to the jail on Sunday night? 2. Who shows up? Why? 3. Who breaks up the near altercation? Chapter 16 1. Where does Atticus not want Jem and Scout to go? 2. What is the one-drop rule? 3. Who do they sit with? Chapter 17 1. Who alerted Heck Tate? 51 2. 3. 4. 5. What did Tate find when he went to the house? What happened to Mayella? What does Bob Ewell say he saw? Mayella‘s right eye was black and Ewell is left handed. What is Atticus trying to prove? Chapter 18 1. Why does Mayella think Atticus is mocking her? 2. Who does Atticus say is missing when this happened? What is he implying? 3. What is wrong with Tom‘s left arm? Chapter 19 1. Where did Mayella send the children? 2. What did Mayella do to Tom? 3. What does Scout think about Mayella? Chapter 20 1. Who does Atticus say it‘s worse to cheat? Chapter 21 1. What does Jem think the verdict will be? 2. What is the jury‘s verdict? 3. How long does it take them to decide? Chapter 22 1. Jem asks how the jury could have returned a guilty verdict. What is Atticus‘s answer? 2. What does Cal find in the morning? 3. Why does Miss Maudie think Atticus defended Tom? 4. What does Bob Ewell do and say to Atticus? Chapter 23 1. When it‘s a white man‘s word against a black man‘s word, who always wins according to Atticus? 2. Why doesn‘t anyone from Maycomb serve on juries? 3. Who wanted an acquittal? What does Atticus think about it? 4. What kind of folks are there according to Scout? 5. Why does Boo stay inside according to Jem? Chapter 24 1. What does Scout say she wants to grow up to be? 2. Where is Scout more at home? 3. What happens to Tom? Chapter 25 1. What is Mr. Underwood‘s editorial about? 52 Chapter 26 1. What two things does Scout compare? 2. Why does Jem get mad at Scout? What does Atticus tell her? Chapter 27 1. What is happening for Halloween? 2. Who takes Scout to the pageant? Chapter 28 1. What happens to Jem and Scout on their way home? 2. What happened to the person who attacked them? Who is it? Chapter 29 1. What saved Scout? 2. Who rescued Jem and carried him home? Chapter 30 1. Who does Atticus think stabbed Bob Ewell? 2. What does Heck say? 3. What does Atticus think Heck is doing? Chapter 31 1. Who left Scout and Jem the gifts? Lesson #13 TKAM Chapter 1, 2, and 3 53 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 1, 2, and 3 Students will briefly describe the main characters Materials Study Guide Novel Character worksheet Procedure 1. Bell Work-Journal Prompt: What is Maycomb like? How does this compare to the town you live in? How is it similar, how is it different? 2. Group activity-worksheet on descriptions of characters so far. Each group will be assigned one character to describe what we know about the characters so far. 3. Whole class discussion about the characters-Each group will share what they wrote about the character they were assigned. Other groups will be allowed to contribute if they feel anything was left out. 4. Brief discussion of Scout‘s first day at school. Ask students how it compares to what they remember from their first day of school. 5. Students will have the opportunity to ask any question they are confused about. 6. Assign homework 7. Begin reading if time allows Homework Read chapters 4, 5, and 6 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation Name_______________________________ Date___________ Period_______ 54 Character Descriptions Chapters 1-3 Scout Jem Atticus Dill Lesson #14 Chapters 4-6 55 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 4-6 Students will define urban legends Students will create their own urban legend Materials Novel Study guide Procedure 1. Bell Work-Journal Prompt: Jem and Scout find trinkets and small gifts in a tree. Who do you think is leaving the gifts? Have you ever found something interesting? 2. Discussion of urban legends-Boo Radley can be considered an urban legend. An urban legend is a secondhand story told as true and just plausible enough to be believed about some horrific, ironic, terrifying, or embarrassing series of events that supposedly happened to a real person. Ask students to try and brainstorm a brief list of urban legends from the area. One example could be the numerous crybaby bridges. Ask students why the stories surrounding Boo could be urban legends. 3. Partner work-With a partner brainstorm an urban legend. It should be just plausible enough to be believed but not completely true. This could be something you know from your town or you could write a completely new urban legend. Write a paragraph describing your urban legend. 4. Share urban legends as time permits 5. Assign homework Homework Read chapters 7 and 8 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation Lesson #15 Chapters 7-8 56 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 7 and 8 Students will consider the novel from another character‘s point of view Materials Novel Study guide Procedure 1. Discussion of the gifts in the tree. It is clear that someone is leaving Scout and Jem gifts. Ask students who is leaving the gifts. Ask students why think Mr. Radley cemented the hole. 2. Various images will be drawn on the board including a square with dots in it, a triangle with circles in it, and a circle with squares in it. Students will be instructed to describe each image in as much detail as they can without actually saying it‘s a square with dots in it, etc… 3. Students will then share their descriptions. This will be an opportunity to show students how people can see the exact same thing but describe it in completely different ways. 4. Group work-Each group will choose a minor character (Cal, Boo, or Miss Maudie). Ask students to consider the viewpoint of their character. What might they see that the children don‘t about the gifts in the tree? What might they see differently? 5. Have groups share their responses. 6. First collection of journals 7. Assign homework Homework Read chapters 9 and 10 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation Journals Lesson #16 TKAM Chapters 9 and 10 57 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 9 and 10 Students will make predictions for the trial Materials Novel Study guide Procedure 1. Return journals 2. Discussion-Students were introduced to the Tom Robinson trial in the previous night‘s reading. Ask the students why Atticus is worried about the case. Ask why Atticus says they were beat 100 years before. 3. Group work-Get into groups of 4 and make predictions about the trial. What will happen? Will the kids be okay? What will the outcome be? 4. Discussion-Share predictions of the outcome of the trial. Allow each group to share. 5. Assign homework Homework Read chapter 11 Review first part of the novel Evaluation Participation Lesson #17 TKAM Chapter 11 58 Objectives Students will find examples of figurative language including imagery, similes, and metaphors Students will define how Lee uses figurative language to assist in telling the story Materials Novel Study guide Quiz Procedure 1. Bell Work-Journal Prompt: Atticus says it‘s a sin to kill a mockingbird. Why? How do you think this fits into the novel and ties into the title? 2. Quiz over Part One 3. Group work-Break into 5 groups. Each group will have two-three chapters. Each group needs to identify at least three examples of figurative language including imagery, similes, and metaphors. The students should describe how the figurative language assists in telling the story. 4. Discussion-Have each group share their examples. Ask the students if all of the characters should be taken literally. Ask if they can find clues as to when the author is using words figuratively. 5. Round table-Students can use the remainder of the period to discuss anything from the novel they would like as long as it‘s appropriate. This should include minimal interaction from the teacher. 6. Assign homework Homework Read chapters 12-14 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation Quiz #3 Name______________________________ Date___________ Period_________ 59 To Kill a Mockingbird Part One Quiz Directions: Write your answers in complete sentences or else the answer is WRONG. 1. Who is the narrator? How old is she approximately when she is telling the story? How old is she when the story takes place? 2. Who is Boo Radley? What do the children try and do to Boo? 3. What is Scout‘s ―sin‖ on the first day of school? 4. Why does Scout attack Walter Cunningham? 5. Name two things the children find in the tree. 6. What happens to Miss Maudie‘s house? 7. Who is Atticus defending? Why is he worried about the trial for the children? 8. What does Aunt Alexandra think Atticus is doing to the family because of the trial? 9. What does Jem call Atticus in chapter 10? Why? 10. What does Jem do to Mrs. Dubose? What is his punishment? Lesson #18 Chapters 12-14 60 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 12-14 Materials Novel Study guide Procedure 1. Bell Work-Journal Prompt: Tom‘s wife, Helen, is having trouble finding a job. Would you hire the spouse of a suspected criminal? Why or why not? 2. Discussion-Tom is accused of raping Bob Ewell‘s daughter. The church takes up a collection to help Tom‘s family while he is unable to work. Ask the students what they think of the church and the reverend‘s idea to raise money. Ask the students what they think Helen is going through and how she‘s reacting. 3. Scout‘s Top Ten List-Students break into groups of 3 to create a top 10 list of things Scout has learned so far throughout the novel about herself and about the character‘s of people in general. 4. Share the lists as a class and compile one list. 5. Assign homework Homework Read chapters 15, 16, and 17 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation Lesson #19 Chapters 15, 16, and 17 61 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 15, 16, and 17 Students will use critical thinking skills to make predictions about the outcome of the trial Materials Novel Study guide Procedure 1. Answer any difficult questions 2. Silent conversation-Students must make one prediction or comment about the trial. This cannot be a plot summary, it has to be the student‘s opinion. After the students are done writing they pass the paper to the right. They read the previous person‘s comment and then they pass the paper again. This keeps going until they have their own paper back or the teacher tells them to stop. 3. Round table-Students are allowed to share any comments they may have about the trial. Take a poll and see how many students think Tom is guilt and how many think he is innocent. Ask the students to compare this trial to the trial from Mississippi Trial, 1955. How are Scout and Hiram similar? How are they different? 4. Assign homework Homework Read chapters 18-21 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation Lesson #20 Chapters 18-21 62 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 18-21 Students will use critical thinking skills to find examples of social injustice still occurring today Materials Novel Study guide Introduction to Trial Reenactment Script Procedure 1. Discussion-What surprised you about the trial? What did you expect? Do you have any questions about the trial? What do you think Hiram would say about this trial? 2. Discussion-Do social injustices still occur today? Ask the students to think of any form of social injustice they are aware of. This could be something minor just in their school or town to something major that is occurring across the world. 3. Explain trial reenactment. Assign parts-Heck, Atticus, Judge, Mayella, Bob Ewell, Prosecutor, and jury. 4. Begin prep for trial reenactment. Pass out scripts. Explain that any character who chooses may deviate from the script. For example, the student playing Atticus may decide to ask another question. However, inform students that all the questions and responses in their scripts must be part of their reenactment. They may only add, they cannot take anything out. Homework Finish preparing for the trial reenactment if not ready Evaluation Participation Mr. Gilmer: ―In your own words, Mr. Tate, would you please tell the jury what you know.‖ 63 Heck Tate: ―I was fetched by Bob-Mr. Ewell, one night-― doctor, Sheriff? Did anyone call a doctor?‖ Atticus: ―Please repeat what you just said.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―What night would that be?‖ Heck Tate: ―No‖ Heck Tate: ―I said it was her right side and she had more bruises. Do you want to hear about them?‖ Heck Tate: ―November 21st. I was just leaving my office when Mr. Ewell came in. He was very upset and said to go to his house quick, that someone had just raped his daughter.‖ Mr. Gilmer‖ ―And did you go?‖ Heck Tate: ―Of course. I got in the car and drove out as fast as I could.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―And what did you find?‖ Atticus: ―You didn‘t call a doctor?‖ Heck Tate: ―No‖ Atticus: ―Why not?‖ Heck Tate: ―I didn‘t think it was necessary. She was really banged up. Something happened, it was obvious‖ Atticus: ―But you didn‘t call a doctor? Did anyone call for a doctor while you were there?‖ Heck Tate: ―No‖ Heck Tate: ―I found her lying in the middle of the floor in the first room of the house. She was really beat up, but I pulled her up and she washed her face in a water bucket in the corner and said she was all right. I asked her who had hurt her and she said it was Tom Robinson. I asked her if she was sure it was Tom who beat her up so badly and she said yes. I asked her if he had taken advantage of her and she said yes he did. I went down to the Robinson‘s house and brought him back. She identified him as the one who had hurt her so I arrested him. That‘s all there was to it.‖ Judge Taylor: ―He answered three times, Atticus. No one called a doctor!‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Thank you.‖ (sits down) Atticus: ―Wait a minute, was it her left facing you or her left looking the same way you were?‖ Judge Taylor: ―Any questions, Atticus?‖ Atticus: ―Yes‖ (Atticus stands up and walks towards Heck Tate) Did you call a Atticus: ―Yes, what were her other injuries?‖ Atticus: ―I‘m just making sure, Judge. Sheriff, you said that she was really banged up. How? Describe her injuries‖ Heck Tate: ―Her arms were bruised and she had finger marks on her neck. Atticus: ―Were they all around her throat or at the back of her neck?‖ Heck Tate: ―All around. She has a small neck, anyone could have reached around it― Atticus ―That will be all, Sheriff‖ (sits back down) Judge Taylor: ―You may be seated, Sheriff. Robert E. Lee Ewell to the stand!‖ Mr. Gilmer: (stands up) ―Mr. Robert Ewell?‖ Heck Tate: ―Well, she had been beaten around her head and there were bruises on her arms. And she had a black eye.‖ Bob Ewell: ―That‘s my name‖ Atticus: ―Which eye?‖ Bob Ewell: ―If I‘m not, I can‘t do anything about it now, her mother is dead.‖ Heck Tate: Let‘s see… (points to a spot in front of him), her left.‖ Heck Tate: ―Oh, that would make it her right. I remember now, she had been beat up on the right side of her face.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Are you the father of Mayella Ewell?‖ Judge Taylor: ―Are you the father of Mayella Ewell?‖ Bob Ewell: ―Yes, sir‖ Judge Taylor: ―I believe this is your first time in court so let me make something clear; there will be no more obscene speculations on any subject in this courtroom while I am sitting here. Do you understand?‖ 64 (Bob Ewell nods) Judge Taylor: ―Good. All right, Mr. Gilmer?‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Thank you, Judge. Mr. Ewell, will you tell us in your own words, what happened on November 21st?‖ Bob Ewell: ―Well, I was coming back from the woods with a load of firewood. Just as I got to the fence I heard Mayella screaming like a stuck pig inside the house.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―What time was this?‖ Bob Ewell: ―Just before sundown. As I was saying, Mayella was screaming at the top of her lungs so I dropped my load of wood and ran as fast as I could to the window and I saw that boy (pointing to Tom Robinson) taking advantage of my Mayella!‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―What did you do when you saw the defendant?‖ Bob Ewell: ―I ran around the house to get in, but he ran out of the front door just before I got there. I saw who he was though. I was too distracted by Mayella to chase after him. I ran in the house and she was lying on the floor screaming and crying. ‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―What did you do then?‖ Bob Ewell: ―I ran for the sheriff as fast as I could.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Thank you, Mr. Ewell‖ (sits down) (Bob Ewell starts to leave the witness stand) Atticus: (standing up) ―Just a moment, sir. Could I ask you a few questions?‖ (Bob Ewell sits back down) Atticus: ―Mr. Ewell, you were doing a lot of running that night. You ran to the house, you ran to the window, you ran inside, you ran to Mayella, you ran for the sheriff. Did you ever run for a doctor?‖ Bob Ewell: ―Didn‘t need to. I saw what happened.‖ Atticus: ―Weren‘t you concerned with Mayella‘s physical condition? Didn‘t you think that her injuries required immediate medical attention?‖ Bob Ewell: ―I never thought of it. I‘ve never called a doctor to see anyone in my family and if I had it would have cost me five dollars. Is that all you need to know?‖ Atticus: ―Not quite. Mr. Ewell, you heard everything Mr. Tate said when he was on the stand didn‘t you?‖ Bob Ewell: ―Yes‖ Atticus: ―Do you agree with his description of Mayella‘s injuries? That her eye was blackened and that she was beaten around the head?‖ Bob Ewell: ―Yes. I agree with everything Tate said.‖ Atticus: ―Do you? Do you have anything to add to it? Do you agree with the sheriff?‖ Bob Ewell: ―I agree with Tate. Her eye was black and she was really beat up.‖ Atticus: ―Mr. Ewell, can you read and write?‖ Mr. Gilmer: (standing up) ―Objection! What does the witness‘s literacy have to do with this case?!‖ Atticus: ―Judge, if you will allow the question, plus another one, you will see.‖ Judge Taylor: ―All right, but make sure we see, Atticus. Overruled.‖ Atticus: ―Mr. Ewell, can you read and write?‖ Bob Ewell: ―Of course, I can!‖ Atticus: ―Will you write your name and show us?‖ Bob Ewell: ―Of course, I will! How do you think I sign my relief checks?‖ Atticus: (gives Bob a piece of paper and a pen) ―Would you write your name very clearly so the jury can see you do it?‖ Bob Ewell: (writes on the paper) ―What‘s so interesting?‖ Judge Taylor: ―You are lefthanded, Mr. Ewell.‖ Bob Ewell: ―What does that have to do with anything?! I am a Christ-fearing man and Atticus Finch is taking advantage of me! Tricking lawyers like you take advantage of me all the time! I told you what happened! I 65 looked through the window, ran that boy off, and then ran for the sheriff!‖ like he did to Papa; trying to make him out to be lefthanded.‖ Atticus: ―No more questions.‖ (sits down) Judge Taylor: ―How old are you?‖ Mr. Gilmer: (stands up) ―About your writing, are you ambidextrous, Mr. Ewell?‖ Mayella: ―Nineteen-and-ahalf‖ Bob Ewell: ―Absolutely not! I can use one hand just as good as the other!‖ Judge Taylor: ―You may be seated, Mr. Ewell. Mayella Violet Ewell to the stand!‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Miss Ewell, would you please tell the jury, in your own words, what happened on November 21st? Where were you at dusk on that evening?‖ Mayella: ―On the front porch‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―What were you doing on the porch?‖ Judge Taylor: ―Mr. Finch has no intention of scaring you. And if he did, I‘m here to stop him. That‘s one reason why I‘m sitting here. Now, you are a big girl, so just sit up straight and tell us what happened to you. You can do that can‘t you?‖ Mayella: ―Well, I was on the porch and he came along and, you see, there was a cabinet in the yard that Papa had brought in to chop up for firewood. Papa told me to do it while he was in the woods, but I wasn‘t feeling strong enough just then, so he came by-― Mr. Gilmer: ―Who is ‗he‘?‖ Mayella: ―Nothing‖ Judge Taylor: ―Just tell us what happened. You can do that, can‘t you?‖ (Mayella starts crying) Judge Taylor: ―That‘s enough now. You don‘t have anything to be afraid of as long as you tell the truth. All of this is new to you, I know, but you have nothing to be ashamed of and nothing to fear. What are you afraid of? Mayella: ―Him‖ (pointing to Atticus) Judge Taylor: ―Mr. Finch?‖ Mayella: (nods) ―I don‘t want him making me look silly Mayella: (pointing to Tom Robinson) ―That one there. Robinson‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Then what happened?‖ Mayella: ―I told him to come over and chop up this cabinet for me; I have a nickel for you. So he came in the yard and I went into the house to get the nickel and I turned around and before I knew it he was on me. He just ran up behind me. He got a hold of my neck and started cussing at me. I fought and yelled but he had me around the neck. He hit me again and again and then threw me on the floor and choked me and took advantage of me.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Did you scream? Did you scream and fight back?‖ Mayella: ―I sure did. I screamed for all I was worth. Kicked and screamed as loud as I could.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Then what happened?‖ Mayella: ―I don‘t remember much, but the next thing I knew Papa was in the room standing over me and yelling ‗Who did it? Who did it?‘ Then I fainted and the next thing I knew, Mr. Tate was pulling me up off the floor and leading me to the water bucket.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―You say that you fought him off as hard as you could? Fought him tooth and nail? Mayella: ―I absolutely did!‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―You are positive that he took full advantage of you?‖ Mayella: ―He did what he was after‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―That‘s all for now. Stay there though, I expect big bad Mr. Finch will have some questions to ask you.‖ Judge Taylor: ―Mr. Gilmer, you will not prejudice the witness against Mr. Finch. At least not now.‖ Atticus: (stands up and walks towards Mayella): ―Miss Mayella, I won‘t try to scare you for awhile. Let‘s get to know each other. How old are you?‖ 66 Mayella: ―I already told the judge that I‘m nineteen‖ Atticus: ―So you did, so you did, ma‘am. You will have to bear with me, Miss Mayella, I‘m getting older and can‘t remember as well as I used to. I might ask you things that you‘ve already answered before, but you will give me an answer though, won‘t you? Good?‖ Mayella: ―I won‘t answer anything as long as you keep making fun of me.‖ Judge Taylor: ―Mr. Finch isn‘t making fun of you. What‘s the matter with you?‖ Mayella: ―As long as he keeps calling me ma‘am and Miss Mayella. I don‘t have to listen to him make fun of me!‖ Judge Taylor: ―That is just Mr. Finch‘s way. We‘ve worked together for many years and Mr. Finch is always polite to everybody. He‘s not trying to make fun of you, he‘s trying to be polite. That‘s just his way. Atticus, let‘s get on with this. And let the record show that the witness has not been sassed.‖ Atticus: ―Did you ever go to school?‖ Mayella: ―I can read and write just as well as my Papa‖ Atticus: ―How long did you go to school?‖ Mayella: ―Two or three years. I don‘t know.‖ Atticus: Miss Mayella, a nineteen-year-old girl like you must have friends. Who are your friends?‖ get on with this case. You said that you asked Tom to chop a cabinet. Did you know Tom? Did you know where he lived? Mayella: (nods) ―I knew who he was. He passed the house everyday.‖ Atticus: ―Was this the first time you asked him to come inside the fence?‖ Mayella: ―Yes, it was‖ Atticus: ―Did you ever ask him to come inside the fence before?‖ Mayella: ―Friends?‖ Atticus: ―Yes. Don‘t you know any boys or girls your age? Mayella: ―Are you making fun of me again, Mr. Finch?‖ Mayella: ―I certainly did not!‖ Atticus: ―You never asked him to do odd jobs for you before?‖ Atticus: ―Do you love your father, Miss Mayella?‖ Mayella: ―Maybe. There were several other black men around.‖ Mayella: ―What do you mean?‖ Atticus: ―Can you remember any other cases?‖ Atticus: ―I mean, is he good to you, is he easy to get along with?‖ Mayella: ―No‖ Mayella: ―He does fine. Except when…‖ Atticus: ―You said you are nineteen. How many brothers and sisters do you have?‖ Atticus: ―Except when he is drinking?‖ Mayella: ―Seven‖ (Mayella nods) Atticus: ―Are you the oldest?‖ Atticus: ―Has he ever beaten you?‖ Mayella: ―Yes‖ Atticus: ―How long has your mother been dead?‖ Mayella: ―My Pa has never touched a hair on my head in my life! He never touched me!‖ Mayella: ―I don‘t know. A long time.‖ Atticus: ―Well, we‘ve had a good talk but now it‘s time to Atticus: ―You said that Tom Robinson was right behind you in the room when you turned around, correct?‖ Mayella: ―Yes‖ Atticus: ―You said that he grabbed you around the neck and cussed at you, correct?‖ Mayella: ―Yes‖ Atticus: ―You said he grabbed you and choked you and took advantage of you, correct?‖ Mayella: ―That‘s what I said!‖ 67 Atticus: ―Do you remember him punching you in the face? You were sure that he choked you. And you were fighting all this time, correct? You kicked and screamed as loud as you could. Do you remember him punching you in the face? It‘s an easy question, Miss Mayella, so I‘ll ask again. Do you remember him punching you in the face? Do you remember him punching you in the face?‖ Mayella: ―I don‘t remember him punching me in the face. I mean yes I do, he hit me!‖ Atticus: ―What is your answer?‖ Mayella: ―Yes, he hit—I just don‘t remember, I just don‘t remember…it all happened so fast.‖ Judge Taylor: ―Now, don‘t start crying, young lady‖ Atticus: ―Let her cry, Judge. We have all the time in the world‖ Mayella: ―I‘ll answer any question you ask me. You get me up here and make fun of me but I‘ll show you. I‘ll answer any question you ask me.‖ Atticus: ―Good, I only have a few more. I want to be sure I understand everything correctly. You said that the defendant hit you, grabbed your neck, choked you and took advantage of you. Will you identify the man who raped you?‖ Mayella: ―Yes, I will. That‘s him there.‖ (points to Tom) Atticus: ―Tom, stand up and let Miss Mayella have a good look at you. Is this the man, Miss Mayella? Is this the man who raped you?‖ (Tom stands. His left arm hangs dead at his side) Mayella: ―Yes it is!‖ Atticus: ―How?‖ Mayella: ―I don‘t know how he did it, but he did! It all happened so fast—― Atticus: ―He punched you in your left eye with his right fist? Mayella: ―I ducked and it—it glanced off‖ Atticus: ―You are remembering things better now aren‘t you? You couldn‘t remember anything a while ago. All right, he choked you, then hit you, then he raped you, correct?‖ Mayella: ―Absolutely!‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Objection! Mr. Finch is browbeating the witness!‖ Judge Taylor: ―Oh sit down and be quiet. He‘s doing no such thing.‖ Atticus: ―Miss Mayella, you have testified that Tom choked and beat you. You didn‘t say that he sneaked up behind you and knocked you cold, but that you turned around and there he was. Do you want to change anything you‘ve said? Mayella: ―Do you want me to say something that didn‘t happen?‖ Atticus: ―No, I want you to tell us something that DID happen. Tell us again, please, what happened?‖ Atticus: ―You‘re a strong girl. What were you doing during all this? Just standing there?‖ Mayella: ―I told you, I screamed and kicked and fought‖ Atticus: ―Why didn‘t you try to run away?‖ Mayella: ―I tried‖ Atticus: ―What kept you from doing so?‖ Mayella: ―I—he threw me down and sat on top of me‖ Atticus: ―And you were screaming all this time?‖ Mayella: ―Of course!‖ Mayella: ―I already told you what happened‖ Atticus: ―You said that you turned around and there he was. Did he choke you then?‖ Mayella: ―Yes‖ Atticus: ―Then he released your throat and hit you‖ Mayella: ―That‘s what I said‖ Atticus: ―Then why didn‘t your brothers and sisters hear you? Where were they? Why didn‘t they hear your screams and come to help you? Or didn‘t you scream until you saw your father at the window? You didn‘t think to scream until then, did you? You didn‘t scream at Tom, you screamed at your father, 68 didn‘t you? Who beat you up, Tom Robinson or your father? Why don‘t you tell the truth, didn‘t Bob Ewell beat you up? (Atticus sits down) Mayella: ―I have something to say.‖ Atticus: ―Would you like to tell us what really happened?‖ Mayella: ―I have something to say and then I won‘t say anymore. That boy took advantage of me and if you fine, fancy gentleman don‘t want to do anything about it then all of you are cowards!‖ Atticus: ―Did he succeed?‖ Tom: ―Yes, sir. Just a little, though, not enough to hurt‖ Atticus: ―And you were both convicted?‖ Tom: ―Yes, sir. I had to serve 30 days in jail because I couldn‘t pay the fine. The other man paid his, though.‖ her that I didn‘t have anything except the hoe, but she told me that she had a hatchet that I could use. She gave me the hatchet and I chopped up the cabinet. Then she said, ‗I suppose I‘ll have to give you a nickel.‘ I told her no, there wasn‘t any charge and I left and went home. But that was last spring, over a year ago!‖ Atticus: ―Were you acquainted with Mayella Violet Ewell?‖ Tom: ―Yes, sir. I had to walk past her house every day to get to the field.‖ Atticus: ―Did you ever go there again?‖ Atticus: ―Whose field?‖ Tom: ―I was there lots of times‖ Tom: ―Yes, sir‖ Atticus: ―When?‖ Tom: ―Mr. Link Deas.‖ Judge Taylor: ―You may be seated Mayella. Atticus, how many witnesses do you have?‖ Atticus: ―One‖ Judge Taylor: ―Well, call him.‖ Atticus: ―Tom Robinson‖ (Tom walks to witness stand and sits down) Atticus: ―Tom, let me get this straight, you are 25 years old, married with 3 children, and you have been in trouble with the law before. You received 30 days in jail for disorderly conduct. Is this correct?‖ Atticus: ―Why?‖ Atticus: ―Were you picking cotton in November?‖ Tom: ―No, sir. I work in his yard during the fall and winter. I work for him pretty much all year around.‖ Atticus: ―Is there any other way to get to work other than to walk past the Ewell place?‖ Tom: ―No, sir. None that I know of‖ Atticus: ―Tom, did Mayella ever speak to you?‖ Tom Robinson: ―Yes, sir‖ Tom: ―Yes, she did. One day she asked me to come inside the fence and chop up a cabinet for her.‖ Atticus: ―What was so disorderly about your conduct?‖ Atticus: ―And when did she ask you to chop up this cabinet?‖ Tom: ―I got into a fight with another man who tried to cut me‖ Tom: ―It was last spring. I remember because it was chopping time and I already had my hoe with me. I told Tom: ―It seemed like every time I walked past the house, she had a job for me to do like chopping wood or carrying water buckets.‖ Atticus: ―And did she pay you for your work?‖ Tom: ―No, sir, I was happy to help. Mr. Ewell didn‘t seem to help her at all and neither did the other children and I knew that she didn‘t have the money to spare. Atticus: ―Where were the other children?‖ Tom: ―They were always there. They watched me work or sit in the window.‖ Atticus: ―Did Miss Mayella talk to you?‖ Tom: ―Yes, sir‖ Atticus: ―Did you ever enter the Ewell property without an invitation from one of them?‖ 69 Tom: ―No sir, I never did. I would never do that.‖ Atticus: ―Tom, what happened on November 21st of last year?‖ Tom: ―I was going home as usual that night and when I passed the Ewell house, Miss Mayella was sitting on the porch just like she said. She asked me to come in the fence and help her for a minute. I went in the fence and looked around for some firewood to chop up, but I didn‘t see any. She told me that she needed something done inside the house; the door had come off its hinges. I asked her if she had a screwdriver and she said yes. I went inside and looked at the door and told her that it looked just fine with me. Then she shut the door in my face. I then realized that the house was really quiet because all of the other children were gone. I asked Miss Mayella where the children were. She kind of laughed at me and said that they had all gone in town to get ice cream. She said it took her over a year to collect seven nickels but she finally did it and they were all in town.‖ dresser. As I reached for the box she grabbed me around my legs. She scared me so much that I jumped off the chair and turned it over. That was the only thing that was messed up in that room when I left, I promise!‖ Atticus: ―What happened after you turned the chair over?‖ Tom: ―I jumped down off the chair and turned around and she jumped on me. She hugged me around the waist.‖ Atticus: ―Then what did she do?‖ Atticus: ―Did you hurt her in any way?‖ Tom: ―I did not‖ Atticus: ―Did you resist her advances?‖ Tom: ―I tried to. I tried to without being mean. I didn‘t want to be mean to her. I didn‘t want to push her or anything.‖ Atticus: ―Who was Mr. Ewell talking to when he spoke through the window?‖ Tom: ―He was talking and looking straight at Miss Mayella‖ Atticus: ―Then you ran?‖ Tom: ―She kissed the side of my face. She said that she had never kissed a grown man before and that she might as well kiss me. She told me to kiss her back. I asked her to let me leave and I tried to run away but she had her back to the door and I didn‘t want to hurt her by pushing her out of the way. I told her to let me out and that‘s when I saw Mr. Ewell through the window.‖ Atticus: ―What did Mr. Ewell say, Tom?‖ Atticus: ―What did you say then, Tom?‖ Tom: ―He said, ‗I‘m going to kill you, you slut!‘‖ Tom: ―I said that was very nice of you to treat them like that and then I told her that I would be leaving since I couldn‘t help her with the door. She told me that there was something else I could help her with. I asked her what that could be and she told me to step on a chair and get a box down off of a Atticus: ―Then what happened, Tom‖ Tom: ―I ran away, Mr. Finch‖ Atticus: ―Did you rape Mayella Ewell, Tom?‖ Tom: ―I did not‖ Tom: ―Yes, sir. I was scared.‖ Atticus: ―Why were you scared?‖ Tom: ―If you were like me you would be scared too, Mr. Finch‖ Link Deas: (stands up) I just want everyone to know that that boy has worked for me for eight years and he has never given me one moment‘s trouble!‖ Judge Taylor: ―Be quiet! If you have anything to say, you can say it under oath and at the appropriate time! Until then, get out of here! Go ahead Mr. Gilmer.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―You were given 30 days for disorderly conduct?‖ Tom: ―Yes, sir‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―What did the other guy look like when you got done with him?‖ 70 Tom: ―He beat me up, sir.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―But you were convicted though, weren‘t you?‖ Tom: ―Yes, sir, I got thirty days.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Robinson, you are pretty good at chopping up cabinets and firewood with one hand aren‘t you?‖ Tom: ―Yes, sir. I felt sorry for her. She seemed to try harder than the rest of them‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―YOU felt sorry her HER? You felt SORRY for her? When you walked past the Ewell house on November 21st, she asked you to come in the fence and chop up a cabinet?‖ Tom: ―No, sir. She said she had something to do inside the house‖ Tom: ―Yes, sir. I guess so.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Are you strong enough to choke the breath out of a woman and throw her to the floor?‖ Tom: ―I‘ve never done that, sir‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―But are you strong enough to? Mr. Gilmer: ―She says she asked you to chop up the cabinet. Are you calling her a liar?‖ Tom: ―No, sir, I don‘t think she is lying. I just think she is mistaken‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Did Mr. Ewell chase you away from the house?‖ Tom: ―I guess so.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―You were awfully nice to do all those jobs for Miss Mayella, weren‘t you?‖ Tom: ―I was just trying to help her out, sir‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―That was nice of you. Didn‘t you have your own chores do to at home? Tom: ―Yes, sir‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Then why were you so willing to do her chores then?‖ Tom: ―It looked like she didn‘t have anyone to help her.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―And you did all this for free?‖ Tom: ―No, sir, I don‘t think he did. I didn‘t stay long enough for him to chase me away.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―Why did you run away so fast? What were you afraid of?‖ Tom: ―I was afraid of being in court, just like I am now. I was scared that I would be put on trial for something I didn‘t do.‖ Mr. Gilmer: ―That‘s all‖ Judge Taylor: ―You may be seated, Tom. Atticus, your closing statement?‖ Atticus: (stands up and walks towards the jury) ―Gentleman, I will be brief. I would like to remind you that this case is an easy one, but it does require you to be ABSOLUTELY sure of the defendant‘s guilt. This case should never have come this far. This case is as simple as black and white. Mr. Gilmer has not produced any evidence to prove Tom‘s guilt in this case. Instead, he has built his entire case on the testimony of two unreliable witnesses. The defendant is not guilty, but someone involved in this case is. I feel nothing but pity for Miss Mayella, but not after she puts an innocent man‘s life on the line in order to hide her own guilt. Yes, I said guilt. She has broken a time-honored code of our society. She is a victim of poverty and ignorance, but I can‘t pity her because she is white. And what is she guilty of? She tried to seduce a black man. And now she is trying to destroy the evidence of her crime, Tom Robinson. Her father witnessed it and Tom has told us of his reaction. And what did Bob Ewell do about it? We don‘t know specifically, but we do know that Mayella was beaten up by someone who is left-handed. These two witnesses have testified under the assumption that simply because they are white their words will be considered truth and that you gentleman also believe in the idea that all blacks lie. Well, we know what the truth is. The truth is that some blacks lie just as some whites lie. There is not one person in this courtroom who has never told a lie. One last thing before I quit. Thomas Jefferson once said that all men are created equal. We know that this is not always the case since some people are smarter than others, some people make more money than others, and 71 some people have more opportunities than others. However, there is one way that all men in this country are created equal, and that is in the courtroom. In our courts, all men are created equal. And a courtroom is only as good as its jury, and the jury is only as good as the men who make it up. I am sure that you gentlemen will review this case without prejudice and come to a decision and send this man back to his family. In the name of God, do your duty.‖ 72 TKAM Tom Robinson Trial Script Directions Requirements: Everyone must participate and choose a role. We may have more than 12 jurors but we will start with 12 until all the roles are decided. You will write down your top three roles on a sheet of paper and then I will assign roles. You must look over your script. Try to memorize your lines as best as possible but you may use your script during the trial. The jury will have to work as a group. You will be responsible for listening and taking notes throughout the trial. I will collect your notes. After the trial you will need to meet as a group to decide a verdict. You MUST tell us your reasoning for the verdict. You can choose a foreman to do all the talking when you present your verdict and rationale. You must dress in some sort of costume! The lawyers, judge, and Heck Tate need to dress in nice pants/skirt and a shirt! Mayella and Bob should have on old/rough looking clothes (like overalls with a checkered shirt). The jurors can wear nice jeans and a nice shirt or they can dress up. Tom should have on some sort of jail looking uniform (sweats and a shirt that match would be a good choice!) Pay close attention to the directions. For example, Atticus stands and walks towards the witness stand. You need to follow these! You will be graded based on your participation and performance (speaking clearly and loudly, etc…) The jurors will be graded on their notes instead of their performance but points will be deducted if jurors are not paying attention to the trial. Lesson #21 Trial Reenactment 73 Objectives Students will reenact the trial of Tom Robinson in order to better understand the trial and the decisions of the people Materials Completed Scripts Novel Classroom should be set up to mimic a courtroom Procedure 1. Brief reminder of the rules of the reenactment 2. Begin the reenactment with Heck Tate‘s testimony 3. Brief closure at the end to discuss the trial so far. Ask the students if they are learning anything new. Ask the students if they could see why the people of Maycomb acted as they did. Homework None-finish reenactment tomorrow Evaluation Trial reenactment Lesson #22 Trial Reenactment 74 Objectives Students will reenact the trial of Tom Robinson in order to better understand the trial and the decisions of the people Materials Completed Scripts Novel Classroom should be set up to mimic a courtroom Procedure 1. Brief reminder of the rules of the reenactment 2. Begin the reenactment with wherever the class left off yesterday 3. Brief closure at the end to discuss the end of the trial. Discuss the verdict. Ask the jurors to defend their decision and explain their reasoning. 4. Assign homework Homework Read chapters 22-24 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Trial reenactment Lesson #23 Chapters 22-24 75 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 22-24 Students will use critical thinking skills to begin to identify the themes of the novel Materials Novel Study guide Theme handout Procedure 1. Bell Work-Journal Prompt: Atticus says when it‘s a white man‘s word against a black man‘s the white man always wins. Do you agree that this happens in the novel? What about in today‘s society? 2. Introduction of social injustice as one of the novel‘s main themes. Briefly ask the students to identify examples of social injustice in the novel. Ask the students to find examples of social injustice in society today. Remind the students of the social injustice in Mississippi Trial, 1955 with Emmett‘s murderers‘ trial and the plot of that novel. 3. Group work-Students should be in groups of 3-4 students. Pass out the theme handout and assign each group a theme. Each group must find two examples of the theme from the book as well as one theme from today‘s society and one example from Mississippi Trial, 1955. Students may need to look back at their notes as is necessary. This will also act as a mini review for Mississippi Trial, 1955. 4. Share answers as a class. Allow students to make other suggestions as well that are not mentioned. 5. Assign homework Homework Read chapters 25-27 Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation Name________________________________ Date__________________ Period_______ 76 Themes of To Kill a Mockingbird and Mississippi Trial, 1955 Directions: Each group will be assigned one theme. You then must find two examples of that theme in TKAM, one example of the theme in MT, and one example of the theme in today‘s society. We will then share the answers as a class. Theme: the fundamental and often universal ideas explored in a literary work. To Kill a Mockingbird examples (2) Mississippi Trial, 1955 example (1) Coexistence of Good and Evil Education Social Inequality Perspective Prejudice Bravery Lesson #24 Chapters 25-27 Example from modern society (1) 77 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 25-27 Students will make predictions about what will occur next Students will demonstrate fluency in Mississippi Trial, 1955 as it relates to To Kill a Mockingbird through an in-class writing assignment Materials Novel Study guide Procedure 1. Bell Work-Journal Prompt: Scout says they began their longest journey together as they head to the Halloween pageant. What do you think is going to happen to them? Why? What evidence from the book supports this? 2. Discussion: Students will share their journal prompts on a voluntary basis. Students will make predictions about the end of the novel. They will share their reasoning behind their predictions and support them with evidence from the novel. 3. In-class writing assignment: Students will have two options. Both options include choosing a scene from TKAM. Option 1: Rewrite a brief scene from TKAM as if Hiram was there. What would he say? What would he do? What would he tell the other characters? This needs to resemble how Hiram would actually speak. Option 2: Describe how Hiram would react to a specific scene. What would he be thinking? 4. Assign homework Homework Read chapters 28-31-END OF THE NOVEL! Complete study guide questions Evaluation Participation Writing Lesson #25 Chapters 28-31 78 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of chapters 28-31 Materials Novel Study guide Procedure 1. Bell Work-Journal Prompt: If you could ask any character from TKAM a question or questions who would you ask? What would you ask them? 2. Discussion: What did you think about the attack? Did you know who was he behind it? Did you know who rescued them? What did you think about Heck Tate? Do you think Bob did fall on the knife? 3. Discussion: What did you think about Boo? Did he surprise you? Did you expect him to act how he did? Do you think he‘ll start to come out of the house more? If the novel had an epilogue what do you think it would say? 4. Interrogation/Hot seat: Call students to the front of the room and assign them a character. Ask another student from the ―audience‖ to ask them a question they would want to ask that character. The student must answer as if he or she was that character. This is voluntary and students do not have to be in the ―hot seat.‖ 5. Collect journals Homework Begin reviewing both MT and TKAM Evaluation Participation Journals 79 Lesson #26 Character Review Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of major characters from To Kill a Mockingbird and Mississippi Trial, 1955 Materials Facbook handout (Attachment B) Study guides (as needed) Procedure 1. Return journals 2. Explain to students that they have completed both novels and will begin reviewing for the test. Give a brief overview of the test and what they can expect. Emphasize that the test will be over BOTH novels, not just TKAM. 3. Character review: The students will be completing a facebook page for every major character from the novels in groups. Pass out sheets. Explain under the information section they need to have the character‘s age, hometown, and any pertinent information they decide. Under friends they should have at least 3 friends from the novel. Under likes they need to list 5 interests the characters exhibited from the novel. On the wall the students need to have six comments from other characters about events that took place in the novel. For example if you are doing Atticus you could have Boo saying, ―I‘m so happy I could help Scout and Jem the night of the Halloween pageant. They are great kids and I really like seeing them in the neighborhood.‖ These need to be specific and relevant to the novel! 4. Split students into groups of two or three and assign the following characters: Hiram, Emmett, RC, Grampa, Scout, Jem, Atticus, Bob Ewell, Cal, and Boo Radley. Tell them to begin working. 5. Share answers as a class. Homework Study for the test Evaluation Participation 80 Lesson #27 Compare and Contrast Objectives Students will compare and contrast the main characters, setting, trial, and the main characters‘ realizations at the end of the novel (Scout and Hiram) in order to review for the test Materials Compare and contrast worksheet Novels Study guides Procedure 1. Remind students that everything they are doing for the next few days is to prepare for the test. Remind them of the date of the test. 2. Pass out the compare and contrast worksheets. Explain the categories. They should discuss the main characters, at least three from each novel, the setting, the trials, and the main characters‘ realizations. 3. Instruct them to work individually for 20 minutes. Walk around and answer questions as necessary. 4. After 20 minutes, tell the students to pair up and discuss their answers for 10 minutes. 5. Answer any questions for the remainder of the period and go over any specific information the students would like to know about. Homework Study for test! Evaluation Participation Name______________________________________ Date_____________ Period______ 81 Compare and Contrast REVIEW Category: Mississippi Trial, 1955 To Kill a Mockingbird Similarities Main characters: At least three! Setting Trial Main Hiram Characters‘ Realizations Scout Lesson #28 MT Review Differences 82 Objectives Students will review Mississippi Trial, 1955 by playing Last Person Standing The review is divided into two days to review both novels in depth Materials Study guides Novels List of questions Procedure 1. Explain the rules for Last Person Standing. The students will all stand up at their desks. The teacher will start with the first row and ask the first student a question. If the student gets the question correct then they remain standing. If the student cannot answer correctly then he or she sits down and anyone in the class can answer the question. The last person left standing wins a small prize (two bonus points on the test). 2. Complete the game. See attached questions. The questions get progressively harder. 3. If there is any time remaining ask students if they have any questions. If they do not have questions then continue asking review questions or give them the remaining time to look over their study guides. Homework Study for test! Evaluation Participation 83 Last Person Standing MT Questions 1. Who is originally suspected as the third man involved in Emmett‘s murder? (RC) 2. Who comes of age because of racial inequality in his own town and learns about the racism of his relatives during a trial? (Hiram) 3. Who comes from Chicago and doesn‘t know the ways of the south? (Emmett) 4. Who believes in segregation because desegregation will ruin the schools? (Grampa) 5. Who does Hiram develop a relationship with beyond normal friendship? (Naomi) 6. Whom do Ralph and Ronnie call the queen of kindness? (Gramma) 7. Who are accused of Emmett‘s murder? (Milam and Bryant) 8. Who donates to the Milam and Bryant trial fund? (Grampa) 9. At the end of the novel what is Grampa trying to get rid of? (His truck) 10. What did Ralph see the night of the murder? (Milam and Grampa in Grampa‘s truck leaving) 11. What happened to Emmett when he was alone at the river? (He was drowning and Hiram saved him) 12. What did RC do to Emmett? (Calls Emmett trash, drags him over to the riverbank, takes out a knife, guts a fish, and spreads it in Emmett‘s face) 13. What is Emmett accused of doing? (Whistling at a white woman in a shop) 14. Where was RC at the time of the murder? (Out of town) 15. Where does Hiram move when he is nine years old? (Tempe, AZ) 16. How does Mr. Paul describe African-American schools? (Very bad, run down, no supplies, etc…) 17. When RC and Hiram go to the river why does RC originally say he won‘t eat the food Ruthanne made? (She‘s African-American) 18. How does Hiram feel after RC attacks Emmett? (Dirty, weak, and ashamed) 19. Why does RC ask Hiram to lie to the sheriff? (RC says Hiram is just as much at fault as he is) 20. What happens to Emmett? (He is abducted in the middle of the night and murdered) 21. Who does Hiram think is the third man involved in the murder? (RC) 22. What is Hiram‘s Grampa upset about instead of being upset about the fact that a boy was murdered? (The murder is getting national interest) 23. What does Hiram‘s Grampa want him to do about testifying at the trial? (He doesn‘t want him to testify in court) 24. What does Grampa say about Emmett‘s death? How could he still be alive? (If he had just stayed in his place he‘d still be alive) 25. Why does Hiram want to testify? (He feels he owes Emmett something) 26. What does Mr. Paul tell Hiram to do about testifying? (Tell the truth) 27. How does Hiram make his decision? (Makes a list of pros and cons and then decides to do what‘s right) 28. Who makes up the jury? (Only white men) 29. What does the sheriff say about the body? (It was unidentifiable) 30. Who says they were able to identify the body as Emmett? (His mother) 31. How long was the jury out? (One hour) 32. What was the jury‘s verdict? (Not guilty) 84 33. How does Hiram feel about the verdict? (Makes him sick) 34. What does Milam do after the verdict? (Gives Grampa a thumbs up) 35. How does Hiram feel about his dad at the beginning of the novel? (Thinks he‘s crazy for not liking Mississippi and too politically correct and involved in racial equality) 36. How does Hiram feel about his dad at the end of the novel? (Understands him better and appreciates where he‘s coming from) Lesson #29 TKAM Review 85 Objectives Students will review To Kill a Mockingbird by playing jeopardy Materials Jeopardy questions Procedure 1. Explain jeopardy rules. There should be approximately 4 teams with 5-6 students in each team. Simply count off by four to make teams. Explain that each group will take turns choosing the question. If they answer the question wrong then the other groups have a chance to ―steal‖ the question to earn points. The winning team gets two points each on their test. 2. Play the game with attached questions. 3. If any time remains then give students a chance to look over study guide questions. Homework Study for test Evaluation Participation TKAM Jeopardy Questions 86 Characters: 100-Narrator, tomboy, develops a more adult perspective throughout the novel (Scout) 200-Old brother, ideals are badly shaken by the trial (Jem) 300-Moral backbone of the novel, lawyer, committed to racial equality (Atticus) 400-Recluse, interests the children, strong symbol of goodness (Boo) 500-Lives out in the woods, considered low class, attacks the children (Bob Ewell) Trial: 100-Tom Robinson is accused of ____ Mayella Ewell (Rape/Beat) 200-Tom Robinson‘s lawyer (Atticus) 300-The verdict of the trial (guilty) 400-Person who stalled the jury (a Cunningham) 500-Fate of Tom Robinson (shot in prison) Quotations: 100-―You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view--until you climb inside of his skin and walk around in it.‖ (Atticus to Scout about considering things from other people‘s point of view) 200-―Mockingbirds don't do one thing but make music for us to enjoy. They don't eat up people's gardens, don't nest in corncribs, they don't do one thing but sing their hearts out for us. That's why it's a sin to kill a mockingbird.‖ (Miss Maudie to Scout when Scout asked why it‘s a sin to kill a mockingbird) 300-―I think there's just one kind of folks. Folks.‖ (Scout about the differences in people) 400-―I wanted you to see what real courage is, instead of getting the idea that courage is a man with a gun in his hand. It's when you know you're licked before you begin but you begin anyway and you see it through no matter what. You rarely win, but sometimes you do.‖ (Atticus to Scout after shooting the rabid dog) 500-―So it took an eight-year-old child to bring 'em to their senses.... That proves something - that a gang of wild animals can be stopped, simply because they're still human. Hmp, maybe we need a police force of children.‖ (Atticus after Scout stopped the men from attacking him at the jail) Themes: 100-What is the major example of social injustice in the novel? (Tom Robinson‘s trial because he was found guilty but was actually innocent) 200-If you kill a mockingbird bird what are you destroying? (Something innocent) 300-What is Boo a symbol of? (Mockingbird or the good that exists within people) 400-What is a minor example of social injustice in the novel? (No women on the jury; class differences; Aunt Alexandra not allowing Scout to play with Walter) 500-What is one example of a gothic detail in the novel? (unnatural snowfall, the fire, children‘s superstitions, the mad dog, or the ominous details of Halloween night) Part 1: 100-Who comes to visit every summer? (Dill) 200-What do Dill and Jem plan to do to Boo? (Try and make him come out of his house) 87 300-Why does Scout get in trouble on her first day of school? (She‘s reading and writing) 400-Name two things the kids find in the tree. (twine, gum, soap angels) 500-What does Jem have to do with Mrs. Dubose? (Read to her every afternoon) Part 2: 100-Who shows up Sunday night when Atticus is sitting outside the jail? (a group of men who want to hurt Tom) 200-What does Mayella say happened to her and who did it? (She was raped by Tom Robinson) 300-What is important about Tom‘s left arm being crippled? (Mayella was beaten mostly on the right-hand side of her face, which would have to be done with a left hand) 400-How long was the jury out and what was the verdict? (One hour-guilty) 500-Who attacked Scout and Jem and who saved them? (Bob Ewell attacked and Boo saved them) Lesson #30 Final Unit Test 88 Objectives Students will demonstrate comprehension of both novels in multiple forms including multiple choice, short answer, and extended response. Materials Test Procedure 1. Pass out tests 2. Instruct students to write their names, the date, and the period at the top. 3. Remind the students that all answers must be in complete sentences or else they will be marked wrong. 4. Students take the test. Evaluation Test Name________________________________ Date__________________ Period_______ 89 Mississippi Trial, 1955 and To Kill a Mockingbird Unit Test Matching-Characters: 1 point each 1. _____ Bully; mean to Emmett; originally suspected as one of the men who killed Emmett 2. _____ Older brother; typical American boy; ideals badly shaken by the evil and injustice of the trial 3. _____ Recluse; dominates the imagination of the children; powerful symbol of goodness 4. _____ Comes of age because of the social injustice in his beloved town; learns about prejudice and racism of his own relatives 5. _____ Committed to racial equality; strong sense of wisdom and empathy. Good moral backbone. 6. _____ From Chicago; no sense of the south‘s morals; murdered by white men 7. _____ Takes part in trying to keep the south segregated; suspected to have some role in the murder 8. _____ Tomboy; combative streak; strong sense of faith in her community; develops a more adult perspective A. Hiram B. RC C. Emmett D. Grampa E. Atticus F. Scout G. Jem H. Boo Multiple Choice: 1 point each 1. Who was stabbed with a kitchen knife? a. Jem b. Scout c. Boo d. Bob Ewell 2. Where does Hiram spend his summer? a. Mississippi b. Chicago c. Tempe d. Alabama 3. Who did Scout find under her bed? a. Bob Ewell b. Dill c. Jem d. Boo Radley 4. How does Hiram‘s Grampa feel about desegregation? a. It‘s a great idea because everyone can learn from each other b. It will ruin the schools and America c. He has no opinion d. He will not discuss his opinion with Hiram because he wants Hiram to make his own opinion 5. Mayella Ewell said Tom Robinson: 90 a. Raped her b. Strangled her c. Beat her d. All of the above 6. What are Jim Crow laws? a. Laws to help African-Americans rise in status b. Laws to desegregate schools c. Laws to keep African-Americans stuck where the have no hope of a future d. Laws to allow African-Americans to vote 7. Who saved Scout and Jem? a. Heck Tate b. Boo Radley c. Atticus d. Cal 8. Emmett is accused of: a. Murdering a white man b. Stealing from a shop c. Whistling at a white woman d. Robbing Hiram‘s house 9. Atticus always said, ―To understand someone you have to _____________‖ a. Live with them b. Know their family c. Talk to them d. Walk in their shoes awhile 10. ________ and _________ are accused and put on trial for Emmett‘s murder a. Hiram and RC b. Milam and Bryant c. Grampa and RC d. RC and Milam 11. Who followed Scout and Jem home after the pageant? a. Boo Radley b. Atticus c. Bob Ewell d. Miss Maudie 12. Hiram‘s Grampa is trying to get rid of his ________ a. Truck b. House c. Clothes d. Friends 13. Why did Jem cry during the Tom Robinson trial? a. He had something in his eye b. He felt it wasn‘t fair c. He got a sliver d. Someone was punching him 91 14. ______ saw Hiram‘s Grampa and Milam in his truck on the night of Emmett‘s murder. a. Hiram b. RC c. Ralph d. Naomi 15. Who said it was a sin to kill a mockingbird? a. Cal b. Atticus c. Miss Maudie d. Aunt Alexandra Short Answer: 1-2 sentences: 3 points each 1. What brave thing did Atticus do in Chapter 10? Why were Jem and Scout shocked? 2. How does Hiram save Emmett? 3. What was Tom‘s handicap and why was it important to the case? 4. What does RC do to Emmett at the river? 5. Why do Dill and Jem want to give Boo Radley a note? What does Atticus say when he finds out about their plan? 6. What was the verdict in the Milam and Bryant trial? What did they do after the trial? (Not in your book but we discussed it in class) 7. What was the importance of Mayella‘s bruises being primarily on the right-hand side of her face? 8. Who does Hiram originally think is the third man involved in the murder? Why can‘t it be this person? 9. Why does Scout get in trouble on her first day of school? What does Atticus say? 92 10. At the end of the novel, who does Hiram think was involved in the murder? Why? Extended Response: 1-2 paragraphs: 10 points each 1. Explain how Harper Lee‘s use of Scout as the narrator affects our understanding of the novel. 2. Explain how Hiram‘s opinions change of the south throughout the novel and who he believes in, his father or his Grampa. Quotations: Identify the speaker and if he/she is speaking to someone. Explain the importance and meaning of the quote. At least three sentences each. 5 points each 1. ―How could they do it? How could they?‖ ―I don‘t know but they did it. They‘ve done it before and they did it tonight and they‘ll do it again and when they do itseems that only children weep.‖ 2. "Whether Maycomb knows it or not, we're paying the highest tribute we can pay a man. We trust him to do right. It's that simple."
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz