Does the Choice of Feed Phosphate Affect Pelleting Behaviour?

F e e d
i n g r e d i e n t s
n e w s
f r o m
T e s s e n d e r l o
G r o u p
November 2007
Does the Choice of Feed Phosphate
Affect Pelleting Behaviour?
Increasing numbers of animal feed compounders have commented
that the choice of feed phosphates can have an effect on pelleting
in terms of energy consumption, die wear and pellet quality. In
order to investigate this, Tessenderlo Group recently
commissioned a trial at the Research Institute of Feed Technology
(IFF, Germany) to study the effect of two different feed phosphates
on the pelleting process.
Trial set-up
The trial included two different levels of conditioning using
saturated steam; high (> 3%) and low (< 1%) moisture
addition. Also the effect of pre- and post-grinding was
studied. Pellets were produced using a ring-die press with a
3 x 60 mm die. Trial mixtures were composed of commonly
used feed ingredients, including either DCP or MCP at
practical inclusions levels. The trial mixture with MCP also
included additional limestone to balance the Ca content (see
table 1).
Table 1: composition and analysis of the trial mixtures
% Control Aliphos Aliphos
Component
Dical
Monocal
Wheat
49
47
46.9
Corn
20
20
20
Full Fat Soybean
15
15
15
Soybean meal
15
15
15
Limestone
1
1
1.6
Aliphos Dical
2
Aliphos Monocal
1.5
Results
Temperature increase (figure 1, next page)
The temperature increase due to friction in the die was
highly affected by conditioning. At high conditioning (> 3%
moisture addition) temperature increase was clearly lower.
The increase in temperature of the trial mixture including
MCP was slightly higher compared to the mixture including
DCP. This would suggest an increase in friction at pelleting.
Specific energy demand (figure 2, next page)
In addition to the effect of conditioning and grinding the
inclusion of feed phosphates increased energy consumption
compared to the control.
Italphos
P1-2
Sila; Micro-encapsulated
products
P2-3
Customer Services Team
P4
However, the type of phosphate (DCP or MCP) in the feed
has a clear effect on energy demand. The use of MCP
tends to create a higher energy demand under all
conditions in this trial.
Increases in energy consumption due to higher friction in
the die will ultimately lead to increased die wear.
Pellet stability (figure 3, next page)
At maximum conditioning and pre-grinding the pellet
quality (abrasion) improved with the use of DCP. When
MCP is included the quality deteriorates slightly. In the
case of post-grinding the pellet quality with MCP is hardly
improved, although the energy consumption is increased.
In all cases the hardness of the pellet is improved with the
mixtures including feed phosphates. There is, however,
hardly any difference between DCP and MCP.
This is Tessenderlo Group’s 8th newsletter
“Talking FEED ingredients”. A large part of this
issue is devoted to our new range of protected and
coated products of Sila replacing the Soda product
range. There is also a report of a pelleting trial in
which the pelleting behaviour of DCP and MCP are
compared. On page 4 the new Customer Services
Team for the Inorganics Business Unit is
introduced to you.
All your comments concerning this and previous
newsletters are most welcome to us at:
[email protected]
The full report is available on demand, please contact:
[email protected]
Aliphos
Differences in pelleting
Behaviour of DCP and
MCP
Windmill
Figure 1: effect of conditioning on
temperture increase pre-grinding
37
37
40
Temp. increase oC
35
31
30
25
20
15
11
8
10
13
New range of microencapsulated nutrients for
Tessenderlo Group.
5
0
Control
DCP
MCP
Control
DCP
cond >3%
In
September
2007
Tessenderlo
Group
introduced, based on the experience of 10 years
of marketing, a new range of micro-encapsulated
products in cooperation with the company Sila
S.r.l. from Italy.
spec. electric. energy Input,
kWh/t
Figure 2: Effect of grinding; on energy
consumption. max conditioning
12.7
14
Sila is a specialist in encapsulation of nutrients for animal
feed and has also developed considerable technical
expertise in encapsulation. A new plant was build in 1999
capable of producing high technological and competitively
priced products adapted to the market needs.
12
10
9.3
8.7
8.5
7.3
8
9.5
6
4
Main products in this range are the micro-encapsulated
organic and inorganic acids, combined in some cases with
natural extracts (essential oils). Products are always
coated in a way that they by-pass the stomach and have
their main effect along the whole digestive tract of the
animals.
2
0
Control
DCP
MCP
Control
pre-grinding
Abrasion acc. to Ligno; %
MCP
cond <1%
DCP
MCP
post-grinding
Target animal species are primarily piglets, sows and
fattening pigs. But these products can also be used for
broilers and laying hens and a special series of products
has been developed for ruminants.
Figure 3: Effect of grinding on
pellet abrasion max conditioning
8
7
6.8
6.4
5.4
6
4.2
5
4.3
4
DCP
MCP
4
3
2
1
0
Control
DCP
pre-grinding
MCP
Control
post-grinding
Conclusion
This trial clearly shows that the use of MCP instead of DCP
results in a higher energy consumption when producing
pelleted feed. With the combination of high conditioning and
pre-grinding the specific energy input was 35% higher with
MCP compared to DCP. In spite of this higher energy
consumption the pellet quality is not improved, using MCP.
Conditioning and grinding also have an influence on
pelleting expressed in terms of energy consumption and
pellet quality. In general, conditioning with saturated steam
results in a lower energy consumption and better pellet
quality. Post-grinding shows improvements in production
and pellet quality compared to pre-grinding.
DCP and MCP are two very distinct feed phosphates: DCP
is a powdered product with a neutral pH, MCP being more
an acidic and granulated product. These chemical and
physical differences may account for the differences
observed during pelleting.
Aliphos
The new production facility of Sila S.r.l.
Tessenderlo Group uses its existing distribution channel to
offer these products on the main European markets.
Italphos
Windmill
In the following table the products are presented
showing their composition and recommended
application. Material is available for you to test the
effect of the products in the field and you will be
convinced that there is a programme with these
products to optimise animal performance.
Table: Overview of the products, the composition and their application.
Product
Composition
Application
MICROACID 455
The standard mixture of encapsulated
acids: fumaric, malic, citric, phosphoric
and sorbic acid.
For a better-balanced microflora in
the intestine and to prevent E. Coli
and Clostridium problems in piglets
and pigs.
Also to be used as an antimicrobial
in ruminants.
MICROACID 455 HE
The same standard mixture but enhanced
with natural extracts allicine and
cinnamaldehyde.
This mixture gives extra activity
because of the presence of the
natural extracts.
MICROACID 650
Encapsulated mixture of mainly formic
acid, citric and fumaric acid. This mixture
can also be enhanced with abovementioned natural extracts.
To be used for pigs and poultry with
extra activity against Salmonella.
Also very well suited to improve the
health status of the animals to
optimize the performance.
MICROACID 650 HE
The same acid mixture but now enhanced
with natural extracts allicine and
cinnamaldehyde.
To be used for pigs and poultry with
extra activity against Salmonella.
This mixture gives extra activity
because of the presence of the
natural extracts.
MICROFORM 350
Encapsulated mixture with formic acid
activity.
Formula that gives a solution for
those situations where the presence
of formic acid is indicated.
PROPIONIC ACID 35%
Encapsulated mixture with propionic acid
activity.
A coated propionic acid activity for
applications against moulds and
salmonella.
SIL COCCISTAT
An encapsulated mixture of vitamins and
natural extracts based on allicin and
cinnamaldehyde.
These natural extracts have been
shown to be active against
pathogenic organisms and stimulate
intestinal secretions to improve
digestion
and
absorption
of
nutrients.
SIL BECOME
Encapsulated mixture of methionin, cholin
chlorid, betaïn and vitamin B2.
Mixtures of (amino) acids and
vitamins for an improved function of
the liver for ruminants.
If you have any further questions or inquiries, please contact your local representative or send an E-mail to:
[email protected].
Aliphos
Italphos
Windmill
Tessenderlo Group launches new Customer
Services Team for its Inorganics Business Unit
As part of our continuing drive to improve the relationship with our customers, Tessenderlo Group has been
in the process of re-organizing its supply chain. One of the outcomes of this project is the creation of a new
centralized Customer Services Team under the direction of John Kraft, based at our site in Tessenderlo
(Belgium). The Team became operational at the beginning of July.
The new Customer Services Team for the Inorganics Business
Unit is led by Ariane Goovaerts and is made up of Customer
Service Representatives (CSRs) who handle the complete endto-end order process, from customer order intake right through
to shipment and invoicing. This change gives the CSRs
complete control over the whole order processing chain,
ensuring that our customers can be quickly updated on the
progress of their orders.
The CSRs are now at your disposal to handle order intakes,
transport booking and call-offs, invoicing and all order-related
questions. Each CSR has responsibility for a portfolio of clients
and products, which are shown in the table below. Naturally, all
commercial topics, such as pricing and sales conditions, will
remain the responsibility of your Sales Manager.
Clients in Spain, Italy, Germany, Holland and the UK and
Ireland should continue to contact their respective local offices
in Madrid (TC España); Cologna Veneta (Italphos); Hamburg
(HGS); Rotterdam (TCR) and Leeds (Britphos) for all enquiries
st
related to order processing. From the 1 of March however,
customers in Spain and the UK should also directly contact the
Customer Services Team in Tessenderlo (Belgium).
Information will be sent to inform you further on this change.
“The centralized coordinates will help ensure all orders
receive immediate attention even in the absence of your
regular CSR. In addition, all orders received via these
coordinates will be automatically archived in case of queries
at a later date,” explains John Kraft.
“When using these new coordinates, we guarantee that your
order will be handled immediately. You are therefore
requested not to use the old telephone and fax numbers
from now on, otherwise you may find that your order is not
processed. You are, of course, free to copy communications
sent to the central coordinates to your regular CSR and
Sales Manager if you feel that this is necessary.”
“Tessenderlo Group is convinced that working with
dedicated Customer Service Representatives will strengthen
our co-operation. Your help in ensuring a smooth transition
is greatly appreciated.”
Client/product
responsibilities
Team leader Inorganics
France & Belgium
(SOP & Phosphates)
Trade Products & DCP 17
(all countries)
Overseas Export
(SOP & Phosphates)
Director John Kraft outside the
Customer Service Team building at Tessenderlo.
When placing orders and communicating with the Customer
Services Team, clients should ensure that from now on
correspondence is sent by email, post or fax to the following
centralized coordinates:
Netherlands; Germany;
FSU & Eastern Europe
(SOP & Phosphates)
Claims Processing
Tessenderlo Group Feed Ingredients
Leading the world in feed phosphates
Tessenderlo Chemie NV
Bergstraat 32, B-3945 Ham, Belgium
Tel: +32 13 611211 Fax: +32 13 611274
www.tessenderlogroup.com
[email protected]
Customer
Services
Representative
Ariane Goovaerts
Olivier Dubois
Telephone number
Sonja Viaene
Peggy Verboven
Gabriele Mini
Katrien Bylemans
Jessie Alenteyns
Maarten Verheyen
+32 13 612752
+33 3 20225811 (France)
+32 13 612747
(Other countries)
+33 3 20225843 (France)
+32 13 612748
(Other countries)
+32 13 612759
+32 13 612749
+32 13 612751
+32 13 612753
+32 13 612754
+32 13 612755
Dajana Cotza
+32 13 612730
Guy Sevenants
+32 13 612715
Evy Soentjes