CHAPTER V HABITAT UTILIZATION 5.1 Introduction The term habitat is usually defined as a dominant vegetation formation, e.g. forest, meadow or wetland (Ricklefs and Miller, 1999), the definition and meaning of habitat heterogeneity varies considerably. Different types of habitat available in an area, which are used by individuals or groups, are not in equal proportions. The seasonal variation of food availability, such as burning of grassland and annual flood also affects the variation of habitat utilization pattern of herbivorous animals (Lahon and Sonowal, 1973; Deb Roy, 1986). Individual habitat selection reflects the basic necessities of the species such as food, water and cover. But, species specific variation in habitat selection pattern has been always there. This is because of the reason that, each species has got certain specific food choice, which may not be available in each area of the home range (Bell, 1971). Elephant foraging activities affects the configuration and species composition of plant communities within their habitats. Elephants impose landscape level impacts upon their habitats by maintaining older seral stages of plant succession, with farreaching effects upon the plant and animal species therein. The physical modifications imposed by elephants upon their environments such as pathways, water seeps and opening up of understorey vegetation may tend to offset competition for forage between elephants and other sympatric ungulate species. Elephants are capable of greatly affecting the structure of vegetation and perhaps animal communities (Cumming, 1982; Western, 1989). At high densities, elephants reduces woodlands and keep on converting them to more open grassland (Laws et al., 1975; Cumming, 1982; Western, 1989). Herbivores favouring ecotone and forest grassland mosaic habitats can benefit from the presence of elephants, whose activities tend to maintain these communities at the expense of closed-canopy forest habitats. In most habitats, plant communities determine the physical structure of the environment and therefore, have a considerable influence on the distributions and interactions of animal species (Lawton, 1983; McCoy and Bell, 1991). Species preferring closed-canopy habitats, such as arboreal primates, may be adversely affected for these same reasons (Eisenberg, 1980). It has been disastrous for elephant populations as the elephants need not only grassland, but also forest for meeting their nutritional requirements (Lahiri-Choudhury, 1980; Sukumar, 1989b). Elephants may also be subject to heat stress in the absence of adequate shade in pure grasslands (Sukumar, 1994b). Grasslands are the preferred feeding habitat of elephants; they do however, need other habitats for movements, resting, shade (cover), breeding and other purposes (Ishwaran, 2001). Feeding preferences and behaviour of Asian elephant are known to change over time due to changes in its habitat (Iswaran, Op. cit.). As people continue to occupy more and more forest land for settlement, agriculture and construction of building and dams and other forms of development, the shrinking habitat area compresses the wildlife population to levels beyond carrying capacity (Sukumar, 1994a). Presently, a number of wildlife habitats have undergone or are being threatened with the fragmentation due to various anthropogenic factors and this has adversely affected the larger mammalian populations residing in it (Johnsingh et al., 1990). The long-term effects will include genetic isolation, habitat fragmentation within the same forest and enhancement in the human-elephant conflict in adjoining areas. Genetic isolation of elephant populations may also increase the chances of replacement of interbreeding to intra-breeding and thereby reduce the population persistence, even for wide ranging wildlife species (Joshi and Singh, 2008). In India Asian elephant habitats were studied by Ali, et al. (1983-84), Daniel et al. (1987), Singh and Chowdhury (1999), Choudhury (2002), Kushwaha and Hazarika (2004), Varma et al. (2008), Williams (2003), Williams et al. (2008)and Zhang and Wang (2003). In North-Eastern India, there are wide varieties of savannah ecosystems, depending upon various origins from a number of forest types, ranging from tropical rain forest, through sub-tropical and humid mountain forests to temperate forest (Champion and Seth, 1968; Puri, 1960). Presently, most of the elephant habitats are destructed by various development activities like road construction, industrial development, slash and burning cultivation, construction of the hydro electric projects and as well as by natural cause like river erosion, sedimentation etc. But, information and assessment on habitat of Asian elephant in North-East India has been found scanty except the assessment of habitat loss in Kameng and Sonitpur Reserves by Kushwaha and Hazarika (2004). They also found that, the moist mixed deciduous forest, which supports highest biodiversity in Assam are facing maximum deforestation. However, little is known about the habitat utilization pattern of Asian elephant in Manas National Park till inception of this study. Hence, it is very much essential for the protected area managers and conservation planners to know the habitat utilization and selection pattern of endangered species like Asian elephant to identify the critical habitat requirements to protect these from the anthropogenic pressure of the ever increasing human population. Thus, the study of habitat utilization pattern of Asian elephant in Manas National Park has been designed to fulfill these requirements and can be used in other areas as the Manas National Park has mixture of grassland habitat and woodland habitats. 5.2 Objective The main objective of this chapter is to investigate the habitat utilization pattern of Asian elephant in Manas National Park. Present study has tried to answer the following question based on above objectives1. What were the available habitats of Asian elephant and landscape matrix of these habitats in Manas National Park? 2. What was the relative habitat use of Asian elephant in Manas National Park? 3. Was there any fluctuation of habitat utilization of Asian elephant during different time slots of day viz. Morning-(06:00 – 10.00 hrs.), Noon (10:00 – 14:00 hrs.), Afternoon (14:00 – 18:00 hrs.) and correlation with the fluctuation of temperature in these three time slots of the day? 4. What was the habitat selectivity of Asian elephant in different types of habitat in MNP? 5.3 Methods To find out the habitat utilization and the selectivity of Asian elephant, all the existing different habitat types of MNP has been categorised and then the satellite imagery was analysed to record the area under different habitat categories. 5.3.1 Categorization Methods 5.3.1.1 Habitat Classification For the categorization of habitat ground truthing with the help of satellite image and GPS locations in different representative types of habitat. 5.3.1.1.1 Satellite imagery The satellite image of Manas National Park was obtained from National Remote Sensing Agency, Secoderbad. 5.3.1.1.2 Habitat Types The different habitat types found in Manas National Park are such as evergreen forest, semi evergreen forest, moist mixed deciduous forest, tall grassland, wet grassland, short grassland which formed the major habitats and rest was classified as miscellaneous habitat. The characteristics of these habitats were observed in the field, based on the description of Champion and Seth (1968). 5.3.1.2 Ground truthing To rectify the false colour composition and to standardize the colour specification of the satellite imagery, field visits were made to locate above representative vegetation types during study period. While observing the different habitats in field, GPS readings were recorded with respect to habitat types, which then incorporated at the satellite imagery to determine the variation in habitat types in regards to the coloration. These data were incorporated into the Geographical Information System (GIS). The GPS data were then imported to satellite imagery and thus habitats were classified accordingly by using supervised classification in ERDAS software. Based on the specific area in different colour of satellite imagery, the landscape matrix of Manas National Park was calculated. 5.3.2 Habitat utilization pattern The same methods that were used for measuring the home range size of elephants also used for measuring the habitat utilization pattern. Whenever the Asian elephant sighted, the types of habitat, GPS location, number of Asian elephant sighted were recorded. The timings of Asian elephant sighting were also recorded. The time period of the day viz. Morning-(06:00 – 10.00 hrs.), Noon (10:00 – 14:00 hrs.), Afternoon (14:00 – 18:00 hrs.), during which the elephant were encountered in that particular habitat has been also recorded. After locating the elephants, the scan animal sampling and Ad. Libitum Sampling (Altmann, 1974) methods were used to collect data on the time spent. Total of 4320 hours of scan animal sampling and Ad. Libitum Sampling were done for Asian elephant in Manas National Park during study period. The relative habitat use pattern was calculated by using the following formulaHabitat utilization of H1 by Asian elephant Habitat utilization (%) = Habitat utilization by Asian elephant in × 100 all habitats (H1+H2+…..+Hn ) (Where H1, H2,......Hn= Habitats utilized by Asian elephant in MNP) 5.3.3 Temperature fluctuation in a day There has been robust temperature fluctuation in different hours of the day. To get the clear picture of temperature fluctuation the temperature was recorded in three times a day viz. Morning-(06:00 – 10.00 hrs.), Noon (10:00 – 14:00 hrs.), Afternoon (14:00 – 18:00 hrs.) covering all the four seasons of the year. The temperature was recorded in the Dwimari camp, which was in the central location of Manas National Park and on the Indo-Bhutan border. 5.3.4 Fluctuation of habitat utilization from the expected level As there were seven different habitat types in MNP that, were considered to be utilized by elephant homogenously i.e. expected relative habitat utilization will be 14.29 %. Deviation of habitat utilization (relative %) by Asian elephant from this level was calculated to observe the habitat utilization preferences. 5.3.5 Habitat Selectivity The variation in habitat use by Asian elephant was supposed to be based on availability of the specific types of habitat. So, the selectivity of the different habitat was calculated to find out the habitat preference. The standardized habitat selection index for constants resources was used to compare habitat selection of Asian elephant in different habitats at Manas National Park. This index was chosen, because it does not fluctuate with inclusion or exclusion of seldom-used resources (Manly et al., 2002) and was considered more versatile than other selection preferences indexes (Garshelis, 2002). The index was based on the selection ratio Wi, which refers the proportional use of habitat divided by the proportional availability of each resource. The formulae was as followsOi Wi = i Where, Oi = Proportion of the sample of used habitat in category i; i = Proportion of available resource in category i; i= evergreen forest/ semi evergreen forest/ moist mixed deciduous forest/ tall grassland/ wet grassland/ short grassland/ miscellaneous habitats. A wi value larger than 1 indicates a positive selection for the resource and a value less than 1 indicates avoidance of the resource. A value around 1 indicates that, the resource was used proportionately to its availability and no resource selection was noted. 5.4 Results 5.4.1 Habitats of Asian elephant With the help of GIS, satellite image and ground truthing methods (GPS location) seven major habitat types has been recognized in Manas National Park. These habitat types were- Evergreen, Semi evergreen, Moist Mixed deciduous forest, Tall Grassland, Wet Grassland, Short Grassland and Miscellaneous types (Figure 5.1). The vegetation characteristics of these habitat types were found as follows- i) Evergreen Forest (1B/C and 2B/C): The evergreen forest habitat was dominated by Bagipoma (Chikrasia tabularis), Bhelu (Tetramales nudiflora), Gonsori (Cinnamomum cicicodaphe), Badam (Mansonia dipikae), Bonsum (Phoebe goalparensis), Titasap (Michelia champaca), Lali (Ammoora wallichii), Dhuna (Canarium resiniferum), Khakan (Duabanga sonnerotoides), Gamari (Gmelina arborea) etc. followed by Parali (Stereospermum personatum), Oxi (Dillenia pentagyna), Nahar (Mesua ferea), Cham (Artocarpus chaplasa), Barham-thuri (Talauma hodgsonii), Larubandha (Macaranga denticulatus) etc. Shrubs species were Kathanaphul (Moninda angustifolia), Kukurathengia (Leea sps.), Kawla (Litsea spp.), Chorat (Laportea crenulata), Tora (Alpinia allughas), Dhopat tita (Clerodendron infortunatum), Kamini Kanchan (Murraya exotica), Narasingha (Murraya kaengii), Pipoli (Piper longum), Basaka (Adatoda vasica) etc. Among grass species Khagori (Phragmites karka), Meghela (Saccharam procerum) and shrubs Eupatorium odoratum etc. were present. Among climbers and epiphytes, the very much conspicuous species found in this habitat were Ghila lota (Entada scandens) and Kuchia lata (Acacia pinnata) etc. During present study this habitat was mentioned as evergreen forest (Figure 5.1). ii) Sub Himalayan High Alluvial Semi evergreen Forests: 2B/CI/ISI. This type of habitat occurs on the high ground of the MNP on the northern boundary. Three distinct sub types were recognized viz. (a) The Jam- Bhelu-Som sub type [(2B/CI/ISI (b)], (b) The Sopa sub type [(2B/CI/ISI (C)], (c) The Bonsum sub type [CB/CI/ISI & 2B/CI/ISI (C)]. There was pure climax type occupying the upper deciduous to semi evergreen type and the third was intermediate type (Figure 5.1). a) The Jam- Bhelu-Som sub type: 2B/CI/ISI (b) This type was transition belt from the deciduous to evergreen type of habitat. The Tetramales nudiflora was the predominant species of this type. The associated tree species were Syzigium cuminii, Tetramales nudiflora, Machilus bombycina, Stereospermum personatum, Albizzia lebbek, Amoora wallichii, Chukrassia velutina, Pterospermum acerifolium, Toona ciliate, Shorea robusta and, Phoebe goalparensis etc. b) The Sopa sub type: 2B/CI/ISI (C) The Sopa sub type occupies comparatively high ground above the Bonsum type. The general canopy level and principal emergent associates were Tetramales nudiflora, Acrocarpus fraxinifolium, Schimia wallichii, Phoebe goalparensis, Michalia champaca, Sterculia alata and Pterospermum acerifolium etc. c) The Bonsum (Phoebe goalparensis) sub type Approximate to CB/CI/ISI & 2B/CI/ISI (C) The Bonsum sub type represented climax vegetation of the locality and occupied a high ground surrounded by other sub types. The conspicuous layer in the top canopy was composed of scattered trees of Michelia champaca, Tetramales nudiflora, Phoebe attenuate, Acrocarpus flexinifolius, Ailanthus grandis with Bombax ceiba along the river bank. Below this layer the proper canopy occurs with Phoebe goalparensis, Sterculia alata, Cinnamomum cecedodaphane, Schimia wallichii, Canarium species, Disoxylum hamiltonii, Gmelina arborea, Terminalia bellirica, Castonopsis species and Pterospermum acerifolium, etc. The third storey was composed of Machilus bombycina, Premna bengalensis etc. The undergrowth characterized by species Morinda tinctoria, Leea sp., Adhatoda vasica etc. and the ground cover consists of Coffea bengalensis and other evergreen shrubs. Thus the habitat was mentioned as semi evergreen forest (Figure 5.1). iii) Moist Eastern Himalayan Mixed Deciduous Forests – 3c/3Cb & 3c/C3 2SI. This habitat represents the composition of both the above forest types. This type of forest occurred in successional stage between the grassland and the semi-evergreen forest. Variation in drainage and moisture retention capacity of the soil seems to be responsible for exclusion of Sal (Shorea robusta) in this area in MNP. Thus the type has been definitely in a transition stage in between the riparian forests and grassland in MNP and was arrested at the pre-climax variation due to local variation of soil. The predominant species in such areas were (associated of Sal) Terminilia bellirica, Sterculia villosa, Lagerstroemia parviflora, Dillenia pentagyna, Michelia champaca, Allibizzia lebbek, Strospermum personatum, Bombax ceiba and Fagara budrunga and Toona ciliate etc. The middle storey was made up of saplings of the above species and Wrightia sp., Emblica sp. and Bridelia sp. etc. In open canopy conditions Imperata sp., Anthistiria gigantia, Saccharum sp., Clerodendron sp., Litsea sp., Coffea bengalensis were found as ground cover. Thus the habitat was mentioned as moist mixed deciduous forest. iv) Tall Grassland This type of habitat occurred as patches of grassland and was characteristic of well drained high land in the plain areas and usually comes in existence in old village clearing and adjacent to village cultivated area. These areas were subject to heavy annual fire and regeneration with heavy grass was often seen with other stunted fire hardy species such as Dillenia scabrellia, Phoebe paniculata, Butea monosperma, Careya arborea, Dillenia pentagyna and Dillenia indica etc. The main grasses in this type of grassland in Manas National Park were Imperata cylidrica, Themeda arundinacea, Themeda caudata, Arundo donax, Phragmites karka, Themeda villosa, Saccharum spontaneum and Erianthus ravennae. The height of this grassland was sometimes more than 5 meter, which was enough to cover an adult elephant. The tree species scattered in grasses were Simul (Bombax ceiba), Koroi (Albizia procera), Amlakhi (Emblica officianalis), Oxi (Dillenia pentagyna), Palash (Butea monosperma) etc. Hereafter, this habitat has been mentioned as tall grassland (Figure 5.1). v) Short Grassland The main species were Imperata cylindrica, Sungrass Imperata arundinacea, Kush Saccharum spontaneum and Meghela Saccharum procerum etc. However, species like Nal (Arundo donax), Khagori (Phragmites karka), Ekara (Erianthus ravanae) etc. also scattered in it. The tree species scattered in the short grassland were Simul (Bombax ceiba), Koroi (Albizia procera), Amlakhi (Emblica officinalis), Oxi (Dillenia pentagyna) and Palash (Butea monosperma) etc. Rare species like Reinwaeditia indica, Desmodium motorum, Pueraria subspicata and Priden pilosa, etc. also found in the short grassland habitat especially in Manas National Park. During present study this type of forest was mentioned as short grassland (Figure 5.1). vi) Eastern Wet alluvium Grassland (Terai formation) This type of forest was found in Manas National Park especially on severely drained and low lying locations with little change of composition. The grass species found were Kush (Saccharum spontaneum), Kahua (Saccharum procerum), Khagori (Phragmites karka), Ekara (Erianthus ravanae). Among the tree species present were Koroi (Albizia procera), Urium (Bischofia javanica), Owtenga (Dillenia indica), Bhelkar (Trewia nudiflora), Simul (Bombax ceiba) etc. During present study this type of forest was mentioned as wet grassland (Figure 5.1). vii) Miscellaneous In the miscellaneous type of habitat the river and sand area, riparian fringing forest, Khoir-sisoo forest, encroached cultivated area inside Manas National Park were included. Other than the cultivated area the riparian fringing forest, Khoir-Sisoo forest contributed major portion under this habitat category (Figure 5.1). (a) Riparian Fringing Forests 4E/RSI This type was consists of plant communities in seral stages found along the banks of the streams that flow through the forest. The succession progresses according to the formation of soil of the river bed with deposition of silts. The principal species were Simul, Khoir, Sissoo. In the later stage, Albizzia procera, Bridelia retusa, Lagerstroemia parviflora and a few species were more characteristic of the miscellaneous type come up. (b) Khoir-Sissoo Forests. 5/IS2 This type comes under primary seral stage of succession of tropical dry deciduous forest. This was found mainly in the Gabharukhunda area and Dwimari area of the Manas National Park. The principal species in this type, as the name itself suggest were Acacia catechu and Dalbergia sissoo growing either in admixture with each other or in separate pure block. Young stands of Sissoo in excellent forms were seen in silt formed in beds of the above rivers as well as the fresh silt deposits on the bank. Most of the growing stock was young and only a few trees of utilizable size were available. But, due to the unstable nature of the soil the excellent growth of the Sissoo or Khoir were often found uprooted and washed away by the rivers during rainy season. (c) Cultivated area In the Manas National Park, more than 20 km2 area in the Panbari and Bhuyapara Range were encroached by human. These areas were used mainly for cultivation of wet and dry paddy Figure 5.1 Map showing different types of habitat in Manas National Park. 5.4.2 Landscape Matrix From the landscape matrix analysis this was found that, area of the Manas National Park was mainly covered with 28.1 % of semi evergreen forest, followed by moist mixed deciduous forest (26.7 %), tall grassland (22.32 %), wet grassland (11.4 %), miscellaneous (5.31 %), short grassland (3.67 %) and least of 2.51% by evergreen forest (Figure 5.1, Figure 5.2). 30 28.1 26.7 Relative area in MNP 25 22.32 20 15 11.4 10 5.31 5 3.67 2.51 0 Evergreen Forest Semievergreen Moist Mixed Tall Grassland Wet Grassland Forest Deciduous Forest Short Grassland Miscellaneous Habitat Figure 5.2 Landscape matrix of different types of habitat in Manas National Park. 5.4.3 Habitat Utilization Pattern During the present study it was found that, annually Asian elephant utilized highest of 28.33 % semi evergreen forest, followed by tall grassland (21.16 %), wet grassland (19.76%), moist mixed deciduous forest (14.12 %), short grassland (8.14 %), evergreen forest (4.38 %) and least of 4.11 % miscellaneous habitat in Manas National Park (Figure Relative Habitat Utilization (%) 5.3). 28.33 30 25 19.76 20 14.12 15 8.14 10 5 21.16 4.38 4.11 0 Evergreen forest Semi evergreen Moist mixed forest deciduous forest Wet grassland Tall grassland Short grassland Miscellaneous Habitat Figure 5.3 Annual habitat utilization patterns of Asian elephant in Manas National Park. 5.4.4 Seasonal Habitat Utilization Pattern The seasonal habitat utilization pattern of different habitats by Asian elephant was found as followsA. Pre-Monsoon Season During study period, it was found that Asian elephant utilized highest of 27.85 % tall grassland during pre-monsoon season, followed by semi evergreen forest (27.81 %), wet grassland (24.96 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (7.66 %), short grassland (6.69 %), miscellaneous (3.14 %) and least of 1.89 % evergreen forest in Manas National Park (Figure 5.4-a). B. Monsoon Season During study period, it was found that during monsoon season Asian elephant utilized highest of 30.64 % semi evergreen forest, followed by moist mixed deciduous forest (21.23 %), wet grassland (17.73 %), tall grassland (14.14 %), evergreen forest (8.23 %), miscellaneous (5.71 %) and lest of 2.32 % short grassland habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.4-b). C. Retreating Monsoon Season During study period, it was found that, during retreating monsoon season Asian elephant utilized highest of 28.48 % semi evergreen forest, followed by tall grassland (22.44 %), wet grassland (21.39 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (15.26 %), short grassland (5.06 %), miscellaneous (4.35 %) and least of 3.02 % evergreen forest in Manas National Park (Figure 5.4-c). D. Winter Season During study period, it was found that, during winter season Asian elephant utilized highest of 26.39 % semi evergreen forest, followed by tall grassland (20.25 %), short grassland (18.49 %), wet grassland (14.96 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (12.31 %), evergreen forest (4.38 %) and least of 3.22 % miscellaneous in Manas National Park (Figure 5.4-d). Relative Habitat Utilization (%) 27.81 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 27.85 24.96 7.66 6.69 3.14 1.89 Evergreen forest Semi evergreen forest Moist mixed Wet grasslandTall grassland deciduous forest Short grassland Miscellaneous Habitat Relative Habitat Utilization (%) (a) Pre-monsoon Season 35 30.64 30 25 21.23 17.73 20 14.14 15 10 8.23 5.71 2.32 5 0 Evergreen forest Semi evergreen forest Moist mixed Wet grassland Tall grassland deciduous forest Short grassland Miscellaneous Habitat Relative Habitat Utilization (%) (b) Monsoon season 28.48 30 25 21.39 20 22.44 15.26 15 10 5 3.02 5.06 4.35 Short grassland Miscellaneous 0 Evergreen forest Semi evergreen forest Moist mixed Wet grassland Tall grassland deciduous forest Habitat (c) Retreating Monsoon Season Relative Habitat Utilization (%) 30 26.39 25 20.25 18.49 20 14.96 12.31 15 10 4.38 5 3.22 0 Evergreen forest Semi evergreen forest Moist mixed deciduous forest Wet grassland Tall grassland Short grassland Miscellaneous Habitat (d) Winter Season Figure 5.4 Habitat utilization pattern of Asian elephant during (a) Pre-monsoon, (b) Monsoon (c) Retreating Monsoon and (d) Winter Season in Manas National Park. 5.4.5 Habitat Utilization Deviated From Expected Level During study period it was found that, Asian elephant utilized semi evergreen forest (14.04 %), tall grassland (6.87 %), wet grassland (5.47 %) habitat more than expected; while it had used the moist mixed deciduous forest (-0.17 %), short grassland (-6.15 %), evergreen forest (-9.91 %), miscellaneous (-10.18 %) habitat less than expected in Manas National Park ( Figure 5.5). Annual relative habitat utilization deviation from expected (%) 20 14.04 15 10 5.47 6.87 5 0 -5 Evergreen forest Semi evergreen forest -0.17 Moist mixed Wet grassland Tall grassland deciduous forest -10 -9.91 -15 Short grassland Miscellaneous -6.15 -10.18 Habitat Figure 5.5 Annual habitat utilization deviation from expected level by Asian elephant in Manas National Park. A. Pre-monsoon Season During study period, it was found that, during pre-monsoon season, Asian elephant used the tall grassland (13.56 %), semi evergreen forest (13.52 %), wet grassland (10.67 %) habitat more than expected; while it had used the moist mixed deciduous forest (-6.63 %), short grassland (-7.6 %), miscellaneous (-11.15 %), evergreen forest (-12.4 %) habitat less than expected in Manas National Park (Figure 5.6-a). B. Monsoon Season During study period, it was found that, during monsoon season, Asian elephant used the semi evergreen forest (16.35 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (6.94 %), wet grassland (3.44 %) more than expected; while it had used the tall grassland (-0.15 %), evergreen forest (-6.06 %), miscellaneous (-8.58 %), short grassland (-11.97 %) habitat less than expected in Manas National Park (Figure 5.6-b). C. Retreating Monsoon Season During study period, it was found that, during retreating monsoon season, Asian elephant used the semi evergreen forest (14.19 %), tall grassland (8.15 %), wet grassland (7.1 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (0.97 %) habitat more than expected; while it had used the short grassland (-9.23 %), miscellaneous (-9.94 %), evergreen forest (-11.27 %) habitat less than expected in Manas National Park (Figure 5.6-c). D. Winter Season During study period, it was found that, during winter season, Asian elephant used the semi evergreen forest (12.1 %), tall grassland (5.96 %), short grassland (4.2 %), wet grassland (0.67 %) habitat more than expected; while it had used the moist mixed deciduous forest (-1.98 %), evergreen forest (-9.91 %), miscellaneous (-11.07 %) habitat less than expected in Manas National Park (Figure 5.6-d). Relative habitat utilization deviation fromexpected (%) during pre-monsoon 13.56 13.52 15 10.67 10 5 0 -5 Evergreen forest Semi evergreen forest -6.63 -10 -15 Moist mixed Wet grasslandTall grassland deciduous forest Short Miscellaneous grassland -7.6 -11.15 -12.4 Habitat (a) Pre-monsoon Season Relative habitat utilization deviation from expected (%) during monsoon 20 16.35 15 10 6.94 3.44 5 0 -5 -10 Evergreen forest -6.06 Semi evergreen forest Moist mixed Wet grasslandTall grassland deciduous -0.15 forest Short Miscellaneous grassland -8.58 -11.97 -15 Habitat (b) Monsoon season Relative habitat utilization deviation fromexpected (%) during retreating monsoon 20 14.19 15 10 7.1 5 8.15 0.97 0 -5 Evergreen forest Semi evergreen forest Moist mixed Wet grasslandTall grassland deciduous forest -10 -15 Short Miscellaneous grassland -9.23 -11.27 Habitat (c) Retreating Monsoon Season -9.94 Relative habitat utilization deviation from expected (%) druing winter 15 12.1 10 5.96 4.2 5 0.67 0 -5 Evergreen forest Semi evergreen forest Moist mixed Wet grasslandTall grassland deciduous forest Short Miscellaneous grassland -1.98 -10 -9.91 -15 -11.07 Habitat (d) Winter Season Figure 5.6 Habitat utilization deviations from expected level of Asian elephant during (a) Pre-monsoon, (b) Monsoon (c) Retreating Monsoon and (d) Winter Season in Manas National Park. 5.4.6 Fluctuation habitat utilization during different time slots The habitat utilization pattern of Asian elephant in different slots of day viz. Morning-(06:00 – 10.00 hrs.), Noon (10:00 – 14:00 hrs.), Afternoon (14:00 – 18:00 hrs.) in different seasons were as followsA. Pre-monsoon Season During present study it was found that, during morning hours of pre-monsoon season, the Asian elephant utilized mostly the tall grassland (34.31 %), followed by utilization of semi evergreen forest (22.4 %), wet grassland (17 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (16.13 %), short grassland (5.38 %), evergreen forest (2.97 %) and least utilization of miscellaneous (1.81 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(a); Table 5.2). During present study it was found that, during noon hours of pre-monsoon season, Asian elephant utilized mostly semi evergreen forest (33.62 %), followed by utilization of wet grassland (22.01 %), tall grassland (15.74 %), short grassland (13.17 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (10.28 %), miscellaneous (3.07 %) and least utilization of evergreen forest (2.11 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(a); Table 5.2). During present study it was found that, during afternoon hours of pre-monsoon season, Asian elephant utilized mostly tall grassland (31.73 %), followed by utilization of wet grassland (25.95 %), semi evergreen forest (29.01 %), short grassland (11.99 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (7.07 %), miscellaneous (1.28 %) and least utilization of evergreen forest (1.09 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(a); Table 5.2). B. Monsoon During present study it was found that, during morning hours of monsoon season, Asian elephant utilized mostly the semi evergreen forest (27.25 %) habitat, followed by utilization of moist mixed deciduous forest (23.75 %), tall grassland (20.25 %), wet grassland (13.91 %), evergreen forest (11.38 %), miscellaneous (1.81 %) and least utilization of Short grassland (1.65 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(b); Table 5.2). During present study it was found that, during noon hours of monsoon season, Asian elephant utilized mostly the semi evergreen forest (46.52 %), followed by utilization of moist mixed deciduous forest (13.22 %), tall grassland (12.57 %), wet grassland (12.57 %), evergreen forest (8.81 %), miscellaneous (3.97 %) and least utilization of short grassland (2.34 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(b); Table 5.2). During present study it was found that, during afternoon hours of monsoon season, Asian elephant utilized mostly the moist mixed deciduous forest (27.66 %), followed by utilization of semi evergreen forest (23.47 %), tall grassland (21.18 %), wet grassland (16.98 %), evergreen forest (5.43 %), short grassland (3.34 %) and least utilization of miscellaneous (1.94 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(b); Table 5.2). C. Retreating Monsoon During present study it was found that, during morning hours of retreating monsoon season, Asian elephant utilized mostly tall grassland (30.53 %), followed by utilization of semi evergreen forest (22.34 %), wet grassland (22.24 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (16.42 %), evergreen forest (3.84 %), short grassland (3.02 %) and least utilization of miscellaneous (1.61 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(c); Table 5.2). During present study it was found that, during noon hours of retreating monsoon season, Asian elephant utilized mostly semi evergreen forest (44.02 %), followed by utilization of wet grassland (19.26 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (12.09 %), tall grassland (10.97 %), short grassland (6.83 %), miscellaneous (3.42 %) and least utilization of evergreen forest (3.41 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(c); Table 5.2). During present study it was found that, during afternoon hours of retreating monsoon season, Asian elephant utilized mostly tall grassland (25.48 %), followed by utilization of wet grassland (23.51 %), semi evergreen forest (23.23 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (17.97 %), short grassland (6.01 %), evergreen forest (2.22 %) and least utilization of miscellaneous (1.58 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(c); Table 5.2). D. Winter During present study it was found that, during morning hours of winter season, Asian elephant utilized mostly semi evergreen forest (32.43 %), followed by utilization of moist mixed deciduous forest (16.27 %), tall grassland (16.16 %), short grassland (13.55 %), wet grassland (13.41 %), evergreen forest (6.7 %) and least utilization of miscellaneous (1.48 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(d); Table 5.2). During present study it was found that, during noon hours of winter season, Asian elephant utilized mostly semi evergreen forest (23.36 %), followed by utilization of short grassland (21.89 %), tall grassland (19.93 %), wet grassland (14.68 %), moist mixed deciduous forest (12.04 %), evergreen forest (5.39 %) and least utilization of miscellaneous (2.71 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(d); Table 5.2). During present study it was found that, during noon hours of winter season, Asian elephant utilized mostly semi evergreen forest (24.8 %), followed by utilization of tall grassland (24.71 %), short grassland (20.39 %), wet grassland (17.16 %), moist mixed deciduous Forest (9.73 %), evergreen forest (1.82 %) and least utilization miscellaneous (1.39 %) habitat in Manas National Park (Figure 5.7-(d); Table 5.2). Evergreen Forest Semievergreen Forest Mixed Deciduous Forest 22.01 29.01 Tall Grassland Wet Grassland 1.81 3.07 1.28 5.38 17 Morning ( 6 am- 10 am ) Noon ( 10 am- 2 pm) Afternoon ( 2 pm- 6 pm) 13.17 11.99 31.73 15.74 16.13 10.28 7.07 34.31 33.62 17.83 22.4 2.97 2.11 1.09 Relative habitat utilization (%) 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Short Grassland Miscellaneous Habitats Morning ( 6 am- 10 am ) Noon ( 10 am- 2 pm) Afternoon ( 2 pm- 6 pm) 1.81 3.97 1.94 Tall Grassland Wet Grassland Evergreen Semievergreen Mixed Forest Forest Deciduous Forest 1.65 2.34 3.34 13.91 12.57 16.98 20.25 12.57 21.18 13.22 23.47 23.75 27.66 46.52 27.25 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 11.38 8.81 5.43 Relative habitat utilization (%) (a) Pre-monsoon Season Short Grassland Miscellaneous Habitats Evergreen Forest Semievergreen Mixed Forest Deciduous Forest Tall Grassland Wet Grassland Habitats (b) Retreating Monsoon Season Short Grassland 1.61 3.42 1.58 3.02 6.83 6.01 22.24 19.26 23.51 25.48 30.53 10.97 16.42 12.09 17.97 23.23 44.02 22.34 Morning ( 6 am- 10 am ) Noon ( 10 am- 2 pm) Afternoon ( 2 pm- 6 pm) 3.84 3.41 2.22 Relative habitat utilization (%) (b) Monsoon season 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Miscellaneous 20.39 21.89 1.48 2.71 1.39 5 13.55 15 13.41 14.68 17.16 20 16.16 19.93 24.71 25 16.27 12.04 9.73 32.43 23.36 24.8 30 6.7 5.39 1.82 Relative habitat utilization (%) 35 10 Morning ( 6 am- 10 am ) Noon ( 10 am- 2 pm) Afternoon ( 2 pm- 6 pm) 0 Tall Grassland Wet Grassland Evergreen Semievergreen Mixed Forest Forest Deciduous Forest Short Grassland Miscellaneous Habitats (d) Winter Season Figure 5.7 Habitat utilization fluctuation during morning, noon, afternoon by Asian elephant during (a) Pre-monsoon, (b) Monsoon (c) Retreating Monsoon and (d) Winter Season in Manas National Park. 5.4.7 Correlation between fluctuation of habitat utilization of Asian elephant with the fluctuation of temperature during different slots of day Present study revealed that, with the fluctuation of daily temperature, humidity during morning, noon, afternoon Asian elephant habitat utilization has positive correlation during pre-monsoon (with temperature r=0.998, p=0.044, N=3; humidity r=0.999, p=0.033, N=3), monsoon (with temperature r=0.546; humidity r=0.621), retreating monsoon (with temperature r=0.987; humidity r=0.951) and winter (with temperature r=0.98; humidity r=0.964) in short grassland habitat of Manas National Park (Table 5.1). Table 5.1 Showing the Correlation between fluctuation of habitat utilization of Asian Short grassland Miscellaneous Semi evergreen Wet grassland Temperature -0.844 -0.932 -0.837 0.998 0.427 0.498 0.842 0.361 0.237 3 3 3 3 3 0.721 -0.229 0.853 0.926 0.827 0.487 0.853 0.35 0.247 0.369 0.033* 3 3 3 3 3 0.568 0.67 -0.584 -0.71 -0.141 0.546 0.809 0.615 0.532 0.603 0.497 0.91 0.632 0.401 3 3 3 3 3 0.642 -0.599 0.506 0.642 0.049 0.621 0.751 0.556 0.591 0.662 0.557 0.969 0.573 0.46 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 0.404 0.799 -0.591 -0.909 -0.56 0.987 0.768 0.735 0.41 0.597 0.273 0.621 0.102 0.442 0.38 0.044* 0.719 3 3 0.999 0.411 Correlation Sig. (2- 0.73 tailed) 3 3 Correlation Sig. (2tailed) N Pearson Humidity Tall grassland Pearson 3 3 Correlation Sig. (2tailed) N Temperature 0.245 tailed) Pearson Monsoon Moist mixed deciduous forest Temperature Sig. (2- N Retreating Monsoon 0.709 Correlation N Humidity Pre-monsoon Pearson Evergreen Habitat Climatic Factor Correlations elephant with the fluctuation of temperature during different slots of day. Pearson Correlation Sig. (2tailed) N Humidity Pearson 3 3 3 3 3 0.261 -0.881 0.707 0.962 0.68 0.951 0.856 Sig. (2- 0.832 0.313 0.5 0.176 0.524 0.199 0.345 3 3 3 3 3 0.405 0.64 -0.749 -0.513 -0.411 0.98 0.739 0.735 0.558 0.461 0.612 0.686 0.127 0.471 3 3 3 3 3 0.339 -0.584 0.7 0.573 0.474 0.964 0.785 0.78 0.603 0.507 0.657 0.731 0.172 0.425 3 3 3 3 3 tailed) Temperature Pearson 3 3 Correlation Sig. (2tailed) N Pearson Humidity 3 Correlation N Winter 3 3 3 Correlation Sig. (2tailed) N 3 3 * Correlation was significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed). Table 5.2 Showing fluctuation of habitat utilization by Asian elephant, temperature and 33.62 10.28 15.74 22.01 13.17 3.07 28.94 47 17.83 7.07 31.73 29.01 11.99 1.28 26.92 55.44 1.81 19.7 Temperature 5.38 Humidity 34.31 17 Miscellaneous 16.13 Short Grassland Tall grassland 22.4 Wet grassland Mixed Deciduous Forest Morning ( 6 2.97 am- 10 am ) Noon ( 10 2.11 am- 2 pm) Afternoon ( 2 1.09 pm- 6 pm) Semi evergreen Forest Season Time slots/Habitat Pre-monsoon Evergreen Forest humidity during morning, noon and afternoon in Manas National Park. 88.67 Monsoon Retreating Monsoon Winter Morning ( 6 11.38 27.25 am- 10 am ) Noon ( 10 am- 2 pm) Afternoon ( 2 pm- 6 pm) Morning ( 6 am- 10 am ) Noon ( 10 am- 2 pm) Afternoon ( 2 pm- 6 pm) Morning ( 6 am- 10 am ) Noon ( 10 am- 2 pm) Afternoon ( 2 pm- 6 pm) 23.75 20.25 13.91 1.65 1.81 26.12 92.6 8.81 46.52 13.22 12.57 12.57 2.34 3.97 31.19 68.27 5.43 23.47 27.66 21.18 16.98 3.34 1.94 29.36 75.01 3.84 22.34 16.42 30.53 22.24 3.02 1.61 23.41 89.8 3.41 44.02 12.09 10.97 19.26 6.83 3.42 30.44 55.83 2.22 23.23 17.97 25.48 23.51 6.01 1.58 27.89 72.68 6.7 32.43 16.27 16.16 13.41 13.55 1.48 13.4 5.39 23.36 12.04 19.93 14.68 21.89 2.71 24.63 39.77 1.82 24.8 9.73 24.71 17.16 20.39 1.39 20.53 62.96 94.03 5.4.8 Habitat Selectivity Present study revealed that, Asian elephant has positive selection for the short grassland (wi=2.96> 1), tall grassland (wi=1.26> 1), evergreen forest (wi=2.33> 1), semi evergreen forest (wi=1.34> 1) and wet grassland (wi=2.31> 1); whereas Asian elephant used the miscellaneous habitats proportionately with its availability (wi=1.03~ 1). However, Asian elephant were found to have lesser selection for the moist mixed deciduous forest (wi=0.7<1) (Table 5.3). Table 5.3 Showing the habitat selectivity index of Asian elephant. Habitat Landscape matrix Evergreen Forest Semi evergreen Forest Moist Mixed Deciduous Forest Tall Grassland Wet Grassland Short Grassland Miscellaneous 2.51 28.1 26.7 22.32 11.4 3.67 5.31 Annual habitat Use 5.84 37.77 18.82 28.23 26.35 10.85 5.47 Selectivity Index 2.33 1.34 0.7 1.26 2.31 2.96 1.03 5.5 Discussion The Asian elephant utilizes the semi evergreen forest (28.33 %) mostly, though they utilized the tall grassland (21.16 %), wet grassland (19.76 %) after semi evergreen forest in Manas national Park. The Asian elephant in Manas National Park utilizes the semi evergreen forest more than expected. The Asian elephant has utilized these habitats not based on habitat availability but depending on the amount of food, shades (cover) and water availability. The semi evergreen forest and the grasslands have closer approximation in Manas National Park. Therefore, Asian elephant prefers these three habitats. These three habitats, forms the highest edges in Manas National Park and in the edges the animal activities are always more due to edge effect (Rabha, 2002). The landscape matrix of the different types of habitat also showed highest area of the park has been covered by the semi evergreen forest (28.1 %). But, it may not be the cause for high utilization of semi evergreen forest habitat by Asian elephant. The semi evergreen forest provides shades and food, which the elephant utilizes during the hot part of the day and feed on the grasses during the morning and afternoon hours of the day. The Asian elephant in Manas National Park maintains a relatively higher density in the jungle edge. It was also suggested by Olivier (1978a), Rood, et al. (2010) and McKay (1973). The Asian elephant in Manas National Park used the primary forest like semi evergreen forest, tall grasslands, wet grasslands which contradicts the findings of Merz (1986) worked in Ivory Coast, showing that elephants use secondary forest more intensively than primary. The Asian elephant has tree main benefits from utilizing the forest edge viz. Firstly, they are able feed on the grassland during morning and afternoon without getting too much discomfort from rising temperature of sun during noon hours; secondly they are getting access to the quality food of trees species and cover (shades) during noon hours in the woodland habitat; thirdly they has greater safety in the woodlands and remaining in ecotone will give them opportunity to get inside the woodland during any danger situation. McKay (1973) also suggested the same except the third benefit. The elephant is therefore strongly identified with a habitat that provides forest cover and grassland in roughly equal proportions (Olivier, 1978a). Mueller-Dombois (1972) notes that elephants make greater use of woody habitats where they occur in the form of smaller stands and in combination with grass covered areas, with more continuous woody habitats utilised to a lesser degree. As secondary re-growth is abundant in forest edges, are generally rich in elephant foliage, which in return could benefit elephants living on the forest-nonforest interface (Sukumar, 1989b, 1990b; Zhang and Wang, 2003). Laws et al. (1975) using faecal and track indices showed that, the majority of elephants that move from the grassland remain in the forest edge, alternating between grassland and forest. During the pre-monsoon season the Asian elephant utilizes the tall grassland (27.85 %) and semi evergreen habitat (27.81 %) mostly, which has been found more than expected in MNP. During the pre monsoon season the grassland has been burned and new sprouts comes out within 2-3 weeks, which attracts the herbivores including Asian elephant in MNP. They graze on the new sprouts of the tall grassland during morning and afternoon hours and they utilize the adjacent semi evergreen forest during the noon hours. Again, during the monsoon, Asian elephant utilizes the semi evergreen forest (30.64 %) and the moist mixed deciduous forest (21.23 %) mostly in MNP. During the onset of the monsoon season, the tall grassland, wet grassland area becomes dense and relatively become impenetrable compared to pre-monsoon season and the grass becomes coarser along with the increasing number of insects disturbing elephants. This makes elephant to move towards the northern part of the Manas National Park, where habitats has been dominated by the semi evergreen, evergreen, moist mixed deciduous and small patches of short grassland present sparsely between the woodlands. Inundations of the habitats present in the southern part of the park during monsoon with the associated increase of muddy area are also found to be the cause of northern movement of Asian elephant. Presuming that, elephants feed more frequently on the bamboo (Dendrocalamus strictus) during monsoon, it is apparent that, elephants were attracted towards the fresh growth of bamboo at the onset of monsoon which has comparatively higher density in the northern part of the Manas National Park. Elephants in Manas National Park were observed to occupy northern part during monsoon season and shifted towards the southern and central part during winter. During retreating monsoon season, elephant utilizes the semi evergreen forest (28.48 %), tall grassland (22.44 %) and wet grassland (21.39 %) mostly. The onset of the retreating monsoon season associated with the flowering of the grass species, which attracts the elephant for moving down towards the grassland distributed on the middle and southern portions of the Manas National Park. The elephant were seen feeding on the apical portion of the pre-flowering stage grasses during the retreating monsoon season. With the onset of the winter season, the grasses and plant starts drying and sheds leaves respectively in Manas National Park, so, the availability of food for Asian elephant becomes low. During this season, the availability of the water has been found uneven, as water availability is more along the southern boundary line and northern boundary line leaving the intermediate portion of the Manas National Park devoid of water excepting the area closer to Beki, Hakua River. The elephant has been seen not preferring the water sources in the southern boundary, as the area associated with anthropogenic disturbance and cattle grazing. Hence, they need to move towards the northern boundary of Manas National park, where they utilizes stream and ponds as the source of water. During winter season the habitat utilization has been determined completely by availability of water in the habitat and on the food. Hence, Asian elephant utilizes the semi evergreen forest (26.39 %), which are present mostly along the northern boundary of the Manas National Park. Waterholes like Dwlabill, Keshipukhri and other small water holes plays important role in supplying water to Asian elephant in Manas National Park. Elephant distribution during the dry season in the Kalahari sand region of Wankie National Park was determined primarily by the provision of water supplies (Weir, 1971). A large mammal like the elephant could be expected to move more considerable distances even with a short period and families of a clan seemed broadly coordinated in their seasonal movement (Sukumar, 1989b). The reason for the elephant and other animals’ migration is the high lands, continuous and uninterrupted hilly terrain for grazing, assured food, ideal breeding ground and thick population (Singh, 1981). During the present study this has been seen in Manas National Park that, daily fluctuation of temperature and humidity plays major role in Asian elephant habitat utilization pattern. Since, Asian elephant is black bodied animal and cannot remain for longer duration as temperature rises during the day period. Hence, there has been fluctuation in habitat utilization by Asian elephant in Manas National Park along with fluctuation of temperature and humidity in the habitat. Asian elephant utilized more open canopied habitats like wet grassland and tall grassland during the morning and afternoon period. During the noon time the Asian elephant has been seen to utilize the closed canopied forest at the edge of grassland such as semi evergreen, evergreen forest in Manas National Park. These habitats are relatively cooler than the grassland habitat. Humidity has also correlation with the fluctuation of habitat utilization by Asian elephant in different period of day but to a lesser extent than the temperature fluctuation in Manas National Park. The elephant utilized the lesser canopied habitat, when the temperature falls in Manas National Park. The habitat specialists are more affected by area and isolation, while habitat generalists more by landscape context. Here, in Manas National Park also Asian elephant has daily movements to the forest inside the Bhutanese territory on a landscape basis. Hence, extensive study on the habitat of Asian elephant in collaboration with Bhutanese authority has been suggested for trans-boundary conservation strategy. There has been need to maintain the connectivity of the habitats of Manas National Park with the habitats present outside the eastern and western boundary by maintaining the existing corridor. Sukumar, (2003) also suggested connecting the fragmented habitats by ensuring connectivity for elephant movements and to expand elephant habitats to a reasonable size. The international highway passing through the eastern boundary of Manas National Park emerging as the major threat to the Asian elephant habitat contiguity. Because of the construction of highway through the eastern boundary of Manas National Park, two migratory routes have been impacted, which is permanent damage to the Asian elephant seasonal movement towards the eastern boundary Subankhata Reserved Forest. Habitat utilization pattern studies hence, important for conservation of Asian elephant in Manas National Park on regular basis. Anon (1995) also suggested habitat-based ecological studies of individual species as the basis for much successful conservation efforts. PLATE 5.1 Asian elephant habitat in Manas National Park. Evergreen forest habitat Semi evergreen forest habitat Moist mixed deciduous forest habitat Tall grassland habitat Wet grassland habitat Short grassland habitat PLATE 5.2 Habitat utilization patterns of Asian elephant in MNP. Elephant herd utilizing the tall grassland habitat after annual burning in MNP. Solitary elephant utilizing the short grassland habitat in MNP.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz