! "
#
%$&(')*+-,.
#
'/
102'34656789
10
;:< =?>@'
/A BDCFE)GIHKJMLNEDGPO(LNE)G
QSR1TIUVXWZYR\[]W*^4_)p*`a[NUbegqWdR\cIVZR1hdY.erWtsUbWZ^4egf\_)h2u/U4R1[IevfikRwhtjlWZR1^V YmTNnNWdR1V7oNfegR1[If1R
p7[NexqyR1V=hX~ exWtY.s{Uz2exƒ…^]„?Uh1i}† sy|NUu/[NR1‡FevfˆSR\Y.hXWdf1R\h\V*† ƒxu/Ry~7† Uyf4† nN€4z*‰ |NpS‚
ŠŒ‹#ŽN‘?’“Ž
nIT“hd^R\TNi˜nNƒvWZUb^ÃWZex^yR1[[IhdUnN[IVZiR8TIWdcIVd^bU4qFW°eviUR7ƒxƒ*qbT“U4^yVZevhZUbhdWdex™Neg^ƒg[RaexU[8ƒxƒgR1UmƒgRaž ”f1U[ŒT“^R1TI[]nNWdƒgR\U4V{WdegWd^cI[KR †
jlR\^fYm^yYmYmY^[ÆR\[IhXiR1RwWXi°Wdeg[NUyh9‡]h_›^^ƒgƒg_^b¶*htW=h1Ub„}WdѓevfkÒÚYÙÆnWZÖNU4Û WdÖegÖI^#[š™FTIs°Vd^yQ7™IRU4™NÜyeg^ƒg[IerWt‡8sŒMU4Q7VZRR
” h.U•YmR1WZUb–—cNR\nNVdevhXWdevfhdR\UVZf=c˜U4ƒg‡^VZexWdcNY™IUyhXRwi
Z
V
^y‡y[šR1[NR1YmWdevR\f1f=h\cI|NUWd[NcIegRhdY.‡R\h[NUR™IWZeghtfWZVZU4Uyƒgf‡WZ^R\VZi˜exWdcN_›VZY6^YœMž T”S^yŸ TNnNegYƒvUbTIWZexƒx^yevf[ –
Üy\Èy^[NÉ݇Ÿ |“|wUÈ][I€iºÎ Ÿ Ñ|wÒ«ÑÒÚÓPÙšÕ ÖNÛ ÖIÖÛ ÖyÖIÎN7×d™FÖIsÛ ÖyÖNž#VZØFR™F_›R1sm[oNhtWZf=RcIWXUbWZÞËR.R1MVSž#ß1VZà R_›ábR1âN[…htoWZf=RcIWXWZUbR_㖠|
exhdWdTIƒgs{Uf1Y.R¢U4WdegcN[]VZWZ^U4nIeg[I‡h c£WdcNWdR(cNR¤hXWZU4T“Wd^evhtTIWZnNegf\ƒgh¡U4WdUeg^™[K^yn† W¡Wd¥9cNR(cNevhdh¦R\U4exV=Yf=c –
_›iR1R\Vw[N|“^4\WZÈR\Éyh?È WZŸ cN†DRS`˜hXWdnNä VZcIeg[NƒxR\‡[]ƒg™“R1R1[Neg‡[Wdc{iR\egVd[.egqWdRwcIieghlWdcITIU4U4W/T“ÑR1VwÒÆ|yhdÙ¤cN^y´nNå4ƒgæti{|4¶2™RScIR1‡VZR1R7[N–æ
TNcIƒgUev[IfexfWR¨htžW=Ub”Wdev©hXhWdevf1T“h(R1Vdf1_›U^[aVZY.™“U4R.[IRf1§RTN†«ƒgegª¬f1[¦erWZƒxWZsacNnIevhhXRwTIikUTWZ^8R\V\R1|*[U –
R1qV=R\U4VdƒgexÄIƒgsRwi•ç ^TN™FWds¹egYmoFUYmƒ © erWZMcÃ`ÅU4nNä [IcNi¹ƒgR1[FéI™“^R1VZeg‡[KR\|NVXWt\s¸ÈyÈyXè \Ÿ Èy|´È¶2Ý cNŸ †evf=cz2¶9RwfUR\h/[y_›WZnNƒxsyVX|
WZcNVdR1R1V–
WZWZhXWZexcN^yU4R[®WdevhXhtWZMWZU4o egf\Wd”7evhtht–—¯ WZ™IegpSUf\h*hd` R\egi¨[Ÿ _›U^egh°iIVZY.U4TNTUbVZWZWd^exegqyT“^R^y[hd[NR\^^yiK_
[†±Wd–—cNnNRo [N”SexU4_›^¯ƒgƒxVZR\pSY­ƒxR`²iYevnInhXWdW=hdVZR\Uberh––
WZWdhdcIU4R\U4WdR8egV=^f=Uy[¹cNiNR\U4WZVZTN^ah(WZR\Ubc[NWZU´excIq^yRU4[Ã[Uf^4TNR°_STNYž ƒgexRwn”iÃW=© UbhUWdegiNT“^UR1[ÅTVd_›WZ^^U4VZ[NWdYmR°eg^U[P^4[I_7fWZWdRR\cNf=U4cNR8[I[NYmi¹evê]^ynNchXR\U´WhqTIR{WdVd^•^yY.YYUeviNnhXR ––
™NYnNnWdWZegU4^Wd[eg^eg[°[{^yR\UTf=R\cVZU4ƒxWd^egf^n[Kh † WZµS^nNUyV iNTIU4VdTR\WZƒxexegqyYmR1exƒg[Is.UUVdi´s³tnIR§hXW9T“R1WdVZcNerR –
eg`[N‡ševf=cIVZU4R\ƒghdR1R\¶2U4V=evff=Ìyc«|}\U4ÈyVZR\ÈUyÈ h8Ÿ † ex[®ž ” hŝM~ eg™R\[K|7ex[]WZR1V=iex[I‡I|U[Ii
”7¯
WZWZYmexex^yqyR1[IRº[]U4W=hdh ƒlRW*hd™NcNer^W^b_D¶˜·IWZR\exWdT¸hXcIW*U4YTNW¡nVZo ^W=™NUbWdƒgR1eg^Y.p7[¹h\`3† Uyf^yVZn^yWdhZT“h(R1UVd_›^VdR\VZTNY.VZh?R\hdWZR1VZ[]UyWZiU4er––
”
_›WdVZcI^hDRÃYëU*hthdW=T“R\Ub^U4WdTIV=evf=hXnNWdc(ƒgevU4f1U4Wdh8ƒgeg‡^U4^y[.™“Vdex‡y^WdR1ncN[NW8YÚR1WdWZ™IevcNf1UyRÃh\hX|bRwhXWdiSRwcNU4^yR#V=[(f=ž cÆYm” R\hdf=TIexYmcIUUf1TN[NR•ƒgevegfhdqFexY.WdevUŃgh/sUWdY.™IcNhtRPUWZexVZ[]T“UyWZ^fUTNWZexR\[ni h–
ƒv^UbT“WdR1eg^V=Ub[/WZ†kex^yª—[IWh#nWdhX^Rwh(R1§WdTNcIƒxR°evfhdexWdR1ƒgƒgsaR\fR1Wd§Feg^Wd[KV=U|?ffW(VZ^yWZhZcNhdR.^bqegYR1V(TIUƒxev[Ifi¹exWYhXWZnNUbWZWZUbeghXWZWdexev^yf1[ h
» ¼y½ ŽN¾2¿7À7’“ŽNÁX¾ ½
_›VZ^YÔWZcNR(T^yTNnNƒvUbWZex^y[WZ^mVdRwUf=c{WZcNR([NR1§]W7hdRW*^_DT“^eg[]WZh2eg[
¥™I9UycNhXRlRwi±‡R1[IR1RqWd^yevƒxf nNUWdegƒx^‡y[I^VZUerVdWZsÂcNY®U4ƒg…‡ž ^VZ”SexWdŸ cN|bY8UyhK|^[IY.R U‰Fex[]ex[IWZiºUex^[_NhÇU¤R\[NR1T“V=^UbTNWZnIex^yƒg[U4–– WdRcI§RTNƒghdevfR\exUWdVZƒgsºf=caWd^#hdTIR1Uy[NfcIRU†º[If¥9R9cNž evh#”exYm© h
TNTƒgR\egf1VXer_›W^yVdhXY.WZU4UWd[IevhtfWZRyegf\†KhSª¬[f\U4WZ[acNegh)™“RTIUnIThXR\RwV\i |
WdU4egVZ^R°[aR1^4qb_ U4ƒgf1nIUUb[IWZiR\evi˜iNUbUWZf\Rf^hX^yV=iƒxnNeg[NWdeg‡k^[IWZh*^¹WdU•^TIU{Vd‡^yeg™NqƒxR1R\[YTI–—hdVdT^yRw™NfƒxexR\ÄY8f|IÄN¶2WdcN[NevRwf=hdc h ^UT“[NR1R1V=¶ÇUbWZ^hXWZVwU4|\Wdf\evU4htƒgWZƒxegRwf\iºht–—o ™I”7UyhX¯ Rwi{pS`¹UiN|wUegTh}WdTIegqVd^yRST[N^]^hX[NRw–…i}nN†D[Io er_›”S^yVd¯ Y±p7`±YnNR1WZ§UbTNWZƒxexev^yf[ –
_›WdnNeg^[I[/f†Wdeg¯ ^[ÅR1¶¦WdcIT“U4^WTNnIiƒgRU4ÄWd[Neg^R\[.hevWdhlcIf1RVdRwR1Ub[FWdqFRweximVZ^™F[NsYmhdR\R1[yƒgR\Wf_›Wd^eg[NV‡WZcNVZR1R8ƒvUbR1Wdqegq^yR\ƒxnNƒxs – ex^4Wd_ºƒgsU4ƒgnIƒxR\hXƒxRwRwh*hWZegcN[ŒRmU•htW=‡yUbR1Wdev[NhXR°Wdevf1ƒg^FhSf1exnI[h_›^y^bVdY.qR\U4VWdegWZ^cN[kR8^T_ ^yWdTNcNnNRmƒvUbiWdeveght^WZ[¸Vdeg™NWd^¹nWZUex^yi[ –
ÄNWdcIW8R1YÂYmR1WdYcNVZ™“^R1nIV=‡hc{^4VZ_(R\Wdf1cI^R•Y™ITNexVZ[IR\U4hdWdR1eg[]^W°[.TU4^y[TNi.nNYƒvUbnWdegW=^Ub[ÆWZex^yU4[.[IiÇ^T“R1R1qV=^yUbƒxWdqFeg^eg[N[‡ h ³t¶2nIexhXWdW c°WdWdcIcNR2R(YTInVdW=^yUb‡WdVZegR\^hZ[mh TN^VZ_D^WZ™cNU4R™Nž egƒxex” Wts(† _›^yV
WdcIU4W ƒx^fnh UiNUTWdegqR\ƒxs
Ÿ
”
iWdMegž#R\^[y^y[W9ƒgiNYm^™[R1R\WdVdY.cN‡^U4|i}[Fw|ËsmÈT“É_ÊÈ^UTNf†
WdnN^¥9ƒvV=UbcNh\WZ|]exR7^yhdT“[knIR1f=hXVdceg_›Ì1^UyRyVZh¡|Y.f1R1U4Vd[I[I^]f1hdf1^FhdR*iN^bex^4q[N_/R\‡mV9UhZUž f=[IcNi8R1YmYevh¡RnNi|WZR1hdUbR1T“WZƒgR1exR\^y[f[ –– ì í˜îKï Á î}ð ¾ ñ íŒî/ò ‘)Ž î ¿£óô¾ Nõ
Wd^TI^T“UTR1f=V=R\cNUbV2^FWZ^]¶l^hXV=R#Rh1†P_›^^T“f¥9nIR1cNV=h*evUbh^WZ^[YmV=Wdh*UcN‰_›R(^yRwV#hY^yexnWmTWZWdU4iNegWderY.Í{eg^U4[8fƒ?nI^T“ƒrWwT“R1| VdR1_›exV=^_7UbVZWZ[NY.^^4VwU4Wm† [Iegf1YR†T“^yª¬hZ[ahdexWZ™NcNƒgRegh | öK÷Êø ùú LNûDüwLü\JMýEšJMEšþ°C]E)C]ü\JMÿ ù G“ý bJÊü\B ”
ªWd¬[mVZR\*U4Wd^Rwƒgi°ƒvU4Uy[Ih*i ©UPh?ž ÏX™” Uf=Ê‰F*‡^yVZƒx^ƒvnNU4[[i}i{|N^\T“ÈFR1€4V=Î UbŸ WZ|´^YV=ÐnW=WZcIUbWZUbexW#^y[f=cI^U4T“[NR1‡yV=R\Ubh9WZ^™NV)exWZeghh ‡¥9f=cNR\cN[N^FR.R^yWZhdT“egegf[NR1Vd‡^y_›^TWZVZcNR\Y.VZRºU4U4VdWd[Ieg^‡f1V=c]R.hºW9^4U4^_¡[IT“i•WdR1cNV=VZRUbR1WZƒgž^R1qbV=hlU4[]UhXWº[Ieg‡iTI[NU4UexV=ÄTNU4f\TNYmU4VZ[]^RWdWZTNƒgR1s•VZV=evh1Ubi†mWdR\R#T*TIR\^bU[I¶¡VZiNUR1h(qyYR1^yR1Vw[ – |
^4Y_ºnNegWZ[IUbiWZexeg^yq][aevinITNUVZ^ƒgh{™U4^™N[NegƒgƒxsÃexWtsm^f1Ñf\ÒÔUhdexÓ¦^y[IÕ ÖNU4ƒg×\ƒxsyØ?| T¶2R\exVSWdcš™IerWwU¨†V=`UbWdncIW=R1UbV{Wdeghd^Ym[•Uegƒxh ƒ WdU4R\VZVZR(h*i_›R^WZV7R1VZWdYmcNRmex[Nž Rwi°” ™]evsh7UR§iNTerR\Í{VdegfR1nI[ƒrfWSR(WZU^hdV2‰ËTI†*Vd¥/egY.V=UU4iNVZs.erWZexR^y§[ITU4R\ƒgVdƒxsyegYm|NWZR1cN[]R1WZs h
_›ÄNVZ§^R\Y i°iUŒnNVZTIegU4[NVd‡WdevWdfcNnNRºƒvU4VZV•nN[Ni[N^egY.[N‡mU4eg^4[«_DWdeg[¤cNRUž iqb” U4†N[¥9fR¸cNegUh9[I‰FiÆeg[Ii°WdcN^4R\_
[ëf^U4[NVZR –
hXU4WZ[U4iÇ[]Wf1UT[ÇU4V=ƒgU4R\YmUyi¦RWZR1WdV{^ŒhdhdRnNWX™WZex–—[I^‡¸TWZU4exY.TNTIU4Vdƒ#^]T“UR1f=c˜Vd_›^egVZh{YmWdUegY[IfR1R•–—f1^¶2[IcNhdR1nN[ÚYmTIeg[NU4‡ –
V=ƒgexU4RwYmhReg[¹WZR1V=Wdh(cIRU4VZ[IRU4egWd[InNUVZTNR.TNWZVZcI^UbTNWVZegWdU4cNWdRR\ƒxsk^ThdWZRexWwY.† U” ƒl[ITIiPUVZ¶2UYmcUbRWWdR\evVh(qb¶lU4^yƒgnNVZR\hdRh
Y.VZR\U´hdR\skU4V=qbf=U4cNVZR\sVZh7¶2cIerWZU´c¨qRWdcNU4R.TNTNR\qƒgeg^R\ƒgi•nWZYmex^yU[a[FskTNVZU^iNfUR\hZTh#WZU4^4Wd_*eg^ž [” WZh\R\†.f=cN*[NevR1ê][nNfR\Rh |
WdegU4[yR\[IWZVZeg^•iNhdY3ex[Nž ‡”^4|_lhUf=[IWdci^kU4[N`R\‡y[NevRcIf=|}UcIU[IU4iNfƒgR1R.U¶2TWZevWZcNfU4ÌyR1Wdeg|/egV^\[kT“ÈyÈR1eg[¨ÈVd_›Ÿ ^ž† VZY.9” Uh(U4hd[If1R\f1Ui°Rk[k^Ê™[8~ R.exWZ™“cNf1R1ƒgR[KUyhdYm|?hd7erR\Äf=exR\[cNi ––
Wdegeg[y[NcIWZ‡¦Rk^°qbWdWd^ÆU4cNƒgVZnNhXR1R^yR{Y^4f\RÅ_UbWdU¹iR\‡RhXWZ^yWdR1VdV=VZegUbR\YWdh\R\eg„ ‡[NsÃev
yhtßWZTà¬egßf¸U4V=VdU4nIYmƒxRyR|WZ=R1à áV.°
yeváh{á “
àU4á ƒx“bßWd¦à¬R\ábVdàRwái˜
á•Uy“f1¶2à¬f1ábcN^àR1V=iFVZ R –
Wd¶2^4cI_¡cNRkU°R\VdhXhXR¡RwWdU4WdV=V=cIUbf=WZR1cÃR1VZ‡yR¡TNs°evVZh?^FThdf1U4^R\V=YmhZU4hYmR¡Wd_›RcI^WZVZU4R1Y¤W{Vw|Ëeg^4Uhm_[InI_›i!R1hdR\R\1iNi¸ß1™Iâ "WdU#X^¹f=á‰
yiáegegË[VZ_›à$R\^yfbßVdWm8Y.WZáUbcNWZ
Rexá^y“f=[cIà¬áb_›U4VZà[N^‡yY R
Wd¶2›cIcIcNR1R˜R\[IVdf1f=RcNR|IVZWZ^cNUYmƒgRkhd^^]TIhXUf\^yU4VZYUƒgƒxYmRwRwhai!RWdUR\[I%V.#Xi«ß&Wd^¸nNb[Iâ(™'iNRaà$R1%VZUy‡ iN^FŸ U4†R\TNh•WdR\‡iŒR\[NevRh{WZegR\f¸[If^^T“iR1RwV=iŒUbWdegex^[][WZ^ h
Kö ÷vö ùú LNûDüwLü\JMýEšJM*E ),+/üwLü\JMýE
egU4oF[[eg[Ii.ž fR Wd” cIYh\R1|nVZUR7W=iNUbcIUWdU´egT^qyWZ[ºR7U4Wdev™“hKeg^R1^yR1[{[N[R?eg[{Y.^4_FYU4Wd[FnNcIsmWZR UbVdTNWZRwexVZhX^yexnNY.[{ƒxWZU4cIh#VZUys*h º‡yƒgUyä^R1f=[N[N‰“R1‡|“Wd™ev\f
R\Èy^R1È]T“[€.R1-]hXV=~ WdUbnexWd™“ieg^exR1Rw[[Ki h |
Ÿ
eg*[Neg‡I[]|NWdR\UyVZiNiU4egT[NW=‡Ub|FWZUex^y[I[i°eg`[8egYf=cnU4W=ƒgUbR1Wd¶2eg^ev[°fÌcI|ËUwTNÈTÈÈR\[I†
h2ž#eg[°R1[NWt¶lR\VZ^mUƒxƒgƒgR1s{qR\hXT“ƒgh\R\† U‰]–
ª¬f[&VZ^yhZWZhdcN^bRÆqR1WdV^egT£hUƒxR\iNqUR\TƒM|WdRwWdiÅcNR¢inIV=VdUbeg[NWZex‡P^¤Wd™“cIRRWt¶¡VdnNR1[˜R\[ ^4_(YU¹nWZž U4Wd” eg^†¡[ QSU´UqF[Ievi h
^4tw_È^yÉyTÈ ŸR\VZTNU4VZWd^^T“V=hP^yhdWZR\^¤i˜TWZcIR\VXUb_›W°^yVdWdY cIR¨^ž [&” U«f1U4f=cI[Æ^yhdhXR1R\[ԃxRwfTIWU_›VdVZR\^[yY Ww|UÅRwUhXf=R1c W
Ÿ UiNUTWdegqR\ƒxs
¶2UiIexWdU4cÅTWZUR\i®ÄN§WdR\cNi¹RÇTNVZVZU4^Wd™eg^ÚU4™N™“egƒxRexWtWts¶¡†•R1R\Ü[±nNƒvYhXWdVZn^W=Yœ
t

\

y
È
y
È
Î
™WdIcIUyRhXRwj2iºµ#^[ºht0W Wd9cIR1UeghdVDR\T“iR1^Vd_›T“^R1VZV=Y.UbWZU4^[IV2f1Rz*†)UbjlWZR ^yVd” [NiNR#UbUWdßegT^à/WZ[Ôá4U4âWdtegU^w[I[¹Èi±%È …/ j2fŸ VZ1µ i^yR1hZ9qFhXz^bevhXqy”#RwR1i ŸV
YmTNVZR^WZ™IcNU^™Niegƒx¶2exWdegcIR\R1hSVZRl™R1WZWtcN¶lR*R\ž R14[ ” 2TR\^VdT“eg^R1iV=Ubevf1WZU4^ƒgV=ƒgh*s™FhXs8¶9U4‡TegqFhDex‡y[Nex‡qyR1Wd3[ cNRm2(cNÄIeg§F‡RwcNi –
R\eg[NhXW7‡{TNWZcNVZ^Rm™YU4™N^]eghtƒxW#exWts{‡yUWZex^{[IhSWZcNeg[kR^ÄNT“WZ[NR1V=R\UbhZh1WZ^†(V2¥DWZnIcIhdUb^WS[acIUU[Ih7ia™R\z2R1^][khdhTNVZt^wÈiÈnIÉ fŸ–
WZR[FU4§FnNWdWZYegR1^[I™“[miR1U4RwV=hi.[IŸ iWZ¶2cNfexR(VZWd^yc8j2hZhX1µRw^bUqy9f=R1c°z VD”TNex[IVdiN^yYmex™IqFRU4evWZi™IcNnIex^ƒgU4eri{WZƒ…ex† Rw™Fh9s{›f^^[I–…RR\–—q[N^^ƒgVZqFY.ex[IU4‡ºƒgexWdÌ\cNR\R#i(YVZR\nU– ƒ
ª¬U[ÚiIU4WdTcNWZR¹R\i˜™“^4iWdnNWdVZ^yexY@
ƒxWZR\cNqRR\ƒM|#VdnIWd[˜cIR¹^_#TNVdU¹^y™Iž U4” ™Iex| ƒgernNWts¦[Nex_›^^_VZYYƒgns¸WZU4^yWdV.eg^[N[Ú^[Negh–
N
[
¨
‡
Ÿ
WdWdnNR\cI[NVdRexYm_›^ƒg^FegVZ[Nf1Ymeve/htƒxWZR1s˜eg§Ff(T“^bhZq^f=R\[IcNVmR1R1[]YmR\WdUevRwU4f=h*cŒƒgƒxisyƒgR\†*^f1f*VdnIRwRwUh\hd†ÚhdhdexR1[IV7éI‡#^Uѓ‡][IÒ«U4iVdWt^b`ÃsÇqUäR\t[NV¡w[NÈWdR1egÉYVÈ RtwnIU4È[IhdÈNR\i° iŒŸ ^biiqR\RRV––
VZeg[Nexqy‡ÔR\iaYUnW=‡UbR\WZ[Nex^yR1V=[ U4ƒ)TIRVd§^yTN™IVZU4R\™NhZeghdƒgexer^yWts£[a^4™]_¡s®iRÑWZÒR1VZ6 Y5 Ÿ eg[NevÙ htWZegf\ U47?ƒgƒx9å sk8 f=;Ÿ c:;<;U4=?[N‡> –
R i 7 5J| evh8 K|WdcNEšR°U4WZVZexYmRRÃf1^›[I‡yhXR1WZ[NUR\[]VZWZU4h\– |
@BA Ñ)D CFEG5då4è Ÿ å$ H > æ :;<= Ÿ ¶2cNR1VZI
H@evhWdcIR°T“^TInNƒgU4Wdeg^[˜hXegÌ1Ry|lU4[
Wdeg^[°f^ynN[]WdR1V Ÿ L† ºUä f=‰X\ÈÈ]è Ÿ TNVd^yT^]hXRwi{UhdR1ƒx_㖬UiNUTWZU4Wdeg^[
Zh6T•f=cNegR1h¡YmWZRcNR(™Fsº[FnNUYiNi™“eg[NR1V2‡*^U2_DTI^yVd™^y³t™IR\U4f™NW9egqbƒgerUWtsSVdevU4q™NR\fƒgR\Wdh^yŸ VN_›ÑM^V2ÙPR\OZUyÑ f=c: ×\egÛ1[IÛ\iÛ1eg×ÊqFÑRegQiFS –
nITNVZU^ƒM†¡™IU¥9™NcNegƒxR(exWtYs*nÑW=UËUb¶2WZexex^yWdcº[8ÑRhZf=U}cNerW=R\hXYR\ƒrRº_}U4Ä[VZhXiW*WZYcNR1n[mW=UbnIWZhdR\R\h2h)WZWZcNcNR(R*YVZR\nNhdWZnNUbƒxWZWdexeg^y[N[‡
ÑU)WZ^.YnW=UbWZRSWZcNRWV…Wdc8^™N³tR\fW2qbU4VZevU4™NƒgR†
Ž‘)ŽÁdyŽÁd’}Z9[P‘? î ¿ Š¦¿*‘]\*ŽNÁ ïlî
^ ¾ ½ Z9_ ½ Átñ=¾  ` aÀ2Ž‘)ŽNÁt¾ ½
b/÷Êø c dC \ÿ bJ›û)ü\JÊý“E¦Rý e7A ù fhg )
WdéNhdVZeg^yf^V?iWdWdnIR1cI[f1R7RSiR1fWZ[I^ycN[]f1RsqyfR1^4^y[N_ [IegR1fU[R\ƒxfƒgTR1R9WZƒgh¡R^4_K^qb_DiURwƒxegnN[yhdWZegf1[NVdVdeg‡eg[IThdWd_›^egegfº^Vº[.U4U{WXUWd‡[IVZR\egim™N[NnU4R[IWdƒgRU^ƒxfUsnI[Ihdh\egih\†#|4Rª¬¶¡§F[kWdR2VZWdexexcI[[NR ––
™NƒgR1egY8[IU4|*VZs]U¹–…R\‡[IR\f[N^RkiRwƒg^iŒfnI^hTWZegexhY.f1UU4ƒºƒgƒghdR\^,i ƒgniWZ#jex^y[/$à Êh Ÿ ^_.UÃex_‡yerW=exqyhR1[šU4ƒgƒgTNR1ƒgVZRk^™Negh–
f1ÖbU–—|Weg[¹[ykWZ#j™VdegR[Ià$hdR1egexfWd|cN^yR\mVV[NerÖk_(R1nN^exWZWdVh.V=U4yUƒh† ƒxiNƒgR1l¦R1ƒgT“RcNR1egR[Ih.WZiNcNÖIhlR1|l^Vm[m^yUVhWZcNƒg“^R*ßf'nITNà$hVZZ^ábeg™Ihâ)ƒxR\er_(Y–—exex[]WZUh{WZ[IVdegUim[IƒxƒghdR1R1eg[ƒgfR – |
R1evfh*[I^iegf1f=Ueg‰Ë[Nƒxƒg|‡ºR\\!i hdÈyf=ÈycIiÎ #jR1Ÿ YmG†/RQS(â |bnN“RyVZ߆ ‡ex
([N†x|b‡Sex_D¶2WdWZcNcIcNR1R¡R(WdVZcN_›nNVZR\[NR\V?ê][IexnN[]ex[NR\WZ‡SVd[I^yf^4[Is_ËhDUS^4U_9ž VdRl ” © exh2[|4hXexUS[8R\‡VXexWZR\WZR\[NhSiR U4MƒgƒguK^ƒxR\fR\ƒxnIqyRwhh–
^bq† Ö R\Ÿ V*¶2WZcNexWdRmcTWd^yegYmTNnNRƒvUb›‡yWdR1eg^[N[aR\VZWdU4R\Wd[Ieg^iN[ hSŸ Wd| ^°k#jex[Rf1VZmâ R\ËUhdß R
2er›_“Wd^°WdcNWdR9cI_›RVZR\ƒgê]exYmnNR\exW([If^4s _
^4R_#1 âm© Ëh#ßWd
R\[Iex_]iNWZhºcNR1WZVZ^8R iNevhKR\f[IVZ^2R\UyWdR\hX[IR8iãR1WZ[^°fWdsºcN^4R._ƒgegex[IYmfVZexWR\Uy^4hX_9eg[NÖN‡2† Ö ^Ÿ V)|/i^R\3V f1VdRRw%UhX–#
egeg[N[I‡IfƒgJ† ex[Il¦R\icNiNRWZR1cNT“R1R1V7[IiNUmh)ƒg^^yf[(nIWdh*cNegR¡h(TN1VZ–…^eg[I™Nf1ƒgR1ƒxegY8[NR\|biKR\|I[IÖbf^–—exi[egf[Nƒg‡Sex[NhZRwf=i}cN|NR\^yYV*Ry[N|b^‡[NR1––
[NR1Wdevfº^T“R1V=UbWd^yVZh9U[Iieg[NexWdevU4ƒ/f1^[IiNerWZex^y[Ih1†
”
Wdp7c–—hdegUb[InIW.fUƒgƒxU4exƒg[IskVZRaR\¶2i˜ex–—Wd›eg^c¨[yVWZWdVdÖ4cNeg[I–…R.eghd[IegTIf1f•Vdƒxeg^y›[N^y‡R\VVZi R\ŸÖ4hZ|Kh7–…ege…[]^† RyWd_lVZ†x|/WZex[IcNWdhdRcNevRf ž Ÿ _›VZ¶2R\|}egê]ƒgWZnNƒ9cNR\U^y[ITNhdfRmT“skR\‡U4^R\V_S[NRmWd ^¨© hºƒx^™“egf[ R e
WdÖ cIŸ R¡†)oU”SƒxƒgR1¯ ƒgR\pShD`&^4_NY.WZcNU4R\‰yhdR R\h}ƒg^nIfhdeFR ¶2^eg_ƒxƒFWdcNR1evqyhDR1f1[]^Wd[FnqU4R\ƒgƒxVds(‡yR1f[I^y[Ff1R
qR1ex[VZ‡_›^yR
VdWZY.^U4ºWdeg›^^y[ V
UUhib³tnI_›R1htRwWZiex[I™I‡mUyf=Wd‰˜cNR(eg[Y_›^ynVdWZY.U4WdUbegWZ^ex[°^y[¦TNVdWd^y^˜™IU4f™I^yex[yƒgerWZWtVds{^yƒ*_›^WZV2cNR•R\UyYf=cnƒgWZ^U4fWdnIeg^h\[š† ™Fs
l¨R¸nIhdRPWdcNR¸_›VdRwê]nNR1[If1sÆ^_ © hex[¤WdcNR¸UƒxƒgR1ƒgR\haex[¤Ušƒx^–
_›VZfVZR\nR\hdh(ê]TnN^b^yR1q[I[R\iVSfegsš[NWZ‡PcN^R._mYT“nÖ ^W=© hTNUbnNWdUyegƒv^hUb[ŒWZWZex^ycNTN[˜RÃVZ^ÊU4™R\VZU4ê]‡™NnNnIegegYƒxqbexWtU4R\s¸ƒg[]R1[]W ^Ÿ Wd_SƒgsaWdWZ^šcI¶¡Ubf\R{W{U4f1ƒvƒgf^UnNf[•ƒvnIUbh\nIWZ†ÆhdR¨Rm¥9f1Wd^cIcIVdRR –
_›WdVZcIR\Rê]nNiR1R1[‡yfVdsPR\R.^4^4__* f© ^yh[Fexq[ÅR1VZUk‡R\ƒg^F[If1fnIRh WZ© h^šU4Ï1ƒgwƒxR\ЃxRw_›h^yVf\U4WZ[ÃcIUb™“WRƒg^ƒg^FfnI^‰yh\†R\iÃuKUyR1Wh
Ÿ
Ÿ
©
U4Ubn WZƒg: ƒgex6R1^yV=ƒg[o×R\5 h(Ÿ 5Seg[Ã6 V*U4[IƒgÙ ^Fi.f1nIѓph Û1ÒÛ\V#ÛXV=æ ^b×o5qŸiR\VºR16[IV¡Wd^4cNÙ&WdRR TWZÛ1cN^yÛ\TNRÛXnNæ _›Ÿ ƒvVZUbR\iWdê]egR1nN^[IR\[Ã^4[IWdU4fRsWWdWdcN^eg_7RYm YR•h#nNÊ‡WZex[•UbR1WZ[IWdexR1^ycIVd[ R –
TNé)VZex‡y^nN™IVZUR(™Negƒxex|1Wtѓs¹Ò^4 _ºV=o× ƒx5 ^Ÿ f1f\nIU4h [mV™UbRSW.f1U4WZexƒvYmfnIhR ƒgU45Wd†¦R\i¥9_›VZcN^R\Y [K|¡n Uyh. VZ;×hX5cIŸ ^bU¶2h
[Å_›^yegƒr[ –
:
ƒg^b¶*h1„
GÑ q´6 V=o× 5 Ÿ s
Ù r)FÒ t&uvC.xè w]y n : 6 V=;× 5 Ÿ CÖIÛ Î yw) r)Ò tuzCr){Ò U Q Ÿ t Ÿ
Wd¶2cIcNR*R\Y.VdhR Ub§y Û exy“Yevh(nNY®U4[PUU4[I™Iimhd^Ymƒgnex[IWdRexY_›nNnNYÂ[IfWdUegƒx^ƒg^b[K¶9| U4rD™NÒ ƒgR9tu8YUn[IW=Ub|i Wdegr)^FÒ [mU TNQ VZ^U4™NVZR –
X
Y
U4r)™IÒ{exƒgU erQ WZexÙ«Rwh2w_›Ö.^yVS}G~bU.† ƒg^fnIh7VdRwhXT“R\fWdegqR1ƒgs|R† ‡I†g|r Òtu Ù®båbæ?U[Ii l¦ê]nNcN1R [R\[kfsWdcI^4_R T“© h?^TNeg[.nIƒgWdU4cIWdRSeg^U4[kƒgƒgevR1h#ƒgR\VZh Ueg[I[.iR\^UyYmf=c.ƒgsƒx^eg[Nf1exnIWdhevU4evƒghlexÌ\hXR\WZi}U4|ËWdevWZhtcNWZegRf\U4_›VdƒgƒxR1s –
U4r)™“ÒF^ t&nNuW Ù¸ÖN† ÑκÒU4[I|Ii‡yexcNqyR\R\[Ih9f^R [°Ñ“WZÒcNRV=×oU´5 qŸ R\هVZU‡r)RNÒH tuN|]> ¶2XcN0evf=C¦cK|ytUyhdC8hdnNÑYmÒ egŸj[N…‡ Ÿ
YR\UynNf=WZcUbYWZxe ^yn [IWZU4hmWdeg_›^^y[V^U¹T“T“R1V=^UbTNWdnNeg^ƒvUb[WZ¶2ex^yer[¦WZc.U4o [I”7i¦¯ æ pS> `¹Ñ†Ò37^b·¶lexTNR\TIqexR1[NVw‡]|´h.¶2er_›WZ^yc V
WdWdcIR\[IR(iÆTNVdWd^y^¦‡ VZf R\^yhZ[Fh q^R1_/VZ‡WZcNRaRWd^«ž ” ¹|KU41[–…egiÆ[]WdVZ֘ex[VZhXR\evhdfSTURw[IfWdi°egqÖbR\–—ƒxexsÆ[]WdVZU4eg[I[IiÇhXevfSWdcNƒx^R\fexV e
Yt nNŸ †?WZUb¥9WZexcN^yev[8h?VZNT \R Vdhd^ynN™IƒrW=U4h?™Iegex[ƒgerWZ™“exRw^4h2WZc.iR\Vdf1RwVdiRwnIUf1hdR\R(iU[Ff1f1nN^YV=i™“egR1[NV ‡^WZ_“^.YR\nê]WZnIU4U4WdegWd^eg^[I[ h
^bH qR\> V tU‰ C.T“^XTI‰ nNC9ƒgÑU4ÒWdeg^ŸjÊ[aŸdŸ ÊUeM† [IRi(†g|.VZH R\i> nftR\KiC []‚nIYU…U…„„ ™“: R1XV)K^4Cm_·IÑegÒTNTN6V=eg×o[N5 ‡yŸdhDŸXŸ{_›^yˆ V
R\¶2Uyexf=WdcckYo ”7n¯WZU4p7Wdeg`¹^[† ^y” T[IR\i8VZU4UyWdh¡eg^Wd[acNR(ÊeM†T“R^†gR| TN† nIƒgU4UŠUŠ„„ Wdeg: ^Ñ[Òf6^yV=[]o× 5qy{Ÿ R1VZˆ ‡Rwæ h1>|]¶2ÑerÒ WZc Ÿ
WdV=UiNerWZex^y[IU4ƒ
™NexWº·IexT¨YnNWZUbWZex^y[K|Keg[a_ÊUyfWw|}_›R1¶¡R1V(U4[ik_›R\¶lR\V
é)U4™Iex‡yexƒgnNerWtVZs{R_›y^„ V*j¡UmU4‡ƒvfR\nN[NƒvRºUbWZƒx^ex[Nf1‡nIh1_›nN† [IfWdeg^[°_›^V¡WZcNR(YnW=UbWZex^y[TNVZ^™N– ^4¶2Þ}egƒxhdƒ¡TNhXVdnNeg[NVZ‡]qFhlexqy‡yRR1[NWdcNR\R{VZU4[IWdRwRi{§FW™Fs{‡R\Y[NR1nNV=WZUbUbWZWZexex^y[I[K‡†WZ¥9cN^ycIhdU4RºWfeg^h\[F|/qyY.R1VZU‡[]R\s•i{Yƒx^nf–e
WZ`U4Wd^]eght^W¡[k^4^y_}TWdcIR\VZR\U4hdR7Wdeg^¶9[IUhShXWdU4R\VZi{RY¶9nUW=hXWdUbRwWdieg^[^h [U4WZVZcNR7^yhZhdU´Rqf1Rw^im[F™]qs{R\Vdo‡y”SR\i°¯ ƒgpS^Ff1` eM†
¯
”
nN›cIƒv^bUbR1¶šWZ[Iexf1^yiNR[¹nNÑVdcIegÒ[NUh(6‡V=oי“Wd5 cNR1ŸdR#R\Ÿ [¹R1_›qy^y‡^VR\ƒg[NnR\R1UyWdV=egf=^UbcP[{WZR\‡^i}R1_}|)[IWdR{¶lcNRmR(ƒx^Äž f1nIVZhXhW|^bU4f1qy_ãUWdR1ƒgR1V(f1V2nNWZƒvUcNUbRWd[NR R1T“¶¦n ^: TNT“6nIV=^×;ƒgTU45 Ÿ–– WdWdcIcIVd^y^yhdnNRº‡f1cÔ^[FUqiIR\VdU4‡yTR\WZiexqyƒxR1^ƒgs®fe…† iRwfVZR\Uhdeg[N‡¦Ñ Ò 6 V=o× 5 Ÿ Wd‹^ r FÒ U QÂ_›^yV
Wdeg^[/† ¥9cNR1[8¶¡Rºf\U4[°TR\VX_›^yVdY o ”7¯ p7`^T“R1V=UbWZex^y[Ih\†
Œ Ž7P
î î y‘Ž •N¾ ‹ òtî `±
b/÷vö c J wÿ +B\JMýE ý“EÇA ù fhg )
” f\f^yVZieg[N‡Wd^WdcNRmfƒvUhZhXexĔ7f\¯ UbWdeg^[a^4_lUyiNU4TW=UbWZex^y[_›^Vž ” h ’D¥9÷ÊcNø R`a“ UbBD§¸CµS)¤[NR\Lh(H*TIVd”{^yED™NƒxCdR\Y6•NhdbegYý– TIƒxCdsP f^ynN[]WZh(WZcNR{^y[NR\hf^[N–
VZUR1iIqFU4exTR\¶lWZexqyRwiR9Uyeg[iNU4hXTNRwWZfUbWZexWZ^yex^y[8[èNWZ|cIo UbW ^f1p7f1nN`6V=h)™“U4R1W?ƒg^Wd[NcN‡]R9h9™“Wd^4^WdWdWd^cIYR–—fƒxR\ƒvUqhZR\h9ƒ^4^4__ WZUex[IR\ikeg[aU™Nex[U4VZs8hXWdVZeg[N‡Uyh2WdcIRÄNWZ[NR\hZh#^4_?WZcIUbW(htWZVdeg[N‡†
_›WdYR1eg^RwnN[aiWZ™IUbTNWZUyexVdf=^y^y‰¨[K™I†)U4eg[™Iª—_›W ex^yƒgnIerVdWtY.hds°R\Ubh
[NWZWZ^yexcN^y[[¹R7–…nIhXWd[NWZ^¨Uber_›WZ^yUegVdhXiNYmWdUevf1Tƒgsh Wdeg^4^bq_}qyR\U4ƒxR1sPV*ƒgƒxR\RwUƒxUR*ibf=³tiNcnIeghthXƒgWWd^VZfWdexnIcI™Ih\Rn|WdYegcI^R1n[{[IWZUyf1U4Rh– ev™N¥9h1excN|WZh2WdR(^(¶9U4Y.egUYÔh¡Ub§nIevh¡eghdYR\Wdi^egÌ1R9_›^^y™^yV2W=[NU4^R\egnNh?[V*eg[.UmhXWdhtUºnIWZiNVdhtWZegs[NVd† eg‡m[N‡If^y† [y” W=U4hXegWd[NVZegex[N[N‡‡(UƒgR1ƒxƒ}[I^y‡4[NWdcmR\h\^|]_DWd\cIÖyU4Ö W
WdWZcIU4WdR*eg^[I[PU4YmMo RS”SoF¯ WZUbpSWZeg` hXWdŸ ev†f1hX–—™IUhdR\i ” iIU4TWZexqyR ¯ ^y[–—p7[Nex_›^VZY®`n–
’D÷vö “ BDC—ýd˜L —ýL úš™ +DE)ÿ4üwJÊý“Ev
”S¯
Ymfo ^R\–…f=R\cIqp7^yUƒx[N`²qyevR¹hXY.eghWdh¨cNYRwWdhXnIcR˜f=UbcšWÃqbU4hdUƒgexnNiNYmR\iÂh¨TNƒg^yR1¶2[NV{exRŒWdWdcÂcIRU§FR\[¦WdUyV=f=UÇWdcëcN^]qbeghXU[IRkƒxinNeghdR¦q]R1evƒxiT“_㖬nIR1UUV¹iNƒMU†€™ITerWZW¸l¦U4WdUeger[I^WZc[i ¥9U4VZcNRmR¡iz2R1^bqFsyevhXURwƒikz2WZ^y^°Uyiºeg[F_›qnNRw[IhtfWZWdex‡]eg^Ub[IWdRmh¡Êž éI^”VZ© Vdh(RwhtT“W)R1U4Vd_›[I^iVZYm`kUer[IW=f=fcNRR1¶2ƒgƒM|erWZwcPÈÈ]VdèR1Ÿ–
oWdeg”S^[ï p7UVd`ÃR.|¡hdTI¶2UbcWZegUbUWƒxƒgsa¶¡R•^y[NUyƒgiNsaiŒ^[IWZ^ÃR.VdWdRwV=U4Uƒ?iNerqWZRwex^yf[IWZ^U4VƒS^™N_9erW°æ›–—·IiegegTÇYmR1Y[InhdegWZ^U4[ – evhdiTR\RwUfƒxWegÌ1WdRw^Pi{hd_›^yf=cNVdY8R\Y.† Uz2TN^bs]VZ^FU4f1ƒ}R\z2hZhX^yegUy[Ni{‡¨_›U4nI[I[Ii¹fWZVZex^yR\[If1^0h Y› ™N: ex[U4Ub[IWdIi eg^›[¹= eg[Åf^U[N[ –
WdU4c[UbiÇW¸fVZ^yR\Ymf1^TNV=niNWZh•U4WdWdegcN^R¦[IU_›ƒxVZƒgs¦R\ê]^nN[IR\ƒx[Is¦fsë^y[N^4R¨_hX^WZ[NU4RwWdevh¨htWZ_›eg^f\h°VÃTRwUR\V°f=c‡yR1ƒx[N^f1R\nIVZU4h1– | WZ%Ý U/ex–…[řIerWZW7U™Iexƒgex^[IVdU–—VdYms°UyhtiWZR°Vdeg[N™N‡]nNh1egƒg†2i~ eg[NUy‡Pf=c™Nƒghd^f=f=cN‰FR\h8Y.MU hdf=œBcNU R\evY.h*U‡h egŸqR\™[UU{hdR\fiÃ^FR^y_ã[ –
WdT“eg^^TN[¢nNƒvWZUbcIWZUbex^yW¨[˜f1U4ÊcNƒvfR1nI[ƒgfU4RWdR\WdhcNRmWdcNYR¹n_›WZVZU4R\Wdê]egnN^[¨R\[ITNfsÆVd^y™I^4U4_.™I^exƒg[IerWtR\s hŸ ^b_›qy^R1V(V8RwUWdcIf=c R Ä^V=f1iexR\R\[yV•NW ev&h•U Wd¶2cNcIRŒegf=[FcknNevYh*™“RwR1ê]VPnIU4^ƒ/_{Wd^ÄN§exWZR\h7ië^V=Ti^]R1hX1V exWdžeg^$ [IœBUh¨Ÿ ¶2ÊUexWdhdcNf=egcN[®R\Y.WdcIU U4© Wh
ƒg¶9^FU4f1V=nIih\R\†Çi¸¥9ex[˜cNevh{WdcIhXRkegYmhXR\TN[IƒgRhXR8R§F^_ºWdV=f1UP^YmhtW=TNUbWdnevW=hXUbWdevWdf1eg^h{[UyU4iNƒ2ifR\^yiÅYevTIh.ƒxR1¶l§FR\exWtƒxƒ7s¸VdU4R1W– ^4hZf=_)cN¶2R1Y.cNevUf=cŸ K† R\› Uyf=: cf1cI^[IUyh9hdevhtÉW=h9Uyi´^4³X_)UÉ.f1R1iN[]egW¡hʳt^ynN[N[IR\fh\WdL† egq› R(= ^f1V=^i[IR\VXhd–¬eghXÉWZh¡hZf=^cN_KR1_›Y.^nNUyVh
WtWd¶¡eg^^•[UU4hd[IT“iR\WZfcNW=h1R7„m[FWZnNcNYR°™[]R\nIV Y^4_K™“™IR1VerWl^4·I_*exTIYTNnNex[IWZUb‡yWZh?ex^y_›^y[IV hRw_›U^f=Vmc.UkYT“nN^WZUbTNWZnIexƒg^yU4[ – ƒgUR1Ÿh qR\› ƒgh: | ^4_*ƒgR1hZqyf=R1cNƒ#R1Y.cIUUyh\„ h ƒg/•R1qy^R1V=ƒ¡iÖÃR1Vd–Z›™“wÝ^4WdhdWdf=^cIYR1Y.ƒgR1UqyhR1ƒ^4Ÿ _*ev¶2h(cNWdevcIf=Rc¸hZRwU4UYmf=c R
^5|FT“^R1[.V=UbWZWZcNex^yRº[KU´†aqR1éIV=^U4Vm‡yR9UkWdT“V=U^iTNexnNWdegƒv^Ub[WZexU4^yƒ“[ÙNer^4W¡_7·IhdegegTÌ1R YH nWZU4UbWdWeg^‡y[{R1[NYR\nVZU4WZU4WdegWd^R\[ h WZfU^yexY[h¡™Negèº[NRw^yh VZiNWt¶¡R1Vd^m–¢¡]UèSi´hZ³Xf=UycNfR1R\[]YmW2Uyhdh f=RwcIUR1f=Y.c{Ufh¡^yegY[™NƒgR1eg[NqyegR1[Nƒ}‡(ÖNWt|¶¡ƒgR1^qyR1UyƒKi´³XèUff1^R1[][NW–
ƒg™IR1qyex[NR1Rwƒmh¡Wd|#cNRU4[IèišhZf=ÄIcN[IR1U4Y.ƒgƒgUys¦h9ƒxexR\[°qR1ƒxR\Wƒ q¡ÚR\ƒDãèWZ†cNRP^TWZexY.U4ƒ
H > Xz Cktv U…C(„ ÑÒ jŸ MŸ eg[IiegqFegiNnIU4ƒvh ¶2cNegƒgRSo ”7¯ p7` YnWZU4WdR\h hZhZf=f=cNcNR1R1Y.Y.UU hŸ f1eg[Æ
^
Y
H > tCƒ‚ U…„ : tCÑҝ6V=×o5 ŸdŸXŸ eg[IiegqFegiNnIU4ƒvh1†?éI^V RwUf=cmYn–
WZ·IU4egTNWdegTN^eg[P[N‡y^h7T“egR1h#V=Ubæ WZ> ex^yÑ[PÒë^[¹^[8U4[PWZcNegR[IiU´egqyq]R1evV=iU4nI‡UR#ƒM|)¶2WZexcNWdcR{WZ[FVZnNUyYier™“WZexR1^yV[I^4U4_2ƒD™N™NexexWW ¥9f^ycNYmRTNÄNnWdWd[IRwR\ikhZhm™Fs^4_ShXnIU•Y™NYmexW.eg[NhX‡WdVZegWd[NcN‡ RmAf^F_›R^yÍ{ŸV f1› exR\:[yW=A Nh Ÿ &UlU4[f1‘i^VZVd› Rw=hXT“ A ^Ÿ[iFegh–
·IegT8YnW=UbWdeg^[8U4[ih† U…„  Ñҝ6V=×;5 Ÿ ¶2erWZco ”7¯ pS`¹†
eg[N‡aWZ^PR\Uf=cÅ^4_*WZcNR8‡egqR\[ÅhZf=cNR1Y.U4œ£U#^_7¶2cNevf=c evhU[
Mutation Probability
P max
P min
0.0
0−Inclined
0.5
1−Inclined
1.0
Frequency of 1’s in the Alleles in a Locus
U…„ :
A
eg‡[IegqhtW=R\U4[°[IUyf1Rh1„L†¤› ¥9cNXRay^ÛxTÛgWZ exŸ Y.ÙÇU4ƒ#Ý%/mhX^yU4ƒxnN[IWdiIeg^› [Ih{X_›^VyÛx› Ûg :Ÿ Ù¤U[I\i‡È]萛 † = U4VZR WZNé 4U ^yWdV
eg^Wd[.V=UѓiÒ¤exWdeg^¶9[UU4h2ƒFhd™NRexW*W?WZ·I^kexTm´Yå4æDn¶2WZU4cIWdexegƒg^R[_›^yWdcNVSR2o TN”7VZ¯ ^™p7U4`3™NegƒxѓexWtÒ¤s(^4qb_“U4YVZegR\ni –
:
=
UUyIi =f U4cmTWZƒx^exqyfR1nƒgs°h U™“f\RfWt^¶¡V=R1iR\eg[N[|‡#r)WdÒF^(t&RwuêynÙÔUbWdbeg^åb[æ UX[I Ÿi|†?r)éIÒF^V U Q RwUÙ&f=c\VdÖ.nN}G[/~(|_›¶¡^yRV
\
R
’D÷…b “ BDC¤L¥A ùN“ •Nbý– Cd þ°CFEDC¦bLü\ý
¥Wd9R\cNV#R*UV=[IU4ia[ioF^T“YÂR\Uu}VZh\–t|)o \” È¥˜ÈF€ TNŸ Vd^yevh#™NƒgU{R1Y뙓^]‡y^yR1ƒx[NRwU4R\[aVZU4hZWdUb^yWZV*eghXÊÄQSURS™NÜyexƒg^exWt[Ns‡|TN§
VZ^^4™NWd–– VZ*R\R\fVdy^ yR VZ|liNR\^yi[NƒgWds¹cNRWdcN™^]RwhXhtRWd–—f=hdcN^4VZ–…_Ê^U4YmV2^]ÄIhXWd^y[NYRwhdRwh7hmR1f=qcIR\U4Vd[Ns•‡y\R\Öyi¸Öm™]R1sÅqbU4fƒgVZnI^yUbhZWZhXex^b^yqy[IR1h\V †
ƒWZgR1UyYëhXevh.‡yR1^y[N[ÅR\VZWZU4cNWdRk^yV)T“iR1R\Vd_›qF^egVZhdY.R\iU4Wd[I^ºf1R°eg[F^q_R\hXžWdeg‡y” U4h\Wd†ÇRlWdª—cNWR2‡yR1R1ޓ[NRwR\fVZW=U4h?Wd^4R\hm_“R1V=TNU4ev[Nht–– egU4[y[WZik^°Y dW cNnNR.WZUb[FWZnNex^yY[k™^R\V(T“R1^4V=_lUbWZR\exqb^yU4[IƒgnIhSUb¶lWZexR\^yVd[IRh1R\†.qbU4~lƒgUnIf=UbcaWZR\R1ia§TU[IR\VdikegYmf1^R1[]nNW([]WdVdRwR1i –
i^4_*^yY;f1ƒgU™“nI^FhXRw^hƒgR\U4hdnN[P™R1³tR\§FfTIW(VdRwWdhd^hdexWZ^ycN[IVZh#R1R{ex[ÃTIf1U^VZ[bU³tYmnIR[IWdfR\WZVZexphqyR{¨[N^Ê[FVZY.nNYU4ƒ
™“R1_›^yVVdY^4_ hdnNƒrW*¶9U h9U´qyR1V=U4‡Rwi.^bqR\Vº\ÖÖeg[IiR1T“R1[iR1[]W7VZnN[Ih\†
™³t“nN^][I^yfƒxWdRwegU4q[¹RPqbfU4ƒvU4VZevnIU4hd™NR\ƒgh R\Ÿ h Ÿ U4]| [I©i«ª6
›[FnNãYWZcN™“R¨R1VƒxR\^4[N_*‡4WZicÇevh›³t^4nI_[IfWdWZcNexR¹qyRfƒv^U4VnhXfRw^h [NŸ – † ¹K÷vö ºSH}û C¦bJÃCFEËü—CdB+ ü£
~nN [NUyexf=_›cÅ^VZYmf1ƒgUƒxs¨nIhXV=R°U4[Ievhi^yf1YmVdRwƒxUbsPWZR\U4iÃ[IiP™FsÃ[IR1hd‡yR1ƒgU4R\WdfegWd[Neg‡k[N!‡ RwUªëf=c¹^N_qbU4¨VZegUq´™NUƒgVdR{evU4¶2™IerƒxWZRwc h ¥9hdcNcN^bR¶2R1[.§exT[mR\Vd_›VZegYm^Y±R1[]é)WSexVZ‡yR\nNhdVZnNRSƒxWZè#h2Wd^y^[kéDieger‡ÞËnIR1VdVZR#R1[]€ºWSVdRwWdR\hXT“hXWSR\fTIWdVdeg^yq™NR1ƒgƒxsR\†
Y.éNh*VZU4^VZY R
TNhdexVZ^y^[K™I|IUWZ™NcNegRmƒxexWtU4s¸egY ÖN† ΐevh7†ŒWd^{éN^yÄV.[IR\iaUyUf=cÅ[aU‡yhZR1hX[NegR\‡VZ[IU4YWdR\R\i¸[]W7™^4^F_?^yƒxWZRwVdU4n[˜WZckR§qbU4TNƒgVZnNR\R\hXh– Wd_›^cIVZR\Y.hdRÃh¡WdÄIV=‡yUnNiVdexRwWdh1eg^|[erU4WPƒ}f1™NU4exW2[«·I™“egT°RÅYhdR1nR\WZ[¢U4WdegWd^cI[°U4WP^T“o R1”SV=Ub¯ WZpS^V9` ^[8^U4nNƒgWdƒ}T“WdR1cIVdR –
WdWd^ÃVZnNRyWdcN†¨R oF¨6eg[IfqbRUWdVdcNevU4R™Nƒg™R\^Fh.^yWdƒxcIRwU4U4[ÃWY.R1§FU4TI‰VdRwRwhhdhdWdex^ycN[PRaegR1h[]WdVZegUVd[IRaiR^y§YTNƒgVZs¨R\hZ‡hXR1eg^[N[ – WdWdRweg^ht[W*h»TI›Vd^y: ™NƒxU4R\[IY.ihh*› ê]=nN†7erWZµSR[fƒgR\VZU^bVdsyƒgUs{ƒ}RVd§N^]f1UR1iTW*_›nN^y[I[°fWZVZex^b^ysy[IUh1ƒË› Vd^]: UUi[I_›ihnN[I› f= –
R1R§V=UbevhtWZW=R\h1i}†S|F¥9WZcNcNR1R(VZRºÄNWZegh9[NR\[IhZ^.h*‡_›nInI[IUfVZWZUex[y^yWZ[R1R7_›^WdV7cIU4WdcNW7RhXnIu}f=–tc8o ” U4[8¥¢UTNhZVZhd^ex‡y™N[NƒgR1YmY R1[]eghW ^4Êhd_.R1R•hdR\éDU4V=eg‡f=cNnIegVd[N|R ‡I|(¡¸ž U4[I” i¦¶2é)exegWd‡c¢nNVZWZhR VZUy/ iŸ er|*WZexi^ynN[IVZU4exƒ([N‡Ã™IerWkWdcN·R•exT¢R\U4YVZƒgsÅnNWZhXUbWZWZU4ex^y‡y[ R
evhºUex™[°R1R1WXWdqbR\UVºƒxnIWdU4cIWdUeg^[P[Ižh\|F” ¶2cN¶2R1ex[Wdc¹WdcIo R(”7ž ¯ ” p7`¹cIUy†Dh¡*™N^bnN¶¡egƒrR1W2qnNR\T8V\|}hXU4^y_ãYmWdR1R#V(nf1R1hXR1Vd––
Uh¡_›^yƒxƒg^b¶*h\„
Z
W
¯
_›YnNnNƒ2WZhZUbf=WZcNex^yR1Y.[U™“hmR\f\o U4”SnIhd¯ Rºp7o ` ”7¯ ^pSnWZ`TR\R1VXÍ{_›^yfVdegY.R1[]hWdƒgWdsV=UU´iqex^yWdegeg^iI[h U4Yƒ¡nN™NWZerWUbWZ·Iex[IegT‡
n $¬‰­ž9® Ÿ Ù ©  ° n $æ±¦²³œ @ U Ÿ
UŠ„ :
WdcI^yhdRºf1^[FqR\Vd‡yR\iƒx^fe…†
Wdl¦hZVZUbegWdcN™NevR\hXnÄIVdWdFR R\eg^i[Ŭ^­9^4V*ž9_7®ÔÖf1^4ƒgf1UWZ^nIcN[IR1hXhdRVZeg¶2hXV=WZev| hDhXRyn ^4† G_©¦æ$±¦f²Gƒvœ U4@ nIU hdŸ R\| hDevU4h°[IiexWd_*cNWdRlcIÄNR°WZ[Nf1R\ƒgUhZnIh
hXfR^[Negh–
ª¬Ê[.QSR\^ÜynI^V [IR‡I§´| T“§
R1^VZexWXYmWZR1R\V?[yU4W=[Ih i.¶¡oFR*T“nIR\hdUR\VZih\|IWZcNwRSÈÈFhZ€ U4Ÿ Ymv† R*l•TIR9UÄIVZU§FYmRw3i RWd¨ÆR\VZh?Wd^.Uyh\Öyeg[Ö
U4è4[ÖyÖ{i›ª¸ƒg^bWd¶Œ^3R1¡NTN†?evhX¥9WZUcNhdR#evh [FŸ nNWdY^™“´R1è4V9ÖyÖ.^4_
›YmfƒvU4R\nIihdegnNR\hFYÔ©«R\TN¶9eghXUWZh¡UyqbhXevU4h VZŸ egR\Wdim^m_›è VZ/]^ÖY Ö
›cIex‡yc°R\TNevhtW=Uhdegh Ÿ †
µ ¶· \ î oÁ ` î/½ Ž Y ŽNÀ70¿ ¸
¹K÷Êø c dC \JMGEŒRý e0ºSH}û ¦C ´$J ÃCFEËü
ª¬¶¡[ÚR^fV=^iYmR1TIV°UWdVd^ÅRwi{WdRwexW7htW•¶2oexWd”7c°¯ WdV=pSU`¹iexWd|*eg^eg[Ç[U4WZƒ}cN™Nevh8exW*R·I§egT8TR\YVdegnYmW=R1Ub[]WdWkeg^[htWZnIU[Iiis
fnN^y[NYex_›^™NVZeg[NYRwikfVZWZ^ycNhZR1hXY6^bqyR1¶2V#erWZ^c¹T“R1fV=^UbYmWd^yYmVZh\^†[IƒxéIsk^VnhXRwRwUi¨f=cPèb–…RT“§^T“eg[]R1VZW(exYmU[IR\iP[yWÖN^4† Î _ Wdé)egex^‡y[nNh9VZR8^[èN„`k”Ub§qyR1µSV=U4[N‡yR\Rh9TN™“VZR\^hX™IWX–¬ƒxhXR\^Y°–M_ʆ UVf1nNVdqyR\hU4‡]U4eg[IhtWR1qbU4ƒgnIU4–
fo ^y”SY¯ ™Np7eg[N` eg[NŸ ‡a|fYVZ^ynhZWZhXU4^bWdqyegR1^V9[ǝMèb›Wd–…V=T“U^ieg[]exWdW eg^^[V¡U4ÖNƒ¡† Î#™NernNW[N·Iex_›eg^T¸VZYÂYnf1WZVdU4^]Wdhdeghd^^b[ÃqR\^yV VŸ éNVZ^Y¢U4™“^bqR R§TR\VdegYmR1[]W/VZR\hdnNƒxWZh\|wexW)f\U4[Uƒghd^2™“RlhdR1R1[WdcIU4W
R\U4\f1[ÖynÖ.i{WdRwiR\i}Uyexޓf=†?R\c.ª¬Vd[°R\WdRw[y^htW#V=W9iVZTNUR1VZVl[I^iWd™N^m^yƒgYR1cIY8U´hdqy|“R1RS\RwÖyiNUÖh*htegWZ¶¡[IVdR1ievfVZR1W*RT“fnIR1^y[hdYmR\ii8R1TI[]U4WZW9^VZegVdhd‡ynN^R1[[{[NhlR\Wd¶¡VZcNU4R(R1WdVZR(hZR7U4egR1Ym[N§FerR –– YT“evhSR1nNVd^yWZ_›™F^Ubq]VZWZegYmex^^yn[PU[IhXƒg^fsT“RyR1†)™“V=RéIUbWd^WdWdV¡^yR\VVSWdcIiWZRºcI^FU4R\hd[aRh(W2Y.Wd^V=U4_KUWXiWdWdRwexR\WdhtVegWZ^R\¶2[iU4exWdTNƒ)c¹Vd™N^yerVZ™NWºR\ƒghd·IR1TY.egTaRwfh1W(Y|No Wdn”S^aWZU4¯ ž WdpSeg”^` [K© h |
WdU4evƒgU4ƒƒWZTcN^yR2TNRnN§ƒvT“UbR1WdVZeg^exYm[hËR1[]_›^W=V}h1|WZcNWdcNR*R9wÄNÖÖ¡WZ[NVdR\nIhZ[Ih?h}TN^4VZ_^RwT“U^f=Vdc#WdegR^§[TUbR\WdVdR2egYmhdR1R1ƒgR\[]fW\Wd†Deg^ª¬[[ ¶2YcNnegf=ƒxcRPƒgnNR\[IhZh er_›i^yexVdÞËY R1VZR1f[IVZ^yf1hZR2hX¶2^bqyerWZR1c.VVdURw[IhXi«T“R\è´fW?–—TWd^y^ex[]ž W”f© VZh ^yT“hZhXR1^bVd_›qy^R1VZVY.hdU4cN[I^bf1¶ R
¶2U4[exWdimcPR1WdƒgercIWZReghXW hXWdYm^^f=cIiUR1hXƒ)WdÊevQSfmR7nN[NÜ^yegq[NR\‡IVZ|hZU4\ƒ ÈF€4hZU4Î YmŸ ¶9TNƒgUegh?[N‡¸nhXRw9iUeg‰[mR1WdVwcI| R#wȞ ÉF” € Ÿ | _›RnN§N[If1fR1WdTegW?^[I_›^yh\V †¤¶2¥9cNR1cN[{evh{f1^y^™IYhX™NR\exVd[IqbR\U4iWdeg^¶2[¦erWZchXcIo ^b”7¶*¯ hmp7WdcI` U4W°^y[iR\VZq^bR\syƒxU^yƒFTNVdTN^]eg[NUi‡
WdU4cI[R9i¨f1WdVdcN^]Rhdhd^bTq^yR\TNVKnNTNƒvUbVZ^Wdeg™I^U[ÙNeghdƒxegexÌ1WtR{sº¶¡¶9UyUh/hÄIhd§FRWRwi(Wd^ÃWZ^SwWtÖsFÖ°TNev_›f1^UVƒFR\q´UyUf=ƒxnIc¨R¡VZÖInNÛ [KÝI†| ‡ž ^F”^i˜© h2T“YR1nVdW=_›^UbVZWZY.ex^y[¦U4[I^f1RT“† R1V=UbWd^yV{TNVZ^4_›^ynN[Iiƒgs¸cNR\ƒxTh{egYTIVd^bqFeg[N‡
100
Average Best Fitness
95
90
85
80
75
BitFlipMut + 2-Point
SANUM + 2-Point
BitFlipMut + Uniform
SANUM + Uniform
70
65
60
0
50
100
Evaluations ( x 100 )
150
200
1
60
0.99
Average Best Fitness
Average Best Fitness
70
50
40
30
BitFlipMut + 2-Point
SANUM + 2-Point
BitFlipMut + Uniform
SANUM + Uniform
20
10
0.98
0.97
0.96
BitFlipMut + 2-Point
SANUM + 2-Point
BitFlipMut + Uniform
SANUM + Uniform
0.95
0.94
0
0.93
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
0
50
100
Evaluations ( x 100 )
150
200
250
300
350
400
Evaluations ( x 100 )
200
0.95
180
0.945
160
Average Best Fitness
Average Best Fitness
dWé)egex^‡y[nNh9VZRƒ^[8¡I„Vd^b”s]U4qyƒ“R1VdV=^]U4U‡yiR_›™“nNR\[IhXfWXWd–¬hXeg^^[h–M_ÊU› V: f1† nNVdqyR\hU4‡]U4eg[IhtWR1qbU4ƒgnIU4– Wd)é ge ex^‡y[nNh9VZR8^[ÎN„u}–t” o ”qyR1¥šV=U4TI‡yVdR^y™N™“ƒxR\R\hXY.WX–¬h9hX^¶2–M_ÊerWZUc°Vƒgf1^bnN¶ÇVdqyR\R\TNhevhtU4W=‡]UU4hdegeg[Ih\†htWR1qbU4ƒgnIU4–
140
120
100
80
60
BitFlipMut + 2-Point
SANUM + 2-Point
BitFlipMut + Uniform
SANUM + Uniform
40
20
0.94
0.935
0.93
0.925
0.92
BitFlipMut + 2-Point
SANUM + 2-Point
BitFlipMut + Uniform
SANUM + Uniform
0.915
0.91
0.905
0.9
0
0
100
200
300
400
Evaluations ( x 100 )
500
600
)Wdé egex^‡y[nNh9VZR^[8/„Vd^b”s]U4qyƒ“R1VdV=^]U4U‡yiR_›™“nNR\[IhXfWXWd–¬hXeg^^[h–M_ÊU› Vf1† nNVdqyR\hU4‡]U4eg[IhtWR1qbU4ƒgnIU4–
=
¼ ½ ¾ ½ ’ ò À7FÁt¾ ½ 
ª¬nN[Ú[Nex_›Wd^cNVZevYhkTYU4T“nR1WZVwU4|ºWdegUŒ^[ [IR1^¶T“R1htV=W=UbUbWZWd^evVwhX|aWdevf1o hX”7–…™I¯ Uyp7hXRw`¹iÇ|UyiNeghŒU4TTNWZexVZqy^R¹T“^y[Nhd^R\[NiK– †
”S¯
WdR¥9ev§f1cNTNh RlƒgexevY[fex_›^Wd^yƒgWdVds•egY.qbWZUbU4^kWdWdegeg^‡^[nI[eg^4iex_YmR{o TNWdƒgcNegf1Rerp7WZYƒxs`£nfW=ev^yUbhK[yWdWZegW=^^7U4[¹egY.[N^yR\U4Ti‰yR\R egVZ[nIU4hdWdWZR egcN^R2^4[K_T“†kWZ^cNo TNR9”SnNhtƒv¯ W=UbUbWZpSWdex^yev` hX[ –
UU4ƒgf=ƒgcIR1exƒgR\RqiR\evh htWZWdVdcNegev™Nh¡n™FWZsex^yn[khXexeg[k[N‡WdcNWdcNRRºf1nNhtW=VZUbVdWZR\eg[yhXWSWdevf1Thl^yTNex[NnN_›ƒv^UbVZWdYmeg^U4[8WdegWZ^^[{Uy^i´_K³tWdnIcIhXRW
WdicInNR VZegY[N‡*nW=WZUbcNWZRlex^yTI[#Vd^yTI‡VdVZ^yR\™IhZU4hK™N^4eg_ƒgerWZWtcNs2R*_›^yž VK” R\Uy†bf=¥9cºcN‡VZR1^[InNR?‡yƒxc^finRwhKfVZUR\iNUUhdTeg[NWd‡2egqWdR\cIƒxs R
YhZU´nNqWZR#UbYWZex^yn[8W=UbTNWdegVd^^y[™Ih9U4™I¶¡exUyƒgerhtWZWZexR\Rwih¡^^[[fWd^ycN[]R\qyY°R1†VZ‡Rwi.ƒx^f1eDo ”7¯ p7`f1U[
WdY¥9ccNnNUbR*WZW7UbTIoWZVdex”7^yR\ƒx[ï egYmp7^exT“`;[IR1UV=VdTUbsR\WZVX^R_›V§^yT“Vd^yY.R1[¸VZhlexYmUk™R1R1hd[]RWXWZWW R1VZ^4V9R\_2WdhdcnNWtsFU4ƒxWZTN[{h?evf1WZ^U4VZ_ËUyƒ9WdicNž exevWd”hleg^hX[IWdWZnUR\hXƒ“iWs™IerTNhdW9VZcN·I^^b™Neg¶ T –
ƒgY.R1Y.U´s{h1†¨™“R¥9UmcNR‡^FR1^§iTR\f\VdU4egYm[IiNR1eg[]iNWU4WdVZR(R\hdYnNƒxnWZWZhU4Wdex[Ieg^iN[8egf\^UbT“WdRR1V=WdUbcIWZU4^WmV¡_›o ^”SVS¯ ž pS” ` h1†
oFeg[IfR(o ”S¯ p7`;¶¡^VZ‰FhlUbWlWdcNR#™^WXWZ^Y–…ƒgR1qyR1ƒ“^4_/YnWZU4Wdeg^[K|
0
50
100
150
200
250
Evaluations ( x 100 )
300
350
400
”
dWé)egex^‡y[nNh9VZR°^[ÝI„u}–to ”qyR1¥šV=U4TI‡yVdR^y™N™“ƒxR\R\hXY.WX–¬h9hX^¶2–M_ÊerWZUc°VYmf1nNRwVdiqyexR\nIhY£U4‡]R\U4TNegeg[IhXWZhtUyWhXR1evh\qb† U4ƒgnIU4–
ex[NW#evê]f1nNUR\[kh7™“_›^RVSR\YUyhXnegƒgW=s8UbWdf1eg^^Y[•™NU4ex[I[IikR\i8f\U4eg[y[aWZ^Uyf^WºWdcNUh2R\VSWZcNURiIU4™TUW=hdUbegWdh7eg^_›^[8V#WZU4R\[If=cU4––
ƒgs]Ì\ex[I‡mU[Ii8iR\hdeg‡[Neg[N‡[NR1¶ÚVdR\ƒgU4WdRwiUƒx‡y^VZerWZcNY.h1†
ª¬‡[•nIƒgWdUcNVDev_›hºnIht[IWZfnIWZiex^ys[|K_›ev^h
V#nIhdWdR\cNiR.WdhZ^(U4‰yf1RUƒg^4f1nN_9ƒvhXUbegWdYmRlTNWdƒgcIerÄR2f\YUbWZnexW=^yUb[kWdegWd^cI[RTNWZVZVd^ev™IU4[NU4––
Wd_›™N^evegU4VZƒxexƒ)Y.Wts_›U4nN_›[I[^yf1fV?RWdR\|¡eg^Uy¶2[f=chºcNevexƒgf=[I^Fc˜hXf1WdnIevRwh.h\U†?ia^yµ7[NYmWZR8cNU´_›R1s8nV
Wd_›_›nInInNVdVX[RWZfcNWd¶¡R1eg^Vº^[VZeg‰¸hYhXTIU4nVd™“f=^bc^qynNRUyWh
ž oR”§”7T©¯ h#^yp7[NTR1`¹R\[NVX–– †
”7¯
WdojlRw”S^f=YmcN¯ [NTIp7evUê]`ÃVdnNegR\†[Nh*‡•_›^^V7™W=YU4egn[NWZR\U4i˜Wdeg^o [evh7p7U`[N^4WZ¶2cNR1erWZV2cÅ_›nN^WdWdnNcNVZR\RV.¶¡U^iNVZU‰TWZU4U4™“Wd^eg^nN[ W
—dC e—¦C bC]E)ÿdC Wdܾ{cI†“;RkB~7BhXR† ¿|R\9ƒxRwÀ´U4fR‰yWd
R1eg^VÁ[˜IX\jà U4Èy¿‘ƒgÉ]‡ÂL^y€ ŸVd%ex†S£WdcN"&z2¿4Y.Rwih\†ÅnIÄf1ª¬exÃ*[N[Œ&߇ËܙN߆ evà UÜIŸh#† ÅSU4ž#[Iâ VZÆ´iR%_›R\eg[Nã[Ià R1Ç.htÍ.WZ R1f1ƒgƒxex|¡R¹R\[I Êf/4R\s8–ti}萆egyŸ [ |†
u/U´¶2VZR1[fRº~ VZƒx™IUnNY ” hdhd^fevUbWdRwh1†
¥ºW† ºUä f=‰±t\ÈyÈyè Ÿ † oFR1ƒx_㖠” iNU4TNWZUbWZex^y[ëeg[ž#R\[NRWZegf ” ƒg‡^–
0.93
Average Best Fitness
0.925
0.92
0.915
0.91
0.905
BitFlipMut + 2-Point
SANUM + 2-Point
BitFlipMut + Uniform
SANUM + Uniform
0.9
0.895
0.89
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Evaluations ( x 100 )
dWé)egex^‡y[nNh9VZR^[€„u}–t” o ”qyR1¥šV=U4TI‡yVdR^y™N™“ƒxR\R\hXY.WX–¬h9hX^¶2–M_ÊerWZUc°VcIf1nNex‡yVdc°qyR\R\hTNevU4ht‡]W=U4Ueghd[Iegh\ht†WR1qbU4ƒgnIU4–
VZDer"WZcNàÇIY.ß3h1†ºi9ª¬àË[•Ê{é¡'.†};ÜN†ß=È ášUVdR\ÂKƒgUBU4"&[I¿3iÉɧ
†³ÅÌ¡à$^ nIÍ{Vd&‡yÊá4ex[Nâ³RÎL› "R\ßiI|Kh1è4† Ÿ Ý´|v¡b¾{–tèy€£B¿†
`ªtÏ¥ § VZR\hZh1†
¥º#†y´† éIº^Uyä ‡f=R\‰ƒM|FtU4wÈ[È]i € Ð)Ÿ †
†y``nevf=W=cIUbUWdƒxegR\^¶23[ eg§?f1ÌUVZ›URwYiNh1R1† ŸWdR\‰| VZÑh\†Ká Rª¬[{
´Ò¥º£B´† Ó3ºDUyä "Ff=‰“Ê{|]9Q%# †
hdâm'erWtàs § ËVdáRwhdÔ3h\†ÂK»R'à¬ábà|y~*y† èN†x1–—~7† 萆 €F†Kµ7§F_›^V=ip*[IexqyR1Vd–
Qz2Rw†hXRwjlU4^yV=Vdf=[Nc RyÕ| ¯ §
^†°WdR z2^y€FhZ„ hšU[IéIi3UyhtÖ
† –—§ u V=†UféWdU4evf1[NU4‡ƒ X~ \Èyqy%È ^/ ƒgnŸ †Wdeg^[ž U4VZ” s
W
”
Ä¥9f1egYegUƒ}R1WZª¬U[y™NWZR1ƒxegƒg[Nƒxeg‡‡†,R\[If×Ryß|IÇ.p*[Iex=qyábR1âKV=ØShXexWtߢs.^4_?à…| ~ Q7iegR\[FTI™NU4nNVdVZWd‡YmcKR\|[ypSWm‚m^4_ † VXWZer–
u‡R\†l[NQSRWZU´egqFfevhU4ƒg‡t\^yÈyVdexÉWdÈ cIŸ Ym† h\”†#iNª¬[•UTQWdeg†}[NoN‡¹f=cI^UbT“ÞËR1V=R1UbV.WZ^›RwVmi}TN† Ÿ VZv| ^¾{™IU;B™NBegƒx¿exWdoegR\"hm6à ÇNeg[ ß
`kÙ U4
|WdR1Á^à¢j ¿Ú” ÂK„I`B"&^¿ÛVZ‡yU[܂(Ã2Ußn“_›ß1Y.àU4ƒ[NI[ÅSâ § ƦnN™Iãƒxà6evÇdhXcIR1Vw|*† ÝÖ4–—ÝyÈN†ÆoU[
‚má †Â
” âxá †Q70DR#"NÜÃ*^y[Nß “‡ß1X$à \{È]€Å»Î yŸ áL† ËÅÌ$à bßÅÌÞR“Ô9á4mâ à—Ô9ß N†o"7§ 6à cIÇNQŒ»ß ÝS¥9ß cNÇNRwá hXBevh1|4 QSRo"–
TIp*U[IVXexWZqyYR1V=R\hX[]exWtW#s{^^4_9_
jl`^Ymevf=cNTNexn‡]WZU4R1[KV(| U4” [[NiP[ jl” ^y™“Y^YVw† nN[Nevf1U4Wdeg^[•of1exR\[IfRwh1|
‚mp7hd† eg” [N‡S†bQSTIVdR9^yÜy™N^ƒxR\[IY¢‡I|b‡`¹R1[I† R1” V=Ub† Wd§
^y^VZWXh}WdWdR\^#V)UR§[ITNpi ƒg^l«VZR †4Wd`ÃcIRl†boR1TޓRwRwU4fWZV=h)hl^X\_NÈR1ÈFTN€ evhtŸ – †
WZÃ*Uy&ßhXevËh\߆)à ª¬J[ÅS¥ºâ Æ´†d%ºUyä ãàf=Ç.‰° ÊR\|i}¡´† Ÿ ¡|Éb¾{j– ¡%/F£ÎB¿N†/oD"SU[àÇI`kßU4ß1Wdà6R\Ç3^IÁ|j ࢔¿p„4ÂK`£^y"&Vd¿N‡]U4%[
‚(U4nN_›YmU[N[K†
”§?U4†yV=~*U4†4Ym~ R1egWd™“R1R1V[Kf1|^z[]†WdVZ*^egƒ []exWd[¹R1V=R\iqeg[N^‡(ƒgnU4WZex[I^y3i [IU4Ð)VZ†4s•`Uevƒxf=‡ycI^UVZƒxerR\WZ¶2cNY.egf1Ì#h1h† X\Á;ÈÊKÈyÊËÈ ÊŸ †
׉dá&¿N%ƒÊ{bâm'àËáÔ|ÂK%0G'à—á4à$% b …è Ÿ „gwè%/4–=/†
WZ¥º›RwU4†i}WdegjS† ^Ÿ [ƆIJ| éI¾{ex^[Ç;‡yBUBWdVX¿‘cNWtR¹sD"ž#X\àR1ÈÇI[NÉyß R1È WdŸÙ ev†f;
IÈ ” UÁƒxVd‡ysF¢à ^¿‡egVZ[Ner‡WZÂLcNWd%Y8cN£pR"&†±¿š§ ª¬Vd[Æ^yϙIÜU4Ã*†¡™N&ß Qeg˃ger߆7Wtàs.oà^f=cI_)ÅSU4`â ޓƦnR\V–#
ã6à Çd=|/\%Ö /–ZwÖÈI†)oU[°`kU4WdR\^I|j ” „`^VZ‡yU[‚(U4nN_›YmU[N[K†
oˆËéN^yVdVZR\hXWSU4[ik`¹†Ë`erW=f=cNR1ƒgƒ9t\ÈyÈyè Ÿ †7z2R\ƒgU4WdegqR™InNexƒvieg[N‡4–
™Nl¦ƒg^cNf=ex‰.WdƒgR1ÄNsšWd[IÊR\R\hZi}h2† Ÿ U4|J[IáviWd'.cNGR(
™IábnNàexƒviegƒ[N‡4D–—"|™NƒgÃ*^ß&f=ˉ{ßcFàs]àT“^4ÅSWZâ cNƦR\hdevãh1à6†
Çdª¬[QÀ††
oU[°`kU4WdR\^I|j ” „`^VZ‡yU[‚(U4nN_›YmU[N[K†
Ÿ
V=ÜÞU4†Ô9YmÜIଆ]Rß&ž#WZR1VdV=R1h.äL_›R1åa_›[I^hXV8áWd¨R1ž#WXá%WdR1RR[N
ÉR1XWd\ÂevÈyf ÔÉÒ=Ý ” ߃x†
‡y“µS^ß1VZà$TerWZWZ&cNexYmY.| egh1Ì\↠U4XWdegÁ;^Ÿ ÊK[m„¡ÊË´^4Êãè_/èbjl–Z׉´^dè4[]á ÉNWdVZ† ^¿Ú‰ƒ §?%U4 –
.ø æ
Qç “†]à~7†]ž#Šèw^á4ƒvà$i%™“‰R1äVZ‡áRtw
hÈÉyåaÈ Ÿá1† ÇdÃ*“&ß ËßàßÎDà ß=0áÅSâ Ʀ¦Æ†ã6à Çdz2RwÌUiƒeg[N‡IÞË|)ß=%á ` ;” Çdä„
” iIieghd^[N– l¨R\hdƒxR\s|
Ü`†yn*W=RwUbhdWZhdex^yR1V¡[ U4§ [IVZi^™z(U4†]™N`¸egƒxexU4Wtä sm[N[Nex[8R\VSž#X\R1[NÈÈIR1Wd evŸ f †D” ¥Dƒg^b‡¶¡^UVZexVZWdiNcNh Y.U4h\[†)µSª¬[°TWZexY.† ¢– §
U4Ġ
o¾2f=%á cFd¶¡ábâãRâx_›ß1R1x⠃…|N¾{z(;†IÒ1`¸âxß éU4ä [N[NÞ³R\bVmâ B›Rw¦iNÆ1h1"† Ÿ;|G%â¾{;êB£áb¿Nà '.D"ºdß1à6|IÇN%è ߟ¡bj–i9¡yèNà̆ ÂL%£"&¿W%
Üà †“ÍJÊ†Ëáb{â7Þ^ƒgÔ9ƒgUà¬[I&ß iÝX†\È]”€Î [NŸ [ N† Å̔ VZ™á Ë^yà—V\á4| $à p7%[N!egqR1|V=hdêerWtá4sP$à '.^4d_#á4â
`%á egRf=cI
àex‡]ÅÌU4[ #
§ VZR\hZh\†
Ÿ † l¦cIUbWPcIU´qR˜s^yn®i^y[NRÅ_›^VPYmR
ƒv#hXUbWZ†(WdUbR\WZ܃xR9s‰nN‡ëŃvR1hXWd[IUVZRiN^WdUY evTf2WdU4egt[Nƒgw‡‡¦È^yÈ]Vd^yÎexWdTcI€
R\Y°VZU4†DWd^ª¬[.Vau TN†4Vd^yܙI†U4~ ™IhdexcNƒgerR1WZƒgexY.RwhU4[8eg[¤›RwUši}† Ÿ htd|WZR\¾{Uyi£s]B– ¿
oD"U[°à ÇI`khß U4ì´Wd6à R\Ç|^I|Á&Ij jà ” ¿‡„ÂK`^B"&VZ‡y¿?U%[Ă(Ã*U4nNß _›“Ymß1$à U[N3[KÅS† â Ʀã6à Çd| ÉN–¬É]€†
Üjl†¡VZ^yu/hZR1hXq^bR\qy[NR1evV#f=‰Újl^yX[y\WZÈVdÈ]^yÎ ƒM†ºŸ †®ª¬[¨`u R1†}WZU4ÜI™I†}er~lW=h1hX„ÅcNR\ž#ƒxY.R\[NU[ÅRWZeg›f¨Rwi}~ † Ÿ [|vi¾{^;‡yBR1B[N¿ƒ^ynIo"h
`k6à ÇNßU4Wdì´R16à^Ç|jÁ&I” jà ¿p„I`kÂK^BVZ"&‡y¿WU4[°š‚(Ã*U4n&ß _›ËY.ßàU[N1[KÅS† â Æ´%ãà Ç. |ÉyÉb–¬ÈyÎN†
oU[
U4ƒgƒg†DÛs `Ål•nNä cN^yƒgVdR1‰Ë[F„™“R1egª[Œ†{X`k\ÈynÈyWZè U4Ÿ Wd†.eg^*[ ^bU4¶Â[Ii£ž#R\*[NRegƒxWZƒvegff ƒgexY” ™Nƒx‡yeg^[NVZ‡IerWZ† cNY.ª¬h([ z2z(R– †
`ÃÂKUä B[N"&[N¿sR1V°‘U4[I¾2i‡%á d#áb†¡âãâgß`kJâ U4¾{[IiNR1Ò1VZâxeg&ß f=î‰ÚÞG›R\4iImâ £h1†Ÿd|1Æ3¾F";;%£ïB¿íêo"kábà '.à6ÇNdß|ß1|2ÀwRÎb
–
è4ÈI†
ÜQ#†]UQh(†FtwoNÈf=ÉycIÈUbŸÞˆ R1Vw” |]zo]WZ† nI” i†sj¡^4U_?VdjlnU4^y[I[]UIWdVZ|y^u xƒ †F§?ÜU4†]V=~lU4YmhXcNR1R\WdƒxR1Y.V=hU[K” |]ÞËUR\[Ifi{WZex[Iz(‡ †
”
WdµS6à ÇNeg^[Nß [¦ƒgexÙ [IµS;R
T§
ÁWdIegR1YmVdjà ¿ _›ex^ÌwÂLVZUbY.WZ%ex£U4^y"&[I[K¿Wf1†PR%‘ª¬^[Å_7Ã*ܞ#&ß †)ËR1Q[Nßà R1† WdNevof ÅSf=cIâ Æ´U4ƒg%ޓ‡R\^yãV°Vdà Ç.exWdÊ cNR\i}Y.|ˆ ŸhºÎ{| _›¾F^y–¬ÝV;ÖI£éIB†)nN¿so[IUfo[ "–
`kU4WdR1^|j ” „I`k^VZ‡yU4[°‚(U4n_›Y.U[N[ƒ§ nN™NƒgeghdcNR\V\†
ÈyW=Ý UbŸ Wd†DR¹oFž#R1ƒxR1_㖬[IURiNWdUevf TWZ” U4Wdƒg‡eg^^[ –
^4VZÜer_m†wWZ~7cN`Y8†´noF†ÆW=YmUbª¬exWdWdÄ[ egc^[Ú¾{U4[Iz*£iBUb¥º¿ÛWZR\†h8DjS"8eg†´[Æ6àéNÇN^yU¦ß Vd‡yÙo]R1;WZVd
ÕR\WtUsÁ;iNÊ˝Xsy\ÊK–tÈo]Êð
à “%á ÔÉÂK»R'à¬ábà | ¡NwÉbj– ¡y%è ¡I†/ªt~l~ š
~ ÂK§ BVZR\"&hZ¿Ûh1† ‡Ê{94mâ '.#
”
Ÿ ”
Wdàeg[N†]I‡]¥/hº| næ exhX[¹^y…è [{ž#Ÿ „2U4R1[I[Nw3i ÝNR1Wd1§
ev–Zf w†]É%z2” /I^yƒg† ‡hZh*^yVdtexwWdÈcNÈyY.É h\3† † ÊFiN94UmâT'Wd$à eg[N%‡.“%á µSTÔR\VZÂKU4Wd»^V Ro'Rà¬áWX–#