Contents Alternate Contents List of Illustrations Preface to Instructors Letter to Students P A R T I Getting Started: From Response to Argument C H A P T E R 1 The Writer as Reader Reading and Responding Kate Chopin Ripe Figs Reading as Re-creation Making Reasonable Inferences Reading with Pen in Hand Recording Your First Responses Identifying Your Audience and Purpose Your Turn: A Writing Assignment A Sample Essay by a Student: “Ripening” The Argument Analyzed Other Possibilities for Writing C H A P T E R 2 The Reader as Writer Developing a Thesis, Drafting and Writing an Argument Pre-writing: Getting Ideas Annotating a Text More about Getting Ideas: A Second Story by Kate Chopin Kate Chopin The Story of an Hour Brainstorming for Ideas for Writing Focused Free Writing Listing Asking Questions Keeping a Journal Arguing with Yourself: Critical Thinking Arguing a Thesis Drafting Your Argument A Sample Draft: “Ironies in an Hour” Revising an Argument Outlining an Argument Soliciting Peer Review v vi Contents Final Version of the Sample Essay: “Ironies of Life in Kate Chopin’s ‘The Story of an Hour’” A Brief Overview of the Final Version Writing with a Word Processor á Checklist: Writing with a Word Processor Your Turn: Two Additional Stories by Kate Chopin Kate Chopin Désirée’s Baby Kate Chopin The Storm A Note about Literary Evaluations C H A P T E R 3 Reading Literature Closely: Explication What Is Literature? Literature and Form Form and Meaning Robert Frost The Span of Life Reading in Slow Motion Explication A Sample Explication Langston Hughes Harlem Working Toward an Explication Some Journal Entries Sample Essay by a Student (Final Version): “Langston Hughes’ ‘Harlem’” Explication as Argument á Checklist: Drafting an Explication Why Write? Purpose and Audience Your Turn: Poems for Explication William Shakespeare Sonnet 73 (That time of year thou mayst in me behold) Ben Jonson On My First Son William Blake London Emily Brontë Spellbound Li-Young Lee I Ask my Mother to Sing Alfred, Lord Tennyson Ulysses C H A P T E R 4 Reading Literature Closely: Analysis Analysis Analyzing a Story from the Hebrew Bible: The Judgment of Solomon Analyzing the Story Other Possible Topics for Analysis Analyzing a Story from the New Testament: The Parable of the Prodigal Son Comparison: An Analytic Tool A Sample Essay by a Student: “Two New Women” Looking at the Essay á Checklist: Revising a Comparison Contents Evaluation in Explication and Analysis Choosing a Topic and Developing a Thesis in an Analytic Paper Analyzing a Story James Thurber The Secret Life of Walter Mitty Working Toward a Thesis: Journal Entries Developing the Thesis: List Notes Sample Draft by a Student: “Walter Mitty Is No Joke” Developing an Argument Introductory Paragraphs Middle Paragraphs Concluding Paragraphs Coherence in Paragraphs: Using Transitions á Checklist: Revising Paragraphs Review: Writing an Analysis A Note on Technical Terminology A Lyric Poem and a Student’s Essay Aphra Behn Song: Love Armed Journal Entries A Sample Essay by a Student: “The Double Nature of Love” á Checklist: Editing a Draft Your Turn: Short Stories and Poems for Analysis Edgar Allan Poe The Fall of the House of Usher Virginia Woolf A Haunted House Guy de Maupassant The Necklace José Armas El Tonto del Barrio Leslie Marmon Silko The Man to Send Rain Clouds Elizabeth Bishop Filling Station Elizabeth Bishop The Fish Elizabeth Bishop One Art C H A P T E R 5 Other Kinds of Writing about Literature Summary Paraphrase What Paraphrase Is The Value of Paraphrase Literary Response Writing a Literary Response A Story by a Student: “The Ticket (A Different View of ‘The Story of an Hour’)” A Poem Based on a Poem William Blake The Tyger X. J. Kennedy For Allen Ginsberg Rewriting a Poem William Butler Yeats Annunciation William Butler Yeats Leda and the Swan [1924] vii viii Contents William Butler Yeats Leda and the Swan [1933] Mona Van Duyn Leda Parody William Carlos Williams This Is Just to Say Reviewing a Dramatic Production A Sample Review by a Student: “An Effective Macbeth” The Review Reviewed C H A P T E R 6 Reading and Writing about Visual Culture The Language of Pictures Analyzing a Picture: Navajo Dancers Entertaining a Tourist Train Notes and a Sample Essay by a Student The Analysis Analyzed Thinking about Dorothea Lange’s Migrant Mother, Nipomo, California A Sample Documented Essay by a Student Photographers on Photography Lou Jacobs JR. What Qualities Does a Good Photograph Have? An American Picture Album: Ten Images P A R T I I Up Close: Thinking Critically about Literary Works and Literary Forms C H A P T E R 7 Critical Thinking: Asking Questions and Making Comparisons What Is Critical Thinking? Asking and Answering Questions Comparing and Contrasting Analyzing and Evaluating Evidence Thinking Critically: Asking Questions and Comparing—E. E. Cummings’s “Buffalo Bill ’s” E. E. Cummings Buffalo Bill ’s Emily Dickinson: Three Versions of a Poem, and More Emily Dickinson I felt a Funeral, in my Brain Emily Dickinson I felt a Cleaving in my Mind— Emily Dickinson The Dust behind I strove to join Imaginative Play: Thinking about Three Poems William Butler Yeats The Wild Swans at Coole Gwendolyn Brooks We Real Cool Andrew Hudgins The Wild Swans Skip School Anonymous The Silver Swan Contents C H A P T E R 8 Reading and Writing about Essays Types of Essays The Essayist’s Persona Voice Tone Pre-writing: Identifying the Topic and Thesis Brent Staples Black Men and Public Space Summarizing Summary and Analysis Preparing a Summary Stating the Thesis of an Essay Drafting a Summary Writing Assignments á Checklist: Getting Ideas for Writing about Essays Your Turn: Essays for Analysis Langston Hughes Salvation Louis Owens The American Indian Wilderness May Sarton The Rewards of Living a Solitary Life John Updike Observations C H A P T E R 9 Reading and Writing about Fiction Stories True and False Grace Paley Samuel Elements of Fiction Plot and Character Foreshadowing Setting and Atmosphere Symbolism Narrative Point of View Style and Point of View Theme á Checklist: Getting Ideas for Writing about Fiction Your Turn: Short Stories for Analysis Nathaniel Hawthorne Young Goodman Brown Anton Chekhov Misery Eudora Welty A Worn Path Isabel Allende If You Touched My Heart Alice Elliott Dark In the Gloaming ix x Contents C H A P T E R 10 Thinking and Writing Critically about Short Stories: Two Case Studies Case Study: Writing about Ralph Ellison’s “Battle Royal” Ralph Ellison Battle Royal Booker T. Washington Atlanta Exposition Address W. E. B. Du Bois Of Our Spiritual Strivings W. E. B. Du Bois Of Mr. Booker T. Washington and Others Gunnar Myrdal On Social Equality Ralph Ellison On Negro Folklore Ralph Ellison Life in Oklahoma City Case Study: Writing about Flannery O’Connor Flannery O’Connor A Good Man Is Hard to Find Flannery O’Connor Revelation Remarks from Essays and Letters From “The Fiction Writer and His Country” From “The Nature and Aim of Fiction” From “Writing Short Stories” On Interpreting “A Good Man Is Hard to Find” “A Reasonable Use of the Unreasonable” C H A P T E R 11 Looking at Pictures, Writing Stories The Impulse to Tell Stories Charles Baxter Music for Airports A. S. Byatt Christ in the House of Martha and Mary Your Turn: Picture to Story C H A P T E R 12 Fiction into Film Asking Questions, Thinking Critically, and Making Comparisons Film as a Medium Film Techniques Shots Sequences Editing Theme Comparing Filmed and Printed Stories Getting Ready to Write Drafting an Essay á Checklist: Getting Ideas for Writing about Film Suggestions for Further Reading A Short Story and a Student’s Essay on the Filmed Version Mary Wilkins Freeman The Revolt of “Mother” Contents A Sample Essay by a Student: “Enjoying Mother’s Revolution” Your Turn: Thinking about Filming Fiction C H A P T E R 13 Reading and Writing about Drama Types of Plays Tragedy Comedy Elements of Drama Theme Plot Gestures Setting Characterization and Motivation Organizing an Analysis of a Character First Draft Revised Draft á Checklist: Getting Ideas for Writing about Drama Thinking about a Filmed Version of a Play á Checklist: Writing about a Filmed Play Your Turn: Plays for Analysis A Note on Greek Tragedy Thinking Critically about a Tragedy: Sophocles’s Antigonê Sophocles Antigone Susan Glaspell Trifles Luis Valdez Los Vendidos C H A P T E R 14 Thinking Critically about Drama Tennessee Williams The Glass Menagerie Tennessee Williams’s Production Notes The Screen Device The Music The Lighting A Sample Essay by a Student Preliminary Notes Final Version of the Student’s Essay: “The Solid Structure of The Glass Menagerie” C H A P T E R 15 Reading and Writing about Poetry Elements of Poetry The Speaker and the Poet Emily Dickinson I’m Nobody! Who are you? Emily Dickinson Wild Nights—Wild Nights xi xii Contents The Language of Poetry: Diction and Tone Writing about the Speaker Robert Frost The Telephone Journal Entries Figurative Language Imagery and Symbolism William Blake The Sick Rose Verbal Irony and Paradox Structure Robert Herrick Upon Julia’s Clothes A Sample Essay by a Student: “Herrick’s Julia, Julia’s Herrick” The Analysis Analyzed Christina Rossetti In an Artist’s Studio Explication An Example William Butler Yeats The Balloon of the Mind Annotations and Journal Entries A Sample Essay by a Student: “Explication of W. B. Yeats’s ‘The Balloon of the Mind’” á Checklist: Explication Rhythm and Versification: A Glossary for Reference Meter Patterns of Sound Stanzaic Patterns Blank Verse and Free Verse á Checklist: Getting Ideas for Writing about Poetry Your Turn: Poems About People, Places, and Things People Robert Browning My Last Duchess E. E. Cummings anyone lived in a pretty how town Sylvia Plath Daddy Louise Erdrich Indian Boarding School: The Runaways Huddie Ledbetter De Titanic Etheridge Knight For Malcolm, a Year After Places Basho An Old Pond William Butler Yeats Sailing to Byzantium James Wright Lying in a Hammock at William Duffy’s Farm in Pine Island, Minnesota Yusef Komunyakaa Facing It Derek Walcott A Far Cry from Africa Anonymous Deep River Things William Carlos Wiilliams The Red Wheelbarrow Walt Whitman A Noiseless Patient Spider Mary Oliver Hawk Contents C H A P T E R 16 Thinking Critically about Poetry Case Study: Writing about Emily Dickinson Emily Dickinson I heard a Fly buzz—when I died— Emily Dickinson The Soul selects her own Society Emily Dickinson These are the days when Birds come back Emily Dickinson Papa above! Emily Dickinson There’s a certain Slant of light Emily Dickinson This World is not Conclusion Emily Dickinson I got so I could hear his name— Emily Dickinson Because I could not stop for Death Emily Dickinson Those—dying, then Emily Dickinson Apparently with no surprise Emily Dickinson Tell all the Truth but tell it slant A Sample Essay by a Student: “Religion and Religious Imagery in Emily Dickinson” P A R T I I I Standing Back: Arguing Interpretations and Evaluations, and Understanding Critical Strategies C H A P T E R 17 Arguing an Interpretation Interpretation and Meaning Is the Author’s Intention a Guide to Meaning? What Characterizes a Sound Interpretation? An Example: Interpreting Pat Mora’s “Immigrants” Thinking Critically about Responses to Literature Two Interpretations by Students Robert Frost Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening Sample Essay by a Student: “Stopping by Woods—and Going On” Sample Essay by a Student: “‘Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening’ as a Short Story” Your Turn: Poems for Interpretation John Milton When I Consider How My Light Is Spent Robert Frost Mending Wall William Wordsworth A Slumber Did My Spirit Seal T. S. Eliot The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock C H A P T E R 18 Arguing an Evaluation Criticism and Evaluation Are There Critical Standards? xiii xiv Contents Morality and Truth as Standards Other Ways of Thinking about Truth and Realism Your Turn: Poems and Stories for Evaluation Matthew Arnold Dover Beach Anthony Hecht The Dover Bitch Robert Frost Design Ira Gershwin The Man That Got Away Ambrose Bierce An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge Katherine Mansfield Miss Brill C H A P T E R 19 Writing about Literature: An Overview of Critical Strategies The Nature of Critical Writing Criticism as Argument: Assumptions and Evidence Some Critical Strategies Formalist Criticism (New Criticism) Deconstruction Reader-Response Criticism Archetypal Criticism (Myth Criticism) Historical Criticism Psychological or Psychoanalytical Criticism Gender Criticism (Feminist, and Lesbian and Gay Criticism) Your Turn: Putting Critical Strategies to Work Suggestions for Further Reading P A R T I V A Thematic Anthology C H A P T E R 20 Love and Hate Essays Sei Shōnagon A Lover’s Departure Judith Ortiz Cofer I Fell in Love, or My Hormones Awakened Louis Menand Love Stories Andrew Sullivan The Love Bloat Fiction Ernest Hemingway Cat in the Rain A Student’s Notes and Journal Entries on “Cat in the Rain” Asking Questions about a Story A Sample Essay by a Student: “Hemingway’s American Wife” A Second Example: An Essay Drawing on Related Material in the Chapter Sample Essay by a Student: “Hemingway’s Unhappy Lovers” Contents xv William Faulkner A Rose for Emily Zora Neale Hurston Sweat Case Study: Writing about Raymond Carver Raymond Carver Mine Raymond Carver Little Things Raymond Carver What We Talk about When We Talk about Love Raymond Carver Cathedral Talking about Stories On Rewriting Michael Gerber and Jonathan Schwarz What We Talk about When We Talk about Doughnuts Poetry Anonymous Western Wind Christopher Marlowe Come Live with Me and Be My Love Sir Walter Raleigh The Nymph’s Reply to the Shepherd John Donne The Bait William Shakespeare Sonnet 29 (When, in disgrace with Fortune and men’s eyes) William Shakespeare Sonnet 116 (Let me not to the marriage of true minds) John Donne A Valediction: Forbidding Mourning Andrew Marvell To His Coy Mistress William Blake The Garden of Love William Blake A Poison Tree Walt Whitman When I Heard at the Close of the Day Walt Whitman I Saw in Louisiana a Live-Oak Growing Christina Rossetti A Birthday Edna St. Vincent Millay Love Is Not All: It Is Not Meat nor Drink Robert Frost The Silken Tent Adrienne Rich Novella Adrienne Rich XI Robert Pack The Frog Prince Joseph Brodsky Love Song Nikki Giovanni Love in Place Carol Muske Chivalry Kitty Tsui A Chinese Banquet Drama Wendy Wasserstein The Man in a Case C H A P T E R 21 Gender Roles: Making Men and Women Essays Katha Pollitt Why Boys Don’t Play with Dolls Scott Russell Sanders The Men We Carry in Our Minds . . . and How They Differ from the Real Lives of Most Men xvi Contents Fiction Charlotte Perkins Gilman The Yellow Wallpaper Richard Wright The Man Who Was Almost a Man Bobbie Ann Mason Shiloh Doris Lessing A Woman on a Roof Gloria Naylor The Two Alice Munro Boys and Girls Poetry Three Nursery Rhymes What Are Little Boys Made Of? Georgie Porgie The Milk Maid Anonymous Higamus, Hogamus Dorothy Parker General Review of the Sex Situation Rita Dove Daystar Robert Hayden Those Winter Sundays Muriel Rukeyser Myth Theodore Roethke My Papa’s Waltz Lucille Clifton wishes for sons Sharon Olds Rites of Passage Frank O’Hara Homosexuality Shel Silverstein A Boy Named Sue Tess Gallagher I Stop Writing the Poem Julia Alvarez Woman’s Work Maud Meehan Is There Life After Feminism Marge Piercy A Work of Artifice Drama Henrik Ibsen A Doll’s House Case Study: Writing about Barbie and Gender Anonymous Beauty and the Barbie Doll Kevin Leary Barbie Curtsies to Political Correctness Meg Wolitzer Sex and the Single Doll Yona Zeldis McDonough What Barbie Really Taught Me Marge Piercy Barbie Doll Denise Duhamel Buddhist Barbie C H A P T E R 22 Innocence and Experience Essay Maya Angelou Graduation Fiction James Joyce Araby Langston Hughes One Friday Morning Contents xvii John Updike A & P Liliana Heker The Stolen Party Toni Cade Bambara The Lesson Poetry William Blake Infant Joy William Blake Infant Sorrow William Blake The Echoing Green Gerard Manley Hopkins Spring and Fall: To a Young Child A. E. Housman When I Was One-and-Twenty (A Shropshire Lad # 13) E. E. Cummings In just— Louise Glück The School Children Louise Glück Gretel in Darkness Drama Case Study: Writing about Shakespeare’s Hamlet A Note on the Elizabethan Theater A Note on the Text of Hamlet William Shakespeare The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark Ernest Jones Hamlet and the Oedipus Complex Anne Barton The Promulgation of Confusion Stanley Wells On the First Soliloquy Elaine Showalter Representing Ophelia Claire Bloom Playing Gertrude on Television Bernice W. Kliman The BBC Hamlet: A Television Production Stanley Kauffmann At Elsinore Will Saretta Branagh’s Film of Hamlet C H A P T E R 23 Identity in America Essays 0 Thomas Jefferson The Declaration of Independence Anna Lisa Raya It’s Hard Enough Being Me Andrew Lam Goodbye, Saigon, Finally Fiction Isaac Bashevis Singer The Son from America Amy Tan Two Kinds Louise Erdrich The Red Convertible Katherine Min Courting a Monk Poetry Emma Lazarus The New Colossus Thomas Bailey Aldrich The Unguarded Gates Joseph Bruchac III Ellis Island Edwin Arlington Robinson Richard Cory 0 xviii Contents Aurora Levins Morales Child of the Americas Gloria Anzaldua To Live in the Borderlands Means You Jimmy Santiago Baca So Mexicans Are Taking Jobs from Americans Langston Hughes Theme for English B Pat Parker For the White Person Who Wants to Know How to Be My Friend Mitsuye Yamada To the Lady Drama 0 August Wilson Fences Case Study: Writing about American Indian Identity An Argument for America Anonymous Arapaho My Children, When at First I Liked the Whites Anonymous Arapaho Father, Have Pity on Me Lydia Howard Huntley Sigourney The Indian’s Welcome to the Pilgrim Fathers Robert Frost The Vanishing Red Wendy Rose Three Thousand Dollar Death Song Nila northSun Moving Camp Too Far Sherman Alexie On the Amtrak from Boston to New York City Representations—Visual and Verbal—of Pocahontas John Smith John Smith Saved by Pocahontas Miss Baker Last Wish of Pocahontas George P. Morris Pocahontas Moses Y. Scott Pocahontas Paula Gunn Allen Pocahontas to Her English Husband, John Rolfe John D’Entremont Review of Disney’s Pocahontas C H A P T E R 24 Art and Life A Note on Connections between Literature and the Other Arts Six Quotations about the Arts Your Turn: Responding to the Arts Essays Essays Oscar Wilde Preface to The Picture of Dorian Gray Pablo Picasso Talking about Art Willa Cather Light on Adobe Walls Ralph Ellison On Bird, Bird-Watching, and Jazz Fiction B. Traven Assembly Line James Baldwin Sonny’s Blues Alice Walker Everyday Use Poetry Edward Hirsch Fast Break W. F. Bolton Might We Too? Contents Walt Whitman That Music Always Round Me William Wordsworth The Solitary Reaper John Keats Ode on a Grecian Urn Archibald MacLeish Ars Poetica Paul Laurence Dunbar The Quilting Nikki Giovanni For Saundra Louise Glück The Mountain Case Study: Writing about Literary Visions (Word and Image) Thinking and Writing about Poems and Pictures A Sample Essay by a Student: Tina Washington, Two Ways of Looking at a Starry Night Word and Image Jane Flanders Van Gogh’s Bed William Carlos Williams The Great Figure Adrienne Rich Mourning Picture Cathy Song Beauty and Sadness Mary Jo Salter The Rebirth of Venus Anne Sexton The Starry Night W. H. Auden Musée des Beaux Arts X. J. Kennedy Nude Descending a Staircase Greg Pape American Flamingo Carl Phillips Luncheon on the Grass John Updike Before the Mirror Wislawa Szymborska Brueghel’s Two Monkeys C H A P T E R 25 Law and Disorder Essays Henry David Thoreau From Civil Disobedience George Orwell A Hanging Martin Luther King Jr. A Call for Unity Case Study: Writing about the Sacco-Vanzetti Trial Columbia Encylopedia Sacco-Vanzetti Case Bartolomeo Vanzetti Remarks to a Reporter Ben Shahn Drawing with Vanzetti’s Words Bartolomeo Vanzetti (adapted by Selden Rodman) Last Speech to the Court Katherine Anne Porter Afterward Countee Cullen Not Sacco and Vanzetti Edna St. Vincent Millay Justice Denied in Massachusetts Fiction Six Very Short Stories Aesop A Lion and Other Animals Go Hunting John [?] The Woman Taken in Adultery Anonymous Three Hasidic Tales xix xx Contents Franz Kafka Before the Law Elizabeth Bishop The Hanging of the Mouse Ursula Le Guin The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas Case Study: Writing about Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery” Shirley Jackson The Lottery Manuscript Materials The Typescript and the Letter by Gustave Lobrano Galley Proofs Shirley Jackson Biography of a Story Encyclopaedia Britannica Scapegoat Five Short Statements about the Theme in Jackson’s “The Lottery” Two Interpretations by Students Poetry Anonymous Birmingham Jail A. E. Housman The Carpenter’s Son A. E. Housman Eight O’Clock A. E. Housman Oh who is that young sinner A. E. Housman The laws of God, the laws of man Edgar Lee Masters Judge Selah Lively Claude McKay If We Must Die Jimmy Santiago Baca Cloudy Day A P P E N D I X A Remarks about Manuscript Form Basic Manuscript Form Corrections in the Final Copy Quotations and Quotation Marks Quotation Marks or Underlining? A Note on the Possessive A P P E N D I X B Writing a Research Paper What Research Is Not, and What Research Is Primary and Secondary Materials Locating Materials: First Steps Other Bibliographic Aids Taking Notes Two Mechanical Aids: The Photocopier and the Word Processor A Guide to Note-Taking Drafting the Paper Focus on Primary Sources Documentation What to Document: Avoiding Plagiarism How to Document: Footnotes, Internal Parenthetical Citations, and a List of Works Cited (MLA Format) Contents A P P E N D I X C New Approaches to the Research Paper: Literature, History, and the World Wide Web Case Study on Literature and History: The Internment of Japanese Americans Literary Texts Mitsuye Yamada The Question of Loyalty David Mura An Argument: On 1942 Historical Sources Basic Reference Books (Short Paper) Getting Deeper (Medium Paper) Other Reference Sources (Long Paper) Too Much Information? Electronic Sources Encyclopedias: Print and Electronic Versions The Internet/World Wide Web Evaluating Sources on the World Wide Web á Checklist: A Review of Using the WWW Documentation: Citing a WWW Source MLA General Conventions á Checklist: Citing WWW Sources Additional Print and Electronic Sources Search Engines and Directories Print Directories Print Articles on Literature, History, and the WWW Evaluating Websites and Materials A P P E N D I X D Literary Research: Print and Electronic Resources The Basics Moving Ahead: Finding Sources for Research Work Literature—Print Reference Sources Other Reference Resources Bibliographies Literature—Electronic Sources Other Useful Sites on Authors History—Reference and Bibliography Sources WWW Sites for History Periodicals—Print and Electronic Sources For General Bibliography in the Humanities For Evaluating Point of View, Content, and Intended Audience of Sources Other Resources What Does your Own Institution Offer? xxi xxii Contents A P P E N D I X E Glossary of Literary Terms Literary Credits Photo Credits Index of Terms Index of Authors, Titles, and First Lines of Poems 0
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz