Empirically evaluating the electoral college. In

!"#%$&')(*$&
+&
., -./103254106/87:9<;=0>2@?
/\ZH]Q_^ `aQbBEcd0C/
A 0CBEDEFG-CH@/DI0KJ/LM2NDO2NP%2@Q=-CFSRQUTV4/-.BE-CWCXZY
A -.[ BePcgf1DI0Khi/DOj.QUH@L]DO2XZk
`l06HmXn;lDe/ZW
oa06Hmj606H@\nhi/DOj.QUH@L]DO2Xp0C/\
254ZQq*-6HNBE\rosQb0CBt254vuiH]W0C/DE?b0>2NDe-C/w
x 0bXvy.z|{#y6}C}y
"~ 5VV6b_56V5"VbS5V5_b ¡¢6V£V 5
¤tV¥s¦p¥§V¨5¤1 ©>Vªb55«55¥§5Vª Sm¬5©¤tUª«5l£55 §N
ªN¯®%Vb°'ª
±N ¢m²³b¤O5¥§Vªa´£ªU µ¶¸·l£NNN¯¥§5g5£b
£55°V¥¹M¬55&5iNº ¡V¥5Na5¶¹¤tVªs¥§¹G VG¶ @
M5b@ ¢²¡» gabª5»¼¶l5¤" b65ªN¬55 ¯55i²¡K ½1 V5¿¾+5V5
~"´N_»I¥§U N·SVªb V¥§º5<¤tªbb¡¤tV1¤tV¥À5<¬VVªb5_<¥§N V
½ V5¾+VV5
~"¢b5¢iÁ¥§sN¢ª
dV m¬5G¶d5¢ªVªbÂl½ 5 5¨¾+VV
¶¸¥sÄÃ|N =¥§VM5b55ª 5 VdpÅ6+G VG¶Æ²+5 gÇmÈVÉ5Ê
V£6¼²+b5¥ªbËbN~".°V¨Ì¥§U N°55b&ÍºªbG¤tVÎ¨5ÏM¶V°_Í¡ª£b5.'~"
NV©²+5#bb¶&»¬UCÐ¸5ªN »¶©£¶§bVV¥§¡VN1²#>5<¥§bV¶
bi_ª¥£6i5¤55i¬VV»¬U±V @¤ÑaN8Vªb Vp «ª¥£>iÍºª£5
5¥§ NVs5¤¿Ò¹5M©Ói5_¥NS¥§V¬¸¬55°.&²#§5_ª¥£6N¤<
5G ¨ N¹V= © V.U¥§5»¶¢ §5VV V°C &VªU 5¥bVlV
V»¬Us65 5¬V55ªV£¥K®%5b°'Ô5ª5U°%5b±UVªb±¾¿5Vb~"
N ¹²#ib¬¸.°5S²+5S &5¤< &5ª ¶5°'NS¶l¼²+sN N¤+ V
G
Õ
|
Ö
Ù
×
M
Ø
Å
×
O
Ú

×
Û
Ü
Û
Ý
E
Þ
@
ß
â
à
'
á
]
ã
"
ä
!
å
]
Ü
Ù
×
E
Þ

×
à
æ
Ú
!
å
@
Ü
ç
M
è
m
Û
ê
é
Å
×
!
å
r
ë
m
è
ê
é

×
G
à
N
Ü
ê
é
à
Ú
*
ì
#
Ö
í
<
á
í

è
í
V
è
í
î
!
î
!
ï
t
ð
ñ
M
ñ
Ä
ì

ò
å
e
Ú
å
m
ç
à
@
Ü
]
å
*
ì
C
ó
ô
]
õ
ö

ö
î
]
÷
ø
ì
í
ùú]û üMÖ|ýmà þ@@ÿå ûO!üÞeä+@àÿÜÞUÛ!
ÝN
èM Þeå
mÞeüM×ÚOüÞE×ÅéGÚåÜ@ùç1ú]ûÖ|ümà ý@Iå ÿOûÞeä+üà@ÜÿÞUÛ!Ý@ò
Û ëÙ×ÙÞE×ÅéGåëèméG×ÙàÜ@éêàìó6Ûëã]ä ]×Åå 'Ü]×Øà IÚE× Þ ì 'à !3Û
#"V$ì %ö&
&îñmø
þ +
ümû-ü Iÿ .$(,/10!2û ì müMü 4333-5+
ü]ûü I4ÿ .(,/10!2û 6
7 ' )(Nû * í
' )(5û *@,
8 ó6àGÜÞeàÝ Û
:9.åÚE×é%; àÚOàå4IéIß#×Ü¿ÞEß@à|èMÛméê×Åå!ëNè]éê×àGÜ@éGàÚì
<4=?>Z×@A"ëÅå!ÜNç+èÞAEààêÞìá|å4eØ åeçBÜ@×ÙØàIÚO×ÙÞìmóCå!ä,E×ÅçCà%D¹ô
&îmö <ï]ø müü # ' E
ú 0)* ' F@
û G
H]û G:4 ì Eú 0)* ' þ @
û GHm
û G
í
Ç
M 5
¾+V5 dV©¤tV~"bl5blV¤tV¨Ï¨M¶V~"&¾+VbVV5|¸ª
¤tV5¬¸i ªU ±&5¤º V©5± C°1¤tVs¾+VV§ 5£ ¯Ç
¥¥£>"5¥¥§5¢ &b¹ª¹5¤'²¡
iº5¤| V¡ªb5 º¤Ñ ¡¥ªb
i_Vª5°
©V¥§¥VNm²¡»¶a¬VN lsªb© © 5S¤tVSÏm¶5¹¤tV¥ 5| b&ªU =G
N
£_¶=5¬¸ & 5 ¥s©Ïm¶5¹²+5«&Vl» © NS &Vªb²+5
@¡~"b5²#V UÇ *5¤' ¹>Vª5¿¬VN S §Ï¨M¶5 È
¨5ºMNs²¡b
a½V N%¾+5VS¬V5²#V 5¶ & b>Vª5"¬V5²+5
iÇmÈVÈVÈiV:£6¼²+± ªb¥£6©ÃbÒ¹m¬V©¾+¬55.°15b¯Íºª£5

5bV°Î+ 5¥&Ï¨5V.Z¾+¬V5&5&_ªV¡¥ V» % SÇMÈ¹G
NZN1ªbU
65 ¥i°]²¡M51Ï5V²#V©%¥ V 'V¥§#¿NV|G
N%NZª>V
¥s ¼ C°¾+¬V5a²#V>Vª5º¬55 £_¶a5£>VªbÇVÇmb°ÙVV©¬V5SVG » ªb
Ns5¹6M°3£ªbº5" b½V N¾+VVN
~"¿5|V²¡b
¿>Vª5Ge¬V5#M5|bN%£>V¥+ÃZ²¿NZÇmÈ °
²¡ ²8ËV5
_V²#Vbª5»¼¶©5¤ £>5 >Vªb5#5 5 5¬VN <Î+ªbM°U£6M5ªb
ËV5
_V b5©²¡±5± V5»e¬V5¥ V»¼¶V° bV¯²+5§ £¶¯sÏVªb5¤
Íº_ N »¬V°²¡
s¬V5¤tVºË5V ªb¶ 5¥§
~">Vª5¬55 ²¿5¬V±5« NVVi V.aÒ¹5²#V¯>Vª5¬55 £¶
5 ¥¢@ »¶ ÇV°ÙVV¢¬55 °V¹5£>Vªb¹N£6VªU¹5¤<> 5V&65S5¤1 b&5
N|¬VN &M5G
£ªb°5"²¡s£>5¾+¬V5ba5bs~"£6¤tV¹¥i°UVG" ½ 5 5¾+5V5
ÓiVºNVª¥§"55+ ¹½V 5.¾+VVM¬V¹» ¿£>£NV¹5ª5
Vb§5§5ÆV¶¯¼¶¸ ±¤tV¥¢5"¥§¸ O5°¿¤tV& N¥5°"Î+5 N¤Ç 5ÊVÈ ¦Ks
5N
i¬V¶gb 6&55
gN=¦:¬VV ©5¤º N MN<¥§¸£5±VgVM5
V§ª» 1 ¬N5ªN " b½ 5 5>¾+VVº5#»<5+>G¤tV¥§§ N NZ~"_ª°¸²¡
²+¨©5"b¶5¿ bV¥N »¬V ¸ªbVN¤'¨¬N5ª¨5¤S6b½1 V5.¾+5V5°
"5>"¸¡m¬US ¹ N¶ ¸V¡N¬¸¹ &¥55¹ª
5s¬N5ªNV.
~"&5¼²+¤tªb5¥§
5²+m¶¸S N¨©½ 5 5%¾+VV5ª>5 5»¶£6µ3M²+.
®%°¡¥M¶£6£5i¤OM¬5VN¤ZV¹N¼¶V#~"Nº° £ªU 55¤%¬55 VªsM¬V
5G¼¶ ¹M5b@ ©²¡b b§>Vªb5¬55 &£ªbV §½V 5<¾+5V5&®VS 5¥b5°
¤'¿"5¶§ N"Ì¥§U NM5bNS¿&²¡²¡ m¬5²¡b¥§b§¥ V#s¤t²
N ° : bS²¡%£>UVG¹ §m¬V51Ì¥¸N ¬VN §5£bªb5 5¶l&Ub
5¤' ¥æ²¡b½1 V5¾+V55~"""_5¶²¡N¡5>ba ¹ 5"5¤
ÇmÈÉ5ÊU°'ÇMÈVÈVÈb°>5l5VVb ¼Vº ¸b]²»¤% b¨¨V 5'V£¥i°²# _m²²¡N

!
¹ NV«£>¼²# M¬V 55¬VN s5¼¶ MNN »¬V5K¢5U¸=5¤
²¡b¥ V¼¶©5¤6 ¨½ V56¾+VVN%~"+<b¶§5NVV5ª N êI¬VN +ªG¬V
ª¯ i ªbb¶KVN »¬V&Vb¦K¬55ga¥§U1£5gV¯N¯ Vg5¤ºÒS¥¢N
5 S êÇ 1 © ¹55¤' ½ 5 5¾+5V5
~"Vbl6V£ C¨5¤Z b©½ V5%¾+VV¹Va¬55 >]²#¨5¤1b¬¸ª5
» dN°¡ bµªl5plVªbV¥§5 @ ª5¥§M5ªN¤¬55 g>]²#
V£5£¼¶N¹¢¬55 ²¡£6©b¬VN
5'l ¥§©VªbV¥§5¤#5l V.S~"
& i£5¤t5¢5¥55¡5¤¨ s¬V5¯>m²+¢¥§M5ª5d i» N ªb O
¸ §=Ç É5È©5bi® 5.5iÓa5
m¬5Ç VÈb°¸¤tV"©¬U² ! I¤' bSb¡²+
£¶¯ 5V©>Vª5¬55 N°1 ªG&5£5£¼¶=N¶5Vª¬VN £M5_§a ¢¯¤OM¬5V©5¤
M5b@ 5Kb© >Vª5¬55 G¶UG ¥¬V¶g¬55 N&5± _ª5E°<£bªb§¥5

55°º5¤¹MN KbK¬55 5Â b¤tVa5 ¸ª5¨¬VN b¯6m²# ®3ªb b°"
65ªN&¬55 a¶¸¥ ¥ ¥§ © blM¬V5Va¬55 K>m²+5V¢ iV @ t5°¡5 »°
® 5%N=Óa5
b]¬5Ç VÈb°65=ÒS¥¢Na5b ¹N 5VbÇ º~"½V 5%¾+V55°3Va
5 b¿N.°»¬¸# bSV N¥V5» 51£_¶¢ N N~"¹
@ +V¬5S5
5¤< S V5Z¬V5¹ iV¬5«M5bN&£5KV«¥ V»¼¶i¬55 §l&
@ §~"_ª°%
¬V5»¬V5 5¤»º¥§b¨b]²rG
N V5 ¬V5S555»¤Z bVV 5
¬V5S ¥§²¡b ½1 V5¾+VV5UG
N¬N5G¶£>5 ¨ ¹5
5¸¸a5¤< ° ¬55 = 6 N ²¡Z«5 5M¬5M¬5 C_¹¬55 6m²#
5dNKªb§ lM¬5 NVa¬VN bK>]²#¢M5d£>a§ NÂªª 5¼¶gªN ¼)¤O5°
N+ _ª¢5¯£¶KÎ¿5 N¤ GÇ VÊVÈ ! 5:ªa N MN<¥§¸<5¤
5Vb¡²#b¬VVC°6²#MNa 5¥§b¥bM5CV£5£¼¶N5am¬55V
¬V5¡"b¬VN
5.ªb¡£>5 s>Vª5+¬VN 5s½ V5¾+VVS¶¸¥§
¦K#m²± @|²¡©V#¤tV¥§%N5N < N M5_N5¶¸'5¤ +M¬5NN£VM5
Vb+N b°b¿b5"¥ª
£N# &5Vª¨¤tV+¤t5¥§ ¹½V 5C¾+V55%¦:ÁG
m²* @²¡½ V5"¾+5V¢¥M¶K5M¬5£6±£N±N5bÌ¥§¸ @ °
V¬5ªbb£ªb V¢N¤'¬55 °» "5G¼¶¢"5b¬N5
NV£¶¢¶¸G ¥s<®ª°
+V 5¸¬V5¿²¡U C%¤t5¥¿>Vª5|¬55 "²¡_V¶²¡§"M¬V 5V¿¬55 1515
¬V¶V §5»¤ê ¨"¤tV+¬55 &6m²#°²+¹b]²n @"²¡¨ ¹5"£>i¥ª
¥§>V 5
¬N5N V¬V5¨6m²#1m¬VZ¿5¬5 N5° ¿¬55 >]²#N¤6»¬Uª5¸» b
²+5ª5¡N¶¢5¹ªbº§>Vªb5+¬55 ¹G¶UG ¥ N¤% © ¹
ô'éêÞEã@åëÙ@ë ¡Þ CÛ"ÚtÞIå
ÞeàÚì à ,eåÚ "
å+å!Ü@ç D¹å×ÙÜ]àì]å!ëëÙÛméå
ÞEà >ëÙàé¼ÞE
Û eåë¸ó6ÛëëÙà Cà%ØÛ!ÞeàÚ ¨ó6ÛÜ CeàÚeÚO×ÛÜNå!ëVçm×ÚO#Þ e×Åé¼Þí
!
"~ 56S¸5S¤tVm²¡ ¼= & M°% 5=²#§VS &5G 5«¥§5S5¤
§½V 5<¾+5V5©~"bK:U 5 ²+§ 5¥§b §¥§5SV:m¬55V&¬V5>]²#°
ªb+²¡N²+VªbS¬V5¡>m²+'m¬51£6¤UV 5N¬V5 ²+#5UN £¶S5VVN
G ¿V"¤%©6Vbª5#¬V5G¶UG ¥ 5s£6sª.#~"bÁ5.VsVbªb
¸¨Ói½ b¨Í Ò ~¡Ï½dÃ ¨Í%~ G
GÓaÃ º¾+~ S®±~¡Ï½Â½1Ô½#¾+~ SÍ Ô±¾ SÔÔ½#Ò¹½
iÓ VG15¤6">Vª5Z _ªN¤6¡½ V53¾+VV¿M¬V¡¤t¸ª§V© ">V£»¼¶N
²¡bº5¤Z b>Vª5"¬V5²¡ 5º²¡s V N.¬V55°Cª
l5Uª Vb
5¤ÇMÈÉ5Êb°ÇmÈVÈVÈb°#5Â5VVUÆ~"N§ b§Vª)5>ÆVªÆN¢£>a=ªbs£>MNªs ¶
5s C¢V 5¡G¶UG ¥ ¼Æ¤O5M°+l¾+5 ªU 55º¾+V¬V 5dVd¬55
5N »¬V¥ ¸¤t5 ba bM°bªbi©65ªN¬VN 5°1Ng
¥ 5+¯¤Om¬5V©5¤º ½V N¡¾+VVN:~"bsV¬V_V VN ²+Vb @
Vb²#VªK£6b N ¯£¶K¥§V65ª5ª N ²¡¯»&5:¤tV¥5
V ¢~"#²+5¿ 5ªV¿N ª5»¶©5¶& ¸ª¿»¤ VN¤. ¨b 5C5N #²+5
l´G¤OM¬V55·¤tV¥*V¨5¤'5V#
@ °b²¡©²#Vª_ª" M²NVª>VG"¤tV¥*V»¶5
N ¹V"VV£ªb¡²#Vªs.5£ ©²¡¹6Vbª5¿¬55 N
I¤l¥5¶: NV5§¤tV©¥§N bi½V N¡¾+VV¢ N© ª§¥M¶¯£>
V 5G¶i¢ Vªb V¥§5¤Z>Vª5¬55 ²+bl_m² b]²5¶ b¨5>C
¦KºMN¢5+5G²+# _ªG 5¢ »¶ O b+& V 53¨ @<<5<5b6
¤tVª¥§© 5£ Vªb l 5 !)Ïºm²+¬V°¿²+sMN)_¬5G VN bsN Vbg£>¼²#
65ªNZ¬V55 º5£5£¼¶ @¿5¼¶ +5N ¡²¡b<¨ V55V5|¦KºM5C°
¤tV% 5¥b5°5 5¥§<²¡N>Vª5|¬55 "5+²+5ª©£>¿§¤tV' ¡Ì¥¸N #5N
¨²¡ ¡½V N¾+V5 5>15¤3¿ ¥N°5VZ¬V ¨>_1N¤>¿ ¥N I¤3¿¬V5
¢²¡ 5 5¤ b ¥S²#©ª£G
5 5»¶VN lN¤5¤>Vª5¡¬V55°6²#
²+5ª§_m²d N< b£bªb V&5¤.¬VN +5V1 b¨ N + 5U¬5N_ 5V§Ì¥¸N ¼
5 b¿²#V° ½ 5 5¾+5V²#Vª£>¹£5s¤OM¬V5ºN¤|Íºª£MN¡ b¡M55
Ïm²¥V+ bS½ V5 ¾+5V¤OM¬5V¿V¨5¤ 5 i~"N¤'S½V 5.¾+VV
5sVN¬V&¥5. æ 5<V±5£65ªb©5¶« bim²³ 6
5N V©5¤6¬V5+ ¹N <~"bG ªb¶§5¤6 NN V©& º>V» 5¸¨ Nª
¹£5¯5: bMs5¤"sM@ Ge¬V5ª¬55°%²¡b
K55b65K= b55¥§& Nª
èMàà1å!ëÅÚOÛ
Ý Û Ý ,ã OÞeß]à å #Cã]ä¿àGÜÞeÚC×ÜÝ»å ØÛ .Û!ÝbÞEß@à1Ú mÚOÞEàGäí
"!#$&%('*),+-
¤tV©5¥5&l ªG¶ O5°<¤tV 5¥§5° ¹5¿5bÂ¸ª5GÇ 5 ! N êI¬55 ª¬5i
a¥5 N a¤tVV¬5g5G¼¶ Ù&M¬V 55G ¬V5²¡N©¤t N VKN¤ºN ²¡
¶§»¬V51~"½1 V56¾+VVº ª¿V »¶©¥§VºV¥§M@ K´MNGI¬55 ·
ªG¬VN¦:=5a G Â_m²¡gNVbÆ£>¼²#nM¬V 5Vl>Vªb5§¬V5=5
V N'¬55 N~"©V¥§MNVs¨N Vª¨M5 dNS°C© N dM¬V
6¡_ª¥£>5¤|N dNº°V NC¬V5
¨S²+%_m²¡.°'V@ ¬5b ¢¥5l¥M¶a£>©V¶¸¥5S¤OM¬V55¤#5ê
ª55¼¶5~"&5²+M¶ VSª
:5G 5lV¶¸¥5S¨5
lN¥¢N_¶
5¤< &5SN¼¶ Ùªb65 «5¤t²À ¹5¹>V£5° £_¶=N _¶
N¤tº °²¡¡bMN#m²¡ª>V+5V#5#¥¢5¶& <5<65£¡ b£¶
MN²¡5£S£ªbº5¡ §¶N¤t¹G O¾+ 5 @ ©Ç 5V¸°U¤tV"!

5V&5¤> 15&51¥§ bUN¤CN 5©5G¶¸¥¢5b !%~"ºV>V V¬55
§b 5²+5¬V5 ¶=5V £ªU b 5 ©G
N²¡
¬V55¤tV5¼¶5°C£ªb55¨5_ª¥£>5¤MN¨ ¶i²¡. ¼a bMN
5¤1VN¬5¥5°C V¶¸¥5S5¤Ñ « VNe¦pa b&½1 V5¾+VV5°6ª

V¶¸¥5b¿b5"5¶§ 55>£6M5ªS SN¸M@ 5¿"¹¾+VG » ªbVN
£¶=55:G
N5]¬5¥ ©5S²¡» KVN »¬V¥5 ¬VG °»¹Vªb«£6& §MN
@©G £ªbV:5¤¡¬V5N5© N &VªgMN V» 5¤tV=5G¶¸¥¢5b¤O]
¬VVV5¤ZN ºs b 5V. I¤ê°3¤tVº 5¥§N°6¥5¶iUVªU G
N
¬V5&]¬5G²¡¥V¶i¤tV bÌ¥¸NM°.= b¢Ì¥¸N MNN &¥m¶a²+l
65ªN+¬V5¹£ªbº6¥¢M¶b5"²¡ b½V N'¾+VVN
I¤ ²+¸V&N< ¹NVV V& b£ªb V§5¤ >Vª5¬V5¨²¿N¿5£¥¢N¿¤tV¿Ò¹55
¾+V ² <53°C bVl¥§VG>VªVªG
N5°6²¡b§ÒSV²#V ²¡» m¬V¹ÊV
5¤1 ¬55 ¹M5GS sÎ+ª Ù Óa5¶N¤#Ì¥¸N ¬55 ¹ º
² <Vil
²¿N K b¹¬VN I¤¿¶«Vª:M¬V£>K 5G¤t¯5N G
N5°1ÒSV§5ª:M¬V
M5»¶²+5 ¨½1 V56¾+VVN ¢ b¨5#5.°UÎ+ª ´G²+5·©5V¡¸ªb¥£6+5¤C¬V5
~' 5+Î#ªbº¾¿5¤tVS²+G VV»¶¤tV"Ò¹V
¾+M5¶V°¶¸¥N S55
+
&V&£>¶V55bb5
5 M5V
¼VZ¹¸b]²Â¤3 1SV£¥ §5 5E°V²+º§¹¥N ¿¡N êI¬VN <ªb¬VN
~"S¥§ bU5V5¶&²#S²¡>¿5 V5¤|¥¸6¬5V6i£¶Ò¹¥55 Sb GÇ °
²¡S S¤tª. 5"M5£>S¤tVª.
~"UªbV¨5¤Z¼²#N º®%M°3ªG V5 Vbªb º²+V N
,
N M5<¤tVM5G =¥¸< @&N V£bG¬N5£
5 5 G ©5¤¨l
@ l
5 ¬V55º~"N¨°3 b¤tVMN ¢¥§¸ ºªb¨Vª£6¨¥N ¹¤tV¡ >
Ì¥§U N¿5N #¬VN º N 5¬V¢#5¤
55%¦:5V#5G ¥N
5¤|m²8¬N55£Vb¡5Sm¬Vº¥§5
£¥§Va¤tV¥5¶V°+VªV£5£b»¼¶ ¥¸V¥§¤tV¥ ¯55¥ 5¥>V_M5
VV5¤%Ì¥§U N¬55 G
N ¶V5 !° I°Vs&º5¤|V£¬N5£bSVV° I°
GÇ
²¡ 61¬V V15¤ 55¥§ ZN1¥ªG1£6"¥N &¤tV¥ ¡N b°_5! 35b" # >5
b>V¿ ¥§Z¦:¹¤tªb b¡5ª¥§S N¡£>5sV¿ ¥§¡5S5¥5»¶b£ªb
²¡a¥§M5 5ba¬N55ºN¨5G ¥Ni¤tV¥ b@
b¡~"¨¥§¿Nº ¬V5
N b¥§»¬V%5+N¡5¥5»¶¨£bªb 5Vª¹ b< 6 ©VbVN5¥§M5Á
½ _ªNV«ÇV
~"©¬5NN£$ 1²+§ª«¤tVM5G©5%¬55 §5©¤tV¥ ¾¿5¥b£6 êÇ
ªb¶V%~"¶ª#M5
©G
N Z¬UN V¤tV¥ ¬UVªM¬5 NV¿NV5Ub N¸¬55 ¿
"5¼²#V°bM@ V%¤tVZ_55&¬U!¼5bV¥ VbV¥+
@ °
¨55£5_m²¡i Sm²+¿
5¥£>"N¤'S N Ù"VN ª5°_ SVbV¥¨Vm²"
N¹ N N°>5s£>5b"N¤Z N ¾+VbVV5N V£5a5 ¨Ì 5 º¾
N5 O¾¿5¥b£6ZÇ U°U¤t5¿ ¹5¥Sb V
Sb+²#"M¬V¿+¤tVMN ¥§Ube°]²#"M5©V|²¡NZ²#Vª©5>&5%V 5
VbVS
5VN®VS 5¥§5°²+§Vªb«V¹_¶¸>5 b M51N 5=G²¡Vªb
K @
m¬55V¬VN ¨¬N5¤tV¥³ 5ª5C Vªb 1Î#¶ b bSG²¡5+¬N5¶§²+S5
¥¢NVªb¡ ¹MNGI¬55 ª¬55
~"5£5£¼¶=¥§¸<5¤" b_¶¸>5 b M5<¬V556VG V%° '&) (+* ¥§bg£¶K
55VVVªb¿5£5£¼¶§¥§Ub &) (+* , &) (-* .0/ &)(-* &) (+
* Ê
!
²¡ /
&)(+* ©_m²¡aVG
5ºªi§¥§¸.G
N²¡¹55²¡bV
¼Vª<M55°¸²+SN¨ G ¢¢¬N5ª@ b5 ªN6 Vª°b²#²¡3
U5 & (+*
¸ª5Z ©555¬N5ªb¤tV¨© N N©Ïm²#¬5°|£¶=5VN¶s
¸V b©55
²¡° /#
&)(-* °U²#SM5¨²¡@¿ ¬V5SG £ªbV§²+Vªb£>5¨5+ bNVN6M¬5 NV¬V5
¬N5+~"¡²¡.s ª5m²8ªb §MNªbN¹V£5£¼¶ N¨5¬VaG
N²¡ £>²#V
£¶ Ì¥¸N ¿¤tV¡©V»¬ViG
N²¡b¹¬55 N
Total vote share
0.50
0.52
95% chance
50% chance
0.48
5% chance
1950
1960
1970
1980
year
1990
2000
®%5ªÇ !
#"%$&
#'()
+*-,/.0*&1&,/. 2'435*-,678 9 &:
;/<= >
=0?== : 8)
& 2
' = = @A
BDC53%EGF C5353H&I
K¦ ºM5 ¢G ¥¢N _ª5 » #N¤ M°¸ªb
¢²¡N¿m¬55V¬55 N+5º 5G¶
¤tVÌ¥¸N M¬5 5 V
5N¤"²¡a½ 5 5+¾+VVN~"
ª» 5& g«®%5ªÇV ¨¹²#5:§¤tV¥â©ÁVª5°'¤< M¬V 5V&¬VN §5
M5 N °C Ì¥§U NM¬V&5£>Vªb¬V:¸¨5¤1²¡¢©V N%5V5 I¤1
M¬V5V¬V55²+]¬5 ¸Ç °3Ì¥§U NSMNN ¹²+5ªa5¥§V¡ª¶²¡C¿~"
V»¶a V²¡
=¥§ £>© 6N¹N%¨ bÇ VÊVÈ V. I¤#V» V¨²#§N
¶²+KÇ VÊ5Èb°>Ì¥¸N ¡¥ V »¶ 5b¬N5 5Vi£¶i½V 5%¾+V5£bªb
JK Ý 6à .å!ÜÞ.ÞEÛ"ß@å Øà'Þeß]à1å Øà eå Cà'ØÛ!Þeà%#à Lã@å!ëVÞeÛ¿ÚEÛä¿àZØ
å!ëã]à-ì N M ìmÞeß]àGÜ¨Þeß]×Ú'éêÛÜNÚtÞIå!ÜÞéGå!Ü 5à1éGå!ëÅéêã@ëå!ÞEàç PO
ß]àEà8en×Ú ÞEß]àÜMã]ä N à
[
[
[
QAU R#ST V N0M WYZ [ X R#U
ST a U;b;c ` Ud Z [ X c ` U
\ %]_^ `
\
[
Û!ÝbÚOÞeå!ÞEàÚå!Ü@ç c ` U ×ÚCÞeß]àØÛÞEà6ÞeãeÜ]ÛãmÞ×ÜSÚtÞIå
Þeàgf6×ÙÜ
É
àå ¼í
4ih
5 b²¡¡1¥#N »¬V¶¤ON|®ª°¸5#V51V¡ b¡²¡#5¤> b>Vª5Z¬VN ºU
£¶s²¡bVlM¬V 5V UÇ 5¤Z¼²#N¼N¼¶s¬V55°6ªb º¤tV¥ ©½ 5 5%¾+VV
5>Vª5¿¬V5S²¡C5V5
Average vote share
0.50
0.52
95% chance
50% chance
0.48
5% chance
1950
1960
1970
1980
year
1990
2000
®%5ª¡ 0 ! ( 92$&= 9> : #' #"%$ #'
) *-,/.g*&1&,/.
2' 35*-, 8 9 &: ; < = >
=0?== : ) &@2
' = = A
B C53%EGF >C5353H
"~ º°Vb]²#¬5°b>5 NbV£¥²¡» ¡55»¶¸%§&®%VªÇV ¼¥§» ¶5°
²+5ºV» VbSV§ªbVªb<£6M5ªbm¬55V¡¬V5 ªb1 º¥b¡M¬V 5V5V<
N 1Ïm²#¬5°»¤C5²¡bºª5ªb¿ C_51£6¼²+ N °N# b¨5N°¸#¥¢M¶
¥¢Nl5¥&ÁV 5¯5N »¬V5°²#5i5:N5¶¸VG ªa¢N V5
M¬V5V§£¶l²+V N &¬V555V ¹5 ª51>VªN V.©~"ª
5>M5"s®%Vªb¹U
¦KV¥§¢b 6£>¼²#±¼²#aÁ5ªaÓiV5 5£¶5°|5»¶=VK½V 5
¾+VV&¥§V¥§²¡N£N¯55¹ bÌ¥§¸ @ °|6N¶ªiaÇ 55s~"N
°¸SÌ¥§¸ @ ºMNN s5V<>Vª5#¬55 5¿ Vª55 ¨V¢
5¡5¤
²¡bS 5.Z~"¿²¿5"5ªs£6M5ªS ¹Ì¥¸N <²+S²¡b&¸Vªb bG
N
²¡«_ª5¥55°C ¶l b¶=5=5 S5¤©´G²+5:¬55 ·À~"§ 65ªb:m¬V¹ ¥
£6M5ªb© §Í¡ªb£M5¨M¬V§
N «²¡:UVªU «
@ ©~"Sb=5Sª=ª«
¬¸VªÁVª5SM5¶V°C£6M5ª ªVªbS²+55¥ªb
«m²+S b§UVªblVª N
S²+5s¬V5
È
"~ ¸ªb°U²#¨ºV¥§º¬¸º @#§Ç 5<5baÇ N5° b¨½V 5>¾+5V¡Vªb§M¬V
&ª¡V 5¶¢ © ¹>Vª5+¬55 N ¼sªb¨ V°U "M5sV»¶5»¶¢5>
¤' >Vª5"¬V5"¬5¶sV5°65»¡²¿5º b©5V5& V. ¼s §Ç VÈ55°35¥¥§
@ V

55=5£65ªb¹Í¡ª£b5p´U
_·V©½V 5Z¾+VVN°.£ªbMN¶²¡@S²¿5S5>
²¿N NSÍ¡ªb£M5¡²#²¡Ã5 5¨£¶sV ¢¥5¶¥5¹¬V5¨5
+Ì¥§U N'~""½V 5b¾+V5#N5º b¨²¡°55%'5|¤tV¥r #V¥
5¤' ¹V5¡®|VªSÇ5i©m²¡b&&Ç VÈVN
¡½1Ô½#¾+~ SÍ Ô±¾ SÔÔ½#Ò¹½ ¨Ì S~ ¨ÒÄÃ "¦½1Í
¼s¡VC°3²# 5¹m²rV5» 55>£6M¬UV¡bªa£¶ ½ 5 5'¾+VV¹ 6
sV£5£»¼¶¯«V¬5)¬55 &»¬Vi)5) V.°+«@ ª5¡¥5ªs:¬N5ª@ s5
V N.¶¸¥s
~"¿V£5£»¼¶¹5¤>¨¬V5¿£>b¬V+Z¥>V 5'¶ p»% ¶V5ªbµª
V b©V 5|VªbV¥§5°5b Sbµªb©ª5|=¥§¸ N¶ 5b=5 »¶V°
£6M5ªbs©Vª±bµªsM5¥§5V¯®V© 5¥b5°<V¥§V© 6M5¥§5Vg 6V
l£>V65 V51 V£5£»¼¶:N¤¨a¬55 £>¬55°<¥ª:£¶¯ >
_ª¥£>¹5¤<¬V5
5VK>¹ª»¹5¤¿5¥§55l 6N°Z5» 5ªVl §5§N¶a NV
V¥§M@ 51bS£>5 ¡5¥5_bM5¥§5V5 ON ¤ê1Î# 5¥§"5ÌSM¬¸°CÇ VÉ
~"ºV£5£¼¶ @<V¿¬V51»¬V¡5& 515¬N5<§¥§b
ªb »¼¶N¤6¬55 °V bº6Vb¬5#5¤.N§ 5 5G¶¸ ¥À S¬VN 1¤tb°U¡ §M5¶&5¤
M5¥§5V CVG °55¥NV¿N¤'¬55 ©>]²# OÍº5¿5 ¸VaÇ VÊVÈb°b®3 V
5s®%V¢Ç É °Î+5¥¡NaÌSM¬¸SÇ É U°
lÇ
Ã|5 b<¥§ ¥§MNª5¤bb»¬Vb|. E5£bVªb .Î¿5 N¤ êÇ VÊ 6b °@²¡b

1 5£5£¼¶ N+5»¬Uª5¬55 <¬V¨ª# b5ª¥§b VN¿5¬55 "5
= &¬V5>b »¶)5Â@¢5V¥s°+²¡» ÆbV£N£ &b =¤t5§5
d5¤¼²#
M5b@ ¦K¹5 ¤t"&º5ª¥§bVs5" b4 2'& &:%' = Z¦pSM5¶¢5
ªM55ª¥§b V.°Z»¸m¬¸a£6
¥5« ¬N5ª@ ¢V¥§6 ba V5#ª
5©¥55# ¿bV£¥ V M5¶S 5 5£5%~"b" 5bV¥¬55 ¥§Ubb°N5¤>VªN°_VV
m¬V¥ÁN V.°65=¤ON¹¥§M@ 5"¤tV¨¬VN b6m²#¹=Å6CVSm¬5&£6
¥§»¶K¥§MNs¯>V» M5 NªN°55£>±ª £_¶gÒ¹¥5.°
S°b5iÎ+VM5 GÇ VÈ ¿5baÒS¥¢N.° ¹N NsÎ¿N¤tª¥§ eNV !
!
K¦ ¡ 6<5§5» N¬V¡NV5
¢¡£5V§¡¥§555¶¸5¤C6_Ã N
Vb|¦:¨ªb¨ª#¤t5¥À¬5¶ 5¢Ç VÊ55< º£5<5¤#5¤ ¥ªbNVZ
M5ªN &M¬V 55§bV£N£¼¶ @5¬Vl¬V5¹S¬5©ªS &>Vª5¨¬VN 5°
V N>VVN°_5N5» N¬Vº¶¸G ¥*§²¡
¢M5
¾+5VVN6<1²+VG 5
V NC¬V55
»ÇV
!<= =0?== : : 2 &: +Î ¤t5V _ªVl»SV£5£¶i£>SVbbSm² &½V 5Z¾+VV¥VS 6
¬V5©>m²+ ¼V" © ¿²#b &Vº©5ªSN¤|b 6 5 5.G¶¸ ¥
~"¡¥GV N¶¸¥Ä% 92$&= ¡5( )
$&= °ªb²¡
& bº5N
»¬¸ º5VG+_ª¥£6+5¤.¬55 #²¡ ¨N +5b.°¸Å>bÃ 53¶¸¥s°
+5 = = V! = = 8 A == ª5°U¢²¡
¬55 ¡5VVª>©¬55
NVb°1±²¡
²¡b§ M5
Æ5V¯5 ¢=Á Â_ª¥£>§5¤´GV 5¿¬55 ·
t²¡» b¹ V56¬55 ¡"V+ 5bV¥»¶NVs S¬V_5¤|5 5" ¨²¡
NV °¸5 s¹M5b@ ²¡s¹¥5¡ V5C¬VN º"b5sS²¡b
¼n¯>Vªb5§¬V5«G¶¸ ¥ ²¡ v¬V5°lV£5£»¼¶ N¶5Vª¬55 =¢»¬Vl
Ð% N° §V£5£»¼¶a N
²¡b g5i£bV¥§N% £ªU 5
²¡¢55¥§ ¯ÇS5 ®V+5V tV+¬V¥§¸N |°U b+5£>²#C5b ¥N
ªSV¥¢5> £ªU 55 °G
5b5ª"5£5£¼¶ t5 ¤ê°U¦K¸Ub¸5¤t5°
Ç É
m²V+ = -°6a²¡
i ¥§¥£65¤<5V²¡! ¥¥£>M¬V
V¹5V¥_¹N¹ ¶l²¡Z5 @ »¶=M5ªbª°Z5= b:&²¡¹5¤+©¬V5«
NVi²¡%V5Z5¤+" ¬VN ¢~" ª5N ¹²+M¶«5¤+b£ b¢½V 5
¾+VVN
¿ S55¥ ¬VN b©¥¸E°U»¿¿¥5+ V5V. ¿¡VS ¥N°ªb65
¢VV5» 5iN $# ¬VN ~"l5Vs¥¨© 5VªbV¥§5°C5
¤Z¶5Vª=5s @V5» 5.°¶VVªb¨¬V5¬V²¡ 5 ¥¢NbV£N£¼¶ % °
²¡
K5 ¥¢N»'¶ & s¥§S b¢V£5£»¼¶l5¤"£>a¬5ªb¢>Vªb5¹¬V5
¶¸¥s1Ïm²#¬V°b ¬55 +b5+§¨5 5NV©m¬5 ¬V56m²#ÐU _ª°U
: bV£N£¼¶5¤¢¬V¬V55°Cm¬55Vbm¬V5.¬55 °C5 ¥¢N»¶ °
¤O5V"5¤ & = N¡ªb"¹6Vbª5¿¬55 ¹G¶UG ¥i
Çm
(

! "$#%'& "( ) *+,-,("!./()"(0%1 $2342%5
6 798:('! ";#'& "< '=>@?BA2/C$DFEHG >JI%K D/LM
$(./N/ 6 7 8:'! "$#&' "( '=>OI%K D/LM
P HRQ9ST UV
WX!Y[Z!UB\
]) ^[,_&/./1 /^[ "#& "( _ *,(") ^[(,_&'/./1 /^`./<"<01 D3D 5
6 798:('! ";#'& "< '=>@? 2 C$DFE:a >JI%K ML/b
D
!^! ^c,-&'/./1 /^d&'./^d^egf-#&' "( /5
6 798:g "g#&' "( '=:>hI
b
$(./N/ 6 7 8:'! "$#&' "( '=>jikH7lI%K ML/b =+m a:k 7lI=>OI%K D I A
nHRQo ST UV
X!pqZ!'UB\
]) ^[,_&/./1 /^[ "#& "( _ *,(") ^[(,_&'/./1 /^`./<"<01 r 3 r ./^#,%)&/./1 ( /^d ";#'& "< /5
6 798:g "$#& "( =H> r tb I2 >hI%K M/u r
D`s
!^! ^c,-&'/./1 /^d "$#& "( v$ ,w0</f./f 1 yx5
M
6 798:('! ";#'& "< '=>@? br C$DFE i >JI%K r b t
$(./N/ 6 7 8:'! "$#&' "( '=>jzkH7lI%K M/u r =+m|{k:7lI%K r b t =;>hI%K DM 2
} H~n\UBU[
cXgpqZ!'UF\'$
:
|_ "_ "n#&' "( c *g(,'<" ^`,%&/./1
(,'gyvHc&/./1 /^"g./<)"(01 r 3 r 5
6 798:g "g#&' "( '=:> r
Dqs
$(./N/ 6 7 8:'! "$#&' "( '=>OI%K D/b I
( /^./(c"(01 r 3 r ./^#,
D
M
r >JI%K I
D/b
M
M
®%5ª h /2= / )$ ' = = 8 43 B%I < & g
B
-.
.@%$ +' (/2= -)
/2
B) _%= + &: ' %Ii : 2
B) _%= ' P #' $ 2' j/. ;(92$&= A> $&= %I
15 §£6Á¢¬5dªb¢¥¢N"V5» 5Æ®35«¥ 5¥§N°¿5: V
²¡ ©¬55 ¡ªb" C¡ V5.ª¡5"b®|Vª 1º"S65ªN+¬V5
¶¸¥s°¸5¶¬V5 Ù1
5bº5¤>£6¹¬5º VÉ m²Âª>V" N ¬V5<5
©5V5"5 bÊ¬55 "6¶V%~"&m²)N»¶¹%¶5Vª%¬55 ¿S£6¿b»¬V
ÇVÇ
I¤C¶5Vª¢Nº© ¡5» V.°V»1ZÁ#5¶&N1 º5#¬V5<& bº5 V£>»MÐ
S5>b²¡» =5£5£¼¶:ÇV¸ °'¶5Vª5V ¬VN 5§b»¬V&l b§
VC°6²¡
:¸ªS»¤ ©¥5Ê¢¬55 5¬¸b V NêUÐ. 5SbV£N£¼¶
~"¢¬VN ba>]²#5¶KN¤¿ ¬55 «¢5» V=¹ c
UÇV¦pN»¤

¶VVªs5S5¡ ¹V5» 5 ~"¶VVªb¡¬55 S²¡>£6¹¬5S¤ ¹¥5¬55 ¨NSb
N b°C²¡
=¸ª¹¤1 ª §N ¬V5 t5 b 5l¶VVª S5© @
Ç©& 5
V>V» ¿¹ ¬55 <© bº5 V.~"º5£5£¼¶5¤> 5>b n »Ç 5Êb
¾+V¥§5© S ¡>Vª5Z¬VN ¡¶¸¥s°¸¶5Vª§M¬Vº¥V¿¬V5¹>m²+<»¤6¶5Vª5¡¡NV
5lS»¤¶VVª«5Vªb5~"&M¬V 5V©¬55 >]²#¹ bÇ c Ç NÊ À °>²¡
=
m²#¿ 5iªb"¹6Vbª5¿¬55 ¹G¶UG ¥ tÃ|5 rN¤®%Vª
®%N¶5°3V5lVbb¥§V5£65 N5 5bV¥§ ¹®V¨ N¥5°6ª>V ©5
¬V5°²¡ 5¥"_V°²¡5"b¬¸& S b¡ ¸ª5»I &V5» 5°NM5

5¤²¡
s+ »¤|b¬¸ 5 V°b5bs©¤tV.°s¹G ªb ªb5<~"a56
¬V5¨5¹¶¸¥¥§M5¶¼ ªN .°bNs§V»¬Vs¬55 º"¬V¹»¤|¹5 ¬55 º
V<U55» V©5" Â Z5b6<²¡» &V£5£»¼¶ p5& §¡ <¼²+¸M5
NVb"¥ªM¬V©V>V ¤t p55.°6²¡» lV£5£¼¶5¤ p5Vª
< VC|~"+V£5£¼¶ NZ5V¿b5>.°V5¸ªb| b+b¬¸bª5V¬VN %'»¬VN°
M > °3²¡
iºm²#¡ 5s 5£5£¼¶¢ª>Vª5"¬V5G¶¸ ¥
t¤tV15V |°¸N<V£5£»¼¶<5b ¥N ¶&c È Z®35< 5¥b5°_»¤ nÊ 5ÊbÇV° b
¹V£5£b»¼¶¢N¤&»¬V¹¬V5¹Ç V 5Ê²¡» S !¼ª ª5¤%NVb°bV¥§5s
5£>Vªb¹Ç UÇM²¡s¥ V¼¶¢ª5
~"&5£>]¬5© 5¥§bN Nª ©5V¥ ¬VN b¥¸E°6»¨ ¶5VªS£>Á
£6a5 V°²¡ i5VºV5» 5"Vb N¶£>¢£> I¤%¶VVª=55 V5¤
l°Z¢bV£N£¼¶l N¶5Vª5» V=¯5 ¥¢N»¶=V>VG 55Z °
5s bV£N£¼¶Nº¶VVª¨5Vº¤Z _ª¢ ¥§ Vs²¡¨
5 ¥¢@ »¶¢bV>VV56 lÐ¹¸ªN¤|¼²#bV£N£ < _ªºMN¡²¡
l°N+5#¤tV % n¥§55Vº5#NVºNVb1¥§¬5+¤t5V¥§ _
ª£¸¼V5» 5
¼G¶UG ¥ ª
5#6b½V NC¾+5V5°¨5» V15¨"5bM55¤. ¥¡N
N)£>=ª£ «VN @ 5.°15± s¥N ¥¢@ 5¿N5¶¸ ªG¢ Âª5VG
@+¬VN ¿¢5V< N "M¬V¥§Vº¬V56m²# eÓi55bsU5¶iÇ VÊVU°bÎ¿N @¤1Ç VÊVÈb°
ÍN£m²¡» 5=Ói555KÇ VÈVÊ !¡~"V¥§55aº5¬N5ia5N°6b]²#¬5° V¬5
Ç]
V£bG¬VÂ5ª§¤tV¥ 5bV¥ ¬VN b:¥§Ub taÓa5VVÇ 5È °<5ÆÒ¹¥5.°
¹N N°"5ÆÎ¿N¤tª¥§5V ! ¼Æ¤O5M°+¬55 ) bi¬V¶)¥5GG
N§ bÆ :M¬VV
¬V5&>m²+°ViM¬V5V OÒ¹¥5.° ¹°b5iÎ+V5b=Ç VÈ
ÅU!<0 &:+ &:9 /2
A == ¨¹5¹£>K5«£¶l¥¢N_¶M5
t5 °|Î+
gÇ É U°'Ói5V5Ç ÉVÉU°'Ós¿Ç É5ÈU°5
¾+5¥£>5&5ÍºN
Ç 5ÈbÇ °V¨N" V M5Nb 5 5V£¥Z²¡» §¹¥¸
@ºN¬55 5ºb>bVµb tV° ¸ªb¬N5 ¶5° NºVª ¨5 >V£55V!
¥ ¿5¤b¤t" _ª5¶ Z~"bS¥§#¥§U6 b5#©5ª¥§¨¬VN ¡N>¸
#£ªb#²¡ §V£5£»¼¶ N¤C¬VN b¤tV1Vº5¤.ºM5bN°Um¶&Ì¥¸NM°V²¡» ¢V¥§
ª 5¼¶«5£>Vªb t¤tV 5¥§N° :5ª:M¬VsV¥¢5%G £ªbVl²¡K¥§M5:b 5s5
55¬UN VU Ïº]²#¬5° #¥§Ub3# ¸¥§© £65ª5>V 5
¶¸¥§ ¼5G ªN° 55¥ a¥ª¨5 M5¶¢£65m²+i ¬5N¶V°65a¥¸
¨¬N5¶¸ =bs5¨5=¥§U¬55 ©VªU 5¥S¶5®Vm²¡Ò¹¥5.° S°
5iÎ+VM5 GÇ 5È °Vb¥§V¡ G¶ §Vb ª5
M5 ¥§¸E°35º¶bi¤t5Å>
Ã N.Vb¿²¡ sªG
5_¼¶N" ¹@ 55e°UVV5e°U5s N ¹¬V
¦K¿V 615bN
&¥§Uº²¡b b<¨V#¬VN "|¬VN1¾+V1
¼²+@¼MNN <V¹²¡¥ V¼¶¹ªb15¶5¬V ª 5.'Ô p£61 #56VG V5
¬V5b 6 N O5 »°'§ 6£>¼²#¯ Ì¥§U N Ù¹N¯Í¡ªb£M5 S¬V5§5
N°
¬¸¯£¶: _ª¥£6©5¤"¬V5° I¤¡¶5Vªg¬V55° @²¡#N Ç ÂV Ç Â §Ð<
¬VN¤|"¬VN ¹"¡&»
¤ vÇ %°.Ç V¤ Ç %°bVSÇ»¤ nb
m²vª>V N"N¡ bbV>VV5C¬VN ¹ 6 5 5º5i5b ¥N SV _ª5ª
5£5£¼¶£bªb V.° !Z~"1£bªb V©M5&V¥"¤tV¥À bV M5¥§¸N¤6¬55
ONÙ»° ©55¥â¬V5¥§Ub ºVS¥§5%¥§Ub¨£5:5: Vlª» ¹V¤tVMN
Ò¹¥5.° Sb°C5blÎ+VM5 êÇ VÈ º5Vª N°6¤tV¥¸b&¬55 5°6N@
N ªb©V£5£» "¤tV¥ ¤tVM5G °.©bS b©b¤tV¥¢@ 5iM¬N55£
¬55 ¡£6¤tVSV¸ª#®V+V6¬V55¶¸°»"¥m¶5©£6S G b&
ª¨¥¸#£5V>ª£N V<5¤'5ª5>Vb¿5#ÒS¥¢N5 ¹ êÇ ¼N_¶
M55°35C N¡"a"V¥SbV£N£¼¶G £ªbV.
®355¶¹MNVN£¶¼ V.°m²##55 ¥¢NZ 1£bªb V N¤U1V>Vê
V5¸¬V5 C_5b£_¶©V _ª5ª¤tªVC ¼§N<MN5° 6 ¢V£5£b»¼¶N¤C!
Ç
!
¬5#<¥§»¶§ i¬5NªN¢N#¨>V_ nb ®35< 5¥b5°¸¼²#NIM5bN
V²¡ ¢Çmb°ÙVV¬55 °»¤3V¿5N¿'¤tVM5GZ SV r5¤+¬VN ¿²¡© 5N
V¹5¤ ° bK§¬55 6 5S¤tV5NÈ ²¡Ks
N5KV5¤¿Ê ~"
5£5£¼¶ N#5»¬Uª5¸¬V51»¬VºZ O 5È 5ÙVÊ ¸ÇmVVV ÙV U°Uª© ¹G
N5C¤tV¥ª¤t5¿ ¹V¥¢NC £ªU 5.
~" N¥§5N¶l¤t5¥§VV¥§M@ « 5°|ª
±5¥ª» 5N§V °
ªb C°5¥ªb 5V¨G¶¸ ¥ ONÙb°b½ V5 ¾+5V 65¿ ¹Î+5@
¥
5G¶©¶¸¥*©²¡
bVV5 ¹²¡¹¥¢ 5¼¶5¤.¬¸ª5¶¼ N ¼¢¥§V
V¥§M@ g V°+§©¥§»¶¯ 5G¶):6»¤Ñ¶ «V£5£b»¼¶¯¥§Ub¿¤tVi
5bV5¤Z6V£Vªb V¥§°C5a²#ViVªU¨ bV£5£»¼¶5¤ b _ª V¥£@ 5
¬5 ©ªb²¡b
±i¬55 ¬55l®V 5¥§5°Z: b½ V5+¾+VVN°|¶V5ª¬VN
¬V"»¤3¶VVª1G
N"% tV%²¡©5"¬V5"5¤6 %5&»¤ê° 2' =2
$&
@ &:
#'5°bSM5bN"51S¥ V»¼¶£5§V¶V ¡5G
N½ ¥¢@ b¨ "bV£N£¼¶
5¤C<¬5¿ _ª+¥§Ub¤tV b V_<£bªb V&5¤Cº¬55 VªbV¥§<5º
@
~"¤tV5°3sVb" §G ¥NSV£5£#5¤ZV¹Vº5bi¬5°6»¡¡!
5G¶g =¢ª)l5£5£¼¶:¥§U+¤tV¬55 sVªbV¥§±¦:²¿N_&:V=£>¶5V) 5¸
V¥ ¬V5¥§Ub5b«ª«¥5©5bb VSN¤#¬55 &VªbV¥§&ÒS¥5.° S°
5=Î+5MN GÇ 5È ¡ÁG
NI£_¶I
@ © 5¤tVM5G b¥¸E°>²¡» lV£5£b» ºVê
>V««s ¬5ª 5¼¶g¼²#K¥§V §£6¤tVi V.)Ï5°#²+sªa
¥"NV5
#²#¹
5N bN ª5VsVªbV¥§5s6 ªb£a»M°>V£
5N »¬V5ªb V¥
¦K¹N£6 #%N¡SV£G¬VaVªb V¥§ t bÌ¥¸N ¨5N Ù¡5¹5¤' b¹¼²#NI5¼¶
¬V5 ¢¾+VV55 '§V¬5§V&¶V5+N¢V£U
5¢¹5£5£¼¶ £ªU 5
5¤º¶U>5MN¿VKVªb V¥§ ¿£_¶g5lV¥¢5¶¼b£ªb :55¥ V&N
NVNe°3VV5e°> N N° 5:¾+V5V5 ¼ ¬5°C²¡= 55l¬¸N V5¤#
NºM5
i¬VE#¦:5£> %5¡ ¹ ªbVªUi5
+NaV"5¡Á Â
M5V5£¡b¡ª 5¼¶§5£>Vªb< V&Vªb V¥§11¬V£¶&ªbG
5¼¶§5£65ªb >°_N
%
®35#N_¶&5¬V V&¶VMN°_²+ª¡ º¥ª» »¬5N@ +bV¥5 £ªU 5©5¤Cº¬5 V 5¤
¬V5SVªbV¥§+©V¥§ªb¨ bSV£5£¼¶&5¤|V¬55 S£>©¬VS¢ bSV.Z®35
K
ò2 Ý1Þeß]àÜMö ã]ä Nà Û!ò:Ý1 Ø ÛÞEà eÚ ö l ×Ú¨í Ûmç]çì'ÞEß]×ÅÚ4å ,EÛ m×ä¿å!ÞEàÚº2ò V & b ì%å!Ü@ç× Ý «×Ú¨àGØàGÜ_ì'× ÞS4å ,EÛ m×ä¿å!ÞEàÚ
]
V W d b
]
V d b
Ç
]
6Vbª5º¬V5¶¸G ¥s°.²#©¥§b bV£5£b»¼¶¤tVN_¶i¬V5Ð.¤tV V5»e¬V5
5gVVV5»IG GI¬VN §¶¸¥§°²+b ¥§ V£5£b»¼¶l²¡:M5
± N 5
G +5 V¥§ªbNVN6M¬5 NVV£5£» °V²#Vb£¶ª5ªb +²¡» ¢G
N
V ³~":5 ª5SbV£N£¼¶)M5ªN V5lV«ªg b:¥ªb »¬N5N sV¥¢5
G £ªbV5¡£6i£¶iÒS¥¢5C° Sb°5iÎ+VM5 êÇ VÈ !
Sªb<ª#N651®%5ª %~"¥§VG1 _b¹¤tN ªbº5¤6¡ÁVªº N1ºm¬55V
5£5£¼¶5¤¬5"
5bV¿b 5¥N M5¶¤tV¥Ä¶V5#¶V5¿£ªU¿1¬¸G ª5¶©ªb 6
£¶
5VZ #V 5_G¶UG ¥iZ~"b'¥¢M¶V¥§#5Zºª dV¬5#55_ª
¤tV¥*¸V »ÇV°U5¨¥§V< >¿ ¨M¬V5VV£5£¼¶©N¤ ¬V¿ £6¥ª
V
¤tV¿ b>Vªb5êI¬VN G¶UG ¥i
3*10^-7
Popular vote
Electoral vote (winner-take-all by state)
Winner-take-all by Congressional district
•
2*10^-7
•
•
•
•
••
•
•
10^-7
•
•
•
1960
•
••
••
•
•
•
0
Avg probability that your vote is decisive
•
•
1970
1980
1990
2000
Year
®%5ª
i
#' : 2
) _%= ' . )
& 2
' == C5351. =$ = #'+$ 2' ; 92$&= 2' = >
=i! %I i #'
$ = -A
B & $ = = $ > %I i : 2
B) _%= A = % %$ 0 $G #' % ; = >
=i
A$ = %I
"~ &ªS=®%Vª s5V¶5 ¥¢@ 5°C5 ªG¹£6M5ªb&5¤1 &6Á©¥¸

V"¥5N°£ªbºN©£>5ªN¤'S¥§»#5ª¥U 5 N"SN ¡5¤¬VN b²+Vªb
5£>" 6 §£¶©
5V b"V 5¸¶¸G ¥s1®V% 5¥b5°G
Nª
¢N1¾¿5»¤tVbº5
~| 5Z @Z²+"NV¿ "5VV¨ V©¥§V|M¬V¡5©V% ªVªbZª16Vbª5
¬V5S¶¸¥ ¢²¡
iN3¬V5¡Vªb_ _ªN¶5~"_ª°Vªb¿ª» ¿V¥5b 6¡V 5
Ç
¶¸¥§5¹5 bN ª5%V£bG¬V:¬VN 5b«bsb5¹ ¶a5b¹Vª¤ON ª5
_ªG 5º5£65ªb"²¡N¡²#Vªs5b6i»¤'¹V N.¶¸¥ ²#
5bV.
¾ ¾¿Ô¨
¦KsM¬Vi_dG
N5¿¥§ bU5V5¶: :¬N5ªN bs¼²#K¥§V5¥¥§V±V¥§5
55¨ ½ V51¾+VV5©¦p:ª£ K s56¥bM5%55»¶¸°» N¤#
V¥§5 +¥"²# ªÁ.
¦p ¢V5 >5 5CN 5¢£5+¢S½ 5 5.¾+VVº²+Áb©¶¸¥N
6M°¡N¢MN5Æª 5p¦Ki)ÁÆN»¢>V£b¤tV§l½V 5
¾+VV¹G¶UG ¥ ¢5 ¢b 6VªbV¥§¡ 5i>Vª5"¬V55°>m²+¬VSV¶²¡ba
NV²¡b¨¬V5¿¬V¶VS¤tV¿S¼²+& 5i5N ¨"²#b]²8_m²v¤tV¥* ¹ V
5¤.5VU°V²¡b§V<5¿ @#V¡V Cbº V5Uª55&²¡U5
& CºVªbV¥§
Sªb+ª» +5£65ªb#¬55 >m²+¿5 ¨½1 V5.¾+5V5º6N"£»+¥§Vªê
b~"b©S¢¤O5¶sV»ÁMN_¨ V 5% @ ªªbVVG @S ©½V N1¾+VV
²¿N¨ªb¤ON" G
5i¬55 ¨Ïm²#¬V°C5¥§¡5£55a NV¥ ¬VN b¢¥§Ue°
²¡
:Vb¶G¼¶¸ :¥¸N¤¿ 5§¦pK²#§¸V5¯N¹ b¥M5%¬55 s£6!
M¬¸V°b²+§5¡Ás¥ª
i 6¹£6¼²+a¬55 >m²+¡ªº½1 V5'¾+VVS5
65ªN¡¬55 ¶¸G ¥§Î+ªb°>ªb ¨5¥§V¹ _ N »¬V£6M5ªbi¥5_§Vª5N¶¸
²+5ª¥§ N¡» ¿¬V55"M5bN¿²#Vªsm¬5£>m¬5i 6 »¶ªbº©6V¸
ªN¬VN ©¶¸G ¥s~"ª65ª¥U 5.°.£ªbS 5 ©55¥ ¬VN b¥¸
@¡ª¿¹» ¸ªb5
¤ºVª5°#Vª¥M51ÁV©=N© ¶¯5§bV¥N »¬V _ªV°#ª
)5
²¡
« V51¶¸¥ 5ª«£6§ª.Ïºm²+¬V°ZVª¹ÁbV¹5K£>&ªK s¬N5ªN ©
65¬55¥§+ N¡ª»¶ ¹5¥N »¬V¹5Vª¥§
Íº½<®%½<Íº½ ¾¿½<
¨
.°ËbÏ GÇ ©ÍºNVN|
5§5b=ªbVªbM / A G$&
== =i °> VÊ bVÉ5ÈU
Î¿5 N¤ê°UËb_Í¹ GÇ VÊ '¦KV §¬55 U <²+V ¥N¥N M5b55»¶¸
$ : ÇmÊ
.° Ç]É
Î¿5 N¤ê°Ëb¿Í¹ GÇ VÊ5È a¥¢5C° Ç]«¬VN ¯K¥N¥N M5º55¶¸N¤l½V 5
¾+VVN == ° U
Î+
3° GÇ É 5SV ¹V£5£»¼¶N¤Z© VC $%= 4? 9 °É bÉ U
Î+ N¥°_6_Ëb»°_5&ÌSM¬¸°¸Ó:Ì êÇ É '~" V Zªb¿©b 5MN¥NVO/ A = =i °CÇVÇ >Ç
Î+ N¥°V6@Ëb»°VNÌSM¬¸°VÓ:@Ì êÇ É !|¾+V¥¥§'V´ ¾¿5¥§55Vª+N¸M@ 5Sª'
V 5CV55° ·©£_¶i¾+55 5e°¾¨>6°3Ô ¬V _ª5°6~S>Ëb°35b U5>°>Ã'>¾¨ / A = =i °CÇ >Ç 5Êb
¾+5¥£>5.°3Ò©°>5baÍ¡5 b
.°>Ó: GÇ VÈUÇ b5 ViV£5£¼¶¢5¤Z5¬5
¬V55 9$ =g/<
i
A
.° Ç V 3ÇmÊU
¾+ °Ò&<¦ °¨5 ¹N N°SËb GÇ ! ~"=M5>VG 5¥¬VVªb Vp5d£5pÅ>
V5V5 V] / A 9$&
= = =i °ÈbÇ] ¸È b
¾+ °<Ò© ¦ °1N ¹N N°1Ëb e5VV <=%
': A
A = 2' i <= =7?
- "%$ @ 59
9 = $ º² <V <¾¿5¥£V¹º¬5¼¶sÃ
® 5e°bÌ>6°5aÓa5
m¬V°CÓ: GÇ VÈ ! i $&
2 &: !
® V.°5Ëb»°V5®%5b°NÓ: GÇ É '~"+5 5b N¤5'¬VN b 'V¹ bV +N5¶¸
/ = =i ° V U
Ò¹¥5.° °U5 @ 5°UËb eNVbÇ !ZÏm²p¥ªb
¢¸+¹¬55 Vª 15 6m²#°UNVb°
5 ¹ V5¾+V551¾¿5»
U¸5US¦:V_bÃ|5> Ç5Ç]UÇV
Ò¹¥5.° ° ¹N N°CËb »°65Î+N¤tª¥§e°>Ëb e5VV ¿¦p¶s 55a¬VN b¢>]²#b V
²+V3+¾¿N
¸U5¸S¦:V_§Ã%5> b ÇVÇ
Ò¹¥5.° »°¡5 Sb°¡Ò© êÇ âªbÁÂ¥¸¡¤t5¢¬N5ªN«V NºG¶¸ ¥5
b ©5] / A 9$&
= = =i .° UÇ
Ò¹¥5.° »° Sb°ZÒ©»°5KÎ+V5b.°%¦ %Ëb GÇ 5È ½¥N V£5£¼¶lN¤"¬5
N1m¬5b¬V#¸ª |²¡Z¶V5ª¬V5ºb»¬V G$&
= ; / A =
! °.Ç b
Óa5C° °U5¶5°Ô6 êÇ VÊV Z~"¹b56¬55 ©5 5¤SV NC5V5ZÍ ¨Ì
¥¥S §U_ª£3°_C° i
A 2' = #' 52
& i = !°
² <V ¦p¶5°.Ç VÊ b
Óa5VV°UÏ êÇ ÉVÉ !1ÃV£N£¼¶§5¤S 5. $w%= +? 9 °.Ç 3Ç ÉU
Ç]É
!
Óa5VV°UÏ êÇ VÈ !~"Î¿5 N¤|¤O55¶5 / A 9$ =g= =i ° UÇ 5Êb
Óie°#6 êÇ É5È !Â¾+» ¬V5«>]²#§ªbi½1 V5º¾+VV a=U
5s¥¸
£5i5iG
N¹¬55 &N o 9$ =gj52= #' ° É5Ê Vb
ÍN£m²¡» 5°CÒ©° N«Óa5V5.° >.½" GÇ VÈVÊ !~"©>]²#SN¤ G
NSl6Cb N
V] / A = =i °Ê UÈVÉU
Íº5°.¦ Ï»°'5 ¸V3°%Ã''¾¨ GÇ 5ÊVÈ ³5¶l5¤< b§5ªªbS5¤#¬55 / A = =i ° _¸
¸ §.°.Ã'CÌ GÇ É5È !¨Ã5£5£¼¶¥§¸º¤tVº>]²#S ¼ i
A 2' = =
i °bC3Ã| ¸V3 ² <V»¬V»¼¶Ã° _ÉVÉ UÇmb
¦K¸¸¸5¤t5°Ó: GÇ É ! ) _%= 48 ; 52= - ² <V <ÓiMÒ¹m²rÏe
ÇmÈ

Download Report

Empirically evaluating the electoral college. In

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz