Showing or Telling: Narrators in the Drama of Tennessee Williams Author(s): Nancy Anne Cluck Source: American Literature, Vol. 51, No. 1 (Mar., 1979), pp. 84-93 Published by: Duke University Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2924921 . Accessed: 15/12/2013 13:11 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. . Duke University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to American Literature. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 137.140.1.131 on Sun, 15 Dec 2013 13:11:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions in theDrama of Showingor Telling:Narrators TennesseeWilliams NANCY ANNE CLUCK Universityof Texas at Dallas Tl RADITIONALLY, dramahas been describedas the mostdirectand . objectiveof the literarygenres.Drama requiresneitherthe speakerof the lyricpoem nor the narratorof prosefiction.It is a uniquelyunmediatedvisionwhichrelieson actionratherthandeThis emphasison showingratherthan tellingoftenbescription. in othergenres.Manynovelistsand critics comestheenvyofwriters of novelsaspireto let a storytell itselfthroughthe actionsof its In fact,PercyLubbockimpliesthata novelis successful characters. to theextentthatit tells. to theextentthatit showsand unsuccessful Lubbocknotes: In hisdiscussionof The Ambassadors, Justas thewriterof a playembodieshis subjectin visibleactionand like Strether's, dealingwitha situation audiblespeech,so thenovelist, of overthesurface thatflickers it bymeansof themovement represents mustbearhis part a character his mind.. . . In dramaof thetheatre of thoughts man,harbouring tobe a desperate unaided;ifhe is required crime, he cannotlookto theauthortoappearat thesideofthestageand his through itforhimself inform theaudience ofthefact;hemustexpress the so arranges wordsand deeds,his looksand tones.The playwright will make the right matterthatthesewill be enough,the spectator inference.' the Lubbockwriteshereof the"dramaof thetheatre," Significantly, however, acteddrama.The unacteddrama may be quite different, obforit movestowardthegenreof fiction.Lubbockperspicuously nothingbutthebaredialogue, servesthat"ifhe (the novelist)offers hisplay amplifying he is writinga kindofplay;justas thedramatist, in a read book,has and puttingit forthto be with'stage-directions' reallywrittena kind of novel."2The dramatistmay,then,tell his of a as thenarrator readersomethingsthroughhis stagedirections, novelrelatesinformation. 1 Percy Lubbock, The Craft of Fiction (London, 2 The Craftof Fiction, p. I92I; rpt. New York, III. This content downloaded from 137.140.1.131 on Sun, 15 Dec 2013 13:11:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions I957), p. I57. Narrators in theDrama of TennesseeWilliams 85 though,to shortdescripare mostoftenconfined, Stagedirections shouldmoveor whatexpression tionsofwhereand how a character he shouldassume.Rarelydo theyadvancetheactionof theplot or inaccessibleinsightsinto characteror theme. providedramatically whichcannotbe subsumedintotheactionof the Anystagedirection to the and antithetical playitselfis generallyconsideredsuperfluous mayspeakto his readersat lengthin a prefaceas art.The dramatist to Shaw did,butrarelydoes he includematerialdirectedexclusively thereaderin thebodyof the play.Yet, TennesseeWilliamsseems critic,and philosopherin manyof his stage to be poet,storyteller, of his acteddrama. fromtheintegrity withoutdetracting directions affirms his concernwith the acted play, while he He vigorously the writtenformin his "Afterword"to Camino Real: deprecates Thereareplaysmeantforreading.I havereadthem.I have readthe fromus who are peras distinguished worksof 'thinking playwrights' them readthemearlierand appreciated mitted onlytofeel,andprobably liketheincantation as muchas thosewhoinvoketheirnamesnowadays a theatre blazeoflivetheatre, ofAristophanes' Buttheincontinent frogs. hasneverbeenand neverwillbe extinmeantforseeingandforfeeling, new or old,bearingvesselsthat guishedbya bucketbrigadeof critics, punchbowltoHavilandteacup.Andinmydissident rangefromcut-glass a playin a bookis onlytheshadowofa playandnotevena clear opinion, shadowofit.3 for the acted play should not be Williams'spreference Certainly, however,Williamsoften notwithstanding, ignored.This statement revealshimselfas poet and even as novelist,not onlyin his poems in theplays. but,perhapsmostsuccessfully, and hisfiction, It is throughTom Wingfieldof The GlassMenageriethatwe can of thedrama.The autobiographical beginto educethepoet-novelist betweenTom Wingfieldand TennesseeWilliamshas long similarity Tom, thenarrator/ butevenwithouttheseaffinities, beenrecognized, can furnishinsightsinto how Williams character/poet/playwright, works.Tom is theacknowledgednarratorof thisplay in whichhe is alsoa majorcharacter. of is an undisguisedconvention Williamsstatesthat"thenarrator is contheplay.He takeswhateverlicensewithdramaticconvention 3 Tennessee Williams, "Afterword" to Camino Real in The Theatre of Tennessee Williams (I953; rpt. New York, I970), II, 423. This content downloaded from 137.140.1.131 on Sun, 15 Dec 2013 13:11:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 86 American Literature venientto his purpose."4Tom does presenttheplay,but he is also who verymuchinvolvedin it.He is notsimplyan objectiveobserver servesas a pointof view; he is a major characterand even playand in theopening The settingof theplayis in hismemory, wright. "Yet,I have tricksin my speech,he castshimselfas artist-magician: I havethingsup mysleeve.But I am theoppositeof a stage pockets, magician.He givesyou illusionthathas theappearanceof truth,I giveyou truthin thepleasantdisguiseof illusion"(I, i, p. 22). As he createstheplaytoexorcisehissisterfromhismemory, playwright, and to freehimselffrom to trytoexplainhisown actionsto himself, entersthepresenttimeof theEpilogue, his guilt.He exitsmemory, and exclaims:"Oh Laura,Laura,I triedto leaveyoubehindme,but I I am morefaithfulthanI intendedto be! I reachfora cigarette, I runintothemoviesor a bar,I buya drink,I speak crossthestreet, thatcan blow yourcandlesout! to the neareststranger-anything For nowadaystheworldis lit by lightning!Blow out yourcandles, Laura-and so goodbye. . ." (II, vii,p. "I5). NeitherTom the can escape the character withinthe play nor Tom the playwright realityof Laura in thepresent. Tom is evenidentified as stagemanagerat one pointin theplay. recountshow thingsused to be when As Amandamelodramatically the stage the at plantationin Mississippi, callers had gentlemen she directions read: "Tom motionsfor music and a spot of lighton Amanda,her eyeslift,her faceglows,her voice becomesrichand elegiac"(I, i, p. 27). Tom not onlyarrangessettingand theme;he also directsthetechnicalaspectsof theplay at thispoint. in this and centralcharacter Tom is,then,theundisguised narrator who mayalso be associated play.Yet thereis also a disguisednarrator forWilliams,and the withTom in so faras Tom is a poet,a stand-in in thestage who appearsprimarily creatorof theplay.This narrator verymuchlike a dramatizednarratorin prose directions, functions who also tellsthestory.Through fiction;he is one of thecharacters directs,and writeshis play,we can begin Tom, who acts,narrates, to understand how Williamsworks.He doesnotmerelylettheplay himselfor anotheriminterjects tellitself;like Tom he frequently which plied narratorinto the play to give the readerinformation 4Tennessee Williams, The Glass Menagerie (I949; furtherreferencesto thisplay will be from this source. rpt. New York, This content downloaded from 137.140.1.131 on Sun, 15 Dec 2013 13:11:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions I970), p. 22. All Narratorsin the Drama of Tennessee Williams 87 play, to theaudienceof theperformed could notbe communicated to commenton the themes,and, occasionally,to imbue the stage quality. witha metaphoric directions information simplyprovidesstraightforward Oftenthestory-teller in are Act I, iii that we told For example, muchas thenovelistdoes. Amandawearsan old robe,"muchtoo largeforherslightfigure,a relicof thefaithlessMr. Wingfield"(p. 40). The audiencein the theatrecould not possiblyknow thatthe robe was once her husis givenin the stagedirections band's.A similarbit of information in Sceneiv. Preparingto go outside,Laura pullson a coat whichis the sleevestoo shortfor made-over, "one of Amanda'sinaccurately know the Laura" (p. 47). Althoughtheaudiencewill undoubtedly onlythereaderreceivesthedefiniteinforcoatis old and ill-fitting, mationthatit has belongedto Amanda.Stilllater,as Laura prepares forhergentlemancaller,we are told thatherdressis "coloredand designedby memory"(II, vi, p. 69). How can thisbe conceivedas a directionto actorsor evento costumedesigners?Whose memory had designedit and evencoloredit? Sincethisis a memoryplay,we mustassumethatTom's memoryfurnishesthe shape and color. providedonlyforthe reader-not thisis information Nevertheless, audience. forthetheatre The impliednarrator on actionand themefromhis also comments AfterthequarrelbetweenAmandaand maskin thestagedirections. by Amanda's Tom, he tellsus thatit was "probablyprecipitated of Tom's creativelabor(I, iii,p. 40). Even thenarrator interruption seemsnotto be entirely sure,buthe can commenton probablecause. He becomesmorephilosophicin I, iv,whenhe describesthemanner to thechurch in whichTom shakeshis noisemaker in counterpoint to thesustained bell"as iftoexpressthetinyspasmofmanin contrast oftheAlmighty"(p. 44). powerand dignity For exambecomespoetin someofhisnarration. The philosopher ple,he tellsus in I, vi, that"It is aboutfiveon a Fridayeveningof latespring"whichcomes"scattering poemsin thesky"(II, vi,p. 69). Thereis no waythat,throughsetor actions,theaudiencecouldknow poems.At thebeginningof thissame scene,the thisspringscatters prettiis givenof Laura: "A fragile,unearthly followingdescription glass nesshas come out in Laura: she is like a piece of translucent radiance,notactual,notlasting" touchedbylight,givenmomentary This content downloaded from 137.140.1.131 on Sun, 15 Dec 2013 13:11:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 88 American Literature (p. 69). Once again the reader,not the theatreaudience,has the advantageof thepoeticmetaphor. The samebeautyof poeticexpression occurslaterwhenLaura sits at thetablewithhergentlemancaller.As thecurtainsbillow,we are toldthat"thereis a sorrowfulmurmurfromthe deep blue dusk" (II, vi, p. 83). In II, vii, the stagedirectionsacquire a patternof imageryfromthe action.Because Tom has chosennot to pay the lightbill,thehouseis dark,and all of thissectionis playedto the lightof candleswhichJimhas carriedin and setbesideLaura. The actuallightof the play is transformed into poeticmetaphorwhen JimleanstowardLaura "witha warmthand charmwhichlightsher inwardlywithaltarcandles"(II, vii,97). Afterhe revealshisengagement,"theholycandleson thealtarofLaura'sfacehavebeensnuffed out" (II, vii,p. 97). This patternofimagery, createdbythenarrator/ of thelyricpoem. The poetof theplay,invokesthe characteristics figurative languagemayinspirethe actorsto portraythe sensitivity ofLaura,butonlythereadercan perceivetheenclosedlyricstructure direction. ofthewritten In hisfirstsuccessful play,then,Williamscreatesbothundisguised and disguisednarrators, both of whom may be Tom Wingfield/ TennesseeWilliams.The personaofthestagedirection suppliesaddiand and action contributes tionalinformation, theme, commentson poetrythroughpatternsof imagery.While the narrativetechnique The Glass Meis particularly appropriateto the autobiographical on a Hot in Cat Tin similar Roof. nagerie,it serves functions The narrator of thislaterplaytakeshis readerintohis confidence withtheuse of thepronoun"we." This intimacyis exhibitednear thebeginningof Act II afterBig Daddy asksReverendTooker,"Y' thinksomebody'saboutt'kickoffaroundhere?"The narratorthen speaksdirectlyfromthe stage directionsto the readerin Act II: "How he wouldanswerthequestionwe'll neverknow,as he'sspared theembarassment by the voice of Gooper'swife,Mae, risinghigh and clearas sheappearswith'Doc' Baugh,thefamilydoctor,through thehalldoor."5 Althoughthis disguisednarratorsometimesallies himselfwith thereaderthroughthepronoun"we," at othertimes,he seemsto be 5 Tennessee Williams, Cat on a Hot Tin Roof (New York, I955), referencesto this work will be fromthis source. p. 49. All further This content downloaded from 137.140.1.131 on Sun, 15 Dec 2013 13:11:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Narratorsin the Drama of Tennessee Williams 89 omniscient, havingunlimitedinformation about the past livesand familiesof variouscharacters. Soon afterBig Mama's firstappearance,thereaderis toldthat"her'family'was maybea littlesuperior to Big Daddy'sbutnotmuch" (I, p. 33). In Act II we are told that "Big Daddy is famousfor his jokes at Big Mama's expense,and nobodylaughslouder than Big Mama herself,thoughsometimes they're pretty crueland Big Mama has to pickup or fusswithsomethingto coverthe hurtthat the loud laugh doesn'tquite cover" (p. 50). AfterBig Mama has playedher own sortof joke on the preacher, thenarrator elaborates, "Big Mama is notorious throughout theDeltaforthissortofineleganthorseplay, Margaretlookson with indulgenthumor,sippingDubonnet'on the rocks'and watching Brick,butMae and Gooperexchangesignsofhumorless anxietyover theseantics,thesortof behaviorwhichMae thinksmayaccountfor theirfailureto quite get in withthesmartest youngmarriedsetin Memphis,despiteall. One of theNegroes,Lacy or Sookey,peeksin, cackling.Theyarewaitingfora signto bringin thecake and champagne.But Big Daddy'snotamused.He doesn'tunderstand why,in spiteof theinfinitereliefhe's receivedfromthe doctor'sreport,he stillhas thesesameold foxteethin his guts.'This spasticthingsure is something,' he saysto himself,but aloud he roarat Big Mama" (II, p. 5I). Someofthisdirection cuestheactors:Maggiecan sip her Dubonnet,Mae can look askanceat Gooper,and the Negroescan lookin. But thereadermustbe told thatBig Mama is notoriousfor herhorseplay;he mustbe toldMae's thoughts by someonewho has accessto them;and onlywiththehelpofan omniscient can narrator he knowwhat Big Daddy is thinking, muchless sayingto himself. The narratorknows moreabout Brickthan Brickhimselfdoes. During the long conversation betweenBrick and Big Daddy in Act II, theomniscient narratorcomments:"Bricklooksback at his fatheragain.He has alreadydecided,withoutknowinghe has made thisdecision,thathe is going to tell his fatherthathe is dyingof cancer.Onlythiscould eventhescorebetweenthem:one inadmissiblethingin return foranother"(II, p. go). Althoughthetheatre audiencecan guessat themaritalrelationship of Big Mama and Big Daddy, thereaderof theplay receivesmore specificinformation. In Act III, when Big Mama fearsshe is about to learnbad newsfromthedoctor,she asks,"Is there?Something? SomethingthatI? Don't-know ?" The stagedirections follow,"In This content downloaded from 137.140.1.131 on Sun, 15 Dec 2013 13:11:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions go American Literature thesefewwords,thisstartled, verysoft,question,Big Mama reviews thehistory of herforty-five yearswithBig Daddy,hergreat,almost true-hearted embarrassingly and simple-minded devotionto Big Daddy,who musthavehad something Brickhas,who madehimself lovedso muchby the'simpleexpedient'of notlovingenoughto disturbhis charmingdetachment, also once coupled,like Brick'swith virilebeauty"(III, p. 103). The actionof theplayshowsBig Mama's loveforBig Daddy,butthiscommenttellsmoreabouthow constant it has alwaysbeen,and explicitly pointsout the similarity between Big Daddy and Brick. This narrator is similarto theone in The GlassMenageriein his abilityto extractfromthe languageof the actedplay a patternof imagery forthestagedirections. Animalimageryabounds;Margaret is Maggie the Cat, the childrenare no-neckmonsters, dogs, and monkeys.Butthestagedirections containan evenmoreconspicuous pattern. At one pointin Act I Brickbreaksaway fromMaggie and raisesa chair"likea liontamer facinga big cat" (I, p. 32). This can, of course,be acted as can Big Mama's "charginglike a rhino"in ActII or eventheactionsofthelittlegirlwho "hopsand shriekslike a monkeygone mad" (II, p. 75). The interesting point,though,is themannerbywhichthesedirections foractingare appropriated by thepoet/narrator forhis similesforMama's dress,forit has "large irregularpatterns, like the markingsof some massiveanimal" (II, p. 5o), and forthedescription of a conversation in Act III when"the stagesoundslike a big bird-cage"(p. ioo). The animalpatterncontinuesin thedescription of thepreacher,whosesmileis "sincereas a bird-call blownon a hunter'swhistle,thelivingembodiment ofthe pious,conventional lie" (II, p. 86). Finally,duringthediscussionbetweenBrickand Big Daddy, the narrator movesfromactingdirections to commentary on thetheme of theplayto dramacriticin his long intrusion in Act II: Brick'sdetachment is at lastbrokenthrough. His heartis accelerated; his forehead sweat-beaded; his breathbecomesmorerapidand his voice hoarse.The thingthey're discussing, timidly and painfully on thesideof BigDaddy,fiercely, violently on Brick'sside,is theinadmissible thingthat Skipperdiedto disavowbetween them.The factthatifit existedit had to be disavowed to 'keepface'in theworldtheylivedin,maybe at the heartofthe'mendacity' thatBrickdrinkstokillhisdisgust with.It may be at therootofhiscollapse. Or maybeitis onlya singlemanifestation of This content downloaded from 137.140.1.131 on Sun, 15 Dec 2013 13:11:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Narratorsin the Drama of Tennessee Willi'ams 9I The birdI hope to catchin thenetof this it,noteventhemostimportant. play is not the solutionof one man's psychologicalproblem.I'm trying to catchthetruequalityof experiencein a groupof people,thatcloudy, of livehumanbeingsin charged-interplay flickering, evanescent-fiercely shouldbe leftin the of a commoncrisis.Some mystery thethundercloud is always revelation of characterin a play,just as a greatdeal of mystery leftin therevelationof characterin life,even in one's own characterto of his dutyto observeand This does not absolvetheplaywright himself. can: but it shouldsteerhim probeas clearlyand deeplyas he legitimately whichmake a play just a awayfrom'pat' conclusions,faciledefinitions play,nota snareforthetruthofhumanexperience.(p. 85) Some of this is directionto the actor; Brick's distresscan be acted; his breathcan come fast,and his voice can actually become hoarse. In the next few sentences,though,the narratortells the reader what is being discussed. He no longer seems omniscientas he speculates that Brick's problem may be his particularmendacity.As if he has not quite made his point yet,the narratorspeaks in the first-person "I," who must be the playwrightsince he tellsus his intentionin the play. Then, he explains his dramatic theory: the playwrightmust always leave some mysteryin his characterswhile attemptingto capturehuman experience.This long stage directionis the epitome of tellingas opposed to showing in Tennessee Williams's dramas. Although the narratorseems much less obvious in the otherplays, he can be discernedat variouspoints.In StreetcarNamed Desire, the reader derives additional informationabout Stanley and his earlier life.Aftersupplyinga physicaldescriptionin Act I, the narratortells us that "since earliestmanhood the centerof his life has been pleasure with women, the giving and taking of it, not with weak indulgence, dependently,but with the power and pride of a richly featheredmale bird among hens. Branching out from this complete and satisfyingcenterare all the auxiliarychannels of rough humor, his love of good drink and food and games, his car, his radio, everythingthatis his, thatbears his emblem of the gaudy seed-bearer.He sizes women up at a glance, with sexual classifications,crude images flashinginto his mind and determiningthe way he smiles at them."6 This omniscientnarrator,who knows about the past lives of the characters,also seems able to enter theirheads at any moment. For example, in Camino Real, as Kilroy imagines the body of the gypsy 6 Tennessee Williams, A StreetcarNamed Desire (New York, I947), p. 29. This content downloaded from 137.140.1.131 on Sun, 15 Dec 2013 13:11:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 92 American Literature tellsus that"a canarywarblesinsidehis underherveil,thenarrator fromhis and excitement head."7We maybe able to see hisconfusion actionson stage,butwe couldhardlyknowaboutthecanarywithout beingtold. In The Rose Tattoo,thenarrator once again takesthereaderinto by usingthefamiliar"we." Afterhe is kickedby the hisconfidence salesman,Alvaro screamsto Serafinathathe mustgo inside her byhimas shehas managedto ignore house.She is palpablyaffected comment: malessincethedeathofherhusband.The stagedirections "We mustunderstandher profoundunconsciousresponseto the suddencontactwithdistressas acuteas her own."8 as a Then,at theopeningof III, iii thepoeticsettingis described, view theexterior explainstothereader,"We seefirst humannarrator of the small framebuildingagainsta nightskywhichis like the starry blue robeof Our Lady." The similewhichassociatesthe sky withtheVirgincannotbe acted:it can onlybe told. The poeticqualitiesof thenarratorare evidentagain in thePrologue to Camino Real. As he setsthe stage,the narratortellsthe readerthatthere"are flickersof a whiteradianceas thoughdaybreakwere a whitebird caughtin a net and strugglingto rise" (p. 431). Laterin thePrologue,he uses thesetto commenton one of thethemesof theplay: "Upwardsis a smallbalconyand behind it a large window exposinga wall on which is hung a phoenix paintedon silk: thisshouldbe softlylightednow and thenin the areso mucha partofitsmeaning"(p. 431). play,sinceresurrections The distinction betweendrama and prose fictionis artistically cloudedin theplaysof TennesseeWilliams.He mayprofessnot to care fortheprinteddrama,but the narrativevoice,bothdisguised and enrichesthereader's speaksfromhisdirections, and undisguised, of his plays.The dramatizednarratorof The Glass Meexperience and nagerierevealshimselfto be the slightlydisguisedplaywright stagemanageras well as poet and actor.While the narratorseems notto be so obviousin Cat On a Hot Tin Roof,a moreobjectively in stagedirections appearsfrequently play,thestory-teller presented to providemoreinformation to takethereaderintohis confidence, 7Tennessee Williams,CaminoReal in The Theatreof TennesseeWilliams(I953; rpt. New York,I970), II, 547. Furtherreferences to thisplay will be fromthissource. 8 TennesseeWilliams,The Rose Tattoo in The Theatreof TennesseeWilliams(I950; rpt.New York, I970), II, 350. All further references to thisplay will be fromthissource. This content downloaded from 137.140.1.131 on Sun, 15 Dec 2013 13:11:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions in theDrama of TennesseeWilli.ams Narrators 93 to aboutthepast lives and the currentthoughtsof his characters, createa patternof imagery,to commenton thethemesof theplay, Williamsdoesnot ofplaywrighting. and finally, topresenthistheory confine hisown commentsto hisprefacesas Shaw tendedto do, but does in prosefiction.He tellsin tellsthestorymuchas thenarrator theprintedplay whiletheactedplay shows.Each versionoffersits ownrichesfortheaudienceor thereader,forWilliamsbothshows andtells. This content downloaded from 137.140.1.131 on Sun, 15 Dec 2013 13:11:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz