Analogy in Problem Solving - CMU School of Computer Science

"!#%$"& ('*)
#%!,+.-/$"&(!0$"& 1,'21,3
4 57698/:<;>=@?BAC8<DE;F6
G HKJMLNPO2L"QSR2TUVOWQXJMLKYZ[RW\]RMZ[RQ^T_JT@`XH"J9abO2cVJMdCefQXghYEJ]ijO2Q]k9JT_gmlnghL"JoghLqpMr*sut>H"J9T_JMdhgwvxJMQXJuT>`XH"J
I
dwJly`{z"QXJ|^}bL~RdhOW29R2\RxOWz"Q^lyJOiNPL"OZ[dhJT2JoRLVTRWlL"OZ[dhJuT_2JT`XH~R`]|Ehw`XHKgm\f"QXOlnJT_z"Q{J] RLVRM
dwO2WgmlMRd"QXJRW\OWL"ghL".HVR2\fdhJuT]kJ<`{OP`XH"JTgm\XlnOvxJEQXZ[H"gml^H,JEQ^\OWLVRdwdhlyO2LV\gmT_JEQf`XOcVJ[kOZ[LkO\`
gwkVO2Q{`^RL`/lyOWL_`{QXgwc"z"`XgwO2L`{O\XlygwJMLVlyJurW(/xOgh`fg\Z<OWQX`{H`{OR2\Z[HVR`/gm\.`XH"g\VOZJMQijzKd""QXOlnJT_z"Q{J
lERdhdwJTRLVRdhOW2V
}~Q^\`CRLV\Z<JMQ[g\y RLVRdhO2WgmlMRd¡Q{JR2\O2L"gwL"ghL_ijJEQ^\<RLR2\VJly`[OiR¢(£x¤j¥_¦^¢VO2c§XJln`ïjQXOWk©L"OZ[dhJuT_2J
RcVO2z"òRªE«x¬_¤{y¦ÖWc§XJly`[`{HVR`gm\\OWkJMH"OZ®\ghk9ghdmRQ/`XO`XH"Jo`^RQ{2JMÈ[(LVRQ{`Xgmlnz"dmRQM¯""Q{O2c"dwJMk°\OWdhvghL"
cRLVRdwO2WghL_ijJMQS\b`XHKJ\O2dwz"`XgwO2LOi[R`SRQXWJM`P"Q{O2c"dwJMk±ijQ{O2k²_L"OZ[dwJT_2JRcVO2z"``XHKJ\O2dwz"`XgwO2L`{O>R
\O2z"QSlyJ]`{HVR`[g\b\ghkgwdmRQ¨`{O`XH"J`SRQXWJM`M
}bLVRdhO2Wq\JMJMkF\]Q^Rk9VRL`ghLRdhdT_OWkRgwLV\OioH_z"kFRLqRu³´RgwQ^\n¯µVOWdhgh`{gmlMRd(¯<dwJMxRd(¯<JEL"2gwL"JMJMQ{ghL"K¯
RLVT@\OOWL¶ijO2QJM·"Rk"dwJ\[\JMJ¯Jx¸"w¯f¸¹ºV¯,s¹2»SP}bL~RdhOW2glMRd.QXJRW\OWL"ghL"g\bRLghkVO2Q{`^RL_`\OWz"Q^lyJOi
KQ^R2ln`XgmlERd¡Q{JR2\O2L"gwL"9RLVTHz"kRLQXJuR2\OWL"ghLKg\¨QXJE"dhJM`{JbOi/RLVRdwO2WghJ\n <¼"QXOWk©`{H"JMgwQ<zV\J½gwLJMvxJMQ{"TKRu
dwg¾ijJP`{ORLVRdwO2WghJ\[ghLkR`XH"JMkFR`XglM\fRLVT>\{lyghJML`Xg¿ÀlPT_g\XlyOvxJMQ{x.ÁbJMQ{JRQ{J\OWkJPJM·KRk9"dhJ\n
ÂbÃÀÄ_ÅMÆ.Ç.È2ÆIÉjÊËÄÌ[»i/OWL"J]ZCRL`^\b`{OcKz"ÍRzV\JuT>lMRQ]j`XH"Jo`^RQ{2JM`n[RLVT>`XO9J\`{ghkR`XJPgw`^\["QXglyJgh`
kFRuoZ<JMdwd"HVR"VJML`XH~R`<`{H"J"QXglyJ[OiRL"O2`{H"JMQlMRQ(R\OWz"Q^lnJ2fZ[gw`XH9R½\ghkgwdmRQkRxJRLVT9R2J2zKgmT_J\
OWL"JxÎÏ\µJ\`XgwkR`{ghO2L´ÐRL_9JM·"Rk"dwJ\/lMRLÍcJPijOWz"LVTgwLÑ¾pMÒWt2(
ÂPÓ,Ô¡ÊjÓ.Ä_ÄÅÊ»Ó,Ô.Ì}©L"JEZ©`{JlHKL"gmlMRd/O2c§XJly`9»`{H"J`^RQXWJM`yg\½`XOcVJÍT_J\ghWL"JT\zVl^HÕ`{HVR`gw`lMRL
VJMQijO2Q{k RB2gwvxJML"HK\gmlERd[ijz"LVly`{ghO2L´Ö(`^\"H_K\glMRd\`{QXzVln`Xz"Q{J>gm\9RLVRdhO2WgmlMRdhdwghLijJMQXQ{JT×ijQ{O2k R
cKghO2dwO2WgmlMRd,O2c§XJly`(R\O2z"QSlyJ2/Z[H"O\J½ijzKLVly`XgwO2Lgm\\gwkghdRQ/`XO`{H"J`XJl^H"L"glMRd"ijz"LVln`XghOWLÍRghk9JTR`M}P\
JE·_VJMQ{ghJMLVlnJ\H"OZ\n¯`{H"JMQXJgm\[R2JML"JEQ^Rd.lnO2L"L"July`XgwO2LcVJM`Z<JMJML9`XH"JPijz"LVln`XghOWLÍRLVT`XH"Jo\`{QXzVln`Xz"Q{JPOiR
\"\`XJMkØÙ<H"J9RLVRdhO2WgmlMRd/ghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJogm\P`XHzV\PcVRW\JTO2LÕ`{H"gm\lyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2LÑRLVTZ<OWQXK\Pc_@\JRQSlH"gwL"
ijOWQPc"gwO2dhOW2glMRdRLVRdhOWx\P`XHVR`RQ{J\gwkghdRQ<`{O`XHKJ]`^RQXWJM`PZQEÈb`XHKJMghQ<ijz"L~ly`XgwO2L@RL~T>`XH"JMLÍghL_ijJEQXQXgwL"
`{H"J"H"\gmlMRd,\`{QXzVln`Xz"Q{JPOi`XH"J`^RQ{2JM`<ijQ{O2kÚ`{H"J\`XQXz~ly`Xz"Q{JPOi`XHKJ½cKghO2dwO2WgmlMRd,RL~RdhOWx\nµxJEJ¸Ò2ijO2Q
`{H"JkO2Q{JT_JM`SRgwdhJT@ÛMÜm«xÝ"Üm^ª["QXOlnJT_z"Q{Jx
}bvghO2LKgmlM\,JML"WghL"JMJEQ^\,Z[H"OZ<JMQ{J[RL~RdhYMgwL"lyOWkVO2L"JML`^\,ijO2Q/RPL"JMZqRghQ^lnQ^Ruij`JM·_Kdhgmlngh`XdwbJEk"dhOxJT
RLVRdwO2WghJ\P`XOijz"L~ly`XgwO2LVRdhdhÍ\ghkgwdmRQlnO2kVO2LKJML_`S\µOiO2dmTJMQRgwQ^lyQSRuij`S\ÞsWsM(Ð>OWQXJJM·KRk9"dhJ\ïjOWQ`XH"J
z~\J]Oi/RLVRdwO2W>ghL9JML"2gwL"JMJMQ{ghL"lERLcVJ½ijO2zKLVT¡¯_ijO2QghL~\`^RLVlyJx¯ghLÑ¾pEÒºV¯ÀpMÒ2ßx(
àáÈ_âã.Ä_äÈ_âÊjåxæ2ÌeO2dwR>¿p2pEÒ\XRMZáRL~RdhOW2glMRd.`XH"gwL"ghL"9R2\RL@RcV\OWdhz"`{J]L"JlnJ\X\ghìjOWQbkFR`XHKJy
kFR`XglMRdÀlyQ{JR`{ghvgh`xçL"JOieOWdhR_ÎÏ\fZ<JMdwd"_LKOZ[LH"JEz"QXg\`XglM\g\y <èé£xê¦ëW«x¬ª¦^¦nÝ>£]ªEÜmìÜhí¿£x¤fîÀ¤X«xÛyíw¦nì
Ûy¦wïE«x¤¦xðÕñK¤në¢ «¬2ª¦oÜh¢¶ªªE«2í¿¬x¢(Üm«xÝ<Ð>OWQXJPQ{JMVO2QX`S\µOiRL~RdhOW2glMRd,Q{JR2\O2L"gwL"gwLkR`{HV\<lMRLcJijO2z"L~T
gwLÑ¾p2pEt"¯Vò_pM
ó( ô.õöø÷nùújûjöøüXþý ü,ÿùû þnþ ú þ õÿùû þ ùújùö õ nú þ ü»ö ! þnþ ú ú^"ý nù#õ %$fù&ú þ õ '
#)+*,.- " ü»ùú/ öøùõ ù0* þ újõù21nöøù43Pù566nõôõöø÷nùú»ûjöøü7'8"öøüjüjû " ú&1 ô:9;9 <:9
p
,åxÊjÄÓåxÄVÌ[z"`XHKJMQijOWQ^T¡ÎÏ\ i RkOWzV\f\O2dmRQ\K\`XJEkÖkOT_JEd_Oi¡`{H"JR`{O2k° \JMJx¯WJxKh¯m¸ò2¹M»´Z[R2\fzV\JT]`XO
kFRxJP"Q{JT_gly`XgwO2LV\RcVO2z"``XH"JRdhdwOZCRc"dwJJML"JMQ{2dhJMvxJMd\Öi/R`XO2kF\yfGIH"JMLUÀRMvxO2g\gwJMQ[T_JEvxJMdhOWJuTH"gm\
O·_WJML`{H"JMO2Q{OilyOWkcKzV\`{ghO2L^¯xH"gm\/`XH"gwL"ghL"JMkKdhOxJT½`{H"J\ghk9ghdmRQXgw`cJE`ZJMJML`XH"JélyO2kc"zV\`XghOWL
OiÀghL"OWQXxRL"gml[\z"cV\`^RL~lyJ\fRLVT`{H"J[RghQ.`XQSRLV\(ijO2QXkFR`XgwO2LgwL]dhzKL"x\n <O2`XHoOiÀ`XHKJ\J"QXOlyJu\X\Ju\7gwL_vxOWdhvxJ/R
l^HVRL"2J[Oi¡O·_WJMLghL`XOlMRQXcVO2L9T_ghO·gmT_JRLVTR"QXOvgm\gwO2LoOiÀH"JR`M/¼"Q^RL"_dwghL,ÎÏ\,RLVRdhOW2gmlERdVQXJRW\OWL"ghL"
ijQ{O2k RUVJMKT_JML <O2`X`{dhJ["HKJML"O2k9JML"O2L`XOodhgw2H`XL"gwL"dhJTH"ghk%`{O]`{H"JPH_VO2`{H"J\gm\¨`{HVR`dhgw2H`XL"gwL"Z[R2\
R½ijOWQXk%Oi.JMdhJln`XQXglygh`xÀÐ>O2Q{JPJM·KRkKdhJ\¡ijO2Q`XH"J\zVlMlyJu\X\fOiRLVRdwO22glMRdÀQXJRW\OWL"ghL"gwL\{lyghJELVlyJlMRLcVJ
ijOWz"LVTghLÑ¾pE"¯"ò2¹"¯V¹ºx(
}bLVRdhO2WgmlMRd[QXJRW\OWL"ghL"Ñgm\lyJML`XQ^Rdb`{OBKQXO2cKdhJMk \OWdhvghL"K¯<dhJuRQXLKghL"K¯[RLVTIlnQXJR`Xghvgh`q(\JMJx¯<Jx¸"w¯
ºx"¯,ßW"¯.ß2ß2»SxghLVlnJgh`HVR2\PcVJMJML@`XHKO2z"WH_ò`XOcVJJ\X\JML`XgmRdf`XOÍlyQ{JR`{ghvxJHz"kRLcJEHVRMv_gwO2QM¯,kRL_
²`XJ\`^\k9O2L"gw`XO2Q`XHKJ@Rc"gwdhgh``XO×T_Q^RMZ²RLVRdhOW2ghJu\y%(LVT_JEJT¡¯<Hz"kRLQXJuR2\OWL"ghLKcIRLVRdwO2WIgm\
~RQX`{gmlyzKdmRQ{dhÍv2RdhzVRc"dhJgwLghdwd¾ T_JyVL"JuT¡¯,lyOWk"dhJE·¡¯"OWQ½LKJMZ \gh`{zVR`{ghOWLV\PcJulMRzV\JOij`XJML@gh`gm\bJRW\gwJMQP`XO
RWT"RK`R\O2z"QSlyJ\zVlH@`XH~R`]gw`bV`S\½`XHKJlyOWLVT_gw`XghOWLV\½Oi[`{H"J`SRQ{2JMò`XHVRLÕ`XOÍ\OWdhvxJ9R"Q{O2c"dwJMk±ijQ{O2k
~Q^\`"QXgwLVlygw"dhJ\n.¼~OWQlyO2kKdhJM·"Q{O2c"dwJMk\,`XH"J\JRQ^l^H\VR2lnJbOi.\OWdhz"`{ghOWLV\/lMRLcVJPH_zK2JRL~TZ[gh`{H"O2z"`
c~R2l^_WQXO2zKLVT L"OZ[dhJuT_2JQ{J\`{QXgmln`XghLK`{H"J\JRQ^l^H@lyO2L~\gmTJMQ^Rc"dhØRlnO2k"dwJM`XJé\JRQ^l^HZ<O2zKdmTQXJ xz"ghQ{J
`{OxO>kzVl^H`XgwkJO2QPkJEkO2Q{Q{J\OWz"Q^lyJu\yo¼~OWQPghdwd¾ T_JyVLKJTRLVTL"JMZ \gw`XzVR`XgwO2LV\P\O2kJo_LKOZ[dwJT_WJgm\
JEvxJML>kg\X\ghL"ijO2QoR\O2dhzK`XghOWL ijQ{O2k°VQ^\`P"QXgwLVlygw"dhJ\nefQXO2cKdhJMk²\OWdhvghL"9c_ØRLVRdhO2Wgm\PRH"JMz"Q{gm\`{gml
`{HVR`QXJ\OWLVT"\b`{OQ{J\OWz"Q^lnJ]dhgwkgh`SR`{ghO2L~\7cÍ\OWdhvghL"R`SRQ{2JM`"QXOWc"dhJEkÚ2z"gT_JTc_`{H"J\O2dwz"`XgwO2L>Oi
R\OWz"Q^lnJ½KQXO2cKdhJMk
ghvxJML`XHKJ¨Z[gT_J<QSRL"WJ[OiÀ\gh`{zVR`{ghO2L~\ gwL]Z[H"glHHz"kRL~\ zV\J<Q{JR2\O2L"gwL"PcRLVRdhOW2\zVlMlyJu\X\ ijzKdhdh¯
gw`bg\bL"OW`P\z"QX"Q{gm\ghL"`{HVR`kRLV\"l^H"O2dwO2WgmlMRdgwL_vxJ\`XgwxR`{ghOWLV\<HVRMvxJ]cVJMJMLØlyO2L~T_zVly`{JT>RcOWz"`H"OZ
Hz"kRLV\QXJRW\OWL OWQ\OWdhvxJ"Q{O2c"dwJMk\cIRLVRdwO2Wx±xgwkghdRQ{dhx¯<gw`HVRW\cVJMJML®RT_QXJRk ijQXOWk `XH"J
JuRQXdwÍT"RM"\<Oi}bQX`{g¾ÀlngmRd.(L`XJMdwdhgw2JMLVlnJ(}PX/`XOc"z"gwdmT\K\`{JMk\[Rc"dhJ`XO9QXJRW\O2LÍc_FRLVRdhO2Wx fv2RL,Îø\
}aP}½U,ç "QXOW2QSRk ¸t2ò ¯*ijOWQ[ghLV\`^RL~lyJx¯"TJRdw`<Z[gh`{H2JEO2kJM`{QXglµ"Q{O2VO2Q{`XgwO2LVRd.RLVRdhO2W"QXOWc"dhJMkF\
\zVl^HR2\<`{H"JO2L"JoghLÍ¼gw2z"Q{Jp2
is to
1
as
2
3
is to:
4
¼.gh2zKQXJp2 /} "Q{O2c"dwJMk°\OWdhvxJTc_fvWRL´Îø\}PaP}½U,ç
5
x ghkz"dR`XgwL"H_z"kFRL|XgwL_`{JMdhdwghWJML_`SµcVJMH~RuvghOWQ/2QXJuR`XdwkO2`{ghvWR`{JT]kzVlHoOi´`XH"JRLVRdhOW2QXJ\JRQSlH
gwLI}PZ[gh`{H`{H"J>zKdh`XgwkR`{JWOxRdbOiVJM·ghc"dwJRL~TOZJMQijz"dlnO2k"zK`^R`{ghOWLVRd\"\`XJMk\nÙ O@z"LVTJMQ
\`^RLVTH"OZ Hz"kRLRLVRdwO22glMRdÀQXJRW\OWL"ghL"ZO2Q{"\<ZCR2\<RL"O2`{H"JMQ[kOW`Xgwv2R`XgwO2LijO2Q<cKz"ghdT_ghL"lyO2k9"z"`XJEQ
þ /û - - yûjùÿ&ü ü :
ù 8 1nöøûj&ü nõbü 5ù yú '
Ò
K QXO2WQ^Rk\`{HVR`F\ghkz"dR`XJHz"kRLqRLVRdwO22glMRdQXJRW\O2LKghL"K [JlyJEL_`{dhx¯.`XH"JÍzV\JÍOiolyOWk"z"`SR`{ghO2L~Rd
RLVRdwO2WÕghL@QXJRd<ZO2QXdTBR""dwgmlMR`XghOWLV\½H~R2\½cVJlnO2kJkOWQXJRLVTÕkO2Q{JghkVO2Q{`^RL_òRL~TBHVR2\`XH"J9O2c_
§XJuly`XgwvxJ`{OBQ{JT_zVlyJ9`XH"JÍ\JuRQ^l^HghL®^«xìbîVíh¦ "QXOWc"dhJEk \OWdhvghL"K¯¨`{O"QXOWO\JØ\O2dwz"`XgwO2LV\ghLqT_OWkRgwLV\
`{HVRòRQXJghdhd¿TJyVL"JTÍRLVTL"OW`½ZJMdhd.z"LVTJMQ^\`XOxOTÕghL`{JMQXk\[OiCQXz"dwJ\PRLVTBTO2kRghL`XHKJMO2Q{ghJ\n¯,RLVT`XO
RMvxOWgmT~R2\`kg\`^RxJ\¨`{OcVJ]Q{JMVJR`{JTgwLKQXO2cKdhJMk°\O2dwv_gwL""Ù<H"J}bQX`{g¾ÀlygRd´ L`XJEdhdhgw2JML~lyJ] }PX\K\
`{JMk\ïjOWQRLVRdhOW2>vWRQXlnO2LV\gmT_JMQSRc"dwghL>`{H"J]JEk"dhOxJTkJl^HVRL"gm\k\y[xO2k9J]\"\`XJMkF\<JMk"HVRW\gwYMJ
RLBJEdmRcVOWQ^R`{JkJMkOWQXT_Ju\ghWL@RLVT>Q{JM`XQ{ghJMvWRd(¯À\O2k9J]\`XQ{J\X\b`{H"JlyOWLV\`{QXzVly`{ghOWL>OikR""gwL"x\n¯¡\O2kJ
RdhdwOZIijO2Qkz"dh`{gh"dwJ\O2zKQ^lyJ\ïjOWQ[`XH"JoRLVRdwO22glMRd.QXJE"dmRMx¯\OWkJbijOlyz~\µOWL§XzV\`Xg¾lMR`{ghO2LOi/RLVRdwO22glMRd
Q{JR2\O2L"gwL""[xOWkJbZO2Q{Z[gh`{HlyO2LKL"Jly`{ghO2LKgm\`QXJMKQXJ\JML_`SR`{ghO2L~\y¯\OWkJPQXzKdhJy cVR2\JT¡¯K\O2k9JbcdwOxO2ghL"
zKlMRW\Jy cVR2\J\y/G@J]\HVRdwd,"QXJu\JML`\JMvxJEQ^Rd´lydmRW\X\J\<Oi\"\`XJMkF\¨ghL`{H"gm\[RQX`XglydhJ
O2kKz"`^R`XghOWLVRd~RLVRdhO2Wgm\n¯2ghLWJML"JMQSRd(¯i RQfijQXOWkÖQXJuR2l^H"ghL"H_z"kFRL]VJMQijO2Q{kRLVlnJRLVT]gw`/\`{ghdhdKgm\
JE·_`{QXJMkJEdhTJMVJMLVT_JML`<OWL>`{H"JoR2ly`{zVRd,Q{JM"QXJu\JML`^R`XghOWLOi`XHKJ]\O2z"QSlyJoRLVT`{H"J`^RQ{2JM`[KQXO2cKdhJMkÙ O
TKR`XJRLVRdwO2WQ{JMkRghL"JT9RQXJ\JRQSlHÍRQXJRZ[gh`{H>kRL_O2VJML"Q{O2c"dwJMk\RLVT>L"O9lyOWkkO2LKdhRWQXJMJuT
`{H"JMOWQXx fvxJML>`{H"J`XJMQ{k |^RL~RdhOW2KOlMlyz"QS\µgwLT_g¿³¡JEQXJML`lyO2L`XJE·_`S\y¯VZ[gh`XHÍT_g¿³ÀJMQXJML`kJRLKghL"\y¯VRL~T
JEvxJMLÍR2\[R\L"O2L_k ijO2Q|^\ghkgwdmRQXgh`KPO2Q[ijO2Q|Xk9JM`^R"H"O2QEø
Ù<H"JP`SR2\K\<`XOocVJ]\O2dwvxJTc9RLVRdhO2WÍ\K\`XJEk\/RQXJkRL"g¿ijO2dTRLVTQ^RLK2JbijQ{O2kÚ"Q{O2c"dwJMk \OWdhvghL"
RLVTlyO2Lu§XJly`XzKQXghLK ]`XOdwJRQ{L"ghLKRL~TB`XJRWlHKghL"K¯fO2Q]L~R`XzKQ^Rd[dRL"WzVRWJz"LVT_JMQS\`SRLVT_gwL""G@J\H~Rdhd
lnO2LVlyJEL_`{Q^R`{JO2L@R""QXOR2l^H"J\P`XO9"QXOWc"dhJMk \OWdhvghL"cÍRLVRdhOW2Z[H"glHØlMRL@cVJQXO2zK2H"dwT_Jy~L"JTR2\
z~\ghLKRP_LKOZ[L9\OWdhz"`{ghOWL`{O]Ro\OWz"Q^lyJ"Q{O2c"dwJMkÖ`{O]RgmTghL`XH"J[WJML"JMQSR`{ghO2LOiR\O2dhzK`XghOWL`{OoR½\ghkgwdmRQ
`SRQ{2JM`"QXOWc"dhJEk¯xO2QzV\gwL"KQXJMvghOWzV\<"QXOWc"dhJEkÚ\O2dhvghLKJM·_VJMQ{ghJML~lyJbijO2QR`^RQXWJM`bKQXO2cKdhJMk
Ù<HKJ]RQX`{gmlydwJPHVR2\<ijO2zKQ[kO2Q{J\Jln`XghOWLV\[T_JRdhgwL"]Z[gw`XHÍRcKQXOxRWTv_gwJMZ Oi/RLVRdwO2Wx¯"Z[gh`{H`{H"JoT_JyVLKgh`XgwO2L
OiT_g¾³ÀJMQ{JML`½`VJ\POiRL~RdhOW2x¯.Z[gh`{HlyO2k9"z"`^R`XgwO2LVRd/R2lMlnO2z"L`^\`XO>KQXO2cKdhJMk \O2dhvghLKc@RL~RdhOW2x¯
RLVTZ[gw`XH`XHKJMO2Q{JMkÚ"Q{OvghLKc_RLVRdwO2Wx
Ù<H"J<LKJM·_`.\Jly`{ghO2L´¯2RLVRdwO22R`fdRQ{2Jx¯ghLVlndhzVT_Ju\,RµvxJMQ{Pc"Q{ghJyiKQXJMvghJEZBOi,\O2kJlyOWL_`{QXgwc"z"`XgwO2LV\ijQ{O2k
KH"ghdwOx\OW"H>RLVT>R2dRLVlnJR`JMkKghQXglMRdKQXJ\z"dh`S\bRLVTkOTJMdm\/OiRLVRdwO22ÍghLÍlyOW2L"gw`XghvxJV\KlHKO2dhOW2
`{HVR`kRMghL VzKJMLVlyJP`{H"JQXJ\JRQSlHgwL>}QX`Xg¿ÀlygRdÀ(L_`{JMdhdwgh2JELVlyJx
xJly`{ghOWLt"Q{Ov_gT_J\RF`{H"JMOWQXJM`{gmlMRd¡ijQ^Rk9JMZ<OWQXijO2Ql^HVRQ^R2ln`XJMQ{ghYMgwL"Tg¾³ÀJMQXJEL_``_VJ\[OiCRL~RdhOW2g¿
lERdfgwL_ijJMQXJELVlyJx}P\[O2"VO\JT`XOOW`XH"JEQPOvxJMQXvghJMZ\<OiCRLVRdhO2WQXJ\JRQSlHÑ»Jx¸"w¯f¸ò2Òj^¯VZ<JoJMk"HVRW\gwYMJ
Q{JMdhJEv2RLVlyJRLVTB\ghkgwdmRQXgh`RW\PxJMghL"WQXJT_gwJML`^\bOi.§XzV\`Xg¾~JTRLVRdhOW2gmlERd/QXJRW\OWL"ghL"ÍQ^R`XH"JMQ`{HVRLijO
lnzV\gwL"BOWL`{H"JÍ\z"c"KQXOlyJ\{\J\OiéQXJM`{QXghJEv2Rd(¯fkR""gwL""¯/JMdmRcVO2Q^R`XgwO2L,¯[RLVTJEv2RdhzVR`XgwO2LH"JMQ{JxÙ<H"gm\
JEk"HVRW\gm\[2gwvxJ\<QXg\Jo`XO9\JMvxJMQSRd,`Ju\µOi[RLVRdwO2WgmlMRdQ{JR2\O2L"gwL""¼~JEZáR`{`XJMkK`^\<HVRMvxJcVJMJML>kFR2T_J
`{OijO2Q{kRdwghYMJo\zVlHØRLgwL_ijJMQXJELVlyJPijQ^RkJMZ<OWQXRLVT¡¯¡gwL>VRQX`{gmlyz"dRQE¯¡RWly`XzVRdhdwgwk"dwJMkJELx`XJT\"\`XJMkF\
TOL"OW`bJE·_"dwgmlygw`XdwQXJyijJMQ[`{O\zVl^H>R]ijQ^RkJMZO2QXÀG@J`XH"gwL"À¯"H"OZ<JMvxJMQE¯_`{HVR``XH"g\[lMRLÍcVJ½gwkVO2Q{`^RL`
ijOWQµijzK`Xz"Q{J]\"\`XJMkF\¨`XH~R`JMk"dwO E¬2ªn¢ Ü [¦ ½RLVRdwO2Wx
xJly`{ghOWLº"Q{J\JEL_`S\<T_g¿³¡JEQXJML`/VRQSR2T_gw2k\/Oi7lyO2kKz"`^R`XghOWLVRdV"Q{O2c"dwJMk \O2dwv_gwL"]c9RLVRdhO2WRL~T
`{H"JMgwQbQ{JRdwghYR`XghOWLRdhO2LKZ[gh`{H>`XHKJ"z"QXVO\JOi`{H"JRLVRdwO22ØR"KQXOxRWlH´¯¡`XH"JTO2kRghLV\[`^RWldhJTÀ¯"`XH"J
L"OZ[dhJuT_2J[Q{JM"QXJu\JML`^R`XghOWLzV\JTÀ¯2`XH"J[`{O2dwJMvxJMdxRdhWO2QXgw`XH"kF\y¯WRLVT]VRQX`{gmlyz"dRQ/lnO2k"zK`^R`{ghOWLVRdxkJulH_
RL"gm\k\¨JEk"dhOxJTÀ¡GBJéT_OL"O2`ClyO2L~\gmTJMQ[R""QXOR2l^H"J\<`{O"QXOWOWQX`{ghO2L~Rd.RL~RdhOW2x¯"k9JM`^R"H"O2QE¯xdhJRQXL_
gwL""¯´RLVT>JM·KR2ln`bQ{JMzV\Jb¼.ghLVRdhdh¯VRL@RK"QXOR2l^H`XO`{H"JMO2Q{JMk°"QXOvghL"c>RLVRdwO2Wgm\[2ghvxJEL>ghLÍkO2Q{J
TJM`^Rghd(
/R2l^H\Jln`XghOWLgm
\ xz"gh`{J\JEd¾i.lnO2L`^RgwL"JTZ[HKgml^HRdhdhOZ\/`XH"JbijOlnzV\JTQ{JR2T_JEQ<`XO\JMdwJly`/`XHKJP`XOW"gmlbOi
HKgm\[O2Q[H"JMQ[gwL_`{JMQXJu\`M
*,nõ (ù ü " ú»öøõ 1 {þ õPöøõ " ÿù -ú -%nú»üj6ö nõ þ þ õ þ 61yöÏùû -&ú ø5ù bû ö Wþ ÷yù.ü ù n&ú <"!$#&% *'!)(9
t
6M; ]8
:
GIHKghdhJ}P<HVRW\bVRQ{`XglyghVR`XJTghLÍ`XH"JRLVRdwO22ÍQXJ\JRQSlHØT_z"Q{ghL"`{H"J]dR2\`T_JlMRWT_J\n¯¡"H"gwdhOx\O2"Hx¯VdhgwL_
Wz"gm\`XglM\y¯RLVTBk9Ox\`L"OW`^Rc"dh@V\Kl^H"O2dwO22H~RuvxJ9RdwO2L"WJMQ`XQSR2T_gw`XghOWLÕghL@ghLvxJ\`XghR`{ghL"RLVRdwO2Wx Ù<HKJMQXJyijOWQXJx¯"cVJyijOWQXJoJM·"RkghLKghL"lyO2kKz"`^R`XghOWLVRd.R""Q{OxR2l^H"J\[`XO9RL~RdhOW2x¯Vgh`[g\[R"KQXO2KQXgmR`XJ`{OdwJRL
c~R2l^RL~TBRW\>Z[H~RòT_gmT>OW`XH"JEQT_gm\{lyghKdhghLKJ\[lyO2L`XQ{ghc"zK`XJ]`{OÍRLVRdhO2W@R"KQXOxRWlHKJ\POiC}P^ O2kJRL_
\Z<JMQS\bRQXJx lyO2WL"gh`{ghvxJPkJEkO2Q{kOT_JMd\¨z"LVTJMQXdw_gwL"RLVRdwO22glMRd.QXJuR2\OWL"ghLK"¯
kOT_JMd\<Oi7\z"c"KQXOlyJ\{\J\[J\`^RcKdhgm\H"ghLKRLVRdwO22glMRd,Q{JR2\O2L"gwL""¯
\`Xz~T_ghJ\POi[`XHKJghkVO2Q{`^RLVlyJRL~T "Q{JMvWRdwJMLVlyJOiRL~RdhOW2glMRd/QXJuR2\OWL"ghLKgwLBHz"kRL>`{H"ghL"ghLK"¯
VRQ{`Xgmlnz"dmRQXdh9ghLÍ\XlygwJMLVlyJ¯_RLVT
ghLvxJ\`{ghxR`XgwO2LV\¡Oi"`{H"J/QXO2dwJ/`XHVR`.RLVRdhO2WgmlMRd_Q{JR2\O2L"gwL""dmRMK\ghLHz"kRLPdhJRQXL"gwL"RL~T½"Q{O2c"dwJMk
\O2dwv_gwL""
"! $ # %&!'
fe H"gwdhO\O2KH"gmlMRdPRQXWz"kJML`^\]`{QXghJuT`XO@"Q{OvgmTJÕ^«xÝKy¦(îV¢(¬£2í,ïE¤X£xì¦)(f«x¤*Mªn¯<`{OÕlnQXJR`XJÍT_JyVLKgh`XgwO2LV\]ijO2Q
RLVRdwO2WgmlMRd<QXJuR2\OWL"ghLK@RLVTB`{OVL~T§XzV\`Xg¿ÀlMR`{ghOWLV\éijOWQRL~RdhOW2glMRdghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJu\yefH"ghdwOx\OW"H"JMQS\½HVRMvxJ
~RQX`{gmlyzKdmRQ{dhRLVRdhYMJT RLVRdhO2WgmlMRdQXJRW\O2LKghL"qghL \XlnghJMLVlnJ@RLVTIHVRMvxJ@\H"OZ[L `{H"Jghk9OWQX`SRLVlyJOi
RLVRdwO2W>ghL`{H"JH"gm\`XO2Q{Oi7\XlnghJMLVlnJx
¼"QXO2k `{H"J`{ghkJoOi`XHKJRLVlnghJML` Q{JMJMK\P`XH"Q{O2z"WH`{H"J`ZJML`XghJE`XH@lyJML`XzKQXx¯.RL~RdhOW2ÕH~R2\½cVJMJEL
\z"c§XJly`[`{OKH"ghdwOx\OW"H"glMRd.RQX2zKkJML`^\y/Ù<HKQXO2zK2H"OWz"`P`XHKJ½HKgm\`{O2Q{x¯VRLVRdhOW2Z[RW\µ`SRxJMLcQXH"JE`XO2Q{gml
RLVTdwghL"Wz"gm\`XglPRLVRdhK\g\[RLVT¡¯À\gwLVlyJRLVRdwO2WgmlMRdgwL_ijJMQXJELVlyJZ[R2\R2ln`XzVRdhdhzV\JTghLÍ\XlygwJMLVlyJ¯ijOWQXkz"dmRM
`{O2QS\½OiC`XH"J9lyOWLVlyJM"Òi\{lyghJEL_`{g¾ÀlkJM`XHKOT¡¯.\zVl^H@R2\ [R2lyOWLI¸ò(¯ÀQXJMRQ^TJTBRLVRdwO2WÕRW\]RQ^R`XghOWLVRd
k9OT_Jx }bQXg\`XOW`XdwJ º2.ghL_ijOWQXkRdhdwT_JyVLKJTQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"c_ÍRL~RdhOW2xoÁbJT_ghvgmT_JuTF`{H"JRL~RdhOW2"Q{O
lnJ\X\bgwL_`{O`Z<O\`XJMV\n bxgwL"2dwJy(gwLV\`SRLVlnJ]ghL~T_zVly`{ghO2LghJMdT_ghLKRQXz"dwJoRLVT>`{H"JT_JuT_zVly`{ghvxJoR"KdhgmlER`XgwO2L
Oif`{H"JPQ{J\z"dw`XgwL"]Q{z"dhJP`{O`XH"J`^RQ{2JMÈ/(`<gm\<cVJMxOWLVT`{H"J\XlnO2VJOi`XH"g\<RQ{`XglydhJP`{O]JMLz"kJEQ^R`{JPRdhdÀ`XH"J
lnO2L`XQXgwc"z"`{ghO2L~\ïjQXO2k°"HKghdhO\OW"H_<xOZ<JPijOlyzV\[O2LØ\OWkJPQXJulyJML`<O2LKJ\y
Ð>ghdwdP¿pMpM["QXOWO\JTqRB\ghkgwdmRQXgh`ÍkJR2\z"QXJFR2\R>"QXOWcVRc"gwdhg\`Xgl§XzV\`{g¾ÀlMR`XgwO2LOiH"gm\RLVRdwO2W
Q{z"dhJ[ÁbJo\z"W2J\`^\b`{HVR` RLVRdwO22glMRdghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJu\<RQ{J]dwghxJMdw`XOcVJ]`{QXz"Jg¿i\OWz"Q^lyJoRLVT>`^RQX2JE`PR2QXJEJ
gwLÍ\O2k9J½KQXO2VJMQ{`XgwJ\[RLVTg¾i.`{H"JghL_ijJMQ{QXJTi RWly`[gm\[lMRzV\JuTFc\O2kJPOi/`XHKJ\J"Q{O2VJMQX`{ghJ\n
+f§XO2k9OZ ¾pEt*slH~RQ^RWly`XJEQXghYEJ\]QXJRW\OWL"ghL"Ñc_qRL~RdhOW2R2\RB`{Q^RLV\ ijJMQ9OigwL_ijO2Q{kR`{ghO2LijQXOWk R
\O2z"QSlyJ`XOÍR`SRQ{2JM`PgwLlMRW\JRQ{JR2\O2LijO2QP`{H"J]`{Q^RLV\ ijJMQJM·_g\`S\yÁbJoO\`{z"dmR`XJ\\JEvxJMQ^Rd.lyO2LVTgh`XgwO2LV\
ijOWQ`XH"J"dRzV\ghc"gwdhgw`qRLVT Q{JMdhgRc"gwdhgw`ÑOiRLVRdhOW2gmlERdghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJ\y¯[RkO2LK`{H"JMk `XH"JQ{JMdhJMvWRLVlyJ>Oi
`{H"J`XQSRLV\(ijJMQXQ{JTÕ"QXOWJEQX`XgwJ\yÑ}bL"OW`XH"JMQoQXJ\z"dhÒiPHKgm\]Z<OWQX@gm\RlydR2\{\g¾lMR`{ghO2LOiRLVRdwO22gwJ\ghL`XO
\`XQ{zVly`XzKQ^R-d ,ijz"LVly`{ghOWLVRd ¯ ijz"LVln`XghOWLVR.d , \`XQ{zVly`{z"Q^Rd(¯/lMRzV\J ,ØJy³ÀJlyòRL~RdhOW2gwJ\]Z[H"gml^H@kJRL~\é`{HVR`
`{H"JRLVRdwO22glMRdÀQXJRW\OWL"ghL"oghL_ijJEQ^\/\gwkghdRQ,ijz"LVly`{ghO2L~\Öi´`Z<O]OWc§XJly`S\ijQ{O2k \ghkgwdmRQ\`{QXzVln`Xz"Q{J\Öi.`XH"J
OWc§XJly`S\<JM`^l2/ÁJRd\O9T_J\XlnQXghcVJ\[Tg¾³ÀJMQXJELVlyJ\/cJE`ZJMJMLQXJuR2\OWL"ghLKcRL~RdhOW2ÍRL~TcgwLVT_zVly`{ghOWL,
GBJEgh`XYEJML_ijJMdT¾pMòW2R2\X\z"kJ\`XHVR``XH"J9JM·_g\`{ghL"Ø\ghk9ghdmRQXgw`XghJE\bcVJM`Z<JEJMLÕR\O2z"QSlyJRLVTR>`^RQ{2JM`
TJM`XJMQ{kghLKJ<`XHKJ[ghL_ijJMQ{QXJT\ghkgwdmRQXgh`{ghJE\,RLVTO³ÀJMQ^\P|ST_JM`XJEQXkgwL"ghL"\`{QXzVln`Xz"Q{J\XR2\fcVRWl2Q{O2z"L~TL"OZ[d¾
JuT_2J§XzV\`Xg¾ijghLKRL~RdhOW2glMRd.ghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJ\y.ÁbJlnO2LV\gmT_JMQS\[R]`XH"JEQXkOT_LVRkgml\K\`{JMkÚR]~RQ^RWT_ghWkR`{gml
lER2\JOiR@T_JM`{JMQXkgwL"ghLK\`{QXzVly`{z"QXJcVJlMRzV\J`{H"J`XHKJMQXkOT_LVRkgml]KQXO2VJMQ{`XgwJ\]Z[ghdwd[RdwZ[RMK\½cVJQXJy
dR`{JTghL9R½L"OZ[LZ[RMxG@JMgw`XYMJMLijJMdmTT_Ju\XlyQ{ghcVJ\/RLVRdhOW2gmlERd¡gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJCR2\<RoT_JT_z~ly`XgwvxJ["QXOlyJu\X\¨`{HVR`
RW\X\z"kJ\<`{H"J]"Q{JMkg\JOi`XH"JT_JM`XJEQXkgwL"ghL"o\`XQXz~ly`Xz"Q{Jx O2L~\J xz"JML`Xdwx¯_`{H"JÎJM·`XQSRu dhO2WgmlMRd(ÎxijO2Q^lnJ½Oi
º
`{HVR`[gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJlyO2k9J\ ijQXOWk©`{H"gm\R2\{\z"kJuT"QXJEkgm\J[`XHVR`[lMRL"L"O2`[cVJoT_JTzVlyJT]ijQXOWkÚR]cVRWl2Q{O2z"L~T
`{H"JMOWQXx
(LVT_z"Q{_HR¹Wr2"RLVRdw_YMJu\ kJE`^RKH"O2QS\RLVT\JMvxJEQ^Rdxk9OT_J\,Oi´RLVRdhOW2gmlERdQXJRW\O2LKghL"K fRL~RdhOW2c
Q{JMLVT_gw`XgwO2L,¯"QXOWOWQX`{ghO2L~Rd.RL~RdhOW2x¯VRLVT"QXJuT_gmly`{ghvxJRLVRdwO22<(L@¸¹2ßÀH"JPgwL_`{QXOT_zVlnJ\¨`{H"JlyOWLV\`{Q^RgwL_`
\JMkRL_`{gmlP`XQSRLV\(ijJMQXJML~lyJZ[H"gml^H>Q{J\`{QXgly`^\RLVRdhOW2gmlERdfgwL_ijJMQXJELVlyJ\[`XO`{H"Ox\JlnO2LV\gm\`{JML`bZ[gw`XH@RWghvxJML
\JMÒilyOWLV\`{Q^RghL`^\»ghL~lydhzVTghL"`{H"JRdhQXJuR2T_L"OZ[Li R2ln`^\S[Ábg\[RLVRdhO2WgmlMRdkFR""gwL"x\RQ{JT_JnVL"JT
RW\µHKO2kOWkO2Q{"H"gm\k\fcVJM`Z<JMJMLFRdhWJMc"QSR2\y
ÁbJ\{\JÍòW¹fgwL_vxJu\`XgwxR`XJT`XH"J9RLVRdhOW2ghJu\écVJM`ZJMJML@\XlnghJML`Xg¿ÀlPkOT_JMd\bZ[gh`{H`XH"JMgwQPJM·"dhglMRL~T_z"k
H"JT_g¾³ÀJMQ{JML`XgmR`XJ\<`{H"J"Q{O2VJMQX`{ghJ\lyOWkkO2L`{O`XH"JokOT_JMd.RLVT>gh`S\bJM·"dhglMRL~T_z"k jO\gw`XghvxJRLVRd¾
OW2V^¯`XH"J"QXOWVJMQX`{ghJ\/L"O2`ClyO2kk9O2LjL"JMR`XgwvxJPRLVRdwO2WS¯"RL~TL"JMz"`{Q^RdKQXO2VJMQ{`XgwJ\ijO2Q<Z[HKgml^HZJPT_O
LKO2`]L"OZ%xJM`PZ[HKJM`XH"JEQ½`{H"JM@RQXJ9lyO2kk9O2L>OWQ]L"OW`MxH"JlMRdhd\b`XH"J"Q{O2c"dwJMk OiCJ\`SRc"dwgm\HKghL"Í`XH"J
lnO2LVT_gw`XgwO2LV\Pz"LVTJMQbZ[HKgml^H@RLVRdhO2WgmlMRdfghLijJMQXJML~lyJgm\bZCRQXQSRL`XJT>`{H"J|XdwO2WgmlMRdf"QXOWc"dhJEk±OiCRLVRdhO2W"
ÁJ\X\J\z"2WJ\`S\]`XHVR`]ghLÑR\K\`{JMk `XHVR`]g\é`{O>cVJzV\JTÑR2\]RkOTJMdijO2QRLÕJE·_"dwgmlMRLVT_z"kØ¯ZJT_O
LKO2`2JML"JEQ^RdwdhL"OZ `{H"JlMRzV\XRd,QXJMdR`{ghO2L~\<Oi`XH"JPKQXO2VJMQ{`XgwJ\ Z[gw`XH`XHKJP"QXOWVJMQX`{ghJ\ E¯Z<JO2L"dw
L"OZI`XH~R`/`XH"J RQXJQXJMdR`{JT`{O`XH"JRLVT CR2\f`{H"JMOlMlyzKQ¨`{O2WJM`XH"JEQ¨gwL`XH"JkOT_JEd(fUVJR`{H"JMQST"RdwJ
¸ß2r2 ¯ <ghJMdR>¿pM2 ¯,RLVT@Ù<HVRxRQSTI¾pEtºx/Rdm\Odwgm\`\OWkJ]`{H"JghkVOWQX`^RL_`éRLVRdhO2WghJ\PgwL`XH"JH"gm\`XOWQX>Oi
cKghO2dwO2WgmlMRd.RLVT"H_K\glMRd´\XlygwJMLVlyJ
' ! # '
} 2 QXJuR`T_JRd¡OilyO2WL"gh`{ghvxJQXJ\JRQSlHH~R2\<cVJMJMLlnO2LVT_z~ly`XJTO2LRLVRdwO22µxgwLVlyJ`XH"JpMr2ßW2\lyO2L~\gmTJMQ
Rc"dhJlnO22LKgh`XgwvxJQXJ\JRQSlHÍHVR2\PcVJMJMLØlMRQ{QXghJuTO2zK`½`{OJMdwzVlygmTKR`XJ`{H"gm\µijOWQXk°Oi`{H"O2z"WH_È¼"O2QPQ{JMv_gwJMZ\
\JMJ9tWr_¯V¹ºV¯"ºò /}bLVRdwO2Wgm\<WJML"JMQSRdhdwRW\X\z"kJT`XOcVJoRcVR2\gmlP"QXOlnJ\X\[ghLdwJRQ{L"ghLKÍ¾p2pE2(¯KlyO2WL"g¾
`{ghvxJT_JEvxJMdhOW"kJML`M¯RLVTlyQ{gh`XglMRdghL"Q{O2c"dwJMk \OWdhvghL"9 ºt fÙ<H"JPgwkVO2Q{`^RL~lyJ[Oi RLVRdhO2W`{O]kR`Xz"Q{J
Q{JR2\O2L"gwL"RL~TJM·VJMQX`{gm\Jbg\7zKLVT_JMQS\XlyOWQXJTc_Lz"kJEQXO2z~\f\`{zVT_ghJu\7Oi."QXOWc"dhJEk \O2dwv_gwL""¯xJx¸"w¯2c_Í¸Ò2ß(
Ù<H"JlyO2L`XQ{ghc"zK`XghOWLV\¡OiKV\"l^H"O2dwO2Wgm\`S\¡`XO`XH"JRLVRdwO22Q{J\JRQ^l^HRQ{J/kRL"g¿ijO2dT¡
bg¿³¡JEQXJML`,`XH"JEO2QXgwJ\
OiRLVRdwO2WgmlMRd<kR""ghLK>RLVTÕQXJM`{QXgwJMvWRdfOiRLVRdhO2\H~RuvxJcVJMJMLÕKQXO2VO\JTÕ`XH~R`RQXJ\z""VO2Q{`XJTÕc
JE·_VJMQ{ghkJML`^RdVT"R`^ROi.Hz"kRLFRLVRdhO2WgmlMRd,QXJRW\OWL"ghL"RLVTc9lyO2kKz"`^R`XghOWLVRdVkOTJMdm\nfÙ<H"Q{JMJZ<JMdwd
L"OZ[LlyOW2L"gw`XgwvxJkOT_JMd\ijOWQoRLVRdhO2WgmlMRd<kR""gwL"ÍRQXJ`XHKJ>x`XQ{zVly`{z"QXJy ÐRK"ghL" fL"WghL"JÍ*Ð C
¸t*s ¯2`XH"J}bLVRdhOW2gmlERd O2LV\`XQSRghL`[ÐR""gwL" 7LK2ghLKJ] } Ð <C¹Wt(¯RLVT`{H"J L~lyQXJMk9JML_`SRd}bL~RdhOW2
ÐRWlHKghL"J }ÐBøsÒ Ù<H"J\JkOT_JMd\bHVRMvxJ]kFRghLKdhcVJMJMLzV\JT `{OJM·"dmRghLHz"kRL>VJMQijOWQXkRLVlyJ
RLVT`{OlnO2kVRQXJPgw`[Z[gh`{H>R\K\`{JMkÎÏ\7VJMQijO2Q{kRLVlnJx
(LB`{H"JijOWdhdwOZ[gwL"ZJQ{JMv_gwJMZ \OWkJ\JMdwJly`{JT>JMk"gwQXglMRd.QXJ\z"dh`S\PRL~TBV\Kl^H"O2dwO22glMRd/kOTJMdm\bOi
RLVRdwO2WgmlMRd¨kFR""gwL"RLVT OikJMkOWQXO2QXRL"gwYR`{ghOWL,Ù<H"JdmR`X`XJEQPZ[gmT_JEdhghL ~z"JMLVlyJuT`XHKJlyO2kKz_
`SR`{ghO2L~RdR""Q{OxRWlH"Ju\µ`{O\O2z"QSlyJQXJM`{QXghJEv2Rd(
ä ÊjÅÊ»åxÈ"É Ä_æ Émâæ
ÂP
fkKghQXglMRdghLvxJ\`{ghxR`XgwO2LV\PHVRMvxJ"QXOvxJT`XHVR`RLVRdwO22glMRd[Q{JR2\O2L"gwL">g\]lyJEL_`{Q^Rd/`{O>Hz"kRL@`XHKghL"x
gwL""Ù<H"JJMkKghQXglMRd,Q{J\JuRQ^l^H@Rd\OJ\`^RcKdhgm\H"JT>JMk9"ghQ{gmlMRd,JMv_gT_JMLVlnJ½ijO2QolyJEQX`^RghL@\z"c""Q{OlyJ\X\J\½Oi
RLVRdwO2WgmlMRdQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"RLVT>\H"OZ<JT`{H"JoT_g¾³ÀJMQ{JMLVlyJ\<gwLJM·_VJMQ{`^\nÎ"RL~TL"OvgmlyJ\nÎ_zV\JOiRLVRdwO22
.Å ,åxÄ_æMæEÄ_æ
Ù<HKJPJRQ{dhgwJ\`/V\"l^H"O2dwO2WgmlMRd¡kOT_JEdm\ ijOWQRLVRdhO2WRW\<Z<JMdwdÀR2\¨k9O2QXJQXJulyJML`fO2L"Ju\<JlHKO½~\KlH"OWdhOW2gmlERd
`{H"JMOWQXghJu\f\`{JMkkgwL"<ijQXOWkÖQXJu\JRQ^l^H]O2L9RL~RdhOW2lyOWk"Q{JMH"JMLV\ghOWLRL~T]"QXOWc"dhJMk \OWdhvghL"K¯2JxKh¯2gwLøs2s¯
pEt2Òx(PxJMvxJEQ^Rd,`{H"JMOWQXghJu\y¯VJxK]¸ò2Ò¯ spx¯pE*s(¯À\zK22Ju\`P`{HVR`P`{H"J½ijOWdhdwOZ[gwL"9\z"c"KQXOlyJ\{\J\lyOWLV\`{gh`{z"`XJ
RLVRdwO2WgmlMRdQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"" ò
P¦(îÀ¤^¦Xª¦nÝ_¢ £2¢(Üm«xÝOi`XH"Jo\O2z"QSlyJRLVT`XH"J`^RQXWJM`M¯
P¦^¢ ¤yÜ»¦êM£2í_OiR]VO2`XJEL_`{gmRdwdhzV\Jnijz"d.\OWz"Q^lyJ¯
(efRQX`XgRdjì£yîxîÀÜmÝ2¥½cVJM`Z<JEJML`XHKJ]\O2z"QSlyJoRLVT`XH"J`SRQXWJM`M¯
íÞ£xÛ^«x¤X£2¢ Üm«xÝOi/`XHKJ½kFR""gwL""¯
êE£2í¿¬_£2¢ Üm«xÝ@£xÝ £x£yîV¢(£2¢ Üm«xÝ]Oi/`{H"JQXJ\z"dh`{JT`^RQXWJM`PTJ\XlyQ{gh"`{ghOWL,¯
¦{£x¤nÝ"ÜmÝ2¥PL"JMZ WJML"JMQSRdwghYR`XghOWLV\7ijQ{O2k°`XHKJ]RLVRdwO2WgmlMRd,`XQ^RLV\ ijJEQM
¼VR2lyJTZ[gw`XH`XH"Jo"QXOWc"dhJEk©Oi/z"LVT_JEQ^\`SRLVTghL"`XH"Jo\`XQXz~ly`Xz"Q{JOi/`{H"JoR`XOWk°O2L"Jkgw2H`
Q{JM`XQ{ghJMvxJ`XH"Jo\OWdmRQP\"\`XJMk°RW\PR\O2zKQ^lyJx¯VRLVT`{H"JMLVJMQijOWQXk²RLØRLVRdhOW2gmlERd.kR"KghL"cVJM`Z<JEJML`XH"J
`ZOO2c§XJln`^\ ,>`{H"J\O2dRQ\"\`XJMk RLVT>`{H"JR`XO2k ºx¹( <ÍRLVRdwO22`{OJML"JEQX2dwJMvxJMdm\<gwL>`{H"J\OWdmRQ
\"\`XJMkØ¯"`XH"JoJML"JMQ{2dhJMvxJEdm\<Oi7`XH"JR`XOWk lMRLcVJ]ghLijJMQXQ{JTRLVRdhO2WgmlMRdhdwxÙ<H"gm\PRLVRdwO2WO2zV\\OWdhz"`{ghOWL
kFRuÍL"O2òcVJlyOWQXQ{Jly`M¯Àc"z"`]LKJMJT"\b`{O>cVJ`XJ\`XJT@RLVT@`XOcVJRWT"R"`{JTB`{O`{H"JQXJRdhgh`ÍOi[`{H"J`^RQ{2JM`
KQXO2cKdhJMkq¼gwLVRdwdhx¯/RW\R Q{J\zKdhÒio`{H"JÍRLVRdhO2WI\O2kJ2JEL"JMQ^RdhgwYMJTBL"OZ[dhJT2Jx¯<J"w¯<R@\Xl^H"JMkFR
JELVlyOT_gwL"]`{H"JP2JEL"JMQ^RdÀlyO2LVlnJM"`/OilyJEL_`{Q^RdijO2Q^lnJP\"\`XJMk\fkgw2H`cVJbijOWQXkJuT(R2\n¯_Jx¸"w¯_TJ\XlyQ{ghcVJTghL
º_sj^
}P\[\HKOZ[LÍQXJlnJML_`{dhghLÑtº2 ¯"`XH"J\Jo\z"c"KQXOlyJ\{\J\[L"JMJuTFLKO2``XOcJoVJMQijOWQXkJTghLÍR\`XQ{gmly`\JMQXgRd
OWQbgwLVT_JMVJML~T_JML`ï R2\H"ghOWLRLVT>\O2kJPOi/`XHKJ]\z"c""Q{OlyJ\{\J\lMRLÍcVJ½k9gm\X\ghL"oghLÍlyJMQ{`^RghLÍ\gw`XzVR`XghOWLV\y
9Ä*âÅÊjÄ*Ã~È"É
}LVRdwO22glMRd,KQXO2cKdhJMk°\O2dwv_gwL"lMRLcVJghL"gw`XgR`XJuTc_FRL>JE·_"dwgmlygw`/H"ghL`<`{OzV\JoR]VRQ{`Xgmlnz"dmRQlMR2\J]RW\bR
\O2z"QSlyJ º_sE(¯2coRPQXJRW\O2LKJMQMÎÏ\JM·"dhglygh`.T_Julygm\ghO2Lo`XOP`{QXo`XO\O2dhvxJRT_gFlyz"dw`"Q{O2c"dwJMkác_RLVRdhOW2RL~T
lnO2LV\`XQXz~ly`XgwL"vWRQXgwO2zV\[\O2z"QSlyJ\/c_9\K\`{JMkR`{gml<`{Q^RL~\ ijO2Q{kR`{ghOWLV\ÒWò(¯xOWQ[c_9\VO2L`^RL"JMOWzV\µQ{JM`XQ{ghJMvWRd
OiR\O2zKQ^lyJPijQXOWkÚ`XHKJ½Q{JR2\O2L"JEQMÎø\[kJMk9O2QXF¹WÒ(
xO2k9JfQXJ\z"dh`S\¡ghL`XHKJ<V\"l^H"O2dwO2WgmlMRd2dhgw`XJMQSR`{z"QXJ\HKOZÑ`XHVR`VJMOW"dhJ\VOWL_`SRL"JMOWzV\dwRWlMlyJ\{\,\O2zKQ^lyJ\
lnz"JTkRgwL"dhPc]`{H"J\O lMRdhdhJuT>|^\zKQi R2lnJbijJR`{z"QXJ\fOi,`XHKJ[`^RQ{2JM` º2ºV¯x¹WÒ2( <z"`/`XOo\OWkJ<JE·_`{JML_``XH"J
\ghkgwdmRQXghÒi\`XQXz~ly`Xz"QSRdlyOWkVO2L"JML`^\Rdm\OghL VzKJMLVlyJ\`XH"J9\VO2L`^RL"JMOWzV\\JMdwJly`{ghO2LÍOiµRLRLVRdwO2"
`XQXz~ly`Xz"QSRd[ijJR`{z"QXJu\]HVRMvxJ>R2Q{JR`{JMQghkVRWly`]`{HVRLT_OÑ\z"Qi R2lyJijJR`{z"QXJ\]OWLIR"QXOWc"dhJEk \OWdhvxJMQEÎø\
Rc"ghdwgh``XO@¬2ª¦RQXJM`{QXgwJMvxJTRLVRdhOW"(LvxJ\`{ghxR`XgwO2LV\[`XHVR``XOxO2@lnO2L`XJM·`XzVRd ijJuR`XzKQXJ\bgwL_`{ORWlMlyOWz"L_`
H~RuvxJo\H"OZ[L>`XH~R``XH"J2ORd.Oi`XH"J`SRQXWJM`"QXOWc"dhJMk "dRuK\[RQXO2dwJghLQXJM`{QXgwJMvWRd,RW\µZJMdhd7¾pEÒ2¹
gml^RLVTÁbOWdhxOxR@ ºsMÀJMk"gwQXgmlERdhdw"QXOvxJT`{HVR`[VJMOW"dhJPijOWQXk RL|{ghLVTzVly`XgwvxJP\{lHKJMkR2PZ[H"JEL
`{H"JMoRQ{J<WghvxJML`Z<OO2Q.kO2Q{J/RL~RdhOW2OWzV\/\`XOWQXgwJ\RcVO2z"`/\ghkgwdmRQ¡"Q{O2c"dwJMk\,RL~T]\OWdhz"`{ghOWLV\< z"LVl^xJMQMÎÏ\
R2TgmR`{ghOWL"QXOWc"dhJMk t2tf\JMQXvxJuTR2\PR`^RQXWJM`MM^Ù<H"JMÍT_JMk9O2LV\`XQ^R`XJT`{HVR``XH"JRMv2RghdRc"gwdhghÒiR
þ ú»ö þ üj6ö nõ4û fü ùbûjùü )û " -ú ùûjûjùû 2þ ÷nù ùùõ -&ú -%nû»ù#ÿ ¡ù 9 1 96 ' uüjùú»õ ù&ú 16 ! þ õÿ *,ø5ù bùõMü"#%$! 9
Müjùú»õ ù&ú 1û " 11yùûjü»ùÿ þ õù þ &ú 6' - yõùõM7ü 7-ú ùûjû .Mÿ2ù nú -&ú -%nújü»6ö nõ þ þ õ þ 61yöøùû'& < ! #"% * ! (¨ü Wþ ü
nõû»öøûjüj!û )& (¡ùõ Mÿöøõ 1 þ ü»üjú»ö " üjùû þ õÿP÷ þ " ùû yú,ü ùfüjùú ,û þ õ þ õ þ 61' *&+%(¡öøõ wùújújöøõ 1<ú " Ïùû.új2ù þ üjöøõ 1 < þ õÿ
#Íü»ùú bû ,&- (Vöøõ új5ù bùõMü þ 66' þ - -öøõ 1 ^7ö 9 ù 96 .WõÿöÏõ 1ú " øùû,új5ù þ üjöøõ 1 < þ õÿ *ü»ùú bû þ õÿ/& 0( þ -- 'Möøõ 1<ü ùûjù/ú " øùû
ü þ 3 ü»üjú»ö " üjùû! <: * þ õÿ>üjùú&û " õMü»ö þ " õö21 " ù yö ù {þ õ ù/ÿöøû ú»ö6öøõ þ ü»ùÿ#9
õ[ü öøû -ú ø5ù ÿ ü yú ûjü.Wõÿ '/&ü ûjù)/4 mú 'MûV&ü fÿùûjü»ú ' õöøõ -Wùú øù,û»ü ü .yú ,öøü ü
ÿ þ þ 1nöøõ
1fü ù ù þ øü þ '<üjöøû» û " ùfü 2"þ ü¡ü ùfú þ þ 'Mû,þ " ûjü " - þ û»û,ü þú& " 1 nõbü ù þ þ 'ü&ü ùfþ ü " nú 965þ õ
ùfû" " ú ù4-ú Ïù2" þ û -&ú ^÷MöÏÿùÿ ' þ ûj&ü nú '<öøõ ö þ 1yùõùú þ xõùùÿùÿPü 41yùü þ þ ú 1yù þ &ú '/ü þ nú»üjújùûj/
û 6 {þ ü»ùÿöøõ[ü ù ùõMü»ù/ú þ
" õMü»ú 'nöøõ nújÿùúVü {þ -ü " újù,öøü 9 #¡ù {þ)" ûjùfü ù,ùõMüjöøújù þ ú ' " Ïÿ<õ yü - þ ûjûû þ h5ù 6' þ yõ 1 þ õ '4nõù,&ú þ #ÿ ^ü /ù 1nùõùú þ ÿöø÷Eöøÿùÿoü ù þ ú& 'öøõMüû& þ 1nú& " -û þ õÿ 2þ ÿ]ù þ 1nú " -]üjú þ ÷yù5 þ yõ1.yõù Àû»ù÷nùú þ ¡ú þ ÿûfü 2þ üfù þ øùÿoü&
ü ù nú»üjú»ùûjû 9)7 4ù 1yú " -û yõM÷nù&ú 1nùÿ]ûj6ö " øü þ õ5ù " û 6' nõü ù yújüjú»ùûjû ùújù<ü ù öÏõùÿ nú ùû.û "5 ùùÿùÿöÏõ
{þ -ü " újöøõ1[öøü 9
¹
\{lHKJMkR½JuR2\Ju\µ`{H"JQXJM`{QXghJEv2Rd¡Oi/R\OWz"Q^lyJ
àáÈ .Ê»Ó,Ô
Ù<HKJ]\z"c""Q{OlyJ\{\bRLVRdwO22glMRd,kFR""gwL"]QSRL"WJ\<ijQXO2k \gwk"dwJbQ{O2dhJé\z"cV\`Xgw`Xz"`{ghO2LcvWRQXgmRc"dhJgwLV\`SRL_
`{gmR`XghOWLV\`XO@vxJMQXÕJEdmRcVOWQ^R`{J>kR""gwL"x\n}°Z<JMdwd¾ _L"OZ[LÕJE·"Rk"dhJ9gm\]`XHKJ>kR""ghLKghL`XH"JØ\OWdmRQ
\"\`XJMk ,R`{O2k RLVRdhOW2x¯/Z[H"JMQ{J@¤¦nêE«2í¿ê¦XªgwLÕ`XHKJ\OWdmRQ\"\`XJMk QXJE"QXJ\JML`^R`{ghOWLÕgm\]kR"VJTB`{O¤¦
êE«2í¿ê¦XªoghL`{H"JR`{O2k QXJE"QXJ\JML`^R`{ghOWL@R2\½ZJMdhdR2\PîVí¿£xÝV¦^¢¨`{O¦^íh¦{y¢ ¤X«xÝ_Ù<H"JkR""ghLK"QXOWc"dhJEk lMRL
cVJT_g lnz"dh`g¾i/`{H"JMQXJg\bRdmRQX2JoL_zKkcVJMQOiRdh`XJEQXLVR`XghvxJkR`^l^H"J\/`XOl^H"OxOx\JRkO2L"KbxJMvxJEQ^Rd.lnO2L_
\`XQSRghL`^\HVRMvxJcVJMJELÕ"QXOWVOx\JuT×`{HVRòQXJTzVlyJ`XH"JlnO2k"dwJM·gh`V P\`XQXz~ly`Xz"QSRdClyO2LV\`XQSRghL`^\n¯/\gwkghdRQXgw`
lnO2LV\`XQ^RghL`^\n¯"QSRWkR`{gmlPlyOWLV\`{Q^RghL`^\y¯VRLVTcVJMH~RuvghOWQ^Rd.lyO2LV\`XQSRghL`^\n
JML_`{L"JMQtWr2ijOWz"LVT`XHVR`<gwLzV\gwL"kJM`SR"HKO2Q^\/O2QRLVRdwO22gwJ\<VJMO2KdhJP"Q{JyijJMQ`XO]kFRlyOWL"L"Jln`XJT
\"\`XJMkF\ OiVQXJMdR`{ghO2L~\2OvxJMQ{L"JTPc_H"gw2H"JEQ O2Q^TJMQfQXJEdmR`{ghOWLV\y¯W\zVl^HR2\C^£x¬ª¦XªÓ2QÜmìbîVí¿Ü»¦{ªn¯2Q^R`XH"JMQ`XHVRL
g\OWdmR`{JT]"Q{JT_gmlER`XJu\y fk"ghQ{gmlMRdxQXJ\z"dh`S\ gwL¸Ò2¹2K\z""VOWQX`/`XH"JQXOWdhJ<OiÀ`XH"J\O lMRdwdhJTo\K\`XJEkR`{gmlygw`R2\
RlyOWLV\`{Q^RgwL_`[OiRL~RdhOW2glMRd,kR""gwL"(\JMJPcVJMdhOZPS©ç`XH"JMQ\`XQ{zVly`XzKQ^Rd.lnO2LV\`XQ^RghL`^\<JM·VJMQXgwkJML`XJT
Z[gw`XHÍRQ{JP`XHKJPQXJ\`XQ{gmly`{ghO2L9`XO]kFR""gwL"x\/cVJM`Z<JMJML9JML_`{gh`{ghJ\Oif`{H"J\{RkJ`_VJPgwL@ º"¯_¹Wt2,RLVT\`XQ{zVl
`{z"Q^Rd,lyOWLV\g\`{JMLVlygwL¸t*s(Ù<H"JPdR`X`{JMQ/kJRLV\`XH~R`<g¿i.`XH"J"Q{O2VOx\gh`XgwO2L ¡g\7kFR"VJT
`{O ^¯2`{H"JML`{H"JlyO2Q{QXJ\OWLVT_gwL"RQX2zKkJML`^\fOi.cVO2`{H\HKO2z"dTRd\O]cVJkRKJuT¡¯xg(Jh¯
`{O RLVT I`XO /}P\¡ijO2Q\gwkghdRQXgw`lyO2LV\`XQSRghL`^\n¯ JML`XL"JMQ ºx22ijOWz"LVT]`XH~R`fgT_JML`XgmlERdxlnO2LVlyJE"`^\.RQ{J
Kz"`bgwL_`{OlyOWQXQ{J\VO2L~T_JMLVlyJZ[H"JEQXJRW\¹2t2À"QXJnijJMQ^\/`XH"JdhOxO\JMQ[kFR""gwL"lyOWLV\`{Q^RgwL_Òi/z~\JMQ\z"""dwghJT
\JMkRL_`{gmlMRdf\ghkgwdmRQ{gh`xÁbO2dwxOxRÀÎø\RLVT <zKQXLV\nÎ¡JMk"gwQXglMRd,Q{J\z"dw`^\¸¹2"¯fpEr2fghL~T_gmlMR`XJ`{HVR``XHKJghL_
ijOWQXkR`XgwO2L@kR"VJT>gwLÕRLVRdwO2WgmlMRd<QXJuR2\OWL"ghLK>gm\PWOxRd¿TJMVJMLVT_JML`M <JMHVRMvghO2QSRd/lnO2LV\`XQ^RghL`^\n¯f\z~lH
RW\ZO2Q{_gwL"Bk9JMkO2Q{>dwghkgw`^\RLVTJy³ÀJly`S\]OicVR2l^_WQXOWz"LVTL"OZ[dhJuT_2Jx¯/HVRMvxJcVJMJML\z"KOWQX`{JTc
JEk"ghQ{gmlMRdVQXJ\z"dh`S\<ghLÑÞsuÒ(
GBJkFRghLKdhQXJMvghJEZ<JT`XH"JV\Kl^H"O2dwO22glMRdZ<O2Q{@RcVO2zK`]`XHKJ\z"c""Q{OlyJ\X\J\½Q{JM`XQ{ghJMvWRdfRLVTBkR_
KghL"ÍcJulMRzV\JO2LKdh>ijJMZ ghLvxJ\`{ghxR`XgwO2LV\bJEdmRcVOWQ^R`{J`XHKJQ{JM"QXJu\JML`^R`XghOWL,¯,JMdmRcVO2Q^R`XgwO2L,¯fJMvWRdhzVR`XghOWL,¯
RLVTdhJRQXL"gwL"\zKc""QXOlnJ\X\J\y/Ù ÁbOZ<JMvxJEQM¯2`{H"JPO2`{H"JMQ\z"c""Q{OlyJ\X\J\[RQ{JghLVlydwzVT_JTghL`XOo`XH"JélyO2kKz_
`SR`{ghO2L~RdR""Q{OxRWlH"Ju\µ"Q{J\JEL_`{JTghLÍ\Jly`XgwO2Lº"
àáÊjæMåxÄÉ»ÉjÈ"Ó.Ä .æ
JMvxJMQ^Rd¡gwL_vxJ\`XgwxR`{ghOWLV\¨HVRMvxJcVJMJMLÍlyO2L~lyJMQXLKJTZ[gh`{HÍT_g¾³ÀJMQ{JMLVlyJ\fgwL`{H"JPzV\JOi7RLVRdhO2WT_JMVJML~T_ghL"
OWLÕ`XHKJJM·_VJMQ{`Xg\JRLVTO2L@`XH"J9R2ly`{zVRd7\gh`{zVR`{ghOWL,Ù<H"JM>gwLVT_glMR`{J`XHVR`PVJMO2"dwJVJMQijO2Q{kcVJM`X`{JMQghL
RLVRdwO2WgmlMRd<QXJuR2\OWL"ghLKZ[H"JML@`XH"JM@RQXJWghvxJMLJE·_"dwgmlygw`bgwLV\`{QXzVln`XghOWLÕRLVT ijJMJuT_cVR2l^q¾pEt2Ò(>x`{JMghL@JM`
Rd(¾pEt_pMfijO2zKLVTB`XH~R`]`{H"J"QXOWcVRc"gwdhgw`Í`XHVR`RJEQ^\OWLÕQXJuR2\OWLV\½c@RL~RdhOW2Õg\T_JMVJMLVT_JEL_Ò2LÑ`XH"J
KQXO2cKdhJMk \OWdhvghL"Ñ\gw`XzVR`XgwO2L,I}\½ijO2QghLVT_gwv_gT_zVRdT_g¾³ÀJMQ{JMLVlyJ\n¯ RL¡UVJMH"LRLVT 2O2L"J\Ø¾pyº[ijO2z"L~T
`{HVR`[gwL"Jy³ÀJly`{ghvxJdhJRQXL"JMQS\fzV\JRLVRdwO2WgmlMRd¡"Q{O2c"dwJMk \OWdhvghL"oghL"dR2lyJOi.OWQ^T_gwLVRQ{KQXO2cKdhJMk \O2dhvghLK"¯
Z[HKJMQXJRW\]2OxOT"QXOWc"dhJMk \O2dwvxJMQ^\PzV\JRLVRdhOW2\VRQ{ghL"Wdh@ghLÕOWQ^T_JMQo`XOØT_JM`XJulyòRLVTBVdwd¨L"OZ[dhJuT_2J
RV\nlHZ[RQXYF¾pMÒWò2fRLVT@Nédwgh·ÑÞsurfgwL_vxJu\`XgwxR`XJ]gwLVT_gwv_gT_zVRdT_g¿³¡JEQXJMLVlnJ\µgwLH_zKkRLØRLVRdhO2WVJMQ
ijOWQXkRLVlyJÍRL~TI\z"W2J\``{HVR`Tg¾³ÀJMQXJELVlyJ\]gwL`{H"J>gwL_ijO2Q{kR`{ghOWLÕ"QXJE"QXOlyJu\X\gwL"IjghL`XH"JØT_JyVLKgh`XgwO2L
OiQXJMdwJMvWRL`µijJR`Xz"Q{J\RLVT>Q{JMdmR`XghOWLV\CT_JM`{JMQXk9ghL"JTg¾³ÀJMQXJEL_`RLVRdwO22ÍVJMQijOWQXkRLVlyJ\nbÁgml^_kRLRL~T
UÀRQXghL@¸ò*sE¡\`^R`XJP`{HVR`C\z"c§XJln`^\fZ[gh`{HRH"ghWHdhJMvxJEd_Oi.JM·_VJMQ{`Xg\J[`XJELVT`{O]zV\JlyOWk"ghdwJT½L"OZ[dhJuT_2J
QSR`{H"JMQ`XHVRLÕRLVRdwO2WgmlMRd¨Q{JR2\O2L"gwL"ghLÑ\gw`XzVR`XghOWLV\PZ[H"JMQ{JlyO2kKghdhJuTFL"OZ[dhJuT_2JJM·gm\`^\nxghk9ghdmRQXdwx¯
RL¡UVJMH"LRLV
T 2OWL"J\¾pnºx2À\z"W2J\`^\/`XHVR`<JMvxJMLWOxOT"QXOWc"dhJMk \O2dwvxJMQ^\Jn³¡July`XgwvxJMdhzV\JPRLVRdwO22ijO2Q
LKJMZ `^RW\K\µOWQ[g¾iL"O"QXgwLVlyghKdhJ\fL"OZ[dhJT_WJgm\[RMvWRghdRc"dwJx
xJMvxJMQSRdQXJMVO2Q{`^\\H"OZÚ`XH~R`ghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJu\½`XOÑl^HVRL"WJ>`{H"J>Q{JM"QXJu\JML`^R`XghOWLOioR`^RQX2JE`kRM@cVJ
lnQXgh`{gmlMRd¡ijO2Q`XH"JRc"gwdhgw``XO9zV\JRLVRdhO2WghJ\¾pMÒxsx¯ÀÒ*s [}bL>JE·"Rk"dhJOiC\zVlHÍR`SRQ{2JM`\gw`XzVR`XghOWLHVR2\
s
cVJMJELTOlyz"kJML`XJuT>ghLÕV\"l^H"OWdhO2WgmlMRd[\`XzVT_gwJ\½Oi z"LVl^xJMQ9t2t(¯fZ[H"JEQXJ\z"c§XJly`S\½Z<JEQXJ"QXJ\JML`XJT
Z[gw`XHÍ"QXOWc"dhJMkF\¨Z[H"glHÍR`VQ^\`\JMJMk `XOcVJz"LV\O2dhvWRc"dhJo2ghvxJEL`{H"Jolyz"Q{QXJML`[`^RQX2JE`bQ{JM"QXJu\JML`^R`XghOWL,
çL"dwRuij`{JMQl^HVRL"WghL"`XHKJ½Q{JM"Q{J\JML`^R`XgwO2L`{H"Jo\z"c§XJln`^\<QXJuR2\OWL"JTc_RLVRdwO2Wx
xO2k9JghLvxJ\`{ghR`XgwO2LV\]H~RuvxJF\H"JTdhgw2HÒ2LQ{JR2\O2LV\]ijO2Qi Rd\JÍRL~RdhOW2gwJ\y >k9gm\dwJR2TghL"Í\zKQi R2lnJ
\ghkgwdmRQXgh`{ghJ\lMRLÍR2lElyJ\X\ï Rdm\JRLVRdhOW2ghJu\]¿p2pM¹.RLVTVRQX`{gmlyz"dRQ{dhL"Ov_glyJ\yÎxQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"c9RLVRdhO2Wgm\
\z"c§XJly`[`{Oi Rdm\J]RLVRdwO2WghJ\[cVJlMRz~\JOi/`{H"JdmRWlOi|^T_JEJMV_L"OZ[dwJT_2J9¸Ò(
à ,Ç.ÄÉ»æ
Ð>OTJMdm\HVRMvxJcJEJMLqT_JMvxJMdwO2VJTÕghLqlyOW2L"gw`XghvxJ9V\KlHKO2dhOW2x¯/kO\`L"OW`^RcKdhkOT_JMd\éijOWQRLVRdwO22glMRd
kFR""gwL"RLVTØijOWQPkJMk9O2QX9O2QXRL"gwYR`{ghOWL,}P\µijOWQ`XH"JRLVRdwO22glMRdkR"KghL"K¯¡`XH"Jk9OT_JMd.OiÐ Q{ghvWRd\`XH~R`fOi.} Ð RLVT]Oi,}PÐ Z[H"gml^H]kRghL"dwT_g¿³¡JEQfghLo`XH"JMgwQfkR""ghLKPlyOWLV\`{Q^RghL`^\y JML_`{L"JMQEÎø\
*Ð ºxg\fcVR2\JTO2L9RL9JMk"HVRW\g\OiR\`{QXzVln`Xz"QSRdÀlyO2L~\`XQSRgwL_È/ÁbO2dwxOxRRLVTÙ<HVRRQ^TÀÎø\[} Ð ¸¹2t2ijOlnzV\J\O2L@"Q^R2kR`XgmlolyO2L~\`XQSRgwL_`RLVT@\ghk9ghdmRQXgw`Í»JE·_"dRgwL"JTgwL@\Jln`XghOWLº"ÏÒ*^¯´RLVT@NPJRL"JÎø\
}PÐ Þsut.RWT"T"\[cJEHVRMv_gwO2Q^Rd.lyO2L~\`XQSRgwL_`S\y
(LQXJlyJEL_`xJRQS\bgh`HVRW\écVJlnO2kJlydhJRQP`XH~R`Rdhd/lyOWLV\`{Q^RghL`^\RQ{JghkVO2Q{`^RL_`R`dhJuR2\ìjO2Q\O2kJ
\`XJM~\¨ghL`XHKJPRLVRdwO22glMRdVQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"]"Q{OlyJ\{\yÁbJMLVlyJ¯2`XOo\OWkJ[JM·`XJML` JML`XL"JEQP º"pngwLVlydwzVT_JT]"QSR
kFR`XgllyO2LV\`XQSRghL`^\[ghL`XOH"JMQ\K\`{JMk°Z[H"ghdwJoÁbO2dwxOxRÍRLVTÙ<HVRRQST¹2t"¯,pEt2òx,ghLVlndhzVT_JuT\`XQ{zVly`XzKQ^Rd
lnO2LV\`XQ^RghL`^\[cVO2`XHÍO2LÍkR"KghL"RLVTQXJM`{QXghJEv2Rd(
}±c"Q{ghJyiéQXJMvghJMZ Oio`XH"J@\"\`XJMk Ð %cVRW\JTOWL JEL_`{L"JMQMÎÏ\gmTJR2\gm\WghvxJMLqghLq`XH"g\\Jln`XghOWL,¯
Z[HKJMQXJRW\]`XH"JÍR""QXOR2l^HOiéÁbO2dwxOxRÑRL~TÙ<H~RxRQ^Tg\]T_g\XlyzV\{\JT@ghLkO2Q{JTJM`^Rghd<gwL\July`XgwO2LÕºKøÒ_
g¾³ÀJMQXJEL_`lnO22LKgh`XgwvxJ]kJEkO2Q{kOTJMdm\b`{HVR`HVRMvxJghL VzKJMLVlyJTÍ}P[QXJ\JRQSlH,¯VghL~RQX`{gmlyzKdmRQghL@lMRW\Jy
c~R2\JuTQXJuR2\OWL"ghLK"¯ÀRQXJ"Q{J\JEL_`{JTR`[`XHKJ½JELVTOi/`{H"gm\[\Jly`XgwO2L,
´àáÂ
Ù<HKJ]x`XQ{zVly`{z"QXJÐR"KghL" 7LK2ghLKJ]Ð <txsMÀlyOWk"z"`{J\fkR"KghL"\7cVJM`ZJMJML`XHKJP2gwvxJML"QXJuT_gmlMR`XJ
lERdmlnz"dhzV\<Q{JM"Q{J\JML`^R`XgwO2LV\[OiR\OWz"Q^lnJRL~T>R`^RQ{2JMÈ[Ábgw2H"JMQ(OWQ^T_JEQbQ{JMdmR`XghOWLV\y¯V\zVl^H>RW\^£x¬2ª¦^¯VRQ{J
z~\JT>gwL`XH"JijO2QXkFRdhgwYR`{ghOWLOi[`{H"J\O2z"QSlyJRLVT>`{H"J`^RQXWJM`M]xgwLVlyJo`XH"JMQ{JlMRLcVJkRLkR""ghLKx\
cVJM`ZJMJML`Z<O@2ghvxJELÕQXJMKQXJ\JML_`SR`{ghO2L~\y¯bÐ ijOlyzV\J\OWL"dhOWL`XHKOx\JÍkRK"ghL"\]`XHVRìjOWdhdwOZ `XH"J
\"\`XJMkFR`Xglygh`KQXghL~lygh"dwJx JML`XLKJMQMÎÏ\b\"\`XJMkR`Xglygh`"QXgwLVlyghKdhJgm\PR\{RdhgwJML`bVRQXÒi`{H"Jx`XQ{zVly`{z"QXJ
ÐR""gwL"Ù<H"JEO2QX º/Z[gmTJMdhÍghL VzKJMLVlyJTcH"JMQV\Kl^H"O2dwO22glMRd7\`Xz~T_ghJ\O2LÕ`{H"JH_z"kFRLz"LVTJMQ
\`^RLVT_ghLKOi/kJM`SR"HKO2Q^\[Z[H"JMQ{J\H"J]JM·`XQSR2ly`{JTFijJuR`XzKQXJ\lH~RQ^RWly`XJEQXghYEghL"WOxOTBkJM`SR"H"OWQ^\¸t2r2((`
\`^R`XJ\b`{HVR`Rk9O2L"`XH"JolyOWkkOWLQXJMdR`{ghO2L~\y¯"`XHKJ½Q{JMdmR`XgwO2LV\[`XHVR`PRQXJokR"VJTRQXJ[§Xz~\``XH"O\J]`{HVR`
~RQX`{gmlygwVR`{J]gwL@RlyO2k9kO2L\"\`XJMk°Oi<Q{JMdmR`XgwO2LV\n µg Jxw¯"QXJMdR`{ghO2L~\PlyO2LKL"Jly`{JTcH"ghWH"JMQ O2QST_JMQQXJMdRu
`{ghOWLV\yÙ<H"JMQ{JyijO2Q{Jx¯x`XH"J\"\`XJMkFR`Xglygh`"Q{JyijJMQ^\f`{OkR9\JM`S\Öi.QXJMdR`XgwO2LV\/2OvxJMQ{L"JTcH"ghWH"JMQ(OWQ^T_JMQ
Q{JMdmR`XgwO2LV\\zVl^HR2\^£x¬2ª¦fQSR`XHKJMQ<`{HVRLgm\O2dR`XJuT"QXJuT_gmlMR`XJ\nf(`<KQXOv_gT_J\/R\L`^R2ln`Xgmll^HVRQSR2ly`{JMQXg\`Xgl
OioR>kR""ghLKcJE`ZJMJMLÕ`ZO>V·_JuTÕRLVTq\VJlyg¿ÀlMRdhdh@`^RghdwO2QXJuTBQXJMKQXJ\JML_`SR`{ghO2L~\y¯/`XHzV\]ghòQXJ xz"ghQ{J\
Q{JM"Q{J\JML`^R`XgwO2LV\/Oi`XH"J\O2z"QSlyJRLVT`XH"JP`SRQ{2JMÈ/Ù<H"gm\RLVTO2`{H"JMQ"QXOWc"dhJMkF\7H~RuvxJcVJMJML`{H"JlyOWQXJPOi
RL>OWL"2OWghL"RQXWz"kJML`[RcOWz"` JEL_`{L"JMQMÎÏ\[R2lMlnO2z"L`M
¼"O2QP`{H"JkRK"ghL"K¯¡O2LKdh>Q{JMdmR`XgwO2LVRdflyOWkkOWLVRdwgh`XgwJ\bjOiCL_RQX"Q{JT_glMR`{J\µZ[gw`XH
plyOWz"L_`
RLVT\gwkghdRQXgw`XgwJ\ gwLR`{`XQ{ghc"z"`{J\P»KQXJT_glMR`{J\fZ[gh`{H pRQXJPgwQXQXJEdhJMvWRL`/z"L"dwJ\X\/`XH"JM9RQ{JP2OvxJMQ{L"JT
cRlyO2k9kO2LH"gw2H"JEQ O2Q^TJMQbQ{JMdmR`XgwO2L,¼~zKQX`XHKJMQXkOWQXJx¯"Ð "QXJnijJMQ^\[lyOWLV\g\`{JML_`[OWL"Jy `XO(OWL"J]OWc§XJly`
kFR""gwL"x\n/Ù<H"JÐ IRdw2OWQXgh`{H"kÚg\<O2z"`{dhghLKJTghLÍÙRc"dhJpPZ[H"glHg\<`^RxJELFijQ{O2k ºxÒ(
¼ghWz"QXJoÒWghvxJ\RLJE·"Rk"dhJOiRLVRdwO22glMRdkR"KghL"\µcVJM`Z<JEJML`XH"JoH"JR`éRLVT>ZCR`XJEQPT_OWkRgwLV\
`{HVR`Z[RW\µKQXOT_zVlnJTc*Ð á º"pn(
Ù<H"JPx`{QXzVly`{z"QXJnÐR""ghLKR"KQXOxRWlHHVRW\cVJMJMLJM·`XJML~T_JT]RLVTghk"dwJMkJML_`{JMTghLe/ÁPa /}½¸t2¹(
e/ÁPa /}½9ghLVlndhzVT_Ju\blyOWL_`{JM·`XzVRdflyOWLV\`{Q^RghL`^\bgwL_`{O`XH"JokRK"ghL"9RL~T `{Q^RL~\ ijJMQPKQXOlyJ\{\y¯¡gw`RdwdhJMvg¾
ß
«^£2í £2¢(/«xÝ*ªn¢ ¤y¬y¢ Üm«xÝ_ o¼~OWQJR2l^HVRgwQPOiCJM·"QXJ\{\gwO2LV\PghL@R\O2z"QSlyJRLVT`^RQXWJM`M¯
g¾i/`{H"JMghQ"Q{JT_gmlER`XJu\[RQXJgT_JML`XglMRd ¯"lyQ{JR`{J]RkR`SlHH_VO2`{H"J\gm\(ÐÁ½JM·"QXJ\{\gwL"`{H"J
O\X\ghc"gwdhgh``{HVR``XH"JMkFR`^l^H, O2QXQ{J\VOWLVT_ghLKRQXWz"kJML`^\fOi.gh`XJEk\ghL9R]ÐÁ RQ{JRd\O
kR`SlH"JuTg¾iJMgh`{H"JMQ
`{H"JMgwQ<"Q{JT_gmlER`XJu\[RQXJgT_JML`XgmlERd(¯
`{H"J"QXJuT_gmlMR`XJ\RQ{J]L_ RQ{QXJMdR`{ghO2L~\<Z[gh`XH pW¯"O2Q
`{H"JM9RQ{J]JML`Xgw`XghJu\y
n
¦
¤nÝ¦^í /«xÝ*ªn¢ ¤y¬y¢ Üm«xÝ_ ¼ghL~T>xJMQXL"JEdkR""gwL"x\bcÍ\`SRQX`{ghL"ÍR`]ÐÁoÎø\[Z[H"gml^H@RQ{JL"O2`
`XH"JMkF\JMdwvxJ\µ`{H"JRQ{2z"k9JML_ÒiRL_OW`XH"JEQM¼"OWQ½JuR2l^H@\zVl^HÕÐÁ ¯,g¿i[gh`gm\\`{QXzVly`{z"Q^Rdhdw
lyO2LV\gm\`XJML`M¯"`{H"JMLgw`RLVTJMvxJMQ{ÐÁ cJEdhOZ gw`[lyOWk"Q{gm\JRxJMQXL"JEd(fç`XH"JMQ{Z[gm\Jx¯_Q{Jlyz"QS\J
O2L>`{H"JoÐÁ]Îø\/`XHVR`PRQXJgh`S\[RQ{2z"kJEL_`S\y
¢(¤n¬y¢(¬¤X£2í êE£2í¿¬_£2¢ Üm«xÝ_ qefQXO2~RxR`XJ\{lyO2Q{J\`XH"Q{O2z"WH `XHKJL"JM`Z<OWQXOiÐÁ]ÎÏ\y¯[zV\ghL"
RQXWz"kJML`lnO2L"L"July`XgwO2LV\`XOVRW\X\R2ln`XghvWR`XghOWLqT_OZ[L_ZCRQ^TÀBÙ<HKgm\½gwk"dwJMkJnL_`S\b`XH"JF\K\
`XJMkR`Xglygh`>KQXJyijJMQ{JMLVlyJBÙ<HKJ\XlnO2QXJOiRkRK"ghL"Ígm\]`{H"JÍ\z"k OiP`{H"JÍ\XlyOWQXJ\]Oigh`S\
ÐÁ]Îø\n
Õ¦n¤j¥_¦^ OWLV\`{QXzVlyòz"Õ`{O 2dwO2cVRd<ghL`XJEQX"Q{JM`^R`XghOWLV\POiµRkR`^l^Hc_zV\ghL"ØRWQXJMJT
RdhWO2Q{gh`XHKk`XOVLVT\`{QXzVln`Xz"QSRdhdwlyOWLV\g\`XJEL_`lyO2kc"gwLVR`{ghO2L~\µOi/xJMQXLKJMdm\[`XHVR`bkFR·ghkgwYMJ
\`XQ{zVly`{z"Q^RdJMvWRdhzVR`XghOWLÍ\XlyOWQXJ\n
ÙRc"dhJp2 <çz"`{dhgwL"JPOi7`XH"JÐ qRdhWO2Q{gh`XHKk
R`XJ\`{H"J>OWL"Jy `XO O2LKJÕkRK"ghL"@QXJ *z"gwQXJMk9JML_òOiÐ [¯RLVT RdwdhOZ\ijO2Q9kR"KghL"@L"O2L(gT_JML`XgmlERd
KQXJT_glMR`{J\y
r
! "$# % &% ')(*+&,,.# &/$0*12,,354%6 7$8&9-;:<=:>?-;(>+'-@0*12%, ,,
AB &=C
! "$! D #EFGG %
, ,3-@! D#/HF%, ,354%6 7')I*&J-K( 9
-LFG G ?-MF%, , ,
NOP:.HQGRI*&S 2**O
I>Q8%S &=TOHU*FPIRO
! '5NV D')(*+&,3-WNV D'$0>%2%,,XI*Y&*21Z
F& OP:P*F OQF&>O&U*F1&Y(%Z
DR%'
I>[89(>+%[F&GG\0>%2[%F\:<=:>[H('# &[! D#] ! [& ! J467[467_^
¼ghWz"QXJoÒ <ÁbJuR` VOZ JM·"Rk"dwJµijOWQPR]kR""gwL"ghLÐ
pM
oàáÂ
}\bO2"VO\JT`XO JML`XLKJMQMÎÏ\µ`{H"JMO2Q{OiC\`{QXzVly`{z"QXJokRK"ghL"K¯¡ÁO2dhxORÍRL~TÙ<HVRRQ^TÑRQXWz"J]ijO2Q`XH"J
LKJlyJ\{\XRQ{ÕghL Vz"JMLVlnJOiP`{H"JQXJuR2\OWL"JMQEÎø\½WOxRd[ghLÕJM·"dwO2QXgwL"RLVRdwO2WxÕÙ<H"JEBgwL_`{QXOT_zVlnJ\gwkghdRQXgw`
RLVTÕ"Q^R2kR`XgllyOWLV\`{Q^RghL`^\yÍÙ<H"JMgwQo\K\`XJEk } Ð %¹Wt/HVRW\]`XH"J9lyO2k9OWL"JML`^\n XpT_LVRk9gmlMRd
lnO2LV\`XQXz~ly`XgwO2L@OiRkR""gwL"L"JM`ZO2QXijO2QoR~RQX`{gmlyzKdmRQéRLVRdhO2WBKQXO2cKdhJMk¯VZ[H"JMQ{J`XH"Jz"L"gw`^\bQ{JM_
Q{J\JEL_`kR"KghL"oH_VO2`XHKJ\J\[RLVT`XH"JdhghLK"\/QXJM"Q{J\JEL_`C\VJlyg¿ÀlbghL~\`^RL_`{gmR`XghOWLV\Öif`{H"JolyO2L~\`XQSRgwL_`S\y¯
RLVTB Ò*CR2ly`{ghvWR`{ghOWL>RdhWO2QXgw`XH"kÚijOWQ\JM`{`XdhgwL"`XHKJ½LKJM`Z<O2Q{ghLOWQ^T_JMQ[`{OgT_JML`Xg¿ij`{H"JcJu\`[kR""ghLK"
UVgwxJ]Ð [¯"} Ð Õ`XQ{ghJ\/`XO½~LVTkR"KghL"\¨cVJM`Z<JMJEL\kcVOWdm\fOi`XH"Jé\O2zKQ^lyJRLVT`XH"J`SRQXWJM`<Q{JM_
Q{J\JEL_`SR`XgwO2LV\nÙ<H"J]gwL_ijO2Q{kR`{ghO2LÍRcOWz"`PQ{JMdhJMvWRLVlyJPijO2Q`XH"Jo2ORd.gm\["QXOvgmT_JTc`XH"JozV\JMQE[} Ð g\µJE·_"dRgwL"JTgwLk9O2QXJéT_JM`^RghdÀghLÍ\Jln`XghOWLº"øÒ
à
NPJRL"JÑRLVT <Q^RMK\HVRMZ²T_J\{lyQXgwcJÍ`XH"J@kOT_JEdbOi}PÐ `{HVR`gwk"dwJMkJEL_`S\]\`{QXzVln`Xz"QSRd(¯\gwkghdRQXgw`x¯
KQ^RWkR`{gml2¯WRL~T½cVJMHVRMvghO2QSRdKlyO2L~\`XQSRgwL_`S\ zV\ghL"\JEQXgmRdlyO2L~\`XQSRgwL_`\XR`Xgm\(i R2ly`{ghOWLÞsut f}PÐÖ2JEL"JMQ^R`XJ\
R\gwL"2dwJ/ghL`XJMQ{"QXJM`SR`{ghO2LcVR2\JTPO2LR[\kRdwdx\z"cV\JE`,OiVVOx\{\gwc"dhJ/kR""ghLKx\cVJM`ZJMJML`XH"J`ZOT_O2kFRghL~\y
Ù<HKJ\"\`XJMk c"zKghdmTK\ézKB`{H"gm\PkR""ghLKghLVlnQXJMkJEL_`SRdhd¿c\JMdhJuly`XgwL"R>\kRdwdVOWQX`XgwO2LÕOiR\OWz"Q^lnJ
TO2kRghLijO2Q[kR""gwL""¯KRLVT`XH"JMLkOvghL"oO2LÍ`XOkRRL"O2`{H"JMQVO2QX`{ghOWL,
àáÄä ÅMÆà ,Ç.Ä_Éjæ
Ù<ZOkJMkOWQXkOT_JEdm\lyO2L~\gmTJMQ^Rc"dhgwL Vz"JML~lyJT`XH"J_LKOZ[dwJT_WJQXJMKQXJ\JML_`SR`{ghO2L@VRQX`Xglyz"dRQXdwghL
lER2\Jn(cVRW\JTÕQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"@\K\`{JMk\y Ù<H"J xë2ÝK£xìÜmì¦ì«x¤yëÍì« _¦Sí/¾pEÒ2Ò2[RLVTÕ`XH"J@¦ ¦ìbîVí¿£x¤ì« _¦Sí
¿p2ps(
Ù<H"J/cVR2\gmlfgmTJR<Oi,*lHVRL"ÀÎø\¡T_LVRkgml.kJMkOWQX<k9OT_JMd2g\¡`XOO2Q{xRLKghYMJlMRW\J\¡Z[H"glHo\HVRQ{J<\ghkgwdmRQ
KQXO2VJMQ{`XgwJ\fz"LVT_JMQ7Rék9O2QXJ/WJML"JMQSRdV\`XQXz~ly`Xz"Q{Jx¯xRPkJMk9O2QXO2Q{xRL"ghYR`XgwO2LVRWlxJE`< ÐBçPe< yxNPO2dwOT_L"JMQ
ijzKQX`XHKJMQT_JMvxJEdhO2VJT`XH"g\PkOT_JMd,c>"Q{O2VOx\ghL"Í`XHVR` ÐBçe/\y¯,JMKgm\OTgmlÐBçe/\y¯,RLVTBlER2\Ju\bcVJMghL"
RQXQSRL"WJT`XOW2JM`{H"JMQ/ghLHKghJMQSRQ^l^H"gwJ\<¸ß2Ò( ÐBçe¨\/\`XO2Q{JbWJML"JMQSRd"L"OZ[dhJuT_2JRcOWz"`[RP`J[Oi.lMRW\J\
RLVT`{H"JMÕOWQXRL"gwYMJ>gwLVT_ghvgmTzVRdClMR2\J\]zV\gwL"ÑR L"JE`ZO2Q{BOighLVTgmlyJ\nÕÙ<H"JWJML"JMQSRdhgwYMJTBJE"gm\OT_J\y¯
\zVl^HRW\ Ê É VäÈ_âÊjåBàáÄÄ*âÊjÓ,Ô¯/lnO2L`^RgwLL"O2Q{k\y¯/lMRW\J\n¯<RLVTÕghLVTgmlyJ\n¯/R2\\H"OZ[LghLq¼gw2z"Q{Jt_
Ù<HKJcO·QXJE"QXJ\JML`^\<L"OWQXk\n¯"`XHVR`Pgm\n¯_ijJR`{z"QXJ\lyOWkkO2L9`XO9RdhdlMRW\J\[z"LVT_JEQb`{H"JÐBçeVÙ,QXgRL"WdhJ\
gwLVT_glMR`{JéijJuR`XzKQXJ\n¯Jx¸"/`XOW"gml2¯VZ[H"glHÍT_g\XlyQ{ghkgwLVR`{JbcVJM`Z<JEJML`XH"JlMR2\J\µOiR2JML"JEQ^RdwghYMJuTFJE"gm\OT_Jx
(LVTgmlyJ\<Q{JM"Q{J\JML`[`XHKJ\JPijJR`Xz"Q{J\y}bL>gwLVT_JM·gm\lyOWkVOx\JuTFOiRLÍghLVTJM·LVRkJx¯_J"|X`{O2"glM_¯ÀRL~T
RL>gwLVT_JM·vWRdhzKJx¯_Jx¸"<}UxÙPKÙ<H"Jv2Rdhz"Ju\[RQXJVO2gwL_`{JMQ^\<`{OJMgh`{H"JMQCR\VJlygRdhgwYMJTÐBçeO2Q[`{OlER2\Ju\y
Ù<HKJkJMkOWQXÍ\`{QXzVln`Xz"Q{Jg\½T_LVRkgml]gwLB`{H"J9\JMLV\J`XH~R`\ghkgwdmRQbVRQX`S\½Oi`ZO>lER2\JFT_J\XlnQXghK`XghOWLV\
RQXJT_LVRkgmlMRdhdwWJML"JMQSRdhgwYMJTghLØRÐBçeIRLVT>`XH"JlMR2\J\PRQXJ]gwLVT_JM·JTz"LVT_JMQ`XHKgm\ÐBçPec`XH"JEghQ
Tg¾³ÀJMQXJELVlyJ\n¨xgwkghdRQXgw`½g\<T_JnVL"JTgwL`XJEQXk\fOilnO2kkOWLijJuR`XzKQXJ\n¯_RLVTR\OWz"Q^lyJélMR2\JPgm\/QXJM`{QXghJEvxJT
c"zV\H"ghL"FT_OZ[L`XH"JT_g\XlyQ{ghkgwLVR`{ghOWLL"JM`Z<OWQX`XO9RlMRW\JZ[gw`XH>k9Ox\`[ijJR`Xz"Q{J\µgwLlyOWkkOWLZ[gh`{H
`{H"J]`SRQ{2JM`lER2\J[Ù<H"J]JEL_`{ghQXJkJMkOWQXgm\RT_g\XlyQ{ghkgwLVR`{ghOWLL"JE`ZO2Q{Z[gw`XH2JEL"JMQ^RdhgwYMJTJM"g\OT_J\(^¯
gwLVT_JM·9LVRkJn^¯ghLVT_JE·vWRdwz"JyS¯VRLVTÍlMR2\Jy L"OT_J\n
Ù<H"JÕ¦ ¦nìbîVí¿£x¤>ì)« _¦^í,ZCR2\T_JMvxJEdhO2VJT@ghL`XH"J9kgmTpMrxs2\Z[H"JML`XH"JFT_gm\{lyOvxJMQX@Oi`_"glMRdwgh`
Jn³¡July`^\dhJT>`{ORQ{J§XJly`{ghOWLBOi[`XHKJlydmRW\X\gmlMRdfv_gwJMZÖ`{HVRòghLV\`^RLVlyJ\POiRÍlMR`{JM2OWQXÑ\HVRQXJLKJlyJ\{\XRQ{
RLVT\z6lygwJML`.R`X`{QXgwc"z"`XJu\<¿p2ps . L~\`XJuR2T¡¯xlER`XJE2O2Q{ghJ\.RQ{J[T_JnVL"JTJM·_`{JMLV\ghO2L~Rdhdwbc`XH"JEghQ,ghL~\`^RLVlyJ\
RLVTBi RkgwdhÍQXJ\JMkcKdmRL~lyJx}lMlyO2QST_ghLK>`XOÍ`XH"J9JM·_JEk"dmRQ»OWQ½i Rkghdw>QXJu\JMkc"dmRLVlyJ2Cv_gwJMZ%lyJEQX`^RghL
OWc§XJly`S\bRQXJ`XH"OWz"2H``XOcJolMR`XJMWO2Q{ghYMJT`{O22JE`XH"JMQcVJlMRzV\Jo`XH"JM9Z<JMQ{J\zFlygwJML_`{dh\ghkgwdmRQE¯xJMgh`{H"JMQ
<.õ yü ùúûjü»ú " ü " újù Wü ù 7 5 8"ûöÏû¡õ yü,ÿöøû 5" û»ûjùÿ ùú»ù 9
p2p
Diplomatic Meeting
Participants are foreign diplomats
Topic is an international contract
Topic involves the United States
Is political and occupational for Vance
Indices:
Topic
Arab-Israel peace
Participant’s
nationality
SALT
Israel
Underlying
topic
USSR
MOP1
case2
case1
Peace
MOP4
Arms limits
case2
case2
Egypt
Topic’s
sides
Israel and
Arabs
USSR
MOP2
case2
case3
Participants
occupations
Foreign
minister
Head of state
MOP3
case2
¼ghWz"QXJot <x`XQ{zVly`XzKQXJOiRL ÐBçe[ bgh"dwO2kR`XglPÐ>JMJM`{ghL"
`{OO2LKJRL"OW`XH"JMQO2Q`XO\O2kJoRc~\`XQSR2ly`é\VJlyg¿ÀlMR`{ghOWL>OiCRlyJML`XQSRd.`XJMLVTJMLVlyx Ù<H"JlMR`XJMWO2Q{ghJ\RQ{J
zKLVT_JMQS\`XOxOTqR2\RkJML`^RdQXJM"Q{J\JEL_`SR`XgwO2L@OilyJEL_`{Q^Rd/`{JMLVT_JML~lyghJ\¿ïE£xìÜhí¿ë>¤^¦Xª¦nìÛyí¿£xÝKy¦½vghJEZP^¯Oi
gwLV\`SRLVlnJ\½n¦ ¦nìbîVíÞ£x¤CvghJEZP^¯_OWQlyO2kc"gwLVR`{ghO2L~\Öi7`XH"J`Z<OÍ¿psx¯,pEÒ2r2
Ù<H"JP`"gmlMRdhgwòOighLV\`^RLVlyJ\<OilMR`{JM2OWQXghJu\<HVR2\<cVJMJMLJMk9"ghQ{gmlMRdhd¿]gwL_vxJ\`XgwxR`{JTghLV\"l^H"OWdhO2Wx¯
J"fgwL@¾pE2"¯Àp2pMò2 ¯"RLVTQXJM"Q{OT_zVlygwc"dhJ`_KgmlMRdhghòQ^R`{ghL"\<`XHVR`T_gm\`XgwL"2z"g\H`_KgmlMRdgwLV\`SRLVlnJ\¨HVRMvxJ
cVJMJELijO2zKLVT¡PxO2k9J½JE·_VJMQ{ghkJML`^RdVkJM`XHKOT"\ïjO2Q`XH"JoJM·`XQ^RWly`XgwO2LOi7`XH"g\µ`"gmlMRdhgw`QSR`{ghL"RQXJo`XH"J
TghQXJuly`[Q^R`XghLKOi/QXJMKQXJ\JML_`SR`{ghvgh`x¯x`XH"JJM·KRk9ghLVR`XghOWLOi/`{H"JQXJRWly`XgwO2L`XgwkJP`XO9T_JlngmT_JPZ[HKJM`XH"JEQPRL
gwLV\`SRLVlnJ>cVJMdhOWL"x\`XOÑRÕlMR`{JM2OWQXx¯`XH"JÍ`XJ\Òi`XH"JÍQXJMKQXOT_zVln`XghOWLOi]gwLV\`SRLVlnJ\y¯[RLVT`{H"J>z~\J>Oi
gwLV\`SRLVlnJ\bghLWJML"JMQSRdwghYR`XghOWLV\RLVTghL@RLVRdwO22glMRdQXJRW\O2LKghL"K]Ù<H"J`"gmlERdhgw`QSR`XgwL"x\PWghvxJ]Q{gm\J]`XO
lnO2LVlyJE"`\`{QXzVly`{z"QXJu\<`XHVR`RQXJo\JM`^\<OifgwLV\`SRLVlyJu\¨VRQX`XgRdwdhOWQ^T_JMQ{JTc`{H"J`_"glMRdwgh`]Q{JMdmR`XgwO2LV\ `{HVR`lnO2kVRQXJbijOWQ<JRWlHFlMR`{JM2OWQX Ø`XH"JTJM2Q{JMJ\Öif`"gmlERdhgw`]Oi7\gwkghdRQfgwLV\`SRLVlnJ\bmijO2Q[JM·KRkKdhJx¯
R]H~RkkJEQfgm\lyO2kk9O2L"dwlyOWLV\gT_JMQXJuTR]kO2Q{Jb`"gmlERdV`XOxOWd,`XHVRL>RlnO2kVRW\X\\XRMZP^ g\[R½VRQX`{gmRd
OWQ^T_JEQbgwL`{H"Jo\JM`[OifgwLV\`SRLVlnJ\y¯VRLVT`"gmlMRd¡gwLV\`SRLVlyJu\<OiRlyOWLVlyJMK`lMRLÍcJoT_JnVL"JTc E /
}bLÍghLV\`^RLVly
J g\PlMRdhdhJuT>R>¢ ëîÀÜm^£2íÜmÝ*ªn¢ £xÝ"y¦Oi g¿i<gw`bg\bkR·_gwkRd»`XH~R`Pg\y¯
`{H"JMQ{J½g\<L"O Z[gh`XH h^¯"Z[Q{gh`{`XJMLÍR2\<`VJM·¡! u# "y
GIgh`{H`XHKJÕpMrWß2W\>lMRkJ`XH"JÍ2QXOZ[gwL"RMZ[RQXJML"Ju\X\Oi]`{H"J>LKJMJT`{OR2TKT_gh`{ghO2L~RdhdwghLVlydwzVT_JÍghL`XO
lER`XJE2O2Q{kOT_JMd\bghLijO2QXkFR`XgwO2L@RcOWz"`]`{H"JMgwQPQXJMdR`{ghO2L~\b`XOO2LKJRL"O2`{H"JMQRLVT@RcVO2z"ò`XH"JQXJEdhJMvWRL~lyJ
$#% nü»ù/ü 2þ ü¡ü öøû,ÿù .2õöøüj6ö nõPÿ Mùûõ n,ü 'nùü nõûjöøÿùú,7ü '-ö {þ Ïöø7ü ' 49 ú 9 ü 9 þ ùújü þ öøõ þ û -2ù ü nú yõEü»'ù &Mü 9
( 7 ù/öøõÿ'ù &) yúÀ7ü '-2'ù & ,6ö 6 ù öøüjü»ùÿö Kü öøû,ÿ Mùû,õ yü {þ" û»ù þ õ ' nõ " ûj6ö nõ
pMÒ
Q{JMdmR`XgwO2LV\PRkO2LK`XH"JR`X`{QXghcKz"`XJ\T_gm\"dmRMxJTc>`XHKJMghQghLV\`^RLVlyJ\nÙ<H"gm\bdwJT>`XOF\JMvxJMQSRd.vWRQXgRL`^\bOi
RLBJE·_"dRLVR`XgwO2L_ cVR2\JTv_gwJMZ ß2ò( bJ\"gh`{J`XH"J\JlH~RL"WJ\POi`XH"JvghJEZ OiClMR`{JM2OWQXghJu\y¯,`_"glMRdwgh`
QSR`{ghL"\bRQXJ\`Xgwdhd,RWlMlyOWz"L_`{JTijO2Q[`{H"JJM·_KdmRL~R`XgwO2LOi7`"glMRdwgh`Jy³ÀJly`S\[RLVTOi7\ghk9ghdmRQXgw`XghJu\y
}P\ijO2QCRLVRdhO2WgmlMRd¡Q{JR2\O2L"gwL""¯cJE`ZJMJMLRo\O2zKQ^lyJRLVT`SRQXWJM`<cVJMdwO2L"WghL"o`XOo`XH"J\XRkJPlER`XJE2O2Q{x¯
`"gmlERd/ghLV\`^RLVlyJ\oRQXJ9Oi\OWkJghL`XJMQ{J\`cVJlMRzV\J`{H"JM@Z<JMQ{J\H"OZ[L`XO>cVJKQXJyijJMQ{QXJT@\OWz"Q^lnJ\]ghL
RLVRdwO2WgmlMRdQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"¿p2pEò"¯,p2pMß2
6 °88- 88/; 6 6 E;FDA 576 :]6@A (LÕ`{H"gm\\Jly`XgwO2LÕZJJE·_"dRgwL@\JMvxJMQSRd/VR`X`XJEQXLV\OiRL~RdhOW2glMRdghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJ`{HVR`lMRLÑcJ9zV\JTghLÑ`XH"J
|{JMdmRcVO2Q^R`XgwO2LVÕ\z"c""Q{OlyJ\{\yIÐ>O\Òié`XH"JÍT_Jy~L"gh`{ghO2L~\]ghLÕ`{H"JQXJMdwJMvWRL`dhgh`{JMQ^R`Xz"Q{JRWQXJMJgwL`{HVR`
RLVRdwO2WgmlMRdPghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJ`XQSRLV\(ijJMQ^\ghL_ijOWQXkR`XgwO2LÕijQXOWk RB\zFlyghJML`XdwBL"OZ[L ªE«x¬¤Xy¦`{OÕRLIR`dhJuR2\`
~RQX`{gmRdhdh9z"L"L"OZ[LÕ¢ £x¤»¥_¦^¢ÀghL`XH"JPijOWdhdhOZ[gwL"2JMLKJMQ^Rd,Z[RM¡ }bLVRdhO2WgmlMRdgwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJoRdwdhOZ\[`XOgwL_ijJMQoÝ)¦ (\gwkghdRQ{gh`XgwJM\/cVJy
`Z<JMJML`{H"Jo\O2zKQ^ly
J RL~T>`XH"J`^RQXWJM` ¯_ijQXOWk *WÝ"« (Ý\ghk9g¾
dmRQXgh`{ghJ\/cVJM`Z<JMJML ×RLVT ½
Ù<H"JoR2ly`{zVRdRL~RdhOW2glMRd.ghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJPHVR2\[`Z<O\`XJMV\ ¯Z[HKgml^HZ<JijO2QXkz"dR`XJghLÍ`XJMQ{k\Öi/lnO2kkOWL
\JMLV\J]L"OW`XghOWLV\T_JyVL"JuTFk9O2QXJ"QXJlngm\JEdhdmR`XJMQE Xp9 LijJMQXQ{ghL"P`{H"JL"JMZI\ghkgwdmRQXghÒi @RLV
T Z¸QM¸`MfRLRW\VJly` ájZ[QXgw`X`XJELR2\µªEÜmìÜhíÞ£x¤ ]{
ijQXO2k°`{H"J_L"OZ[LÍ\gwkghdRQ{gh`]Z¸QMÈ/RLÍR2\VJly` %»Z[Q{gh`{`XJMLÍR2\PªEÜmìÜhí¿£x¤ ñ ^
(Òx9 LijJMQXQ{ghL"o`XH"JR2ly`{zVRd´T_J\{lyQXgw"`XgwO2LOi.`XHKJR2\July` ijO2Q<`{H"J`^RQ{2JM`/ijQXOWk©`{H"JPL"OZ[LT_J\{lyQXgw_
`XghOWL>Oi ijOWQb`{H"Jo\O2zKQ^lyJoRL~T`XHKJ½Q{J\zKdh`[Oi7\`{JM@Xp^
Ù<HKJµVQS\`fgwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJx{pÀgm\`{H"JR2ln`XzVRdVRLVRdhOW2gmlERdVghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJ[RL~T(Ò*lMRLcVJPlyOWLV\gT_JMQ{JT]RT_JTzVly`XgwvxJ
gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJx
@ Xp»ixO2zÕL"OZ%`XH~R`lMRQ RL~TlER"Q !×RQXJÍ\ghkgwdmRQZQM¸`M`XH"JEghQkRxJRLVTÕ`XH"JEghQ
xJuRQ/Oi´"QXOT_z~ly`XgwO2L,¯`XH"JMLxO2zkRM]gwL_ijJMQ/RLVRdwO2WgmlMRdhdh`{HVR`ClMR#Q ]RLVTlMR"Q !RQXJRdm\Oo\ghk9ghdmRQZ¸QM¸`M
`{H"JMgwQ["QXglyJx
Ò*C}PT"T_gw`XgwO2LVRdhdhL"OZ[ghL"`{H"J"QXglyJPOi¨lMR#Q xO2zÍlMRLgwL_ijJMQR]dwghxJMdw"QXglyJPOi¨lMR$Q !,
}bLVRdhO2WgmlMRd/ghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJlERLcVJJMk"dwOxJT`{O>"Q{OvgmTJRLR""Q{O·ghkFR`XJTJ\XlyQ{gh"`{ghOWLÕOiRLR2\(
VJln` Oi.`XH"J`^RQXWJM%` ½¯xg¿i,`XHKJ\OWz"Q^lyJéRLVT`{H"JP`SRQXWJM`[RQXJ\O2kJEH"OZI\gwkghdRQ/RLVT`{H"JT_J\{lyQXgw"`XgwO2L
Oi`{H"JRW\VJly` ²gm\L"OZ[LijO2Q`XHKJ\OWz"Q^ln&J < Ù<H"g\dhJRWT"\zV\`XOR ~Q^\`ÍR`X`XJEk"``XOZCRQ^TK\R
ijOWQXkRdhgwYR`{ghO2L9c_`{H"JPijO2dwdhOZ[ghL"gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJQXz"dwJ\y \\gwgwkkghghddRRQEQE'' o
"\ghQ{kO2cVgwdmRRc"QEdh' ) Po ^(¯ ' /
OWQPlnO2kc"ghL"JuT
\ghk9ghdmRQM
\ghk9ghdmRQM ]S*¯ ' /
"QXOWcVRc"dw+ , é
- Mö66ö þ ú 6'/&ü 2þ /ü <.ú»öøûjü yü øùfû " 11nùû»üjùÿ 9
pMt
Z[HKJMQXJ`XH"J<ijOWQXk%Oi,`XHKJ[ghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJQXz"dwJ\kJuRLV\`{HVR`/gw`fgm\fRdhdwOZJT]`XOolyOWLVlydwzVT_J[`XHKJ[dhOZ<JMQ.i R2lyìjQ{O2k
`{H"Jz""VJMQ[i R2ly`S\y
}PT"T_gw`XgwO2LVRdhdh¯`{H"J[QXJ\z"dh`/Oi,`XHKJRLVRdhO2WgmlMRd¡gwL_ijJMQXJELVlyJ[\H"O2zKdmTcJlyOWL_VQXk9JT½OWL"dhg¿i¡gw`/T_OxJ\/L"O2`
lnO2L`XQ^RWT_gmln`b`{H"J]L"OZ[dhJT2JghL_ijJEQ^RcKdhJPijO2Q`XH"Jo`^RQX2JE`bcÍRT_JuT_zVly`{ghvxJPgwL_ijJMQXJELVlyJx¯Z[H"gml^H>g\[\ghdwJML`Xdh
RW\X\z"kJTijQ{O2k°L"OZáO2L,Ù<H"g\PR2\{\z"k9"`XgwO2L>cVJMdwO2L"\P`XO`{H"JlyOWLV\`{Q^RghL`^\PlyOWkkOWL"dh9R2lMlnJM"`XJuTFijO2Q
RLVRdwO2WgmlMRd[ghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJ>Ù<H"JEQXJg\Rdm\O@RlyO2L~\JMLV\zV\RcVOWz"`RL"OW`XH"JEQlyO2LV\`XQSRghLÒiéRL~RdhOW2glMRdghL_
ijJEQXJMLVlnJ\y <`{H"J]gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJo\HKO2z"dT>L"O2`PcVJVOx\{\gwc"dhJZ[gw`XH"OWz"`PL"OZ[ghL"9R\OWz"Q^lnJx½xOWkJR""Q{OxR2l^H"J\
RWT"T_gw`XghOWLVRdwdhÍQXJ xz"ghQ{J]`{HVR`P`{H"JQXJu\z"dw`^\bOi[RLVRdwO2WgmlMRd¨gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJ\<kzV\`bL"OW`cJRWlHKghJMvWRcKdhJ]cÍT_Jy
TzVly`XgwvxJghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJò2(<G@J\_gw>`{H"gm\[lyOWLV\`{Q^RghL`PRLVTRdwdhOZ ijO2QRL~RdhOW2glMRd.ghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJ\<`XHVR`bkFRu
KQXOv_gT_JoRLØRc"c"Q{JMvgmR`{ghOWLOi/RT_JTzVly`XgwvxJPghLijJMQXJML~lyJx
+b`XO]LKOZ gh`/g\<\`{ghdwd"vWR2zKJx¯"Z[HVR`gm\/kJRL`fcRW\VJly`S\y¯c_\ghkgwdmRQ{gh`x¯WRLVTZ[H"gml^HRWT"T_gw`XghOWLVRd
\ghkgwdmRQXgh`{ghJ\À\H"OWz"dmT]cVJ[gwL_ijJMQXQ{JTéijQ{O2k Z[H"gml^H]L"OZ[L\gwkghdRQXgw`XgwJ\yÀ(`g\fRd\OPL"OW`/\zKcV\`SRL`XgmR`XJTxJMÈ¯
( Kë`XHKOx\J9\gwkghdRQ{gh`XgwJ\[lMRLBcVJgwL_ijJMQXQ{JT¡(L@`XH"JijO2dwdhOZ[ghLKZJR`{`XJMkK`P`XOÍkRxJo`XH"J\JLKO2`XgwO2LV\
RLVTBQ{JR2\O2LV\RW\½"Q{Jlygm\JR2\O\X\ghc"dwJxG@J\HVRdwd/xJMJM`XHKJvxJMQ{2JMLKJMQ^Rd<TJyVL"gw`XghOWLOiRLVRdwO22glMRd
Q{JR2\O2L"gwL""¯.Z[H"gml^H>gwLVlydwzVT_J\lyQXO\X\(T_OWkRgwLÕRLVRdwO2WghJ\n¯ g Jxw¯VRLVRdhOW2ghJu\ijOWQZ[H"gml^H RLVT cVJMdwO2L"
`{OT_g¾³ÀJMQ{JML`[T_OWkRgwLV\y/xO2z"QSlyJ\[RLVT`^RQ{2JM`S\<Z[ghdwdcVJlERdhdwJT«xÛ ¦{n¢¶ªZ[H"gml^HOWL"JlMRLgwkRWghL"J[`{OcVJ
`{H"ghLKx\y¯À\gw`XzVR`XgwO2LV\n¯V\K\`XJEk\y¯xJM`Sl2
9æ /Ä_å2âæ
}Lá£ªîV¦{y¢o«ïÍ£xÝ«xÛ ¦{y¢[gm\R VRQXÒi`XH"JOWc§XJly`MÎÏ\T_J\{lyQXgw"`XgwO2L,ÕOWL"JlMRLghkR2ghLKJx¯fJxKh¯R\JM`
Oi]ijJR`Xz"Q{Jy v2Rdhz"J~RghQS\y¯O2QÍRBVQ^\ÒWQ^T_JEQ"QXJuT_gmlMR`XJ@lMRdmlyzKdhzV\ijOWQXkz"dmR`XOÑQXJM"Q{J\JEL_`RL RW\VJly`
ijOWQoRlnJMQX`SRghLOWc§XJlyÈ}bdh`{H"O2zK2H@RL~RdhOW2glMRd/ghLijJMQXJML~lyJ]g\bL"O2`Q{J\`{QXgmln`XJT>`{O>\O2z"QSlyJ\RL~T `SRQXWJM`^\
Q{JM"Q{J\JML`XJuT gwLRijO2Q{kRd/dmRL"2z~R2J¯¨ZJQ{JMdh@O2LÕ`{H"gm\QXJMKQXJ\JML_`SR`{ghO2LÑghLÕOWQ^T_JMQo`XOzV\JghLijJMQXJML~lyJ
Q{z"dhJu\y
UVJM` cJ9RFijOWQXkRdfdmRL"2z~R2J9ghL@Z[H"gml^HB`{H"JO2c§XJly`S\ RQ{JT_J\{lyQXgwcVJTRLVTÑR2\X\z"kJ9RFV·JT
gwL_`{JMQXKQXJM`SR`XgwO2LOi I`{HVR`ghL`XJEQX"Q{JM`XJ\`XH"JlyOWLV\`SRL`^\ c_Í`XH"JO2c§XJln`^\ }bL@RW\VJlyògm\
Rijz"L~ly`XgwO2L>`{HVR``^RxJu\bRW\½RL@RQ{2z"kJEL_`RLBOWc§XJly
` RLVTQXJE`Xz"Q{LV\bRijO2QXkz"dRgwL }bLRW\VJly`
ijzKLVly`XgwO2L9lMRLcVJPVRQX`XgRdwdhTJyVL"JTÀ¯*g Jxw¯kFRuL"OW`<HVRMvxJRv2Rdhz"J<ijOWQ[\O2kJ[OWc§XJly`^\ [JMkJMkcVJMQ
`{HVR` ,kJRLV\¨`{HVR``XHKJ½vWRQXgmRc"dhJ gm\<gwLV\`SRL`XgR`XJuTFc`{H"JolyO2LV\`^RL_`
/
* ¼"O2QR½V·JTgwL_`{JMQX"Q{JM`^R`XgwO2LOi <¯KRLÑ£ªîV¦{y¢ gm\T_JyVL"JuTRW\[R½VRQX`{gmRd
ijzKLVly`XgwO2L,¯.kRK"ghL"9O2c§XJly`S\ `XOØRL"O2L_ `^Rz"`XOWdhOW2gmlERdïjOWQXkz"dmR Oi Z[gh`XHÑRòkOx\`PO2LKJ
ijQ{JMJvWRQXgRc"dwJ "!#,¯V\zVl^H`XHVR` $ % & Àgm(\ '*),+-"
(L_ijO2Q{kRdwdh\VJRghL"K¯_ijO2QRLOWc§XJly#` RLVTRLÍR2\July` ¯ gm\[R½ijOWQXkz"dmRT_Ju\XlyQ{ghc"gwL"
gw.L <JlMRzV\JOi.`{H"JbijQ{JMJbvWRQXgmRc"dhJZ<JlMRLJE·_"Q{J\X\/`XHVR`<`Z<OoO2c§XJln`^(\ RLV.T RQ{JPgmT_JEL_`{gmlMRd
Z¸QM¸`M/RLØR2\July` c_Z[Q{gh`{ghL"
OWLV\gT_JMQP`{H"JoR2\July
` /1032"46587x¯VRlERQo(RLOWc§XJly`n9 Ö¯ÀRlyO2LV\`^RL_` ijQ{O2:
k ijO2
Q ¯VRLVTRc"gmln"lydwJ
UVJM
` ;=< $ P9 >ÖpE ?@;*A CB ;=<À$ PD ?@; FE A B HG¡8 éI ?@JK;* 1L NM $ P > pMWcVJ ',)*+F-z"LVT_JMQ`XH"J
~·_JTgwL_`{JMQX"Q{JM`^R`XgwO2L,/Ù<H"JEL`{H"JvWRdhzKJ½Oi /1032"46587 lyOWz"dmTcVJ]`{H"JPijO2QXkz"dR
;=< $ ¡ > pM ?K;*A CB ;=<À$ ¡O ?K; FE A B HG¡$ ¡ ?PJK;, 1L NM $ ¡ >®pM2
Q ü,öÏû ¡5ù 6 Mõ ,õböø.õ < ü 2þ /ü þ õ ':yü ùú,ú»5ù -ú»ùûjùõMü þ üj6ö yõû {þ õ ù/üjú þ õ&û þ üjùÿPöøõMü <û ù 61nö 9
SR ú»ùù/÷ þ ú»ö þ øùû þ ú»ù÷ þ újö þ Ïùû,öÏõ þ n&ú " þ ü Wþ ü þ újùfõ yü " õÿ ' þ 1 "Wþ õEü»ö .Wùú,û " þ û T yVú U9 <.!û --%nû»ùÿ
ü þ 1nö {þ ÿù .2õöøüjö6nõ þ .nõbûjùõûjùÿù .Wõöøüjö6yõ nõûjöøÿùú»û Xþ W wú»ùù[÷ þ ú»ö )þ øùZY þ û þ W 1yùõùú þ øö\[ þ ü»ö6nõCY wú þ õ
'ù & þ .- Ïù
pyº
Z[gw`XHÍ`XH"JPijQXJEJPvWRQXgRc"dwJ
¼"OWQPRL"O2`{H"JMQlMRQ `{HVR`HVRW\µL"ORghQ{cVR /1032"465$7 lyOWz"dmTcVJ]`{H"JPijO2Q{kz"dR
; < 8 ´ > pE ?P; E A B
3G¡8¡?KJK;* 1L NM $¡> pE2
cVJlERzV\J
;*A CB ; <À8
g\µLKO29` '*),+-"
Ù<HKJ]vWRdwz"JOi /1032"465$7 ijOWQ[`XH"Jc"glyKlydhJ %lnO2z"dTFcVJo`XH"JPijO2Q{kzKdmR
?K;=< $ ¡ >qò
;*J M A$;*J HE $ t*O
Ù<HKJ<JM·KRkKdhJ\V\HKOZ@`XH~R`.`XH"J/vWRdwz"J\¡OiK`XHKJ<RW\VJlyV` /1032"46587ijO2Q.T_g¿³ÀJMQXJML`,O2c§XJuly`^\n¯\XRMx¯WlMRQS\y¯c"gmlyKlydwJ\y¯
`{Q^RghLV\n¯JM`Sl2flERLcVJ½ijO2Q{kzKdmR2\/`XHVR`PlERLÍT_g¾³ÀJMQlnO2LV\gmT_JMQSRc"dwx
Ù<H"JWghvxJMLÑT_JyVLKgh`XgwO2LÕOiRW\VJly`S\]gm\vxJMQXWJML"JMQSRd[RLVTÕHVR2\]`{O>cVJO2VJMQSR`XgwO2LVRdhgwYMJT ijOWQlyOWk
K z"`^R`XghOWLVRdCR2lMlnO2z"L`^\bcJM·"dhglygh`{dh9T_JyVLKghL"`XHKJ]ijz"LVly`{ghO2L O2Qc>Q{J\`{QXgmln`XghLKR2\July`^\n¯ J"w¯¡`XO
ijzKLVly`XgwO2LV\<Z[HKOx\JvWRdwz"J\[RQXJR`XO2k9gmlµijOWQXkz"dmRW\7Z[gw`XH~·_JT"Q{JT_glMR`{J\yÙ<H"JzV\JPOi/RW\VJly`S\<Q^R`XH"JMQ
`{HVRL@\ghkKdhJbijJR`Xz"Q{J\[gm\[ghLRWlMlyOWQ^T"RLVlyJ]Z[gw`XHÍQXJ\JRQSlHÍ`XHVR`P\H"OZ\b`XHVR`RL~RdhOW2Ígm\[L"O2`§XzV\``XH"J
dRM_gwL"O2z"Òi7\gwkghdRQ{gh`XgwJ\cVRW\JTO2LØ\HVRQXJTijJR`{z"QXJ\PjJxK º»S
Ù<H"J2ghvxJEL@R2\VJln`T_Jy~L"gh`{ghO2L@gm\PZJMdhd/\z"gh`{JTijO2Qo"QXOWc"dhJEk \O2dwv_gwL""9}bLÑR2\VJln` A lMRL
TJ\XlyQ{ghcVJ\O2dwz"`XgwO2LV\f`{HVR`kRM½vWRQXghL`XHKJMghQ/\_L`^RWly`XglMRd~\`XQ{zVly`{z"QXJRLVTghL`XHKJbgwL_vxOWdhvxJTP O2VE JM QSR`{O2Q^\n
Ù<HKJR2\VJly` L CB J`XH~R`T_J\{lyQXgwcVJ\<ghL"gw`XgRd,\`^R`XJ\RLVT2ORdm\[kRM9T_g¾³ÀJMQ[gwL`{H"JzV\JuTFKQXJT_glMR`{J\
RLVTgwL`XH"Jo\L`^R2ln`Xgml\`XQ{zVly`{z"QXJx
$ #
'
G@JHVRMvxJ]`XOÍ\Julyg¾ijZ[HVR`]\H"O2zKdmTcJlnO2LV\gmT_JMQ{JTR2\\ghkgwdmRQ{gh`cJE`ZJMJML@\O2z"QSlyJRLVT`^RQXWJM`M(L
lnO2k"zK`^R`{ghOWLVRd/\"\`XJMkF\y¯ijQ{J *zKJML_`{dhÍR2dwO2cVRd¨Lz"kJEQXgml\ghkgwdmRQ{gh`kJuR2\zKQXJ]g\lMRdlyz"dmR`XJT>c~R2\JuT
OWLdhOlMRdf\ghkgwdmRQXgh`{ghJ\fcVJM`Z<JEJMLijJR`{z"QXJ\<ijQXOWk²RWghvxJMLÍ\JE`bOiïjJuR`XzKQXJ\n bg¾³ÀJMQ{JML`bdwOlMRd\gwkghdRQXgw`
k9JR2\z"QXJ\<H~RuvxJcJEJMLJMk"dwOxJuT¡¯xRk9O2L"`{H"JMk
Z[HKJMQXJ
A$J$; B 3 ; CM $; 3 ; B $; 3; CM $; B
CM
B
H; CM g\<`XH"Jo\gwYMJPOiR\JM`RL~T.; B RQXJo\JE`^\[Oi.ijJR`{z"QXJvWRdwz"J\y<ç`{H"JMQ[kJRW\z"Q{J\<RQXJ
; B
A$J$; B p ; B KQXghkFRQXgwdh]ijOWQP\JM`^\<Oi\kcVOWdhgml<ijJR`Xz"Q{J½vWRdhz"J\n¯VRLVT
; B
A$J8 ; B ijOWQPLz"kJMQ{gml<ijJR`{z"QXJvWRdwz"J#\ ; B ¯_Z[HKJMQXJ ; B gm\[`XH"JoRcV\OWdhz"`{Jv2Rdhz"JOi/`XH"JT_g¾³ÀJMQ{JMLVlyJcJE`ZJMJML
;RL~T B ¯RLVT gm\f`XHKJPRcV\OWdhz"`{JPvWRdhzKJbcVJM`Z<JEJML`{H"Jz""VJMQ[RLVT`{H"JbdwOZ<JMQ/cVO2z"L~T"\Öi.`XH"JghL`XJMQ{vWRd
Oi/VOx\{\ghcKdhJvWRdhzKJ\µOif`{H"JPijJR`{z"QXJ
pMò
ç LVlyJ>`{H"JÑ\JMÒidwOlMRd\ghkgwdmRQXgh`{ghJ\HVR2\cVJMJML®T_Jy~L"JTijO2QJRWlHijJR`{z"QXJ¯b`XHKJMHVRMvxJÍ`XOcVJ
lnO2kc"ghL"JuTghL®R×WdhOWcVRd\ghk9ghdmRQXgw`ÑkJR2\z"QXJ>ijOWQ>`{H"JBOWc§XJly`S\ ÚxO2kJ@Z<JEdhd¾ L"OZ[LI2dhOWcVRd
k9JR2\z"QXJ\[RQXJx gh`x <dwOlÀ p A$J $; B L Z[HKJMQXJ L gm\`XH"JLz"kcJEQ[Oi<ijJuR`XzKQXJ\n¯ A$J `{H"JdhOlMRd/\gwkghdRQ{gh`k9JR2\z"QXJijO2Q`XH"Jg¿(`{H>ijJR`{z"QXJ ; RLVT B
fzVlydhgT_JRL, p A$J $; B X L ÐR·ghkz"kÍ JK;* A$J $; B
Z[HKJMQXJo RQXJQXJMdwJMvWRLVlnJPZ<JMgw2H`^\<Z[gw`XH p
xghk9"dhJÐR`SlH"gwL" OxJ%lygwJML`M [Z HKJMQXJ gm\ `{H"J[L_zKkcVJMQ,Oi.RWQXJMJEghL"K¯2VOx\gw`XgwvxJïjJR`Xz"Q{J\y¯ gm\,`XH"J[Lz"kcV JMQ,Oi´ghLVlyOWLV\g\`{JML_È¯VO\gh`{ghvxJ
ijJuR`XzKQXJ\n¯ `XH"J@Lz"kcVJMQOigwLVlyOWLV\g\`XJEL_`LKJMxR`XghvxJijJR`Xz"Q{J\y¯RLVT `XH"J@L_zKkcVJMQOiR2QXJEJMghL"
LKJMxR`XghvxJijJR`{z"QXJ\n¨xgwkghdRQ{dh]`{O]`{H"JPdmR`X`{JMQM¯Ù<vxJMQS\Í¾pMtW¹2ÀT_JyVL"Ju\<\gwkghdRQ{ghòR2\[R½ZJMghWH_`{JT\z"k
Oi/Z<JEgh2H`XJuTRWQXJMJMgwL"ijJR`{z"QXJ\n¯"OiZ<JMgw2H`XJTijJR`Xz"Q{J\<O2LKdhgwL ¯"RL~TOi7Z<JMgw2H`XJTijJuR`XzKQXJ\[O2L"dw
gwL JEL_`{L"JMQo º.RQX2zKJ\y¯VH"OZ<JMvxJEQM¯x`XHVR`b`{H"gm\<k9JR2\z"QXJPg\<`XOxO9\gwk"dhg\`{gml2
}P\bOW"VOx\JuT `{O`{H"J xzVRL`Xgw`^R`{ghvxJ\ghk9ghdmRQXgw`kJRW\z"Q{J\y¯VkRL_ÍRK"QXOR2l^H"J\P`XOÍRL~RdhOW2@R2QXJEJ
gwLÕTJyVL"gwL"\ghkgwdmRQ{gh`{ghJE\ xzVRdwgh`SR`XgwvxJMdhÍRW\½RVRQ{`XgRd/gmT_JEL_`{ghÒi`XHKJ\O2z"QSlyJ RLVTB`{H"J`^RQ{2JM` ºxß"¯.òºV¯/pWpMr"¯/pyºWºx(¼"O2Qo`XH"J"z"Q{O\JOiRLVRdwO2WgmlMRd<ghLijJMQXJML~lyJcVR2\JTBOWLR2\July`^\Z<J9T_JyVL"J9`XH"J
|S\gwkghdRQXgw`ZQM¸`MRLRW\VJly` HKJMQXJRW\
/
" !$#&%'!(' ('
*F ¼"O2Q`XHKJR2\VJln` o¯,`Z<OO2c§XJuly`^\ RLVT RQXJ\ghk9ghdmRQ/ZQM¸`M g¾i
}P\`XH"JijO2dhdwOZ[ghL"@JM·KRk"dwJ\HKOZ\n¯[H"OZ<JMvxJMQE¯¨`{H"gm\9T_JyVL"gw`XgwO2LOio\gwkghdRQ{gh`@RdwO2L"J@T_OxJu\L"O2`
\zFlyghJML`XdwQ{J\`{QXgly`<`{H"JoRLVRdhO2WgmlMRdgwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJghLO2QST_JMQ[`{O"Q{OT_zVlyJC§XzV\`{g¾VJuTRLVRdhOW2ghJu\y
i`ZO@T_JMvgmlyJ\ ®RL~T %RWQXJMJgwLÕ`XH"JEgh*Q ),+,-$.,/10,2,34.C',)*+50 '*+,)-"¯À`XH"JMLÑgh`lERLcVJ
gwL_ijJMQ{QXJT@RLVRdhOW2gmlERdhdw>`{HVRò"QXJ\z"kRc"dhÍ`XH"JMgw7Q 6*+890=':/<;=8g\P`XH"J9\XRkJR2\Z<JMdwd((LÕlyOWkcKghLVR`XghOWL
Z[gw`XHL"OZ[ghL"Z[HVR`b`{H"Jbijz"L~ly`XgwO2LOi Õg\<dhghxJ¯*`{H"JR""QXO·ghkR`XJbijzKLVly`XgwO2LOi ®lMRLcVJghL_ijJMQ{QXJTÀ
çL`XHKJOW`XH"JEQ]HVRLVT¡¯[RLVRdwO22glMRdwdh@ghL_ijJEQXQXgwL">`{H">J 6*+890 '$/<;=8ijQXOWk RT_JMvgmlyJZ[gh`{HÕ`XHKJ>\{RkJ9`XH"J
0,;,3; )\JMJMk\/`XOcVJRLghdhdwJM2gw`XgwkR`{J[ghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJ
Ù<H"gm\JM·KRkKdhJ9lydhJRQXdw\H"OZ\`XHVR`Z<JL"JEJTRL"O2`{H"JMQghL"WQXJT_gwJML`]ijO2Q9RLVRdhO2WgmlMRdbQ{JR2\O2L"gwL""¯
L~RkJMdw\O2kJ_gwLVTOiQXJMdwJMvWRLVlyJ_L"OZ[dwJT_2J
@? 5ù b5ù ùú 2ü ù[ü»ú " ü )BADCFEG I H=JLK ! " õÿùú/û ù . &Mùÿ]öÏõMü»ùú -ú»ùü þ üj6ö nõ þ øújù þ ÿ ' 5ù 6nõ 1yû&ü Pü ù[ÿù .Wõöøüj6ö nõ
:A 9
pM¹
#
Ù<HKJB"Q{O2c"dwJMk g\\`{ghdwdbOWJEL,¯bOWL T_JnVL"ghLK×ijOWQZ[H"glH RLVT lMRL `{H"J@R2TKT_gh`{ghO2L~Rdo\gwkghdRQXgw`
A$JKA ; ]/cVJT_JEQXghvxJuT9ijQ{O2k²`XH"Jo_L"OZ[L@\ghkgwdmRQ{gh` A8J A ; ' ^Ù<H"g\b"Q{O2c"dwJMk°Z[R2\
RWT"T_Q{J\X\JTc_ÁbJu\X\Jò2¹,RLVTJMkKHVR2\ghYMJTc µzV\{\JMdwdÀRLVTO2`{H"JMQS\P¾pEt*s¯ÀpMò2"¯tW"¯¡pMÒW"¯r2t"¯"òW¹_¯KÒºV¯
tW¹"¯¡¹Wt2(Ù<H"JMÍRdwdgwL_vxJ\`XgwxR`{J`XH"JlyO2LVTgh`XgwO2LV\z"LVT_JMQZ[H"glHØRL@RL~RdhOW2glMRdfgwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJgm\[dhgwxJMdh`XO
cVJ E¬2ªn¢(Ü [¦ 2¯"`{H"JlyOWLVT_gw`XghOWLV\<`XH~R`["Q{OvgmTJPR`[dhJRW\`R]lnJMQX`SRghL9"QXOWcVRc"gwdhgwìjO2Q[`{H"JRLVRdwO22glMRd.lnO2L_
lndhzV\ghO2L9`XOcVJP`XQ{z"JxÙ<H"J\JolyOWLVT_gw`XghOWLV\¨cVJMdwO2L"o`XO`{H"JPcVRWl2Q{O2z"LVT_L"OZ[dwJT_2JzV\JTghLRLVRdwO22glMRd
Q{JR2\O2L"gwL"RLVT¡¯.H"JMLVlyJ¯x§XzV\`{g¾VJuTBRLVRdwO22glMRd/gwL_ijJMQXJELVlyJ]g\lyO2LV\gmT_JEQXJT>L"OZ[dhJT2Jy cVR2\JTO2"VOx\JT
`{OcKdhghL~T\ghkgwdmRQXgh`x(c~R2\JuTRLVRdwO22glMRd,gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJx
Ð>Ox\`PR`X`XJEk"`^\<`{OKghLTOZ[LØRLVTijO2Q{kRdwghYMJ/§Xz~\`Xg¿ÀlMR`XghOWLijOWQPRLVRdwO22glMRd.ghLijJMQXJML~lyJ\[RQ{JlyJEL_
`{JMQXJuTRQ{O2z"LVT\O2kJL"O2`{ghOWLOi.QXJMdwJMvWRLVlnJxf¼"O2QghLV\`^RLVlyJx¯"l^HVRLKT_JEvxJMdhOWJuTR]`{H"JMO2Q{Oi.JM·"dmRLVRu
`{ghOWLVR`{`XJMQ{LV\<`XOlMRK`Xz"Q{JP`XH"JQXJEdhJMvWRL~lyJµijOWQ<`{H"JPkR""ghLK½KQXOlyJ\{\P¿pMÒ2t2 [zV\X\JMdhd7¾pEÒ2À"QXJu\z"kJu\
TJM`XJMQ{kghL~R`XgwO2LV\.cJE`ZJMJML9R2\July`^\/`XO]cVJPWghvxJMLJM·"dhglygh`{dhPgwLR]TO2kRghL`XHKJMO2Q{ RQXcVOWL"JMdhd7ÒWtÀR2\(
\z"kJ\/\O lMRdwdhJT§XzV\`{g¾ÀlER`XgwO2LV\n¯_Q{JMdhJMvWRL_ìjOWQ[R"QXOWc"dhJMk \OWdhvghL"o"QXOlyJu\X\¨`{HVR`HVRMvxJ[`XOocJélH"JulxJT
gwLO2QST_JMQ.`XO/§XzV\`Xg¿ij]R"QXOWc"dhJMk \O2dwv_gwL"PcoRLVRdhO2Wx/(LlyOWk"z"`SR`{ghO2L~Rd\K\`{JMk\¡ijO2QRLVRdhOW2gmlERd"Q{JRu
\O2L"gwL"`XH"g\<QXJMdwJMvWRLVlyJ_L"OZ[dwJT_2JHVR2\[`XOcVJc"z"gwdh`<gwL@»ghk9"dhglygh`{d¾V^¯2gwvxJMLghLRTO2kRghL`XH"JEO2QX¯_O2Q
`{OcVJoJM·_Kdhgmlngh`Xdw]"Q{Ov_gT_JTghL`XHKJ½KQXO2cKdhJMkÚQ{JM"Q{J\JML`^R`XgwO2LOWQb"Q{O2c"dwJMk°\O2dhvghLKJM"gm\OT_J\n <JyijOWQXJ
ZJT_g\XlyzV\{\¨VRQX`{gmlyz"dRQlyOWk"z"`SR`XgwO2LVRdÀ\K\`XJEk\fghL`XH"JPLKJM·_`\Jly`XgwO2LghLk9O2QXJTJM`^Rghd(¯xZJbWdmRL~lyJR`
`VJ\<Oi/L"OZ[dhJuT_2J§XzV\`Xg¾ijghLKRL~RdhOW2Í`XHVR`[_gwJMdmTTg¾³ÀJMQXJEL_`[`Ju\<Oi7RLVRdhO2WgmlMRdgwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJx
pW Ó.Ó.Ä_å2âÊ VÓ ÈKæMÄ_ÇIÈKÓÈ"É "ÔÀÊ»åxÈ"ÉÊ»Ó¡Ë{ÄÅÄ_Ó.åxÄ
/«xÝ"Ý¦{y¢ Üm«xÝ*ªÍgm\_LKOZ[dwJT_WJB`{HVR`JMLVlnOT_J\>ªE«xì¦T_JMVJML~T_JMLVlyqOi9RL RW\VJly` ijQ{O2k RL
R2\VJln` T_JML"OW`XJTcÑ ( O2L"LKJly`XgwO2LV\.§XzV\`Xg¾ijFRLVRdhO2WgmlMRdfghLijJMQXJML~lyJ\¨`{O\O2kJJM·`XJEL_È
iRblyOWL"L"Jln`XghOWL Pxg\¡_LKOZ[L´¯2`XH"JEL]`XHKJ¨gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJ\Xl^H"JMkFR7ijO2Q E¬2ªn¢(Ü [¦ RLVRdhO2W]cVJlyOWkJ\n P
L CB ; B '
L CB ; B ' E {
Ù<H"JÍT_JM2Q{JMJOiQXJMdwgmRc"ghdwgh`>Oi`XH"Jo§XzV\`Xg¿ÀlMR`{ghOWLÕgm\]Q{J\VO2L~\ghcKdhJijO2Q`{H"J"QXOWcVRc"gwdhgw`@Oié`XH"J
R2Q{JMJMkJEL_Òi RLVTÀ¯¨`{H_zV\n¯ijO2Qo`XH"JQXJEdhgmRc"ghdwghÒi`XH"J9QXJ\z"dh
` E ^¼"O2Q
RL R2\VJln` o¯ oRLVT béRQXJ@`XQ{ghvgmRdlyO2LKL"Jly`{ghO2L~\y¯bZ[HKJMQXJ`{H"JBdR`{`XJMQg\`XH"J
lyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2LcVJM`ZJMJML`XH"JPOvxJMQSRdwd¡TJ\XlyQ{gh"`{ghOWL @OiRLO2c§XJln`<RLVT`XH"JéR2\VJln` o/Ù<H"J\J
`XQXgwv_gRdVlnO2L"L"July`XgwO2LV\fTO½LKO2`lMRQ{QXRL§XzV\`{g¾ijghL"ghL_ijOWQXkR`XgwO2L,¯xRLVTH"JMLVlyJ[ZJ[JM·KlydhzVTJ<`XHKJMk
ghL`XH"JPijOWdhdhOZ[gwL""
7k9"dhOghL"P`{H"gm\/\{lH"JEkRµijO2Q/VLVT_gwL"]`{H"JT_J\XlnQXghK`XghOWLOi.R2ghvxJELWOxRd´R2\July
` ijOWQ[R`^RQ{2JM`
dhJRWT"\<`XO`XHKJéijOWdhdwOZ[gwL""Q{OlyJT_z"Q{Jx JM`RlyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWL@ b
bù .- " ü þ üj6ö nõ þ W&û 'Mûjüj2ù û ,n&ú ,öÏü ÿ þ öøõü 5ù nú»öøùûfü Wþ ü,'ù &-øö öÏ&ü 6' yõEü þ öøõ yõõù üj6ö nõû 2ù 9 1 9666 ! 9 ùP&û 'Eû»üj5ù bû ù 9 1 96 #% %$ !5ù -6'
þ ûjû " ùÿ yõõù ü»6ö nõû nü ùújû .ù 9 1%9 "! ! " û»ù
'ù &-øö öÏ&ü 6' n&ú " þ üjùÿ nõõù üj6ö yõû.û "
éþ û ?$#&%'# < % 7 & 8 (2( 9 ù,û 'Mû»üj5ù bû 20!ù÷yùõ 1nùõùú þ üjù yõõù üj6ö nõû
þ nü¡õú õ" ù õb üjüjö66ö yõ ù ùùü9 1 ¡96ù ù õ' ü ,y 7ü 7þ -û-2újöøù õM üjü»öøû.õ 1fü Wü þ
ü ù þ hú»ù ùþ ü ú»" ù5új-ùú»û¡ùûjújù2ù õMÏùü»÷ ùþÿ õMü '[nü ú ,þ / ûjùùú»üjü û"þ öøA'õ + 1þ þõ7ÿ-9,.& Mù+ ùfûj"ù õüjM6ö ÿnõùû, öø9#õ ( þ ùõú ù '[" ú ÿþ *ö )xõùújùùü õE &ü 6' " øÿ þ
ùúj5ù -ú»ùûjùõEü»ùÿ '/'ù & öøü»öÏõ 14øöÏõ Eû ùü ¡ùùõü ù,õ Mÿù,û ,A'+ þ õÿ[ü ù,õ Mÿùû )/,.+ 9 # " ü¡ü öøûVöøû 5ù 'yõÿ[ü ùújù þ 6
Vü öøû Wþ -üjùú 9
ps
[ JM`{QXghJEvxJPR\O2z"QSlyJ @ijO2Q[Z[H"glH ¼"O2Q[`XHKgm\gh`gm\<dwghxJMdw`XHVR`

JM`- »Z[H"glHgm\<L"OZ[L¡S
Ù.RxJ [RW\µ`{H"JoR"KQXO·_gwkR`{J E S
6 ²»i`XH"JlMRQ 3; ZCR2\["QXOTzVlyJTghLÕpEr2rW_¯¡`{HVR`gh`S\<kRxJPg\bÁO2LVT"RM gwv_gl2¯VRL~T
`XHVR`]gh`S\P"QXglyJ gm\pEt_¯øW2ø2 Ð xO2zZO2z"dT gwL_ijJMQoRL~RdhOW2glMRdwdh>`{HVR`RlMRQ H; !@Z[H"glH
Z[R2\"Q{OT_zVlyJuTghLápMrWr2RL~T `{H"J>kRxJOiZ[HKgml^Hgm\ÁbOWLVT"Ru ghvgml>ZO2z"dT"QXOWcVRcKdhIlnOx\`
RcVO2z"`pMt_¯Ï2W_øW PÐÕVÙ<H"JQ{JMdhJMvWRLVlyJPL"OZ[dhJT2J`XHVR`f§Xz~\`Xg¿VJ\<`{H"gm\<VRQX`{gmlyz"dRQRLVRdwO22glMRd
ghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJg\`{H"JlyOWL"L"Jln`XghOWLá PcVJM`Z<JMJEL »`{H"J>kFRxJÍRLVTxJuRQOioRÕlERQyRLVTgw`^\
"QXglyJ
"âÈ"É[å VÓ.ÓÄå2âÊ Ó.æ
i IgwLVlydwzVT_J\£2íhí2`{H"J[ghLijO2QXkFR`XgwO2LoQXJMdwJMvWRL``{O ¯2`XHKJML`XH"JlnO2L"L"July`XgwO2LÍ Pxijz"dhdw[§XzV\`Xg¿VJ\
`XH"JRLVRdwO2WgmlMRd<ghLijJMQXJML~lyJxÙ<H"JMLÕ`{H"JRLVRdwO22ÑlMRLÕcVJJM·July`XJT>`{O>ghJMdTBRÍlyO2Q{QXJln`½vWRdhz"J
E ^/Ù<H"JMQ{JyijO2Q{Jx¯_`{H"Jo\Xl^H"JMkRgm\<`{H"JML
¯. P

E
6 ¼"z"LVly`{ghO2L~RdT_JMVJMLVTJMLVlygwJ\PghLÑT"R`SRcVRW\J\9¾pMtWß2RQXJ9`XO2`SRdlyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWLV\y¼"O2Q
]8 ; ; ; ; 6E ;*J 8 ; ? B A E M ; 8 ; ? J 6E $ ; ÍRLVT 8 B L ; 1L 6E $ B P.gm\R`XOW`^RdlyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWL,P}bL@RLVRdwO2WgmlMRdfghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJPzV\gwL"`{H"gm\PlnO2L_
L"Jly`{ghO2LÑlyOWLVlydhz~T_J\bijO2QoJEQ^\OWLV\X RL~T Z[H"gml^H@HVRMvxJ`XH"J\{RkJdR2\`]LVRkJx¯¡c"gwQX`{HVT"RMx¯
RLVTkO2`{H"JMQ<`{OH~RuvxJ`XH"Jo\XRkJVR2\{\VO2Q{`PLz"kcVJMQE
¼~OWQR½Q{J\`{QXgmln`XJTR2\July`[QXJMKQXJ\JML_`SR`{ghO2LcR`XO2k9gml<ijO2QXkz"dR2\ o$ ; ; xfZ[gw`XHR½V·JT
"QXJTgmlMR`XJ o¯ µzV\{\JMdwd/¿pMÒ22.TJyVL"J\<`{O2`SRd.lyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWLV\y¯VlMRdhdwJT`XOW`^RdfT_JE`XJMQ{kghLVR`XgwO2LV\n¯*cÀ )9 !) ) MHE JKA g¿³
o ?
] XXS¯<Z[H"JMQ{J IRQ{J>`XzK"dhJ\]Oi
v2RQXgRc"dwJ\y
µzV\{\JMdwd[¿pMÒWRQXWz"J\b`{HVR`T_JM`{JMQXk9ghLVR`XghOWLV\[RQ{J]ZJRxJMQ[L"OZ[dhJuT_2J`XH~RLghk9"dhglMR`{ghO2L~\<RL~T
QXJM"Q{J\JEL_`S\<`XH"JZ<JuRL"J\X\<cT_JnVL"ghLK" MHE J A %g¾³
' o {XbijOWQRQXJMdR`XgwO2L %Z[H"glH
QXJMdR`XJu\]`XH"JÍv2Rdhz"Ju\]Oi `XO@`XH"JvWRdwz"J\]Oi IxghLVlnJ Úg\L"OW`\VJlyg¾~JTRLVT¡¯/`XHzV\n¯<L"O2`
O2VJMQ^R`XgwO2LVRdhghYEJT¡¯`{H"gm\T_JnVL"gh`{ghOWLBOi M3E JKA gm\PZ<JRxJMQ`XHVRLÕ`XH~R`]Oi`XH"Jghk9"dhglMR`{ghO2L
' o X^
Ù<H"JT_JyVLKgh`XgwO2LoOi´RP`XO2`SRdVTJM`XJMQ{kghL~R`XgwO2LPg\ xz"gh`{J[\`{QXOWL""¯\gwLVlyJgh`T_OxJ\L"OW`RdhdwOZBijO2QfJE·"lyJE_
`XghOWLV\fRLVT]QXJ xz"gwQXJ\¡`{OP_LKOZqRdhdx`XHKJ[ghL_ijOWQXkR`XghOWL`XHVR`/T_JM`{JMQXkgwL"J\ QSR`XHKJMQ`{HVRLOWL"dho\O2kJ
ghL VzKJMLVlyJ\ ¨ghLVlyJJM·"dhglygh`,`{O2`^RdVT_JM`{JMQXk9ghLVR`XghOWLV\,RQ{J[Q^RQXJMdw]RMvWRgwdmRc"dhJghLTO2kRghL]`{H"JMOWQXghJu\y¯
ö " ú»ûjù " øÿPújù 1 " öøújù þ Eÿö. {þ ü»ö yõ "ü 4
ù " ü !ù "ü ù þ õ þ 61yö Xþ 2öÏõ wùújùõ ù 9
pMß
µzV\{\JMdwd(ÎÏ\bR""QXOR2l^HBH~R2\PcVJMJML@\zKc§XJly``XOlyQ{gh`{gmlyg\kÚkRghL"dwcVJlMRzV\JOi<gw`^\bdwghkgw`^R`XghOWLV\ïjO2Q
`XH"Jo\XlnO2VJ]OiRLVRdhOW2gmlERd,QXJuR2\OWL"ghLK"
Ù<H"J\`{QXOWL"2J\`\JulygmRd<lER2\JOi`{O2`SRd[lnO2L"L"July`XgwO2LV\RQ{Jghk9"dhglMR`{g¾OWLVRdlyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWLV\]T_JnVL"JT
R2\y P,g¿³ ! ¡' o ¡ X/ijO2QRT_O2kFRghL9`XH"JMOWQX
NéJuT"RQ RcJEdhdhgoøsMºW[JM·_`{Q^RWly`^\ghk"dwgmlMR`XgwO2LVRd/lyO2LKL"Jly`{ghO2L~\»JM·"dmRLVR`{ghOWLV\c f·"dmRLVR`{ghOWL
[R2\JuT JML"JMQSRdhgwYR`{ghOWL>ijQXO2k RÍT_O2kFRghL`{H"JMOWQX 9Ù<H"J9RLVRdhO2WgmlMRd/ghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJu\bcVR2\JTBOWL
ghk"dwgmlMR`XgwO2LVRd¡lnO2L"L"July`XgwO2LV\[lMRL>cVJoT_J\{lyQXgwcJuTFc`XH"Jo\Xl^H"JMkFR_ o E V' o X
E
abO2`{J[`XHVR`¨gwk"dwgmlMR`XghOWLVRdRLVRdwO2WgmlMRdQ{JR2\O2L"gwL""QXOvgmT_Ju\_LKOZ[dwJT_WJ[`XHVR`<lnO2z"dT]cJ[gwL_ijJMQ{QXJT
T_JT_zVln`XghvxJEdhRW\]Z<JMdwd(¯.Z[H"gml^HBg\]\O2kJM`{ghkJu\bL"O2òQXJMRQST_JTR>"QXOWVJMQRLVRdwO22glMRd[Q{JR2\O2L"gwL""
k9"dhglMR`{ghO2L~RdKRLVRdhO2Wx¯_HKOZJMvxJMQE¯kRM"Q{OvgmTJPRc"c"QXJEv_gR`XgwO2LV\fOi.T_JTzVly`XgwvxJ<Q{JR2\O2L"gwL"]"Q{O
lyJT_z"Q{J\RLVTI`XHzV\\XR`Xg\ VJ\O2L"J@Oi`XH"J@RWT_vWRL`^R2JMOWzV\ijJR`{z"QXJu\FOiRLVRdwO22À gwLVlyQXJuR2\gwL"
J lnghJMLVlnx
yÓ.å Vä .ÉjÄ*âÄ9å Ó.Ó.Ä_å2âÊ VÓæ
Ù<Z<OghLVTK\µOi<LKO2L_ `XOW`^Rd ¯¡`XH~R`gm\y¯VghL~lyO2kKdhJM`{JlyO2LKL"Jly`{ghO2L~\µJM·gm\`M¯"z"L~lyJMQX`SRgwLRL~T>OvxJEQX2JEL_
JMQ^RdlyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2LV\nÕÙ<H"JÍRLVRdwO22glMRd[gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJijO2QÍÜmÝ"^«xìbîVíw¦^¢¦lnO2L"L"July`XgwO2LV\9 [zV\z~Rdhdw
QXJ xz"ghQ{J\\zKcV\J xz"JML`kOT_g¿ÀlMR`XghOWLÕOié`XH"JO2zK`^lyOWkJxÕÐRL_×lyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2LV\]gwLH_z"kFRLÕQ{JRu
\O2LKghL"9RQ{gm\JijQXO2k JM·_VJMQ{ghJML~lyJRLVTÀ¯"`XH"JMQ{JyijO2Q{Jx¯_`{H"JMJM·"QXJ\{\¡§XzV\`R]`XJML~T_JMLVlyOWL"dh/ÁbJMLVlyJ¯
`XH"J\J[lyOWL"L"Jln`XghOWLV\,HVRMvxJ<RlyJMQ{`^RghLoT_JMWQXJMJ/Oi~"QXOWcVRc"gwdhgw``XHVR`/lMRz~\J\.RLoz"LVlyJMQ{`^RghL`[ijO2Q`XH"J
lyO2Q{QXJ\OWLVT_gwL"RLVRdwO22glMRdKghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJÙ<HKJ\Xl^H"JMkRïjOWQ<RLVRdwO2WgmlMRd"ghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJ<Z[gh`{Hz"LVlyJEQX`^RghL
lyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2LV\[gm\n P
L CB ; B '
L CB ; B E
6 Ù<H"JlyOWL"L"Jln`XghOWLOikOWL_`{H>RLVT>Z<JuR`XHKJMQbg\bz"LVlnJMQX`SRghL´PÁbJML~lyJPijO2QP`{H"J\{RkJ
kO2L`XHqghLápMrWß2RL~T pMr2rxsÕ`{H"J\{RkJÍZ<JR`XH"JMQFlMRLIcVJ>gwL_ijJMQ{QXJTqRLVRdhO2WgmlMRdhdwZ[gh`{HI\O2kJ
"QXOWcVRc"gwdhgw`9O2L"dwx
}%lyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2L× g\]«xê¦n¤»¥_¦Ý¦n¤X£2í_ijOWQRL@RLVRdwO2WgmlMRdfghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJ½g¿i/O2LKdhÍR\gwkghdRQ{ghÒi
RLVT ZQE`M lMRLcJ\`SR`XJuT>RL~T FB J +\ghLKRLOvxJMQ{2JMLKJMQ^Rd.lyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2L
¡kRxJ\/\JML~\Jg¾iR]kOWQXJ\VJlyg¿ÀlPlyOWL"L"Jln`XghOWL@ g\<L"O2`[L"OZ[L,/Ù<H"JELÕ ¡\`Xgwdhd
"QXOvgmT_J\[\O2kJ7§XzV\`{g¾ÀlMR`XgwO2L,
Ù<H"JbgT_JML`XgwÒi ØRLVT ZQE`M.RLR2\July` \z"cV\z"kJT]c T_OxJ\f2zVRQ^RL_`{JMJPRLgT_JML`Xgw`
Oi qRLVT Z¸QM¸`M\OWkJRW\VJly` `{HVR`gm\ \zKcV\z"k9JTc O2L"dw>QSR`XHKJMQP`XH~RL@ZQM¸`M
Ù<H_zV\n¯RLVRdhO2WgmlMRdbgwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJ\cVR2\JTO2LqOvxJMQXWJML"JMQSRdlyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWLV\]HVRMvxJ>`{H"JÍT_Q^RMZ[cVRWl`XO
3 <.û-2ù ü»û {þ õ ù öøùú þ ú ö {þ 6' yú 1 þ õ\ö [ùÿ 'ü ùfúj5ù þ ü»6ö n
õ 59
A!"$#&% A('ö 9A(CFEG*) A(' CFEG¡öøû þ ü )þ " ü 61' yú þ 6,E 9
# & þ .-øù !7 ù þ &û -Wù ,
ü +.-0/12.3 45/6 ,ü ù þ û -2ù 8ü 7941;: <0=7>4?=;3@/A +.-B/"12.3 4/
pMr
cJdwJ\X\[QXJEdhgmRc"dhJ`{HVRL`{H"Ox\JcVR2\JT>O2L`{O2`^Rd/lyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWLV\y¼~OWQPRLOvxJMQXWJML"JMQSRdlyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2L
(¯_ijOWQ J ¯VRLVTijOWQP\O2kJ j`XHVR`PkghWH_`L"O2`JMvxJMLcVJ]JE·_"dwgmlygw`Xdw_L"OZ[L¡
Z[gh`XH FB J B `{H" JR L~RdhOW2glMRd"gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVly JlMRL_gwJMdmT E Ó2L"dwx.Ù<H"gm\k9JRLV\,gh`lMRL
_gwJMdmTRLR""QXO·ghkR`XJ E /OWL"dh/Ù<H"JghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJé\Xl^H"JMkRPijO2Q[OvxJMQXWJML"JMQSRd´lyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2LV\
gm\y ¯.

L CB ; B E
6 (L`{H"JPc"gwO2L"glbJM·KRkKdhJ[ijQXO2k \July`XgwO2LpPZJPHVRMvxJb`{H"JolyO2LKL"Jly`{ghO2L "ijO2Q ' 6*/+,85Z[0 H"'$gl/<H; 8]g\bR\LVz"+T cV\zKk J.CT'*c_),+90=6,'*+,+*85)F0 -K': /1Ñ; 8¡R.LV}bT LØIRRW2QXQ{JMJMJMJPk9gwJMLL_`{`/H"OJMi ghQ q. +5RLV;,T0 2:lMR.1L>; )O2:LK/ dh8 cV6,J½+,gw89L_0=ijJM':Q{/1QXJ; T8
ijO2Q \OWkJ[T_Ju\XlyQ{gh"`{ghO2L \z"cV\z"kJTc_ . '*)*+50 ',+*)-<QSR`XHKJMQf`XH~RLijO2Q/`XH"J[Z[HKO2dhJ .C'*),+90='*+*)F-K
Ò bÆÊjåxÈ"É ^ÊjÓænâÈ"Ó.åxÄ/ È"æEÄ_ÇqÈ"ÓÈKÉ"ÔÀÊ»åxÈKÉ<ÊjÓ´Ë{ÄÅÄ_Ó.åxÄ
e¨\"l^H"OWdhO2WgmlMRd¡gwL_vxJ\`XgwxR`{ghOWLV\¨"Q{Ov_gT_JTJMv_gT_JMLVlnJb`{HVR`[`"gmlMRdVghLV\`^RL~lyJ\<RQXJP`{H"JP"Q{JyijJMQ{QXJT
\O2zKQ^lyJ\<ijO2QéRLRLVRdwO2WgmlMRdQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"Z[HKJMQXJ\O2zKQ^lyJRLVT`^RQ{2JM`RQ{J]gwLV\`SRLVlyJu\µOi/`XH"Jo\{RkJ
lMR`{JM2OWQX%G@JPlMRL"L"OW`<JM·"dmRghL`{H"gm\f"Q{JyijJMQXJELVlyJ<cghL`XJEQX"Q{JM`XgwL"P`XHKOx\JRL~RdhOW2glMRdÀghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJu\
R2\.lyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2L_ cVRW\JTghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJu\y¯MZ[gh`{H |XcVJMdwO2L"WghL"`XO`XHKJ<\{RkJ7lydmRW\X\X<ijO2QRlyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2L
(Ù<H"J[lyOWL"L"Jln`XghOWL_ cVR2\JTRLVRdhOW2gmlERdghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJT_JnVL"JToRcVOvxJT_OxJ\L"OW`JE·_"dRgwL]Z[H]R
`"glMRdWghLV\`^RL~lyJ<kRM["Q{JyijJMQSRc"dw\JMQ{vxJ/R2\,`XHKJ<\O2z"QSlyJxÁbJMLVlyJ¯MZ<JfL"JEJTRb\Julyg¾Àl/RLVRdwO22glMRd
ghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJcVRW\JTOWL`_KgmlMRdgwLV\`SRLVlnJ\y/}bL9R`{`XJMk9"`Þsò¡`{O½ijO2Q{kRdwghYMJRLVRdwO2WgmlMRd¡ghLijJMQXJML~lyJ
cVR2\JTOWL`"gmlERdVghLV\`^RLVlyJ\<zV\J\[RlyOWL_`{JM·_`(gwLVT_JMVJML~T_JML`¨`"gmlERdhgw`Q^R`{ghL" ghL`XQXOTzVlyJT
ghLI\Jly`{ghO2LÒ_ÏÒÕR2\RBVRQX`XgRdO2QST_JMQQXJMdR`XgwO2LqghLIlnO2LVlyJE"`\`XQ{zVly`XzKQXJ\ áRLVT`XHKJ>QXJEdhJMvWRL~lyJ
_L"OZ[dwJT_2J| ágm\<QXJEdhJMvWRL`<ijO2Q[`{H"J`_"glMRdÀghLV\`^RLVlyJR2\T_JyVL"JuTFLKJM·_`E
®}bLoR2\VJln` gm\,lMRdhdwJT¤¦Síh¦nêM£xÝ_¢¡ijOWQ.RLghLV\`^RLVly(J »Z[QXgw`X`{JMLR2\ ; E áX
g¾³ C[,gm\[`XQ{z"JoRLVTijOWQPRdhd,gwLV\`SRLVlyJu\ VZ[gh`{H HKO2dmTK\µ`{HVR` Cø
gm\<JMgw`XH"JM9Q '*)*+F-OWQ +,8 - 6$/ 8F-V
Ù<H"JQXJMdwJMvWRLVlyJghLijO2QXkFR`XgwO2Lz~\JTHKJMQXJTg¾³ÀJMQ^\fijQXOWkÚ`XH"JQXJMdwJMvWRLVlyJL"OZ[dhJT_WJR2\{\z"k9JTijO2Q
`XH"JØlyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2L_ cVRW\JTIRLVRdwO22glMRdghLijJMQXJML~lyJ\yqÙ<H"g\L"OZ[dhJT2J>VJMQ{kgh`S\½`{ORLVRdhOW2gmlERdhdw
ghL_ijJMQ áijO2QR`SRQ{2JM` áRLVTR\OWz"Q^lnJ g¾i qRLVT ECL ,' /^Ù<H"g\b2gwvxJ\µQ{gm\J]`XO9`XH"J
ghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJé\Xl^H"JMkR
E L , ¨ ; E /

E
Z[H"JMQXJ ijO2Q9R@lMR`{JM2OWQX JEL_`SRghd\RB\ghkgwdmRQXgh`ÍcJE`ZJMJML`XHKJ>`_KgmlMRd<ghL~\`^RLVlyJ RLVTÕ`XHKJgwLV\`SRLVlnJ ½ µJMk9JMkcVJMQR2\]z~\zVRdhdh¯fRLqRLVRdwO22glMRd[gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJcVR2\JTÕO2L`_KgmlMRd
ghLV\`^RL~lyJ\¨g\<lyOWL_VQ{kJTO2L"dwg¾i.gh`S\fQXJ\z"dh`CT_OxJ\¨LKO2`lyOWL_`{Q^R2Tgmly`/`XHKJP_LKOZ[dwJT_WJbgwL_ijJMQ^Rc"dhJ[ijO2Q
`XH"J`^RQXWJM`bcT_JuT_zVly`{ghO2L´
6 }bLJM·"Rk"dwJijO2Q.`XH"J`_"glMRdxgwLV\`SRLVlnJy(c~R2\JuT]RL~RdhOW2glMRdghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJ¨g\y ,»i <JEQXdhgwL
gm\R`_KgmlMRdflygw`x¯¡RLVTgh`^\`XQ^RLV\VOWQX`^R`XgwO2L\"\`XJMk²ghLVlydwzVT_J\RLz"LVTJMQXWQXO2zKLVT¡¯cKzV\X\J\y¯.RL~T
Ò2
`^R·gm\n¯xRL~T½g¾i <JMQXdwghLPg\ `{H"J/`"glMRdxJM·KRk9"dhJ,ijO2Q[O2k9JfghLo`XH"JlMR`XJMWO2QXgwJ\,OiÀlygw`XgwJ\f»g Jxw¯µOWkJ
gm\\ghkgwdmRQ`XO <JMQXdwghL¡S¯<`XH"JEL µOWkJxÎø\`XQSRLV\VO2QX`SR`{ghO2L \K\`XJEk ghL~lydhzVTJ\RL zKLVT_JMQ{2QXOWz"LVT¡¯
c"zV\X\J\y¯ÀRL~T`^R·_g\<`XOxOK
7k9"dhOghL"o`XH"J %\Xl^H"JMkR`XOVLVT`{H"JoT_J\{lyQXgw"`XgwO2LOiR2ORdR2\July` ijOWQR`SRQ{2JM` `XHVR`bg\[RL>gwLV\`SRLVlnJ½Oi/RlMR`XJMWO2QXÕghJMdT"\¨`{H"JPijO2dwdhOZ[ghL"KQXOlyJTz"QXJx JM`R`_KgmlMRdgwLV\`SRLVlnJ Z[gw`XH
HKJlZ[H"JM`{H"JM-Q ág\<QXJMdwJMvWRL`ïjO2Q
Ù.RxJ R2-\ Z[H"glH92ghvxJu\ E ^
t,ÊjäÊ»ÉjÈ"ÅÊ¶â^Æ ÈKæMÄ_ÇÑÈ"ÓÈKÉ "ÔÀÊ»åxÈKÉ<ÊjÓ´Ë{ÄÅÄ_Ó.åxÄ
i½RLIRLVRdwO2WgmlMRdPghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJgm\O2L"dwcVR2\JTOWLI`XH"JØRkOWz"L_ÒiJM·gm\`XghLK@\ghk9ghdmRQXgwÒio`XH"J
OvxJEQ^RdwdfTJ\XlyQ{gh"`{ghOWLV\µOi`XH"J\O2z"QSlyJx¯ÀT_JML"OW`XJT>c`XH"JRW\VJly` <¯´RLVTR`SRQ{2JMÈ¯¡`XH"JELqÝ"«
E¬ªn¢ Ü ^£2¢ Üm«xÝBgm\]ghL~lydhzVTJT¡(L_`{JMQXKQXJM`{ghL"Í`XH"g\lMR2\J>RW\OWL"J>Z[gw`XHqRLqz"L"gT_JML`Xg¾~JTBQXJEdhJMvWRL`
R2\VJln`¨dwJR2TK\7`{O`XH"J[vghJMZ`{HVR`\OWkJ[RW\VJly`lyOWz"dmTcVJ[QXJMdwJMvWRL`f`XO IJEvxJML]g¿i¡`{H"JlyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2L
gm\L"OW`/_L"OZ[LJM·"dwgmlygw`Xdh¡Ù<H"g\kJRLV\,`XHVR`/RPlyOWkkO2L~Rdhgw`bOi¡dRQ{2J[VRQX`^\fOi \JMQXvxJ\,`XO
ghLVlyQ{JR2\J`XH"JdhgwxJMdhgwH"OxOT`{HVR``XH"JQ{JMdhJMvWRL_`RW\VJly`Z[ghdwd¡cVJghLVlydwzVT_JTghL`XO`XH"JolyOWkkO2L~Rdhgw`
¾p2pEr"¯¡sß2 ¯"RL~T`XHKgm\<2gwvxJ\<`XHKJ]\{lHKJMkR_ w
lydhO\J `{O ¨
nà L CB ; B '
L CB ; B E
(LVT_JMJTÀ¯¡\ghkgwdmRQ{gh`x(cVRW\JTRLVRdwO22glMRdghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJoHVR2\POij`XJMLcVJMJMLgwk"dwJMkJEL_`{JMTRdw`XH"OWz"2H@gh`gm\
`{H"JdhJRW\`§XzV\`{g¾VJuT`_VJOiRLVRdwO2Wx
. # Ù<HKJL"O2`{ghO2LOiC\ghk9ghdmRQXgw`LKJMJT"\[`XOcVJJM·`XJELVT_JTcVJlMRzV\J`{H"J\ghkgwdmRQ{ghÒi%RLVT ZQM¸`M`XH"J
RW\VJly` g\éOij`XJML@ijO2z"LVTÕckRK"ghL"ÍlyOWLV\`SRL`^\»ghL~lydhzVTghL"ijz"LVln`XghOWLV\]RLVTÕQXJMdR`{ghO2L~\Oi `XO
lnO2LV\`^RL`^\<Oi ½}PlMlyOWQ^T_gwL"2dwx¯xkz~lHoOi`XH"JZ<OWQXO2LRLVRdwO229HVR2\ïjOlyz~\JTOWLVLVTghL"ªEëWìÛ^«2í ¢ «
ªEëWìÛ^«2íkFR""gwL"x\.cJE`ZJMJML ¦ bQXJM"Q{J\JEL_`SR`XgwO2LV\.Oi,`{H"J\O2zKQ^lyJRLVT`XHKJb`SRQXWJM`(\JMJ\Jln`XghOWLº"ÏÒ*^
¼"OWQ½gwLV\`SRLVlnJx¯f¸ò2/\z"KOWQX`S\é`{H"JkR""ghLKcÍRL |^RL~RdhOW2glMRd/H"gwL_`SRLVTBlnO2LV\`XQ^RghL`^\bgw`P`XO9cJR
~RQX`[OilyJMQ{`^RgwLB|SRcV\`XQSR2ly`{ghO2L~\X_GIghLV\`XO2L ¾pMòpM,\`XQXJu\X\JuT`XH"JkR""ghLK½OiP|{ghkVOWQX`^RL_`SPQXJMdR`XgwO2LV\
cVJM`ZJMJML@T_J\{lyQXgw"`XgwO2LV\n¯,Z[H"JMQXJuR2\ JML`XL"JEQ ºxfJMk"H~R2\gwYMJT`XH"JkR""gwL"cVJM`Z<JMJELQXJMdR`XgwO2LV\QXJy
dR`{JT]c_|{H"ghWH"JMQ O2QST_JMQfQ{JMdmR`XgwO2LV\{P\zVl^HRW\P|Xghk9"dhgwJ\X[RLVT>|^lMRzV\Ju\X_<çZJML,Îø\.RL~RdhOW2gwL]`XHKJMO2Q{JMk
KQXOv_gwL"¿pMWr2JEk"dhOK\ JE·_`{JMLV\gwO2LV\/Oi.kR""gwL"x\fOi \kcVOWdm\fOlMlyz"Q{QXgwL"]gwL`{H"JP\O2z"QSlyJP`{H"JMO2Q{JMk%`XO
`{H"Ox\J]OlMlnz"QXQ{ghL"ghL`{H"J`^RQX2JE`b`{H"JMO2Q{JMk°RLVT`{H"JMghQCR2\{\z"kK`XghOWLV\y
(`¡`XzKQXLV\,O2z"`,`{HVR`.`XHKJ/\kcVOWd2kR""ghLK"¯M2JEL"JMQ^RdhdwPRWlMlyJM"`{JTbijO2Q.RLVRdwO22glMRdxgwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJx¯ngm\¡OWL"dhR
\VJlygmRdVlMRW\J[OiÀQ{JyijO2Q{kz"dR`{ghO2L~\y¯M`XH~R`\H"OWz"dmT]cVJ[gwLVlydhz~T_JT½gwL_`{Ob`{H"JRL~RdhOW2glMRd"gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJx.Ù<H"J/i R2ly`
`{HVR``XH"JClyO2kk9O2LVRdhgh`{ghJ\"Oi¡`{H"J[\O2z"QSlyJRL~T½`XHKJ[`^RQ{2JM`RQ{J[L"O2`.L"JlnJ\X\{RQXgwdhJM·"dhglygh`{dh[Q{JM"QXJu\JML`XJTÀ¯
cKz"`HVRMvxJ]`XOcVJQXJEvxJRdwJT¡¯V\zK22Ju\`^\`XH"JoghL`XQ{OT_zVly`{ghO2LOiRl^HVRL"2JOi[QXJE"QXJ\JML`^R`{ghOWL>OiCO2c§XJln`^\
gwL_`{OQXJyijOWQXkz"dmR`XghOWL, f·"Rk"dhJu\ ijO2Q/H"OZ T_g¿³¡JEQXJML`fQXJE"QXJ\JML`^R`{ghOWLV\fkRM]H"gT_JR]lyOWkkOWLVRdwgh`RQ{Jx Ò_p
} `{ghkJØT_J\XlnQXghK`XghOWL lMRL cVJBWghvxJMLIgwL `{JMQXkF\OiH"O2z"QS\O2Q>gwLI`XJMQ{k\OikOWQXL"gwL""¯[L"OxOWL,¯
uR ij`XJEQXL"OxOWL,¯JEvxJML"ghLK"¯"RLVTLKgh2H` ¨JEdhOlygw`ÍlMRLcVJT_J\XlnQXghcVJTghL`{JMQXk\[OikgwdhJ\<VJMQH"O2z"QéR2\PZ<JMdwdfRW\PghL>`{JMQXkF\µOi<ghdwO2kJE`XJMQ
JEQbH"OWz"QM
xghL~lyJ<ZJRQXJ[gwL_`{JMQXJu\`XJuT½ghL§Xz~\`Xg¿VJTRLVRdwO22glMRdKghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJu\y¯Z<JlyOWLV\gT_JMQf`{H"Ox\JbQ{JyijO2Q{kz"dR`{ghO2L~\
OWL"dh`{HVRò"QXJu\JMQ{vxJ]`XHKJlyOWL"L"Jln`XghOWLI /R`HVRLVT¡} l^HVRL"WJOi[Q{JM"QXJu\JML`^R`XghOWLBc>kFR""gwL"
RijO2Q{kz"dR`{OÍRFdwO2WgmlMRdhdhJ xz"gwv2RdhJML`[ijO2QXkz"dRR2\PZ<JEdhdR2\½`{OÍR9ijOWQXkz"dmRJ xz"ghvWRdhJML`bZ[gw`XH@QXJ\VJly`
`{ORT_OWkRgwL`XH"JMOWQX RLVTÕlnJMQX`SRghL@RcV\`{Q^RWly`XgwO2LV\cJEdhO2LK`{O`XH"J9R2T_k9gm\X\ghc"dwJ]Q{JyijO2Q{kz"dR`{ghO2L~\
TJyVL"JTc¡ /
!) !)
, QXJyijOWQXkz"dwR`XgwO2LV\RQXJkR""ghLKx\ OiOWc§XJly`
TJ\XlyQ{gh"`{ghOWLV\<`XOO2c§XJln`[QXJM"Q{J\JEL_`SR`XgwO2LV\/Z[H"gml^H"QXJu\JMQ{vxJP`XH"JolyOWL"L"Jln`XghOWLÑ (
pW}bcV\`{Q^RWly`XgwO2L
UVJM` cJ`XH"JRW\VJly`CT_J\{lyQXgwc"ghL"o`XgwkJ»gwL`{JMQXk\fOi.H"O2z"QS\[RLVTkgwL_zK`XJ\^.RLVTT"RM Oi ZJMJMÀ
Ù<H"JÍR2\VJln` ²T_J\XlnQXghcVJ\Z[H"JM`{H"JMQ`XHKJ\`{O2QXJu\RQXJO2VJMLghL JMQ{kRLxÙ<H"JELJuR2l^HÕQXJyijOWQ
kz"dR`{ghO2L ÕkFR""gwL"@RB`{ghkJcVJM`ZJMJMLqr_Ï2ÕRLVT pWp2øWB`XO®|XkOWQXL"gwL"x¯[R `{ghkJ9cJE`ZJMJML
p2p2Ï_pÍRLVT pMtø2`XOI|{L"OxO2L~_¯R `{ghkJcVJM`ZJMJMLIpEt_øp>RLVT pEß_Ït2`XOI|^RMij`XJMQ{L"OxO2L~_¯R>`XgwkJ
cJE`ZJMJMLpEß_øtpPRLVTÒWÒ_Ï2½`{O|XJMvxJMLKghL"_¯2OWQ<RP`{ghkJ/cVJM`Z<JMJELÒ2Ò_Ï_pRLVTr_Ï2P`XO|XLKgh2H`^gm\fR
¾ QXJyijOWQXkz"dmR`XgwO2LcVJlMRzV\J\`XOWQXJ\[ghL JEQXkRL_RQXJoO2VJML»z~\zVRdhdhVfijQXOWk²r_øW`XHKQXO2zK2H
pMß_Ït2
Ò 7k9"dhOghL"T_O2kRghLJ *z"gwvWRdhJELVlyJ\
gwvxJMLqRÕT_OWkRgwL`{H"JMOWQXÕ`{HVR`lnO2L`^RgwLV\`XH"JijO2Q{kzKdmRÕ ,$ J
p =¹ G J ^{^¯[R
kR"KghL" 9 J L p ¹ G J [g\[R P¾ QXJnijO2QXkz"dR`XgwO2LijO2
Q RL+ RL~T t}bdh`{JMQ^R`XghOWL@(NPL"OZ[ghL"HKOZ lHVRL"2Ju\<Oi lHVRL"2
J ]
UVJM``XH"JOWc§XJly`^\ RLVT %cVJFi RkghdwghJ\n¯`{H"JR2\VJly` °T_J\{lyQXgwcVJ`XH"JLz"kcJEQ½Oil^H"gwdmT_Q{JML
RLVT>`{H"JoR2\VJln` T_Ju\XlyQ{ghcVJ\[`XH"JLz"kcVJMQOi/cVJTK\µL"JEJT_JT¡ /R2l^HkR"KghL"gwLVlyQXJuR2\gwL"`XH"J
L_z"kcVJMQPOil^H"ghdT_QXJMLc £xÝ gwLVlyQXJuR2\gwL"`XH"JLz"kcVJMQOicVJTK\éc ÕRW\½Z<JEdhd.gm\RÕ P¿
QXJyijOWQXkz"dmR`XghOWL,ÁJMQXJ9lyJMQ{`^RgwLÕl^HVRL"2J\POi ÚlERzV\JlyJMQ{`^RgwLBL"OZ[Ll^HVRLK2J\Oi >ç`{H"JMQ
QXJyijOWQXkz"dmR`XghOWLV\fOi.`{H"gm\f`_VJRQXJ_LKOZ[L9ghL`{H"JMO2Q{JMk%"Q{OvghLK½c9RLVRdhO2Wx¯*ijOWQ<JM·KRk9"dhJx¯W`XH"J
)*+O- 8 ']QXJnijO2QXkz"dR`XgwO2L \JMJo\Jly`XgwO2Lòx^
¼"O2QRL O2VJMQSR`XgwO2LVRdhgwYR`{ghO2L Z<J@RW\X\z"kJ@R\JMÒiÍ P¿(Q{JyijO2Q{kz"dR`{ghO2L~\]`XOcVJBWghvxJMLijOWQ>R
T O2kRghLÍR`HVRL~T¡[Ù<H"JQXJnijO2QXkz"dR`XgwO2LV\/kz~\`[R`bdwJR2\`[H"JMz"Q{gm\`XgmlERdhdwKQXJ\JMQXvxJP`{H"JJMk"dwOxJTlnO2L_
LKJly`XgwO2LijO2Q`XHKJT_OWkRgwL,¯fH"JMLVlnJQ{JyijO2Q{kzKdmR`{ghOWLV\]RQXJTO2kRghL_ T_JMVJMLVTJML_È ¾pE2ß"¯[pyºWbz~\JQXJyijOWQ
kz"dR`XgwO2LV\P`{HVR`H"JEz"QXg\`XglMRdwdh"Q{J\JEQXvxJ`XH"JJEk"dhOxJTÍlyO2LKL"Jly`{ghO2LÑghLR>WJMO2kJE`XQXglT_O2kFRghL´¯ ijO2Q
gwLV\`SRLVlnJx¯lyJMQX`SRgwLRcV\`{Q^R2ln`XghOWLV\y¯QXJ ~Jly`XgwO2L,¯WQXO2`SR`{ghO2L´¯"RL~T`XQSRLV\dmR`{ghOWL,¾pEò2"zV\Ju\<\JE`^\fOi.Q{JyijO2Q{kz_
dR`{ghO2L~\é`{HVR`HVRMvxJ]cVJMJMLWJML"JMQSR`XJuT>`XO"Q{J\JEQXvxJR2ghvxJELlyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWL>ijO2QPQ{J\`{QXgmln`XJTVL"gh`{J\JM`^\bOi
OWc§XJly`S\y<xJMvxJEQ^RdÀVRVJMQS\bRWT"T_Q{J\X\RcV\`XQSR2ly`{ghL"QXJyijOWQXkz"dmR`XgwO2LV\¾pMò¯Vr2ò"¯,pnº_s(
n,ú yú " þ û "ü ù (ù ü,ÿùû új6ö -üj6ö yõ þ õÿ þ újù nú " þ üj6ö nõ 9
Ò2Ò
<Ù H"JL"JlnJ\X\gh``XOQXJMvxJuRd\ghkgwdmRQ{gh`{ghJE\]dhJRWT"\`XOqRL JM·`XJMLVTJTT_JnVL"gh`{ghOWL Oi\ghkgwdmRQXgh`Õ`{HVR`
lnO2LV\gmT_JMQS\PRL@O2c§XJuly` R2\\ghk9ghdmRQ[`XO áZQE`MÖg¿i lMRLcVJQ{JyijO2Q{kz"dR`{JT`XO+ cRL
RWT_kg\X\gwc"dhJQXJyijOWQXkz"dmR`XghOWL V /
" !$# @RLVT IRQXJb \gwkghdRQ.Z[gh`XH9QXJ\July`/`XOoRLRW\VJly`
®g¾i.`{H"JMQXJJM·_g\`S\¨R ¾ QXJyijOWQXkz"dmR`XghOW
L Oi.`XH"JéT_J\XlnQXghK`XghOWLOi Ñ\zVl^H`{HVR`
(LVlydhz~T_ghL"ØR2T_k9gm\X\ghc"dwJQ{JyijO2Q{kzKdmR`{ghOWLBJM·`XJELVT"\]`XHKJL"O2`{ghOWLOié\gwkghdRQ{gh`RLVTg\]RkJRL~\½`XO
kFRxJRL~RdhOW2glMRdÀghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJu\dhJ\{\/T_JMVJMLVT_JEL_`/O2L9`XH"JR2ly`{zVRdVQ{JM"QXJu\JML`^R`XghOWLOi.`XH"J\OWz"Q^lnJRLVT`XH"J
`SRQ{2JMÈÁbJMLVlyJ¯ghL~lydhzVTghL"ÍQXJyijOWQXkz"dmR`XghOWLBgwL_`{O@RLVRdhOW2gmlERd[ghLijJMQXJML~lyJ\P"QXOvgmT_Ju\½kOWQXJJMdRcVO2QSR`{J
RLVRdwO2WghJ\/`XHVR`[RQ{JPZ[gh`{H"ghL`{H"J\XlyOWJOi.Hz"kRLRLVRdwO2WlMRVRcKghdhgw`XgwJ\y.Ù<H"JPJE·_g\`XJELVlyJ<OiR P¿
Q{JyijO2Q{kzKdmR`{ghOWL ijOWQPR`XOW`^Rd.lyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2LÑ P,WghvxJ\/QXgm\J`XO`XHKJ]RLVRdwO2WgmlMRdgwL_ijJMQXJELVlyJ\{lH"JEkR_ P
9

Â E
fk"dhOghL"9`XH"g\½\{lHKJMkR`{O>ghLijJMQoRLVRdhO2WgmlMRdhdwÕR2OxRd[T_Ju\XlyQ{gh"`{ghO2L %ijO2QR`^RQXWJM` ÖghJMdT"\
`{H"JPijO2dwdhOZ[ghL"KQXOlyJTz"QXJx JE`PRlyOWL"L"Jln`XghOWLÑ
µJM`{QXgwJMvxJR]\O2z"QSlyJ >ijOWQ<Z[H"glH lMRL9cJQXJyijOWQXkz"dmR`XJTc_R P¿(Q{JyijO2Q{kzKdmR`{ghOWL `XO
b Ù<H"JQXJM`{QXgwJMvWRd,lERL>cVJoT_OWL"J]c\JRQSlHKghL"]ijOWQb`{H"J <Z[gw`XH ¾
µJyijOWQXkz"dmR`XJ c V
ÙRxJ RW\ E ^
.ääÈ"ÅMÆ
G@JPgwLVlyQXJEkJML`^Rdwd¿PghL`XQ{OT_zVlyJT`XHKJbL"OW`XgwO2LV\/Oi\gwkghdRQ{gh`RL~TQXJMdwJMvWRLVlnJ[Z[H"gml^HRQXJcVR2\gmlµijOWQRLVRM
dwO2WgmlMRd_Q{JR2\O2L"gwL""<xJEvxJMQ^Rdn§XzV\`{g¾ÀlMR`XgwO2LV\Oi´RLVRdhO2WgmlMRd"ghLijJMQXJML~lyJ\¡c]Tg¾³ÀJMQXJEL_`._gwLVT"\,OiÀQXJEdhJMvWRL~lyJ
L"OZ[dhJuT_2JPZJMQXJlyOWLV\gT_JMQXJuTRLVTdhJT`{OT_g¿³ÀJMQXJML`\Xl^H"JMkRW\ijO2Q[RLVRdwO2WgmlMRd¡ghLijJMQXJML~lyJxfÙ<HKJPQXJ\z"dh`
gwL"ghLijJMQXJML~lyJ\{lHKJMkR2\T_Ju\XlyQ{ghcVJRL~RdhOW2glMRd[gwL_ijJMQXJELVlyJijO2QlyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWL_(c~R2\JuT¡¯/\gwkghdRQXgw`* cVR2\JT¡¯
RLVT>`_KgmlMRd¾ ghLV\`^RL~lyJy cVR2\JT>RLVRdwO22glMRd.ghLijJMQXJML~lyJ\yC¼~zKQX`XHKJMQXkOWQXJx¯gh``Xz"Q{L"JTO2z"``XHVR`RQXJRW\O2L
Rc"dhJ9RL~T Z[gT_JMdhÍR""dhglMRcKdhJT_Jy~L"gh`{ghO2LOi\ghkgwdmRQ{ghìjO2QoRLVRdhOW2gmlERd/ghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJ½LKJMJT"\P`XOgwLVlydhz~T_J
Q{JyijO2Q{kzKdmR`{ghOWLV\Öi/`XH"Jo\O2z"QSlyJZ[H"gml^H"QXJ\JMQXvxJ`XH"J§XzV\`Xg¾lMR`{ghO2L´
' # #
"¼ OWQ<RLghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJ<QXJEdmR`{ghOWL`XOPcVJL"O2L_ kOWL"O2`{O2L"gl<kJRL~\ `{HVR`RLgwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJcVR2\JTOWL\OWkJ<L"OZ[d¾
JuT_2JlMRL>cVJ]gwL_vWRdhgmTKR`XJuTcRLgwL_ijJMQXJELVlyJcVR2\JT>O2LØR2T"Tgh`XgwO2LVRdfL"OZ[dhJT_WJx[}P\[O2KO\JT`XO9`XH"J
lndmR2\{\glMRdÀghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJ[Q{JMdmR`XgwO2LghL"Q{JT_glMR`{JbdwO22gl2¯RLVRdhOW2gmlERd¡gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJ[g\<lyOWkkO2LKdholyO2L~\gmTJMQXJT`XO
cVJ[L"OWL_ T_JT_zVln`XghvxJ¯`{JML_`SR`{ghvxJx¯WRLVT]LKO2L_ kO2LKO2`XOWL"gmlWfÙ<H"J\J<ijJR`{z"QXJu\ Oi,RLVRdwO2WgmlMRdQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"PHVRMvxJ
cVJMJELR2T"T_Q{J\X\JTJM·_Kdhgmlngh`XdwbgwLÍ ºß_¯xòW"¯_pEÒ2V¯2rWt2VRLVT]gwk"dwgmlygw`Xd¿bKQXJ\z""VOx\JTgwLRdwd"`XH"JR""Q{OxR2l^H"J\
`{OQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"c_RLVRdwO2Wx
$ 7 öøû,û 5ù þ , " øÿbõùùÿ&ü ù .Mÿö .Wùÿ yú,öøõ -øùüjù nõõù üj6ö nõû 9
Ò2t
VU JM`zV\PdhOxOWÕR`]RLÕJM·KRkKdhJx NPL"OZ[ghL"Í`XHVR``XH"J9lMRQ H; Z[RW\½"Q{OT_zVlyJuT gwLpEr2r2¯f`XHVR`]gw`^\
kFRxJgm\<ÁO2LVT"RM gwv_gl2¯RLVT`{HVR`[gw`^\¨KQXgmlnJbg\bpMt¯øW2_Ï2 PÐxO2z9Z<O2zKdmTgwL_ijJMQRLVRdhOW2gmlERdhdw`{HVR`R
lERQ H; !Z[H"glHZ[RW\¨"Q{OT_zVlyJTghLÍpMr2rWRLVT`{H"JbkFRxJ[Oi.Z[HKgml^Hg\¨ÁO2LVT"RM gwv_glµZO2z"dT"Q{O2cVRc"dh
lnOx\òRcOWz"`pEt_¯Ï22øW PÐÕÀÙ<H"JQXJMdwJMvWRLVlyJo_LKOZ[dwJT_WJ]`XH~R`§XzV\`{g¾VJu\b`XH"g\bVRQX`Xglyz"dRQRLVRdwO22glMRd
gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJgm\`XH"JTJM`XJMQ{kghL~R`XgwO2L@Oi`{H"J"Q{gmlyJOiRlMRQoc_@gh`S\½kRxJRLVTÕxJRQ]OilyOWLV\`{QXzVln`XghOWL,
<zK`[Z[HVR`[HVR"VJMLV\[g¾i.xOWzxRghL`XH"JoRWT"T_gh`{ghOWLVRd,L"OZ[dhJT2JP`{HVR` H; !gm\<Q{zV\`9RLVTZ[RW\µgwL_vxOWdhvxJT
gwLÕkRL_Ø\JMvxJMQ{JR2lMlngmT_JML`^\^ Ù<H"JML@xO2zÕZO2z"dTBL"OÍdhO2LK2JMQoghL_ijJMQ`{H"JKQXgmlnJOiopMt_¯Ï2W_øW PÐ ijO2Q
H; !.fÙ<H"g\¨JM·KRkKdhJ["Q{OvgmTJ\/Rlydhz"J[ijO2Q`XH"JL"O2L_ kOWL"O2`{O2L"glygh`]Oi/lnO2L"L"July`XgwO2L_ cVR2\JTRLVRdwO22glMRd
gwL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJ\/Z[H"gml^HÍ\`{JMk\7ijQ{O2kÚ`{H"JoT_Jyi Rz"dh`l^HVRQSR2ly`{JMQ[Oi`XHKJ<§Xz~\`Xg¿ij_gwL"lyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWLV\y
¼"O2QPz"L~T_JMQ^\`^RLVT_ghLK`{H"JL"OWL_(k9O2L"OW`XO2LKgmlygwÒi[RLVRdwO2WgmlMRdfQXJRW\OWL"ghL"Z[gw`XH`_KgmlMRdgwLV\`SRLVlyJu\y¯
Q{JMkJMkcVJMQ`XH"J@lndmR2\{\glMRdÙ<ZJMJM`q\`XOWQXOioL"OWL_ kO2L"OW`XOWL"gml>Q{JR2\O2L"gwL"" @}bdwd[c"ghQST"\ Vx Ù<ZJMJM`
g\R>c"ghQST¡@Ù<Z<JMJE`g\R>VJML"2zKghLqRLVTÀ¯f`XH"JMQ{JyijO2Q{Jx¯/Ù<Z<JEJM`@lMRL"LKO2` Vx@(L`XH"g\]\`XO2Q{Õ`XHKJL"O2L
k9O2L"OW`XO2LKgmlygw`HVRW\PRdwO2`[`{OT_OZ[gh`{H>`{H"Jc"QXJRT_OZ[L>OiRLÍghL"HKJMQXgw`^RL~lyJghL`XH"JolMR`XJMWO2Q{|{c"ghQST"_
OWQXQ{J\VO2L~T_ghL"Wdhx¯À`XH"JL"OWL_(k9O2L"OW`XO2LKgmlygw`9OiRLVRdwO22glMRd.ghLijJMQXJML~lyJcVR2\JTOWL>`_KgmlMRd,ghLV\`^RL~lyJ\[gm\
lERzV\JTc`XH"JÍT_Jyi Rz"dh`l^HVRQ^R2ln`XJMQOi`XH"JÍ_LKOZ[dwJT_WJ>RcVO2z"``{H"JQXJMdwJMvWRLVlnJOioRLR2\JulyìjOWQR
`"gmlERd¡gwLV\`SRLVlnJ½OiRlMR`{JM2OWQXZ[H"glHg\[R2\X\z"kJT`XOH"O2dT9ijOWQbOW`XH"JEQ[ghLV\`^RL~lyJ\[R2\[Z<JEdhd(
}P\RÕQXJu\z"dw`M¯b`{H"JL"OWL_(k9O2L"OW`XO2LKgmlygw`qOiRLVRdhO2WgmlMRdghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJÍkRMQXJ xz"ghQ{J`XH"J@RWT"T_gw`XghOWLVRd
l^H"JlÔiCZ[H"JM`XHKJMQP`XHKJQXJ\z"dh`POi[`{H"JRLVRdwO2WgmlMRdfghL_ijJEQXJMLVlnJlyOWL_`{Q^R2Tgmly`S\PRL@T_JT_z~ly`XgwvxJMdhTJMQXgwvxJT
L"OZ[dhJuT_2Jx¯"g¿i.gh`[g\<L"JlyJ\{\XRQX`{OWzVRQSRL`XJMJo\OWz"LVT_LKJ\X\n
; ×?Í8-]8<DE;6 :<; ; D6 6 E;
Ú
Ù<HKJ`{JMQXk |{"QXOWc"dhJEk \O2dhvghLKx>HVRW\]cJEJMLÕzV\JTBZ[gmTJMdhgwL}PµijOWQghL`XJMdwdhghWJML`PRWly`XgwO2LV\]`{OR2l^H"gwJMvxJ
ZJMdhd¿TJyVL"JT2ORdm\n%abJMZJMdhdRLVT xghkOWLá¿pM2ò2élHVRQ^RWly`XJMQ{ghYMJuT×KQXO2cKdhJMk \O2dwv_gwL"RW\\JMdhJuly`XgwL"ÕR
\J
xz"JMLVlyJOiOWVJMQ^R`XO2QS\`{HVRò`XQSRLV\(ijO2QXkF\]RLÑghL"gw`XgmRd\`^R`XJgwL_`{OÍRT_J\gwQXJT2ORd\`^R`{JxÍÐRLQXJy
\JRQSlHKJMQ^\PRWT_O2K`XJT>`{H"gm\[v_gwJMZ»Jx¸"w¯f¸t2ß_¯.pMÒpx¯pE2¹2j^P} T_g¾³ÀJMQ{JML`R""Q{OxRWlHHVRW\PcJEJML>"Q{O2VOx\JT
cÐl JMQXkOW`X`¸r2Ò2À`XHVR`[v_gwJMZ\¨"Q{O2c"dwJMk \O2dwv_gwL"RW\bRo\OWdhz"`{ghO2LOWQ["dmRLgwLV\`SRL`XgR`XgwO2LcgmT_JML`Xg¿
ijghLKRLVTghL~\`^RL_`{gmR`XghLKJM·gm\`XgwL"\zKgh`^Rc"dhJo"dmRLV\yo(L>`{H"gm\P\JMLV\Jx¯¡`XHKJ"QXOWc"dhJMk²\O2dhvghLKkJM`{H"OT"\
TJMvxJMdhOWVJTgwL@}P[lMRLcVJOWQXxRL"ghYEJT>ghL@RKQXO2cKdhJMk²\OWdhvghL"9QXJRW\O2LKghL"ÍlyOWL_`{ghLz"z"k¯"QSRL"WghL"ijQ{O2k
ª¦{£x¤{ ÍÜmÝ_¢¦nÝ*ªEÜmê¦[`XO *WÝ"« (¨íw¦ M¥_¦ÜmÝ_¢¦nÝ*ªEÜmê¦[k9JM`XH"OTK\y
efz"QXJC\JRQ^l^HghL`XJMLV\ghvxJ/kJM`{H"OT"\.\JRQ^l^HJM·HVRzV\`XgwvxJMdhbijOWQ/RP\O2dhzK`XghOWL]ijQXOWk VQS\`f"Q{ghLVlngh"dwJ\y¯Mg Jxw¯
gwLVT_gwv_gT_zVRd´\`{JMV\[`XHVR`bkOTJMdÀR`XOWkgmlR2ly`{ghO2L~\µgwL`{H"J`^RW\T_OWkRgwLÍRLVTkRMcJol^HVRgwL"JT`XO]ijOWQXk
R\OWdhz"`{ghOWL>`XOR"Q{O2c"dwJMk.efz"QXJo_L"OZ[dwJT_2JghL`XJMLV\ghvxJkJM`{H"OT"\ïjO2Q"Q{O2c"dwJMkÚ\O2dwv_gwL""QXJu\z""VO\J
`{H"J>JE·_g\`XJELVlyJOioRBlnO2dhdwJly`{ghO2LÑOigwLV\`SRLVlyJOWQWJML"JMQSRdhgwYMJT\OWdhz"`{ghOWLV\ijQ{O2k Z[HKJMQXJÍ`XH"J"Q{O2c"dwJMk
\O2dwvxJMQ[kRMQXJE`XQXgwJMvxJRLVTJMvxJML`XzVRdhdhghL~\`^RL_`{gmR`XJ`XH"JR2T_J *zVR`XJo\OWdhz"`{ghOWL, RQ{gmR`{ghOWLV\CijQ{O2k°`XHKJ\J
`ZOJM·`XQXJEkJRK"QXOR2l^H"J\bJM·`XJELVT`{H"J\JRQ^l^H>gwL_`{JMLV\gwvxJPVRQ^R2Tgh2k `{OH"JMzKQXgm\`Xgl½\JRQSlHKghL"K¯Z[H"gwdhJ
`{H"J_L"OZ[dwJT_2JghL`XJELV\gwvxJ]JM·`XQ{JMkJ]JE·_`{JMLVT"\P`XOÍlMRW\Jy cVRW\JTBQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"R""Q{OxR2l^H"J\ghL@Z[H"gml^H@`XH"J
Q{JM`XQ{ghJMvxJuT\OWdhz"`{ghO2LkRMcVJ]RWT"RK`XJTÍRuij`XJEQ[cJEghL"QXJM`{QXgwJMvxJTRLVTghLV\`^RL`XgR`{JT¡
}ályO2kKQXO2k9gm\gwL"R""Q{OxR2l^H>cVJM`ZJMJML`XH"Jo`Z<OJM·`XQ{JMkJ\/gm\<`XOF\O2dwvxJoRL"JEZ%»`SRQXWJM`y"Q{O2c"dwJMk
ÛEë£xÝ"£2í¿«^¥xë<`XOoRP"QXJEv_gwO2zV\dho\OWdhvxJT\gwkghdRQ/(\O2z"QSlyJ2."Q{O2c"dwJMk.Ù<H"gm\."QXOlyJu\X\¨JEL_`SRghd\f\JuRQ^l^H"gwL"bijO2Q
\ghkgwdmRQ¡VRW\`."QXOWc"dhJMkF\¡RL~T]`XQ^RLV\ ijOWQXkgwL"[`XHKJMghQ´\O2dwz"`XgwO2LV\.ghL`XO\OWdhz"`{ghOWLV\ VOW`XJML`XgRdhdwPR""dwgmlMRc"dhJ/`XO
`{H"JPL"JEZI"QXOWc"dhJMkØ¨xzVl^H9R]kJM`XHKOTZCR2\[R2TvxOlMR`{JTghL Ò2Ò(/}PlElyO2QST_ghL"`{O RQXcVOWL"JMdhd ¯"RLVRdwO22glMRd
KQXO2cKdhJMk \OWdhvghL"lMRLcVJoT_JyVL"JuTR2\[R"QXOWc"dhJMk \OWdhvghL"\`{Q^R`{JM29`XHVR`[`XQ^RLV\ ijJEQ^\<L"OZ[dhJT_WJµijQ{O2k
~R2\`Í"QXOWc"dhJEk \O2dwz"`XgwO2LV\OWQFijQ{O2k VRW\`Í"QXOWc"dhJMk \OWdhvghL"JM"g\OT_Ju\F`{OIRÕ`^RQXWJM`"QXOWc"dhJMk `{HVR`
\HVRQ{J\f\gh2LKg¾ÀlMRL_`.RW\VJly`S\ Z[gw`XHo`XH"JlyOWQXQXJu\VO2LVTghL"P~R2\`.JM·VJMQXgwJMLVlyJ/RLVT½JEk"dhOK\`{H"J/`XQ^RLV\ ijJEQXQXJuT
L"OZ[dhJuT_2J`{OlyO2L~\`XQ{zVly`\O2dwz"`XgwO2LV\ijOWQ`XHKJ>`^RQXWJM`"Q{O2c"dwJMk©|nxghWL"g¾lMRL`RW\VJly`S\\HVRQXJTc
Òº
\ O2z"QSlyJ@RL~T`^RQ{2JM`SlMRLIcVJ>gwL_`{JMQXKQXJM`{JTR2\R2\July`^\Q{JMdhJEv2RL_``XOÑ`XH"JÍ2OxRdP`XOÑcJ@RWlHKghJMvxJTÕc
`{H"J"QXOWc"dhJMk \OWdhvghL"KÙ<HVR`g\y¯,`XH"JRLVRdwO2WgmlMRd¨KQXO2cKdhJMk \O2dwv_gwL"ÍlMRL@cVJcVR2\JTO2LÑlyO2L"LKJly`XgwO2LV\
cVJM`ZJMJMLÍRdwd[|^\gw2L"g¿ÀlMRL_`RW\VJly`S\XRLVT`XH"J2ORd
xO2k9Jv2RQXgR`XgwO2LV\Oi`XH"J@2JMLKJMQ^Rd]RLVRdwO2WgmlMRd]"Q{OlyJ\X\ÍlMRK`Xz"Q{JÕT_g¿³ÀJMQXJML`dhJMvxJEdm\Oi"Q{O2c"dwJMk
\O2dwv_gwL">JM·VJMQXgwJMLVlyJÙ,Q^RLV\ ijOWQXkR`XgwO2LVRd[RL~RdhOW2 ¸Ò_pn¨z~\J\o\ghk9"dh`XHKJVLVRd<\O2z"QSlyJ\O2dhzK`XghOWLÕ`XO
Wz"gmTJ<`XHKJ¨`SRQ{2JM`.\O2dhzK`XghOWL,¯2Z[H"JEQXJRW\,T_JMQXgwvWR`XgwO2LVRdRLVRdhOW29ÒWt2xzV\J\¡`{H"J/_LKOZ[dwJT_WJ¨Q{JMdhJEv2RL_`,gwL`XH"J
\O2z"QSlyJP"Q{O2c"dwJMk \OWdhvghL"o"QXOlnJ\X\»Jx¸"h¯lyO2L`XQ{O2d¡L"OZ[dhJuT_2J2.`{O]2zKgmT_J`XH"J`^RQXWJM`<"Q{O2c"dwJMk \OWdhvghL"
KQXOlyJ\{\y/GBJ[ijOlyzV\<OWL"Q{J\JML`XgwL"`XH"JlyOWk"z"`SR`XgwO2LVRdÀR2\VJln`^\ÖiT_JMQ{ghvWR`{ghO2L~Rd,RLVRdwO2Wx¯"RW\¨gh`HVR2\
\H"OZ[L>`{OcVJoRVOZ<JEQijz"d.lyOWk"z"`SR`{ghO2L~Rd¡gwk"dwJMkJnL_`SR`XgwO2LOi"QXOWc"dhJEk°\OWdhvghL"cRL~RdhOW2x
# # '
JMQXgwv2R`XgwO2LVRdPRLVRdwO22T_JML"OW`XJ\9R
" Q{OlyJ\{\`XHVR`TQ^RMZ\RL~RdhOW2gwJ\ijQXOWk `XH"JÍJM·_VJMQ{ghJML~lyJ\½Oio`XH"J
~R2\òQXJRW\OWL"ghL""Q{OlyJ\{\yÙ<H"Jz"LVT_JMQ{dhghL"9xJM>gwLV\gw2H`Pgm\b`{HVR`zV\Jyijz"d/JM·VJMQXgwJMLVlyJgm\PJML~lyOT_JTghL
`{H"JQXJRW\O2LKghL"Í"QXOlyJu\X\PzV\JuT `{O>TJMQXgwvxJ\OWdhz"`{ghOWLV\½`{O>\ghkgwdmRQ["QXOWc"dhJMkF\y¯¡QSR`XHKJMQ`XHVRL§XzV\`ghL@`XH"J
~LVRd/\O2dwz"`XgwO2L,oÙ<H"JMQ{JyijO2Q{Jx¯¡TJMQXgwv2R`XgwO2LVRd/RLVRdhOW2>g\PR¤^¦{^«xÝ*ªn¢(¤n¬y¢(Ümê¦bkJE`XH"OTc_Z[H"glHÍdhghLKJ\µOi
Q{JR2\O2L"gwL"RQXJ>`{Q^RLV\ ijJMQ{QXJTqRLVTIRWT"RK`XJT`XORL"JMZÚKQXO2cKdhJMk RW\O2KO\JT`{OB`{Q^RLV\ ijOWQXkR`XghOWLVRd
k9JM`XH"OTK\<`XHVR`PRWT"R"`T_gwQXJly`{dhVLVRd.\O2dwz"`XgwO2LV\n
RQ{cOWL"JMdwdÒWtT_g\XlyzV\{\J\oRLÕJE·"Rk"dhJo`XHVR`\H"OZ\]`XH"J9R2T_vWRL_`SR2JOiT_JMQXgwvWR`XgwO2LVRdRLVRdhO2W¡ z""VOx\J]xO2zHVRMvxJlyOTJTR xz"glK\OWQX`/QXOWz"`XgwL"JPghLFefR2\{lMRd ¯_RLVT`XH"JELxO2zRQXJRW\xJT`XOQ{JlyOT_J`XH"J
Q{O2z"`{ghL"JghLÕUÀXe.,}bdw`XH"OWz"2H@`XH"JKQXO2cKdhJMk \OWdhvghL""Q{OlyJ\X\PkRM"Q{J\JMQ{vxJ]kzVl^H>Oi`{H"JgwL"H"JMQ{JML`
\ghkgwdmRQXgh`x¯M`{H"J[QXJu\z"dw`^RL`/\O2dhzK`XghOWLV\fkRMPcVJbH~RQ^Tdh\ghkgwdmRQM,}dwghL"Jy c* dhgwL"J/`XQ^RLV\ ijJEQ¨g\flydwJRQ{dhL"O2`
R""Q{O2"Q{gmR`{Jx¯Vc"z"`RQXJMzV\JOikRM§XO2QC\`{QXzVly`{z"Q^Rd.RLVTÍlyO2L`XQ{O2d.T_Julygm\ghO2L~\<QXJ xz"ghQ{JT`{OlyO2LV\`XQ{zVly``XH"J
eR2\XlERd"QXOW2Q^Rkágm\,O\X\ghc"dwJx.Ù<H"JMQXJnijO2QXJ¯`{H"JRLVRdhO2W]kzV\`ÀcVJ¨Wz"gmTJT½cR[QXJlyOWLV\gT_JMQSR`XgwO2LOi~`XH"J
xJE]TJlygm\ghOWLV\ghLdwghWH_`.OiÀ`XHKJ[L"JMZq\gw`XzVR`XghOWL,/(L]VRQX`{gmlyz"dRQE¯2`XH"JTJMQXgwv2R`XgwO2LOiÀ`{H"JPUÀXe xz"glK\OWQX`
KQXO2WQ^Rk°\`SRQX`S\ïjQXOWk©`{H"J\XRkJ\VJlyg¿ÀlMR`{ghOWL,¯xQXJM`SRghLKghL"o`XH"J\{RkJT_gwv_gT_Jy RLVT* lyOWL *zKJMQ\`XQSR`{JM2x¯
cKz"`]gw`PkRMÍT_ghvxJMQ{2JgwL`XH"J9\JMdwJly`{ghO2LOiT"R`^RÍ\`XQ{zVly`{z"QXJ\jdhgm\`PvK\y,RQXQ^RMK\O2QoghL`{H"Jk9JM`XH"OT>Oi
l^H"OxO\ghLK`{H"JlyOWkVRQ{gm\O2L>JEdhJMkJEL_È<ÁbOZJMvxJMQM¯_ijzK`Xz"Q{JT_Jlyg\ghOWLV\[`XHVR`T_OL"OW`T_JMVJML~T>O2L@JRQ{dhghJEQ
TghvxJMQ{2JML`[T_Julygm\ghO2L~\[lMRLÍ\`{ghdwd,cJ`{Q^RL~\ ijJMQ{QXJT`XO`XHKJ½LKJMZ TO2kRghLQSR`XHKJMQb`{HVRLÍQXJlnO2k"zK`XJT¡
Ù<H"JT_JMQXgwvWR`XgwO2LVRd,RLVRdwO22ijQ^Rk9JMZ<OWQX]H~R2\<cVJMJMLghLV\`^RL_`{gmR`{JTc\JMvxJEQ^RdÀlyOWk"z"`SR`{ghO2L~RdÀ\K\
`{JMk\n¯2ghLVlndhzVT_gwL" bç } á¾pE2t2 ¯ /Ð}P ®¾pMt(¯e b} øs ¯x}P-e +ár(¯xRLVTc_e7Q{OT_ghW u}bLVRM
dwO2W¿pyºxt(Ù<H"J\Jé\K\`XJEk\R""dw`XORPvWRQ{ghJMÒi,"Q{O2c"dwJMk \OWdhvghL"oR2ln`Xghvgh`{ghJ\n¯gwLVlydwzVT_ghLK\Oij`ZCRQ{J
Q{JMzV\JghLR +aP ©"Q{O2WQ^Rk9kghL"ÍT_OWkRgwLI¸r ¯f`XH"JTJ\gw2LÕOiPHz"kRLÕlyOWk"z"`{JMQghL`XJMQi R2lyJu\¿pMt(¯
RLVTkz"dw`XghKdhJ["dRL"L"gwL"9R""dwgmlMR`XgwO2LV\øs_¯,pnºxt2
GBJ9\H~RdhdlyOWLVlyJML`XQSR`{JO2z"Qo"QXJ\JML`^R`{ghOWLBOilyOWk"z"`SR`XgwO2LVRd/ghk"dwJMkJyL`^R`XghOWLV\[OiRL~RdhOW2@ghL
KQXO2cKdhJMk \OWdhvghL"@O2Lq`XH"JØefQXOT_gw2 }bLVRdhOW2I\"\`XJMkØ¯fcJulMRzV\Jgh`gwk"dhJEkJML`^\Rdhd\zKc""QXOlnJ\X\J\
OiRLVRdhO2Wx¯bgw`g\RÕT_OWkRgwL_ ghLVT_JEJELVT_JML`\K\`{JMk JMkcVJTKT_JTÕghL`XOÑRB2JEL"JMQ^RdbKQXO2cKdhJMk \OWdhvghL"
RQ^l^H"gh`{Jly`{z"QXJ@(R@L"O2L_ dhgwL"JRQ"dmRL"L"JMQn]QSR`{H"JMQ`{HVRL RÕ\`^RLVT* RdhOWL"J@`XOxO2d ¯[gh`9RdhdwOZ\ijO2Qkz"dw`XghKdhJ
\O2z"QSlyJ\/`XO]cVJPQ{JM"dRuxJuT½ijO2Q[R`^RQX2JE`M¯"RLVTcVJlMRz~\JPgw`¨H~RLVT_dwJ\¨dRQ{2JlMR2\JPcVR2\J\bjOvxJMQpM2WlMR2\J\
RLVT>RWT"T_Q{J\X\ghL"`XH"JgwLVT_JM·ghL"RLVTOWQXRL"gwYR`{ghO2LÍOi"dmRL"L"gwL"lER2\Ju\y
.Å VæM
Ä VäÈ"ÊjÓæ ÍÓ É»ÄÇ,Ô¡Ä 9Ä .ÅÄ_æMÄÓâuÈ_âÊ Ó
Ù<HKJBkRghLI"zKQXVOx\JBOiT_JMQ{ghvWR`{ghOWLVRdoRL~RdhOW2Ig\F`{Oq\O2dwvxJ"QXOWc"dhJEk\k9O2QXJJ%lygwJML`XdhÑ`XHVRL RL
OWQXgw2ghL~RdVcVR2\gmlbKQXO2cKdhJMk \O2dwvxJMQ[jO2Q<KdmRLKL"JMQy.cQXJMz~\ghLK½~R2\`/JM·VJMQXgwJMLVlyJ[`{O2z"gT_Jb`{H"J2JML"JEQ^R`{ghOWL
Oi\O2dhzK`XghOWLV\µijOWQPL"JMZá"Q{O2c"dwJMk\[RL~T>`XHzV\PRMvxO2gT_ghL"9RlyO2k9"dhJM`{JMdhLKJMZ \JRQ^l^HJy³ÀO2QXÈ f·"Rk"dhJu\
Oif`{H"JPQ{J\z"dw`^\/O2c"`SRghLKJTc_9efQXOT_gw2 }bLVRdhOW2gwL`XJMQ{k\fOighLVlnQXJRW\JTJ FlyghJML~ly]OWc"`^RghL"JTijOWQ[`XH"J
Ò2ò
KQXO2cKdhJMk\RQXJWghvxJMLijO2QJM·KRk9"dhJoghL ¿pyºx¹2 ¯Z[H"JEQXJ`{H"Jc~R2\Jn(dwJMvxJMd/"dmRL"L"gwL">Jy³ÀOWQX`gm\lyOWkVRQXJT
Z[gw`XH9RLVRdhOW2gmlERd""dRL"LKghL"2zKgmT_JT]co\OWz"Q^lyJlMRW\J\nfefQXOT_gw2}bL~RdhOW2VJMQXkgw`^\,RPVRQX`XgRd"`{Q^RLV\ ijJMQ
Oi\OWdhz"`{ghOWLV\µZ[HKJMLÍR`{O2`^Rd,`XQSRLV\(ijJMQPlERL"L"OW`bcVJ§XzV\`Xg¾~JT¡
efQXOT_gw2 }bLVRdhOW2Z[RW\RLVTlyOWL_`{ghLz"J\]`{OcJØT_JMkOWLV\`{Q^R`XJTÕghLqR>vWRQ{ghJM`ÕOioT_OWkRgwLV\y¯/¼"O2Q
gwLV\`SRLVlnJ]R`XQSRLV\VO2QX`SR`{ghO2L@TO2kRghL,¯
efQXOT_gw2 }bLVRdhOW2gm\<c"zKghdh`[OWL`XO2ÍOi/`{H"J"dmRL"L"JMQ[Oif`{H"JoefQXOT_gw2ÍRQSlH"gw`XJln`Xz"Q{JxfÙ<H"g\<2JMLKJMQ
R`XgwvxJP"dmRL"L"JMQ[g\[Rk9JRLV\((JELVT"\<RLVRdw"\gm\<cVRWlZ[RQ^T* l^HVRgwL"ghL"LKO2L"dwghL"JRQ["dmRL"L"JMQE 9 ! # 'ÀÎø\
LKO2L"dwghL"JRQ[l^HVRQSR2ly`{JMQ\`{JMk\ijQXOWk%gh`^\T_LVRkgl<2ORd,\JMdhJuly`XgwO2LZ[H"gml^HJELVRc"dwJ\f`XH"J"dmRL"L"JMQ/`XOijz"dhdw
gwL_`{JMQXdwJRMvxJ"dmRLV\y¯¡JE·_"dwO2gw`XghLKlyO2k9kO2LÍ\zKc"2ORdm\RLVTBRWT"T_Q{J\X\ghL"gm\{\z"Ju\bOiCQXJ\O2z"QSlyJlyO2L`XJEL_`{ghO2L´
9 ! # 'lyOWkcKghL"J\\`^R`XJy \~R2lyJo\JuRQ^l^H9lyO2Q{QXJ\OWLVT_gwL"`XOR]\gwkzKdmR`{ghOWLOi."dRLJM·JlyzK`XghOWLOi
`{H"J"dmRLRLVTcVRWlZ[RQ^T* l^HVRgwL"ghL"Q{J\VOWLV\gwc"dhJPijO2Q[WOxRd¾ T_ghQ{Jly`XJuTFQ{JR2\O2L"gwL"Ø¾pyºÒ2(
}%T_O2kFRghLg\P\VJlng¾VJT>gwLÕefQ{OT_ghW@R2\RlydmRW\X\PH"ghJEQ^RQSlHOiCO2c§XJly`S\y¯.R\JMÒi[OWVJMQ^R`XO2QS\y¯.ghL_
ijJEQXJMLVlnJ>QXzKdhJ\n¯[RLVTIlnO2L`XQXOWdbQ{z"dhJu\y /R2l^HO2VJMQSR`{O2QHVR2\9RB"QXJulyO2LVTgh`XgwO2LqJM·_KQXJ\{\ghOWL`{HVR`kzV\`
cVJ@\{R`Xg\ VJuTcJnijO2QXJÍ`XH"JÍO2VJMQSR`XOWQÍlMRLIcVJR""dwghJT¡¯CRLVTIRLIJy³ÀJly`^\dhg\`Z[gh`{HIR2TKT*9RLVTITJMdhJM`{J
\`^R`XJMkJEL_`S\yf}\<RL9JM·"Rk"dwJx¯x¼gw2z"Q{JPº\H"OZ\<`XH"JPOWVJMQ^R`XO2Q 3,;2 '*),+90 ijQXO2k R]dhOW2g\`XglM\f`XQSRLV\(
VOWQX`^R`XgwO2LÑT_O2kRghL`XH~R`\VJlyg¿VJ\[`XHVR`PRLO2c§XJly`lERL>cVJdwOxR2TJTgwL_`{OR`XQ{zVl9g¾i/`{H"JO2c§XJly`RL~T
`{H"J`XQXz~lRQXJR`/`{H"J\XRkJ[dhOlMR`XgwO2L,/(L`XHKgm\/T_O2kFRghL~R2l^2R2J\/RQXJ`XOcVJbkOvxJToRkOWL"T_g¿³ÀJMQXJML`
lngh`XgwJ\yeR2l^2R2J\RQXJlMRQXQXgwJTZ[gw`XH"gwL`XH"J\{RkJlygh`ghL`{QXzVl^K\bRLVT cVJM`ZJMJMLlngh`XgwJ\[ghL@RgwQX"dRL"Ju\y
}[`[JRWlHÍlygw``XHKJMQXJRQXJo\JEvxJMQ^Rd,dhOlMR`XghOWLV\y¯"J"w¯_VOx\`bO*lnJ\[RLVTÍRgwQXVO2Q{`^\y
7# %
! 7B2 %U*F+
): & >O
(
71%!*,
%U*F+ !*,
%2%F S6 7 !V&7 *,
%F%PZ V! *, ,,
): FO
2%F 2&F%F%PZ,
): G %U*F+ FH Z,
&
( ( %2%F ,
%U*F1
+ &U*F1
+ %2%F, ,,
GGF1O P,
H*O%1 %U*F1
+ &
( %U*F1+, ,
2 ( &
( %2F , ,,, ,
¼gw2z"Q{JPº" f ·"Rk"dwJbOiRL@çbVJMQSR`{O2QghLÍefQXOT_gw2
} KQXO2cKdhJMk lyO2L~\gm\`^\OiRLgwL"gh`{gmRd7\`^R`XJÍRL~TÕR>2ORd<JE·_"Q{J\X\ghOWL,>Ù<HKJghL"gw`XgRd\`SR`XJ9gm\]RÍ\JM`
Oiodhgh`{JMQ^Rdm\T_J\{lyQXgwc"ghL"`{H"JghLKgh`XgRd\gh`Xz~R`XgwO2L,®¼"O2QJM·KRk9"dhJx¯/lnO2LV\gmT_JMQ`XHKJ>"Q{O2c"dwJMk ghdhdwzV\`{Q^R`XJT
gwL¼gw2z"Q{Jò>(L@`XH"g\½"Q{O2c"dwJMk `XH"JEQXJ9RQXJ9`ZOO2c§XJly`S\y¯ ; @RLVT ; ¯,OWL"J`XQ{zVl^ ',)"!"¯.RLVTBO2LKJ
RghQ{"dmRL">J )93"#xÙ<H"JEQXJgm\½OWL"Jlygw` 0$>Z[gh`XHÑRVO\Ò FlyJ )%$RLVTÕRLRgwQXVO2Q{` 2$(L@`XH"JgwL"gh`{gmRd
\`^R`XJx¯ ; gm\[R` ) $RLVT`{H"J2OxRdg\<`XOHVRMvxJ ;ghLV\gmT_JOi '*)&!K
O2Q{QXJ\OWLVT_gwL"`XOgh`S\\JRQSlHlyKlydwJx¯efQXOT_gw2ÀÎø\f"dmRL"L"JMQ"QXOT_z~lyJ\fRP"dRLZ[gh`{HT_Jlyg\gwO2L]LKOT_J\y¯
g Jxw¯WOxRd ¯<O2VJMQSR`{O2QM¯c"ghLVTghL"\y¯/RL~TRK"dhÕLKOT_J\y}z"`XOWkR`{gml2JML"JEQ^R`{ghOWLOiP`{H"JÍT_JMQ{ghvWR`{ghO2L~Rd
KdmRLKL"ghL"ÑJM"gm\OT_J\OlMlyzKQ^\cJM·_`{JMLVT_gwL"@`XH"JÍcVR2\Jy(dwJMvxJMd2JMLKJMQ^R`XghvxJ"dRL"LKJMQZ[gh`{H`{H"J@Rc"gwdhgw`
`{O>JM·KRk9ghL"Jgw`^\PghL`XJMQ{LVRd7T_Jlyg\ghOWLÕln"lydwJx¯¡Q{JlyO2QST_ghLK>`XHKJP§XzV\`Xg¿ÀlMR`{ghOWLV\éijOWQ½JuR2l^HÕT_Julygm\ghO2LÑT_z"Q{ghL"
gw`^\o\JRQ^l^HÕ"QXOlnJ\X\n>Ù<H"J9cVR2\Jy(dwJMvxJMd 9 ! # '>Q{JR2\O2LV\RcOWz"`kz"dh`{gh"dwJ½WOxRdm\RL~T×kz"dw`XghKdhJ
Ò2¹
(state (and
(at-obj ob4 p3)
(at-obj ob7 a3)
(at-truck tr9 a3)
(at-airplane pl1 a3)
(same-city a3 p3))
city c3
p3
a3
pl1
ob4
tr9
ob7
tr9
(goal
(inside-truck ob4 tr9))
ob4
¼.gh2zKQXJò f·"Rk"dwJx /Ù<H"J]WOxRdfgm\<`{OdhOR2TOWL"J]OWc§XJly`ghL`XO`{H"J]`{QXzVl^¡(L"gh`{gmRdhdh`XHKJ]`XQ{zVl^gm\[L"O2`
R`b`{H"JO2c§XJln`MÎø\<dwOlMR`{ghOWL,
Rdh`{JMQXLVR`XgwvxJO2VJMQ^R`XOWQ^\]QXJEdhJMvWRL`P`{O>RWlHKghJMvghL"9`XH"JWOxRd\yÙ<H"g\lH"OWgmlyJOi[OWJEQ^R`{O2QS\]Rk9O2z"L`^\P`XO
kz"dw`XghKdhJZ[RM"\<Oif`{QXghL"`{ORWlHKghJMvxJP`{H"Jo\XRkJP2ORd <Ù<H"JEQXJyijOWQXJx¯ghLÍR2T"Tgh`XgwO2LÍ`XO9\JRQ^l^H"ghL"gwL`XH"J
\VR2lnJ½Oi.kzKdh`Xgw"dhJ2ORd,O2QST_JMQ{ghL"\y¯"RW\<kOx\`/Oi.`XHKJ\`SRLVT"RQ^TL"OWL"dhgwL"JRQ"dmRL"L"JMQS\[T_O"¯O2z"Q"dmRL"L"JMQ
\JRQSlHKJ\]J xzVRdwdh@ghL`XH"JÍ\VR2lyJOikzKdh`Xgw"dhJTg¾³ÀJMQXJEL_`R""Q{OxRWlH"Ju\`{O@\O2dwv_gwL"@R"QXOWc"dhJMkØBÙ<HKJ
\JRQSlHgwLcVO2`XHÍOi`XH"Ju\J\VR2lyJu\<cJEL"JyV`S\ïjQXO2k `XH"JRLVRdwO2WgmlMRd,2z"gT"RLVlnJ½KQXOv_gT_JTc`XH"J\ghkgwdmRQ
KdmRLKL"ghL"oJM"g\OT_J\nÖefQ{OT_ghW u}bLVRdwO2W"QXOvgmT_Ju\¨Rí¿£xÝ2¥x¬£M¥_¦`XH"
J E¬ªn¢ Ü ^£2¢ Üm«xÝ*ª/ijO2Q/`XH"JéT_Jlyg\ghOWLV\
kFR2T_Jx }±"dRL"LKghL"lER2\JÍ`XOÕcVJ@\`XO2Q{JTIlyOWLV\g\`^\`XH"JMQ{JyijO2Q{J>Oi]`{H"J\zVlMlyJu\X\ ijzKdP\O2dhzK`XghOWLI`XQSR2lyJ
Rz"2k9JML_`{JTZ[gh`XH@`XHKJ§XzV\`{g¾ÀlER`XgwO2LV\n¯g Jxw¯ `{H"J9T_JMQXgwvWR`XgwO2LVRd<`{Q^R2lnJxefQXOT_gw2 }bLVRdhOW2ÕgT_JML`Xg¾~JT
`{HVR``XH"JxJM½ijJR`Xz"Q{JbOi.`XH"g\fdmRLK2zVR2JPg\¨`XH~R`<gw`/L"JMJT"\f`{O]cVJbQ{JMghL`XJEQX"Q{JM`^Rc"dhJR`<"dRL"L"gwL"QXJMKdmRM
`{ghkJÕGBJÍZ[ghdhddmR`XJMQijz"QX`{H"JMQlyOWkkJMLÒ2Lq`XH"g\g\X\zKJx¼.gh2zKQXJ¹@\HKOZ\`XHKJ\`{QXzVln`Xz"Q{JOio`XH"J
§Xz~\`Xg¿ÀlMR`XghOWL\dhO2`S\[R``XH"Jo\`XO2Q{JT>TJlygm\ghOWLL"OT_J\n
!
#"$%'&(%
#"$%'&)*&(
,+ .-&(0/"%.
,+ .-&(!01&(%.
213
&(4
!
#"#%&(
,+ .-&(!56&(
2178.!1&(!9
!9
#"#%&(%'
#"#%&)*&(
,+ .-.&),+ .-.&(!01&(
3.&)!
¼ ghWz"QXJé¹_ 2zV\`{g¾ÀlMR`XgwO2LQXJlnO2Q^T\`XQXz~ly`Xz"Q{J
Ù<H"JMQ{JRQXJkRghL"dw>`{H"QXJMJFT_g¾³ÀJMQ{JML_`ghLVTK\½Oi§Xz~\`Xg¿ÀlMR`XghOWLV\y dwghL"K\RkOWL"l^H"O2glyJ\lMR"`Xz"Q{ghL"
`{H"JÍ\z"cK2OxRdhgwL"\`{QXzVln`Xz"Q{JB \dwO2`^*\ )*)-0,;=8 ; 6RLVT )F-,3,-:92=8*' '9;x^¯,QXJlnO2Q^TK\]OiJM·"dwO2QXJuT i RgwdhJT
Rdh`{JMQXLVR`XgwvxJ\P»`{H"J./ 53 / 8 \dhO2`S\S¯VRLVTOWghL`XJMQS\<`XO9RLRK"dhgwJT2z"gT"RLVlnJj`XH"<J ;,+- \dhOW`^\^^
GBJ\H"OZIRLJM·"Rk"dwJÖi,`{H"J[2JMLKJMQ^R`XghOWLRLVTQXJM"Q{J\JEL_`SR`XgwO2LoOi.RP"dRL"LKghL"lER2\J !"M O2LV\gmT_JMQ
`{H"J"QXOWc"dhJMk \H"OZ[L@ghL@¼gw2z"Q{Jò_Ù<HKJMQXJRQXJ`ZOO2VJMQSR`{O2Q^\`XHVRòRQXJQXJEdhJMvWRL`[ijO2Qo\OWdhvghL"`{H"gm\
KQXO2cKdhJMk .`XH"JO2VJMQ^R`XOWQ 3,;2 ='*),+90 ¯WR2\\VJlyg¿VJTgwL¼gw2z"Q{J½ºK¯"RLVT`{H"JPO2VJMQSR`{O2Q ):/.:- ='*),+90
`{HVR`C\`SR`XJu\7`{HVR`CRP`XQXz~llMRLkOvxJïjQ{JMJMdhcVJM`Z<JEJMLdwOlMR`{ghOWLV\fZ[gh`XHKghL`XH"J\{RkJlygw`x.¼ghWz"QXJso(R*
\H"OZ\b`XHKJ]TJlygm\ghOWL`{QXJMJolyOWQXQ{J\VO2L~T_ghL"`XO9efQXOT_gw2ÀÎø\\JRQ^l^HijOWQ[`XH"J\O2dwz"`XgwO2L,abOT_Ju\bRQXJ]Lz"k
cVJMQ{JTghLI`{H"JO2QST_JMQgwLIZ[H"gml^H`{H"J@\JuRQ^l^H \~R2lyJg\JM·VRLVTJT¡áÙ<H"J@\JRQSlHIg\RÕ\J *z"JELVlyJ>Oi
WOxRdfl^H"O2glyJ\fijO2dhdwOZ<JTcO2VJMQ^R`XOWQPl^H"O2glyJ\fijO2dhdwOZ<JTOlElMR2\ghO2L~RdhdwcR""dhghLKO2VJMQ^R`XOWQ^\[`XO`XH"J
KdmRLKL"JMQMÎÏ\µgwL_`{JMQXL~Rd.\`SR`{J]Z[H"JMLÍ`XH"JEghQ["Q{JlyO2L~T_gh`{ghO2L~\[RQXJo`XQ{z"JghL>`{HVR`\`SR`{JRL~T`XHKJT_Jlngm\gwO2LijO2Q
gwkkJTgmR`{JoR""dwgmlMR`XgwO2L@gm\bkRWT_JxÙ<H"J9\OWdhz"`{ghO2L@ijO2z"LVT@lyOWLV\g\`^\OiµT_QXgwv_gwL"`XH"J`{QXzVl^>ijQXOWk `XH"J
(7 ù -&ú ø5ù bû ûjùÿ>öøõü ù]'ù & þ -øùû þ ú»ùûj6ö .- Ïù núbü ù½û þ yù þ øù þ úbö 6 " û»üjú þ üj6ö nõ )7ü ù þ õ þ 61yö {þ újù þ û nõ
öÏõ 1 -ú ùû»û 9 "
Ò*s
RghQ{OWQX``XO`XH"JVOx\`bO*lnJ]RLVT`{H"JMLdhOR2T_gwL"`XH"JO2c§XJuly`M
Ù<H"gm\f`{Q^R2lnJ[ghdhdwzV\`{Q^R`XJ\ 9 ! #ÍHVRLVTdhghLK½kz"dw`XghKdhJlHKO2gmlnJ\Oi´H"OZ`{O]ghL~\`^RL_`{gmR`XJ[O2VJMQSR`{O2Q^\n
Ù<HKJMQXJRQXJP`ZO½gwLV\`SRL`XgR`XgwO2LV\/Oi.`{H"JbOWVJMQ^R`XO27Q 3,;,2 ='*)*+50 `XH~R`[RQXJPQ{JMdhJEv2RL_`/`{O]`XHKJbWghvxJML2ORd(¯
g Jxw¯x`XH"JghL~\`^RL_`{gmR`XghOWLV\ 3;,2 ',)*+50 ; '*)&! )%$oRLVT 3;,2 ',)*+50 ; ',)"!42$oR2T"T`XH"J
WOxRd / 8$.,/ - ='*),+ 0 ; ',)"!,}bLOWc§XJly`lMRLcVJ[dhOR2T_JT]gwL_`{ORb`{QXzVlôR`fcVO2`{HVO\`/O FlyJRL~T
RghQ{OWQX`dhOlMR`XgwO2LV\n<abOTJ 8\H"OZ\[`XHVR`[`XH"JoRdw`XJMQ{LVR`{ghvxJPOifdwOxRWT_ghL"`{H"J`XQ{zVl9R``XHKJRgwQXVO2Q{` 2$
g\<JM·"dhOWQXJTVQS\`M/Ù<HKgm\[dhJRWT"\<`XO`Z<O]i RghdwJTVR`XHV\n<Ù<H"J\OWdhz"`{ghO2Lg\ïjO2z"LVTÍRuij`{JMQ[cVR2l^`XQ^RWlghLK]`XO
`{H"JRdh`XJEQXLVR`XghvxJl^H"gwdmT]Oi.LKOT_7J 8 #*abOT_J\ 8]`{H"QXOWz"2>H 8 #o\H"OZI`XHKJµVL~Rd,\J xz"JMLVlyJ[Oi\zVlElyJ\X\(ijz"d
TJlygm\ghOWLV\y 8\H"OZ\é`{H"JlyOWQXQXJuly`Pl^H"OWgmlyJoOidhOR2T_gwL"`XH"J`{QXzVl^ÍR`P`{H"JVOx\Ò*lyJ¯¡Z[H"JMQ{>J ; gm\
dwOlMR`{JT¡Ù<H"J\O2dhzK`XghOWLlyOWQXQXJu\VO2LVTK\µ`{O`XH"JP`ZO\`{JMV\[R""dhgwJTR`[L"OT_Ju(\ 8 ##½RLVT 8 #K `{H"JP`{QXzVl^
'*)"!gm\[T_Q{ghvxJMLijQXO2k 2$`X
O )%$V¯"RW\bl^H"O\JMLÍR`L"OT_J 8RL~T`XHKJMLgh`[gm\<dwOxRWT_JTZ[gh`{H ;¡ cn1
n1
(inside-truck ob4 tr9)
:precond-of user
(inside-truck
ob4 tr9)
n8
n2
(load-truck
ob4 tr9 p3)
n9
(at-truck
tr9 p3)
n10
cn2
(load-truck
ob4 tr9 a3)
n3
(at-obj
ob4 a3)
n4
n7
(drive-truck (unload-airplane (unload-truck
ob4 pl1 a3
ob4 tr9 a3) cn3
tr9 a3p3)
n11
n5
(inside-airplane
Failure
APPLY
tr9 pl1)
goal-loop
(drive-truck
n6
(inside-truck cn4
tr9 a3 p3)
ob4 tr9
(load-airplane
n12
ob4 pl1 a3)
APPLY
(load-truck
cn5
Failure
ob4 tr9 p3)
goal-loop
(at-obj
ob4 a3)
cn6
(load-truck ob4 tr9 p3)
:relevant-to cn1
:sibling-ops
((load-truck ob4 tr9 a3)
(goal-loop
(inside-truck ob4 tr9)
(at-obj ob4 a3)))
(at-truck tr9 p3)
:precond-of cn2
(drive-truck tr9 a3 p3)
:relevant-to cn3
APPLY
(drive-truck tr9 a3 p3)
APPLY
(load-truck ob4 tr9 a3)
(a)
(b)
.¼ gh2zKQXJÕsx I R*Ù<HKJÕ\JRQSlHq`XQXJEJ`XOq\OWdhvxJ>`{H"J"Q{O2c"dwJMk gwLI¼gw2z"Q{J@ò'»c¡Ù<HKJ@lyO2Q{QXJ\OWLVT_gwL"
KQXO2cKdhJMk°\O2dwv_gwL"JM"g\OT_Jo`XOcVJ\`XO2Q{JT¡
¼ghWz"QXJsÍ»c¡\H"OZ\P`XH"JlMRW\JWJML"JMQSR`XJuTijQXO2k²`XH"JKQXO2cKdhJMk \O2dwv_gwL"gwL@¼ghWz"QXJs R*S¯ Z[HKJMQXJ
OWL"dhÍR\z"c~\JM`[Oi/`XH"J§XzV\`Xg¿ÀlMR`{ghOWLV\µg\[\H"OZ[L,Ù<H"JoJML_`{ghQ{J\JRQ^l^H`XQXJEJ½g\<L"O2`\`{O2Q{JTgwL`{H"JolMR2\Jx¯
cKz"Ò2L"dw>`XHKJT_Jlyg\ghOWL>L"OTJ\POi[`{H"J]VLVRd/\z~lMlyJ\{\ ijz"df~R`XH´]Ù<H"J9\zKc"2ORdhgwL"Í\`{QXzVly`{z"QXJRLVT`XH"J
Q{JlyOWQ^TÕOi`{H"Ji RghdhzKQXJ\RQXJÍRL"LKO2`^R`XJTqR``{H"J\JL"OTJ\y /R2l^H2ORdgm\R>"Q{JlyO2L~T_gh`{ghO2LOi\O2kJ
OWVJMQ^R`XO2QRLVTBJRWlHOWVJMQ^R`XO2Qg\lH"O\JMLÑRL~TBR""dhgwJTcJulMRzV\Jgw`gm\PQXJMdwJMvWRL`P`XOØ\OWkJ2ORd<`{HVR`
LKJMJT"\[`XOcVJRWlHKghJMvxJTÀÙ<HKJéi RghdwJTRdh`{JMQXL~R`XgwvxJ\<RQXJo\`{O2Q{JTZ[gw`XHÍRLÍR`{`^RWlH"JuTQXJuR2\OWL>Oii RghdhzKQXJx
}P\[RLJE·"Rk"dhJ¯*LKOT_>J 0=8lyOWQXQ{J\VO2L~T"\b`XO`XHKJ\JuRQ^l^H`XQ{JMJL"OT_J 8Ù<H"gm\\JuRQ^l^H>LKOT_JHVR2\
R9\ghcKdhghLKRdh`{JMQXL~R`XgwvxJ 8Z[HKgml^H>Z[RW\µJE·_"dwO2Q{JT>RLVTFi RghdhJuT¡[Ù<H"Ji RghdwJT\z"cK`XQXJEJ]QXOxOW`XJTR` 8HVR2\
`ZO>i Rghdwz"QXJdhJuRuvxJu\y¯L~RkJMdwR` 8
ÍRLVT 8%VÙ<H"J\Ji Rgwdhz"Q{JQXJuR2\OWLV\RQ{JRLKL"O2`SR`XJuTRò`XH"JFlMR2\J
LKOT_J 0 8K
Ä*ÃÀÄÉ 9É¶Ô VÅÊ¶âã.ä
efQ{OT_ghW u}bLVRdwO2Wgm\/`XH"Jb~Q^\`C\K\`{JMk%`XHVR`[RWlH"gwJMvxJTRLgwL_`{JM2QSR`{ghO2LOi.WJML"JMQSR`{ghvxJ"dmRL"L"ghLKRL~T
RLVRdwO2W ¾pnºxò (òlMR2\`^\`XH"J9lyO2k9"dhJM`{JlyKlydwJ]OilnO2LV\`XQXz~ly`XgwL""¯.\`{O2Q{ghL"K¯QXJE`XQXgwJMvghL"K¯,RLVT@QXJMzV\ghL"
- % nü»ù,ü Wþ üVÿ þ öøõ möøõÿ5ù -2ùõÿùõMü bùü EÿûK&ü /üj&ú '&ü /újùÿ " ùü ùûjù þ ú ù )nú»ü 6 !Wöøõ 1nùõùú þ 2ÿ fõ yü {þ -ü " ú»ù
ÿ þ öøõ[û -2ù ö . 4 nõMüj&ú #Mõ /øùÿ 1nù $ ö " ûjü ùü ùõ þ) 1 " öøújùÿ '.øù þ újõöøõ 1%9
Ò2ß
KdmRLKL"ghL"JM·VJMQXgwJMLVlyJx/¼.gh2zKQXJoß\H"OZ\bHKOZ e7Q{OT_ghWu}bLVRdhO2WJM·_`{JMLVT"\<`{H"JlndmR2\{\glMRd,WJML"JMQSR`XgwvxJ
KdmRLKL"ghL"9VRQSR2T_gw2kZ[gw`XHÍ`XH"JRc"gwdhgh``{OQXJE"dmRMVOx\{\gwc"dhÍkz"dw`Xgw"dhJVR2\`P"dRL"L"gwL"JM"gm\OT_J\b`{HVR`
RQXJijO2z"LVTc_`XHKJ½Q{JM`XQ{ghJMvWRd¡"Q{OlyJT_z"Q{J]`{OlyOvxJMQ,§XOWghL`Xdh9RL"JMZ "dmRL"L"ghLK"Q{O2c"dwJMk
Justification-Based REPLAY
RETRIEVAL
Similar scenario
Similar goals
STORAGE
ADAPT, MERGE
planning cases
Extra work:
Operator-Based
Planner
L I B R A R Y
O F
Relevant features
of scenario
GENERATION
Rationale capture
Successes and failures
Multiple indexing by
goal interactions
P L A N N I N G
C A S E S
¼.gh2zKQXJoß_ /efQXOTgh2}LVRdwO22À µJM`{QXgwJMvWRd(¯xQ{JM"dmRMx¯xWJML"JMQSR`XgwO2L,¯KRLVT\`XO2QSRWJ]Oi"dRL"L"gwL"]JE"gm\OT_J\y
}µij`XJEQfRP"Q{O2c"dwJMk%\O2dhvghLK]lER2\Jgm\.2JML"JEQ^R`{JT¡¯xgh`gm\f\`XO2Q{JT¡/¼"QXOWkÖ`{H"JbJE·_"dwO2QSR`XgwO2LOi,`XHKJP\JRQSlH
\VR2lnJ]RLVTc_ijO2dwdhOZ[ghLK]`XHKJ\z"cK2OxRdhgwL"dwghL"K\¨gwL`XHKJT_JMQ{ghvWR`{ghO2L~Rd¡`{Q^RWlyJPOi`XHKJP"dmRL,¯"`XHKJ\K\`{JMk
gT_JML`Xg¿VJ\y¯VijO2QPJRWlHWOxRd(¯,`XH"J\JMÒi (¨¦{£ *x¦{ªn¢<îÀ¤¦{^«xÝ xÜh¢ Üm«xÝ*ª[LKJlyJ\{\XRQ{>`{O>RWlHKghJMvxJo`XHVR`P2ORd((`
Q{Jlyz"QS\gwvxJMdholyQ{JR`{J\f`XH"J/ïE««2¢ îÀ¤nÜmÝ_¢OiRPzV\JEQ 2ghvxJELWOxRdÀlyOWL§Xz"LVln`¨cT_OWghL"2ORdÀQXJMWQXJ\{\ghOWL¿pyºr2(¯
g Jx,"Q{O§XJly`{ghL"cVR2l^]gw`^\ZJRxJ\`f"Q{JlyO2L~T_gh`{ghO2L~\ghL`XOP`{H"J[dhgw`XJMQSRd\ gwL`XH"J[gwL"gh`{gmRdK\`SR`{JxfÙ<H"J[dwgh`{JMQ^Rdm\
gwL`XH"JoghL"gw`XgRd\`^R`XJRQXJx¯V`XH"JEQXJyijOWQXJx¯^£2¢¦j¥«x¤yÜ ¦ ]RWlMlyOWQ^T_gwL"`XO9`XH"JWOxRd7lyO2L§XzKLVly`P`{HVR`PJEk"dhOxJT
`{H"JMk gwLBgw`^\\OWdhz"`{ghO2L´ ORd/QXJE2QXJu\X\gwO2LRWly`^\RW\]RLÑJM·_KdmRL~R`XgwO2L@Oi`{H"J\zVlMlyJu\X\ ijzKdfVR`{H,¼"OxO2`
KQXghL`XgwL"gm\\gwkghdRQ/`XOJM·"dmRLVR`{ghOWL_(c~R2\JuTghL~T_JM·ghL"o`XJl^H"L"g *z"Ju\P¾pE2Ò2.RLVT>l^H_zKL"_gwL"¸ß*s,gwL`{HVR`
gw`[zV\Ju\[RL>JE·_"dRLVR`XgwO2L"QXOvgmT_JuTFc`XH"Jo\zKc"2ORdhgwL"9lHVRghLÍ\zK""dhgwJTc`XHKJ½zKLVT_JMQ{dhghL"T_O2kRghL
`{H"JMOWQXx
Ù<H"J9\K\`XJEk Rz"`XOWkR`{gmlMRdhdhÍgmT_JEL_`{g¾VJ\`XH"J\JM`^\OigwL_`{JMQ^RWly`XgwL"2OxRdm\]OiR"dRLÕcVRQ{`XgRdhdw
OWQ^T_JEQXghLKÕ`XH"J`{O2`SRdhdwO2Q^TJMQXJTI\O2dwz"`XgwO2LijO2zKLVT¡áÙ<H"J@lyOWL"L"Jln`XJTqlyO2kVOWL"JML`^\Oio`XH"JÍVRQ{`XgRdhdw
OWQ^T_JEQXJT"dmRLT_JM`{JMQXk9ghL"J/`XHKJbgwLVT_JMVJMLVTJML_`.ijQ^RWkJML`^\Oi.`XH"JlER2\JJRWlH9lyO2Q{QXJ\VO2LVT_gwL"]`{OR\JE`Öi
gwL_`{JMQ^RWly`XgwL"2ORd\y ¨RWlHÍlMRW\Jgm\<kz"dw`XghKdhghL~T_JM·JTc`{H"J\JoT_g¿³ÀJMQXJML`\JE`^\<Oi7ghL`XJMQSR2ly`{ghL"o2OxRdm\n
(LÕefQXOTgh2 }LVRdwO22q\O2z"QSlyJRL~TB`^RQX2JE`lMR2\JcVJMdhOWL"`XOÍ`XH"J\{RkJ9T_OWkRgwL,GIHKJMLRLKJMZ
KQXO2cKdhJMkÚg\<"QXJu\JML`XJT`{O`XH"Jo\K\`{JMk¯`XH"JQXJE`XQXgwJMvWRdÀ"QXOlyJuT_z"QXJkzV\`»VRQX`{gmRdwdhV/kR`SlH`XHKJ½LKJMZ
gwL"gh`{gmRd.\`^R`XJRLVT>WOxRd7\`^R`XJMk9JML_`CRRghL~\`P`{H"J]gwLVT_gmlnJ\<Oi/`{H"JlER2\Ju\µgwL>`XHKJ]lER2\Jodhgwc"Q^RQXx[Ù.RcKdhJÒ
\H"OZ\½`{H"JQ{JM`XQ{ghJMvWRdf"QXOlnJT_z"Q{JZ[H"JEQXJ`XH"Jz"LVT_JEQXdhghLK\`{Q^R`{JM2@gm\`XO>WJM`2z"gT"RL~lyJijQ{O2k lMRW\J\
`{HVR`lyOvxJMQ`XH"JdmRQXWJ\`VOx\X\ghc"dwJo\JM`[Oi/ghL`XJMQSR2ly`{ghL"o2ORdm\n
Ù<H"JQXJM`{QXghJEv2RdfRdhWO2QXgw`XH"kijOlnzV\J\O2L@QXJM`{QXgwJMv_gwL"VR2\`lMRW\J\PZ[H"JMQ{J`{H"J"dRL"L"JEQ½JE·_VJMQ{ghJMLVlnJT
J *z"gwvWRdhJEL_`2OxRdgwL_`{JMQ^RWly`XgwO2LV\RLVTHVR2\[RQXJuR2\OWLVRcKdhJkR`SlH9cJE`ZJMJMLgwL"gh`{gmRd,\`SR`{J\<cVJlMRz~\J`XH"JEL
gwòlMRLJM·VJly`P`{OÍR2l^H"ghJMvxJoRdmRQXWJQ{JT_zVly`{ghOWLghL`XHKJL"JMZÖKdmRLKL"ghL"F\JRQ^l^HBJy³ÀOWQX`MÙ<H"JQ{JM`XQ{ghJMvWRd
KQXOlyJTz"QXJkRM]Q{JM`XzKQXLR\JM`<Oi\ghk9ghdmRQf"dRL"L"gwL"lER2\Ju\y /R2l^HQXJM`{QXghJEvxJTlMR2\JP"Q{OvgmTJ\f2z"gT"RLVlnJ
`{OoR½\JM`fOi,ghL`XJEQ^R2ln`XghLKbWOxRd\7ijQ{O2kÖ`{H"J[`^RQXWJM`/2OxRd(/}P\RLJM·"Rk"dwJx¯¼ghWz"QXJr\H"OZ\¨RPL"JEZKQXO2c
dwJMk²RLVT>`ZOVR2\`lMRW\J\P\JMdhJuly`XJTijOWQPQXJMKdmRMc_ÍRL~RdhOW2xÙ<HKJlMRW\J\PRQXJVRQX`{gmRdwdhghL~\`^RL_`{gmR`XJT
`{OkFR`^l^H`{H"JL"JMZ®\gh`{zVR`{ghOWL,<¼"z"Q{`XH"JEQ<ghL~\`^RL_`{gmR`XghOWLV\[OlMlyz"Q[Z[H"gwdhJPQ{JM"dRughLK"
Ò2r
213
/26
+ 21"
+ !0 % !5!
.! !4 9 #23
"! #%$ !'&!
( $*)$,+.-/#
#!9$' !0!
01-/2 ! 243 65798
!9$'>=<!9 !)- !0!4 !3
3
!9$'> =<!9 @ !0 /A " 2 4 #!293!#% %.!4<!93 5*,B.5!5 !!5 /A "24 %'
!9$'> =!D !0 !4 %. !3726
-.! "- E !3
3'B5*,B.5 !0 3E<!
% !0!
!
<; !9$'> =<!9 !0 !3!<3
2G
<; !9$'> =<!9 !0! 0/33914 /
<!93 + 213
I
<K L2 #! *4 ' !0%' 7 " M
<!3
0/3314(/-2 !521 .21 4 21! 39
4 <'!3 3'
N !5/2 !0 9!O
N !5217<!02 3.
'! % 4(/3!4 !0 '! 3' 39
26I
5!0 /A "2
4 $.!2'3!#% %!4
<!3 5 !53/221.!!4 %' !-!3726I
<R 78#/!!5 . #21!1D
- 0/26 4 2 !01
<!3
%' <T !0D
<!3
% 0/"!!0/! !9 7#/!!09 #26!1U
- 0/26 "! + !0 +
#!# !0!
!0 4 !1&)26$.!
#!# !0'! '4 !03.
'! './% <; 4 !5 !.!0/
<!93 " 87.!0
#21
!5210
21!0"0I
5 !0 <!0 3/221.! 39
! !09! '4 <'!3 3'
53.!#/ + !0 !0!02 %!<" 387.21I
5
%! !9 J <; 4 !0!X W + !0 !0!!5I
<!3 5!0% ! ! P <; 4 ! 0'!X W + !0 !5!!0
<'!3 5 !0 321!0 A/ " 2 4#!293!#% %' !
<'!3 5
%.! ! P : <;
;
? <
C <;
F
H
J
P
Q
S
:
V
:B:
:
?
Ù.Rc"dwJoÒ_ µJM`{QXgwJMv_gwL"o\gwkghdRQ<~R2\`lMRW\J\
Ù<H"JQXJE"dmRMkJl^HVRLKgm\k ghLvxO2dhvxJu\[RlnO2k"dwJM`XJgwL_`{JMQX"Q{JM`^R`XgwO2L>Oi`XH"J§XzV\`Xg¿ÀlMR`{ghOWL@\`XQ{zVly`{z"QXJ\
RL"L"OW`^R`{JTghL`{H"JVR2\`lMRW\J\ghL`{H"JÍlyO2L`XJM·`]Oi`XHKJLKJMZ©KQXO2cKdhJMk `{OBcVJÍ\OWdhvxJTÀ xz"gwv2RdhJML`
l^H"OWgmlyJ\RQXJÍkR2T_JZ[H"JEL`XHKJ`{Q^RLV\ ijOWQXkJT§XzV\`Xg¿ÀlMR`{ghOWLV\HKO2dmTÀ ç`XH"JMQ{Z[gm\Jx¯<efQ{OT_ghW u}bLVRdwO2W
KdmRL~\9ijOWQ`XHKJL"JMZ°2ORdm\zV\ghL"Ñgh`^\9T_O2kRghLqO2VJMQ^R`XOWQ^\>RWT"T_gwL"ÕL"JMZ²\`XJMV\`{OÕ`XH"J@\O2dwz"`XgwO2LIO2Q
\_gw""gwL"z"L"L"JlnJ\X\{RQXØ\`{JMV\µijQ{O2k`{H"JVRW\òlMR2\J\yÙRc"dhJt\HKOZ\P`{H"JkRgwL VOZáOiµlyO2L`XQ{O2dfOi
`{H"JQXJMKdmRMRdw2OWQXgh`{H"k
Past cases
(goal (inside-airplane ob3 pl5))
(relevant-state (at-obj ob3 <ap3>)
(at-airplane pl5 a12))
(goal (inside-truck ob8 tr2))
(relevant-state (at-obj ob8 p4)
(at-truck tr2 <ap7>))
New problem
(goal (inside-airplane ob3 pl5)
(inside-truck ob8 tr2))
(initial-state
(inside-truck ob3 tr2)
(at-truck tr2 p4)
(at-airplane pl5 a12)
(at-obj ob8 p4))
¼.gh2zKQXJr <efRW\`lMR2\J\[lyOvxJMQ`XH"JL"JMZ 2ORdRLVTVRQ{`XgRdhdwkR`^l^H`{H"JL"JMZ gwL"gh`{gmRdÀ\`^R`{Jx
t2
2L #!*4 !0%. 0'!XW #!5!0!B
! 4(21E !0 ! 4 %/
#% 3 2 3
*4 !521 4 2 '
!9 21"
.7#% + 2 ; 4 4(#/21 3/.!21
I5!0 "3.!023
3.!#/ 4 + #%!0 %/
#%
39 ! !0 .2121#!9!
<; 4 %. 4 26E
<!3' 35!5
6/!9 W 3'!
6; 4 !78'
!9
I5 % !<! ? C : '
!9 !0%
# ! ! !5<3<
B 73 !5 3'<! ! !
C ? 21! + %' 3!9 C C 3! !0 2!2 3 9 $ !03B
5 "5&(7 #4 2
C F '
!9 !5 2!92 .
"#
#% 3 3
<; 4 ! 78
!I
!5 %' T9 /! W 3! 21321
4 4(#/21!M
< 26 #.4 L2 +
93!9 <! ! ? !0 + 29!2 ! !03 B 73 !0 3 !9! !
C H $
3!9
!<! ? C J
<; 4 .3"<2!92 4 21'
!39 3 5!0
; 4 !3
! 5%. !9<! ? F : 3 *4 !3 " #!03/2921!!0!B
!0 + .
2!2
!!0<3' B 78.3!0<3 !!
F ? $
!
3! F C -!0 2!2 !<! : F F
: <K
? F
C
ÙRc"dhJot_ /Ù<HKJ]kRghL V OZ OilnO2L`XQXOWd,Oi`XH"JQ{JM"dmRMKQXOlyJTz"QXJx
t_p
¼ ghWz"QXJpE\H"OZ\f`XH"J[Q{JM"dRuJMKgm\OTJb`{OP2JMLKJMQ^R`XJRP\OWdhz"`{ghO2L`XO`{H"J[L"JMZ"Q{O2c"dwJMkÖOi.¼gw2z"Q{J[r_
Ù<HKJL"JMZ \gh`Xz~R`XgwO2LÕg\\H"OZ[LR`]`XHKJQXgw2H`½H~RLVTÕ\gmT_J9Oi[`{H"JVWz"QXJFRLVTB`{H"J`ZO>VRW\ò2z"gT_ghL"
lER2\Ju\bR`b`{H"JdhJyijÈ
cn1 - goal
n1 - goal
(inside-airplane ob3 pl5)
(inside-airplane ob3 pl5)
cn2 - op
n2 - op
(load-airplane ob3 pl5 a4)
(load-airplane ob3 pl5 a4)
:precond-of user
:relevant-to cn1
:sibling-ops
((load-airplane ob3 pl5 a12)
(goal-loop (inside-airplane ob3 pl5)))
cn3 - goal
(at-airplane pl5 a4)
:precond-of cn2
cn4 - op
(fly-airplane pl5 a12 a4)
:relevant-to cn3
:why-this-op (applicable)
cn5 - APPLY
(fly-airplane pl5 a12 a4)
cn6 - APPLY
(load-airplane ob3 pl5 a4)
cn1’ -goal
(inside-truck ob8 tr2)
:precond-of user
:precond-of user
:relevant-to n1
n3 - goal
(at-airplane pl5 a4)
:precond-of n2
n4 - op
(fly-airplane pl5 a12 a4)
:relevant-to n3
n5 - APPLY
(fly-airplane pl5 a12 a4)
n6 - goal
(inside-truck ob8 tr2)
:precond-of user
n7 - op
(load-truck ob8 tr2 p4)
:relevant-to n6
n8 - APPLY
(load-truck ob8 tr2 p4)
n9 - goal
(at-obj ob3 a4)
cn2’ - op
(load-truck ob8 tr2 p4)
:relevant-to cn1’
:sibling-ops
((load-truck ob8 tr2 <ap7>)
(goal-loop (inside-truck ob8 tr2)))
:precond-of n2
n10- op
(unload-truck ob3 tr2 a4)
:relevant-to n9
n11 - goal
(at-truck tr2 a4)
cn3’ - goal
(at-truck tr2 p4)
:precond-of n10
:precond-of cn2’
n12 - op
cn4’ - op
:relevant-to n11
(drive-truck tr2 <ap7> p4)
:relevant-to cn3’
cn5’ - APPLY
(drive-truck tr2 <ap7> p4)
cn6’ - APPLY
(load-truck ob8 tr2 p4)
(drive-truck tr2 p4 a4)
n13 - APPLY
(drive-truck tr2 p4 a4)
n14 - APPLY
(unload-truck ob3 tr2 a4)
n15 - APPLY
¼ gw2z"Q{JpE_ bJMQ{ghvWR`{ghO2L~Rd,QXJE"dmRMOi/kz"dh`{gh"dwJlMR2\J\y
Ù<H"J<`{Q^RLV\ ijJMQ.OlMlyzKQ^\cghL`XJMQ{dhJRMvghL"`XH"J`ZObWz"gmTghL"lMR2\J\y¯WJEQijO2Q{kghLKRL]RWT"T_gw`XghOWLVRdZ<OWQX
LKJMJT_JT`{ORWlMlyO2k9"dhg\HQXJMkRghL"gwL"\z"c"WOxRd\y¯ÀRLVTÍ\gh"KghL"VRW\`Z<OWQX`{HVR`T_OxJ\[L"O2`L"JMJuTF`{OcVJ
TO2L"Jx9(LVRQ{`Xgmlnz"dmRQM¯,`XH"J9lMRW\JL"OT_J\ 0=8 $ `{H"QXOWz"2H 0 8 RQ{JLKO2`]Q{JMzV\JT¡¯,RW\½`XHKJMQXJg\½R`{QXzVl^
RdhQ{JR2T_×R``XHKJVOx\Ò*lnJghLÕ`{H"JL"JEZ©"Q{O2c"dwJMkÍÙ<H"JL"OTJ*\ 8&! #@lyOWQXQ{J\VO2L~T×`{Oz"L"Wz"gmT_JuT
RWT"T_gw`XghOWLVRdÀ"dmRL"L"gwL"T_OWL"JPgwL`XH"JL"JMZIJE"gm\OT_Jx }[`/L"OT_7J 8 ¯efQXOTgh2 }LVRdwO229"QXz"LKJ\ÖWz"`[RL
Rdh`{JMQXLVR`XgwvxJ½OWVJMQ^R`XO2QE¯¡LVRkJMdh`XO9dhOxRWT`{H"J]`{QXzVl^R`éRL>RghQ{OWQXÈ¯cVJlMRzV\JOi/`XHKJ]QXJulyO2QST_JT~R2\`
i Rghdwz"QXJR`P`XH"JWz"gmTghL"LKOT_>J 0=8 Ù<H"JQXJlnO2Q^TJT>QXJRW\OWL>ijO2Q`XHVR`bi Rgwdhz"Q{Jx¯VLVRkJEdhR2ORd¿(dwOxO2
Z[gw`XHÍ`XH"J / 8:./ - ' ),+90 ; ',)¯xgm\[vWRdhgT"R`{JTghL`{H"J]LKJMZ \gh`{zVR`{ghO2L´¯VR2\[`XHVR`bWOxRd.gm\<gwL`XH"J
lnz"QXQ{JML_`é\JM`POi[OWJELBWOxRd\y¯R`PL"OTJ 8
"oabOW`XJ`XH~R``XH"J`ZO>lER2\Ju\PRQ{JkJEQX2JuTzV\ghL"Rc"gR2\P`XO
VO\`XVOWL"JR2T"Tgh`XgwO2LVRdKdmRLKL"ghL"LKJMJT_JTÀ bg¾³ÀJMQ{JML_`kJMQ{2J\RQXJVOx\{\gwc"dhJx
Ù<H"JQXJMKdmRM ijzKLVly`XgwO2LVRdhgw`@`XQSRLV\(ijO2Q{k\]`XH"J"dRL"LKJMQM¯ijQ{O2k RkOT_z"dwJ`XH~R`9lyOx\`Xdh@2JEL"JMQ^R`XJ\
VO\X\gwc"dhJO2VJMQSR`{O2Q^\P`{O>RWlHKghJMvxJ`XHKJ2OxRdm\RL~TB\JRQSlH"Ju\µ`{H"QXOWz"2H@`XH"J\VR2lnJOi[Rdh`{JMQXLVR`XgwvxJ\µWJML_
SQ#% nü»ù[ü Wþ üf'ù &Müjú þ ûjüj2ù -4
û þ ' ù[öøõû»ùújü»ùÿ þ ü þ õ ' - yöÏõMü xöøõEü»ùújú " -ü»öÏõ 1 þ õÿ]öÏõMü»ùú øù þ ÷Möøõ 1Pü ù - þ ûjü {þ ûjùû þ õÿ
õ nü " ûjü þ ü,ü ù/ùõÿ )Kü ù {þ ûjùû 9
t2Ò
(load-airplane ob3 pl5 a4)
JEQ^R`{JT¡¯[ghL`XOÑRBkOTz"dhJ`XH~R``{J\`S\`XH"JÍvWRdhgT_gh`ÕOio`XH"JØlH"OWgmlyJu\]"QXOWO\JTIc~R2\`9JM·_VJMQ{ghJML~lyJ
RLVT ijOWdhdhOZ\bJ *z"gwvWRdhJEL_`\JRQ^l^H@T_ghQ{Jly`{ghO2L~\yoÙ<H"JQ{JM"dRu"Q{OlyJT_zKQXJx¯.\HKOZ[L@ghL`{H"J"QXOlyJuT_z"QXJOi
Ù.RcKdhJt¯""QXOvgmT_Ju\¨`XHKJéijOWdhdwOZ[gwL"cVJML"Jy~`^\y e7Q{O2VOx\{RdRLVTBvWRdwgmT"R`XghOWLÕOiµlHKO2gmlnJ\bvxJMQS\zV\P2JEL"JMQ^R`XgwO2LRLVTÕ\JuRQ^l^H@OiRdw`XJMQ{LVR`{ghvxJ\
(\`{JMV\Ò_¯Vthp2¯Vtøt¯Vt_ºK¯VRLVTº"wp^
µJTzVly`XgwO2LOi<`{H"Jc"QSRLVl^H"ghLKi RWly`XOWQ ,FVR2\`éi RghdwJT>Rdh`XJEQXLVR`XghvxJu\[RQXJKQXz"L"JuT>c_Ív2Rdhg¿
T"R`{ghL"o`XH"J[i Rgwdhz"Q{J\QXJulyO2QST_JTghL`XHKJbVRW\`ClMR2\J\[(\`{JM9t_º g¾iÀcVR2l^`XQ^RWlghLKPgm\fL"JMJuT_JT
e7Q{OT_ghW u}bLVRdhO2WcVR2l^_`{Q^RWlK\<Rdm\OgwL`XHKJP2z"gT_ghLKlMR2\J\ ,`{H"QXOWz"2HÍ`XH"JPdwghL"K\¨Ju\`^Rc_
dhgm\H"JTR`\`{JMV\PtøÒ_¯´t_øòRLVT>º"ÏÒ ,RLVTzV\Ju\bghL_ijOWQXkR`XgwO2L>OWL>i Rgwdhz"Q{J]`XOkRxJkO2Q{J
ghL_ijOWQXkJTcVR2l^_`{Q^RWlghL"T_Jlyg\gwO2LV\n
xz"c"WOxRdwghL"dwghL"K\<gmT_JEL_`{g¾ij`{H"J\z"c"VRQX`^\Oi/`{H"JlMRW\J`{OQ{JM"dmRM ,9`XH"J\`XJEV\b`XH~R`RQXJ
L"O2`VRQ{`[Oi`XH"JoRWly`XgwvxJbWOxRd\bRQXJo\ghKJuT¡/Ù<H"J"QXOlnJT_z"Q{J½`{OR2T_vWRLVlyJ`XH"JolMRW\J\n¯VR2\
lMRdwdhJTghL@\`{JMV\PtøÒ¯,t_ÏòRLVT>º"ÏÒ_¯,ghWL"O2Q{J\b`{H"J2ORdm\`XHVR`]RQXJL"OW`PL"JMJuT_JTRL~T>`XH"JMgwQ
lyO2Q{QXJ\OWLVT_gwL""dRL"L"gwL"\`{JMV\n
È"ÅMâÊjå ÉjÈ"Å V
ä âÈâÊ VÓ.È"É Ä_åã.ÓÊ .Ä_æ
aO2`XJ`{HVR``XH"JVRQX`{gmlyz"dRQlyOWk"z"`SR`{ghO2L~Rd¡`{Jl^H"L"g xz"J\/JMk"dwOxJTgwLefQXOT_gw2 }bL~RdhOW2ØRQXJ RL"L"OW`^R`XghLKP`XH"JCT_Jlyg\gwO2LL"OT_J\.RL~T½QXJn(gwL_`{JMQX"Q{JM`^R`XgwO2LOiV`{H"JÀ§XzV\`{g¾ÀlER`XgwO2L\`XQ{zVly`{z"QXJ\n¯
`XH"JPijOxO2`(KQXghL`XgwL"ghL`XH"JolMRW\Jo\`{O2QSR2JKQXOlyJ\{\y¯
`XH"JolMRdmlyz"dR`{ghO2LOi/`XH"Jo\ghkgwdmRQ{gh`]k9JM`XQ{gml<ghL`{H"JQXJM`{QXghJEv2Rd(¯KRLVT
`XH"J2zKgmT"RLVlyJ]ckz"dw`Xgw"dhJlMRW\J\[ghL`{H"JQXJM"dRM"Q{OlyJ\{\y
´««2¢ îÀ¤nÜmÝ_¢ ÜmÝ2¥]\H"OZ<JT`XOcVJRL>gwL_`{JMQXJ\`XgwL"`XJl^H"L"g *zKJP`XO~LVTWOxRd¿(Q{JMdhJEv2RLVlyJxCÙ OghdwdhzV\`XQ^R`XJ
HKOZ°ijOxO2`("Q{ghL`XgwL"ÕZ<OWQXK\y¯lyOWLV\gT_JMQ9RÕT_O2kFRghLqZ[H"JMQ{J@RBQXOWcOW`kOvxJ\]RkO2L"ÑQXOxO2kF\"zV\H"ghL"
cVO·J\y [OxO2k\RQXJlnO2L"L"July`XJT`XH"Q{O2z"WHÕTOxO2Q^\P`{HVR`lERLcVJO2VJML,¯´lydhO\JT¡¯ÀO2QPdwOlxJTÀb¼.gh2zKQXJp2p
\H"OZ\fR<"Q{O2c"dwJMk%»WOxRdm\y¯WghL"gw`XgmRdx\`^R`{J2ÀRL~T½gh`S\ijOxO2`("Q{ghL` ijOWQfR<KdmRL´fabOW`XJ/`XHVR` ijOxOW` "QXgwL_`{ghL"RL~T
gw`^\fL"OW`XghOWLOi´2ORd¾ QXJEdhJMvWRL~lyJ[gm\/T_JMVJML~T_JML`ÖWL`{H"JVRQ{`Xgmlnz"dmRQ/\OWdhz"`{ghO2LFlyO2LV\gmT_JEQXJT¡.(LVRQ{`Xgmlnz"dmRQM¯
Tg¾³ÀJMQXJEL_`"dRLV\PijO2Q]`{H"J9\XRk9J"QXOWc"dhJMk lERLÕzV\JT_g¿³¡JEQXJML`bijJR`Xz"Q{J\½Oi[`XHKJghL"gw`XgRd/RLVTB`XHKJMQXJyijOWQXJ
ghJEdmTT_g¿³ÀJMQXJML`<ijOxO2`(KQXghL`^\n
t2t
2'
P= S( ,
&:*P
*,,
=<H*12SO1%'
H &R &(
,
H &S(S&,
H &S( &
*,
:*H ,
F 2O Q *,
&
%H :%Z>,
=F&&>F1O &
X&,
=F&&>F1O R&
&
>,
:*2&&
P= S( &,
P= S(
&,
P= +1ZR*,
&:*PR,
%2F1+&S*,
):U*OPI(*2X(,
F& * FOY
S& &,
F& * FOY &
&>,
7!%77 (,
$#A! AN77 (Y ,
7 ! A
,
7!%7 N77 ,
7 ! A
,
7!%7 N77 >,
7# N77 >,
G% :=% GSI*R=<H*12SO1%
H &R &(
,
:*H ,
F 2O Q*,
&
%H :%Z>,
=F&&>F1O &
X&
,
=F&&>F1O R&
&
>,
G Y(I F&&
U>F*P0
H &S( &,
:*H ,
2O/
: U*OHI&(>2 (,
= F&&>F1OQ &
,
¼gw2z"Q{Jp2p2 Ù<H"JPijOxO2`(KQXghL`XJuTghLKgh`XgRd´\`^R`XJPijO2QR"dmRL>RLVTWOxRd
tº
x ghL~lyJL"O2`Rdhd,ijJR`{z"QXJu\bghLÍ`XH"JijOxO2` "Q{ghL`XJT>gwL"gh`{gmRd.\`^R`XJRQ{J]J
xzVRdhdh9QXJMdwJMvWRL`bgwL\OWdhvghL"9`XH"J
~RQX`{gmlyzKdmRQ[WOxRd(¯V`XH"JbijOxOW` "QXgwL_`{JTgwL"gh`{gmRd,\`SR`{J½g\<O2Q{xRLKghYMJTgwL>RTgm\XlnQXghk9ghLVR`XghOWL`{QXJMJ/Ù<H"gm\<`{QXJMJ
lER"`{z"QXJ\T_g¾³ÀJMQ{JML`¨dwJMvxJMd\ Oi.QXJMdwJMvWRLVlyJ[c`XHKJT_gm\`^RLVlyJ`XO]`{H"JQXOxO2È<} \`{O2Q{JTlMRW\Jgm\fghLVTJM·_JuTc
`{H"J]~RQ^RkJM`{QXghYEJT2ORd/RLVT`{H"J½ijOxOW` "QXgwL_`{JTgwL"gh`{gmRd.\`^R`XJxCÙ<H"J]gwLVT_JM·ghL"WOxRdm\PRQXJ\`XOWQXJTghLR
H~R2\H`SRc"dwJOWghL`XgwL"`XO`XH"JoT_g\XlyQ{ghkgwLVR`{ghOWLL"JE`ZO2Q{Oi/`XH"JPijOxOW` "QXgwL_`{JTghL"gw`XgmRd,\`^R`{Jx
Ù<H"JlMR2\JPQXJM`{QXgwJMvWRd"gT_JML`Xg¾~J\f\gwkghdRQfKQXO2cKdhJMk\R2lMlyOWQ^T_gwL"]`{O]`{H"JµijOWdhdwOZ[gwL"ªEÜmìÜhíÞ£x¤yÜh¢ ë]ì¦^¢ ¤nÜm
`{HVR``SRxJ\ghL`XOØR2lMlyOWz"L`]`XHKJlyO2Lu§Xz"LVlyò2OxRdm\]kR`^l^H"JT>`{O>`XHKJ`^RQX2JE`2OxRdm\RLVTÕ`XH"J9T_JMWQXJMJOi
kFR`^l^HOi/`XH"JPijOxOW` "QXgwL_`{JTghL"gw`XgmRd,\`^R`{J]`{HVR`lyOWQXQ{J\VO2L~T"\b`XO`{H"J\J]lnO2L§Xz"L~ly`bWOxRdm\y
/
5 ! I I UVJE` ÖcVJR`^RQX2JE`]"Q{O2c"dwJMk RLVT RÍ\OWz"Q^lyJKQXO2cKdhJMk¯ÀQXJ\July`XgwvxJMdhZ[gw`XHgwL"gh`{gmRd7\`^R`XJ*\ RLVT !@RLVT WOxRdm\ RLVT %!.UVJM` cVJ`XHKJL_zKkcVJMQPOiPdwgh`{JMQ^Rdm\POi kR`SlH"JuT Z[gw`XHÕ`{H"Ox\JOi %!¯fzKLVT_JMQ\z"cV\`Xgw`Xz"`{ghO2
L f¯fRL~T×dwJM`
IcVJ]`XHKJ½kFR`^l^H"JT2ORd\ybUVJM`
cVJ½`{H"J½ijOxOW` "QXgwL_`{JTghL"gw`XgRd,\`^R`XJ]Oi BijOWQb`{H"Jo\JM`[Oi
kFR`^l^H"JT]WOxRdm\ ÜVJM` cVJP`XHKJb Lz"kcJEQfOi.dwgh`XJEQ^Rd\fOi kR`^l^H"JT]Z[gw`XHdwgh`XJEQ^Rd\Oi #!
zKLVT_JMQ\z"c~\`Xgw`Xz"`{ghOWL f
Ù<HKJML @ijOxO2` "Q{ghL`bkR`^l^H"J\ Z[gw`XHkR`SlH9v2Rdhz"J
Ù<H"J]Q{JM"dRu9ghLVlydwzVT_J\[`Z<OkRgwL"QXOlyJuT_z"QXJu\y [`XH"JovWRdhgT"R`{ghOWL>Oi`{H"J[§XzV\`Xg¿ÀlMR`{ghOWLV\bRL"L"OW`^R`{JT
gwL `XHKJlMR2\Jx¯RLVT `XHKJk9JMQXWJOi9`XH"JÕkz"dw`XghKdhJ>Wz"gmTghL"lMR2\J\Õ(RW\>ghdhdwzV\`{Q^R`XJTIghLá¼.gh2zKQXJIpE*^
efQ{OT_ghW u}bLVRdwO2WlERLqlyO2L~\`XQ{zVly`R>L"JMZ \O2dwz"`XgwO2LBijQ{O2k R\JM`]OiPWz"gmTghL"ØlMR2\J\R2\]OW"VOx\JuT`XO
R\gwL"2dwJPVRW\`lMRW\Jx OWk"dhJE·"QXOWc"dhJMkF\¨kRMcVJo\O2dwvxJTcQ{J\OWdhvghL"okghLKO2Q/ghL`XJMQSR2ly`{ghOWLV\<RkO2L"
\ghkKdhJMQÀVR2\`/lMR2\J\y z"gmT"RLVlyJfijQXOWk \JMvxJMQSRdlMRW\J\.lMRL]cVJ<kJEQX2JuTbghLe7Q{OT_ghW u}bLVRdhO2W]gwL]\JMvxJMQSRd
k9OT_J\<Z[gh`{HÍT_g¾³ÀJMQ{JML_`TJM2Q{JMJ\<Oi7T_JMdwghcVJMQSR`XgwO2LO2LÍ`XH"J"Q{JT_gly`XJTdhJMvxJMdVOifgwL_`{JMQ^RWly`XgwO2L,
9ÄË{ÄÅÄ_Ó.åxÄâ Bâã.Ä oãÄ VÅMÆ ´Äå2âÊ VÓ
[RW\glMRdwdhx¯VT_JEQXghvWR`XghOWLVRd.RLVRdwO2W>gm\lyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWL_(c~R2\JuT¡ bJMQXgwvWR`XgwO2LVRdfRLVRdwO2W>ghk9"dhglyg¿`XdhQ{JRdwghYMJu\
RlyOWL"L"Jly`{ghOWL_(c~R2\JuTRLVRdwO2WgmlMRd,ghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJQ^R`XH"JEQ[`XHVRL>R""dw_gwL"`XH"JghL_ijJMQ{JMLVlyJ\Xl^H"JMkFR B
(LÍ`XJMQ{k\<OiRW\VJly`S\µ`{H"J]Q{JM"Q{J\JML`^R`XgwO2L>Oi/`XHKJ]"Q{O2c"dwJMk°\OWdhz"`{ghOWLlyOWQXQXJu\VO2LVTK\b`XO`{H"JoR2\July` RLVTRdwd¨`{H"J\O2dhzK`XghOWL_ QXJMdwJMvWRL`éi RWly`^\olyO2Lu§Xz"LVly`{ghvxJMdw>c"z"gwdmT`XH"J9R2\VJly` o JMQXgwv2R`XgwO2LVRd<RLVRdwO2W
ijOWdhdwOZ\<KQ^R2ln`XgmlERd¡LKJMJT"\/c_ghLVlndhzVT_gwL"]gwL_`{O ®cOW`XHØlyO2L`XQ{O2d¡L"OZ[dhJuT_2JPJELVlyOT_JTgwL§XzV\`{g¾ÀlER`XgwO2LV\
RLVT2ORd¿(Q{JMdhJMvWRL_`]ijJR`Xz"Q{J\]Oié`XH"JghLKgh`XgRdC\`^R`XJxIxgwLVlyJzV\z~RdhdwÕO2LKdhRîK£x¤¢ Üm£2í,kR`SlHlERLcVJ
RWlHKghJMvxJTÀ¯*`{H"JghkKdhgmlngh`/lyOWL"L"Jln`XghOWLV\ P.RQXJOvxJMQXWJML"JMQSRd(
efQXOT_gw2 }bLVRdhOW2oT_LVRkglMRdwdh[JM·`XQSR2ly`S\¡`XH"J\O2dhzK`XghOWL_ QXJMdwJMvWRLìjJR`Xz"Q{J\ OiVRlMRW\J/`XHVR`cVJMdwO2L"
`{O`XHKJ]"Q{O2c"dwJMk°T_J\{lyQXgw"`XgwO2LÍc_ijOxOW` "QXgwL_`{ghL"9`XH"JoghL"gw`XgmRd.\`SR`XJb(LÍR2TKT_gh`{ghO2L´¯¡\O2kJghLijO2QXkFR`XgwO2L
Q{JMdhJEv2RL_``XOoR2l^H"ghJEvxJ¨`{H"J[2ORd ¯*`{HVR`/g\L"O2`/JML~lyOT_JTghL`{H"J["QXOWc"dhJEk%T_J\{lyQXgw"`XgwO2LR`Rdwd(¯2g\fR2l xz"gwQXJT
Tz"QXgwL"]`{H"JP\O2z"QSlyJP"dRL"LKghL""Q{OlyJ\X\RLVTJMLVlyOT_JuTghL`XH"J§XzV\`Xg¾lMR`{ghO2L~\<RLKL"O2`SR`XgwL"`XHKJb"dRL9T_Jy
lngm\gwO2LL"OTJ\yÙ<H"J\J.§XzV\`{g¾ÀlMR`XgwO2LV\fRQXJJMLVlyOTJT]ghLRlyOWL_`{QXO2d¿(dRL"WzVRWJP`XH~R`fg\¨Tg¾³ÀJMQXJEL_`,ijQXOWk%`XH"J
OWc§XJly`(dwJMvxJMd.dmRLK2zVR2JOi[`{H"J"Q{O2c"dwJMk T_Ju\XlyQ{gh"`{ghO2L´]Ù<H"J9lyOWQXQXJu\VO2LVTJMLVlyJOi[`XHKgm\bWOxRd¿(Q{JMdhJEv2RL_`
gwL_ijO2Q{kR`{ghOWLghLÑ\O2zKQ^lyJ9RLVT@`^RQ{2JMòlMRLÕO2LKdh>cVJJu\`^Rc"dhg\H"JuTT_z"QXgwL"`XH"J9RL~RdhOW2glMRdQXJM"dRMRL~T
`{H"gm\.gm\.T_O2L"J[cl^H"Jl^ghL"`XH"J.§XzV\`Xg¿ÀlMR`{ghOWLV\y}\kcOWd_kFR""gwL"gm\,O\X\ghc"dwJ[ghLefQ{OT_ghW u}bLVRdwO2W
c`Jn("Q{J\JEQXvghL"gwLV\`SRL`XgmR`XgwO2LV\n/Ù<H"gm\[RkO2z"L`^\<`{OR\ghkKdhJdhJMvxJMdVOi/QXJyijOWQXkz"dmR`XgwO2L,
# % % !
"!$#&%('*),+,- "-/.0%(12"!$312"!4%(57698:6,8:-/';82+,-/.0!4.0<1,+= 3!$1,->[email protected]$CD%( #E'F1$-,!4G3/1=.41,5=H("'F%(1,5
-BI,'KJMLONPAJQSRUTWV(X(YZ312@[Q\J]_^M`
aV
%(!06% 312@FR I 35" @ T a Y @ "8 .05(1,G@FA8:6,8:-/' #"!4!0"@ Q J]_^ Q123!0%(57. #"! JS%(1 8 -/>3.01 - ]_3)
)=.41,5;^1,57.41,
312@_;8:6,8:-/' QJM Q12"!4%75 -//.073!$6 JS%7128 -B 3.01 - $3-B. 8 C 7#&-/.0%(1 T a V(Y -BI232%7-/I_+28: #&%71,1,"#E-/.4%71,. 8:-3># I,.0-/"#E-/+,B` R I="8 8 6=8 -/ ';8M3B278 "@%71_/"8:+,!4->8 CD/%(' )28:6,# I,%7!4%(57.
# 3!B"8 G3 # I;7
8 !4! (8 -BI,%(B-/. #3! #&%71 $. #E-/.4%7128'F),I (8 .0<.41=5 -BI,/%(!0 %3C 8:-/B+2#&-/+= 3!Z#&%(1 8 . 8:-/1 #&6H
8:';"1 -B. # 8:.4'F.0! 3B.4-:6H$31 @ ),>35(' 3-/. # /!07312#&`MR I,98:-/B+2#&-/+= 3! #E%(128:-/ ".41$- 8:+,),)2%(B- 8 ';"),),.41=58
-BI23-M' $.4'F. <-/I,O#&%(1 8 . 8:-/1 #&6 %"C /! 3-B.4%(1 3!?#E%(/B"8 )2%712@ 12#E
2- 1 -/I=!0'F1$- 8?%3C -/I=- %
"123!0%(5
8 $6 (8B8 +,'F.01,5-/I2"-M- %% /"#E- 8 "/8:.4'F.0! " -B%A-/I= $-/1$-S-/I2"- -/I=6 8 B 78 "/5(+='F1$- 8
%"CS8:.4'F.0! "),/G@ . #"-/"8S"12@F . #& 8/$` .41 #& 8:.4'F.0! "/.4-:6 #"1,1,%(
- 2 B"@ +2#E"@ -B% 8 -B/+2#&-B+, "!?#&%7128 . 8 -B12#&6H(-/I,8:';"1 -B. #S8 .0'F.4! 3/.0-:6#&%(1 8 -/>3.01 - 1 CD%(>#&"8 ';"),),.01,58 %"C ),/"@$. #"-/"!8 MI=. # I 3/8:+,),)2%8:"@
-B%FI28:.4'F.0! 3'F""1,.41,58&`R I,), "5(';"-/. # #E1 -B "!4.4-:6*#&%(1 8 -/>3.01 - C %(>8 ' 3),),.01,58 %"CS!0'F1$- 8
B!4 ("1 -M-B%9-/I,),+=/)2%8:9%3C -/I, 31 3!4%75(. #3! /"78 %71,.41,5=`
"$#&%'(*)+ ,!(
/.0+123+546+'&%+)7+,*898:0(*,;&<(*=>9?:@,&)
Q J ]_^
CD%$#E+28 "8 %71;-/I, 8 +?,),/%$#E"8/8 %"CBADCFEGE3HJIKMLONPLQARLQISJTM%"CS 8 %7+, #&UM.4-/I;!0'F1$- 8 %3C A- 3B5( (8 G@ %719.41$-/>(#&-B.41,58:-//+ #&-/+,>3! H8 ' 31$-/. #7H"312@A),>357';3-B. # #E%(128:-/ ".41$- 8E`WV - 8 )=+,/)2%8:M. 8 -B% 'F%$@ !
I$+,';"1 312"!4%75(. # 3! ' 3),),.01,5;"12@ -/I=1 -B%[#&%('F) 3/9-BI,*#&%('F)=+,-/'F%$@ !S312@_I$+,';31 "123!0%(576
)2:CD%(B';312#E` U
Q JM . 89@ "8:.45(1="@ -B% -BI,[8/3'* 571,>3!M1 @ "12@ @ ""! 8M.0-/I -BI,YXZL[S\XQH@LQ]CN %"C
8:%(+,>#&"8E` R I2"-. 8&H,%71,!46;8:.41,57!48:^+ ,),B%$#&"8B8 "8 "/- 7Z# $!4GR
@ 6*-/I, 8 6=8 -B';8E`
._ 457+,/ `[@ ),. #&- 8 -BI,F.41=),+,- 8 +,)=),!4.0"@ -/%[-/I,*8 6=8 -B'KCD%( 31 7 ,"'F),!4H MI,B;Q\J]_a
^ M(8
+ 8 "@F-/% 8:.4' +,! "-/"1 7 ),! 312"-/.0%(6
1 $6F"123!0%(576
6 2- 1*-/I,c
b % %"WC 3-BM#"+28 Gd
@ $6*@ . e B1 -B. "!
)=/"8B8 +,B312@9-/I=
b2% %"C?I,""-#3+28:"R
@ $69@ f. e /1$-/. 3!,-B'F)2>3-/+=/&` V 1 _ .45(+=/g
` GH $W$
31 @
IhiI A"/-/I,12"'F"8S%3CS-BI, 8 %(+= #& 31 @ - "/57-!0.4-B "! 8&HB"8 )2"#&-B.4!06`
Q 8M.41_-/I= ^SQ R _j L k ,"'F),!0 %"C _ .457+,/
7` H?Q J]_^ 5(1= "!4!46;+28:"8F8 6$/
' %7!4. #\B),BF 8:1$- 3-B.4%71 %3C 8 %(+= #&*312@ - 3B5(- .41 [8 .4'*),!4f. l2"@ 8 .0%(1_%"C-/I, ),/G@ . #"-/ #"! #&+=!4+28E` R I= ),>35 ' 3-/. #9#&%(1 8 -/>3.01 ->8 #E%('F9.01 -B% )=! 5
6 M.4-BI %7),-/.0%(12"! .01,),+,->8 %"CM-/I= CD%7/' mV:]_N L R Q nO
R ooop31 @
q
N ^ r ]_q
^ so7oo>>
` \V:]_N U
L R Q n u
R tM!4'*1 7- v I278A-/5
% 2;5(.01 7 ),!0. #&.0-/!06_(89"1 .41,),+=- CD%(
G(# x
I w/!0'F1$[- yg % /G#&-H/ ! 3-B.4%71?H(CD%(/' +,! z -/I2"- . 8 / !4731$-CD%(M-BI,57%"!?%3C -/I=312"!4%75(6H,` 5,`0H N ^ z r ]_q
^ s|oo7o}S.01,),+,-/)=/"8:1 ->8 -BI,
,. (8 -/% A+ 8 .01 -B12@ "@9';"),),.41=5,` ' 31$-/. #
{ +,B6`SQq
8:.4'F.0! "/.4-:6973!0+,"8M"/ 8 +,)=),!4.0"@F-/% Q J]_>
^ $6F $),!4. #&.4-8 ->3-B'F1$- 8%3C -/I, CD%(B'
:V:]5V j Q ~t#&%712#&)=-Ovt#&%(1
#&),-`vt@ 57/Gv>`
V 1_%( @$ -/%;B),/G8 1$- { +,B.4"8M-/I 3- 8 BA-B% CD%$#E+283-/-B1$-/.4%71_%(1 -/I,9)= 357';3-B. #"!4!06;#&1$-/>3!
78 )2"#&- %3C\- "/57- 312"!4%75,HQ\J]_^ 3!0!4%898 %7'F;"/5(+='F1$- 8 -/%2F73/. ,!0"8M.4-BI { +,G8 -/.0%(1
' 3| H$(8S.41/*FCD%(M#E/%8B8 8 -B/+2#&-B+,/ { +, /.4G8312@*(8 .41
**?*z
^ CD%7 .01 -B/12"! { +,/.0"8
78.41 _ .457+,//
7` ` JS/%8/8 8 -B/+2#E-/+,B { +, /.4G8 .412@ . #3-B -/I 3- -BI, 3128 -B% -BI, { +=/6[8 I=%(+,! @#&%7'F
CDB%(' 8 .41,5_-BI,B!4 ("1 - #&%(B/"8:)2%(12@ 12#&"89.41 -/I=%(-BI, "123!0%(5,` _ %( =3'F)=!4H . Cg[[? . 8
' 3),)2"@ -/
% $H -BI,a
1 $G 8A)2%(!0.4-B. #"!M .0 89#&%(+=! x
@ 2-/>3128 CD/B"@ -B>
% U[[?
` V 1$-/ 1 3! { +,B.4"8.412@ . #3-B -BI23--BI,F"128 A. 8 -/M
% 29CD%(+,1
@ M.4-BI,.41 -/I,*8 -B/+2#E-/+,B -BI23- #&%(1$- ".4128-/I,
{ +,B6H . `W`0H-/I, 3128 F. 8 8:%('F["/5(+='F1$- 3!4B"(@$6 )=/"8:1 -9.01 -BI,_8:-//+ #&-/+,B` _ %( .4128:- 31 #&H
¢£¤?¥8:+,5(57"8 ->8 -B% .0128 ->31$-/. 3-/
**^*z
^¦M.4-BI _),/%7)2%8 .0-/.0%(1

G!¡Q
*^?G
.01 -BI,;- 3B5(- / ),/"8:1$- 3-B.4%71 %"C -BI,7 ,"'F),!4 .41 _ .05(+,B
` ` R I, { +, /
6
*
?3* .41
)=/%()2%8 .4-B.4%75
1 ¢££\%"CS-/I= ->3B5(-MB),/G8 1$- 8 -BI,+,^1 $1,% M1# 3+28:A%3C I,""
- b % `
Q\J]_^ I2(
8 21 3),),!0.4"@F-B% =3'*),!4"8S-/I2"-.012#&!0+2@ ),B% ,!0' ';"),),.01,5$
8 @ 3-/ §
b2% Ï,"3b % $),! 312"-/.4%71?H!0.45(I$B
- ,+,P! M>(@ . 3-/.0%(1_),B% ,!0';8EH CD%(/-B/"8B
8 M>(@ . 3-B.4%(1_)=/% =!4';[8 H2"123!0%(5(. #3!
"/57+,'F1$- 8EH $),! 312"-/%(B6[312"!4%(57.4"8EH 8 -/%7/6[31 3!4%75(.0"8&H' 3),),.01,5
8 2- 1_8 - 8%"CS';3-BI,';"-/. #3!
CD%7/' +,! 78&H=312@;'F- "),I,%7 8&`
a
+ 3+.
(*'
. 23(*%: 8 &=
_ B%('K-BI,9.41=),+,-#&%7128 . 8 -B.41,5F%"C-/I,9B),/G8 1$- "-/.4%7128%"C -BI, 8 %7+, #E 312@-BI,9- "/5( -312@_%()=-/.4%7123!
.01 CD%(B';3-B.4%71 %7+,- 8 .0'F.4! 3B.4-:6;31 @ ), "5(';"-/. # .0'F)2%(/->312#E Q\J]_^ 571,>3-B"8 1,-%(| `FR I=
1=- %([(88/# I,';"-/. # 3!4!06 @ . 8:),! 6"@F.01 _ .45(+=/6 a #E%(128:. 8 ->8%3C +,1,.4->8 -BI23-/ ),/"8:1$-MI 6$)2%(-/I="8 "8
2%(+,- -/I, )2".4/.01,5%"CO8 %7+, #& 312@ - "/57-A!0'F1$- 8EH%3C-%_8 )2"#E. 3!BD), "5(';"-/. # 31 @ 8 ' 31$-/. #
+=1,.4->8&H "12@ %3C =#&.0-/%(B6 312@ .41,I=P. ,.0-/%(B6 !4.4?1 ,D
8 2- 1 -/I,_+=1,.4->8&` n+,'/2/G@ # 3),.0- 3!!4 -/-/ 8
B),B"8 1$-?),B%()2%8:.4-/.0%(128EH+,1,1$+,R
' 2B"@ #"),.4->3!$!4-B-/>8/)=/"8:1 -?)=/"@ . #3-B"8&H731 @ !4% #78 S!4 -/-/ 8
B),B"8 1$-S% /"#E- 8&`S%(!0. @ !0.41,G8 /)=/"8:1 -S =#&.0- 3-B%(B6A!4.0^1 =8 "12@F@ %7-/-B"@ !4.01,"8/ ),/"8:1$-.41,I=P. ,.0-/%(B6
!0.4^1 =8&ÙQK1,- %(| 78 .01 _ .457+,/
a #&%7128 . 8 - 8F%"C9+,1,.0- 8 -BI23-*/),B"8 1 -FI$6$)%7-/I,G8 "8F 2%(+,-[-/I,
) 3.4B.41,5[%3C 8 %(+= #&*312@ - 3B5(- !4 'F1$- 8&H2%3C - %[8 )2"#&. 3!S+,1,.0- 8EH "12@ %"C ,#E.4-/%7/6 312@_.41,I=P. ,.0-/%(B6
!0.4^1 =§
8 2- 1F-/I,+,1=.4- 8E`
a
!"#%$
&'
()*&,+
.-'
(
(/0"#$
&'
())1&2
'!3#$4#5'
6)*&7)
3'89(!"#$
:9'%;#$
:'%2<&=)
.>%'()?#%$
:'%%+@#%$
:'%2)@&A)
B/%%C%%D"#$#9'
6E#%$
:'%7)@&F)
B/%%C%%D"#$
:9'%;#$
:'%G9C&H)
.>%'()!3#$:'7?#$:'G51&I
J -
&K-8MLN(POQ
-?&K:9'?RTS
.-
&0"#$#9'
6E#%$
:9'E#%$
&'
(E#$//5@&,+VU)
J /%%C%%EC--CW5P'9E-
&XS
'5D.&I?&,+CU@&,++
.:%C85D"#%$4#9'6)Y#$4
:'%=<&+C2
.:%C85D"#%$4
:9'E#%$4
:'%A)@&+C7)
.>%'()!3#$4:'=?#$4:'A)1&,+ZG5
J '89(?C--CW5P'9E:%C85EC--)CW9
'5D.&A?&,+G9@&,+V=)
[
\]('>)^(5
!"#%$%
--)`_a+
.-'
(
(/0"#$%
--`_%2)
.(C8/9'
(
%%D"#%$%
--)b#%$:'%%+C7`_%F)
.(C8/9'
(
%%D"#%$)%C#5b#%$
:'%%+G5c_H
.>%'()!3#$:'+C7Y#$
:'%+ZG5c_I
.-
&0"#$%
--b#%$)%C#5b#%$_9'(K#%$#%'<_d+VU)
J &_'
(e'5f(_5f-&)g
'5,ZgC//%%V(5^W5gc_a+CUb_a++
.:%C85D"#%$4%
--);#$4
:'%+V=)c_d+V2)
.:%C85D"#%$4)4%C#5b#%$4
:'%%+CA)1_d+C7
.>%'()?#%$4
:'%%+C=?#$4:'+CA`_a+G9
_
.45(+=//`h§M),B"8 1$- "-/.0%(1F%"CS-/I,$ 3-/ 0b2% 312@FI,G3-0b2% 8:.4-/+ 3-/.0%(128
ai
INPUT
TARGET
SOURCE
Semantic
Weights for
Pragmatic
Information
T1 A(a)
S1 M(m)
A=M
IMPORTANT D
T2 B(b)
S2 N(n)
C=O
T3 C(a,b)
S3 O(m,n)
T4 D(b,a)
S4 P(n,m)
PARTIAL RESULTING NETWORK
A=M
semantic
unit
_
A=N
B=N
B=M
T1=S1
T1=S2
T2=S2
T2=S1
a=m
a=n
T3=S3
T3=S4
T4=S4
T4=S3
C=O
C=P
D=P
D=O
b=n
b=m
.05(+,B/ a M
h $# I,';"-/. #MQ\J]_^ ';3),)=.41,5 1,- %7|
aX
pragmatic
unit
R %9B"8 -B/. #E-/.4%7128M3B+28 "@F-B% !0.4'F.0--/I,1$+,'/ %3C +,1,.0- 8VhSR I,- 6$)2/"8:-//. #&-/.0%(1F!0.4'F.0- 8';")
§
)=.41,58 -/%A-BI,%8:2- 1 !0'F1$- 8 %3C -/I=T7CGARLBS EL h %/G#&- -B%A%/G#&-H1 3B6 ),B"@ . #3-B -/% 1:"/6
)=/"@ . #3-BH?"12@ ),B%()2%8:.4-/.0%(1 -B%;),/%7)%8 .0-/.4%71?` Q ) 3/-:#E%(/B"8 )2%712@ 12#E B"8 -B/. #E-/.4%71 3),)=!4.4G8. C -/I,
"123!0%(58 3B@ .4$. @$"@ .41$-/% '; /%7 )2"/- 8E` R I= ';3)=),.41,5 +,1,.0- 8 .41 _ .457+,// a B),B"8 1$-M"!4! )%8/8:.P,!0
) 3.4B.41,58 %"CS!0'F1$- 8 %"CS-/I=A8B3'FO- 6$)2H `W5,`0HJ UL H,Q
] H2 '_H$"12@R *7`
6$'F'FE-//. # =#&.4->3-/%7/6 !4.0^1 ,83B9#&B"3-B"R
@ 2- 1F';3)=),.41,59I$6$)%7-/I,G8 "8 -BI23-O3B GIGT7HTQSLQIS
M.0-/I "7# I %7-/I, ` _ %(AG(# I ),/%7)2%8 .0-/.0%(1 ' 3),),.01,5,H =#&.4->3-/%7/6 !4.0^
1 ,8 3B;#&/G3-/G
@ 2- 1 -/I,
)=/%()2%8 .4-B.4%71 ';3)=),.41,58 31 @ -BI,F#E%(/B"8 )2%712@ .41=5 ' 3),),.01,58%3CM-BI,9),B%()2%8:.4-/.0%(1 8 ),B"@ . #3-B"8 31 @
"/57+,'F1$- 8EH `W5=`4q
H 2- 1 R [312@ Q
*
] 31 @ - 1 R 312@ *
'_` _ %(
)=/"@ . #3-B"8-BI23- I G 'F%(BA-BI231_%71, 3B5(+,'F 1 - H-BI, 3B5(+,'F 1 -M';"),),.01,58 8:+,),)2%(B-"(# I%7-/I,
$6A7 ,#&.0-/%7/6!4.0^
1 ,8?.419%7 @ -/%/G3!4.0<S-/I,
TQS\X FS X|CN GIzTQS\X|CGHJIS H(`W5,`0HR a a H$ ' 8 +=),)2%(/->W
8 1?`SW^ ,#E.4- "-/%7/6 !4.4?1 ,83/\#&/""-/"/
@ - 1F)=/"@ . #3-BF ';3),)=.41,5+,1,.0- 8312@;-/I,.0#&%(B/"8:)%712@ .01,5
"/57+,'F1$- ';3)=),.41,5M+=1,.4->8&`Q J]_^ .0'F),!0' 1- 8,-/I, #&%(1 8 -/>3.01 - %3C TLZADCGISmH T7HJADHPNfCGXFHPS $6 !4.0^1 .01,5
"1 6[';3)=),.41,5*+,1,.4-/ ! 3-B.41,5*- %;8 ';31$-/. #3!0!46*8 .4'*.4! "M),/G@ . #"-/"8M-/%*-/I, 8:)G#&. "!S8 ' 31$-/. # +,1=.4-BI23-OI2(8 '; .0'9+,' (#&-B.473-B.4%(1[73!4+=` 3!0+,"83B9),/%"$. @ "
@ 6_ V:5
] Vj Q §:8:- "-/'F 1 ->8&
` V CS1,%
7"!4+,[. 8A5(.01?HSQ J]_^ 78/8 +='F"89_'F.41,.0'9+,'K7"!4+,` r1,.0- 8AB! "-/.41=5_. @ 1$-/. #3!S),B"@ . #3-B"893B
#E%(1,1,G#&-/"@[3+,-B%(';"-/. #3!0!46F-B% -BI,98:';31$-/. # +,1,.4B
- M.4-BII,.05(I[("!4+,G8%3CS7 ,#&.0- "-/.4%71?`.0'F.4! 3B!46H$-/I,
)= 357';3-B. #M+,1,.0- . 8!4.4?1 "@ -B%A';"),),.41=5 +,1,.0- W8 M.4-B6
I V:]_N U
L R U
Q n R !4'F 1- 8&`ZQ CD-/ 3!4!2+,1=.4- 8I2
2 1ACD%(/'*"@H"8 6$'F'F -//.0#?.41,I=P. ,.0-/%(B6 !4.0^
1 =8?3/M)=! (#E"
@ - 1I$6 )2%(-BI,"8:"8 -/I 3- 3/M.012#&%7128 . 8 -/ 1 - H
-BI23-*. D
8 - 1 3!0!M+,1,.0- 89-/I2"- B),/G8 1$- 3!0-/B123-B.4;';3)=),.41,58 CD%( -/I, 8/"'F;!4'*1 - H ` 5,`0H
2- 1 1_"12@ '_`
Q 8 +,'*';3B6 %"CM-BI, Q\J]_^ 3!05(%7/.4-BI,';8 CD%7 CD%(/'*.41,5;F';"),),.01,5F1,- %(| "12@_!4""/1,.01,5;-/I,
)=/% ,.0!4.4-B.4"8S%3C ';3)=),.41,58 . 8 5(.01F.01;R ,!4 DMI,. # I*. 8 -> 1 CD/%(' T a Y ` R %*8 +,'*';3B.4<7^H 31 @
À.0'F),!0'FE1 - -/I, 8:-//+ #&-/+,>3!Z#&%(128:-/>3.41$-H a .4'F)=!4' 1$- 8 -BI,8 ';31$-/. #M8 .4'*.4! "/.0- 6 #&%(1 8 -/>3.01 - H,31 @
*31 @V 3!4%71,/
5 M.4-/I;-BI,1,%(-B .01 ` .0'F),!4 ' 1-S-BI,), "5(';"-/. #O#&1$-/ "!4.0- 6 #E%(128:-/ ".41$-`
k I,1 -/I=F1,- %7| I (898 ->
,.0!4.0<"@H-BI,%8: ' 3),),.01,5I$6$)%7-/I,G8 "8AB),/G8 1$-/"
@ 6 -BI,F+,1=.4- 8
M.0-/I -/I,I,.05(I,"8:-S(#E-/.47"-/.4%7
1 /%7.41$-/!069@ -B/'*.41, ';3)=),.41,5O%3C?-BI,8 %7+, #EB),/G8 1$- "-/.4%71 312@ -/I,
->3B5(-/)=/"8:1 ->3-B.4%(1;-BI23
- 2"8:- 8B3-/. 8 l2G8 -BI,5(.4 1F.41$-/>(#&-B.41,5 #&%(1 8 -/>3.01 ->8&`
V;-M+,)
';"),),.01,5A1, -%(`
(` _ 7
% A"7# I )=/%()2%8 .4-B.4%71 ? \F oooF "12@ "(# I ),/%7)%8 .0-/.4%71
? mF ooo[F *"/_.41 -BI, 8/3'*)2"/- ` 5,`0HW5(%3!09%3C -/I,.0
B"8 )2"#E-/.4O8 -B/+2#E-/+,BA"12@ I GO-/I, 8/"'F1 +='R2S%3C 3/57+,'F1$- 8
H ^ ? H=312@;"(# I
JS%(1 8 -/B+2#&--/I,+,1=.4- 8 7 aF `
8 2- 1 @ ? ^ `
"12
JS%(1 8 -/B+2#&-!4.0^1 ,q
8 2- 1 I F aF `
"12@ "7# JS%(1 8 -/B+2#&-!4.0^1 ,q
S
J
(
%
1
8
/
B
2
+
&
#
S
4
!
0
.
1
^
=
8
2
1
?

"
2
1
@A"7# /
I F F `
8 2- 1;"7# I*)23.0%"q
C F aF `
JS%(1 8 -/B+2#&-!4.0^1 ,q
` ` JS%7128 -B/+2#E- .01,I,P. =.4-/%7/6 !0.4^
1 =8 M.4-BI 1, 53-B.4q
.45(I$-H"8:&- 6@ &C "+,!4- )2" 3'*-/
! H 2- 1"1 6*+,1,.4->8 -/I2"-B),B"8 1$- .012#&%7'F)23-BP. ,!0' 3),),.01,58E`
n%(-/
h§V C9';3)=),.41,5 +,1,.0-#&%(1=1,"#&->8"1_.41$-/B123! { +,B6F73/. ,!0A-B%F8:%('F%(-BI,
tU!4'*1 Q- vH,-/I=1 #E%(128:-//+ #&- ,#E.4-/%7/6[ 3-BI,-/I 31 .41,I,. ,.4-B%(B6!4.0^
1 =8-/%;%(-BI,
+=1,.4->8 /),B"8 1 -B.41,5 )%8/8:P. ,!0A';"),),.41=58 -BM
% t !4 'F1$- v`
a ` _ %7M"(# IF),B"@ . # 3-/Q ';"),),.01,5A+,1=.4"- ? #^ #E%(128:-//+ #&-A!4.0^1 CDB%(' -BI,
8:';"1 -B. # +=1,.4
- (8 G@ %(1 -/I,*@ 57/ %3C 8 ' 31$-/. # 8 .0'F.4! 3/.0-:6
6 2- 1_-BI,9- %
)=/"@ . #3-B"8&
H M.0-/I
.457I -F>31,57.41,5 CDB%(' 'F.01,.4'9+=' 73!0+,HM. C -BI,/_. 8 1,%
8:.4'F.0! "/.4-:67H(-/%*9'; $.4'9+,'U73!4+=H,. C -BI,),/"@$. #"-/"8M"/. @ 1 -B. #"! `
,` _ %7 G(# I !0'F1$-M!4. 8 -B"@ 7
8 V:]_N U
L R U
Q n R H#E%(128:-//+ #&-9;!4.4?1 CD/%7' -/I, ),>35 ' 3-/. # +,1,.0--/%O"(# IA+,1=.4- #&%(12#E/1,.01,5O';3)=),.41,5MCD%( -/I 3-!0'F1$- M.0-/I c
.05(I$ { +2"!-B%F #&B- 3.01F)2" 3'*-/$ 7`
V ` _ %7 G(# I +,1=.4-!4. 8 -/G@_(8Aq
N ^ r ]_q
^ sAH?#&%7128 -B/+2#E-9F!4.0^1 CDB%(' -/I= ),>357';3-B. #
+=1,.4
- M.0-/I[
.05(I$-M { +23!?-B% )2" "'F-/ " ^`$`
+,1;-BI, 1,- %(| *8 ->3B-/.41=R
5 M.0-/IF'; .0' +=' 7"!4+,D
CD%7M-/I,\8 ';"1 -B. #312@F-BI, ),>35 ';3-B. #A+,1,.0-9"12
@ M.4-BI 8:%('F .41=.4-/. 3!7"!4+,9CD%( 3!4!S%7-/I, +,1,.0- 8&`;QM-"(# I #&6,#E!4D
&% #3! #&+,! "-/-/I= 1= 7#&-/.073-/.0%(1 %3C 3!4!?+=1,.4->"8 'F(# #&%(>@ .41,5 -/%
@&% u 0ZO|()"% *Q ,+-.( @["% ! * Q \ 0Z/(0+ ! * >H MI=/1
. 8
F@ "#6;)2" 3'*-/ H * Q . 8M-/I,91, - =#&.0- 3-B%(B6 .01,),+,- H ! * Q . 8-/I, 1,-.41,I,. ,.4-B%(B6
.41,),+=-^H M.4-B2
I + ! * 3( 31 4
@ +- (`
V|V
5hML+,-/!0.41,
R =!4
%"C-BI, Q\J]_^ 3!05(%(B.4-BI,'
^
R I,2"8 - ';3)=),.41,5_%7+,-/)=+,- 89%3C-BI,[Q\J]_^U3!05(%(B.4-BI,' CD%( -/I,
8:I,%M1.01 _ .45(+=// =`
^SQSR _qj Lk
7,"'F),!4*. 8
#5(?8'//,ZW>f'-()KI7N^O) S
K
U
=2
U
=2
U
UU
G
^ U
Z+VU
U
HG
U
FG
U
H7
U
FA
U
HG
A [I
U
Z+ZG
,+ZGN[+G
U
FU
4 A 4 5+CA
U
H9+
4 = 4 5+C=
U
H9+
I [I
U
FH
8'//,ZW>?I g ^)gY
Y'f/%Z#5 S U
FH
,+VU [,+VU
U H=
U HU
G 5+G
U F=
7 5+C7
U F=
U HI
2 5+G
U UI
9+ 5+C7
U UI
U HI
[ [
U HU
_
.05(+,B/ 5hQ J]_^ 82"8:-';"),),.01,5A%7+,-/),+=-%"CS-/I,
"B9^%8:!G#!.09^%#"g(*='&# 898:@(*,&9^.
^SQSR _j Lk
,"'F),!0
+ &,!:!$#&+)
M+,1,1=.41,5[ 1, +, "!1,- B- I23-UM(8O8 - +=)$6[Q\J]_^MH2+,) @,3-B"8 -/I, (#&-B.473-B.4%(1 8\%"C+,1,.4->8+,1$-/.0!"!4!
+=1,.4->8 I2/G(# I,"@;31 7 8 6$'F),-/%7-/. # (#&-B.473-B.4%71?`MR I, /"8:+,!4-B.41,59+,1=.4-O(#&-B.473-B.4%(1 8"/A.01 -B/)=/-B"@
78 -BI,),/%
2=.4!4.0-/.0"8 %3C -/,I )2"/-B. #&+,! 3M';"),),.01,59I 6$)2%(-BI,"8 G8&`
%g0Z '& & )( @[ @[ H MI, / . 8-/I,S%(+=-/),+,- .41 #&6=#&!0W2%3C M+,1,.0- ! "12@ ( . 8-BI,(#&-B.473-B.4%71
%"C -BI, !4.4?1 5 - 1 ! "12@ '2H. 8 .01 -B/),B-/G@_(89 '*"(8:+,/ %3C-BI, %">3!0!! l2-A%"C-/I,*'FB5(.41=5
' 3),),.01,5 -/%F-BI,9#&%7128 -B ".41$- 8&`R I=9# I,%(. #&%3C'F.41=.4';"!"12@'; .0' +,' 7#&-/.073-/.0%(1[("!4+,G8 312@%"C
-BI, @ &C "+,!4-M73!0+,"8M%3C 8 .0'F.4! 3/.0-:6931 @ / !4731 #&#&!0"3B!46 .41 b2+=12#&"8S-/I,%7+,-/),+=-%"CS-/I,B+,1?`
+=1,1,.41=5 -BI,F1, - 6$.4 ! @,88:6 1=/576_%3CO@ f. e /1$- #&%(128:-/>3.41$- 8E` _ %(A.0128 ->312#EH .01 -BI,
^SQS
R L k =3'F)=!4H-/I= .01 CD%(B';3-B.4%71 -BI23B
- 2%(-BM
I M"-/O31 @#&% e A"/ !4. { +,. @,8 "12@ I2 b 3--/%7)
_qj -B12@,8 -/% 12#&%7+, "5(M
3-B -B% ';") -B% #E% e >3-BI, -/I2"1 -/% I,"3- a
` s"8 )=.4-/;-BI,. 89'F. 8:!4"7@ .41=5
8:.4'F.0! "/.4-:69.01 CD%(B';3-B.4%(1ZH -BI, 8 -B/+2#&-B+, "!?.41 CD%7/';"-/.0%(1FCD/%7'
Jb2% % m2" M% $. 3!?
% m 3-B
% )=.4)2 q$ GM"12@
G`
Jb2% %
:#E%e A%
. #&F #&+^2 %
I,G3-%\23Q I z
12, !0"8 Q\J]_^ -/% #&/"@$.4-9I,.05(I, 7#&-/.073-/.0%(1 -/% -/I,[I 6$)2%(-/I="8 . 8 -BI23-/M"-/ ';3) 8A-/% I,"3-*(8
8:I,%M
1.01 _ .45(+=// =`
.41 #&Q J]_^ 8 .41,)=+,- 8$mV:]_N LUR QUn R~o7oo @ .e MCD%(O@ .e B1$-M5(%"! 8M%3CS-BI,9"123!0%(57. #"! B"
8:%(1,.01,5,H 91, 1,-MI278 -B%R2 #&%(1 8 -/B+2#&-B"@ CD%("(# IF1, 5(%"! `
V 1 # (8 [Q J]_^ . 8A+28 "@ -B% 2
l 1 @ ),B%,
!0' 8 %7!4+,-B.4%71$6 ';3)=),.41,5=H-/I,;57%3!. 8A-B% l 12@ "1
.0128 ->31$-/. 3-/.0%(1 T - Y %3CS7"/. , !4G8 - .41_9CD%(/' +,! `MR I,9.0128 ->31$-/. 3-/.0%(1[. 88 +,575("8:-/"@M$6;-/I,
' $ .4';"!4!46*(#E-/.47"-/"@%"C 1=%$@ "8D ( - "12@> ( CD%( G(# I - `V 1_-BI,9/)=/"8:1 ->3-B.4%(1[%3C -/I,
^ QSR _j Lk = 3'*),!4.41 _ .457+,/ ` H,-BI, ),+=/)2%8: %"C-BI,"123!0%(5(6*. 8 # 3),-B+,/"@/ 6 -/I,O),/%7)%8 .f
-B.4%71
G!¡Q
^
*z* ¢h£ ¤?¥x¢h££G¥ HGM
I, / -BI, .41$-/ /12"! { +,B6973/. ,
!0
**?
*
B),B"8 1$- 8-BI,M+,1^$ 1,%M
1;#"+28 %3CZ-/I,I,""- b % .419-BI,->3B5(- ` .412#E
OI2(8S-/I,@ G8 .4B"@ACD"3-B+,/
$6F$.4B-/+, %"CS.4->8M3),)2"" "12#&A.01;-/I, )=/%()2%8 .4-B.4%71 ¡ 3G!¡ h£ ¤?
¥ h££G¥ HGM
I, /"789@$%"8 1=%(-H
-BI,F+,1=.4- 8CD%7A';"),),.41=5
["/F)=/&CDB/"@ ` R I=. 8 '*"3128-/I, ';3)=),.41,5;%"C
;-B% ¢ ;. 8 ),B&CDB/"@
-B% -BI,;';3)=),.41,5[%3C
[-/%¢ 312@ H -/I, /&CD%7/H-BI,;';3),)=.41,5[%3C$?*
-/%5*
?***
.8
)=/&CDB/"@ -/%-BI,;';3)=),.41,5;%"C*z 3*;
-B%5 ^*

G*=
` .012#&
*^3GU
. 8A-B/""-/"@
78 7"/. , !4*-/I2"- 8 +,),)2%7/- 89 "-/I, 9-/I2"1 #E%('F)2-B"8M
.4-/I
8 )2"#&.fl # 73!0+,"898 + # I 78 ¢ =HQ J]_^
B)2%(B- 8 %7-/Ix
*
?*G^ 312@¢ 782 "8:-M';3) 8 CD%(
,`
O@[
#&%7//G8 )2%(12@=8 -/% 31 .0128 ->31$-/. 3-/.0%(1
- %3Cg +=1^ 1=%M
13
.01 FCD%(B' +,! -BI23- . 8
8:+,5(57"8 -B"@ 6 -/I=_';$ .4';"!4! 6 (#&-B.473-B"@ %"CA1=%$@ "85 ( - 312@ ( CD%(F"7# I - ` Q J]_^
.0128 ->31$-/. 3-/G8 ->3/57-M73B. = !4"8§$ 6F';"),)2"@F!4'*1 ->8&`
R I,@ G8 .4571;@ "#E. 8 .0%(1 -/I2"-M-/I,O';3),)=.41,5I$6 )2%(-BI,"8:"8 %3C A)2"/-B. #&+,! 3S= 3'F)=!4 CD%(B' -BI, +,1=.4- 8
. 88 %('*M
I23-%7/-/I=%(5(%7123!-/%;-/I=F#&%7'F'F%71_#&%71,1,"#&-B.4%71,. 8:- 'F%$@ ! 8&`D
s +, -B%[8 %('*D " 1,G8/8 G8\%"C
Q J]_^-/I,. 89@ "#&. 8 .0%(1 I2(89/"#E1 -B!46- 1 /"#&%7128 . @ B"@ .01 T Y HS"12@ -/I,BF+,1,.0- 8/),B"8 1 - -/I,
)=/"@ . #3-B"8A"12@ %/ "#E- 8 %"C -BI,;8:%(+,>#&;31 @
-BI,F->3/57-9-/I=F!4.01^, 8$2 - 1 +,1,.0- 8/),B"8 1 - -/I,
' 3),),.01,5 I 6$)2%(-/I="8 "8E` j .41?, 8 "/ #&%(128:-/B+2#&-/G@d2 -
1-BI,"8: +=1,.4->8 .01_(# #&%(>@,312#EA-/% -/I=A';")
)=.41,5;#E%(128:-/ ".41$- 8E` R I, 8 -B-/!4G@ 1,-
%(|;
),B%" . @ "8 'FG(8 +=/A%"CS-/I=931 3!4%75(. #3!S#E%(/B"8 )2%712@ 12#E
%"C -
%+,1,.0- 8(8A-BI,;#&%712@ .0-/.4%7123!S),B%2
,
.4!0.4-:6_-/I 3- ->3B5(- +,1,.4-$2
l /G8 5(.01 -/I2"-9)2"/-/. #&+,! 3
8:%(+,>#&A+=1,.4-§2l B"8&`
4 +!+%+,G+68(8 &+
!+(*%
h+8:@(*,
#"%$
G#3+28:%"C -/I,O@ .fe /1$-S)23>(@ .05(';8 #E%(1,1,G#&-/.0%(1,. 8 -1, - 8 =8&` /+,!0F\2(8:"@ .41$CD/1 #&?.0- . 8S@ . #&+,!0-B%[#&%('F) 3/ Q\J]_^ .41 @$- ".4!&M.4-/I_-BI,9.41$CD/1 #&98B# I, ';(8M%3C 8 G#&-/.0%(1 a ` Q -O31 28:-/>(#&-!4 ! H
I=% H-BI,9), "5(';"-/. # #E%(128:-/ ".41$- %3C Q J]_^ #3152 #&%7128 . @ B"@_(8!0"(@$.41,5F-B%;F#&%71,1,"#E-/.4%71?H
Q J]_
^ 8 ';"),),.41=5;#312;#&%7128 . @ /G@_ /ECD%(/' +,! 3-/.0%(1?H 31 @ CD%(B' +,! (8.01 Q J]_^ 8c$1,%M!4G@ 5(
B),B"8 1$- "-/.0%(1 5M.4-BI ' G6 2 @ . e B1$- .4128:- "1 -B. 3-B.4%7128 %"C#&%7128 ->31$-H B! "-/.0%(1?H 31 @ ),/%7)2%8 .0-/.0%(1
8:6 /
' 2%(! 8 #3
1 2;#&%7128 . @ /G@ 78 )2"#&->8 .41 -/I= CD "'F %7| [),/"8:1$-/"@.01 8 "#E-/.4%71 a `V C . 8-/I,
57%"!M%3CO31
312"!4%(57. #"! .01 CD/ 12#&9.41 Q J]_^ H?-BI,1 -/I,;#E%(1 /+,1 #&-/.0%(1 %3U
C V:]_N L R Q nO
R CD%7/' +,! 78
CD%7/';8*31 78 )2"#&- -/I 3-;. 8F8:^+ 28:+,'F"
@ $6 -BI,
CD/%(' #&%(1,1="#&-/.0%(1 T
Y ` R I, #&%(1=1,"Z# -B.4%71_#"1 2%"/571,>3! . C 8 %('*@ -B/'F.01,.41=5 .01 CD%(B';3-B.4%71F'F.457I - 2 '*. 8/8:.41,5 .41;-/I= + 8 57.41
V:]_N U
L R Q n R DCD%(/' +,! (8&`
>3!CD""-/+,B"8#31,1=%($
- 29#"),-/+,B"M
@ $6 -BI,A.01 CDB12#& 8/# I,' (8 "
%( 4
H,.41_)2" -B. #&+=! 39-BI,;.41$-/>(#&-B.4%71 %3C @$. e / 1 - #&%7128 -B ".41$- 8&` _ +,B-/I, /'F%7/HSQ J]_^. D
8 ,. 78 "@ .41 C %(9%"C
-BI,98:-/B+2#&-/+= 3! /! 3-/.0%(1 G3B5(+,'F 1 -@ ) 12@ 12#E.4"§
8 MI,. # I;I2 1,% { +,.073!4 1 -M.01_8 G#&-/.0%(1 a `Q 8
B"8 +=!4-HZQ\J]_
^ 8%(+,-B),+,- $-// 'F!46*@ )21 @,8 %(1 -/I, 7#&-/+2"! CD%(B';3!0.4<""-/.0%(1%"CM-BI,9),/
% ,!4 ' 31 @
@$%(';".41?H (89#&%7//G#&-/!06)2%(.01 -B"@ %(+=D
- 6 %"C 8 ->(@ -B;T V i Y `[R I,F.01 b2+, 12#& %3C-/I=F), "5(';"-/. # +,1=.4.01[Q\J]_^ $. .01,),+,->8 q
N ^ z r ]_q
^ s|oo7o'*/!06AB"8 )2"#&->8 ),/G8 +,),)2%8 "@F';"),),.41=58&`SR I=. 8 # 3
1 2
('
&
*)
+)
,
-/.0.
54
a
21,3
E# %(128:. @ B"@A-/"# I,1,. { +, -/% B"@ +2#&S-BI,M8:"3># I 8 )27#& CD%7';3)=),.41,58 >3-BI, -/I2"1 278 . # .41,57/"@ .01$%"C31 3!4%75(. #3! .41 CD /12#E`
O
"!$# %
&'
&)(*+,
R % #E%('F),+=- 3-B.4%7123!312"!4%(576 8 6=8 -/ ';8&H NLORL T"Y31 @ RV cj RS6 ),. #3!fV 128:- "12#&F (8:"@ j ""/1
§
.01,5;6,8:-/'-T V a Y H,'F),!0%369-:6$),. # 3! .41 8 - "12#&F\278 "@;31 3!4%75(. #3! /"78 %71,.41,5=`MR I,.0 #E%(5(1=.4-/.0 )28:6z
# I,%7!4%(57. #"c
! (8 . 8&HM-/I= C 3'*.4!46 /G8 '/,! "12#&F$.47H -/I2"-F#E! (8B8 .fl2"89.4128:- 31 #&"8F7##&%(>@ .41=5 -B% -/I, .4
8:.4'F.0! "/.4-:6_-B% -:6$),. #"! .0128 ->312#&G8A 3-BI, -/I2"1 -B% 1,G#&"8/8B3B6 312@ 8 + #&.01 -CD"3-B+,/G8 I278 =/.4Qb26
2 1/ .0 "@9.41[8:"#&-/.0%(1 ` `` `
&
&
'
.-
)/
"$#&%'(*)+*;W<(*=9^:0,!); -,!( /.@+12+54 +'&%+)+,898:0(,
"/. 8/8F"12@ N %7/-/ 6
,+,.0!4- -/I, 8 6=8 -/ ' NqLORL10 -/I%2"-3$)4657.4->872"1%28495(5(.;:<284=>3?278@5(1=.41,5 CA5B=*-/I3
.01 -3<=2C:&-/.9D)312(8B8 . 8 -2"1%:E3+5"C IF3+=/. 8 -B.G:1:E4G278/8:.lH:<2"-/.95(1.01.9464 @I3Fl 13"@;@I5BJK23.41 8&`V -BL3 5(.41 8M2(8M2 15?D .;:E3
2"12@ . 8 -N23+,57I -3$)4G2"1%23-B.65(1 8O5"CP:E4G278/8:.lH:<2"-/.95(128231 @753CQJF. 8:-2)3G8 $6R26w/->3S2B: I3<=[y$`SNqL RL10T=>3&CA3U= 8
-5-/I 3M-:6$),G. :<2?44.0- V
6 53CZ.4128:- 2"%1 :E3"8WJK23.41F446CA5C=-/I3=3->=B.63<DC2?4I5"C.0128 -N231%:X3"8 -/I'23-8@3<=D)3278 8 5(+=N:E3"8 CA5C=S-/I3
:X4G2(8B8 f. lH:<23-B6. 571?/
` V
- =>3<406. 3"
8 5(Y
1 :E5(571,.4-B6. D)3 )28 F6 : FI 5B46575(;. :<284278/8:+ JF),-B6. 5(1 8 8:+%: IZ2(8 D- 6$),.;:<284f|.4128:-2"1%:E3F
'2(@8 3G[
@ :<23- 3B5 5C=/.4S< 23-/9. 5(\
1 2312@;-/I 3T3 . 8 - 3%1 :E3M5"
C 2 %) 2?=/-BG. 284.5B=>I@ 3<=V5(1[.4128:- 23'1 :E3"
8 53
C :<2">- 3C5 5B=B6. 3"8M.412@$%+ :E3"@
$6F-B
I 3- 6$),;. :<2840.4-:6`
8 231 57-/I 3U= .0128 N- 23%1 :X3Fm'2(@8 3G^
@ :E4G278/8 f. lH:<2"-/6. 571 8 6=8 - 3<J R V cj -B%I 23
- =3<449. 3"+
8 5(1 -/I 3
] %I 231=5 I@ 3"8 :E=/. L3G
C_2?JF6. 40
6 =>3G@8 3<J/4G2"%1 :E31D$6. 3`27c
8 3U464 `OR I 3D)3a
6 :E571 - =/P. =+,-/9. 5(b
1 5"C fT V a Y. 8 2:E5BJ*),+,- 2"-/9. 5(%1 2?4WJ3 -/I 5$@
CA5C=MJ3?278 + =B.41,5 -/FI 3A-:6 )=G. :<2?44.4-:R
6 53
C 2"1_.4128:- 2"%1 :E3+2"12Z
@ 27:E4;2(8B8 . lL:<23-B6. 5(Z
1 2?44C5 5B=/.0-/I J MI,;. : I 8 - 5B=>3Gc
8 5(1 406
-:6$),G. :U284.0128 N- 23%1 :X3"c
8 278 %) 5(>- 3 1 -BG. 284.2"%1 28495(58&`
N L R1
q
L 0 %I 2(W8 5B=|)3G@ .0R
1 :E44.01,G. :<2?42"+2@ 9. 5B46575(/
6 MI,G. : I9.4d1 D)5B49D)3"8?-/I 3V3<DC2840%+ 23-B6. 5(e
1 231 @ @ ;. 23571 58:. &
8 5"C
FI 3?28=B.41,5 @ . 8 5B= d@ 3<= 8E`SR V cj 'I 2(8 %3<3 1 2"),) 449. 3"@F8:%+ :<:E3"8B8 CD+ 49446 .4e
1 23f
1 2?=/-/f. lH:&;. 284 I@ 5BJK23.41ZH .01 -BI 3OI@ 5BJf2".41
5"T
C :E571,B5 =3"8/8:6. 5('1 284D)5(-B.41,[
5 =3?:E5C= @,8EH AC 5C=+Jf2840.45('1 231$-A-/F+ J5B=g:E4G278/8 f. lH:<2"-/6. 571?HS@ ;. 2%3>- 3G+
8 :E4G278/8 f. lH:<2"-/6. 571?H
2"12@ .01;-/I 3 @ ;. 235(F1 58 . 8 5"CSI 3?2?=/-@ . @8 3?27@8 3q` V 1;-/FI 3\AC 5C46495M.01,D
5 3T:E57%1 :E31$>- =N23- 3571[
N LOR1
L 02`
V 1;q
N L R1
L 02dH 3?2B: I 3d3<JFF) 4G28=P53O
C 2+:<23- 3B5 5C=/6 . 8 =>3 ) =>3"8 31$>- 3"D
@ 69AC 3?2"-/+ =3"
8 2"12
@ 3 F) 4G23'1 23-/9. 5(12
8 5"C
3S2B: I AC 3?2"-/+ =3G ,8 =3<463<DC2"%1 :E3M>- 5-BI 3M:U23>- 3 B5 5B=B6` _ .05(+ =3 V :X5(1$- 23.012&
8 37I3<J*) 4G2?= h8 53C?-BI 3:<23- 3B5 5C=/6 ji?CGHJXOT
M.0-/I9-B
I 36. =h37Ik4;23%1 2?l>m95Bn28E`S&
^ 2C: T
I n5$I@ 3m9nol/FI m .8 :<28l3<pB5C=>q+r l>=s%:El>sF=>3m;rt3Um6l/FI 3<=,2?n+m6n%r l2?n%:E3F:E5Bndl2?m6nm9np
:U28l>3UpB5B=q+5B=2OI@ 5BJf2?m6nTk=>m9Jm6lm6D)3 AC 3?2?l>s=35B=,3d3<JkF4G28=Q ` _ 5C=Wm9n%r@lN28n%:E3BH l/I 3nF5$I@ 34G2L3U463"@ CGXFADX[L|TQS
Jem6p(dI l:X5Bndl28m9nf3I3UJk4G2?=>qR2?=>J=3?r@lNr&IH 3S2B: I;I@ 3?r:E=>m L3Gd
@ dq AC 3?2?l>s=3?r28n u
@ 3dk4G2?n%28lm65Cn%r&`
R I 3<=3o2?=>31l/FI =>3<31l qIk%3?r5"
C m6n I@ 3dm6npgIn5493"I@ pB3h,=>3<Jm9n2I@ m9np)rEvH kF=>5Bl5Bl qdkmG:<2?46m9l@qH 28n u
@ 3d3<Jk4;28=
d@ meH3<=>3Un%:E3?rEq` Vn _ m6pCs=>3/+l/FI 3Mm6n2d@ mG:E3?r28=3or:I 5n[2Cr49m6n^Fr AC =5BJ AC 3?2?l>s=3?rl>5R:U28l>3UpB5B=m63?rA=>3<Jem6n2z@ m9np)r[ .H 46m6n?rAC =>5CJw:<28l3<pB5C=>m93?rMl>5[2Cr>r 5d:EmG2?l>3"x
@ 37I3<Jek4G2?=r I@ 3<pB=3<3+53V
C kF=>5Bl5Bl qdkmG:<2?46m9l@q* HH 46m6n?r AC =5BJ
CA3S28l>sF=>3?rcl5f3I3UJk4G2?=rA=>3<Jm9n2I@ m9np)r[ %H 28n @ I@ mfeH3<=>3<n':E3o49m6n^Fr AC =5BJy5Bn3+3d3<JkF4G28=l5fD)3<=>qfr m6Jm94G2?=
37I3<Jek4G2?=r&`
3UJm6n2d
@ m6npzr3?r@lm6Jf2?l>3MlBI 3+46m )3<46m0I 5)5$
@ 53
C k%28=l>m;:Es4G2?=c37I3<Jek4G2?=r5B={:<28l3<pB5C=>m63Src%3<m6npR=>3U463<DC28ndl
l5+l/I 3Vk=5d:E3?r>r m6np+5"PC 2ol2?=>pB3Ul:<2Cr@3q` 3<Jm9n2I@ m6nFp)r AC =5BJ|2\AC 3?2?l>s=3cl5R2o:<2?l>3<pC5B=>qH r@s': f
I 2CrM}[C j~XZL|TQS
m9n2I@ 3dm6nFp ji?CGHJXm6n _ m6pCs=>37 H r spBpC3?r@lRl/%I 2?l7lBI 3bm9n%r@lN28n%:X3?ro531
C lBI 3a:<28l3<pB5C=>q %I 2<D)3fl/I 3FAC 3?2?l>s=3`
Q =3<Jm9n2I@ m6nFpAAC =>5BJ2 AC 3?28ls=>3Tl>5a28n[3d3<JkF4G28= %H r@s%: Z

I 2BrE*LL|TQS\CNm6n2d@ 3Im9np ji?CGHJXS1m9n _ m9pBs=3 H
r spBpC3?r@lNrlB%I 28llBI 3M3d3<JkF4G28=qm9464%l>5Rr 5BJ3V3dl>3<n2R
@ Jf28lN: e
I :<2Br 3?r d@ 3?r>:E=mP%3"R
@ dqRl/I m;r AC 3?28ls=>3` ^ 2B: I
=3<Jm9n2I@ m6nFp9%I 2Br128nZ2Cr>r 5d:EmG2?l>3"Z
@ r@l=>3<npCl/5
I MI m;: a
I mGrcs'r@3"b
@ l55B=>I@ 3<=MlBI 3o49mGr@lV53
C =>3<l=>m93<D)3"
@ :<2?n2I@ m @ 28l3
r 5Bs=N:E3o37I3<Jek4G2?=r&`
,N =>5Bl5Bl qdkmG:<2?46m9l@qk%28=l>mG2?4649q5C= I@ 3U=r,l/I 337I3<Jek4G2?=rm6lBI m6nR2:<28l3<pB5C=>q+2C:<:E5C= I@ m9np1l>5MlBI 3<m6=P=>3?:E5C= @
5"C r@s%:U:E3?r>rVm6nZk=>3<Ddm65Cs%rM:E4;2Brr@mlL:<28lm65Bn'r&` ,N =>5Bl5Bl qdkmG:<2?46m9l@qa3?r@lm6Jf2?l>3?rl/FI 3+k%r@qF: FI 5B465CpBm;:<284n5Cl>m65Cnx5"C
&
&
&
made of
function
Chairs
made of
exemplar
Wheels
exemplar
Chair 1
Chair 2
Armrest
Pedestral
function
Backrest
Seat
Legs (4)
Wood
Metal
enables
Lateral support
enables
associated
Holds(person)
enables
Seat support
specialization
Rigid Material
specialization
_
specialization
specialization
m9pBs=3R V)hQ`:<28l3<pB5C=>qfr l>=>s':El>s=3153CNqLORL10
Pedestal
Armrest
Seat
Legs (4)
Backrest
Chairs
strongly
prototypical
weakly prototypical
difference(armrest, pedestal)
Chair 1
_
Chair 2
m6pCs=>3/7)h V n @I3dm6npgIn5493"@IpB3 CA5C=ji?CGHJX `WrVn4G2L3U463"@46m9n^Fr28=3o=3<Jm6n @Im6npzr
difference (legs(4))
C_2?Jm649q7=3?r@3UJR4;28n%:X3$ r@3U3or 3?:Elm65Bn-`$` `z>H^MImG: IfmGrlBI3 @I3<pB=3<31l>5/MImG: Ia28nf3d3<Jk4;28=mGrr@m9Jm64;28=l>5
5Cl/I 3U=M:<2?l>3<pC5B=qJ3<J/%3<=rE` V n _ m6pBsF=>3/ ji?CGHJX<cm;rJ5B=3Mk=>5Cl>5Cl@qdkm;:<284hlBI%28n ji?CGHJX `
R I 313d3<Jk4;28=SI@ mfeH3<=>3<n':E3?r&m9n2I@ 3R3d3<Jk4;28=Nr dqRl/I 3 AC 3?2?l>s=3lB%I 28ld@ mGr@lm6npCsmGr:Ifl/I3<J CA=>5CJ 3G
3UJk4G2?=rWm6lBa
I r@m6Jem64G2?=SI@ 3?r:E=>m9kl>m95Bn%rEq
` V n _ m6pCs=>3 ol/FI 3I@ mGr l>m9npBsm;r I m9np AC 3S28l>sF=>3?r$CGXQADXZL|TQS*E*LL|TQS\CN
2?n2
@ N L0KT1=>3Sr@k%3?:Elm6D)3<49qBH 53C ji?CGHJXS28n @ ji?CGHJX 2?nn5Cl28l3olBI 3 I@ meH3<=3<n%:E3M49m6n^Fr&`
N L R1
q
L 0Rs%r 3?rc2?n2b
@ :X5BJJRsnm9:<2?l>3?r,3dk4G2?n%28lm65Cn%r§MI mG: a
I 28=337Ik=3?r>r 3"
@ m6na2+k=>3"d@ 3Fl%n3"
@ 4;28n
pCs%28pC3+53C I@ 3Fl%nFm6l>m95Bn%2?4 FH :<28s%r284 "H 2?n2f
@ :E5B==>3<4;28l>m95Bn%2?4h=>3<4;28lm65Bn'r2BrpBm6D)3Unum9n _ m6pCs=>3D h
V
%^-5ZW,C(9W'%OKCW(')
K,V:'CW(P(
%%
C-Q'W?W5O C_'f>)VW5'%CR'
(5^W
/'
(K
f8(
%'%OKL)C9C:f&5V(
_
'5
_'f-
W5^(5W
CW%'#9
C%%f&9C(_
KW5
^()CW(P&9C(_
8/5
C>>(
C/9f(
_
m9pBs=3D
h
NqLORL10*3dk4G2?n%28lm65Cnu4;28npCs%28pC3
G
+ 3+.
(*'
. 23(*%: 8 &=
( i"$4
-
-$
R IF3il'=r@lr@l3<k53C NqLORL10*IkF=>5d:E3?rr@m9npR2n37:<2Br 3m;r,l/I3M=3<l>=m63<DC2?4 Hd2Brr:I5num9nFR.2F463VolN2)3<n
CA=5BJ T Y h
nFksl2+2 lN28=>pC3<l3d3<Jk4;28=l>5/%3T:E4G2Cr>r@mfl%3"@`
3<l=>m93<D)3=>3<Jm9n2@Im9np)r%2Cr@3"@o5Cn7lBI3lN28=pB3<l CA3S28l>sF=>3?r,2?n2@AI3<sF=>mGr l>m;:<284946q1:E5CJRFm6n3,lBI3<J_`
V

`
XZLmE*LCS
X[LmE*LCS
r r@3+l/IF3Rr@l>=5BnpC3?r@lT:E5CJRFm6n3"@=3<Jm6n @Im6npRl>5Kr@3<493?:El12:U28l>3UpB5B=qZ28n2@[s%r 3+k=>5Cl>5
a l qdkmG:U2846m9l q+l>5Rr@3U463?:Ell/I 31J5zr@lk=5Bl5Bl qIkFmG:<2?4"3d3<Jk4;28=CA=>5CJ l/I3T:<2?l>3<pC5B=>q`
IS\HPN2?n[2(d
@ 3 { s'28l>3U46qR3IkF4G28m9n3"
@ Jf2?l: 7
I m;r AC 5Bsn2@
VrMr@3 I@ meH3<=3<n%:E3T46m6n?rl5m6JkF=>5?D)3Ml/FI 3+:E4;2Br>r mlH:U28l>m95Bn-Iqa:E5Cn%r@m I@ 3<=>m9npRn3<m6p7I %5C=>m6nFp3G
3<Jk4;28=r2BrV2849l>3<=n%28lm6D)3?rE`
O
N =3?r@3UnIllBI 31Jf28lN: f
I 2?n2u
@ 37Ik4;28n%2?l>m95Bnfl>5+lBI 31l>3?2C: I 3U=`
H l/
I 31l3?2B: I 3<= I@ mGr28kk=5?D)3?r
S i*LQI7=3 { s3?r@ln3 I@ 5BJK28m6ndn5463"d@ pB3 AC =>5CJ l/I 31l3?2B: I 3<=
I 3=3<Jm9n2I@ m6nFp)rWMI mG: a
I r@spCpB3?r l>3"f
@ l/I 313d3<JkF4G28=
i 3F2Brr@3?rrcl/F
IS\HPNl/F
I 3l3?2B: I 3<=28kkF=>5?D)3?r&B
` H l/FI 3JK28l: I m;rD)3<=>qer@l=>5BnFp
XS i*LQI7Je3<=>pC3clBI 31l28=pB3<lBm6lBf
I l/I 313d3<Jk4;28= `
L[NTL27@,
@ l/I 3l28=pB3<ll5+l/I 3{:<28l3<pB5C=>qe2Br2on33d3<Jk4;28= q
` H lBI 3MlN28=>pC3<l2Cr&m9nm6lmG284946q
JmGr:E4G2Cr>r@mfl%3"@H
S i*LQI7m9n%r@lN28494?I
@ mfe"3U=>3<n%:X3M46m9n^rl5+l/I 31m9n%r@lN28n%:E3Srm9nID)5C46D)3"@`
IS\HPNl>=N28m9nm6np+m;r:E5BJek463<l3`
RW2463 Vh R I3 NqLORL102?46pC5B=>m9l/IJ
I3<nZr 3?28=N: Im9npFCA5B=T2fr@5Cs=:E3e:<2Cr@3H?NqLORL10 l'=r@lT:E5C46493?:Elrl/IF37=3<Jm6n @Im6npzrl5a:<28l3<pB5C=>m63Sr&`
R IF3 CA3?28ls=>3?r.53HC 2clN28=pB3<l:U2Br@3s'r@s%2?4646q1qdm63<4 @MnIsJe3<=>5Cs%rw=2ByM=>3<Jem6n2@Im9np)r*MImG: IolBI3<nR2?=>3 IF3<s=>m;r lmG:<2?4649q :E5CJRFm6n3"b
@ l5 I@ 3<l3<=>Jm9n3+l/FI 3uJe5)r@lT46m )3<46q\:<28n2d@ m @ 2?l>3a:E4G2Cr>r mlH:<2?l>m95Bn AC 5C=+l/I3fl2?=>pC3<lR:<2Br 3`
3<4;28l>3G^
@ :<28l3<pB5C=>m63Sr28=3Z:E5BJ/m6nF3">
@ dq r@sJJem6np[lBI 3Zr@l=>3<npCl/%I r5"C I@ skF46mG:U28l>3a=>3<Jem6n2I@ m9np)rR28n @
dq m9n,
I 3<=m6lm6npZ=>3<Jem6n2I@ m9np)r+l>5 r s^H:<28l3<pB5C=>m63Sr&` V
L n49q lBI 3Zr@l=>5CnpB3?r l[:E5CJRFm6n3"@ =3<Jm6n I@ m6npzr+28=3
=3<l>sF=>n3"@ ` _ 5C=m9n%r@lN28n%:E3vH m .C l/I 3MAC 3?2?l>s=3?r&5".C l/I 3MlN28=pB3<l:<2Br 3Mm6n%:X46s2I@ 3g}[C j~
X[L|TQSH28n26
@ E*LL|TQS\CN H$
N L R1
L 0RmGr=3<Jm9n2I@ 3"o
@ 5",C lBI 3T:<28l3<pB5C=>q ji?CGHJX28n K
@ lBI 313d3<Jk4;28= ji?CGHJX<"`SR I 3 FI 3<s=>m;r@lmG:M:E5CJRFm6n%2?l>m65Cn
lBI 3<n qdm63U4 @ rM2ar@l=>5BnFp[=>3<Jm9n2I@ m9npl>5 ji?CGHJX<"`;qN LOR
L 0 :<28n I@ 3<=m6D)3+=>3UJm6n2d@ m6npzr 3dk4;28n%2?l>m65Cn%rZ
CA=5BJ l/FI 3lBI 3 I@ 5BJK28m6nel/I 3<5C=>q`S^M` p,`4H AC =5BJ lBI 313dk4G2?n%28lm65Bn
k
h3<n%2463?rci N TE*LQXOT GIMIm;: Ifm;rl/I3 CAsn%:Xl>m65Cnf53C ji?CGHJX `
2+=>3UJm6n2@dm6np CA=>5CJ¦TLCS"l>5 ji?CGHJXmGrM@I3<=m6D)3"@ `
R I3n37Ilgr@l>3Uk m;rl5Zr@3<493?:El+2?n 3 I3UJk4G2?=Ml>5Zr 3<=>D)3K2Br+2[r@5Cs=:X3 CA5C=+l/I3K28n%2?465BpCmG:<2?4V:E4G2Cr>r ml^
:U28l>m95Bn?` NLORL10fJf2<qs%r 3+k=>5Cl>5Cl@qdkm;:<2849m6l
q 46m9n3 a 35 CBl I3R2849pB5C=>m6Bl IJ m9n RW2463 VGl>5ar 3<463?:XlM2?n
37I3<Jek4G2?= CA=>5CJy2:<28l3<pB5C=>qfm6na/l I3Tr 3<lc"5 C:<282n @dm @2?l>3+:X4G2Brr@fm lH:<28lm65Cn%&r `V CBl I3<=3o2?=>3Tn5=>3UJm62n @dm6npzr
l5Z2 k'28=>lmG:EsF4G28=T3 d3<Jk4;28= HhBl I3J5zr@lol qdkmG:U2843 d3<Jk4;28=1mGrTr@3<493?:El>G3 @` _ 5B=+3 F28Jek463 Hhm C2bl28=pB3<l
:U2Br@313<D)
5 )3?r,=>3<Jem62n @Im9np)r,l5 j?i CGHJX|Tqsln5+=3<Jm92n @Im6nFp)rWl5+k%28=l>mG:Xs4G2?=3 d3<Jk4;28=N&r HBBl I3<;
n NqLORL10
kF=>&3 CA3<=N
r j?i CGHJX<c %2Cr@"3 @f5Bnal@qdkm;:<2849m6l q `
TLCS
m6n'284649qH$NqL RL10K:E5B49463?:ElNr&=3<Jm6n @Im6npzr CA=>5BJ lBI31l28=pB3<l7 r CA3?2?l>s=3?rl>5+k%2?=>l>m;:Es4;28=3d3<Jk4;28=Nr
2?n2@b27@,@rBl I3?r@3l>5+l/IF349mGr l53CP3d3<Jk4;28=Nr§ 5C= @I3<=3"@6IqR=>3UJm6n2@dm6np1r l>=3<npBlBI `R I3M=3?r@sF46lmGr2o46m;r@l
5"C:<2?2n @Im @F28l>313 d3<JkF4G28=NWr MImG: Ia28=>31l=>m6G3 @Kl5+Jf28lN: I m6/l IfBl I31l28=pB3<l `
0)5 C_2?=M/l I3+=3<Jm92n @Im6nFp)r28n @ k=5Bl5Bl qIkFmG:<2?46m6l qf2?=>3+s%r "3 @bl>5e=>3<l=>m63UD)3o2?n[3 d3<Jk4;28=5Bn[73 Ik%3?:ElN2 lm65Cn35 Ctr@m6Jem64G2?=>m9l@q `V C"nF3?:E3?rr>28=q Hd(2 @,@dm6l>m95Bn%2?4hr m6Jm94G28=m6l qMm;rO=3<D)3?2?46"3 @$I5
q wIn5 49"3 @IpBQ3 m%2Cr@"3 @Rk%28ll>3<=n
JK28l: Im9nGp ym6n r@l>3U
k b"5 CV/l I3f2?46pC5B=>m9/l IJ 73 Ik4;28m9n"3 @M%3<465 /l I%2?lok=58Ddm @d3?ro2?n 3 dk4G2?n%28lm65Bd
n >s%r lm CAqdm6npZ/l IF3bk=3?r@3<n':E3f35 CCA3?28ls=>3Sr m9n /l IF3bl2?=>pC3<lf:<2Cr@3 ` _ 5B=73 2?Jk463 HNPL0KTam6n /l I3al28=pB3<lemGr
k'28l>l3<=>n Jf2?l: I"3 @7lR
5 E*L L|TQS\CN)m6nf/l IF373 I3<Jek4G2?= ?i CGHJXSVs%r@m9npR/l I$
3 dn5 46"3 @IpC3
"
!
#$ %& H
MIFmG: Ibr spBpC3?r@lNrBl I%28lV/l IF
3 CA3?28ls=>3S
r NPL0KTT2?2n @6EL LTQSmCNF:<28
n %31Jf28lN: IG3 @ %3?:<2?s%r@313?2C: Ifk=5?DIm @I3?r
3UDIm @I3<n%:E3 CA5B
= TLCST EGE GXZSD`
R I
3 @Ifm eH3<=>3<n':E3cm92n @Im;:E3?r28=3s'r@"3 @7m9nfr@l3<[
k V"5 C,Bl I312849pB5C=>m6Bl IJ|G2 CAl>3UM= NqLORL9
0 CA5Cs2n @f2k%2?=>lmG284
JK28l: I 35 CT/l IF3bl2?=>pC3<6
l m6Bl I^2x=3<l>=m63<D)G3 @x3 d3<Jk4;28=+2?2n @ n5Cl>"3 @ Jm;r@Jf2?l: I3Ur35 CCA3?2?l>s=3?&r ` R I3Un
nF3<m67p I%5B=Nr"5 C/l IF3+=>3<l=>m63UD)"3 @u3 d3<JkF4G28=Nrc2?=>3e:E5Bn'r@m @d3<=>"3 @[2Cr1:<282n @dm @2?l>3?r CA5B=T6
2 %3<l>l3<=1Jf28lN: IZ` _ 5B=
m9n%r@lN28n%:X3 HBm C'/l I3lN28=>pC3<l:<2Cr@3k%28=l>mG2?4649qJK28l: I3?r ?i CGHJX Fsl I%2CrW/l I3V72 @,@Im9l>m65Cn%28$4 CA3?28ls=>335 C CGXFADX[L|TQSDH
lBI3<na/l I3 @Ifm e"3U=>3<n%:X3M46m9^n r spBpC3?r@lN
r ?i CGHJXS" `
R I33<D)3<ndl>s'284649qM=>3Ul>=>m93<D)"3 @1r@5Cs=:X33 I3UJk4G2?(= 'bm;rWs%r "3 @ol>51:X4G2Brr@m CAqo/l IF3l2?=>pC3<l 2?2n @+/l I3Jf2?l: I
%3<l 3<3<)
n ' 2?2n @ ^mGrs%r "3 @l>5R3 dk4G2?m6nBl ImGr:E4;2Brr@m lL:<28lm65BZn `SR I3+:E4;2Brr@m lL:<28lm65Bna2?2n @3 IkF4G28n'28l>m95BnamGr
w>@ImGr:Es%rr@"3 @^y/m6/l Ia/l I3Tl>3?2C: IF3<$
= r l>3<k%Br i "5 CRW2 463 Vz MI5Jf2<qR3 dk4G2?m6na:E5B==>3?:XlM:E4;2Brr@m lL:<28lm65Bn'&r H
lBIg
3 XZLONPLQ]CGI FL.35 C=CA3?28ls=>3?Er H)28n @oJf2<qMk=>5?Ddm @I3 @I5BJK28m6$
n dn5 46"3 @dpB3 CA5C=,3 dk4G2?n%28lm65Cn%&r ` R I3l3?2B: I3<7= r
m9nIl3<=2C:El>m95BnR:<2?n7=3?r@sF46l,m9n: I%28nFpB"3 @+=>3<Jem62n @Im9np)r.28n @ m9n7493?28=nm6np35 ChkF=>5Bl5Bl qdkmG:<2?46m9l@qT2?2n @73 d3<Jk4;28=
@dm eH3<=>3Un%:E3?Er `
_
"B9^%8:!G#!.09^%#"g(*='&# 898:@(*,&9^.
+ &,!:!$#&+)
0z3<D)3<=2?4m92n @I3 dm6npal>3?: Inm { sF3?r I%2<D)36%3<3<n 3dk4;28m6nF3"@ 2%5?D)3`V n 2(@,@Im9l>m95Bn?HSNqLORL10 :U28n 463?2?=>n
m9n2@I3dm6nFpMdn5463"@IpC3 CA5B=T3d3<Jk4;28=r28n2@ :E5Cn%:E3<klgr@l=>s%:Els=>3Sr\CA=>5CJ l=2?m6nm9npMdq 2fl>3?2C: IF3<=MI5
kF=>5?DIm @I3?r"m9n%r@lN28n%:E3Srtl5M:E4;2Brr@m CAq28n @o28kFk=>5?D)3?r.:E4G2Cr>r mlH:<2?l>m95Bn%rE`R I3k=5Bl>5Cl qIkm;:<2849m6l qV53CH2?no3d3<Jk4;28=
m;rtm9n%:E=3?2Br "3 @MI3<n1m6l 2Br.r@s%:<:X3?r>r CAs4649qMs%r@G3 @OCA5C=,2V:E4;2Br>r m lH:U28l>m95B?n ` R I3J5B=3,n3 :<2Br 3?rWr s%:<:E3Sr>r CAsF4646q
JK28l: If2?nb3 d3<Jk4;28= HB/l I31J5C=>3Ml qdkmG:U284"m9l %3?:E5BJe3?&r `
NqL RL10T2?4Gr@5{2B: { sm6=3?r,2?2n @ s'r@3?rWJK28l: Im9nc
p dn5 46G3 @IpB3 Hzr@s%: I+2CrOm9Jk%5B=l28n':E3"5 CCA3?2?l>s=3?r,28n @
JK28l: I[r l>=3<npBBl I?` NqLORL1;
0 I3<s=mGr l>mG:U284649q3?r l>m6JK28l>3Sr/l I3Tm6Jk%5B=l2?n%:E3o"5 CCA3?2?l>s=3?rcl>5K2:<28l3<pB5C=>q
dq[2?n%2849+
q *Um6nF
p CA3?2?l>s=F3 l5 :<28l3<pB5C=>q[3 dk4;28n%2?l>m65Cn%&r ` _ 5B=1m6n'r@l2?n%:E3 H2CA=>5BJy/l I3+73 Ik4;28n%2?l>m95BnZ=>3<4;28l>m9np
?i CGHJXS Or CA3S28l>sF=>3?r1m6n _ m6pCs=>-3 fl>5bBl I3e:<28l3<pB5C=>q j?i CGHJXOTEH.m6l13?r l>m6JK28l>3Src/l I%2?Rl TLCS,m;r2?n 3?rr@3<ndl>m;284
CA3S28l>sF=>3f35 C{2 j?i CGHJX|TEH,/l I%2?D
l EL LTQSmCNhmGr+2bJe$5 @I3<=2?l>3<49q[m6Jk%5C=>l2?nI
l CA3?28ls=>3e35 C{2 j?i CGHJXOTEH28n @ Bl I%28l
, *i = L[L[%NTV3<l mGr3<2R3Unr@ksF=>rm65Cks%sr =>m9CA5B3?s%28[r lRs=>2831n 35@¨CjA?i m6CGJHJXOk%TE5C`q=>Vlnd2?l>nI3<Ql = n%` 2849R 46q IH(3bCA3?3S2?r@l>l>sm9Jf=3128=>l3<3?49ro3<DC:U2828n%n :E3%mG3ar=>=>3<3<DdkmG=r 3?"3 r@@x3UnIm lC"3 /l @RIFd3<qqf2qIm9nd3<4s@ RJ 2 %3</
JemGr>:X4G2Brr@fm lH:<28lm65Cn5B=28nf3 dk4G2?n%28lm65Cnb=>3 >3?:El>G3 @ dq/l IF3l3?2B: I3<= `
NqL RL1\
0 @I3<l>3U=>Jm9n3?r MIm;: ICA3?28ls=>3?rh35 CQ2?n+3 I3UJk4G2?=.28=3m6JekL5C=>lN28ndl CA5C=2Mr@s':<:E3?rr CAs4dJf28lN: IZ`
V CO28nam6Jk%5B=l2?nIS
l CA3?28ls=>3135 CP/l IF3=3<l>=m63<D)G3 @ 3 d3<JkF4G28= @I5)3Srn5Ccl %3<495BnpRl>5+Bl I31l2?=>pB3Ul @I3?r>:X=>m6kFl>m65C?n H
~ I , NPL KL-[} CTL E?CS@SLQXQIMADCSj?i HJIKT28l>l3<JklNr&l5+m6n CA3<=m6Sl CA=>5BJ|/l I3MlN28=pB3<Ml CA3?28ls=>3Sr&s%r m6nD
p dn5 4 G3 @IpB3 `SR IF
3 InF5 49"3 @IpCF3 m'2Br@G3 @7Jf28lN: IFm6npMm;r
2 I3<s=mGr@lmG:r 3?28=N: IBl I%28l %3<pBm9n%r CA=5BJ 3?2B: I7sFnJf28lN: IF"3 @
73 I3<Jek4G2?= CA3?2?l>s=3+28n @[: I%2?m6n%r/l IF=>5BsF(
p I[/l IF3on3<l 5B|= f"5 CqInF5 49"3 @IpC3osndl>m94h=>3?2C: Im9npR3<m6Bl I3<=V2R:<2Br 3
CA3S28l>sF=>3b5C=7Bl I_
3 @d3<k/l I%5BsF2n @` ^2B: I^r@3S28=: I^r l>3<k 3 dl>3U2n @r+/l I3a:Es==>3<ndl+k%2?/l Im9/l I 2 =3<4G2?l>m65C?n `
i
Qk'28l/IY:E5Cnn3?:Elm6npK28nZ3I3UJk4G2?= CA3?28ls=>3Dm9l/IZ2l2?=>pC3<l CA3?28ls=>3+m;rM28nZ3dk4G2?n%28lm65Bn[5"CMI5 l/I3
CA3S28l>sF=>31mGrw3 { sFm6DC28493<nIlOy dH m6nfl/I 3Tr 3<n%r@3Tl/I%2?ll/I3 CA3?2?l>s=3?rr@sFpBpB3Sr@lMlBI3Tr>28Je31:E4G2Cr>r mlH:<2?l>m95Bn?`
R I 3f3F28Jk4935 +2%58D)3\r I 53"@ I 5 lBI 3FCA3?28ls=>3Sr NPL0KTa28n2@E*LL|TQSmCNP:<28n %3bk%2?l>l>3U=>n
JK28l: I 3"^
@ 2?n2@M
H lBI 3<=>37Iq
H lBI 3xkF=>3?r 3<n%:E3[5"e
C 28nm6Jk%5B=l2?nIl AC 3S28l>sF=>3Zm6nl/I 3Zl2?=>pB3Ulum;rf:E5Bnl'=>J3"@ `
R 'I 28lm;r&
H s%r m6npYIn5493"I@ pB3
H l/I 3\r@m9Jm64;28=>m9l qb53T
C lBI 3[r 5Bs=N:E3[2?n2@ l/I 3al2?=>pB3Ul7m;r J5C=>3a2B:U:Es=2?l>3<49q
3Sr@l>m9Jf28l3"
@ 5C=dH kslI@ meH3<=3<ndl>46q8H =3<D)3?28493"@` n5463"d@ pB3F\%2Br 3"+
@ k%28ll>3<=n7Jf2?l: I m6nFpcm9n N LOR1
L 0Ts%r@3?r
@ 5BJf2?m6n_m6n2d@ 3<k%3<n2I@ 3<ndlSI 3<s=mGr l>mG:UrOl5+3<DC2849s%28l3Ml/I 3 { s%2849m6l q+53PC 2ok'28l/
I m9l/f
I l/I 3ks=>k%5zr@31l>5l%n @
a i d
lBI 3Tr@l=>5BnFpB3?r lM3dk4G2?n%28lm65Bna2?n2u
@ l5+k=>snF33S2R5Bn3?rE`
!+(*%
4 +!+%+,G+68(8 &+
h+8:@(*,
#"%$
J5C=>=3?r@k%5Bn @Im6npZl>5[Bl I3l qdkmG:<2?4 _m6n%r l2?n%:E/
3 %2Br 3"@ 28n'28465CpBm;:<284m9n CA3<=>3Un%:E3Rr>: I3<JK2 " HNqLORL10
JK2Sq[s'r@3fl/I3eJ5)r lok=5Bl>5Cl qIkm;:<284m9n%r@lN28n%:E3 '53C2[: I5zr@3<n :U28l>3UpB5B=q 2Br+2[r 5Bs=N:E3m CVn5[=>3<Jem6n2@z
m9np)rMl5b2fr kL3S:Em lH:o73 I3<Jek4G2?= 3<=A
3 CA5Bs2n @ `9R I3e2Br@k%3?:Xl mGr&HH53CV:X5Bs=Nr@3H"=3<463UDB2?nIlCA5B= '%3?:U28s%r 3
m;r
`6V CBl I3Rl28=pB3<lT:<2Cr@3R=>3<Jem6nr NqLORL0a53C2k%2?=>lmG:Es4;28=13d3<Jk4;28= HLlBI3<nZl/I3
:U2Br@3 rcm9Jk%5B=>lN28ndl CA3?28ls=>3Srck=>5?DdmI31Bl I3R2Br kL3S:El MIm;: IapBm6D)3Sr=mGr@3Tl>5e2:E5Cnn3?:Elm65Cn m'2Br@3[28n%2 495BpCmG:<2?4Wm9n CA3<=>3Un%:E
3 m9/l I ` n5 463dpBF3 \%2Br 3uk'28l>l3<=>naJf28lN: IFm6npg:<28n L3gr@3<3Un[2Br
2b=&3 CA5B=J7sF4G28lm65Cn[/l I%2?l+sl>m946m *U3?rI5BJf2?m6nZ3 { sm6DC28493<n%:E3Sr{5C=om9Jk46m;:<28lm65Cn%&r `V n Bl ImGrT:<2Br 3 HNqLORL10
3UJk465?qFr,28nK28n%2?465BpCmG:<2?4"m9n CA3<=>3Un%:E3m9n%:E49sIm6nFp=&3 CA5B=J7sF4G28lm65Cn+35 C Bl I%28lJ7s%r l,n5ClF3 eH3?:ElBl I3M2Cr@k%3?:El
`
*
!&F#"%$!'& '
0z5)(_2?=R3u=3<Ddm633 N,=>5*Im9pBq "Qcn'28465CpBq%+ Q\J]_^,+28n NqLORL0Y2?n :E5?D)3<=3xl-3<m6=+kFs=>k%5)r 3?r+
dn5 463IpB3a=>3<k=3?r@3UnIlN28l>m95Bn%r+.I5BJf2?m6n%r+&l5Bk^493<D)3<4V2849pB5C=>m6l-Jfr+2?n^r@5CJ3bk%2?=>lmG:Es4;28=e:E5BJeksl2
lm65Cn%284,l3?:-nm { s3?Er ` R/-3+=3(A3<=3<n%:E3?rl5f5Bs=Ml-3<5C=>3<lmG:<2?4Wk=3?r@3UnIlN28l>m95Bn%rVm6n[r 3?:Elm65Bn a :E463?2?=>49qbr0-5 l-31Ifm e"3U=>3<n%:X3?ro5(Tl-F3?r@3\r@qFr@l>3UJfr m9n^2 r qr l>3<JK28l>m;R
: 2<q ` N,=>5*Im9pBq "Qcn%2?465CpBq^s%r 3?r7:X5Bnn3S:El>m95Bn '2Br@3 2?n%28495BpC
q m9l-Z58D)3U=>pB3Un3<=2?4:E5BnnF3?:El>m95Bn%r12?n6
>s%r l>m lL:<28lm65Bn m%2Cr@3Yr@m6Jem64G2?=>m9l@q3?2 Q J]_^ 3<R
J kF465?qr1:E5Cnn3?:Xl>m65Cn%rM3 dk46m;:Em6l46qpCm6D)3<n[m9n[l-3R5 >3?:XlI3?r:E=>m9kl>m95BnZ28nx3 dk46m;:Em6l46q=3<k=>3Sr@3<ndl>3[r m6R
J m94G2?=>m6l q32 NqLORL10[sl>m946m *<3?rcl qdkmG:<2?4 _m6n%r l2?n%:ED
3 %2Cr@3 2?n :E5Cnn3?:Xl>m65Cn \%2Br 3 28n%2?465BpCq `[R/-3l-F=>3<3
r qr l>3<JKro24I=>3?rr =3(A5B=J7sF4G28lm65Cn5Ifm eH3<=>3<ndl>49q `_N,=>5*dm6pBq "QVn%28495BpB
q l%nrol qdk%3k=>3Sr@3<=DIm9npZr@qdR
J %5C4
JK28kkm9np)r?+ Q J]_^6(A5d:Es%r@3Src5Bn[m9nIl3<= 7I5BJK28m6n8-m9p4-3U= _5B=d3<=MJf2?kkm6nFp)r+H28n_
NLORL10f3<D)3<nfslm 49m *<3Sr dn5 463IpCF3 \%2Br 3u=3(A5B=J7s4;28lm65BZn `
4
4
4
Qc465Cnp[r 3<D)3<=N2849Im9J3<n%r m65Cn%r+.28n'28465CpBm;:<284=3?2Br 5Bnm9np[:<2?nx%3fr@3U3<n 28n s'r@3 2Cro2ar@qdn5BndqIJwl>5
:U2Br@3Qm%2Cr@3Z=>3?2Cr@5BnFm6npY J +,-3<=3wN:<2Br 3?r|yfk4G2<q[l-F37=5B463+5(V5>3?:Xlr&`*R/-3Rl>3<=Jw:<2Br 3Fm'2Br@3
=3?2Br 5Bnm9np$2CrWm6ndl>=5*Is%:E3dq+0d:-%28n^ ` _ =3 { sF3<nIl46q%+?:U2Br@3Qm%2Cr@3o=3?2Br 5Bnm9np1mGr,:X5Bn%r mI3<=3o2CrWm6ndl>=N2
&
d5BJf2?m6nY28n%2?465BpCq%+!,-FmG:-xJ3S28n%rcl-%28lTl-3er@5Cs=:X32?nxl-F37lN28=>pC3<l%3<495Bnpal>5fl-F3r28J3:I5BJK28m6n;+
2Cro5Bkk%5zr@3 l>5\28n%2?465CpBq 2C:E=>5zr>r<d5BJf2?m6n%r1l-%2?lomGrI3S2846g
l m6l
- dq r 5BJ3R2?n%28495BpCq r@qFr@l3<Jf&r `;]b5C=>3
m9Jk%5B=l28ndl>49q%+IJe5)r@lkF=>3<Ddm65Cs%r J =>3Sr@3?2?=:-=-'2BrM2<(A5d:Es%rl-%2?lcm;r,Im eH3<=3<ndl/(A=>5BJ l-31Jf28m9nmGrr@s3?r
5(V2?n%28495BpBqZr qr l>3<JK&r `k>-3<=3?2BrVJ5)r l128n%2?465CpBq[=>3Sr@3?2?=:-[r@l=>3?rr@3bl-B3 >s%r l>m lL:<28lm65Bn[5(V2?n%28495BpBm;:<284
m9n?(A3<=3<n%:E3?r28nl-31Jf28kkFm6np+vJe5)r@l J ^=>3Sr@3?2?=:-3<Jk-'2Br@m *<3+l-315C=>p)2?nm *S28l>m95Bnf5(O:<2Cr@$
3 %2Br 3?r+
l-3=3<l>=m63<DC2842?n r@l5B=N28pB3f5(:<2Br 3?r+P28n r@5CJ3e242?kl2?l>m65Cn 5(r@5Cs=:X3f:<2Br 3?r 5C465*In3U;
= T i (Y@+A(A5B=
m9n%r@lN28n%:X3%+)28n'2846q *<3?r J 2CrW2cpC3<n3<=N284Fr@3 { s3<n':E3,5(Qr l>3<k%rhpB=5Bsk%3om9nIl5l-=3<3k-%2Br 3?Cr h |3sm94Im9np
l-3Y:<2Br 3[46Pm F=28=q%$
+ m`G7=3<l>=m63<Ddm6nFp :<2Cr@3?r+M2?n~
a e28kFk46qdm6npYl-3Z=>3<l=>m93<D)3 :<2Br 3?rl>5 l-F3[l28=pB3<l
r m6ls%28lm65Bn;+"2?nf2B:<:E5C=Im9npRl>[
5 TEYhl-3Tr l28n28=B J :EqF:E463VmGr 3<l>=m63<D)3C+ 3<s%r 3%^+ 3<DdmGr 3%^+ 3<l2?m6?n `
R/-5
3 l%=r lbr 5 :<2849463
J $r@qFr@l3<J 2Cr JSP$r10 T i `"YD+12 { s3?r@lm65Cn 2?n%r 3<=>m9np^r qr l>3<J m6l&
&
&
&
&
X
dn5463IpB3g2%5Bsl1l=2<D)3<4GrV28nbJ3<3<lm6npzr&5(l-3Dr0[0z3?:E=>3Ul28=q5(V0)lN28l3FJqI=s%r 2?n%:E3ÒR/-3o4;2Br@l
d3?:<24d3 -%2Crr@3<3Un 2Yr@l>3S24Iq pB=5 5(1m6ndl>3U=>3?r l+m6n J 28n 2 r@s%:U:E3?r>rD(As4k=5BpB=3?r>rRm6n J =>3F
r 3?28=N: -Z2?n[r@qFr@l3<Jfr,I3UD)3<465CkJ3<nd
l Tf ^Y `M0)3<D)3<=N284P:E5BJJe3<=:mG2?4hr@qFr@l3<Jfr2?n J I3<D)3<495BkJ3UnIl
l5)5B4;r3<J3U=>pB3u2?l1l-D
3 %3<pCm6nnm9npf5(l-
3 X(X Cr+Pr@s%:-Z2B9
r J j Q $V:^q j 5dZ: *-3<3 + J B`5mV n?(A3<= 3Un%:E9
3 J5B=?k `B,+ ^$0 RM^S^S] ^r@l3<3<J 0)5(Al 28=>g
3 V n%(: `f+ QSRM^¨ QZ: dn5)r 5(AQl +2?n 0 /JQ0 ^¨ l3?
: V nn5
V/
J >` J Je3<l-5*d5B465CpBq[k=5?D)3 lM
5 %3J5zr@lT28kFk=>5Ck=>m;28l>3 (A5C=+:E4;2Br>r m lH:U28l>m95Bn lN2Br rTr@s%:- 2Br
dmG28pCn5)r mGr+%2Br>r 3?r>r J3<ndl
+)2?n -3U46k I3?r R28kkF46mG:U28l>m95Bn%Wr %3?:<2?s%r@3{:E4G2Cr>r@fm lH:<2?l>m65Cn7JK28m6nF46q1=>3<49m63?r.5Bne:<2Br 3
=3<l>=m63<DC2?4=28l-3<=Rl-%2?n242?kl2?l>m95B?n ` _ 73 3<=R2?kk46m;:<28lm65Cn%r 5B= (A5C=7kF4G28nFnm6npY28n>I3?r@m9pBn l2Br r
,-FmG:-b2?=>31J5C=>3Im f:Xs46lm6nfl>3<=Jfr&5(2 28kFl28lm65C?
n `
R/-;
3 J k%28=N24Im9pBJw:E5?D)3<=Nr2=N28npC35( Im eH3<=3<nIl1J3Ul-5*r,(A5B=o5C=>pz28nm *<m6np+W=3<l>=m63<Ddm6np+h28n
sFl>m649m *<m9np+l-F
3 dn5 463IpC3+r l>5B=3bm6n\:<2Br 3?&r ÒR§58dm eH3<=>3UnIlJ3UJ5B=q+J5*I3<4;r _r@3<3gr@3?:Elm65C5
n ` ` `z28=3
(A5C46495 3x
Iq J r@qFr@l3<Jf&r ` R/-F3 JSPir0Zr@qFr@l3<J T i `(YD+3 ` ,p ` +,m;
r %2Br 3 5Cn 0d:-%2?^n r Iqdn%28Jm;:
Je3<J5B=qxJe5*I3<
4 Tf`
`(Y3 IkF4G28m9n3 m6n r@3?:Xl>m65Cn ` ` `$` R/-_
3 NqLORL10 r@qFr@l3<J T i YVmGD
r %2Br 3 5Cn^l-3
73 I3<Jek4G2?=MDIm93 5(1:U28l>3UpB5B=m63?r1l-%2?lopCm6D)3?rM=>m;r@3l5[2fJ3<J5C=>qf5B=p)28nFm *?2?l>m65Cn 2Brok=3?r@3<ndl>3 m9
n =` a `
sVm eH3<=>3UnIl1=>3Uk=>3?r 3<ndl28lm65Cn%rM5(:<2Cr@3?rT28=>3:I3?r:E=>m %3 m9n 6
2 l*d3 5C=o5CkL3Un D)5d:<2 Fs4G2?=>qZ28n 28=R
3 bH28l
_r@3<lNr 5(T28ll>=Pm slF3 _DB2?46s3ak%28m9=[r o5C=r l>=>s':El>s=3 2Br+
3 ` ,p ` +r -5 n^m9n _ m6pBsF=>x
3 i §+ ,-F3<=>3fl-FM
3 %5B4 5B=Brcm6nImG:<2?l>31
5 >3S:Elr2?nul-3om9l2849mG:cm9nIm;:<28l3 (A3S28l>sF=>3?Er `MR/-3(A3S28l>sF=>3?r5( (^8+. I5Rn5Bl28kFk46q
l57l-315 >3?:Xl #!,239^.@()/ `
&
&
&
&
&
'
&
&
Hotel
Comfort
Type of Bathroom
Name
Case
Price
Region
Month
_
Bedroom1
Type of Bed
Bungalow
Kitchen
No of Bedrooms
m6pCs=>3/
Bedroom2
Type of Bed
Bedroom3
Type of Bed
^ F28JkF463M5(2Rr@l=>s%:Els=>3K=3<k=3?r@3<ndl2?l>m95Bn
i h W
J2Br 3xm9nI3 dm6npYmGr2?n m9Jk%5B=>lN28ndlmGrr@s3Z5*
( J 2?kk46m;:<28lm65Cn%rl-%2?lus'r@3Z2 4;28=pB3Z:<2Cr@3%2Br 3
%3?:U28s%r 3m6l1r 3<463S:ElrM25_r@Jf2?464@r@s?%r@3<l15(,(A3?28ls=>3?rV5(V:U2Br@3Srl>5ar kL3U3 sFkxl-3+=>3<l=>m93<DC2842?n +Wl-Is'r+
2<D)5Cmrl>5e:E5BJek%28=3128494.:<2Br 3?r (A=5BJ l-3+:U2Br@3$%2Cr@3gm6l-al-31n37 lN28=>pC3<l:<2Br 3`§V n\r@5BJe312B:<2 I3<Jm;:
r qr l>3<JKr+):E5CJk493 ImGr:E=>m9Jm6n%2?l>m95BnonF3<l 5B= rP28=>3Vs%r 3 `SQcn+3 F28Jek463mGr2ImGr:E=>m9Jm6n%2?l>m95BnonF3<l5B=
(A=5BJ JSP$r0fr0-5 n[m6n _ m6pCs=>
3 X7l-%2?l1:E5CnIlN28m6n'r ] LON&g
r r@3U3+r@3S:El>m95B5
n `$` `G,-mG:-[r l>5C=>3Rr -'28=>3
(A3S28l>sF=>3?r15(m6lr1:<2Cr@3?rT28n m9nI3 [l-5)r 3f:<2Br 3?&r `nc5*I3?r1m6n l-37nF3<l 5B= x3Um6l-F3<=-5B4 r@m9npB493:<2Cr@3?r
5C=R28=3br ^s ] LON&rol-%28lTl-3UJfr@3<49D)3?rM:E=3?28l38Im;r>:E=m6Jm9n%28lm65Bn[nF3<l 5B= Er `5V n _ m9pBs=5
3 X*+,l>=>m;28npC463?r
=3<k=3?r@3<ndl { s3?r@lm65Cn%r+%2?n4G2 %3<4;r5Cna28=:Ur=3<k=>3Sr@3<ndl2?n%r 3<=Er ` 5 d3?r2?=>9
3 ] LON&r `
&
V
&
Diplomatic Meeting
The actor is Cyrus Vance
Participants are foreign diplomats
Topic is an international contract
Participants talk to each other
Participants
Topic
SALT
Camp David
accords
case2
Begin
Jerusalem
case3
Dayan
Gromyko
case4
case2
MOP3
Topic is Camp David accords
MOP2
Participants include Begin
Participants are Israeli
Topic concerns Israel and Arabs
Topic
Participants
Begin
Dayan
Jerusalem
Camp David
accords
MOP4
case4
case3
MOP4
_
m9pBs=3R X)h cs mGr:E=>m9Jm6n'28l>m95Bn cn 3<l5C=| (A=>5CJKJSP$r0
V
n =>3?2?4\5C=>4f2?kk46m;:<28lm65Cn%rr 3<D)3<=2?4"J3Ul-5*r I3<D)3<495Bk%37m9n;][2B:-m9n3 j 3?2?=>nm9npR28=33UJk465?q)3
(A5C= sm94Im9npRm6nI37ul=>3<3Src2?nb=>3<l=>m93<DIm9npR:<2Cr@3?r+h28J5CnpRl-3<J Vs a 2?nMG0fl>=>3U3?r&ÒQ~G0bl=>3<3TmGr
Fsm649
l Iq=3<k%3?28l3I49q7k%2?=>lm6l>m95Bnm9npRl-3T:<2Cr@$
3 %2Br 3om9nb
2 '284G2?n%:E32<q` ^&2C: -an5*I3Tm6nfl-3$G0l=>3<3
=3<k=3?r@3<ndlr12fr@?s %r@3<lT5(:<2Br 3?rm9nxl-3R:<2Br 6
3 %2Cr@3 `*ÔD)3U=>qbm9nn3<=1n5*d37k%2?=>lm6l>m95Bn%r1l-3er@3Ul5(V:<2Cr@3?r
=3<k=3?r@3<ndl>3 dql-3nF5*I3cm9nIl5cl 5ImGr >5Bm9nIlPr@^s 'r@3<lNrWs%r@m9np12 dmGr>:X=>m6Jem6n%2?l>m6nFp (A3?2?l>s=3 `WV n _ m6pBsF=>B3 ` Al2 )3<n=(A=5BJ T a Y@+(A5B=Vm6n'r@l2?n%:E3%+ Ql6
5 V2?=>3g:<2Br 3?rcm6n\R
2 `0dm6J3<n'r@m65Cn%284 (A3S28l>sF=>3+r k%2B:X
3 28n
Pg `
V
F
50
X
G
C
<=35
> 35
40
Y
E
30
B
<= 30
20
C, E
<= 15
>30
H, I
F, G
> 15
I
A
A, B
10
> 30 <= 35
X
D
10
Y
H
20
30
40
_
D
m9pBs=3g` )h^W2?Jk493M5(O2 G7Kl=>3<3
50
60
70
R/-F3DL5C4b49m6n3?rr0-5`l-3Tk%28=l>m6lm65Cnm6np:Is=m6npel-3g:E=>3?2?l>m95Bnb5(l-F3G0bl=>3<3` R/-3o=3?r@s49l>m9npRG7
l=>3<3VmGrr0-5n2?ll-F3=>m6p -Il9-%2?nr mI3` /R -3VJ3<l-F5*ol>3<=Jm6n%2?l>3?r,-3<nRl-F3ck%2?=>lm6l>m95Bn%r2?=>3r@Jf2?46463U=
l-%28nZ2+pBm9D)3<nfl-=3?r -F5B4 `M/R -3G7ul>=3<31J3?:-%28nFmGr@J :U28nb3 f:Em93<ndl>46q -'28nI493ondsJ3<=mG:/(A3?28ls=>3Sr&` V l
kF=>5*Is%:X3?rc2D3U464\%2?4G28n':E3Rm9n%28=qfr@3S28=:-fl>=3<3`
Vs a 28sl5BJf2?l>m;:<284946qZpB3<n3U=28l3?r+21I3?:Em;r@m65Cn l>=>3U3 (A=5BJ 2Zr@3Ul+5(1l=28m9nm6nFpZ:<2Br 3?r&` V l+s%r@3?r<-Fm6464f
:X46m6J/m9np28nT2 -3Us=>m;r@l>m;:WJ3?2Cr@s=3:<2?46463Rw>m9n?(A5B=Jf28lm65Bn1pz28m6n yl5sm64 Ml-3l>=3<3` /R -3m6n*(A5B=>JK28l>m95Bn
pz28m9no3<DC2849s%28l3?r.28n1kmG:[r%l-3J5zr@l Im;r>:E=m6Jm9n%28lm6np=3<463<DC2?nIl(A3?28ls=>3?rh2Cr+B3` p,` +<m6n _ m9pBs=3§`4+,-F3<=>3
'
m9n l-F3=>5)5Clon5*I3fm9lor 3<463S:ElrMl-F3 (A3?28ls=>3 GIS i%3?:<2?s%r@3em6l1qIm93<4Fr{l-3 -m9p4-3Sr@l1m6n%:X=>3?2Cr@3R5(l-3
9m n?(A5B=Jf28lm65Cnupz28m9n[J3?2Br s=>3U,-mG:-f3?r@lm6Jf2?l>3?r9-5~3<464Q2 (A3S28l>sF=>3 dmGr>:X=>m6Jem6n%2?l>3?rW%3<l3<3Unb:X4G2Brr@3?r
m9l-al-3Tr>2?J3MlN28=>pC3<l/(A3?2?l>s=R
3 Am6nfl-F373 2?Jk463Vl-F3-F5Bl>3U4hn%28J3
`
Month?
Hotel
Price
Region
Month
Case 1
A
125
India
April
Case 2
B
200
Egypt
June
Case 3
C
175
India
April
India
Egypt
Case 4
B
200
Egypt
May
Case 1
Case 3
_
May
Case 4
June
April
Region?
Case 2
m6pCs=>3g`h Q I3S:EmGr m65Bnel>=>3U3 F sm64 (A=>5CJ 2+:U2Br@3g%2Br 315(9-5Cl>3<4;r
QMr (A5B=Tl-3R=>3<l=>m93<DC284D+hDC28=m65Cs%rl3?: -Fnm { s3?r (A5C=o=3<l>=m63<DC2849-%2<D)3D%3<3<n I3<D)3<495Bk%3 +hm6n':E46sdm6npfm6l
V`
3U=28lm6D)3%+dk%28=N2849463<4@+%28na:E5Bn%r l>=N28m6ndlr>2?l>m;r7(_2B:Xl>m65Cnbl3?: -Fnm { s3?rE`&0)3<D)3U=284Hl>3?:-nm { sF3?r (A5C=Mr 3<463?:Xl>m6nFp+l-3
Je5)r@l=>3<493<DC28ndl1:<2Br G3 [r Vm6n%:E49sI3 Im eH3<=3<nIl=28?n Im9npar>:-3<J3?rV28nxr m6Jm94G28=m6l qRJ3<l>=mG:<r+Ll-3+5?D)3<=>4;28k
5(r>2?46m93<nIl/(A3S28l>sF=>3?r+%28nbl-31m6Jk%5B=l2?n%:E3M5(r -%2?=>3=(A3S28l>sF=>3?§r m9l-bl-31l2?=>pB3UlM:<2Cr@3 ` n5 463dpBF3 m9nIl3<n%r m6D)3r@3<493?:Elm65Bn1J3Ul-5*r"l qdkmG:U284649qcpC3<n3<=N28l33 dk4G2?n%28lm65Cn%rWl-'28lPr@skk%5C=>ll-3=2?^n Im9npVk=>5d:E3Sr>&r `
k>-Fm6463er@5CJ;
3 J r qr l>3<JfrM=3<l>=m63<D)3g2[r@5BsF=:E3f:U2Br@3 %2Br 3x5Bn r qIndl2C:El>m;:<284r m6Jm94G2?=>m6lm63?r5(VkF=>5 493<Jfqr 3 ` ,p ` + JSP$r0 T i(a Y@+ NQSRs ^ Tf Y0+B5Cl-3U=r28ll>3<JkFlWl5m9n%:E49sI3r 3<Jf2?nIlmG:r@m9Jm64;28=>m9l D
q 3 ` ,p ` +
NqLORL1*
0 T i YD+ JQ0 ^ P T i 3Y@>`QckFk=>5z2B:-3?r m6l5
- w=>3<l=>m93<DC284%(A5B=2 28klN28lm65Bn y -'2SD)3 %3<3<nRr@sFpBpB3Sr@l>3
(A5C=+l-3R=>3Ul>=>m93<DC284m6n TY28n T a "Y28nxl-3U
q %3?2?=+r@5CJ3R=>3?r 3<R
J F4G28n':E3ol5b=>3(A5B=>JRs4;28l>m95Bn \%2Cr@3
2?n%28495BpCq`
Q nIs/
J %3<=15(Tr qr l>3<JKr=>3Ul>=>m93<D)3f:<2Cr@3?r(A=5BJ m6nI3 d3x=>3Uk=>3?r 3<ndl28lm65Cn%r+'(A5B=Rm6n%r l2?n%:E
3 IqYl-3
nF3?28=3?r@ln3Um6p4- %5B=l>3?:-nm { s3V2?kk49m637l
5 G0Rl>=>3U3?r&5C§= d6
q Vs a + ,-m;: -Rs%r@3Srl-3 I3?:Em;r@m95Bnl=>3<B3 sm946l
d
q Vs a (A=5BJ l-31:<2Cr@$
3 %2Br 3om9n5B=BI3<=l>
5 l'nul-3MJ5zr@lr m6Jm94G2?=:U2Br@3S&r `MLcnfl-3M5Bl-3<=,-%2?n +%r 5BJ3
r qr l>3<JKrr>:U28nbl-313<ndl>m6=3M:U2Br@$
3 %2Cr@3T=28l-3<=l-%28na28nam6nd3 I37J3<J5C=>q%+C3 ` =p ` G+ Iqen3?28=3?r@lnF3<m6p - %5B=
JK28l:-m9n,p `_R/-F3unF3?28=3?r@l+n3Um6p4- %5B=+Jf2?l:-m6nFpb:X5BJksFl>3?r121I3<pB=3<35(MJf2?l:
- m9l- r 5BJ3epB46
5 %284
r m6Jm94G2?=>m6l q A5B=Im;r@lN28n%:E
3 (Asn':El>m95Bx
n _r@3<3Tr 3?:El>m95Bn a V2?nb=2?^n r,-m9p4-3<=r>:X5B=>m9npf:<2Cr@3?r %3(A5B=3o495 3<=
r:E5B=m6npR5BnF3?&r `R/-mGrm;rk%5)r>r Pm 4931m6n I5BJK28m6n'§r ,-3<=>31l-3T:E5)r lr5(O28n%r 3<=m6np { sF3?r@lm65Bn'rmGrJm9nm6Je284
5C=cl-3 28lN2 '2Br@3TmGrr Jf28494"m6lNr@3<4 (P28n3+l-ds%r+l-3Tr@3<l5('(A3?28ls=>3Sr/-%2Brn5BllR
5 %31=>3Sr@l>=mG:El3 `
QMr (A5B=l-31=>3<s'r@3%+%:E5CkIqdm6nFp+28nb24F28klN28l>m95BnZ2?=>31k%5)r>r Pm 493Tr@^s lN2Br Er `3S:E3<ndl/dmGr>:Xs%r>r m65Bn'r -%2<D)3
r0-5 n l-%28lR2?n 2?kk=5Bk=mG28l3a242?kl2?l>m65Cn m;r Im K:Es49lo2?n n3<3Frok=>5(A5Bsn!I5CJf28m9x
n dn5 463IpC3 `
3<n%:E3%+%(A3 r@qFr@l>3UJfr2C:El>s%2?4649qf242?kl,(A5B=>Je3<=:<2Cr@3?r+3 ` =p ` 2+ JQ$0 ^P T i "Y `
k>-3<nl-3Yr@5C46slm65CnpB3<nF3<=2?l>3
Iq l-3Y=>3<l=>m63UDB2?4128n =3<s%r@3ZmGrn5Cl[:E5C=>=3?:El
+2 =3<DIm;r@m95BnmGr
nF3?:E3?rr>28=q `J ^ _ TWV a YD+3 ` ,p ` +Islm646m *<3?r:<28s%r28&4 InF5 493IpC3ol>5RpB3Un3<=2?l>3T28n[73 Ik4;28n%2?l>m95Bn (A5B=2 (_2?s46l
,-FmG:-xm;rm6n':E46sd3bm6ndl>5a2 (_2?m649s=>3RJ3<J5C=>
q ` R/-3<nZl-3?r 33 dk4G2?n%28lm65Cn%r128=>3es%r@3[l>5aJ5*Im (Aq[l-3
r 5B49sl>m95B
n IqK24Im9npRr@l3<k%rm9nIl5ol-F3Mk4G2??n `0)s%:-f2o=>3<DdmGr m65CnmGr Im K:Es49l2?nb2?4Gr 5+=>3<4;28l>m9D)3<46qT=2?=>31m6n
J r@qFr@l>3UJf&r `
&
('
('
&
B5 =J5B=3,I3Ul28m94Gr,2?n2Cr&2Mk%5Bm9nIl3<=l>51l-F3M:E5CJk=3
-3<n%r m6D)3q%5*IqR5(.2?n%28495BpCq7=3?r@3?2?=:-D3=3(A3<=
l-3Mm9nIl3<=>3?r l>3o=3?24d3<=:E5B49463?:Elm65Cn%rW5(.k'28k%3<=rm6nRl-328n'28465CpBqf2?=>3?2*TWV7V?+* i +Y ` Q~ X i Xo5?D)3<=DIm93
m;rpCm6D)3<nem6n 2849m4 r TWV
`3Y ` _ 5C=/(As=>l-3<=.I3Ul28m94Gr5Cn J q)5CsuJem6p4-dl:E5Bn'r@s49l 5B495*In3<7= §r %5)5 T i 7YD+
l-3+5?D)3<=>Ddm673 5( QM2?J5*Il12?n N,4;2 *?_
2 Tf&Y@+"l-3T3<DC2849s%28lm65BnZ5(:E5CJJ3<=N:Em9284 J l>5)5C4Gr T a YD+"5C=1l-3
kF=>5d:E3<3Im6npzr5(l-F3=3?:E3<ndWl l%=r lcm9nIl3<=>n'28l>m95Bn%2?4.:E5Bn*(A3<=>3<n':E3M5B_
n J Tf ?Y `
_
&
&
&
R/-F3<5B=3<J$k=>5?Ddm6np-Iq\28n%2?465CpBq%+2Cror)3Ul:-3um9n
6m pBsF=>3 ``?+l%nrT2uk=5)5(,(A5C=+2l2?=>pB3Ulol-F3<5B=3<J
pCsmd3 dq2+k=5)5(5(2 pCm6D)3<nKr@5BsF=:E31k=5493<J ,-m;: -m;rcr m6Jm94G2?=&l5+l-31lN28=>pC3<lVl-3<5C=>3<J `
][28l-3<Jf2?l>mG:XmG28n'r -'2SD)3{:E463?2?=>49q+=>3?:E5CpBnm *<37l-31k%5 3<=5(O28n'28465CpBm;:<284h=3?2Br 5Bnm9np7m9nJf2?l-3<JK28l
m;:<284k=>5
463UJwr@5B49DIm9np T V%+ a Y ` 53<D)3<=+W2?n%28495BpCq m6n l-3<5C=>3<J$k=5?DIm9np -%2Br1=>3?:X3<m6D)3b49m6Jm9l>3
2?l>l3<nIlm65Cn5I3Sr@km9l>3Rm6lrVm6Jk%5B=l2?n%:E3+m6nZJf2?l-3<JK28l>m;:<r28nxl-3e:E4;28m6JKrJf2 I3<(A5B=1m9lrMs%r@3(As46n3Sr>rMm6n
l-3<5C=>3<J kF=>5?DIm9np+m6n Tf%+ V`(Y `
! !#"`,'&%$X
& '"
_
(
W
.&
49m6np? rc5B=| T i Y&2BrV5Bn3+5(l-3l%=Nr@l12?l>l>3UJklrm6nal-3U5B=>3UJ kF=>5?DIm9np6dqa28n%2?465BpCq` mGrVr@qFr@l3<J
3Sr>r@3UnIlmG284946qak=>5*Is':E3?rMJf28kFkm6npzrc%3<l 3<3Un[k=>3dmG:<2?l>3Rr@qd/
J L5C4GrEÀR/-3Sr@3RJf28kkFm6npzrM28=32?kk46m93bl>5
Va
source theorem
target theorem
source axioms and lemmas
target axioms and lemmas
new lemmas
source proof
target proof
?
source methods
target methods
SOURCE
_
TARGET
m9pBs=3g``)hQcn%2?465CpBqm9nul-3<5C=>3<J kF=>5?DIm9np,`qs2Br -F3b2?=>=>5Vrm6ndmG:<2?l>3Ml-313<4G2L5C=2?l>m65Cnbk=5d:E3?rr&`
l-3T2Brr@sJkFl>m65Cn%r5(Pl-3Tr@5Cs=:X3ok=5)5(l5 l%nKl-3T2Brr@sJkFl>m65Cn%r (A5B=Vl-F3lN28=pB3<lk=5)5(B`
]bsndq)3<= T 7Y (A5d:Xs%r@3?r15Bn l-3 (A5B=>JRs4;2Br I3U=>m6D)3bm6nZ3?2B:-xkF=>5)5(r l>3<kZ` 3e28kkF46m63Sr2ar@qdJR%5C4
JK28kkm9np+:E5Cn%r@l=>s%:El3 (A=5BJ l-3ar@5Cs=:E3\28n l2?=>pB3Ul7l-3<5B=3<J +,l5xl-3?r@3 (A5C=>JRs4G2Crm6n 5C=I3<=Rl>5
5
l2?m6nal-3 I3<=m6D)3 (A5B=>JRs4;2Br&m9nfl-31l2?=>pC3<lckF=>5)5B( `
LB3<[
n Tf (X(YFl-5C=>5BsFp4-49qR28n%2?46q *<3 49m6n?p r,2?n ]bsnIq)3U= r.28kFk=>5z2B:-3?r&l51l-3<5C=>3<J k=>5?Ddm6n$
p dq
2?n%28495BpCq2?nr -F5 3+l-3<J m6n%2 I3 { s%28l3c3UD)3<n(A5C=&JK28ndq+r@m9Jk4932?n%28495BpCm63?r+28Je5Bnp15Bl-3<=Nr %3?:U28s%r 3
l-3<m9=oJf2?kkm6nFM
p 2Cr nF5BlRr@s f:Em93<ndl>46
q b%3 dPm 493 ` LB3Un rT2B:<:E5Csndl+3<Jk-%2Cr@m *<3?rMl-3eJf28lN: -3U=l-%28l
=3?:Es=Nr@m9D)3<46qg:E5Bn%r l>=s%:Elrr qI/
J %5B4%Jf2?kkm6nFp)r2?nf28=pBsJ3UnIlk%2?m6=>m9np)Er ` 3Vl>=2?n%r7(A3U=cr T7HJIKN L:<2?4G:Es49s%r
r l>3<k'r+hm ` 3 `^m6n'28=>qf=3?r@5C46slm65BnZ2?n[k%28=N28J5*IsF4G28lm65Cn + (A=>5CJ l-3+r 5Bs=N:E3+k=>5)5(l5ukF=>5?DIm I3+r l>3<k'rcm6n
2+l2?=>pC3<lckF=>5)5(B`
T73YVr@lN28=lD
r m6l- 2bs%r 3<= _k=58Ddmd3 m6nm9l>mG2?4r@qdR
J %5B4Jf28kFkm6npZ2?n k%28m9=>m9npx5(1r 5Bs=N:E3f463<JeJf2Br
m9l-Rl2?=>pB3Ul&493<JJf2Crh28n (A5d:Es%r@3SrO5Cn (_2?m6493+:E5Bn'r@l>=s%:Elm65Bn'r&5(t28n%2?465CpB5Bs'r&k=5)5(_r28n 5Cn -3Us=>m;r@l>m;:<r
(A5C=k%2?l:-m6nFpol2?=>pC3<lk=5)5(_Er `qVnel-3r>2?J3m6ndl>3<49463?:Xl>s%2?4Il=24dm6l>m95Bn 493r 5)3M:E5CnIlm6nds3 I3S2846m9n$
p m6ll-3 I3 FspBpCm6np5(28n%2?465BpCm63?Br Iq8-m;rk=3?:E5CnIm6lm65Cnbk=58D)3U= T`(Y `]b5B=>3T=>3?:X3<nIl46q%Z+ T a Y,2?n T`7X?+ i Y
3UJk465?qf:X3<=>lN28m6nZr 3?:E5Cnz _5B=d3<=MJf2?l:-m6npzrm9n[5B=BI3<=Ml5u3Sr@l2 46m;r -Z2?nZ28n%2?465BpCmG:<2?4Jf28kkFm6npe28n[l>5
l=2?n%r7(A3<=Vk=5)5(_r&`
V nor sJJf2?=>q%+X:E5CJkslN28lm65Bn'284d2B:U:E5Bsndlrh5('l-3<5C=>3<J k=>5?Ddm6n
p dq128n'28465CpBq-%2<D)q3 %3<3<n I5BJem6n%2?l>3
dqRl-3VmI3S25(.JK28kkm9npTr@qdR
J %5C4GrW5(,l-3Mr 5Bs=N:E3Ml-3<5B=3<Jl>5gr@qdR
J %5C4Gr,5(.l-3clN28=pB3<ll-3<5B=3<J 28n
3UJk465?qdm6npR2?nx73 Il3<nI3ar@qdR
J %5C4WJf2?k=(A5C=Ml>=N28n%rD(A3<=>=m6npfr m6npC463+k=5)5(r@l>3Uk%rc5(l-3Rr@5Cs=:E3+l5fl-3
lN28=pB3<l ` ^,JkFm6=>m;:<284.m6ndD)3?r l>m6pz28lm65Bn'9
r TWX + X(Y@+A-F5 3<D)3<=+tkF=>5?DIm I3b3<Ddmd3<n%:E3+l-%28l1l-FmGrm I3?28I5)3?r
nF5Bl2?kk=5Bk=mG28l3<46qg:E5?D)3<=.Jf28ndqT28n%2?465BpCm63?r I=2 /
n IqTJf28l-3<Jf2?l>m;:Em928n%r+8n5Cl3<D)3<n+2?464l-328n%2?465BpCm63?r
5(2Rr@l2?n2?=ul3 d|l %5)5 T a `3Y `SR/-313<Jkm9=>mG:U284Hr@lsIm63Sr/-%2<D)31r -5 nal-%2?l h
n >s%r@lRr m6npC463e:<284;:Es49s%ror l>3<k%r+28=3l>=N28n%rD(A3<=>=3 28n'28465CpBm;:<284946qZm6n
]b3<l-5*Fr+=28l-3<=Tl-%2?
Jf28l-3<Jf2?l>mG:U284%l-3U5B=>3UJ k=5?DIm9nD
p IqK28n%2?465BpCq `
C
5
c
=
K
J
8
2
d
n
7
q
5
,
(
l
?
3
@
r
T
3
?
2
%
n
8
2
9
4
B
5
B
p
9
m
?
3
r
%
+
r
qI/
J %5B4HJf28kkFm6np+m;r5Bn49qm6n%r s K:Em63<ndl ` Q`:-%28npC315(2
_
k=>
5 463<J=3<k=3?r@3<ndl2?l>m95BD
n dq%+B3 ` ,p ` +Csn?(A5B4 Im6nFpo2IQ3 l%nm6lm65Cn +):<2?R
n %3Vn3?:E3?rr>2?=>q+l>51=3<D)3?284
l-3:E5BJeJ5Bn%2?46m9l@q5(hl-3<5C=>3<Jfr.5B=2Brr@sJkFl>m65Cn%r+)sk%5C6
n ,-mG:-+l-F3M2?n%28495BpBm;:<284%l=28n'r7(A3<=
mGr %2Cr@3 ` LVl-3<="JK28kkm9np)r"5(%k=5 493<Jfr"2?nkF=>5)5(_rhl-'28l.pBB5 L3Uq)5Bn1r@qd/
J L5C4BJf2?kkm9np
28=>3Tn3?:E3Sr>r>2?=>qa2Br 3U464 ` _ 5B=r@5CJ3T28n%2?465BpCm63?r+ l'=r@lVl-F3o=>m9p4-dlc493<D)3<4%5i
( C)Z} TQS\X|CQSmHGI -%2Br
l>/
5 L3 (A5Csn %3(A5C=>3Tl>=2?n%r7(A3U=>=>m9npR2+k=>5)5B( `
'
&
'
!#"$%&'!%()+*,-./!0!
12!3)
-4567!8!.9:%;135<
<1=-))6.96>!
? '-.A@9BBBCD-:E&.FHG<
.3@BIJ%CK;
3%1)
-;3-5!*.
L!&M"$
1N
!"(-<!9
;O
V
][28ndqok=5)5(_rWIqg28n%2?465CpBq+=>3Sr@s49lA(A=5BJl=2?n%r7(A3<==>m9np$E^CGX[SJTh5(Hl-F3Vr@5BsF=:E3k=5)5(Ql>5E?CGX[S T
5(Hl-3l2?=>pB3UlWk=5)5(+d28nor@5CJ3k=>5)5(_rWIq12?n%28495BpCqol>=N28n%rD(A3<=.5Bn49ql-3kF=>5)5(Hm I3?2?+,-m9463
5Bl-F3<=rl>=N28n%rD(A3<=V2 d3<l2?m64637k=>5)5B( `
]b3<46m;r T X i Y d3<D)3<465Ck%3f2 n73 `28kkF=>5)2C: -al>5Rl-3U5B=>3UJ k=>5?Ddm6nD
p dqf2?n%28495BpBq\28nf3 dk4G2?m6n36,-dq
l-3BE*NfCGI463UD)3<4Im;r28nf2?kk=>5Ck=>m;28l3M5Bn3,(A5B=l-3M2?n%28495BpCmG:<2?4"l>=N28n%rD(A3<= `Mrr -5 nm9_
n T X(V"YLl-mGr,J3Ul-5*
:U28nZ:E5CkLD
3 m9l-[l-3+2?n%28495BpBm93?rcm9nbl-F3+J3<ndl>m65Cn37l3 d|l %5)5 Z2?nbmGr3<D)3<n\2 493ol>5 I3?28&4 m6l-[J5B=3
:X5BJk49mG:<2?l>3[Jf2?l-3<JK28l>m;:<284.l-F3<5B=3<Jfr TWX7X3Yr s%:- 2Cr+2bn5Bn l=>m6DdmG2?4 3Um6nF3 5B=3<4,l-3<5B=3<_
J `[R/-mGr
372?Jk463,-'2B§r %3<3<nkF=>5Bk%5zr@3m6n T`"Yh2Cr2+:-%2849463<npCm6np13 F28Jek4639(A5B=l-F3<5B=3<Jk=>5?Ddm6ng
p IqR2?n%28495BpCq
2?nb:X5Bs4 KnF5BBl L3Tr 5B46D)3d
dqk=3<Ddm65Bs'r28kk=5)2C: -3Srl5R28n%2?465BpCqbm9nl-3U5B=>3UJ k=>5?Ddm6n=p `
V nl-3=>3<Jf2?m6nd3<=5(Pl-m;rr@3?:Elm65Cnl-3{28n%2?465BpCz
q 7I=m6D)3<nfk=5)5J( _k4G2?n[:E5Cn%r@l=>s%:Elm65Cnum;rk=>3Sr@3<ndl>33+
l-3<nal-3T28n'28465CpBm;:<284hl=28n'r7(A3<=V5(Pl-3 3Um6nF3 5B=3<4%k=>5)5J( kF4G28n[m;r,I3?r:E=>m L3ur l>3<
k dqfr@l3<?k `
&
&
&
&
# L*+
, M
.'&1 ,* LP&,"
V n 2?sl>5CJf28l3xl-3<5B=3<J$k=58Ddm6nFp[28n'28465CpBq m;rMs%r@3(AsF4 (A5B=T465Cnp[2?n :E5BJkF463ak=>5)5(_rol-%2?l+:<2?nx%3
(A5CsnMdqa28nZ28sFl>5BJK28l>3ul-F3<5B=3<J k=>5?D)3<=m9l-[s%r 3<=M2Cr>r mGr@lN28n%:X3+5Bn49qu5C= (A5B=Vk=5)5(_rMl-%2?l1:<2?nn5Bl
%3 (A5Bsnx2?sl>5CJf28lmG:<2?4646qK28lT28494 `gVn[l-3?r 3+:<2Cr@3?rMl-F3R24Im9l>m95Bn%2?4,F3 eH5B=l5(Vr l>5B=m6npK28n[=>3<kF4G2<qIm9np
2er@5BsF=:E3+k%2<qFcr dqb2<D)5CmIm9np7JK28ndqs%r@3U=cm9nIl3<=2C:El>m95Bn%r5B
= dqfk=>5?DdmIm9npe2r@5C46slm65BnZ2?lM2?464@+L3 ` ,p ` + dq
r spBpC3?r@lm6npen3<3I37l2?=>pB3Ulc493<JJe2Br,5B=V5?D)3<=>=mIm9np+r 3?28=N: -8-3<sF=>mGr l>m;:<r&`
r %3<3Un7m9nIl=>5*Is%:X3 dq snd
q i Y `^k=>5)5(,kF4G28n;+I2Crr0-5 num9n _ m6pBsF=>U3 ` a +
=>5)5(.kF4G28nFnm6np -%2B§
m;r128nY2 %r l>=2C:El1=>3<kF=>3?r 3<nIlN28lm65BnZ5(2fk=>5)5(l-'28l1mGr12l>=3<
3 5C=o2 (A5C=>3?r Fl V5(J3<l-F5*un5*I3Sr ,-m;: 2?=>3g:E5BnnF3?:El>3R
IqKr@3 { s3<ndlr+:<2?46463KpC5)2?4G&r `
¦ARL[SGi ?7mGr+x
2 k'28=>lmG2?@4 1r k%3?:Em lL:<28lm65BnY5({2bl2B:Xl>mG: +,=>3<k=3?r@3UnIl3 m9n 2bJ3<lN2 _463<D)3U4,4G2?npBs%2?pB3%+
,-F3<=>3R2+l2C:El>m;:3 d3?:Esl3?r27nds/
J L3U=5(495BpBm;:<284.m6n*(A3<=>3<n':E3?
r 3Y `/-3TJ3<l-F5*rs'r@3f4G28l3<=Vm6nbl-mGr
r 3?:Elm65Bn -%2<D)B3 L3U3<n dF3 l%n3+m6
n (YH28n7l-3<qR2?=>3,(A=28JeF3 49Pm )3r@l=>s%:Xl>s=3?r m9l-Rk=>F3 P2?n7k%5)r l:E5CnIfm lm65Cn%^r >s%r l2BrWl-3V:E5CJJ5Bnk4G2?nnm6nFpM5Bk%3<=N28l>5C=Er `0)m6Jm94G2?=hl>5Vk4G2?nnm6nFpM5Bk%3<=N28l>5C=r+2cJ3Ul-5*
] -%2Br
l-3 (A5C46495 m9npr@465ClVr hWk%2?=28Je3<l>3<=+<k=>3S:E5Bndm6l>m95Bn%qr kF=>G3 ]|+<k%5z r@l:X5BnIm9l>m95B
n k%5zr@l ]|B+):E5Bn'r@l>=N28m9nIlNr+
kF=>5)5(Or>:-3<JK2M28nRk=>5d:E3Is=>3 `,k=>G3 ].mGr2Tr@3<l5(Pr@3 { s3<ndlr (A=5Bu
J ,-mG:-7l-328kk49mG:<2?l>m95Bn5(.l-3
Je3<l-5*:I3<=>m9D)3?r,k%5)r@7l ] ,-mG:-mGr2or 3<l5(r 3 { sF3<nIlNr2B§r 3U464 `.k=>3 ]P28nk%5)r l ]r@3<=D)3M2Crl-3
m9nkslO28no5Csl>ksFl&5(HJ3<l-F5*rtm9nok4;28nnFm6n=p `/-3V:E5Cn%r@l=2?m6ndlr,2?=>3/(A5B=J7sF4G28l3Mm6ng2cJ3<lN24G28nFpBs%2?pB3
2?n[r@3U=>D)31l>5R=>3?r l>=mG:Ell-3+r 3?28=N: - Is=m6npek4G2?nnm6nFp+3 ` ,p ` +=3?r@l=>m;:El>m95Bn%r5(kF=>G3 ]+k%5)r l ]B+L5C=c5(
l-3+k%2?=28Je3<l>3<=N&r `r l28n28=Bxk=>5CpB=N28J$m6n[l-3Rr@495BlMkF=>5d:E3ds=>3+3 d3?:EsFl>3?rl-3R2?kk49mG:<2?l>m65Cn[5(l-3
kF=>5)5(r: -F3<Jf2 `/-3Rk=>5)5(Vr>:-3<JK2 m;rM2 I3?:X4G28=N28lm6D)3+r: -F3<Jf28lmG:M=>3Uk=>3?r 3<ndl28lm65Cn[5(k=>5)5(_rm9n[l-3
5 >3?:ElT465BpCmG:4+.=>3<49qIm9npf5Bn l-F
3 nM28ls=2?4 sc3Is%:Elm65Bn mns {:<284;:Es49s%r128n 5Bn m9nID)
5 Im9npa28sl5BJf2?l>3
l-3<5C=>3<Jk=5?D)3<=r,r s%:-R2Br !&Y `/-3Vk=>5)5(Pr>:-3<Jf246m9n3?r,:E5CnIlN28m9nR2{4;2 %3<4@+I21r 3 { sF3<nIl+)28n
2+46m9nF3 }>s%r@lm lH:U28l>m95B?n `/-F349m6nQ3 f>s%r l>fm lH:<28lm65Cnb:X5Bn%r mGr@lNr5(,l-3on'28J3M5(28n ns =s463%+l-31n%28Je3M5(2
kF=>5?D)3<=
+C5B= j ^S]_]" m9nR:<2Br 3%+)l-3Vr 3 { sF3<nIlPmGr,m6n+k=G3 ]>`# dm6l>m95Bn%2?4649qm9l,Jf2<qom9n%:E49sI3r skk%5B=l>m9np
49m6n3S&r ` _ 5B=m9n%r@lN28n%:E3C+
mV 2 `G
a o%$'&
d3?r>:E=Pm %3?rWl-%28(l $'& mGr I3<=>m9D)3 (A=>5CJl-3r 3 { s3<ndlWm9no46m9n3 `V5(Hl-3k=>5)5(.r: -3UJf§2 Iq1l-3 ns =s463
V `)cnf3 F28Jek463V5(2+J3<l-5*7m;rl-3 (A5B49465 m6nFp
&
+*-,.0/213.547698:; >< =%?@BA+C<!) -.+
-"7 = -" "$
13'-- "$
13'D@ . - 5FE*%&'-<-M<!&.
5;:15#H 4-.'!5 "$
"$6*.
2C6'-.
5C"$
13'-2C!&
-" "$
13'-5C8!1:,O
I ? M.7 *%
135.<!.
-"D6JKLH M)I -MON <!<-5 )6
-4%2
35< *
* O
6
+G
P
*
G
k'28=2?J3<l3<=
kF=>3?:E5CnIm9l>m65Cn%r
k%5zr@l:X5BnIm9l>m95Bn
:X5Bn%r l>=2?m6ndlr
kF=>5)5(r: -3UJf2
h#(A5C=>JRs4G2*+ 1
$ hr@3Ul5('(A5C=>JRs4G2Cr
& 0$
)
0$
&
O
O
MO@
= C7MO@
BO
<#" N% $&A$('A
<9I * A
? MO@
<
!
? @
?
=
?
?
Fk =>5d:E3ds=>3
r@lN28n2?=ar>:-3<Jf2,+ m9nIl3<=>k=3<l>3U=
/-3?r 37J3Ul-5*rImfeH3<=1Jf28m9n46q (A=>5CJ l-5)r 3m6n i.- m6nZl-'28lol-3Rl2B:Xl>mG:Rr@495Bl1mGrM=3<k4G2C:E35IqZ2
d3?:E4G2?=2?l>m6D)31k=5)5(r: -F3<Jf6
2 CGIFo2 kF=>5d:E3ds=>3Tm6ndl>3<=k=>3<lm6npTl-m;rcr: -F3<Jf2 0/ /-3om9nIl3<nIlm65Cn6%3
-m6n
l-mGr.Ifm e"3U=>3<n%:X3MmGrl5+3<n%2 F4631=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m95Bn%r5(PJ3<l-F5*r /
J3<l-F5*7mGr GXFX[L FS%m (+IpCm6D)3<nfk=3 13254B+Il-3<nbl-31J3<l-5*7qdm63<4 r27:X5B=>=3?:Elk=>5)5(5(k%5)r ,l 13254
m9n:U2Br@3Vl-F3M:E5Cn%r@l=2?m6ndlr28=3Mr28l>m;r l%3 / _ 5B=D)3<=>m (AqIm9np12M46m9n3 m6l-21:<2?4645(P28ne28sl5BJf2?l>3+l-F3<5B=3<J
kF=>5?D)3<=
+d3 / p /76 98+H2ol>m6Je3c49m6Jm9l&m;rr@3<ll57kF=>5?D)3Ml-F3or 3 { s3<ndl /
0)m6n':E31Jf28l-3<Jf2?l>mG:U284%k=>5)5(_rM28=3+:E5Cn%r@l=>s%:Xl>3fl>5Bk I5 nZ28n
%5Bl>l5BJysk *+ 3+:X5Bn%r mI3<= '2B;: :<+
28=B
CGIF (A5B|= 28=Bur 3?28=N: -em6nk=5)5(Pk4G2?nnm9npR28n:IF3 l%n3k4G2?nnm6nFp+5Bk%3<=2?l>5C=rl>D
5 %312?n =( + J3Ul-5*
5C=
2 + Je3<l-5* =3?r@k%3?:Elm6D)3<49q / V n k4;28nnm9np+9=( + J3Ul-5*ropC3<lRl-3<m9=+k=>3S:E5Bndm6l>m95Bn%r+2Cr m9nksle28n
k%5zr@l:X5BnIm9l>m95Bn%r+2Cr5BsFl>kslW2 +_J3<l-F5*
r 5B>= :[=>3<D)3U=r@3U46q / 3? / =( +28n
@+ J3Ul-5*r m946W4 %3l=>3?2?l>3
dm eH3<=>3UnIl46/
q Iql-3T28n%2?465CpBqfk=>5d:X3Is=3 /
V5)284;ro2?n 2Brr@sJekl>m95Bn%rT28=>3er@3 { s3UnIlNr+.28nY2 E3X -PE*N}CGIKm;r2 (A5B=3?r@l / 8&2C: -Yk%28l- m6nY2ul=>3<3
:X5Bn%r mGr@lNr5(r@3 { s3UnIln5*d3?rc2?nuJe3<l-5*n5*d3?rl-%28lr>2?l>m;r7(Aql-6
3 NfHJI)~ GIG HPSmHGI+l-%2?lMr2<qrl-%2?lM2
Je3<l-5*n5*dA
3 2 (A5B46495 Vr27r 3 { sF3<nIln5*IC
3 B2?nk=>3?:X3I3?rl-3Tr@3 { s3<ndln5*d3?Dr B ooo B m (
BEGF
1AkL5zr@Hl 13254I428nJ F
1Ak=>K3 13254I4 LMB o7oo B (A5C=V27r ^s %r@lm6lsl>m95Bn F 5(k%2?=28Je3<l>3<=Nr /
r m6l- 2 pC5)2?N
4 B 28n2Brr@sJekl>m95Bn%G
r 13O & 4B+ ,-3<=3 2?=>3Zk=>5)5=( +
=>5)5(RkF4G28nFnm6np r l28=l
2Cr>r sJklm65Bn'r+12 dm65CJfr+.IQ3 l%nm6lm65Cn%r+V5B=f463<JeJ2Cr / /-3xkF=>5)5(RkF4G28nFnm6np k=5d:E3<3Fd
r dq m9n%r@3U=>l>m9np
Je3<l-5*FrW2?n+r@3 { s3<ndlVr h @+ J3Ul-5* (A5B46495 VrW2cpC5)2?4%28noqdm63U4r"n73 P1 r ^s Q4 pC5)2?4Gr,2CrWm6lNrWr s%:<:E3?rr@5C=r /
Vn==( +_J3<l-F5*uk=3?:E3I3Src2Cr>r@sFJkl>m95Bn%rV28nbqIm93<4r2Rn3 k=3?:E3dm6npe2Brr@sJkFl>m65Cn / 4G28nFnm6npe28m9Jfr
2?l=>3ds%:Em6nFpl-3Mpz28
k %3<l 3<3<nR463S2(hpC5)2?4Gr28nu2Cr>r sJklm65Bn'r / j 3S2(PpB5)2?4Grl-%2?lV28=>3n5Bl3 { s'284"l5+2?n
2Cr>r sJklm65Bna2?=>3T:<2849463 FE*LQIRK CN T / Mrr@5)5Cn[2BrV2opB5z28R4 B 3 { s%2?4Gr2?na2Br>r sJklm65Cn +Il-31l 5on5*d3?r
:X5B464;28k%r 3 / /-F3<G
n B m;rcn5495BnpC3<=28nZ5Bk%3<n[pB5z28W4 Fs
l T7CS\HT=SL / /-3+kF4G28nFnm6npel>3<=Jm6n%2?l>3?rm (l-F3<=>3
/
2?=>3Tn575Ck%3<nfpB5)2?4Gr
/-3Vr@5Cs=:X3ck=5)5=( +_k4G2?n%r2?=>3Vl>=3<3?!r m9l-Rl-3Vr 5Bs=N:E3ckF=>5 F463<J 28ll-3=5)5Bl+ m6l-+n5o5Ck%3<n7pC5)2?4Gr+
2?n>
m9l- :X5B=>=3?:ElTJ3<l-F5*r / /-F3b2?n%28495BpCq k=>5d:X3Is=3us'r@3?6
r NfHJI*LCGXFHUTL7k=5)5=( +_k4G2?n%r+5B=d3<=>3x
dq
l-3Zr@3 { s3Un%:E3fm6n ,-mG:- l-3bn5*d3?r -%2<D)M
3 %3<3<n 24I3 l>5 l-3bk4;28n / Mr+m6n - >s%r l>fm lH:<28lm65Cn
r l>=s%:El>sF=>3?r+s%r@3 l>5Y3<n%:E5*I3 >s%r@lm lH:U28l>m95Bn%r<(A5B=Rl-F3 I3?:XmGr@m95Bn Jf2 I3%+28nn5Cl2?l>3[l-F3bk4;28n nF5*I3?r /
/-F3?r@(
3 V TQSmH S [CSmHGIzT:<2?kl>sF=>3ol-3+r ^s pC5)2849m6npKr@l>=s%:Els=>3T5(27kF4G28n\28nbk%5Cm6ndlcl5=>3?2Cr@5Cn%r (A5B=l-3
:-5CmG:E3%+dr s%: -K2Br28kFk46m;:<28lm65BnK:E5Bndm6l>m95Bn%r5(P2oJ3Ul-5* +)s%r 3<W= +_pBm9D)3<npCsm2?n%:E3%+d5B=k=>X3 +_k=5BpB=N28JJe3
:X5Bndl>=>5CR4 :InF5 493IpC3 / /-3T:E5B==>3?:Xl>n3?rr5(2oJe3<l-5*m;r5Bn315(Ol-3 >s%r l>m lL:<28lm65Bn'r /
Y L GXQAGNfCSmHGIGT128=3Jf2?kkm6nFp)Nr Z[5(12fk=>5)5=( + kF4G28n l>5\2bk=>5)5=( + k4;28n ,-m;: -Zs%r@s'284649q%W+ slTn5Bl
nF3?:E3?rr>28=m649q%+&kF=>3?r 3<=>D)3fl-F3b:X5B=>=3?:Eln3?r>r+5({J3<l-F5*rom6n l-3ak4G2?n / /-3<qY3<n%:E5*I3aJf28l-3<Jf2?l>m;:<284
\\[]I^ 2C
a_ H
C
C
_ H
%(. &-M<!1 O <O )6*
..
&-L -1%.)O
D.-* +1
3*
)<
. #.91:.<-.9
- .9M#;).*,-6" #1
1
.
86*.
.7 #;).*,! 5 #1
KO
C
3H
JKLH
b
9H
;`
C
,-
-F3<s=>m;r@lmG:<r5Bn -5 27k=5)5(=+_k4G2?n :-%28npC3?r.I3<k%3<nI3UnIlM5CnZ:E3<=l28m9n[:-%28nFpB3?rc5(l-3Tk=>5
463<J l56%3
kF=>5?D)3 / 3(A5B=J7s4;28lm65Bn'r&Jf2<qm9n%r@3<=lMr s^k4;28n%r5B==>3<k4;2B:E31J3Ul-5*rV28nbJf2<q:-%28nFpB3oJe3<l-5*Fr+
r 3 { s3<ndlr+%2?n
>s'r@l>fm lH:<2?l>m65Cn%r5(Pk4;28nbnF5*I3?r /
33&m;r,28kFk46m93 m9n+l-373 2?Jk463 %3<465 / V l,m;r28k +
_ 5B=,3 F28Jek463%+?l-F3=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m65Cn
kF46mG:U2 493m (L2 (AsFn%:El>m95B
n Km;rtl$
5 L3JK28kk%31l>512 (AsFn%:El>m95B
n + ,-3<=3V28=pBsJ3UnIlNr - 5
( e28=>3JK28kk%3
l
5 Z28=pBsJ3UnIlNr5
( 2 (A5B=1m9n%r@lN28n%:E3C+tm (l-3 (Asn%:Elm65Cn ( ( - l-%28l1lM2 :)3?r12Br128=pBsJe3<nIlNrcl 5f=>3S284
nds/
J %3<=&r - 28n=>3Ul>s=n%r&l-3M=>3S284"m9nIl3<=>DC2?4 - - -%2Crl>D
5 %3MJf2?kk%37l5R2(Asn%:Elm65Bn ( ( ( ( l-%28llM2 :)3?r2Br2?=>pCsJ3<ndlr#(A5BsF==>3S284nds/
J L3U="r - ( 2?n7=>3Ul>s=n%r28nm9nIl3<=>DC28L4 - ( - m9
n +
l-3<n **m;rM28kFk46m;:<2 493 / /-3+k=>5d:X3Is=3 *
*1=>3<kF4G2B:X3?rcl-F3<(Asn%:Elm65B
n dq[l-F3 (Asn%:Elm65C
n !m9l-!IsFk46m;:<28l3 1 m / 3 / + u`4128=pBsJe3<nIlNrcm6nYpB5)2?4Gr+,2Brr@sJekl>m95Bn%r^+ >s%r l>m lL:<2 +
lm65Cn%r+%2?nJ3<l-F5*r / Vl284;r@5+qdm63<4 r2 Im6lm65Cn%284H=>3<4;28l>3: -'28npC3?rm6nl-3Mk=5)5(r: -F3<Jf2c5(,F3 eH3?:Xl>3
Je3<l-5*Fr&r s%:-f2Br=>3<k4;2B:Em9npT:E3<=l28m9nr ^s ?(A5C=>JRs4G2Cr dqR:E5Cn >sn%:Elm65Cn%r28n dsk46m;:<28lm6npT:E3U=>l2?m6nR46m9n3?r
5(Ml-3k=5)5(Tr: -F3<Jf6
2 ,-mG:-ZJf2<qZ284Gr 5Z:<28s'r@3l-3 Isk49mG:<2?l>m65Cnx5(M=3<4G2?l>3Zk=>3?:X5BnIm9l>m95Bn%r15(l-3
Je3<l-5* 1 r 3<
3 ! M- (A5B=1J5C=>3 I3Ul28m94G;r 4 / V (V2J3<l-5* rVk=>3?:X5BnIm9l>m95B
n xL3S:<28J3 Isk49mG:<2?l>33+"l-3Un
3G3J5*Ifm l%3?rol-3ar@l>=s%:Els=>3a5(1l-3bk=5)5=( +_k4G2?
n Iq Isk49mG:<2?l>m6nFpxl-3ar@^s kF4G28n^l-%28l
qdm63U4rl-31pB5)2?4 S2Br>r sJklm65C
n um9nul-315B=m6pBm9n%284hkF=>5)5=( +_k4;28n /
+ ,-3Un
GmGr2?kk49m63+l>5+Jf2?k7l-3 (Asn':El>m95B
n ( ( - l>5Tl-3 (AsFn%:El>m95Bn
_ 5B=73 2?Jk463C
( ( ( ( - +d2+k=>5)5=( + r: -F3<Jf2o46m9n3
4
O
l57l-3146m9n3
2?nb2+46m9n3
l5
O
E
E
(E
01 - 4
&- "!$#&%0 ! * (E
E
E
X1
-4
-4 4
O
&- ' ()# *! #+%@ ! ** # 1 1
-4 &, -, , , ( -%. - / (
01
-- - 0 (
13254768479:47;&47<>=@?@A
=CBD6E/9E/;FEG<IHKJL6NM?@A =CBO6EG9EG;PEG<QHKJL;RMTS&U0=CBO6EG9EG;PEG<IHKJL9VMTS&U =WBD6E/9E/;FEG<IHXJL<RJ
8,D)3<n
m (1m6lRJm6p -IlRr 3<3<J l-'28l 3362Cr I3?r m6pBnF3 3F2B:El46q (A5C=l-3ZYc3<m9n3X+ 5B=>3U4
372?Jk463T3dk4G2?m6n3fm6n I3<lN28m64.4G2?l>3<=+h5B=1l-%2?l1l-m;rck%28=l>m;:Es4G2?=M3F28JkF4632Br1:-5)r 3<nZ2B:<:X5B=dm6npfl>5
l-3R=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m65Cn +%l-m;r{m;D
r I Sl-3R:U2Br@3 / 331k=>5?D)3bl5 %3e2 (_28m6=46q8(A=>3 { s3<ndl128n
pC3<n3<=N284d=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m95Bn1l-%2?l'-%2C!r %3<3<nos'r@31m6n+r 3<D)3<=N284)3 F28JkF463?rH28n
2Br'I5d:XsJ3<ndl>3Vm6n PM+ b - /
2b5C=>3<5?D)3<=+Il-31k%28=l>mG:Xs4G2?[= Yc3<m6nFX3 + 5C=>3<4%3 F28Jek46B3 2Crc:-5)r 3<nfm6nd3<k%3<nI3<ndl>49q7m9n ` - /
&
&
&
& $
&
&(."F\ "^]& # L
V
")# I t"
/-F3upC3<n3<=N284mI3?2f5(2?n%28495BpBq+7I=>m9D)3<n k=>5)5(=+ k4;28n :E5Cn%r@l=>s%:Elm65Cn m;rl5bs%r 3ul-349m6n3?2?=>m *<3[r@5Cs=:X3
kF=>5)5(=+_k4;28n2Br+2bpCsmd3 (A5C=R:E5Bn'r@l>=s%:Elm6npZ2?n 2?n%28495BpC5Bs%r7lN28=pB3<l+k=5)5(=+_k4G2?n +l5[=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>3Rl-3
r 5Bs=N:E3Vk4G2?n +d28n+l>5Ml=2?n%r7(A3<=J3Ul-5*r+BpB5z284;r+d28nR2Brr@sJekl>m95Bn%r,5(Q2M=>3(A5B=>JRs4;28l>3or@5Cs=:X3k=>5)5(=+
kF4G28n[l5l-F3ol2?=>pC3<lckF=>5)5=( +_k4;28n / /-3g28n%2?465CpBq +0I=m6D)3<n[kF=>5)5=( +_k4;28nZ:E5Cn%r@l=>s%:Elm65Cn[mGrV2 I3<=m6DC28lm65Bn'284
2?n%28495BpCq%+ ,-m;: - -%2Br,n5Cql L3U3<n+s%r@3(A5B=l-3U5B=>3UJk=58Ddm6nF
p %3(A5B=3%+B3 dl>3<nI3
dq=3(A5B=J7sF4G28lm65Cn+28n
FmIm9=>3?:Elm65Cn%284Hk4G2?nnm6nFp /
scs=m6np[l-3f28n'28465CpBm;:<284l=28n'r7(A3<=+m9lomGr+:-3?;: :)3M
,-3Ul-3<=Tl-g
3 >s%r l>fm lH:<28lm65Cn%r (A=5BJ l-3fr@5Cs=:X3
nF5*I3<-5C4 (A5B=l-F3o:X5B=>=3?r@k%5CnIm6nFpn5*I31m6nfl-31l28=pB3<l+3 / p / ,-3<l-3<=l-F3o2?kk49mG:<2?l>m65Cna:E5Bndm6l>m95Bn%r
5(12bJe3<l-5*1-5B4 m9n l-F3l2?=>pB3Ul /(_ -F3?: :dm6nFpbl-F$
3 >s%r@lm lH:U28l>m95Bn%roJK.2 :)3?rMm6lTk%5)r>r Pm 493fl>5Z:E5Cn%r@m I3<=
X: 5Bndl>=>5C4Wm9n?(A5B=Jf28lm65Cnul-%28lmGrn5Cl12<DB2?m64;2493m9nbl-3Tr@5BsF=:E3g28nblN28=>pC3<lVk=>5
463<JKr+^slV=>3U463<DC28ndll>5
l-31k=>5)5(k=>5d:E3Sr>r /
/-32?n%28495BpC<q +7I=>m9D)3<nokF=>5)5=( +_k4;28ne:E5Bn%r l>=s%:El>m95BnT3<Jk4958qFr"=>3(A5B=>JRs4;28l>m95Bn%r"l-%28lP28m9J 28l,Jf2?l:-m6nFp
2er@5BsF=:E3TpB5)2?W4 m6l-a27l2?=>pB3UlcpC5)284P5B=2BrcJf2?nIqRk=3?:E5BnIm6lm65Bn'r5(2r@5Cs=:X3=( +_J3<l-F5*d
m9l-al28=pB3<l
2Cr>r sJklm65Bn'r=>3Sr@k%3?:Elm6D)3<49q / /-3?r 37=3(A5B=J7sF4G28lm65Cn%rM:-%28npC3l-F37k=5)5=( +_k4G2?n / W2 463 bbr0-5 Vrol-3
l5Bk +_463UD)3<4%k=>5d:E3Is=>35(.l-F3128n%2?465CpBq +0I=m6D)3<nek=>5)5=( + k4;28na:E5Cn%r@l=>s%:Elm65Cn / Vm6D)3<ne249m6n3?2?=>m *<3+r@5Cs=:X3
kF=>5)5=( +_k4;28n +,lN28=>pC3<l+2Cr>r sJklm65Bn'r+.28nY2ul2?=>pC3<l1pB5)2?4D+.l-3R5BslkslT5(l-3Rk=>5d:E3Is=>3RmGr12fl28=pB3<l
kF=>5)5=( +_k4;28n /
m9nks^l h&49m6n3S28=>m *<3Rr@5Cs=:E31k4;28n R+ 1A5Bk%3<Qn 4l2?=>pC3<lcpC5)2?4D+%:E5Cn l3I3<n':E31463<D)3<4 +
5Csl>kFsl h1 49m6n3?2?=>m *<3 4Pl28=pB3<lkF4G28n
/ / !:0.0+ l-3<=>3T2?=>315Bk%3<nal28=pB3<lVpB5z284;r 1&(
` / : r 5Bs=N:E31k4G2?num;r3 *-%28s%r l>33+ 8!+, %2Cr@X3 +_463UD)3<4"k4;28n (A5B=Vl-F35Ck%3<nbpC5)284;r /
/ V3<l,n3 dlr 3 { sF3<nIl (A=>5CJ r@5Cs=:E3kF4G28n / /-3Vr@3 { s3<ndl,m;rW3<m6l-3<=2?n2Cr>r sJklm65Bn+5C=2{pC5)2?4 /
: um;r28n\2Br>r sJklm65Cn + 8&+, pB5Rl>5 /
/ : l-F3<=>3VmGr2=>3(A5B=>JRs4;28l>m95BAn Z+Fr@s%:-7l-%28l Z KJK28l:-3?rP28n5CkL3UnulN28=pB3<lpB5)2?4 (A5B= ,-mG:l-3 >s%r l>fm lH:<28lm65Cn%r/-5B4 + 8&+,
n Iq Zf2?nul=28n'r7(A3<§= l57l-31l2?=>pB3Ulck4;28n /
=>3(A5B=>JRs4;28l>3r@5Cs=:X3kF4G28l +_J3<l-5* 2 /
0)3<493?:El9(A=>5BJ|l-31=>3(A5B=>JRs4;28l>37r 5Bs=N:E3ol-31=>3<493<DC28nd§
= 2 l5ol-F3Ml2?=>pB3Ulk4;28n
_ -3?;: : 2x *r >s%r l>fm lH:<28lm65Cn%r / : l-F3<q -5B4 + 8 !+, l>=N28n%rD(A3<9
28nusk32?l>3o5Ck%3<nbpC5)284;r /
: >s'r@l>fm lH:<2?l>m65Cn I5)3?rn5Bl.-5B4 + 8&+, : -5)5zr@3Tr@sFm6l2 463T2C:El>m95Bn h
( 2$mGr=3IsnF28ndl
+
IDC28n%:X3l-3Tr@5Cs=:E31m t=ql>5R3?r@lN2 49mGr0-ul-3 >s%r@lm lH:U28l>m95Bn%r+5B=
2Br@03 + 493<D)3<4%k4G2?n /
/ 0)3<493?:El (A=5BJ l-31=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>3Rr@5Cs=:X3l-31=>3<493<DC28ndl =( +_J3<l-5* 2 /
b / : l-3U=>3om;rc2R=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m65Cn Z 463(AlMr s%: -al-%2?l + ! ! *^ 1 Z 254^t +$28nbl-%28l >s%r@lm lH:<,2 +
l>m95Bn%r/-5C4 (A5B=Vl-F3JK28l:-3+l2?=>pC3<lM2Cr>r sJklm65Bn'r 8!+,
n d
q 1@%3?r@0l 4
ZF%2?n46m9n :+l-3VJf2?l:-3+l28=pB3<l2Brr@sJ@k +
=>3(A5B=>JRs4;28l>3Vr 5Bs=N:E3Mk4;286
l>m95Bn%rl5r 5Bs=N:E31k4G2?n /
r >s%r l>m lL:<28lm65Bn'r /
_ -3?;: : 2x : >s'r@l>fm lH:<2?l>m65Cn I5)3?rn5Bl.-5B4 + 8&+, : -5)5zr@3Tr@sFm6l2 463T2C:El>m95Bna2BrV2 %5?D)3 /
.2 49
3 bh 6 sl46m9n3M5(Ol-3T28n'28465CpBq +0d=>m6D)3UnukF=>5)5=( +_k4;28nZ:E5Cn%r@l=>s%:Elm65Cn
&
)0 l>3Ukum;rc=>3U463<DC28ndl,(A5B=T27k4;28nn3U= m9l-5%2C: :2?=[r 3?28=N: -[5Cn46q-,-3<=>3S2Br1r@l3<k f28n b28kFk46q
l5xl-3fl>=3?28lJ3<ndl5( (A5C=|28= k4G2?nnm9np / /-3fl55F=28n': -3Sr ImeH3<=+Jf2?m6n49q[m6n l-%28l ZY28m6JKro28l
JK28l:-m9npZ2xr 5Bs=N:E3bpC5)2?4cl5x5Cn3blN28=>pC3<lRpB5)2?4D+,-3<=3?2BrAZF2?m6JfrT28lRJf28lN: -Fm6npZ2Cr Jf2?nIqYr@5Cs=:X3
2Cr>r sJklm65Bn'r2Brk%5zr>r@m 463l>5olN28=pB3<lV2Cr>r@sFJkl>m95Bn%r / + ! ! *^ 1 ZF 254Gt +)+ J3?2?n%r,l-%2?l493?r>rl-%2?n
+ k=3?:E5CnIm6lm65Cn%rM5(l-3e:Es==>3<ndl>49qbl>=3?28l3x=3(A5B=J7s4;28l3 =( +_J3<l-5* 2 d5bn5Cl+Jf28lN: -Z2fl28=pB3<l
2Cr>r sJklm65Bn / /-3ar@3 { s3<ndlro5/
( ADHT[T7HJIK1 ZF254$%3?:E5CJ3n73 5CkL3Un pB5z284;r m (( ZFmGrT28n 2B:<:E3Ukl2 463
=3(A5B=J7sF4G28lm65Cn / + mGrM27kF=>5d:E3ds=>3+k%2?=2?J3<l>3U= ,-mG:-bm9nImG:U28l>3Srl-3+:E5Cn l3I3Un%:E3om9nZ28nZ2?n%28495BpBm;:<284
l=2?n%r7(A3<= I3?r km6l31JmGrr@m6nFplN28=pB3<lV463<JeJf2Br /
/-
3 l%=r lcpC5)2?4D+s%r s%284946ql-3Tr@5BsF=:E3Tk=>
5 463<J +m;r: -5zr@3<n / V@( :<28
n %3o=3(A5B=J7sF4G28l3D
Iqf2
Zer@s': -l-%28lm9lJf28lN: -3SrOl-3MlN28=>pC3<lk=5 493<J +dl-3<n ZDm646*4 %3T28kkF46m63 l5+l-A3 1_:Es==>3<ndXl 4Pr@5Cs=:X3
`
808
94 ;
-"D)*
6..
!"
$
-
3
12!*
i
*&-M-1)6.
C
kF4G28n 28n[l-3RJ3<l-5* 2 m9l-Zk%5)r@lH13254 LZ m;r12u:U28nIm 28l3 (A5C=ol-3+l>=N28n%rD(A3<=ol5ul-3Rl28=pB3<l
kF4G28n / V (l-375C=>m9pBm6n'2843>s%r@lmlH:U28l>m95Bn%r -5C4 (A5B= 2 m6n[l-3Rl28=pB3<l+Wl-3<n 2 mGrMl=28n'r7(A3<==>3Z28nZl-3
5Ck%3<nxpC5)2?4Gr128=3+sk328l3 dqb=3<J5?Ddm6np+k%5)r l,1 254M2?nbm6ndl>=5*Is%:Em9npf2?464r 3 { sF3<nIlNr (A=5BJyk=>31 254V2Br
5Ck%3<n[pB5z284Gr / /-F3ok=5d:E3Is=31mGr=>3UkL3S28l>3um (Pl-F3<=>312?=>3T5Bk%3<nbpC5)2?4GrV28nfm (Or@5BJe3or 5Bs=N:E31k4G2?nbn5*d3
-'2Brn5BlVq)3<§l %3<3UnbDdmGr@m9l>3 /
(Al>3U=cl-3+=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m95Bn +Ifm eH3<=>3<ndl12C:El>m95Bn%rM:U28
n L3+lN.2 :)3<n;+"m (
2 >s%r l>fm lH:<28lm65Cn%rI5)3?rcn5Cl-5B4 /
(A5C9= 2 m6nRl-3Vl2?=>pB3Ul /-32B:Elm65Cn%r9I3<k%3<n75Cn7l-3 :Im9n 5(.DIm95B4;28l>3 >s%r@lm lH:<2?l>m95Bn / _ 5B=m9n%r@lN28n%:E3C+I2
=3(A5B=J7sF4G28l3MJ3<l-5*MJm6p -IlHn5BWl %3:E5B==>3?:E&l %3?:<2?s%r@3=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m65Cn%r I5Vn5BlPn3?:E3?rr>2?=>m649qMk=3?r@3<=D)3
:X5B=>=3?:Eln3?r>r / V (Pl-3T:E5C=>=3?:El>nF3?r>3r +f>s%r l>fm lH:<28lm65Cn d5)3?rnF5Bl.-5B4 (A5B= 25+Il-3<nfl-F3ok=5d:E3Is=31l>=>m93?rl>5
A?G
H 2 l5R27:E5C=>=3?:ElJe3<l-5* 2x / 6 n31k%5)rr@m 4631J5*Ifm lH:<2?l>m65Cnl>3S: -nFm { s3 d3?:E5BJekL5zr@3?9r 2wr@s': l-%28l21:E5B==>3?:El T d}@J3<l-5*A
2x)=>3?r s46lN!r m6l-7k%5zr@,l 1 254 k%5)r ,l 132x4P28n 2xC=>3<k4;2B:E3S
r 2 :E=3?28lm6npT2?n
/
2 Im9l>m65Cn%284%5CkL3UnpB5z284 V (Q2Mk=>3S:E5Bndm6l>m95BnR5( 2 d5)3?r&n5Cl9-5B4 m9n7l-3l2?=>pB3Ul
+Il-3<n+m9l:U28/
n L3JK24I3
2?nx5Ck%3<n[pB5z284,l-%28l -'2BrMl>6
5 %3+k=5?D)36
Iq %2Br X3 + 493<D)3<4hk4;28nnFm6np+"m / 3 / +dk4G2?nnm6nF6
p m6l-5BslpBsm 28n%:X3
dqe28n%2?465BpCq / Mr&m9n =>5*Im9pBq 7cn%2?465CpBqa28n5Cl-3U=2B:Xl>m65CnfmGr&lN.
2 :)3<nem (.l-F31:Es==>3<ndlpB5)2?4hmGrr>28lmGmr l%3m6n
/
l-31l2?=>pB3UlM2?46=>3S24Iq /-F3<
n 2 m;rr@sk%3<= b%s5Bs'rcm6nfl-F3lN28=pB3<l28nf:<2?M
n %3TWr :dm6kk%3 /
k>-3<nZ2?464,J3Ul-5*r5(l-3Rr 5Bs=N:E3+k4;28n -%2<D)D
3 %3<3<n[DdmGr m6l>3 +Ll-3<n[l-3+=>3<JK28m6nFm6npR5Bk%3<n[pC5)284;r
-'2SD)31lR
5 %31k=>5?D)3/
I6
q '2Br@03 + 493<D)3<4"kF4G28nFnm6np /
t5Ym64649s%r@l=2?l>3[l-F3[k=>5d:E3Is=>5
3 3b3 dk4;28m6n2Y: -%2?46493<npBm9np 3 F28Jek463fn3 dl / /-FmGr3 F28Jk493fmGr
kF=>3?r 3<nIl3m6n ! ,- m9l-a28494 I3<l2?m64;r /
4
!
FE*LQI6TL[S T
&
&#"%$ %& |*g
!
- GXZLON->
LQHJIL

d}
_} -
C FN TL MHJISLQXQ]CN C I HPSL T 7CGD
^
A HPN
%
HT
G]LQXZLf}
%
C 7CGADHPN
, i?Hji G]LQX|T
_ 5B=>JK2846m *<3 h#%$'&(M)*&(M+$',-) EC4/. =0.1&2436587:9<;
==.NJ^JE+B>$E8) H/?A@B2'C
2+DFE==EHGI2MAKJ;KJ UL9 =0E JM BM$E ) H?A@E J
ONKN =3<DdmG28l3 h$'&
P LZHJIL- GXZL[N- Q UCQN TL6XZL QSmCGIK
NPLPC _} _ - 3 HT G]LZXZL+} C 7CGADHPN
% FE*LQIdTL[SJT \HJI qSGi*LQI5S i*LQX[L$HTgC S I?HPSL$T I} 7CGADHPN R % , i?Hji G]LQX|T C _} _ - ( MST&+
( MSUV&+
( MS$,AF) MSTW,AU EW4/. ==.X&2Y3Z5 7[9<
; ==[. J JE+BM$ E ) E8T EU H:?
_ 5B=>JK2846m *<3 h#%$&+( MS)*&
@B2'C 2DF
E ==E\GI
2 MTA/J;K@J UL89 ==E JM'BM$ E ) E8T EU H:?A@E J /
ONKN=3<DdmG28l3 h$ )& r -F5^V] rl-3[k=>5)5(=+ kF4G28n (A5B='Y `_ ,] -mG:- +m6n (_2C:El
+qdm63<4 r72 k=5)5(g5(Y `_ ,] -3Un
_ m6pCs=>3`
/
3%Ia 3?:Xsl>3 /-F3 Im9pBm6lN284P28nnF5Bl2?l>m95Bn%rM5(l-3oJ3Ul-5*rm6nImG:<2?l>31l-F3o5B=BI3<=Mm9n,] -m;: -al-3TJ3<l-5*r
-'2SD)3'%N 3<3<nfm9nIl=>5*Is%:X3m6ndl>5+l-F3kF=>5)5(=+_k4;28n /
6 n35(%m9lr
1 :X5B=>=3?:El04%J3<l-F5*r"mGrhJ3<l-5*<+ _b_b_ +^,] -F3<=>3l-3=>3U4G28lm65Cn%r
! * ! [ * #+%0 ! * dc %e
-'2SD)3l-3,5bdN Ddm65Bs'r"J3?28nFm6npzr 1 l'nm6l3%+<5Bk%3<n +C:E495)r@3<+ m9nIl3<=>DC2?4D+?:E5?D)3<=Nr+<r sK%N r 3<lX4Q28nMl-3'(Asn%:Elm65Bn{r@qdJ +
N%5C4Gr/ % ( ( - 2?=>3fm6ndl>3U=>k=3<l>3Z2Bro=m6p -Il + Jf2?=>pCm6n+_5(+,493(AlW+_Jf28=pBm9n+ 5(+Wm9nIl3<=>DC284+"] m9l-+_skk%3<= +
2?n<+_465f] 3U=W+LLN 5Csn +Q28nsnm95Bn +=3?r@k%3?:Xl>m6D)3U46q / j 28n j I3Un5Bl3kF=>5)5(2Cr>r@sFJkl>m95Bn%r(1A463<JeJf2Br;4 /
Lgi
h *M6
%L M
-"DM
-",! 135 &-Mh M/M
-"D%
!" % )<-.D<9G#C ;7A
!" ,-
\HJI
i
Gi
9S
S *LQI5S *LQXZLiHTDC
PC _} - "!
&
&
G
86135< 2!;O
P
HB1
i
refutation
1
method
goal/assumption
∆ , -Th |- false
method-0
6
∆, -Th |- F2
method-2
L6
...
5
∆ ,-Th |- F1
Nit1
L17
method-1
4
∆ ,-Th |- F3
L17
L2
method-11
CIA
method-111
L4
m6pCs=>3g` Dh /-3ok=5)5(=+_k4G2?nb5(VY `_ ]m6l-a28nn5Cl2?l>3fJ3<l-F5*7n5*I3?r
&
£££
k'28=2?J3<l3<=
kF=>3?:E5CnIm9l>m65Cn%r
k%5zr@l:X5BnIm9l>m95Bn
:X5Bn%r l>=2?m6ndlr
kF=>5)5(r: -3UJf2

j
%
+j
10$ #+%0 ! * * % (
(
! * ! [
4
&
h _h _
?h _h
?h _h2< A
)
?!"2< # A
$
M&%('*) ? M,+- <-/.10 _234#5F<-A _ 3678-A
?:2 < A,;<2 < A
9 =
? == MA%(' ?? @# @67,0
H =
=
=
=
<#_ N C HA 2A
< #N * " ) A
< NC C A
< A
<= N,> * " C
2A
< A
<#_ I+C ) C C 9 C ? A
?
BO
BO
O
O
I O
O
@
@
@
<
C
C
@
C
+
?
I
B
?
r>:-3<Jf2,+ m9nIl3<=>kF=>3<l3<=
kF=>5d:E3ds=>3
B
B
C
@ C
MI
J6O
?
C
@
O
&: 2
L5
2
L3
BDCFE HG
IA
3
∆ ,-Th |- F4
_
L1
I
JILK MG &NHE
"
&9 ^2"
VJ5Bnp[l-3493<JJf2Cr j _ oo7o j _ + ncm6l _ + _ V- +WV+ s%r 3 m6n l-3fk=>5)5(15( Y `_ +r@3UD)3<=2?4463UJJ2Cr+
n'28J3<49q j _ + j `?+ j b?+ j i + j _ ?+ j _ `?+ j _ + j _ + j _ 2? =>3[k%5Bl3<nIlmG2?4c493<JJf2Cr (A5B= Y `x2Cr ]3<494
N%3?:U28s%r 3+l-3<qa:E5CnIlN28m9n[5Bn49qbr qIJ+N%5B4;rn5Cl1r@k%3?:XmlH: (A5B= / + m;rcr 3<lMl5f274G2?=>pC3ondsJN%3<=SN%3?:U28s%r 3
JK28ndq7493<JJf2Cr&2?=>31Jm;r>r@m9np(A5C[= Y ` /
/-3V:-5Bm;:E35(hl-F3=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m65Cn%rhmGr,2Cr>r@m;r@l3
NIqg2Ms%r@3<= + r skk49m63+:X5Bnn3S:El>m95Bn+_l2fN463 +f],-m;: :X5Bndl28m9n%r:X5Bnn3S:El>m95Bn%rW5(.l-93 :dm6nr%+ 1 ++ + - +B+ +B+ +B+ + - 4+ 1C#+%@ ! ** #+%@ G #Z;4 / 1CYV3<=>
3 ++ + - 2?n
+B+ +B+ +B+ + - 28=3
&
&
PO3Q
&
b
O*Q
82 n - ( - ( - 4 / [=3?r@l=>mG:Xlrcl-3r 3?28=N: - (A5B=
=3(A5B=J7sF4G28lm65Cn%rW2?n7=3Is%:E3SrWl-3ndsJ+N%3<=h5(Qk%28=N28J3<l3<=r.l-%2?l -'2SD)3l>5'N%3cm9n%r@lN28ndl>m;28l>3ol>5'N%3M2fN463
l57kF=>5?D)3Tr@spCpB3?r l>3fl28=pB3<l493<JJf2Cr2(Al>3U=l-3T28n'28465CpBqfk=5d:E3Is=3 /
/-3Zr@5Cs=:X3[k=>5)5(=+ k4;28nmGr7=3(A5B=J7sF4G28l3 r@l3<[k ]m;r@3\28465Cnp ]m6l-^2 r@l3<k NIq r l>3<k^l=28n'r7(A3<=5(
:X5B=>=3?:ElJ3Ul-5*Vr h
_ / /-3Mr 5Bs=N:E3pB5z284 Y `_ -%2Br,lV5 N%3=3(A5B=J7s4;28l31r@s%:-+l-%2?lm6l.Jf28lN: -3SQr Y ` / /-3=3(A5B=J7sF4G2 +
l>m65Cn[:E5Cn%r@m;r@lNrc5(l-
3 *

GF+m6n'r@l2?nIlmG2?l>m6nFp7l-31k%28=N28J3<l3<=r % * ! * ! [
l>5Rl-3T:E5Cn%r@lN28ndlBr % * ! * ! [M5( Y `+2?nu5( ],-FmG:-um9nIl3<=2?46m;2o=>X3 +
k4G2C:E3?r&l-Q3 Nm6n%2?=>q (Asn%:Elm65C"
n ( ( - NIq+l-3 M+ 2?=>q (Asn%:Elm65Bn ( ( ( ( - 28nRm6ndl>=>5*ds%:E3?rl-3
24Im9l>m95Bn%2?4Wk%2?=2?J3<l>3U=Rr % H2?nb:E5Cn%r@lN28ndl[r # / nc5:IskF46mG:U28l>m95Bnf5(Or@/s Nk4G2?n%rc5d:<:Xs=rm6n
l-m;r2?kk49mG:<2?l>m65Cn[5(
G / /-F3
G
7J3Ul-5*ar@l2<qFrMsn%:-%28npC3
NslT2?464
5Bl-F3<=cJe3<l-5*Fr28=>3T:-%28nFpB3 Ndql-31=3(A5B=J7s4;28lm65Bn /
` / ncd3 adl
+%l-3gr@5BsF=:E3g2Br>r sJklm65Cn j
1A=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>3m6n\r@l3<k _ 4463?2 rl-3=( + J3Ul-5*fJ3<l-F5*< +
= Y `NsFl
+r@m9n%:E2
3 + mGro4;28=>pC3%+
_b_b_ / nc5[493<JJf2CrM:E5C=>=>3Sr@k%5Bndm6npZl>5 j + j Z28=3upCm6D)3<n1(A5B
l-m;rd5)3?rn5CloJf2?l>l3<= / /-3Rk%28=N28J3Ul>3<= #+%0 ! * % %. ^h5d:<:Es=Tm6n[l-F37=3(A5B=J7s4;28l3
3 *

G3F #+%@ ! ** #+%@ G #m;r (A5C=:E3
NIq ],-m946[3 % %. ^
j + j +dl-ds%r&l-
:<28nnF5Bl N%3[m6n'r@l2?nIlmG2?l>3 28n =>3<Jf2?m6n k%2?=28Je3<l>3<=Nr / Je3<l-5* + _ _b_ m;r =3(A5B=J7s4;28l3xl>5Yl-3
:E5B==>3?:ElJe3<l-5* + _ _b_ KNdql-31=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m65Cn%r&5(r l>3<k _ 28n `)h
]=m6ll>3<n (A5B=Tl-3<(Asn':El>m95Bn%r -
-
o - &
&
&
&
O3Q
*£££
k%2?=28Je3<l>3<=
% % k=3?:E5BnIm6lm65Bn'r j + j ^
k%5)r l:E5CnIm6lm65Cn 1 $ )& 4
:E5Cn%r@l=28m9nIlNr
l qdk%31m;4 Vl qIk%31\F4+)l qIk%31-%.R4 Vl qIk%31-%. 4
k=5)5(r>:-3<Jf2
/
H = = =
O = I<O
M O = O = JO = M
?
BO
BO
O
k=5d:E3Is=3
) $ &%(' )
?
?
@
@
?
?
9
? &%('
''hAh _P_ hAh _ _P 'h @_P_ ''hAh _P 'hA_P <U< R_ON C HA 2A
' ;h 5_< h #_P A ' h _ 'h <4N * " ) A
M,+F- ; <5- < .0 _# 2A 3 #5 <- A _ # F67,- A<<UR NC FA C A
_P2 < 2 < AA A*;<2 < ;< < # 9 A # A
<= N,> * "
5A
@ # 617,0
<UR A
< _)I+C ) C C 9 C ? A
?
!C
!C
B
@
?
@
-C
?
?
@
@
MI
B
@
-C
!C
!C
@
?
+
!C
B
!C
?
r: -F3<Jf2 _+ m6ndl>3U=>k=3<l>3<=
I
C
I
1 & 8#4128n l-3f:E5C=W+
/
=>3?r kL5CnIm9np=(=+_J3<l-5*bmGrcJe3<l-5*+ _ _ nc5f463UJJ2Cr:E5B==>3?r k%5BnIm9npbl5 j + _ V+h2?=>3+pCm6D)3<n
m6n l-3l2?=>pC3<l],-mG:-!I5)3Sron5BlTJf28ll>3<='N%3?:<2?s%r@3f5(Vl-34;28=>pC31+ / nc5[=3(A5B=J7s4;28lm65Bn'rM28=3
n3?:E3?rr>2?=>q / J3Ul-5*<+ _b_ mGr:E5C=>=3?:El /
/ 8&rr@3<ndl>m;284946ql-3Tr>28Je3MmGrl=>s3 (A5B=l-31n3dadlV2Brr@sJkFl>m65Cna28nfJ3<l-F5*<+ _ /
/ nc5f] m6l.mGr"J3Ul-5*<+ ` rtls=>n / #**[5d:<:Es=NrWm6n1l-3k=3?:E5CnIm6lm65Cn%rt5(%J3<l-5*<+ `?2?no=>3<JK28m6n'r
2{k'28=2?J3<l3<=,r m6n%:X3n51463<JJe2l>51Jf2?l:- j 5B= j mGr.pBm6D)3Unom6n+l-3l2?=>pC3<l / nc5=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m65Cn
l2.): 3Srk4G2C:E3 /
b_
1
4
/-3fn3dadl kF=>3<Ddm65Cs%r@49q[=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>3 r@5BsF=:E3fr 3 { s3<ndlomGr 0$T
F- 3?: :dm6nFp7l-3 s%r@lmlH:U28l>m95Bn%rM5(J3<l-5*<+ `%m6lMls=>n'r{5Csl1l-%2?l1J3<l-F5*<+`Lm;rMn5Bl
:X5B=>=3?:El*NL3S:<28s%r 3o49m6n3715(l-31k=>5)5(r>:-3<JK2mGrn5Cl /
V n[5C=I3<=1l5u3Sr@lf2 N46m;r -Zl-3 s'r@l>fm lH:<2?l>m65CnxJe3<l-5*
+`"mGr d3?:E5BJekL5zr@3bm9nIl5a2KkF4G28n
:X5Bn%r mGr@lm6npe5(l-3+:X5B=>=3?:ElMJe3<l-5* +` _ B]m9l-[k%5)r ,l 1 Je3<l-5* +Ù4 k%5zr@,l 1AJ3<l-5*< +
` _ 4+Il-31r K
s NpB5z284 B ],-FmG:-mGrm6nk=3 1 Je3<l-5* +Ù4+d2?nf2on5BlV:E5C=>=3?:ElJe3<l-5* +
`
`K]m9l-fk%5)r@Hl 1 J3Ul-5*<
+ `Ù4 B /
Je3<l-5* +` _ %:<2?n N%3Tl>=2?n%r7(A3U=>=>3Kl5+l-31lN28=>pC3<l28n B =3<Jf2?m6n%r28na5Bk%3<napB5)2?4 /
b / 10$ & `4Mm;rl-F3nd3 adl+r 5Bs=N:E3f2Brr@sJekl>m95Bn 2?n 463?2 rol>5aJ3<l-F5*< + / nV5 (As=>l-3<=
=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m65Cn -%2?kk%3<n%rm6nfl-m;rr@l3<ka28nfJ3<l-F5*< + mGr:E5C=>=3?:El /
nc5Bl3l-%2?lhJ5B=3,l>3?:-nm { sF3?r":E5Cs4`
N%3,d3<D)3<465Ck%3 (A5B=P28sFl>5BJK28l>m;:<284946qJ5*dm (Aqdm6npl-3n5Cl,:E5C=>=3?:El
lN28=pB3<l,Je3<l-5*FrWr s%: -R2Cr,^2 N3Is':El>m95B
n _ ` - ],-mG:-+2?sl>5CJf28lmG:<2?4649qMk=>5?DdmI3SrW2 Im6lm65Cn%284kF=>3?:E5CnIm9l>m65Cn%r
m9n^5B=BI3<=Rl>5 k=5?D)3bl2?=>pC3<lJ3<l-5*rR:E5B==>3?:Xl2?n4
],-mG:- -'2Br -%2?nI493 l-3ak=>5)5(+5(+2 Im K:Es49l
:X5BJk493<l>3Un3?r>rl-3U5B=>3UJ /
_
('
54
(NJ8:HG2 JI B CFEE B N09&G
/-F3V28n%2?465BpCqok=5d:E3IsF=>3qdm63<4 r"l-3kF4G28n;+)r -5f]n+m9n _ m9pBs=3` +F]m6l-T=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>3MpC5)284;r+)2Cr>r sJk+
lm65Cn%r128nxJe3<l-5*Frck=>5?D)3bl5 NL3R:X5B=>=3?:El / /-3Rl28=pB3<l1k4;28n (A5B= Y `7495)5:FrM46m :)3Tl-%2?l (A5B= Y `_
3%a:E3UklMl-'28lTr@5CJ3on%3 ]493<JJf2Cr ooo%=>3<k4;2B:E3 o7ooh28nx2?464,J3Ul-5*rQNsl1J3<l-5*<+ `28=3+=>3X+
kF4G2B:X3
NIq1l-3:E5C=>=3?r@k%5BnIm6np1=3(A5B=J7s4;28l3cJ3<l-5*r / J3<l-5*< + `cmGrh=>3Uk4G2C:E3V
Ndq1m6lNrt=3(A5B=J7s4;28l3
r Ks NJ3Ul-5*J3<l-5*< + ` _ /
M:Els%284946q%+<l-mGrWkF=>5)5=( +_k4;28n -%2Cr NL3U3<n+k=>5*ds%:E3
NdqoJf2?nIs'284649q1:-5)5)r m6np1l-F3=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m65Cn%Br Nsl
2?kk49qIm9npfl-3<J28sl5BJf2?l>m;:<284946q / /-3e28n%2?465BpCq[k=>5d:X3Is=3r spBpC3?r@l3x2Cr5CkL3UnxpC5)284;rl-3+463<JeJf2Br
+ ncm6Ol `?+ _ V+ G+ V+ +)28n78p ],-m;: -e28=3c493(All>
5 N%3MkF=>5?D)3om6nel-3
j + j ^ + j + j + j + j _ _ + j _ ?
/
lN28=pB3<l
463r@5)G3 r5B=m6pBm9n%284 (A5C=>Jf2?46m *?28lm65Bne5(Pl-3 Yc3<m9nX3 + 5B=3<4%l-3<5C=>3<JKr+IpCm6D)3<nK^2 N%5?D)3%+l-%2?lM:X5Bn +
_ 5B=
lN28m9n%r7l-F3=(Asn%:Xl>m65Cn%
r +B+ + - 2?n ++ ++ ++ + - 2?n l-%2?lf2Brr@sJe3?r j _ + j `?+ j i + j _ *+ j _ l>5 N%3al28=pB3<l
493<JJf2Cr+)r qI+
J N%5B4%Jf2?kkm6nFpm;r&n5ClVr@s K:Em93<nIl'(A5C=l-3M=3(A5B=J7sF4G28lm65Cn+5(Pl-3 Y `_ k=5)5(Pk4G2?n / /-mGr
(A5C=:E3Srl-312?=>pCsJ3<ndlr,5( ++ + - l>
5 N%3IsFk46m;:<28l372?n +l-Is%r+2o=3(A5B=J7s4;28lm65Bn 33,-%2Br
l`
5 N%32?kk46m93l-%28lO: -%2?npB3Srtl-3k=5)5(Hk4;28n 1 2?nJe3<l-5*Fr 4 / s%r@lPr@qd+
J NL5C4)Jf28kFkm6np +B+ + - l>5 +B+ +B+ +B+ + ]m9l-5CslMl-3+5Bl-3<=: -%2?npB3Srck=>5?DdmI3 Ndq *
*`]5Bs4 bqIm93<4f27lN28=pB3<lMkF=>5)5=( +_k4;28n 1 5B=
kF=>5)50( 4Pl-%2?l,4G2C: :FrtnF3?:E3?rr>28=q(A3?2?l>s=3?r,2?nol-m;r ]5Cs4om9Jk49qcJf2?nI'
q N=3?.2 :If5 ]n%rW5(Hl-3V2?n%28495BpBm;:<284
=3<k4;2Sqe5B=V248-5d:=3<k%2?m6=r2Cr+%3 / p / +)k=N2B:ElmG:E3m9
n _ - /
&
&
&
&
'
&
C G
E^8 C/4 C G*898: E,G E /-F3b=>5 Ns%r l>n3?rr 5(1l-F3b2?n%28495BpCq<7+ I=>m9D)3<n kF=>5)5(=+_k4;28n:E5Cn%r@l=>s%:Elm65Cn l55dmeH3<=>3UnIl<(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m65Cn%r5(
l-3<5C=>3<JfrMm;ro28n m9Jk%5B=>lN28ndl1mGr>r s3 / M:Els%284946q%+ ]3R465)5:)3 28l+l-=>3<3:Imfe"3U=>3<ndl (A5B=>JRs4;28l>m95Bn%r`],-3Un
d3?2849m6np]m9l-bl-3 Yc3<m9n3X+ 5B=>3U4L3%a2?Jk463Sr h
_ / j 3<lcl-31k=>5 N463UJ (A5C=>Jf2?46m*U3]m6l-5BsFll-3 (Asn%:Xl>m65Cn%r B+ + + - 28n B+ + B+ + B+ + + - +)m / 3 / +
:@= 8M//:J8
1
&
Y
2 T?! U J;U=!"8J 36DFE==E\GI2MTA/J;KJ@UL98==E JM$# ?-@E J28nY
&`_ h 2T?!<U8Sd9<T =!"8J 3ZDFEZ=0EHGI2 M AKJ;KJ@U"9 ==E JM%# ?A@E J +
28nfl-3Tr@5CJ31r 5Bs=N:E3+2Cr>r@sFJkl>m95Bn
+G
`
'& -1)69% )
*%
.6!.9 O
b`
&
`h
HB2
method
refutation
sequent
∆ , -Th’ |- false
method-0’
∆, -Th ’ |- F2
method-21’
∆ ,-Th’ |- F1’
L7’ L9’ L10. . . L14 Nit2
L6
method-1’
∆ ,-Th’ |- F3’
L17’
open goal
g’5a
L2
L1
IA’
method-11’
∆ ,-Th’ |- F4’
L5’
CIA’
method-111’
_
m6pCs=>3g` 9h/-F3ok=5)5(=+_k4G2?nb5(
Y
L3’
&
L4’
`
1N254 # 0= T?!<UbJ;U0=!# B
J 36DF6E/97=!#"L BD6EG9:H:M6 &+(M9V&+(3J^J 2?nul-31l2?=>pB3UlV2Br>r sJklm65Cn
1N254 # 0= T?!<U8S%9 T =!# J 36DF6EG9EG;FE/<= #LBD6EG9EG;FE/< H M 6&+(M9V&+(3J^JM;V&(M< &(
/
>-3<nfl-3.(Asn%:Elm65Bn ( ( - 5d:<:Xs=rl%=Nr@lm6nl-3Mk=5)5(=+_k4G2?n +Ll-31:E5Cnn3?:Xl>m65Cnl2fN463,(A5B=N:E3?rm9lr
Jf28kkFm6npTl>5 ( ( ( ( - 2?nl-m;rl>=m6pBpC3<=rl-3M=3(A5B=J7s4;28lm65Bn
G35Cn46qe4G28l3<=
l-%2?n m6nYl-R
3 l'=r@lR2?n%28495BpCq r l>3<k / /-3Rl'=r@l+5d:U:Es=>=3<n%:E3e5(l-3 (Asn%:Xl>m65Cn ( ( - I3UkL3Unr+
-f5 ]3<D)3<=+I5Cnbl-F3o2C:El>s'284hk=5)5(5(VY `_ /
V@(Pl-F3(A5B=Jf2849m *?2?l>m95Bn%r5I
( Y `_ 28n)
Y `<-%2<D)3Tr@sk%3<= lH:Em;284649q dm eH3<=>3UnIlV2Cr>r@sFJkl>m95Bn%r5C=M:X5Bn+
:E46s%r m65Cn%rc2Crm6n
k
`
/
&
&
&
LT U J;U=!"8J 2 DFE==E\GI2MAKJ;/J UL98==E J7M # ?A@E J
& 1 e % ! * ! [1 4 # - c 4+
l-3<n 2KnF5B=>JK2846m *<m6nFp=>3(A5C=>JRs4G2?l>m95Bn 1An5Bl ImGr:Es%rr@3[m6nZl-m;rMk%28k%3<=04+#-'2Brl5N%3e28kk49m63[l>5
l-3fr 5Bs=N:E3k4;28n m9nx5C=I3U=ol>5aJf28lN: -Y `_ ]m6l-Y ` / 0)s%:- 2fn5B=Jf2849m*?2?l>m65Cnxm9nIl=>5*Is':E3?r
28na24dm6l>m95Bn%2?4hJ3<l-5*72?ll-3l>5Bkf5(,l-31r@5Cs=:X3Mk=>5)5(=+ kF4G28nal-%2?lV28kkF46m63Sr&l-F3I3Fl%nFm6l>m95Bn5(
#&%0 ! *01 428nfqIm93<4Fr2+kL5zr@lN:E5Bndm6l>m95Bnal-%2?lM:<2?n L
N 3TJf28lN: -F3 ] m9l-)Y ` /
rMr@m9np % * R1 4hm9n%r@l3?24+5(h01 4 ( % 1 4m9n+l-3V2Cr>r sJklm65Bn'r,:<28s'r@3+k=>5 N 463UJfr %N 3?:U28s%r 3
`_
Y
&
Y
&
h ?!
`)hoo7o
/
&
&
&
l-3T28n'28465CpBqak=>5d:E3Is=>3Tr spBpC3?r@lNrc2+l2?=>pB3Ulc493<JJe2
j 1324768484:4 /4U 4/T 4/U 4/9047A
=
&+('M&+( M Q&('M>U&+('M'TS&( MU'&('M'9O&+('M A &
(M,RM$O,U7MTW,AU M+9O,A3 ==T 9 ;U"9+SF=@6E+BEE E U@HKJFMT6& BMT E UE 9 EGAPH M
?=9 ; U =CBMT E8U E89 E/AFHXJ
, ?=9<; U =CBEE ECU@HKJ M
? 9<; U =CB>T EUE9 EÂFH@J ,?=9<; U =CBEE EÛ HKJ 3 BMT E8UE89 E/AFH:?
b
B E E EÛ HKJ^J
cn 5 I 3Fl%nm9l>m95BnR5( %m* ]2Br#(A5Csn+l-%2?l:<2?nr28l>m;r7(Aq j vm9n+l-3Vl2?=>pC3<l'(A5B=Wlad3 d3Fl%nm9l>m65Cn%r
5( + Im6DdmGr m65Bn;+I3<lN: / 2Cr (As'n :El>m95Bn%r2?nu=3<4G2?l>m65Cn%r5( /
$ &
! & X %&W%
H!M !MP
( V,h"
/-F3o2?n%28495BpCq<+7I=>m9D)3<nk=5)5(=+_k4G2?na:E5Bn%r l>=s%:El>m95Bnf3<JkF465?qr NL5Cl-fl-F3I3<=m6DC28lm65Bn'284h2?n7l-3Ml>=N28n%rD(A5B= +
JK28l>m95Bn%2?4Wk'28=2 Im6pCJ Ndqf=>3<k4;2<qIm9np+l-3 I3?:Em;r@m95Bn%r5(l-F3+r@5Cs=:X3+k4G2?nnm6nFp7k=5d:E3?rrM28nNdqfl>=N28n%r3+
(A5C=>Jm9np+l-F3or 5Bs=N:E31k=>5)5(k4;28nbDdmG2o=3(A5B=J7sF4G28lm65Cn%r /
cn%2?465BpC<q +7I=m6D)3<nkF=>5)5=( +_k4;28n[:X5Bn%r l>=>s':El>m95Bnfm6JkF46mG:Xm6l>49q1=>3?2?46m *U3?r2R:E5BnFn3?:Elm65B@n +"N%2Cr@3f2?n%28495BpBm;:<284
m9n?(A3<=3<n%:E3 ]m6l- =3(A5B=J7s4;28lm65Bn'r+=28l-3<=l-%28n 28kkF46qdm6np l-3bm9n?(A3<=3<n%:E3fr: -F3<Jf2 8 _ / V n l3<=>JKr
5(g2Br@k%3?:Xlr+l-3b=3<k=>3Sr@3<ndl2?l>m65Cn 5(Tl-3ak=>5)5=( + kF4G28n :E5C=>=>3Sr@k%5BnFr7l>5 l-3[2Cr@k%3?:El 28n^2?464Vl-3
kF=>5)5=( +_=>3U463<DC28ndl,(_2B:ElNrc:E5Cn sn%:Xl>m6D)3U46
q Nsm l-3T2Br k%3?:El /
Mr (A5B=.d3<=>m9DB2?l>m95Bn%2?4.28n%2?465BpCqm6nfpC3<n3<=N284D+l-3Mk=5)5=( +_=>3<493<DC28ndlcm9n?(A5B=Jf28lm65Cnl-%2?lmGrn5Clck'28=>l5(
l-3Rk=>5 N463<J I3Sr>:E=m6klm65Bn;B+ NslT2B: { sm9=>3 Is=m6npfl-F3Rr@5BsF=:E3Rr 5B46Ddm6nFpukF=>5d:E3?rr+hmGrV3<n%:E5*I3 m9n[l-3
s'r@l>fm lH:<2?l>m65Cn%rM2?nn5BlN28lm6npl-3okF4G28nan5*I3?r / /-3g:E5B==>3?r k%5BnI3Un%:E3o5(l-F3 s%r l>m lL:<28lm65Bn'rcm6nar@5Cs=:X3
2?nulN28=pB3<lV:<2?nf5Bn49q N%3M3?r@lN^2 N49mGr0-38Is=m6np+l-3128n'28465CpBm;:<284h=3<k4G2<qe28nfmGr I5Bn'
3 Ndqf:-3?;: :Im9np1l-3
s'r@l>fm lH:<2?l>m65Cn%r / _ 5BJek%28=3 ]m6l- pB3<n3U=284.d3<=>m9DB2?l>m95Bn%2?4V28n%2?465BpCq l-3a28n'28465CpBq +0d=>m6D)3Un kF=>5)5=( +_k4;28n
:X5Bn%r l>=>s':El>m95Bna24dm6l>m95Bn%2?4649q7slm649m *<3?r,=3(A5B=J7s4;28lm65Bn'r ],-FmG:- -3<s=mGr l>mG:U284649q+k=>3Sr@3<=D)3cl-3T:E5BnnF3?:El>m95Bn
N%3<l ]3<3<n 1 k=b5 N493<J % s%r@lm lH:<2?l>m95BQn 42?nuk=5)5=( +_k4G2?n /
>:
6
/-FmGrV]5B= I]2BrTr@skFkL5C=>l3xm6nZk%2?=>l'NIq[l-3 2?n Ndq
"/
pB=N28ndl
" +NIq[l-3 2[2fa
24I3 5BsnF28l>m95Bn +
! # "%$&! ' )( +* -,
/. ]>G#:<E1E\F%10aR2E0 +&F-3C 3 82E\58^64-@ 6 / ZR$ T_7a`02894%":;R:<3%b `6 "=6dcV>!Y4?f02eW3A@%gDB$ 4?h6D!iCe\'Z3%j)E .(FH GI_ * :J3%.AK.RGMj LN_ F-%:Ok3-( PQ/ CR8TSULNKV02EJBW8266V3?X 8YLZF-:N[-XFHG\B
M-
l +nm / =02E;o3?pqjR8 / 1KG\8^3%0&jr /ts 4-G\0^FHE\EM4Rjt4-6D5
C
2 / 24?6>4?@%3 /u Y eZvH!ieZ
w <x Zh %'Z$zyN!Y"%{I"?'-eMb
|"?'-e;h Y e;"?' !Y%}~ %{/' /I 6 E\FH0^028^@%FH6DLZFj 6 aP3AG#C)j _%A /
, - G\ 8Y:Jj E\3AE\kA02%F k / yZ!y "%{T-$&! #' df~)cDeyi}" / YW4?G;XA4?G#CU=6V82XFHGM:<82EJBG;F-:\:Zj)4?+ NG\89CR@%Fj
_
- s 4%LN3A6toF@%G\F+4?EU826D:JE#4-KG#4-E\823A6ts =3-XRK 3AG\@4-6RKVj=3A GC 82G\F+LNE\8^3%6D:uLZ3%6DLNFG\68^6@E\oF
8^` 6RE;!2FH{2{aG\jDVDG\4-FH@%EM4?F-E\:18^3%. 6 * 3?_ P1A.R6DO4-E\K4-G; F NVG\8Y6C @%F¥ =6V82XKFHGMG\:<E;82EHEJjOB¦F+7CR82G\E;F+3%:\GH:NjIj _%% }%,u{T! '#3%c G;82@ cV_!2{§ ?.A' ¨RN ¡cDeZy\'=xy £¢1"¤$
§- VG\©FH6 E\89s LNF4-G\FH89:\6:Zj Qs 7/²³ª«4?6t@AQ02FH3%BG\jtE;FHF-GHC jr82E\4?3A6DGHC¬j 1y T1N)e#e;ªh!Y82AF}?GH'<7xG\3A$ćDE\3e:Nx yd6$YcFH® µdRFHu$<edyN094?"%G<$z¯z! °D4A:<"%F-{·CU¶ 02F-4-y\G\¸H6'#8^c 6N@±¡ 4?R ¯
` "dcV!YfeW¹qe;"yN!YA}%jD4?@AF-:¥ºH.+*.% 3AG\@4-6 l 4?KRPU4-66tj³º k(
- / M28J5*dlV28n8 / 4;2*?2 /
C2 r@3X+LN%2Br 3u=3?2Br 5Bnm9np '5Csn2?l>m95Bn%2?4Wm;r>r@sF3?r+J3Ul-5*I5C465CpBmG:U284
DC2?=>mG2?l>m95Bn%r+"2?nfr@qFr@l>3UJ 28kkF=>5)2C: -F3?r / + P?+ _ P /
/
- _/ 2 / ] * A2 / 8
_
_
§,
( VG\ FH6 E\89s LNF4-G\FHµd89R:\:Z$JjeZyNs V/"%ª«$&!tQ"%3%{ G\E;FHGHRjryZ4?6D"%C¬{ <1x T1)"Rªb 82FGH"dcV7!YfG\3Ae¥E\gD3:N$R h !ie\6'ZjDFH. ® FH u, 09* 4?G<¯z°Dº%4AjI:<º F-CUk%k02F- 4-G\68^6@±4?R¯
A§
_
` `
k e&¡³s yde;4-'-G\eZFHR89:\$z:Z"% $&!eZ=7¡D{T"?{ '#"'yd! b ##"?"%'-$&e;!h· "wIh{2e;¹7hHe;}R"e yZ !Y%}% ! '!2L$z!4%CRfFH 8YL1
G;F-! :\:Ze;j h s 3:J¡E\¡³3%y6r?jt"º #ck $ Ne&¡D$

- s oD4?6D:;4?0^84-6DC ©W W4?GM4?6DCR8z B 6RE;oF-:J8Y:)3?PfW G;3%@%GM4?U:tKD:J826@CRFHG;82XA4?E;823%6>4?0 4?6>4?023A@%B
` "dcV!YfeW¹qe;"yN!YA}%jtºH¨ jtº % R
ºH¨ H¯&s ,82#FHa09A4R. (Z* ??@A, 33 jIC º 4-k 6DC %:<KVG<Pz4%LZF-: ±4?6D4-023%@A82F-:W8^6¤:;LN82FH6 E\8T]³L8^6 K82G;82F-:Z g !ieZ Ne <xg H!ieZ Ne#j

§
º%º ª«89 LNª«G\3 Fs 02F-02LNF+E;CG\:<3A36F8Y³LH:I4-o6DF1C KDI:<F13A3?uP 4?K6DE;4-FH02G13A@% B¦F+Ld826¦o6V4?3%KV02E\3A3%@% B4?IE\3A89LG\D3%G\GM34?3-E;Pq823%CR6r8Y:;j LN3-XK>FH:<G\E\B8^6ttjDF-Ld orj³º FHtk W ¯#º k+¯nk § j

§
ºH. ª« ª« s 02F-CV:<3F VG\F-LN3A6DCR8Ê\823A6UG\3-XFHGIP3%G4?6D4-023%@AB¢1! ?g³H'Z$<eZ'ZjD-,©.%. * .-,R(jIº %%
ºH s s 02KVuFH6 E\oD4-0& e&¡D{ "%!Y%} Q¡³! ' - hRe\' <x" ` eM$&"N¡c y ¡¡D{T! # "%$z! µdR$<edy9x" Ne e\'!a}DeZyd
7oDm«E\oF+:<8Y:ZjD=68^XFHG#:J82EJB
3-P F®4A:Nj G;E\8 ]fLN8Y4-0 6 E\FH0^028^@%FH6DLZF²³4-°tj KD:JE\826rjtº % ¨R
ºN, l ¶ "s yM¸3%! '#G;c 6NFH¡ GH u E\IG;KD"?LN'-E;e#Kbi¢|G#4-"?07'-:Je;82h u8^0Ye;4?"?G;' 82EJBV!Y4%%:=&} @A%(K')8Y')C*%4-j-6DXLN3%F·0^K826uFILH4A²³:<FN¯zW°D4% :Jj F-s CFHG;CR028^F-6t:J82j%@Aº 6t ,V $6 #G\!YyM8^6'Z$I@%FH ,G +Iy FHN¡DG;0Ye;4-"@
% º - F+l CR 82E;"s 3%3%GH! jG;61FH1G5 tµMb 3 '1-0 4-G#¶ C:Wy\P¸H3%'#G\c N¡ 4?02/8 .-¤4?E;I823A"?6'-eM82bi6 ¢1LH"?4A'-:<e;FNh ¯z°D4%e;:J"?F-' C VG;F-!Y%4%}%:J3%j 68^F-64-@ E\E;P023AFG
j³º :JBR6 ,E\oV F-:<89:N 6¤m
o>4Rj
%
º §- s s G\3(3 2)j II33%DFHGj4?6DC¤ª«q8^FHG#LZ F 6D4?0^3%@%89LH4?0G\F-4A:<3A6826@4-6DC¤G\33-P·CR89:\ LN3-XFHG;B 6
Oe;h²DK>N3: $z2!4?$6>9;C 541;X:AFHj-G;X°D3%FH0^K1F 2³ujFF-RCRºH82E;¨W3%GM3-:NP7j ¹7e Zy $ 7yd68e'%<$Yc%$Jµde\R'$<ed!YyN"%$z! =¡ "%{1$<eZ yg dx-H!ieZeZy# eZNe#Nje >4? @%F+:, $ ,-*, "%§ $Je;kRh j
G\@%3A66Fjtº kAkR G\8^6@%FGH
º?( s²Q s s G;3=3 2V:NI=3A6D4?6>4?02B E\89L¥LN3%6DLZFHEP3AG\U4-E\8^3%6±4?6DCuuFu3%G;B
826>:<E#4-6DLNF-:Z 6 3:;Ldo±4?6>C
A@jtfº ²D (+0^3?kRBV C)jF-C 82E\3AG#:ZjI d}!2$&! "Vh I"%$Je} yZ?! >"%$&! jD4?@AF-:º §% * .Rº Q7G\0^°D4?K j =8^020Y:;C4?0^F
ºHk s K6DCRB)oF K>:<F13?PtF®R0^8YLN8ÊOV0Y4?6>:E;3¥@%K89CRF826DC KDLNE\8^XFG;33?Pz:Z 6uR²DKD: 2u4-6DC B 41XFHGJ¯
°DX3AFH02FCK2)jtF-FCR 8Ê\ºH3A¨¤G#:N3?j P¦¹qy e N7$68 '%yd$YFe c< µZR%$J$JeZe\'yZ!Y"% $z! "%={1¡ $<dedx-y eZydg edH !iNeZe NeM jWD4?@A$F-:º%"%ºA$Jºde;hD*>ºH.%¨ e;jh Z$&G\!@%3AE669;F j¥º W ,k%k :Aj
G\8^6@%FHG
º - s ~Q©wIm
e#{TvNs$Yc KG; 6D:N H R"%G1{3 4-0·d:<x-82eZy#eZ820Y 4-NG\e 8Ê<<B x¥82$Y6 cDe¦4?6D 4-#02}3%@A!28Y$zLH!Y4-v?0¥eg G\H3A!i°eZ 02FHN e¥g :< 3AH02!iX e#82$z6?@Vj =8^02609:\C 4-02y F j NIe#e;@hjt!Y%º }?' ¨ <x$YcDe
%
.%¨ l ¶± ! '#s '-KDeZ:\L#' otdcVj"<1xZ$ IRIVoKh G\89# :<E;Uy#$´4?' 6#cV6ryNJj !2$@$ijD -l , KkG\E;#ot©.RjIº 4?6D* .C º 1jIº ²³4?k-6 ,2 3 -¥ s 8^3%6/8 20282FZPFHG\E¥7G;3%°0^FHu0 3! :<K6V@
§
.Rº @L G·O4?G;°f3A6FH 0^0&u²DF-4?G;6826V@° B4?6>4?023A@%B³
3AG\¦K0Y4-E\826V@U4?6DC@%F6FHG#4-02/8 .H826@0Y4-6D:=PG\3% >4%:<E
F¹q®Re;D"FHyNG;V82!YFH%6D}RLZ F 6 y#$& ! !Y"%{89Ldµdo>R4?$<0YeM: {22R{T!aB}R,j ed@ ?+G·e 7 ¡4?¡³G;y °f-3A"6dcFH0^j0&Dj74-4-@%6DF-C¤:W( º#* .R82QEMLdo8^F3%02@0&4AjD7F-CRK8^°E\0&3A^G#jt:N7j 4-` 023 " d cV02!YE;D3e j
º kAR
§%
.%. F@®RLG·D FHOG;82FH4?6DG;LZ°fF3A 6FH 60^0&u²D F-4? G;682896VLd@oD4-° 0Y:B2R8z4?j56>@4?L02G·3A@%B³
4-G\3A°DG\3%¦6VFHK020Y0z4-jIE\4?826V6D@UC¤4?W6DC@% F6FH82G#E#4-L#02o8/.HFH820^60&j)@F+CR820YE;4-3%6DG#:=:Zj PG\3% "d>cV4%!YD:<Ee
¹qe;" yNV!Y%}R y#$&! H!Y "%{)µZR$Je#{^{T!a}ReZ He ¡¡³y -"dc j D4?@AF-:º(Z*Dº § º% G\8^6@%FHGjtº k?, `
.% @L G·f4?G;°D3%6FH0^0&qm=FHG\8^XA4? E\8^3%6D4-0t4-6D4?0^3%@%B³ E;oFH3%G;Bu3?PQG;F-LN3A6D:<E;G\KDLNE;82XF1G\3A°02F:<3%0^XR8^6@¦4?6>C
F` ®R"DdFHcVG;E\!Yf8Y:JeWF¹q4Ae;L1"yNKV8Y:<!YA8Ê\}R8^3% 6t 6 y#$z! H !Y "%{f8YµdL#RoD$J4?e#09{2:3{T2 !a} BeZj @N?e G· ¡¡³4-y G\-°D"3%d6Vc FHj02D0zjO4?4-@A6DF-:CW(ºd * . 82EM LdoV3%FHG;02@0z4?j6 F-CRl 82E;4?3%KRGMPY:N¯ j
4?66±7K°0z2jf²D3: 02E\3:Njtº k §
.?, @Ne# e;h)!YA}?4-' G\°D<3%x¦6V$YFHcD02e0q4?~)6DcVC !Yy; h µZ $<DeZIyZ3%"%0^02$z82!6>:NI"%W{ 4-E\K!YGMR4?$·0q :<FHUdx-4-eZ6Ry#E;eZ8Y LHN:7e 8^68Q 4?G;E\y#8 ]f$&! LN 8Y4-!Y0t"%82{6 E\µdFHR0^$J02e#82@A{2{TFH!a} 6DeZLN FN e# j 6 E#4?y 6 %¯ b
_
P3AG#C)j) jtº (+R
. - 1 %I02FuFH6 EH) 4=°>:<FHG;XF-CWuFHE\oV3 C:rP3AGO@AFH6FHGM4?E;826@4?6D4-023A@%82F+:O826:\LN8^FH6RE;8 ]³LQG\3A°02FH :J3%02X 826V@
#}V!2$&!Yv?e¥g H!ied Ne#jQºH.R %§ +* k § jº kAkR
. §- 1 7I02FHFH6RE4?6>C¤m
G1FH6 E\6VFHGH B:JE\FH 4?E\89LN82EJB±4%:·4:JFH02F-LZE\823A6¤LZ3%6D:JE\G#4-826 E
8^6¤4-6D4?0^3%@%89LH4?0
4?8^6@¥ #}V!2$&!Yv?eWg H!ieZ Ne#jqº ©k *DºHA.Rj7º % º%
.( @~)IcVI!Yy;02h FH FHV6R ER "%{ 6>4?d023Ax-@%eZB¤y#eZ @ANFHe6FH<GMx¥4?E;$YcD823%e¦6 82#6}:;LN!2$z82!YFHv?6 e¥E\8Tg ]³HL
!ieZ G;N3%e¥°0^g FH5H¯n!i:<e#3%$z?0^XRjt8^º 6@k º% 6 y Ne#e;h!Y%}?' <x$YcDe

.%k @QI02FHuF6RE 6D4-023%@A8YLH4-0OG;F-4%:J3%68^6@UD4?E;E\FHG;6D:=8^6FH®RDFHG;E=VG\3%°V02FH :<3A02X 826@V 6 y Ne#e;h!Y%}?'
<x $´cDeI# y#$´c V R"%{ dx-eZy#eZ Ne <x·$YcDe¦ d}!2$&!Yv-eWg H!ieZ Ne¥g H!ie#$z?jDD4-@%F-:W( * kRºAjOº kA.R
. - fIKVG\82F6tW $z!2{/'1¡ y={T" y#e v?e¡V"y "%{ d}!ie#I7oDm E\oF-:J8Y:Zj=68^XFHG#:J82E;F =FH6G;8tO3A826DLH4-G\F
¯W4-6DLNBj³º A%
%¨ W<x $YcD-em4+% X 8Y$Y:Qc 4?µd6>RC $<ed yN @"% $z!KD:\"%:JFH{ 020z !YR02$3A@% 89LH4?dx-0 eZ4-yded G\N3e 4%L#o E\ 3WydG;$zF-! 4%:JH3%!Y6"%8^{I6µZ@WR°$Je#B¥{2{ 4?!a}R6>eZ4? 023ANe#@%jB D 4-6 @%F- :y . Ne#,-e;* h.!Y%(+}?¨R' j
§
8^0Y4-6 EM4?02Bj)º k( 3AG\@4-6 _ l 4?K PU4?66r
Rº W s 3?B CRF0Y4Ut3%KG·4-6DC t4+PFHG;G#4R¦7G\33-P14-6D4?0^3%@%B8^6 8^6RE;FHG#4ALNE\8^XF¥ E\oFH 3AG\FH G;3-XR8^6@
11FHE\ oµM3 b CHE\3·jf>FH4?® @%F+G\: F-:;A:I 4?* 6DACu jQKDº :J F=k8^(E X 8Y4¥:<F-LZ3%6DC53AG#CRFGD4-E\E\FG\6uU4-E#L#o826V@ 6 y Ne#e;h!Y%}?' <x$YcDe
%. QQm=FHKD:;:<FH6t "%L{ &}y +¡¡DeZ h $ "%$<edRjOX3A02KuF % 3?P ·eZ!YhRe#{ NeZyi}Redy ~"?' #cDeZ dcDeZy#
G\8^6@%FHGjtº (º%
% l Dm=KV6DL 2FGH 416UG;3%°0^FH :<3A02X 826@V ' dc %{ #}! #"%{ ` #}y\"N¡c'Zj kRjQº ,
?, F+WCRT821E;3%)GHIj : 2RG;V8Y"%CR{ @A#F}! #"% {Io BR°VG\f8YCUe N$zu! 3 CR'ZFHjD0tD3-4?P@ALNF-3%:16 .%E\¨8^6R(ZK* .-3A,KD:W 4- 6D°4?0^023%F@%®)89j LHI4?0q@G\j)F-º 4A:<3%,V6V 826@V 6 l @ =3%0^B374 2³j
§
%
- W 6 L G·- XA8^4-6D6D3: :N2 B jF-CRG\8^3AE\3A@%GHGM4?j) gteZP3%GQ"E\ o$&!F
:JµZ3%d02KVx E\82yZ3A6¥"%3?$zPD! @A FH3% uy F E\NG\e\89'#LO'4-!Y%6D}A4?)0^3%º @ABk 8^6R E;FH020^82@AFH6DLNFQE\F-:JE KVF-:<E;823%6>:N

§
§- ¡Ds { "D"%4?$&/0 2! FH 6oD 4-y 826 NFHe\G'#W'ZQ¹77e;"oDyZm !Y%E;o}WF-x:Jy 8Y:NjD 1 6cV82X+FH'GM! :<#8^"%E<{B· 3?P"% 0^{ 02#82}6V!i3%e;8Y'-:Z j = G\°DgD4-$ 6Dh4+ ¯;I!YoD 4- uD"%4?{ 8^#@%}6tUj " ²QhUjtº $´cDk e¥ -b

( s D4?/0 2FH6oD4-826FGHj l =am·1 3AG\°KD:ZjI4?6DC m
J G=F6RE;6 FHGHoF E;G\KDLZE\KG;FN¯ 4-8^6@76@A826F 6
y Ne#e;h!YA}?' <x·$YcDe µ#b -jD7o8^0Y4%C FH02oV8Y4RjV jtº k §
§%§
%k VG\a3-XR 8^6O@/8 2E\F-3¦:4-G;6D3%C °0^·FH @ :<13A0282X 0Y:;826:<3A@V6t yd $z! H !Y"% {) µdR$Je#6{2FC{T!a-«} eZ4?He#VjtG\3.R4A^ºHLdk o±* E\3¦.A¨%E\k ojF·º 4-(º%02 89LH4?E;823A6 3-PIE\oVFH3%G;FH

- m·"?' G=y F 6RNE;e\6'#FH'GH 5E\KDedCRyN!8^#F-": 3?Pq u' FH#EMc 4?%{ oV#}3%!G1#"%4?{)6>gC LNH3A!ie#u$z?j 02F®¦3A4?6R6DE;4-G\F-023%4-@A0&82j)F-º :Z kA ¨R6 g³A=¡ ?'! ` e#$z"N¡c y

,¨ m· G1FH6 E\6VFHGH E\G;KDLNE\KVG\FU4-826V@ E;oFH3%G;FHE\89LH4?01PG#4?1F -3AG 2¬P3AG±4?6D4-023%@AB #}!2$z!Yv?e
g H!ieZ Ne#jQ( .)#^º % *Dº-(-¨RjIº k%
,º F+m·CR; 82E;G13%FHG#:Z6 j=E\6g³F!YGH!2{T"oyZ!2F·$z¤u"F-L#oDh 4?6V 8Y:< "%{ #:}3-!P#"%4?{ 6D4-02e;3%"?@A' 8YLH4-0O!YA0^}%F-4?jG;D64-826V@%F-@: º 6 * .?+I,Vº%3¥:J68Y4A4?CR¦3%°KG\894-CR6D@%C F± = 6418^XG\FHE;G#3%:J6 82EJBB j
%

7G;F-:\:Zjtº k
,. m· y G=Ne#Fe;6RhE;!Y6A}?FH'GHj <xl $ácDm
e gf?! 3A-G\$<e#°edKDR:Z$´jc 4? 6>C "%/ª«{O #FHx-G\eZ@AydeZKD :<3ANe6t <x $Y6>cDLNe·G\FH d}FH6R!2EM$&4?!Y0v-e:<E;g G\HKD!iLZeZE\ KNG;e=FN¯&g H4?!ie#$z?8^6j@D4-@%F-6 :
ºHH* RºkRj =8^020Y:;C4?0^Fj I@j)º % ,
, m· G=F6RE;6FHG¦4?6> Cm
G1FH6 E\6FGH O 023 -826V@ -4?E;FHG#:
3AG5E;FHFHu8^6@LZG\3 -1C:N FH6 E#4-0u3 CRF0Y:
3-²³P114 -FH02G;F+FHLN6DE\LNG;8YF·LN8^7E<BG\0^ °D4?6K m·j) º G1 k%FH6 E\6FHG·4-6DC E\FHXF6D:NjtF-CR8Ê\3AG#:Nj ` eZR$z"%{ ` -hRe#{/'Zj7D4-@%F-: % *DºHA¨R
,%, m· 6 G=y F 6RNE;e#6e;FHhG¦!Y%4?}-6>' C <x±$ćD²³eU4?µZ6>RCR$JFHeZG#yZ:Z "%$z ! 6D4-"%02{3%@A 8YLH4-d0x-eZG\y#FHeZ N826De CR8^6 @ gf+ 'Z$JeZ@%33 ' C "4? E#L#o"8YV:
h oDI4-G#= C¬NedE;yN3feM]D$&6D! dC)'Zj
`
tKDLH:J3%6 j)º k
, - 4-/ª«5°V 8YG=CR8^@A°F¥°D=:Z6~)8^XcDFHe G#:J 82EJB¦eM$&7! dG\' F-:;<:Nx j)` 4?!Y¦hR° G;#8YCR!a@A} F jDy\"%º $z!Yv?,e ~)c -}?c $ t¹ "%} "H}Re "h hReZy\'Z$&"h!YA}%
%
, §-
T²QI G=89L 2 4-6DC l @ =3A02B374 2³ 6D4?0^3%@A8YLH4-0
G;3%°0^FH :<3A02X 826@V #}!2$z!Yv?e ' dc %{ d}?j
º.R©%¨ § * A jIº k%¨
,R(
'T ²Qd c G1%{ 8Y#L }2?jt4?º6DC º7l #^ ºd@*J %=kRjq3A02º B3kA74 R2³ L#oFHU4U826DC KDLNE\8^3%64-6DC 4-6D4?0^3%@A8YLH4-0E\G#4-6D:nPFGH« #}!2$z!Yv?e
B

,k F+CR 82E;G13%3GHFHj °D FHV0& "%{ #}3: !2#"%FE#{7L#"oV3?hPQµd4-6Dh4? 0^3%N$&@A!YBUv-e4%:7µddG\x-F+eZ4%yd:<ed3A 6N82e#6VjD@ X-3%0282KVE;uouFWF KD4?(0^823-EJB¥P¹7oRB e ZD$ 3% E;ydoe F-<:<F+%:N$J e\ ' 6 l ¤©O @=4?¡ 6 E 2$JeZFy j

g H!ieZ Ne#j³D4?@AF-:=.-,H* . R G\8^6@%FHGjtº k
, -
G13AG#CR3A6tj 820^6FHGj4?6>C 1aQª¤4AC3: -3%G;E\ot=h!Y Ry}?cU¹5 # s ` e #cV"?! >-e;h5¹ #}! <x
=¡ $z"%$&! R²DF-LNE;KG\F =3%E;F-:826I3%KE\FG LN82F6DLNF¥(-kR G;826@AFHGHj FG\028^6tjDº (
¨ º J kAG1kR G\FH8^6FHGH²DF-4-G\68^6@° BK6DCRFG#:<EM4?6DC 826@4-6D4?0^3%@%8^F-:N yd$z! H!Y"%{7µZ $<e#{^{T!a}ReZ +e#j ©kRº#*DºH. j

º @7 G;F-W:\4%:ZCjD4-UG;824?6DGMLZC)FHE\3A~)6tcDjte º , ' dc %{ #} <xµZVv?eZR$z! U!Y5$´cDe ` "%$YcDeZ"%$&! #"%{ #!ie#{Th%D7G\8^6DLNFHE;3%6¦=6V82X³

. ay#Q$z! = H!Y4?"%02{)0z)µZI $<3%e#u{^{T!aV}RKeZE# 4-NE\e#82jQ3A6D 4?0>º 4?#© G;*>3ºH4A.ALd¨RojIF+:º E;3¥k 4? 6>4?023A@%89LH4?0DG\F+4%:<3A6826V@ LZ3%uD4-G#4-E\82XF4?6D4-02BV:<89:N
B

l #Wx-4-eZydueZuN3Ae 6DC) 7 Wy#$& ! H !Y"% {|uµdR3 $JCe#{2FH{T0)!a} 3-eZPI LHN4Ae#j:<FN>¯z°D4?4A@%:<F+F-:uCU. 0Y(N4-* 6.6(82ºA6Vj
@ ²D36 : y 02E;3Ne#:Ze;j=h !Y% }?' j1#º ! xZk $´Kc <¥"%3A$z! G\@4?"%6 {
§
§
l 4-KRPU4?6V6t
§(
,
3 8 CRWFH0Y4?:ZGM 4?@A KD6 LdoV81©O4?6D8C @4? 6 E2 FG;j78 2AF-41C -82E\4 3A GHj F-4A"%:<3%{ d6V}82!6#@"%{1°R"B h 4?6>µZ4?V023Ah@%BN$z!Y4%v?:e 4De;"?4-' G\E\894?!Y0%}%8YCRj7FHX6 3AE\028^KEJBuF°fF. E3-FHFH3-6 P
§A
¹qe N$ Ry#e < %$<e\l ' <x¦ =¡ $JeZy=g H!ieZ NeMj)D4?@AF-: § ºd*k( G;826@AFHGHjt º k(
%- m· =FH02 4?6t "%{ #}! #"%{ e;"?' V!Y%}% l 02K -FHG LH4ACRFHu89LKV°0289:<oFHGj)º k%k
%§-
13% E\=G;F·F+:\mW:<F4?u` Fj)?hRº eM{/'¥" Vh "%{ d}!ie\'·!Y5g H!ieZ Ne# 6DCR894?6D4 7=6V82XFHGM:<82EJB¥3?P 13%E\G;FWm4?uF17G\F+:\:Nj
A§%§
( V G\63%@%°VFH0209FH4 Ul :Z = 6 8YL 2 ~)UcDe4?6% 4?6D$Yc C @%8^V020 R
"%t{·²³ 4?G 2Rdx-8^6teZy# eZ 6RNE;e FHG\<6Dx4-07~)4-cD6De4?0^ 3%#@A}B) !2$z !Yv?eug3 CR!iFHeZ0t 3?NPeUE\gG#4- 6DH:n!ie#PF$z?IG j-D824-E;o@%F-826 :
+* § ¨Rj =820^0Y:\CV4?02Fj A@j)º A ¨ O²³41-G\FH6DLZF
7G;02°D4-K :;:<3 LN894?E\F+:N
k m· =3-Pz:<EM4%CRE;FHGH G\FHX 82CF - 3-PFH6REM4?0³02F-4-D:N 6D4?0^3%@%BU8^6LZG\F-4-E\82XF¥E;o3%K@AoRE µ ` "H}7" >!Yfe#j
º §B #T( * k%¨ jIº %A
%- m· , =3?Pz:JE#4ACRE\FHG· 4-6DC 82E#L#oFH0^0& s 63-XFHG;XR8^1F - 3-P E\oVFuLN3ARBVLH4-EWG\3 \F-LNEH F-L#o FHD3%G\E
7¯ .H¯#º % º%j 6DCR8Y4-6D4=68^XFHG#:J82EJB 0233Au826V@%E\3A6tj 6DC 8Y4?6>4Rjtº A ºA
§ ¨ l @ =3A02B374 2³ oF±G#4-@%U4-E\8YL: 3-P4-6D4?0^3% @A8YLH4-0WE\GM4?6D:&PFHGH 6 G· s 3 -FHGHjF+CR82E;3%GHj~)cDe
' dc %{ #} <x¹qe;"yNV!Y%}u"h ` %$z!YvH"%$&! L4%CRFH8YL7G\F-:;:Njtº k
§ º l @ =3A02B34 2) V"%{ #}! #"%{I fe N$z! ' %{)µ\µM °02F®)j I@jtº % ,V
§ . l @ =3%0^B374 2 4?6DC l l 3Aot KGJPz4%LNF±4-6DC :JE\G\K>LNE\KGM4?0:<8^u82094?G\8^EJB826 4?6D4-023A@%8YL4?01E\G#4-6D:nPFGH
` eZ yZ d}!2$&! jOº B , #©%%.H* -,¨RjIº k(
§ l @ =3%0^B374 2 4?6DC·O-oD4-@4?GMC) 6D4?0^3%@%89LH4?0 4?8^6@° B¥LN3%6>:<E\GM4?8^6REQ:;4?E\89:nPz4ALNE\8^3%6tQ #}!2$z!Yv?e
g H!ieZ Ne#jqºHR©. A * % jº k
§ , l4- @5B °V1G\3%8YC 02B@%3F74 j 24? 6DCUj)º Q oD4-@4?GMC) ` edR$&"%{D¹7e;"N¡'- "%{ #}¦!YIyde;"%$z!Yv?eu~)c -}?c $ s GM4%CP3AG#C)j
%%
§%- B 1KD4?6@Vj l FHG;°DFHGHj l 3%o0^ oD4%:JFj4-6DFC @ 89Ldo E#:Z FE\o3 C:7¯7E;oF1°D4%:J8YL=K6V82E#:OP3AG094?6R¯
6V 824%64?@±G;°4?G 6>KD! C L2XFHFH6tG\jt8TPº BRA8^ 6,V@¦ G\3G;3-826Pz:N@A FHGH6 y Ne#e;h!Y%}-' <x _ "?cVyde\'Z$z"H} %}x &y R'Z$i{T! #cDe5µZ $<e#{^{T!a}ReZB >Zj
§%§- AF =KD4-6@ e#{2edvH" H · wI{2e;hH}Re"h V"%{ #}! #"%{ e;"?' !Y%}%Q7oDm E;oF-:<89:NjV Wj l j
º % R
§ ( @© =KuuF0ij s s KG\6D:ZjD4?6DC l @ =3A02B34 2) 6D4?0^3%@%89LH4?0t 4?8^6@° BUCRB 6D4?u89L=°8^6DCR826V@
,V7º G;§FH*028^,%u, 82 6D 4- G\B°0^82FH6 ®³Xj F-A:<E;@82@jt4?º E\%8^3% 6D,:Z 6 l @ =3%0^B3472³jIF-CR82E;3%Gj V"%{ #}!#"%{
Vfe N$z!'Zj=D4-@%F-:
§ k s FHE# 4-6DCRoKV3%G GM2 :oR4?B 6D4 C± 4?6D 4-02V3A@%G\823-F+®:N·82U 4-dE\}F!2:J$&FH!Yv-UeW4-g 6RHE;!i8YeZL NE\GMeM4?j76Dº%:&ºAP/FH,%G\, F6D*LN,Fk% ¨ jI º kLN(3%uVKE#4-E\823A6D4?0UE;oFH3%G;B 3-P

§%- s 8^826 6DCR KVG 2 oRB 4 3 CRF-:3?P4-6D4?0^3%@%B 6 l ©O @4?6 E 2FjRF-CR8^E\3AGHj y Ne#e;h!Y%}?' <x¥$´cDe±¶ yM¸+b
'#º c Nk ¡ "%{ #}! #"%{·"h¬µdh N$&!Yv-e µddx-eZy#eZ Ne %(' )'%j1D4?@AF-:. º?(N*.%A¨Rj FH826VoD4?GMC:<°G;K66tj
(-¨ l 4?¦°oD4-uD4?E;8I4?6>C @ =F6DCR02FGH X%4-0289C4?E;823%6 °D4%:JF-C¤E\oFH3AG\B3?P1094?6¤3 CR8 ]³L4?E\8^3%6
4-6DC G;FHKD:JF yd$z! H!Y"%{)µdR$Je#{2{T!a} eZ He#j % 2º +*. j7º A .R
§k
(º
º kAkRl F-4?6VF "%{ #}!#"%{ y )Z{2eZ g %{TvH!YA}%
70^028Y: 13%G-33 C ª820^FHB Mj)Io8YL#oF-:JE\FHGjD76@%094?6DC)j

(-.
F-©W4-6 Fl j F-4?I6²DF3%@%8^F6DjILNG;4?FH6>uC FH6G·E#74-0I74?G#CR6>34?:N023Aj7@%F-8/C.H82826E\3A@VG#:Zj¹IoV!YFHf3%e;G;' B <4-x 6DC¬~)cV!Y3 ¸ACR!Y%FH} 0& 6 e el N @$&! G1' 820ô3¤3%0^$YBcDj e a'W-b
l#c %{ #} <xU~)c -}?c $ %{)µ#ª820^FHBjDº A ¨
(-
©W l F-4-6F±4?6DC s GM4HB:JoD14 -¥¤oFu8^6DLNG;FHuFH6 E#4-0I4?6D4-023A@%BU4%L#o8^6F 6m
02FHFH 4?6tj
F+CR82E;3%GHj~)cV!Yy;h y N¡De;"¶ y\¸A!Y%}5gte;'#'! ` " dcV!YfeW¹qe;"yNV!Y%}%jf²D3A6DCR3A6tj7º k%k
(H, aW l F-C4-G<¯;4?°DFH020^8&7KG;D3:<FZ¯J CR8^G\F-LZE\F-C· 4?6D4-023%@AB 6 y 6 <x$ćDe #}!2$z!Yv?eg H!ieZ Neg !ie#$&
#x-eZydeZ Ne#jf>4?@%F+:º ¨+*>º A j G\X 826VFjf j³º k
( -
l FG\°DFHGI4-6DC5 FH0^8Y:NVW:<8^6@¥FH® FHu094?G\AB 2R63 -0^F-CR@%FP3AG \KD :<E;8 ]DF-C4-6D4? 0^3%@A8YLH4-0fG;F-4%:J3%68^6@
6gre 8YhL#oFH¶ 0Im1ydDF{ h¤G1 0Y4A:
dx-4-eZ6DydedC Ne BC .H89 :<094 $YcD- e 7# 14 -0Yh4 "2)5jtF-eZRCR$z8Ê\"%3A{/' G#:N<jx ¶ Wy#$z5 ! # H!Y"%µ {µd' R$Je#{2{T!a} eZy NNe#e#je;h>!Y%4?}?@%'F+:u<x¦º $Y(ZcD* e
º § k j)74-G\89:Nj G#4-6DLNFj³º %A 6=@ 23AGH
( §- G· l 02F826t V028YL4?E\8^3%6D:¥3?P 4?6D4-023A@%8YL4?0G\F+4%:<3A6826V@ ` eM$&"N¡c yu"Vh g³% %{ ! Z$&!YvH!2$z?j
. a.A¨Rºd*.RºkRjIº k(
(%( G·y } l 02FH8^! 6¦d'Z4?jt6DºC R @%*>ªºHFH¨?82,VE j7.HFHº 6RPk%F. 0YC) VoF=K>:<F13?PQ4-6D4?0^3%@A82F-:I826¦LN3AuD4?GM4?°8^028Ê<B·4-6D4?0^B:J8Y:N ¡¡D{T!ie;h
A
(-k º a(º% l 0^826@V >4?G#4ACR82@A P3%G¥G\F+4%:<3A6826V@° B4?6>4?023A@%B yd$z! H!Y"%{QµZR$Je#{2{ !a}ReZ Ne#j.R2ºZ,R(Z*Dº?(+kRj

( - l 0282®³ s FH@4?° K6V@:nP3AG#:;Ldo K6@-¯WFH8^66FHKFGWª F@ 8^6CRFHIG 23A@%68^E\8^XFH6 6 E\FH0^0282@AFH6 .-C 8Y4?@A63:JE\/8 2)
ed!2$´' dcVyZ! xZ$fx y ' dc %{ 6Tjtº º B, Ma § ¨+*%k( jº kAR
k%¨ l 3F+:<E\0^FHGH·~)cDe N$ <x¦Iyde;"%$z! Rq89LH4%C 3%GHjt²D3%6>CR3%6tjQº A§ ,V
kRº P3AorG= G;lFHKD3A:J0282°D6F·@4?6DG;C33?IPz:Zot ª 6 4? 02E;y o NFHe#Ge; h !Y%F-}?LZ'3%6D<Cx ¯z$´3%cDGMeCRFH% G10U$Ycu4?µZEM Ld$<oVeZ82yZ6@¥"%u$z! 3 CR"%KV{ 023FH!YXAR4?$10^KD 4?E;82d3Ax-6 edyd* eZ 4
Ne E\F+Ldo6V 8 y#K$z!2F b
_
H!Y"%{ µdR$Je#{2{T!a} eZ Ne#j 3%6 E\G;F-4?0zj)º %% 3%G;@4-6 l 4?KRP 4?66t
k%. @A.% k l jO3Aº 023 k%CR 6V FHGH F+LN3%6D:JE\G;KDLNE\8^XF
uFu3%G;B) LN3%KE\FG=u3 C FH0& d}!2$&!Yv-e g H!ieZ Ne#jI(©.%kRº#*

k% @Ne# e;l h!Y3%A0^}?3 ' CR6<x¥FHG$Y cDeFHIE;G\"?8^'-FHe#XRb8^¢16"?@W'-FHe;Xh F6REMe;: "?P' G\3A!YALH} 4%¶:JFWuyM¸FH'#uc N3A¡G\B³5 D4-)G# 4?0^jR02FH>0D4?8^@%uF+:=02.AF%5+*FZ6R.?,EM4?E;jO823%I6r0^F- 4? G6 - 4?E;y FH%G b

s F+4%L#otj)º k%k
k?, @ l 3A023 CR6FGH·I"?'-e#bi¢1"?'-e;h e;"?' !Y%}% 3AG\@4-6 l 4?K PU4?66±7K°0^8Y:JoFHG#:Zj)º %
k - ²Q. l jO3%º 4?. E# :JKt F+LNFH6 EWXR8^1F -1:=3-PLN3%6DLZFHE\K>4?0I:JE\G\K>LNE\KG;F ' dc %{ #}! #"%{O¢ {^{2e#$z!YRj=º.%. ¨A¨+*
§ %
k §- Q:;4% L#oRl K>3A:<E\FH3AE;6tE#: 6D
:<E;'82!YE;%K}E\F¥ 3?MP¡fedtyNF-!iLdeZoV 6Ne3%0^3%!Y@%B¹7j)²³e;"4?yZ°D3%!YGM%4?}E\3A"G\B±h 3?P Iy )3AZu{2eZ KE;g FHG%{TvH!YLZ%82FH}%6D LZF7jDoDº m k E\ oVF-:<89:Nj 4A:n¯

k( @%3Ao6«=²³4-82G#C³j¥74?K0 3:<FH6 °0233AjW4-6DC 020^FH6 =1F -FH020z IoRK6 2R8^6@826 4 oVF
4-6D4?E;3%¦Bu3?P4@%FH6FG#4?0t0^F-4?G;6826V@uF-L#oD4?689:<± ` " dcV!YfeW¹qe;"yNV!Y%}%j)ºA2ºAºd*, § j7º k §
§%
k%k
k -
¨
º
.

,
%-
%§-
(
k
%-
ºHÄ¨
ºH¨ º
ºHÄ.
ºHÄ
ºH¨-,
ºH¨ ?
G·²³4723-p
?
4
D
6
C
@%3Ao6D:J3%6t ` e#$&"N¡c y\' ¶ eu¹!Yv?eu¢1- =6V82XFHGM:<82EJB3?PIoV8YLH4-@%37G\F+:\:Nj

IoV8YLH4-@%3j ²Qjtº k%¨R
ª«E;FHG# CV
4?f²Dj³F+4?º E\ oV(FH,G# C4-02F~)cDe %{2e<x "%{ #} ` ?hReM{ "h ` e#$z"N¡c yd =3AG\E;o13%02094?6DC³j U:n¯
l )²D3AG\FH6 . 6D4?0^3%@AB4A:=4:J3%KGMLNF
3-PI:;LN82F6DLNFIg H!ieZ NeMj7ºHk a.A. * .%-,jIº (H,V
ª«²³4-°Dª«3%G# 4- E\3AL?G\IBj K 6F4-, E\41oD:1E\E;4?FH6>GC .Ra ¨W KD:Jm=FHG#82X :I8Y@%:J82K3A896tCRj F³ G;@%F+3ALd6o66VF8YLHj 4- 0 020^826F3Af8Y3A:ZG\j)E º A ¨ ²¯ ¨ j G\@A3%66F W4-E\823A6D4?0
m· + LHm=FHG;u3%E;EH77094?668^6@¦4?6>C4%LZE\823A6t¥ #}!2$z!Yv?e¥g H!ieZ NeMjt.RT(ºd*>ºH¨ j7º %§ (
G1FHG;UFH4?0^8Y6 :ZB jD E\º KDAC ¨BW 3?PVu3 CRF-:D3?P>4?6D4-023A@%8YL4?0 G\F-4A:<3%6V826@V 4¯&G;FHD3%G;E )j G m·j s 82G\0^826@Ao3-XFH6tj
3-P 4AFH4?02G\89°V:NG K>! L 26>FH4?6r023Aj @% 8^F-4%:4-G\°D°FHG E KD! -L F2FHFH656tjtVºG\3%3? Pz : *4·LH4%:JF¥:<E;KDCRB l ¯ FHD3%G\E ¯ +¯MºH.Rj³=68^XFHG#:J82EJB
¯ HF¯J02¨8Y:Z( jt=I6VoD82X4?6VFHGM@%:<F82EJB3?P·3-PG\FH V4AG\4?F-G;:J°FHG6RKD!EML4?2E;82F3%6t6j 8^64%4-E\G\o°FG 3%KD! G\L F2 FH6tjQVG\º 3-AXR 8^ 6 @¤° B4-6D4?0^3%@%B l ¯ FHD3%G\E
$YcD e¦ FH#0^}8Y:ZJ !2$z=!Yv?3 e¥- g UH!i4?eZE;oNFHe¥Ug 4- E\H8Y!iLZe#8Y$z4??6>j:>V4?@%G\3-F+X: FW§ E\.?oV,?FH* 3%§ G;.AFHkRUj :N E; 0Y64-6R EM4Ry j G16 FH<3Ax·G\@A$YcD8Y4¦e
"%2jV{Iº % d,x- eZyded Ne <x
q4? D FHG FH0^=8Y:Z3U (- 6D4-jt0213A@%6B82X¯JCRFHGMG;82:<X8^E<FHB63-PG;I33?CRPY82¯z6 °0YK4-6G;@%otLN3%j 6>W:<E\G;m=KDLNFE;82EH3%jD6rm=F F-EHL#Do3?6P 89 LH4?G\0 E\8T]³LNF89f4?3A0 G\ E6RE;m FH020^82 @AFH6DF-LN:JFF-j 4?IGMLdCo ¯

8^6R°VKG\@Aotjtº A%
µdR $J eZyNFHV02"%89:N$&! "%u{ 3 _ CRFH!Y0R3-$±P³4? 6>4?d02x-3AeZ@%ydBed¯J C NG\e 82XF6
G;3y#$&3?! PY¯zH!Y0Y"%4-{=6uµZLN 3A$<6De#:<{^{TE;!aG\}RKDeZLZE\N82e#3Aj·6tD 4?6 @AF- : y ºNk%e#.+e;*>hºH!Y%k }? ' j < x$Y3AcD6Re E;G\% F-04-$Y0&c j
º %A
w yM ¸H'#FHc 0289N:¡ 4-6D¤C I "?'-, e#+bi¢1F02"?3'-:Je;3h e;6D"?'4?0^3%@%!YB%}%UjD74 4-2@%F-F-:1:¥ºHG\H3*D3-º-Pz:(j PF- 4AF+:<4?8^E\°E;0202FF j³º A6 ,m
oD4Rj7F+CR82E;3%GHj =1 µ#b
1#c % { #}FH?G\XjD8YA:1.R4?ak 6D C*>º%º jIº3 :;Ldk orº% 4-E\FH@A3%G\/8 .-4?E;823A6 3-P 4?E\KVG#4?0 4=° \F+LNE#:Z "%{ eZvH!ieZw <x '-b
@ 8^020&g³H'Z$<eZ
<x¹ #}! 76OµdfU %{^{2e N$Je;h ¶ yM¸H' <x _ ?cVgD$ R"y#$ ` !2{2{ %/{ 6 rµ;µ\µ ¢ ?¸
µ;µ\µMI=682XFG#:<8^EJB
3?P 3AG\3%6 E\37G\F-:;:NjDt3%G;3%6 E\3jt4?6>4%C4 jOº (- jf]DGM:<EK°V028Y:JoF-CºHk(-
@AtFH3%6 FHGM 4?0^8 .- 4-E\8^82E#3AL#6to FH02 0zj K689Ld8ToDPBR4-8^G#6C @
X 82 1F l -¥FH 020^` FHGH" j-d4-cV6D!YC feW U¹qe;4%"CyN4-GQ!YAW}% j)l ºAF-/,RCV(Z4?* G<kA¯;¨Rj74?°Dº FHk0^02§ 8z 7®R094?6D4-E\8^3%6R¯z°D4%:JF-C
@ 3:JE\3 -¥Wm1F-:<8^@%6° B±CRFHG;82XA4?E;823%6>4?0q4?6D4-023%@AB) :\:JKF-:=8^6UE\oF4?KE;3%U4-E\F-CUG\FH094HB 3-PCRF-:J82@A6
V0Y4?6>:N yd$z! H!Y"%{)µdR$<eM{2{T!a}Red +eMj),¨ ºd¯n M2ºAº *>º-k?,Vjº k

E;@oT1F-:J 8Y:NjDK16 6B82FHXGHFH GM:<8Ê<VB·"%3?{ #P}
4-"?02'8TP"3%G\` 6V8Ye;4R"j ' 4?6<x E#4u·I! ' G\K .v?j³eZyZº
kR!Yº% y )N{2eZ g %{Tv!Y%}u"h¹qe;"yNV!Y%}%³o>m
=1F -FH020>4?6DC 8û3%6t R" y )N{2ed g %{TvH!YA}%I7G\FH6 E\89LNFN¯ W4?0^0&j76@A021F -33 C I028Tpr:Nj
A@jtº (+.R
(-¨
ºH¨ §?
ºH¨(
ºHÄk
ºH¨ ?
º%º¨
º%ºAº
º%º.
º%º
º%ºZ,
º%º ?
º%º §?
º%º-(
º%ºk
º%º ?
ºH.A¨
ºH. º
ºH.A.
ºH.A
ºH.-,
· @ 1820Y:;:<3A6t yN!Y !/¡D{2e\' <x yd$z! H!Y"%{)µd!2$<eM{2{T!a}Red +eM=8^3%@4RjD74-023 02E;3jf jtº kA¨R
²Q #¡DeZyZ1!Y53?X eZ8YRL$z2¦"%{4?6> C ' l dc @%{ #=}3A02B¹734e;"2)yZ !Y%4-}7E\ oFUeZ4?E;8YyZLH4-0f"VG\h3%°V 02FH# }:<!2$z3A!02X R826jt@ºN,V° aBU 4?k+6>*,4?02º 3A @%jIBº %_ º% yN"%{ <x
`

D ¶ 3A G\4·E\yM8^¸[3%W'#6Dc 4?4-NGM0¡ 4R4- 6D 4?0^3%u@%B3 "%C{ dFH}G;073%!#3?°"%P10^{7FHE;U"oF:Nh -µZ G\6 F-hCRl F+:\N©LNO$z!YG;v?82e@E;4?µd8263%dx-E6 2eZ y#FeZj³V G\F-N3 CRe#LN82j E;F-3%s :;G:FHj G\8^0^6¤ 826ty E\jDoNº Fe#%e; LNh.3A!YA6R}?E; 'FH®RG\<E¥8^x63-@%$´P1cDFHeG@% FHµZ3A u$<eZFHyZE\G;"%8YL
$z!G;3?"%¯ {
4 -FH6t "%{ d}x y $ "%$Je;h e;"?' !Y%}A LH4%C FHu8YL7G;F-:\:Zjtº % ¨R
3-QPI ²QG\F+DLN7K82G#G;:J3%820^X028QF14?6>G\C3A@%@GM4? u u 8^6D6CR@FH:GM2R:<3%8^026r09:NWIo"F¥VG\"3Ah02!YF¥"3?PI_ 0^F-4?G;yN6V82"%6V{ @ <x PG;3% ' #FHc ®V%4?{ #}?02jDF-:I 826Ua.-,E\¨HoV* F
.4A(+1L .RjIKº 8Y:J82k E\ 8^3% 6
m·%70Y4-8Y:JE\F-C)oFH3%G;FH«G\3-X 826@ -8Ê\o4?°D:JE\G#4ALNE\8^3%6t y#$&! H!Y"%{µdR$Je#{2{T!a} eZ Ne#j)º § /, (N*>ºH¨%k j)º kRºA
G·Q3%02B 4 ` "%$ćDeZ"%$z! d'|"h {T" %'! N{2e e;"?' V!Y%}%D7G\8^6DLNFHE;3%61682XFHGM:<8Ê<B7G\F-:;:Nj A@jRº % ,V
G·DO3A02B 4 w $ g %{Tv-e!2$.-6DC F+C)m=3AK°0^F-C4HBj =1F - 3%G 2)j³º % (
8Y L#oRE;FHG4-6DsC ªF-:\:Z 82u 8^0Y4?G;82EJBjK6DLZFHG\EM4?826 EJBj4-6DCLH4A:<FN¯z°D4%:JF-CG\F+4%:<3A6826V@58^6 ¯
m¢{2 e;h?' %e# 6 l 02K- FH Gj)º 3-%B FHºAGH jF-CR82E;3%Gj $ "%$Je;h e;"?' !Y%} '#'"H'!Y Ry <x ¶ -h
²Q"V h 82DDeZ:Zy #"% {)6DCR¢KDe\LZcVE\"82vHX!F \y#KDjtCRºN@A,VFH §%u§AFH*6 §E#:1kRºA4?jI°Dº3%KV( E
6D 4-E\KGM4?0LH4?E;FH@%3AG\8^F-:N _ yN"%{ <x feZy #"%{7¹7e;"yZ!Y%}
²Q ' d c=6 73-XR¹789e;L "2³yZ !Y%6D}4? 0^3%` @%89eZLH4?0 E\yZGM¦4?6D":&PhFHGHjAdG\}3A°!2$&02FH! jt:J82ºNu, 8^0Y4?MG; 82EJºB¨+jZ* 4? 6>.%C
¨ jIFH®Rº D FHkAG;kRE\ 89:<F _ RyZ 6<x #¡DeZyN!Y 6
3:;Ldot 4?E\KVG#4?0QL4?E\F@%3%G;82F-:Z
#}V!2$&!Yv?e ' dc %{ #}?j,VaA.%k+* ¨Rj7º (-
Ld o3A3026:\89L#L ot2³tjt7F-G\CR3A8Ê\E\3%3%EJGB j D<·F¥eZLNw 0Y4A:\~:Jy#8 eZ]³LHh?4-' E\8^3%!Y6U4- 6DC5 N023Ae&¡D@%89$ LHR4?"%0r{ LN 0Y4Ae&:\¡³:<y#8T]³e\'-LHeZ4-RE\82$z3A"%6t$&! 7DoVFWOE cV-"%3·{2{êZ:<%BV}R:<E;e\FH' U$ :N 6!Y"H}Re# l$ '
~)cDe yZ j D4?@AF-:W(-+*k § )7G\0^°D4?KVj=8^0209:\C4-02Fj Hj³º kAR
@ K>:\:<F020& 6D4-023A@%B¦°RB¦:J82u8^0Y4?G;82EJB 6m
=FH0Û4?6rj%F-CR8Ê\3%Gj "%{ #}! #"%{ e;"?' !YA}%jRD4-@%F-:
. º#* . §A l 02K-FHG LH4ACRFHu89LKV°0289:<oFHGj)º k%k
@ K>:\:<F020&~)cDe '-e <x w{2e;hH} e·!Y V"%{ #}"h µdh Z$&! RQ782E;U4?6rjR²D3%6DC 3%6tjtº k
2©ºAm
º *> ºH4% LN FHjIGMCRº 3% E;(H8&,¥ 70Y4-668^6@u826 45o8^FHG#4-G#L#oRBu3-P4?°D:JE\G#4ALNE\8^3%6 :<D4ALNF-:Z yd$z! H!Y"%{tµZR$Je#{^{T!a}ReZ He#j
4- 15 °V G\8YLdC oD@%4-F¥6 2³=E 6V82·XFHAGM:<82"EJB¦! 7 G\F+` :\:NeZj) 4-yZ5 °VG\ 8YC @%~)F¥cD7e 6yZ@A 0Y4?<6>xuC)¹7jtºe;" yZk%.R!Y %} !Y e N¡D{2e±"h =¡ $<eZy\'Z
3A%@@AjtFHº G 1k § L#oD4?6 2)) #¡D{T"V"%$&! "%$i$JeZyZ'Z)²³14 -G\FH6>LNFW7G;02°D4-K :;:<3 LN894?E;F-:Nj 6DLA2)j =8^0209:\C4-02Fj
m·gre# $i$z!Y %}±L#o!Y 3%! 6tg HG=!Y"%F{ 6 FHG#%4-{T!E\H8^X F
` ue#FH$z"NEM¡4?c oVy3%GH" V h 6 ~) c 5-41}?G\c E;$3%j6 DB4?j)@AF-F-C :W82E\º 3A GH,?j * .Ak% OeZy\'J4?¡f¦e Z°$&G\!Yv?89CRe @%F = 68^y X)FHNG#{2ed:J82
EJB b
7G;F-:\:Zj)4?¦°G\89CR@%FjV l j)º (
(º
ºH. ?
ºH. §?
ºH.(
Iedor!2 $´' dLdcVoyZ-! xZ4-$fGx . y KV'G dfc FC%.H{ 6T8 jt]º2 X, 3A 6uº7M72º-G (N2* FH.A6R6 jIKº 6 @k :J§ G\3(.HF-:;:<FH6¦°DFH8DU4?E;oFHU4-E\8Y:;Ldo =3 L#oR°DFH@4?°E;FH6t
1¢|"? '-e; h F8 e;P"?FH'G;EH !YG1%3}A4?jR0YD:4-82@%6UF-:1G;FH u (N826>* CR 82§%6 @j :N 4? 6 6 y 4- E\NFHe#3Ve;j)h!Y% }-'j)<º x¥ kA$YkRcDeI 3% G\ @4?)6 l ¶ 4?K Py\U¸H'#4?c 6N6r¡ ¤I"?'-eMb
1Ne# e; h!Y A}? 'FH8 P<Fx G\E¥$ćD4-eU6DC {2l eZv?T1eZ J $ć G=GM 4HB dx-eZy#FeZ G\NF-e :JFH<6 x±E#4?$YE;cD82e3A6D 4?0I#}8Y:;:<!2K$z!YF+v?:e 826g H4?!ieZ6> 4?N023Ae@%89g LH 4?H0!ie#E\$zG#?4-j16D:nDP4?F@AGHF-:U 6 %¨H* y %(bj
1820209:\C4-02Fj I@jtº k ³G;02°D4-K
ºH.Ak sº L G·#^ ºH82¨-0^X, FHG\*>UºH¨4-( 6t jI º 6Dk%4?R0^3% @%BU8^6:<BV:<E;FH U4-6D4?@AFHuFH6 EHµ;I ~Vy\"' 6 ` ""hI= NedyNfeM$&! d'Zj
z§

ºH. ? ©| u8^E\o4?6DCm
T²Q F-CR8^6tQI"%$<e} yN!ie\'"Vh5 Ne&¡D$Y'Z W4-G\XA4?GMC5=6V82XFHGM:<82EJB7G\F-:;:Njº kRºA
ºHA¨ s e;"? ' ¦BR!YE;%o}%j4?>6D4?C @%F+ :=.A©W¨ *l .%.AF-¨R4-6j Fs FHG;028^6tFHE;j)G\º 82FXR8^,V6 @4%G\C8^4-6@%E#FH4-G° 02F LH4A:<F-:Z 6 ~ N¡³! #'!Y«I"?'-e#bi¢|"?'-e;h

% ºH º s E\FH8^6tj l Rª 4HBj ©| s FH668^6@?]>FH0YC)jV4?6DC1 =F+CR@%F-LZ3%K@AotI3%6D:JE\GM4?826 E#:3%6 :<D3%6 ¯
EM4?6F3%KD:E\GM4?6D:&PFHG=8^6UG\3A°02FH¦¯J:J3%02X 826V@
E#4A3: 2V:N ` eZ yN¦"h #}V!2$&! RjQºN,V/,%.+*,%,Vº%jIº k §
ºHA. @ E\FG\6 °fFG\@ I3%uD3%6VFH6REG;3 LNF-:;:<F-: 8^6 4?6D4-023A@%8YL4?0G\F+4%:<3A6826V@ ' dc 6 eZvH!ieZwOj
k-, B, #© +* (-k jº (A(
ºHA QFHE\FHG E;3%6Fj 4-6RKVFH0Y4 +I FH0^3:J3jU4?6>C @%82 s 0^BRE;oF oF6FHF-C P3AGCR8 p³FHG;FH6RE CR3AU4?8^ 6R¯
8^ 6D{TCR"FHVDFH!Y6>%}CRFHg³6 HE='Zo$<edFKG\'Z89j:<E\D894?LH@A:NF- :6 º § ,-*Dy º N§Ae# e;j,h@%!Y%KV}?6' F¦<º x%$´ cD,e¥ gte huµZR$JeZyZ"%$&! V"%{= #x-eZydeZ Ne µ
ºH-, Q1oD4?@4?G#C³ oF @AG\F-4-E\F-:JE±4?6D4-023%@A82F-:U826E;oF o>:<E\3AG\B 3?P :\LN8^FH6DLNF I""h!Y" y#$&! !Y"%{
µdR$Je#{2{T!a} eZ He#jtD4?@AF-:ºZ,?*.%¨RjQº A
ºH ? QDoD4?@4?GMC)j l @ =3A02B34 2)j G· =FH09:<3A6tj4-6DCUm
G13 LdoRPF0YC) 6D4?0^3%@G;FHE\G;82FHXA4?0³°RBLN3A6D:<E;G#4?8^6RE
:;4?E;8Y:nPz4ALNE\8^3%6t y#$&! !Y"%{)µZR$Je#{2{ !a}ReZ He#j), § a. % * Rº¨RjIº A ¨
ºH §? DXFHG#: 2RB F-4?E;KG\F-:3-PI:J82u8^0Y4-G\82EJB ' dc 6 eZvH!ieZwOj³k?, , #aA.(Z* .RjIº (%(
ºH( g>$ -h!ieZ\ 3%> R73 y=-¥¹ #m=}82! F ¸ WhReZ4?y¥KVw7E<! P'#3%'-G;eZu' FH#6¥cVK"<xZ6D$iC{T! #¯zcDG\FeZ@% FH0^6yMCR¸FHeZGR $z6D4-! 'Z023A @% 82F+2A:\4AL#CRoFH0 uKD! :\8^:JF F+I FH6 G;0YG·4?@V j l s G FH3%! G;°D02FH8^6tGj%jDF-º CR8^E\(3A GHj
%§
ºHAk @©m
m·7jt1º 0202kA ¨R 4?66t yN!Y !/¡D{2e\' <x ·"%$z)" #"?'-eg³+'Z$JeZ'Z I3AuKE;FHG LN8^FH6DLNF¦7G\F+:\:Nj 3 L 2RX 820^02Fj

ºH ? +4ACRFHG#4 t7G\33-P7° B4-6D4?0^3%@%B826¦5KGM4?0z # yZ"%{ 'J¡De N$´' <x· =¡ $&!Y%}Ajf(^ºHkA+* .A¨ § jOº %%
ºN,¨ l ) +4?6)²DFo6u4-6DC ) @%3A6F-:Z s FHE\E;FHG70^F-4?G;6FHG#:7KD:JFW4-6D4?0^3%@A8YLH4-0)G;3%°0^FH:<3A02X 826@·:<>4?G\8^6@%0^B
-6 , j y Ne#e;ohFH!YG#%:J}?EH' j <x $YcDj³eº %~D eZRR$Yc µZ3%RG;$J@eZ4?yZ6"%l $&! 4-KRVP"%U{O4?6V6t#x- eZydeZ Ne ` " dcV!Yfe¹qe;"yNV!Y%}%j-D4?@AF-:I%%kH*
ºN,Vº eZ4-v?6Re#KV{ NFH¡³0Y$4 5+IedRFH$i0^3:J3G\4?8^6D6C @%FG @A+I6DFH4?G;0YG 4?@V j 4?4uLN3 E;3%CR°DEjFHG¥F-CRº 82E;3%GM:N I"?'-e#bi¢1"?'-e;h e;"?' !YA} e\'-e;"y dc¬"h
A%§
(-.
ºN,. @%8^ 4-6RKVs FH0^BR0Y4E;o+IFFH 0^3 6R:<3VE;FHj@%@GM4-4?82E;u826F¥@4?09G;4?°f63A6V6826FH@¦0^0&j 4- 6DC 0^F-024?8YG;LZ68Y4¥826@VFH7G\F1.ojF·mW 4-6824FH0 m s G3%G;G#4 \4?3VGMLdjDo8Ê\KVF-@%LZFHE\6KF G;FO 8^62³jyN4?V6>"%C {
_
<x M¡fedyN!Y5eZ $&"%{q"h¤~)cDe yde#$z!#"%{ yd$z! H!Y"%{tµZ $<e#{^{T!a}ReZ Ne#j7( º#©kRºd*>ºH.A¨RjIº A%
ºN, 5 +IFH0^3:<3V ¹7e;"yZ!Y%} H "%{ #}! #"%{ e;"?' !Y%} !Y WeZfeZy;"%{ y )N{2ed g %{TvH!YA}% o>m
E;oF-:J8Y:Nj)4-G\6F@%82F FH0^023A6U=68^XFHG#:J82EJB)j
jD782E\EM:<°KVG\@%orjD j³º % .R= ¯\ ¯ .H¯#º-(H,V
ºN,A, 6 y 1 +I76FH02<3x:<$´3cD eO$z0^wFH®e#{82xZ°$Yc0^F7<¥:JE\"%G#$z4-! E\FH@A"%B¥{t02 F-4-G\#6x-8êZ6yd@eZ N e 6D4- 023A @%8YydL$z4?! 0 HG\!YFH"%{09µZ4HBW$<3?e#PD{^{T!aV}RG\eZ3% °V+02"eFH %('):<'13A002Xj 826F-@4?E;FE\0^F8Y:Jj?3 ª CRF- :Nj
º % ,
ºN, ? 3A G 2³jtB +Iº FH0^3,:< 3V {T"!YA}"h5¹qe;"yN!YA} H "%{ #}! #"%{ e;"?' !Y%}% G\8^6@%FGHj s FHG;02826rj =1F %
ºN, §?L4%:< F·4A5 L1+IFHKV0^8Y3:<:<8Ê\3 8^3%4?6t6>jVC :<E\@3A?G#G·4-@%Fj³4-4?G\6D°DCU3%6KFE\8^02020&8/ .-4?m=E;82FH3%G\6r8^XA 4?E\8^"3%6D#cV4-!Y0Wf4-eW6D¹74?e;0^3%"@AyZB¬!Y%8^6}%jt º¨R©.?4, m * G.(-kRjqº KVE\R3% 4?E\8^6@
%
`
ºN, ( '10 7 +Ww 8^02yM094+¸]D'#c 3ANG\82¡EM4W4?±6>!YC R$JeZy\ " NFH$z°D!Yv?4%e¥:JE\'89+4?'Z6$J8zeZD'ZG;j 33?PQU:J09E\4?FH6GM6VC824?6 @Wj° Bº 4-°D,:< E;G#4ALNE\8^3%6t 6 y Ne#e;h!Y%}?' µMb
A
ºN,k X F; G#+I:<8^3EJBu:<67894%G\CRF+3A:\:NKjt4?º 6DkC 5 41G\E;3%6 Bug³!Y!2{T"yZ!2$&±"h "%{ #}! #"%{ e;"?' V!Y%}% 4-5°VG\8YC @%F¦=68T¯

ºN, ? %ª 4?09CR826@AFHGH Ldo8^FH X 826@:<FHXFG#4?0 @%34?09::<8^5KV02E#4-6FH3AKD:<0^B 6 ·) @ =8^0Y:\:J3%6¦4-6DC s Aª FH °V°fFGHj
F+ CR 82E;jt3%ºG#:Z j k º% e;"h!Y%}?'!Y y#$z! H!Y"%{%µZ $<e#{^{T!a}ReZ +e#jD4-@%F-:Q. ¨+*.(ºA 3%G;@4-6 l 4?KRP 4?6tj%²D3: 0^E\3:Nj
º ¨ @ %ªFH82E .HFH6RPF0YC) +4-0289C
G\F-4A:<3%6V826@·°RB4?6D4-023%@AB cV!2{ ?' N¡cV <xg H!ieZ NeMj º%^ºH(N*DºZ, jOº k?,V
º º Q 7ª8^6D:<E;3%6t«²DF-4?G;6826V@¤4-6DC G\F-4A:<3A6826@ °RB4?6>4?023A@%B RV! #"%$&! ' <x±$YcDe ` j
.A ºH. M § k *V(-¨Ajº kA¨R
º . ²QIA0^8 ª pr:N3jt:Nº kAkR$ "%$Je;h e;"?' !Y%}R *)*=¢1"?'! e\'-e;"y dc y )Z{2eZ'Z7G;FH6RE;8YLNFZ¯ W4-020zj-6V@%02CF -33 C

º @ oD4-6@ F02F-LNE;826@E<B 89LH4?0Q826D:JE#4-6DLNF-:W826826>:<E#4-6DLNFN¯z°D4A:<F-C02F-4-G\68^6@ 6m
0^FHFHU4-64?6>C
Q¹qe;"IyNVBC !Y-%4-}%G#jCD:Z4-j=@%F-F-C:82,RE\3A(+G#¨+:Z*j , ( y j N e#4?e;6 h!Y A}?4?' E;FH<3xj)$Y cDe j³<¥º !YAR $Y.Rc µZ $<eZyZ"%$z! "%{U¶ yM¸H'#c N¡ ` " dcV!YDe
(-

Download Report

Analogy in Problem Solving - CMU School of Computer Science

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz