One Stop Shop For Educators The following instructional plan is part of a GaDOE collection of Unit Frameworks, Performance Tasks, examples of Student Work, and Teacher Commentary for the American Government course. American Government Unit 6 – “Why THIS type of government? How did we get here?” Elaborated Unit Focus The idea behind this unit is that students, with all the working knowledge they have acquired the first 5 units, can now take a critical look at how our form of government came to be. By focusing on beliefs and ideals, students will get a better understanding of decisions made at the Constitutional Convention, the historical basis for our government, and the fundamental principles found in the Constitution. By revisiting distribution of power, students will have a better understanding of checks and balances and separation of powers, as well as a framework for comparing our government with other styles of government. The concept of rule of law appears in this unit to help students understand the need for a constitution, the case of Marbury v. Madison, and historical documents that influenced the writers of the Constitution and Declaration of Independence. Standards/Elements SSCG1 The student will demonstrate knowledge of the political philosophies that shaped the development of United States constitutional government. a. Analyze key ideas of limited government and the rule of law as seen in the Magna Carta, the Petition of Rights, and the English Bill of Rights. b. Analyze the writings of Hobbes (Leviathan), Locke (Second Treatise on Government), and Montesquieu (The Spirit of Laws) as they affect our concept of government. SSCG2 The student will analyze the natural rights philosophy and the nature of government expressed in the Declaration of Independence. a. Compare and contrast the Declaration of Independence and the Social Contract Theory. b. Evaluate the Declaration of Independence as a persuasive argument. SSCG3 The student will demonstrate knowledge of the United States Constitution. a. Explain the main ideas in debate over ratification; include those in The Federalist. b. Analyze the purpose of government stated in the Preamble of the United States Constitution. c. Explain the fundamental principles upon which the United States Constitution is based; include the rule of law, popular sovereignty, separation of powers, checks and balances, and federalism. SSCG4 The student will demonstrate knowledge of the organization and powers of the national government. a. Describe the structure and powers of the legislative, executive, and judicial branches. b. Analyze the relationship between the three branches in a system of checks and balances and separation of powers. Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 1 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved One Stop Shop For Educators SSCG16 The student will demonstrate knowledge of the operation of the federal judiciary. b. Examine how John Marshall established the Supreme Court as an independent, coequal branch of government through his opinions in Marbury v. Madison. SSCG19 The student will compare and contrast governments that are unitary, confederal, and federal; autocratic, oligarchic and democratic; and presidential and parliamentary. Enduring Understandings/Essential Questions Students will understand that in a democracy, rule of law influences the behavior of citizens, establishes procedures for making policies, and limits the power of government. How does the idea of rule of law manifest itself in the Constitution? In what ways is our idea of rule of law influenced by previous political philosophers? Students will understand that distribution of power in government is based on documents and laws that specify structure combined with contemporary values and beliefs. How effective is the Constitution at distributing power in terms of checks and balances and separation of powers? How does the American distribution of power compare with other forms of government around the world? Students will understand that the beliefs and ideals of a society influence the social, political, and economic decisions of that society. What ideals were in conflict in regards to the ratification of the Constitution? How have the beliefs and ideals found in our early government documents changed or remained the same through our country’s development? Sample Balanced Assessment Plan Description of assessment GPS After reading excerpts from the Declaration of Independence and after some class discussion on social contract theory, have students complete a graphic organizer comparing the two. Once complete, have students assume the role of someone living in the colonies in 1776 who has read the Declaration. They will evaluate in their journal how well the document persuaded them to support the cause for independence. 2 After discussion and assigned reading, have students create a brief skit involving someone who is pro-ratification and someone who is antiratification. 3a Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 2 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved Type of assessment *Informal Observation *Dialogue and Discussion *Constructed Response *Self-assessment *Informal Observation *Dialogue and Discussion *Constructed Response One Stop Shop For Educators Quiz matching connecting certain powers/responsibilities to their correct branch of government. Include a short answer question where students analyze the relationship. 4 Students make a case brief for Marbury v. Madison and create a two stanza limerick describing the importance of the case in terms of separation of powers. Multiple Choice quiz on various government types. 19 1. The instructor should have provided background notes and discussion on how the Supreme Court hears cases and defined judicial activism and judicial restraint for the students. 2. Distribute to the students the following handout found in Vital Statistics on American Politics by Harold W. Stanley and Richard G. Niemi. This handout illustrates the Supreme Court’s use of judicial review to overturn both federal and state and local laws. SSC G16 a, SSC G16 d, SSC G5f Years 1789-1799 Federal Laws 0 State/Local Laws 0 1800-1809 1 1 1810-1819 0 7 1820-1829 0 8 1830-1839 0 3 1840-1849 0 9 1850-1859 1 7 1860-1869 4 23 1870-1879 7 36 1880-1889 4 46 1890-1899 5 36 Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 3 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved *Informal Observation *Dialogue and Discussion *Constructed Response *Selected Response *Informal Observation *Constructed Response *Self-Assessment *Selected Response One Stop Shop For Educators Years Federal Laws State/Local Laws 1900-1909 9 40 1910-1919 6 118 1920-1929 15 139 1930-1939 13 93 1940-1949 2 58 1950-1959 5 60 1960-1969 16 149 1970-1979 20 193 1980-1989 16 162 1990-1999 20 51 3. Students are to then answer the following questions on a separate sheet of paper based on the information in the chart. a) Why does it appear the Court was less active in the early 1800s? Why were so few federal laws overturned? b) Why does it consistently appear as though the Court overturned more state and local laws than it did federal laws? c) What was going on historically during the times in which the number of laws overturned was high? This question could be used as two separate questions depending upon the type of laws examined. 4. Students will then discuss their answers with the class. 1. To reinforce material and notes already covered by the instructor on SSC the various forms of government, including representative and direct G19 democracies, parliamentary, confederal, federal, and oligarchic, students will research the various forms of government in the world and assess the most common types of government. For this assignment, students may work independently or with a partner. 2. Students are to locate as many types of representative democracies as possible. They are to list the country names, their leaders, how long their government has existed, and if the government has a constitution. They are to identify at least five representative democracies. Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 4 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved Constructed response, Selected response, teacher observation One Stop Shop For Educators 3. Students are then to identify as many types of monarchies as possible and determine if these monarchies are constitutional in nature. They are to identify at least three monarchies. 4. Students are then to find at least three communist governments. As in steps one and two, students are to list the country names, leaders and length of time this government has existed. 5. Students are to write their answers on a separate sheet of paper. If they choose to work with a partner, they are to staple their work together for submission. 6. To assist students in identifying the countries of the world, they may use the following website: www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook. They are to click on “guide to country profiles.” They may select countries from the drop-down menu at random. There is some analysis involved here as they are to read their government profiles to determine what kind of government the selected country has. 7. Upon completion of the research, students should develop a reflective paragraph comparing/contrasting the most common types of governments they located and whether there was any relationship between government type, population size and Gross Domestic Product. 8. In the next class period, there can be a roundtable discussion of students’ findings led by the instructor. 1. Students are assigned Federalist #10 by James Madison to read. This document is found in the back of most American History and American Government textbooks. The instructor must convey to students that the Federalist Papers were the propaganda tool used to rally support in the Framers’ efforts to ratify the U.S. Constitution and that they are also used to gauge the intent of the Framers when they wrote the Constitution. 2. Students will take notes on what they think the author is saying as well as discuss the importance the document in both the development of the Constitution and our new form of government. Students will also answer a series of questions that they will summarize in the first half of their essay. Sample questions to be answered: 1. What are the advantages of the proposed government? 2. What is a faction? Why will society always possess factions? 3. What are the two methods of controlling factions? What are the causes of factions and why is it impossible to remove the causes of factions? 4. Thus, how does one control the effects of factions? 5. Why is a republic a superior form of government to a direct democracy? Compare and contrast the two forms of government. 6. Why is a larger republic the preferred form of government and how does a republic control the effects of faction? 7. How does Madison address the role of states and localities? Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 5 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved SSC G3a, SSC G3c Constructed response, selected One Stop Shop For Educators 8. Why does the Constitution resolve problems common to many republics? 9. Who was the intended audience for Madison’s arguments? How does he respond to critics of the Constitution? 10. Discuss Madison’s intent regarding the structure of the government and your beliefs regarding the role and direction of our government today. 3. For the next step in this assignment, students will compare and contrast the key themes of Federalist #10 with another Federalist paper or an Anti-Federalist paper of their choice. 4. Students will in the conclusion of their essay, determine whether the Federalists or Anti-Federalists was correct in their views on the role of government and defend their answer. 5. The day the three-page 500 word minimum double-spaced typed paper is due in class, the students will be given a surprise. Upon entering class, they will be engaged in an in-class debate. They will be assigned to the opposite side of the position they took in their paper as they debate the merits of the arguments of the Federalists and Anti-Federalists. By staging an in-class debate, students will be forced to consider both sides of the argument and think on their feet as the instructor queries them as to both sides of the constitutional debate. Additionally, an in-class debate may be considered a way for students who are better public speakers than they are writers to demonstrate analytical skills. Sample debate questions: 1. What were the arguments of the Federalists? 2. Why did the Anti-Federalists oppose the Constitution? 3. Why were the Articles of Confederation a failure? 4. Why did the Framers take power they weren’t given at the Constitutional Convention? Was this move justified? Why or why not? 5. How can states be reassured the new proposed government won’t be too strong? 6. What about the rights of citizens? Where are they guaranteed? 7. What do the Anti-Federalists have to offer the Federalists? 1. Students will read the Declaration of Independence, found in most SSC American History and American Government textbooks. This G2b document can also be found at the following websites: www.us.history.org/declaration or www.loc.gov. 2. In small groups, students will answer the following questions in complete sentences on a separate sheet of paper. 1. Who was the author of the Declaration of Independence? Why was he chosen? 2. Whose concepts did the Declaration of Independence draw Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 6 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved Constructed response, selected response , teacher observation One Stop Shop For Educators on? 3. What were people’s natural rights? 4. What changes were made to the idea of natural rights in this document? 5. How do governments obtain their power? What can people do if the government is not fulfilling its responsibility? 6. What do inalienable rights mean? 7. What does the phrase “all men are created equal” mean? What does it not mean? Who, significantly, was left out of this document? 8. In this first draft, what did Jefferson include? 9. Why was this section dropped? 10. When did the delegates vote the colonies were free? 11. When was the Declaration of Independence adopted? 12. Where was it read? 13. What Congress (First or Second Continental) adopted the Declaration of Independence? 14. What was a Loyalist? What was a Patriot? 15. What does the Preamble of the Declaration of Independence explain? 16. Why do the colonies have a right to abolish their destructive governments? 17. If it is the right of the people to abolish a destructive government, what are they then to do? 18. Who is “he” in the Declaration of Independence? 19. How has “he” mistreated the colonies’ representative government? 20. Why has “he” kept standing armies in the colonies? 21. What were the Intolerable Acts? 22. Does the author of the Declaration of Independence claim the colonies have tried to work things out with England? How so? 23. Why do the colonies hold the British as enemies? 24. Why should the United States of America be free? 25. What powers and rights do the colonies have as free and independent states? 26. Who will protect the colonists? 27. Why was John Hancock’s signature so large? 28. Who were Georgia’s representatives? Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 7 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved One Stop Shop For Educators 3. Students then use their answers to the above questions to evaluate the persuasiveness of the Declaration of Independence. Each group should be prepared to report back to the whole class. 4. In preparing the group’s evaluation, students should consider the purpose of the Declaration of Independence, discuss its significance and also for further analysis, students may research how the Declaration of Independence has influenced other countries and groups in their pursuit of freedom. The idea is to determine students’ knowledge of the background of the Declaration of Independence, its purpose, and its importance in American history and the ideals of American government. Students will also be asked to determine whether or not the charges in the Declaration of Independence were justified or not, and provide reasons from the document and time period defending their responses. Students will look at the Articles PowerPoint and fill out the strengths SSC and weaknesses T-Chart. They will explain in a paragraph how G 1a the beliefs and ideals found in our early government documents changed or remained the same through our country’s development. Students will identify and cite examples of the checks and balances of 3c, 4 the three branches of government and complete the graphic organizer Students will read excerpts from the Federalist papers and Patrick Henry’s anti-federalist speeches. They will debate the issues of ratification then and compare the arguments to issues of today. They will write an essay answering “How have the beliefs and ideals found in our early government documents changed or remained the same throughout our country’s development? Websites Federalist papers: http://www.foundingfathers.info/federalistpapers/ Summary and analysis of the Federalist Papers: http://www.foundingfathers.info/federalistpapers/ Anti-Federalist papers: The Address and Reasons of Dissent of the Minority of the Convention of Pennsylvania to their Constituents Speeches of Patrick Henry http://www.constitution.org/afp/afp.htm Other sites: http://www.let.rug.nl/usa/D/1776-1800/federalist/antixx.htm Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 8 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved 3a Dialog and discussion Constructed response Dialog and discussion Constructed response Dialog and discussion Constructed response One Stop Shop For Educators Students will watch the PowerPoint on the foundations of government. They will work in small groups, as individuals, whole class and finally on their own to create a chart, timeline, list and essay over the causes leading to the Declaration of Independence 1 a-b Informal 2b observation Dialog and response Constructed response Selected response Students will read about landmark court cases. They will put together 16 c Read and interpret a court case graphic organizer. From it students will create a chart Assemble a graphic of major court cases and determine the importance of these court organizer and copy cases to the rule of law. They will answer questions explaining Constructed how the Supreme Court is able to interpret, reverse, and use response selective incorporation in the decisions that are given in landmark Small group work cases. Websites used to create Supreme Court Case lesson: http://library.thinkquest.org/11572/cc/index.html Student will use a copy of the Declaration of Independence, read 1 a, Informal excerpts from the philosophers that influenced the writing of the b observation Declaration and compare their theories to the current 2a Constructed Constitution. Explain how parts of the constitution came directly response from the reading and experiences of the founders Create T chart showing the philosopher and the reference in the Declaration and write an essay answering the question “How have the beliefs and ideals found in our early government documents changed or remained the same though our country’s development?” The works that influenced the founders of the nation: The Magna Carta http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/featured_documents/magna_carta/ http://www.britannia.com/history/docs/magna2.html The English Bill of Rights http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/england.htm Petition of Rights: http://www.britannia.com/history/docs/petition.html Hobbes moral and political philosophy http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hobbes-moral/ http://www.iep.utm.edu/h/hobmoral.htm#SH5a John Locke theories http://www.philosophypages.com/hy/4n.htm Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 9 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved One Stop Shop For Educators http://www.constitution.org/jl/2ndtreat.htm Baron de Montesquieu http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/montesquieu/ Sample Test Items If the United States were operating today under the Articles of Confederation, issues concerning how to best clean up the environment would be handled by the A executive branch B judicial branch C national guard D individual states The United States system of checks and balances allows the A Congress to remove a member of the Cabinet B Supreme Court to declare a law unconstitutional C Supreme Court to remove members of Congress D president to remove the speaker of the House of Representatives In general the anti-federalists felt that the government created by the United States Constitution was too A strong and centralized B large and disorganized C protective of civil rights D weak to control the states The Magna Carta was important because it A was America’s first legislature B separated church and state C established limited government D gave power to the Colonies The Supreme Court power of judicial review began with the case of A Roe v. Wade B Plessy v. Ferguson C Miranda v. Arizona D Marbury v. Madison Read the following passage and answer the question ”But when a long train of abuses and usurpations , pursuing invariably the same object, evinces a design to reduce them under absolute despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such government…” Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 10 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved SSC G 1a D 3c, 4 B 3a A 1a C 16c D 1 a, b 2a A One Stop Shop For Educators This quote from The Declaration of Independence reflects John Locke’s theory of A the social contract B survival of the fittest C the separation of powers D equality in the state of nature Resources for UNIT 6 http://www.constitution.org/ - Contains links to documents that influenced the Constitution and Declaration of Independence and a wealth of other information. FOR SAMPLE PERFORMANCE TASKS FOR THIS UNIT, PLEASE VISIT http://www.georgiastandards.org/socialstudiesframework.aspx Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 11 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved One Stop Shop For Educators Articles of Confederation Lesson Enduring Understanding: Students will understand that the beliefs and ideals of a society influence the social, political, and economic decisions of that society. Essential Questions: How have the beliefs and ideals found in our early government documents changed or remained the same through our country’s development? Standards: SSCG1 a Time: two 50 minute periods One block period Materials Articles of Confederation PowerPoint Articles of Confederation T-Chart Directions: 1. 2. 3. 4. Show the Articles of Confederation PowerPoint and explain the strengths and weaknesses of the plan Have students complete the strengths and weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation T-Chart Students will write a paragraph explaining how the Articles of Confederation caused economic problems and led to the current Constitution Advanced students might be asked to analyze how the economic problems of this time period are reflected in the current economy. Is there too much or too little government aid? Question: If the United States were operating today under the Articles of Confederation, issues such as the effect of acid rain on the environment would be handled by the A executive branch. B Supreme Court. C Supreme Court. D individual states. Description of Assessment Students will look at the Articles PowerPoint and fill out the strengths and weaknesses T-Chart. They will explain how economic factors influenced the writing of the current constitution GPS SSCG 1 a Type of Assessment Dialog and discussion Constructed response Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 12 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved One Stop Shop For Educators Articles of Confederation T-Chart Strengths Name_________________________ Weaknesses______________ Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 13 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved One Stop Shop For Educators Foundations of Government Enduring Understanding: : Students will understand that the beliefs and ideals of a society influence the social, political, and economic decisions of that society. Essential Questions: In what ways is our rule of law influenced by previous political philosophers? How have the beliefs and ideals found in our early government documents changed or remained the same though our country’s development? Standards: SSCG 1 a, b SSCG 2 b Directions: 1. Watch the PowerPoint “Foundations of Government” 2. Assign pairs of students a topic to research Have them create a chart of the name of the background topic, date, a short description, and the significance of the topic (why is unimportant or how did it contribute to the desire to break from England. 3. Have student do a short presentation of the background topics. 4. Place the topics in the hall or around the room and have students do a walk about and complete the chart. 5. When students have completed the chart have them create a timeline of events and documents on the back. 6. Students will compare the chart to the list of grievances in the Declaration of Independence and generate a list of problems the colonists found with the British government. This can be completed as a whole class assignment 7. Students will write an essay comparing the list of grievances from the past with the current conditions today. Background leading to the writing of the Declaration of Independence Magna Carta English Bill of Rights House of Burgesses French and Indian War Mercantilism Magna Carta English Bill of Rights House of Burgesses French and Indian War Mercantilism 1st Continental Congress Committee of Correspondence American Revolution Declaration of Independence 2nd Continental Congress Articles of Confederation. Description of assessments Students will watch the PowerPoint on the foundations of government. They will work in small groups, as individuals, whole class and finally on their own to create a chart, timeline, list and essay over the causes leading to the Declaration of Independence GPS 1 a-b 2b Type of Assessment Informal observation Dialog and response Constructed response Selected response Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 14 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved One Stop Shop For Educators Historical documents and events up to the Declaration of Independence Date Event Name___________________________ Description Significance Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 15 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved One Stop Shop For Educators Complete timeline on the back 1. The Magna Carta was important because it A B C D was America’s first legislature separated church and state established limited government * gave power to the Colonies Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 16 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved One Stop Shop For Educators The Philosophers and the Declaration of Independence Enduring Understanding: : Students will understand that the beliefs and ideals of a society influence the social, political, and economic decisions of that society. Essential Questions: In what ways is our rule of law influenced by previous political philosophers? How have the beliefs and ideals found in our early government documents changed or remained the same though our country’s development? Standards: SSCG 1 a, b SSCG 2 b Time: 1 regular period ½ block period Materials: Computer internet, copy of Declaration of Independence Directions Student will use a copy of the Declaration of Independence, read excerpts from the philosophers that influenced the writing of the Declaration The works that influenced the founders of the nation: The Magna Carta http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/featured_documents/magna_carta/ http://www.britannia.com/history/docs/magna2.html The English Bill of Rights http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/england.htm Petition of Rights: http://www.britannia.com/history/docs/petition.html Hobbes moral and political philosophy http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hobbes-moral/ http://www.iep.utm.edu/h/hobmoral.htm#SH5a John Locke theories http://www.philosophypages.com/hy/4n.htm http://www.constitution.org/jl/2ndtreat.htm Baron de Montesquieu http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/montesquieu/ Read excerpts from the above listed titles and compare their theories to the Constitution. Explain how parts of the constitution came directly from the reading and experiences of the founders Create T chart showing the philosopher and the reference in the Declaration Philosopher Declaration Question: Read the following passage and answer the question ”But when a long train of abuses and usurpations , pursuing invariably the same object, evinces a design to reduce them under absolute despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such government…” Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 17 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved One Stop Shop For Educators 1. This quote from The Declaration of Independence reflects John Locke’s theory of A the social contract * B survival of the fittest C the separation of powers D equality in the state of nature Georgia Department of Education Dr. John D. Barge, State School Superintendent American Government/Civics Framework Unit 5 UPDATED 2/14/11 Page 18 of 18 Copyright 2011 © All Rights Reserved
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz