JACC Vol. 19. No. I March I5, 1992 :759-s4 759 METHODS Intravascular Ultrasound Imaging of Saphenous Vein Grafts In Vitro ; Comparison With Histologic and Quantitative Angiographic Findings JOHN E . WILLARD, MD," t DYMPHNA NETTO, MD ." SABA E . DEMIAN, MD,' DON R. HAAGEN . RCFL,v M. ELIZABETH BRICKNER . M U .rt ERIC J . EICHHORN . MD, FACC,*t PAUL A . GRAYBURN. M D . FACC*t Dallas, Texas The ubiquity of coronary artery disease and the resultant widespread use of saphenous veins for coronary artery bypass surgery has stimulated considerable interest in the morphologic and pathophysiologic alterations these vessels undergo after implantation, This study was undertaken to determine the ability of intravascular ultrasound to identify and chs :acterize abreormali . lies in saphenous vein grafts. Ten saphenous vein grafts excised at autopsy and nine saphenous vein segments harvested during coronary artery bypass surgery were examined with intravascular ultrasound imaging, quantitative overeat-3 a,lgiogrzphic techniques and histologic analysis . lntravasenlar ultrasound lumen measurements were strongly correlated with quantitative coronary arterfographic measurements (r 0.91, SEE 0.5 mm), Wall thickness was significantly greater in the vein grafts after bag-term implantation than in the freshly harvested veins (average thickness 1.4 m 0.5 vs. 0.7 = 0 .2 mm, p < 0,007); lhs0ndne ;veeelxted histeiogicatly with sum wall fibrosis . There was good correlation between ntlrasmmd imaging and histologic analysis, with the ability to distinguish among normal intim, iastimbi hyperpfaxia, vein wait fibrosis and atheromatous plaque. Thus, this preliminary study, deaaastrates the ability of mrra vascular titraseand to provide real-time crvvs-seetiomal images of saphenous veins land morphologic characterization of their was . This modality may have important clinical applications, including the ability to detect serial changes in vein graft iatimal hyperplasta and atheroscleross . (j Am Call Canna! 1992 ;19:759-64) The ubiquity of severe coronary ariery disease has resulted in the widespread use of reversed autogenous saphenous veins for coronary artery bypass surgery, Consequently, there is considerable interest in the morphologic and pathophysiologic alterations these vessels undergo after implantation . Histologic analysis of grafts excised at the time of reoperation or autopsy has revealed most of what is known about saphenous vein graft disease (1-3) . There have been several attempts to correlate cineangiographic findings with histologic analysis at variable intervals after implantation (4-6). Although these studies provide important assessment of saphenous vein grafts, cineargiography provides little more than a two-dimensional image of the lumen contour without a significant correlation with the volume of atheroma present or the pathologic changes in vessel wall morphology demonstrated by necropsy his- tologic studies (7-10) . These studies are further flawed by the extended time intervals between cine:aigiography and histologic analysis that frequently occur in human auiusy studies . thus allowing for considerah!e pathologic changes to From the •Cardiac Catbetedzation Laboratory and Department of Interml Medicine, Divisan tfCardialogy . Dallas Veterans Altars Medical Center and ttiniversily of Texas South-- Medical Center, Dallas, Texas. This study Was presented in pmt al the 63rd Scientific Sessions of the American Heart Association, Dallas . Texas, November 1590. Manuscript received Jane 25.1991 : revised manuscript received August 26 . 1991. accepted September 12. 1991 . Address for reprints: pant A . Graybum. MD. Division of Cardiology 011A, . Veterans Affairs Medical Cemer .4500Soulh Lamaaler Road. Dallas. Texas 75219, 01992 by the Anreacan Colks* or Cardwlogy occur between data points . An in vivo modality capable of accurately defining the morphologic features of saphenous vein grafts that evolve after implantation viould have goal clinical potential for identifying and chaexeterizing serial pathologic changes such as intimal hyperplasia and atherosclerosis, Intravascular ultrasound is an imaging modality that could potentially provide such information- Recent work has shown that it can generate detailed images from within the lumen of arteries (11) . distinguish muscular from elastic arteries and differentiate normal vegsrt wnlt from atherosclerosis (12-18) . Unfortunately, few data exist regarding the utility of in : avascular utrresoend imaging in sapheuous vein grafts . Therefore, the purpose of this in vitro study was twofold : I) to compare the ability of intravascular ultrasound imaging to accurately measure lumen diameter with that of quantitative angiography, and 2) to compare the ability of intravascular ultrasound imaging to distinguish among normal intima, intimal hyperplasia . vein wall fibrosis, and atheromatous plaque with that of histologic study . 0725-io97.5295 .00 760 IACC Vat . 19. No. 4 March 15, 1992 :759-64 WILLARD F.T At INTRAVASCULAR ULTRASOUND IMAGING OF GRAFTS l-P 0 tine r-0 .9t y =o.7s. .t .5 5EE=0 .0 mm Figure 1 . A saphenous vein s°gment w attached with a silk ligature at each end to an SF hemostatic sheath . The side arm of one sheath was connected ton fluid-filled pressure transducer calibrated to mercury . The other side arm was attached to a fluid reservoir containing a 50VVr, mixture of saline solution and iodinated contrast medium . The reservoir could he raised or lowered to maintain a constant irtraluminal distending pressure, (:incangiooraphy (tine) Figure 2. Relation between measurement, was performed with the intravascular ultrmound (IVUS) catheter diameter by intravascular ultrasound ly axis) and quantitative cor- positioned at the site of measurements . onary arteriography (QCA) (x axis) is depicted as compared by linear regression analysis . Other abbreviations as in Figure 1 . Methods . We examined 10 saphenous vein Experimental protocol grafts excised at autopsy and 9 freshly harvested saphenous vein segments obtained during coronary artery bypass surgery . The vessels were subjected to intravascular ultrasound imaging, quantitative coronary angiography and histologic study. A saphenous vein segment was attached with a silk ligature at each end to an 8F hemostatic sheath (Fig. U . The side arm of one sheath was connected to a fluid-filled pressure transducer calibrated to mercury. The other side arm was attached to a fluid reservoir containing a 50% mixture of saline solution and iodinated contrast medium . The reservoir could be raised or lowered to maintain a constant intraluminal distending pressure . We empirically used a constant pressure of 30 mm Hg to facilitate comparisons between the imaging modalities employed. The vessel was submerged in a water bath to allow for both intravascular ultrasound imaging and cineongiography . Intravascular ultrasound. A 4 .81' intravascular ultrasound catheter (Boston Scientific) was introduced into the sheath and positioned in the mid-portion of the vein . The catheter was operated at a carrier frequency of 20 MHz by a Diasonics Intravascular Ultrasound imaging console . This system employ s a mechanical transducer rotating at 900 rpm to image the entire vessel circumference at a 10° Irok . forward angle . Measurements of lumen dia tteter and wall thickness were made an-line by using the software package built into the instrument . Images were recorded on 0 .5 in.(1 .27-cm) VHS videotape . Quantitative aupiography . For each saphenous vein segment . single-plane 35-mm cineangiographic images were acquired. The cineangiograms were made with the intravascular ultrasound catheter still in position to allow for diameter measurement at the same site used by the ullrasouttd transducer. Quantitative coronary angiography was performed with use of a Tagarno projector interfaced with the Coronary Angiographic Analysis System . A calibration fac . for for image magnification was determined by caliper mea- 4 5 6 7 OCA Diameter Imm) of maximal (Max) lumen suretnent of the external diameter of the hemostatic sheath . Measurements of lumen diameter, with correction for pincushion distortion, were then made on-line as previously described (19,20) . Histology . After the final cineangiogram each vein segment was distended with 10% buffered formalin to the same distending pressure used for ultrasound and angiographic imaging. The vein segments were then submerged in formalie to allow for overnight fixation. Transverse sections were prepared from veins at specific sites where ultrasound images had been recorded, and at I cm intervals . The histologic sections were stained with hematoxylin-eosin, Verhoeff-van Gieson and Masson trichrome stains . The sections were then examined microscopically by a pathologist who had no prior knowledge of the ultrasound appearance of the vein segments . Statistical analysis . Maximal vessel lumen diameters obtoined by intravascular ultrasound imaging and quantitative coronary angiographic measurements were compared with each other by linear regression analysis to determine the standard error of the estimate (SEE) . The wall thickness, as determined by intravascular ultrasound imaging, of chronically implanted vein grafts was compared with that of freshly harvested veins by an unpaired Student I test . A p value < 0-05 was accepted as statistically ,ignificaat . Results Comparison of intravascular ultrasound and angiugrnphlc measurements . Figure 2 illustrates the relation between measurements of maximal lumen diameter by intravascular ultrasound ly axis) and quantitative coronary arteriography (x axis). Linear regression analysis revealed a strong correlation (r 0.91, SEE 0.5 mm) . Although these two imaging techniques were concordant in measuring lumen diameter, intravascular ultrasound was able to identify encroachment of the lemon by diffuse pathologic processes such as intimal hyperplasia . Conversely . angiography- which shows only JACC Val . 19. No.4 March 15. 1997 :759-64 the column of contrast medium within the vessel lumen . was generally unable to identify diffuse narrowing of the lumen . Freshly harvested vein graft morphology . Low power microscopy of a freshly harvested saphenous vein, performed with use of a Verhoeff-van Gieson elastic stain (Fig . 3), typically revealed a normal thin-walled vein with a widely patent lumen without evidence of intimal hyperplasia . The dark black fibers represent elastin, which probably accounts for the bright echogenic appearance on intravascular ultrasound imaging. A typical ultrasound image of a freshly harvested vein reveals a thin-walled vessel with an absence of echo reflectance within the vessel lumen . Chronically implanted vein graft morphology . Chronically implanted saphenous vein grafts may demonstrate a variety of pathologic changes . including intimal proliferation WILLARD ET AL. INTRAVASCELAR ULTRASOUND IMAGING OF GRAFTS 76 1 Figure 3. Left panel, Histologic cross-sectional view of a freshly harvested saphetlous vein stained with Verhoeffvan Gieson stain Imagnificalion X6 .25, reduced by 287c). A normal thin-walled vein with a widely patent lumen is demonstrated. The dark black fibers represent elaslin. which accounts for the bright echogeni- epy arance on intresascular ultrasound imaging (right panel). Note the absence of echo reflectance within the vessel lumen . Figure 4L Len pod, ilistotogic cross-sectional view ot a tong-tern implanted saphenous vein graft stained with Vedloei< van C`eson slain fmagnificalion x615, reduced by 359c) . Concentric thickening and sclerosis of the vein wall tract anon) and narrowing of the vessel lumen by inrirnal hypcrplasia (lbn arrow) are evident . Right panel, Intravascular ultraseund imaging revealed a bright highly relkCtive region that correlates with the llickened vein wall (rmdr ron) and a faint echolucent band within the vessel lumen that coeetaes with The intimat hyperplasia observed on histologic study (thin rmw)- 762 WILL ARD ET AL . INTRAVASCULAR ULTRASOUND IMAGING OF GRAFTS Figures . Len panel, Histologic cross-sectional view of a t0-year old saphenous vein graft stained with Verhoef-van Gieson slain (magnificalion x6,25, reduced by 28)5) . lmimal hyperplasia and atherosclerosis involving the intima and media (small arrows) with microcystic degeneration (thick arrow) are evident . Right panel, Ultrasound image from the same area of the graft reveals a highly reflective thickened vein wall (open arrow) with an echogenic atheroma from the 4 o'clock to the 9 o'clock position (small arrows) that coreiates with the plaque on Verhoeff-van Gieson staining . On intravascular ultrasound imaging atherosclerosis appears more heterogeneous than does intimal hyperplasia . Left panel, Magnification x6.25. reduced by 20W. and atherosclerosis . Figure 4 shows uniform narrowing of the vessel lumen by intimal hyperplasia . The vein wall itself is thickened and sclerotic in contrast to the freshly harvested vein seen previously. Intravascular ultrasound imaging revealed a bright, highly reflective region that cur relates with the thickened vein wall ; intimal hyperplasia appears as a faint echolucent band within the vessel lumen. Fix... 5 is u representtniv, ennnlple ofthe appearance of athernsclerosis. The ultrasound image of a 10-year old saphenous vein graft reveals a highly reflective . thickened vein wall with an echogenic atheroma from the 4 o'clock to the 9 o'clock position that correlates with the plaque on Verlloeff-van Gieson =laming (Fig . 3) . Inlimal hyperplasia is also present and appears as a faint echolucent band within the vessel lumen . Wall thickness was significantly greater in the vein grafts after long-term implantation than in the freshly harvested veins, Specifically • wall thickness averaged 1 .4 1 0 .5 nim in the old vein grafts versus 0 .7 *_ 0.2 turn in the new saphenous veins . As demonstrated histologically . this difference in vein wall thickness was due primarily to vein wall sclerosis . Despite the remarkable refinement of this technology and JACC Vo1 . 19. No. a March 15. 199175'4-64 miniaturization of the ultrasound catheters, their access is confined to lumens of moderate-sized diameter . Figure 6 illustrates a severely diseased portion of a graft that could not be imaged because of the small lumen diameter . Discussion Intravascular ultrasound imaging . This preliminary study demonstrates the ability of intravascular ultrasound to provide real-time truss-sectional images of saphenous vein grafts and to distinguish among the pathologic abnormalities of the vein graft wall that evolve after implantation . This new modality provides detailed information regarding the alterations in vessel wall morphology, thus allowing the detection of diffuse disease encroaching on the vessel lumen that would be missed by contrast angiography . Although this preliminary study involved a small number of vein grafts (especially those containing intimal lipid deposition), the correlation between histologic analysis and ultrasound images suggest that this methodology could be used to establish the sequential changes of autogenous vein grafts after implantation . This capability would eliminate the potential for histologic processing artifacts and the temporal disparity between cineangiographic and histologic analysis common LO autopsy studies . Three are sere,, nmrphologir aIterations that ran nrcur in m+tngenous vein grafts idler implantation into the arterial circulation : I) endothelial damage, 2) medial hypertrophy, 3) medial necrosis, 4) graft wall fibrosis (media and adventitia) . 5) intimal hyperplasia• 6) atherosclerosis, and 7) aneurysmal dilation (1) . This study suggests that intravascular ultrasound can distinguish between the normal appearance of freshly harvested veins and I) vein graft wall fibrosis JACC Vol. 19. No. J March 15 . 1992.759-64 IN rRAV,sSC LuL .R W I LLARD ET AL. t :LTBASOutuD rmAGtNG OF GRAFTS 263 Figure 6. Histologie cros •s ectional viof the graft depicted in Figure 5 . Note the extensive compromise or the lumen by severe vein graft atherosclerosis and disrupted intimal plaque . This view illustrates one of the limitations of intraluminal ultrasound in which severe lumen -wing presents justapositional maneuvering of the iruravascular ultrasound catheter . (media and adventilia), 2) intimal hyperplasia, and 3) atherosclerosis . Wall thickness. A marked increase in vessel wall thickness was detected among the chronically implanted saphenous vein grafts in comparison with wall thickness in the freshly harvested saphenous vein segments . Histologic analysis correborated this Boding and identified graft wall fibrosis as the primary pathologic lesion responsible for the increased wall thickness, with a very thin layer of intimal hyperplasia present and identifiable on intravascular imaging. It was also possible with microscopy to identify etastin within the vessel wall by the use of an elastic stain (Verhneff-van Gieson) and to correlate its presence with its bright echogenic appearance within the media on ultrasound imaging, Lumen diameter . The lumen diameters obtained from the intravascular ultrasound images in this study correlated closely with our angiugraphic measurements (Fig . 21. This finding is in agreement with the previously reported (211 comparison of intravascular ultrasound and quantitative coronary angiography in muscular arteries, However . it appears that this Close correlation may not be applicable after angioplasty . Angioplasty often results in tissue dissection planes that can fill with contrast medium, resulting in a hazy appearance on angiography that may lead to significant overestimation of the residual lumen (22-25) . We have not evaluated the accuracy of intravascular ultrasound measurements after saphenous vein graft angioplasty . Clinical implications . The ability to perform serial in vivo characterization of vein graft morphologic appearance would allow serial assessment of pharmacologic interventions directed at reducing the rapidity of vein graft failure and restenosis after vein graft angioplasty . The use of intravascular ultrasound imaging during interventional procedures may yield a more accurate assessment of one lumen dimensions. thus allowing for the optimal depth of tissue eartucl ion with atixerectomy or ratoablation . 11 may also permit better assessment of the need for additional dilations during augioplasty or the presence of a flap that is partially occlusive of the lumen and that could be excised with adjunctive atherectea y. Furthermore . the use of intravascular ultrasound could be extended to the operative suite to evaluate patency of the distal anastomotic site, thus ensuring that it is not flow restrictive . Moreover. inlravascularultrasoundimagiuguray be valuable selectut th_ -pt;m&I dicta] art,autoniy site and thus avoiding placement of the anastomotic site in the midst of or just proximal to a significant corontry artery stenosis. Limitations of the study. This study was performed in vitro under idealized conditions and is therefore subject to several potential limitations, In viva . small vein grafts or those with a significantly reduced lumen diameter, due to atherosclerosis. intimal hyperplasia or thrombus . might preclude proper positioning of the intravascular sitaisound catheter . Because the vein grafts obtained after long-term implantarlan were excised dnringauropsy, their press vasion and processing may have resulted in inadvertent dislodgmeat of loosely adherent thrombus . Moreover, we were unable to evaluate thromhoscd vein grafts because the residual lumen was generally obliterated and did not allow room for the imaging catheter . Thus, we did not acquire any data an the ultrasound appearance ofthrombus in saphenous vein grafts. Laboratory processing may also have resulted in artifacts that influenced the histologic appearance of the vein grafts. Finally, this preliminary study included a small number of vein grafts for interrogation_ therefore the significance of these findings is subject to the limitations of the small sample size . 76 4 WILLARD CT AL . INTRA V ASCULAR ULTRASOUND IMAGING OF GRAFTS Conclusions . In this in vitro study we compared !he information obtained by iniravascular ultrasound imaging, cineangiography and histologic study of saphenous vein grafts. fnlravascular ultrasound imaging is capable of accurate measurement of lumen dimensions of saphenous vein grafts as compared with results obtained Gvith quantitative cineangiogaphy . Although angiography is limited to outlining a vessel's lumen, intravusculnr alnrasound imaging also provides morphologic chart-Aericat :co of the v .eel vial litre aprons with histologic data. The clinical relevance of determining vessel wall morphologic features of saphenous vein grails by intravascular ultrasound imaging avails the results of ongoing in vivo studies, References I . nary Spray TL • Rooms WC . Chengc ; in saphannvs "inn usud en bypass Oman. Am Hcan J 197784 :500-16. 2. Smith SH, Gee, JC . Morphulugy of a mbenous vein-coronary artery bypass grafts. Arch Panhel Lab Med 1987 :107 : i3--8. 3. Lie JT. Law- GM. Morris GC. Anmomrorsry bypass saphenous vain graft stheroslerosic anatomic study of99 vein grafts from normal and hypedipopraeiaamic patients up to 75 months postopemlively. Am I Cardial 1977;40:906-14 . 4. Lawrie GM, Lie 1T, Morris GC Jr. Beazley HL . Vein gmn potency and imimal proliferation after aortocoronary bypass early and loeig .arrm argirOralhdogic oomlations . Am 1 Cordial 1976 .38 :856-62. 5 . Bj6rk VC, teen T, Lamina C . Anglor,raphic changes in mtemal mammon' artery and s, pheraas vein grafls-two weeks . one yearam i five years after ovary Imp ess surgery. Stand f Thorac Cardiovasv Surg 1981 ;IS:L'+-70 . 6 . Camp- L, Enjalbert M . Lmperance J . Vaislic C . Grondin CM . Bourassa MG, Atherosclerosis and lme closure at aar000nmlary saphenous vein grafts: sequential angiographic studin,at E creeks . 1 year.510 7 years, and 10 to I^_ years after surgery . Circuhtion 1983t68lsuppl Iti'~11-I-?. 7 . Vlndaver /., Frech R, Van Tassel RA . Edwards IF . Carrrdalmn at inc anmmmtem coronary arteriagram and the postmurlnm specimen . Clrcuralion 1n•1, .47 :r6Z-9. 8 . Arnett ET . raiser 161, Redwood DR . el al . Coronary artery ma-AC in ca-my heart dictate : Campannan of eineanglagrapldr and necropsy Poi Ann late. Med 1979 :91750-6. 9, EnstermanlH,AchorRWP .KincaidOW.BrassALJr.Athcrasclcmtic disease of the ccaunary anencs. a vatlwlupk-r,i iulogla-aetelative sicdy . Circulation 191,2:76 :1788-955 in. Wmrer BE PaStOr WC. Arnounl of narrowing by mheroselrtat:r plaque JACC Vet, 19 . No . 4 March 15, 1992:759-64 M 44 non.bypass .d and 52 bypassed -jot epicardial coronary arteries in 12 neempsy patio ms who died within m e month oiaonotOa000ry bypass grafting, ,4m 1 Card-1 1980 ;46:9.56-62. 11 . Ysn:k PG. Johnson EL. Linker Dr, Inlrasascular ultrasound: development and clinical porentiol . Am 1 Cnmiee Imaging 1988 :2:185-93. 12 . Gasaenhoven El . Essed CE, Lancer C T . et al . Arteual wall &1 lies determined by iruwnaueular uhrasound hnaging : an in vitro study . J .4m Call Cards 1999:14:947-521), Oussenheven El, Easrd CE. Frielman P, er al . Inbavascular ultrasonic imaging: histologic and echographic coroeimion EurJ Vans Surg 1989 :3: 570-1i . 14 . Giessenhoven EJ . Essed CE, Frietman F, heravascular echographic assesamcel of vessel wall chamctern ica1 a eorrelanirn with histolney . ]At J Camine Imaging 1919:4:103-16, 15 . Tobis SM . ValteryJ, lahon D.ct al .lalrovascularullresound imatingof human cocaar; arteries in viva. analysis of tissue charavlen .alioas with . Circulation 199n13 :9t7comparison to in vitm hisrological specimens 2G . 16 . Landini L. Samelli R, Pwano E, Salvation M . Evaluation of frequency dcpcndcnce of backscancr eaM6eient in normal and mherosclerulic conic walls. Ultrasound Mall Bial 1936 .12 :897-41,1 . 17 . Barzilai B . Saffiz 3E . Miller JG . Sobel BE . Quantitative ultrasonic chxmeleriro;rmv ordhe tram re of al lwroseleroli, plaques in human aorta . Cite Rae 1987160 :459-63 . 18. Linker DT. Torts PG . Grpnnimgsaether A . Johansen E. Angelsen BAK. Analysis or backrcattemd ultrasound from normal and diseased arterial wall . Inn I Cord Imaging 1989:4:177-85 . 19. RaberJHC.KooiimonCJ .SlagerCI •etal .Coronary artery dimensions from eangielra s :methadalogyandvalidelionofacoMputer-assisted analysis procedure. IEEE Traps Med Imaging 1964;MI.3 :131-41 . 20. Reiber JHC, Semi PW. Kooijman CJ, et al. Assessment of short., medium-, and Iang.term variations in arteral dimensions from computer. assisted quantilation of coronary cincangiagrams Circulation 1985;71 : 280 .8 . 21 . Nissan SE. Cmines CL. Gurley 3C . el al . Appkcarion of a new phasedarray ultrasound imaging catheter in the assessment of vascular dimeavivo eompmi on to cinsangiogmphy .Cireulation 1990 :81:660-6 . 22. Tobis 1M. hamkry JA, Gessen 1, et al, Inbavascular ultrasound crosssectioned anoint imaging before and after balloon angioplasly, in vitro . Cimulallan 191910;873-82. 23. Mnllery JA . Table JM, Grifhlh 1, el al . Assessment of normal and athnoaelemlic arterial wag thickness with an irnnavarcutar ultrasound imaging call Am Heart J 1995,119'.1192-4W. 24. Pnrkire BN . Banorelli AL . Gessen 3M, e1 al. Coronary artery imaging with irtnvascular highh frequency uhresoued. Circulation 1990 :81 :157585 . 25, Yak PG. Frail PI. Linker DT. .Asses BA!. int .vescular Alan-ad guidanw fur calhelnr-based wroaary inten'enlions, 1 Am Call Cardurl193p173Wi-459 .
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz