!"#$% !&'(!& ()&" "*&+,
&"$)!- "- ."#$%& /0)+
&"$)!- "- ."#$%& /0)+ ©
!1%0'151 ")200% "('+/0$+
!" #$%$&'()&*+, ,#-()# :#$'*. #(%)#( )"($ ,/(-0
&1"-% +(*$,!$2"(- !(1).! ,!3!3,
!'4)1 )-# !" ,)-0- #(%'.% ,).,
&3$! )$-.
*
"!"# $% ?&'# $% ?$%"# $%" "()("*+ ),-, $.%/!")' 0-.)"- 12)' )'2, 1.3+ .3'0
"),-, #('4 1."5'+,4 6"2.$'.7+", 0"')80 $0*0*$ 0+ (.4.5!")523"!$ $(,")(
68 ,1.7"".20" (".)"75!0 1.+#") 1.35'+,+ $)(.$ $4.#$" 6"4*$ 08 $.%/!")' 6,"8
(3.#44 $3.- — .4!8 ("#'$'0*0 "- — 9"*3 7"".2 08 $6'!$$ 2.+,, +6"!'(6)# .6*
("8'"( 0+ .4!8 7"".2 .5'+,0 (3"": 3," (3";3, ,(.35+' ("2#..($ "- -6.)7 1%.+.5'
'<)64 9$, "843. ,("-./,4 $0- ("8'"( "3=+.. )+-*+ (")4(2$$ (- 0.67, (".5'+,
.(.()4# $)62$0 .%*), 62", +,+0 5'+,$ 08 $+!> . 9* -0,0- .("*0+$ 9("- 00*
&'#$ ,$%"#$ — 5'+,$ ()"(4 6"2.'(".)"75! +"0+0 $.%/!")' 2#..($ "),-,4
9.4+ 9.0"47$ +"5+5 08 1.(80 (%,), 5'+,0 (.0*0*$ $+.7$" .* 985" — !"#$"
0+ )(".4 1..2.24$ #"(.3$ .0* 6/.* )4#,$ $-)$ <0.-" 9-*, $".$0-$ 6"2.$'.7+",
("."08 )"8%,4+ ("0.8.$ ,((#"'$ (.0"+$ (08"($ 9")!8 9"7* ,(.20!'"-.3$ $0*0*$
.1..5'+, 6"2.'.7+", 9.4 ("3#4$$ 0"')8 .6.0 1.-.4, %,"!"+ 0+*" 7+",$" $!28
,$% 0"')80 .1.6.7-($ .3.6 1"#(, ("#"!0 "% ()72,4 ("-4",$ $0- 9.4, ("4) (",7"6
.5'+,0 $0*0*$ 0+ (.4.5!")523"!$ $(,")( 9-*," ,4) .86, <)8 +. ,$.%/!")' 985
$.%/!")' 0+ "),-, ()("* 9.4 9".,6$ 08 9$ 1(2$ 9, 6,8 )4* 9.8$'6# -)"!$
$),-,0 ()("* ((0 .(+)63 "0.- ,9*- .9$.3.4 064$$ 08 9$" "% $)8$ 0+ $()("*0
')"2'")' *$.0/)$ .,"#(3.4$ %*),$ ,1.5'+,0 )3.%6) )'2 (.4 9!.6 ,1.5'+,0 )"2'")'
,)!#,'(.,8 *.0!)4 ,$.3)"'.0! (5.2)4.3"- ,Boalt Hall 1.5'+,0 )'2$'(.4 ,#'23
.,ECGI1 (")4# 5'+,0 .'").-$ 62",$
0"')80 $0*0*$ 0+ (.4.5!")523"!$ $(,")( "!"# $% ?&'# $% ?$%"# $%" $.%/!")' 0-.)".39/ (5",+() #. !"#$%& "5'+,4 6"2.$'.7+",
.392—39/ %,84 ,!% ,0+,0 ,"-)
.396 %,84 ,!%
.$,-($4 ,409'" 40/ ,404 %,84 ,!%
151
+
1
2
3
4
&"$)!- "- ."#$%& /0)+
/1"2 ("+%
"0 ((0 ."(.'4 6",80 $+!(, .(..$ /,(.#*"3$ $)8$$ -+", -"$+ ,0!3)' ),( 0+
'"()*+ ',-.'+ :.%,", /,&0 1+4 )'2, !0# -"$+ ,),-,$ .+,, "% $)8$ ()("* ($+.7$ :<* (./,(4 "7./$0 9(.3+ .%*), 9"8.5 $08, 6,!"1.2!'%.$ 3* +(".&0 3%
$)"/4 $8.'+$ <*4" ,1..%"# 1.2#.0 9",- .2#. 9.4 $3#4$$ (- $0')8 5'+,0 (.0*0*$
,$)"-*0 .(.)4$'("/)- 0+ (.!28$ ("4)($ 08" 5'+,$ 08 ((.4.5!")526) (.32)$
(")"+4 .$.%/!")' 0+ "(6,8 9.40 "% $6,8 9.4 )(". !",8" ?.)# 6"7.3 08 4"+#0 $+!
."%$ (.)"-*0$ $).(2$ (- 4+..0 $23- ("-4$
9$+ $64"84 9",5+ .#"3., +!", 08 8.4/$0 #)*$$ 9, ,1.)46$ )!.80 +7.3 1)54
&8")0 6,"8 $% +!", ."9",-"0 (.)484 1.,7)"(, duciary #3",$ 9$" trust #3",$
$-0, $6.,4 ?'"# "3.-+ 1.3''4) .5'+, #3", -"$ trust'+ 9"".*, 1.0-)+. 1.35'+,0
94",4 9",- (".$0 4..# duciary .2#.4 :9%"-$ (- )420 .6* !) .duciary'$ 62", (,duciary .2#. 1$.3.4 9.-+ 1.66/ 9.4 17 (".$0 0"*. $% 94",4 9",- 10"- ,trust 0+
,trustee1 9,-3$ (- 1.*'"$ — trust ,"3..$6 — ("3,-3 .2#. ,0.4!,4 *$%"#0 1.66/ 9"7*
0+ 6,8,4 1$+ 1.+3- 1..-!.),-$ 1.6.7-($ .3.64 ,0"')8 ?.2"$0 .6*" *duciary'0
,duciary duties ("3"*,$ ,(".5'+, ("4"# 1.4# — 1.)"5!).6 ,0+,0 — duciary
.* — 0!3)' 0+ .%*),$ $3"8.5 .,care1 (").$%" ,loyalty1 9",- ("4"# ("00"* )+4..#, — .%"# 62", "4 $(-)+ <*4 "9",-" 7+",$ (- $)!.8 5'+,0 (.0*0*$ $+.7$
("3#4$ "0.#$4 (".4!8 08 6.'!$0 +)63 .0-)+.$ 95'+,$ .(".#"3., ("3#4$0 ("!!%.$
.$0.*43 ,"00$0 .1.35'+, 13.-+ 1.+3-0 $3"+-)4" +-)4 $3'", 0!3)' 0+ $)"4.#
0+ ",")4+ (".3.6, ("0-+0 1..53""0)'-0" 1.,.,+, 1.-)3 (.5'+,$ $3.)5!"6$
.2#. 7""20 9(.3 $.("4!84+ ,(.5'+,$ $3.)5!"64 $)",(0 .0!3)' (2)"7 ,.* -0 .10"8
("4)($ 08 ?!.$'(4#) (.0.0+ $8'+$ +. ,.%"# 9.6* 9",-$ 9.6 (-" 1..%"# 1.2#.* 9",0+ $)'$ 1"+, 9",- (4"# ()'$4 $-")$ $2.'($ $84!($+, ;.(.-!.),-$ (.!28$
(.+83 $)'$$" ,$0.8, .+8,4 !46$ .)2",$ 9"0!$'("- $)'$$ 9, $#,3 ,(.%"# $#54$
(- (+5+5, .%"# 4.). 0+ $.)"75!0 ,trustee1 9,-3$ ()48$ ..()4# ."3.70 ("#' $."-)
$4+#,0 1.,."2, 1.3,-3 ("85$0 0"08 )46$ ."(!%#0 04!, $0$+ 1.2*3$ 0+ 16,8,
9",-$ 9.6 9.4 $3#4$$ 0+ (".6..,$ ("*0+$$ 9.4 <.1$0 1.*..+ 1("3,-34+ 1.2*3$+
9.6$+ $37$$ (6., (-" 87'30 ("6,"8$ ("3"+$ ("'")($ (- 0!3)' $3", $%"#$ 9.60
1.2#.4 "0.-" ,(.@)A, $37$, $3$3 ,beneciary1 $3$3$ 9",- .2#.4 .1.3!, 5'+,$'.(4"
(- #.54$0 .)!.8$ 053$ 05", ".08" ,("047", $)'$, 87'3$ 0+ ".("'")( 1..%"#
1.."3.+$ :00"+ (*0"$" 9",-4 $8)0 +",.+ .3'4 "4/.3+ 1.,"2#,$ (0.'3" 0!3)' ),( /
.113 (""2+() $ !"()*, #$%& "(.5'+,$ ("3+)'4" (.5'+,$ $3.)5!"64 1.)(23$
Tamar Frankel Trust and Honesty – America's Business Culture at a Crossroad ,Oxford, 6
.2JJ51
.119—118 %,84 ,/ $)8$ 3"*3 ,0!3)' 2
.122—120 %,84 ,!% 8
152
!"#$% !&'(!& ()&" "*&+,
&"$)!- "- ."#$%& /0)+
)/!$ #""54+ .''08'?-+ 9"".*, ,(.()4#'00* $3.#4, $0.8.'-0 -.$ $-/"($ K.".3..38
1$.2#. (- 4/80 )*.3 +'"# 1.66/$ 9, (00"+ 9",- .2#. .470 $).,#,$ ("2#..($$
"1.).""#, 1$0+ 1.#"")$ .62'$" 1.3,-3$ 08 ("0#$ ("047$$" <")-$ #""54 ,13"/)*
."3.+$ 9, $-/"(*9 (#-" 1.)+8$ $-,$ 0+ $(0.#( 9,0 "3.3.80 $073$ !%3"0 $-""+$4
1J
.":(.5'+,$ $3.)5!"64
Daniel Fischel'* 1.6,"0, 0+ 1#('0 &4") -5#$ ,0!3)'6 -4.0- ?1+-$ .,4
("4-$ 9, ,$0- 1.+.- .Richard Posner'" Frank Easterbrook (,7"6 1.5'"+"
1.6,"0, ,9.6'.*)"8 0+ $!%# $8"3( "7.$3$ ,5'+,0 (.0*0*$ $+.7$ 0+ 1.62..,$
Easterbrook 0+ 12)"',$ 1),-, 08 $8.4/, -.$ ,(.(6"!3 .0!3)' (38"5 ,1.5'"+"
Wsol 9..384 12)"','-0 9.6'!2' 08" 11,9",-$ (4"#" $%"#$ 08 1993 (3+, Fischel'"
$,"6 $%"%( ()(-, 0!3)' (")4#$ .3.64 17 12.Posner 5'"+$ 0+ "58'.)' ,v. Fiduciary
$)4#$ .",.64 $0"( 0!3)' <*0 $4.2$ (- .$%"#4 +76 (,.+0 9",- ("4"#4 +76 (,.+,
1%
:$(860 1$.(.0*0*$ (")'2$ 9, 0"-+$ ,,nexus of contracts1 "1.%"# 0+ (8!'"*
...("3,-3 9.40 1.%"# 9.4 1..5'+,$ 1.064$0 $(86 $3(3 -0 (.0*0*$ (")'2$"
0+ $("#' $6., "+.6!$+ )#-," ,%$0*0*$" 5'+,$% 1"#(, 1.)!"# 1(".$4 04$% ."3.+ 10"- .(50"4 $* 1.%"#0 ("3,-3, $+.07$ $(.$ -0 ,1.0.,0 40'(,"+(
.470 (#"")$ $86$ (- 17 1,8" ,$)4#$ ()72,4 1.2#.$ 0+ 1(.,6( (- $3.+
".$)4#$ (0$3$ 0+ $.("4"#
$0"08 $),-,4 $7./, 0!3)'+ #"(.3$ 9, 1.0"8$ 1.54.$$ 0*0 $-0, ("2#..($
9(.3 ,+4,%0.-, %0.- .",/8 ),-,$ 0+ $%, 4) 1.6",8 )'2, .3''08 8)(+$0
9",-$ 9.6 9.4 $3#4$$ +"5+5, 8"430 ("0"08+ ("*0+$$ 0+ 9(),"# (6., $, ("+!$0
.9$0 (38"5 0!3)'+ (".()4#$ ("-/"($ $% +"5+5, #",/0 ("0"08 1-" ,$%"#$ 9.60
$3#4$$ +"5+5 .470 0!3)' 0+ $(385 13,"-$ — (".4.5.%"' ("0-+ ("))"8(, ,'"4%
9.4 ,.4.5.%"'$ 9.64 .5'+,$ 4/,$ (- 9"*3'0- ()-(, 1..%"# 1.2#.0 9",- .2#. 9.4
.126—12/ %,84 ,!% 9
.119 %,84 ,!% 10
Daniel R. Fischel & Frank H. Easterbrook TContract and Fiduciary DutyT $U J. L. & 11
.Economics ,1KK$1 %25
.(Wsol 9..38 :90$0) Wsol v. Fiduciary Mgmt. Assocs., 2UU F.$d U5% ,;th Cir. 2JJ11 12
()"(4 6"2.'.),-, .3+4 (.%"#$ (8!'$ .",.6 0+ ")"!, .129 %,84 ,/ $)8$ 3"*3 ,0!3)' 13
Michael C. Jensen & William H. Meckling TManagerial Behavior, :"-) .$,).'$
Agency Costs, and Ownership StructureT $ J. Fin. Econ. ,1K;U1 $J5] Armen A. Alchian
& Harold Demsetz TProduction, Information Costs, and Economic OrganizationT U2
.Am. Econ. Rev. ,1K;21 ;;;
.129 %,84 ,/ $)8$ 3"*3 ,0!3)' 14
15$
&"$)!- "- ."#$%& /0)+
/1"2 ("+%
0!3)' 0+ .(4.2$ #"(.3$ 1- ("+!$0 9(.3 ,'"%"3% ?0-)+.4 9.4" (.)4$'("/)-4
$+.74 -"$ 1+-$ 13,"-$ ,5)'4 .()-"(,$ $)",(0 "0.4"$ )+- 1.,)"7$ 08 6,"8 9*.$)/!4 $0- ("6"!30 2#..(- 90$0 ?5'+,0 (.0*0*$
,$,-($4" — 1..%"# 1.2#.0 9",- .2#. 9.4 $3#4$$+ !'2 9.- ,$3"+-)$ $6"!30 )+-4
00*4" ,04"!,$ 5'+,$ ("*)8,4 )(".4 ("!",8$ 9, -.$ — $%"#$ 9.60 9",-$ 9.6 9.4
9$ 9$4+ ("4.234 87"3 $0- 1.2#. ("*)8, 9.4 .3"+$ 15.(.0-)+.$ 5'+,$ (*)8,4 $%
'",* .$0- 1.66/0 ("6,"8$ ("."*%4" 9$0 1.66/$ 08 ("0#$ ("4"#$ 0+ 93*"(4 ,("#,"/
10"- .87'30 ("6,"8$ ("'")($ 1"#(4 ("!'3 +. $% .3"+0 ,0!3)' (3../,+ .'* ,9*
(.%"#$ 1.2#.$ (*)8, .1.2#.$ ("*)8, 0+ 9..'"-4 .6"2. 064$ ."/, $3#4$$ +)"+4
7"-60 .-+) 16- 0* .* $#3$$ $4 (0'"!, ..)2)""6- .'"- (084 ("4.). 08 (22"4,
.4.5,)"3 9..38* 9$" (("7$3(, (".)4$ <*) .)"-.( 9..38* 9$ — "(0"*. 45.,* ".3..380
6/ 0* 08 $0.5, ,$0.7)$ $(2)74 ,(.%"# 1.2#. (*)8, .("7$3(. (".)4$+ ."-) <*)
1U
."16- — 16-0 16-" (!%#4 ,$)4#4 1..# 0+ (".0,.3., $6.,'(",-4 6",80 $$% $4"#
-.$ $'")/$ $(2)74 1;.1.66/$ 9.4 #"* .064$ 08 (22"4, 9",- .2#. (*)8, ,$(,"80
5'+, (*)8, ."5'+, (5.+" 9+".,$ #3",$ 08 "5'+, (*)8," #3",$ (- ?.68, .3- 1/
(",)"3$ (*)8, (-" 9.6$ ('.*-0 1.08"'$ ("62",$ (- ,!"2'$" (")#$ 9.6$ (- (00"*
.1$.0- 2#.4 (".0,)"''-0$ ("./3""3"!$"
.2#.* ".$. %)*,4 1.'((+,$ 9.4 1.2#.$ .* ,<*0 ?-+3 -0" :!)4 9)$- 5'"+$ .)46 "-) 16
.* ,0"0+3 <- .$7+$ (4 $3.- Homo Homini Deus 0+ ("7$3($ (,) .$%0 $% 1.*-0,
Homo Homini 4-% — 16-0 16- 0+ $+.7$ )")+( %)*,4 1.'((+,$ 9.4+ 1.2#.4
16- .* ,9")!.8$ )")+. %)*,4 1.'((+,$ 16-$ .34 9.4+ 1.2#.4 .* ,<*0 ?-+3 .Lupus
9* .//8 ,/33 (1)%0 6"' ,&$*- )3," '"- %4 &$*- +%& -"-. 202;29 -"8 ".16- — 16-0
+2,-*3 "5.0+ /"2+ '"- %4 &$*- *-%!.0- !"".,-"5 +.,-6' "',."% /9;80 &"74 "-)
.40$'1"( (4"# .6.'08 84!3 .0,.3.,$ ("7$3($$ 9!( 0-)+.4 .828 (1)$0 6"' ,!"3%,."1.2#.4 ((.0-)+.$ $("8) (- #)*$4 (''"# $3.-+) 40'1"( (4"# $0# (.)4$'("/)-4
.Uniform Commercial Code'$ )674 1..)#2,
812;29 -"84 !)4 9)$- 5'"+$ 84! ,"#*$ 084 08 (05",$ (.00* $4"# -.$ 9",-$ (4"#" 12
$'!"( (- (!3". "% $8.4! .280—229 ,2/3 (3)#0 6"' ,&$*- .74,,#1",$ .3." (4- %4 ",),(
Meinhard v. Salmon, 1U% N.E. 5%5, (+)'4 Cardozo 5'"+$ 0+ 1.,2)"',$ ".)46,
TMany forms of conduct permissible in a :(Salmon (*0$ :90$0) 5%U ,N.Y. 1K2<1
workaday world for those acting at arm's length, are forbidden to those bound by
duciary ties. A trustee is held to something stricter than the morals of the market place.
Not honesty alone, but the punctilio of an honor the most sensitive, is then the standard
of behavior. As to this there has developed a tradition that is unbending and inveterate.
Uncompromising rigidity has been the attitude of courts of ebuity when petitioned to
undermine the rule of undivided loyalty by the 'disintegrating erosion' of particular
exceptions... Only thus has the level of conduct for duciaries been kept at a level
.higher than that trodden by the crowdT
$0- 6"2. ("3")!8" .* ,280 %,84 ,!% ,!)4 9)$- 5'"+$ ),- Cardozo 5'"+$ 0+ $0- 1.)46 08
15%
!"#$% !&'(!& ()&" "*&+,
&"$)!- "- ."#$%& /0)+
(!%#4 ,$3$3$ (4"50 !)" <- 0"8'0 — duciary'$ — 9",- 4#$ #"*$ 084 08 $0.5,
."<-0, — 16-0 16-"
&)#3 .()4# ."3.74 (0!(3 9*- $0-* 1.2#.4 9",- ()'$ 1- -.$ (6)'3 $0-+
'.(4 0+ 1(4"7(4 !) )4"6, 9.- .0!3)' 0+ $(385* ,(.%"# ("4..#($ ()'$ )+-, )(".
()"+!($ .8/,-" 4#)$ )"4./$ 0+ 1("2#..($4 -0- ,$0- (")'$4 10!(.$4 5'+,$
.* -.$ .(",+)($ .(.+.- (",+)($ .''08 (*(#3 $4"+($ )46 0+ "'"24 .$0- (")'$0
2"'")5"'-, "- ,6#"+ 05"3 "- 1.'2*4 08",$ $))+ 084, 60"2 )"4./$ .)46$ <* 9*,$)4#$ (- "40"#" )+- (.)"4./ $)4#4 9..38 084, "- "("2#'94 0+ ".2*34 6. #0"+$
)(". $0"67 ("3.."84 1.2#..(, 5'+,$'.(4 17 ."$%"# (- )',$ $%"# 084, )+-, )(".
.5)'0, )/!( $8.).$" ,(".%"# ("4"# .)', 0- )+-, 9",- ("4"# .)', 09",-$ 9.6 9.4 $3#4$$ (- (""+$0 9(.3 ,5'+,$ (*)8,4 $(".%*)," $(,/"8 (3.#4,
$(*% $3")#-$ $3#4$$+ 6"84 10"- 1<.1+-$ 9.60 9..3!$ 9.6 9.4 $3#4$0 $%"#$ 9.60
0+ $(3850 6"2. +. 1K,5'+,0 (.0*0*$ $+.7$ 0+ (")'24 1.4#)3 #"(.'4" $)*$4
$(8.4!4 (!6"/ 0!3)' ,9*'08 )(. .$,"6 6,8,4 $(*% -0 $3"+-)$ $3#4$$ .* 0!3)'
Easterbrook 9"7* ,5'+,0 (.0*0*$ $+.74 .%*),$ 1)%$ 0+ 1.50"4 1.)4"6 .*
$)4#4 1.+3- 9.4 (".3"/)$ 9.0,"7$'("."2#..($ 00* (- 7""20 1.5"3 ,Fischel'"
(.3")!8$ (;3"*3$ ()%73 17 $% 7"".2, ..%"# .'"- ("084 9.0,"7'("."2#..($* ,society1
Easterbrook "385+ .'* ,1.%"#$ +'"#, !0#* 9",- ("4"# 08 ("3($0 (")+'-4 ).*$0
2J
.Fischel'"
.6.'08" 1.)*%3$ 1.)4"6$ .6.'08 (84",$ — $3",-4 .6"2. .(4+#, 0+* +. .3.84
$.3($0 -+", 0-* (".5'+,$ 9",-$ ("4"#0 2#..($0 9(.3 .* — 1$.("4!84 1.*0"$$
.2#. !) -0") duciary 7"2, 9",- .2#. 0+ (*)8,0 .3"/) 9'"-4 1.23*3$ 1.66/ .(.%"#
"- ,(".2"'.5$ 9",-$ ("4"# 0+ 9(0"#( 08 +)"',4 1.*2$0 1.0"*. (trust 7"2, 9",'(6"!3 9*+ ,6.)", "3.-" $08, "3.- $% 9..38 .-00*, "% $,*2$ 1$0 2#..0 0"*. 9.6$+
1- .$.3($0 (3(.3 $3.-" (.537"! -.$ ,loyalty1 9",-$ (4"#+ -.$ 9",-$ 9.64 #(',$
$.4" $.3, 1.*'$3 1$ ,$3$3$ .'0* "0+ 9",-$ (4"#, 219",-$'4# (- 1.)5"' 1.66/$
,$!.2'$ )#+4 6"2.$ 9")!8 (- 50! 5'+,$ (.4 ,9*- ...(.5'+,$ "3(5.+ 08 17 1.04"!,
."0-)+. #2"3 04"!,$ 5'+,$, !0#* ,"30+ "3.*)/ .' 08 "("- #(', "$.)$ %-,"
%#-" 9$* 1..# ,).,% !#/. ,!)4 9)$-) /&),8 .$) "1+-$ 9.6" 9..3!$ 9.6" 9,6.)' 0-.36 "-) 18
.241 (6",+( ,1.*)"8
Guido Calabresi & Douglas A. Melamed TProperty :94",* ,-"$ 12)"',$ 6"2.$'),-, 19
Rules, Liability Rules, and Inalienability: One View of the CathedralT <5 Harv. L. Rev!
.,1K;21 1J<K
.Fischel & Easterbrook, supra note 11 20
,1.5'+,$ 6)+, ,)"4./$ 9".80 #2"3) ',4,&& "4"2 (,6 ' "6.80+ )(2,(+ "-) $% 7+",0 21
www.idclawreview. — (8$'4(* )(-4 +.73 ,/13—/12 1.'.82 ,100—99 (- <)* ,6"2+(
.org
155
&"$)!- "- ."#$%& /0)+
/1"2 ("+%
1.2#. "- "("'("+" .2#. ,"("#.0+" .2#. 1$.2#. (- ("3*0 1.0"*. 1.66/$ .1.4.).0
9",- (4"# )68.$4 .1.85," 1.85", ".$. $0- 1.."3.* <- ,"$)+, -+"3" (".3, 084" 0+
$3$3$ — -0,$ ."0.7$ (4"#" 1.3..38 6"7.34 0"8'0 )"2.-$ — 1..6"2.$ $.)4.- .3+ 08
4"5" ,.0,.3., 9!(4 ".'0* ("7$3($0 $..'./0 )48, )460 6"8 .-*% "3.- $0- 1.2#.4
."9",-$'4#" .3', 17 ".3..38 08 )",+0 7-6. 1- $+8.
$%"# 0+ 9.60 9",-$ 9.6 (*.'$ :)",-0 ,0!3)' 0+ $(385 %"00 1.8.7, "3- 9-*"
0+ .0*0*$ #"(.3$ -!""6 ,.3").- #)"-4 .(.()4# $3.#4, (".32)$ ("-/"(0 $0.4",
94"-)+ 0.8. $% $.$. 6"-, 1.4) 1.)!,4 ."% $3850 2.24 +. 8"6, ).$4,$ -"$ 5'+,$
$6.,4 08'. 9"8,+ .* +"+#0 ."+8 94"-)+ -0- .1."2, 1%., 8"/.40 9"8,+4 8..(2.
.()*",$ 7./3$ (..84 ,(./,(4 ,"% .94"-) 0+ "(4"50 -0" ,"0+ "(4"50 ()#- "- "%*
("*)8, 22.1..%"# 1.8/,-4 -0 5)'4 ,-0, 9")('0 (3(.3 $3.- 7./3$ (..84 ,-!8 -6
.2#. 0+ (",."2, ("*)8, ()67$ .6.'08 $.840 1."2, $38, ("3("3 04"!,$ 5'+,$
$)%#4 9",- .2#. (),$ .<*, 84"3$ ("."*%$" ("4"#$ <)8, 08 ,duciary .2#.* (;7./3
++#$ (,#, (;7./3 .%"# ")+!.. -0+ $% 94",4 ,!"+ 0+*0 1")7( 1..%"# 1.2#.0
0+ (")*",$ (".84$ 0+4 ,(-% .1.7./3$ 0+ (.52.3"5)"'"- ("7$3($ .3', (!6/",$)
9",- (4"# (8.4! .,adverse selection1 (.0.0+ $).#4" ,moral hazard1 .)2", 9"*.2
9'"-4 4..#($0 6/0 ()+'-, -.$+ <*4 !"+$ 0+* 08 ()47(, 9"4.)$ .6.'08 (.537"!
(",)"3$" 5'+,$ (*)8, $4+ $)4#4 ,(-% (,"80 .)#-$ 6/$ 0+ "(4"50 0"8'0 9,.$,
08 0#$ ("7$3($ 9!( 0+ )(". $).,#," (6)'3 $.)"75!4 (").*, 93.- (".5'+,'-0$
<*0 2$.1.5)'$ 9.4 (trust 0+ 94",4 18'$) .66$$ 9",-$ ("''")($0 ("'/0 9(.3 1.7./3
.9'!.$" (".")+!($$ )'2, 08 (".0.0+ ("*0+$ (".$0 ("."'/
4/,$ (3.#4, .* 83*"+, .3.- ,$..3+$ $6"!30 1.8.7, "3- <*4" ,9*'.''08'?(38"5 0!3)'+ $6.,4 $%"#$ 9.60 9",-$ 9.6 9.4 $3#4$$ $+5+"5 .4.5.%"'$ .5'+,$
$3', 0!3)' $)",-$ $3#4$$ +"5+50 $.-)* .0-)+.4 9.4" (.)4$'("/)-4 9.4 ,$0
6!,($0 <.)/ $.$ 5'+,$'(.4 .* (38"5" 2%,"#$% 9..384 Posner 5'"+$ 0+ "3.6'!2'0
,58, ("4*)", 9.6$'!2' ("64"8 .!%3 (",..!($ 0+ $0-+4 -0" ,84"($ +"*) (0.534
("4.234 9",- (4"# ()'$ 0+ $3850 2.24$ $, 9.5"0#0 )")4 -0 ,),-.$0 (3(.3 (,-$"
9*"2 0+ $."-) $!.64'.-4 873 ,#"0+* $08' )+- ,(84(30 2#".+ 06#,$ .$+)'$
0+ $0-+ 17 9*0" ,(").$% (4"# ()'$ 0+ $0-+ )!.84 ))"80 ."+8 $% 06#, .$2)"4
$+)'4 .(".%*),$ ("(*,2-$ 9, "3.- "#$% 9..384 9.6$'!2' ,9*'08 )(. .!%3 (",..!($
"(")4# )5+, .3..38 ).62$0 <)8 (")..3 ("+) ("*,2" 5*.0 ).,8 "-) )(". -0, 5").'0 22
.46 (""2+() (6)4 !"2"70'
(-+$0 00*'<)64 1.08"' 1$+ $% 94",4 1..03"./) 1.5)'$ .* $#3$ $,"07 0.80 $3854 23
.(.+.-$ 1(08"(
.12 $)8$ 3"*3 ,Wsol 9..38 24
15U
!"#$% !&'(!& ()&" "*&+,
&"$)!- "- ."#$%& /0)+
"08"'4 ,"0+ 9",-$ (4"# (- )',$ 9",-'4# .* )")4 9'"-4 84!3 25,&'()*+ 9..384 ,()#0-)+.4 .$4+$4" ("3"4+# 9(,4 4..# ,$3$30 -0, 86., )"2,0 .04," 1.3..38 6"7.34
$0.8, <"( (.+.-$ "(4"50 08"'$ ("8!+$ &8"." 1.!.( 0$3, 0+ — <",2 )+!$4 84!3
0+ $)"/ 0* 0"0*0 ("."+8" ,6#".,4 ("4#) 87'30 ("6,"8$ ("'")($ .* — "#"!0 9",-4
2U
.&.,- .(4.2 )+!4 1$.0- )"+! -"$ 9.-+ 1.!%3 ("4)0 ,1.!%3 (45$" $4+$
(')"7 $,7, (,..! .* 8"4!0 $+! $)4#4 1.)"5!).6 0+ )(". 6!",, )+!$4 17
(;3"*3 08 8.4/$0 50#$4 9(.3 ,-2.7 6#, ..-!.),-$ 5'+,4 9",-$ 9.6 ("''")($ 0+
(.2#. 0"67 9"),( 4#), $)+, .-+"30 )+'-0 )""06 0+ 5'+,$'.(4 4)!4 ()4"7
<*0 $,7"6 .$(,/"8 -"0,4 $0# 1$0+ 9",-$ (4"# 9$4+ ("4.234 17 1,/8 18 4.5.$0
053 )+- )"5!).6 18 6"-, 5'+,$'(.4 0!$ 1+ 2;,,+$- 9..384 9.6$'!2'4 $3(.3
(7/.., $3.- ,+$- (*0$ ,-2.7 <6.-, .$)"-*0 $4 9..38 $.$ $)4#0+ (.!28 ("3,6%$
9.6$ .470 1.6,"0,$ (6,8 (- "- (.)4$'("/)- ("3.6, )(.4 "% $.7"24 9.6$ (- #)*$4
(3.6, 0+ 1.0.!,$ 1.3#4,$ (- 630.),4 5'+,$'(.4 $#6 2<./++'# (+)'4 ,<* .."/)$
)464 2K&/%0$( (*0$ 0+ ()+'(,'.(04$" $+!"3$ (.00*$ $+.7$ (- &,.-" ,)""06
()($0 $).,#,$ ()72,$ (- 5'+,$'(.4 0.#$ 9..38 0+ "'"70 .duciaries'0 2#.$
0+ (")4#$ )5+, ("3")!84 (37"8, -.$+ .'* ,$)4#$ 0+ (.!28 ("3,6%$ (0.53
.("$, 86., 0* 0+ $)4#0 -0,$ ."0.7$ (4"# $%*),4 )+- ,American Law Institute'$
$J
.("3,6%$$ (0.53 .3'0
8"430 ("."+8+ ("+!$ ("-/"($ )464 0!3)' 0+ $(3854 <,"($ )#- 9.6'!2'
(.)4$'("/)-4 9(.3 ,9",-$ 9.6 08 $%"#$ 9.6 ("50(+$ ("4!84 ,9",-$ (4"# 08 $.3($,
(.)4$'("/)-4 1.6.7-($ (!.!#4 $./%.0)4.0$ 07 ()72,4 $1.123$((*%% (+)'4
,LLC – limited (047", (".)#-4 $)4# 9"7* ,1.6.7-(0 ("+6# (".5'+, (")72, "84!3
,9",-$ (4"# 08 .!0# 9'"-4 ("3($0 !"#$ .''08 (.-*% )+- liability corporation1
0"8'($ 1*2$ ()72,4 ,1.67-(,$ ",.*2$ $+)' $("-4 $2.(")67", ("4.234 ("#'0
6#- 7$3 9*- <* ,8.(',4 -0 .$)4#$ .!284 (")#($0 1.-+) 1.)4#$ .* ,$)4#$ 0+
)674 08' $0$ .* 84! ".$"-4 5'+,$'(.4 .$)4#$ 0+ 86., 0/3, -"$+ <"( ,1.67-(,$
("-) .'0 ,(*#"7, "- $,"78 -.$+ — (04!(,$ $-/"($ .0"8'($ 1*2$ .''08 )(",$
.(.6.7-($ ()72,$ 0+ 50#", 9"0+.* $)!, 0*4 -.$ — 93"4(,$ 0+ ".3.8
)+'-, !"#$ 1".*" ,(")4#$ .3.64 ("#('($ $0# ("3")#-$ $3+$ 1.)+84 ,9*.General Automotive Mfg. Co. v. Singer, 12J N.W.2d U5K ,Wis. 1KU$1
"-) 5)"', 9".60 .38/ (3)73 6"' ,&$*- (2***+ 9.* ',.""4 '.'* %4 /"#.( 36/4;92 -"8 "-)
./31 (#"3+( ,$..3+ $)"6$,) - #$%&- 03, .%,* '""%* "4"2 9,6.)' 0-.36
.Broz v. Cellular Information Systems, Inc., U;$ A.2d 1%< ,Del. 1KKU1
.Northeast Harbor Golf Club, Inc. v Harris, UU1 A.2d 11%U ,Me. 1KK51
.12 $)8$ 3"*3
.American Law Institute, Principles of Corporate Governance sec. 5.J5 ,1KK21
.McConnell v. Hunt Sports Enterprises, ;25 N.E. 2d 11K$ ,Ohio 1KKK1
.Uniform Limited Liability Corporation Act, sec. 1J$,b1,21,i1
15;
2/
26
22
28
29
30
31
32
&"$)!- "- ."#$%& /0)+
/1"2 ("+%
$'.+#$ (- 0)53,+ 9'"-4 $)4#4 $)+,$ .-+"3 0+ 1$.("4"# 08 ("3($0 ("0! )(.4
."'.+0 ("4..#($ ,)"5' 9(, ("8/,-4 (-%" ,$)'$$ ("-/"(0 $)+,$ -+"3 0+ (.0*0*$
(")4#$ .3.6 ()72,4 9$.08 ("3($0 9(.3+ ("4"#$ :!..60 +. 9-* <- $$.#"5.4 (+.*) "..)2",$ 9"*.2$ (..840 (.3")!8 $'"+# $3.- 9()'$ )+- $0- !)" <- 9$ 1..00*$
(6404 #"5.4 ("8/,-4) (.!0# $6.,4" (").$%$ (4"# ()'$ "% ()72,4 ("00*3 30.%"84"! )""06 (3.6, 0+ (")4#$ !"# ,'".-+!',5.0- .40'1"(4 9",-$ (4"# ()'$ 17
9",-$ (4"# ()'$ 08 $0# $3.- $.'0* )"5!).6 0+ ("4# 08 ("3($0 $)4#$ ("*,2 .*
$%
.40'1"( )2"#4 1.06#, "- 1.+8, 08 "- ,loyalty1
9.64 9",-$ 9.6 (8.04 08 )460 9..68 16!", ,(.4.5.%"'$ $3.#4$ 9, ("#'0 .* -/,3
Fischel'" Easterbrook 0+ 1(-.)!'1(385 .0-)+.4 9.4" (.)4$'("/)-4 9.4 ,$%"#$
.40'(0-+, )674 $(8'(80 $)("3
$0*0*$ 0+ $(,")( (- <.)8$0 9(.3 6/.* — (.+.0+$ $6"!30 ,9* 1- ,"387$
1.2#.4 $-/"($ .$," $4.2$ .$, ,5)'4" ?$%"#$ 9.60" 9",-$ 9.60 5'+,$ 0+ "("2#..($0
?$%"#$ 9.60 9",-$ 9.6 9.4 9853$ +"5+5$ 9.40 5'+,0 (.0*0*$ $+.7$ (..08 9.4+
$64"8$" ,(.0*0*$ (")'24 "$%"#" #3",4 +",.+$ 1/8+ -"$ 0!3)' 0+ $(385 )!.8
,.5'+,$ #.+$ 0+ ."3.+0 "0.4"$ ,(".5'+, ("3#4$4 -()"' 1.!6 13.- 1.30*0*+
.",.6$ 9..68 #"B) .0*0*$ #.+4 .* !0"# 9.- .$("00*4 $)4#4 (")",(0 — ".("4!84"
("34"($ ("00*(+$ ("4!84 10"- .1.%"# 0+ (8!'* ($,).'$ ,!".6 )(.0) $)4#$ 0+
("'"0#" 1.#"(.' "% #"(.3 ()72,0 "#,/ ,1.,0+", 1.%"# 4"(*0 (0"*.$ ("047, )464
(-+ )(.4 +76", "% ()72,4 $5.9..3! ("."*% — )#- .5'+, 6"2.'7+", 08 1.*,(2,$
#"(.3 .(8.6. 45.,0 9..68 9.- "% ()72,4 .9..3!$ 0840 +.+ $5.0+4 9",5$ #"*$ 6"2.
9* 1- 2#..(, 0!3)' 0+ $3"8.5 .(duciary 0+ 94",4) "9",-" 7+",$ 0+ .0*0*
$+.7$ 1"#(, 1.6,"0,0 $.$+ 86.0 ,!".6 )(.0" ,1.3",+$ ("3+4 $0*0*4 86.$ 4/,0
.$'"!( $("-4 $0*0*4 86.$ 4/, ("6"-'08 5'+,0 (.0*0*$
()67", 9,%'(6"!34 "8.'"$ )+- ("3".8) 0+ (",7"6 (")*", ("3".8)$ 0+ $.)"52.$4
$-,$ (.+-)4 Martin Luther 0+ $./,)"')4 $.$ <* .$)4#$ .3' (- "3.+" (.2#.
"("-6""$'.- 9")!8" #"2.3 .* Morton J. Horwitz 985 )(". 4")! )+!$4 .$)+8'++$
0+ (".5'+, ("3.)5!"64 1.."3.+0 )46 0+ "'"24 0.4"$ Werner Heisenberg .6.'08
$-,$ (.+-) 0+ (.)4$'("/)-4 (".()4#'(".0*0* ("*0+$ <*0 "86"3 .*" ,(".(4.2
.189 #"2 ,1999'5"3+( ,(")4#$ !"#0 261'" 2/8 1.'.82 33
0+ $("$, .* 1.)46$ .0"+4 ).8- .Delaware General Corporation Law, sec. 1J2,b1,;1 34
Melvin A. :"-) .$*)/ 0* 9..68 ()""#, $3.- )""06 0+ (")4#$ .3.64 40$'1"( (+.)6
.Eisenberg TThe Duty of Good Faith in Corporate LawT $1 Del. J. Corp. L. ,2JJU1
Oliver Hart & John Moore TProperty Rights and the Nature of the FirmT :0+,0 ,"-) 3/
K< J. Pol. Econ. ,1KKJ1 111K] Oliver Hart Firms, Contracts and Financial Structure
.,Oxford, 1KK51
15<
!"#$% !&'(!& ()&" "*&+,
&"$)!- "- ."#$%& /0)+
2#..0 ,.(860 ,)+'-'.- ,$0- ("3".8) 0+ 1(".%*), ("),0" ,9*'.''08'?- $U.1.)+8$
(".()4#$ ("4.230 $4#)$4 2#..($0 .04, (8)*, (.()4# $8'+$ 1(",*+0" 1$0
!".6'.- 6/.* 1"0$0 $+! $% 7"2, #"(.3 )68.$4 .("3".8) 1("- "8.'"$ 9()72,4+
.9$.08 $8.4/, 0!3)'+ (")",($ (- 00"#0 0"*. (.5'+, $3#4$4
0+ 9,".!4 "- (.5'+,$ $3#4$$'.- 0+ $,".!4 $).'* 1"+, 9.- 0.80 )",-4 :!"6"
1.))"8, (.-!.),-$ $)4#4 (",7, ("6"-'08 0!3)' 0+ $.3"8.5 .(".()4#$ (")",($
-0 $0- 1.3"8.5 ,9*'08 )(. ."% $)4#4 -0, 9'"-4 $)"8, "3.-+ ., 4)!4 17 )*", 6$
6"2. +. ,1($ 9.4" -*$ 9.4 .(.0-)+.$ $)4#0 1("- 2#..3 1- 17 1.,)"/ "- 1.)% "8,+..
18 4.5.$0 )*.3 9"),( 4#),, 1.3$3 — 9",,$ #"* "- $))+$ #"* — #"*$ .084+ $3850
.6.'08 (*,(3 $3.- $385$ 1- ?- .#"*$ .)2# 0+ 13"4+#'08 ("3,"%, 1.(.80 ,1,/8
)!30 9..68 $."+8 — !"#$ ,)",-0 — 1..0,)"'$ 1..()4#$ ("62",$ 0+ .4.5.%"' #"(.3
9'"-4 8.4/$0 -"$ ,94",* ,.+"!$ ..()4#$ 4/,$ 9*- $% .0,)"''-0 9'"-4+ $+"#($
08 ("*,(2$0 )48, ,$4 <,"(" "% 9.8, ("-./, 00"#, )+- .()4# 9"373, 08 83*+,
1.*)8" ("3",- ,(".()4# (",)"3 0+ 9,".! #.*"$0" )(-0 +. <* 1+0 ..,.3' 8"3*+
:$-4$ $)"/$ (- %- +40( 0!3)' 0+ $(385 .("4)( — (./,(4" ,$)4#4 1.#"")$
)+*$$ (- $0.67$ )+- $)",( 1.3")#-$ 1.)"+8$ (+"0+4 $0# (.-!.),-$ ("4)(4
.9",- .2#.* .()"2, 9'"-4 (")*",+ ("4.234 17 1,/8 18 4.5.$0 #"* .0840 9(.3+
1.,..!$ 1.0*4 )*%3$ 7"2$ 9, $385 <.)'$0 "- (,-0 )+'-'.- ,)8/$ $4),0
9'"-4 .6,0 $4"5 $)"/4 ("+8.$0 0"*. ("."4)( 0+ .%")"7.) #"(.3 .$)4#$ .86,4 1".*
0+ "%0 (.)4$'("/)- 0+ ("4)($ (- ,0+,0 ,(""+$0 9(.3 ,),"0* *6404 .(-""+$
(.-!.),-$ ("4)($ "% (.#"(.3 ()72,4 $;.$'").- 4)8,4 ("."/,$ $0-0 "- 0-)+.
-/".*" )+"8, ,$))+, )%73* — 7)6C, .064$0 )(". 4) )+*$ (3("3" $+.76, 9*("4)(0 $% 94",4 $,"6 (.0-)+.$ ("4)($ .$'").- 4)8,4 ("."4)($ )+-, — $0-4
)464 ("385 9"#40 9"/)'.8.4+, 1.0* 1".* "3.6.4 9.- ,(-% (,"80 $<.(.-!.),-$
.()4# 62", 9$ ("."4)( .* (2)"7 (#"")$ $86$ .(.,"-0 ("4)(4 1.!$4", 1.."3.+
87"34 1..3"+-) 1..).',- 1.-/,, .1.3+ ("-," 1.)"+8 0+ $6.,'$3!4 )(".4 4./.
!"#0 ("./ .470 ,5)'4" — #"*4 +",.+ 0+ (",)"3 .470 (".("4)( ("6,8 0+ 9("4./.0
Morton J. Horwitz The Transformation of American Law 1<;J–1KUJ: The Crisis of
36
.Legal Orthodoxy ,Oxford, 1KK21 U2–UU
Shalom H. Schwartz TCultural Value Differences: Some Implications for WorkT %< :"-)
32
:"-) (")4# )5+, .470 "% (.5)"-.( ()72, (0#$0 *Appl'd Psychol. Int'l Rev. ,1KKK1 2$
Amir N. Licht TThe Mother of All Path Dependencies: Toward a Cross–Cultural Theory
.of Corporate Governance SystemsT 2U Del. J. Corp. L. ,2JJ11 1%;
Shalom H. Schwartz TMapping and Interpreting Cultural Differences around the :"-)
WorldT in Comparing Cultures: Dimensions of Culture in a Comparative Perspective
.,Boston, Henk Vinken, Joseph Soeters & Peter Ester eds., 2JJ%1 %$
15K
38
&"$)!- "- ."#$%& /0)+
/1"2 ("+%
.("3")#-$ 1.3+$ 1.+"0+4 ("#'0 ,$% 9..384 ()*.3 ("4./. 08 1.6.8, 9*- — ("(.#+"
.$4 1.*,"( 13.- 17 <- ,0!3)' $7./$+ $385$ (- 1.*.)', 13.- $0- 1.-/,,
(.-!.),-$ $)4#4 .* $)420 1..07) +.+ $,"6 ,(.).',- $#*"$0 9(.3 "3.- )46$ 1- ?<*0 1.."5.4$ .1.3")#-$ 1.)"+8$ <0$,4 (".3),+ (".7"0"-.6.-4 $*.,($ $)47($
1)%$ 0+ 1.50"4$ 1.)4"6$ (- — 9".6$ -+", .5'+,$ )+!$0 )"%#3 1- .)"'2, 1.4)
50#$4 9(.3 ,1$.08 $8.4/, 0!3)'+ $0- (- 5)'4" ,5'+,0 (.0*0*$ $+.74 .%*),$
0+ 1.!$4",$ 1.3..'-,$ 9.4 ,$3$" ."7!.+ (0"*2- 0+ .3),+$ 1)%$ .7/..,* 7""20
(.3),+$ $+.7$ %J..()4# 9"."".+'.-4 $*.,( 0+ 6"2.$ 17 ."/, (.3),+$ $.7"0"-.6.-$
("-/"(0 )+*$ (3("3" ,(".()4# 9.0,"7'("."2#..($0 ()72,* $%"#$ (- $+.76, 9*#"*$ 084 9.4 9"."".+'.-0 ("0.4", 9$ )+-* 17 $0-* 9.0,"7'("."2#..($, ("84"3$
$%"#$ 9.6 0+ "3)! (..084 ("-)0 9(.3 ,9,(2,$ $4+#,$'<0$ .'0 %1."0 1.'"'*$ 9.40
.)(". ("4#) (".()4# (")",( 0+ ("'!(+$ 1"+, 9",-$ 9.6 0+ ((3853$) "(6.).4"
1%.0)4.0$ 0+ (,."2, $7.234" ("3),+$ 0+ (.2#. (")47($4 ("3..'-(, $0- (")",(
.3.64 (",7,$ (- .6,0 $4"5 $)"/4 ()-(, "% $./.%"'")' ,.3.84 .(.-!.),-$ $)4#4
.5'+,0 .0*0*$ #"(.3$ (+.7 0+ $8'+$$ 9, 8")70 .04, (-%" ,(.)4$'("/)-4 (")4#$
.$.470 ("),2, 8"4!0 )+'-'.-+ ,6404 (.(",+)($ $3!2,4 )4"6, ,1"!, 0*,
.6* $4 +. )+-" ,$.0- (2#..(, $3.- 0!3)'+ $4"+# $.7"2 08 8.4/- ,1"*.20
5'+,0 (.0*0*$ $+.7$ 0+ $(#0/$ 6"24 (87"3 "% $.7"2 .?2"3 )!#,0 9"".* (""($0
1..(84+ !(), $% ."3.+ .(.)4$'("/)-4 .5'+,$ #.+4 .533.,"6 $* 6,8,0 $(..08"
.6.'08 90"* ")8)"8 5'+,$ 0+ .20!$ .0*0*$ #"(.3$ 0+ 6"2.$'.34- .* "3)*"%4
0+ 1("0.8.4 $!"6-$ $3",-4 $0*" (.03"./)$ $).#4$ 06",4 0#$ ,1,/8 1.30*0*$
("3853$ (")",($ 9.40 (.0*0*$ $+.7$ 9.4 )+!0 .!0# )42$ ."/, <*4+ 9*(.. .1.!""+
%2
.)#- 68",0 $#6.. $.7"24 9".6$ <- ,5'+,4
$K
Amir N. Licht, Chanan Goldschmidt & Shalom H. Schwartz TCulture Rules: The :"-)
Foundations of the Rule of Law and Other Norms of GovernanceT ,working paper, 2JJ51
.available at http:eepapers.ssrn.comesol$epapers.cfmfabstractgidh$1%55K ,<.5.2JJU1
John T. Jost, Jack :"-) (.7"0"*.2'$ (")'24 1.-/,,$ 0+ 08'#"(.30" $'.!, $).!20
Glaser, Arie W. Kruglansky & Frank J. Sulloway TPolitical Conservatism as Motivated
.Social CognitionT 12K Psychol. Bull. ,2JJ$1 $$K
Michael Bradley, Cindy A. Schipani, Anant K. Sundaram & James P. :"-) .00* 9".60
Walsh TThe Purposes and Accountability of the Corporation in Contemporary Society:
39
40
41
.Corporate Governance at a CrossroadsT U2 Law & Contemp. Probs. ,1KKK1 K
:0+,0 ,"-) 42
.Rev. ,2JJ51 $J$
Anita Bernstein TWhatever Happened to Law and EconomicsfT U% Md. L.
1UJ