W W Rostow,The StâgesofEconomic Gro$'th: A Non-Communist... http://uvwmtholyoke.edûacad/intrelrpe/ronow.htm W.W. Rosto% TheStagesof Economic Grawh: A Non-CommunistMunifesto (Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,1960),Chapter2, "The Five Stagesof Growth--A Summary" pp, 4-16 CIIAPTER 2 TIIE FIVE STAGES.OF.GROWTII.-A SUMMARY It is possibleto identifyall societies, in theireconomicdimensions, aslying within oneoffive catego.ies:the traditional society,the preconditionsfor take-off,the take-off,the drive to matu.ity, and theageofhigh mass-conslunption. TÏIE TRADITIONAL SOCIETY First,thetraditionalsociety.A traditionalsocietyis onewhosestructureis developed within limited productionfunctions,basedon pre-Newtonianscienc€andtechnology,and on pre-Newtonianattitudes towardsthe physicalworld. Newton is hereusedasa symbol for that watershedin history whenmen camewidely to believethat the externalworld wassubjectto a few knowablelaws, and was systematiÇally çapableof productivemanipulation. The conceptionofthe taditional societyis, however,in no sensestatic;and it would not exclude increasesin output.Acreagecould be expanded;somead ioc technicalinnovalions,often highly productiveinnovations,could be introducedin trade,industryandagiculture; productivity could rise with, for example,the impovement ofinigation works or the discoveryanddiffusion ofa new crop. But the cenfal fact aboutthe faditional societywasthat a ceiling existedon the level ofattainable outputper head.This ceiling resultedfrom the fact that th€ potentialitieswhich flow from modem scienceandtechnologywereçither not availableor not regularly andsystematicallyapplied. Both in the longerpastandin recenttimesthe story of traditionalsoçietieswasthusa story of endless change.The areaandvolumeoftrade within them andbetweenthemfluctuated,for example,with the degreeofpolitical andsocialturbulence, theefficiencyofcentralrule,theupkeepofthe roads. Population-and,within limits, the level oflife-rose andfell not only with the sequenceofthe harvests,but with the incidenceofwar and ofplague. Varyingdegreesofmanufactured€veloped;bu! asin agriculture, the levelofproductivitywaslimitedby the inaccessibility ofmodemscience,its applications,aad its frameofmind. Generallyspeaking,thesesocieties,becauseofthe limitation on productivity,hadto devotea very high Foportion oftheir resourcesto agricultue; andflowing from the agdculturalsystemtherewasan hierarchicalsocialstructwe,with relatively narrowsçope--butsomescope-for vertical mobility. Family andclan connexionsplayeda largerole in socialorganization.The value systemofthese societieswasgenerallygearedto what might be calleda long-runfatalisq that is, the assumplionthat the rangeofpossibilities opento one'sgrandchildrenwould bejust aboutwhat it hadbeenfor one's grandpaxents. But this long-runfatalismby no meansexcludedthe short-runoption that, within a considerablerange,it waspossibleandlegitimatefor the individual to shive to improvehis lot, within his lifetime.In Chinesevillages,for example,therewasan endlesssfuggleto acquireor to avoid losing land,yielding a situationwhereland rarely remainedwithin the samefamily for a century. Although centralpolitical rule--in oneform or another--oftenexistedin ûaditional socigties, transcendingthe relatively self-sufficientf€gions,the centreof graviq/ ofpolitical powergenerallylay l of 9 21.O2.2012 2l:24 W W Rosl,os.The S.agesof FcoromicGo\ah q \on-Communisl hfip://www mtholyoke.edu/rcadliûtrel/ip€./rostow. htm in the regions,in the handsofthose who ownedor controlledthe land. The landownermaintained fluctuatingbut usuallyprofoundinfluenceoversuchcentralpoliticalpowerasexisted,backedby its transcending enlourage ofcivil seûantsandsoldiers,imbuedwith attitudesandconholledby interests theregions. In termsofhistorythen,with thephrase'traditionalsociery'wearegroupingthewholepre-NeMonian world : thedynasties in China;thecivilizationofthe MiddleEastandtheMediterraneaq theworldof medievalEurope.And to themwe addthe post-NeMoniansocietieswhich, for a tim€, remained untouchedor unmovedby man'snew capabilityfor regularlymanipulatinghis environmentto his economicadvantage. To placetheseinfinitely various,changingsocietiesin a singlecategory,on the groundthat they all shareda ceiling on the productivity oftheir economictechniques,is to sayvery little indeed.But we are,afterall, merelyclearingtheway in orderto getat thesubjectofthis boob thatis, the post-traditonalsocieties, in whicheachofthe majorcharacteristics ofthe traditionalsocietywas alteredin suchwaysas1opermit regulargrowth: its politics, socialstructurc,and(to a degee) its values,aswell asits economy. THE PRECONDITIONS FORTAKE-OFF The secondstageof$owth embraces in theplocessoftransitiontthatis, theperiodwhenthe societies preconditionsfor take-off aredeveloped;for it takestime to transforma traditional socieryin the ways necessary for it to exploitthefruitsof modemscience, to fendoffdiminishingretums,andthus!o enjoy the blessingsand choicesopenedup by the marchofcompound intercst Thepreconditions for take-offwereinitiallydeveloped, in a clearlymarkedway,in WestemEuropeof the late seventeenth andeady eighteenthc€nturiesasthe insightsofmodem sciencebeganto b€ translatedinto n€w productionfunctionsin both agricultur€and industry,in a settinggiven dynamism by the lateml expansionof world marketsandthe intemationalcompetitionfor them.But all that lies behindthe break-upof the Middle Ages is relevantio the creationof the preconditionsfor take-otr in WestemEurope.Among the WestemEuropeanstates,B tain, favouredby geography,natural resources,tradingpossibilities,socialandpolitical structure,wasth€ first 1odevelopfully the pre€onditions for take-ofl The moregeneralcasein modemhistory,however,sawthestageofpreconditions arisenot €ndogenously but from someextemalintrusionby moreadvanced societies. Theseinvasionsliteralor figurative-shockedthe traditional societyandbeganor haslenedits undoing;but they also setin motionideasandsentiments whichinitiatedtheprocess by whicha modemaltemativeto the traditional societywasconstructedout ofthe old culture. is a The ideaspreads not merelythateconomicprogress is possible, hut thateconomicprogress necessary conditionfor someotherpurpos€,judged to be good:b€ it nalionaldignity,privateprofit,the generalwelfare,or a beûerlife for the children.Education,for someat least,broadensandchangesto suittheneedsofmodemeconomicactivity.New typesofenterprisingmencomeforward*inthe private economy,in govemment,or both--willing to mobilize savingsard to takedsks in pursuit of plofit or modemization.Banksandoth€r institutionsfor mobilizing capitalappearInvestment increases,notably in transport,communications,andin raw materialsin which othernationsmay have an economicinterest.The scopeofcommerce,internalandexternal,widens.And, hereandthere, modemmanufacturing ent€rprise appears, usingthe newmethods. But all this acûviryproceeds at a limited pacewithin an economyanda socierystill mainly characterizedby traditional low-Foductivity methods,by the old social structue andvalues,andby the regionallybasedpolifical institutionsthat 2 o19 21.02.201221:24 ww Rostow.The StâsesofEconomicGroù,th:ANon-Communist... htto://www mtholvokeedr/acâd/intrel/iDe/rostowhùyr developedin conjunctionwith them. In rnanyrecentcases,for example,the traditionalsocietypersistedsideby sidewith modem€conomic power açtivities,conducted for limitqdeconomicpurposes by a colonialor quasi-colonial Although the periodoftransition:between the taditional societyandthe take-off-saw major changes in boththeeconomyitselfandin thebalanceof socialvalues,a decisivefeaturewasoftenpolitical. Politically,thebuildingofan efectivecentalizednationalstate--on thebasisofcoalitionstouched with a new nationalism,in oppositionto the traditionallarded regionalinterests,the colonial power,or both, wasa decisiveaspectofthe Fecondilionsperiod:andit was,almostuniversally,a necessary conditionfor tak€-ofï Thereis a greatdeal morethat needsto be saidaboutthe preconditionsperiod,but we shall leaveit for chapter3, whereth€ anatomyofthe transitionfrom a traditjonalto a modemsocietyis examined. THE TAKE-OFF We com€now to the greatwatershedin the life ofmodem societies:the third stagein this sequence, the ake-off The take-offis the intervalwhenthe old blocksandresistancesôosteadygroMh are finally overcome.The forcesmakingfor economicprogress,which yielded limited bu6ts and enclaves ofmodern activiq/, expandandcome1odominatethe society.Growth b€comesits normalcondition. Compoundinterestbecomesbuilt, as it were,into its habitsandinstitutionalstructule. ln Britain andthe well-endowedpartsof the world populatedsubstantiallyûom Britain (the United States,Canadaetc.) the proximatestimulusfor take-offwasmainly (but not wholly) technological.In the more generalcase,the take-offawaitednot only the build-up ofsocial overheadcapitaland a surge oftechnological developmentin industryandagriculture,but alsothe emergetrce to political powe! of a group preparedto regardthe modemizationofthe economyasserious,high-orderpolitical business. During the take-off,the rate ofeffective investmentandsavingsmay rise from, say,5 0%ofthe national incometo 100% or more;althoughwherehealy socialoverheadcapitalinvestmentwasr€quiredto createthe technicalpreçonditionsfor take-offthe investmentratein the preconditionsperiod could be higherthan 5%, as,for example,in Canadabeforethe 1890'sandArgentiûabefore 1914.In suchcases capital importsusually formeda high proportionoftotal investmcntin the preconditionsperiod and sometimesev€ndurirg the take-off itself, asin RussiaandCanadaduring their pre-1914railway booms. During the iake-offnew indusûiesexpandrapidly,yielding profits a largeproportionofwhich are reinvested in newplanqandthes€newindustri€s, in tum, stimulate, though theirrapidlyexpanding requiremenlfor faclory workers,the servicesto suppo( them,andfor othermanufacturedgoods,a further expansionin urbanareasand in othermodernindustrialplants.Tbe whole proc€ssofexpansion in the modernsectoryields an increaseof incomein the handsof thosewho not only savea1high rates but placetheirsavingsat thedisposalofthoseengaged in modemsectoractiviti€s.Thenewclassof entrepreneurs expands;andit directsthe enlargingflows of investmentin the private sector The economyexploitshithertounusednaturalresourcesandmethodsof production. New techniquesspreadin agricultureaswell asindustry,asagdaulhre is commercialized,and increasingnumben offa.mers arepreparedto acceptthe new methodsandthe deepchangesthey bring to ways oflife. The revolutionarychangesin agriculturalproductivityare an essentialconditionfor successfultake-off; for modemizationofa socieryincreasesradically its bill for agricultunl Foducts. In a decadeof two both the basicsfuctule ofthe economyandthe socialand political sauctureofthe socieryare transformedin sucha way that a st€adyrate of gro!'vthcanbe, thereafter,regularly 3 of9 21 02.2Ol221:24 WW Rostoq TbeStagesofEconomicG.owth:A Non-Communist.. http://wwiv mtholyok€.edu/acadlintrel,4pe/rostowhtm su$alneo. As indicatedin chapter4, onecanapproximatelyallocatethe take-offofBritain to the two decades after 1783; Franceandthe United Statesto the severaldecadesprecedingI 860; Germany,the third quarterofthe nineteenthcentury'Japan,the fourth quarterofthe nineteenthcentury;Russiaand Canadathe quarter-centuryor so preaeding1914;while during the 1950'sIndia and Chinahave,in quite different ways,larmchedtheir respectivetale-offs. ]}IE DRIVE TO MATURITY After take-offtherefollows a long interval ofsusiainediffluctuatng progress,asthe now regularly growing economydrivesto extendmodemtechnologyover the whole liont ofits economicactivity. Some10-20%ofthe nationalincomeis steadilyinvested,permittingoutputregularlyto outstrip the increasein population.The make-upofthe economychang€sunc€asinglyasûechniqueimprov€s,new industriesaccelerate,older indust eslevel ofi The economyfinds its placein the international economy:goodsform€rly importedareproducedat home;new import requirementsdevelop,arld new exportçommoditiesto matchthem.The societymakessuchtermsas it will with the requirem€ntsof modem€mcient production,balancingoff the new againstthe older valuesard institutions,or revising the latter in suchways asto supportÉther thanto retardthe gro\athprocess. Somesixty yearsafter take-offbegins(say,forry yealsafter the endoftake-off) what may be called maturity is generallyattained.The economy,focusedduringthe take-offa.ould a relatively nar.ow complexof industryandtechnology,hasextendedits rarge into morerefinedandtechlologically often morecomplexprocesses; for example,theremay be a shift in focusftom the coal, iron, andheavy engineeringindustriesofthe railway phaseto machine-tools,chemicals,andelectricalequipment. This, for example,wasthe fiansition throughwhich Germany,Britaiq Ffance,andthe Uniied States hadpassedby the endofthc nineteenthcenturyor shortlythereafter But thereareother sectoral pattemswhich havebeenfollowed in the sequencefrom take-offûomatudty,which are consideredin ahapter5. Formally,we candefinematurity asthe stagein which an economydemonshates the capacityto move beyondthe original industrieswhich poweredits take-of andto absorbandto apply efficiently over a very wide rangeof its resoruces--ifnot the whole range--themost advancedfruits of (then)modem technology.This is the stag€in which an economydemonstatesthat it hasthe technologicalard entrepreneurialskills to producenot everything,but anythingthat it choosesto produce.It may laçk (like contemporarySwedenand Switzerland,for example)the raw materialsor other supplyconditions requiredto producea giventype of outputeconomically;but its dependence is a matterof economic political priority choiceor ratherthan a teçhnologicalor institutionalnecessity. Historically, it would appea.that somethinglike sixty yearswasrequircdto movea societyfrom the beginningoftake-offto matu.ity.Analytically the explanationfor somesuchinterval may lie in the powerful arithmeticof compoundinterestappliedto the çapitalstock,combinedwith the brcader consequenc€s for a society'sability to absorbmodemteahnologS/ ofthree successivegenerationsliving undera regimewheregrowth is the normalcondition.But, clearly,no dogmatismisjustified aboutthe exactlengthofthe interval from take-offto maturity. THE AGE OF HIGH MASS-CONSLMPTION Wecomenow to theageofhigh mass-consumption, where,in time,the leadingsectorsshjfttowards durableconsumers'goodsand services:a phasefrom which Americansarc beginningto emeige; whosenot uequivocal joys WestemEuropeandJapanarebeginningeneryeticallyto probe;andwith which Sovietsocietyis engagedin an uneasyflirtation. 4 of 9 2l.O2.2012 2l:24 WW Rostow-TheStaqes ofEconomicGrowthrANon-Communist... http://rlww.mtholyokeedl/acaMnEel/ipe/rostow.htm As societiesachievedmaturiryin the twentiethcenturytwo thingshappened:real incomeper headrose to a point wherea largenumberofpersonsgaineda commandover consumptionwhich transcended basicfood, shelter,and clothing; andthe structureofthe working forc€ changedin wayswhich increasednot only the proportionof urbanto total population,but alsothe proportionofthe population working in ollices or in skilled factoryjobs-awareofand anxiousto açquirethe consumptionfruits of a matwe economy. In additionto theseeconomicchanges,the societyceasedto acceptths further extensionofmodern technologyasan overridingobjective.It is in this post-matu.itystage,for example,thal, throughthe political process,Westemsocietieshavechos€nto allocateircreasedresourcesto soçial welfareand security.The€mergence ofthe welfareslateis onemanifestation ofa society'smovingbeyond maturity; it is resources increasingly technical but alsoat this stagethat teûd to be directedto the productionof consumers' durables andto the diffusionofserviceson a massbasis,if consumers' sovercigntyr€igns.The sewing-machine, the bicycle,andthenthe variouselectric-poweredhousehold gadgetswere graduallydiffused.Historically,however,the decisiveelementhasbeenthe cheapmass automobilewith its quite revolutionaryeffects--socialaswell aseconomic--onthe life and expectations of society. For theUnitedStates, thetumingpointwas,perhaps, HenryFord'smovingassembly line of l913-14; groMh post-war but it was in the 1920's,and againin the decade,1946-56,that this stageof was pressedto, virtually, its logiçal conclusion.In the 1950'sWestemEuropeandJapanappearto have fully enteredthis phase,accountingsubstantiallyfor a momentumin their economiesquite unexpected in the immediatepost-waryears.The SovietUnion is technicallyreadyfor this stage,ard, by every sign,its citizenshungerfor iq but Communistleadersfacedimcultpoliticalandsocialproblemsof adjustmentifthis stageis launched. BEYOND CONSIMPÏON Beyond,it is impossibleto predict,exceptperhapsto obsewethat Ame cans,at least,havebehavedin the pastdecadeasifdiminishiDgrelativemarginalutility setsin, aftera point,for durableconsumers' goods;andthey havechosen,at the margin,largerfamilies- behaviourin the pattemofBuddenbrooks dynamics.* * In ThomasMann'snovelofthreegenerations, the first soughtmoney;the second,bom positiont to money,soughtsocialandcivic the third, bom to comfort andfamily prestig€, lookedto the life ofmusic. The phraseis designedto suggest,then,the changing aspirationsofgenerations,asthey placea low valueon what theytake for grantedand seeknew forms of satisfaction. Am€ricanshavebehaved asif, havingbeenbom into a systemthatprovided€conomics€cudtyand high mass-consumption, theyplaceda lower valuationolr acqui ng additionalincrementsofreal incomein the conventionalform asopposedto the advantagesandvaluesofan enlargedfamily. But evenin this adventur€in generalizationit is a shadetoo soonto create--onthe basisof onecas€--anew stage-of-groMh,basedon babies,in succession to the ageofconsumels'durables:aseçonomistsmight the income-elasticrty for may well vary from socictyto society.But it is true that say, ofdemand babies the implicationsofthe babyboomalong with the not wholly unrelateddeficit in socialoverhead capital are likely 10dominatethe Americaneconomyover the next decaderatherthan the further difusion ofconsi'mers'durables. Here then,in an impressionisticratherthanan analyticway,arethe slages-of-groMhwhich canbe 5 of 9 21.02.2012 2l:24 WW Rosloq the Stages ofEconomiccrowth: ANon-Communist... http://www mtholyoke.edù/âcad/intrei/iDe/rostow.htrn distinguished oncea traditionalsocietybeginsits modemizationi thetransitional periodwhenthe preconditions for take-offareqeatedgenerallyin response to the intrusionofa foreignpowel convergingwith certaindomesticforcesmakingfor modemization;the take-off itself; the sw€epinto maturitygenerallytakingup the life ofabouttwo furthergenerations; andthen,finaliy,rfthe riie of incomebasmatchedthe spreadoftechnologicalvituosity (which, aswe shall see,it neednot imrnediatelydo) the diversionofthe fully matule economyto the provisionofdurable consumerc, goodsandservices(aswell asthe welfareslate)for its increasinglyurban_and then subùrban_ population. Beyondliesthequestionofwhetheror not secularspiritualstagnation will arise,and,if it does,how manmight fend it ofl a matterconsideredin chapter6. ln the four chaptersthat follow we shalltake a hardet andmorerigorouslook at the preconditions,the take-offthed ve to maturity,andtheprocesses whichhaveledto the ageofhigh mass-consumption. But evenin this introductorychapteronecharacteristiçofthis systemshouldbe madeclear A DYNAM]C TI]EORY OF PRODUCTION Thesestagesare not merely descriptiv€_They are not merelya way ofgeneralizing certainfactual observations aboutthesequence ofdevelopment ofmodemsocieties. Theyhavean innerlogicand continuiry.They havean analyticbone-structure,rooûedin a dynamictheoryofploduction. The classicaltheoryofproduction is formulatedunderessentiallystaticassumptionswhich.freeze_or permitonly once-over change-in thevariablesmostrelevantto the process oficonomic growth.As modemeconomistshavesoughtto mergeclassicalproductiontheorywith Keynesianincomeanalysis they haveintoduced the dynamicvariables:population,technology,entepreneurshipetc.But they havetend€dio do so in forms so rigid andgeneralthat their modelscannotgrip the ess€ntial phenomenaofgowth, asthey appearto an economichistodan.Werequireà dlnamic theory of Foducûonwhichisolatesnot only thedistributionofinçomebetweenconsumption, saving,and investment(andthe balanceofFoduction betweenconsume$andcapitalgooàs)but which focuses direcdyandin somedetail on the compositionofinvestrnentandon developmentswithin particular secto$ofthe economy.The argumentthat follows is basedon sucha flexible, disaggregaûed theory of production. Whentheconventional limits on thetheoryofproductionarewidened,it is possibleto define theoretical equilibriumpositionsnot only for output.rnvestment, andconsumption asa whore,but rbr eachsectorofthe economv* * W.W Rostow,TlreProcessofEconomic Grov,th(Oxford,l953),especially chapterrv. AIso'Trendsin thÊAllocationofResoucesin SecularGrowth,',chaÏler 15of bconomrc Progre.rs, ed.LeonH. Dupriez,with tle assislance of DouglasC Hagle (Louvain,1955). within the frarneworksetby forcesdeterminingthe total revelofoulput, sectoraloptimumpositions aredeteminedon thesideofdemand,by the levelsof incomeandofpopulation,andby thecharacter of tastes;on the sideof supply,by the stateof technologyandthe qualiry of €nfepreneushjp,asthe latterdetermines theproportionoftechnicay availabre andpotentiay profitabreinnovations aÇtuay incorpoËtedin the capitalstock.* * ln a closedmodel,a dynamictheory ofproductionmustaccountfor changilgstocksof basicandappliedscience, assectoralaspects ofinvesûnent, whichis donein I&e procers ofE.onomi.Grovth. especially pp.22-5. 6of9 2t0220t2 21 24 WW Rostoq Th€Stages of EconomicGro$th:ANon-Commùnist.. pe/rostow.htm http://www mtholyokeedu/acad/intrel/i In addition,one must introducean extremelysignificantempiricalhypothesis:namely,that decelerationis the nomal optimumpathofa sector,dueto a variety offactors operatingon it, from the sideofboth supplyanddemand.* * I'rocets of EconomicGrowth,pp. 96-703. The equilibria which emergefrom the applicationofthese crite a area setof sectoralpaths,from which flows, asfirst derivatives,a sequenceof optimumpatt€msof investrnent. Historical pattemsof investmentdid not, ofcourse, exactlyfollow theseoptimumpatterns.They were distortedby imp€rfectionsin the privale investmentprocess,by the policiesofgovemments,andby the impactof waIS.Warstempora ly alteredthe profitabledirectionsofinvestnent by settingup arbitrarydemandsandby changingthe conditionsofsupply;they destroyedcapital;and,occasionally, economyand shiftedthe they acceleratedthe developmentof n€w technologyrelevantto the pea.c€lime political and socialframeworkin waysconduciveto peacetimegro*th.* The historicalsequenceof business-cycles andtrend-oeriodsresultsfrom * Prccessof EconomicGtowth, chapterVlL esp€ciallypp. 164-7. thesedeviationsofactual from optimalpattems;and suchfluctuations,along with the impactofwars, yield historical pathsof growth which diIïer from thqsewhich the optima,calculatedbeforethe event, wouldhaveyielded. Nevçrthçlçss,thç eçonomichistory ofgrowing societiestakesa part ofits rude shapefrom the €ffort of soÇietiesto approximatethe optimumsectoralpaths. At any periodof time, the rateof glowth in the sectorswill vary greatly;and it is possibleto isolate empirically certainleadingsectors,at early stagesof their evolution,whoserapid rate of expansion plays an essentialdirect andindirectrole in maintainingthe overall momentumofth€ economy.* For someoulDoses 1tls * For a discussionofthe leadingsectors,their direct ard indirect consequences: andthe impact, in Allocation in Secular diverseroutesoftheir see'Trends the ofResources Gro\t"'th',bc. cit. usefulto characterizean economyin termsof its leadingsecto$,and a part of the technicalbasisfor the stagesofgro\ath lies in the changingsequenceofleading sectors.ln essenceit is the fact that sectorstendto havea rapid grou'th-phase,early in their life, that makesit possibleandusefulto regard economichistory asa sequenc€of stag€sratherthanmerelyasa continuum,within which naturenever makesaJump. The stages-of-goMhalsorequire,however,that elasticitiesofdemandbe takeninlo account,andthat this familiar conceptbe widened;for theserapid growth phasesin the sectorsderivenot merely from the discontinuityof productionfunctionsbut also from high price- or income-elasticitiesof demand. Leadingsectorsaredetenined not merelyby the changingflow oftechnology andthe changing 7 of 9 2l.02.201221:24 WW. Rosto\ The Stages ofEcononic Grolrth:ANon'Communist... httDr/ r'wwmtholvoke.eôtacadintrel/iDdrostowhtm willingnessofentreprençursto aaçeptavailablginnovations;they are alsopartially determinedby thosetypesofdemandwhichhaveexhibitedhighelasticitywith respectûopric€,income,or both. The demandfor resourceshas.esulted,however,not merelyfrom demandssetup by privatetastçand choice,but alsofrom socialdecisions andfromth€policiesofgovernm€fis--wheth€r democratically responsive in thedisposition or not.It is necessary, therefore, to lookat thechoicesmadeby societies in termswhichtnnscendconvenlional It is necessary oftheir resources marketprocesses. ûolook at processes theirwelfarefunctions,in th€widestsense,includingthe non-economic whichdetermined them. The courseofbirth-rates,for example,.epresents oneform ofwelfarechoicemadeby societies, as incone haschanged;andpopulationcurvesreflect (in additionto changingdeath-rates)how the calculusaboutfamilysizewasmadein theva ousstages; from theusual(butnot universal)declinein birth-rates,during or soonafter the take-off,asurbanizationtook hold and progressbecamea palpable possibility,to the recent se,asAmericans(and othersin societiesmarkedby high mass-consumption) haveappearedto seekin largerfamilies valuesbeyondthosealTordedby economicsecu ty andby an amplesupplyof dwable consumers'goodsand servicesAnd thereare otherdecisionsaswell that societieshavemadeasthe choiçesopento them havebeen alteredby the unfolding processof economicgro*th; andthesebroadcollectivedecisions,determined by many factors-deepin history culture,andthe activepolitical Focess-outsidethe market-place,have interplayedwith the dynamicsofmarket demand,risk-taking,technologyandentrepenewship,to determinethe specificcontentofthe stagesofgrowth fof eachsociety. How, for example,shouldthe traditionalsocjetyreactto the intrusionof a moreadvancedpoweri with cohesion,promptness,and vigour, like the Japanese; by makinga virtue iffecklessn€ss,like the oppressedIrish ofthe eighteenthc€ntuy: by slowly andreluctantlyalteringthe haditional society,like the Chincse? When independentmodemnationhoodis achieved,how shouldthe nationalenergiesbe disposed:in possibilities extemalaggression, for to ght old wrongsor to exploitnewlycrcatedor perceived enlargednationalpower; in completingard refining the political victory ofthe new national govemmentover old rcgionalinter€sts,or in modemizingthe economy? Onc€growth is underway,with the take-ofï,to what extentshouldthe requirementsofdiffusing moderntechnologyand maximizingthe rateofgrowth be moderatedby the desireto increase consumptionper capitaandto increasewelfare? Whcntechnological maturiryis reached, andthenationhasat ih commanda modemized and differentiatedindustrialmachine,to what endsshouldit be put, andin what proportions:to increase social secu ty, throughthe welfare state;to expald mass-consumption into the rangeof durable consumels'goodsard servic€s;to incrqasethe nation'sstatureandpoweron the world sçene;or to increase leisule? And thenth€ questionbeyond,wherehistory offers us only fragments:what to do whenthe increasein real incomeitself losesits charm?Babies,boredom,three-dayweek-ends,the moon,or the creaton of new inner,humanfrontiersin substitutionfor the imperativesofscajcity? ln surveyingnow the broadçontowsofeaah stage-of-gro\th,we areexamining,then,not merely the sgctolalstructureofeconomies,asthey hansfomed themselvesfor growlh, andgrew; we are also examininga succession ofstrategicchoicesmadeby varioussocieties conceming the dispositionof theû resources,which includ€but ûanscendthe income-andp ce-elasticitiesof demand. 8 of 9 21.02.2012 21:24 W W Rostow.The Stacesof EconomicGror\lh: A Non-Communist. http //www mlholyoke edu/acad/jntrel/ipe/rostowhtm l?chtrnto Jlnnia'.rth)!r1!Jlug! !lqat!a !a (i!!'hL!!L!!)!Ltall!c! lt e4tLt4ttLll liL!!!s! to 11'liSvllubll lfal1urn 9 of9 21.O22012 21 24
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz