WMO RADIOSONDE HUMIDITY SENSOR INTERCOMPARISON

WMO RADIOSONDE HUMIDITY SENSOR INTERCOMPARISON
PHASE II - FIELD TEST
Laboratory for Hydrospheric Processes
Goddard Space Flight Center, Wallops Flight Facility
Wallops Island, Virginia (USA)
8-26 September 1995
TABLE OF CONTENTS - PHASE II
0
Summary - Phase II .......................................................................................................... 1
1
Introduction and Objectives ............................................................................................. 1
2
Test Plan and Schedule .................................................................................................... 3
3
Radiosonde Description and Performance ....................................................................... 4
4
Profiles and Analyses ....................................................................................................... 7
5
Statistical Results ........................................................................................................... 14
6
Summary and Conclusions............................................................................................. 23
7
Recommendations .......................................................................................................... 25
8
References ...................................................................................................................... 26
PHASE II - FIELD TEST
0
Summary - Phase II
This relative humidity sensor intercomparison report discusses the performance of the relative
humidity sensors available on operational radiosondes used global-wide. The intercomparison
was sponsored by the World Meteorological Organization and hosted in two parts. The first
by the CAO Russian Federation in Moscow, and the second part at NASA Wallops Flight
Facility, Virginia USA. Results of the first part of the intercomparison are presented
elsewhere; this document discuss the field trial that dook place in September 1995 at Wallops
Island. It should be noted that the results of this intercomparison are long overdue and this
document provides information about the relative humidity sensors as existed in 1995.
1
Introduction and Objectives
The adequacy of radiosonde relative humidity sensor accuracy has concerned meteorologists
for many years (Elliott and Gaffen, 1991; Morrissey and Brousaides, 1970; Brousaides and
Morrissey, 1974). Intercomparisons sponsored by the World Meteorological Organization
(WMO) and other organizations, showed that improvement of relative humidity sensor
accuracy is needed. Especially in the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere. Thus,
radiosonde manufacturers are challenged to produce more reliable and accurate relative
humidity sensors to meet the routine needs of national meteorological services.
Meteorological services are major purchasers of radiosondes, nevertheless, the large variety
of research programs also are very much concerned about the quality of radiosonde relative
humidity data. Among these are numerical weather prediction investigators, projects such as
GEWEX, TOGA-COARE, TRMM, and others. Basically, relative humidity measurement
discrepancies stem from: the different types of sensors in use and the methods in which they
are handled; the manner in which they are mounted or otherwise exposed on the radiosonde;
and, from deficiencies in transfer equations or algorithms (Wade, 1995). Not only are
differences between radiosonde humidity measurements a problem for the meteorological
community, but disagreement between remotely sensed and in situ radiosonde measurements
pose particular troublesome problems. It is typical to validate remote observations using
radiosonde measurements (Soden et al, 1994). Unfortunately, relative humidity measurement
uncertainties make remote sensor validation results questionable, and in many instances
misleading. An intercomparison of operational relative humidity sensors was planned
byWMO and conducted in 1995 from Wallops Island, Virginia USA. This intercomparison’s
objective was to identify measurement discrepancies and a better understanding of the role
atmospheric humidity plays in dynamical and hydrological processes at various temporal and
spatial scales.
The WMO Commission on Instruments and Methods of Observation (CIMO) agreed to a
proposal from the Working Group on Upper-Air Observations that an intercomparison of
relative humidity sensors was necessary. The role of the Upper-Air Working Group is to
monitor upper air instrument performance, identify observation discrepancies, and insure that
meaningful measurement practices are recommended and,so far as practicable, followed.
Previous intercomparisons (Hooper, 1986; Nash and Schmidlin, 1987; Schmidlin, 1988;
Ivanov et al, 1991; and, Yagi et al, 1996) pointed to temperature measurements as a major
cause of radiosonde differences, but recognized that the different relative humidity sensors
employed was also a problem. An International Organizing Committee (IOC) was organized
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
to define the intercomparison objectives, to monitor its conduct, and to insure that results
would be disseminated. The IOC met during February 1995 at the facilities of the Central
Aerological Observatory (CAO) in Moscow, Russian Federation. Participants were from
Finland, Russia, Switzerland, United Kingdom (UK), and The United States of America
(USA).
The intercomparison took place in two phases. Phase 1, a laboratory comparison employed
environmental test chambers capable of operating over a large range of temperature and
relative humidity values. Phase 1 was carried out during June 1995in the laboratories of CAO
in Moscow. Phase II was hosted between September 8-26 1995by the National Aeronautics
and Space Administration (NASA) at Wallops Flight Facility (WFF) of the Goddard Space
Flight Facility (GSFC) located at Wallops Island, Virginia USA. Phase II included the
Russian MRZ-3 radiosonde, the Atmospheric Instrumentation Research, Inc. (AIR) digital
Intellisonde, the Vaisala RS-80-15LA, RS80-15LH, and RS-90 radiosondes, and the VIZ
Manufacturing Co. (VIZ) MK-2 digital radiosonde (VIZ was taken over by Sippican, Inc in
1997 and Sippican subsequently was incorporated into Lockheed Martin Sippican). Table 1
lists the radiosondes and sensor types flown in the intercomparison. The Phase II operations
plan required each participant to prepare its own radiosonde for flight, acquire and verify its
data, process and provide their data in a format suitable for analysis. Personnel from VIZ
Manufacturing Co. and Vaisala Co. arrived at Wallops Flight Facility three days ahead of the
first scheduled observation. Personnel from AIR, Inc. arrived at Wallops Island a few days
after the initiation of the intercomparison. The first AIR radiosonde was flown beginning with
flight number 17 on 12 September at 1700:35 UTC. Preparation of this instrument was
simple, because of alkaline dry-cell batteries used to power this instrument. The dry-cell
batteries also made it possible to turn the radiosonde on and off, as necessary. The Russian
participants arrived on 14 September and rapidly set up their equipment. The first
measurement of the Russian MRZ-3 radiosonde was obtained on 15 September. Data from all
participants were delivered to the Project Leader as agreed to in the IOC operation plan.
The specific objectives of the Phase II field test were to:
(a) investigate performance of relative humidity sensors over a substantial range of flight
conditions;
(b) assess differences between simultaneous measurements;
(c) determine whether adjustments for systematic relative humidity measurement error would
be feasible; and,
(d) obtain information to examine day-night relative humidity differences and determine
whether contamination of the relative humidity sensors occurs after passing through clouds.
PHASE II - page 2
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
Table 1. Radiosonde types, manufacturer, and characteristics of the participating radiosondes
flown in Phase II of the WMO International Radiosonde Relative Humidity Sensor Intercomparison are
listed below. The MRZ-3 radiosonde of the CAO, Russian Federation was considered to be an
anomalous radiosonde in that it did not use a pressure sensor and the temperature sensor mount
was fitted with a second relative humidity sensor.
Radiosonde
Name
Manufacture
r
VIS MK 2
VIZ Mfg Co.
Transmitte
r
Frequency
MHz
403
RS80-15LA
Vaisala Co.
403
RS80-15LH
Vaisala Co.
403
RS90
Vaisala Co.
403
Intellisonde
AIR Inc.
403
MRZ-3
CAO, Russian
Federation
1782
Pressure
Sensor
Thermistor
Sensor
Relative
Humidity
Sensor
Capacitive
Aneroid
Capacitive
Aneroid
Capacitive
Aneroid
Capacitive
Aneroid
Capacitive
Aneroid
None
Resistive
Carbon
Hygristor
Capacitive
Humicap
Capacitive
Humicap
Heated
Capacitive
Capacitive
Capacitive
Capacitive
Capacitive
Capacitive
None
1 – Capacitive
2 - Goldbeaters
2
Test Plan and Schedule
As in previous WMO radiosonde intercomparisons, the IOC requested the host facility to
designate one person to act as the Project Leader. The Project Leader’s responsibilities are: to
specify the test procedures that the participants agree to observe, conduct the final analysis,
and prepare the results for publication by WMO. It was agreed by the participants that any
observation reaching the 50-hPa pressure level would be considered successful. This pressure
level was acceptable because present day relative humidity sensors normally can not measure
to low pressures. Each participating organization also was to appoint a Team Leader
responsible for the performance of their group, and to provide coordination with the other
groups. The Project Leader, with the cooperation of the Team Leaders, organized and
scheduled the day-to-day balloon flights. To facilitate smooth and on-time performance a
Balloon Launch Manager, assigned by the Project Leader and an employee of the host
facility, insures that the balloon and flight train are correctly prepared and that each team's
radiosonde is ready for flight at the designated time. Within 30 to 60 minutes following each
balloon flight the NASA Data Coordinator transmitted each participants data to the central
computing facility via the Wallops Island internal network where knnowledgable personnel
reviewed the submitted measurement files for completeness, provide quality checking,
arrange the data into a uniform format and, provide plots of each participants data to the
respective teams for final quality check.
Prior to the first balloon flight it was agreed that only five radiosonde types would be
simultaneously flown on the instrument platform. The platform was constructed of two
Styrofoam cross arms positioned 40 meters below the balloon allowing all radiosondes to
obtain measurements at the same level. All instruments were suspended approximately
1 meter below the platform. Thus, the radiosondes made measurements at the same time and
in the same place in space, except for the nominal horizontal separation between radiosondes
of about 2.5 meters. A small parachute was necessary to allow safe descent of the instruments
PHASE II - page 3
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
after balloon burst. A parachute is necessary on all free-flying balloons to meet the safety
regulations of the United States Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). It was also
necessary that the balloon configuration (total payload weight, individual instrument weight
and size or density, number of instruments, etc) meet FAA regulations for unmanned, freeflying balloons (FAA, 1986). Four balloon flights were scheduled each day, weather
permitting, two during daylight and two during nighttime. Observations were not be made in
heavy precipitation because of potential sensor contamination, nor when surface winds were
high and would inhibit an effective and safe launch of the balloon. The balloon release
schedule and types of radiosondes flown is given in Table 2.
3
Radiosonde Description and Performance
Brief descriptions of the participating radiosondes are provided below. This information is
brief since it is expected that Members are generally familiar with operational radiosonde
instrumentation. Additional details may be obtained from each participating manufacturer.
a. Atmospheric Instrumentation Research, Inc. (AIR) – Intellisonde
The Atmospheric Instrumentation Research, Inc. (AIR) Intellisonde transits at a frequency of
403 MHz using digital transmission technology. Relative humidity is obtained using a
hygroscopic
polymer-type sensor. The sensor is a capacitive type encapsulated in polymer and is protected
from direct water contact by a Teflon shield. As the relative humidity changes the
capacitance of the sensor changes. The pressure sensor is a capacitive aneroid cell and a small
aluminized bead thermistor was employed to measure temperature. The radiosonde is
powered by
a 9 volt alkaline or, optionally, a lithium battery. Wind data are not available from the
Intellisonde.
b. Russian Federation - (MRZ-3 with Capacitive and Goldbeaters Skin)
The Central Aerological Observatory of the Russian Federation brought MRZ-3 radiosonde
instruments to Wallops Island. This radiosonde was modified to accommodate two relative
humidity sensors. One, a capacitive relative humidity sensor and the second, goldbeaters skin.
Goldbeaters skin has been used for many decades in a number of countries, and to some
extent is still used today in Russia and China. Because of its large size, it was not practicable
to transport the Russian ground station to Wallops Flight Facility. Alternatively, a receiver
and data converter were brought to Wallops Island allowing measurements to be obtained
from both sensors. The radiosonde transmitter frequency was 1790 MHz. Temperatures were
not available from these instruments because the capacitive relative humidity sensor was
substituted in the channel used for the temperature sensor. In order to convert the signals
received into humidity data, temperature measurements were used from another participating
radiosonde; possible because elapsed time was a common comparison parameter for every
flight. The Russian radiosonde used a small lead-acid battery for power.
c. Vaisala Co. – RS80-15LA and RS80-15LH
Typically, the RS-80 radiosonde samples pressure, temperature, relative humidity, and wind
at intervals of approximately 1-2 seconds; 2-second intervals were provided for this
intercomparison. The relative humidity sensor is a capacitive type with a range of 10 to 100
percent. Two RS80 radiosondes were included in the intercomparison, each employing a
different humidity sensor. The RS80-15LA employs the A-humicap and the RS80-15LH the
PHASE II - page 4
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
H-humicap. The L inidicates that the wind information is obtained using the navaid signal,
LORAN-C. The A- and H-humicap sensors are slightly different but, as determined from the
Phase II results held in 1985 their performance is similar. The pressure and temperture
sensors are capacitive types with the aneroid cell measuring between 1060 hPa and 3 hPa and
the temperature sensor measuring between 60°C and -90°C. Corrections to the temperature
measurements in the form of ‘look-up’ tables keyed to atmospheric pressures and solar
elevation angles, are incorporated in the data reduction software. A water activated battery is
used, and a frequency of 403 MHz is used.
d. Vaisala Co. – RS90
The Vaisala RS90 humidity sensor is the same type of polymer material as the H-humicap.
There are two sensors, each one-half the size of the nominal RS80 H-humicap, that are
alternately heated and cooled during flight to eliminate moisture that may form on the
polymer surface as the radiosonde goes through clouds and moisture layers. The heating
function usually is discontinued when ambient temperature reaches -40ºC. The temperature
sensor is a capacitive type but is a different design than the type used with RS80 radiosondes.
It is a faster responding sensor through the use of fine wires acting as capacitive plates. The
pressure is measured with a capacitive-type aneroid cell. The transmitter frequency is 403
MHz.
e. VIZ Manufacturing Co. – MK 2 Radiosonde
Pressure, temperature, and humidity measurements from the VIZ MK-2 radiosonde are
transmitted digitally approximately every 1.3 seconds over a frequency of 403 MHz.The
carbon-coated relative humidity sensor, called 'hygristor', is used with the MK2 radiosonde
and is smaller than the older type sensor but still operates on the same resistance principle,
whereby resistance increases as atmospheric moisture decreases. The hygristor is a polymer
strip coated with a carbon slurry. The spaces between the carbon molecules increase or
decrease as the relative humidity changes (i.e., as the number of water molecules change)
leading to a resistance change. The hygristor is designed to provide measurements between 5
and 100 percent. A capacitive aneroid cell is used for the pressure measurement between 1050
hPa and 2 hPa. The temperature sensor is a shorter version (~2 cm long) of the white-coated
(~4 cm long) resistive rod thermistor and measures between 50°C and -90°C. Resistance
increases with decreasing temperature. It is now known (Schmidlin, 2002) that the short
thermistor has a different radiation error than the long thermistor; operational corrections for
either does not exist. A multi-thermistor method is available (Schmidlin, 1992) that is still
being improved at this time. Wind direction and speed is obtained using the LORAN-C
navaid technique. A 9-volt water-activated battery provides power to the radiosonde.
All of the radiosondes performed well, however, it was not possible to place all of them on
the balloon platform at the same time. The solution adopted was to stagger the placement of
the instruments to allow the maximum number of comparison pairs to be obtained. Table 2
furnishes the dates and launch times of each balloon package, top altitudes, and lowest
pressures reached. Additionally, the crosses indicate which radiosondes flew on any particular
balloon flight.
PHASE II - page 5
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
TABLE 2. Ballon release schedule for Phase II of Wmo Relative Humidity Sensor Comparison.
PHASE II - page 6
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
4
Profiles and Analyses
Between 8 and 26 September 1995, sixty-one balloons were released; two failed to reach 50
hPa, the established criterion for a successful balloon flight. Flights number 32 and 33 listed
in Table 2, ended at the 64.1-hPa and 70.8-hPa pressure levels, respectively. Although not
meeting the criterion for a successful flight, they, nonetheless, are used in our analysis. The
following discussion include differences between relative humidity measurements made
during balloon ascent and descent by the same radiosonde. Up and down profiles are
reasonably good indicators of sensor sensitivity and repeatability. Results of a statistical
analysis are also presented.
Flight 4, at 0232+51 UTC on 9 September 1995, shown in Figure 1 is a particularly
interesting study of vertical humidity structure. The profiles in Figure 1a display considerable
fidelity. Although biases exist between the profiles, the perturbations follow each other quite
well. The first recorded measurement of humidity, approximately two seconds after balloon
release, disagreed with the surface observed relative humidity of 89 percent. Two seconds
after release humidity measurements of 80 and 94 percent were reported by the humicaps and
the hygristor, respectively. This raised the question, what is the proper radiosonde value that
should be the used at release of the radiosondes? The first record of the radiosonde flight data,
or the observation obtained from the surface equipment? In order to avoid reconciling very
awkward differences between the surface and the first recorded radiosonde measurement the
recorded radiosonde measurements at the time of balloon release would provide improved
continuity to the measured profiles. This assumes that the radiosonde was properly
conditioned to the ambient environment.
Instrumentation necessary to remotely measure temperature and relative humidity at 10
meters above the ground was installed at the top of the balloon inflation shelter. Although the
radiosondes and remote sensors were separated horizontally, the 10-meter height allowed
comparisons to br made immediately following balloon release. The location of the remote
instrument was an obvious choice since the rise rate of the balloon is typically 5 meters per
second. The humicap measurements were approximately 3 to 9 percent lower than those
measured by the remote surface observing equipment, while the RS90 measurements were
within 1-2 percent. Using the same assessment method as above, the VIZ hygristor indicated
3 to 5 percent more relative humidity than the observation at 10 meters. This seemed to occur
when the ambient humidity was above about 70 percent. At relative humidity values below
70 percent the hygristor recorded values of up to 3 percent lower than the surface observing
equipment. AIR, Inc. capacitive sensor had the largest dry bias, up to 11 percent lower than
the surface equipment.
PHASE II - page 7
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
9 September 1995 02:32:51 UTC
Figure 1. (a) Comparison of relative humidity profiles of the Vaisala A- and H-humicaps abd the VIZ
hygristor as a function of elapsed time in minutes; (b) comparison of mixing ratio on a linear scale
as a function of altitude showing the saturation mixing ratio from the Vaisala temperature
measurements; (c) similar to (b) except VIZ temperatures used to define saturation mixing ratio.
Table 3. Average differences between first recorded RH and Surface RH observations. The first
radiosonbde RH occurs at two seconds after balloon release. AIR, Inc.Intellisonde recordes the first
RH at four seconds.
R. H.
Percent
VIZ
Hygristor
Vaisala
A-humicap
Vaisala
H-humicap
Vaisala
RS90
AIR, Inc.
Capacitive
91-100
81-90
71-80
61-70
51-60
6
5.8
0.5
-2.6
-1.9
-4.7
-6.3
-9
-8
-7.5
-3
-6.7
-7
-7.2
-5
-0.3
-3
-0.5
-1.3
-2.5
-0.8
-5.6
-9
-10.2
Table 3 provides more comparative information about the relative humidity measurements
reported 2 seconds after balloon release with the surface observations measured at 10 meters.
Figure 1a, shows that the relative humidity reported between minutes 2 and 4 by the the Aand H-humicaps, indicated approximately 96 percent relative humidity, respectively, while
the hygristor indicated 100 percent. Although the VIZ reduction software limits the relative
humidity measurements to 100 percent, it is likely that the hygristor measurement actually
reached super saturation. The A- and H-humicap dry-bias also had been noted in earlier
intercomparisons. When the atmosphere is dry, the hygristor usually reports less relative
humidity than the humicaps, as observed near minute 25 in Figure 1a. However, the
extremely dry hygristor value is probably an artifact of a VIZ software practice that adjusts
the relative humidity values using a system of compensating coefficients.
PHASE II - page 8
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
Figure 1a also shows separation of the relative humidity measurements of the A- and Hhumicaps near minute 45 of the flight (~240 hPa and -37°C), with the A-humicap reporting
less humidity than the H-humicap. Furthermore, the slow drop of the relative humidity values
above minute 45 shown by the Vaisala RS80 radiosondes suggests that the sensors may be ice
coated.
Mixing ratios for each of the radiosondes are examined in Figure 1b. The satruration mixing
ratio curve was determined from the temperature and pressure measurements of the RS8015LA radiosonde. Between the surface and 10 km altitude the mixing ratios did not reach
saturation. Using the mixing ratio calculated with the RS80, which is our ‘working’ standard,
even the hygristor-measured relative humidity, usually moist, does not reach saturation. This
is unusual since the hygristor profile in Figure 1a touches 100 percent relative humidity on
three occasions before 15 minutes after release has elapsed. On the other hand, when VIZ
temperature and pressure measurements are used to derive the saturation mixing ratio, as in
Figure 1c, the hygristor measurements not only reach saturation but in some cases, indicated
super saturation. In fact, careful examination of the figure reveals that between 500 and 1000
meters even the RS80 A- and H-humicaps had exceeded saturation. The difference in the
presentations of Figure 1b and Figure 1c is a result of different temperature and pressure
measurements by VIZ and Vaisala radiosondes (Hooper, 1986; Schmidlin, 1988; Yagi et al,
1996).
Another nighttime flight at 2347+09 UT on 20th September, 1995, Figure 2a, illustrates
relative humidity profiles from the RS80 A-humicap, RS90, VIZ hygristor, AIR capacitive,
and the Russian MRZ-3 capacitive and goldbeaters skin sensors. In this example the surface
relative humidity was reported as 69 percent. Relative humidity, two seconds after balloon
release, was reported to be 60 percent by the Vaisala A-humicap while the Vaisala RS90
reported 68 percent. The VIZ hygristor, reported 70 percent and the MRZ-3 capacitive and
goldbeaters skin sensors reported 69 and 64 percent, respectively. As can be noted, the
relative humidity values measured immediately after balloon release are different from the
relative humidity values reported by the surface observation equipment.
Relative humidity differences observed after release, i.e., at two seconds, indicated the RS80
A-humicap and the surface equipment report less humidity than the other sensors. The
relative humidity profiles in Figure 2a converged to near 90 percent approximately six
minutes after balloon release. Between 15 and 20 minutes, the VIZ hygristor and the RS90
reported about 98 percent relative humidity. However, near minute 23, a sharp reduction in
the measured relative humidity occurred. The hygristor reported about 10-20 percent lower
relative humidity than reported by the A-humicap. Near minute 23, Figure 2a, the hygristor
continues to report the driest value, consistent with the presumed application of adjustments
to the VIZ algorithm. Less relative humidity is measured when ambient relative humidity
generally is below 30-40 percent.
PHASE II - page 9
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
20 September 1995
23:47:09 UTC
Figure 2. (a) Comparison of RH sensors as a function of elapsed time; Comparison of mixing ratio
from the sensors listed (Russian capacitive and goldbeaters skin not included) compared to the
saturation mixing ratio from Vaisala temperature measurements against altitude.
Figure 2a also suggests that at minute 34 and later (~230 hPa and -30°C) the amount of
humidity recorded by all of the sensors starts to disagree, becoming increasingly further apart
with altitude. After minute 34, the RS90 reports more relative humidity than the Vaisala RS80
A-humicap. After 45 minutes the AIR sensor reported approximately 7-10 percent less
relative humidity than the RS90. The saturation mixing ratio curve in Figure 2b was
determined using the Vaisala RS80-15LA temperature and pressure measurements. The
mixing ratio diagram also indicates that the hygristor reported more humidity than the other
radiosondes when the ambient relative humidity was above 70 percent. This is obvious
between the surface and about 1.5 km and again between 4 and 5.5 km; however, the
hygristor reports dryer relative humidity at other altitudes There is an indication in Figure 2b
that the hygristor measurement exceeded saturation near 1 km. This appears to be an artifact
resulting from the use of RS80 temperature and pressure measurements since the hygristor
measurement never reached 100 percent. The saturation given by the hygristor measurement
should be compared near minute four with the hygristor relative humidity profile in Figure 2a.
Figure 3a contains daytime measurements from flight 31 made on 16 September at 2005+09
UTC. Relative humidity measurements between Vaisala RS80 A- and H-humicaps, VIZ
PHASE II - page 10
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
hygristor, AIR capacitive sensor, and the Russian MRZ-3 capacitive and goldbeaters skin
sensors are shown.
AIR Intellisonde and Vaisala RS80 A-humicap measurements are similar from balloon
release to about minute 24. The VIZ hygristor indicated more moisture than the other sensors
from balloon release until approximately minute 18. Near minute 20 the hygristor
momentarily reported less relative humidity than the other sensors, but again increased to
higher values until near minute 33, when the hygristor sensed dryer humidity. Data from the
hygristor ends near minute 50 and indications are that it has failed. The Russian capacitive
sensor profiles are similar to the relative humidity profiles of the other sensors to
approximately 22 minutes after balloon launch. After minute 23 the Russian capacitive sensor
is noted to have an exceedingly dry bias relative to the other sensors, while the goldbeaters
skin sensor continues to fit within the envelop of the other sensors to minute 30. Also at
minute 22 the AIR capacitive sensor seems to have lost its sensitivity since it no longer
imitates the perturbations shown by the other sensors. Sensor measurements were also
examined immediately after balloon release. Unfortunately, the MRZ-3 did not record data
for the first minute.
The Vaisala humicaps and the VIZ hygristor reported relative humidity two seconds after
balloon release while the AIR instrument first reported its first value at six seconds. The
surface observed relative humidity was 75 percent. Two seconds after release of the
instruments, the A- and H-humicaps reported 68 and 69 percent relative humidity,
respectively, while the VIZ hygristor reported 80 percent.
Comparison of ascending and descending relative humidity profiles measured with the same
instrument is useful for appraising the sensors’ repeatability. Although not a normal
operational practice, a limited number of descent observations were obtained. Figures 4(a-c)
show only three upleg-downleg profiles. On 23 September 1995 at 2000+31 UTC; the ascent
and descent data of the AIR capacitive, Vaisala A-humicap, and VIZ hygristor sensors are
discussed.
The measurements from these sensors were simultaneously obtained on the same balloon
platform. It should be borne in mind that radiosondes typically do not descend over the same
trajectory as their ascent so a true measure of repeatability is not expected. Nonetheless the
similarity between the up and down profiles does provide a useful indication of repeatability.
In the example, winds moved the balloon approximately 75 km east of the launch site. As
Figure 4(a-c) shows, the relative humidity profiles have no similarity to each other below 300
hPa. After the sensors were immersed for tens of minutes in very cold, dry air it was expected
that their response would improve, but as indicated the point where the ascent and descent
measurements begin to agree occurs at different pressures.
PHASE II - page 11
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
16 September 1995
20:05:09 UTC
Figure 3. Same as Figure 2.
In the case of the AIR sensor, during descent, Figure 4a, above 400 hPa nearly similar
performance is noted. It is interesting that the humidity measurements obtained with the AIR
capacitive sensor between 150 and 20 hPa maintained a nearly constant 35-40 percent relative
humidity, although during descent the relative humidity slowly decreased to about 18 percent
at about 150 hPa, indicative of a poorly responding sensor. Figure 4b illustrates ascent and
descent profiles from the Vaisala RS80 A-humicap. At the top of the flight (~20 hPa) the Ahumicap relative humidity decreased to about 10 percent and maintained that value down to
about 100 hPa before increasing to match the relative humidity measured during ascent. The
VIZ hygristor measurements in Figure 4c, reported 0 percent relative humidity on ascent and
descent, and exhibited noise as well. This condition may be due to the compensating
coefficients invoked in the VIZ software. However, at pressures higher than 200 hPa the
ascent and descent profiles show significant differences and tend toward saturation in the
lower troposphere.
PHASE II - page 12
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
23 September 1995 20:00:31 UTC
Figure 4. Comparison of RH profiles during upleg and downleg measurements.
The ascending and descending measurements lead to speculation whether the relative
humidity sensors are capable of accurately measuring humidity at pressures lower than about
200-300 hPa. Figure 4a, indicates that the AIR sensor’s ascent and descent measurements
agree between the surface and approximately 300 hPa. Even considering that the up and down
tracks are separated by 75 km or so, the agreement is good. There is a question, however, why
did this sensor measure higher humidity on the ascent and less humidity on the descent? In
fact, the same question should be asked of the Vaisala A-humicap at pressures lower than 200
hPa, in Figure 4b. Figure 4c suggests that the VIZ hygristor was very noisy at pressures lower
than 250 hPa, but the in spite of the measured differences between the ascent and descent
profiles, above 200-300 hPa this sensor may only be capable of measurements at higher
pressures, i.e., higher temperatures. The failure of the humidity sensors to adequately measure
at low pressures can be correlated with low atmospheric temperature. Temperatures near
300 hPa are approximately -32°C and temperatures near 200 hPa are about -37°C. This, and
PHASE II - page 13
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
the earlier discussions (Figures 1-3), suggest that some of the current relative humidity
sensors are not able to measure well at temperatures lower than approximately -35°C. For the
most part, this is continues to be true in 2005. Since the 1995 intercomparison, adjustments to
the Vaisala RS80 A- and H-humicaps have been developed, as well as the RS90 (Wang et al,
2002; Miloshevich, 2004), while these adjustments have found application in research, they
have not been adopted for operational use bu weather services.
5
Statistical Results
A simple approach describing differences observed between the various ralative humidity
sensors would require an observation-by-observation discussion. This would necessarily be
long, boring, and confusing. Alternatively, a statistical approach was employed. The analysis
presented below was prepared with regard to the arbitrarily adopted ‘working’ standard
relative humidity instrument allowing consistent comparisons of the sensors. The Vaisala
RS80-15LA radiosonde was adopted as this working standard; another relative humidity
sensor could have fulfilled the same purpose.This working standard should not be considered
a reference radiosonde.
Histograms comparing each sensor’s measurements with the RS80 A-humicap working
standard are illustrated in Figure 5. These histograms were produced for the 0200 UTC
release time at temperatures of 0ºC, -40ºC, and -60ºC. The A-humicap's variance was smaller
than the other sensors which made it reasonably stable for judging the behavior of the other
sensors. Nighttime observations were selected because heating effects from sunlight on the
sensors’ supports would be different for each radiosonde. Nighttime comparisons should
achieve more consistent results, although the effect of long-wave radiation error has not yet
been considered. Listed on each panel in Figure 5 is the temperature at which the sensors
were compared, the mean humidity difference determined from a Guassian fit, the standard
deviation, and the name of the radiosonde or sensor being compared with the working
standard. The arrowheads are included to indicate zero of the histogram so as not to confuse it
with the different cells, nor mean difference. Figure 5a compares the VIZ hygristor with the
Vaisala RS80 A-humicap at 0°C. The mean difference of -4.6 percent between these sensors,
shown by the Gaussian curve, indicates that the hygristor reports less relative humidity. The
standard deviation of the differences, 8.5 percent, is the smalllest value of the three
temperatures cases shown in the figure. This suggests that the differences between the
hygristor and A-humicap had large variation. Although not an intercomparison issue, the
differences are seen to have a bi-modal distribution. These data have not been examined
further to determine which sensor caused this variance. Two peaks are seen, one at 5 percent
and a second, more major peak, at -9 percent relative humidity. Finally, in Figure 5a, the data,
are not significantly skewed, and outliers are a minimum. At -40°C in Figure 5b the bi-modal
distribution is still somewhat obvious and the distribution is negatively skewed. The
difference, shown near -10 percent, is isolated from the bulk of the measurement differences.
The Guassian indicates the mean difference is -11.9 percent, and outliers are not observed. At
-40ºC the sensors begin to show a lack of response. At -60°C, Figure 5c, the distribution is
vastly irregular, probably resulting from loss of measurement ability of both sensors at this
low temperature.
PHASE II - page 14
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
(h)
(i)
(j)
(k)
(l)
(m)
(n)
(o)
Figure 5. Histograms of RH distribution of various sensors compared to the RS80 A-humicap.
Comparison with the RS80 H-humicap not shown. The distributions are given for 0ºC, -40ºC, and
-60ºC.
PHASE II - page 15
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
Figures 5d, 5e, and 5f, compare the RS90 with the RS80 A-humicap. At 0°C, Figure 5d, the
relative humidity mean difference is 2 percent with the RS90 reporting slightly higher relative
humidity. The agreement between the RS90 and the working standard is very good only
indicating a slight bias; note, however, there is a suggestion of a bi-model distribution.The
variation between these sensors is quite small suggesting good agreement and good
repeatability. At -40°C the agreement between the RS90 and working standard is seriously
skewed to the right suggesting a wet bias of the RS90. This bias was also reported in Wang et
al (2002) and Miloshovich et al (2004) At -60°C, Figure 5f, the RS90 indicates 11 percent
higher humidity than the working standard, but overall the agreement is not good at the lower
temperature.
The AIR Intellisonde compared with the working standard at 0°C, Figure 5g, agrees in the
mean. By inference with Figure 5d, AIR is also in reasonably good agreement with the RS90.
The standard deviation between the AIR and RS80 is relatively large, but smaller than shown
in Figure 5a between VIZ and the strandard, indicating the AIR Intellisonde sensor’s
measurements have greater variability than the RS90 and RS80. Although the difference
between the Intellisonde and RS80A are the same at 0ºC and -40ºC, the standard deviation is
larger at the lower temperature. The number of outliers is a contributor to the larger variance.
It is interesting however, that the AIR Intellisonde measurements at -40ºC are in better
agreement with the RS80 than is the RS90 with the RS80A. At -60°C the distribution is
positively skewed with a mean difference of about 7-percent relative humidity. It is
questionable whether the sensors are responding properly at the low temperature.
The number of Russian MRZ-3 measurements available was small, 24 instruments only were
available during the intercomparison. In spite of this, 21 pairs were compared with the
Vaisala RS80 A-humicap and 18 pairs with the H-humicap as indicated in Table 2. Figure 5j
illustrates the nighttime comparison between the MRZ-3 capacitive sensor and the A-humicap
at 0°C. The outliers suggest that the MRZ-3 sensor might actually be reporting drier relative
humidity than the A-humicap. This figure also indicates no mean difference between the
measurements. The comparisons at -40°C and -60°C do not agree well and also are very
different than the comparison at 0ºC. At -40°C the MRZ-3 capacitive sensor is negatively
skewed. The goldbeaters skin measurements at 0°C in Figure 5m, indicate a mean difference
of about 12 percent. In Figure 5n, the paired differences are similar to the differences shown
in Figure 5m. A bi-modal distribution is evident but the bulk of the mean relative humidity
differences is, once again, about 12 percent. The paired differences at -60°C, shown in Figure
5o, lacks agreement suggesting that goldbeaters skin performs poorly at cold temperatures.
The pattern presented at the three temperatures is clear. At low temperature, humidity
measurements are difficult to obtain with great accuracy. Thus,as the temperature decreases,
disagreement between relative humidity sensors increases indicating a loss of the sensors'
sensitivity. The results of the RS80 H-humicap measurements are not shown in Figure 5
because of its close similarity with measurements of the A-humicap.
PHASE II - page 16
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
Figure 6. Nighttime measurements comparing all RH sensors against selected standard
measurements adopted for the intercomparison discussion. Upper panel represent mean RH
differences at ambient temperatures between 25ºC and -45ºC. Lower panel is the standard
deviations of the RH differences.
A comparison of measured mean relative humidity differences vs a range of temperatures for
nighttime flights is shown in Figure 6. Differences were calculated from 25°C to -45°C at 5°C
intervals. Standard deviations are also presented. The analysis was not made at temperatures
lower than shown in the figure.
The nighttime relative humidity mean differences as a function of temperature and standard
deviations of all sensors are shown in Figure 6. At temperatures above 10°C all sensors
reported higher relative humidity than the working standard. The Vaisala RS80 H-humicap
whose measurements are quite similar to the chosen standard is an exception. Differences
between the Russian MRZ-3 radiosonde’s goldbeaters skin and the Vaisala RS80A-humicap
showed goldbeaters skin to differ by about 5 percent at 20°C and as the temperature
decreased, the difference increased to about 15 percent at -25°C, similar to the increase shown
between Figures 5n and 5o. The RS90, RS80 H-humicap, and AIR Intellisonde capacitive
sensors agreed with the working standard within 5 percent between 25°C and -40°C. The
RS80 H-humicap differed by about 1 percent to -35ºC. The difference between the RS90 and
RS80 A-humicap increased to approximately 10 percent at -45°C, while the difference
PHASE II - page 17
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
between the H-humicap and A-humicap increased to 7 percent at -45°C. The Russian MRZ-3
capacitive sensor also agreed within 5 percent of the A-humicap except at temperatures lower
than -25°C where the difference decreased to -10 percent at -45°C. The hygristor
measurements at 5°C and higher indicated higher relative humidity values than the RS80
working standard. At temperatures lower than 5°C differences between the hygristor and
standard sernsor increased to -12 percent at -35°C. The standard deviation of the differences
between the VIZ hygristor and the working standard was the largest and the H-humicap
indicated the smallest standard deviation with the working standard. The RS90 relative
humidity variation relative to the working standard measurement was 10 percent at -35°C.
Figure 7 compares daytime relative humidity mean differences as a function of temperature.
The Russian goldbeaters skin measured the largest difference from the working standard at
temperatures lower than 0°C, while both the VIZ hygristor and AIR capacitive sensor
measurements indicated greater than 10 percent. The AIR sensor consistently recorded lower
relative humidity than the working standard. It is significant that the AIR sensor records
lower humidity during the daytime and greater humidity during the nighttime, as seen in
Figure 8.
Apparently, there exists a diurnal bias of some consequence between day and night. This bias,
may be a result from the heating of the sensor’s mounting arm. Between –5°C and –45°C, the
measurements agreed within 5 percent of the RS80 A-humicap standard values, except at -45°
C the where the RS90 indicated 6 percent higher relative humidity. The standard deviation
between the H-humicap and the standard sensor is similar to the nighttime comparison shown
in Figure 6, while the RS90 appears to have less variability during daytime. The standard
deviations of the other radiosondes' measurements are grouped with a mean standard
deviation of approximately 4-8 percent.
PHASE II - page 18
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
Figure 7. Same as shown in Figure 6, except for daytime measurements.
AIR capacitive and VIZ hygristor sensors agreed, both showed lower values than the
standard. The hygristor measurements, however, indicated higher relative humidity than the
working standard’s measurements at temperatures above 5°C. The Russian MRZ-3 capacitive
sensor differs from the standard sensor’s measurement and slopes from approximately 10
percent higher than the standard at 25°C to 8 percent lower at -45°C.
Differences between nighttime mean relative humidity measurements relative to ambient
relative humidity are examined in Figure 8. Clearly, the VIZ hygristor measurements record
lower values relative to the standard except at relative humidity higher than 60 percent.
Figure 8 indicates that the hygristor reads considerably drier than the A-humicap at relative
humidity lower than 60 percent. Above 60 percent the hygristor measured humidity rapidly
increases. Below 90 percent, goldbeaters skin measures more relative humidity compared
with the standard, but the difference is within 5 percent between 70 and 100 percent. The
other radiosonde sensors, including the AIR capacitive sensor is in relatively good agreement
with the working standard. The standard deviation of the nighttime data set will not be
discussed.
PHASE II - page 19
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
Figure 8. Nighttime measurements compared to standard test instrument adopted for this
intercomparison. RH data are with respect to measured RH. Upper panel represents mean RH
differences; lower panel standard deviations.
Daytime relative humidity mean differences are shown in Figure 9 as a function of ambient
relative humidity. The AIR Intellisonde capacitive sensor reads lower, in the mean, than the
working standard at relative humidity lower than 50 percent. The VIZ hygristor relative
humidity is consistently lower than the working standard, and Russian goldbeaters skin
measurements suggest that the comments made about the nighttime results also apply during
daytime. The RS90, and RS80 H-humicap agreed within 5 percent of the standard sensor. In
particular, the H- RS90 and H-humicap are small, i.e., 2-4 percent. The other sensors indicate
larger variances, i.e., approximately 6-10 percent.
PHASE II - page 20
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
Figure 9. Same as Figure 8, except for daytime measurements.
Observations when clouds were absent were examined with the results shown in Figure 10.
Figure 10 clearly shows that mean differences of most of the sensors agreed to within 5-7
percent of each other except at -45°C. The exception is the goldbeaters skin sensor showing
mean differences of nearly 15 percent. Of particular interest is the AIR capacitive sensor
because of its very good agreement with the RS80 A-humicap sensor to temperatures as low
as -45°C. humicap measurements are very close to the RS80 A-humicap. The standard
deviations of the
When clouds were present the mean differences have a larger spread than during clear skies.
VIZ and goldbeaters skin had the largest differences overall. AIR capacitive, H-humicap,
RS90, and the Russian capacitive sensors agreed with the standard sensor to within 5 percent
The results of Figures 10 and 11 indicate that clouds have an important influence on sensor
measurement response and accuracy. Furthermore, sensor mount design may incourage
heating of the sensors from sunlight.
PHASE II - page 21
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
Figure 10. All RH measurements compared with the adopted standard RH data relative to
temperature during no-cloud conditions. Upper panel is mean RH differences and lower panel
standard deviations.
Figure 11. RH differences relative to temperature during cloud-only conditions. Cloud cover is
without regard to type. Upper panel is mean RH differences and lower panel standard deviations.
PHASE II - page 22
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
6
Summary and Conclusions
The WMO Radiosonde Relative Humidity Sensor Intercomparison was designed to examine
sensor accuracies in laboratory chambers, to monitor differences through field comparisons,
to review new sensor technology and recommend to national weather services and radiosonde
vendors potential sensor improvements. This report identifies and discusses some of the more
obvious radiosonde relative humidity sensor shortcomings.
Sixty-one balloons, carrying 3-6 radiosonde instruments each, were flown from Wallops
Flight Facility during the period of 8-26 September, 1995, in the second Phase of the relative
humidity sensor intercomparison. A variety of radiosonde types, each with a unique humidity
sensor was arranged on the balloon platform to obtain as many comparison pairs as possible.
Individual relative humidity sensors disagreed with each other, however, the Vaisala RS80 Aand H-humicap sensors consistently reported, in the mean, nearly the same relative humidity
values whenever flown together on the same balloon. It was noted that, although the relative
humidity measurements between the Vaisala sensors were generally the same values, they
tended to report different relative humidity at a pressure of approximately 200-250 hPa, with
the RS80 H-humicap measurements reporting more relative humidity, i.e., generally at
temperatures lower than –35°C. Similarly, the Vaisala RS90 indicated more relative humidity
than the RS80A-humicap at low pressures. At low ambient relative humidity the VIZ
hygristor measurements were lower by about 15 percent than the working standard RS80 Ahumicap measurements. The histograms of Figures 5(a-c) indicate that at night, relative
humidity measurement differences between the VIZ MK-2 carbon hygristor and Vaisala
RS80 A-humicap are biased, with the hygristor measuring lower relative humidity values. At
temperatures above 0°C the hygristor relative humidity measurements are higher, as shown in
Figures 6 and 7. The AIR Intellisonde capacitive sensor performed nominally relative to the
other sensors during nighttime, but reported consistently lower relative humidity than the
standard sensor during daytime. Nighttime AIR and RS80 A-humicap measurement
differences in Figure 6 are less than 5 percent, except at –45°C. During the daytime the AIR
sensor reports 5-11 percent lower relative humidity than the A-humicap, as shown in Figure
7. Temperature is a parameter necessary for the conversion of engineering units to relative
humidity values, suggesting that the diurnal difference in the relative humidity observed
between Figures 6 and 7 might be related to day-night temperature differences of the sensor
mount. The Russian MRZ-3 goldbeaters skin performance is reasonably good from the
surface to about 600 hPa, but at lower pressures the measurements become less dependable
and, for the most part, not usable. The MRZ-3 capacitive sensor worked well during
nighttime, however, a bias of about 5 percent occurred at high temperatures and a negative
bias of about 10 percent was found at a temperature of -45ºC. A similar bias appears in the
daytime, except at high temperatures the bias is about 10 percent. The cause is thought to be
the relative humidity sensor's sensitivity to temperature since the MRZ-3 sensor extended
outside of the radiosonde case. In fact, only the VIZ sensor is located in a duct.
Relative humidity measurements obtained from ascending and descending radiosondes were
relatively similar between the surface and 200-300 hPa. The descent measurements
correspond at approximately 300 hPa to measurements made on the ascent. This suggests that
at pressures less than 300 hPa (i.e., at low temperatures) the sensors probably lost sensitivity.
During some of the ascents it is probable that the sensors may also have become frozen, thus
inhibiting reliable measurement. On the descent we suspect that the accumulated ice picked
up during ascent apparently sublimated allowing recovery of sensor response. When
PHASE II - page 23
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
differences in space and time between the ascent and descent trajectories are considered, the
repeatability at pressures higher than 300 hPa is relatively good. The up-and-down
measurement exercise suggested that the limit of present day relative humidity sensors is
approximately 200-300 hPa, or the corresponding temperatures at these pressures. Perhaps a
different mounting and/or exposure of the sensor on the radiosonde may improve
measurement capability.
The dry bias experienced by the Vaisala RS80 A-humicap after balloon release was also
found in the RS80 H-humicap measurements. A more thorough and detailed examination of
this dry bias is necessary, e.g., how long after instrument release does this bias persist. Given
that this apparent dry bias is real then the differences between the sensors at higher
temperature or higher ambient relative humidity could probably be reduced. Wang et al
(2002) reported on the dry bias found in the RS80 humidity data of the TOGA-COARE test
held in the central Pacific Ocean , and also developed an adjustment for sensor contamination
and mis-calibration. Even so, the adjustments should be used cautiously especially in the
upper troposphere. Miloschevich et al (2004) added additional information to the RS80 and
RS90 methods of adjustment. Nevertheless, evan with the availability of djustments for the
Vaisala RS80 and RS90 radiosondes, when ambient temperature is lower than -35°C there is
still some level of uncertainty whether any of the sensors are reporting the correct relative
humidity.
After examining the relative humidity data from the intercomparison it is concluded that:
1.
During any one of the 61 balloon ascents none of the sensors reported the same
relative humidity.
2.
The Vaisala RS80 A- and H-humicap radiosondes reported relative humidity values
very close to each other, but analysis suggests that given the uncertainty present in either
sensor neither the RS80A nor RS80H can be considered better than the other.
3.
Within 2 seconds following release of the balloon (e.g., ~10 meters altitude) the
capacitive sensors of the AIR and Vaisala RS80 A- and H-humicap radiosondes showed a dry
bias of 7-9 percent, on average, compared with the surface observing equipment while the
VIZ hygristor reported a moist bias of 3-5 percent.
4.
At relative humidity values above about 70 percent, the VIZ hygristor reported higher
relative humidity compared with the working standard sensor used for comparison and, at low
ambient relative humidity less relative humidity.
5.
Goldbeaters skin is a viable sensor at temperatures above 0°C but it responds very
slowly. At pressures lower than about 600 hPa the goldbeaters skin no longer senses well.
6.
Comparing the relative humidity measurements during clear and cloudy sky
conditions the measurements from all of the sensors, except goldbeaters skin, grouped very
closely together. There is an implication in the plotted data that there was a contamination
problem when the sensors had experienced clouds during ascent.
PHASE II - page 24
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
7.
A final, and very important conclusion is that one must be careful accepting the
absolute values of relative humidity measurements at temperatures lower than about -35 to 40°C.
7
Recommendations
In view of what must be considered unacceptable agreement among the relative humidity
sensors, recommendations are offered to manufacturers and weather services. If accuracies of
the humidity sensors are to adequately meet the needs of users, the recommendations should
not be overly burdensome to execute. On the other hand, improving the accuracy will require
considerable effort and be costly, and may prove to be quite difficult and complex to
accomplish. An amalgamation of manufacturers and users with the idea of designing better
humidity sensor capability meeting present day radiosonde standards may prove
advantageous to both groups.
a.
Recommendations to Manufacturers
1.
Design the relative humidity sensor mount to ensure the removal of, or inhibit,
external influences, such as heating of the sensor mount from sunlight; reflections from the
radiosonde case; or, other factors that could ventilation of the sensor.
2.
Apply the actual temperature of the sensor, not the ambient temperature, to the
processing of relative humidity. Some sensors already have temperature sensors imbedded,
but new investigations into whether they perform properly is needed.
3.
Review the relative humidity sensor manufacturing process paying special attention
that coatings used are applied uniformly.
4.
Take steps to determine relative humidity sensor response at higher and lower
ventilation rates than the optimal 5 meter per second balloon rise rate.
5.
Provide calibrations at relative humidity extremes using recognized procedures and
include at least three additional calibration points between the extremes. Each calibration
point might also be calibrated over a representative range of temperatures.
6.
Considering that present sensor accuracies are not adequate, it becomes important to
identify calibration standards that apply to every sensor. These should be traceable to a
primary standard. Further, the characteristics of the standard used and procedures adopted
should also be available to users.
7.
It should be incumbent on manufacturers to make known changes to algorithms and
also be responsible for providing updated software when instrument design or performance
changes.
b.
Recommendations to Weather Services
1.
The procedure for reporting the necessary measured weather parameters at release of
the radiosonde should be standardized. This should include all parameters, not just relative
humidity. During the intercomparison it was learned that some observers used the first point
PHASE II - page 25
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
reported by the radiosonde as the release record. Others used the independent surface
observation as the first point of the radiosonde profile; occasionally the first reported record
also alternated between surface observed data and radiosonde observed data. This should be
identified as an important action item for purposes of observation quality and uniformity
among all upper air stations.
2.
Weather services should meet with manufacturers often to keep abreast of
manufacturing changes, changes to transfer equations, and to provide feedback to the
manufacturer of problems encountered in the field. Such problems would include, as a
minimum, change of sensors, change in instrument performance, change of estimated
accuracy, new documentation, etc.
3.
It is also recommended that weather services and other users provide to manufacturers
the accuracies desired to carry out various missions. Only by making these known to
manufacturers in a timely manner can instrument performance be improved. It is known that
some weather services specify accuracy requirements, others do not.
4.
Review algorithms making sure that bias, arising from artificial adjustment of relative
humidity measurements available for some radiosonde types, does not occur. Consider
improving these algorithms. In addition, determine whether the variance of artificially
adjusted measurements are comparable to all sensors, especially sensors used as references,
for example the SNOW WHITE chilled mirror.
8
References
Balagurov, A., A. Kats, and N. Krestyannikova, ,1998: Implementation and results of the
WMO radiosonde humidity sensors intercomparison (Phase I laboratory test). WMO Conf.
on Meteorological and Environmental Instruments and Methods of Observation.
Casablanca, Morocco. WMO Rep. 70, 181-184.
Elliott, W. P. and D. J. Gaffen, 1991: On the utility of radiosonde humidity archives for
climate studies, Bull. Amer. Meteor. Soc., 72, (10) pp 1507-1520.
Hooper, A. H., 1986: WMO international radiosonde comparison Phase I, Beaufort Park, UK,
1984. WMO Instruments and Methods of Observations Report No. 28, 118 pp.
Morrissey, J. F. and F. J. Brousaides, 1970:Temperature-induced errors in the ML-476
humidity data, J. Appl. Meteor., 8, 805-808.
Brousaides, F. J. and J. F. Morrissey, 1974: Residual temperature-induced humidity errors in
the National Weather Service radiosonde, Final Report, USAF Report AFCRL-TR-740111, Feb. 1971, 39 pp.
FAA, 1986: Federal Aviation Regulations, Part 101, Moored Balloons, Kites, Unmanned
rockets, and unmanned free balloonbs. CFR Title 14, Subchaper F.
Ivanov, A., A. Kats, S. Kurnosenko, J. Nash, and N. Zeitseva, 1991: WMO international
radiosonde comparison, Phase 3, WMO Instruments and Observing Methods Report No.
40, 135 pp.
PHASE II - page 26
PHASE II - Field Test. WMO Radiosonde Humidity Sensor Intercomparison, Sept. 1995
Miloschevich, L. M., A. Paukkunen, H, Vömel, and S. J. Oltmans, 2004: Development and
validation of time-lag correction for Vaisala radiosonde humidity measurements. J. Atmos.
Oceanic Technol., 21, 1305-1327.
Nash, J., and F. J. Schmidlin, 1987: Final report of the WMO International Radiosonde
Intercomparison. WMO Report No. 30. 123 PP.
Schmidlin, F. J., 1988: WMO International Radiosonde Intercomparison, Phase II, 1985:
Wallops Island, Virginia USA. WMO Report-Instruments and Observing Methods Report
No. 29. 113 pp.
Soden, B. J., S. A. Ackerman, D. O'C. Starr, S. H. Melfi, and R. A. Ferrare, 1994:
Comparison of upper tropospheric water vapor from GOES, Raman lidar, and cross-chain
loran atmospheric sounding system measurements. J. Geophys. Res., 99, 21005-21016.
Wade, C. G., 1994: An Evaluation of Problems Affecting the Measurement of Low Relative
Humidity on the United States Radiosonde. J. Atmos. Oceanic Technol., 11, 687-700.
Wang, J., H. L. Cole, D. J. Carlson, E. R. Miller, K. Beierle, A. Paukkunen, and T. K. Laine,
2002: Corrections of humidity measurement errors from the Vaisala RS80 radiosondeApplications to TOGA COARE data. J. Atmos. Oceanic Technol., 19, 981-1002.
Yagi, S., A. Mita, and N. Inoue, 1996: WMO International Radiosonde Comparison - Phase
IV - Tsukuba, Japan, 15 February - 12 March 1993, Final Report, Instruments and
Observing Methods Report No. 59, 130 pp.
___________________
PHASE II - page 27