Running head: Motivation Cases and Analysis
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
Name:
Institution Affiliation:
1
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
Topic: Outline
I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.
VI.
Introduction
-
Discussion on motivation: extrinsic and intrinsic motivation
-
Introduction of theoretical models
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs
-
Discussion of the theory/model
-
Application to the motivation cases (pharmacist A, B, C, and M)
Alderfer’s ERG Model
-
Discussion of the theory
-
Application to the motivation cases (pharmacist A, B, C, and M)
McClelland’s achievement and acquired needs theory
-
Discussion of the theory
-
Application to the motivation cases (pharmacist A, B, C, and M)
Motivation in Pharmacy Practice
-
Need for patient-centered care competencies
-
Communication skills
-
Students from colleges lacking necessary skills
-
Training to bridge skills gap
-
Career development
Conclusion
2
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
3
Introduction
Motivation refers to factors that make an employee pursue tasks and goals. In
particular, motivation determines the behavior and actions of an employee in certain
ways. Motivation can either be extrinsic or intrinsic. Extrinsic motivation relates to
external factors that make an employee fulfill tasks and goals. In most cases, external
factors are rewards or punishment. Punishment can motivate employees to perform
tasks so that they avoid punishment. Rewards also ensure that employees who act
based on outlined guidelines receive rewards. On the contrary, intrinsic motivation
refers to factors within employees. Employees become intrinsically motivated when the
work they perform is satisfying, enjoyable, and fulfilling. This paper analyzes motivation
cases in relation to employees who work in a pharmacy department. The paper adopts
motivation models such as Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, Alderfer’s ERG model, as well
as the McClelland’s achievement and acquired needs theory.
Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs theory is based on the assumption that each person
has needs arranged in terms of hierarchy. Needs should be satisfied from the base of
the pyramid to the top. The most basic needs are those found at the base of the
pyramid. Physiological subsistence is the most basic need of a person followed by
needs in relation to social circles such that a person can pursue talent, thereby leading
to self-actualization (Brown & Cullen, 2006). However, when a person experiences
unfulfilled needs in the lower base of the pyramid, they cannot meet needs high up in
the pyramid. The pyramid contains needs in relation to physiological needs, safety,
belonging, self-esteem, and self-actualization. When physiological and safety needs are
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
4
not met or satisfied, then a person feels the deficit, thereby leading to a stifled
development of an individual (Hayashi Jr, 2015).
In the motivation case, pharmacist M lacks proper climate in which he/she can
develop the fullest potential. The manager embarrasses pharmacist M in front of
colleagues thereby leading to low levels of motivation. Managers should understand
that job recognition is a critical need that should be met so that an employee feels
motivated to achieve their full potential. For the three years pharmacist M has worked at
the department, it is clear that the employer has met deficiency needs in terms of proper
wages. Besides, a safe environment does not exist. Safety as a need should not be
viewed in terms of hazards alone. A safe environment motivates employees. Unsafe
factors such as ridicule that cause embarrassment do not motivate employees to
perform to their full potential. Failure to guarantee a proper climate in which pharmacist
M can perform is likely to lead to low job satisfaction and withdrawal from the
organization. Pharmacist M may have good remuneration that covers all physiological
needs. However, when job satisfaction and job recognition are not achieved, they
become less motivated to work to their full potential.
Pharmacist A is less motivated because of lack of training. The manager has
also not guaranteed a proper climate in which pharmacist A can train so that they
perform duties and tasks. Non cooperative employees during training sessions, as well
as laziness during training, have affected the ability of pharmacist M to achieve full
potential. As a result, being ignored by colleagues, anger, and complaints in case of
mistakes are factors that cause low levels of motivation. The failure to guarantee quality
training needs by the management leads to poor performance by pharmacist M.
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
5
In relation to pharmacist B, the management does not provide equal
remuneration so that employees feel motivated to work. Discrimination against local
employees is a clear indication that the pharmacy department does not consider esteem
needs. Poor remuneration means that even when employees can meet physiological
needs, they feel discriminated since foreigners receive high levels of remuneration.
Pharmacist C, despite showing high levels of efficiency and great skills in the
performance of tasks, does not benefit from a non-cooperative work environment. A
perfect environment is not available in which pharmacist C can develop to full potential.
As a result, lack of cooperation from other employee’s means that frustration contributes
to low performance as well as low job satisfaction levels.
Alderfer’s ERG model
The ERG model as developed by Alderfer’s in 1969 condenses all five human
needs as outlined in Maslow’s needs theory into three categories: Existence,
Relatedness, and Growth. Existence needs involve all material and physiological
desires further; relatedness needs involve social and external esteem (Arnolds &
Boshoff, 2002). Relationships with co-workers and employers should be favorable so
that a climate is created which enables employees to perform to full potential. In
particular, relatedness needs involve an assumption that employees should be
recognized so that they feel part of the organization. Regarding growth needs, each
person needs internal esteem as well as self-actualization. Internal esteem and selfactualization enables a person to be creative and productive so that they progress
towards the ideal self. Growth needs should be viewed in relation to desires to be
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
6
creative and productive so that an employee completes meaningful tasks (Arnolds &
Boshoff, 2002).
In the case of pharmacist B, discrimination in the workplace shows a lack of
relatedness needs. Pharmacist B requires an environment where employees can be
viewed as members of a group or a unit. Discrimination in terms of salary means that
pharmacist B cannot feel secure as part of the team. In the case of pharmacist C, noncooperative colleagues even when there are high levels of efficiency reflects a lack of
relatedness needs. In particular, poor relationship are affecting pharmacist C
concerning the ability to feel part of the group and the department. Pharmacist C,
despite showing high levels of efficiency and great skills in the performance of tasks,
does not benefit from a non-cooperative work environment. A proper climate lacks in
which pharmacist C can develop to full potential. As a result, lack of cooperation from
other employees means that frustration contributes to low performance as well as low
job satisfaction levels.
Pharmacist ‘A’ feels ignored. In particular, growth needs are not available at the
workplace. Lack of employee training so that productivity is achieved means that an
employee cannot grow. As a result, lack of growth leads to low levels of motivation.
Pharmacist A’s desires to be creative and productive have been affected by poor
training policies whereby employees do not cooperate or demonstrate high levels of
laziness.
In the case of pharmacist M, embarrassing her in front of colleagues means that job
recognition as part of relatedness needs cannot be achieved in the organization.
Pharmacist M lacks social and external esteem since the manager embarrasses her in
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
7
front of colleagues. Relationships at the pharmacy department cannot be developed so
that all employees and co-workers feel part of a family or group. The department should
guarantee job recognition so that pharmacist M does not show low levels of energy and
willingness to perform duties.
The ERG model categorizes needs in terms of concreteness. The most concrete
needs that should be satisfied first are Existence needs. Relatedness needs depend on
the relationship formed among employees. It should be noted that existence needs are
more concrete than relatedness needs. In terms of growth needs, the management
should consider the uniqueness of each person so that their specific needs are met
within the workplace. Managers should be concerned about identifying factors that
cause frustration among employees. In most cases, frustration arises because of poor
relationships among employees as well as poor job recognition. Frustration affects
creativity and productivity levels among employees.
McClelland were achievement and acquired needs theory
McClelland introduces the concept of acquired needs theory. In particular, a
person’s needs are acquired over time. Also, needs depend on experiences in life.
McClelland describes three motivational needs such as n-ach achievement motivation,
n-pow authority/power motivation, and n-affil- affiliation motivation (Arnolds & Boshoff,
2003).
The n-pow motivation relates to employees motivated by authority. Authority as a driver
for motivation enables employees to be influential, productive, and creative so that their
impact is felt within the organization. Leadership and application of ideals are necessary
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
8
so that employees prevail. Further, factors such as prestige and status enable an
employee to perform to their full potential (Arnolds & Boshoff, 2003).
The n-affil motivation refers to the necessity of relationships at the workplace.
Cooperation and friendly relationships are necessary so that employees perform to their
full potential. Harmony among employees as well as the need to feel accepted within
the workplace is necessary for improved levels of motivation (Arnolds & Boshoff, 2003).
Pharmacist C can be described as the n-affil employees who depend on friendly
relationships to perform duties. Lack of cooperation at the workplace affects the ability
of pharmacist C to achieve efficiency in job performance. Reports that pharmacist C is
not cooperative and unwilling to assist colleagues is not true since they have not been
allowed to present their side of the story. Furthermore, pharmacist C would prefer an
environment whereby interaction with colleagues leads to friendly relationships so that
they can take minimum risks and reduce the level of errors when performing duties.
Pharmacist B is an n-ach person who is motivated to achieve high levels of production
and creativity. However, discrimination in terms of remuneration affects productivity
levels. Pharmacist B has already pledged that he will work at the minimum for the
amount of money paid by the department. In such cases, the department needs to
reduce any discrimination arising from remuneration.
Pharmacist A lacks training so that he/she becomes a high achiever. As an n-ach
person, pharmacist A cannot engage in challenging projects and reachable goals since
training at the pharmacy department lacks cooperation among employees. Laziness as
a factor that affects training also prohibits pharmacist A from completing assigned tasks.
In the end, pharmacist A feels less motivated to work. In the case of pharmacist M, n-
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
9
affil motivation applies. Lack of job recognition since the manager embarrasses
pharmacist M in front of colleagues means that a cooperative environment cannot be
achieved. Employees with high levels of affiliation are motivated to perform to their full
potential. Managers should not engage in any activity likely to cause embarrassment of
employees.
Motivation in Pharmacy Practice
Pharmacy as a practice requires the need to acquire practical counseling skills
so that patients achieve positive health outcomes. Accreditation systems such as the
American Association of Colleges of Pharmacy (AACP) focus on communication skills
so that pharmacists can improve the health and wellness of patients. Based on
accreditation goals and objectives, pharmacy students should possess patient-centered
care competencies. Also, pharmacy as a practice needs students who can apply
therapeutic principles, use evidence-based research, as well as consider other factors
that influence therapeutic outcomes (Freeman, 2012).
Pharmacy as a practice also demands that practitioners manage health care
resources while consulting the patient and the medical team so that therapeutic
outcomes, necessary medication, and distribution of resources can be achieved. As a
result, skills for effective communication cannot be ignored by students of pharmacy
willing to meet full potential at the workplace. Every level of patient contact needs
certain skills so that practitioners engage in effective communication and service to
patients (Holdford & Lovelace-Elmore, 2001).
Despite the importance of patient-centered counseling skills as part of pharmacy
practice, most students coming out of colleges do not possess necessary skills that
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
10
guarantee quality services at the workplace. In most cases, pharmacy students coming
out of colleges and university have general communication skills with no focus on
pharmacy setting. Such students become less motivated to perform to their full potential
when they realize that there are skill gaps so that they function efficiently. The role of
pharmacy departments is to assist students with skill gaps so that they undertake
necessary training that guarantee quality service delivery (Varunki, Katajavuori, &
Postareff, 2015).
Patient counseling depends on settings under which counseling takes place. In
addition, patient counseling in pharmacy as a practice depends on skills and philosophy
of pharmacists. It should be noted that advanced pharmacy practice experiences are
based on programmatic outcomes. As a result, skill gaps lead to challenges about an
inability of practitioners to deliver consistent and comprehensive training so that
pharmacists develop necessary counseling skills (Wells, Jones, & Jones, 2013).
In the past, pharmacists focused on the product while neglecting the need to
concentrate on the patient. Pharmacy as a practice has identified the need for staff
development in pharmacy so that growth and professional development become part of
the practice (Freeman, 2012). Professional growth and belief structure of each
pharmacist is necessary so that quality services are provided to the patients. Pharmacy
as a practice also considers facilitation of development and refinement of practice,
beliefs, value systems, as well as competency in critical skills necessary for better
service delivery to patients.
According to Holdford and Lovelace-Elmore (2001), growth and development
regarding staff require an understanding that employees need to adopt patient-centered
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
11
approaches to service delivery. Skills necessary for decision making, motivation, and
communication have become relevant to pharmacists. In modern practice, decision
making, motivation, and communication have become part of proficiencies required as
part of pharmacist skills, education and training.
Currently, pharmacists have an obligation to think and act differently. Past
approaches to pharmacy depended on accountability and responsibility to physicians,
nurses, and their employers (Holdford & Lovelace-Elmore, 2001). Pharmacists
traditionally provided a discrete and limited range of services. In the current practice,
pharmacists are expected to be productive members of patient care teams. In particular,
pharmacists have recognized the need to think as peer physicians, nurses, and other
healthcare providers. Experiential education has also become a key aspect of career
progression in pharmacy. A focus on clinical trials continues to inform development and
training of pharmacists who can acclimatize to modern work environments (Varunki et
al., 2015). As a result, new opportunities exist that enable pharmacists to expand scope
and responsibilities in the healthcare system. Pharmacists, therefore, have a role in
motivating, inspiring, and training the next generation of pharmacists.
Managers and employers should motivate pharmacists and potential practitioners
so that they acquire necessary skills based on current trends in the profession (Wells et
al., 2013). Also, employers must inspire new employees so that they view pharmacy as
a profession of choice. Management practices that do not encourage pharmacists are
likely to cause poor service delivery. As a result, training the next generation of
employees in the pharmacy profession should be a top priority for all managers and
employers.
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
12
Although most students taking pharmacy courses are motivated and enthusiastic
about future career progress, some students should be given guidance and leadership
so that they become ideal employees of choice to employers. New hires need
encouragement so that they are motivated by their experiences and outcomes while
performing duties within the guidelines of the organization and the profession. Skills
supported by practice, training, and motivation by employers ensure that pharmacists
work in a rewarding atmosphere that guarantees quality service delivery.
Collaboration among all professionals is also necessary so that new practitioners
achieve appropriate guidance that guarantees a credible profession. In particular,
communication and collaboration ensure that practitioners collaborate so that
intervention measures adopted meet professional guidelines. Community settings are
also necessary so that pharmacists obtain experiences in serving communities and
local societies. Practical knowledge must never be neglected since the employee
achieves an opportunity to apply knowledge already learned in the classroom.
Conclusion
Provision of physiological needs alone is not a guarantee that an employee feels
motivated in the workplace. Employers should ensure that work environments focus on
the development of relationships so that employees achieve their full potential. The
achievement of duties by the employees reflects in the growth of the company as a
whole in terms of profits. Inadequate employee training is another factor that should not
be allowed since it brings negative energy to the company. This reflects negatively in
the quality and growth of the company. Career growth is part of the intrinsic motivation
that enables employees to be satisfied. Further, discrimination regarding remuneration
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
13
should not be allowed to cause divisions within the workplace. This can be addressed
by remunerating the employees fairly.
MOTIVATION CASES AND ANALYSIS
14
References
Arnolds, C. A., & Boshoff, C. (2002). Compensation, esteem valence and job
performance: an empirical assessment of Alderfer’s ERG theory. The International
Journal of Human Resource Management, 13(4), 697–719.
Arnolds, C. A., & Boshoff, C. (2003). The Influence of McClelland’s Need Satisfaction
Theory on Employee Job Performance. Journal of African Business, 4(3), 55–81.
Brown, K., & Cullen, C. (2006). Maslow’s hierarchy of needs used to measure
motivation for religious behaviour. Mental Health, Religion & Culture, 9(1), 99–108.
Freeman, E. (2012). The Design and Implementation of a Career Orientation Course for
Undergraduate Majors. College Teaching, 60(4), 154–163.
Hayashi Jr., P. (2015). Tattvabodha and the hierarchical necessity of Abraham Maslow.
Journal of Management, Spirituality & Religion, 6(5), 1–12.
Holdford, D., & Lovelace-Elmore, B. (2001). Applying the Principles of Human
Motivation to Pharmaceutical Education. Journal of Pharmacy Teaching, 8(4), 1–
18.
Varunki, M., Katajavuori, N., & Postareff, L. (2015). First-year students’ approaches to
learning, and factors related to change or stability in their deep approach during a
pharmacy course. Studies in Higher Education, 1(8) 23.
Wells, H., Jones, A., & Jones, S. C. (2013). Teaching reluctant students: using the
principles and techniques of motivational interviewing to foster better student–
teacher interactions. Innovations in Education and Teaching International, 51(2),
175–184.