Win, Lose, or Draw

Name:___________________________________Date:__________________________Class:_______________________
Win, Lose, or Draw Application
Problem: What are the shapes and polarity of some common molecules (covalent compounds)?
Materials:
Ball and stick model pieces and a Periodic Table
Information:
As you learned in the last unit nuclear charge , the shielding effect and the energy levels of the electrons determines how the electrons behave in an atom. The
valence electrons (the ones on the outside) specifically are responsible for reacting and forming chemical bonds. You have seen that some atoms are willing to
gain electrons to form anions; others are willing to lose electrons to form cations. In this activity, you will see that other atoms are willing to share electrons.
This is called covalent bonding. The fact that an atom will gain, lose or share electrons so that it has the electron configuration of a noble gas is called the octet
rule. If the number of electrons being shared is 2, this is called a single bond. A double bond will share 4 electrons and a triple bond will share 6 electrons.
When two atoms share electrons to complete their octet, the amount of time the shared electrons, also known as bonding electrons, spend between the atoms does
not have to be equal. Electronegativity was defined as the ability of an atom to attract an electron to itself in a bond. This means that when two atoms are
bonded covalently the electrons may be more attracted to one atom than the other based on the atoms’ electronegativities. When this happens, the bond between
the two atoms is called a polar bond and the electronegativity difference between the two atoms is generally 0.5-1.7. A difference below 0.5 is considered to be
equal sharing of the electrons and the bond is considered to be nonpolar; above 1.7 and the bond is considered to be ionic, the electrons are not shared at all but
completely transferred.
Based on how the bonds are arranged in a molecule, a molecule may be considered polar or nonpolar as well. Valence Shell Electron Pair Repulsion (VSEPR)
Theory states that the electrons will in a molecule will always be found in pairs and that these pairs of electrons will repel each other as much as possible.
Unshared pairs also known as lone pairs or nonbonding pairs of electrons repel other electrons and bonding electrons the most. The distance between the
pairs of electrons created by the repulsion results in the shape of the molecule. When this shape is created, if the molecule has any polar bonds, you must look at
where the electrons are being attracted (pulled toward). As in a tug of war, if the electrons are being pulled equally, no one bond wins and the molecule is
considered to be nonpolar. However, if one bond or several bonds on the same of the molecule attracts electrons more, then the molecule is polar.
Prelab Questions:
1) What does the word octet mean? ____________
2) How many valence electrons do most of the noble gases have? __________
3) Which noble gas is an exception to the octet rule? ____________Why? ____________________________________________________________
What other elements would be an exception to the octet rule when they react?
4) Would an electron be attracted to an atom with a high electronegativity or a low one? __________________
5) Why would pairs of electrons repel each other as described in the VSEPR theory?
Procedure: Fill out the table of information on the molecules by doing the following:
1. Prepare Lewis dot structures of each of the following molecules. Based on what you know about their Lewis dot diagrams and the octet rule.
2. Determine if the bonds are polar or nonpolar by subtracting the electronegativities of the two atoms in each bond.. This must be done for
EVERY bond in the molecule. Then list the total number of bonds and the total number of lone pairs of electrons.
3. Build the molecule using the model pieces and then draw a three dimensional representation of each molecule.
4. Name the shape of the three dimensional structure for each molecule using the information on the last page of this packet.
5. In the shape picture, draw an arrow on any polar bond you determined in step 2 in the direction of the atom with the higher
electronegativity. Based on the arrows, determine if one side of the molecule wins a tug-of-war. If yes, the entire molecule is polar. Use this
to fillin the last column of the table.
6. Then answer the summary questions.
Molecules
Model Pieces
H2
NH3
C = black
Cl2
H2O
H = yellow
CF3H
CO2
O = red
AlH3
O2
N = light blue
PH3
N2
Halogens (F, Cl, Br, I) = green, orange, purple
HCl
CH4
Al, P = white (Be very gentle with these.)
CH2F2
Formula
H2
Cl2
CF3H
Lewis dot diagram
Bonds polar or
nonpolar?
# bonds &
# lone pairs
Name of Shape
3-D picture of
shape
Molecule polar
or nonpolar?
Formula
NH3
PH3
AlH3
HCl
CH4
Lewis dot diagram
Bonds polar or
nonpolar?
# bonds &
# lone pairs
Name of Shape
3-D picture of
shape
Molecule polar
or nonpolar?
Formula
CO2
H2O
O2
N2
CH2F2
Lewis dot diagram
Bonds polar or
nonpolar?
# bonds &
# lone pairs
Name of Shape
3-D picture of
shape
Molecule polar
or nonpolar?
Summing Up:
1. What minimum number of bonds does an atom need to form in order to be a central atom? ______________
2. Can any element be a central atom?________________ Why or Why not?
3. Compare and contrast the Lewis dot structures of AlH3 and PH3?
4. Compare the shapes of AlH3 and PH3?
5. In H2O, the oxygen has two hydrogens attached. In CO2, the carbon has two oxygens attached. Explain why the geometries of
H2O and CO2 are different.
6. Summarize the effect of the presence of unshared electrons on the shape of a molecule.
7. What two factors do you have to use to determine the polarity of a molecule?