BUTTERFLIES OF HIGH PARK Compiled by Bob Yukich November 2000; fifth revision December 2012 With its varied habitats and ease of access, High Park is an excellent place to observe butterflies within the heart of the city. At least 68 species have been recorded in recent years, and another 12, including the Karner Blue and Mottled Duskywing, were observed historically. High Park lies at the easternmost edge of the Carolinian Zone. The recently restored black oak savannah, lush with wild lupines, woodland sunflowers and prairie grasses, provides nectar for adult butterflies and host plants for their caterpillars. Several species of small grass-skippers occur here, including Delaware and Crossline Skippers. It Eastern Tiger Swallowtail Bob Yukich is also home to larger showy species such as Eastern Tiger Swallowtail and the rarer Spicebush Swallowtail. The latter is at the northern limit of its range in High Park and uses the abundant sassafras, a more southern tree species, as its host. Oaks, the signature trees of High Park, are the food plants for the tiny and occasionally numerous Banded Hairstreak and, until recently, Edwards’ Hairstreak. This species, local within its range, may one day return as young oaks continue to regenerate. Northern Cloudywing and Eastern Tailed-Blue, both common throughout the park, lay their eggs on native tick trefoils. Silvery Checkerspot is seen on rare occasions. Its caterpillars feed on composites such as woodland sunflower. Two recent additions to the park’s butterfly fauna, Silvery Blue and Wild Indigo Duskywing, arrived after range extensions following the spread of their adopted host plants, cow vetch and crown vetch. There have been recent rare sightings of Bronze Copper, Broad-winged Skipper and Black Dash, all wetland species, along the re-vegetated shores of Grenadier Pond. During late summer and fall the ornamental gardens of High Park are a magnet for butterflies, especially after nectar sources in the wild have disappeared. Migrating Monarchs, Red Admirals, American Ladies and Question Marks are more easily observed at this time, especially when on butterfly bush gorging themselves with nectar! In warmer years Fiery Skippers, and sometimes other southern rarities, arrive in High Park after crossing Lake Ontario – look for them in flower beds. Excerpted from Butterflies of Toronto, City of Toronto, 2011 NOTES: This list comprises 80 species and one subspecies of butterfly known to have occurred in High Park up to the end of 2012. All of the species listed are known to or assumed to breed, or have bred, in High Park unless otherwise noted. Common names used in this list are those found in Checklist & English Names of North American Butterflies, Second Edition, published by the North American Butterfly Association (NABA). Scientific names are taken from A Catalogue of the Butterflies of the United States and Canada by Jonathan P. Pelham, revised February 14, 2012. Host plants listed for each species were taken from The Butterflies of Canada by R. A. Layberry, P. W. Hall and J. D. Lafontaine 1998, and The Ontario Butterfly Atlas by A. M. Holmes, Q. F. Hess, R. R. Tasker and A. J. Hanks 1991. ROM = Royal Ontario Museum. The species abundance designations are based on a typical year, and a skilled observer being in suitable habitat, in the appropriate season, under favourable weather conditions. It should be noted, however, that the population of any butterfly species can fluctuate dramatically from year to year, or even within a breeding season, due to a variety of environmental factors. abundant: usually recorded in large numbers on all visits common: normally recorded on all visits fairly common: likely to be recorded on most visits uncommon: present in small numbers; can be missed on most visits rare: can be less than annual in occurrence very rare: often several years between sightings; not to be expected BUTTERFLIES OF HIGH PARK Common Name Scientific Name Status in High Park Status in Ontario Host Plant Comments SKIPPERS Silver-spotted Skipper HESPERIIDAE Epargyreus clarus fairly common locally fairly common, mainly in the south closely associated with black locust in our area Long-tailed Skipper Urbanus proteus very rare southern immigrant very rare immigrant in the south; one record each at Point Pelee and Windsor in 1994, and two seen near Hamilton on Sept. 1, 2012 black locust, hog peanut, showy tick trefoil legume family vines, including beans Southern Cloudywing Thorybes bathyllus historical record (hypothetical) locally rare to common in the southwest legumes Northern Cloudywing Thorybes pylades common common and widespread Dreamy Duskywing Erynnis icelus historical record Juvenal’s Duskywing Erynnis juvenalis historical records; a recent rare breeder common and widespread throughout common and widespread, mainly in the southern part of the province legumes including tick trefoil and vetch poplar, aspen, willow, birch oaks Mottled Duskywing Erynnis martialis historical record rare and local New Jersey tea Funereal Duskywing Erynnis funeralis very rare southern immigrant very rare immigrant in the south legumes Wild Indigo Duskywing Erynnis baptisiae uncommon locally uncommon to common in the south legumes including wild indigo, crown vetch (mainly) and wild lupine Columbine Duskywing Erynnis lucilius historical record wild columbine Least Skipper Ancyloxypha numitor uncommon locally common, mainly in the southern part of the province common in the southern and central regions European Skipper Thymelicus lineola common to abundant Compiled by Bob Yukich November 2000; fifth revision December 2012 common to abundant throughout wetland grasses including bluegrass, rice cut grass, marsh millet grasses including timothy and red top a species from the southern U.S., not known to breed at this latitude; on October 4, 2012 one was photographed by Bob Yukich as it nectared on Buddleia at the Hillside Gardens; this is the most northerly record for Ontario (2012 was a spectacular year for southern immigrants in the province) one of two old specimens from Toronto in the ROM has been attributed to High Park; likely a rare breeder in our area historically High Park’s population density may be the highest in the province with high counts of 100+ in recent years old specimens from High Park in the ROM old specimens from High Park in the ROM; Bob Yukich saw a fresh male at the north end of Plot 1C on May 10, 2006, and another male north of the allotment gardens in Plot 9B on June 6, 2008; one or two individuals are now recorded annually in the park old specimens from High Park in the ROM; declining; federally endangered; apparently common in High Park in the early 1900s stray only; essentially a tropical species that does not breed in the province; Bob Yukich recorded an individual nectaring on purple loosestrife along the south end of Grenadier Pond on August 12, 1999: fourth record for Ontario and Canada this species was first recorded in Toronto in 1998, having undergone a northward range extension from the U.S. following plantings of crown vetch; Bob Yukich recorded a single individual on the open hillside near the High Park Forest School on August 1, 2002; egg laying on wild lupine was recorded in the park on July 25, 2008; now breeds in small numbers one old specimen from High Park in the ROM breeds in and near wetlands in High Park our only non-native skipper; introduced near London, Ontario around 1910 1 BUTTERFLIES OF HIGH PARK Common Name Fiery Skipper Scientific Name Hylephila phyleus Status in High Park uncommon to common southern immigrant Status in Ontario uncommon to common immigrant in the southern part of the province Host Plant various weedy grasses Leonard’s Skipper Hesperia leonardus historical record Peck's Skipper Polites peckius uncommon Tawny-edged Skipper Polites thermistocles uncommon locally common, mainly in the southern part of the province locally uncommon to common throughout common and widespread Crossline Skipper Polites origenes common Long Dash Polites mystic rare Northern Broken-Dash Wallengrenia egeremet common locally common, mainly in the south Little Glassywing Pompeius verna uncommon Sachem Atalopedes campestris very rare southern immigrant Delaware Skipper Anatrytone logan common locally uncommon in the south very rare immigrant in the south; in June 1988 several were found in southwestern Ontario, with confirmed breeding at Point Pelee; there was another larger incursion in 2012; otherwise, very few records locally uncommon to common in the south various grasses including bluestem and panic grass grasses including rice grass grasses including panic grass grasses including purpletop and little bluestem grasses including bluegrass, quack, barnyard, timothy grasses including panic grass and crab grass grasses including purpletop grasses including Bermuda grass and crab grass Hobomok Skipper Poanes hobomok common Compiled by Bob Yukich November 2000; fifth revision December 2012 locally uncommon to common, mainly in the south common and widespread common and widespread grasses including bluestem, switch, woolly beard grasses including panic and bluegrass Comments typically a late summer immigrant in warmer years, breeding after its arrival and producing one or more generations that often persist into October; does not over-winter in the province an old specimen from High Park in the ROM previously uncommon in High Park, this species has recently become quite common, likely due in part to habitat improvement few park records; has likely bred easily confused with other small dark skippers easily confused with other small dark skippers during the summer of 2012 this species migrated into southern Ontario in unprecedented numbers, breeding as far north as Toronto; on August 13, 2012 Bob Yukich photographed a female on the lawn in front of the High Park Training Centre, the only known record for the park (2012 was a spectacular year for southern immigrants in the province) this species was present in the park in the 1980s but may have since been over-looked due to its scarcity; Bob Yukich observed a fresh male in a wet meadow along Spring Creek on July 11, 2000; a few individuals, including a female ovipositing on big bluestem, were observed in plot 1D during July 2002; there was a viable colony here in 2004; it has recently been undergoing a range expansion in the province and is now quite common in the park one of our earliest-flying skippers; closely associated with woodlands 2 BUTTERFLIES OF HIGH PARK Common Name Broad-winged Skipper Scientific Name Poanes viator Status in High Park historical record; possibly now a rare breeder Status in Ontario locally common, mainly in the south Host Plant sedges and phragmites Black Dash Euphyes conspicua one sighting locally uncommon in southern Ontario sedges including tussock sedge Dun Skipper Euphyes vestris common common and widespread sedges Ocola Skipper Panoquina ocola very rare southern immigrant very rare immigrant in the south, with most records from Point Pelee grasses SWALLOWTAILS Pipevine Swallowtail PAPILIONIDAE Battus philenor rare southern immigrant rare immigrant, mainly in the southern part of the province pipevines (Aristolochia) Black Swallowtail Papilio polyxenes uncommon to fairly common common, mainly in the south Giant Swallowtail Papilio cresphontes rare resident and southern immigrant uncommon to common in the southern part of the province where host plants occur; in recent years has colonized areas north of historical range parsley family including Queen Anne’s Lace hop tree, prickly ash, non-native ornamentals in the citrus family Compiled by Bob Yukich November 2000; fifth revision December 2012 Comments a wetland species; old specimens from High Park in the ROM; Bob Yukich saw a fresh male nectaring on wild bergamot along the east side of Grenadier Pond on July 10, 2007; Alfred Adamo and John Foster photographed one on phragmites at the south end of Grenadier Pond (where it may now breed) on July 14, 2012; the closest known colony to High Park is in the Rouge Valley Bob Yukich observed a fresh individual of this wetland species, the first record for the city of Toronto, in plot 1D near Grenadier Pond on July 16, 2004; at the time the most easterly known colony in the province was in Halton region; has since colonized wetlands northeast of Toronto in northern Durham region; the remarkable occurrence of this non-migratory species in High Park is most likely related to its range expansion the most common small dark skipper in High Park; can sometimes be confused with other small dark skippers does not breed at this latitude; one was photographed by Bob Yukich as it nectared on sedum in a large flowerbed at Colborne Lodge on Sept. 23, 2012, the most northerly record ever for the province; also present the following day; this was the only report of Ocola Skipper in Ontario in 2012 (a spectacular year for southern immigrants) occasionally breeds in the province where its host plant occurs as an ornamental only (native further south); a few fresh individuals recorded in High Park in late August 2000, and again in June and August of 2001 and 2002, probably emerged nearby; this species was easily seen in the park in 2012, a year which saw an unprecented migration of this species into the province Bob Yukich recorded the first individual for High Park on August 28, 2003 following a northward incursion of this species into our area; since 2006 this species has been reported almost annually in the park in small numbers; a female was observed ovipositing on an ornamental hop tree in the park in 2011 by Jay Paluck; it is now a rare breeder in the Toronto region, using non-native ornamentals as well as native host plants 3 BUTTERFLIES OF HIGH PARK Common Name Eastern Tiger Swallowtail Scientific Name Papilio glaucus Status in High Park common Status in Ontario common in the southern part of the province; sporadically distributed north of Toronto Host Plant cherry, ash, tulip tree, hop tree Spicebush Swallowtail Papilio troilus rare to uncommon; occasionally common as in 2008 and 2012 uncommon to common in the southwest spicebush, sassafras WHITES AND YELLOWS Cabbage White Clouded Sulphur PIERIDAE Pieris rapae Colias philodice common common common and widespread common and widespread Orange Sulphur Colias eurytheme common southern immigrant common and widespread immigrant mustard family white clover, alfalfa, vetch alfalfa, white clover Little Yellow Pyrisitia lisa rare southern immigrant rare immigrant mainly in the south Cassia GOSSAMER-WINGS American Copper LYCAENIDAE Lycaena phlaeas historical record locally common throughout Bronze Copper Lycaena hyllus historical record; one recent sighting; breeding uncertain locally common, especially in the south sheep sorrel, curled dock curled dock, water dock, smartweed Acadian Hairstreak Satyrium acadica rare to uncommon widespread, mostly in the south willows Coral Hairstreak Satyrium titus uncertain, likely extirpated cherry, plum Edwards' Hairstreak Satyrium edwardsii extirpated locally common in the south locally uncommon to common in the south Banded Hairstreak Satyrium calanus fairly common oak, walnut, hickory Hickory Hairstreak Satyrium caryaevorus rare Striped Hairstreak Satyrium liparops uncommon common mainly in the south typically rare to uncommon in the south uncommon to fairly common throughout Compiled by Bob Yukich November 2000; fifth revision December 2012 oak saplings, especially black oak hickories, oaks and others heath and rose families including hawthorn, cherry, plum Comments the northern edge of this species’ range is not clearly delineated; it overlaps the southern edge of the range of the smaller, more northern Canadian Tiger Swallowtail P. canadensis which is almost identical in appearance bred in High Park in 1999 (two broods) and in subsequent years in variable numbers, using abundant sassafras as host; over-winters as a pupa within 30 cm of the ground; small, isolated population makes it vulnerable non-native; introduced from Europe around 1860 breeds after its arrival producing at least two more generations; at times abundant in southern Ontario; not known to over-winter in the province does not over-winter in the province; not known to breed in our area an old specimen from High Park in the ROM old specimens from High Park in the ROM; a species associated with wetlands; Bob Yukich saw a very fresh individual in suitable breeding habitat along the east side of Grenadier Pond on July 10, 2007 once more common in High Park, this species is now rarely encountered; in July 2008 Bob Yukich observed a freshly emerged individual near the Forest School, and later, a worn one near Grenadier Pond reported from High Park in the 1980s once common, this very local species disappeared from High Park in the mid-1990’s, a period when there were very few young oaks the most common hairstreak in High Park few park records; can be difficult to distinguish from S. calanus 4 BUTTERFLIES OF HIGH PARK Common Name Gray Hairstreak Scientific Name Strymon melinus Status in High Park rare southern immigrant Status in Ontario uncommon immigrant (resident?) in the extreme southwest; a resident population breeds locally in the north Host Plant a wide variety including "weedy" plants; sweetfern in the north Marine Blue Leptotes marina very rare southern immigrant very rare immigrant in the south; previously reported only from Point Pelee (twice) where it bred in 1993, producing three generations in a single season various legumes Eastern Tailed-Blue Cupido comyntas common Spring Azure Celastrina lucia uncommon common, mainly in the south common and widespread Summer Azure Celastrina neglecta common common in the south, less so in the north Silvery Blue Glaucopsyche lygdamus fairly common Karner Blue Plebejus samuelis historical record common, except absent from much of the southwest, where it continues to spread extirpated about 1991 legumes including tick trefoil wide variety including cherry, blueberry, viburnums wide variety including dogwoods, viburnums, New Jersey tea and white sweet-clover legumes, mainly cow vetch in our area BRUSHFOOTS American Snout NYMPHALIDAE Libytheana carinenta rare southern immigrant uncommon to common southern immigrant as far north as Ottawa; previously confined mainly to the southwest hackberries Variegated Fritillary Euptoieta claudia rare southern immigrant rare immigrant, mainly in the south Great Spangled Fritillary Speyeria cybele uncommon common and widespread wide variety including violets, flax, stonecrop, plantain violets Compiled by Bob Yukich November 2000; fifth revision December 2012 wild lupine Comments a few recorded in High Park in 1999 (a year that saw many rare southern butterflies in the province); likely bred that year, producing a second generation that emerged in the fall; a fresh individual was also recorded in the park on Aug. 3, 2008 by Barry Harrison, and it likely bred again in 2012 when 2 females were found (one ovipositing on wild lupine) by Bob Yukich essentially a tropical species that migrates northward, occasionally reaching the U.S. midwest; a small colony of freshly emerged individuals was discovered near Marie Curtis Park, Toronto on July 12, 2008. On July 22, 2008 Bob Yukich observed a freshly emerged male and female of this species nectaring on blue vervain in a wet meadow at the southeast corner of Grenadier Pond in most years this species is common in High Park; in some it is almost absent flies in April and May; much less common throughout much of the city than C. neglecta which flies later in the season similar in appearance to C. lucia, but does not fly until early June this species has been undergoing a southward range extension and was first recorded in Toronto in 1997; the first confirmed breeding in High Park was in plot 1D in June 2003; it is now established in the park extirpated from High Park around 1926 migrates annually into the southern part of the province, breeding at locations such as Point Pelee and Pelee Island where its host plant is common; not known to over-winter; Barry Harrison saw a single individual, the only park record, in ornamental gardens near the High Park Training Centre on July 29, 2007, a year when there were many sightings of this species north of its usual range; it has since become an annual breeder at locations along the Toronto waterfront, using hackberry trees planted by the city as hosts occasionally breeds after its arrival, as in 2012 when it became widespread in southern parts of the province 5 BUTTERFLIES OF HIGH PARK Common Name Aphrodite Fritillary Scientific Name Speyeria aphrodite Status in High Park historical record Status in Ontario common to uncommon throughout much of the province common in the north; absent from the southwest locally common throughout much of the province Host Plant violets Comments old specimens from High Park in the ROM Atlantis Fritillary Speyeria atlantis historical record violets two old specimens from High Park in the ROM Meadow Fritillary Boloria bellona historical record; one or two recent sightings; does not breed violets rare locally uncommon to common throughout, but more widespread in the north composites such as sunflowers, asters Phyciodes tharos usually uncommon asters Northern Crescent Phyciodes cocyta usually uncommon uncommon to common in the south common and widespread Tawny Crescent Phyciodes batesii historical record asters Baltimore Checkerspot Euphydryas phaeton historical record Question Mark Polygonia interrogationis uncommon to common southern immigrant locally uncommon to common throughout locally common where host plant occurs uncommon to common immigrant throughout old specimens from High Park in the ROM; Bob Yukich saw a fresh female nectaring on boneset in a wet meadow, its preferred habitat, at the southeast corner of Grenadier Pond on August 21, 2006; there are no known colonies in the west end of Toronto, but this species is known to wander Bob Yukich recorded two individuals in High Park in plot 1B on July 10, 2000 (first known record for the park); single individuals were subsequently recorded here in July of 2001 and 2002, as well as in plot 9B in July 2004; a rare breeder in the park, this species appears to be susceptible to habitat disturbance similar in appearance to P. cocyta, and can sometimes be confused with that species similar in appearance to P. tharos, and can sometimes be confused with that species one old specimen from High Park in the ROM Silvery Checkerspot Chlosyne nycteis Pearl Crescent Eastern Comma Polygonia comma uncommon to common nettles, elms, hops Gray Comma Polygonia progne rare uncommon to common throughout uncommon to fairly common throughout much of the province Compton Tortoiseshell Nymphalis l-album uncommon uncommon to common throughout willow, birch, poplar Mourning Cloak Nymphalis antiopa fairly common common and widespread Milbert’s Tortoiseshell Nymphalis milberti historical record; a few recent sightings; breeding uncertain locally uncommon to fairly common throughout much of the province wide variety including willows, elms, poplars nettles American Lady Vanessa virginiensis uncommon to common southern immigrant uncommon to common immigrant throughout Compiled by Bob Yukich November 2000; fifth revision December 2012 asters turtlehead nettles, elms, hops currants, gooseberries, birches, elms everlastings, wormwoods, burdocks, ironweed an old specimen from High Park in the ROM; a species associated with wetlands does not typically over-winter in the province, but recent evidence suggests it may on rare occasions like other Polygonia, hibernates over the winter as an adult old specimens from High Park in the ROM; on July 27, 2008 Bob Yukich photographed a fresh individual nectaring on purple coneflower at the Children’s Garden along Colborne Lodge Dr. in High Park, the first known record for the park in modern times often recorded in High Park in early spring; these are likely migrants from the north that, having arrived the previous fall, hibernated over the winter; there are a few summer records for the park; occasionally breeds like other Nymphalis, hibernates over the winter as an adult old specimens from High Park in the ROM; a few individuals were observed nectaring on ornamentals at various locations in High Park during the summer of 2007 breeds after its arrival, producing one or more generations; does not over-winter in the province 6 BUTTERFLIES OF HIGH PARK Common Name Painted Lady Scientific Name Vanessa cardui Status in High Park rare to common southern immigrant Status in Ontario rare to common immigrant throughout Red Admiral Vanessa atalanta Common Buckeye Junonia coenia uncommon to common southern immigrant rare to uncommon southern immigrant White Admiral Limenitis arthemis arthemis uncommon Red-spotted Purple Limenitis arthemis astyanax uncommon Viceroy Limenitis archippus rare uncommon to common immigrant throughout uncommon to common immigrant, mainly in the south common in the north, mostly absent from the southwest common in the south, mainly absent from the north common throughout, especially in the south Northern Pearly-Eye Lethe anthedon uncommon to rare (extirpated?) locally uncommon to common throughout Eyed Brown Lethe eurydice historical record Little Wood-Satyr Megisto cymela common to abundant Common Ringlet Coenonympha tullia uncommon to fairly common Common Wood-Nymph Cercyonis pegala fairly common locally common to abundant, mainly in the southern part of the province common to abundant throughout, especially in the south common to abundant throughout much of the province common throughout Monarch Danaus plexippus common southern immigrant common and widespread NOTES: This list comprises 80 species and one subspecies of butterfly known to have occurred in High Park up to the end of 2012. All of the species listed are known to or assumed to breed, or have bred, in High Park unless otherwise noted. Common names used in this list are those found in Checklist & English Names of North American Butterflies, Second Edition, published by the North American Butterfly Association (NABA). Scientific names are taken from A Catalogue of the Butterflies of the United States and Canada by Jonathan P. Pelham, revised February 14, 2012. Host plants listed for each species were taken from The Butterflies of Canada by R. A. Layberry, P. W. Hall and J. D. Lafontaine 1998, and The Ontario Butterfly Atlas by A. M. Holmes, Q. F. Hess, R. R. Tasker and A. J. Hanks 1991. ROM = Royal Ontario Museum. Compiled by Bob Yukich November 2000; fifth revision December 2012 Host Plant composites including thistles, knapweed, burdock, sunflowers nettles gerardia, toadflax, plantain willow, aspen, poplar, birch cherries, poplars, oaks willows, poplars various grasses including purple oat and reed canary sedges various grasses including bluegrass and orchard grass various grasses including bluegrass and needle grass various grasses including wild oat, bluestem, purpletop milkweeds Comments usually rare but in certain years quite common; usually breeds after its arrival, producing one or more generations; does not over-winter in the province breeds after its arrival, producing one or more generations; may over-winter rarely, only as an adult an annual colonizer; not known to over-winter; has recently become more common in the southern parts of the province; common in High Park in 2012 L. a. arthemis and L. a. astyanax were once considered separate species intermediates between astyanax and arthemis are often seen in the Toronto region; both forms can sometimes be seen side by side in High Park mainly associated with wetlands; surprisingly, this species is rarely encountered in High Park where it is not known to breed a species of shady, light-dappled woodlands; often perches on tree trunks; not reported from the park in recent years old specimens from High Park in the ROM; a wetland species does not over-winter; southbound migration can be observed over High Park each fall The species abundance designations are based on a typical year, and a skilled observer being in suitable habitat, in the appropriate season, under favourable weather conditions. It should be noted, however, that the population of any butterfly species can fluctuate dramatically from year to year, or even within a breeding season, due to a variety of environmental factors. abundant: usually recorded in large numbers on all visits common: normally recorded on all visits fairly common: likely to be recorded on most visits uncommon: present in small numbers; can be missed on most visits rare: can be less than annual in occurrence very rare: often several years between sightings; not to be expected 7
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz