Articles Dry Valley Streams in Antarctica: Ecosystems Waitingfor Water DIANEM. MCKNIGHT, DEVK. NIYOGI,ALEXANDER S. ALGER,ARNEBOMBLIES,PETERA. CONOVITZ, AND CATHYM. TATE n the McMurdo DryValleysof SouthVictoriaLand, Antarctica,the striking features of the stark landscape includethe wide expansesof barrengroundpatternedwith largehexagonalshapescreatedby periglacial(freeze-thaw) processes, the high mountains interspersedwith alpine glaciers,and the large,permanentlyice-coveredlakesin the valley floors. For most of the year, it is the cold winds descendingfrom the polar plateauthat graduallyshapethe dry valley landscape. The dominant influences of wind erosion and cold temperatureson the landscape are less potent during the australsummer,when the temperatures become warm enough for melting to occur on the surface and face of the glaciers (Fountain et al. 1999). During runoff,streamsflow down the sides of the valleys,carrying water,solutes,and sedimentsto the lakes. Since the first exploration of the McMurdo Sound region of Antarctica by Robert Scott's expedition in 1904-1906, the dry valleys, which are located across the sound from Scott's base, have intrigued scientists from many disciplines.The McMurdoDry Valleysare the coldest and driestdesertsin the world and arerepresentativeof the 2% of the Antarcticcontinent that is ice free.The valleys encompass an area of approximately4000 km2. This region has experienceda warming trend since it was first explored, and most lakes have risen more than 1 m since 1968, when the New ZealandAntarcticResearchProgram began monitoring lake levels (Chinn 1993). The biota that grow in the soils, lakes,and glacialmeltwater streams of this harsh environment are primarily cyanobacteria,eukaryotic algae, mosses, and heterotrophic and chemoautotrophic bacteria. The multicellular organismsrepresentinghigher trophic levels are generally low in diversityand abundance.Aside from the occasional skua gull, the largest animals in the dry valley ecosystems are nematodes. Streams in the McMurdo Dry Valleys region are very different from most streams on the planet. Dry valley streamsare fed by melting glaciersand flow only for up to 10 weeks each year.They vary in length from less than 1 km to 30 km, in the case of the Onyx Riverin WrightValley. Because of the lack of precipitation and terrestrial runoff,there arelimited interactionsbetween streamsand the surroundingbarren landscape.For example, because there are no vascularplants in the region, there is no leaf litter input to the streams.One might expect these streams ECOLOGICALLEGACIESALLOWABUNDANT CYANOBACTERIALMATS TO OCCUR IN DRY VALLEYSTREAMS to be relativelybarrenof life, and some of them are (Alger et al. 1997); however,in many streams diverse microbial communities persist despite the extremeconditions. The microbial communities present in the dry valley streams consist primarily of cyanobacteria, although chlorophytes and diatoms are also common. The harsh conditions limit stream fauna to nematodes, rotifers,and tardigrades.There are no insects or other macroscopic streamconsumers,which are common in most temperate streams.Algal communities grow in the streams as mats and have different colors because of photosynthetic and accessory pigments. These perennial algal mats can survive long periods of desiccation,allowinghigh biomass to develop, even by temperate-zone standards (McKnight and Tate 1997). Consequently, these streams can be hotspots of life in an otherwise barrenlandscape. Researchon dry valley streamshas been conducted primarily in Wright Valley,TaylorValley,and Miers Valley. Canada Stream, a productive stream in the Lake Fryxell basin of TaylorValley (Figure 1), has been studied most thoroughly (Vincent and Howard-Williams1986,Vincent 1988). Since 1993, additional research on the stream ecosystems has been conducted as part of the McMurdo Dry Valleys Long-TermEcological Research(LTER)project, which is one of a networkof LTERprojectslocated in is a researchassoDianeMcKnight ([email protected]) ciate and Dev K. Niyogiand ArneBombliesare graduatestudents at the Institute for Arctic and Alpine Research, Universityof Colorado,Boulder,CO80309. McKnightis also an associate proand Architectural fessor in the Departmentof Civil,Environmental, Engineering,Universityof Colorado,Boulder,CO80309. Alexander S. Algeris a graduatestudent at the Universityof Michigan,Ann Arbor,MI 48109. Peter A. Conovitzis a graduate student at FortCollins,CO80523. CathyM.Tateis ColoradoState University, a biologistwith the US GeologicalSurvey,Denver,CO 80223. ? 1999 AmericanInstituteof BiologicalSciences. December1999 / Vol.49 No. 12 * BioScience 985 University of California Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve, and extend access to BioScience ® www.jstor.org Articles ~Iv Cree Relict CA K0. S Channel , Figure 1. Map of the LakeFryxellbasin in TaylorValley,McMurdoDry Valleys region,Antarctica.Solid circlesindicate streamgauging stations, and open circlesindicate the locations of algal transectstations. legacies (Moorheadet al. 1999) that control the responseof streamecosystemsto the changingclimate. Characteristicsof dry valley stream habitats - 'N wad 2 km In the extreme environment of the McMurdo Dry Valleys, physical and chemical factors determine biological presence and activity.Therefore,characterizationof the unusualhydrology,geomorphology, and geochemistry of dry valley streamsprovidesa foundation for understanding the ecology of these streams. Hydrology. Thedrainageof meltwater Figure2. A dry valley stream (PriscuStream,in the Lake Bonney Basin of TaylorValley).The dark bands of the watersaturatedhyporheiczone are visiblealong the stream.Stream width in thephotographis approximately1-3 m. 22 diverseregions acrossthe globe. In our research,we use descriptive measurements of hydrology, chemistry, and biology in combination with short- and long-term stream-scale experiments. In this article, we discuss the dynamic interactionsbetween cyanobacterialmats in the dry valley streams and the physical and geochemical processes of the stream ecosystems. We also discuss the persistenceof algalmats despite the long periods of desiccation and extreme cold and emphasize the ecological 986 BioScience - December1999 / Vol.49 No. 12 from the alpine glaciers into meltwater streams supports the brief annual productivity of the stream ecosystems. For 4-10 weeks during the austral summer, the meltwaterstreams become a distinctive feature of the barrenlandscape.The land surfaceis composed of an unconsolidatedsedimentthat has large (5 m), hexagonally patterned ground features caused by periglacial processes.A layer of active permafrost,which freezes and thaws annually,begins 0.1 m below the surfacelayer and extends to approximately0.5 m in depth. The true permafrostlayerthen begins at 0.5 m beneaththe surface.The streambedsvary in width from 1 m to 30 m. Because the streambankvegetationis limited to small patchesof moss, the stream banks consist of steeply sloped, poorly sorted sediment and are generallyunstable.Undercuttingof the banks during high streamflowperiods can result in 1-2 cm deposits of sediment in lower reaches of the streams (Diane M. McKnight,personalobservation). During the australsummer,darkbands that border the streams can be seen (Figure 2); these moist areas,which develop as the summer progresses,are the surficialmanifestations of the hyporheic zone. The term "hyporheic zone" refers to the area adjacent to and underneath the stream,in which waterflows through the streambedin the downstream direction and exchanges with water in the main channel (Figure3). In Huey Creekin the LakeFryxell basin (Figure 1), the high permeabilityof the hyporheic zone sediment and the steep gradient of the stream result in exchange rates of water with the main channel that are more rapid than exchangeratesmeasuredin temperate streams at similar flows (Figure 4; Runkel et al. Articles at low flow in GreenCreekin the 1998).Measurements LakeFryxellbasin(Figure1), whichhas a shallowgradient,yieldedexchangecoefficientsthatareat the high end of the rangemeasuredin temperatestreams(Figure4). The rapidexchangerates and the absenceof lateral inflowsfromshallowgroundwater resultin a substantial lateralextentof the hyporheiczone.Forlongstreamsduring low-flowyears,waterstoragein the hyporheiczone can accountfor a significantportionof the annualmeltwaterfrom the glacier(Bomblies1998,Conovitzet al. 1998).The depthof the hyporheiczone is controlledby the thawdepthof the activepermafrostlayer(Figure3), whichextendsto a greaterdepththroughoutthevalleysas the summerprogresses.Measurement of the active-layer thawdepthat 18transectson threedifferentstreamsindicatedthatthedepthwas5-10 cm atthebeginningof summerandincreasedto 50-60 cm by the endof the summer (Conovitz1999).Both the rapidexchangeratesand the increasingvolume through the summer indicatethat hyporheiczone processesare potentiallyimportantin thesestreamecosystems. Themeasurement of streamflowprovidesa contextfor interannual understanding changesin the streams.The flow of the OnyxRiverin WrightValleyhas been monitoredat two gaugingsitessince1968,anddatafor annual to LakeVandaindicateconsiderable interannual discharge variation(Figure5a). Becausethe Onyx Riverreceives which abutsa pieddrainagefrom LakeBrownsworth, mont glacier,as well as fromtributarystreamsdraining alpineglaciers,its flowmaybe affectedby climaticconditions in McMurdoSoundin additionto those in Wright Valley.A networkof streamgaugeswasestablishedin the LakeFryxellbasinin 1990(von Guerardet al. 1994)and was extendedto includethe entireTaylorValleyin 1993. TaylorValleystreamsalsohaveasmuchas a fivefoldinterannualvariationin streamflow (Figure5b;Houseet al. 1995). In additionto showinginterannualvariation,average streamflowratescan show considerabledaily variation duringthe summer,dependingon insolationandairtemperature.Hydrologicdataindicatethat streamflow can varyas muchas 5-10-foldduringa singleday,depending on the orientationof the sourceglacierwithrespectto the i i ci Ma r Si ,i i i. T iT Permafrost a Hyporheic 9 zone .. Stream channel Permafrost Figure3. Schematicdiagram illustratingthe hyporheic zone in dry valley streams. Waterleaves the main stream channel and passes throughthe substrateon the sides and below the stream and then may return to the main channel.Solutesalso pass throughthe streambedand may undergoreactionsthat affect their transport.The hyporheiczone may also be a sourceof some nutrients to the water in the main stream channel. solar trajectory (Conovitz et al. 1998). For example, the flow in Huey Creekcan range from a trickleof clearwater at 5 L/s in the early morning to a surging flow of turbid, sediment-ladenwater at 80 L/s by the afternoon. During cold periods, when there is no meltwatersource from the glacier,the recessionof the hydrographis controlledprimarilyby drainageof the hyporheic zone (Conovitz et al. 1998). To understand climatic responses of streams throughout the McMurdo Dry Valleys, it is important to know what causes variation in climate-stream flow relations. Our analysis(Bomblies 1998) indicatesthat, in additionto being relatedto variation in meltwatergenerationassociated with characteristicsof the glacier,some of the interstream variation is relatedto stream length and geomorphology,which affectthe storageof waterin the hyporheic zone. Becausethe physicalprocessesthat control the flow in the stream channels and hyporheic exchange have a high degree of temporal variability during a single day, 10-1 Figure4. Comparisonof hyporheicexchangerate among temperateand dry valley streams.The exchangerate is a measureof howfast water exchangesbetween the main stream channel and the hyporheiczone and is estimatedfrom conservativetracerprofiles.Diamonds indicate values estimatedfor individual reachesat each stream.LittleLost Man and Uvas Creeksare in California;Saint Kevin Gulchand SnakeRiverare in Colorado;and Greenand Huey Creeksare in TaylorValley,Antarctica(datafrom Runkelet al. 1998, Diane M. McKnight,RobertL. Runkel,JohnH. Duff, CathyM. Tate,Daryl L. Moorhead,unpublishedmanuscript). 10-2C-, 1o- ?10-3- > o o 10-4 110-6 LU Little Uvas Saint Snake Green Huey Lost Creek Kevin River Creek Creek Gulch Man Stream December1999 / Vol.49 No. 12 * BioScience 987 Articles 140-- Figure5. Annual variation in stream dischargefor two of the McMurdoDry Valley streams.(a) OnyxRiver,at VandaStation in the Wright Valley(north of Taylor Valley).(b) Canada Stream, in the LakeFryxellbasin in TaylorValley(see Figure 1). a - Onyx River 120 100....... .... ... 80 60 40 E 20 0 o .. C0) 'It • ,O,r• N"- N- N-,- CO M 0M N- N- CO Cr O O M') O O ) QD 0' M0 O O O0 -u (0350 O S b - Canada Stream S300 ..... 250 . 150 0 4 tO Year within a summer, and among years,the stream habitat is dynamic during the brief summer period of flow. Thus, streamecosystemscontain algalspecies that must not only survive the long period of desiccation during fall, winter, and spring but also sustain primary production under a highly variableflow regime. featuresof the dry Geomorphology. Geomorphological valley streams also control the suitability of streams for supporting algal mats. Algae are generally abundant in many moderate-gradient stream reaches, in which the rocks of the streambedare arrangedin a stone pavement. These stone pavements are similar to those commonly found along the shores of alpine lakes, which form throughperiglacialprocesses.We inferthat the stone pavements in dry valley streamsare also a result of periglacial processes acting over long periods of time, perhaps centuries or longer.We propose that as the saturatedalluvium freezes,the expansion of the alluvium surroundinga rock 988 BioScience * December1999 / Vol.49 No. 12 rotates the rock until the largest flat side is upward. This process, which occurs across the streambed,wedges t C M, CI3 '• the rocks together, creating 0") 0') 0) 0) 0") 0') the appearanceof a flat pavement. The stone pavement configurationmay limit sediment transportand scour and create smooth flow conditions, thereby providing a favorable habitat for algal .. . mats (Algeret al. 1997). Thus, we propose that these stone pavements are an important physical legacy from past summers that promotes the current growth of cyanobacterial mats and shape the ecological system. In contrast to their abundance in reaches of moderate NC gradient, algae are scarce in steep reaches of dry valley streams, where the rocks are uneven and jumbled, and in shallow gradient reaches, where the streambed consists of moving sand. In steep reaches, algal growth is present as sheets of the chlorophyte Prasiola on the underside of rocks. High stream velocities, turbulence, and abrasion may limit growth of other taxa in these steep reaches (Vincent et al. 1993a, Alger et al. 1997). Stone pavementsprobablydo not form in steep reaches because the alluvium drains rapidly, before freeze-thaw processes move the rocks into a stone pavement formation. Furthermore,high-flow events may removesand and smallerrocksin these reaches.In shallow reaches,which are common near the outlet to lakes, the instabilityof the sand substrateis most likely the limiting factor for algal growth (Alger et al. 1997). In both steepand shallow-gradientreaches, rivulets of water occur on the sides of the active channel and are important habitat for algal mats. The rivulets, which are called parafluvial seeps, appearto drain the hyporheiczone. In shallow-gradient reaches,the algal mats in the parafluvialseeps may representmost of the algalbiomass (Algeret al. 1997). Articles 226 m 50 m 2000 497 m 327 m (D 1500 0 _00_ 00 80 60 0 l.. "" 0 40 10 25 aa 20 15 - 21 23 25 27 29 21 23 25 27 29 21 23 25 27 29 21 23 25 27 29 Time (h) tracer),nitrate, Figure6. Concentration profilesatfoursitesbelowan experimental injectionpointof chloride(conservative andphosphate.A solutionof nutrientsandchloridesaltwasinjectedinto thestreamfor 4 hours(startingat 21 hours). Distancedownstream frominjectionlocationis shownabovepanels.At thesite497 m downstream fromtheinjectionpoint, theabsenceof detectableconcentrations of nitrateandphosphateindicatestherapiduptakeof thesenutrientsbystream biota.Theopensquaresrepresent actualdatapoints,whereasthesolidlinesrepresentsimulationsusinga hyporheic RobertL Runkel,JohnH. Duff, exchangemodelwithvariableflow andfirst-orderuptakeof nutrients(DianeM.McKnight, their CathyM. Tate,DarylL.Moorhead,unpublished manuscript). If thenutrientshad behavedconservatively, concentration at 50 m at profileswouldbesimilarto thechlorideprofileat eachsite.Theslightincreasesin concentrations theendof theinjectionresultfroma decreasein streamflow duringthattime. Currently active streams in the dry valleys constitute only a subset of the fluvialfeaturesof the landscape.Satellite images revealwhat appearto be relict streamchannels in the McMurdoDry Valleysregion.Furthermore,approximately 50% of the streams marked on the topographic maps of the region do not appearto be flowing duringthe 1990s. Some of these "streams"may representsubglacial flowpaths that were carved out when terminal glaciers extended farther down the valleys (David R. Marchant, Boston University,personal communication). Other relict channels may have lost their water source afterthe retreat of alpine glaciers,which now feed new streamchannels,or they may have been cut off from meltwaterby upstream sediment deposition that formed a barrierto flow. Future field studies may revealwhich of these featuresare truly relict streamchannels,as opposed to subglacialflowpaths, and may indicatewhetherstone pavementswere common habitatswhen the channels were active. Biogeochemistry. Streamsin the dry valleyslink the glaciersand the lakes.Severalabiotic and biotic processes in stream ecosystems affect the sources, sinks, and transport of chemicals along these flowpaths.These processes may occur not only along the streambedbut also in the hyporheic zone below and alongside the active channel. A role for hyporheic zones in biogeochemical cycling has been documented in many streams (e.g., Triskaet al. 1993, Holmes et al. 1994, Jones et al. 1995, Mulhollandet December1999 / Vol.49 No. 12 * BioScience 989 Articles al. 1997).As discussedby Vervieret al. (1992),hyporheic processesarelikelyto playan importantbiogeochemical As rolein streamsunderconditionsof highpermeability. waterin the hyporheiczone exchangeswith waterin the mainstreamchannel,solutesarealso exchanged(Runkel et al. 1998).Examination of majorcationandsilicatedata for manyTaylorValleystreamsindicatesthatweathering of silicaterocksandothermineralsoccursin thehyporheic zone at surprisinglyhigh rates (Lyonset al. 1998a, 1998b).Thisconclusionis furthersupportedby observationsthatin vonGuerardStreamin theLakeFryxellbasin, of majorions, includingsilicate,increase concentrations with distance downstream(AlexanderBlum, Michael Gooseff,W. BerryLyons,Diane McKnight,unpublished data).Similarly,Greenet al. (1988)proposedthatin dry valley streams,weatheringof apatiteis the source for phosphate,andleachingof atmosphericdepositionis the source for nitrate. Thus, dissolved nutrients can be released through hyporheic zone reactions. Primary weatheringreactionsand dissolutionof marineaerosols probablyoccurin the hyporheiczone,greatlymodifying the chemicalcompositionof glacialmeltwaterwithinthe streamsaswaterflowsto the lakes(Lyonset al. 1998a). Biologicallycontrolledprocessingof streamsolutesis also evident in dry valley streams. Mats of Nostoc fix atmosphericnitrogen,accountingfor as cyanobacteria muchas 10%of the nitrogeninputsin streams(Howardet al. (1989,1998) Williamset al. 1989).Howard-Williams transform communities that reported algal inorganic may nitrogenin dryvalleystreamsto organicformsof nitrogen to thelakeecosystems. Monitorthatarethentransported and has shown that nitrate of stream phoschemistry ing arehigherin streamswithoutalgal phateconcentrations mats than in streamswith mats, indicatingthat algal uptakeof nutrientsin streamsregulatesinorganicnutrient flux to the lakes(DianeM. McKnight,RobertL. Runkel, JohnH. Duff,CathyM. Tate,DarylL.Moorhead,unpubet al. (1998) also lished manuscript).Howard-Williams acrossthe concentrations decreased that nitrate reported boulderpavementin the OnyxRiver,an areaof extensive of dissolvedorganicnitrogen algalmats;concentrations in streamsthathave increasedacrossthisreach.Moreover, in algalmats,nutrientconcentrations the hyporheiczone arehigherthanthosein the streamwater,indicatingthat there is a constant nutrient supply to the mats through hyporheicweatheringand exchangewith surfacewater.At the end of the austral summer, drainage from the hyporheic zone therefore becomes a source of nutrientrich waterto the algal mats. To examine the controls on dissolved nutrient flux to the lakes,we conducted a nutrient injection experimentin Green Creek (Figure 1), a stream that has abundant algal mats. The injectate concentrations corresponded to drainageof nutrient-richhyporheicwater into the stream in late summer (55 iM nitrate and 18 iM phosphate; Diane M. McKnight, Robert L. Runkel, John H. Duff, 990 BioScience * December1999 / Vol.49 No. 12 Cathy M. Tate, Daryl L. Moorhead, unpublished manuscript). Chloride was injected and monitored as a conservative (i.e., nonreactive) tracer, and chloride data were used to model hydrologic exchange. Unlike chloride, nitrateand phosphatedid not behaveconservatively;concentrations of these solutes at the downstreamsites were much lower than those of chloride (Figure6). During the arrivalof the chloridetracerat a site 497 m downstreamof the injection point, nitrateand phosphateremainedbelow detection (less than 1-2 1iM), indicating rapid nutrient removal from the stream water (presumablybecause of algal uptake). Moreover,the production of nitrite at two intermediatesites (226 m and 327 m downstreamof the injection point) indicates that other nitrogen cycling processes, in addition to uptake, were occurring during the injection of nitrate. Incomplete nitrification or denitrificationcould account for the nitrite production (Diane M. McKnight,Robert L. Runkel,John H. Duff, Cathy M. Tate, Daryl L. Moorhead, unpublished manuscript). We used a solute-transport model (Runkel 1998), in which nutrient uptakewas representedas a first-orderprocess,to determine reach-scale parametersfor nitrate and phosphate uptake.The best match to the experimentaldatawas providedby a model in which phosphateuptakeoccurs in the main channel and nitrate uptake occurs in the main channel and the hyporheiczone, possiblyrepresentingloss due to denitrification(7-16% of total nitrateuptake). In summary, once the stream ecosystem has been "turned on" by the arrival of water, there will be some nutrientsupplyto algalmats through primaryweathering, leachingof depositedaerosols,and internalnutrienttransformationswithin the hyporheic zone. Algal mats take up inorganic nutrients from the streambut releasedissolved organic nutrients, which are then transported to lakes. Scouringof the algalmats from the streambedduringhigh flows then providesa source of particulateorganiccarbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus as well as microbiota to the lakes,but this flux has not been quantified. mats in dry Algal communities. The cyanobacterial valley streamsare essentiallyperennial,growing at a slow rate during the summer flow period and overwinteringin a freeze-dried state. The abundance of cyanobacteriain dry valley streamsis to be expectedbecause cyanobacteria dominate the microbial populations of many extreme environments (Potts 1994). Furthermore,the survival of cyanobacteriain a freeze-driedstate is not surprising;for example,freeze-dryingis used for the preservationof bacterialsamples in culture collections (Potts 1994). Previous ecological studies of dry valley algal communities have focused on the algal mats and mosses in CanadaStream, located in TaylorValley(Figure 1; Howard-Williamset al. 1986,Vincent and Howard-Williams1986,Vincent 1988). One remarkableobservationis that some algal mats begin photosynthesizingwithin 10-20 minutes of being rewetted afterdesiccation(Vincent and Howard-Williams1986, Articles Figure7.Algalmatsgrowingin an areaof stone pavementin GreenCreekin theLakeFryxellbasin. Orangematsarepresentin themainchannel 1 m across)and black(Nostoc)mats (approximately as near theedgesof themainchannel. grow tufts Haweset al. 1992). Comparedto streamecosystemsat other sites in the LTERnetwork, dry valley streams representseveral extremes-they lack terrestrialinputsof coarseorganic matter,they havehigh standingalgalbiomass,they have low primaryproductivity, andtheyhavelow grazinglosses (McKnightand Tate1997,Websterand Meyer1997). The high standingbiomassis a resultof the perennial natureof the matsaswellasthe lackof macroinvertebrate grazing,whichin turnis relatedto theharshnessof theclimate.Algalmatsof filamentouscyanobacteria in the main channelusuallyconsistof an orangeupperlayerthat is enrichedin accessory pigments,anda greenlowerlayerthat hasgreaterchlorophyll a contentandgreaterphotosynthetic activity(Vincentet al. 1993b).Therelatively low ratesof unit streambed area and per primaryproductivity perunit reflect fact that in the the mats is chlorophyll growth restricted to thelayerof algaeon theundersideof themats. Thedryvalleystreamshavewidelyvaryingproductivity,in partbecauseof variationsin algalmatbiomass.For example,whereasmatsare abundantin CanadaStream, in HouseCreek,a stream is nearlyindetectable chlorophyll in theLakeHoarebasinin TaylorValleythatflowsthrough an ice-boundmoraine(Algeret al. 1997,McKnightet al. 1998).Net primaryproductionratesrangefrom0.6 ? 0.1 of carbon (mean ? 1 SE) for sediment at tg.cm-2-h-' House Creekto 12.2? 1.3pg.cm-2-h-1 of carbonforblack Nostocmatsin the relictchannelin the LakeFryxellbasin (Diane M. McKnight,CathyM. Tate,Dev K. Niyogi, unpublisheddata).Primaryproductionratesreflectdifferencesin wherealgaeoccur.In streamsthathaveabundantalgae,the matsformextensive,blanketlikecoverage overmostof the streambed(Figure7), whereasin streams that havesparsemats the algaeoccuras patchesat the marginsof the activechannelor as smoothsheetson the sidesandundersidesof jumbledrocks,receivingsunlight whenthe sun is low on the horizon(Vincent1988,Alger et al. 1997).Mossesoccurfartherup the streambanks, wherethey arewetted for short periods of the australsummer, or in flat areas that become damp but where open waterflow does not occur (Algeret al. 1997). To document the range of biomass content in the stream ecosystems, we collected samples of algae at 16 streamsites containing permanentlyestablishedtransects. At each site, we had delineateda transectacrossthe stream and mapped a reachof approximately40 m encompassing the transect; locations of topographic features, stream banks, thalweg (lowest point on channel bed), stream edges, wetted-zone edges, and distribution of algal mats had been recorded (Alger et al. 1997). Within each tran- sect, algalmatswerevisuallyidentifiedas eitherorange, red,black,or green,althoughnot all types of algalmat werefound at everysite. Blackmats are found nearthe channelmargins,and greenmats are attachedto large rocksin the mainchannel.Orangeand redmatsoccurin flowingwaterhabitats,eitherin the main channelor in rivuletsdrainingthe hyporheiczone at the streammarit is similaritiesin physicalcharacteristics gins.Therefore, of the streamhabitat,ratherthan differencesin water quality,that determinethe occurrenceof the different algalmatsin streams. A total of 30 taxa of cyanobacteria and chlorophytes werepresentat the 16 streamsites,and the speciescompositionof the differentmattypeswas consistentamong sites,evensitesthatdifferedwidelyin productivity(Alger et al. 1997).Evennessvalues(Zar 1996),which indicate homogeneityexpressedasa ratioof diversityto maximum possiblediversity,werecalculatedfromthe algalspecies compositionof each communitytype (McKnightet al. 1998).Theblackalgalmatsweredominatedby Nostocsp. andhada low evennessof 0.13? 0.07 (mean? SD).The green algal mats were also made up of essentiallyone or species,beingcomposedchieflyof Prasiolacalophylla Prasiolacrispa,and had an evennessof 0.17 ? 0.10.The orangeand red algalmatswere composedof speciesof Oscillatoria andPhormidium andhadmorediverseassemof For the blages species. orangeand red algalmats,the evennessvalueswere0.55 ? 0.16 and0.48? 0.21,respectively.Theorangeandredmatsalsohad a highdegreeof in speciesdistribution, intrasiteheterogeneity as indicated data within from five of mats collected by samples orange a 20 m reachin GreenCreek(Figure8). Basedon the uniformityof thealgalspeciesacrossstreamsthatrangewidewe proposethatthe limitedset of algal ly in productivity, in dry valleystreamsrepresentsa that are found species second majorlegacy(alongwith the first legacy,stone pavements)forthe streamecosystems. In additionto cyanobacteria, 38 speciesof diatomswere identifiedin dry valleystreams(Alger1999). Manyof these species (e.g., Hantzschiaamphioxys,Stauroneis anceps,and Pinnulariaborealis)arecosmopolitanandare December 1999/ Vol.49 No. 12 e BioScience991 Articles which sustained stream flow was last recordedin the summer of 1969 (Diane M. tectorum E 8B. spp. McKnight, Cathy M. Tate, Dev K. Niyogi, G. kuetzingiana unpublished data). In January 1995, we ..Nostoc o. S-i60 UP. frigidum L constructed a sandbag control structure D autumnale J and routed meltwaterto this relict channel C 40 0. koettlitziH .]p. I (Figure 1). We discovered that both black koettlitziF .-O O. and orange algal mats had persisted in the D 20 EP. crouaniE channel and that these mats grew rapidly irriguaD -O. a few days of the arrival of flow. a0 C within irrigua 0. Ei 1 2 3 4 5 EC0. subproboscidea A Because of the accumulation of aeolian material on the freeze-dried algae, these Replicate number mats had not been apparentbefore flow was restored. Within 2 weeks, a full microbial Figure8. Speciescompositionof orangealgal matsfrom GreenCreekin the was activeover the 1.5 km stream ecosystem LakeFryxellbasin. Five replicatesamples,collectedwithin 20 m of each other, reach. Both mat types became quite extenhighlight the intrasite variation in speciescompositionin these communities. sive the second week of flow. The species by Generaare as follows: B., Binuclearia;G.,Gleocapsa;0., Oscillatoria;P., the black and orange mats were composing Phormidium. Lettersafter species referto morphotypes.Figurereprinted the same as those commonly found in simfrom Algeret al. (1997). colored in other dry valley mats ilarly streams. consideredto be aerophilicor soil diatoms,whereasothers Experiments conducted during the second year after meltwaterwas reroutedto the relictchannel indicatedthat (Muelleriameridionalisand Muelleriaperaustralis)appear to be endemic to the Antarcticcontinent (Spauldingand the black mats in the relict channel had higher net primaStoermer1997). In fact, approximately60% of the diatom ry productivity than black mats from streams that had in streams be endemic to Antarcticonsistent annual flow (Figure9; Niyogi et al. 1998). The species dry valley may ca (Alger 1999). relict channel also had higher solutes,including nutrients, than other dry valley streams,which may account for the greater productivity of the mats (Diane M. McKnight, Long-termpersistenceof Cathy M. Tate, Dev K. Niyogi, unpublished data). This cyanobacterialmats To understandthe basis for the long-term persistenceof ongoing experiment has demonstrated that microbial stream algal mats, we studied a relict stream channel for stream ecosystems can persist in a cryptobiotic state for long periodsand can respondrapidlyto renewed flow.The toleranceof a cryptobioticstate,which allows the cyanobacterialmats to overwinter, Figure9. Rates of net primaryproduction of algal communitytypes in also providesfor the preservationof algal mats threestreamsin the LakeFryxellbasin:Canada Stream,von Guerard in inactivechannels and their rapidresponseto Stream,and the relictchannel.Mat types referto colors,as follows:B, climatic and geomorphologicalshifts. black algal mats (Nostoc); O, orangealgal mats (Phormidium); G,green algal mats (Prasiola). Valuesare means ? 1 SE (fromNiyogi et aL 1998). 100 0,diatoms 80 Anthropogeniceffectson stream communities 140 o 120 100 8o. E c0 80 60 T 20- B O Canada Stream G B O Von Guerard Stream Algal mat 992 BioScience * December1999 / Vol.49 No. 12 B O Relict Channel The long-term persistenceof the streamecosystems should be considered in the context of anthropogenicchanges that may affect the dry valleys. The current and future effects range from local, apparently short-term site disturbances associatedwith scientistsand tourists to the effects of climate and ultraviolet radiation associatedwith global processes. The Antarctic Treaty System has adopted comprehensiveprotocols to limit environmental damage in the Antarcticby providing a system to assess environmentaleffects of planned activities. The stream research carried out by the McMurdoDry ValleysLTERhas been permitted after an environmental assessment Articles process in which the activitieswere evaluatedin the context of natural processes. The environmental protocols also apply to the activitiesof tourists visiting the dry valleys. During January1995, the firstvisit of tourists to Taylor Valley--part of an overall increase in Antarctic tourism-brought several groups to the banks of Green Creek.Sincethen, touristvisits to the dry valleyshave generallyinvolvedgroups of 10-20 people brought in by helicopterfrom ships in McMurdoSound. The environmental protocols for the dry valleys recommend several steps to minimize disturbance to the algal mats; these include crossing the stream at a perpendicular angle, avoiding stepping on the mats, and limiting activitieson the banks that may deposit sediment into the stream.Touristsvisiting the dry valleys may not be aware of the presence of algal mats and their perennialcharacter,but the protocols will help them avoid disturbing the mats. While the streamsareflowing,touristsprobablywould not choose to walk in the channel for any distance. However,before or after stream flow, the stream channels present easy pathways for foot travel and convenient flat places for helicopter landings. Extensivetrampling of the freeze-dried algal mats in the channels could alter the stream ecosystems. The algal mats may be resilient to natural changes, poised waiting for water; however, they may not be resilientenough to withstanddisturbanceby modern-day tourists. Therefore,clear communication between scientists and tour operatorsin the dry valleys is essential for preservationof these unique ecosystems. In addition, anthropogenicchanges associatedwith the modification of the earth's atmosphere may result in changing temperatures and climate in the dry valleys. Nevertheless,because the interannualvariationin climate and flow conditions is alreadyvery large,it is doubtfulthat the new mean climatewould produceflow conditions outside the range observed in the past two decades. We hypothesize that the dry valley streams'response to climate is mediated by major ecological legacies,specifically the stablestone pavementof the streambedand the biodiversity of the algal flora.Although we would expect some change in spatial distribution of currentmat types in the streamswith a graduallychanging climate,we would not expect dramaticshifts, such as loss of mat types. The Antarctichas alreadyexperienced a change in the radiative environment associated with the springtime development of an ozone hole over the continent that allows penetration of ultraviolet radiation at intensities greatlyexceedingthose anywhereelse on the planet (Jones and Shanklin1995). This increasedexposureto ultraviolet radiationoccurs in August and September,well before the onset of stream flow. During these months, the freezedried cyanobacterialmats may be directlyexposed to the increasedultravioletradiation unless they are coveredby accumulated snow or are shaded in an incised stream channel.The potential for damageto the mats and impairment of productivity in the following summer months will depend on the extent to which the radiation penetratesthe upper layersof the mat to the lower layers,where active growth occurs (Vincent et al. 1993b).Cyanobacteria do have accessorypigments that limit damagefrom excess light and ultravioletradiation(Vincent et al. 1993b,Hawes and Howard-Williams1998), but the ability of these pigments to protect cells during prolonged desiccationis not known. For relict mats that go for many years without receiving flow, the damage from increased exposure to ultravioletradiationmay accumulateover time and could impair rapid regrowthonce flow returns. Summaryand conclusions An axiom of ecology is: "Wherethere is water,there is life." In dry valley ecosystems of Antarctica,this axiom can be extended to: "Where there has been and will be water, there is life."Stream communities in the dry valleys can withstand desiccation on an annual basis and also for longer periods-as much as decades or even centuries. These intact ecosystems,consistingprimarilyof cyanobacteria and eukaryotic algae, spring back to life with the returnof water.Soil organismsin the dry valleysalso have remarkablesurvivalcapabilities(Virginiaand Wall 1999), emerging from dormancywith the arrivalof water. Streamsin the dry valleyscarrymeltwaterfrom a glacier or ice-field source to the lakes on the valley floors and generallyflow for 4-10 weeksduring the summer,depending on climatic conditions. Many of these streamscontain abundant algal mats that are perennial in the sense that they arein a freeze-driedstateduringthe winter and begin growing again within minutes of becoming wetted by the first flow of the season. The algal species present in the streams are mainly filamentous cyanobacteria(approximately 20 species of the genera Phormidium,Oscillatoria, and Nostoc),two green algal species of the genus Prasiola, and numerous diatom taxa that are characteristicof soil habitats and polar regions. Algal abundancesare greatest in those streamsin which periglacialprocesses,actingover periods of perhapsa century,have produced a stable stone pavement in the streambed.This habitat results in a less turbulent flow regime and limits sediment scour from the streambed. Because dry valley glaciers advance and retreat over periods of centuriesand millenniaand streamnetworksin the dry valleys evolve through sediment deposition and transport,some of the currentlyinactive stream channels may receive flow again in the future. Insights into the process of algal persistence and reactivation will come from long-term experimentsthat study the effectsof reintroducing water flow to channels in which flow has not occurredfor decades or centuries. The present work of the McMurdo Dry Valleys LTER has led us to conclude that the legacy of past conditions constitutes a dominant influence on present-day ecosystem structureand function in the dry valleys (Moorhead et al. 1999). For example,Virginia and Wall (1999) have December1999 / Vol.49 No. 12 * BioScience 993 Articles found that soil nematodes are partly sustained by relict organic carbon from algae that grew during the high lake stands of 8000-10,000 years ago. Similarly,the growth of current algal populations in the lakes of the dry valleys is supported by diffusion of nutrients from relict nutrient pools in the deep bottom waters (Priscu et al. 1999). For the streamecosystems,abundantalgal mats are presentin channels that have stable stone pavements,which formed through freeze-thaw cycles occurring over long periods, possibly hundreds of years. We hypothesize that these stone pavements are an important ecological legacy permitting the successful"waitingfor water"strategy.Similarly,the biodiversityof algal species that can survive the harsh conditions in the streamsof the dry valleys may be stable for centuriesor more, representinga second important ecologicallegacy. Acknowledgments Researchreported in this article as part of the McMurdo Dry ValleysLTERis supportedby NSF grant no. OPP 92117733.We thank Dr. PaulBrooks,DurelleScott,EarlCassidy,MarthaCrawford,and four anonymous reviewersfor helpful comments on the manuscript. Referencescited AlgerAS. 1999.Diatoms of the McMurdoDry Valleys,Antarctica:A taxonomic appraisalincluding a detailed study of the genus Hantzschia. Master'sthesis.Universityof Michigan,Ann Arbor,MI. AlgerAS, McKnightDM, SpauldingSA, TateCM, Shupe GH, WelchKA, EdwardsR, AndrewsED, House HR. 1997. EcologicalProcessesin a Cold Desert Ecosystem:The Abundanceand Species Distributionof Algal Mats in GlacialMeltwaterStreamsin TaylorValley,Antarctica. Boulder (CO): Institute of Arctic and Alpine Research.Occasional Paperno. 51. Bomblies A. 1998. Climatic controls on streamflow generation from Antarcticglaciers.Master'sthesis.Universityof Colorado,Boulder,CO. Chinn TH. 1993.Physicalhydrologyof the dry valleylakes.Pages 1-51 in GreenWJ,FriedmannEI, eds. Physicaland BiogeochemicalProcesses in Antarctic Lakes.Antarctic ResearchSeries, Vol. 59. Washington (DC): AmericanGeophysicalUnion. Conovitz PA. 1999. Permafrostdynamicsand hyporheic zone storagein LakeFryxellBasin,McMurdoDry Valleys,Antarctica.Master'sthesis. ColoradoStateUniversity,FortCollins,CO. Conovitz PA, McKnightDM, MacDonaldLH, FountainAG, House HR. 1998.Hydrologicprocessesinfluencingstreamflowvariationin Fryxell Basin,Antarctica.Pages93-108 in PriscuJC,ed. EcosystemProcesses in a Polar Desert: The McMurdo Dry Valleys,Antarctica.Antarctic ResearchSeries, Vol. 72. Washington (DC): American Geophysical Union. FountainAG,et al. 1999.Physicalcontrolson the TaylorValleyecosystem, Antarctica.BioScience49: 961-971. Green WJ, Angle MP, Chave KE. 1988. The geochemistry of Antarctic streamsand their role in the evolution of four lakesin the McMurdo Dry Valleys.Geochimicaet CosmochimicaActa 52: 1265-1274. Hawes I, Howard-WilliamsC. 1998. Primary production processes in streams of the McMurdo Dry Valleys,Antarctica.Pages 129-140 in Priscu JC, ed. EcosystemProcessesin a Polar Desert:The McMurdo Dry Valleys,Antarctica.AntarcticResearchSeries,Vol. 72. Washington (DC): AmericanGeophysicalUnion. HawesI, Howard-WilliamsC,VincentWF.1992.Desiccationand recovery of Antarcticcyanobacterialmats.PolarBiology 12:587-594. Holmes RM, FisherSG, Grimm NB. 1994. Parafluvialnitrogen dynamics in a desertstreamecosystem.Journalof the North AmericanBentho- 994 BioScience o December1999 / Vol.49 No. 12 logical Society 13:468-478. House HR, McKnightDM, von GuerardP. 1995.The influenceof stream channel characteristicson stream flow and annual water budgets for lakes in Taylor Valley.Antarctic Journal of the United States 30: 284-287. Howard-WilliamsC, Vincent CL,BroadyPA,VincentWF. 1986.Antarctic stream ecosystems:Variabilityin environmentalpropertiesand algal community structure.InternationaleRevueder GesamtenHydrobiolgie 71: 511-544. Howard-WilliamsC, PriscuJC,VincentWF. 1989. Nitrogen dynamicsin two Antarcticstreams.Hydrobiologia172:51-61. Howard-WilliamsC, Hawes I, SchwarzA-M, Hall JA. 1998. Sourcesand sinks of nutrientsin a polar desertstream,the Onyx River,Antarctica. Pages 155-172 in Lyons WB, Howard-WilliamsC, Hawes I, eds. EcosystemProcessesin AntarcticIce-FreeLandscapes.Rotterdam(The Netherlands):A. A. Balkema. JonesAE,ShanklinJD. 1995.Continueddecline of total ozone over Hally, Antarctica,since 1985.Nature376:409-411. JonesJB,FisherSG, GrimmNB, 1995.Nitrificationin the hyporheiczone of a desert streamecosystem.Journalof the North AmericanBenthological Society 14:249-258. LyonsWB, Welch KA, Neumann K, ToxeyJK,McArthurR, Williams C, McKnight DM, Moorhead D. 1998a. Geochemicallinkages among glaciers,streamsand lakeswithin TaylorValley,Antarctica.Pages77-92 in PriscuJC,ed. EcosystemProcessesin a PolarDesert:The McMurdo Dry Valleys,Antarctica.AntarcticResearchSeries,Vol. 72. Washington (DC):AmericanGeophysicalUnion. LyonsWB, WelchKA,Nezat CA, McKnightDM, CrickK, ToxeyJK,Mastrine JA. 1998b.Chemicalweatheringrates and reactionsin the Lake Fryxell Basin, TaylorValley:Comparison to temperate river basins. Pages 147-154 in Lyons WB, Howard-WilliamsC, Hawes I, eds. EcosystemProcessesin AntarcticIce-FreeLandscapes.Rotterdam(The Netherlands):A. A. Balkema. McKnightDM, TateCM. 1997.CanadaStream:A glacialmeltwaterstream in TaylorValley,South VictoriaLand,Antarctica.Journalof the North AmericanBenthologicalSociety 16: 14-17. McKnightDM, AlgerA, TateCM, Shupe G, SpauldingS. 1998.Longitudinal patternsin algalabundanceand speciesdistributionin meltwater streams in TaylorValley,Southern Victoria Land, Antarctica.Pages 109-128 in PriscuJC,ed. EcosystemProcessesin a PolarDesert:The McMurdoDry Valleys,Antarctica.AntarcticResearchSeries,Vol. 72. Washington(DC):AmericanGeophysicalUnion. MoorheadDL,Doran PT,FountainAG, LyonsWB,McKnightDM, Priscu JC,VirginiaRA,WallDH. 1999.Ecologicallegacies:Impactson ecosystems of the McMurdoDry Valleys.BioScience49: 1009-1019. MulhollandPJ,MarzolfER,WebsterJR,Hart DR, HendricksSP.1997.Evidence that hyporheic zones increase heterotrophicmetabolism and phosphorus uptake in forest streams.Limnology and Oceanography 42: 443-451. Niyogi DK, Tate CM, McKnightDM, Duff JH, Alger AS. 1998. Species compositionand primaryproductionof algalcommunitiesin DryValley streamsin Antarctica:Examinationof the functionalrole of biodiversity.Pages171-179 in LyonsWB,Howard-WilliamsC, HawesI, eds. EcosystemProcessesin AntarcticIce-FreeLandscapes.Rotterdam(The Netherlands):A. A. Balkema. Potts M. 1994. Desiccation tolerance of prokaryotes.Microbiological Reviews58: 755-805. PriscuJC,Wolf CF,TakacsCD, FritsenCH, Laybourn-Parry J,RobertsEC, SattlerB, LyonsWB. 1999. Carbon transformationsin a perennially ice-coveredAntarcticlake.BioScience49: 997-1008. Runkel RL. 1998. One-dimensional transport with inflow and storage (OTIS):A solute transportmodel for streamsand rivers.Washington (DC): US Geological Survey.Water-ResourcesInvestigationsReport no. 98-4018. RunkelRL,McKnightDM, AndrewsEA. 1998.Analysisof transientstorage subjectto unsteadyflow:Diel flowvariationin an Antarcticstream. Journalof the North AmericanBenthologicalSociety 17: 143-154. SpauldingSA,StoermerEF.1997.Taxonomyand distributionof the genus Articles "Muelleria" Frenguelli.Diatom Research12:95-115. TriskaFJ,Duff JH,AvanzinoRJ.1993.The role of waterexchangebetween a streamchanneland its hyporheiczone in nitrogencyclingat the terrestrial-aquaticinterface.Hydrobiologia251: 167-184. VervierP,GibertJ,MarmonierP,Dole-OliverM-J. 1992.A perspectiveon the permeabilityof the surfacefreshwater-groundwater ecotone.Journal of the North AmericanBenthologicalSociety 11:93-102. VincentWF. 1988. MicrobialEcosystemsof Antarctica.New York:CambridgeUniversityPress. Vincent WF, Howard-WilliamsC. 1986. Antarctic stream ecosystems: Physiologicalecology of a blue-greenalgalepilithon. FreshwaterBiology 16:219-233. VincentWF,Howard-WilliamsC, BroadyPA. 1993a.Microbialcommunities and processesin flowing waters.Pages543-569 in FriedmannEI, ed. AntarcticMicrobiology.New York:Wiley-Liss. Vincent WF, Downes MT, CastenholzRW,Howard-WilliamsC. 1993b. Community structure and pigment organisation of cyanobacteriadominatedmicrobialmats in Antarctica.EuropeanJournalof Phycology 28: 213-231. Virginia RA, Wall DH. 1999. How soils structure communities in the Antarcticdry valleys.BioScience49: 973-983. von GuerardP, McKnightDM, Harnish RA, GartnerJW,AndrewsED. 1994. Streamflow,water-temperature,and specific-conductancedata for selected streamsdraining into Lake Fryxell,LowerTaylorValley, VictoriaLand,Antarctica,1990-92. Washington(DC): US Geological Survey.Open-FileReportno. 94-545. WebsterJR,MeyerJL.1997.Introduction:Streamorganicmatterbudgets. Journalof the North AmericanBenthologicalSociety 16:5-13. Zar JH. 1996. BiostatisticalAnalysis.Upper Saddle River (NJ): Prentice Hall. of Society 21st Quebec Scientists Wetland Annual City, August meeting Canada Qu6bec, 2000 6-12, ScheduledEvents: QuBbec 2000 Millennium Wetlands Event * PlenarySessions * andExhibits Workshops * StudentPresentations andAwards * FieldTrips * SocialActivities The SWS annualmeetingwillbe held in conjunctionwiththe annual meetings of The International Society of Ecologists Peat International the Society (IPS), and the (INTECOL), InternationalMire ConservationGroup (IMCG);and will be knownas theQuebec2000 WetlandMillenniumEvent. sws Informationabout the Quebec 2000 Wetland MillenniumEvent's venue, technical program, partners, cultural events, and your participation,can be viewed at the conference Web site: http://www/cqvb.qc.ca/wetland2000/or by contactingthe secretariateat (4 18) 657-3853 orby e-mail: cqvb @cqvb.qc.ca. December1999 / Vol.49 No. 12 * BioScience 995
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz