Country Ranking: Social Capital Achievement By Ronald Lattin & Stephen Young Under the Principles for Business proposed by the Caux Round Table, economic development does not occur within its own financial vacuum chamber isolated from society and only autonomously self-starting and selfsustaining. Wealth creation is not an isolate, but rather draws upon pre-existing social and cultural conditions for its health and energy. Strong and vibrant markets arise only in facilitating environments. Markets are organic processes, linked to participants through multiple inter-connections. If we seek to benefit from robust markets as a goad to economic development, we must first put in place a fertilized bed in which to better culture the seeds of productive enterprise. But as wealth is created and markets thrive to expand the number and capacity of participants in commerce and enterprise, society in turn benefits. Culture changes; new professions and social classes emerge; educational achievement and conditions of public health advance; political institutions shift to incorporate the new dynamics. The growing inter-action between the economy and its surrounding culture and institutional arrangements accumulates in the formation of social capital. Countries with high levels of social capital formation are more livable, providing for a higher quality of life for individuals and their families; such countries attract immigrants from societies with low levels of social capital. The quality of social capital accumulation tracks the moral quality noted in the Second Vatican Ecumenical Council pastoral Constitution, Gaudium et Spes: the common good is widely understood to be the sum of those conditions of social life which enable groups and individuals to achieve their fulfillment more completely and readily. (p. 26) Accordingly, societies with low levels of social capital experience outflows of human capital as well as of liquid economic wealth. Fulfillment of life goals in these societies is more fitful and transient as a result. Social capital achievement, therefore, is an aggregate of three subsystems: 1) economic variables, 2) social/cultural variables, and 3) legal and political institutions. Since there are no direct measurements of social capital, we have created a Social Capital Achievement (SCA) score for 180 countries as an approximation of social capital accumulation. The SCA is computed by first ranking each country on 13 different criteria. A country’s rank in each category is converted into a percentile reflecting its achievements vis-à-vis other countries. An average ranking for each country is then calculated of the country’s 13 different percentile rankings and the SCA is a ranking of the overall average. The economic components for the rankings embrace GDP per capita and sovereign credit ratings. Relevant cultural variables and social richness are modeled by indices of corruption, economic freedom, political freedom, civil liberties and human development. Legal and political institutions can be assessed through measures of, the rule of law, 12-core best practice standards for management of financial institutions and other governance indicators. The Path Towards Progress As measured by the various country indices available, a country’s accumulated social capital is caught in a static moment of assessment. The time scale is not dynamic, but frozen in time. The indices, therefore, are not necessarily predictive of future social capital formation. Under equilibrium conditions, we hypothesize that social/cultural patterns heavily influence legal and political institutions, which in turn structure incentives, risk/return utility functions, and pricing conditions for economic activity. Economic activity, with its allocation of risks and returns, in turn tends to sustain those who embody and articulate the dominant social and cultural patterns of the society. 2 From this point of view, economic development will occur most robustly under favorable legal and political conditions, which, in turn, will respond to cultural and value-sensitive imperatives, influenced in their turn by changing economic interests and incentives. Thus it is possible to trigger a virtuous cycle of cultural initiative, then political accommodation to the new cultural guidelines, then economic progress in response to new opportunities, and, then to reinforcement of the facilitating cultural norms. This is the formula for growth advocated by Adam Smith in his Inquiry into the Causes of the Wealth of Nations and vindicated much more recently by David Landes in his The Wealth and Poverty of Nations. Measuring separately the economic, the social/cultural, and the legal/political components of social capital permits a preliminary assessment to be made of what should be done in a given country to trigger a virtuous cycle of growth and accumulation of social capital. Changes can be authored in the legal/political sub-system, but, to do so, something first must happen in the cultural/social sub-system as a triggering break with the status quo. Then, resulting activity in the economic sub-system will evidence the effectiveness, or not, of the legal/political reforms undertaken to date. What often hinders change in the cultural/social sub-system are self-interested elites who, one, benefit economically from the current equilibrium state of the society, and, two, whose ideas have been adjusted to legitimate the institutions facilitating their preferential treatment under the status quo. Change agents, therefore, must arise either out of dissatisfaction within the elite under current conditions or from new conditions that give members of the elite new but attractive intellectual options with which to think about political and legal institutions and habits. Social Capital Achievement Rankings The following indexes were used to create each country’s Social Capital Achievement ranking. Countries that had 8 or fewer of the 13 indicators were not included in the overall ranking but are listed separately. More detailed information on these 13 indexes can be found under the Sources and Notes section on page 6. The 13 basic indexes are: PPP - Gross Domestic Product Per Capita in Purchasing Power Parity HD - United Nation Development Program’s Human Development Index FREE - Freedom House’s Freedom Index EF – Fraser Institute’s Economic Freedom of the World ESF - eStandards Forum's Compliance Summary Index S & P - Standard & Poor’s Foreign Currency Issuer Ratings Moody's - Moody’s Foreign Currency Issuer Ratings VA - World Bank Governance Indicator - Voice and Accountability GE - World Bank Governance Indicator - Government Effectiveness RQ - World Bank Governance Indicator - Regulatory Quality RL - World Bank Governance Indicator - Rule of Law CC - World Bank Governance Indicator - Control of Corruption CP - Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index # - Number of Indices Used in Rakings Rank 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 41 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 Social Capital Achievement Countries Netherlands Finland Sweden Australia United Kingdom Switzerland Canada Iceland United States Norway Luxembourg Ireland New Zealand Austria Denmark Germany Belgium France Spain Singapore Japan Portugal Chile Italy Estonia Malta Hong Kong, China (SAR) Hungary Cyprus Bahamas Barbados Slovenia Greece Czech Republic Israel Taiwan Korea, Rep. of Slovakia Costa Rica Mauritius Poland Lithuania Latvia Kuwait Botswana Bahrain United Arab Emirates Seychelles Qatar Trinidad and Tobago Uruguay Oman Malaysia South Africa Mexico Panama Croatia Bulgaria Grenada Thailand Namibia Belize Sri Lanka Brazil Jamaica Peru Guyana Suriname Jordan Tunisia Romania El Salvador Fiji Saudi Arabia Mongolia Macedonia, TFYR Philippines SCA 0.9698 0.9660 0.9623 0.9609 0.9565 0.9549 0.9540 0.9508 0.9469 0.9444 0.9436 0.9384 0.9351 0.9323 0.9321 0.9291 0.8979 0.8865 0.8807 0.8669 0.8466 0.8405 0.8143 0.8115 0.8002 0.7965 0.7943 0.7925 0.7855 0.7711 0.7621 0.7609 0.7600 0.7487 0.7436 0.7346 0.7328 0.7052 0.7043 0.7043 0.6999 0.6889 0.6881 0.6715 0.6697 0.6604 0.6552 0.6481 0.6431 0.6305 0.6187 0.6153 0.6101 0.5977 0.5976 0.5929 0.5861 0.5835 0.5722 0.5674 0.5494 0.5370 0.5055 0.5009 0.5008 0.4990 0.4977 0.4959 0.4944 0.4942 0.4921 0.4915 0.4866 0.4807 0.4805 0.4698 0.4641 # 13 13 13 13 12 13 13 12 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 12 13 13 12 11 12 13 13 13 13 11 13 13 12 11 13 13 13 12 12 12 12 9 11 12 13 12 13 13 13 12 13 13 9 13 10 11 11 13 12 13 9 11 13 13 13 12 10 12 10 10 13 PPP 0.9714 0.9200 0.9829 0.9771 0.9257 0.9429 0.9543 0.9886 0.9600 0.9943 0.9143 0.9314 0.8857 0.9086 0.9371 0.8971 0.9657 0.9029 0.8914 0.8400 0.9486 0.8686 0.7543 0.8800 0.7657 0.8114 0.8514 0.7829 0.8571 0.7200 0.8457 0.8343 0.8629 0.8171 0.8743 HD 0.9718 0.9266 0.9887 0.9831 0.9322 0.9379 0.9774 0.9605 0.9548 0.9944 0.9153 0.9435 0.8983 0.9209 0.9040 0.8927 0.9661 0.9096 0.8870 0.8588 0.9492 0.8531 0.7571 0.8814 0.7966 0.8249 0.8701 0.7853 0.8305 0.7119 0.8362 0.8475 0.8644 0.8192 0.8757 0.8286 0.7771 0.7600 0.6457 0.8000 0.7429 0.7143 0.7371 0.2857 0.7886 0.7257 0.7943 0.7486 0.6914 0.7714 0.5486 0.6686 0.3657 0.6857 0.6629 0.7314 0.6743 0.4686 0.5771 0.2914 0.6171 0.4343 0.6286 0.5543 0.5314 0.4743 0.5600 0.4857 0.4800 0.5886 0.4000 0.5371 0.5829 0.3314 0.6571 0.5143 0.8418 0.7627 0.7458 0.6384 0.7910 0.7684 0.7175 0.7514 0.2768 0.7740 0.7232 0.8023 0.7345 0.6949 0.7401 0.5819 0.6667 0.3277 0.7006 0.6554 0.7288 0.6836 0.4746 0.5706 0.2881 0.4407 0.4576 0.5932 0.5537 0.5198 0.4124 0.6215 0.4915 0.4802 0.6102 0.4181 0.5424 0.5650 0.3390 0.6610 0.5311 FREE 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.3389 0.7889 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.4611 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.7889 0.9944 0.7111 0.7889 0.7889 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.9944 0.7111 0.7889 0.3389 0.7111 0.2889 0.1278 0.5556 0.2556 0.5556 0.9944 0.2556 0.4000 0.7889 0.7111 0.7889 0.7111 0.7889 0.7889 0.6222 0.6222 0.7889 0.5556 0.6222 0.6222 0.6222 0.7111 0.7889 0.3389 0.2556 0.6222 0.6222 0.4611 0.0333 0.7111 0.5556 0.6222 EF 0.9106 0.9106 0.8211 0.9431 0.9756 0.9756 0.9431 0.8862 0.9756 0.7073 0.9268 0.9268 0.9756 0.8699 0.8862 0.8211 0.8537 0.6423 0.7480 0.9837 0.7073 0.7805 0.8211 0.7073 0.9106 0.6423 0.9919 0.8211 0.5854 0.4472 0.2358 0.3984 0.6667 0.6667 0.5854 0.8211 0.7480 0.5854 0.7480 0.7805 0.5041 0.6423 0.7073 0.8537 0.8537 0.7480 0.8699 0.7480 0.6423 0.8537 0.5285 0.6423 0.5285 0.7805 0.3252 0.3659 ESF 0.9759 0.8795 0.9398 0.9639 0.9518 0.7590 0.9036 0.9880 0.9036 0.7831 0.9398 0.7590 0.8675 0.5301 0.9398 0.8434 0.8313 0.7108 0.7229 0.8313 0.6627 0.7711 0.8072 0.7952 0.6867 0.8675 0.4940 0.7108 0.6867 0.5301 0.2048 0.7349 0.6506 0.6024 0.6024 0.5783 0.5400 0.6400 0.6400 0.7400 0.7100 0.6400 0.3012 0.2289 0.4096 0.5783 0.6386 0.5542 0.6265 0.5935 0.5041 0.4472 0.3659 0.3984 0.6667 0.6423 0.5041 0.3494 0.7073 0.4472 0.1626 0.7805 0.3659 0.1446 0.3133 0.6145 0.7400 0.5400 0.1800 0.5400 0.6400 0.4800 0.4800 0.3700 0.4800 0.4400 0.0200 0.5400 Moody's 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.7895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.9895 0.7789 0.5263 0.7789 0.7368 0.5895 0.7368 0.7368 0.6737 0.5895 0.4737 0.7579 0.7368 0.7368 0.6737 0.7579 0.5895 0.6737 0.3579 0.4737 0.6737 0.5895 0.6737 0.6737 0.6737 0.5263 0.7368 0.5895 0.4211 0.0947 0.4737 0.5895 0.5263 0.5263 0.3579 0.4211 0.3579 0.5263 0.0900 0.3855 0.3494 0.4940 0.2530 0.5854 S&P 0.9900 0.9900 0.9900 0.9900 0.9900 0.9900 0.9900 0.7900 0.9900 0.9900 0.9900 0.9900 0.8200 0.9900 0.9900 0.9900 0.8200 0.9900 0.9900 0.9900 0.7900 0.8000 0.7100 0.7900 0.7100 0.7100 0.7400 0.6400 0.7100 0.6400 0.5400 0.7900 0.7100 0.6400 0.6400 0.7900 0.6400 0.6400 0.3700 0.5060 0.3000 0.1800 0.3700 0.2421 0.2421 0.2526 0.0900 0.3700 0.4800 0.4100 0.4100 0.2421 0.2947 0.4737 0.3579 0.4211 0.2947 0.4737 0.7100 0.1800 0.3700 0.3000 0.2421 VA 0.9800 0.9950 0.9900 0.9440 0.9390 0.9750 0.9490 0.9650 0.9090 0.9850 0.9290 0.9190 0.9700 0.8990 1.0000 0.9550 0.9340 0.8840 0.8790 0.6570 0.7930 0.8940 0.8430 0.8380 0.8030 0.8890 0.5350 0.8540 0.7730 0.8690 0.9140 0.8280 0.8130 0.7470 0.6720 0.7420 0.6770 0.7630 0.8480 0.7170 0.8330 0.7370 0.7530 0.4140 0.7120 0.2470 0.3590 0.5610 0.3280 0.6620 0.7780 0.3130 0.4240 0.7070 0.5960 0.6460 0.6360 0.6670 0.7020 0.5710 0.5910 0.7220 0.4800 0.5810 0.6520 0.5760 0.6920 0.5860 0.3840 0.2270 0.6110 0.5150 0.4850 0.0910 0.6310 0.4190 0.5400 GE 0.9900 0.9740 0.9380 0.9280 0.9790 0.9950 0.9480 0.9640 0.9120 0.9330 0.9850 0.8970 0.9590 0.9230 0.9690 0.9180 0.9430 0.9070 0.8920 1.0000 0.8450 0.8400 0.8660 0.8040 0.7470 0.8560 0.8870 0.7420 0.8300 0.8810 0.8710 0.7680 0.7630 0.7370 0.8350 0.8250 0.7940 0.6750 0.6650 0.6960 0.7110 0.7060 0.7220 0.6240 0.7990 0.7530 0.7890 0.5880 0.7320 0.6800 0.6860 0.7270 0.8090 0.6910 0.6190 0.5360 0.6390 0.5620 0.6700 0.6490 0.6290 0.5520 0.5980 0.5000 0.5460 0.3870 0.4740 0.5310 0.6600 0.7160 0.4640 0.3560 0.6030 0.5820 0.5150 0.4480 0.5570 RQ 0.9900 1.0000 0.9690 0.9480 0.9790 0.9330 0.9380 0.9230 0.9120 0.9180 0.9850 0.9430 0.9640 0.9540 0.9740 0.9280 0.8710 0.8560 0.8760 0.9950 0.7890 0.8970 0.9020 0.8350 0.8660 0.8140 0.9070 0.8400 0.8510 0.8610 0.8300 0.7530 0.8250 0.8200 0.7990 0.8090 0.7630 0.7320 0.7270 0.6650 0.7110 0.7940 0.7580 0.6440 0.7470 0.7780 0.7840 0.4640 0.6190 0.7060 0.6700 0.7010 0.6860 0.6910 0.6800 0.6750 0.6240 0.6960 0.6600 0.6550 0.6390 0.5980 0.5880 0.6340 0.6490 0.6290 0.4070 0.2780 0.5820 0.5360 0.5570 0.5620 0.5100 0.5720 0.4900 0.5150 0.5770 RL 0.9480 0.9850 0.9690 0.9540 0.9430 1.0000 0.9380 0.9950 0.9180 0.9740 0.9900 0.9230 0.9640 0.9590 0.9790 0.9280 0.8970 0.8760 0.8450 0.9330 0.8870 0.8610 0.8710 0.7580 0.7470 0.8300 0.8660 0.7890 0.7680 0.8810 0.8920 0.8350 0.7420 0.7320 0.8140 0.8090 0.7780 0.6550 0.7220 0.7840 0.7060 0.6800 0.6750 0.7530 0.7270 0.7940 0.8040 0.6860 0.7730 0.6440 0.6910 0.7630 0.6960 0.5980 0.5210 0.5570 0.5880 0.5670 0.6190 0.6240 0.6700 0.5620 0.6080 0.5000 0.4590 0.4070 0.4230 0.4690 0.6290 0.6130 0.5410 0.3970 0.4540 0.6650 0.6490 0.4430 0.3810 CC 0.9640 1.0000 0.9790 0.9380 0.9430 0.9690 0.9590 0.9740 0.9230 0.9480 0.9540 0.9180 0.9900 0.9330 0.9850 0.9280 0.9120 0.8920 0.8970 0.9950 0.8510 0.8810 0.9070 0.7630 0.7420 0.7680 0.9020 0.7370 0.7990 0.8870 0.8560 0.8040 0.7320 0.6860 0.8350 0.7730 0.6650 0.6490 0.7940 0.7220 0.6910 0.6440 0.6080 0.8300 0.7530 0.8200 0.8400 0.7110 0.8140 0.5720 0.7580 0.8250 0.6800 0.6750 0.5210 0.5100 0.6390 0.5260 0.7470 0.5360 0.6290 0.5000 0.5460 0.5670 0.3920 0.5150 0.3810 0.6240 0.5930 0.6700 0.4540 0.3660 0.6130 0.7270 0.5410 0.2940 0.3760 CP 0.9315 0.9932 0.9589 0.9384 0.9247 0.9521 0.9178 0.9795 0.8836 0.9452 0.9110 0.8836 0.9863 0.9110 0.9795 0.8973 0.8836 0.8493 0.8493 0.9658 0.8356 0.8151 0.8630 0.7123 0.7877 0.8288 0.8904 0.7123 0.7534 0.8562 0.7877 0.6644 0.6507 0.8219 0.7603 0.6781 0.6096 0.7192 0.6301 0.5411 0.6986 0.6096 0.6986 0.7877 0.7671 0.8014 0.6712 0.7397 0.6507 0.8082 0.8014 0.7329 0.6986 0.5616 0.5753 0.5411 0.6301 0.5616 0.6301 0.5890 0.5411 0.5959 0.4932 0.5411 0.6644 0.7466 0.7329 0.4041 0.6507 0.5137 0.4178 0.3356 0.3014 4 Rank 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 Countries India Ghana Turkey Armenia Morocco Colombia China Senegal Dominican Republic Egypt Argentina Albania Russian Federation Madagascar Gabon Bosnia and Herzegovina Nicaragua Lebanon Cuba Honduras Benin Moldova, Rep. of Guatemala Kazakhstan Mali Bolivia Nepal Uganda Ukraine Papua New Guinea Burkina Faso Tanzania, U. Rep. of Iran, Islamic Rep. of Georgia Venezuela Ecuador Indonesia Belarus Zambia Viet Nam Malawi Algeria Kyrgyzstan Cambodia Syrian Arab Republic Mozambique Gambia Occupied Palestinian Territories Libyan Arab Jamahiriya Paraguay Kenya Azerbaijan Pakistan Eritrea Bangladesh Niger Yemen Ethiopia Togo Tajikistan Rwanda Uzbekistan Guinea-Bissau Congo Nigeria Côte d'Ivoire Turkmenistan Sierra Leone Chad Cameroon Central African Republic Sudan Zimbabwe Haiti Burundi Angola Myanmar Congo, Dem. Rep. of the SCA 0.4531 0.4370 0.4313 0.4265 0.4116 0.4107 0.4016 0.3990 0.3974 0.3880 0.3872 0.3869 0.3865 0.3832 0.3680 0.3548 0.3544 0.3477 0.3415 0.3380 0.3359 0.3293 0.3259 0.3241 0.3223 0.3202 0.3200 0.3184 0.3166 0.2943 0.2938 0.2909 0.2890 0.2877 0.2867 0.2864 0.2855 0.2828 0.2792 0.2784 0.2783 0.2730 0.2726 0.2718 0.2677 0.2665 0.2651 0.2608 0.2573 0.2520 0.2409 0.2408 0.2374 0.2358 0.2172 0.2140 0.2119 0.2114 0.2036 0.1767 0.1713 0.1702 0.1699 0.1676 0.1553 0.1543 0.1522 0.1494 0.1457 0.1388 0.1339 0.1150 0.1105 0.1092 0.0938 0.0926 0.0721 0.0416 # 13 12 13 9 13 13 13 11 13 13 13 10 13 11 10 10 11 12 10 12 11 10 13 12 11 13 10 10 13 12 9 11 11 9 13 13 13 9 10 12 10 11 9 9 11 10 9 9 9 12 11 9 13 9 11 10 9 9 9 9 9 10 9 10 11 11 10 10 10 11 9 9 10 10 9 9 10 10 PPP 0.2743 0.2629 0.4514 0.4286 0.2800 0.6343 0.4057 0.1086 0.4629 0.3143 0.8057 0.4571 0.6400 0.1486 0.3257 0.6229 0.3086 0.5257 0.7029 0.3429 0.0914 0.3829 0.3200 0.5657 0.0171 0.3486 0.1829 0.1600 0.5714 0.2457 0.0114 0.0857 0.3943 0.4971 0.6057 0.4457 0.3600 0.6971 0.0686 0.3771 0.0743 0.3886 0.4171 0.2571 0.3714 0.0286 0.1371 0.4400 0.6514 0.5200 0.1657 0.4914 0.1771 0.1143 0.2057 0.0057 0.1543 0.0343 0.1943 0.3543 0.0971 0.4229 0.0514 0.2000 0.1314 0.0800 0.5029 0.0000 0.0571 0.1886 0.0400 0.2114 0.1714 0.1429 0.0229 0.0629 0.2514 0.0457 HD 0.2825 0.2599 0.5028 0.5367 0.2938 0.5876 0.4689 0.1130 0.4463 0.3220 0.8079 0.6328 0.6780 0.1525 0.3107 0.6271 0.3333 0.5480 0.7062 0.3503 0.0904 0.3616 0.3164 0.5593 0.0169 0.3559 0.2090 0.1751 0.6045 0.2486 0.0113 0.0847 0.4294 0.4520 0.6158 0.4350 0.3729 0.6497 0.0734 0.3672 0.0678 0.3898 0.3785 0.2655 0.4011 0.0339 0.1243 0.4237 0.6723 0.4972 0.1638 0.4859 0.1977 0.1186 0.2203 0.0056 0.1582 0.0395 0.1921 0.3446 0.1017 0.3955 0.0282 0.1864 0.1469 0.0791 0.5141 0.0000 0.0565 0.2034 0.0452 0.2147 0.1695 0.1356 0.0226 0.0621 0.2542 0.0508 FREE 0.6222 0.7111 0.5556 0.3389 0.3389 0.4000 0.0833 0.6222 0.7111 0.2556 0.7111 0.5556 0.2556 0.5556 0.3389 0.4611 0.5556 0.2556 0.0333 0.5556 0.7111 0.4611 0.4000 0.2556 0.7111 0.5556 0.2889 0.3389 0.4611 0.5556 0.3389 0.4611 0.1278 0.4611 0.4611 0.5556 0.4611 0.0833 0.4000 0.0833 0.4000 0.2556 0.2556 0.2556 0.0333 0.4611 0.4000 0.1278 0.0333 0.5556 0.5556 0.2556 0.2556 0.0833 0.4000 0.5556 0.2889 0.2889 0.2556 0.2556 0.2556 0.0833 0.4000 0.3389 0.4000 0.1278 0.0333 0.4611 0.2556 0.1278 0.2556 0.0333 0.0833 0.0833 0.2889 0.2556 0.0333 0.1278 EF 0.4472 0.4472 0.1870 ESF 0.3976 0.2410 0.4699 S&P 0.4100 0.2500 0.3000 Moody's 0.4211 0.3252 0.1301 0.2683 0.3008 0.5854 0.3984 0.3008 0.2683 0.0732 0.1870 0.0894 0.1687 0.3855 0.1928 0.3700 0.3700 0.5400 0.2500 0.0200 0.4100 0.0200 0.3579 0.2947 0.6737 0.4400 0.1800 0.4211 0.0964 0.3855 0.4217 0.4458 0.5041 0.1687 0.5041 0.1626 0.2651 0.5041 0.2169 0.5542 0.2358 0.5285 0.2358 0.5854 0.1301 0.2358 0.0900 0.2421 0.0947 0.3579 0.0526 0.0947 0.0526 0.1579 0.0526 0.1579 0.2500 0.0964 0.4458 0.3000 0.4400 0.1800 0.0900 0.2500 0.1800 0.1800 0.0526 0.2947 0.4211 0.0947 0.2421 0.2421 0.4472 0.3659 0.1205 0.0241 0.0407 0.2358 0.3008 0.2892 0.2892 0.4699 0.1800 0.0900 0.2500 0.1579 0.0526 0.1579 0.0482 0.3000 0.2421 0.5854 0.1870 0.0407 0.0602 0.2358 0.1626 0.0000 0.1800 0.3984 0.5041 0.0723 0.2683 0.3253 0.3252 0.1301 0.1084 0.0900 0.0526 0.2500 0.1579 0.0894 0.1301 0.1325 0.0488 0.0650 0.2683 0.3008 0.1807 0.0120 0.1579 0.0976 0.1626 0.0482 0.0244 0.0081 0.3659 0.0650 0.0000 0.0163 0.0300 VA 0.6060 0.5050 0.3640 0.3690 0.4040 0.3080 0.1010 0.5300 0.5660 0.2220 0.5250 0.4950 0.3380 0.4900 0.3740 0.4390 0.5200 0.3180 0.0300 0.4600 0.5100 0.4090 0.3540 0.1770 0.5510 0.5000 0.3330 0.2420 0.2780 0.4650 0.4290 0.3790 0.1820 0.3990 0.3890 0.4750 0.3480 0.0760 0.3940 0.1060 0.2980 0.2020 0.1970 0.3030 0.0560 0.4340 0.1870 0.1720 0.0450 0.3230 0.2830 0.1920 0.1570 0.0100 0.2930 0.4490 0.2170 0.1460 0.1210 0.2120 0.0860 0.0510 0.2580 0.1620 0.2630 0.1160 0.0250 0.2880 0.2070 0.1670 0.2370 0.0400 0.0710 0.1520 0.1410 0.0960 0.0150 0.0200 GE 0.5410 0.5930 0.5050 0.4120 0.6130 0.4540 0.6340 0.5210 0.4180 0.4690 0.3760 0.3810 0.4430 0.4590 0.3970 0.1490 0.1750 0.4330 0.4900 0.2730 0.3140 0.3040 0.3200 0.2160 0.1910 0.3450 0.3660 0.4380 0.2630 0.2370 0.2780 0.3610 0.3920 0.2530 0.1030 0.1340 0.3400 0.1290 0.1440 0.4850 0.2840 0.3250 0.2060 0.3350 0.3300 0.4280 0.2110 0.1240 0.1800 0.0720 0.1860 0.1390 0.3710 0.4070 0.3510 0.2320 0.1700 0.1600 0.0930 0.0880 0.2010 0.1190 0.0620 0.0820 0.1080 0.1550 0.0360 0.0260 0.2580 0.3090 0.0460 0.1130 0.2220 0.0210 0.0410 0.0980 0.0770 0.0150 RQ 0.4380 0.4480 0.5670 0.5930 0.5520 0.5310 0.4020 0.4690 0.5000 0.3810 0.1960 0.4120 0.4430 0.4540 0.4850 0.1800 0.3970 0.3710 0.1080 0.4180 0.3200 0.4950 0.5210 0.2420 0.3610 0.5050 0.3560 0.5410 0.2840 0.3870 0.4790 0.3350 0.0820 0.2160 0.3450 0.3040 0.2630 0.0360 0.2990 0.2530 0.4280 0.3400 0.3760 0.3920 0.1650 0.2680 0.3300 0.1440 0.0460 0.3140 0.3510 0.2220 0.2270 0.1240 0.1390 0.2580 0.2890 0.1550 0.2730 0.0770 0.1750 0.0570 0.1910 0.1600 0.1130 0.4230 0.0100 0.0720 0.1340 0.1860 0.2320 0.1190 0.0410 0.1700 0.0980 0.0670 0.0210 0.0310 RL 0.5720 0.5360 0.5520 0.4180 0.5930 0.2680 0.5150 0.5260 0.4280 0.5770 0.2780 0.1750 0.2530 0.5310 0.5050 0.1910 0.3200 0.5100 0.1650 0.2370 0.4330 0.3920 0.2160 0.1860 0.3450 0.3250 0.3760 0.2110 0.2470 0.2270 0.3400 0.3870 0.3350 0.0980 0.1340 0.3300 0.2320 0.1130 0.3560 0.4480 0.4640 0.3510 0.2220 0.2010 0.4380 0.2990 0.3710 0.4950 0.1800 0.1190 0.1390 0.2420 0.2840 0.3610 0.2630 0.2580 0.0770 0.4120 0.2890 0.0670 0.1440 0.1030 0.1550 0.0820 0.0520 0.0880 0.1080 0.0720 0.1700 0.0620 0.1960 0.0460 0.0570 0.0100 0.0360 0.0310 0.0210 0.0050 CC 0.4950 0.4280 0.4380 0.3040 0.5820 0.3870 0.4230 0.5310 0.4330 0.4790 0.2780 0.2320 0.2110 0.6190 0.3610 0.3450 0.3970 0.4590 0.5520 0.2730 0.3400 0.2160 0.3090 0.1080 0.4640 0.2530 0.4690 0.1910 0.1750 0.2060 0.5770 0.1550 0.4430 0.1240 0.1860 0.1440 0.0670 0.2680 0.1700 0.3300 0.1960 0.3140 0.2370 0.2010 0.4740 0.1490 0.2420 0.1600 0.2470 0.0410 0.1130 0.0980 0.2990 0.6030 0.0770 0.0820 0.3200 0.4480 0.3250 0.1030 0.3510 0.1190 0.3350 0.1800 0.0310 0.2270 0.0460 0.2580 0.1290 0.0880 0.1290 0.0930 0.0620 0.0050 0.1290 0.0720 0.0210 0.0150 CP 0.3836 0.5616 0.4726 0.4384 0.4726 0.5890 0.5137 0.4178 0.4041 0.4726 0.2603 0.2603 0.3836 0.4384 0.4932 0.4384 0.3356 0.3356 0.5753 0.2192 0.4726 0.2192 0.1644 0.1644 0.4726 0.1644 0.3836 0.3014 0.1644 0.3014 0.3836 0.4041 0.0890 0.2192 0.2329 0.0890 0.4932 0.3014 0.3014 0.3836 0.3356 0.1644 0.5137 0.3836 0.3836 0.2603 0.2603 0.0411 0.1164 0.0411 0.1164 0.3014 0.0068 0.1644 0.2329 0.2192 0.0890 0.2192 0.2192 0.0137 0.0890 0.0890 0.2192 0.0274 0.1164 0.1644 0.2192 0.0068 0.0890 0.0274 0.0890 5 Countries Dominica Antigua and Barbuda Saint Kitts and Nevis Saint Lucia Saint Vincent and the Grenadines Samoa (Western) Brunei Darussalam Cape Verde Maldives Sao Tome and Principe Bhutan Lesotho Vanuatu Tonga Mauritania Serbia and Montenegro Solomon Islands Swaziland Timor-Leste Comoros Djibouti Guinea Equatorial Guinea Lao People's Dem. Rep. Iraq SCA 0.7120 0.7050 0.6950 0.6600 # 8 8 8 8 PPP 0.6114 0.6800 0.7086 0.5943 HD 0.4633 0.6893 0.7797 0.5989 FREE 0.9944 0.7111 0.7889 0.7889 0.6507 0.6394 0.6380 0.5845 0.5376 0.4480 0.4214 0.4209 0.4199 0.3879 0.3712 0.3296 0.3049 0.2962 0.2920 0.2555 0.2324 0.2084 0.1360 0.1349 0.0406 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 7 8 8 8 8 7 8 8 8 8 8 7 0.5429 0.6000 0.8229 0.4114 0.5086 0.3029 0.2229 0.2171 0.2686 0.5085 0.5763 0.8136 0.4068 0.5254 0.3051 0.2429 0.1808 0.2712 0.6441 0.1412 0.7889 0.7111 0.2556 0.9944 0.2556 0.7111 0.2556 0.6222 0.7111 0.4000 0.2556 0.6222 0.5556 0.1278 0.5556 0.4000 0.2889 0.2556 0.0833 0.0833 0.1278 0.1200 0.2971 0.2400 0.2343 0.1257 0.1029 0.3371 0.2286 0.2994 0.2260 0.1073 0.2316 0.1299 0.0960 0.3842 0.2373 EF ESF S&P 0.2500 Moody's VA 0.8080 0.5450 0.7830 0.7980 GE 0.6550 0.7010 0.5670 0.5670 RQ 0.7370 0.7160 0.6030 0.6030 RL 0.7160 0.8200 0.6340 0.6340 CC 0.7110 0.7780 0.6960 0.6960 0.7880 0.6970 0.2320 0.6160 0.2530 0.6410 0.1360 0.4550 0.7320 0.4700 0.2730 0.4440 0.6010 0.1310 0.5560 0.3430 0.2680 0.1260 0.0810 0.0350 0.0050 0.5670 0.6440 0.8200 0.5100 0.7580 0.2890 0.8140 0.4950 0.2940 0.2940 0.5260 0.2680 0.0670 0.4020 0.2420 0.1960 0.1650 0.2470 0.0570 0.2270 0.0100 0.6030 0.5260 0.8040 0.4740 0.7420 0.4330 0.3090 0.3660 0.2010 0.2010 0.5460 0.2940 0.0930 0.4590 0.0880 0.1490 0.2320 0.2110 0.0520 0.1030 0.0000 0.7110 0.7990 0.7010 0.6030 0.6600 0.4020 0.5820 0.5460 0.4790 0.3040 0.4740 0.1600 0.3040 0.2940 0.1240 0.2060 0.3660 0.2730 0.0930 0.1290 0.0150 0.6960 0.5620 0.6550 0.6600 0.5980 0.5000 0.8090 0.4850 0.4020 0.4020 0.6340 0.2630 0.2220 0.4900 0.3710 0.2840 0.2840 0.3560 0.0000 0.0360 0.0100 CP 0.3356 0.1164 Sources and Notes for the Social Capital Achievement Ratings PPP - Gross Domestic Product Per Capita in Purchasing Power Parity - World Bank - World Development Indicators 2003 GDP per capita PPP involves the use of standardized international dollar price weights, which are applied to the quantities of final goods and services produced in a given economy. HD - United Nation Development Program’s Human Development Index 2002 Measures a country’s achievements in three aspects of human development: longevity, knowledge, and standard of living. FREE - Freedom House’s Freedom Index 2005 An evaluation of political rights and civil liberties by a standard emphasizing the importance of democracy and freedom. EF – Fraser Institute’s Economic Freedom of the World 2004 Measures the degree of economic freedom present in five major areas: size of government: expenditures, taxes and enterprises; legal structure and security of property rights; sound money; freedom to trade with foreigners; and regulations of credit, labor and business. ESF - eStandards Forum's Compliance Summary Index (March 2005) Provides a snapshot of a country's overall compliance with the twelve internationally recognized standards of best practices in key policy areas. S & P - Standard & Poor’s Foreign Currency Issuer Ratings & Moody's - Moody’s Foreign Currency Issuer Ratings (March 2005) Country risk considerations are a standard part of an analysis for credit ratings on any issuer or issue. Currency of repayment is a key factor in this analysis. An issuer's capacity to repay foreign currency obligations may be lower than its capacity to repay obligations in its local currency. These sovereign risk considerations are incorporated in the debt ratings assigned to specific issues. Foreign currency issuer ratings are also distinguished from local currency issuer ratings to identify those instances where sovereign risks make them different for the same issuer. World Bank Governance Indicators 2002: VA - Voice and Accountability, GE - Government Effectiveness, RQ - Regulatory Quality, RL - Rule of Law, CC - Control of Corruption These indicators attempt to capture how governments are selected, monitored, and replaced; a government’s capacity to formulate and implement sound policies; and the respect of citizens and the state for the institutions that govern them. CP - Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index 2004 Ranks countries in terms of the degree to which corruption is perceived to exist among public officials and politicians.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz