NELLCO
NELLCO Legal Scholarship Repository
New York University Public Law and Legal Theory
Working Papers
New York University School of Law
5-1-2012
The Principle of Loyal Opposition
Jeremy J. Waldron
NYU School of Law, [email protected]
Follow this and additional works at: http://lsr.nellco.org/nyu_plltwp
Part of the Constitutional Law Commons, Jurisprudence Commons, Legal History, Theory and
Process Commons, Legislation Commons, Politics Commons, and the Public Law and Legal Theory
Commons
Recommended Citation
Waldron, Jeremy J., "The Principle of Loyal Opposition" (2012). New York University Public Law and Legal Theory Working Papers.
Paper 328.
http://lsr.nellco.org/nyu_plltwp/328
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the New York University School of Law at NELLCO Legal Scholarship Repository. It has been
accepted for inclusion in New York University Public Law and Legal Theory Working Papers by an authorized administrator of NELLCO Legal
Scholarship Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected].
!
"#$%
# % & "
# %% ' (%%(%)
%%#(*(&+
$#%%-$(##
##(
.#%&/%(#(#
%##&0#1%
2/%%
%34.
&/%%
#&
0 5 5 %&6%%(%#
7
%&
# % # % #
((%
# % ( %% %%#&0
%&
8%)
%%(%%#%
#%%(%5
.% (#
"
& 9:&
2/%
:;<;=
)%%&0>%
%4%&
%# %
% % % %(# % (& ? &&& %%#%(#
(&
/% % ) # # 4%%%%5%
( %(&
@#>%)%%#
% # % %
(%4%
###& 8%
%.%4%#&
$%4%#%
&%(%
%1.%
4##4(&
8 %* % % (# (
.(#'4(+%%
# % & /% 5 %%#%(#
(&0(#?
#%?(&
&?%#
%( % % # # & ?%% % # # %% (
6%% % 6 7
%7#%5
<">
=A'%4%&+
A?%&=&
=&&"#$%
:::&
& ? #
%%#%%&
1#(
# ( % # % (&/%#(
( # %* % ( %%%%(#
&(4
#(%
(%((#6
(
#4%7#7
#.(
# (%& 0 # & (&/%.
#%#(
%%(
&
!"#$
%
#&
( # # % % . 5 & 2 %#(%5
*.%
(%&8
#44%
#(#>%B%%(
#%&8#*
%>1'C/DECD%
(%+##
9#>
!!&
<9<'#%(#F.
4#%.%#(&?%
5%%5%#3(3
#%(&+8%#'CD%%
(%%%%&GB%#(%*+
)HHH&
(#&0#((%
B##&
E#*.%&/5%0)(#
#(%##
(1
####4#
% % #(&
?##.*
&/I#/'F
%%&+
JI'.5
#&+0#(%'%#+
#%%7%
?(%%7#(I%%5%
/*&
1-7.*
(#%%
5-
'(
%%#
(#
(##
%#
(%&0#((3
#%#%3#
5%.%%&
0#%%#
;"6")>
???J&=J&A&J&8*
/!
"
&=A1'C@D%%(
5353(
%%&*
/50)(
K?J&A
:/!
8.&???J&<&<
!?%&8.&???J&9&=&
?%&8.&???J&A&!:%J&A&<A&
(%(%
(%%
)
%*
?%#.I
((%(%#
#%%*%#&$
*
.%%&?
#)4.
%&#(
5%1)#%%
#5757
4.# %
%%&/%%%43
% . %
%#&
$.%&8##
((3%
#(%%B%%8.
'%C D ( % &+ /((
%(%&"
%((
#%
##%
(#(7#.
%&0
& /%%%.
# . (# % *%%%%
(#%%#&
? . % % %
%((%%
B%%8.)%#L/'
#E%#+<=
#
$!!: !!A!A&/%%%1'?%.5%%
%#((!=&/*
#%6(#&
# 5 (&
( M # % %%##&
(&%(%
54%%
#%%#%
#%(%%
# % ( % (%& .%(%
(1%(#-8(
%&05# #*(
#%&%##.&
$(#&0.%
%(#I&$
(#7
%5%#(#(
I#%%&$
(%(%%
% & / I ( (#%(%&
+
? % . % !!#>
. . %
#& %4%
#%..>
. #%
#& %( # % %&?%#(
%(#%.
</%#(&$%%(#%
((.6%%&J.#>%
0.&
A'%?G*+#>'%
#%#%&+
%&>*
(%1#
'
&+8
(%
# ( 4 %&?
(#(%#
%%&
0 #& (%%%(%
%%(&
%%#&0#
%&8#(#
4%(%
#%(%##%
% I 5 # % % & 3I
%%&?.#%
%#&
0?(%#.
4%%(&5
I%#5%%
&I(###(
%(*I
% & 0 * # # ( # % 6 % (&?#%
(#(.*
.(%&
14%%)%
I%7I%
# . ( %
%%(&/%
> I # 7
=>
&%!=&
9?%&<&
%%#
% %7 % %&0.#(%'%#
%%%(&+ /%
%%(1.%5
7%$%%
0%%%$7%%
% 3 % %# % % 3 % %# 4 I%&0(
#3 >*%'CD# (I (# I%
.#%F&+8#
% # %% ' (
%&+
,-."/
E##%%%
(13#%6.3
% ( % % (*
%#3%*I
#%((#&
/#%&8
% # #% #& ? &
? 6. 5 ?3%45?
( % # &?8(
"'CD
##%%8#
%&+
?8%%##B6
. %
# % ) %%I%&0#%*4
;?%& ("'8#+%
&
< ::;A;&
I%3# ' & # 4##2J%%2
E4#*
#&0%
%66
%%#:<;'2J
% 2 # 2E4#*L((
2+7%%(#
)(%%%& $%& 8 4# % I% % % ' % % % # (+ %%*#(%%
. # %# E 5 %% 5%#&/?("1'?#
L(%#5O !!!#%
3
%(&+
/# E2# % %#% %J% %
/%8&'?:!=
:B&E2#'>
%
8J+
(9::=A&A<6A= !EJ/:<;&0I%
'
%+%%#J:<;&
$%E'
#J.4&+B&
E2#'>
%8
J+
(9::=AA<AA!&
E%5GCD
#%L((L(
&+66/%
2J%:<;)%
2%#E2#HH&
<K22
%%:<;2%%&HHH&
A?(":HH&
%% 2 J (% #I%2%
%%5%P;!!!%%
%E&&+
/##(7'I
.(#%#%(
(%#+7%%'
#(&+
/ # ( % % % # # %% # #
& 0
%(
(3#
% & 2 % %
% # # E % E *
%
%2J%I
%&
0 % .(#
%1
%%J%
% # % 4 %%%&/%#
4 . % (
#J&
$- 0%%
(#%%#(&8
=E2#'>
%+&AA<&0%#
%/: !%%%
%#%:A;#%&?%&&
AA&?8%%#%2
%&
#
%Q%:=
9("'8#+&A;/&
&
!
%
"R.E: AK&?&A=&/1/$8
@S#%%#
%&F+
;/'L81JG*+>%&
)
R@:99<&<6A&
0%"*&
- #..
%&?8#
'+2J"'?
#'
2J&I
. ? %7 . ( I % # % %* %3 ( % % %% % %5%#& 0
%
J / (% # %% % ( %# E*
%%#(%#
:0I%#/%:==&/#
#%#'%##56E
(#%%#
%%&+T*(7>&E&*+,
!
%
,
R.1&EU:;<7)%(#L&
2$
<;:;=9&"&>(
*+,
9::;=A::&
<!?%&>&/J((#%
&"
%& <6A1'0J#
%#5&#(%
(&+
<8!
"
& =3"
%&A<:&
< #>
.#I%
J%9!.)%#%#&>
)21'$(%/#BF
#%&?
#%4%#
%%#%&+ J&"
%&A9A1'0%#.
#%#L(%#
L(L(.%((E#
%#.E
%#&?
#%2L((#%#%
%#%#&+
# #(#E 5
##&+
8#%#
73*
7# '
(+ '% %+ '
5#L(U
# % # % . L( (
#+7%#(B%%
8.*%'((&+ 0
#%(#%(
J7.& ?I
%#S%
% % %%% 5# %
#%%((&
E#%
/)%'L81JG*+&A6=&"
<6A1'0
%#
L(4%
J#(46
5E%
%%%L(#%##
.#&2(
#E&2..%
%2&+/"
%&A9A6=1
G0#%%V%.U
JVVV&0E(%
%%(L(&0(
$(%4%%
%%(%%%.&0L(
((%E%#(%%8(%%0%#&
0(%9&<!&&%#(
(%(%!&&+
<=2%
%7:;<1'C0DU2E4#U#
4%&&&&+
<9#B%1/W1L(1XX&&(&X)X)H;&
(%"&; !!&
<;"&<&
8.)%#>1
&'0#
J%8%?F&+
'5%(+
% # I ( % % % 5
? . 7 # ( &
?%
(& 'J+?("
'#L(%%
.(%&+ /%
%%%1 '2 E4#U 2 E4#U (
L(& 0 % 2 E4#U
( E&+ (# %#7 (% (667#%#I
%& 0 # %( % #
%8.%%%
<:E2#'>
%+&A<:1'/.
%(%#%
(3.#55
(%&+
A!"'8#+=!:6!&?("
%&91'0(L(%
%&?L(&?
%#&G2E4#U*%&2E4#%
L(&+
A>
('
5(((#%%#
((%&+
A 8I-/'L81JG*+&91'0%(
#
((&+/.2J
%
J%%'##I%
%#I%%5%L(
5E#%#&+66)%'L81
JG*+&9&
A<"&<&
AA?%&&;:&'L81JG*+&A#1'E%
%%2E4#*(
%((E%
#%E
(&+
%(%%I%& 0 % # % %
#%#
( . 5 5
%(2&/J
((#%#%(#& B((#.
%%5& ?
%# # (# % #%#(& /
"1
? % (
#%((%&0
( ( . %&?#%7%
7%(&
A=/'
#E%#+!<&
A9J(-
<=&/%)&#
-
&//'
#?/E%#+&!91
'0L()%%%&+
A;J)%'L81JG*+&9&
A";!1'0%
(.((#.%%.
%%#.#%(
L(#&+8!
"
&
91'/.(
%&E(.%%#%%#%&0#(%
%%#(%%&8#
%%(%6#7
%%#7(#
%(&%1(
3%#
)&84.%GJ%#.-*
#%6#GJ%#%%-?
%#%%3?((%
##%3*Y&/%%#%%
%(%..%
7(%#
7(%&+
A:"<&
/% %% (#1 ' # %#.
# % 5 5 &+ 0 8.* '
(#+7%####7
?#74#
%%##%
# & 0 . (% #
%%1#%%
%I%(&
7#%
.%##%%&0'2
2E4#*
#+%(EE&
J 2 % 9 2 J& (#.6##$%03
%J((3#%>
##1"%(('.%
%% # &+#?#.
(#8&
$%(
%
@%.I%
% ( # % # % &0%/
8 '0 $%+ ! #! !!:7*
=!?%&
="
%91'0(L(%
%&+
= 26.6.38#*%
&
=<!
!:;'0%###%#
V2E4#U&V?%#%3%#%#
G%%#*
(%&+1XX)#&#&XX&Z!B9B<8=A9;</:!/:A/A=8;=!<
=A"'8#+&=!:6!&
%'##)%&+?#
%(%##.@
)%#%#&/L/
0 % ( L 8 5%%%#%##&?
#@%#
#%&F?
2 J I %
(%#
#
%(%(((2
J%&
?#@#7?(
% 8 % /
7?58
##&
0
*
(#%#
8 & ?%% %%
%%#3.7%.7
#%
%&0%(##%%
%%%%
* % &8
.%%
II%8&0%
%%###%&8
% # % % %%%##%
7 & ? 6
.#
%%(
==1XX&&X666(%X A9X#6!6 !!:X6%666#6
=9/'
#E%#+&!A&
#)&?##
&
0%%
# # & ? # . 8
J%/I%
#
#.#.#.##
#.%##&$
5%
L()((#78.%
'J(+7%#%
(#%#%(#(#
& #55
#%/
%%%%(
2>(&0
%8%%
( % (# !! #6
4%#7%
(#%#%%&?
##5#
3 % I% #
# . (# % # # %& /
>E%%#>I%
%#%
%% ' ( %#%&+ > . I% % ' # %
I%+
? # &/%?(%8
J&?%(%%(
=;&&/J
-
.
"
J
!&
=>E%%#
&>'
(&LL1
0
+
A !!9&::6!.'(
(%#%&+
% # % ( %%%#(
% ## 7 &
8 8 / K # ( .%
#&#
1(#%& ?
% %% % # %(
(%%4%#
%7?#7#&
?B
&8%".5(#&8
#K8%#. !
7 % #%#..%&?#
( ( %#8%#
#%%
5%#5#
&
$.%7
?I##%
& ?4(%*
# #3 % I %3
'%%#%#
%(%#&+ ?4%
(# % I %(% #I%((
7(I%.%%
%%(#.(
%((&
/
#
=:/'
#E%#+#'/.%%
#(%
#%&+?
8%&
9!/K#/
0
9
%2'($#?I1
/%(%
+%
!!A&
% ( # % I%
. ' # F#(&+
123#
* &
0 % # ?
. ) %#& E# # % ) ? # #%(5%(
.#
%##(%
%(&
R#.'$#)-
26%%#-2##%#
#%5%#-$
#%%(%%
%-+(
# # # 6% 1 8 > / %
/57(%
%#5%%&
%.%
%%#&
0 # ( (% %#*#(%
%&8#%
%4
%%5%
.%
L%(%4(%
9 'L81JG*+&<&
9<"
%91'?%#&+
9A?'>(1?(1/J(J5+)
A9::<& %'.%#((%%#
#
M%#%%%&+
%#(%#%
%&
?(.%
%%I%%%
% 4 % %%I#
%&
L % ( 6% ( . (#%
%%#&
??.%##
. (# % % # ##(#%%& E#(#
%#*(#
% (# ( % % &8%*%
#&0#*&
R##(#&
/%I.'(G5*1
%(&?)#
%%(5#&+ 0%*#
%#(.##%%#%
&/%
%%
%##
(#%#%%5
& 0?#%%3(%
5 % % 9=I.'EJ#1/+!
1
%%#%JE?0 !!< &=&/%%#I.
##%(%
#Z#(%%)%&&
99>
&9:==69!1'0#%(#
.4#%.%#
(&?%5%%5%#3
(3#%(&%%(
%%%%&GB%#(%&*.
%((%#4(
#.#(&+
6%#((
%%(%
&
2 4
$%?#
%
(#%
#&
?@%)(
%
7%%%
K6%# /% !A1 '0
JF#(%%K%%
% % %#&0%%.#(
K%%&0
" /%* K % ;:; ( 0
"%%%&+
#%#
#7J#
7 ( ((% I% 'E#
%+%%%%%&
8
#7%%
#7 % % 6
%&
L / I %##%(##
( ( # % %#
%3%
#(%5%(
(%& (
%&
E %#1 # %( % 5%I%6%%6%6
9;/'
#E%#+!&
9%%%
(G+%&
9:(%"&
*
! :6
!! %3
4###
%% # %
#&0@S
%@#
)&#.
CD#..
./5 % . % %%#(%
%%C(D&
8%(%
%(%
(&$
#%%6%#
2(%#%%6
%5(&/%7
7%& 0
6%%7#%
;!/'
#E%#+!!1'0@%%
.(B5((#&0###(
((&/##(
5%%5(##((
(7#
%&+
;#'@%+< %
::;
=&
; ?%&
;<#&=;1'0%%6I%%#6
%(%%
(%%#%%%%&+
;A/%#((#%#%
#%(%4###&$
5(66#66%(#%6#
J&/1%%5(&
$ 2& 8 # / # ( 8
#(%
( %& J # % % . % I ( %
%#
%&$(%&/%
(#%77#
# & 0 7 %*
(%(6%6%4%(7
% % # % &
/%% % %#%(%%
#%%
##
I5.
%.%(&
# % (%%
&$
5%('6+7
% !!:& 02>(%
%#4#
&/%&
%%#
%.%%
;=#"
(%>%2&%'+:-0
0
0
< !!=6 !!91'C0D%%.%(%5(
(##%#%%%2%
%#%(%%%##&+
;9#'@%+&=<#
;;/.>%/
2
)
)=@&J2?J/L&
&>BK&A<
A::6=!=::(#I%#%
%#&?%%2L.
!
3445
!
* *
!
)
A2/>K/>
/$>BK?B$
A !!&
% (& 0 4# # 2 >( %%&
/ % % %
)##
#/&
%?5%4%#&0
%
J& 0# . % %#(%7.7#%
%% # 4%* %%((%
J& ? 4 J1 #
%&6%#%
%##%
%%#& ?%#J
/%%#&/%(
%(# 4% (# %
&
#(%#
/#%& 2.'
+'%%%/(
) # . %
;#4%%%###
#%%##%
&0##7
#%(%4#
%%J%#&
;:/%%%%%&
/4%#%#%%%##>
%%%.>
#(%>#%
&%%(6
#4%#4%%#%
#*#&
&+?.%#%%
&
0 @% J % % 1
# % # # % %##%#
% )#
%4%%5(.
(%#
%%#%%& 0
% % #
% & & 0 ) 5(
%4%##%5
% % % ) 5(##4%%%&
) #6 %#& 8 /%
.%3%.%
# & 0
# % 4% ( %(3%#7%%.
%7#%
) ( (& 0 %%
%
(#&%#
#%%#J#
%(3
7 ( 5
%%
(6[6((%(&/%((&
7(#%%%7
/#&
!#'@%+&HH&/##*1
'F%%%/()
#.%)#
%%%%%#&+
J
.%E)&
5
*
%4 0%##
#%7
%#
(%
& (% # L$@(#5 %'L(+%6
$
!!:&0(#
%%&
0@%6.6#&
. ( ( # % %
. % % ( #& 0 # #%#& @S % 2
E4#*(#J
&
(# % '(+
(#%5&/%(%#
#4%%3
.#((
&/%(%(#(
4 #& # %
#
%#(&
/%'
(+ %# %&
#%
%%#%%
.%7*#%#7#(
% & /% % L(66%#(%'L(
+:6
$=A69 A !!:&
<%#%(1%%
('
+& <A &#-
% % &
0(#4%#%&6
4%#%(#(#
%&
#%#&
%#%#6I#(#
%&
#
%%%(%%4%((#
(4%%6.#
(%&>
(%4%((%
(#%.&
0 % 5 7
#>%.7(%
.##
#&
0((%#
# % # & 0# .
# / #3 # . #
5
(#((&
8#%& $?.
(%85
%#%%
7 (# ( 7# 7
)&
% $% $ L 8 '
L(+ % 4 & 0
# % ( 5 # % ((%)%
%(&?#((
#)%
%
##%
A.
*B:93>I'0>(J+3$%'0
J?#+
!%
3%$%'%
.(/J-+
% # % . L(&
/ % %
#%:=!& 0
(&%'.
L(%%
&0###(%
#&+/%(%2
J/85%1
$:A!#%%
%JL(%&
0#%&(##
%6%(
% & 0 # JL(&?%.
#& %% %% (#%#
L(%2E4#U#&?.%
%%(%#
%%%&0
%G23%%&
$%2E4#U#%
(#%(
?%%&*0#%%(#
##&+
?%*4%(&/%#
#%(I6#
8%%$& @#.
8#
J((%#
% ( # #7 ='L81JG*+&=&
92%1
%J
%7:;<
;2%18/85J7 9:A<&
# % (# 5( 5 ( &
0#%.#%
( ((
##
% I % ##&
6
&
?#%%% ##
%%%?.%5#
# & L/ % 'CD FF
#%
#F
U #&+ # % (( ' %% %4(%
%%%%%
%(%&+ ?.%
(#&
$?%
%% % 6
%%#
%6%& ?%
%?:9:%:;!& 8
##
%% .#6(%
(JJJ5
#6(%(
IL#
8%#&$(
%#J
#(%'+(8
:=!%9!&
$J2%'2E4#*
#+ 9EL0#%
' C D # /'
#E%#+&! !&
:J-
% E4#* (&+
(
"%
#8'#&+ ?#%8 #%#(&0##
W%$=;%
#%%#('?(#
%#%4#%#&+ %
8%@21'C?D%#&&&
((#6%L(
## ((%%(
&+
0%#(
# #& 5 % % I (%&
J(%#
(%&
/
%%%
%%(#.(@S
&
8
%&:<;J((E&&%
%
:!!
!:;&=(
:"'8#+&A1
: 7
/
# ;=;&
:<2%1/%%>#7E#9:;:
:A8!
"
& =&8%#(%
.#%&
:="
%&A9=1'%%CD&
0#&#%#
&0%(%%(%&
.:AJL(:=%%
%(&F/##
%(%#)L(
J>&+
% % % ( > (& 0
J(( (* # 7 7% > ( % * '+ & /
%%2J1
0 % &&& L(& # # L(&2#%
E%(&
/#%& /%
('2E4#*
G%*1
C%DL(&+
$&
$ % '#+ '
# +- 0
(#%#%
.%'#-+$%
*%%'#+-
7
89#?8%%'2E4#*
#&+?##- ?
(%&?%%%((
# ( (%"*'&+
0 %# L(%#
:9J&!
)1
"
,1
& 96 !1'0%%
%%%%#
%(%%66(%#
(3#(%#(%#
#(&+
:;$)%%A6=&
:'L81JG*+&=&
::/'
#E%#+&!<1'0
EL((#%
#&+
# & ? L( .% & 0 L( % %# %& ? % % (#
# . G&*0 %#
%(%%&B
L( & 0
# (% % %%5&/#S%#
L(&
J# # ( % 1 E # (
%#
###&
8 % % % # - 0 % (8%J
#%#
&8%&?@SE (##%
(J1
'? & & & # /# L% ? % 2 E4# W BI % % & L%&+ (% 2 J % # % ?
#%
.&
!!"
%&<9<6A&'L81
JG*+&;1?K%'%2E4#*
L(2E4#*##W*%
&+
!"
%&<=A&
! 'L(+&=::JYJJ
2J
#!
>!X9 !!(
1XX&&.XXXX !!X!69&%
!<'L(+&9!!>%S#
.2
J
#XJX99< 6A !!:(
1XX&&.XXXXX6!99<&%
7
86
#
?@%5
## '#+ % J&
/K?@J)%%%
5(%4%'%#/+
J&
8 ( # ((J& 0@
J*#4%
&0%%%
J '( %+ % ' 2&+R%##%
" 8 # # (&
##%%%#
%#(#
% . 5 * 7 /%::(((
(% 5
# & 0 # %% % . (#%
%
%##&
>*&.
##%'
%6.&+
!A@S'L81JG*+&9#
%L((')
(%%%&
!=?@J'?E%#?%
%%J@%%%3?
%3?.##(
(3%?%#%%?
&L%&+
!9J&
?F##%
% . %
% % & I% ( %( % %&
7
8:6
#
;J(#'
%+##-J%5"
>*'+ %
& / ? % > .#&/%#
'CD ( % # F & 0 . ( %#&+ %'%#
(%+
'%F(4&+ 2 % # &
0%#%4>*
.&?(%7&&
# % I %%
%
% % ( .
%(&2%( 'CD
%CD%4
!;>
& <==6=:&
!J.&
!:>$
*A:&
!">
::9& ;61'C0DF%
%%#%(#(&
#
%%%%(%
I%&+
.####%%
+%.
#6#%(
(%%5 (#
&/%.%5
%(####
%##&
? % > . # #?.&0
(# %%
%&0
?%&0#(
%%I(%
.
& $*#
?%&& A1'C0D%#%#)#
((#G&*+%&& A1'
%4%4
I#)&+?(I%%
T"#$%'>%G"*J+$
!!;7%?*&
>
551'$I4
#(%%)%%
#%%%%
4&+/%& =1'(%##
%%%#((
#)((%
)4&+
<?%.&%
%5%&0#%&& < #'%#
%I%#5%
5)%%%%
%#%%%I
%(%%&0
%#%##I%%%&+
%%&& 1'C?D((
%#5)%#4%%
%#%(##(%&
)(#(()%#4%
%%((.%#
%%%%(&+
##%.
4%
6&
?.#%
%#%(#%
%#(%%
#%J& ?
%4%(&0J%
%%
%%#%#
& 8.(#%%
(%%#
1 %4% 5%&>%%4
@ J % (% %
#%(%%#(#
J%& %>%#
%#7#
#76%%#
%@%#%6%%
'+$%
&<! 6 &
=E%%E66B&
#%##%&
9*(S8'"%/
#+"::;:;;&
;J%4%
Y
Y&5#<%A(&
>*4
&A!;1'?%(F
4%(#4%
#U#&01#
#%(
3%#%%%#%
%%#%%)#3%
(#
%&+
:>5'#%%
%%%(+%&& A:&
(& 05.%#& &
8%#%
%&0#
%%#
(4#%%(&
7
48#% B(###
#(#%
7'%%#+ %%%
#- %J%
#'5
5&+0
%(%.%##
%%##%%
&E#'+7
%% # J , 0 %7
3#%%*8%#
%%%#&##
'#+8-$T
#%7
(#)4- /#
5%%%%##%
(%%#%%
#%# !>%#/5.%%
%@%#%%6%%#&"
>'SJ(E0#+
&<!<<==
%&:::&
$) >
& ;6 1'/%(#
%%%#%
&+
</)%'L81JG*&+
AJ&
$##%*.
# # #% # %.#&0
. '#+ # . & 5 @
J(#.%%
&%###(
I # (./KJ
% - /(3 ( %& E# .
/ K % # % %%%%#
%#%&8/.%%
#(.
& ? %* .74%
..(
)(##&
748
?%%
# &
E###&8
# 6@7 ?%
(8J%&%
%%#
. ## % & /(%
*##%%?*
I % / I # I% %&
$(.%#%
##&
?#%.#
%%#%#
%&?82
%B
%%
#1C$DL((%3
#3#3&&&(2
=J)
(&
E4#U#+ /#%*#
I(4#*.
%%%#&0##
##%##
5&8((%
'(+%%%%& ?.
##%)%%%'#+
# # ( %%%&
.%5S#
%#%%#
( '% % % %
)(#&+ 2%'+7#
(%5
I%J$%& 8.%%
%#5#(
(##L
%1 # '%#6%
%#%5%
%C(#D6+% %%
92%1B
%%
%7"#A:;9&
;S'L#10K+
& <;&
'L(+%'$&+1'?
%(%%#
(#(*&FC0D
5/%2%#%$L#&
2UI###4#%
%(%(#$
J&$#%I%'$+
%&F?%.'#+&F
%#5#%
##%(&F0
%%(%#
%&?(%##
'$+%&%
F#(&06%
'%#+7%#%%%(###
?-
47(
#%(%#&
#%%6(
I%&
?(
# '+ # % # ((%%%&8%
I%'%#+%
6%%##
#%- ?%*.#
&
J# % %# % ##
#& $(.
##%%%5#
5%(#(#
#& 0 %
% % ( %
(#%#&(#
3%(%&
?.?##.%
'#+ # % % ( # %% & ? # . %
()
% ( # & ?% #%'#+'
#+%
%#%#
#%%#&0%
'#+#(%#1
%%#3##
)%3%&0##
:?%&& <6:&
<!0))#%
%#1
?%5#(?0.#&0
##4%#.#.%
#7##(#)%
%#&>
?'&+
<J$%
&HH&
)% # # .& ? #1 ## (%%%
%?(
.&0#%#
##I
%((& 0#
%#
(#%#.%%
&0%
(%##
#%%#&
'6#
#%57??
(%(%5%
%%#
.(&
/%
%2
B%
5# % '( $# ?I+1'?.%%
#%#
%#%#&+ ? 3 ? 2 %
% %( .% %
& E 7 6%%
%##
#>%#
&?#5#
< 0#.)6&
#?.%
.#%##5##&
&: 1'?%.%F#
(%7#%%.&?
(%(####
%%%%(%&
<<S1V%5&?
%#6%%&+-
<A2'($#?I+
&
& # # 3 ( ##(3
#48*#
%#& " > 51 %% ' % #
+'%&+ 0
? 5 %( >* ( 7(##7?%
.&
$?5%#.J
J%0#?%%
%%7#%%7%(#
.% ( #&0#%#
3#%5
( # %% 4%#%#%(##
%&?#%#
# % %% % ( % 4 . (%=;%(>
( %#& 0 # %#%%
#%%#(
%.&
?.%%(
%#&?.(%
%/
. I %
%&#>*.%
(% 3 # %
%% % 1 ? . . # R@ J%#42
(?%%&
<=?.133(#3
33%3
%%((3%%4%#&
<9">$
* ,
A:
%7?%#%7
.4%)#
.%(%&
8.%
%&?(%
(%%##
% % # (
#7 . /6.%
. % 7
I%%#%%
(%#%#&
/#%((L
S%'%+#& ? :
%&
/#%
%%&$(.#
%%%%%#%
#%#%
> ' ( #+ #& / ? % 5
%7
%(#%&B(4(
4%#
#(%#%%
#&
<;J%#>
&9:99
<W/%&