Environmental Education and Service Learning in the Tropics: Making Global Connections By Sarah Haines Research has suggested that a service-learning component can add a powerful dimension to learning course content in a variety of science disciplines, in addition to assisting students in seeing connections between their studies and the world outside the classroom. This article describes a tropical ecology course designed for science preservice teachers that was taught in Costa Rica and contained several servicelearning requirements. 16 Journal of College Science Teaching T he idea of incorporating service-learning components into college-level coursework is not new, but it has been gaining popularity in recent years. For the purposes of this article, I define service learning as “a teaching and learning strategy that integrates meaningful community service with instruction and reflection to enrich the learning experience, teach civic responsibility, and strengthen communities” (Kaye 2004). Some of the popularity of the service-learning model can be attributable to research findings that show it to be a very effective and valuable teaching tool in both K–12 and postsecondary educational arenas (Kravetz 2006; Boyle-Baise et al. 2006; Handa et al. 2008). Service learning as a part of instruction in college-level science courses is also growing in popularity, spearheaded largely by the National Center for Science & Civic Engagement’s SENCER (Science Education for New Civic Engagements and Responsibilities) initiative. Funded by the National Science Foundation and launched in 2001, the program aims Environmental Education and Service Learning in the Tropics an audience likely to include school-age children. The course aims to provide students with the knowledge and skills they need to plan and implement environmental education activities that are of a high caliber and that will contribute to K–12 students’ environmental literacy and knowledge of global environmental concerns. Service-learning opportunities are utilized during the course to emphasize global environmental issues and to encourage students to implement service-learning strategies with their own students once they begin teaching in their own classrooms. BIOL 382/582: Environmental Education and Service Learning in the Tropics This course is offered as part of the Study Abroad Programs office at Towson University, a comprehensive university located outside of Baltimore, Maryland. It is taught in various locations in Costa Rica during the summer semester. This three-credit course is open for either graduate or undergraduate credit. Designed for those interested in teaching in either formal or nonformal settings, the course generally attracts the following majors: elementary education, secondary education/biology, environmental science, and environmental studies. The course was first taught in the summer 2008 term. At that time, 10 students enrolled, all of whom were undergraduates. Of those, 4 were environmental science or environmental studies majors, 1 was a special education major, 3 were biology majors, and 2 were elementary education majors. Course curriculum emphasizes the application of forest ecology concepts to K–12 environmental education and human use and management of natural resources in the tropics. We used Project Learning Tree curricula as our textbooks; in particular the Forest Ecology secondary module, designed for grades 9–12 (American Forest Foundation 2006), and the PreK–8 Environmental Education Activity Guide (American Forest Foundation 2007). As we covered course concepts, we examined the corresponding activities in these guides and discussed how these concepts would likely be taught in a K–12 classroom. See Figure 1 for course goals and objectives (a complete list is available in the online version of this article). Sarah Haines to “strengthen students’ understanding of science and their capacity for responsible work and citizenship” (www.sencer.net). An evaluation of the SENCER project revealed that students enrolling in SENCER courses with a service-learning component were more likely to participate in civic activities than were those students who enrolled in similar courses without such a component. Further, students reported that having instructors frame course content around civic issues and service-learning opportunities was more engaging than a more traditional approach to delivering the content, and they perceived it as helpful to their learning. As a biology professor whose primary teaching assignments include courses intended for students enrolled in elementary and secondary teacher preparation programs or those interested in pursuing careers in environmental education, I became very interested in incorporating the service-learning model into my courses for both majors and nonmajors. Although all students can surely benefit from the service-learning approach, it seemed especially appropriate for the nonmajors I was reaching, as well as for the preservice teachers enrolled in my courses (Haines 2003). I viewed the service-learning model as a way to engage nonmajors in the science content they were learning as well as community issues associated with the content. In the same way, I saw service learning as an opportunity for preservice biology, life science, or environmental education teachers to become more engaged with the community they would one day end up serving. As pointed out by Handa et al. (2008), during their undergraduate tenure, preservice teachers are often disconnected from the very communities in which they will ultimately be teaching. Service-learning activities could potentially alleviate this problem. Here, I present a course developed for science majors who are interested in teaching in K–12 settings or in nonformal educational centers such as zoos, aquaria, or nature centers that cater to Poorman’s umbrella (Gunnera insignis), a typical plant species of wet subtropical areas and mountainous tropical zones. January/February 2010 17 Workshops related to science content As indicated in Figure 1, students participated in workshops co-led by a local Costa Rican guide and me. These workshops were meant to develop the content knowledge necessary for students to fully understand the connections between our field studies, the service-learning opportunities we would be engaging in, and the ecological concepts presented throughout the course. The first workshop, Introduction to the Rain forest, took place immediately upon our arrival to Selva Verde Reserve. Topics covered in this session included the definition of a rain forest; where they are found; characteristics of soil, precipitation, and tem- perature; and seasonality. Next, students were introduced to general adaptations of the plants and animals inhabiting the rain forest. This led to a discussion of the interactions between animals and plants living in this biome. Nutrient cycling was discussed as well. Finally, students were acquainted with some of the threats facing rain forests today and what some possible solutions to those threats might be. The topic of the second workshop was rain forest fragmentation. Here, the topics of the first session were expanded upon as students examined issues related to habitat fragmentation. Students also learned how loss of unbroken expanses of habitat affects rain forest species. The topic of the third workshop was environmental education and conservation. This session began with a discussion of global economy and how that economy threatens habitat in Costa Rica. Main threats discussed were wood production, cattle ranching, population pressure, forest fragmentation, pollution, and lack of education. Next students examined responsible practices and discussed how these practices can impact the environment. Practices discussed included organic farming, biological control, and recycling and reusing. The session emphasized that forests are not separate isolated units, and that conservation efforts must be comprehensive in nature in order to be effective. FIGURE 1 BIOL 382 course goals and objectives. Goals: Students will develop an awareness and appreciation for aspects of Costa Rican culture that are different from their own. Objectives: 1.1 Students will complete a Rain Forest Structure and Forest Fragmentation workshop with participation from the local community. (Assessment: Exam, Unit Plan) 1.2 Students will work with local community members on a reforestation project at a local site. (Assessment: Participation and Daily Reflection) 1.3 Students will attend a charla hosted by a local community member describing life in rural Costa Rica. (Assessment: Participation and Daily Reflection) 1.4 Students will complete an Environmental Education and Conservation Workshop with local community members. Students will be able to describe local cultural trends with regard to land usage, family structure, and economic activities. (Assessment: Exam, Unit Plan) 1.5 Students will assist a local ecology club in completing a service project. (Assessment: Participation and Daily Reflection) 1.6 Students will participate in salsa dancing lessons organized by the Sarapiqui Conservation Learning Center with local community instructors. 1.7 Students will undertake a whitewater rafting excursion on the Sarapiqui River. – Students will make a difference in the local host community by assisting in the completion of two environmental action projects. 2.1 Students will work with local community members on a reforestation project at a local site. 2.2 Students will assist a local ecology club in completing a service project. (Assessment: Participation and Daily Reflection) – Students will be able to identify several animal species that can be found in the La Selva and Atlantic coastal regions of Costa Rica. 3.1 Students will take a guided in-depth tour of InBio Parque, the Institute of Biodiversity. (Assessment: Participation, Exam, Unit Plan) 3.2 Students will participate in morning bird walks at Selva Verde Lodge. (Assessment: Participation) 3.3 Students will complete a hike into Selva Verde Reserve, guided by a local wildlife expert. (Assessment: Participation) 3.4 As part of the Introduction to the Rain Forest workshop, students will be able to identify many of the common animal species found there. (Assessment: Exam, Unit Plan) 3.5 As part of the Rain Forest Structure and Fragmentation workshop, students will be able to describe the habits of many of the animal species inhabiting these forests. (Assessment: Exam, Unit Plan) 3.6 Students will be led on a nocturnal hike of the Selva Verde grounds. (Assessment: Participation) 3.7 Students will conduct qualitative observations of the animal species found at Selva Verde. (Assessment: Participation and Exam) 3.8 Students will be led on an in-depth tour of the Avarios Del Caribe Sloth Rehabilitation Center. (Assessment: Participation and Exam) 3.9 Students will list and photo catalog the aquatic organisms found along the tidal pools, wave erosion areas, rocky reefs, and shorelines of Manzanillo. (Assessment: Participation and Exam) 18 Journal of College Science Teaching Environmental Education and Service Learning in the Tropics Field studies and observations • Half-day trip to InBio Parque (Institute of Biodiversity). Provided students with knowledge pertaining to national park structure in Costa Rica, biodiversity of regional plants and animals, and local species flora and fauna. • Six days and six nights spent at Selva Verde Reserve. Helpful in teaching rain forest structure and adaptations, deforestation and its consequences, reforestation practices and species used, and habits of creatures of the day and night inhabiting these forests. • Full-day trip to Arenal Volcano. Helpful in introducing the concept of ecological succession. • Several hours spent on a tour of the Avarios Del Caribe Sloth Rehabilitation Center. Here students examined how rain forest resource use and misuse has affected this particular species. • Two days at Manzanillo Reserve. Here students compared the abiotic and biotic factors present along the coastline to those found in the upland areas. Students undertook a short study of marine biodiversity in tropical regions. Service-learning components In my opinion, students enrolled in the course learned as much about global environmental issues and human impact on the environment by participating in the service-learning aspect of the course as they did by participating in the biological studies they undertook. Our service-learning projects were all coordinated by the Sarapiqui Conservation and Learning Center (SCLC), a fully independent U.S. and Costa Rica registered nonprofit organization. The SCLC’s mission is to link communi- Sarah Haines Students had the opportunity to visit several areas of ecological importance in Costa Rica over the duration of the course. These included the following: Students planting a vegetable garden at a local elementary school. ties and conservation through education and ecotourism in the Sarapiquí region of Costa Rica’s northern lowlands. The SCLC focuses its efforts in four areas—environmental education, community development, conservation, and tourism—in order to help form future environmental leaders, raise the organizational capacity of local communities, promote sustainable land use, and connect tourists to the local community. Programs serve hundreds of local people and thousands of ecotourists each year (www.learningcentercostarica.org). The concepts that our first servicelearning project would help to reinforce were sustainable farming practices, stream buffers and erosion, and the benefits of ecotourism. We spent a considerable amount of time examining the farming practices of the local people, studying their methods of planting as well as the types of crops planted in an area. Students examined the water quality of the local streams bordering the farmland, as well as that of the Sarapiqui River, the largest body of water in the district. A connection was made between land usage and water quality. We next had an employee of the SCLC deliver a short lecture on the practice of ecotourism, explaining to the students how ecotourism works, and what the benefits are to both the tourists and the local people. Disadvantages were discussed as well. Next, students traveled to a local farm where they spent an entire day. Students assisted the farmer in planting trees on his property. The trees are serving as a buffer for the surrounding Sarapiqui River. By taking part in the project, students were able to see firsthand how various farming practices can either harm or benefit the surrounding landscape. A discussion of our participation in the ecotourism model followed our return. Students were able to make connections between the local economy, tourism opportunities, and sustainable practices that would contribute to a cleaner water supply for the community. The following is an excerpt from a student’s daily reflection: Over the past few days we learned that the famous exports from Costa Rica, such as bananas, coffee, and pineapple, have been much of the reason behind the deforestation. I could relate much of these practices to the U.S. I was saddened to learn about how much of the rain forest was destroyed for something as simple as a banana. I loved that January/February 2010 19 we were able to fight back with a reforestation project. I plan on doing projects such as this one when teaching environmental science. Following the first service-learning project, we spent time developing the ideas of composting, tying the concept in with the decomposition rates on the rain forest floor. Students compared the fertility of the soil found in the local area with other areas of the world and explored reasons for the differences. Students were asked to determine what the fertility of the soil (or lack thereof) would mean for the average farmer. We also discussed nutrient cycling and the connection between nutrient cycling and composting. Finally, we began a comparison study of the educational systems of the United States and Costa Rica. Our next service project involved spending a day at a local school. There, students constructed a compost bin and a vegetable garden. The vegetables that were grown in the garden would be used to feed the school children lunch. For many of the local children, this meal is the only one they have each day. Waste generated from serving lunch would be composted in the new compost bin, and eventually the compost would be used on the vegetable garden. Thus, the students were able to visualize this cycling of material from garden to table to compost, and back to garden again. It was an oppressively hot day, and the tools we had to complete our task were few. Most of the students had little experience performing such demand- ing manual labor under such difficult conditions. However, many students expressed to me a great sense of accomplishment and pride after finishing this project. They also enjoyed interacting with the young Costa Rican students and learned much about the local culture. Below is a representative quote from a student’s daily reflection: What an eye-opening experience that was! It made me think about how much I take things for granted, along with other U.S. citizens. I couldn’t have been happier to help make a garden that would feed the kids there. Our final service project was planned for a local senior center and was meant FIGURE 2 Daily reflection rubric—graduates and undergraduates. Assignment is on time. (Grade will be lowered for late assignments.) Yes _________No __________ Adheres to format: All written assignments are to describe how your experiences for the day in question have affected you and how they can inform your teaching. Please include your name and a title, and staple the pages together. Yes _________No __________ A range A +Exceptionally high quality narrative with clear articulation of one or more experiences that affected the writer. Concise summary of applicability to teaching, clearly articulated attempt to link experiences or activities to the classroom. Demonstrates high-quality thinking that links daily experiences to overall environmental themes and driving questions. A –High professional quality writing that demonstrates the conventions of standard English, and not limited to clarity of expression, grammar, sentence structure, and spelling. B range B + Quality work with one or more experiences described. Fairly clear summary that contains some links to classroom practice. Demonstrates an attempt at linking daily experiences to overall environmental themes. B – Professional-quality writing that demonstrates the conventions of standard English, and not limited to clarity of expression, grammar, sentence structure, and spelling. C range C +Average work that may or may not articulate an overall theme(s), or may just provide summaries of daily events. Attempt to link daily experiences to overall environmental theme(s) and classroom practice is weak or nonexistent. Work appears to be done quickly with little articulated thought. C – Low-quality writing that demonstrates the conventions of the English language. Yet, errors in grammar, spelling, and/or sentence structure are evident. Other 20 Journal of College Science Teaching Environmental Education and Service Learning in the Tropics to be similar to the two service projects described previously. The senior center had planned for us to create a small garden for them and to paint some of their outbuildings. However, tropical climate being what it is, the rain kept us from completing the project on the day it was scheduled, and our itinerary was not flexible enough to reschedule. I am hopeful that my next group of students will be able to complete this project. Course goals are listed in Figure 1. Objectives listed under each goal served as the means by which the goal was planned to be attained. Assessment of the degree to which course goals were met was measured through four aspects: participation, daily reflections, a comprehensive exam, and a unit plan covering forest ecology/tropical ecology content. Daily reflections consisted of written narratives with a clear articulation of one or more experiences that occurred on a given day that affected the writer. Students were expected to include a concise summary of applicability to science teaching, as well as a clearly articulated attempt to link experiences or activities to the classroom. In these narratives, students were expected to demonstrate high-quality thinking that linked daily experiences to overall global environmental themes (see rubric in Figure 2). Students performed very well on this assessment. Daily scores ranged from 7 to 10 points on a 10-point scale. Using the knowledge gained in the course, students were also required to design an exemplary unit that would engage students in a grade level of their choosing. The activities in the unit explored important ecological concepts related to forest ecology, sustainability, and/or global forest resource use. A service-learning component was required to be included in the plan. Students were given two weeks upon return to the United States to complete this assignment. The average score on this assignment was Sarah Haines Course assessment Students planting buffer at a local farm. 83%. See Figure 3 for a description of this assignment. The comprehensive exam was administered just prior to departure from Costa Rica and was written in standard essay format. Topics covered included ecological succession, layers of the rain forest, symbiosis, agricultural practices, factors affecting plant growth, plant adaptations, and the relationship between geography and climate. The average score was 75%. Sample questions included the following: 1.Discuss the distinct life zones of the tropical rain forest as characterized by the particular varieties of plant and animal life. 2.A farmer wants to clear a section of rain forest to plant corn. Explain whether or not this would be a sustainable enterprise, and why. 3.This course has provided many opportunities for experiencing and learning about different examples of sustainable development and ecotourism. What do we mean when we use these terms? How does it benefit the Costa Rican government? The Costa Rican people? The environment? Give an example that you experienced. Student responses to the course Students reacted well to the course content and rigor. Many of them had very limited travel experience abroad, and most expressed a desire to return to Costa Rica to become more fluent in the Spanish language or to travel to other locations to carry out service-learning projects. After returning home, some students expressed a desire to continue to assist the school we had visited by sending supplies or equipment. Many seemed to realize the magnitude of the ecological footprints we leave on our environment and how differing practices and social norms between countries such as the United States and Costa Rica can affect our resource use (and misuse). Following are a few sample answers to questions appearing on the course evaluation form along with student excerpts from daily reflections: Evaluation form question: What aspects of the course did you particularly enjoy? Interaction with the Costa Rican people. I have never met a culture so dedicated to protecting and preserving their environment. January/February 2010 21 FIGURE 3 Forest ecology/environmental education unit plan guidelines—graduates and undergraduates. Using the knowledge you have gained in this course, you are to design an exemplary unit that will teach students in a grade level of your choosing important ecological concepts related to forest ecology, sustainability, and/or global forest resource use. • Your unit plan will be due two weeks after our return to the United States. • Please number each page in your unit. • Include a cover sheet with the title of your unit, your name, and course title. UNIT PLAN FORMAT Part I. Rationale (1- to 2-page narrative) • What scientific content and processes do you want your children to learn? • What kinds of activities will you use to teach the scientific content and processes? • How will you integrate other subject areas into your lessons? • How do you plan to meet the needs of students with different talents and abilities? • Why is it important for your students to know this information or to know how to use this skill? Part II. Daily Lesson Plans • Include at least five individual lesson plans based on the content discussed in Part I. • Follow the lesson plan format discussed earlier. • Include any teacher-created activity sheets you will use to guide students during lessons. Part III. Assessment (1 page) • How will you assess the material taught in the entire unit? • What will the students have to do with the new information? • How will you determine if the students learned the information you taught? • What forms of informal assessment will you use? • What kinds of checklists or rubrics will you use to assess learning? SCIENCE LESSON PLAN FORMAT Date Grade Level/Subject I. Science Topic Addressed What science topic are you teaching in this lesson? II. Rationale/Applications to Real Life This is where you state your rationale for teaching the lesson. Why should the students learn what you are teaching? How does this information affect them in their everyday lives? III. Scientific Content/Processes Addressed What science content or science-process skills will the students use to learn what you are teaching? IV. Objectives What do you expect the students to do or get from the lesson? V. National Science Education Standards Addressed Write out the entire standard and explain how your topic coordinates with this standard. For example: Life Science: Content Standard C As a result of activities in grades K–4, all students should develop understanding of • The characteristics of organisms • Life cycles of organisms • Organisms and environments VI. Procedure A. Description of discrepant event/introductory activity How will you focus the students’ attention before starting thelesson? B.Instructional materials needed What kinds of things do you need, and how much? C. Safety Are there any safety issues to address? D. Detailed description of activities Describe what the students will do, step by step. E. Typical questions you will ask students When will you ask them? F.Assessment/Evaluation How will you tell if the students learned what you taught? VII. Expected Conclusion What should the students observe or find out from this lesson? What are some possible outcomes if your activity is an openended one with many correct answers? This is where you convince me you know the science you are teaching. 22 Journal of College Science Teaching Environmental Education and Service Learning in the Tropics Helping the community through our service-learning projects and connecting those projects to forest ecology issues. I learned how rewarding community service is. Evaluation form question: What activities had the greatest impact on you? Going to the school. I loved being able to help the school feed the neighborhood children. Working at the school. It really made me think about global responsibility. Seeing how the children at the school are educated and fed really made me want to help them more. I was so happy to go to the school and share in the culture with the young students. I am determined to learn more Spanish now. Evaluation form question: How will you apply this experience to the classroom or to your future career? I plan to expand students’ understanding of the many different ecosystems of the world and how each one is somehow connected. Understanding the planet as a whole is so important to all of us. I intend to make more connections between our lives in the U.S. and how we affect other areas of the world. This is going to be much easier to do and I will be able to make real comparisons now that I have been to Costa Rica. The following was written by a student four months after returning from the trip: I am still slightly obsessed with our whole abroad experience . . . Not only did I learn all about the environment in ways that I never thought of before but I was pushed outside my comfort zone . . . I use the skills and experience from that trip in a lot of aspects of my life still! Just the other day in a class we were talking about issues that we dealt with in Costa Rica and I got to speak and give firsthand knowledge of what I did! I would recommend this abroad experience to anyone! We did so many things in such a short span of time it was so exciting! Conclusion Incorporating a service-learning component into postsecondary science courses can be a highly effective method to increase student awareness of many issues that are of both global and local importance, whether teaching a course for science majors or nonmajors. In keeping with the results suggested here, Tan and Phillips (2005) reported that computer science students participating in service-learning projects felt a greater sense of professional responsibility upon completion of the project. As college and university science instructors, we need to provide students with opportunities to interact with people and agencies outside of the classroom so that they can gain a more global perspective to their studies and see how the content they are learning is related to the world outside the classroom. As more instructors utilize the service-learning approach, we will be better able to produce the type of scientifically literate citizens that the world will require in the years to come. References American Forest Foundation. 2006. Project Learning Tree secondary environmental education program. The changing forest: Forest ecology. 2nd ed. Washington, DC: American Forest Foundation. American Forest Foundation. 2007. Project Learning Tree preK-8 environmental education activity guide. Washington, DC: American Forest Foundation. Boyle-Baise, M., R. Brown, M. Hsu, D. Jones, A. Prakash, M. Rausch, S. Vitols, and Z. Wahlquist. 2006. Learning service or service learning: Enabling the civic. International Journal of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education 18 (1): 17–26. Ernst, J. 2007. Factors influencing K–12 teachers’ use of environment-based education. The Journal of Environmental Education 38 (3): 15–32. Ernst, J., and M. Monroe. 2004. The effects of environment-based education on students’ critical thinking skills and disposition toward critical thinking. Environmental Education Research 10 (4): 507–522. Fredericks, L., E. Kaplan, and J. Zeisler. 2001. Integrating youth voice in service learning. Denver, CO: Education Commission of the States. Handa, V., D. Tippins, N. Thomson, P. Bilbao, L. Morano, B. Hallar, and K. Miller. 2008. A dialogue of life: Integrating service learning in a community-immersion model of preservice science teacher preparation. Journal of College Science Teaching 37 (6): 14–20. Haines, S.A. 2003. Incorporating service learning components into biology education. Journal of College Science Teaching 32 (7): 440–442. Kalivas, J. 2008. A service learning project based on a research supportive curriculum format in the general chemistry laboratory. Journal of Chemical Education 85 (10): 1410–1415. Kaye, C.B. 2004. The complete guide to service learning: Proven practical ways to engage students in civic responsibility, academic curriculum and social action. Minneapolis, MN: Free Spirit Publishing. Kravetz, K. 2006. Transforming communities: The role of service learning in a community studies course. International Journal of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education 18 (1): 49–56. Tan, J., and J. Phillips. 2005. Incorporating service learning into computer science courses. Journal of Computing Science in Colleges 20 (4): 57–62. Sarah Haines ([email protected]) is an associate professor in the Department of Biological Sciences at Towson University in Towson, Maryland. January/February 2010 23
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz