Brigham Young University BYU ScholarsArchive All Theses and Dissertations 1984 The Incidence of Obesity in LDS College Women: The Effect of Selected Physical SocioEnvironmental Variables on total Percent Body Fat in Two Populations of LDS Women Carrie Tanner Summers Brigham Young University - Provo Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd Part of the Dietetics and Clinical Nutrition Commons, Medical Sciences Commons, and the Mormon Studies Commons BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Summers, Carrie Tanner, "The Incidence of Obesity in LDS College Women: The Effect of Selected Physical Socio-Environmental Variables on total Percent Body Fat in Two Populations of LDS Women" (1984). All Theses and Dissertations. Paper 5152. This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in All Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected]. rvv L k 3.02 302 THE INCIDENCE OF OBESITY IN LDS COLLEGE WOMEN EFFECT OF SELECTED PHYSICAL SOCIO VARIABLES TWO ON TOTAL A environmental PERCENT BODY FAT PAT IN populations OF LDS WOMEN I s thes thesis 1 presented to the department of health sciences brigham young university in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree master of science by carrie tanner summers august 1984 THE 4 this thesis present form young by by carrie tanner summers is accepted in its is the department of health sciences of brigham university as satisfying the thesis requirement for the degree of master of science IA robert burgener A I1 C date committe commltfee commit4e chairman ron L rhodes committee member ron L rhodes department chairman 7 acknowledgements deep appreciation is expressed to those who toward the completion of lent so much this thesis special thanks Is offered to dr robert burgener and dr ronald rhodes for their continuing encouragement and guidance throughout this project peterson thanks is also given to joyce peerson and prepare this thesis who helped type in final form finally gratitude is offered to the authors parents and husband ray this thesis could for without their continual love and support never have been written table of contents page I edgements acknow acknowledgements edge ments I1 1 list list of tables 0 0 9 0 0 ID 9 iiI i 1 vi vi 0 of figures vi vii vilI 1 chapter 1 introduction 1 statement of the problem nu nuilI null I 1 1 hypothesis 0 0 0 0 alternate hypothesis delimitations 0 0 0 0 2 0 2 0 2 9 0 0 definition of terms 2 review of literature 0 9 9 0 16 9 0 0 as fs a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Is 0 0 0 10 4 4 theories of obesity 6 selfconcept self concept 7 obesity and measuring obesity related studies procedures on G obesity 0 0 10 0 0 sequence of events i agn gn design research des 0 0 0 0 0 iv 0 Is 0 7 0 0 0 0 8 0 0 0 6 0 0 0 a 0 Is 12 9 0 0 4 0 12 0 0 0 0 0 9 12 0 0 16 0 0 0 6 13 0 0 & 8 8 0 0 14 0 ID 0 0 0 0 15 0 0 Is 0 0 0 Is 0 0 0 0 0 0 & 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 10 0 0 0 0 0 16 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 conclusions and recommendations analysis of data 0 0 population and sample 4 0 3 causes of obesity obesity and health 3 2 Is 0 0 0 0 0 9 chapter 5 page paae daae summary conclusions and recommendations summary of the findings conclusions Is recommendations I ography bibliography B I1 b I1 1 0 0 0 40 0 0 19 0 10 0 0 Is 0 0 41 9 0 0 0 ID 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 27 21 if 27 0 Is 29 29 31 appendices A questionnaire B nomogram 354 4 e v Is 0 0 1 1 0 Is 9 0 0 0 0 0 39 59 list of tables page tab ie tabie table 1 the relationship between total percent fat and age height and weight 0 2 an analysis of variance between age percent body fat Is 3 an 0 9 an 7 0 0 0 0 G relationship between snack foods body fat 0 0 0 0 0 and 0 0 0 19 0 total 0 0 0 0 analysis of variance between weight total percent body fat percent 6 0 0 0 5 0 Is and analysis of variance between height total tota percent body fat I1 4 0 body 0 0 0 6 10 0 21 0 0 0 0 0 22 and 0 0 and 0 23 0 total 0 0 24 1 the relationship between total percent body fat and major among women attending BYU and CSUF 25 the relationship between irregular menstrual cycle and total percent body fat 0 vi vl 0 26 list of figures page figure 1 relationship between age group body 2 3 fat 0 0 0 0 0 9 S and 0 0 relationship between height group percent body fat a 0 0 0 0 vl vil vii 0 0 0 0 10 0 1 0 Is 0 9 0 17 0 0 19 0 9 20 49 0 total and 0 0 total and relationship between weight group percent body fat total percent 0 0 0 0 0 diapter diaster CHAPTER ONE introduction peoplet obesity Is not solely for most people nutritional problem nor one of genetic susceptibility lifestyle consisting of patterns a problem of a medical or it becomes of eating and physical activity 16 in the affluence beauty and health was a mark of referred to as now the word a behavior maladjustment obesitym obesity Is derived from to eat carrying with however trait longer regard obesity as a positive we no is nineteenth century excess weight in a person it today instead 8 over ob last 20 old assumption that obesity the centuries centuriesold 3 the simplest definition of obesity Is there Is when 28 it only years has evidence begun to accumulate which contra- dicts this unitary concept which edere and Is a single entity due to the single cause of overeating in the it an a condition in excessive amount of body fat specifically exceeds 20 to 25 percent body fat for males and 25 to percent body fat for females are involved with obesity involving physiological it 168 because other factors faceted problem is clearly a multi multifaceted psychological and cultural factors 168 many studies have been done in a variety of areas related 2 esty ob esly to obesity esty I ege co college I1 1 esly unfortunately though research involving ob obesity I f Ic an andd a spec specific women 1 ame y th re 19 on nnameiy namely religion church urch of thee ch 1I 1 jesus christ of latterday latter day saints this study reason was 1 1I are limited LDS undertaken using college LDS for this women as subjects statement of the problem the purpose of the study Is to determine if there Is a difference between total percent body fat selected physical and socio environmental variables gathered from a demographic question- naire nuil hypothesis null there Is between no significant difference at total percent body fat environmental variables among provo utah university at Ful fui fullerson fullerton leron fulleron BYU and alpha level selected physical socio college and 05.05 05 women at brigham young california state university california CSUF alternate hypothesis there Is between significant difference at a total percent body fat environmental variables among provo utah university at Ful erton fu fui leron fullerson fulleron I1 1I BYU CSUF and alpha level saclo selected physical soclo college and .05 05 05 women at brigham young california state university I f orn I a ca california 1I 1 1 dellmlalons the study sudy Is confined 0too utah white whie single whle women single attending brigham LDS college young women university LDS cal and cai ifornia california sae college white whie whle attending california state university 3 a fui ful at fullerton leron definition of terms LDS person A who Is a member of the church of jesus day saints latterday christ of latter california CSUF women have lived the last college 10 LDS women time 858.5 85 credit hours 25 to 28 attending an accumulation of BYU or CSUF as full fat tissue which exceeds percent of body weight in females as a percentage of the Sk sklnfold skinfold infold the amount of fat in the total Call caliper cail per A pinching device designed to measure millimeters fat beneath the skin by cambridge utah 10 scientific industries BYU women body expressed body weight in LDS women lange calipers manufactured were used in attending BYU this study who have lived years in the state of utah institute by CSUF who students percent body fat the last attending years in the state of california women obesity LDS women religion auxiliary institution sponsored the church of jesus christ of latterday latter day saints which offers classes in of religious study CHAPTER TWO review of literature obesity has been referred to of the twentieth century it problem was valued as a mark of affluence beauty this Is not the case today weight carry a negative stigma sigma lean it new was 100 prior to the twentieth century adiposity fatty however 8 although obesity Is not a 8 Is being recognized as such more than years ago tissue the health problem by many as and underweight as and health overeating and excess the trend now designates slim the acceptable criteria of beauty causes of obesity while the underlying causes of obesity are unknown of exercise may be a major contributor there Is america and other developed countries to eat too when one reaches middle age 811 people who a tendency in much especially overeat and are not their excess active are often the victims of creeping obesity the result of modern sedentary lifestyles body weight Is lack 68 endocrine problems are a rare but occasional cause of obesity only two to five percent of all obesity endocrine disorders age both may activity be a results from 8 factor in obesity and basal metabolic patterns remain constant 19 4 rate in the may elderly person decrease while eating 5 cultural factors also play associated with Is still good in fellowship and in associated with affluence hereditary to obesity societies obesity some 1316 bred to produce more or less fat it Is believed genetic factors them foods are often genetic factors are increasingly implicated and just as animals are obesity role a 16823 families predispose in some seventy seventyfive five percent of overweight children have at least one overweight parent most obesity Is to satisfy related to overeating out of habit or other than physical hunger react to emotional stress with group may to eat some need food has become something or satisfaction 16 a feeling they need that imparts individuals need help such in to deal with their problems without overeating a sense of security feeling adequate attention to 16823 emotional problems must precede any dieting it the latter 6 difficult to cure than cancer 8 it has even been suggested that obesity cannot be on ed much like ke al onlyy control onlyy 15 to cured but on cohol sm alcoholism ilke controlled has been said obesity Is more 1I 25 I1 1I 1I percent of those who it off for at least one 3819 and then some 1I try to lose weight are successful in losing the desired amount and keeping year 1I there Is a completely different viewpoint health professionals contend that certain people can be chronically overweight but otherwise healthy these individuals should be permitted to be plump rather than become anxious about a few extra pounds 1611 6 theonies theories of obesity psychodynamic psychodynamic formulations of obesity are conceptualized as beginning in infancy and caused rejection by feeling of by a fundamental the mother towards her child because of these strong feelings of rejection the mother attempts to compensate by over overprotective protective behaviors toward her child including excessive the mother Is perceived as responding to feeding needs by the giving of food a 11 the childs 19 externality persons penson research has indicated that the obese person behavior is primarily determined by internal cues of hunger and 19 by eating external cues rather then lons of this theory ions implications the impi ications icat the research cited in its support are that obese persons are not only more sensitive in their eating behavior to cues such as the smell and cues and taste of foody food the salience of the food the effort involved in obtaining the food but that obese persons are also more responsive than normal weight persons to external cues in general experimental findings suggest that the obese are more distractible ibie and are more responsive to distract ible variety of highly salient external cues a 19 learning learning theory explanations of obesity have centered around the concept of eating as a highly overlearned habit has generalized to a variety of environmental cues and of emotional arousal 19 that states 7 taIon lalon imitation learning or modeling Is another influence considered Im important in the obese initial learning later maintenance of the the repeated opportunity to observe other persons state one family overeat in ones and andor eat in response to cues unrelated to hunger results in the child learning this pattern may be or social approval similar eating pattern further maintained through parental reinforcement 19 Self Concept selfconcept there Is a little and obe obesity selfconcept self concept argument against the axiom Is a significant variable in human individuals an behavior acceptance of himself Is positively and significantly correlated with his acceptance of others his own body process how an individual perceives has an important influence on his behavior and his reaction to the environment which is a 10 the formation of the body image vital part of the total self concept Is a complex 15 evidence from related studies shows feelings about the body image are similar to feelings about the self correlates with but with emotional body which stress selfrejecting self rejecting individual negative concepts about ones does not cause and anxiety so a negative body a usually bring about feelings of insecurity and inadequacy ultimately influence selfconcept self concept and performance predisposing factors to functional disorders such as obesity 15 obesity and health obesity complicates and may predispose to many serious 8 health problems including diabetes hypertension varicose veins diseases of the digestive system cerebral hemorrhage and circulatory 16811 collapse Is itself a research suggests that some some obesity disease because of the metabolic differences and non obese persons nonobese a symptom of a in obese other studies reveal obesity as merely disease 68 measuring obesity for years most people have solely depended upon now weight charts to determine proper height heightweight research has shown inadequate when life insurance company added frame to the height welgot welght weight charts heightweight size and weight ranges more accurate and could measure the so called socalled for each category by a they became way general appearance pinching method to diagnose obesity Is to consider and subcutaneous fat as estimated anthropometric measurements with sk skinfold infold 8 calipers measure width in skinfold millimeters of sk infold at various arm mid upper trtcep midupper at tricep the the tricea ie A percentage of bone hip above the 812 iliac body sites Is obtained by triceps value using a nomogram appendix in the the third column by weight ideal 1113 the most practical weight recent weight height weight charts are heightweight in many cases metropolitan body a first percent column with body B by and suprabody fat aligning the supraillac the suprailiac suprai subrai lac value in fat value can be determined reading where the straight edge crosses the middle column for example a female who measures 21mm at the supraillac suprailiac crosses the supralltac 26 at the tricep tricea and 25mm percent body fat mark in the 9 center column this with ats kith hts percentage of considered obese 2 densimetry body fat she underwater weighing the precise calculation of the fraction of the by 201 fat 211 method permits body weight represented although anthropometric measurement Is the simplest for evaluating obesity densimetry Is related studies many would be on accurate 219 more obesity studies have been completed using socio environmental factors as predictors of obesity there are three reasons be considered in why the social environment should the control of obesity first social forces play a very important part in producing and maintaining obesity despite increases second in of individual obese persons to be desired the effectiveness of the treatment this treatment sti still leaves 1I 1I much third modifying the social environment has already produced substantial benefits in the control of obesity and the lessons thus can be applied even more widely 19 epiderniologic epidemlologic studies of obesity that have included socioeconomic status indicate that social strong determinants of obesity and economic factors are as garn has stated involve measures of soctoeconomic socioeconomic status we socloeconcmic find further problems with a simple genetic explanation for poor boys and poor girls are leaner than those more when we generalized to poor men as well but in adulthood it Is the poor woman who Is fatter and the rich woman who Is leaner and fatness decreases linearly with increasing income in women if the level of fatness follows socioeconomic status or educational level in such a circuitous way then it Is difficult to credit a purely genetic explanation at the present time breed lean women nearly outbreed obese women in the united states ou 20 21 since this indicates that our now nowfat fat country Is on its way to becoming fatter we need to find out why 18 180 affluent and this statement may be 10 I rst ev I dence of evidence the ffinst first 1 1 influences obesity was Ilarge I ronment I a ange sca arge aca env rosment benv lange the iange environment largescale scalee soc social how obtained 1 by 1I striking association the results of the study women were obese social class and class no more than 16 5 among women percent among percent in the upper social the influence of socioeconomic status social class of their parents it was longer a persons family had been in to the was more prevalent also the case that the this country the less likely 1724 be obese 70 196870 the ten state nutrition survey of 1968 showed that was more common among white than among black men but the opposite true for was the level of in adolescents women obesity in affect the incidence but for both black and white was more older associated with 3 income did not levels were associated with groups class mobile subjects than those who remained in the among downwardly women 324 those of middle analyses of this study demonstrated that obesity obesity and survey of midtown mcdown manhattan enabled causal influences mtdown be drawn about he was status 24 A to to this study 30 percent of lower that showed compared 317 between socioeconomic particularly the prevalence of obesity 1 town study a comprehensive midtown the mid survey of the epidemiology of mental illness showed a I1 1 women a lower level of men of obesity lower income obesity in younger prevalent in the lower socioeconomic both black and white a lower prevalence of lower income was obesity 319 religious affiliation is yet another social factor linked 11 to obesity 324 prevalence of obesity and the midtown manhattan study the greatest in protestants was among jews among protestants the pattern the largest amount of obesity explained by roman followed further was was found among with a decreasing prevalence among methodists episcopalians catholics baptists Baptis tst Luth erans and lutherans 17 studies on the incidence of obesity are practically non existent nonexistent college students among there is but one study done at boston university in 1969 wherein health records of 2343 students ty nc dence of obes obesity the incidence i I i zed and were ut utilized I1 1I 1 1I I cu I was ca abed ated calculated 1 1 the researchers compared majors of obese students to see iff there were any the results suggested correlations between obesity and major incidence of obesity there were ty obes obesity i no regarding the LDS relationship field with philosophy having the highest 14 other studies done I ege women among co college 1I a 1 ing and noth nothing on the incidence of at aall ali ail has been done I1 1I religion al ail of the socio environmental studies suggest all that with increasing affluence social attitudes fads social class level one social of acculturation and religion all major aspects of ones I1 environment are strongly related to obesity 24 CHAFTER THREE CHAPTER procedures the purpose of the study a was difference between total percent to determine if there fat body and was selected physical socio environmental variables gathered from a demographic question- naire end sample population and the population of this study consisted of al all ali ail 1I students enrolled in semester 1984 of religion was all and at CSUF classes at PE 177 BYU during winter quarter 1984 administered to 316 BYU women and 130 female during the winter at the institute female students enrolled LDS LDS A questionnaire CSUF women sequence of events the instrument used for data collection was a 20 lem item iem researcher the questionnaire the questionnaire for final approval was was reviewed by appendix pilot study at was by the the graduate faculty brigham young university refined after faculty input brigham young university was this study multiple choice questionnaire designed of the department of health sciences A in and resubmitted A conducted in two health classes at 25 women participated the pilot study intended to expose any major flaws in the questionnaire 12 13 the researcher evaluated the pilot questionnaires and found one question consistently answered incorrectly was modified slightly was by adding this question choices to narrow the possibilities of not understanding the question appendix question A 16 along with the questionnaire each subject was given using lange sk skinfold sklnfold infold calipers infold test a sk sklnfold skinfold measured by the researcher on the this data and was recorded on were then appi appl applied led percent of total to CSUF were given the researcher to calculate the B questionnaire infold test and a sk skinfold sklnfold subjects enrolled at by BYU in PE the 177 first week of january the sk sklnfold skinfold tests taken in january were all administered infold qualified instructors and taken on with lange sk sklnfold skinfold calipers infold the right tricep tricea and were involved in while taking was used suprailiac supraillac suprai subrai lac these previous measurements were used as a baseline measurement for the exercise programs B by questionnaire and asked to transfer their sk skinfold sklnfold infold measurements which had been taken during the 1984 these measurements subjects at the institute of religion in march 1984 were given the appendix supralltac supraillac right suprailiac and fat in february 1984 at tr1cep right tricep tricea the questionnaire a nomogram body each female was PE 177 to calculate total percent the body women same nomogram appendix fat research design since this study Is descriptive research there Is this situation tuckman recommends ex post facto design specifically co expost corelational relational 22 this manipulation of variables an no design Is diagrammed below in 14 YI CSUF 01 oi Y YI1 BYU 02 ya y22 CSUF 05 03 ya y2 BYU 04 ya y3 yj CSUF 05 ya y3 BYU OB 06 where Y yj aj age YZ height ya y33 weight CSUF 0 01 03 05 BYU 0 02 04 05 percent body ffat at percent body fat only those variables proving to be significant 06 05 placed when into interaction with all other variables remained in the final prediction equations the research variables are 1 environmental enviromental selected physical socio envlronmenal independent variables 2 dependent percent 3 moderator Y yj aj age YZ height ya y33 weight body fat ond recommendations rac mendat conclusions and ionS mendations lons conclusions and recommendations were formulated as function of the data collected and analyzed by means of a sion the data was analyzed lowed followed fol fourway four way analysis of co covariance variance foi the hypotheses were tested at the .05 05 05 a by regres- level of significance CHAPTER FOUR analysis of data daa the purpose of this study a was to determine if there difference in obesity using total percent physical socio environmental variables on brigham young university of fullerton A tered to CSUF institute california infold test classes PE 177 of religion for and utah 10 was adminis- and 130 CSUF only those females or more years remained due to the imbalance of race and marital the final study status among the two universities single women both having lived ived in these were narrowed to white their respective state for 1I or more years the final sample consisted of white nonwhite all non and 105 CSUF women 84 BYU women and married women were excluded the study due to the imbalance from there three possible explanations for the large were number of women dropped from 1 naire for selected attending and sk sktnfold skinfold A females enrolled in BYU having lived in 10 LDS women and california state university and questionnaire appendix 316 fat CSUF females attending in BYU body was the BYU many were unknown women the BYU were not sample fully completing the question- excluding the socioeconomic status question reasons therefore these subjects were dropped from the study due to this incompletion 15 16 there were 2 than attending school BYU women CSUF women there were 3 were more married more minorities attending BYU than there CSUF this chapter Is devoted to the statistical analysis the computer program used the data collected designed to was baci faci analysis of any data with unequal sample sizes libate facilitate litate analysts program developed statistical penn at state university by norman nye package for the social sciences analysis of co covariance variance followed by SPSS regression of A was used this Is called fourway four way to obtain the data the data computed in the following manner by SPSS 1 will be presented and analyzed grams will scattergrams scatergrams scatter be presented to indicate relationships between the variables of age height weight grams scattergrams scatter analysis of these scatergrams 2 statistical data and their and accompanying presentation of tables including analysis 3 of variance to determine if there were any significant relationships between the variables and and total percent saI body fat analysis of the sal statistical sIcal information as and 4 discussion it relates to I ab es the var variables 1 1I figure between 1 scatergram Is a scattergram scatter gram which presents the relationships total percent body fat down and age group across the data were arranged so that the higher age measurements corresponded with the higher percent of body at the 0.05 005 level figure fat the value 0000 Is significant of confidence indicating a high correlation 2 Is a gram scattergram scatergram scatter which plots the relationship 17 figure 3 LL relationship 0 L percent C 0 0 total ul sz cl CL W 000 OOL 006 0 rs 03 at apt T 0017 iff 8 00 1 ac 8c n CD 1 4- a Q between L0 age group CD CY CL eat fat CD li 0 008 ooo OOG body 0 a n wao IC pi g 00 ooz booz r ch oo 00 ea rv Nr ooo 009 6 ooo 000 CD m n a1 o 0 cv rd com coc 0 x N az 9z n arf rrf ru n ru r Z ru z 1 0 cit it 0 0 IV nc ry nc M r nam ram ir ru H- rrf nc arf Iz oz omm oz9 z N 000 oon OOL APAP colw 001 m n 006 vc n oom OOG n apercent C body 0 nc tfo9 ryo afo cmob nob 8 aDOa ooz booz ooo 006 aue aan 03 ac 4c arx ale cy fat rx chr chtL ooo 009 TZ cy oo o00 6 o6 hcd 6bcd r com coc 000 mma ama G if CD ell 1I V 9 t 18oo00 figure 0 a 4 0C U relationship cr 1 mor CIL mol 2 m group height 1 1 3 between co percent body a 0 0 fat 1 Lu and total 0 0 08 0rL CD ittr S ooo 000 bit y atop ftop S oot ftp itp co CL UC S 00 1 n OD BE oam 008 con oor cor 00c cd to m ic n OD r n AVE ri 006 009 t 0 if az 4z 1rd n o ra ooo 000 00c 0 G it 1 CD v197u 19 L C cpin cinc CM vr ru fisi fili fiig nc X n 9o 0 G Z rvin M cno9 neni neri G airi G riri rnc hch 6 6ach 9om f fr Z orv 9ocv icv odd 9odt oft U 4 L n denoig dnoig mry ncy mcd ake ale rv cpin cloc 9 edl eel edlo delo r 0 t iv zeb leb b iV 1 1I V 3 V v V U c 1I V 0 ooo 000 m balf bflf s- 0 cor cob r oolp colp 00 1IIF 1 aa n 0 0 0 0 009 008 ic n n 1fc percent CL 0 oon td be M body fa 0 ooo 006 VZ M 0 0 0091z OOCBT ry trl tri iri ooo 000 G 1I 19 between total percent the data fat body down and height group that the shorter height shows across measurements correspond fat the significant value of 0004 correlation at the 05 level of confidence between with the higher percent body indicates body fat a high height and figure between gnam which plots the relationship scattergram Is a scatergram scatter gram 3 total percent fat body down and weight group across the data explains the smaller weight measurements correspond fat with smaller body that there Is a very high fat between body table A 1 0.000 0000 indicates significance value of oooo correlation at the .05 05 05 level of confidence and weight presents the relationships between the moderator variables age height and weight and the dependent variable total percent body fat the alternate hypothesis states there Is a significant difference at the .05 05 05 level of confidence between selected physical socio environmental variables body fat at BYU and CSUF and total percent this hypothesis Is accepted at the 0.05 005 level of confidence table 1 the relationship between total percent and age height and weight moderator variable age height weight F ratio 8.575583 8575583 12.90713 1290713 132.3914 1323914 significance at 0.05 005 level of confidence body fat significance of 0.000 0000 0.004 0004 oooo 0.000 0000 F 20 keight group between weight relationship total tota percent and 008 O 0 8 8 r I1 008 body 008 cid rid 08 0in 08 0 OD m ai m B eat fat 80 lh 080 00 0 ro N 200 180 176 176180 171 175 171175 166 170 166170 rj 161 165 161165 156 160 156160 151 155 151155 0 146 50 150 1461 146150 1 1 U cd rd 141 145 141145 cv ru cv 3 140 136 136140 CU CU 131 155 135 131155 131135 meea m rd cm 126 130 126130 rv rvru ruru CU 12 121 125 121125 1 rd ard rd nrd cv n ru cd 116 120 116120 M 111 1111 15 1 106 110 106110 101 105 101105 rd 00 0 ai 00 0 0 00 0 0 4 percent body fat 00 0 N cv 96 100 96100 rd 00 21 table females age 2 shows and the relationship which exists between the total percent fat she contains body 005 level alternate hypothesis Is accepted at the 0.05 with an F 0.000 0000 significance of oooo a the of confidence the acceptance of this alternate hypothesis indicates a strong relationship between age and total percent body fat the range years with a was 18 30 1830 mean age of 20 table 2 analysis of variance between age and total percent body fat an percent age 18 20 1820 38 24 20.1 201 127 12.7 127 19.69 1969 20.73 2073 24.58 2458 L 5 189 100.0 1000 22.200 22200 2219 22.19 2219 21 total F significance body 667 66.7 667 126 22 2122 23 25 2325 26 30 2630 mean of sample N fat clio 0.000 0000 significance at 0.05 005 level of confidence table 3 shows between height and the positive relationship which exists total percent body fat the alternate hypothesis Is accepted at the 0.05 005 level of confidence with strong relationship between height and total percent the range 61411 with a mean 4101161411 was 41011 table and significance the acceptance of this alternate hypothesis indicates of 0.004 0004 a an F 4 shows total percent at the 0.05 005 level body height of body fat 51511 the relationship which exists between weight fat the alternate hypothesis Is accepted of confidence with an F significance of 0.000 0000 22 table an analysis of variance between height and total percent body fat percent height in inches 4044 4548 48 45 454.8 4548 494.11 49 411 49411 50 54 505.4 5054 55 58 555.8 5558 595.11 59 511 59511 60 64 606.4 6064 total 4044 40 404.4 44 N of sample 3 3 4 lg ig 1.6 16 ig lg 1.6 16 21 2.1 21 122 12.2 122 23 lg ig 1.6 16 3 body 2219 22.19 2219 100.0 1000 189 total 18.00 1800 24.33 2433 26.50 2650 18.85 1885 19.13 1913 19.08 1908 18.66 1866 48.1 481 91 6064 mean 328 528 32.8 328 62 5054 5558 F 3 significance 0.004 0004 significance aat 0.05 005 level of confidence the acceptance of this al ernae hypothesis indicates alternate a strong relationship between weight and total percent was 96 200 96200 the range obesity the total sample when was not determined BYU mean body fat at the 0.05 005 level are considered the it trends was seem that was BYU and CSUF the incidence of obesity did have a lower percent of body fat CSUF percento percente with 22.48 2248 percent since 22.19 2219 percent there was no significance of confidence showing the sample populations same Is of interest to note from these results that several to appear of snack foods were asked individuals at was examined with 21.82 2182 percent compared to the fat pounds with a mean weight of 130 was found among but body the first the trend observed in this study women participating in the study to identify which foods they snacked on between meals fat 23 25 table an analysis of variance between weight and total percent body fat percent I ght we weight aht 1 in 4 lbs 100 96 96100 101 105 101105 110 106 106110 111 115 111115 120 116 116120 121 125 121125 130 126 126130 131 155 135 131155 131135 140 136 156 136140 156140 141 145 141145 150 146 146150 151 155 151155 160 156 156160 161 165 161165 170 166 166170 175 171 171175 176 180 176180 N of sample 8 5 42 4.2 26 2.6 53 55 74 7.4 74 127 12.7 127 17 go 90 9.0 10.1 101 toi lol 122 12.2 122 90 58 5.8 58 11.1 111 lii iii 37 57 3.7 5.7 37 57 58 5.8 58 26 2.6 26 7 11 5 5 5 20.18 2018 2219 22.19 2219 25.28 2528 26.72 2672 27.20 2720 28.60 2860 30.40 50.40 3040 5040 29.00 2900 28.50 2850 48.00 4800 22.19 2219 oooo 0.000 0000 26 26 26 2.6 26 2.6 .5 5 1 1.1 11 ll ii 2 1 J 100.0 1000 .5 5 189 fat 18.50 1850 19.00 1900 17.80 1780 19.50 1950 21.16 2116 18.63 18.65 1863 1865 21.47 2147 21.17 2117 53 55 5.5 5.3 10 14 24 19 23 25 21 total F significance icance signia signif acance body 42 26 11 200 mean significance at 005 level of confidence there were five categories they were asked to choose the results are listed in table it percent the utah women snacks it on body fat on fruit that the california known how long women had and vegetable snacks had a higher percent body Is not and 5 Is of interest to note a higher from these fat on fat women had and and sugar snack ing been snacking these foods the second trend observed in the study was the relationship 24 table 5 relationship between snack foods total percent body fat snack food body BYU vegetable sugar other at the 0.05 005 level of confidence those information it women who came body CSUF fat 28.33 2833 25.00 2500 22.00 2200 18.50 1850 20.46 2046 status between TPBF and socioeconomic although not significant provided some interesting from families whose yearly 20000 30000 had an average total percent 2000030000 income was between fat of 25.29 2529 percent women fat 22.44 2244 18.50 1850 29.13 2913 31.14 3114 24.00 2400 fruit fat body and in contrast to 18.50 1850 percent for those 100000 90000 900004100000 90000100000 whose famtliesv families yearly income was between this trend agrees with the studies that have been done on socioeconomic status and obesity there Is more obesity among those people of lower incomes than those of higher incomes the third trend that provided fat body fine arts obesity was found among also found among the those women in the humanities fields at both BYU and CSUF obesity those women at CSUF in the physical and and communications among mathematical sciences in interesting information the relationship between academic major and total percent was was some women in the lowest percent of biological and the field of physical education body fat agricultural sciences table was found and 6 shows a more also detailed 25 table 6 the relationship between total percent body fat and major among women attending BYU and CSUF academic major agricultural science biological education engineering science & technology family home social science fine arts & N BYU CSUF 8 19.75 1975 19.60 1960 23.50 2550 2350 22.83 2283 2285 25.50 2550 25.17 2517 ooo 0.00 000 20.33 2033 2035 20.50 2050 22.30 2230 19.23 1923 19.50 1950 20.69 2069 21 7 47 19 15 2 communications humanities nursing physical & mathematical sciences physical education non major nonmajor business 4 19 17 20 2300 21.96 2196 25.54 2554 25.44 2544 23.50 2350 27.00 2700 18.44 1844 21.65 2165 22.00 2200 I ty De noes obes denotes obesity 1 view of body fat the comparison between BYU 0.064 0064 confidence level it was relationship between was the closest of all trends with thus indicating that obese likely to have irregular menstrual cycles who had 12 times per year 1012 irregular periods 10 28.33 2833 percent of body fat in contrast to those to three irregularities per year body fat table category each categorys 7 TPBF although not significant at the irregular menstrual cycle 0.05 005 level of confidence more regarding total percent and academic major the last trend observed and and CSUF who had an women those are women had an average women with one average 21.52 2152 percent indicates the total percent body fat with 26 table 7 relationship between irregular menstrual cycle and total percent body fat irregularities per year N 133 66 26 1 46 4 6 7 9 12 10 1012 79 12 9 never Z total F significance 189 total percent body fat 21.52 2152 22.73 2273 2275 22.83 2283 28.33 2833 21.73 2173 2219 22.19 2219 0.064 0064 I ty obes denotes oberty obesty 1 CHAPTER FIVE summary conclusions and recommendations this chapter concludes the report a summary of of the study and presents the findings offers conclusion conclusionssp and makes recom- mendat mendations ions the findings summary of purpose CO the purpose of this study a difference was obesity using total percent in physical socio environmental variables young to determine if there university BYU on body fat LDS women was selected and attending brigham Ful leron california state university at fullerton and CSUF research procedure the study sample consisted of PE 177 classes religion each subject was asked naire and have fat and 105 CSUF women infold test a sk skinfold total percent nomogram appendix naire were fed into fat body 84 women BYU attending CSUF to complete institute of a 20 item iem lem question- to determine total percent was then calculated by means body of a al all ail answers to questions on the question- B 1I a VAX computer and analyzed way analysts then a four analysis of co fourway variance followed covariance was used led in enrol enrolled by a SPSS program by regression to test the data for significance at the 0.05 005 level I dence of conf confidence 1 27 28 finding summation signia signif icant significant icart relationship A 1 height weight and total percent was found between age fat these three variables were all statistically reliable at the 0.05 005 level of significance no significant relationship was found between irregular 2 menstrual cycle and total percent body fat at the 0.05 005 level a however body trend seems to appear indicating obese have women irregular menstrual cycles more no 3 significant relationship was found between snack 005 level of confidence fat at the 0.05 trend seems to appear at both universities no significant relationship was found between socio- foods and total percent body a however 4 status economic of confidence income total percent however no does indicate the lower the fat body significant relationship total percent 6 005 level fat at the 0.05 body this study the higher the percent of 5 and and body obesity 005 level fat at the 0.05 was found among but upon total population analysis at either university was found between major of confidence individuals at it was BYU and CSUF not found significant this Is because the total percent body fat averages did not exceed the standard criteria of 25 percent BYU was did have a lower average percent established that it 2182 fat with 21.82 body compared to CSUF with 22.48 2248 the combined average total percent body fat was 22.19 2219 which Is below the obesity eve level 1I 1I 29 conclusions based on the findings of this study the following conclusions were made body 1 age 2 the height and weight positively affect total percent fat than the enough at women at women CSUF BYU had a lower this difference total percent was body fat not significant to divide the population 3 irregular menstrual cycle closely approached significance I I I tyo 064 probabl probab 0.064 probability with th a 00064 w 1I 1 1 cat I ng n d 1I indicating 1I 1 1 obese women are more ke y likely I1 I1 1I to have irregular menstrual cycles 4 socioeconomic status followed the same pattern as studies done in the past on women and obesity and socioeconomic status status had a higher percent body the relationship between those women of lower income fat than those of higher income levels 5 the average total percent body fat for the entire sample was below the obesity level remmmendfll2as based on the findings and conclusions of the following recommendations were 1 made the questionnaire should be administered only to single white 2 this study women to see if the results infold tests Sk sklnfold skinfold would be the same should include the thigh measurement for more accuracy 3 sklnfold skinfold tests should all sk infold be taken by one researcher 30 for more accuracy 4 A larger sample should be taken so more data daa can be analyzed and compared 5 A more equal sample should be used so both contain approximately the same number of 6 populations women the questionnaire should be altered and expanded to include other religions 7 further study should irregular menstrual cycles be pursued on and obesity as relationship between it relates to the distri- bution of adipose tissue 8 natton should determination dearmi deermi nation 9 use a sample with similar population catchment area be made on length of snacking snack ing habits ie education physical education religion religion physical educationphysical bibliography 32 I isography ilography bib lio Ilo llo graphy B 1I b 1 2 allsen philip life wm A IA I1 bray bray george brown CA 1984 onn america amed obesity in amer 1979 A o bethesda Beh esda NIH MD obesity Beh esda behesda obesid in perspective bethesda obesiu publication 1973 DHEW A MD moment koment attitudes toward obesity college womens ap 10 12 1012 research report vol 143 1978 pp jim 5 chambliss 6 eagles randall new 7 mountain view joyce M harrlson harrison barbara vance fitness an indolyl individualj2ed approach groach 3rd ed dubuque indlyl Zed Ag duail duali duall duallzed C george life E publication 4 1 steps to a longer abbo fred E 1979 world publication inc for 3 I1 glenn E R monon moron B monton morton P duton dutton but 1I 1974 1980 wnt ant don 8 nutrition hafen brent al lyn and bacon 1981 allyn 9 hibscher obesity A characteristics vo psychol voi psychology vol lo logical ciral psychal eat that much new york food and weight cootrq controlI 00. J therapeutic nutrition handbook of normal and raven press york 11 1 Di dieting dieling eting obese bese I1 and boston the expression of journel journal nai nal of comprehensive physiojqur jour 91 80 1977 pp ap 374 37480 10 acceptance by others and its relation to mcintyne C mclntyre mcintyre acceptance of self and others journal of abnormal and ap 624 25 010 vol 16 1952 pp 62425 psychology olo social Psych psycholo 11 mcwilliams stare nutrition for good health george F stickley stick ley company 1974 12 survey on body image weight and diet of miller T M journal bourna of american merican diet association college students journa 66 ap 561 56166 vol 77 1980 pp philadelphia 1 13 neuberger human A nutrition sies lancaster england 14 pargman Par gnan david students 26 pp ap 621 62126 15 schilder paul london current issues MTP press limited controverand Con tromer 1982 among college of obesity incidence the 19690 journal of school schoo hgaltho health vol 39 1969 appearance amace image imace and AQUe alue drance alle arance alance of kegan paul franch frubnerp Fr ubner drubner frubner the human 2 body 1935 and co 33 16 somogyl Somogyit J C strole srole T nutritional new york of obesity 17 esyahol psychological icat ical and karger 1978 social aspects lil ill in langer S T michael mental health herlth lii mcgraw new york manhattan manhatten the metropolis the Man battan study hattan stul L S HIII hlllilg 1962 H i 118 18 kard A stunkard Sun medicine vol 37 J the case of obesity 1975 19 stunkard Sun kard A J 20 stunkard Sun kard A J howard 21 vol tolson lindsey 2nd ed tuckman bruce W new york ed 23 vener obesity qbesitv W to action in psychosomatic psychosomatic medicine saunders company B 1980 obesity and the social environment 90 85 1980 pp ap 178 17890 dowell dowel I1 I A IA 1 corbin wm C brown 1970 conducting CondUct ido loo educational research 2nd jovanovlch inc 1978 harcourt brace jovanovich 226 1982 pp ap 1982t an overview 1102 09 110209 benjamin B psychological aspects of obesity new york van Nos rand reinhold company 1982 nostrand wolman libb concepts conceqt& education concerts in physical Uu Catlon cation over Weight Obese patients weightobese tionerp tioner vol 24 195 236 195236 pp ap dubuque 22 A from from explanation practi- APPENDIX PHYSICAL SOCIO A environmental questionnaire 35 cai cal ipen measurements caliper iper trtcep icep tr bicep lac suprati supraillac suprailiac subrati persona Pars onal 1 1 2 A HEIGHT 22 2122 4044 418 415 415418 48 45 4548 25 23 2325 11 4 99444111 419 4194111 30 26 2630 510 510514 54 50 514 410 410414 44 40 414 20 18 1820 21 31 35 3135 5054 518 515 515518 58 55 5558 40 36 3640 519 5195111 59 5111 41 610 610614 60 614 64 6064 615 65 3 WEIGHT under 90 120 116 116120 146 150 146150 180 176 176180 M OR 7 90 95 9095 121 125 121125 151 155 151155 181 185 181185 100 96 96100 126 130 126130 156 160 156160 186 190 186190 101 105 101105 131 135 131135 161 165 161165 191 195 191195 110 106 106110 140 136 136140 170 166 166170 196 200 196200 111 115 111115 141 145 141145 171 175 171175 200 1f af 4 B 5 YEAR MAJOR 1I spa n i c hispanic ack Hj asian other othe HOOL IN SC SCHOOL freshman 6 american indian white RACE sophomore IN SCHOOL SCHO junior senior graduate 36 7 70 OVERALL GPA 10 15 101.5 1015 1620 16 20 162.0 1620 2125 21 25 212.5 2125 8 9 25 30 253.0 2530 3135 31 35 313.5 3135 3640 36 40 364.0 3640 2530 MARITAL STATUS single married divorced separated 1 attend sacrament meeting one or two weeks three or long have you been a member of the how lifetime 11 05 yrs ars 16 20 1620 LDS more weeks church 15 yrs 1115 ars 0 5 yrs ars yrs ars 10 6610 11 1 widowed how many weeks a month do you never 10 I I dren how many ch children u I mea ffuli mealss do you full how many 1I I1 1 eat per day 45 0011 4 5 23 6 2 3 12 are you 13 which of the following most on a vegetable fruit ie ie check fat foods ie ie 1 all that apply candy cookies cake potato chips trench french fries of 2 or more if yes explain closely resembles one of your celery carrots other explain I nation comb combination no apple orange high sugar foods high yes special diet typical snacks or more 37 how many 14 times per month do you date 45 0011 4 5 23 6 2 3 15 how many times this year did you mor or mon moree experience irregularities with your menstrual cycle cycl cyale 79 46 133 never 10 12 1012 7 9 4 6 1 father FA hg Is your father a member of the 16 yes church LDS which priesthood does he hold elder seventy HP no iff yes how 1I long has he been a member ars 05 yrs 25 2125 21 yrs ars 10 6610 0 5 yrs ars 26 30 2630 15 yrs 1115 ars 11 yrs 16 20 1620 yrs ars etime lifetime if entime I1 Is he generally very slender average slender over uver overweight weight obese socioeconomic status of your family 17 below beio belo 60000 70000 6000070000 20000 000800000 2000030000 pooo 30pooo oooo 40 30000 40000 3000040000 ooo ooo 50 40 000 50000 40000 4000050000 00050 000 50000 60000 50000460000 5000060000 ooo 000 800000 70 70000 80000 7000080000 .000800000 ooo ooo 000 000 300 200 30000 20000 000300 900000 80000 90000 8000090000 1000000 90000 100000 90000100000 v 0 00 0000 100000 1 mother Is your mother a member of the 18 if yes how ars 05 yrs 0 5 25 yrs 2125 ars 21 LDS yes church long has she been a member 6610 10 yrs ars 26 30 2630 15 yrs 1115 ars 11 yrs lifetime 16 20 1620 yrs ars no 38 Is she generally very slender slender average averane overweight average ave raola racle racla overweight average overweight obese 19 are your siblings generally very slender slender obese 20 would you consider very slender yourself slender obese hone hane what iIss your home how many state years have you 1I lived ived there APPENDIX B 6 NOMOGRAM 40 vom WOM FO f4 won fa lom kon C 0 I 01D r 47 1 tricep TRICE welce weice tricea prr pcrcent parent 0064 an partnt fn rrtr i cSUPTP clma illao lma billao liao nold gle gie folt win vin nolt 14 eal eai 4 fold ski rold rolo folo m MM M hm .55 55 3- 30co ya y5 350 35 i so 1 30 0o za 2z5 25 27 21 zc 20 v aq 2q 16 24 & 15 0 O 10 10 S 15 5 5 IZ adapted from a nomogram by irene paul 21 THE INCIDENCE OF OBESITY EFFECT OF SELECTED PHYSICAL SOCIO VARIABLES TWO swe TOE THE IN LDS COLLEGE WOMEN ON TOTAL environmental PERCENT BODY FAT IN populations OF LDS WOMEN carrie tanner summers department of health sciences MS degree august 1984 ABSTRACT the purpose of the study was to determine the effect of selected physical socio environmental variables on total percent body fat the sample population consisted of single LDS white women attending brigham young university BYU and california state university at Ful significant data as well as trends fullerton leron CSUF that appeared were included in this paper from the data collected it was concluded that the sample populations at BYU and CSUF were the same the incidence of obesity determined only among individuals attending both universities the entire sample population mean was 22.19 2219 percent this percentage did not meet the obesity criteria was 005 correlation at the 0.05 of confidence between total percent body fat and the variables level lof of age height and weight analysis of data indicated a high I1 f C COMMITTEE OMMITTEE APPROVAL CommItte 4 chairman robert burgener committee ron L rhodes committee member ron L rhodes aman cha I rman department chairman 1
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz