DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR EXTERNAL POLICIES OF THE UNION POLICY DEPARTMENT THE DAWN OF PARLIAMENTARY DEMOCRACY IN EGYPT POLICY BRIEFING Abstract Egypt's political influence stems from its strategic geographic position, historical and cultural importance and the strength of its diplomacy and military. Egypt's roles in the League of Arab States, the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process and the Nile Basin make the country a critical Middle Eastern and North African partner for the EU and its Member States. Egypt's parliamentary elections gave the Islamist parties a landslide victory — a two-thirds majority in the new People's Assembly. Some concerns have been raised over this majority and its commitment to safeguarding principles of democracy and pluralism in the new constitution, protecting human rights and preserving Egypt’s international relations. The current human rights situation in Egypt is worrisome, in particular concerning the use of excessive force, the crackdown on civil society organisations and violence against women. The Egyptian economy is also in a desperate state, with foreign currency reserves down to an alarming level. If the current economic uncertainty continues, the country risks social unrest for some time to come. Egypt is a major trading partner for the EU. For many decades, the EU has been engaged in the political, social and economic development of the country via various programmes. Since the revolution, the EU’s approach has not radically changed, and its assistance has increased only incrementally. DG EXPO/B/PolDep/Note/2012_032 PE 457.147 February/2012 EN Policy Department DG External Policies This Policy Briefing is an initiative of the Policy Department, DG EXPO. AUTHOR: Pekka HAKALA and Paolo NAPOLITANO Directorate-General for External Policies of the Union Policy Department WIB 06 M 071 rue Wiertz 60 B-1047 Brussels Feedback to [email protected] is welcome Editorial Assistant: Agnieszka PUNZET LINGUISTIC VERSION Original: EN ABOUT THE EDITOR Manuscript completed on 8 February 2012. © European Parliament, [2012] Printed in [Belgium] The study is available on the Internet at http://www.europarl.europa.eu/activities/committees/studies.do?language=EN. To obtain copies, please send a request by e-mail to: [email protected] DISCLAIMER Any opinions expressed in this document are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily represent the official position of the European Parliament. Reproduction and translation, except for commercial purposes, are authorised, provided the source is acknowledged and provided the publisher is given prior notice and supplied with a copy of the publication. 2 Policy Briefing: The Dawn of Parliamentary Democracy in Egypt TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. INTERNAL SITUATION 4 1.1 ELECTIONS RESULTS AND COMPOSITION OF THE NEW PARLIAMENT 4 1.2 MAIN POLITICAL CHALLENGES AHEAD 8 1.3 SOCIO ECONOMIC CHALLENGES 10 2. REGIONAL CONTEXT 11 2.1 MORE ACTIVE ARAB LEAGUE 11 2.2 STRAINED EGYPTIAN-ISRAELI RELATIONS 11 2.3 THE NILE BASIN INITIATIVE 12 3. RELATIONS WITH THE EUROPEAN UNION 12 4. SOURCES 14 3 Policy Department DG External Policies 1. INTERNAL SITUATION A year after Egypt's President Hosni Mubarak’s resigned from office, the Egyptian revolution remains in many ways still unfinished. The country is experiencing a complex and difficult transitional phase where several processes are taking place simultaneously: the military and the security apparatus have maintained their power, the prerogatives of the new elected Parliament have yet to be defined, the timeframe for the handover of power to civilian authorities is still unclear, and a new constitution is needed before the presidential elections scheduled for the summer. Elections results and composition of the new parliament After a complicated electoral process that stretched over 55 days, the Egyptian High Judicial Elections Committee announced the final results of the People's Assembly, the lower and more powerful house of the Egyptian parliament, on 21 January. The election of the members of the Shura Council, the upper house, is ongoing and will end on 4 March. The outcome of the Shura elections will be significant, as the two houses will jointly nominate the members of the Constitutional Assembly, which in turn will draft the new Egyptian constitution. The Islamist parties (the Freedom and Justice Party and the al-Nour Party) have won a significant victory in the People's Assembly elections, gaining more than 70 % of the seats. The secular and liberal parties, on the other hand, scored badly — between 3 and 8 % each. However the historically significant alWafd party and the secular Egyptian bloc performed rather well in some constituencies. Around 30 million voters out of a potential 50 million cast their ballot. Final election results Major orientation Freedom and Justice Party Democratic Alliance Al-Nour Party - Alliance for Egypt Seats % of seats Moderate Islamist 235 47 % Radical Islamist (Salafist) 121 24 % Al-Wafd Party Secular liberal 38 8 % Egyptian Bloc Secular centre-left 34 7% Al-Wasat Party Moderate Islamist 10 2% Reform and Development Party Liberal 9 2% Revolution Continues Coalition Leftist 7 1% 15 3% 29 6% NDP and Off-shoots of Mubarak's party Former Regime Others/Independents Total 498 4 100 % Policy Briefing: The Dawn of Parliamentary Democracy in Egypt Composition of the new Parliament 121 38 34 235 10 9 7 15 29 Freedom and Justice Party -Democratic Alliance Al-Nour Party Al Wafd Party Egyptian Bloc Al Wasat Party Reform and Development Party Revolution Continue Coalition NDP and Off-shoots of Mubarak's party Others/Independents (c) European Parliament, DG Expo Policy Dep. 2012, PH/ap No governmental institutions - including the EU - had been invited to observe the elections, although a few local and international NGOs were allowed to oversee the electoral process. While the Egyptian High Electoral Committee declared the elections to have been fair and transparent, the international community pointed out some shortcomings, but also admitted that the election results reflected the will of the Egyptian people. Some observers reported problems outside the polling stations, such as illegal campaigning, confusion, and insufficient surveillance of the ballot boxes 1 . Further problems arose when the High Electoral Committee hesitated to release official data. Elections had to be repeated in several districts. As depicted in the political landscape map below, the parties that were better organised at the grassroots level, - i.e., the Muslim Brothers and the Salafists - scored well across the entire country. As expected, the Muslim Brotherhood's Freedom and Justice Party (FJP) emerged as the dominant political force in the vast majority of governorates. The party built on its well-established grassroots networks, presenting itself as a movement cutting across all social classes, and reaped the rewards of poor and middle class votes. The strong performance of the Salafists' al-Nour party (24 %) shocked all the commentators and observers. al-Nour came first in two sparsely populated western governorates (New Valley and Matruh), three governorates in the Delta (Damietta, Kafr al-Shaikh, al-Buhayrah) and in Suez. The party also obtained a good result in its traditional stronghold Alexandria, where it was defeated by the FJP by a narrow margin. The groups within the al-Nour party form a well-connected network linked to Salafist groups that carry out charitable activities throughout the country. All share an ultra-conservative Islamist ideology based on rigorous application of Shari'a law. Their outstanding performance is due to 1 Some witnesses reported that many ballot boxes were found outside the polling stations with no surveillance. 5 Policy Department DG External Policies several factors: their ability to campaign in all districts, a well-connected network of charities, a populist political platform that has enticed the poorest voters, a political message that stressed their differences from the Muslim Brotherhood, and dubious electoral practices reported in some remote areas of the country (where al-Nour did well). 2 The secular coalition of the Egyptian Bloc did reasonably well in the main urban centres such as Cairo, Asyout, Sohag and Minya. The al-Wafd party, which benefitted from well-connected social networks, was confirmed as a viable political formation with passably good results in some governorates in the Delta and in South Sinai. (c) European Parliament, DG Expo Policy Dep. 2012, PH/ap 2 According to some witnesses, Al Nour party took advantage of the scarce surveillance at polling stations and campaigned during the electoral process. 6 Policy Briefing: The Dawn of Parliamentary Democracy in Egypt Election results by governorate (party lists) FJP Al-Nour Egyptian Bloc Al Wafd 34,50% 31,50% 11% 6% 34% 24% 9% 8% Asyut 36,50% 23,50% 19% 4% Beheira 35,50% 38% 3% 9% 41% 33,50% 5% 9,50% Cairo 38,75% 21,75% 20,25% 8,50% Dakahlia 33,60% 28% 2,60% 10,60% Damietta 31% 39% 3% 5% Faiyum 45% 34,50% 4% 2% Gharbia 33,50% 29,50% 6% 15,50% Giza 39,50% 28,50% 10,50% 6,50% 38% 28% 7% 7% 30,50% 30,50% 1% 13,50% Matruh 14% 68% 2% 7% Minya 41% 25% 13% 5,50% 36,50% 19% 3% 18% New Valley 26% 40% 7% 4% North Sinai 35% 27% 2% 6% Port Said 33% 21% 10% 14% Qalyubia 37% 26,50% 6% 9% 29,50% 20,50% 2% 7,50% Red Sea 36% 0% 17% 10% Sharqia 37% 24% 6% 12,50% 25,50% 24% 15,50% 7% South Sinai 43% 0% 11% 17% Suez 27% 46% 8% 5% Luxor 37% 16% 13% 11% Alexandria Aswan Beni Suef Ismailia Kafr el-Sheikh Monufia Qena Sohag FJP - the biggest party; Al- Nour - the biggest party; Egyptian Bloc - stronghold; Al-Wafd: - stronghold 7 Policy Department DG External Policies Main political challenges ahead Muslim Brotherhood seeks coalition partner(s) The FJP is only 20 seats short of an absolute majority in the lower house; it would need 255 seats of the total 508, while it now holds 235 In the new parliament, the party occupies the most powerful parliamentary committees, including the foreign affairs and budget committees3 . To form the government, the FJP will have to create a coalition with other political groups. The first contender may be the al-Wafd party, with which the FJP signed a political agreement outlining basic constitutional principles in September 2011. The Muslim Brotherhood (MB) might also attempt to form a coalition with the Salafists' al-Nour party, whose striking performance is a source of concern for many observers. However, but the FJP leadership has consistently refused to enter into a formal alliance with al-Nour. The MB's slogan 'participation not domination' — which refers to the organisation’s desire to play a decisive role in the political process, without making key decisions on its own — will certainly be used in its parliamentary activity. The party will probably apply a 'consensus model', at least in the short term; rather that assume complete authority and responsibility, it would prefer to improve education and effect a long-term change of culture towards it own its religious and social model. The MB must, in any case, respond to the expectations of its lower- and middle-class electorate, in cities, suburbs and the countryside. It will also have to refute the claim of its rival, al-Nour, to be the purest representation of the Islamist agenda in Egypt. Uncertain constitutional path The future of Egypt is still uncertain, and much depends on the future relation between the FJP and the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF), the group of senior military officials that has effectively ruled Egypt since Mubarak stepped down 4 . On 23 January the People's Assembly convened for the first time and elected, during a chaotic first session, its speaker, Said al-Katatni, a prominent FJP leader. The exact powers of the newly elected Assembly are not clear. In conjunction with the Shura Council, the Assembly will appoint the 100 members of the Constitutional Assembly, which will draft the new Constitution. The timetable is not yet defined. The SCAF wishes to hold presidential elections only after the new constitution has been prepared (by the end of June 2012). The FJP, on the other hand, has suggested drafting the new constitution in parallel with the presidential elections, in order to accelerate the handover of military power in the spirit of the 25 January revolution. Realistically, a three-month period for drafting and approving the new constitution appears too short given the delicate state of Egypt today. A compromise between the SCAF and the FJP is expected on this topic. Incomplete revolutionary process During the recent and somewhat confused period in Egyptian history, protest and politics have overlapped. The delayed transition from military to civilian rule has been the main source of confusion and anger among those generations and social strata that took to the streets in January 2011. These people now sense their revolution has been betrayed by the SCAF. The SCAF has responded by announcing that the state of emergency will be lifted, except in those cases necessary to protect the country against ‘thuggery’. That said, the 'Tahrir Square principles' cannot yet be said to have triumphed. The democratically elected parliament will now have to take up the banner of reform. 3 In a forward-looking spirit, al-Nour has opted for the chairmanship of the education committee. 4 With reference to the Constitutional principles, the Muslim Brotherhood advocates a mixed or semi-presidential system, supporting a civil and democratic Constitution with Islamic reference that allows popular sovereignty through the existing institutions. 8 Policy Briefing: The Dawn of Parliamentary Democracy in Egypt According to many international human rights organisations (including Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International), there has been no improvement in human rights in Egypt during the last year of unrest. Under Emergency Law, the military referred more than 12 000 civilians to military courts and used excessive force to break up demonstrations in July, November and December 2011. The majority of human rights activists argue that the country will deteriorate without a comprehensive police reform. Many violations have been reported in the last year, including torture and excessive use of force by military and police officers, killing unarmed protesters, violence against religious minorities. Improvements are also badly needed in the field of labour rights protection. There have been many calls for an expanded freedom of expression in Egypt since the beginning of the uprising. Yet when bloggers and journalists have criticised the SCAF and the military, many have faced prolonged and unjustified detentions. Military rule has targeted NGOs, in particular those that receive foreign funding. The offices of many organisations have been raided and they have been prevented from working on the ground. On 29 December 2011, the offices of 10 civil society organizations operating in Egypt were searched, their officers investigated and banned from leaving the country. Many US-funded NGOs, such as the International Republican Institute (IRI), Freedom House, the International Center for Journalists, the National Democratic Institute (NDI), as well as the German Konrad Adenauer Foundation, have been vilified by the SCAF. The accusations faced by the organisations range from illegal foreign funding to carrying out 'political training programmes', or even supporting illegal election campaigns by financing individual or groups in the recent elections. On 6 February 2012, the Egyptian public prosecutor released the names of 44 persons indicted of illegal funding who will be tried in the upcoming weeks. The US and Egypt have long disputed the question of NGOs for a long time, but relations have sharply deteriorated as a result of crackdown on US-funded NGOs 5 . The situation concerning women's rights appears even worse. Women have been the victims of increasing physical assaults over the past year. Regarding their political rights the SCAF eliminated the quota of 64 seats that had been assigned to women in the People's Assembly and has only required the political parties to nominate at least one female candidate in their lists. This has resulted in a dramatic fall in women among the elected Parliament — from 64 seats to only 8. Discrimination against women in Egypt has long been a problem, and the victory of the Islamists parties in the elections raises serious concerns about for their future situation. The Islamist victory has also created worries for the fate of the Coptic minority in Egypt. Numbering around 5-7 million people, Egypt's native Christian minority have been the victims of several attacks in the past months. The EU institutions have repeatedly expressed their deep concern about their situation. Finally, the excellent electoral performance of the Salafists has eroded the Muslim Brothers' constituencies in some areas of the country. In all but one governorates, the Salafists came at least second 6 . The Salafists' have no experience of party politics or parliamentary activity, as they only recently accepted participating in political institutions. Some time will need to elapse before their parliamentary behaviour can be evaluated. They are likely to act both to preserve their own support 5 Whereas Egypt maintains that foreign NGOs operating in the country and receiving foreign funding should register with the Ministry of Social Solidarity., US legislation in force since 2004 establishes that no US assistance should be subject to prior approval by the partner country's government. Egypt currently receives 1.3 million USD in aid. In its appropriation bill adopted last year, the Congress linked the disbursement of this assistance to an obligation of the Egyptian administration to guarantee that Egypt is holding free elections and that it protects freedom of expression and association. 6 They were banned from running in the Red Sea Governorate due to a legal infringement in the registration of candidates 9 Policy Department DG External Policies base, which is rooted in the lower strata of population, and to challenge the Muslim Brothers on the issue of 'true Islamic policy-making'. Socio economic challenges Egypt is one of the most developed countries in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region and the main economic partner for the EU in the region. It is also the most populous Arab country and the third-most populous on the African continent. Its demographic evolution has been impressive, and its population is expected to double by 2040-50. In 2010 the EU’s exports to Egypt stood at EUR 15 billion, and imports from Egypt at EUR 7 billion. The agricultural sector represents 10% of GDP and employs 32 % of the labour force. The industrial sector represents 29 % of GDP and employs 17 % of the labour force. The main industrial sectors are steel, electricity, oil extraction and refining, chemicals, domestic goods and automobiles. The service sector is the largest contributor to the Egyptian economy, representing 61 % of GDP and employs around 50 % of the workforce. Prior to the uprising, the service sector was rapidly developing. Today, as a result of a precipitous drop in tourism– -- faces a dramatic crisis. The unfinished revolution has virtually paralysed the Egyptian economy. According to the International Monetary Fund (IMF), GDP growth in 2011 was 1.2 %, down from 5.1 % in 2010. The IMF predicts a growth of 1.8 % in 2012. If the prevailing political uncertainty can be laid to rest, we can expect much better growth rates (7-8 %) in the upcoming years. Several sectors have been strongly affected by the current crisis, with tourist visits down 24 %, with only 2.7 million visitors to the country in 2011, compared to 3.6 million the year before. Total tourist income recorded a 40 % drop last year. The manufacturing sector contracted by 3.3 %, and the construction sector by 2 %. During the crisis, investor confidence fell dramatically, and private investment was down by 20 %. In June 2011, unhappy with the terms the SCAF blocked the IMF loan, and the government continued its policy of borrowing "locally", mainly in the Gulf States in order to compensate for the budget deficit and boost economic growth. However, this policy also resulted in a rise in inflation to 9 % in November 2011, and the Egyptian Central Bank raised its interest rate for the first time since 2008. In January 2012, with the economic crisis ongoing, the government decided to negotiate another IFM loan. The loan could lessen the government's reliance on domestic borrowings, in which case local banks would finance internal economic growth rather than the deficit. The loan might also help convince foreign investors to return to the Egyptian capital market. Given the importance of confidence for the markets, Egypt’s economic improvement will depend on the outcome of the current political transition. What the country now urgently needs is liquidity. The Muslim Brotherhood has listed a series of economic priorities in its political programme, including connecting households to the natural gas network; obtaining a fair price for land sold by the government (land was previously given to businessmen and investors for free) ; reviewing oil and gas export deals (particularly those with Israel); imposing a 10 % tax on the communication sector; revising subsidies in order to favour those who are most in need; and introducing a tax on capital gains. 10 Policy Briefing: The Dawn of Parliamentary Democracy in Egypt INTERNAL CHALLENGES handover power to civilian authorities through the formation of a coalition government based on a parliamentary majority safeguard human rights and fundamental freedoms clarify the constitutional process, timeline and principles organise a referendum on constitution and presidential elections improve the economic situation, solve the liquidity crisis and implement needed social measures (e.g., a minimum salary and job creation programmes), 2. REGIONAL CONTEXT More active Arab League Appointed in summer of 2011, the Egyptian Secretary General of the League of Arab States, Nabil elAraby, , has worked to expand the organisation's international role despite its obsolete decision-making processes and lack of institutional stature. As reported by many observers on the ground, the atmosphere around the Arab League's premises in Cairo has changed, and the organisation has begun to work again after years of disarray and inactivity. Al-Araby's activism was decisive during the Libyan crisis, when the League asked the United Nations to impose a no-fly zone over the territory in order to protect civilians. Later, the League suspended Syria's membership and imposed economic sanctions before finally presenting its peace initiative to the United Nations. Much of this activism could be interpreted as reflecting Egypt's desire to regain stature in the regional arena. For the time being, the League's ability to act depends on the willingness of its member states, and first and foremost those also seeking regional authority, Saudi Arabia and Qatar. Strained Egyptian-Israeli relations The recent victory of Islamist parties in the Egyptian elections has raised concern about the future of Egyptian-Israeli relations and the solidity of the 1978 Camp David Treaty. In recent years, the situation in the Sinai Peninsula has deteriorated as a result of the lack of development; the growth of an alternative economy, led by the Bedouin community and based on long-established smuggling routes; and an extensive radicalisation resulting from the conversion of many Sufi Bedouins to radical Sunni Islam. Since Hamas took over of the Gaza Strip in 2007, the Sinai has become the refuge for the Islamist movement, and the 'tunnel economy' is estimated to be worth USD 300 million annually. Tension on the Israeli-Egyptian border is extremely high. During the electoral campaign, the Muslim Brotherhood stated that they would recognize the Camp David treaty, but downgrade diplomatic relations. The FJP has since reaffirmed this commitment, although the movement generally has no clear international strategy. Any future Egyptian government resulting from the democratically elected parliament will have to consider Egyptian public opinion on the matter. 11 Policy Department DG External Policies The Nile Basin Initiative The African dimension of the Egyptian foreign policy merits being closely followed. Instability in Egypt's immediate southern neighbourhood has repercussions all the way to Cairo. In order to manage and sustainably develop the vital shared water resources of the Nile Basin, Egypt has made efforts to resolve its dispute with Ethiopia through the Nile Basin Initiative (NBI). A dispute over the renegotiation of national rights to the waters of the Nile between Egypt and Ethiopia, where 85 % of the river’s water originates, has been exacerbated by plans to construct a massive hydroelectric project in Ethiopia, known as the Millennium Dam. Under Mubarak, Egypt has strongly opposed this project, causing the two countries' relations to freeze. (Current conventions give the country veto power over all upstream projects.) Last year, however, relations thawed somewhat, and in September 2011, the Ethiopian Prime Minister Meles Zenawi visited Egypt. The countries have demonstrated their desire to renew relations and have agreed to form a technical team in order to study the dam's effects on countries downstream. 3. RELATIONS WITH THE EUROPEAN UNION The EU is Egypt's first commercial partner. For the EU, Egypt is a key player in the framework of the European Neighbourhood Policy (ENP) and the Union for the Mediterranean. Since the Egyptian uprising, the EU has carefully observed the transitional process and has begun to reorient its contribution and activity in the country. High Representative and Vice President (HR/VP) Catherine Ashton recently acknowledged the first session of People's Assembly as a first step towards democracy and stressed the importance of transferring power to civilian rule as quickly as possible. 7 As the situation on the ground remains uncertain, the HR/VP expressed deep concerns about the ongoing crackdown on civil society and urged the Egyptian authorities to allow civil society organizations to play their role in building a sustainable democracy 8 . Alarmed by the events at the football stadium in Port Said on 1 February — in which at least 79 people were killed — HR/VP Ashton called for an independent probe to find out why and how knife-wielding fans overwhelmed stadium security following a football match 9 . The EU-Egypt Association Agreement, which entered into force in 2004, forms the legal basis governing relations between Egypt and the EU. Cooperation between the EU and Egypt is based on the Action Plan adopted in 2007 in order to promote political, economic and social development. The country strategy paper fixes the framework for the Commission's priorities in terms of financial cooperation with Egypt. According to this document, two Multi-Annual Indicative Programmes (MIPs), for 2007-2010 and 2011-2013, address a set of priorities: human rights and political reform, economic reform and sustainable social development. Main focuses Reforms in the areas of democracy, human rights and justice 7 2007-2010 2011-2013 € million € million 40 http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_Data/docs/pressdata/EN/foraff/127477.pdf http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_Data/docs/pressdata/EN/foraff/127777.pdf 9 http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_data/docs/pressdata/EN/foraff/127786.pdf 8 12 50 Policy Briefing: The Dawn of Parliamentary Democracy in Egypt Competitiveness and productivity of the economy 220 199 Sustainability of social development and better management of human and natural resources 298 200 558 449 Total The total budget allocated for the period 2011-2013 is EUR 449 million, but the evolving situation has led to slight reorientation and restructuring of the programmes via frontloading and regrouping existing funds to support civil society organisations, democratic dialogue and women's empowerment. The amount of additional funding for Egypt remains moderate, some EUR 5 million, as the EU has hesitated to make new commitments until the current situation is somewhat settled and democratically elected institutions take office. Programme/Action Contents Amount Agricultural SMEs (fall 2011) Improve access to finance for farmers, increase productivity, improving farmers living conditions €22 million Civil society package (2011) Strengthen civil society organizations, support for democracy €20 million On December 2011 the Council gave the Commission the mandate to open bilateral negotiations with Egypt, alongside Jordan, Morocco and Tunisia, for a Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Agreement (DCFTA). However, the Egyptian authorities have not wished to engage in formal negotiations because they cannot engage in any international commitment until the transitional phase has been completed. Relating to the Mobility Partnership, referred to in the reformed neighbourhood policy, preparatory talks started in Cairo on June 2011, but again the Egyptian authorities have stated they cannot commit to any agreement before the elected officeholders take responsibility for the question. REGIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL CHALLENGES The League of Arab States: a future partner to tackle regional issues Egypt's role in the resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict The Nile EU: reallocation of assistance to match the new realities, effective use of other instruments to deepen relations with its key partner in the Arab World ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 13 Policy Department DG External Policies 4. SOURCES PRIMARY SOURCES - OFFICIAL DOCUMENTS http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_Data/docs/pressdata/EN/foraff/127477.pdf http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_Data/docs/pressdata/EN/foraff/127777.pdf http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_data/docs/pressdata/EN/foraff/127786.pdf http://ec.europa.eu/europeaid/where/neighbourhood/countrycooperation/egypt/egypt_en.htm REPORTS Human Rights Watch (2012), http://www.hrw.org/world-report-2012/world-report-2012-egypt Economist Intelligence Unit (2012), Egypt, available at http://country.eiu.com/FileHandler.ashx?issue_id=188752803&mode=pdf Oxford Analytica (2012), Egypt country profile, available at http://www.oxan.com/analysis/c/default.aspx?q=Egypt Institute for Security Studies (2011), Egyptian democracy and the Muslim Brotherhood, available at http://www.iss.europa.eu/publications/detail/article/egyptian-democracy-and-the-muslimbrotherhood/ Brown N. (2012), When Victory Becomes an Option, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, available at http://carnegieendowment.org/ files/brotherhood_success.pdf WEB ARTICLES http://www.ikhwanweb.com/ http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world/middle_east/ http://www.jadaliyya.com/ http://www.arabist.net http://english.ahram.org.eg/ http://www.nytimes.com/pages/world/middleeast/index.html http://www.sandmonkey.org/ http://www.thedailybeast.com STATISTICS http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/docs/2006/september/tradoc_113375.pdf 14
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz