University of Khartoum TOWNS IN THE SUDAN IN THE EIGHTEENTH AND EARLY NINETEENTH CENTURIES Author(s): El-Sayed El-Bushra Source: Sudan Notes and Records, Vol. 52 (1971), pp. 63-70 Published by: University of Khartoum Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/42677876 Accessed: 27-01-2016 06:38 UTC Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/ info/about/policies/terms.jsp JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. University of Khartoum is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Sudan Notes and Records. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 41.67.21.5 on Wed, 27 Jan 2016 06:38:07 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions EIGHTEENTH TOWNS AND IN THE EARLY IN THE SUDAN NINETEENTH CENTURIES by El-Sayed el-Bushra It is oftenassumedthaturbanlifein sub-SaharanAfricawas firstintroduced by Europeans. Althoughthisis true of most parts of the continent,indigenous townswere alreadyin existencein both east and west AfricabeforeEuropean colonisation.Towns of purelySudanese, Ethiopian and Nigerian origin bear witnessto this fact.Indeed, urban lifein the Sudan goes to as far back as the pre-historic period.This paper is onlyconcernedwiththe Sudan, and its purpose is to give a short reviewof Sudanese towns duringthe eighteenthand early centuries. nineteenth invasionof 1821,whatis now northand central Priorto theTurco-Egyptian Sudan was dominatedby two kingdoms.The Fung kingdomof Sennarruledthe easternpart of the regionincludingthe Nile Valley; and the kingdomof Darfur, whichwas relatedto the formerWadai kingdomof West Africa,occupied the westernpart of the regionincludingKordofan.Informationabout population, settlements and commercialactivityis lacking,as a resultof whichit has become difficult to reconstruct the social, economicand demographicpatterns extremely of the area beforethe Turco-Egyptian invasion.The information presentedhere was collectedfromtravelliteraturewhichwas made available by European and Arab travellersduringthe eighteenthand nineteenthcenturies.Travellerssuch as J.Bruce,W. G. Browne,J.L. Burckhardt and MuhammadIbn 'Omar al-Tūnisi, among others,visiteddifferent parts of the regionduringthat period.1Browne (1793-5) was concernedwith Darfur,Burckhardt(1814) visitedNubia and the Red Sea coast, and Brucewho set out in 1768 to discoverthe sourceof the Nile, account of Sennar and the countryto the northin 1772-3, gave an interesting when followingthe Blue Nile downstreamon his way back fromGondar in Ethiopia to Cairo in Egypt.The mostreputedArab travellerduringthatperiod was Al-Tūnisi,who aftertenyearsof stayin Darfur(1803-13),was able to provide the most comprehensiveinformationon administrative, tribal and social conditionsthroughoutthe kingdom. Comparedwithexistingstandards,agricultural productionin the regionwas verylow mainlybecause of primitivetechniquesand crude implementsand so was also the volume of trade. Shiftingcultivationwas generallypractisedand littlesurpluswas producedto enterforeigntrade. Low agriculturalproduction togetherwith famines,diseases and tribalwars retardedpopulationgrowth,as a resultof whichfewsettlements werefound. in leftby travellers, about twentysettlements Accordingto the information the regionwere activein commerceand trade,and weretherefore referred to as towns.Towns were significant forboth commerceand administration. Of those 1J.Bruce,Travels to Discover theSourceof theNile, London,1806,Vol. iv; M. Poncet, A Voyage toEthiopia andSyria Travels inAfrica , London, 1709;W.G. Browne, , Egypt , London, Travels in Nubia Ibn 'Omaral-Tūnisi, 1799;J. L. Burckhardt, , London,1819;Muhammad Tashhīdh al-Adhhãn biSīratBilãdal-Arabwa-l-Sūdān, edited andM.M.Mus'ad, byK. M.'Asāker TheFungKingdom 1951; A. Moorehead, Cairo,1965;O. G. S. Crawford, , Gloucester, ofSennar TheBlueNile, London,1965. 63 This content downloaded from 41.67.21.5 on Wed, 27 Jan 2016 06:38:07 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 64 Sudan Notes and Records CARAVAN ROUTES This content downloaded from 41.67.21.5 on Wed, 27 Jan 2016 06:38:07 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Sudan Towns in the Eighteenth and Early Nineteenth Centuries 65 the most importantin the easternarea were Sennar,the capital of the Fung kingdom,Wad Medani, Arbagi,Shendi,Berber,Darnerand Suakin,all of which of the except the latterwere located along the Nile. Cobbé, to the north-west presentsiteof El-Fasher,was the capital of the westernkingdomand was by far the most importanttown; otherswere Ril, Sweini,Kabkabiya and Kurma.1The sultanor monarchof eitherof thetwo kingdomsresidedin thecapitalcity,while his delegatesto thevariouspartsofthekingdomlivedin smallertowns.Throughof the sultan and sent in out the regiontaxes were collectedby representatives each year. The caravan routewas of primeimportancein developingtrade,and towns which were located along such routes gained commercialmomentum. Caravans linkeddifferent parts of the region,and extendedfromCobbé in the westto Suakin on the Red Sea coast,and fromShendiand Berberin thenorthto Sennarin the south. Major caravan routeshad also penetrateddeep beyondthe region'sboundariesas far as Upper Egypt,Ethiopia (Map), southwardto the negrokingdomof Dar Kulla, and westwardinto Bornuand Hausaland. Furthermore,thecaravanlinkwiththeportof Suakinbroughttheregionin contactwith Trade Arabia, India and China and made possibletheexchangeof commodities.2 was in factthe verylife-bloodof societyin thosetowns. The size of settlements Littlementionwas made by travellersabout populationand size of settlements,indicatingthat most were too small to capture any attention.In 1699 C. Poncet describedSennar as a verypopulous place having a population of 100,000,but it seems that the figurewas greatlyexaggerated.P. Trémaux,who visitedthe town in 1860,foundthat it had a populationof 4,000 afterthe disof the Fung kingdom,and estimatedthatthe figurewas about 10,000 integration on theeve of theEgyptianinvasion.It is probablethatat its climaxSennarmight have had a populationof over 10,000,but was by no means as largeas 100,000. In theearlypartof theeighteenth centuryHalfaya,to thenorthof thepresentsite of Khartoum,had 300 housesindicatingonce morethe small size of settlements. In the same way Derr in Nubia consistedof 200 houses,Gerriwas a place of 140 houses,Damer had 500 houses,and Shendi,one of thelargesttowns,had between 800 and 1,000houses. Suakin,one of the major portson the Red Sea, had 600 houses and 8,000 people. Places such as Dongola, Khandak, Debba and Korti were rather small, having only a few hundred inhabitants.It can therefore be concludedthatthethreemajortownsin theeasternregionbeforetheEgyptian invasionwere Sennar,Shendi and Suakin, all of whichwere importantcaravan centresand seats of administration. Browne estimatedthe total population in Darfurto be not more than 200,000,and statedthat the most populous place was Cobbé witha populationof 6,000.The remainingpopulationin Darfurlived in small villagesof one or two hundredinhabitants.3 1Browne, op. cit.,pp. 236-40,284-6;Burckhardt, op. cit.,pp. 212,265,268,277-8,431; Poncet, op.cit.,pp.470,517,529-30, Moorehead, op.cit.,pp.161-73; op.cit.,pp.16-8;Bruce, 545;Crawford, op. cit.,pp.61,64, op. cit.,pp. 53,55-7,61-3,65,67,72, 118-26;Al-Tūnisi, 306. 118, 2Burckhardt, op. cit.,pp. 164-7;Crawford, op. cit.,pp. 235,239,299,324; Moorehead, cit.,pp. 58,62-3,72,319,321. op. 3Poncet, op. cit.,pp 284-5; op. cit.,p. 18; Crawford, op. cit.,pp. 319,322,325; Browne, Burckhardt, op. cit.,pp. 235,266,278,432,447. This content downloaded from 41.67.21.5 on Wed, 27 Jan 2016 06:38:07 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 66 Sudan Notes and Records Thefunctions of towns was one of thefunctions sharedby most As mentionedearlier,administration in all the important towns,because usually the sultan had his representatives Trade was anotherimportantfunctionwhichwas closelyassociated settlements. withcaravan routesthatbroughttownsin contactwiththe outsideworld.Large commercialcentreswerethoselocatedon majorcaravanroutes.In 1701,T. Krump describedSennaras one of the mostimportanttradingcentresin Africa,and as visitedby caravansfromNubia, Darfur,Cairo, Fezzan, Bornu beingwas regularly and Ethiopia,while the caravan route to Suakin connectedthe town with sea itscommercial routesto Arabia and India. The dailymarketat Sennarmanifested to certaindays of in othertowns,however,marketswererestricted significance; the week. There were also numerousvillagesin the vicinityof Sennarthat had economicrelationswithit. The radiatingroutesfromthetownto theneighbouring of thepoliticaland commercialleadership habitationswereanothermanifestation of Sennar.There weretwo marketplaces in the town,one of whichoccupied a wide area in the centreof the city.BetweenSennarand Shendito the norththe of Wad Medani and Arbagiwerementionedby Bruce,but they two settlements seemedto have been of far less commercialsignificance. Halfáya on the east of the main Nile was knownfor the manufactureof a coarse cotton cloth called dammūrwhichwas wornthroughout the region.No mentionwas made of either Omdurmanor Khartoumwhich were then small hamlets. to as a large town and capital Shendito the northof Halfãya was referred of its district, as well as an importantentrepôtof trade,and was thethirdlargest town afterSennarand Cobbé. It was joined by caravan to Sennar,Suakin and Darfur.CommoditiesfromEgypt,Ethiopia,India, Arabia and Venicewerefound in Shendimarket.Therewas a dailymarketand a largeweeklyone forthevillagers in the neighbourhood.Therewas alwayssome new caravanarrivingand another departingindicatingthe high commercialstandingof the town. The market occupied the centreof the cityin a large open space wherethreerows of huts werearrangedto supplypeople withthecommoditiestheyneeded.The people of Shendiweretraders,and almosteverybodywas engagedin commerceor related was carriedout in the vicinityof the town. occupations,and so littleagriculture It was also the nearestplace on the Nile to the Red Sea exit,and therefore to Arabia, India and the Far East. PilgrimsfromcentralAfricapassed through Shendi on theirway to Mecca, while Burckhardtstatedthat about 5,000 slaves used to pass throughthe town each year. Shendi consistedof severalquarters separatedfromone anotherby public places or markets,probablyindicatingthe various tribal areas withinthe town. Anothertownon theNile, to thesouthof theconfluenceof theAtbarariver, was Damer, a holy place witha large mosque. It was therethat studentsfrom Sennarand Darfurcame to studythe Sharťa and the Koran. Besidesits religious in the region,Damer was also an importantcentreof cottonmanusignificance facture.It is probable that because of its long traditionin cottonweavingthe townmighthave givenitsnameto thecloth.The townsof Old Dongola, Khandak, Debba and Korti were importantnodes along the caravan route to Kordofan. Dongola was an importantpoint of tax collectionin Nubia duringthe Fung period.However,withthecollapseoftheChristianKingdomand theestablishment of Fung rulein Nubia duringthe earlyyearsof the sixteenth centurythe importanceof thelattertownwas reducedconsiderably.By themiddleof theeighteenth destroyedbytheSha'igîyabecause centurytheold cityof Dongola was completely This content downloaded from 41.67.21.5 on Wed, 27 Jan 2016 06:38:07 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Sudan Towns in the Eighteenth and Early Nineteenth Centuries 67 of disagreements withits rulers.At present,a small villageof about a hundred inhabitantsstands as remnantsof the once famous Christiancapital.2 Suakin startedas a tradingportas earlyas theeighthcenturya.d. Although fromthethirteenth theportbeganto gaincommercialmomentum onwards, century its real growthcommencedwiththe beginningof the fifteenth century,when it startedto trade with India, Ceylon and China. From the sixteenthcentury onwardsSuakin,whichwas controlledby the Egyptians,came to be dominated by the Turks who were by thenin fullcontrolin Egypt.It was the Turks who enlargedand improvedSuakin,whichwas describedby Don Juanda Castro as one of the richesttownsin the East. The main town of Suakin was built on a circularisland,withits suburb,the Geyf,on the mainland.The insularityof the port manifestedits strategicposition.Those who were concernedwithshipping operationstogetherwith governmentofficialsresided on the island, while the majorityof people residedin thesuburbon themainland,wherethemainmarket was located.Of the8,000inhabitants only3,000livedon theisland.The population The hub ofthe ofthetownwas engagedin commerceand othershippingactivities. townwas on theisland,whereall the shippingoperationswereexecuted,and the busiestpart of the town was around the island shore wheretradersboats were loaded and unloaded. In Burckhardt^time(1814), Suakin had startedto decay, and some of thebuildingswerealreadyabandoned.The portcontinuedto decline in importanceuntilit was finallydesertedin 1905 whena modernportwas built at Marsa al-SheikhBarghūthwhich was referredto as Port Sudan. However, Suakincontinuesto handlea largenumberof pilgrimsfromtheSudan and central Africaon theirway to Mecca.2 In Darfur,on the otherhand, about ten townsexistedbeforethe Egyptian invasion,the largestwas Cobbé, the capital of the kingdom.Othertownswere Sweini,Kurma,Kabkabiya,Ril, Cours, Shoba, Gadid, Gellé and El Fasher,the presentcapital of DarfurProvince.Most of those townswere located withina shortdistanceof Cobbé and commandedtraderoutes.Ril was thekeyofthesouth and east roads, as was Kabkabiya of the west,and Sweini of the north.Cobbé commandedthe famousDarb al-Arba'īnor 'fortyday road' thatjoined thetown caravanrouteacrossthe withAssiutin Upper Egypt.This was themostimportant Sahara that linkedthe BarbaryStates and Egyptwiththe negroidtribesin the rainlandsof the south. One caravan mightconsistof as manycamels as 2,000 and 1,000 slaves, but that was consideredvery large compared with normal standards.The volume of trade was relativelylarge,and Browneestimatedthe value of the merchandisecarriedby the caravan by whichhe returnedto Egypt in 1796 at the highfigureof £E 115,000. The townsmentionedweremarketcentresand each was visitedby villagers in the neighbourhoodon marketdays.Therewereno dailymarketsas in Sennar, and in Cobbé themarketwas heldtwicea week,on Monday and Friday.Browne statedthatat shortdistancesfromCobbé weresmallvillageswhichweredependent on it. The dailymovementof people fromthe surrounding villagesto the town resultedin a temporary increasein populationin the capitalduringthe day time. 1N. Shuquair, andHistory Beirut, 1967,p. 101. oftheSudan(inArabic), Geography 2Burckhardt, op. cit.,pp.24,28; op. cit.,pp.265-6,289-90,309,324,432-3,439;Poncet, "TheRedSea Style", Kush,i, Crawford, op.cit.,pp.56-63,65-8,72,77,79; D. H. Matthews, 545;Browne, 1953, op.cit.,pp.479-80, 485,514,529-30, op.cit.,pp.243-4,276-80. p. 61; Bruce, SeealsoD. Roden,"Thetwentieth decline ofSuakin", S.N.R., li,1970,pp.1-22. century This content downloaded from 41.67.21.5 on Wed, 27 Jan 2016 06:38:07 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 68 Sudan Notes and Records thetown'spopulaThis dailypulsationof people,thoughmisleadingin estimating thedominatinginfluenceof Cobbé withinits region.No mention tion,manifested was made of public buildingsin the towns of Darfur,except for four or five schools in Cobbé, where studentswere taught the Koran and theology. In Kordofan the most importantcommercialcentrewas El Obeid.1 Cobbé and the othertowns of the kingdomwere located withinan area direction.These mountains surroundedby mountainsthat run in a north-south kingdoms,such as the gave rise to naturalprotectionagainstthe neighbouring Fung kingdomto the east, the negrotribesto the south and the west African kingdomsof Bornuand Bagirmito thewest.Those naturaldefencefeatureswere of paramountimportancein those days, whenwars among tribeswereendemic. Water,as noted by Browne,was the keynotein developingcentresof even a few thousandpeople. The sands and clays of Darfurand Kordofan supplied small amountsof groundwatertherebylimitingboth the size and distribution of settlements. However,thehillyarea in whichthosetownswerelocated did not onlyoffernaturalprotectionagainsttheenemy,but also providedenoughsupplies of waterfordrinkingpurposes. Buildingmaterialsand architecture theregionwereone storeyhigh,poorly As a generalrule,housesthroughout and decorationof buildings built,withflatand conical roofs.Fine architecture werenotto be foundanywherein theregion,and theonlybuildingmaterialin use was clay. In the southernpartsincreasedrainfallenforcedthe erectionof straw hutswithconical roofsto withstandthe heavydownpours.Sennar,forexample, had two typesof houses, round huts withconical strawroofslike those in the countrysideand rectangularmud houses followingthe Nubian and Egyptian type.There were also a towerof design,some of whichwere of the two-storey fourstoreysand a mosque as remnantsof the decayedcapital. The same sort of mud house existedalong the Nile and in Darfur.For instance,Berber,just to the northof the confluenceof the Atbara withthe Nile, consistedof fourvillages, and was situatedon the borderof the arable land in a sandyarea. Each village consistedof about a dozen quartersstandingseparatelyfromeach other.They tribalgroupsresidingin the area, as segregation probablyindicatedthe different withinthe residentialquarterswas purelymade accordingto ethnic or tribal for social reasons,to live in their affiliation. People of the same tribepreferred, own quartersratherthan minglewithothers.Tribal areas are, in fact,traceable in some of the old townseven to thisday. Thus, mostof thewardswithintowns have continuedto bear the names of the originaltribeseven thoughthe previous tribaldivisionsare no longervalid.2 Houses were separatedfromone anotherby large courtyardswhich were used for keepinganimals.The resultwas irregularpatternsof streets.The large yardsownedby each familywerethendividedintoinnerand outercourts.Around this yard were the familyrooms all of one storey.Two of the apartmentswere 1 op.cit.,pp.236,243-4,284-5. 2Browne, op. cit., Browne, op.cit.,p. 212;Bruce, op.cit.,p. 471;Poncet, op.cit.,p. 286;Burckhardt, ThePre-Industrial , Glencoe, City:PastandPresent op.cit.,p. 204;G. Sj0berg, p. 14;Al-Tūnisi, TheWorld FreePress,1960,p. 100; X. de Planhol, Press, , CornellUniversity ofIslam Illinois, "TheStructure oftheMuslim , Town",American Anthropologist 1959, p.9; G. E. vonGrunebaum, No. 81,April, Memoir 1955,p. 147. This content downloaded from 41.67.21.5 on Wed, 27 Jan 2016 06:38:07 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Sudan Towns in the Eighteenth and Early Nineteenth Centuries 69 and a fourthforthereception inhabitedbythefamily,a thirdservedas storeroom, of visitors.Rooms seldomhad morethan one windowand a wooden door. The innercourt was used to keep livestockand had an area for storingdura stalks whichwereused as feedduringthe summer.The outercourtcontaineda well for wateringanimals,and it was in thiscourtthatthe male inhabitantsof the house togetherwithmale strangerssleep duringthe hot season. Most of whatwas said in the region. about Berberapplied to manyothersettlements the of Suakin were by no means purelySudanese,as By contrast, buildings both Egyptianand Turkishstyleswere dominant.However,some local designs appeared on the mainland,while the Beja tribes,who providedthe necessary labour forceforport operations,continuedto live in tents.Houses on the island werebuiltof stoneand wereof two and threestoreyhighwithbalconies.There was no doubt that in its buildingSuakin belongedto the Red Sea Stylerather than to thatof the Sudan, and its paralleloccurredin otherRed Sea portssuch as Jedda, Hodeida and Massawa.1 In Darfurhouses were built of clay and people of high rank coveredthem with plaster and coloured them white,red and black. Browne describedthe apartmentsas beingof threekinds.One was called donga, whichmeasuredtwenty and by twelvefeet.It had a flatroofconsistingof high beams laid horizontally, was coveredwithclay.The secondwas calledkurnuk , whichwas largerthandonga, had no mud walls but was supportedby rafters.This was used for receiving visitorsand sleeping.The thirdwas a roundone of thesame kindused by women forcooking.In most cases a rakübaor shed was added to the house to provide shelterfromthesun,and was a place wherepeople could sitand talk in the open. Al-Tūnisidescribedtwo typesof conical huts,namely,suktaiaand tukulti , both of whichwerebuiltof dukhnstalks.The formerwas tall and narrowwitha steep roof,while the latterwas shorterand had a roundedroof. Houses were bounded by an innerand outer fence; the innerone was in the formof a clay wall, whereasthe outer one was made of thornybushes to keep the cattlefromgoing astray.As mentionedearlier,in the case of Berber, it was the hot climate,on one hand, and the habit of keepinganimalsinsidethe house, on the other,that resultedin those large courtyards.Anotherimportant featurewas the well whichprovidedwaterforboth man and beast. Houses were separatedfromone anotherby wide intervals,as familiesused to cultivatethe fieldsnext to theirhomes. The resultwas a haphazard and amorphoussprawl of buildings.BrownestatedthatCobbé foran extentof two mileshad not more than a hundreddistinctenclosureswhichcould properlybe termedhouses. The of thetownwas devotedto the market. largeopen space to the south-west The residentsin towns were mostlymerchants,and in Kurma the whole place was occupied by them.Very small numbersof native Fur were foundin towns,the majoritylivingin small agriculturalvillages.Only Gadid, inhabited by nativereligiouspeople,could be considereda religiouscentre.But even there, merchants, thoughnotresidingin thetown,had some houses.Populationin those townswas diverse;beside the small numbersof Fur Fellata fromWest Africa, Mahas and Danagla fromnorthernNile Valley, Arab tribesfromthe Sudan, variedfrom But thedegreeof diversity Egyptiansand Tunisianswererepresented. town to town,the largesthad the most cosmopolitanpopulation.2 1Matthews, op.cit.,pp.60-1,67; Burckhardt, op.cit.,p. 432. 2Browne, op.cit.,pp.286-7;Al-Tūnisi, op.cit.,pp.202-4. This content downloaded from 41.67.21.5 on Wed, 27 Jan 2016 06:38:07 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 70 Sudan Notes and Records Conclusion Burckhardtstatedthatthewordmedinahor citycould not be appliedto any place of thispart of the Sudan.1 ComparingthemwithEuropean towns,which weremoreadvancedwithrespectto planning,townzonationand civicamenities, he ought to have found them smaller,haphazardlybuilt,and poorly provided witheventhebasic urbanservices.Althoughlackingin mostof thecharacteristics maintainedby European towns,places such as Sennar,Cobbé, Shendi,Berber and Suakin mighteasily be describedas towns,since theyperformedfunctions of both trade and administration not only forthemselves,but also for the surThe regionas a wholewas verysparselypopulatedand so roundingcountryside. large towns did not exist. Consequently,places of a few thousandpopulation, whichprovidedservicesfortheirregionmight,nevertheless, be classifiedas towns. The commonesttypeof habitationwas the small village,and scatteredisolated huts ratherthan the town. The powers of monarchswere concentratedin the was able to acquire other capital which,because of its political significance, functionssuch as those of trade and education.Caravan routesencouragedthe spread of marketcentresand made possible the exchangeof commodities.The only towns of importancein Burckhardt^time (1814) were Sennar and Cobbé which had startedas administrative centres,and Shendi, Berber and Suakin whichowed theirimportanceto caravan routesthattapped variouspartsof the countryand the lands beyond.The Nile itselfbeingan importantarteryof trade and communication, and a sourceof lifein a desolatedesert,attractedsettlements whichwereto growlaterinto largetowns. On the whole,it may be said that both the numberand size of settlements were small priorto the Turco-Egyptian invasionof 1821, and the townswhich existedprovideda limitednumberof servicesand functions.Some of the towns which existed before the invasion had disappeared, others have since then developedintominoror majorcentresprovidinga widerrangeof urbanfunctions. Acknowledgement Many thanks are due to Sayed O. Satti, CartographicTechnicianin the Dept. of Geography,Universityof Khartoum,fordrawingthe map. 1Burckhardt, op.cit.,p. 265. This content downloaded from 41.67.21.5 on Wed, 27 Jan 2016 06:38:07 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz