Vertebrate Palaeodistributional Patterns and Continental Drift Author(s): C. Barry Cox Source: Journal of Biogeography, Vol. 1, No. 2 (Jun., 1974), pp. 75-94 Published by: Blackwell Publishing Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3037956 Accessed: 01/09/2010 19:51 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use. Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=black. Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission. JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Blackwell Publishing is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Journal of Biogeography. http://www.jstor.org Journalof Biogeography (1974) 1, 75-94 Vertebrate palaeodistributional patterns and continental drift C. BARRY COX King's College,Strand,London Zoology Department, merica' (Asia plus westernNorth America) and 'Euramerica' (easternNorth Americaplus Europe). A barrierappears to haveformedbetweenAsia and westernNorthAmericain the UppermostCretaceous. Bothmarsupialsand condylarth placentalmammals appear to have crossedbetweenLaurasia and GondAbstract wanaland in the Upper Cretaceous; theirroute is island sweepstakes (primarily uncertain,but a trans-Caribbean of vertebrates Thepatternsof distribution route seems the most likely. Marsupials probably terrestrialforms) are analysed from the Silurian enteredAustraliafromSouthAmericavia Antarctica, onwards,usingpalaeogeographicalmaps whichshow placentalsevolvinglater and being unable to follow oceans. seas as wellas intercontinental epicontinental thembecause theSouthAmerica-Antarctica linkhad Silurian vertebrates(fish) are known almost by thenbroken. exclusivelyfrom Euramerica.Many Devonian fish The apparent areas of origin of the different foundinfreshwatersseemto have whichare normally mammalianordersare shownin Venndiagrams.The seas between one been able to cross intervening and another.It is suggestedthatthisability historyof the faunal relationshipsof the mammal continent landmassesduringtheTertiary faunasof thedifferent relatedto theircapacityto use maybe physiologically is outlined. aerial respiration.There is some evidencefor a separate Devonian osteostracanfishfauna in China. Amphibiansare firstknownfrom the uppermost Introduction Devonian of the Euramericancontinent,and land are knownalmost exclusivelyfrom that vertebrates Much of biogeographyis at presentin a state of untiltheMid Permian.It is suggestedthat continent adjustmentto the new frameworkof plate tectonics. tetrapodsmay have evolvedin Euramerica,and were only able to colonizeAsia and Gondwanalandafter Geophysicistshave almostliterallytakentheground from under old theories. Much biogeographical continentaldrifthad linked these areas withEurin evencomparatively recentliterature america, causing the Uralian and Alleghanian interpretation has tended to accept the old hypotheses,based on orogenies. staticgeography,and to seek new justificationsfor The tetrapodfauna of the Upper Permian and Triassicappears to have been cosmopolitan.Though them in the shiftingpatternsof plate tectonics.A fresh start should instead be made, plottingthe Pangaea startedto break up in the Jurassic,land distributional patternson palaeogeographicalassemvertebrateswere still able to dispersebetweenEurblages and tryingto see whattheimplicationsare for americaand Asia (probablyvia theBeringregion)and biological connections.These new between the Northernand Southern Hemispheres intercontinental ideas formthe rationalebehindthispaper. In many (probablyvia southernEurope). cases, palaeogeographicaldata are now morefirmly Thereis littleevidencethatdinosaurswereable to and cross the Cretaceous Tethyansea barrierbetween establishedthanthedata of palaeodistributions, Laurasia and Gondwanaland. Lower Cretaceous should be used to generate-questions to ask the palaeobiological world. In some cases, however, dinosaurs were able to disperse throughoutthe NorthernHemisphere, presumablyby a continuation distributionaldata are still the betterknown, and may help to indicatethemostlikelysolutionforthe of theBeringlink.In the UpperCretaceous,theMidContinental Seaway of NorthAmerica,togetherwith palaeogeographers.Of course, where there is an betweenthe implicationsof theTurgaiStraitsbetweenEuropeand Asia, separated apparentinconsistency the two sets of data, both must be regarded as two land areas withdistinctdinosaurfaunas: 'Asia6 75 76 C. BarryCox meriting reconsiderationuntil an interpretation acceptableto both disciplineshas been reached. There are many factors which can bias our knowledgeof the fossil record. Obviously enough, fossilscan onlybe foundin a particulararea if they were deposited in sediments laid down in the appropriate environment,which are themselves revealedby erosion or earthmovement,in an area thatis physicallyaccessibleand is visitedby a sufficientlycuriousor trainedobserveror collector.The absence of fossilsfroma particularstretchof geological time,from a particulargeographicarea or fromdepositsof a particularcharacter,may be due to the absence of any of thesenecessaryconditions. Such an explanation is probably often,even normally, correct.Nevertheless,this should not blind us to thepossibilitythata taxon may not have been found in a particulararea because, quite simply,it neverexistedthere. Our new understandingof palaeogeographyalso reveals new possible anomalies. As will be seen later, the presenceof a new taxon in a particular continenthas in some cases been suggestedon the basis of somewhat unconvincingevidence, which does notincludethecriticaldiagnosticfeaturesof the taxon. One's doubts of thesesuggestionsare strengthenedif it now appears thattheyare the onlybasis forbelievingthe taxon to be presentnot merelyin a single modern continent,but in an entire supercontinentsuch as Gondwanaland. Though ideally one should take into account all of any givenperiodof time theorganicdistributions when tryingto evaluate patternsof life,the record of the vertebratesis comparativelywell known,and in particularthe normallyterrestrialmode of life of tetrapodsprovidesa good test of land connections; accordingly,it is the palaeodistributional patternsof these groups from the Silurian period onwards which are to be examined in the present study. Maps prepared for a 1971 Symposium in Cambridge, England (Smith, Briden & Drewry, 1973) have been used as a palaeogeographicbasis for the study,witha few minormodificationsnoted in thelegends.For theMesozoic period,thesemaps are based upon data from three independentlines of enquiry-palaeomagnetism,sea floorspreadingand computer fittingof continentalshelves. For the Palaeozoic, beforePangaea had formed,the maps were produced by dividing Pangaea along preMesozoic orogenicbelts and using palaeomagnetic data alone to place each resultingfragmentin an appropriateorientation.Though the palaeomagnetic data of thisperiodindicatethe approximatepalaeoit shouldbe notedthatthe latitudeof each fragment, palaeolongitudinal(east-west)distancesbetweenthe are unknown.For a moredetaileddiscussfragments ion ofthesepoints,see Smith,Briden& Drewry,1973. The maps presentedhereinextend over 270? of longitude. Where they lie within a reassembled or at some distancefromtheedge of supercontinent, the continentalshelf, present day coastlines are lines. Details of the shallow, shown as interrupted epicontinentalseas have been added, mainly after Kummel (1970), as thesewere almostas effective as oceans in actingas barriersto thespreadofterrestrial organisms.Though the extentof theseseas, and the width of the oceans, will have varied somewhat duringthe period of timecoveredby each map, the basic biogeographicalpatternswill not have been affected.The locations of the major sites at which vertebrateshave been found have also been added, to givesome idea of theextentofthefactualbasis for statementswhichrelateto biogeographicalpatterns of distribution. Silurian-Devonianpatterns(Fig. 1) In the Palaeozoic period, Gondwanaland seems to have had a historyquite different fromthat of the restof the world(Briden,1973). It seems alreadyto have been complete in the Ordovician, as it is traversedby no orogenic belts youngerthan 500 millionyears. In contrast,North America,Europe and Siberia wereall separatefromone another,and the Palaeozoic whereabouts of China are still uncertain(Smith,Briden& Drewry,1973). That NorthAmerica,Europe and Asia wereall in relativemotion duringthe Palaeozoic is suggested not only by the fact that theydid meet in the late Palaeozoic, but also by the orogenicactivityalong their margins. The fusion of the Canadian and Baltic Shields took place in the Upper Silurian to Mid Devonian,judgingbythedate oftheCaledonian and Acadian orogenies which signal that meeting (McKerrow & Ziegler,1972). Partlybecause of this erosional-sedimentary activityin theNorthAmerican and European plates,partlybecause of theirpalaeoequatorial position, and partly because of the intensityof palaeontological investigationin these areas, our knowledge of Ordovician and Silurian vertebrateevolution,in the formof fishgroups,is almost entirelyconfinedto these two plates. The acanthodian Nostolepis and undescribed hetero- and continental Vertebrate drift 77 palaeodistributions . '' ----- ' " "". .... ......... '''...... ....I........ 1-.... ... ......... ................ ..1.1.1.1.1. ................. -.-.-.....-.-.-.....-...-.-..... ,.:-,.,-,.,.,-" .................... I.I.I.I... ."I'll, .......... -.'.-.-.-.-.-.%-. .''--"--'--'"--'-.... %-.-.-.-.-.-.-:.:-:..-:-:.:..-,.:.:-:-:.,:::::::::::::::::::: 11 '-..,......::::::--..:.:.:.:.-.-.:.:.:.:...,.,.,.,. ......... ................................... .-. ..'.....,x......... -.' ................ :::::: ... ... ......................... '' .. ._-1'-1-_-I_-i: -..::____--_-__----_I:.--'.-'..."-----""' . .. ... ........... "-l'-,-'-.I"..,.,..,.,.".,-.... .....:-............ ...... ...:: ......... ......'..........'.'.'.'.'.%%.. ...... :....... ,:::.:.. 70,'N....-,::.. .:::::..-. ...-:-'-'-'.'.'.'. .... ...: ... ..::::::::::::::::::,.,.,.,.,........ --..::.-'--:::::::..-,...:::::::....,: ............. ":-:-.-K-:.:-:-:-:.I.-.-.-.-. '-....',...... I_'_I_ ....'.':::::::". ........ ....:.I.I.I.I.I.I...... ............... %...'........ ..II.:: .... ..... ........... .I.,. ...::: .. ,,,......................... .% ................. . '.'.'.'.'."'.'.'.. ... _ .I..:.-.'.I.-. . . ........ :-:-:-:-:-'_:_:_:_.-%1-1-1 .S L UR -'--.'"'-.'-'.---" I.I..... :_:-:C-:_. :-'-. ..... -.'-'-'.'.-' """' :t. ""' ................,'..........'.--.. :::::: .... ,:,:,:,:,::.:.:. ".:-:-:-:.:.,.:-.-:-:.:.:.:-:.:.:.,-,-.-I "."', .. ...._ ... -.--..... ... .:::::::::::::::: .............. -,.-..-..-..... _'_-----_-_ ... 1...... -.....'............ .._.-.-...'-.-.-:-:-: -.-,-:.:-:.: . ....... ......... ..... ................ ......... .-:-:-,-,-,-: %%...: '-.' ------:..........'.' ' :-:-:-:-.-.-::::::::::::::.. '..'....%......................,............................ -....:.-r.-.:-.-. %%,.-.-.-.-.-.-. -..........'.........i.-'.'.-: ............ ....... ...". ...I-........ ..............I....... t: "', .: ..-' .. .. ..", .... : .-,,, z. .................... "":. ,:::, ......................................... .:'-. ... ".'..... _j ..... ..... _'_ .,-:-:-:-:-..,-,.:::,.,..:,,."...,%,...'."'. .......... -. -...... ... --...,-........ ....... ...........'.....................,...... .... :,-::::: '.-' ...-:::.-.....'.% I." ... ... '.'-.'.'.,.-'...,-.-,.l'i"'.ii.-....".,,."", .. ....-:.:.:.:-:-:-:-:-% --...:: ....--------_............ .....'. ............. ... -'-:..::::-'.':::::: ... E V NIA N . .: -" --.-.---..... :.:-:...-,:::::,.:-:.:.:"::-,::::... . ..... .:.:-:-:-:-: -'. .-:-D .. .:.:.:-:.,-:.:.:.:.:.:.:,:.:-:-:.:-:.:.:.:-,. : :. :' '.'.-.-...-.-...........,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,..,....-.-......... .. : ::-.. . -..-.-...-..-.-.--.-..--.----.-------' __-......... ...... ............................................................................. ... X...' ' ' -IIIIII......0 ..... . . ... ...... ..... -:::j::::::::::?.::'-:-:':-'__ ................ ......-....................................... .... ' ............. . .::,:":,:,:,:,:.:-:j:.:.:.:-:-,::...".'.'.'-'-'-'-'-'."1-1.1-1-1-1.I...I.I.............. .. ....... .... ............... ..i:::: -*' ..i.,-... _.: "I ....... *.'...'.'.. ..,.,.. ..... ... :j:: e---........ ..-.. '... ............ ... :-:::-:'. I...I'.:.:-: ........ -::::::::::::::-.::-.::'-'-'.::::-" ... .:-.-.-....%,.:.:.:-.'-.,-:-:-:.:-,..-:.:-:.: ... :.:.. . .... -':-"-X':. . ... .... ...... ."-*i......._............-:........... ......... .... ... .. ......'....::::-.*.-.. ....:.:.:."............. . .......--_-.-.-.--....... _............................ ':`' .. ...- -:i.::.:.:.-:-... 1-1 ...... ....%.::, ..:.:.:'......... ...... -. ..... , -....'.....' ...... "'' ''''..-.,...:-. .. ..... ::.::.: ................... -. ................. -:-.-.-:-:-:-:-:.. ,"' :,. __ ' "'- - .-...................... ....'. ....... ...... ........:::.,.:.:.:.:-%,.,..:.,:,.,::...:::-".,-:-.-.:,...:: ............ ..-.,-, ..... .-... ............ ....__j............. '.'"............. .... .:.I.................... -:-:-%':':':':'::-_------......... ..'-,-.---..'..-.i -.....',-.... '-'-'-:::::-.-::::........... ......... .... .. "..:".".-:-::::::.-,.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.: ..:.... %..... .................... ......................... .. .... ....... ........ ....N::-:.:.:.:':. ..."'.''i'.. ......... ....: ......;A...--, .--.--.-----. .' .1:. ..................... ....................... -..... .. .--. '. .............-... _. ........:_X_:_I_--I-I._I-I-I _... _-----------_---_-_-_-._---_ I'll '.,-.:.:. ..... ..-...................:""":...:"",.,:,.,:..".,:,:,:,.,.:,::.,.,.,::::-'.-'.'.':::: ............ -.,.' ....... .. ................. :.:.:.:.:. .................. ...... .........-. : :..... :....... ............. .. ............ . ......... .'.'.'.,.,.-.-.-.::.,-,-.......:......... ....-....-............................ ............... ::* ", ..... :::::...,................,.....: ". ................. .'-.'-::&:.:.:....J. .............. I........-, .0......... --.. ............ ' ' ' ...... ' ' ..:::-,. ...................... "".",* ' 11 ....... ... .::.., % IX.I.......::: ,.,::::::-,-,-,-,.. .1.1 ..I . .1-1 I I11.I........... ..I. ... ' -..... ..... -, -':':"""':':""':'-"': .. .1.1.1. .-.I.I.-.-.-.-.i:.-:::.......X. .* ........ .............. .... . . '..:..:.:_:-:_:-:-X_:.::. :ill-.----................. -......,:::::::::,.,.,-::::..:::.-::..::..:::::..::..:: ... '.................. . .......... ..... -,.,-,-:.-........-.................... _-_-__--------_-_-----_-----_. ..........'%1.1.1.1.1.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.: ...1-1.1 ..... :---...::................. ........... -:.:.:.:.:.:-, --""',....... " - ... .... -'-.-..:-:-:-.-:.:.:.:-.'-.-,.:-:..-,-,-,.. .. ...... "............... - i--'-.-'.'.'.-.-....... ......... ",.-.....-.-X-.X-:-:-: ...'::" .-.,.-.,.-.-.-........ , ,::: -:: .-:-:j:' -:... ,.......* ..............'..: '' ....::,% "',,,,,,,,,,,,,, ..... ... ............... -:]:j:::. '::.--:.,:. .:. ..........................'-:-......:.:.....:':':.......::..................... .i-: ............%........ I-.-..-.I..". .-.:-.---.----...--.......... . ......... .. ........-.-.-.,.,.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.. ...... -I--,", -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.% ........ ". ............ : .... ... . ........ .:-:.:-,-,-.,.:.:.:.,-.-:-:-.--:.:-,.... -: .:-: .... .......................... .... .:!.::.:x........... ... .... ............. .: -, %%. :-:-.-, -I .., .......... ... .... ...... --..-...-.-,-.-,.-..-...--..'-..."..,..: ::.... :::::::: %..... .............. ::-.'.'.'.-.-:-:-: .... ....... ..... -.. %.................. .... -'... -1-111 ...... ' ...... ..... :.:.X-I_:_:_:_I_I-'-'-:::::.. _._.-._..'.'.'.. ....'.'.'.'.'.'.% .....-.. -':-:-.-.-::::::::::::--.'.-.. ....... .-....X.:.X :.,.:...: .... -:::-'... ................. ........... ... :".... :-.,.:.,.\ ..... -:-V-:.:.:.-.-.-.,,,.'.. ..:.:-:.......:-:.:-,.-:.:.:.:.:, ,.:-:: -:-.-.-:-.-.-:-.-X-:-.-:-:-:' ...... :'_:-:-X_:_-... ....... -.,. :-:-:-:.. ...:: ".',',',',',',',',' ....................... -... .... --:. ... ........... ... .....'.........I.I.I.I.I: .................. ".,::::.--. ....... '-."-... ... "."""''-'"'..... -:...A....... '.... :.-""""::::::'.:: " ... -' ............. .- -i-* .-.-.-.-.-.-...-..:.:-.-.-:-:-:.:-:"'.: ... . .....::::..... -...' "." ..':::::::.-'-."..... .... i:.:i:i::]:.,:.,:.:.:.:..:.:.,:]:.:.....' .... . . -.-..%:..'. ...... .........,,......, .. :'.-.-:-:-:-X-.-.-.-:-:-%.... .-. ............. '---.. -1 . .......'-.1 ,,.. . -I...:::::::.,:::::::..:::::::.-::::....: ..... ..... I.,.-:::-.::..:::::::::::::.,.:.-....-... .... .. -:...:.:.:.:.. ........ :.:.% -.............' ....... -.-.-.-.-.-.-. ........X ...............I , ':':':':.:-':'-'.:-:-:-:.:.:-':-':-:.:.:,.,.,.,.,.'I ''-.-:.:-:::::::::.:.:,:::::::,...-:::::..... "'. . :':':':'::j:::::::::. :'---'.-.".-.-.-..-'........ ... ...........,.... .... .... ... .... I.,.,. .,*-, 'i ....--'""' .:*-i''-..-)'-*-:. ........:.: i---.'--i.:--'i:.ii. ......, X1.,.:.:.%'.'....,..... ....: -:-:.:-:-. ::: ...... .-:-:-.-.-.. ... ......... .... ...: -.... - .... N:.:.:-:-:-:-:-:. .:..-.-. ....:,.-,--,-,,,,,%,,,, -.-.-.,.,.-.-.,.-.,.,.%%..,.,...,.,....:..:-:-..:.:-"... ... -:'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'...... ....... ...':--ii-'.i.:.:...:.:.:.:.:.. "' ' -............... -........ ,,.,,-,,,,..,,,.,-,, --".-:.-.-.-.-.I.-.-.-:-:-:-:-.-. .........::-..,::: .% X.... .1.1.1.1.1. .........%%.......' ... ........-..-.,.-.-.-.,. -'.----.. -, ...: ........ ':-:-.-x-:!:-... ...........".. ..... '' -%':ii, :.:.:.:.:.:.:..:-:-:i:..::.::: ', .:-:.:-:.: ' ' ............... ..-:-:-,-:-:.:.:-:.:-:-:-:-..,. ..'---'---'.-'---'*'----.:::::, ...... ......:::::::'-'-'-:.:::. ...'.-.-.'.'.'.'.... . .:.:-:.,-... ..:::::::: . . .,.,. ....._... :-:-:-:-:-:............. '.. " .-.,,,,.,, ....... ..:.:'.:.:i:.,:.:::-,!.!+:;:::::::.:.:::::::::::::::::",.,.,,,, 'f........ ......... .......... :... -,,.:-.-.:-: . .'.'--... . ... .... ..-.-.%,.,.,.,.-.-.,.-.-.-.,.-.-.-.% i.-iii." '.i--.-i- .........","'-..-.-.I.I.-.-.-.%I.-X-'-.-. .% . . .......... -I' .'. : :::...-:::::::-.:::::.-...-::::: .,............ .................. : : :.,:.:.:.:.:..:,::!k,..."4-.-:,: . . . ........... N.:--.:-:. I. ::::::,::: .. .. '%:-'::-'.:.-.-. ..... .. ..'........ I::::::::::.-'-'-%'-' ii,.ii'.ii--i:i.i-.-iii]....' ::::::::::. ::::..-.-:-:..-:.:-:.:-M-:-.-.-.-.........%-.-.-.-. : ":......"' .-.'-.-.-:-.-.-'-:-.-:-:-.-.-:: .............. ..... ..-.-.'.'.'.-.-... , ,-':!: _..::..... .. .I........ ......,.,.,..,.. .. ..'. %.I...........'....%:-.-.,.:,.,:::,.% .."'.,-,., ..-.-.'_:-:-:_:_'_'-'-'_'_'_'_' ............................ -.-.-.-.,.-.-.-.-..:,:..: .... .......... ... . ........ ---:-:-.-:-.-:-'-..::::::::.-.-.:.:.I.:.-.:.:.: ....... ..... ....... .......... .:':"-'-':X .... ....-:. ....... ............ ........................ I'll ...-:.r ..'..... -....%.:.:.:-:-:-,-:-:.:.:.:.:-:-:-..,.,-:::-,..:::::::,.%:-:-:.:-,............................................. ......... --1 ........ --..... -....... -- "' ... , --i'-'.i].i]. ......I., i-.'i-'"'ii.,...,...,:::"",:-"i":-..:j:.K. .-........ .............................. . -",.,.,. ........ .. ,-.--.-----.--.-'........ .... , ...... ..... ,.-.-.-.,.,.,-.-.,.,.-.-.-.-. .......-. . .:':.....:::::-,-.-.-.-.-.-:-:-^ ,:.:,::::: ......... ... ........ . ...1. .. 11 '.-,I.-.I.'.-. '........ ......... ........7 -'..... .. -:::::::::::::-.-.I.I. ................ ..... -...'.'.'.'.'.':::..::.. ...:..... :::::::.-,.-, ........... ............. N .:::::::--..:::::::-,... -:.,.%: .... .... .. .. -........ :::-.:::::::::::::::::::::::::: ......... ......'........ --:.:-:-:..-:-: '']-.ii--i'---:-' -.-. , -.-'::--':":": "--.-,k . . . -. .:-:-:-.,-:-:-:-:-:..-:-:-;,;...,, ' -.: .... I--...:::: ......... .. ' .......... -.I.-.I.: ........ ' ' ..............: .......................... .... .... """", iii' ..:-iii-:. ....... --. ".' -.-,, ."'..."'..... -................. -..:-:.:.:..-.-:-:.:....-:.::::.-.-..... .::-X-:-:-'_'-'-'-' ":.':.':.:.:.-:':'-.....'.." ..-:-:-:-:-.-._.-..:"i,.-.-..'-.,...,..,.-."................, ".":,:,.:.:.:,-X ....-.,.,.-.-.-.,. .:.-:..:. .. ..... .1.1. .......". ... "' :.-.-.-.-:-'.-.:'-.-'-..... -.,,, ...-iii]i-'..-. '' 'i"''':-'-":j:.':.':.:j:::- ii.-: -..' -i-''-.-. ...... : .\..:............ :':':-.. ...... :-'--."-.---.-.--:-:.. .. . -. V:-:.....: 0.: .................... .... :::::.1 ...... .. :.:. ..... ... .......... -':::::::%'-:::::::-'-'-'-.. ..'..'....-'.:::::::::.--.-.:.--.-.--.:.:: '-:.-'-'.--'-.: ......... .-... -:.,.,:::: . .... . . . . . ......... ........... ..... .............. .....""....... .--:::::.-.:::::::::'. ....--.....:..-......:.....-.:.:.........:::::,. - .. ...... .. 1-1 ::., .......... .. .. -.,:,-..... -....'....... K:-... .........-..'.'.'..'.'.''%-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.. --.:_:-:-:-:-: ...: -.-,-..::::::::::: ..... .:.:-.-.-.-.-...",..--...'.-...,..,.--.--...--.: .............. ...... V........ ... '.'..'.....I......:.x.:.:.:.... 1.1-1, 'k'..." .. -......-'-'-'-'-'....'......... ''i."iK" .'-'ii-i... -..,':.'.. '::':::::.-:.jj---i:i::-'.Ii:x -'''.. ........ ..... .-,...-,-....,..,--,..:.-:..:.:.:.:-': , ..'..:.: ............ ....i... ....... ... ' ... .... --. "' "::: -.:::::::::-'--:::'-'-'-.::: *.*i'.'.'.*'-.-.-.-................. -... i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ii`---'.. .:-,:,..-:-:-:.:.:.:-:-:-:-:-:.:-.-. -:j:. .-.-. ."]' :iii]. -.. .-... ':j:::. .':j ... .. .-... ............................. ....V --, ..".. ----.---.-.-." -,..-,... --'''"."','' --.-'.... ....... ....-.-.:.:.-.....'"' .....,......... ...................:....... ................. ":":' .. .................. -:.. ....... -.... ..:'................. i.-ii--.. .:.,:. .:.-:.-.-'..... -iii' ...... .ii -...... ...I.I.I.."..........x.: ........ -...:-,:. "-.... ..............:.. ...,... ........................... .......... -.: -... .1 :.-.-.--..-.-.-.---.-. ",."".",.........:........,.:-..:...-.., ......... %"................. ..-.-..-.-.............:....:i:-...... ".-"""", . .......... . ..... .. ..........%....'............... ........ ---.-.-.-. ......... ... ....' -'---'-'-----*-'-'--'.---.... ....... ......',-....... ::.,.-,. ............ ... "-.1 ... ... .................. .. . .... ............ ................ ..'.........:-......:---: ---'--------.... .. ......... .....-.-.I.I.-.I.I:::::: ............ ... ...... :.:.:j:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.::::::::: .................................. .".-..-.-...,.:.'.:..-:::::::;:::::::::::.,::::::::::::.:............... ":.:..:.:.: .-.-.%%,.,.,........ ...% ':'I'I':':"-:---'---': ........ ' .........-1-1-1-:.:-...-:.:.:.:.,...:.,-,-:.:-: -:.:..." ".." "-,"", .. .......:. I........."'. -:.:.:.:.-...-...-...-.-.-.,.,.-.-.-.%-.-.-.-.-.-.......... ",-,::q:.':.'--.-.-.--.I.I.I.I.1.1.-.-.%%,.,.,.,.-.-.,.":':':.:.:.:-':-:..:,::::: ........ ::::::::. ,....... I...... ...... , .:. ................ .. . ................. -.-:-:..-.-:.:.:.,-.-: ' .."'...................... .. .... .................. .:-:. . ..... .:i:i:.:.-,..:::i::-:::::::::::::::::::::::::: "-.1-....... .... . ... .:.:..-,.,-,-..-. ..-.-.,.-.-.-.,.,.,.,.-.-.-.-.,.,.,.-.''. '- '" %-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-..: .... .. ... "", --ii ..... ..... ..:....... "". -'.-....,....,-.."..-...-...,."".-.-.,..-.'.'.'..-..'.-..'.'..-..... ...... .:. -...:.:.%%%-.-.-.-.-.-.-........... ....... ............ ' -'..'-.".'-.-'.-'.'...,.-,..-,....-,....,.'.-..'.......-...-..-.....:.,."...,.,.",..,.,."",...,":... ............................... .. ."I ..........'':.:.:-:-.-.-:-:-.-.-.-:-:-:-.-.-.-.-.-:-...-.... ................................. .I.I.I... .................... .. ................. .................. ",:. .... -:.., ' """:':'-'Z' i-%:'.: -----.---'--x----.. .......... ....... ........ ' , ' -"' ....................... .::-, "............. ' .; :" . .... ::::::::. . %..:. ......... .. . ", .. ::j.::.,:i:.,::::.'-'::i:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::..:..*!: .... ,'':::::::::.... .. .-:-:-:-'-'-'-:-:-... .'. :-.-.,.,. -,-"-".-., -:-:-x-:-:-x-:-:-:-:.................... ... .-....:.:-....:-:-:-.-:.:.:.:.:-.::.. -:::::::....-"::::::: ... "I* :. ..............V............ ......-..... ..-.-.-.:. . . .. ...-... ..."..,...-.,....,.-.,.".-'-.....'...................... :-:.:.:..:,:.:-:-:.:':.:':':':':-:.: '.'.'.'.'-'.,-:.:-:-.---:-:-:-:.,.. .... ::::,:, ......... :i;!i::--:.;:!: -:-:.:..-....,.:-.-..:::-:-.--............-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-...'..... "'-......'.'.. . . .................. .......:-:-:%'...'.... ....:.%%-.-.-.-.-.-....-.%....-.-.-.-.-.-.%...-.-.-.-.-.-.-. -............'.:.: .,..-",,-..-:,.--...-",-...-,...-..,:.:,-: ...-.'.; """".'.'. .......... _._X_:_:_:_:-:-:-.-.-.-:-X: .... -:.:.:-:-. .......... . ................ ..'..:::::.. .:..-.-,-.. ..'.I.I.I.I'I.I.I.I::'::j:.':........ .......... ---" ....... ..... ................ ...... .. .::::-:-'-'-'-'-'-....... ......::::::....: -.-:.:-:-.-.-,-:.:..-.-.-.-.-.,.,.,.,.I :::-:".I'.'..'.'.'.I.-.-' ....-...... ........ X ...1:.,.:::.,-, ..... - -:-X-:-:-:-:-:-'-.-:-:.'.'.'.'..'.'.'.'.'.'.....''--:::::::.-.':::'.::'".-.I.I.-:'--'-'-.:j:j:]:.:' ....... .:,:.:.:.:.::::::::::::......,.,.,...,..... .... .... ................ ............... ................. I........I.i! : %:.:.:-:.:.,., ' ' ""-'-'-'-:::.-:: ':....... .-:.:.-.-.-. ---.-.-.-.-.-:-:.-.-.-.I.I.%I.-.I ---...... ----.....................%......:%..:.:.:-:.:-.-.-:.:.:-..:.:.:.:-. ....."', ,,.............. ..'...... . ..... . ..... .........1-.1.1.......-' I.I...... ...... -.:,:,-..,....,..-,..,..-.,-.."...,..,-,.,..",".-.'.'.'..-.'...... .,.":.:-:.:-:-:-:-,-:-.-.-:-:-:-:--.,. ------.-.-.-.%..:-:-:."-,:::::::::..:::::-.::..::::::: . ........:.:-:., :...-.-.-.:.:.%%-.-.-.-.. .-.:.:.%%%::,. -.-..-.:..:-,....:..:-.:.:...,.:.:.: ,: . .,..--,.,....................-..,:.XI.-:.:.:.:.: .......-........... - --%..... _1-1_1_:_:-:-%:_:-:.: :: :::-'-.'-'-'-'-'-'-':... .."", ...-,:::....%%-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-. ."... .....,,, X........................................ ................ %%1.1.1.1 :.:.x-.... ..... :.:."... ""'-'-'-'.'-'-'::-.: ...... --...i............ ,.:::--'-:-.-.-:-:-:-:.:_:_:_:-:-% ..-'.'.....,.,-,..-.-,.,.-...-.,..., .I...' .............._.I. ,............ %..... ...............%.... .......................................................... ......... "", ...... ..............%........... !.. ... ::.:-.'..:.:':.....:.:............ .: ....... ..................:. :-:-:-'.'.'.'.'.' ---..... . ":. ,x......i.i.i... ..............%%....... .... ..... '.'.'.'.'.'., ............................ . . .. .' %%_._._._.-._..:.: "... ..... ........'"' :N.::-:-,.:-:.:.:-:j:-:..:..:...:.:..:.,:-::' ....... ... :':.:.:-:_-_:_:_:-._:_:-_ ................. ....... ........ %-."'.---.-.-:-:-.-.-.-.' %'. ' ... .I...' ---. ........ ,' .--'''X .-. ...... :j:j:.:]%':.-:.:j ...x.:.:.:. .....:.... ... ::.:.:.:..::::::: .............,.-.,..%% '-" ---I....... ... .-:X-.-...-:-,.. :.... -:-:-:_-_:_:-:-. ...: .............. .,-:.:-:. .....",::::.,:::::::::,..-...:::::::.,.., .... ::...:.:.:.:-...:-:-.,-:-..:.:.:.: ..... -... ............. "...I.I........ ": ... ..'..-I................... ,................. -.-.-...,-,...,...::::::::::%,.,.,.,,--..,::::::::::::::::::::-:.:..:..:.:.: .... . ".......... .... .... .......I.I..... :-"'..... ............ ,. .. .. .. ....-........ .,-.. 11" .....i'.."i"i.,..,.-,.,..,..,'-'...".,.-:-:.:.:.:.:.:-:-:-:-:-:.:.:.:.::........:................... I..... ........... ..............: .- .. ::.:-.::::: ...... :.:.:-,..-:-:-:-: ....... %. .:-:-:-:....:-:.:-:.:-:.:.:.:.:-.'.:.:-:... ... .1.1 ..:.:.:.:.:. ::::.,.,: :::: .. ......... ..I......... .......... -....... ........-...... x-.-._._._.-._:_:_I"' :-:-.:.*i:.-*3 ......I.......................'.'....". ............... %......... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.,.:...:-:.,..:-:.: -- ..... .1, ...... .1.1.1.1.1.-%.. I......%. ..... .:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: 11.1 i:.....-................ ...... :,..::"....:. ........ ................:.'.'.'.,::::::: .......:I Africa,butthis groupswhichappearto be limitedto one environareknownfromnorthwest stracans be area mayhave been partof the NorthAmerican mentor the other,and whichmighttherefore of distripatterns andits expectedto have quitedifferent plateuntilafterclosureoftheproto-Atlantic to distinguish are bution.But in practiceit is difficult The onlyotherexceptions Jurassic reopening. and thisis equally patterns, suchdifferent specimensof the marinethelodontLoganiafrom precisely Myers(1938)found Siberia(Halstead& Turner,1973),and thepossibly trueforlivingfish.Forexample, 'divisions'of threedifferent torecognize itnecessary fromChina. Kiangsuaspis UpperSilurian divisionwhichincludes A morecompleterecordof fishevolutioncom- freshwaterfish:a primary to freshwater;a secondary confined mencesin theLowerDevonian.ThoughDevonian thosestrictly in divisionwiththose that have a littlesalt water andvariety numbers fisharestillknowningreater withthosethat division, and a peripheral thananywhere else,theyarealso known tolerance, Euramerica ofsaltwater. fromSiberia, China and Gondwanaland.Most areverytolerant to be entirely certain rhipidistians, It is thusclearlyimpossible majorgroups(dipnoans,coelacanths, offossilfishes. Many tolerances and antiarchs) arthrodires arefound oftheenvironmental heterostracans, freshwaterformsmayhavebeen deposits.It is often of theapparently in bothmarineand freshwater able to colonize ofsea water,and therefore at lowertaxonomiclevels, tolerant possibleto distinguish, 78 C. BarryCox otherriversystems,eitheron theiroriginaltectonic Euramericawas stillisolated.Its fusionwithSiberia, markedby the Uralian orogeny,took place in Mid plate or on anotherplate. In the case of the great continentof Gondwanalandin particular,extension Permiantimes(McKerrow & Ziegler,1972). As will be seen later, the fusion betweenEuramerica and of therangesof such fishmightotherwisehave been Gondwanaland may also have taken place at this very slow. Some known examples support this generalization. The Upper Devonian antiarch time. Figure 2 is thereforeintendedto show the freshwaterdeposits Palaeozoic worldafterland vertebrateshad evolved is foundin fluviatile Bothriolepis in Euramerica, Siberia, China, North Africa, but beforePangaea had formed. The existenceof theseseparatecontinentsis fully Antarcticaand centralAustralia.The inferencethat supportedby referenceto the Upper Carboniferous it could cross interveningstretchesof sea is conand Lower Permianplantdistributions (Chaloner & firmedby its presencein the marineinterreeffacies of the GlossopLacey, 1973),in whichtherestriction Australia(GardiGogo Formationof northwestern terisflorato Gondwanaland,and of theEuramerican ner & Miles, 1974). This faunaalso providesanother example, for it includes specimens of rhyncho- florato thatcontinent,is well known.*However,it does not appear to have been notedthusfarthatthe dipteridlungfish,which are otherwiseknown only Angaranflorais restricted to Asia untilthe Uralian fromfreshwater sedimentsin Euramerica.It may orogeny.It is also likelythat the differentiation of be relevantto note herethat,as Thomson(1969) has the Cathaysianflora of China reflectsan isolation pointedout, livingfishwhichat any timeuse aerial respiration exclusivelymust excrete their nitro- fromAsia imposed by interveningoceans, or epicontinentalseas. genous waste in the formof urea. Since Devonian Furtherevidencefor this may be derivedfroma lungfishaestivationburrowsare known, these fish studyof the contemporarydistributionsof amphiwere probably(like theirlivingdescendantsPolypbians, which are firstknown from the Devonian/ terusand Lepidosiren)able to retain urea at least Carboniferous boundary. Since even partially seasonally. By its retentionin the body fluid to terrestrial formsof lifeare muchmore reliable than increase the osmotic pressureof these fluids,urea purelyaquatic formsas indicatorsof separateland can also be used forosmoregulationin the sea, as in the coelacanth Latimeria masses-potentiallyseparatefaunalregions-fishare living chondrichthyans, excludedfromfurther therefore considerationin this and the anuran Rana cancrivora.Retentionof urea have provided study. forexcretorypurposesmay therefore The biogeographicalstandards for judging the the startingpointforan evolutionarychange which typeof physicaland biologicalrelationshipsexisting allowed the Devonian lung bearingfish(for Bothbetweentwo faunal regionswas explainedlong ago riolepis,too, had lungs) to survivein the sea and by Simpson (1940), who distinguishedthree types even perhapsto colonize it. of relationship.First, two areas may share a conCurrentinformationalso indicatesthat thereare a few cases in which contemporarydistributional siderableproportionof theirfaunalelements,which appear to representa wide range of environmental patternsdo seem to conformto the patternof late preferences.This would implythat the two areas Palaeozoic continents.Though the earliestanaspid, were joined by an ecologically wide 'corridor' Jamoytius,appears to have been marine (Ritchie, incorporatinga commensuratevarietyof environand have 1968), all later anaspids were freshwater ments,such as the latitudinallywide link between been foundonlyon the Euramericanplate. There is Europe and Asia today. Secondly,the faunas of the also a hint of the existenceof a distinctendemic two areas may share some taxa, but each may lack faunain China, as thegaleaspidosteostracanswhich taxa foundin a particularrange of environments in Liu (1965, p. 131) describesas 'verypeculiar' have been found only in that area. It seems significant the otherarea. This would implythatthe two areas werejoined by an ecologicallyrestricted'filter',so that these distinctiveformshave not as yet been that animals unable to toleratethisrestricted foundinthemuchbetterknownfaunasofEuramerica range of habitatswould be unable to pass throughfrom or Australia. one area to theother,just as thetropicalPanamanian land bridgetoday denies passage to the temperate faunal elementsof the two continentsthat it links. Carboniferous-LowerPermianpatterns(Fig. 2) At the beginning of the Carboniferous period, * In the Devonian and Lower Carboniferous thereseems, flora. puzzingly,to be a single,world-wide Vertebratepalaeodistributions and continentaldrift - X.... ........ . ....................... .1.1.1.%,.,.,.%,.,.-.,.%,.-.,.-.-.,.-.-.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.......%.. -.-..... ........... ....... ......... .... .. ... .. ........................................ . .-.... ........... 79 "'. ."..-.-.-.-.-.%-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.%,.,.,.,.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.I ........ ,, ....1.1.'.%,Nl.:-,..:-,..:.:.,.:-:.:.:-..:.,:: .............................................. ..... X............ .:.:.:.,-:.:.:-:.:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.............-.-...-.-.-...::..: .....:...%% ....,.,.,.,.,.,.,.-.-.,.,.,.-.,.,.,.-.I ...."II-,---. ........... ....... .. :............... ..%: I.....I......., ........ I'll:.... .... ..--.-_---.----.--.-. .. ....... . ......... 70,N.I............. .................................... -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.. ..:.:.:...:.:.::.:.:-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.. .N - X-:.:::-,.,.:.:.-.-...-.....-...-.-.-.-.-.-.... . ................... "I'll, ................................. -.. %""`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v .I.I.., ..... ... .::":::: .-.,.,.,.,.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-................... ........... ........ . ...............................-.-.....-.-.-.% . ....!" .........-.'.,-.:::.:::::.:. ..........:.. .................................. :.:.:,:-,.. I............ ............................................... 1--,:.:::. . I......................... . ..... .................,..................:.:.:.:.:.:.-.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:11-111-1 ........ ............... - - - ........... ................................... ,.-.,.-.,.%%,.,.,.,-.-:-:.%,-.,.:::::-,-,-:-:-:-:.. ............... ".., " '.." .................................. ::::: .................._...,_...... P E -R A N ....... ::: :, ................ -.-.:::::::::,;,-:-:-:.:....-.-.-.-.-.-..1.1.1.1.-.,.-.,.-....................................... ::::-.-:.:.:.:-,L..-:-:-.-.-:.:-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-..-. ................. " 1` ........................... 11................ ........ ........... _ .. -L __._............. ...... _M .. I........ __ -:-:.:.-.-.:.:.:.%-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.%-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.....:.!.:,:. .... , ... .1.1.1.1.1.111.1.....,.................................-....:.:....:. ..:.:.:,.,-:::::::-, .,.............................................. . . . . . . . .....' ...... %% ........ , .. ............. .1.1.1.-.%-.,.,.-..............................,......................... .............................................................. :.:.: .................. -----I...................-- ............................ ...... :'..:-,.:-:.:.:.:.:-.% -:-:-.-:.:.:-.. .. .................. ...I.I..................... .:.:.:.::::::.,::-:.:-:-:-:-:.:.:.:.:. ................................. I................................................................. -----,," --........ ............ -I.,.,.,.,.,.%, .I.I.I.I.I.I...., .. .... % ....... ..............................%........................ ... :................ ... .... ........................... .1.1.1.-.%-.-.-.%................................................................... ............................... ..,..'............... ........ :.:.:.:.: . . :-:-:..-:.:Y.:-:-.:::::::%,.,.,.,.,-.., ......... ... %.... . .,.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.%........................,.'..................................... ....% ........ ...... %,.,.,.,.-.,.-.,.,.,...,...,.,.,.,.,.,.,..-'.'-'.'........................ %.,..................-.-.-.-.-.-, .I.................... . I.I.I...I.I....... .............. %.... -.-.-.-.-.-.%-.-.,.,.-.,.-.,., ................... ............... ..... ::.....-.::,-,...,.,-,.,-,.,-.-, ...........................-.-.-.-..... .... ... ..................... -.-.-.-:-:-:-:.:.:.:..%-.-.-.%,.,.%,.,.,.,.-.,.,...-.-.-.-.I ....................... ....... -.-.-.... .. ::,-%,.,.,.,...............I............. ........ ,............... ,............... ..:.:.:.:.:.:-.... .......................... ..................-.-.-.-...-.....-.-.-.......-.........-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-...-.....-.-...-.-. I"I ......I....... -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-..-..:. .11'.1.1. II.%.....,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-...,...............................\ x_-_-.--_'_-_I-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.%-.,.-.-.-.-.... ..... : . ....................... -.-.-.-.-.-,-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-,-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.......... ..--.. _.. .: 1. , ....".1.1.1.111.1 I.I.I.I....... ............................... ..:.:..-.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.-.-.-.-.-.,.-.,.-...-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.:.-.-.:.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I ...... . . ...............I......... ....I.I.I.I.I.. 11111 "."I" .........I........... -....-.-.%-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.-.-.-".-.-.-.-.,.-.-., ,,,," , " " :: ,-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.-.-.-.-.-.-,-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-l-.-.-.-.,.,.l.-.-.-.-.11 ...... . . ...._... ....'.. _...... I.....I...I.I.I.I.I..."I.I.I...." 111 ,- - ...............I.... I.,.,.,.,.,.,.-. '.."...................... ...-I.Il.%,.,.,.,.,".,.,".,.-.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.I. ....... ......I........................ ............................ ,,---...--............'....... .........-.-.-.-.-.........-.-.-.-.-...-.-.... 1- \_\_ -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-........,.,.,.,.-.-.,.,.,.,.1.1.1.-.-.-.-.-.......... -.. ...---::.: ...... ,-------,-::-".:--I"-.,.,...-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-,-.-.--.-.-.-.-........ ....... ........ ................. ....-...-. .,-,-...,...-.-.-.-...-.-.-.-.....-. ....... ........................ -.--...... ....... ....1.1.1, ...... ..,.................... ... -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.-.-" I ....... %............... " ............ .. ........... " I......................................... ...... %% ............................. .. "-..I'll" .................... ...... ... ........ I..........."....................................................................,..................................,.......... ....... ....... " -, " ........ , .............. ...... ........... -1'....' ,",......I................................................... ..... ....... ....... . ...... 11 _1111-1111, :.:..:.:.:.:.:.-...............-... 1.1.: . ,................................................................................................ ------- -"-::' --V,., rI .,...... .......,... ................................... IIIIIIII.I.-........................... .................... ... ........................ ............. . :.:..::::::::::"-,., .. ............:.:.:.:.:.......-.....-.............................-.-.................-...-................ ... -............................................. ... .-................ i.... x -...- '... ................. "".......-.-.-.-.-............... ..-.:::.,.-.,i....'.'........................... . .. -."." .... i. ............. ..... ---: -................ .... .......................... ...,-.-.:.-. -.,.-.-,-.-.-.-.-.,.-.-.-.-.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-........................................ - ............... .......................... :.:-:-.-......-..-.-.-.-.-...-...-..-..-.-.-.-.-.-..-......................................,".....................................................:,:" -,-,-,-,-,.:::::::-,-,-,.,.,-,.,.,.,.'......... ..... .-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-. ".-.-.-.-.,1.1.1.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.,.,.-.-.-.-.-...........,......I ..., .................. :............... ,..............................................-....." ,.-...... .........'.............. ........ ...:: ............. ........ ......,..........I. I -.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.,.,.,.-.,.,.-.,.-.,.,.-.-.,.-...........-.....-.-.-.....-...-.-.-.....-.-.-........... ...............,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,......................................................................... ................................. .......... ......... -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-._.-._. ...... II.-II.I.I.I.I.-.-.-.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.-.,.,.,.,.,.-.-.-.-.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-............................... ....... ........ ... ............ .I...........................................................................-.-.:.:.,.....-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-........ .. I.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.......-...-.-. .......... .................... ....... ................ ............... ... 1_, J ,::...................................... ........ ," ..... :.:.:.:. ................................ ..................................................... ................ . . 1--.,.-.-.,.-.,.-...,......................................'............,.....................................:-:-:-:-:-:-:I......................... ..\ . ...,..-.-.-.-.-.-.-........................................... . -.-.......................................................... ...................................................................:.:.:.:.:-.,-:., ...'...................... I'll . . ................................................. ........... , :.............. ... .... .......... ........................ . 11-11-11 ........... I........................................................................... ........... ..................................................................,....................... ...... :.:.:.: ...................I............................... ............. 1.1.11111.1.1.1.1.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.....-................ ............... .............................. ... -.... ....... ......... ....'....., . ........... ............................................................,........ ....... ................ ...... , . ......... .:: ll.-Il.-.-".,.,.,...............,...................................,........................,...............,................................................. ....... ................................... ........ ....................................................,........................I :::.. ....-.-::( . ,,..:.-.-.%-.-.-.....,...,.......... -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-..... .... :.::::::,.. . -............I......... . " I................................................ IIIIII..'..._.... e- __a .................................................................. - ... :.:.:.:.:-,-,-:-:.:......-........:-:.:.:-: .......................................................................................................................I........ I......................................................................... -- .:.:.:.:.:.:.:.--.-.-.-. ............................... ' ' ............................,.,.-.,.,.,.,.,.:.. " I...... ::,:: t-:;-?4- '.',-` -'-'-'-'-'- -- .. - .. - :.:.:.:.:.:.:...::::::::::::::::.,-,-.-,-% ............. . ... " - - - - - - - ,-,,,,,,,,.,,:: ....... ........: ,-:-..,.:-, .-.-.-.-.%-.-.,.,.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.%%. ..... .-.-.-.-.,.-.,.,.,.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.%-.-.-.-.-.-.- . ". .-:.:-:-:-:..-:-:-:-,-.-::.::::-, ,.-.-.-..::::::: .... I I.:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:.......................-.-.-...-...-.......... ,il.,..:.......,...,.........-.-.-.-.,.,.,.-.,...,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.I ............................................................ ........................................ ................................................................ ...................... -...............-.-.,.,.-.-.-.-.........-.-.......................-.-.-.-.-..-....... ........................ ........... L........ ................................'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'......................................... :....... I.I.I.--.-.-.-.,.-.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.,.-.-.-.-.-........,-.-.....-.-...........-.-.-...-.-.-.....-...-.................................. .......................-..,.,..,.,..........,.,.,.,.......-.-.-.-...-...-.-.-.1.1.1.1.1.-......... . .................................................................... " ""' I -.... -.""........... ...................... .................................................................................:.:.:.:,:.:. iI.I.I.I.....I.I., . ................................................................................. _I\ .:. ...................... ........ .......................................................... ..-.----. i."...............................................................................................................................................:.:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.......... . . . . .. __, .'-''.'..'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'-'.'.'-'-'-,--.,.,.,.,.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'. .................. .... .... :.:. .1.11-.-.-.,."-.-.,.1.1.1.1.-.-.-..............................................,................................... ............I--.1.1.1.1..........-.-,-................:::. ........ ...I.................. ......... .......... . .................. .... I....I............................... ........... ... :.:.:.:.:-:.:-:.:.:.:.: ........ ..................................................................... )........ -11 ..... ....... .................... ....-............,................,.....:-:-:-,-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.,-,-,-,-.-,-..,....'..'.-'.., . .................. .... .......... _ :...........I..." v-:-:-:-:-:-:-:..-...-.-............................................. " ---" .................. --..............................................................................................................:.-:-:-:-:-:.:.:-:-:..,-:'' " .......... '...... ..................................,...........................,.... . ....... "", :................................................................ ,.::::::::::::,-,.,., .................. .-.,.,-.-.l-.-.-.-.-.,.,.-.,.,1.1.1.1.1.1.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-....................................,.,.................................................................,.,...,..I ........... ...................... .................................................................................. ................ .................... ...... ::::::::::::-:-:-:.:-:-: ........................................................................................... ... T ......... . C A H..... ............ " ...-."..,.-.-.-.,.-.-.-.,.,...........I ........... ......................................................... . :-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.:-:-:-:-,..-,.,.,.'.'-'-'-'-...-.........-.-................ ........ p ..... ............................ I........I...................... 1_11111111.1.1,1.1.1.1.. ...._...... -. .......................................................... :-:,:--.,-,-.-,-.-..,.'.'-'.'-'-'. ...................... ... ............ :.:.:.:.:.:.:.-....-.........-.....-....................................................................................................... ..... .................. .,';................................................... ...............................:.:.:.:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.:.,.,-,.,-'.'.'.'.'.'.......... ......................................... ....... -_ ................... . ....... "I'l-I.I.I.I.I.--.1.1.1."..............-.,.-.-.-.-.-.-................................................................................................................ ... ....... ....................................... 11\C-, ................................ ........... .. ........ ...................................................... ................................................................................................... 1.1.' ... -..:.....................-.-,-".,.-.-.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-...-.-.-.....-..................................................................... ....... J ...................................................,........ . .. . ..........................................................,. ..................... .....-.-::::::::::::, \,N I\ "". '..", 1.11.,I.I..:..............................,...,...........................'...........,............-..................................................... " " " '" ,-" " " '',1-11,111I " " " '".,"'."........... " " " " " " " " '" " " -'''".,.,.,.,.,.,.,." ................. ......... .................. .......................................... .................................... ....................... .................. ... ... -.%-.-.-.-.-.-. . ..................., ...................... ........ "I,.:...,.,.,...,................ ....................................................... ............................,.,...........,...... "" I,--,-" " -," " " ,11-111,111,111-11-1-11ll," ..... I........ ........-..,.,............................. ...............'........ ........ll,1.1l.,.-.l-.-..."............".....................................'...................,., ......................................................\ \ ................../..........................................,.......,........................................ . .... ................... ", ... ,...-................,..............................-.-.-.....-.-,-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.%-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-...-...............-.-.-...-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-...-.-.: ......... .............. .........,......................................................... , . ..... ..-.'.'.'.'.'o .................................................................................. .............. ..... ... ........... .,:.,. . ... ... . -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--,-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--..-..-.-..-. .I...................... ............................... I.,.,.,.,., I..,... I..,.......... .............................. -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,..,.,.,.-.,.-.,.-I :.'..:..:.:.: - I.............. _..... ...... .1..1.1.11.I.-I'.-.-I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.-..-.-.-.,.I.I.I.I.I.I.I.-.,.-"-.I..-."-.-.-.-.,..---.-.-.-.-.-...... " I'll" , ......................................... . ......................................... .................................................... .........................,.%,...-......................-..,.% .............................. 1.1.1.1.11--.,.-.-.-.-.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.-.---.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-........,............ ........................................... .11 ... ..... -1 . " ..- ...-.-.......-.-.%-.-.-.-.-...-.-.-.....-.-.-.-.............-.-.-,-......:.%:.:.:.:.:-:.:.:.:-:-: .............................. ...: _- ....:::::,-,-::-. ................................. .. ... '.,.I."-.,.,.,".,.-.,.,.,.-.-.-.-,.................................,.........,............................................................................................,.,.... ...........................................................................................................-.-.-...-...-..,............. .................................t' " : II_ :"","'.'.''.'.,.,.,.,.,.-.-.--.-...............-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.......'.....................................................-.-...........................,.................................... . . . . . . . 1-11_11-1 I. I........................................ .. " 11 .......... - ............... ........ ... .. .................................................................... ................. ...............:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:-:.:-:.:-: :......... ,. " " .......... . . . . . . . ... .... .......................................................,.,.............................. ..I............ ........ X.............,............................................................................................. ... .._ ...........I.I. --i"..",'"'.",,.,.."I'l-'-"""""""'-""'-"""""""'ll.,.', ,-'.:',X'-.'-.'.I " .:., 1:1 ...I...... _ _ ..................... ............... ..........................................,............................... %-.I.I.I.I.I.I.............. __ .I-__----* . ..... .-,...................... .... . -........ .........................................................................................,. ..... .... ........I... ..........I............................ '.---.., .........--*...--. :-,..,...,-:-:-:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:-:-:-A 1I.I.-.1.1 ............... ,-."..;.,.,.,,,.%,.,.,.,.,.,.,.-.-.-.I.I.I.I.I'.-%...................... . ... ....... ........ .... ---.....".11 ........... ..... ................................ .... ............. ..... ..." " ............................. .....I......... -, -:_ i-:-:N_ . ..................... .-."......................................... .............. ..................................... , , . .-'I:j -,., ...-.i*j: " '..."" '....." ". -- - - - -- -...............-, 1.1il..............................,.,.-...........-.-......, .....'):.:.:.:.:-:-.-:.:.:,F - , , , , , , ,....... , , - " :," "', ,.::.:.:.:..::I.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:!F..:.I:.:. I'll".l-."-.,.,.....-.-........................... -_-.-,.::f* , ........ .................................................................. ............ .. ............................,.................................,...................... ".".. ...\ 's. I.--............................................... -, -',-. ":,.-.-II.I.I. .. . - ,.,..i:.'].i.j,-%:.-.-:- .,.., . ....................... . ",-",-,.,.,."","""""".""",.,.,".,.,-""""""". 1................... ....................... ...:-> ".", " "" ,................ "............................. 1-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:" -:-:-:A-:.:-.-.-.. . ...-*),i . k.. \--i:.:::::::::..::.... '-'.'.'-'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'-'-'-'.'.'.'-'.'.'-'-'-'-'.'.'.'.'-'.'.:-.-,-,.,-,.,-'-'-'-'-'.'.'.'-'-'.'-'.'.':.:.:.:................ :.:.:.:.k:-,......................................................................................................... ......................................... ..........:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:-..,-.-, .......... "".... ................ ..::". .'.'.'i'.'.'..'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.... .... ::. ........... .2 .............. .............................. .... ...... , f:.:.:-:-:-:-:.:.I. .:-:-:-:.:X.:.:.:.:-:-:-. ;> .:. -:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.", ............................... ...... I.-,." .................. . -...-......................... .. , -.....I -- , , ........... 'I, .,.,;, _.: , . --1 ........................... ...............................................................,.,.................... ...................%....... ,............. ....... ........... ......... " .."-.-.,.-.-.........................,.,.,.,.:......-... ................. . ..........................'... ___I :-: .1.1.1. -:'-'. ...:.:.:.: -.-.-.,.,.-.-.-.,.......-................... ...% -'. I.,.,.,., ........ .. :-:.:.:.-..-.-.-,--.--..-.-.-.--...-.-::.. ::: ::, :: ..,. ..::::,: ---. _ ......... :.:-:_:-:-:-:-:-:-i-.I----:-:-:-:-:-:-:-,.,.'-'-.-.-.-...-.........-.-.. .,.:4`.I'.`.,.` ................. . ........ .... ........ ........ .. ........................... ...................................... ........ ---------... :: -......... ... I., ........... 1................................ . . - ..s. -... -,.. '.--,`--.: ................ t ............ ......1-1 .A.,...+ :: "'.. ........... .... ..:......... ............... .......................................... . . . . . . . . . .X .,.,.,.,. "....... , ... ..................................................... ........ %........................ .1.1.1'.I.....I.I..., ........... .:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:-,.,-,-, . .::.:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.: : .... ..................., ...I...................... 1.1.-.-.-.-..................-.......,.,.,.,.,......................::::::, .:...:.:::::::::. '......... .............................................,.,.,.-.-.l.-.,.-.,.I . - .... . .. - . ............ ................ ......... ', ............................................... ,... ,...........................1.1.1. ......... ......................... ................................ ......... ..... .. .: .:::.::: .:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-t 6. -''.:.i3. .. ::::: -, ........................................ ......................... ........ -'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-..,-,-.-:.:...." '... 11I I-..... ::,-.3......... ...... ""-'-:: . ...... .... --..,. -f ,.,.,.,...,. . ....... ... -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.,.,.,.-.-.-.,.I ........................ .................... ........ ..."..".."...I.I.I., ,.......... -.-.,."-.,.,l.-.,.-...-............................................ --...... ,..,....-.,.-. .. . ..."., -,-....................... ........... .-.,----------------------------------------I ," ..... :.. -.1.1 .,.......,.,.,.,.,........................................ --, ................... .....111-1 .-............................................ ........ . .-,.-.-.-,-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.-.-.,.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.,.,.,.l.,.-.-.-.....-.-... - C, (, - 1 -, I... J--\qI.I................................................. ....... ...:.:...:-.-:-: ",. .--.1.1".-".,.-.,.,.,.I.I.......-..,................... .-".,.,.,.,.,.-.,.-.1.1.1.1.-.,.,.-.,.-.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-... -,J-1 ..... -.-,-.,.,."-,-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,......................... . , .......... .............. .. 1.1.11111.1.'.,.,.,.,.I.I.I.I.I.I I................ ..........'.'..... """"' "..... ........ ... .:: ,-jO'o- ,-, .... ................ ........,............. ....i.]i..:-it) ... ,.,...,.,. ( .................I................. ."I . .,. '.'.'.','.'.'.'.','.'.','.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.. _ ........ -. -) .111.-.%-.-.-.-.-.,.''.,..,.,.-.-.,.-..,-. '1,) -\ ............ ;... . . ... . .. . ... . ) -------.-i-* . 1--......-..... ) . . ,;j . .... .. .. .. ......) ............ ,........... ......... I--,......- -,._ 1................ .11-j pl' ............................... ) ...................... . .......... ,.... ..........1.111.1.1 ..........,.!. 111.1.-.-,..-.I.I.I.I",.............. ,)EA 1,"', 111 ........ %-.-...._ I.. 1. ... 1-1 I. I ..... I .......... I I 1.................. ...... 11.1-..................... ............ .................. .. ........... I-1`1.1.11'1.1.111.1.1.1..,, ) ( / ... II........ ................... ...............'.... ...fN \1N J,I I..11`111`.111.1.1.... ................ ............. .... .....c 1) 11.1111'.1.1.1.-...-,'.................-............. ......... ..... ..I... 11.1.1.1. .\11 \, ,'.'.'.'.'.',' ............. I.I.I... i:., ....... .) ,-11111-.-,-.-...-I.I......''..-.-.....-...(' %,.-.-. \,,.I.I.I.I.I.I.1111;.I.I.I.I.-.I, ......... ....................... ..... ... ,..........."........, ............... ....... . j 1.1.-.--,-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-...-.-. ......... .ii .."."..." III-11-1.1 ................ ...... ..... ........ ....... I I................ ....... .............. .. ..-.....,.,.,.,.,.,.......................,................. -.,.-.1.11-.,111.1..... .. ..............: :.:.:.:.A:-:.,7................. ........ I......... . I.......I....... ::.:.:.:-:.:-:. -) :: , I...... .................',.......... ........ ".\ ,1 .. 111.1.11-".-.,.-.-.,.I.I.I.I.I.I.,::::: : --.,-,..-,.,:: * .:.:--.,.................. . $ ....... . - . - ,.................. ........................... " .,-,-'-..:::.:.,:;:-, ....... '......,., " ...".--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.'.'.-.,.-.,.-.-.-.-. .., .... :::::::,.:.:::: .,.-:":,:-..--: .-.-.-.-.,.-.,." ....""...... " ," ".. .......,.,..-,-,-.-,-..,.,.'.'.'.'.'........... . :.... --------------............................-.,.,.,.,..., -:....... .., ..... .;.>:.:.:.:.:-:-:-:.,.,-,.,.,.. ...::. .........................................:.:.: ---"........ .....,.,.,..................................... .... -. .................. ...,.,.................................................. . .:..., . .-..::: ....... .............-...-.-.-.-................... ---,........ -.............................................................. -" -............-.-.-.-.,.,.-.-.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-................... " ............................................................ . ........ .................................. .... 0 ........ ,.,.-.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.' ..................... . ... ......: ............... .......................... ....... ....... ................ :: .... ........ .........................,...............,........................................... .......................... ... -................................. .....-.-.-.-.-..-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.-.,.I I... ............ ........................................................................................ ......... ..:. -:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:....................................................................................................... ........ .......:.:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.'-'.'.'.'.'-'-'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'-'.'.'."""'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'-"'-""'.'.'."'.""'I ...... ......................., :.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:-:.:-:.:.:.:.-.-...--.-....-.-.-.-..--.--.-..:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.,.,.,-,.,..,.-'..".'..'.'..--......%.,.......,.......................,.............-............................................................................................................... .'.'.'-'-'-'.'.'.'.'-....,...,....,...,........,.,.,.....................................................................,.,.-.-.,.,.,..................:,:.:.:.:..-...-.....-...-.-.-.-.-..............................................................................'.,..,....................................................................................... .. ........ ....... ....... . ................. ................. . ........ ............,.,.......-...-..... ...........,......,...............-..... "....... ' ' ' ""' ................................. .......... .... ,........ ........ --.;-- --i ........-...............,............................ ............................................................-........................... .......................... ....... ....... ........... .....................................,............. ... ..............................:.. ................... ..............., /',/:........ %........ .................. .-..-..-.. E Q U A T O R :.............................. .....--. , ,*-..-.--,-'-i i.,.i .............. ............... : :-:'::'::':::':'::': .......................... .. ..... ... ................ --HHHHHH .... ............ . ................ . ::` ....... .....................................:::,...................................'....... .............................. \ -.-.-.-.,.,.,.,...............-.-.......-...-............... -.%-.-.,.,.,.,.,.%-.-,-.-.-.-.,...............................................%..... ,... . "...I" ' . -.1.1.1.1.1..,.,...............%.... ........._.................. c ...............,.-.-.-.-,-,-..,........ ....... ..... ..-.-.-.-.-.-.-.....................,..-.-.-.-.. ..... I -_`_ I-.%-.-.-.,.,.,.,.-.-.-.-,-.-.-%..................,...,.,...........%................%..... . ..................... ..... ............... ....... ........ I.., ................ ....................... I -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.-................................ .. _ I...-.-........ ..-.--.-.-.. _ .....c - ............................ ...... .................. II........................ - ...I.,.,.,.,.,.,., .......:......... ......'........................ .1-11, I........ ............. ..... ........ -e...:: ........................ ........ ..................,.,.,.,....... -.%-.-.,.,.-.-.-.,.-.-.I.I.I.I.I.....%..................-.-.............................. ........ ........ 1. ......... ....................... __ ."..,/N-........... ...................... -................................................ . ......... I..........................,.......---..:. I-,.-.-.,.-.-.-.,.,.,.,..-............,.. .................. ------------.............................. -------.."' ...... --........'... -... .......................................... ....-.-.-.........,.,.I.I.I.I.I..:.:.:.:.:-:-:-,.,.,............................". . ........ ....................... ........ .........................-.-.-.-.-.,.I.I..........-.-,..............,..........-.-.-................. ....... . ........ -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-....................... ....... ...... ...... .................. ................ ....... -.................. ........................................ .... ' ,....................................................... :.:-:.:...:.:.:-:.:.:::::::::::: ....... ....-.-.-.-.-.-.-.%-....,.........%" ...................:.:.:.:::::::::::: .". ' ..... ..-,---"." .... .. ................ . .. ................................ ................. ... . ............................ :......... :..,.:-:.:.:.:-:-:-:-:.:.: ................................. , " , ....................................... ...... ..............., ............................... ........... . . .. .. ..................... .,.,.,. .... ........... _-.---.---. .......................... ... . ...... ..,. ..... ....i..............' ... M ,_,;;; ... :-,-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.....-................................. .. ............. ......... ................... --. :................... :::............... .. -..... ................ .......... ............... --..::,:,:.:.::i:......................,........................ :........ ................ ....A . ... .. ..... . .. ............... ........ . -:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.,-'-'-'-' .::.* j:-N ..................... ... .. ...'.. 7_-__ 5. ....I.I.I.I.I.I., ................ ...................... . . . . . . . ........... :!:7.-.-.-.-.-.-- - z_ ....-... - ................................... .......................................................... , , , I i:i: . . . . . . . . :---:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-,.-.,... ......... ............... I_'--_'-'--_'-'_'-'-'-'-' I... Thirdly,two areas may have faunas which are in fromone another,but do also mostrespectsdifferent sharea fewtaxa. This suggeststhatthereis a major barrierto dispersalbetweenthetworegionsbutthat, overlong periodsof geologicaltime,thepassage of a few organismsdoes occur by chance. This type of faunal relationship,known as a 'sweepstakes'route todayby thefaunal or 'waifdispersal',is exemplified compositionof such isolatedislandsas theHawaiian group. An excellentexample of the consequencesof the existenceof an ecological filteris provided in the of patternsof Upper Carboniferousand distribution Lower Permian tetrapods, studied by Milner & Panchen (1973). Terrestrialtetrapodsare similarin ` , "' - ..... ...". . . . -.-.-.,.,.-.,. .... ..... ............... .........I ...- . . . . ..: ...... ..,.......................,.,.,.,.,. ..............,......................... ::::::: ...... ................ , ...... ................-..-.....-....... .................,................ ... :-.-,.,...... both the North Americanand the European parts in the of Euramerica.However,thereare differences fresh water aquatic tetrapods in which, although sevenfamiliesare foundin bothareas, anotherseven are confinedto NorthAmericaand threeto Europe. Milner & Panchen (1973) commentthat theremust have been a partial barrierto the spread of fresh water forms,but not to that of terrestrialforms. They suggestthat thismightwell have been caused by the Caledonian chain of mountainsthat marks the Devonian meetingof the North Americanand European plates. Studies of the Carboniferoustetrapodsalso serve to illustrateanother aspect of the approach to palaeodistributionalpatterns,as based -on palaeo- 80 C. BarryCox geographicreconstructions.Like the bulk of the Devonian fish,Carboniferoustetrapodshave been foundonlyinEuramerica(Panchen,1973).Ofcourse, this area also includes the Greenland sites of the earliestknownamphibians(fromthe Upper Devonian/Carboniferousboundary as previouslynoted) and Panchen has suggestedthat the Amphibiamay actuallyhave evolved in thisarea. This picturehas sincebecomeslightly morecomplicatedwiththediscovery of apparent tetrapod tracks in the Upper Devonian of Australia(Warren& Wakefield,1972). Nevertheless, Panchen'sinference is supportedby the Permian patternsof distiibution,as we shall see. Furthermore,terrestrialamphibians may have evolved in responseto a combinationof predator pressurein thewaterand of unexploitedinvertebrate foodon land (Schmalhausen,1957; Cox, 1967).If so, the near equatorialpositionof Euramerica,and the resulting lush Carboniferous coal swamps of southern Euramerica, would have provided an environment in whichtherecould well have been an adequate food supply for the emergenceof these amphibians. Like the Carboniferoustetrapods,the amphibians and reptiles of the Lower Permian are almost entirely restricted to Euramerica. This Lower Permianfauna is knownbest fromthe Red Beds of Texas, from which thirteenfamiliesand forty-five generaof reptileshave been recorded(Romer, 1973). The European recordis certainlypoorer,containing onlyfivefamiliesand eightgenera.But theseinclude a fair cross section of the North Americanforms, from little captorhinidsand araeoscelids to large edaphosaurs(thegenusEdaphosaurusis knownfrom both areas). It thereforeseems likely that the difference betweenthe two faunas is only due to the fact that the North Americanstrata are unusually fossiliferous and well prospected. A surprisingfact is that these amphibians and reptiles of the Upper Carboniferousand Lower Permian are almost unknownfrom other parts of the world, such as the continentof Asia, then approachingEurope fromthenortheast, or thevast southernsupercontinent of Gondwanaland.There is in fact one lone recordfromAsia, and a few from Gondwanaland. The Asian record is of a small, apparently larval aquatic amphibian, Tungussogyrinus(wronglyregardedas Lower Triassic in my 1973a paper), of uncertain affinities.The small Upper Carboniferousaquatic reptile Mesosaurus, fromboth Brazil and South Africa,was for long a tantalizinglyinconclusive suggestion of a juxta- position of the two continents.From Northern Brazil,Pricein 1945foundtheremainsof an aquatic amphibian,a long-snoutedfish-eatingarchegosaur (Price, 1948). The best evidence for tetrapods in Gondwanaland before the Upper Permian comes fromthePermo-Carboniferous beds of the Kashmir region of northernIndia. Several amphibianshave been foundhere: aquatic archegosaurs(Woodward, 1905; Tewari, 1962), an actinodont (Wadia & Swinton, 1928; Branson, 1935) and an eryopoid (Verma, 1962). Finally,thoughRomer (1973) refers to a captorhinidbone fromTasmania, the identification of this is uncertainand it is in any case of Lower Triassicage (Cox, 1973d). It has been usual to ascribethe lack of tetrapods fromAsia and Gondwanalandmerelyto thefactthat less work has been carriedout in these areas, and fewercontinentaldeposits have been found. This would be an acceptable explanationif there were only a difference of degree,the tetrapodfaunas of these areas being merely poorer than those of Euramerica. But this is not the case. With the exceptionsnoted above, Carboniferousand Lower Permiantetrapodsare unknownfromthree-quarters of the land surfaceof the world. One cannot even say thattheseareas have lacked competentpalaeontological collectors. Such skilled workers as LlewellynPrice in Brazil and James Kitching in South Africa have spent their lifetimescollecting fossil vertebrates.Romer has taken at least one major expeditionto Argentinaspecificallyto look forvertebrates in the PermianPaganzo Beds, but to no avail. This explanationwas moreovercertainlycredible in the days beforecontinentaldriftwas accepted. Since Europe is adjacent to Asia and has had intermittentcontacts with Africa during the Cenozoic and Mesozoic, and theserelationshipswerethought to have been permanent,it was also thoughtto be 'obvious' that the fauna of Europe musthave been able to penetratetheseadjacent continentsover the millions of years of the Permo-Carboniferousespeciallyas it seemedas thoughit had managed to cross an ocean to or fromNorthAmerica.But there now seems littledoubt thatAsia was separatefrom Euramericauntilthemid-Permian(Hamilton,1970). It is surelynot merelycoincidencethat it was only afterthateventthattetrapodsfirstappeared in Asia -therocephalians in centralAsia and pareiasaursin China. The timeof themeetingof Euramericaand Gondto establish.Certainly,the wanalandis moredifficult drift 81 and continental palaeodistributions Vertebrate date oftheAlleghanianorogeny,whichresultedfrom the approach and meetingof thesetwo continentsis the least well established of all the Appalachian orogenies(Rodgers,1967,p. 419). It is knownto have begun in the Upper Carboniferous(McKerrow & Ziegler,1972; Burrett,1972),and to have continued untilsome timeafterthe Lower Permian(Rodgers, 1967). But the early date of the beginningof this orogenydoes not implythatthe two continentsmet at this time,for a contractingocean betweenthem must have contained a subductiontrench.If this trenchwas adjacent to Euramerica,an Andean type orogenywould have commencedtherelong before collisionof the continentscaused a Himalayan type orogeny. It is indeed temptingto suggestthat there is a connectionbetweenthedate of thiscollisionand the factthattetrapodsdo not appear in Gondwanaland untilthe Upper Permian,or in otherwords that,as in the case of Asia, land tetrapodswere unable to cross fromEuramericato Gondwanaland untilthe process of continentaldrifthad united these two continents. Followingtheirarrivalin Gondwanaland, theythenappeared in vast numbersand variety,for Romer (1973) listssixteenfamiliesand seventy-seven genera of reptile from the early Upper Permian TapinocephalusZone of SouthAfrica.These reptiles are mainly mammal like reptiles. Their sudden evolutionaryradiationmight,under this suggested hypothesis,be the resultof the sudden accessibility to themof new and extensiveareas forcolonization, involvingmuch greaterrangesof palaeolatitudeand new floral regions, for the Euramerican plate extended to no more than c4O0N palaeolatitude, whereasAsia and Gondwanaland extendedto their respectivegeographicalpoles. The newlyaccessible regionsof Asia and Gondwanaland also contained thedistinctive Angaran,Cathaysianand Glossopteris floras,which must also have increased the possibilitiesof ecological diversification open to the early land vertebrates.If my hypothesisis correct,then Irving & Brown's (1964) discoverythat the distributionof Upper Carboniferousand Lower Permian amphibians is closely related to the palaeoequator may be merelya resultof theirgeographical opportunities rather than the provision of an insightinto theirphysiologicalpreferences,or tolerances. There seems,at least, littledoubt that the Upper Permiantetrapodsof Gondwanalandare the results of a full meetingbetweenthat continentand Euramerica. If, instead,therehad only been a sweep- stakes or filterroute connectionbetweenthe two continents,one would expect that the immigrants to Gondwanaland would, in more or less complete isolationthere,have evolvedinto an endemicfauna, different in manywaysfromthatfoundin theNorth. What we in factfind,in theUpper Permianof South It is a fauna whose roots Africa,is quite different. can be traced,withfewgaps of lineage,throughthe earlierMid Permianand Lower Permianfaunas of Euramerica.Romer says (1973, p. 164) 'As between (European) Russia and South Africa,however,the situationis clear. The two areas show faunasclosely related to one another(the Africanone somewhat of Simpson later).. .'. The indexof faunalsimilarity (C/C1x 100, where C is the number of taxa in common, and Ci is the number of taxa in the smallerof the two faunas) betweenthe two areas is in palaeolatitude. 70 %, despitetheirgreatdifference Even the differences betweenthe two areas are not due to the presenceof quite different groups in the two areas. Thus the reptile fauna of European Russia containsseven suborders,and that of South Africaeight,but six of theseare commonto thetwo areas. The two unique South Africanforms(millerettidsand bauriamorphs)are merelylines which evolved within the Upper Permian of that continent. Finally,as we shall see, thepicturein thesucceeding Triassic Period is completelydifferent,with extensivesimilaritiesbetweenthe faunas of all of today's continents.The Gondwanaland record is richer,not poorer, than that of Laurasia: out of fifty-seven families of wholly terrestrialtetrapod, in are presentin Laurasia and forty-six thirty-nine Gondwanaland. Are we reallyto believe that these between the Permian and the Triassic differences recordsin Gondwanaland are simplybecause there betweenthe was, by chance, so great a difference areas of depositionof fossiliferous rocks of appropriateage, or ofthediscoveryoffossilsin theserocks, in the 50 million years of the Lower and Middle Permianas comparedwiththe35 millionyearsof the Triassic? Though, as suggestedabove, it is possible that continentaldriftwas thefactorthateventuallymade it possiblefor tetrapodsto reach Gondwanaland,it is also possible that they were excluded by other factors,such as unknown epicontinentalseas or desertregions.Whateverthe reason may be, there seems at least a primafacie case for the possibility that tetrapodsdid not colonize the major part of Gondwanaland until the Upper Permian. 82 C. BarryCox major geographical barriersbetween these areas, climaticbarriers but also thattherewereno effective separatingthem. a faunaldifference evento substantiate It is difficult betweenLaurasia and Gondwanaland. Taking the of the sixtyfamilies Triassicas a whole,thirty-three tetrapodare knownin both areas, and of terrestrial theremainderare mostlyeitherrareforms,foundin onlyone or two adjacent localities,or formsof an stratain onlyone of by fossiliferous age represented the two super continents.If this latter effectis reduced by taking a shortertime span, then for examplein theUpper Triassicthereare twenty-eight families of terrestrialtetrapod in Laurasia, and in Gondwanaland,of whichnineteenare twenty-five of faunal common to the two areas-a coefficient similarity of 76 %. The Triassic is probably the simplest of all for biogeographically, geologicalperiodsto interpret thereis positiveevidencelinkingall of today's con- UpperPermian-Triassicpatterns(Fig. 3) These are the periods of radiation of (mainly mammal like) reptileswithinthe single world wide continentalmass of Pangaea, undivided by epicontinentalseas, major mountainchains or deserts. The Upper Permiantetrapodfaunas,knownbest fromSouth Africa,have been recordedalso in Asia, China, India and Euramerica(Romer, 1973). For the Triassic,I have already published(Cox, 1973a, b) a detailed analysisof the distributionof terrestrialvertebratefaunas, and shown that the fauna is a world wide one (Fig. 4). These Triassic coefficientsare very similar to those given by McKenna (1973) for familiesof livingmammal in the states of Oregonand New York. The surprising aspect of the Triassic figuresis thereforehow high they are, even for areas then thousands of miles apart,such as Europe and India, or Asia and Africa. The clear implicationis that not onlywere thereno ".... ,.................................. ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,," ,,,, ''.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'-'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.-.'-'.'., ... ....... .......... ............. ...,.,.,.",.,-,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,-,.,.,.'.'."'.",.,.,.,.,-,.,.......-.::.:-:.:.:-:.:.:-:-:.:.:-:-:/ .'.............._....'. ........... .. .-.......... .-.. ... ....... ... .................-.-.-.................. ..... ........ ...._ ......."................. .....'......... \_ ,.-,..,...............:.:-:.:.:-:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:-:.:.,-,-,.,-,-,.,-,-,.,,,-,-,.,.,-,.,___.. ..... ....................................... . ..... ........................................................... ...................................................................................... ...... ....._... ....I.............I...... ................... ........ .. ..,.............-.,...-.................................................." ...,., - _.._. ........................................... ",,-__....... ".... :-........'........ .......... ................ ......... ... _ ... -_'.......'...... ....... _ ..... ., ................... ....... ...,..........-........-....... . -.......-,.'..''..,........ . ...... ....... . "._...,., ._ ._._.._._ ._ _ I c "...I........ -....._ . ........................ ........... ................ :.:.:.:.:-:-:.:-:-:.:.:-:-:.:-:-:.:-,-,.-.,-,.,.,-, ..... .I....._.... ......,............'...... .................",..,.",..........."-,.-.. ........ ..-.." .,...,......................, ........................... ........................... .......... ........... -1.-- -._................... . _..-. .......... ............ ,.,...."..,....,.-..........................................-.. ............._ r) ................. . ....;.... """"""""""""""""'-"-"-,, ;...... ,'-',',','-',','-',',,-,,,,,,,,,,,,,-,,,,,,',',',',',',,-,,,,,, ......: ...... ........... ................ _.......... ... -,. ,....'.......... ................ .......... .. -,.......,.,....... ........ ....... ... . i _....... i ....... ..I.... ...... ....................... ... ....... .. ... ..... ... .... . . . . .............,........... __ _-._ ..... '. .......' '. ,. ... .......... ............................... .................................'.'.. ........_... -.-.... --i-' -,. . .,...........,.................................................. .. . . . . .. . . . . . .. . .. ..... .......-... ....... t.............. ....................... ,, ,\ ,_,j ...... ."....... ....... ... -.. - __::_ .......... ....... '....... ... -I",,, ....., .... _. ... ... ................... "......".......................... ........ ........................ ._. ......'.... . . -....-.... -,i .... ....... I........................ ...... ..................... ............. ... ....., ,'' :.:.:. ....... ... ........ ..................._........ . ....... .. .... ..... .:. .-.---.-.---.-.---.-.-.-.-.-.......... ... ..... ,.... --_-'4 ..:., i.-,'.",:::::: ................... ,.',..... .. ...............................-.......' .. , --... ........ , ..............-.........................,..........-. ....' \\ ................ .... ........... ...... j., ;L : . . ........ .... ....... ...... ... . ............-......................... ,.... . i`-` ,. ... .................. ................ . . .. . .. .... . .. ..... . . - ............, .....-, .. . ... .. :k L.............:::: - -.-., -..' .: .. ..... .. .. .. .. .. .. ....... -]-. .... .. . . .. .......-. . .... ........... .,:i .4i ::::::::: r VI:"C_..... . ... :_. ' --ii: .......................:.:.:.:.:.:-:-:.:-:.:.:-:-:-:-:-:,r.. ..... ......... ....................... , ................... .,_-j x::::`:, :-::::::::::, x::.::.::_..:. ... ............. ....................... _ ....... .-..-..-... / ....... C,:), . ..............-.............. ................. 13... ...... .....,.. ::.:::",---..,..]..-,. ... `-...r . .....-....,....................-.. 0s .......... . j . ....... ...... ................::. . -/I -) c GIL -........,.,.,..,.,.,."..:.::.:,:,.::.:,-::.. ..................... ---,'*::.:-:.:.:.:-:-:.:.:.:.:.:-:-:.:.:.:.:.:.., ............ ;_ ........,,:: ... .. -17 r J ......... _........... .. \ I- n')1-2'TI-\ ,-J 0e....................'. ........... . . . -..-.......:::::::::::::::::.:.:.:[:-:.:L:.:.:.:.:-:...,.-:: ........ .... :..... /,...,, -'............. ." ), ( , ......::: .-I.......... ..-.-.-.-:::::-:::.:-,.::: ...-? ..:. :: ....... ... ....:...:.:::...:::,:,: ..... i. r --I k__ IA J 1-1/ ................................... ................ ... :::: I.. ................. ................................,.....-........ ...:.:: .... ............. ......--...... . ....I....... _; s0. ......::::::::::::::::: 7 ...... - . """, -, ,..,".. 0I\ ... .....,." ..............................,..,......... ................ ) \ ( . _ ....... . ..... """""""""""""""""""", """, 1) ........ )J '. ........................ _........... ........ ............ ....... .... I ... 7i n.) LA U R A S I A... .............................. ..._ ...'................'....... ". ....-J .......,.........................-,. ..':,:,:,:,:,:,:, ._-............... ....... ..-....,..............-........ ..... .... ............... ............ ..... .... ,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,-','-'-','-" .... ..." ....... ...'.."...._ I.....I ............ ........ ........-,..... ,"-.,.,.-..,-.,.-,." .... '. ......... ._........ ........ . . .,... .-.,---_-----,n . ,,. ) _.... I /.......................... C\ ....... .. . _.... , ''. .. _...................... ,_.'. ........ ....... .....-...... .X ....... ... - ............._ ---. ...... ...... ......_.....".......- ........U. P E R M I A N . .. . . . . . .. . -..-................:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-":-:- - '........... . . . . . . . . . . . _ 11_... -1, . ..:.:.:,-.,:: . . . _... . . . .-.-:-,-,-,-,-,-,- .............. . . . . - -. .... . . . . . . . . . .... _i_ ... . .... -...... -_ 1:: - .: . . .... . .-.....'-L.-.........l.'-.............-.............' '..... L . . ........-............" . . - . . . . ..... - "..". ...... "....- . ...-.-..-'. -...... .. . . .-.. . . .'..- -.-.-.---. . . . ........................-.,'.."......-,...-........ 1.I ........... .. .. .. .,-,. . . ... .-_. jj .-._"_.-.-.. ... ... ..., . . L." . _ ...... ............... . .- I.-....... . . . . . . . . .............. ......_ . . , . ..........._................', I . . I . . ........... ............. . . . . ............,.'....-...'.'I .......( . .. . .. . . . ... . ..I............. ... .. ...... .....-........."............... ... ..... ...... . ......,................................._ .........., . .. .... . .... ... ... . . .... . . .... .... .- ....-. .. ... . .... .. ...- ...... ..... ...... . ... . ......._........ .. ... .... . .............. ... ....., . ...,, --.:: --..::::::::::: " - ......... ... :. ......... . .. .. .....................-................,-."...........,... . . . . .. . . . ... .. . . _...... . ... . .. . .. . .. ... .............. _ ., . ... .... .I ................ ..... .. . . . ... . .. . .. . I . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..,_" ..,....... . . . . . . .-.,-,.,.,-,-,[,.:::::::::.:::::::::::::::::::::::::-"-,,-"-."-"-"-."-""""-"...'.,.-..-.,..,...,.,.,"-, _ . ................) . . .. . . .. ....... . .........._.................. . ............... . .... . _. . . . . _.............. . ... . . . . . ...........- .............. ......_ ...._ -.-........... . .. . . . ... . ... ............. . . . ... ... . . . .... ... . . ... . .... .... . . .. . .... . ... . . . . . _.. .... . . . . . ... . ... ..... . .. . .. ............... . . .. . . . . . ...............-....-..-........ . . . . .. . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . I . ................ _........... . . . . . . . ............... ......... .............. .................................... .... .... ........ ............. ................... . ... ... .. ... ... .... . .. . .....- ......... ... ........................._.......... .... .... . . .... . . ... ...... - . ................... . . . . . . .. . . :i : . .. ...... . . . ., . ._....... ... . . . ........ ... ... .. ............. . .................. ......_ _ . . . ..., ..... ........ ............................ .. . . . . .. .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... ....... ... ... ...... .. .... ... .................... . 1- _.,............... ........... ...............................-..................I .......... ...................... . . . . . . . . ... . .. ...... . . ............ . . . ..... . . .. . . . . . .. ..... . .... .............. ......... ........ ....................... . . . . . . . . . ... . - . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I .......'....... . . . . ...... ... . . . . . . . ........ ....... . : - ...._........... . . . . . . . ...............'.............. . ............. . ......., ..... .........._...... . . . , . . . . . ........ . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . ................ I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..... .. . . . . . . . . .. ............. ..._.............. . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . - . . . . . ........_.................... .... ............... 0 _, _. ,\\ r - ( ) . . .- ... ,\ \'_,.,.,-,.,.: "I L, ,1 ,-" I -\ f - 0 .0 0. nv / f#-\ :::::::::::::.:::: 00 .- . ... .. .. ...... , f 0 , -. e 3/ , / . . - 0 ::: ::::.:::::::::::' -'-'-'-'-'-'-'- ................'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'..'.'..' - . ....,. .:.::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::,:.:.: .'.- , - " L, " L" 0, -."'...L....' ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::, , ..... .. I . __ .... . '............... .'.'.'-":.:-:-:-:--...,..-..--, -.- - ..L.......... .,I.::.:.: -_._ ._.._ , ............. :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::..'.'.'.'.'.-.'.'.'.-.-.L . . . . . . . . ............ ............, '. . .. . . .. ........-.-..-.- ......I.. - - - ...---'-'-- ---- - L 01 ..........................I 1-1 . .. . .. . I........... ... _......... ......... ....... ........... ................ : _ . . . . . " . ..... . I..........-.,.............., _,_ . ...-.,. ............... .......... '' L........... .......-? :.:::::::::::: - - - - ."'-.'. .., -c I I...-- -... ...__-- :::::::-:::::::::::::::.......,.......................,.,.,.,','' ...... ... . . . .. . . :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::......... . .. . . . .. ..... . ....-.................,..,....".. I.. ............., . . ............... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . ... ' ' :_.............. . ... ... . . .. ., ..... _ ....'.'.'.'.'.'.-"...L..''.L.. ................. ......... . . . ,_A.-__-._______--_.-__I-I-. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . - .. . 1 . .. - ......_....... ....... ......".....,.., ........,...................,................. ............ . ............. . . .. . ......'.........,..-.-........ . . ... . . ... . , . ,. . ... . . ... . . . . . . ... . . . . . I.. I . . . I ... . . .... " .....'. .... .. . - ... ............ ...'.................. ....... .............._. ,..-.,.... ..... '' .. . .. . .. . . .. . . iiii.'i. . . . . ... . . ... ... ... ... . . . . . . . . . . . . _ .. .. . . . . . . .. .-. ......... .....'................'.... '-'-'-'-'-'-' L...'."..'.''.L. . ... . . . ... . . . .. . _... . . . ... . . . . .... . . . . . ... .. . .. .... .. . .. . .. ... . . :::::: .. .. .. ... . .. . . . .. .. .. ..... .. . . . .... . ..... . .'...'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'...'."''.L.. -.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'." ..L . .. .... . .I.............. . . .. . ... .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . . .._ . . .... ,- ...'... .................'-"""'-""""'-'.'.'_'_'.'.'.'.'.'.'."-_'.''.'.'' __-.'.L ..............'......_........ ...... .. .......... ./ .' -'-'.'-'-''-- " L .-.,-,-,..-,-,.,.,.,.-.,-,-,.--,-..- I I I I I - I I -I I I - I'--" , " ,--_ I ,.-.,-,.,.,.,., -.,-,.-.,-,.,.,- . " ' ............. /* . . . . . . . ... . . . ... . . ................................... .. "--.-'.:::::::::::::::: ............... . .............. ...,: '. .,.:- .. X .. ::.: . . .,,,--........................-.............' ... .'' IX.. " - - I......................... - -_i ........ .........'.'.'.-.'.'.'.........L...-......'...."...........'.'_'.'.'.'. .......... ....... ... .... . .'. " ... -.... ...... . . . -. ..... . -. ....... ............... . "- '. ,.,.,.,:, .i;. ...... .'.'.' --.. . . . . . . .... . ....... . . . . ... -... ', --, ,:::. . ;i: ....... .. . `. ;_ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......... .... - . . . . . . . . . ..'....... ....... ..'.'.'.'...'.'.....'.......L-......'.................'. .......-......................................-..........,.,. ........... .... ................. I... . . . .. . . , --."'..." .............-............................ .................... . .. . . . . . .. . . ................ ..-. -:( : ...................... .. .. . . .. . .. .. . .. . .. . .........._..... . ..........................-..-............. ..... ... :::.::-N .. _', ;.f - ---, -1 - Q\ '!. iiiiii_-_ii--i. ., -Oi :: ::, .: , A /) .,.,. 7I0 N--." ,I.. II..... ........... .-........ -._,...,._..... ....... .._ .......... ......._ .,.,........" ',........._.11.1.111111 ......... ..._ ... ... .................... .............. .............. ... ..... ..... . . ."..........'.'...'......... ............ ''....... -,.,.:.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,-,.,..,............ . .,:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:,:,:.:.:.::,:: ' ..'..........._ ............. ... -, .:: ................I ... ... .............. I......... ... :-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:,:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:,:.,.-...............................,.. ..................., ....... ........ .. 1" _... ........_............. ..............."".. ..... '" ''''''l.l.l.......... ."-.,.'-,.,.' -, .,....... ' , ...................::::::::::::::::::.''.,-.,/ ,....... "....... M., ,-""""', _ _ I_ _ .............., ............. :, ... . ........ ,-/ ................:::::::::::::::::: ...'.... 1. I. .... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::]::::::::: ... ..:::-:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:-:-:.:-:-:.:.:.:.:-:,:. . .. :::,::,.,.."""."".",","""""""""::::::::::: --.-..... ................. ---, .......' ....... .....: .....- _.......-. -.,. . - -............... -...., ..................._ ... ........ .....I...... ...... , ",-, .. I.. _..., .............. _ ..._.._.... _:.:_:.:_.:-:-.i ......... ...-.,...'., :: .... 0 0: O P J ,., .,......-.,-.I..... c.'. .'- ,. _ --, _ ... .:.::::. -1 -,._:_:.:_:_:,.,_,.,_, . .- I ._............... &_....,.,...._.'.'......'.- .,.- .............. ........... .. ... . ........"... .. 1-1-1.1-1. 111-.1- ......- . ................._.... . . . . . . . . . . ........... ............... ... ... ..................... - ................. ................................ ...... .. ,....... /............. .......... . . . . . . . . . .. . . ..... . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... '.'.'.'-,:::::::::::::::::: . . . . . . . . . . . . ............................ ......1 ..'..'........... ....................... _....... _.... . -. . ,. . .. . .... .............. . .,.. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . ..... ............... _........... . . . . . . . ................ .. _.........-- . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...... . . .- . .-. .- . ............ . ..- . .'.. . . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. .... .. . . . . . . . . . .. ...........'....-.. -,-,. ... . . . . . . . . . . . ................... . . . . . . . ....... . . . . - . . . . . . .. . . ................. .. ........-...... . . -. . . .........'..... . . . . . . . . ................. .:-:-:.:.:-.. . . . . ........... -. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .-...-..... . . . . . .... . . . . . . . . .I....... . . . . . . . . . . . I....... . \. . ..................:.:.:.:.x . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............. . ,. ............... .............. . . . . . . . . .....I.............. . . ................ .. . . . . . . . . . .:::::::.. . . . . . ... . . . . . . .. . . . . .. .... . . . . .. .- ................ ....... ........ _ 1....., . . . . . , ......... ....... . I .. .:,:,:.:.:.:,:: and continental drift 83 palaeodistributions Vertebrate Europe North America (16) (41) 87 5 % Europe Asia (18-5) South America(19) Africa (42 5) India (16) 44% 56% 75% 59% 80% 74 % 59% 81% 51% 89% 41% South America 74% 56% Asia Africa 75 % afterCox (1973a, b), at familylevelbetweentheTriassicfaunasof today'scontinents, Fig. 4. Coefficients of faunalsimilarity amendedto includetheexistenceoftraversodont cynodontsin EuropeanRussia (Tatarinov,1973)and Asia (Young, 1974).The Triassicfamiliesfoundin thatcontinent;where numbershownin bracketsaftereach continent showsthenumberof terrestrial a scoreof 0 5 has been added. thepresenceof a familyis not yetfullyconfirmed, tinents. The distributionpatterns of vertebrates to understandin theJurassic become more difficult and Cretaceous,for threereasons. First,the supercontinentsbeganto breakup withtheappearanceof spreadingridges;it is not always possible,however, to be sure exactly when each of these spreading movements commenced. Secondly, there remain uncertaintiesas to the exact relationshipsbetween land masses in particular,crucial areas, as we shall see-e.g. North America in respect of South America, South America in respectof Antarctica, and NorthAmericain respectof Asia. Thirdly,even when two areas lay on the same tectonicplate, the spread of shallowepicontinentalseas in theJurassic and Cretaceous may have made it impossiblefor animals to travel between them. For example, a shallow Turgai Sea separated Europe from Asia fromthe Mid Jurassicuntilthe Middle Eocene. Jurassicpatterns(Fig. 5) The CentralAtlantic,betweenNorth America and Africa,began to open in the Lower Jurassic(Dewey et al., 1973). Though this part of the connection between Laurasia and Gondwanaland became impassable,theremust have been some connection forland vertebrates betweenthe two. This is clearly oftheirdinosaurfaunas shownbythegreatsimilarity in theUpperJurassic,bestknownfromtheMorrison Formation of the U.S.A. and fromTendaguru in Tanzania (Charig, 1971; Colbert, 1973). Hypsilophodonts and the large sauropods (cetiosaurs, brachiosaursand diplodocines) are found in both faunas. This resemblancedoes not end merelyat familylevel, but extendsas far as genera: Bothriospondylus,Brachiosaurusand Barosaurusare genera commonto both faunas (Charig, 1973). This degree of similarity impliesa land routeround at least one end of the expandingCentralAtlantic.This expansion was by movementof Gondwanalandaway from NorthAmerica,whichmusttherefore have separated from both Africa and South America. The route from North America to Africa was therefore probablyvia Europe. The movementsof the different small areas which caused the Alpine System orogenyare so complex(see Dewey et al., 1973) that it is impossibleto establishcoastlinesin this area, and one can only presume that a land bridge existedfora briefperiod or periodsin the Jurassic, as shown in Fig. 5, permitting the passage of these dinosaurs. The relationshipsbetweenthe dinosaurfaunas of these different areas are shown in Fig. 6, the data being derivedfromCharig (1973), omittingmonogenericgroups known from only one area. Only threeJurassicfamilies(the coelurids,megalosaurs and stegosaurs)are foundin all threeareas. Though most of the Euramerican groups are known in Gondwanaland, only half are known in Asia, mainly because the four Euramerican sauropod subfamiliesare unknownthere.Much of thepoverty of the Asian Jurassicdinosaur fauna is probably spurious, being due to lack of knowledge, but Jurassicpalaeogeographydoes suggestthatanyroute betweenAsia and Euramericawould have involveda filterregion.An occasional trans-Turgaiconnection would have provided one such route. The other C. Barry Cox 84 --. -.-__--' "" ""' _'- ...... ...: ....... -- '.................. ,.".,::.:::.,.::,.-..-..---...-.......... '.'-'-'-'-'-"'-'-'-'-'-'-' '''''------""""""' \':__ ....r...... :-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.--'.'.'-'.'.'-,.,.-.,.,.1-1-1-1.1-1.1---,.1-1.1--.-.,.,.,.l.-.,.,.",.,.,.,.,.,...,... ..... ... ........'......... .............................. '/ . ........ ........ ........................... ": _-'-,,,-,,i,.,-,.-.,.,.,.,-,.-.,-,.,.,-,.,..-,--..-,.,.,-,-,....-..-..-..-..-..-..-..-..-..-..-.--.--.............-... ..... .................. .- ..-4-"'""'_'_"'_'_7.......... .::.::::: .............. '.........%...........,.,............................ .. .............................................. M I DD LE '-""'.-'.""',.,t,..".",', .. ............7;;: .'..K ................. ....... .........,.........,.,............ ............... :: .:::::--' ...... '!..... ,:-:.:.,.,.,.,-,.,.,.,.,-'-"-' .....,.,........................,.,.,.,.,.,.:-:.:.:-:.:-:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:-:.,.,-,.,.,.,.,..," .I.I.I.I......... .: ::::.,:::::::::::::::.::I:::: ... V..... .... . . . . . . -.-'.-'.-.-.....-.....-................. ... . . .. . .. . ....................... '-I I . ..': ...: : .'.'.'.%'.'.'.'.'.. .-.:-:.:.:-::::::::::::::::.:,?.,.,.,.-..'Z.'i_ ,,, ''':":: .....-:.:-:-i .i'_-i. -I . . -'.! .: -., .................. . .. ..i . ... ' " " --,-" .... I :.' .' .. " ---.-.,.,.,.I.I.I.I.I.I.1.1--....... .......... -.' .::...:.:.:-:.:.,-,...,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,". 11 " ' ............ " '. --..-. .. j.:.:.:.:.:--....:. ...... ......... -. -:..-....V ............. 1-1 R A S S Ir . . . I . . ............. ' ''':':':-: ._A ' .... ..... ::::.:-:.:.:'::::':::::::::::::: .........:. - -. ... .1...-...... % ::::.I.I.-.-.-. .. . . . : ' .::.:-:.:.:-:.:.:-:.:.:-:.:.:-:.:.. . ............ ;-.- -.-:;i;; 6. :-:-:- -. .... .- -.-.-.-.-.-.-.....-.-....-........-.....-...........-.,................ . : ... .. . ..... - : :_ .... -.-: .:.:............. , -_$. I ':-:-:-:_:-:-:. .....:.,.:;'-.7 . .-* '.-, ...'-.: .......: i-I-..-i-.-.-_' -?"'.. --. .im -:-:-:-:-:-: ...tx ......::.:.:.:.:.:.:.:,: ' -.... .. .".'--............................ .--ii'.. ili.. "I -..:: -.:.'. .. .4 ....... .r..0.'.' ..-!.... :.,-. .....:.: 8:-: . ... ................... .I.-.-.-.%-.-."'4"% ... ..... ._ "M-.. . ..... .-I.................... ' "':':"' _. ..:.:.:.:.:.-.. ....... ... .:4:-:-:-'------'-... ..'.... ..." ........ . ......-.-.-.-. . " 4..4 L ' ....... ... R "!-- -.. V 'i''.''.'"--'"..::::-:-:;K . .................... .... ::-':::-: .... ... .. .......... -..-:.,:::::::.:.:.>:.:::.-:.. .............' .. ...... ..... ...... ..... ..... -,:::::: ... . .'. .... .? .... ................. . . : ....... :::: '' X: 11) ; ' I-'5 .......... ........... ... ........... .:.:.:.:.:-:.:.: ................. . "" .......................... . : " .r . _- &' :.:.:.f i*.-*::.:: "i,' '. -... ... ---..".,:::::::::::::::::::::" . . ijij': -..-C - ..": s .i.j.I... j ..'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'. .. R .-:::::' ..... ......... ....... ........ . . ......... ...!.!!.. -&_ X ...............X.. .. ."... ,,--__ - ) r,,,, . ..:.:.:.:.:.:,: _' --'-. .....j .:.... ........ ...: ... .......... .-...:::::::::: -:.:.:.:.:.:-:.: ":-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:........ -!-!._.'..................... ..... .-.........:: .... -I-.. ': .. .""... -'I,' - . I" r,( .:--..i.. ' :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ' ..% ....... "" . .............. .............:Ii. . .. ,?g!::::::::::: ' .:.:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:-:.: /I ...........................' .............. ........'........ ..-':::-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'...............I -............ .;.X .., ...-1--.:........ :'I'%-" _.':......... ii-_-!'_.. .. _!_ .... :.-...::::::::-:j:]:.-:j::.:i::..:i.: . .. ...' . -* '* ....... ......................... ( .... :: :iIi, , i " *..... .. ................ . '........ . -.: . .-.-.-.-.-.-.-...............:.:. ....... .'.... .:" , , .......'.........t ...... " A * ::::-'-'..-.. ']_ ... -i:i. .,. % -*:' .. . ./ .*. -i'i-i-:. _.. ........... -ii. z . " ....... .-. ::..'......... .......... ......A ....... .'.i.i..... ... ...I1.-'-'.-...IIIII.I.-I..... ' ::::::: .... ii. -:::-, --** _'-*.'i`ii'-.i'. ...I ........ .............. :.:-:.:.::::::::::::,-,-,.,-,::::::. . ......... ...'.:' I....................... ....... . ........... ..'_...........- .. ..... -1...:::,!.!.M-:.:-7 ..... " : .. " :::::::::::::::::::.: ...: : . ........ .. ..................-...-.' .. -" .. ........... .... - -'-'..'... ...... ...... ' ':: .,:::..:...:.:.:.:.:.:,:.:. ........ ............ .....: - -.. ..,- .. -_-i --- .-.. .-' _'*I-I*-.I-" ......... '.-. '' . -......: .,.,.-.--,.,.:-:.:.:-:.:.:::::::::::::::::::::::- """""" -- - - ' '.:" ,.,.,.., - - N:......'. ..... -':::::-5- ..... L_ .. = ') .. .. ...... .. ....... ;.? :: :-:: ::: .. ....... .:::::::::::: .. ... .......... .... ..... . ........... ..........."........ .... ::::::-:.:-:-:.:.: . j:. '_ . .-:i::-:j::.:i::.:i:i:..i::.:: .... '..." ........ .. ........ ............. .'.-.-.-.-:-:-:-:-:-.--.' "--.' ................. ........... ................ --:::::: - -:::: ... .... ................. -::::-. %................ .................. . .......... .....I...... ...................:.:.:.:.:.:.:...:.:.:-:-:,:-:.:.:-:::::::::.....,...,........... .. ..... .I.I.I.I... .......... ..... ". ....:.:.:.:-:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:-:.:.:-:.:" .......... ::: V ...'..... ................. ........ _... %........ -.. . .. . .. .. .. . : -.:.,:::::::::::::::::.,:::::::::::::::::: ............ ...... .." .. "' .(' ... ,:.::.:.:-:.:.:-:.. ' ' ...... -' .']''' . .- . . _' -- ' "' C '/ ...... ....... ....... ......... ............ ............... 11 fl - ....I.I................... ... -............. \_. '. k 54 .................... .,.:.:.:.:.:,:.:.:.: ............ ...................... ... . ." .I........... .... -'.'-'-:-'-'-'-'-.'-'." ................"...... .. .... .. " :":: ...... ............ ...... ..-..:. :-:-:-:-:"""" " T ......... .........X '.'.'.'..-...-I_..',_.'.'_.- -:-.*.:i*.:i*. -:j:]:.:j" '-':'.'.'.'.'. -'-'-'. ' . ... ' ".... "'' "''-"....'-i- --''_.__''i ) \' I '..... %:.,.....i::.:i::.:i:]:-:..]:.:j::.:i::.: :-:. . -:-:-:::i* ... .1....:... - ::::j:j:::.:j:: -.. .... ..... ' II/ ..:-'.'-, :"' :%-.-..-.' -:: -. F -.-i'----i' '-'iii ..... -.i'.i'-.']:, %-.-.-.-. ..1i, .-i -..- ".iL,( ..i'.]i ..,,,,,,.,. ..,::::, .]i, .]i....... ':. . . -.':-'. .-...... .. ... --::::::: ,.i--..'......I... ... X-1 ...... .:-. '. 11 ...... . . . ..............'. ..:::::::. ..: ' . .... EA " _j .:.:. , :........ .........0 ' j.. - j.-'--'-'-'-'-',. ............. ... -'-'.-'-'.-' ... _ , . . f -..' :.:::::,.:-.'::::::::-:-::.:':................ ": ......... .L, ........... " ..... I' """'.. --:.:::::::::::::,.:,.:-:.,. - ---"---. ....... :. %'.'.:.:-:,:.:-:.:.:-:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:::...... .)......... :.... .:-,:": ......... ..-..__ . ..:.% ' 0 ............. .. . , -....-......... :-1 . ... -. .----........ -....--.-P .,.,.,.:-:.:.:::::::::::: ::............. .:.:.:.:.:.:-:, .:.:.:.-"'-'-",." ' .. _..... ..-.__ ....0 ........... ...... .-.--_-.."'I"'I". __. . i. . . .. . .!.. :::::::::::::. ::..:.:.:::::::::::: .......... -.:::::::.. .X :'-:::::::'-..'-'-'-'-'-'-..... ...... . .. .... g .., '... ... ".:.:.:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:.v.:.:.:.: I .."i ' , '_I.. ... ............. ........, ... . .,.,.,." .......:::::::::::-,..:...:-.:.-::::.,:,.:..::.::::":::::::::: : ,.:.:.:-:-:. ...... ....... ....... ...... -.-... .................. -.:.,.%,...%'.'.'.::.:,........."........'.'.-.-.-.-.-. % .... .:.:::.:.:.:.:.:.:.: _ ........ .:.:-:.:.:-:.: ................ -..-.11. ...... .,.,... . ..... V....---"I,'-," -.... %."% -........ -. .:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:a.:. ..-.-.-.-.-.::.:.:.:.:.:.: -:-:, :-:-:-: .:.:...'-...' ...' ..... V.1. -'. .:- 1-...'. ........................ ...................... ... . . ........ ............... .. .:%,.,. .................... .......................... .... ........ .... ...... " .. ....... ............................................................ : '.%...:":: ....-......-..::-:.......,.,.,-..-.,-.---'.'.'.'.'.'.'-'.'.'.,.......... .... ... %.-:.:.:.:.:.:: -'--.:..:%.... .............. ..:-:.:.. :-:: .... I....-...-....... -.--'.-: -: , .::.. ..... -:................ .:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:.".-,:,"....................... ...... .,.-.-.-.-.-.-.%........................................... ....... ....... .I......... ........ " '........ ;'K ' .% -'-'-'-..,-,.:::::,-:.,::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.:::::::.,.,...,...,.,.-.,.'.-.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.-.,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-. .. .... . . . . . . . . . ..... .. .. A ........ - - .... ............'........ ............... ........ ................. .....'.... .... .."............. . . . . " ....'.................... :-. """' ........ --:..:.-i.--:.:..:..:i::.:i::..:i::.:" . ..I. . ....... ........... . "%. I....... :-:.:.:-:.:.--.. ..." ............:...,:.:...:...:.:-..:-:-..:.:-..:-:.:: ..I.I..................." '..........".... .. '. ....'.............. V5-.i' !.'o -x i:i:.:i; ' - I - - " " . .-." .............. possibilityis dispersalvia Alaska and Siberia. The boundary betweenthe Euramericanplate and the Asian plate appears to have lain in the Cherskiy regionof northeasternSiberia (Churkin,1972), and the northwestwardmovementof the Euramerican plateappears to have caused boththecollisionof the adjacentpartsof thesetwo platesin thelate Jurassic (Churkin, 1972), and also the appearance of new land in westernNorth America in the Nevadan orogeny (Coney, 1973). The Jurassic palaeogeographic map suggests that the resultingAlaskaSiberialinkwould have lain at a highpalaeolatitude. However,in theabsenceof polar icesheetsduringthe Mesozoic, mild climatesseem to have extendedinto quite high palaeolatitudes. The Early Cretaceous florasof North America and Siberia show similarities (Barnard,1973) suggestinga Jurassicbiological connectionbetweenthesetwo areas, and Cretaceous florasare certainlyknownfromequallyhighpalaeo- ,.,:-,:::::::::.,::::::::::-,:,.:-,:,.,-,.,.,-,-....,.'.-'-'.-'-'-'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.-.'.'.-.','.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-,-.- . . !.. . . .............. ............. .: ................... . . . . . . .......................................I...... . ...... '.".. ::::::.:...% :..............." -:-:-:-:-:-:-:-,-,-,,1-1.1-1l.-.,.,:: ...."..,' .... ..... .I.I.I.I...' .. .... ..'.. ............ _ ........ .. ...... _....'.":..-.:* .....................,'. .-.-.-.-.-.'.'. ........ ........... ........ ....................... ....... . ...... .*:..:. .. '*.. ]-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-.-:-:-:-:-:-.. . .'..-.-. . -':'-'-.' ....:::::: ....... :::: .... ... "'-'-'-'-'.:::".,.,.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:...:.:-.'.'. .:::...... ....,.:::::..:::::::::::..:::::::..,:,.. ........................... .. I...'................ .............. ...... .. " " :-'::::.,i:i::i:i:i:i:i:i:::::.: ......i: .... -... .::::::. .*.*::. . ... "............ " '.'........... ...........'......'........ .... ......."..,..........,......... .. I. -' .. ...................... ....................iiiiii .......I............ ........ ........... .........- - . . . .. . . .. ... ......-... .:-:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:-:-:.:-.-.,.-. ..i. .... I.......... .... .......... ..... . .................. ............... . ,:-,:::::::::::::::::::::::: . . -'-':' . . .. . . ....... ". :-:-:.:-:-:-"-:-:-.-.-........ ._............. <. ............. ......... :::::::::::$_-::::::::::::::::,....,-..:,:.:,:,:.'.. ....... ....... . . ......... ..... '. ' . . ' . . . - j -. '. i - ..'-' -" -- .. ' ' ' ,,, ,," . . ... .. .............. .,.,.,.,.,..:.:"-..,.:-..:.:.:.. .. ..... , . .. ..... . , -:.:-:.:.:.:.:...:.:.:.:-:-.. .. ,:, .... N :.,.:-:.:-:.:.:.:-:.:-:.: , :1 .",::..::::::::::........::::::....:::..:..-.:: ,, . . . - .- ..,.:.:..,-.'-.-.-:-:.:.:...:,..:...:. ... K.:.:-:.:-:.:-:.:...:-..:.:-:.:.:.:.:",::::-,..-....::::::...:::..:"-,.., .... .. ' :..::::::::::,-::, .":.'.'.::-.-.-.::: '.............. " .... '..... I.....I .......I............ I... ......... . .... - '-' .-. I............. ........... ."-i-i-," ..........".. --.............V I...'...... ..."-'. -",-,::-,.:::.,-:":,-..:::::::.:.:.:.:.,:'.' ".... ................ ........................... .... '... ....... ,"........ ..'................' ... ' ...."... ..... ... ......... . ............... .. .. .........' .............. ...:. .:::::::::::::: "......... .. I .................... . .,.,.%.,. ............ .::::::::: .. . :...:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.,.,. .-:.:. ..... :::........ .... ................ .... . . . ................:......:.:.:.:.:.:.:...:,:...:, . . . ....... .'.:..'. ............... ...'.'.... ...I........... ... .,. . . . ............ .............................. II _' - ........... '. -. ..,::..-:::::::::::::...-::::.,-.,:".": -:::::::::::..:::..::::..::::::..:::::::::::.,., ............. ' .., .... .. ' . ...... .. .......... " '............... ... -)_1 / ........ , .'.'.'.'.'.'.'. -'-'-..:::-,.,: -'.'__.i'-_. ............... ................ ' ........' '. -' . ' ....................... " .... . ... .. . ................ .. .......'.'.... ::::-'.-.::::,...-.::::."-.::--..'.-' 11 .......I............ ... I .-I:.-.:.-.....- ...... ... ' ' '" "'."......'.. .........'...".." ............ ...:...:* ...:..... -.. ::::,-::""..,. ..................."........... .....'.:....-. ... ......... ..... i ................." .. .":".,., ....". .... ..... ........: II........................ ..... .................... ....*.. 'i-'-ii-.:]iiii . ::::.,..:'--.-.-. ........:...... ]-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:-:.... . . .. .. -.'-'/ :.................... :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::,:::.:::: ...::...::'.... .. .i, .. ""I"-.... I"I"....... ..."'I" . '.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:-:.:-:.: I :.:-._.-.-._.-.-........: ........ ,..... ...... ..... ...... -,;._. -,.-.,.,.,. .-..,-..,..,..,. ........ -.,(' .:.:.:.:-:.:.:-:.: ........ ....... ...... . . . . .... . ..... - ............ '.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.........,. ........................... u............... ......................... :,.",::.,.,.,:. ..... latitudes. It would thereforeseem that both the climatesand the florasof theseregionswould have provideda migrationroutefordinosaurs,whichwere themselvesapparentlywarmblooded (Russell,1965). Finally,as we shall see, thereis also some evidence thatdinosaursused thisAlaska-Siberiarouteduring the Cretaceous. Cretaceouspatterns(Figs 7 and 9) In general, the patterns of palaeogeographical change seen in the Jurassic continued into the Cretaceous. Epicontinentalseas across Asia and North America were still extensiveenough in time and space that they mighthave caused detectable effectson patterns of faunal distribution.The Central Atlanticcontinuedto widen, but the Euramerican plate remained whole. The continuing and continental Vertebrate palaeodistributions drift 85 Euramerica Asia \0 5 8 Gondwanaland Fig. 6. Venndiagramofthedistribution of Jurassicdinosaur faunas. Figuresreferto familiesexceptin the case of the have been used instead. sauropods,wheresubfamilies westwardmovementofNorthAmericaled to further mountain building (the Sevier and Laramide orogenies) in the western part of the continent (Coney, 1973), and thismay have increasedtheland linkage to Asia. Though South America finally separatedfromAfricain the Upper Cretaceous,this took place too late to affect the distributional patternof dinosaurs though,as will be seen, it is relevantwhen consideringthose of mammals. The distributions of dinosaurs and mammals will accordinglybe consideredin turn. Dinosaurs The patterns of distributionof the Cretaceous dinosaur faunas of Euramerica, Asia and Gondwanaland are shown in Fig. 8. Withinthe northern continents, there was considerable interchange betweenEuramericaand Asia. Since the Turgai Sea was stillin existence,and in view of the geological evidence for land linkage between Alaska and Siberia,the latterroute was probablystillthe pathway of intercontinental dispersal. The climate of such a route certainlyseems to have been quite warm. Smiley's (1972) studies on the Cretaceous florasof northernAlaska show a peak of warmthin the late Lower Cretaceous (Albian), when the climatetherewas frostfreeand subtropical,and a gradualcooling tillthe end of the Cretaceous,when it had become cool-temperate.Certainly,plants seem to have dispersedby thisroutefor,as already cited, the Early Cretaceous floras of Siberia and BritishColumbia are verysimilar(Barnard, 1973). In addition to this link within the Northern Hemisphere,it is commonlystatedthatthe dinosaur faunas of the Cretaceous world require land connection between Laurasia and Gondwanaland (Charig,1971; Colbert,1974). As alreadyshown,the Upper Jurassicdinosaurfaunasof the two areas are similar. It follows, therefore,that both areas inheriteda similardinosaurfauna in the Cretaceous, and that the bulk of their Cretaceous dinosaur faunas could be merelythe descendantsof common Jurassic stock. Evidence as to Cretaceous intercontinentalconnectionscan thereforeonly be provided by a considerationof those new formswhich evolved solely withinthe Cretaceousperiod. There are sevensuchnewCretaceousdinosaurfamilies:the saurischiantyrannosaurs,dromaeosaursand orniand theornithischian thomimids, hadrosaurs,protoAll ceratopians,ceratopiansand pachycephalosaurs. are knownin bothEuramericaand Asia. But though theliterature containssomereportsofthesegroupsin Gondwanaland,few of theseappear to be reliable. The two supposed ornithomimids fromIndia have recentlybeen statedto be nominavana, of doubtful nature (Russell, 1972). The supposed tyrannosaur and ceratopian specimens from Argentina (von Huene 1929) are all incompletespecimenswhich show none of thediagnosticfeaturesof thesegroups. Though a dromaeosauris reportedfromthe Upper Cretaceous of South America (Ostrom, personal communication),this group is known from the earliestLower Cretaceous in North America and mayhave spreadto Gondwanalandbeforethatsupercontinentbecameisolated.The onlyreliableevidence for faunal connection between Northern and Southern Hemispheres during the Cretaceous is thereforethe presenceof a hadrosaurinehadrosaur in the Upper Cretaceous of Argentina(Casamiquela, 1964; Brett-Surman,personal communication). Like that of the Upper Cretaceousmammals of South America,theaccess routeof thishadrosaur group is uncertain,but was probably via a filter routefromNorthAmerica(see p. 89). At generic level, the only Cretaceous dinosaur reportedin both Laurasia and Gondwanaland is the sauropod Titanosaurus, but the evidenceforthis is unreliable(Colbert,1974). Accordingly it seems clear that the dinosaur faunas of the Cretaceous provide no reliable evidence to contradict the diverse evidence from marine invertebratestudies (Hallam, 1973) that a 86 C. B :: - :::::::::::::::: ................ ............. : .......'.'.'.................. '..... :::: 7 0 N :::::::::::::::I - ,.,.,.,........ .:::.:.:.:,':::::. ... I............... ................. I........................... '- ..... . .. ............ .............. ....... -.. --------------............ - . ............... ::::::':':::"::::: ............... ..................................... . - ... . ................-,.-,-,.-:::::::::::::::::::::::::P .... ............'., .... .... I - - :-.:.: . '::'-'-'-'-'-"'-'.'-'-'-'-' .. .:.:.-*. .4. I I__ --:L;4-:-:-:.............'.."::: .1511 .1.1. .1 , --- ,-,-,.,-..,.,--.-.-.,.--'-'-""-" ...... .... .1.1 . . . .:-:SL:L::^:_:_ -:-:.:,:.I.:-: I' .. ........ . . , j.j_:_:-:.:_ ....'......... ..... _....II....... .......'................... .. -:-:.:-:-:,',.------' _....... .......... . ':"I ..........I...... ............. . -:-:-:-:'._:_:_:_:_:-:-:-:..... ... I........ ................. ... , ...... ... .. .................... ................,......................... ... -::::: . .................... ..... ....................... .. ..... ......................................... ................. .................... ....... ........ .... _............................ . . .......... ... ................................................... ........ ........ .1.1.1 ...I......... ................... ......................................... .. ....................... .... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............... ............... ............... .. .................................................,.........-..................-... ....................................................,..................... ... .'.'..... . . .' .' -1 .. ..... ... ...... . ............................... .......,...,...................................... ..........-...... I........ ............................ ... ........................................... .. ......................................... .............................................-.-......... ...... . '. .. .... ........ ` .,.,.,.,.-.-_ ........ I....... ...................... .. ...................................................-.............. .... ...... ............... ..........................,............-....,.. I., ....'......... ....... ..'.............. .... ............................ -........ ........... ...... .. ................... _ ............... ............................................. . ..... '' ............................................................. ..'..... .......".-,.,.,....................................... ............... : -:-:_:_:_:_:_X _:_:-:-: .. .I.I.I..................... .... . - .. ...... ..................................................-.....,..... ... ......... -:-: . . . . ......................... _X -:-:-:-:-:-:-'.-'.-:-: ...........,...................................:.:.:.:.:-:-:-:-:-:.:.:-:I.............................................:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:-- ....................... ..... ..... -:-:-:-:-:-:.:-: . .: .............................,.................. ........................................................--..-. .......................... , , ................... .. ...... .. ..... .........................................:.:.:.:.:,:.:,:.:-:-:. .......................................:.:.:.:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.:i ...... ........................................ ..........................................:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.I ....... ...............................................,:.:.:.:.:-:-:-:-:-:.:...... .................................. .. ''I,- ..... .. .....................,................................:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.:.:.:.\................ ............ .... ..... _ :_:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:_:_T . ..........I..... . . . . :........ . . . . . ..... . . . . . . ..... : -:-:-:_:_:-:_:-:-:_:-X-%.....'.-I ............... ............... .......... .. ..... .................. ....,..................................................:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:-:.:-:-:-N:..% .................... .................... .'A .................... . "" ............. ............. ..... I........... . '' :.-:-:_:_:-:-:-:-:-:.:.:.:.'. ....... ,.-.-.-.-.-.-.........................................: :::::::::::.:.:.:.:]::.:j::.'-. ""'.' 'iNN ':,::, .............. ........ . .................... '......'..'.'.. I......... " ' ...........................................................-....................11:1 ........................... .... ..''. ..... ..: '-'.'.'.'.'.'-'-,-,. ........................................ ... ...........'.'.......... ...................................................' ......................................... .............". .-.-.-:-A:-: " .." .......I..... " ....... ... . . . .............'.... . . . . . .........',', ..'.',........ .............. . . . . . . ................. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...... . I . ...:.:.-.:.:.:.:.:.:.I.:.:.:.:. " ................ ...I........................... .:......'........: .... .1.......... . .. . . . . ................ ..................... ....I.........._ ........ . . . . -:-:-:-"5 . "C-:.:-:-:-X-:-:-:-: ....................... ,..... ... ' .........'....... -.1....... .................... . . . . ...............::.:.:,:,:.:.:.:-:-:-:-:-:-.-Ik;.: .... " -.. ....... -.-..:.:--..-. .... . . . . .. ......_............: ,:.:.:.:.:. . .,:,:-.\.,,.---. ...... ..'... I.I.I............. ........ . I.I.I..........' ... . . . . . . . ...'............' . ' . . . . . . . . . ................. . . .......... ...... .............. ........ ............... . ... . . . . . . . ................................... . . . . . . . .'............. ........ . . . . . . . ......... .....:. . . . .... .... .......... .. ................ ....... ..I.I.......................... ............... .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ............... .............. ........ .,.. ... ... .. . ... .. . -.... . ...............................,....... . . . . . . . ............... . . , .. .... . . . ............... .............. ........ ............... ........ ............... ........ . . . . . . - ............................... . . . . . . . ............... . .. . . . . . . ............."'. ............... ........ .. ....... . . . ................. ....... . . . . . . . . . . . , . . ...... .. ................' ............... ........ .................................... -...... ........................................ ...............,................................................................... _. .. ' ... ........... ' ................. ......--.... ........................ ...... ........ ............... ......... ........ ............ .........................-...-....:.:.:-:.:-:-:-:-:-:.:.:.:.:.:.....--.-.-.......................... .......'.......... ....... ---II............................... -.1,,"-; '.........: ....,.,.,-,-'...:-:-:-:-:_:_:_'-'.-. ....... .,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-...-............................................-, ...._.... .::::::::::: I............... .............. :-:-:-:.: ..................... I.........., .. .............. ,.-.-.,.-.,.%,................................ .. .,.-.-.-.-.-.-.,..............................................,............................. "A ....... ' .,.-.-.-.-.-.-.,............................. ....... ........ ....... ................... ....... ... ............ .I.............' ................................. ....... .. .. ' Tethyan marine belt (presumablya shallow epicontinentalsea) separatedGondwanaland fromthe northernland areas duringthe Cretaceous. Even withinthe NorthernHemisphere,epicontinental seas stronglyaffectedthe distributionof Cretaceousterrestrial vertebrates. The new typesof dinosaur which evolved in the Lower Cretaceous (comithomimids, pachycephalosaurs and hadrosaurinehadrosaurs)were able to spread throughout theNorthernHemisphere.But the formationof the Mid-ContinentalSeaway across North America in the Upper Cretaceous(Fig. 9) createdtwo separate land masses in the NorthernHemisphere: 'Asiamerica' (Asia plus westernNorth America) and 'Euramerica'(easternNorth America plus Europe). As Colbert(1974) has pointedout, thisgeographical situation explains the restrictionof the tyrannosaursand protoceratopids to thefirstof thesetwo land masses-and it should be noted that both groups evolved withinthe Upper Cretaceous,after the seaway had formed. However, Colbert also suggeststhatthepresenceof hadrosaursin bothland masses shows that it was possible for some dinosaurs, at least, to cross the Seaway. In fact,closer analysis shows that the only hadrosaursknown in Euramerica are the most primitiveforms, the hadrosaurines.As already noted, these evolved in the Lower Cretaceous,beforethe Seaway formed. The otherthreehadrosaursubfamilies(the Saurolophinae,Cheneosaurinaeand Lambeosaurinae)evol- and continental Vertebrate palaeodistributions drift 87 Euramerica 18 Asia 112 12 9 Gondwanaland Fig. 8. Venn diagram of the distributionof Cretaceous dinosaurfaunas.Figuresreferto familiesexceptin the case have been used instead. of thesauropods,wheresubfamilies ved in the Upper Cretaceous,afterthe Seaway had formed,and are foundonlyin Asiamerica. The survivalof iguanodontsand primitiveankylosaurs (the acanthopholids) in the Upper Cretaceous of Euramericamay also have been due to the isolation of that area at that time. These groups became extinctin the Upper Cretaceous of Asiamerica,wheretheywould have been in competition with such new groups as the protoceratopidsand advanced hadrosaurs. Although,if one takes the Upper Cretaceousas a whole, it is thus possible to identifya single Asiamerican faunal region, this itselfhad apparently become subdividedby the Uppermost Cretaceous (Kielan-Jaworowska,1974). Thisfactis notapparent at familylevel,as thefamiliesfoundin bothAsia and westernNorth America in the early Upper Cretaceous survive in both areas until the end of the Cretaceous. Kielan-Jaworowska(pers. comm.) has pointed out, however, that only two genera are commonto both areas, and also thattheUppermost Cretaceous North American family Ceratopidae may well be absent fromAsia, since its supposed presencethereis based only on a singleskull bone (Charig, 1973) of doubtfuldiagnosticvalue. This suggeststhata barrierhad formedbetweenAsia and North America,and a spread of epicontinentalseas betweenthemseemsthe mostlikelyexplanation.As will be seen, the distributionof UppermostCretaceous mammalssupportsthishypothesis. Within the Southern Hemisphere, dinosaurs doubtless became widely distributedduring the Jurassicand Lower Cretaceous, when Gondwanaland was stillwhole. Their presencein the separate parts of Gondwanaland in the Upper Cretaceous does not, therefore, implyland routesbetweenthese areas at that time,as Colbert (1974) suggests,but merelythe presenceof descendantsof the dinosaur fauna thatwas commonto all of Gondwanaland in the Lower Cretaceous. Mammals The distribution of Cretaceousmammalspresentsa varietyof problems,mainlybecause of the imperfection of our knowledgeboth of theearlyevolutionof marsupialsand placentalsand also of thefinaldates of separationbetweenthedifferent land masses.The palaeogeographyof the Upper Cretaceousis shown in Fig. 9, and threemajor biogeographicproblems involving the differentialdistributionsof Upper Cretaceous mammals will be considered in turn: these relate to distributionsin North America as against Asia; Laurasia as against Gondwanaland; and withinGondwanalanditself. The distribution of UppermostCretaceousmammals providesfurther evidenceof a barrierbetween Asia and westernNorth America. North America appears to have been invaded by severalfamiliesof Asian placentals (Lillegraven, 1969) and multituberculates(Kielan-Jaworowska,1974). However, the multituberculatesand varied marsupials of North Americado not appear to have been able to colonize Asia.* Kielan-Jaworowska(1974) points out that this situationis not easily explicable by to a possiblefilterconnectionbetweenAsia reference and North America,as this should have permitted passage equally well in each direction.Instead, she believesthatit suggestsa sweepstakesroutebetween the two areas, possiblyacross marinestraitswithin whichthe currentsfavouredeastwardcrossingsbut not westwardcrossings. Relationshipsbetweenmammalsin SouthAmerica on the one hand, and NorthAmericaand Africaon the other,pose difficult problemsin both the Upper Cretaceousand the Lower Tertiary,and neitherthe * Butler& Kielan-Jaworowska (1973) have suggestedthat the Asian familyDeltatheridiidae mayhave some marsupial dentalcharacters, as wellas placentalcharacters;theyprefer to classifythe group as early mammals of metatherianeutheriangrade,and theirpresencein Asia does not necessarilyimplythepresencethereof fullymarsupialmammals, closelyrelatedto themarsupialsof NorthAmerica. 88 70 '"-------". N-,I. . .-.- C. BarryCox - I.. -.... .. .1.1.1.1,, """"""' ---.-.--:::-:'-.--.:.:"' .I.'""' .I.I.'-'-'I':-.'-'-"" 1.1.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.............:. .,.,., ..1 %:.-.-:::::-.-.'-'::;P' ,.,.:::::.,:::,.".:":...:..,::.., . .. .I.......I.I.... ...... (- ,_""""""""" -"",::,:,:-:.......' . '....... - -- -."..,. ................"',"" .................. ... .':;,::.I::::-k-::::.L.-.,.,.%,., .:. .:..:..:.,.,..,.,. ,,::, ............ : ............... -'-.-' , ' ".'.-...:.:.N. -i;.-.' X...:.:.:.-.:.:.;, .......... ..... .. ..._..... .. ......... .. -N-'.', ::,-%.::: --..%'(. ..... ..::: ,.- U P P E R "' -N..... -.,.,.. ....... -. ' .... . ..,.,.,.-.-.-.% ' ' .............. 'j" X%-"..,... , "",:i?;. ...... :.'.'.'..'.'.........% ...... --...,.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.%-.-.-.-.-.-.-......X"'':' -- - .,-,. -....-.. . ..-................. , , -, .1.1 ................. iii....xi.M. :.:.:;k::n ...... . ::::. . ..S.. :.,...,.:.:-:-:-.. .?F """ .......... ..I---....:: .. ..-----............................... -,-:.:.,-:-:-:.,.%: . -....... ... . ........ .... .......,.............t.'j ................. ... , ""': III.-........ IIII:.:.,.,..:-:-:.:.:.:,:.:.:-,-I,-,.%:-:.:-.-...:,W-:-:.:-,.,%. III.. t.---..... . ... ..... ,:::::::::::,.3::. ,.,::::" , ,w. -.--'.--.-. .'... ,,, ...... :.:::::.... I:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:.....:.: 1-::: -I,-" W'--:::::'-' .--'--- ..'--------i'-I I. .. . .. ...:-:-:-:-:-, ..:f. . ......... ___ ...... .... .,-:-:.,.%:::::-,.,:::.:....::::::::::r.:-....,.. ... %%........ .... .... .- 0I..:::::, '7-*i;g:.. -. ..v .-I., .... ...... , -'-.-'.-:-:-.'-.-:-:-% ..-.--... ..........-.:::::::::::::::::::: ........... ......... --.---: ?' ...........................M.. .......... "" -------.. ................................. % .... "':-:-:-:-.-.-:-A .. /. .--.1.... . .I.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.% .... :-:e.-:.,.,..-.-,-. .WL --------. :....................... ................... - ----..-. . . . . . ....- ....I::....%,.,.-.-.,.-.%%-.-.-........:.:.:.y %%-.-.-.-.._--- ----:-.'-_-----. ................ .................................... -.-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-. .:-:-: ................ "'-""'::':-' .:.:.:.,.,.,......,........-.,.,........,................ .. .' :,-::::::::::r......,....-......... ..."-....... .... %.........................................-...... '....."... ..... ............................ ....... .... ...." -...:::.: .'........ ,:.:.:.:::::::.:::::::.... %......................................... .:":.. -.------........... ...... i'-'--'-:' __( "... .:-:.:.:.,.,-,-,.,.,.,.-..,.,-,-,-'.-,.'.'.'.'.'-'.'-,-,--... 11'1-._),- --' ;X......-Q,"' .............................'... .....,..,......................... ....-...I ......... %... .... *":i]'.'.i.:......, .... ................................................. :-:-:.. .... "".'-:-*'-:-.:..:.:;i:K ... -.,.%% .......................... ....X......,.,. .. . ---.-:::::::::::. .. ... .... ... 11........................'.. -I.'I\ .---..... .... ............................. I)j 1-.. .' :.!.-.----.--.-................................ ...........................:::' Z-1 .-.-.% -.-.-.-.%-.-.-.-.-.......-............ .......... "-.:"-----'----'--f......'....... .....!'-.'-'.?.......... .........'....... .........-.-.......-.-.,.,.-.I.,.,., .......................................................... ....... ...... "i'\'.,:.:. .I.......'...'........... -...-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-. ............ ' .: ...... .................................... ........ . .... ......................... _... ...... .............. ....... ............. ....... ..... :-:-:-:.:-:-,,..,-,.,.1-1.-.'-,.................. .............. ......... ......... .............. ............................................................................................ ....... _Z',.......................".I.... : ':' . . . .. _L ............,............................... ..... j .::::.::::::::::: ................I.--.. ... ... ::.:.:.% ................. ...... ............... .... .:.:.:.:-:-:....-:-:-:.-.-.-.N .................. ................... ........ .......... .............. ......... ................... ...................:.. I-I.I........ ... .........1 ''I "', 1- ... .....'. .'i...: * X.... . .... -:-:-:-:-: ..... .............:' ... :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::........... '-:-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-' ...........-'. ............ .............-,. ........I.. :'.:.:':j:.:.: -('.. -'.',... ............................. .......................... .-.-." ....... . .-.1.1.1.-.-.-.-.-.-,-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.,.I .... ...--I.................................I..... -.-.-.-.%-.-.-.-,-. - ..............-C,\-f-I 11-11,........-...........I%. ........I..................."4........................ I..............,............................ I....................... ......... .......................... ............................................ ....... ..... "' LJ"--'-kx.... ... ...... '' ...,.,..,, '- '-'"F-.... ,...... . .:. ......... ;'-', .....'..-.-.-.-.-.-....- . -.. ......... --II I'I-:-----'-N---------- ,-Ic-)Z, A?'_ I','f........... 1-1 I'. . ........'.'... \ ... '.'.............. S::::--:f ..... I....... ..........................u"" .'........ .::: ........ .............. ,.,.,.,.,.,.,. .... ..... .."".........-.... ... ............... ... ............. ..... " ii'-i'i -.... ...........--0.'.'.'.'."-..-....... ......... ...................i-i-i-''i'i.i]. .....]........ ...1. ............... .......... ........... ........ .............. ']''ij..' ... 'i'i'i*i**-i]'-. ........... .....]....... ...... .......... .. .... ............. ... .... ... :-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:-:..,\&.:: .............. ............' . ... ..... :::-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.,\ ........: ............... ...-... .i.--... .i]' ]i-'6 .................... ::: .:-:-:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:-N-,* ...::...:::.."-'-.--'. ............................... .................................. -'. ..............................,......... ......... ::::::..::--'.---. .... ", '-'-'.-.-"-"': ,-."-'.'.'! ........... .:,:.:.:-:.:.:-:,:-:-:.:.,.." .-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.......,...-.-.-. ........... ''.-%,.:::...-..:::.......... ...... .-.-.-.,.-.,.,.,. .................................. ..-.-,-.-.-.-.-.-.........-.-........:I ................................... .................................... ,-..ii'iiii-:",-..:,-' ................................... '............................................................ -,':........ .-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.,.-.-.-.-................ -::.-'::',:!::' .................................. .... -........ ---'-'-:-:-:-.-:'-*'-."-", ............................... .......... .................... ... ...............................:.. .... .::::::,-:-,.,-..,." -..-.-.-.-.-.-.-.............,... ............. ....................................... ...................................................::::."...,i:,. ..............I... -............................... .............. ..... .. .. .. ... ... ... ... ...:::.:.. I ...........'.'.'.'.'.I.I..,.,.,I ......... .........I................... ....... ..........-....,-..,.-....-.-....,......-. ................. .......................-"' " '.-,.....-. , 'J -?. .. ...... ..'. " .1.1 1.1.11 .... ............. ........ ... .. ........... .... ...0................ ... ....... .. ..... :.:.T.:' ......... ..... ......I............... )P ....-) _:> :-:-:-:-:-:-:-: .:-:-:-:--Z..:.-.. - "" ............... ....... .... i-i:- -::,:,-......* 7'- i--....... ,.'.-.-.-.'.'.'.-....................................... ...i. .... ........ -- ..... I... .... . .._... ............... :::::.............. ... ... ... :.:. .''..... .... : : :::-:'.. .. :.. ::::: :..: ....:-:-, ...",'.6 .......... .............................. ...... ......... .............. "::.,.'i'.]'.-'.'i"...-...-,-.'I .............. . ........... ......... ........ .... ... ...' I...'*.O"' .... ...-... -.1. .............................. ........ X'.-.'.'.'.'....... .':-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.L-l.. .............................................:..:::.: ........................ ....................... :-:-:-:-:-:-:-;' I..................... .. .......................--........................-....................... .:-:-:.:.::;, ............................................. :-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.:. .::::: .,:::::::::::::::::.::::::::::::::.,..,..,.,.,..,.-,...-'.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-...........-...-....:...,.,.,.:-:-:-:-.-:.:.:-:.I .................... ............ ............................................... ...................................................................................... ....... ..:.:.:.:..-..:-,-:f . ................ ................................................. ........ ...... ......... ..... %................................................................ ..:-:-:-:-:-:-I I ............................................................... ... - I ......................................................................:... ..... ...................................I.......................:-:-:-:-:,I . ........ ............................,..........,...............................................................................................,.,.. .................................................................... ..................,......................................................................................................,................ ..................................................I.............I....i.. ...................................................................... ................... - ................................................. ........ I.................................................................... .............................................................. ........ ........ ... ........................................... ........... .......................................... .......... .................. -............... .................... .... ..... .................................................. ................................................ ............. ......... .....................':................ ................................................. ........ ............. ......................................... ..........................,..... .... ................... ....... ::: : .,..,.... .......... .................... ...: ............. ..", .............I... -::,:.. .... :::: . .......... . :::.'.-.'.'.'.-.'. ....... ...I...........-..1.1.1.1.1.1.1 .. .............................................. . ... I..---------.-.-.-.-.-. .,.,.,. ...'........................................ - - -.11. I.... -.. ..... I... .'...'. ....... .... ........... -) ' ?... ........-.-................. X1.1,"..... :-:-:-:-:-:-.-.-.-...........-...".. ' ' " ........::...... .............................,..........-.-.,.,.,.,".'. -K...-- - - -,.. .-., ........................... ::,-,.::.:-:-:.:.:.:.,.-.."..,.,.., i'.! ......'..""', ", ........ ..' I ' ' I ' ................................................ ... ............ - .,.,-,::""".,-,.:.:,:.:"-,:-,.,.'....., ... ............. ".....:... .............................,.......,...... "....". ........ X. .........................,............... .,...: ...........................- . . . . . . . . I........ ::::::, ..... .. ...............................,. -:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:.:..-.-:.:.:.:..:.:.:.:-:.:.,..:: -,:,-.::.,.,.,., ... . ... :.... ................................ %..... . .:..:.:::::.-,.:.,.,.,:;:-:.-.,..:;: .... . . .... .......................... --:-:--' .................................. I..,.,..,.,..:.:.:.:..:..: ..:.. .,.,.-.,.,.,.,.,............................................................... ...... -.-.-.-.-.-.-...-. .............................. ....... ..... .:.:.:.:.:.,.:..,..,.:.:-:."".:..,i, : ::....::::. .:-:-:.:-:.:.:.:-:.:-:-:.:.:.:.:.,.,.,.,.,-1-1-1-1--.-.--,-,.....:-.,:-..:., ............................................ :::::::::::'-'-'-'.'ji I.I.I....i-"-'---".". ...............'_ .......... .............. ....." ...... ..... ................................,........ %...... : -:..-::"", - - ....... ..... ... ..... .:::::::::::..:.,:. ......................... .-.,.-.-. %.................................... ............... ::j::-ji:: , I .......................................... ........ -......... ..................... - '-: ..-::",." -.,.,::::::::.,.,.,-.. ......................................................................... I.... I'll I.................. .......I........ .......... ...... ............_....................:.... ........ .. ..ii. 'i." --'iii: ............. ....... ...,..,.,.,.,..::::: ........-................. ............ .1.1.1.-.,.,.-.-,-,,.-.-.-....."...."...'.........'.....' ................................... ........ .. ....... ........-.-.-.-.-.-.-........................ .. . " I.,, ...........I.......... ........-::::... ..::, .:. ...-i::-i:'-: ....................................................... .:: ..:::::::::::::.. . '--'::.-'.-'--.-'-_""" "' '... ' ' .. " ., " ' " ".'.'.-.'.'.'.'.-'......... ..-.. :::: .1. I F..-..-..".-..],...-:--]......,.....i. :-:-----;.-i.-'::: "..... ............."........................-'-'-'-'-,.,.:::: " .........I... ......I. .I... :- __ ......... -....................................... ... ..... -1 :::: : :.... '-' ... -.. .. .... :-.-... ................. -..... ...:.- -' ................................. .. ............ . ... ............ ... ......... ............... ............................. :. .... I I - - - ..................... -.... . ........ ....... ..... .:.. ..... ... ........ ...... . .................... .......... .......... ..... ...: ............. .... .. ........ .,\........ . . ............. ::;.. . .'..... ................... -.............. ............ .............. ... .....'...'.'...... ........... ........... ,.-.,.,.,.,.-.,.. . .............................................. ... .... .'................ .......... .'..........I........... ..... ......................... .. .......................................... ........... -1-.1 f) .-.-......................... . .................%.............. ..... ..11 ............................. ....... .............. -....I................I............ - -",'-','-""-l - - - - - - - - - - - -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-................... __I lk::..::' ............... .....I...................... .. .... .............................................. ........ ......... "..."'. """"""",..."...",""",., ...................... ................-...........-.................-.............-.......... .....................................,...,.. """"".'.-..'.'.'.'.""" .. -:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:-,. ................. ........... ................ ...... :.:.:..:.:...:. -. .. ...: ..'.. "" ........................... ................ ..."...'..."'....."', .:.:.:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:..,.,-::::::::::::::::.. -' : .....:. I ' .................................X 1-11,1111, "",....................................,...-,:::::::,-,: ......................................I.-X. -, ................. ................... ................ .. ".. ' , ....................... ....:, ::::::.:-:-:-:-:.:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:-,..:...:".:...,...,..,'..I ' - -'..... :-:-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-'-.......' ........ .:.::...:*....................................... ....... .... ........... ...... .... ....... ..:...:.:.:.:.:-..:,..:...".'...:,"...,. .I.I.-I., ,-. ... ................... -.1.11 ..... --'2 .. X :.:-::.. ........I............ .. ....................................... .. ........ .. ................... ......0 ......... ...........'. .................. .. .............,.,.:.:.,...,-,...,.:.:.:..,.,.,.... .....'.. .. .................... ............. X............. .....-.::: ... "' '... ......-*:.:. ...,.................................... -j:j:j:.:.:.:'-:.:.:]:: :......'....., . ".............. ..... ....... ......:. ' ' " .... ............... ...................................... .............. ...................... ..............................:.:.:.: .....:::: .......................... ...................... ........::,4-:, :' -"' .......I................... ... - .'......... . ...I............ ................. ..... ,,........... ...... .... ........................-'i....-i'. ......................'.....'..'.. ................. ... ........ .................................................. ........,.,........................ ................. ..........I...............I....... .................. ................... ............,......................... -:.:.:.:-,-.-,-.-..,..,..,.,.-.--, .... .:-:-: ::.,............... ........ ...........-............ 1- ...... ....... ................. -......................... 11 ........... ......... 11 .................................. .. ........ ......................... ..... -.-.,.,.-.-.,.,., ...:........ ....,.-.,.,.-.-.-.-. .. ...........I................ ............................................... -::::: :......... '..."...".".".".", ............................::::::::::::::::.: " -, .... . .......................... ............................ .... . ............. ................... ......................... -......... 1. -........ ... .: -......................... ......I.................... ... .--....................... ......... .'.'. .......................... I ... ..... -....... . .. .............................. . . . . . .................................... ....................:::,..:................................ .,.'--. ,""..."',"'.......'.. ......I.......... - -:"f.. ..... .... .................. ...... . .... .......................... . . . ..-.::.:.:.:-:.:.:.:.:.:-:-:.:.I . ......... ... ............. ... ............................... ...I............ :::::::::::::::::::::::::: : :........ ......................................... E TA C E 0"'US ,,, .,.,: rR ...' ......... ,,,".'..'- , -' ,,, .:.:.,-:-:-:.:-:-:.:"".-.'..'.I ....... -11, ..-.-:-,.-:-:-:-:.:.t.... ... .....' .. ' .. ..'. '_.....................................................0E ..'-'.'.. _.. .............. ............,...... ........... :-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:.\0 :-:-:-,-,.:-:.:.:.:.:....-.-,-.........:,:::::::,::::, ........... ............ ...... -'.-i'\ X.. ....................... .......... .)I/j\Ir ........ ....... . .................... :" ....... ............ ... '.''...... .. ................. ............-......... ........... -,'........ ....-:..'... r.......................,.,...,...,..0I> .....'........................ I--,-,,, .................... ....... . ........ .. I.........................:: ... m C ............ .................................. ........ ............................. ... ........................-'............................ ....................... .................''...................... ................: ................. .........,...,......................... ........ . ...... --................ .%... . ............... -':'--:.:.:-:..-..,...,.,.,.,.,."",i, ...... , -.:..,i:. ..."', . .......I.I.I.I.I.I., .."-'...... ......... I........... I. ......... . .... .. ...... "I .................... .-,..,.,., .::,:-'-'t` .......I...... -;',' ,:,., , '' ................................... ..... .......I........................... ...................... .. :::,.:-.:::::::,-::.",... -.. -. ............... .'..... .................................................................................-..... . .. . .... ................................ I.I.I.I.I.I.I.I......" ..................................................'' ..... ...".... .................................................................:. ..........................................................:.:.,.:.:.:.:.:.:-:.:-:-:-:-:-:.:.-..-.-.-... .......... ........ ........ .................................................::. -"'-'-'-"-:'.""' ............................... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.,.,. ::..; '..........: 1. ............................... ........ ......... ......,--.,.,.,.,.:::::::: ... , .. I.."."' .........................'.. ..- -..:.,,., ... .......... - .... -. :'-'-',' ..........I......... ................ .......................................... ................ ...........................,...-...................::::.:: .,:,.":...:,-.,. I........T ................. 1. -.... ................................"...,. ........... 'f I I I...: ........ ..................................... .................. -. -...'..'..............'. .........,., -I I I. I"I ..... ............................. .. L .................... .::: ::: ::I. ............ ..... .. ... .. E 0 U AT0 :::I_. ........ ... ........ ............. A..."."'..""""'. i-ii;.'; "i.,................. ........ ......... ........ --....................-.........-...-......,...,..,.,.-.-.-.-.............................,.,.,.,.,.,...................."...',.,.,., ..................................:-:-,.:-:.:.:.:.:-:.:.:-:-:-],:...........................................-.:-:-:-:-:.:-:-:.:..................,. L_ 2-.-.-.-.-.-.%-.-.......................... ..........."'..... ........................... .............................................. ... .... ..................................... ........ ....::::: ..' _'--................................... .....' .... ..................................................... ........ X................... .... ..::-:::::.''.. .... ... .............'........... .. ............................. '.....'......... ...............' ........................................... .''.. ........................................ ...................'-...... ............... ........................-.-...::::::::::::::::.::::::,:,::...... .. ...... ................................ .............. ...............................:...... .... ....................-"" -.-.-.,.-.-.-.-.,.,.-.I.,.,.,., ::: .... .............'........ ..........................:............... ...................:....... ........,_I_ ............................................... :::::::::::::::"'._ ..1111 '.' .. ........... ........'.:-:............................................................3........ ... .... .. -, .. .............................. ................................. ....... .. -..:.: ....................... .... .................................. :-:-:-: I ...:.. -:-"::::.-'.."' geologicalnor thebiogeographicalevidenceis as yet adequate to providereliable answersto these. The geological historyof the Caribbean area remains complex and uncertain.Sea floor spreadingdata, now givingreliable estimatesof the Upper Cretaceous positionof Africarelativeto North America (Pitman & Talwani, 1972) and to South America (Le Pichon & Hayes, 1971; Sclater & McKenzie, 1973), show that the North Atlantic was already SouthAmerica wide,whereasnorthern comparatively was stillnot fardistantfromAfrica(Fig. 9). The Cretaceous biogeographical evidence is the adequate onlyforNorthAmerica.Untilrecently, fact that it containedthe most diverseCretaceous marsupial fauna known led to the belief that the group had evolved in that area. But Cretaceous marsupials and condylarthplacentals have now been foundin South America(Sige, 1968, 1972); in of thiscontinent'sCretaceous particularthediversity marsupialfaunahas alreadyprovideda considerable surprise,leading Hoffstetter (1970) to suggestthat marsupials might have evolved somewhere in Gondwanaland.More surprisesmaywell be in store, both from South America and also from Africa, whose Cretaceous and Early Tertiary mammal faunas are completelyunknown. As Sige (1972) pointsout,it would be unwiseto attemptto erectan elaboratebiogeographichypothesison existingdata. One can only suggesta few possibilities. Since marsupials are known from both Gond- Vertebrate and continental palaeodistributions drift 89 wanaland and Euramericain the Upper Cretaceous, theymusthavecrossedthesea barrierwhichseparated the dinosaurfaunas of the Northernand Southern Hemispheres.Two routes are possible, and both involve difficulties. Though, as just discussed, it seems likely that there was a considerable gap betweenNorthand SouthAmerica,it is possiblethat fromthe thisgap containedvolcanicislandsresulting complicated tectonic events taking place in the Caribbean (Malfait & Dinkelman, 1972). These route,allowingmarsupials mighthave actedas a filter and condylarthplacentals to cross betweenNorth and South America,but preventingthe passage of dinosaurs,excepthadrosaurs. The alternativeis a more circuitousroute from westernNorth Americato Euramerica,and thento Africaand SouthAmerica.This would have involved crossingthe Mid-ContinentalSeaway, the Tethyan seaway betweenEurope and Africa,and the early, narrowSouth Atlantic.This last mighthave been no great problem,since the interveningMid-Atlantic Ridge may have surfacedas volcanic islands which would have providedpossibleaids to thedispersalof terrestrial animalsfromone continentto the other; the Cape Verde Islands and Canary Islands seem to be relicsof such a chain in the more northernpart oftheRidge(Klerkx& de Paepe, 1971).Nevertheless, the threesea barriersinvolvedin thisroutetogether form a formidable series of obstacles. Another is that, if marsupialshad spread by this difficulty to findno traceof themin the route,it is surprising well known European Upper Paleocene mammal faunas. The presentevidence,thoughinconclusive,therefore favoursa trans-Caribbeanfilterroute for the passage of marsupials and condylarthsbetween Northand SouthAmerica. I have recently(Cox, 1973c) discussedtheproblem of the connectionbetweenSouth America and the rest of Gondwanaland, and its relationshipto the spread of marsupials to Australia. In brief, the simplestexplanationis thatmarsupialscrossedfrom landmass SouthAmericato theAntarctica-Australia beforethisbrokeaway,and thatthisseparationtook place before placentals arrivedin South America. As a result,the placentals were unable to reach Australia. Australia later split from Antarctica; sea floor spreadingdata (Weissel & Hayes, 1971) show thatthistook place in theEocene. One crucial factorin this theory is the timing of the break betweenSouth Americaand Antarctica,whichmust have taken place by at least the Late Cretaceousto have excludedtheknownPaleocene South American placentalsfromaccess to Australia.Though earlier workers had suggested that the break was not untilEarly Tertiarytimes,therecentview of Dalziel et al. (1973) that it took place beforethe Late Cretaceous is helpfulto my suggestedexplanation.* Tertiarypatterns To understandproperlythe distributionalpatterns of different mammalianfamilies,it is necessaryto know where each of these originated.For some familiesit is impossibleto be sureof this,because of gaps in the record in particularareas and times. Many families,however,are endemic to one particular tectonic plate, and accordingly it seems reasonableto assumeprovisionallythatthisincludes theirarea of origin. Figure 10 is a Venn diagramof the areas of first known occurrenceof different mammalian orders. Many of theseare firstknownfromNorthAmerica, because therecordforthatcontinentis knownfrom theUpper Cretacousonwards,whereastheEuropean record does not begin until the Mid-Upper Paleocene. Late thoughthisEuropean record is, it none the less contains representativesof most of the 'North American' groups. As North America and Europe were stilljoined untilthe end of the Lower Eocene, one cannot localize the apparent area of origin of these orders more preciselythan 'Euramerica' and theyare shownas such in Figs 10 and 11. OnlythoseNorthAmericanorderswhichdo not appear in the European recordin the Upper Paleocene are shown as originatingin North America. As alreadymentioned,placentalsappear to have originated in Asia. The earliest placentals are normallyplaced in the order Insectivora but, as Butler(1972) has pointed out, theyare reallyonly primitive placentals, rather than being closely related to the living types of insectivore.Butler suggeststhat the earlyformsbe placed in an order Proteutheria,and the later, more modern typesof insectivorebe placed in an order Lipotyphla.This suggestionhas been acceptedhere. Figure 11 shows the faunal relationshipsof the * ThoughRaven & Axelrod(1972, 1974) referto thefinal break of the link betweenAustraliaand South Americaas to thedate of beingmiddleEocene,theyare in factreferring the break betweenAustraliaand Antarctica;theydo also (1974) note the above-quoteddata for the separationof South AmericafromAntarctica. 90 C. BarryCox ProteutheriatU Cret LagomorphaU Eo ASIA Dlnocerata t U Pal t /esmostylia U Oligo U P /NPrimataU Cret/L Pal L Pal |Carnivora Lipotyphla Mid Pal Taeniodontat L Pal MUd Chiroptera Pantodonta t Mid Pal Pal Rodentia U Pal Creodonto t U Pal U Pal Perissodactyla Mu/ti- tLubercutat EUROPE Tst llodontat L Eo P MidEo Ui PalL EArtiodactyla Edentat yrUcoidraLslig \SU NORTH I CA AMERICA Pholidota U Pal \ \ \ \ / >< on y arthrat Li Cret Marsupiaba U Cret \ // E~~~~~URAMERICA / \ > /~\ M id Eo Sl~~~~~~~~~~renia / \ U.Eo theareas,andtimes,offirstknownoccueProboscidea Fig. 10. Venn diagram of order s nEdentata L.Obigo | U Pal Hyrcolde tUPal\ E-mbrIlhopododt Xenutngul/ato Trlgonost/oodet L Oligo0 L Olilgo U P IMscrosce/wd(es Notoungulatat U Pal L 11oplernott U Pal\/ \ Astropothertlot L Eo \ PYrotherlo t L E o/ \ o \uulett / \ L/i AFRICA / \SOUTH/ Fig. 10. Venn diagram of the areas, and times, of firstknown occurrence of orders of mammals. Endemic orders italic. Extinct orders shown by t symbol. land masses fromthe Upper Cretaceousto different the Middle Eocene. Arrows indicate the time of appearanceofan orderin a newarea and itsprobable geographical origin. The firstappearance in the palaeontologicalrecordis probablyoftensome time but it is later than its actual time of immigration, best to portrayonly what is at presentestablished. During thisperiod,theTurgai Sea stillobstructed directland travelbetweenEurope and Asia. Though thedisappearanceof the Mid-ContinentalSeaway at the beginning of the Tertiary allowed dispersal betweenWesternNorth America and Euramerica, Greenland began to separate from Europe in the Paleocene (Bott, 1973). ConnectionsbetweenNorth possibleonlyin Americaand Europe weretherefore the north,where northernGreenland was sliding past Svalbard (Spitzbergen) along the de Geer fracturezone. As Szalay & McKenna (1971) have pointed out, this connectionwas at a fairlyhigh palaeolatitude,and would have acted as a faunal filter.The closenessof the relationshipbetweenthe two areas is demonstrated by thefactthattenUpper Paleocene mammal generaare found in both areas (Kurten, 1973). As can be seen fromFig. 12, the NorthAmericanfauna is less similarto thatof Asia than to that of Europe. Szalay & McKenna (1971) suggestthatthisis because the Beringconnectionto Asia would have lain at c 750 N palaeolatitude,8? furthernorth than the Svalbard route to Europe. in latitudeis small, and it However,this difference Vertebrate palaeodistributions and continental drift 91 A S IA Multituberculata U Pal Proteutheria U Pal UPa _t Dinocerata Cret RUPHIU NORTH J AMERICA lPantodonta "Perissodactyla Taeniodonta Dinocerata Pholidota Notoungulata Xenungulata Marsupialia U Pal I Mid Pal A AFRICA Condylarthra Edentata SOUTH AMERICA U Eo Rodentia Multituberculata Condylarthra Primata Astrapotheria Litopterna Pyrotheria Marsupialia Trigonostylopoidea La Lipotyphla Creodonta L [o Carnivora U Pal Lagontorpha L Eo Artiodactyla Til aodonta Chiroptera EURAMERICA IINDIA 2 ? - AUSTRALIA ANTARCTICA Fig. 11. Geographicaldistribution and dispersalof mammalianordersduringthe Upper Cretaceousto Lower Eocene. NorthAmerica Europe Fig. 12. Venn diagramof the distributionof mammalian familiesin the NorthernHemisphereduringthe Paleocene and LowerEocene. was due seemsmorelikelythatthefaunal difference to a continuationof the Late Cretaceous barrier betweenAsia and NorthAmerica. Notoungulateswereable to dispersefrom South Americato NorthAmericaand thenceto Asia in the Upper Paleocene. Since no other groups crossed betweenNorth and South America in eitherdirec7 tion,thisappears to have been a sweepstakesroute, again presumably along a Caribbean chain of islands. The faunas of Africa,India and Australiaat this time are unknown. These patterns of possible faunal movements became radically altered in the Middle Eocene. Szalay & McKenna (1971) have suggestedthat the divergencebetween the faunas of North America and Europe,whichbeginsat thistime,mayhave been due to the final breaking of the Svalbard link between Greenland and Europe. Due to the disappearance of the Turgai Sea at this same time, Europe's linkswiththe restof the NorthernHemivia Asia and not via North spherewere henceforth America. Elsewhere,Tertiaryclimaticchanges,and changes in sea levels, produced a complicated patternof alternatingperiods of faunal isolation and linkage betweenAsia and North America fromthe Oligocene onwards,whichhas recentlybeen discussedby Colbert (1974). Recent work (Powell & Conaghan, 1973) has suggestedthatIndia had become attached to Asia by the Middle Eocene, and thisis supported by the presence of condylarths,artiodactylsand perissodactylsin the Upper Eocene Kalakot fauna of India (Ranga Rao, 1971, 1972; Ranga Rao & Obergfell,1973). 92 C. BarryCox The mammalfauna of Africais unknownbefore the Upper Eocene-Lower OligoceneFayum faunas, whichhave recentlybeen discussedby Coryndon& Savage (1973). Though theyare probablyonly very limitedsamples of the total Africanfauna, so that othergroupsmayhave been present,thefactthatthe faunas are dominatedby groups which evolved in Africaand did notreachothercontinentsuntilmuch later, suggeststhat Africa was linked to Europe solely by a sweepstakesroute during this time, probablydue to the presenceof epicontinentalseas Africa. overnorthern rodents Monkey-likeprimatesand hystricognath appeared in both Africaand South America in the Lower Oligocene.The sourceof theSouth American membersof thesetwo groups is stillhotlydebated, Wood (1974) favouringa North American origin, (1973) an African and Lavocat (1974) and Hoffstetter origin.Whicheverwas theircontinentalhomeland, the fact that othergroups fromthat continentdid not accompany them suggestsagain that a sweepstakes route was involved.This could have been a chain of islands, either across the Caribbean or along the Mid-Atlanticridge betweenWest Africa and Brazil. It was not untilthe Upper Pliocene that of a continuousland routeby thefinalestablishment way of the Panama isthmusresultedin a complex patternof extinctionand faunal interchangewith North America,which has been fullydocumented by Simpson(1950). The mammalfauna of Australiais firstknownin the Upper Oligocene-LowerMiocene. The factthat familiesof marit already contained ten different supial stronglysuggeststhat the group had entered Australiaconsiderablyearlier.If thesuggestionmade earlier(page 89) is correct,marsupialswould have reached the Antarctica-Australiacontinentin the Late Cretaceous. It was, however,not until much later that placental mammals were able to enter Australia from Southeast Asia. Rats are the only terrestrialplacentals to have made this journey unaided by man, but theirabsence fromthe Late Pliocene H4amiltonfauna of Victoria, Australia (Turnbull & Lundelius, 1970) suggeststhat their arrivalwas quite late. because thegeographical puzzles.This was primarily unitsused in compilingfaunal listswere,as we can now see, ofteninvalid.The acceptanceof continental drifttheoryprovidesa seriesof datesfortheunionor tectonicplates.It is therefore separationof different essentialforzoogeographersnow to use appropriate palaeogeographicmaps and the appropriatestretch of time duringwhich a particularcontinentalconfigurationwas in existence,when attemptingto analysethe faunas of the past. Such maps show the appropriategeographicunitsforfaunalanalysisand comparison,suggestpossible routesof faunal interchange at specifictimes,and also aid in the identificationof specificissuesof physiologicalor climatic tolerance. stillof course remain, Problemsof interpretation butat leastzoogeographerscan now attemptto solve the real problems(e.g. why didn't placentalsenter Australiafromthe rest of Gondwanaland?) rather than spurious ones (why didn't placentals enter Australia fromAsia ?). Finally, some new typesof queries-and answers-arise. Thus in the past, palaeontologistshave tended to explain all cases involvingthe absence of individual groups from particularareas as merelythe resultof inadequate explorationor sampling.It is now apparentthat,in at leastsomecases,theseabsencesare consistentwith palaeogeographicevidencethatthe area in question was isolatedat thattime,and withtheidea thatfossils have not been found theresimplybecause the animals did not live there. Acknowledgments versionof thispaper was givenat the A preliminary InternationalCongress of Systematicand Evolutionary Biology, Boulder, Colorado, U.S.A., in August 1973. I am pleased to acknowledgehelpful discussions and correspondencewith Drs M.K. Brett-Surman,W.G. Chaloner, A.J. Charig, E.H. Colbert, B.G. Gardiner, Z. Kielan-Jaworowska, M.C. McKenna, R.S. Miles, A.R. Milner and J.H. Ostrom. References and P.D.W. (1973) Mesozoic floras.In: Organisms Time(Ed. by N.F. Hughes).Spec. Pap. through Continents Palaeont.12, 175-187. BOTT, M.H.P. (1973) The evolutionof the Atlanticnorthof Until recently,zoogeography was based on the Driftto of Continental theFaeroe Islands.In: Implications assumptionof static geography.Not surprisingly, the Earth Sciences(Ed. by D.H. Tarlingand S.K. Runanalyses of distributionalpatternsrevealed many corn),Vol. 1, pp. 175-189.AcademicPress,London. Conclusions BARNARD, Vertebrate and continental drift 93 palaeodistributions BRANSON, C.C. (1935) A labyrinthodont fromthe Lower Gondwana of Kashmir and a new edestid from the Permianof the Salt Range. Mem. Conn.Acad. ArtsSci. 9, 19-26. BRIDEN, J.C. (1973) Applicabilityof plate tectonicsto preMesozoic time.Nature,Lond. 244, 400-405. BRIDEN, J.C., MORRIS, W.A. & PIPER, J.D.A. (1973) Palaeomagneticstudiesin theBritishCaledonides-VI. Regional and global implications. Geophys. J. R. astr. Soc. 34, 107-134. BURRETT, C.F. (1972) Plate tectonicsand the Hercynian orogeny.Nature,Lond.239, 155-157. BUTLER, P.M. (1972) The problemof insectivoreclassifica- tion. In: Studies in Vertebrate Evolution(Ed. by K.A. Joyseyand T.S. Kemp), pp. 253-265. Oliver & Boyd, Edinburgh. BUTLER, P.M. & KIELAN-JAWOROWsKA, Z. (1973) Is Deltaa marsupial?Nature,Lond. 245, 105-106. theridium R.M. (1964) Sobre un dinosauriohadrosaurio CASAMIQUELA, de la Argentina.RevtaAssoc.paleont.Argent.3, 285-312. CHALONER,W.G. & LACEY,W.S. (1973) The distribution of Late Palaeozoic floras. In: Organismsand Continents Time(Ed. by N.F. Hughes). Spec. Pap. Palaeont. through 12, 271-289. A.J. CHARIG, (1971) Faunal provinceson land: evidence of fossiltetrapods,withespecial based on the distribution reference to thereptilesof the Permianand Mesozoic. In: Faunal Provincesin Space and Time(Ed. by Middlemiss, Rawson 128. and Newell). Spec. Iss. geol. J. 4, 111- CHARIG, A.J. (1973) Jurassicand Cretaceousdinosaurs.In: Atlas ofPalaeobiogeography (Ed. by A. Hallam), pp. 339- 352. Elsevier, Amsterdam. CHURKIN, M. (1972) Westernboundaryof theNorthAmeri- can continentalplate in Asia. Bull. geol. Soc. Am. 83, 1027-1030. COLBERT,E.H. (1973) Continentaldriftand thedistributions offossilreptiles.In: Implications of Continental Driftto the EarthSciences.(Ed. by D.H. Tarlingand S.K. Runcorn), Vol. 1, pp. 395-412. AcademicPress,London. COLBERT, E.H. (1974) WanderingLands and Animals. Hutchinson, London. CONEY, P.J. (1973) Non-collision tectogenesis in western NorthAmerica.In: Implications of Continental Driftto the Earth Sciences(Ed. by D.H. Tarlingand S.K. Runcorn), Vol. 2, pp. 713-727. AcademicPress,London. CORYNDON, S.C. & SAVAGE,R.J.G. (1973) The originand of Africanmammalfaunas. In: Organismsand affinities Continents Time(Ed. by N.F. Hughes).Spec. Pap. through Palaeont.12, 121-135. Cox, C.B. (1967) Cutaneousrespiration and theoriginof the modernAmphibia.Proc. Linn.Soc. Lond. 178, 37-47. Cox, C.B. (1973a) Triassic tetrapods.In: Atlas of Palaeobiogeography (Ed. by A. Hallam), pp. 213-233. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Cox, C.B. (1973b) The distributionof Triassic terrestrial tetrapodfamilies.In: Implicationsof Continental Driftto theEarthSciences(Ed. byD.H. Tarlingand S.K. Runcorn), Vol. 1, pp. 369-371. Academic Press, London. Cox, C.B. (1973c) Systematicsand plate tectonicsin the spreadofmarsupials.In: Organisms and Continents through Time(Ed. by N.F. Hughes). Spec. Pap. Palaeont.12, 113119. Cox, C.B. (1973d) GondwanalandTriassicStratigraphy. An. Acad. Bras. Cienc.45, 115-119. DALZIEL, I.W.D., KLIGFIELD, R., LOWRIE, W. & OPDYKE, N.D. (1973) Palaeomagneticdata fromthe Southernmost Andes and the Antarctandes.In: Implicationsof ContinentalDriftto theEarthSciences(Ed. by D.H. Tarlingand S.K. Runcorn), Vol. 1, pp. 87-101. Academic Press, London. DEWEY,J.F., PITMAN, W.C., RYAN,W.B.F. & BONNIN,J. (1973) Plate tectonicsand the evolutionof the Alpine System.Biill.geol. Soc. Am. 84, 3137-3180. GARDINER, B.G. & MILES,R.S. (1974) Devonianfishesof the Gogo Formation, Western Australia. Colloqutesnatn. Cent.natn.Rech. scient.In press. HALLAM, A. (1973) Atlas of Palaeobiogeography. Elsevier, Amsterdam. HALSTEAD,L.B. & TURNER, S. (1973) Silurianand Devonian ostracoderms.In: Atlas of Palaeobiogeography (Ed. by A.Hallam), pp. 67-79. Elsevier,Amsterdam. HAMILTON, W. (1970) The Uralides and the motionof the Russian and Siberianplatforms.Bull. geol. Soc. Am. 81, 2553-2576. HOFFSTETTER, R. (1970) L'histoire biogeographiquedes marsupiaux et la dichotomie marsupiaux-placentaires. C. r. hebd.seanc.Acad. Sci., Paris,271, 388-391. HOFFSTETTER, R. (1973) Relationships,originsand history of theceboid monkeysand caviomorphrodents;a modern reinterpretation. Evolut.Biol. 6, 323-347. HUENE,F. VON (1929) Los saurisquiosy ornitisquiosdel CretaceoArgentino.An. Mus. La Plata 3, 1-196. IRVING, E. & BROWN, D.A. (1964) Abundanceand diversity of the labyrinthodonts as a functionof paleolatitude. Am.J. Sci. 262, 689-708. Z. (1974) Migrationsof the MultiKIELAN-JAWOROWSKA, tuberculataand the Late Cretaceousconnectionsbetween Asia and NorthAmerica.Ann.S. Afr.Mus. 64, 231-243. KLERKX,J. & DE PAEPE,P. (1971) Cape Verde Islands: evidencefor a Mesozoic oceanic ridge.Naturephys.Sci. 233, 117-118. KUMMEL,B. (1970) Historyof the Earth. Freeman, San Francisco. KURTEN,B. (1973) EarlyTertiaryland mammals.In: Atlas of Palaeobiogeography (Ed. by A. Hallam), pp. 437-442. Elsevier,Amsterdam. LAVOCAT,R. (1974) What is an hystricomorph rodent? Symp.Zool. Soc. Lond.34, 7-20. LE PICHON,X. & HAYES,D.E. (1971) Marginal offsets, fracture zones and theearlyopeningof theSouthAtlantic. J. geophys.Res. 76, 6283-6293. LILLEGRAVEN, J.A. (1969) Latest Cretaceous mammals of upperpart of EdmontonFormationof Alberta,Canada, and review of marsupial-placental dichotomyin mammalianevolution.Paleont.Contr.Univ.Kans. 50, 1-122. LIu, Y.H. (1965) New Devonian agnathans of Yunnan. Vertebr. palasiat. 9, 130-134. MALFAIT, B.T. & DINKELMAN, M.G. (1972)Circum-Caribbean tectonicand igneous activityand the evolutionof the Caribbeanplate. Bull. geol. Soc. Am. 83, 251-272. McKENNA, M.C. (1973) Sweepstakes,filters,corridors, Noah's arks and beached Vikingfuneralshipsin palaeogeography.In: Implicationsof ContinentalDrift to the EarthSciences(Ed. by D.H. Tarlingand S.K. Runcorn), Vol. 1, pp. 295-308. AcademicPress,London. J.G. (1971) The evolutionof the McKENZIE, D. & SCLATER, Indian Ocean since the Late Cretaceous. Geophys.J.R. astr.Soc. 25, 437-528. W.S. & ZIEGLER, A.M. (1972) Palaeozoic McKERROw, oceans. Naturephys.Sci. 240, 92-94. MILNER, A.R. & PANCHEN, A.L. (1973) Geographicalvariation in the tetrapodfaunas of the Upper Carboniferous and Lower Permian.In: Implications of Continental Drift to the Earth Sciences (Ed. by D.H. Tarling and S.K. Runcorn),Vol. 1, pp. 353-368. AcademicPress,London. MYERS, G.S. (1938) Freshwaterfishes and West Indian zoogeography.Smithson.Rep. 1937, 339-364. PANCHEN, A.L. (1973) Carboniferous tetrapods.In: Atlas of Palaeobiogeography (Ed. by A. Hallam), pp. 117-125. Elsevier, Amsterdam. 94 C. BarryCox PITMAN,W.C. & TALWANI,M. (1972) Sea floorspreadingin the NorthAtlantic.Bull. geol. Soc. Am. 83, 619-643. POWELL, C. McA. & CONAGHAN,P.J. (1973) Plate tectonics and the Himalayas.Earthplan. Sci. Lett. 20, 1-12. PRICE, L. I. (1948) Um anfibiolabirintodonte de Formacao Pedra de Fogo, Estado do Maranhao. Bolm. Div. Geol. Miner.,Bras. 124, 1-32. RANGO RAO,A. (1971) New mammalsfromMurree(Kalakot Zone) of the Himalayan Foot-hills near Kalakot, Jammu & KashmirState,India. J. geol. Soc. India, 12, 125-134. RANGORAO,A. (1972) New mammaliangeneraand species from the Kalakot Zone of Himalayan Foothills near Kalakot, Jammu& KashmirState,India. Spec. Pap. Dir. Oil nat. Gas Comm.India,1, 1-22. RANGO RAO, A. & OBERGFELL, F. A. (1973) Hyrachyus asiaticus,new speciesof an Upper Eocene tapiroid(Mammalia, Perissodactyla)from Kalakot, India. Spec. Pap. Dir. Oil nat. Gas. Comm.India 3, 1-8. RAVEN, P.M. & AXELROD, D.I. (1972) Plate tectonics and Australasianpaleobiogeography. Science,176, 1379-1386. RAVEN,P.M. & AXELROD, D.I. (1974) Angiospermbiogeographyand past continental movements. Ann.Mo. bot.Gdn. 61 (in press). RITCHIE,A. (1968)New evidenceon Janoytius kerwoodi White, an important fromtheSilurianof Lanarkshire, ostracoderm Scotland.Palaeontology, 11, 21-39. RODGERS,J. (1967) Chronology of tectonic movements in the Appalachianregionof easternNorthAmerica.Am.J. Sci. 265, 408-427. ROMER, A.S. (1973) Permianreptiles.In: Atlas of Palaeobiogeography (Ed. by A.Hallam), pp. 150-167. Elsevier, Amsterdam. RUSSELL, D.A. (1972) Ostrich dinosaurs from the Late peruviennes).C. r. hebd. seanc. Acad. Sci., Paris, 267, 1495-1498. SIGE, B. (1972) La faunule de mammiferesdu Cretace superieurde Laguna Umayo (Andes peruviennes).Bull. Mus. natn.Hist. nat.,Paris, 99, 375-409. G.G. (1940) Mammalsand land bridges.J. Wash. SIMPSON, Acad. Sci. 30, 137-163. SIMPSON, G.G. (1950) Historyof thefaunaof LatinAmerica. Am. Scient.38, 361-389. SMILEY,C.J. (1972) Plantmegafossilsequences,NorthSlope Cretaceous.Geoscienceand Man, 4, 91-99. SMITH,A.G., BRIDEN,J.C. & DREWRY, G.E. (1973) Phanero- zoic world maps. In: Organismsand Continents through Time(Ed. by N.F. Hughes).Spec. Pap. Palaeont.12, 1-47. SZALAY, F.S. & McKENNA,M.C. (1971) Beginningoftheage of mammalsin Asia: the Late Paleocene Gashato fauna, Mongolia. Bull. Am. Mus. nat. Hist. 144, 273-317. TATARINOV, L.P. (1973) Cynodontsof Gondwanatypein the Middle Triassicof the U.S.S.R. Pal. Zh. 7, 83-89. TEWARI, A.P. (1962) A newspeciesofArchegosaurus fromthe Lower Gondwana of Kashmir.Rec. geol. Surv.India, 89, 427-434. THOMSON, K.S. (1969) The biologyof the lobe-finned fishes. Biol. Rev. 44, 91-154. TURNBULL, W.D. & LUNDELIUS, E.L. (1970) The Hamilton fauna,a Late PliocenemammalianfaunafromtheGrange Burn,Victoria,Australia.FieldianaGeol.19, 1-163. VERMA,K.K. (1962) Chelydosaurus n. sp., a marahomensis newfossillabyrinthodont fromtheLower Gondwananear Maharom,AnantnagDistrict,Kashmir.Indian Minerals, 16, 180-182. WADIA,D.N. & SWINTON, W.E. (1928) Actinodonrisinensis n.sp. in the Lower Gondwana of Vihi District,Kashmir. Rec. geol. Surv.India, 61, 141-145. WARREN, J.W. & WAKEFIELD, N.A. (1972) Trackwaysof tetrapodvertebratesfromthe Upper Devonian of Victoria,Australia.Nature,Lond. 238, 469-470. WEISSEL,J.K. & HAYES,D.E. (1971) Asymmetric seafloor Cretaceousof WesternCanada. Can. J. EarthSci. 9, 375402. of dinosaursand its RUSSELL, L.S. (1965) Body temperature J.Pal. 39, 497-501. to theirextinction. relationships of the SCHMALHAUSEN,I.I. (1957) Biological fundamentals spreading south of Australia. Nature, Lond. 231, 518-522. Izv. Akad. Nauk. S.S.S.R., originof terrestrial vertebrates. WOOD,A.E. (1974) The evolutionof Old World and New Biol. 1, 3-30. Worldhystricomorphs. Symp.zool. Soc. Lond. 34, 21-54. SCLATER,J.G. & McKENZIE, D.P. (1973) Paleobathymetry WOODWARD, A.S. (1905) Permo-Carboniferous plants and of the South Atlantic.Bull. geol. Soc. Am. 84, 3203-3216. vertebrates from Kashmir II. Fishes and labyrinthodonts. SIGE, B. (1968) Dents de micromammifRreset fragmentsde Mem. geol. Surv.IndiaPalaeont.indica.2, 10-13. coquilles d'oeufsde dinosauriensdans la faunede vert&- YOUNG, C.-C. (1974) A new genus of Traversodontidae in Jiyuan,Honan. Vertebr. palasiat. 12, 203-211. bres du Cretace superieurde Laguno Umayo (Andes
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz