Historic Shoreline Changes in Southwest Florida Emmett R. Foster, P.E. and Rebecca J. Savage ------------------------------------------------------------Notes Added To The WEB Copy , 3/04/97, by E.F. : 1) This paper Proceedings of was published the Sixth Management, 1989, Vol. 5, American Society of Civil to place this copy on in Coastal Symposium on pp. 4420-4433, Zone '89, the Coastal and Ocean published by Engineers, N.Y., USA. the Permission the FDEP/BBCS WEB site was granted by ASCE in January 1997. 2) The agency Environmental Systems. name is Protection, now Office Florida of Department Beaches and of Coastal The author's e-mail address is as follows : [email protected] 3) The the opinions expressed (as of jan. 2000). in this paper are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the FDEP. 4) The conditions in this area have not remained static. particular, there have been major renourishment In projects on Anna Maria Key, Longboat Key, Venice, and possibly Lido Key. A smaller renourishment project occurred on Knight Island Charlotte County, in Pass ebb shoals. the erosion pocket Several south of the Stump groinfields on Anna Maria Key Longboat Key were removed prior to the filling. in Erosion and has spread southward in the pocket beach south of Point of Rocks, in Sarasota County. 4) The figures for the ASCII text version have been enclosed in the zipped total file as separate bitmap files, which can viewed and Wordperfect, printed via Adobe, etc. many software The intent products, was to be e.g., produce a document for general informational purposes which can be read independent of any particular software. ------------------------------------------------------------- Abstract An overview of the results of an analysis of historic shoreline changes in three adjacent southwest Florida coastal counties coastal is presented. survey maps and The data Florida set includes historic Department of Natural Resources beach profile surveys. findings is that the part of this region and underlying One of the more interesting shoreline configuration in the is strongly influenced by limestone topography. The central the nearshore areas of concern from an erosion viewpoint are those locations where there a deficit of sand supply sand transport. too close to in a wave climate of net southerly In many areas, structures were simply the beach to allow will depend upon a built for normal beach width fluctuations or gradual shoreline evolution. management plans is Effective beach basic understanding of the coastal processes as developed in these studies. Introduction The subject area encompasses three adjacent southwest Florida counties bordering the Gulf of Mexico. Figure 1 shows the coast of Manatee County, consisting of Anna Maria Key and the north portion of Longboat Key. Figure 2 shows the coast of Sarasota County, which includes the southern part of Longboat Key, all of Lido Key, Siesta Key, Casey Key, the Venice area, and most of Manasota Key. Coastal Charlotte County is shown in Figure 3 and consists of the southern end of Manasota Key, Knight Island, and the northern portion of Gasparilla Island. The sands along this semi-tropical coast generally consist of varying mixtures of quartz and shell. In an analysis of historic shoreline changes, it is generally useful to have a both the wave large reliable data base, climate and geology understanding of the and to examine of the subject coastal features area. which characteristic of the area can then be developed and An are applied both in an overall and site by site review. Data Set and Methods of Analysis These items article in are discussed this However, a brief in detail publication: in Foster review is warranted an accompanying and Savage (1989). to help visualize how the results were obtained. In essence, all the historic coastal topographic survey of the area National (USGS), by the U.S. Ocean have Survey been standardized scale done by contract the (NOS), carefully at U.S. digitized Florida Florida Geodetic Survey (USC&GS), and and coordinate researchers with Coast & maps Geologic Survey and systems. State compared on This work was University under Department of Natural Resources (DNR). The DNR coastal survey monument and beach profile set was used as a shoreline sampling 1000 feet (300 meter) spacing. pattern with DNR beach profile survey data from 1972 to 1988 were added to the data sets. a set of computer-generated approximate composite maps The result is showing all the digitized shorelines, and tabulated data sets of quantitative changes along profile bearings from the 1850's to 1988. shoreline changes are all relative to the location The of the approximate Mean High Water (MHW) contour. In the subject reaches area, the data according to the were divided into location significant littoral boundaries. longshore sequences changes were of not at of inlets geographic or other It was readily observed distance/time all constant in plots that shoreline over time in many areas. With the large amount of data, it became possible to identify basic long-term coastal processes at work within the of shoreline changes. pattern Historic and recent aerial photography sets were used for qualitative verification of the timing and conditions shown vegetation, dune patterns, as nearshore rock in the ridge, well as survey overwash, for features. maps, and for studying wave the refraction locating coastal structures and Field observations present beach conditions and processes. were made of Historic bathymetric surveys were qualitative offshore also digitized, comparison profile at surveys shapes and bottom features the beach. but this were have been used only for time. Soundings from DNR used to investigate profile within 3000 feet (900 A literature review meters) of of previous studies of the areas was also conducted in order to compare the results conclusions. Previous studies include and those by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (1977, 1979, and 1984). Weather and Wave Climate The shoreline changes and evolving shoreline orientations the subject area over the last 100 years are extremely consistent with net southerly littoral transport. wave data U.S. from the Army Corps Experiment Station (1988) for as the personal observations since 1972, confirm that Hindcast of Engineers Waterway the period 1956-1975, as of one of the higher energy the southeasterly passage cold fronts across the southern states. well authors (Foster) waves generally approach from the northwest during the winter season. waves result from in The NW of a series A discussion of of the cold front pattern has been given by Rosendal (1965). Summer waves are typically lower energy, high frequency, wind waves and lower frequency swell from the southwest. wave energy coast in general, with height of 0.8 meters, and there coastal shelf. Nevertheless, higher energy NW geology and the wave a mean significant is a very in this pattern, This is a as low wave wide and shallow area the prevailing modified by the local occasional tropical storm, was found to be the primary force controlling shoreline changes over the last 100 years. It is noted that there are indications in the data littoral drift reversals other occurred, the but randomly and surveys and unevenly spaced future, more frequent than seasonal that net have probably aerial photography are too to prove this point. monitoring of beach In the conditions should help to verify how and when this process occurs. The tropical storm season extends from June to November. These storms can affect the shoreline in many ways on the path, speed, Lists of intensity, and frequency of historic tropical storms have depending occurrence. been generated from Neumann, et.al (1981), the Mariner's Weather Log of the Dept. of studies. past are Commerce (1981-1988), The effects difficult as of any storm of to determine well U.S. as from previous set of storms in with accuracy. the However, there is occasionally shoreline change should be with a noted. photographic a strong storm or There records lower Florida transport of are linking break-throughs or washouts that a tropical correspondence set of sand to storms, and major changes to certain storms. coast major this also occasional written and storm following a Gulf of It is noted northward path along could the north, such as inlet the theoretically cause a net due to the more organized wind field in the northeast quadrant. Discussion of Geology It is well founded on known that limestone, the Florida including the peninsula is largely coastal shelf on the Gulf, as discussed by White (1970) and Hine, et.al. (1985). It is coastal perhaps not so well island group is strongly known that the subject influenced and possibly founded in part on limestone and beachrock outcroppings. This coast pocket contains beaches, as a can sequence be of inlets, headlands, and seen in Figures 1 thru 3. The coastal islands extend northwest and southeast of a area which directly fronts the Gulf. mainland This is the Venice area of Sarasota County, which is a geologically complex headland feature and peat having stratifications, several readily limestone offshore bathymetry, and quartz, shell, heavy observable outcrops, extremely dark colored beach minerals, sand and irregular sand containing fossils (e.g. shark teeth). In addition to the there are sequences somewhat centralized Venice headland, of major and minor headlands along the coastal islands to either side which are apparently based on high spots in the topography of the underlying limestone and superficial beachrock formations. Beachrock is defined here as a composite of cemented layers of sand and/or shell. The limestone varies in composition mixture of mud, sand, and but is generally a hardened shell, at least in nearshore grab samples obtained by the authors and as described by Gould and Stewart (1956). The formations is unknown. thickness and true extent of the However, the report of the U.S. Corps of Engineers for Sarasota County (1984) contains a of minimum area sediment depth (Plate 1 of that extrapolated landward, and Manasota formations Key may be contours in report). These intersect with major headlands. related as a the offshore This group map county contours, the Longboat, Army when Casey, suggests the and that there is considerable regional extent. In Manatee County to the north, there are also three known nearshore rock exposures of significant size along the Further north, formation in southern half of Anna there is roughly the a massive same Maria Key. offshore alignment limestone off the central Pinellas County coast, related to the Indian Rocks as discussed by Evans, et.al. headland, (1985), and Winston, et.al. (1968). The few available geologic opinions between Miocene and Pleistocene the limestone, e.g. as the age(s) of (1985), The Pinellas County feature is reported to be Miocene per Evans, et.al. which appears cover probably origin for Gould and Stewart (1956), Bland and Campbell (1985). to appear to be divided Pleistocene, the (1985). limestone particularly at The in beachrock, some areas, is Point of Rocks on Siesta Key, per Puri and Vernon (1964). It is observed that several known past and present inlets are located in close suggested that proximity the inlets to may have areas of the limestone topography. hydraulically stable as a natural jetty effects. natural headlands. formed in It is weak or low Such inlets could be more result of less resistance and/or These findings suggest the A systematic seismic need for more geologic and core beach, islands, and offshore research. sampling program along the is suggested to accurately map the underlying formations. Characteristic Coastal Features It is important headlands are to understand that subject to level storm events, and the upland areas severe erosion during high most have consequently been armored by property owners with seawalls, revetments, groinfields to protect protection offered by on the the upland property. the underlying rock water heavily and/or The amount of depends primarily on the elevation of the rock layer and the longshore/offshore extent of the formation. The post-storm recovery of the beach in these areas depends a great deal on the availability of sand to resupply that moved off the site. Very little sand may be available from offshore due to a hard bottom, and the longshore sufficient, sand supply depending on may or site may not specific be available conditions. or The heavily armored limestone associated headlands in the subject area are the following, from north to south: three locations along central and southern Anna Maria Key; the Longboat Key headland; Point of Rocks; the Casey Key headland; the headland; the Manasota Key major headland; and the County Line minor headland. The headlands are Venice Charlotte labeled in Figures 1 thru 3. It has also been observed that sand often moves in masses or "slugs", up to 10000 feet (3000 meters) in within between the headlands apparently aerial larger in pocket and inlets. response photographs to suggest fluid traveling back beaches between The similarity in beach width, on the order of 150 energy. The to a highly viscous a bowl. result in significant headlands, and wave also occasionally move across the headlands. in general can length, movement is slow but directional and forth in large The sand masses This phenomena short-term variability feet (50 meters). The large pockets which exhibit this phenomena are the following: between the Casey Key headland and Venice inlet; between Venice headland and the Manasota Key the headland; between the latter and the Charlotte County Line minor headland; and from the latter to Stump Pass. The remaining bulbous-shaped major features to be accretion/fluctuation discussed areas are located the on the south sides of the unstabilized inlets. These areas developed for several reasons: the large ebb tidal shoals on the south shelter the side of the inlets energy wave activity except the shoals areas from during high water level occasionally merge onto the high storms; shoreline; and shoals can refract or bend waves such that sand transport generally directed into seasons. the area from the south during the is all Frequent and random shoal re-orientations result in extremely unstable beaches in these areas. Anna Maria Key, Island, and Longboat Key, Lido Gasparilla Island The north ends of Key, Siesta Key, are all Knight typical cases. north sides of the inlets are equally or more unstable The since they are protected by lesser shoals. A Brief Tour Some of the more will now be interesting site specific beach described, working from conditions north to south through the area. Anna Maria Key has a highly fluctuating, north bulbous shaped area. Due to the potentially tremendous hurricane surge volume which can pass to and from Tampa Bay, the north end of Anna Maria away, as Key is particularly vulnerable happened during a hurricane to being in 1921. washed The north central zone appears to be somewhat protected and supplied by the massive offshore shoals, and the beach width has fluctuated depending on the shoal and storm conditions. There are three nearshore limestone features and southern Anna Maria Key. south of a the 1920's ft/yr (less than 1 m/yr). been This section of the refraction nodal zone retreating since obscured by the along central island is and has historically at an approximate rate been of 1-3 An estimate of just how fast construction of a has near continuous mixture of seawalls, revetments, and groinfields starting the 1950's with major development of the the same time southernmost stabilized with a terminal groin the island. end of the At about island and a groinfield. If was left alone, the shoreline would have been expected to continue evolve in a curved orientation to face the in to northwest waves, with some anchoring by the rock outcrops. Ground level photographs from the 1950's and 1960's show essentially the same conditions as the present in that a mix of coastal pockets. structures with It appears no beach that buildings area: except in minor and roads were simply built on lots too close to and perhaps water from the very beginning. remain: continuing storm even out into the The costs of the construction damage, perpetual structural repairs, and no recreational beach. At Longboat Pass, dredging for rearranged the shoals and added navigation purposes sand to the north and has south shores. This pass was also washed out by storms in the early 1960's. The inlet has migrated northward over time, structures built on the previous leaving bulbous area exposed to major erosion and storm damage. Continuing with Longboat Key, there is a small, high erosion pocket immediately south of the armored area, followed longer, to The relatively Longboat approximately stable Key at major the mildly eroding pocket beach. headland Manatee/Sarasota appears to begin County Line. This shoreline contains many groinfields and seawalls during and since the 1960's. area was heavily eroding by a constructed However, it does not appear the before or after the armoring. Erosion rates have been on the order of 0-1 ft/yr (0-0.5 m). South of the headland there is a continuing shoreline retreat towards New Pass, at approximately 2-3 ft/yr (0.5-1 m), indicating a sand deficit exists across the headland. It is noted that Longboat Key is actually composed of two islands which were once separated previous by an inlet (prior to the 1883 survey) adjacent to the most prominent rock outcroppings on the headland. Lido Key is unique in that shoreline which was constructed between a set of small it has an entirely man-made in the 1920's by islands. There filling in have been six renourishment projects to maintain the beaches on the heavily developed island from 1964 to 1987, totaling approximately 1.4 M cubic yards (1.1 M cubic meters). building at both ends over time, The shoals have been modifying the wave refraction pattern and resulting in accretion at both ends of the shoreline. There is a historic erosion "hot spot" south of the northern shoals. the refracted wave pattern Aerial photography shows tends to remove sand just that from this area without replacement. Continuing southward, it is of interest to note that pre-development 1948 aerial photographs of Siesta Key show pattern of seaward tending accretionary dune ridges, on this coast system. Key by of the south side of an on the shoals, and typical extremely large pass Big Sarasota Pass has been pressured against wave action a Siesta the shoal-protected north point is not a stable landform. continuous along the channel Armoring is heavy and northernmost point. large pocket beach between the armored north point and of Rocks has historically stable in recent years. been tends to align itself to The Point accreting, and relatively The only obvious source of supply is the ebb shoal system. and present The beach within this pocket face directional wave energy, seasonal or otherwise. From Point of County, there similar and Rocks is essentially relatively headlands. The same each cell. The problem is generally true For southward example, stable a repetitive series of very pocket beaches and armored basic processes occur along road and within of structures built too far all along the the to Stump Pass in Charlotte along major and minor the Casey seaward headlands. Key headland has repeatedly washed out since the 1930's. It is noted that Midnight Pass has existed within the between Point of Rocks and the caused highly fluctuating beach the inlet. and has widths in areas adjacent to The channel extended as far northward as Point of Rocks in 1883. relocate Casey Key headland, pocket the The inlet closed in 1983 during an attempt to unstable channel away from some threatened residential structures. A more complex headland exists at (0.5-1 m) Venice, range. jetties have very with little significant erosion rates At Venice been in have acted as and a generally Inlet on place and in the 1-3 ft/yr the north repaired since effective littoral barriers. maintenance developed to the dredging, south along the a problem side, the 1937-8, and There has been net sand deficit has Venice headland, and sand has accreted against the north jetty. The previously described moving sand mass phenomena appears to be the dominant cause of major beach width changes in sequence of three large pocket beaches the extending southward from Venice into Charlotte County. It is noted that an existed prior to 1883 inlet known as Old Blind Pass once immediately south of the Manasota Key major headland. In the southern end of our subject area, in Charlotte County south of Stump Pass, there is an unusual island which will be referred to here as Knight Island. composite of three recent islands : It is actually a Knight, Don Pedro, and Little Gasparilla Islands. This island and the immediately north of and including Stump Pass are area distinctly different from the coastal islands to the north in that there are no apparent stabilizing many major multiple shoreline inlets and rock features. changes in by more landward, storms, such as This area is located at the end of a long southward littoral transport system. of have been this vicinity, including rearrangements occurred in the 1950's. There older islands. There are portions It is also transitional zone between two distinct shoreline in a alignments. To the south, Gasparilla and a successive chain of islands in Lee County orientation. have a significantly closer to north-south Gasparilla Island also has extensive nearshore beachrock outcroppings along its' central and southern in apparent alignment with the new half, general island chain orientation. Knight Island has a bulbous-shaped, highly fluctuating north end adjacent to Stump Pass, followed by a refraction- caused erosion pocket. The remainder retreating toward the south Bulges in the shoreline being smoothed out. beaches on both of the and the Gasparilla Pass due to prior inlets There are fluctuating, sides of island is slowly Gasparilla shoals. are gradually shoal-influenced Pass. A large, bulbous-shaped beach exists on the north tip of Gasparilla Island, followed by a relatively stable, shoal- supplied zone extending into Lee County. The processes and Gasparilla Island, although the presently incomplete, conditions on analysis for that island appear very similar to is those of Anna Maria Key at the very opposite end of the subject area. It can be said that, in the entire subject area, erosion occurs in general at any net sand supply deficit either littoral barrier cases are or a location where there due to a natural or wave refraction the following: significant the pattern. southern half man-made The worst of Anna Maria Key; the armored area just south of Longboat Pass; the half of Longboat immediately south Key; of the Point middle of of is a south Lido Key; the area Rocks; and the Venice area south of Venice Inlet. Conclusions The Gulf coast of in southwest Manatee, Sarasota, and Charlotte Florida beaches, and headlands. be a direct result contains a Counties series of inlets, pocket Historic shoreline changes appear to of long-term net southerly transport, as modified by geologic features and tropical storms. There are erosion problems in areas lacking adequate sand supply due to littoral barriers refraction effects (man-made around shoal or natural) systems. and/or In many wave problem areas, residential structures were simply built too close the active beach fluctuations or the The armored to allow for natural gradual pattern of natural headlands will beach to width shoreline evolution. continue to be very vulnerable to storm damage, although the mean high water line tends to recover in the long term if there is available supply. Areas adjacent to unstabilized inlets will to experience large scale beach width sand continue fluctuations due random changes in the offshore shoals and storm attack. larger pocket beaches beach width can experience significant variability due to the movement of to The short-term large sand masses within the bowl-shaped pockets and occasionally across the boundary headlands. With the large and growing amount of coastal for this is now area, it coastal processes possible to occurring at a local data available recognize the major and regional level, and to use this information for making better management regulatory decisions. and References Bland, M.J., 1985. "Holocene Sarasota Bay, Florida", Geologic History of Little unpublished M.S. thesis, Department of Geology, University of South Florida, Tampa, Florida. Campbell, K.M., 1985. "Geology of Sarasota County, Florida", Open File Report #10, Florida Geological Survey, Tallahassee, Florida. Evans, M.W., Hine, A.C., 1985. "Bedrock West-Central Belknap, D.F. and Davis Controls Florida on Coast", Barrier Marine Jr., R.A., Island Development: Geology, 63, pp. 263- 283. Foster, E.R. and Savage, R.J., 1989. Shoreline Analysis", Coastal Zone "Methods of Historical '89, American Society of Civil Engineers, New York, N.Y. Gould, H.R. Sediments in and Stewart, R.H., 1956. the Northeastern Gulf of "Continental Terrace Mexico", in "Finding Ancient Shorelines", edited by Hough, J.L. and Menard, SEPM Special Publication No. 3, 1956, H.W., Tulsa, Oklahoma, pp. 2-20. Hine, A.C., Evans, Belknap, D.F., M.W., Sedimentary Coastline: Barrier 1985. "General Processes of the and edited by Geologic Background Coast", in "Geology of Marsh-Dominated Davis, Hutton, J.G., and and Open Marine, Marsh-Dominated West-Central Florida Island Florida", Osking, E.B., R.A., Coast, the West-Central Hine, A.C. and Belknap, D.F., University of South Florida, Tampa, Florida. Neumann, 1981. C.J., Cry, "Tropical G.W., Cyclones Caso, of E.L. and Jarvinen, B.R., the North Atlantic Ocean, 1871-1980", National Climatic Center, NOAA, Asheville, North Carolina. Puri, H.S. and Vernon, R.O., of Florida and a Guide 1964. Book to "Summary of the Geology the Classic Exposures", Florida Geological Survey, Special Publication No. 5. Rosendal, H.E., 1965. "Northers of the Gulf of Mexico and Central American Waters", Mariner's Weather Log, Vol. 9, 6, Nov., Weather Bureau, U.S. Washington, D.C., pp. 186-188. Department No. of Commerce, U.S. Army Corps "Feasibility of Engineers, Jacksonville District, Report for Beach Erosion 1977. Control, Charlotte County Beaches, Florida", Jacksonville, Fla. U.S. Army Corps "Manatee County, of Engineers, Jacksonville District, Beach Erosion Control Project, U.S. 1979. Army General Design Memorandum", Jacksonville, Fla. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Jacksonville District, "Beach Erosion Control Study for Sarasota 1984. County, Florida", Jacksonville, Fla. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Waterways Experiment 1988. Station, Preliminary Gulf Coast Hindcast Wave Data for 1956- 75 (unpublished), Vicksburg, Miss. U.S. Department of Commerce, "Mariner's Weather January Issues 1981 to 1988, North Atlantic Tropical Annual Reports, Weather Bureau and Log", Cyclone Environmental Data Service, Washington D.C. White, W.A., 1970. "Geomorphology of the Florida Peninsula", Florida Bureau of Geology Bulletin #51, Tallahassee, Florida. Winston, R.H., D., 1968. Riggs, S.R., "Geologic O'Conner, Evaluation M.P. and Breuninger, of Coastal Petroleum Company's Offshore Lease from the Honeymoon Island Area South to Blind Pass, Pinellas County, Florida", Company, Tallahassee, Florida. Coastal Petroleum
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz