Three Varieties of Causal Overdetermination

!
"
!
#
!
$
%
&
#
'
(
&
)
*
!
&
+
!
,
-
.
.
&
&
'
/
1
0
3
4
#
5
1
2
!6
3
&
-
-
!
'
!
&
7
4
*
!
*
,8
%
*
&
.
)
*
*
%
*
2
%
*
'
'
4
4
%
*
4
"
5
"5!
9
"
,4
2
%
:
"
"5
"5
;
&
'
7
*
!
4
'
7
&
% "5
'
<
'
'
9
$
'
%
7
=
*
=
*
2
'
/'
1 %
"
*
2
0
>
3
#
&
-
&
'
7
2
)
7
"
"
?
#
"
=
3
.
/
#
4
@
0
!5
-
*
)
9
'
*
'
7
*
!
'
#
*
%
%
8
"
'
'
'
.
%
*
"
.
2
A
'
7
7
5
&
#
7
"
7
9
-
"
7
'
7
7
"
)
!
!2
C
B6!
"
&
2
!
'
.
6
9
&
-
2
7
"
#
!
!
"
>
!
"
/
'
'
=
5
2
3
7
0
3
.
'
-
#
3
$
#
3
3
9
'
D&
"
$
%$
3
% $
%
%
$
6
3
%
E
/
0&
'
9
#
8
#
3
&
%
&
' (
)
6
'
(F
3
9
&
/
0 '
((
7
'
&
&
'
=
"
(+
)
"
*
7
4
4
!
% "5
9
,"
&
-
'
#
9
'
'
3
/
-
0
'
*
'
4
!
9
!
"
4
% "5&"5
4
"
/
0
G
H
*
(1
*
#
10
H
!
H %
*
H
*
(:
H
*
H
>
'
*
7
3
.
*
!
7
* *
* *
3
.
* *
'
/
0
/
!
*
0
'
%
*
B
3
'
H %
*
'
11
*
#
'
9
7
!(;
6
7
'
!
7
/
"
/
0
0
*
!#
!
'
*
'
9
/
0
6
*
12
%
'
'
!
4)"
7
'
>!
3
!
!
2
7
(! 2
'
4
&
#
+! 2
'
*
'
&
,B
13
'
1!
'
'
9
'
9
*
3
*+
,
-
)
'
*+
,
3
@
*
@'
3
G
9
!
H !>
14
.
9
9 7
%
!I
J
33
#
-'
H
%
%
!
(<
33
/
&
0'
&
=
7
*
*
'
*
'
7
#
#
*
3
"
6
%/
0
.
3
15
*
6
"
>
"
K
3
3
B
33
L
(?
6
9
(
+
"
M
>
5
1
>
(A
>
'
/
0
)
3
(C
#
*
.
*
%
16
,
+F
H
&
6
%
'
&
%
"
/
0
"
"
>/
0
1
&
*
/
0
*
/
'
!
'
*
7
=
7
*
7
=
7
#
17
*
-
&
*
#
*
!
*
9
"
B
(C<F%
+(
*
D
D
)
*
3
&
*
2
*
*
"
4 7
7
7
7
=
7
=
7
,2
.
=
/
0
-
7
'
4
D%
,2
2
3 G
AF
/.0
CF
A: ;<N
/.0 4
18
G
%
2
3
,
24 56
,
'
%
*
*
7
#
'
*
*
4
8
B
7
0++ '
/
8
#
#
5
+1
9
6
7
9
4
7
8
7
19
5
%
%
"
#
7
L
L
'
+:
L
%
9
2
.
'
'
7
.
7
#
&
/
0
20
'
&
2
/
0
&
9
"
.
'
/
4
#
-
B
O
21
0
+;
#$%$
(
#
$
%
#
E
%
!
G# 5
!9
!
/
$
+
0
%
%
"
$
%$
%
'
*
*
#
-
*
*
*
1
"
)
L
)L>2
/5
O
B
5
87
+FF(!
3
G
9
'
H
/5
B
OH>
/
0
*
#
0
O
M
22
(F( )
B
+ "
(CC1!K#
(CC+!+:;*+AFK)
L
5
/'
L
)L>2
:
4
5
O
)
5
0
6
"
5
.
)
:1 (CAF!1;(*<?K'
)L>2
#
)L>2
/'
/
O
B
"
/2
9
-
/5
"
5 8
L
9
#
1 (CAC!:?*?<K
H
"
:+ (CA+!;C*<:K
09
*
G
L
(CAF!
>'
*
)
(CA+!
7
"
E
: %
0
B
;
<
B
/5
O
0
P
0
5
G
)
9
(CC1!(C*;F
B
8" B
&
;
&
#
/"
0
+FFF!+1;*+;<
*
?
A
5
. 3
/
2
0;
(C?C!
*
(1:*(;F
C
4
/B
B
(F
8
$
%0*
*
<
&& )
L
)L>2
(CA<!(C<*(CC
)
$
%
$
23
%
O
((
6
2
2
(+
0;
#
9
)
9
9
/'
)
5
H
)
=.
L
% /6
B
>" B
C=(F +FF(!
)
9
*6
%'
(*1:
)L>9
.
5
0 /
/$
4
B
>4 E
0
#
5">'
.
-
H
/
5 'B
'
)
%
(CC+! H
%
(:
5
E
((
#
.
2
)
)
(C<(!
(1
6
M
*
(CCA!
/'
)
*6
%'
5
0
(;
=
.
5 8
#
(<
/
G
%
/
9
.
H
(CC+
"
" '
'
#
0
L
0*
*
==
(CC?!(<(
>" 4
.
5
0)
+( : G (CA?!+;
(A
+A
#
G
O
+F
># "
6
>
(C
#
)
(?
6
.
/#
% /'
5
H
/
9
B
'
"
9
"
(C?;!
#
0 9
24
/
.
>
+(
9
B
= )
L
/2 B
0/
)L>
O
,0/
)
L
5
0
'
E
0 *
+1
#
5
*
/4
(*
.
/
,
*
.
#
/
G
H
.
<
8
E
/8
4
E
(CCA!
(CC:!:+F "
<
*
>)
(CCF!(;;*(<+K4
*
(CC:!K
7
,
B
)
/
(C?;!1(1 '
(
O
5">.
++
B
/
)L>
6
/
8
%/
&& ++1*++:
2
0#
"
M
(F(
(CC;!:+*<+
+:
'
)
+;
/5
0
+ (CC+!+:;*+AF
'
6
M
E
25
*
#
>