Binding of Aromatic Isocyanides on Gold Nanoparticle Surfaces Investigated by Surface-Enhanced Raman Scattering SANG-W OO JOO,* W AN-JOONG KIM , WAN SOO YUN, SUNGU HWANG, and INSUNG S. CHOI Department of Chemistry, Soongsil University, Seoul 156-743, Korea (S.-W.J.); Department of Chemistry and School of Molecular Science (BK21), Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST), Daejeon 305-701, Korea (W.-J.K., I.S.C.); Electronic Device Group, Korea Research Institute of Standards and Science, Daejeon 305-600, Korea (W.S.Y.); and School of Free Major, Miryang National University, Miryang, Gyeongnam 627-702, Korea (S.H.) The adsorption structure and binding of phenyl isocyanide (PNC), 2,6-dimethyl phenyl isocyanide (DM PNC), and benzyl isocyanide (BZI) on gold nanoparticle surfaces have been studied by means of surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS). PNC, DM PNC, and BZI have been found to adsorb on gold assuming a standing geometry with respect to the surfaces. The presence of the n(CH) band in the SERS spectra denotes a vertical orientation of the phenyl ring of PNC, DMPNC, and BZI on Au. The lack of a substantial red shift and signi cant band broadening of the ring breathing modes implied that a direct ring p orbital interaction with metal substrates should be quite low. For PNC, the band ascribed to the C–NC stretch ing vibration was found to almost disappear after adsorption on Au. On the other hand, the C–NC band rem ained quite strong for DMPNC after adsorption. This result suggests a rather bent angle of C–N[C: for the nitrogen atom of the NC binding group on the surfaces, whereas a linear angle of C–N[C: should be more favorable on gold surfaces due to an intramolecular steric hindrance of its two methyl groups. SERS of BZI on gold nanopaticles also supports a bent angle of :C[N–CH 2 for its nitrogen atom, suggesting a preference of sp 3 (or sp 2 ) hybridization for the nitrogen atom. Index Headings: Phenyl isocyanide; 2,6-Dimethyl phenyl isocyanide; Benzyl isocyanide; Au; Adsorption; Surface-enhanced Raman scattering; SERS. INT RODUCTIO N In a theoretical work on self-assembled monolayers (SAM s) of alkanethiolates on Au surfaces, sp 3 hybridization for the sulfur atom on the three-fold hollow sites was predicted to be energetically most stable.1 Aromatic thiols such as benzyl mercaptan and p-biphenylmethanethiol were reported to form closely packed and highly ordered monolayers on gold while a lower surface coverage was form ed for thiophenol and p-biphenylthiol. 2 The C–Se bond of benzeneselenolate also appeared to be rather parallel to the surface as indicated by a decrease in its Raman intensity upon adsorption on Au.3 Although the structure and binding of thiolates have been studied extensively by microscopic and spectroscopic tools,4 relatively little is known about the adsorption structures of aryl isocyanides. There have been several reports exploring the chemisorption of organoisocyanides on metal surfaces.5–8 We recently reported dissimilar adsorption orientations of p-biphenylisocyanide Received 6 May 2003; accepted 13 October 2003. * Author to whom correspondence should be sent. E-mail: sjoo@ssu. ac.kr. 218 Volume 58, Number 2, 2004 on gold and silver nanoparticle surfaces. 9 The detailed origins of its different adsorption characteristics on Ag and Au have not been fully clari ed. The phenomenon of surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) has become one of the most sensitive techniques in monitoring adsorbates on metal substrates at the submonolayer coverage limit.10,11 In order to further investigate interfacial structure and binding of self-assembly m onolayers prepared by aryl isocyanide, we performed a SERS study of phenyl isocyanide (PNC), 2,6dimethyl phenyl isocyanide (DMPNC), and benzyl isocyanide (BZI) on Au nanoparticle surfaces. DM PNC has two methyl groups that m ay affect the orientation upon adsorption on surfaces. The main purpose of this study is to investigate different binding structures of arom atic isocyanides on Au in uenced by an intramolecular steric hindrance of the adsorbate. EXPERIMENTAL Sample Preparations. Phenyl isocyanide (PNC) was prepared by a literature method.12 Phosphorus oxychloride (0.06 mol, 5.60 mL) dissolved in 40 mL of tetrahydrofuran (THF) was added to a stirred mixture of formanilide (0.02 mol, 2.29 g) and triethylamine (0.09 m ol, 12.54 m L) in 10 m L of THF at 278 8C over 30 m in. The mixture was gradually warm ed to 0 8C overnight with stirring and cooled to 215 8C. An ice-cold aqueous 50 mL solution of Na 2CO 3 (10%) was added dropwise to the mixture and warmed up to room temperature. The organic phase was separated and extracted with an ice-cold aqueous solution of Na 2CO 3 (10%), and then dried over MgSO 4 . The solvent was evaporated and the crude product was chromatographed on a Florisil column using ethyl acetate and hexane with a ratio of 1:2 as an eluting solution to yield PNC (1.73 g, 89%). The chemicals DMPNC ($98%) and BZI (98%) were purchased from Fluka and Sigma Aldrich, respectively, and used as received. The citrate-stabilized gold nanoparticle was synthesized by following the procedures in the literature:13 A portion of 133.5 mg of KAuCl 4 (Aldrich) was initially dissolved in 250 m L of water, and the solution was brought to boiling. A 25 mL solution of sodium citrate (1%) was then added to the KAuCl4 solution under vigorous stirring, and boiling was continued for approximately 20 min. The resulting Au nanoparticle solution was stable for several weeks. All the chemicals were re- 0003-7028 / 04 / 5802-0218$2.00 / 0 q 2004 Society for Applied Spectroscop y APPLIED SPECTROSCOPY F IG . 1. (a) TEM image, (b) size distribution, (c) UV-Vis absorption spectrum, and (d ) XRD pattern of gold nanoparticles. agent grade, and triply distilled water, of resistivity greater than 18.0 MV·cm, was used in making the aqueous solutions. Transmission Electron M icroscopy, UV-Vis, X-ray Diffraction, and Raman M easurements. To estimate the size of the gold nanoparticles, their transmission electron microscopy (TEM ) images were obtained with a Tecnai F20 Philips m icroscope after placing a drop of colloidal solution on a carbon-coated copper grid. UVVis absorption spectra of the colloidal solutions were obtained with a Shimadzu UV-1601PC spectrophotometer. X-ray diffraction (XRD) m easurements were carried out to examine the crystallinity of Au nanoparticles. The pattern was obtained at a scanning rate of 38 per minute by a Rigaku D-M AX/IIIC diffractometer using Cu Ka radiation at 0.154 nm. Raman spectral measurements were described in the previous literature.8,9 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Characterization of G old Nanoparticles. Figures 1a and 1b show a representative TEM image and a size distribution of the prepared gold nanoparticles. The mean particle diameter and its relative standard deviations were obtained for each sample by counting at least 150 gold particles. The statistical analysis revealed a size distribution of standard deviations in diameters, s ; 8.6% for 15.2 nm particles, respectively. Figure 1c shows the UVVis absorption spectrum of the gold nanoparticles. The lmax value was found at 520 nm. The full width at halfmaximum for the samples was m easured to be 86 nm. The X-ray diffraction pattern of the Au nanoparticles was measured to examine the crystallinity of the nanoparticles as shown in Fig. 1d. The (111), (200), (220), and (311) planes represent a cubic structure of the metallic gold. Raman Spectra of PNC. Figures 2a and 2b show the ordinary Raman (OR ) spectrum of PNC in the liquid state and the Au SERS spectrum, respectively. In order to obtain inform ation on the surface adsorption m echanism, it is necessary to analyze spectral changes according to the adsorption process. Consulting the earlier vibrational assignments,14 –16 we analyzed the Raman spectra in Fig. 2. It was rather straightforward to correlate the OR bands with the Au SERS bands. Their peak positions are listed in Table I along with the appropriate vibrational assignments. Figure 2b shows the Au SERS spectrum taken using a He–Ne laser at 632.8 nm. The n(NC) stretching peak on Au was blue shifted by 62 cm 2 1 from that of a free state. Also, the bandwidth APPLIED SPECTROSCOPY 219 TABLE I. Spectral data and vibrational assignments of PNC. a a b F IG . 2. (a) OR spectrum of PNC in the liquid state and (b) SERS spectrum of PNC in aqueous gold nanoparticle solution. The spectral region between 2800 and 2400 cm 2 1 was omitted due to the lack of any information. (c) n(CH) stretching region between 3200 and 2800 cm 2 1 . (FW HM: full width at half-maximum) of the n(NC ) band of a free state became broadened upon adsorption on the gold surface. Such a higher blue shift indicated the donation from the N[C: group to the Au surface.8 As shown in Fig. 2c, the benzene ring CH stretching band was identi ed very weakly at ;3080 cm 2 1 for PNC. This may be due to a weak response of the charge-coupled device (CCD) camera at the far wing of the He–Ne laser excitation frequency of 632.8 nm.9 Our result supports a rather vertical orientation of PNC on gold.17 It is noteworthy that the peak at ;620 cm 2 1 almost disappeared in the Au SERS spectrum, as shown in Fig. 3. Although it is tempting to assign this band as the n6b band of the benzene ring mode, the peak position and the strong intensity in the OR spectrum may indicate that it is ascribed to the C–NC band as referring from the peak positions of the C–S and C–Se band. 3 The weakness of the band in the SERS spectrum suggests a rather bent angle of C– N[C: after adsorption on the gold surfaces. Raman Spectra of DM PNC. Figure 4 shows the OR and SERS spectrum of 2,6-dimethyl phenyl isocyanide (DMPNC) on gold nanoparticle surfaces. Their peak positions are listed in Table II along with the appropriate vibrational assignments. Our assignment for DMPNC is mainly based on the case of meta-Di-‘‘light’’ in Ref. 14. The observed n(NC) bands of DMBNC were blue shifted in the Au SERS spectra by 56 cm 2 1 from that of the OR 220 Volume 58, Number 2, 2004 OR Au SERS 3072 1596 1487 1188 1166 1029 1002 769 621 473 332 3080w 1592 1485 1194 1167 1021 1001 790 514 527 2126 621 2188 352 Assignmentb In-plane 2 (A 1 ) n(C–H) 8a (A 1 ) n(C–C) 19a (A 1 ) n(C–C) 9a (A 1 ) b(C–H) 9b (B 2 ) b(C–H) 18a (A 1 ) b(C–H) 12 (A 1 ) Ring breathing 1 (A 1 ) a(C–C–C) 6b (B 2 ) a(C–C–C) and g(CC–H) 6a (A 1 ) a(C–C–C) 15 (B 2 ) b(C–H) Out-of-plane 16b (B 1 ) g(C–C–C) Substituents n(NC) n(C–NC) Units in cm 2 1. w 5 weak. Based on Ref. 14 in Wilson notation with symm etries based on C 2v point group. The symm etry in parentheses corresponds to C 2v point group. a and b, in-plane deformation; g, out-of-plane deformation; n, stretching. spectrum. As shown in Fig. 4c, the benzene ring CH stretching band was identi ed weakly at ;3050 cm 2 1 for DMPNC. This result also supports a rather vertical orientation of DM PNC on gold.17 Different from the case of PNC, the band at ;640 cm 2 1 rem ained quite strong even after the adsorption on Au. This result may indicate quite a linear angle of C–N[C: on the gold surface. This may be presumably due to a steric hindrance of the methyl groups of DM PNC. It would not be favorable for the C–N[C: angle of DM PNC to have a bent geometry on the surface because of the methyl groups. This steric hindrance should lead to sp hybridization of the nitrogen atom in the NC group. In order to check the adsorption F IG . 3. n(C–NC) stretching region between 680 and 560 cm 2 1 in (a) OR and (b) Au SERS spectrum for PNC. F IG . 5. (a) OR spectrum of BZI in the liquid state and (b) SERS spectrum of ;5 3 10 2 4 M BZI in aqueous gold nanoparticle solutions. The spectral region between 2820 and 2300 cm 2 1 was omitted due to the lack of any information. F IG . 4. (a) OR spectrum of DMPNC in the liquid state and (b) SERS spectrum of ;10 2 5 M DMPNC in aqueous gold nanoparticle solution. The spectral region between 2900 and 2400 cm 2 1 was omitted due to the lack of any information. (c) n(CH) stretching region between 3200 and 2800 cm 2 1. TABLE II. Spectral data and vibrational assignments of DMPNC. a OR Au SERS Assignmentb characteristics of aromatic isocyanides, we performed SERS of benzyl isocyanide (BZI) on gold nanoparticles. Raman Spectra of BZI. Figure 5 shows the ordinary Raman (OR) spectrum in the neat liquid state and the Au SERS spectrum of BZI, respectively. Table III lists the frequency positions of BZI on gold nanoparticle surfaces. The concentration of BZI in the colloidal solution was ;5 3 10 2 4 M. The n(NC) stretching frequency at 2215 cm 2 1 in Fig. 5b is higher by 64 cm 2 1 than that at 2151 cm 2 1 of a free state in Fig. 5a. The absence of either a TABLE III. Spectral data and vibrational assignments of BZI.a In-plane 3074 3046 1604 1593 1269 1259 1175 1097 1082 995 365 497 463 2987 2950 2921 2856 2123 1468 1443 1386 1377 640 3046w 1590 1264 1264 1174 1089 377 497 2927 2865 2179 1463 1419 658 20b (B 2 ) n(C–H) 2 (A 1 ) n(C–H) 8b (B 2 ) n(C–C) 8a (A 1 ) n(C–C) 13 (A 1 ) n(C–C–NC) 3 (B 2 ) b(C–H) 9b (B 1 ) b(C–H) 18b (B 2 ) b(C–H) 18a (A 1 ) b(C–H) 12 (A 1 ) Ring breathing 9a (A 1 ) b(C–H) Out-of-plane 16a (A 2 ) g(C–C–C) 16b (B 1 ) g(C–C–C) Substituents nas (CH 3) ip nas (CH 3) op ns (CH 3 ) ns (CH 3 ) n (NC) das 1 (CH 3 ) das 1 (CH 3 ) ds1 (CH 3 ) ds1 (CH 3 ) n (C–NC) Units in cm 2 1 . w, weak; ip, in-plane; op, out-of-plane; as, asymmetric; s, symm etric. b Based on Ref. 14 in Wilson notation with symm etries based on C 2v point group. The symm etry in parentheses corresponds to C 2v point group. d, bending vibrations to which a well-de ned plane cannot be related. a OR Au SERS 3061 1609 1588 1443 1203 1181 1157 1029 1003 601 814 474 272 3062 1603 1589 1433w 1199 745 401 224 746 2931 2151 1443 1203 798 619 1158 1029 1002 602 812 433 316 240 2215 1433w 1199 800 619 Assignmentb In-plane 2 (A 1 ) n(C–H) 8a (A 1 ) n(C–C) 8b (B 2 ) n(C–C) 19b (B 2 ) n(C–C) 13 (A 1 ) n(C–C–CH 2 ) 9a (A 1 ) b(C–H) 9b (B 2 ) b(C–H) 18a (A 1 ) b(C–H) 12 (A 1 ) Ring breathing 6b (B 2 ) a(C–C–C) and g(CC–H) 1 (A 1 ) a(C–C–C) 6a (A 1 ) a(C–C–C) 15 (B 2 ) b(C–H) Out-of-plane 11 (B 1 ) g(C–H) 16a (A 2 ) g(C–C–C) 10b (B 1 ) g(C–C–N) Substituents nas (CH 2 ) n (NC) bs (CH 2 ) (scissor, i.p.)c gs (CH 2 ) (wag or twist, o.p.)d ba s (CH 2 ) (rock, i.p.)c n(C–NC) Units in cm 2 1. w 5 weak. Based on Ref. 14 in Wilson notation with symm etries based on C 2v point group. The symm etry in parentheses corresponds to C 2v point group. c i.p., in-plane. d o.p., out-of-plane. a b APPLIED SPECTROSCOPY 221 TABLE IV. Relative enhancement factors of Au SERS bands of PNC, DMPNC, and BZI. Symmetry typea A1 F IG . 6. OR spectrum of BZI in (a) neat liquid state and (b) SERS spectrum of ;5 3 10 2 4 M BZI in aqueous gold nanoparticles in the spectral region between 3200 and 2800 cm 2 1 . The spectral region between 3200 and 2820 cm 2 1 in Fig. 5b was magni ed by a factor of 5 for a better presentation. substantial red shift or a signi cant band broadening of the ring breathing n12 mode at ;1000 cm 2 1 implied that a direct ring p orbital interaction with the gold substrate should be quite low. This result indicated that the adsorbate should have a rather vertical structure on Au. Figure 6 shows the spectral region between 3200 –2800 cm 2 1 for BZI to exhibit a change of the nas(CH 2) and n(CH) bands upon adsorption on gold. Regarding the geometry of the benzene ring, the appearance of the CH stretching band is identi ed at ;3060 cm 2 1, suggesting that BZI has an upright orientation on the Au surface, as discussed.17 It is noteworthy that the nas(CH 2 ) stretching band of BZI at ;2930 cm 2 1 almost disappeared, whereas the n(CH) band at ;3060 cm 2 1 remained conspicuous after adsorption on gold nanoparticles, as shown in Fig. 6. This result suggests a rather parallel orientation of the asymmetric methylene stretching vibration in BZI on the gold surface. This result supports a preference of sp 3 (or sp 2 ) hybridization for the nitrogen atom of BZI upon adsorption on gold resulting from a bent angle of :C[N–CH 2 for its nitrogen atom. Plausible Orientations. The m ajor bands associated with the ring vibrational m odes can be divided into four symmetry species assuming C 2v symm etry. 14 The relative intensities have been evaluated for the normal modes of PNC, DM PNC, and BZI and are listed in Table IV. According to the electromagnetic (EM) theory on the SERS selection rule,18,19 the in-plane vibration m odes of molecules adsorbed in a perpendicular orientation should be more enhanced than the out-of-plane ones. For PNC and DMPNC, although most ring m odes were found to belong to those of in-plane modes, the features at 460;530 cm 2 1 could be ascribed to the n16a and n16b out-of-plane ring m odes. The weakness of the out-of-plane band suggests that the adsorbates should have a rather vertical structure. A sm aller enhancement of the out-of-plane mode of DMPNC may support a m ore vertical orientation of its phenyl ring since it is likely that sp hybridization of DMPNC m ay lead to a m ore vertical stance on the surface. It seems, however, dif cult to discuss in detail the differences in phenyl ring orientation of PNC, 222 Volume 58, Number 2, 2004 Tensor elemen ts b Normal mode c axx ayy azz 1 2 12 13 8a 9a 18a 19a 16a 10b 11 16b 6b 8b 9b 15 19b A2 B1 axy axz B2 ayz n(NC) n(C–NC) bs (CH 2 ) ba s(CH 2 ) gs (CH 2 ) Relative enhancemen t factor PNC DMPNC 0.341 0.229 1.69 1.44 7.00 2.92 1.06 8.61 7.48 7.00 0.335 2.94 BZI 4.27 3.88 6.21 15.9 7.00 7.33 0.205 4.83 8.56 4.89 6.89 0.830 3.41 1.54 2.35 0.418 5.47 9.20 4.75 2.59 4.59 18.6 7.12 4.59 7.92 15.9 Symmetry types corresponding to the C 2v point group. Subscripts, i.e., x, y, and z, correspond to the conventional molecular axes. The x-axis lies perpendicular to the ring, and the z-axis passes through the NC group. c See Table I for vibrational assignment. d Normalized to 7.00 for the n8a band at ;1600 cm 2 1 . a b DMPNC, and BZI on Au due to the lack of suf cient ring modes to analyze. Plausible orientations of PNC, DMPNC, and BZI on gold nanoparticle surfaces are depicted in Fig. 7. p-Biphenylisocyanide appeared to have a more vertical stance on Ag than on Au from our previous study.9 This result may indicate an sp hybridization for the nitrogen atom on Ag, as in the case of the sulfur atom of alkanethiolates.1 It is not absolutely certain whether the bent structure of both thiolate and isocyanide monolayers on gold resulted from substrate-dependent properties of gold nanoparticles. It is also a matter of conjecture as to how polycrystalline surfaces of nanoparticles, as shown in Fig. 1d, would affect the observed orientation. Since SERS selection rules do not provide a precise interpretation of band intensities, we have currently been applying other spectroscopic techniques to reach a more consistent conclusion. Our future research will characterize F IG . 7. Plausible orientations of (a) PNC, (b) DMPNC, and (c) BZI on gold. aromatic isocyanide-coated gold particles by combined spectroscopic and microscopic m ethods. We plan to perform a molecular mechanics calculation to ensure that an intramolecular steric hindrance from the two m ethyl groups can affect the orientation on surfaces. Thermodynamic and electrochemical studies shall also be bene cial to explain the different adsorption characteristics of PNC, DMPNC, and BZI on Au surfaces. CONCLUSION The binding structure of phenyl isocyanide (PNC) and 2,6-dimethyl phenyl isocyanide (DMPNC) on gold nanoparticle surfaces has been investigated by means of surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS). As evidenced from the appearance of the ring CH stretching band, PNC and DM PNC have a rather vertical stance on gold surfaces. The disappearance of the n(C–NC) band after adsorption on gold suggests a rather bent C–N[C: angle. Thus, a bent con guration would be a favorable hybridization state at the nitrogen atom. For DM PNC, the strong intensity of the n(C–NC) band in the Au SERS spectrum indicates that sp hybridization should be m ore advantageous due to an intramolecular steric interaction between the isocyanide and the two methyl groups. SERS of BZI suggests a rather parallel orientation of the asymmetric methylene stretching vibration on the gold surface. This is also thought to result from a bent angle of :C[N– CH 2 for its nitrogen atom. ACK NOW LEDGM ENTS This work was supported by the Soongsil University Research Fund. S.W.J. would like to thank Prof. Kwan Kim for his guidance on SERS studies of self-assem bled monolayers prepared by aromatic isocyanides. 1. H. Sellers, A. Ulman, Y. Shnidman, and J. E. Eilers, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 115, 9389 (1993). 2. Y.-T. Tao, C.-C. Wu, J.-Y. Eu, W.-L. Lin, K.-C. Wu, and C.-h. Chen, Langmuir 13, 4018 (1997). 3. F. K. Huang, Jr., R. C. Horton, D. C. Myles, and R. L. Garrell, Langmuir 14, 4802 (1998). 4. P. E. Laibinis, G. M. W hitesides, D. L. Allara, Y.-T. Tao, A. N. Parikh, and R. G. Nuzzo, J. Am . Chem. Soc. 113, 7152 (1991). 5. (a) M. J. Robertson and R. J. Angelici, Langmuir 10, 1488 (1994); (b) A. C. Ontko and R. J. Angelici, Langmuir 14, 1684 (1998); (c) A. C. Ontko and R. J. Angelici, Langmuir 14, 3071 (1998); (d) A. C. Ontko and R. J. Angelici, Langmuir 15, 151 (1999). 6. (a) J. I. Henderson, S. Feng, G. M. Ferrence, T. Bein, and C. P. Kubiak, Inorg. Chim. Acta 242, 115 (1996); (b) J. I. Henderson, S. Feng, T. Bein, and C. P. Kubiak, Langmuir 16, 6183 (2000). 7. S. Lin and R. L. M cCarley, Langmuir 15, 151 (1999). 8. H. S. Han, S. W. Han, S. W. Joo, and K. Kim, Langmuir 15, 6868 (1999). 9. S. J. Bae, C.-r. Lee, I. S. Choi, C. S. Hw ang, M.-S. Gong, K. Kim, and S. W. Joo, J. Phys. Chem. B 106, 7076 (2002). 10. R. K. Chang and T. E. Furtak, Surface Enhanced Raman Scattering (Plenum Press, New York, 1982). 11. S. Rywkin, C. M. Hosten, J. R. Lombardi, and R. L. Birke, Langm uir 18, 5869 (2002). 12. (a) R. J. Linderman, S. Binet, and S. R. Petrich, J. Org. Chem. 64, 336 (1999); (b) Y. Ito, A. Ohnishi, H. Ohsaki, and M . Murakami, Synthesis 715 (1999); (c) K. Kobayashi, T. Nakashima, M. Mano, O. Morikawa, and H. Konishi, Chem. Lett. 602 (2001). 13. P. C. Lee and D. Meisel, J. Phys. Chem. 86, 3391 (1982). 14. G. Varsany, Assignments for Vibrational Spectra of Seven Hundred Benzene Derivatives (Acad emic Kiado, Budapest, 1974). 15. T. H. Joo, K. Kim, H. Kim, and M. S. Kim, Chem. Phys. Lett. 117, 518 (1985). 16. S. W. Joo, S. W. Han, and K. Kim, J. Phys. Chem. B 103, 10831 (1999). 17. P. Gao and M. J. Weaver, J. Phys. Chem. 89, 5040 (1985). 18. M . Moskovits, Rev. Mod. Phys. 57, 783 (1985). 19. J. A. Creighton, Surf. Sci. 124, 209 (1983). APPLIED SPECTROSCOPY 223
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz