Standards-Based Writing for Middle and High School English Language
Learners
Erin Haynes, American Institutes for Research
Excerpt from The Voice That Challenged a ation: Marian Anderson and the Struggle
for Equal Rights by Russell Freedman 1
[1] Despite cold and threatening weather, the crowd began to assemble long before the concert was to
begin. People arrived singly and in pairs and in large animated groups. Soon the streets leading to the
Mall in Washington, D.C., were jammed with thousands of people heading for the Lincoln Memorial.
[2] The earliest arrivals found places as close as possible to the steps of the great marble monument.
As the crowd grew, it spread back along the Mall, stretching around both sides of the long reflecting
pool and extending beyond to the base of the Washington Monument, three-quarters of a mile away.
Baby carriages were parked among the trees. Folks cradled sleeping infants in their arms and held
youngsters by the hand or propped up on their shoulders. Uniformed Boy Scouts moved through the
festive holiday throng handing out programs.
[3] Anticipating a huge turnout, the National Park Service had enlisted the help of some five hundred
Washington police officers. By five o’clock that afternoon, when the concert was scheduled to start,
an estimated 75,000 people had gathered on the Mall. They waited patiently under overcast skies,
bundled up against the brisk wind that whipped in from the Potomac River. They had come on this
chilly Easter Sunday to hear one of the great voices of the time and to demonstrate their support for
racial justice in the nation’s capital.
[4] Marian Anderson had been applauded by many of the crowned heads of Europe. She had been
welcomed at the White House, where she sang for the president and first lady, Franklin and Eleanor
Roosevelt. She had performed before appreciative audiences in concert halls across the United States.
But because she was an African American, she had been denied the right to sing at Constitution Hall,
Washington’s largest and finest auditorium. The Daughters of the American Revolution, the patriotic
organization that owned Constitution Hall, had ruled several years earlier that black artists would not
be permitted to appear there.
[5] News of the DAR’s ban had caused an angry controversy and set the stage for a historic event in
the struggle for civil rights. Working behind the scenes, a group of influential political figures had
found an appropriate concert space for Anderson. Barred from Constitution Hall, she would give a
free open-air concert on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial.
1
Excerpt from The voice that challenged a nation: Marian Anderson and the struggle for equal rights by Russell
Freedman (pp. 1–3). Copyright © 2004 by Russell Freedman.
Copyright © 2015 American Institutes for Research.
All rights reserved.
Standards-Based Writing For ELLs—1
[6] Shortly before the concert got under way, the skies above Washington began to clear. Clouds,
which had shadowed the monument, skittered away to the north, and the late afternoon sun broke
through to bathe the reflecting pool and shine on the gaily dressed Easter crowd. Secretary of the
Interior Harold L. Ickes appeared on the speaker’s platform. He introduced Miss Anderson, and she
stepped forward to the bank of microphones.
[7] The massive figure of Abraham Lincoln gazed down at her as she looked out at the expectant
throng. Silencing the ovation with a slight wave of her hand, she paused. A profound hush settled
over the crowd. For that moment, Marian Anderson seemed vulnerable and alone. Then she closed
her eyes, lifted her head, clasped her hands before her, and began to sing.
Copyright © 2015 American Institutes for Research.
All rights reserved.
Functional Grammar Analysis—2
Activity 1: Supplementary Questions
Directions: Create text-dependent supplementary questions for one of the following guiding
questions or for a portion of the text. Ensure questions are:
Aligned to a reading standard
Text dependent
Sequenced to support understanding
Consider incorporating the following strategies to make it easier for ELLs to answer your
questions:
Define key words prior to asking the question
Restate phrases or sentences that will help ELLs answer the question
Guiding questions:
Why had so many people come to the concert?
Who was Marian Anderson? What were her accomplishments?
Guiding Question or
Paragraph Number
Supplementary Question
Supplementary Question
Supplementary Question
Supplementary Question
Copyright © 2015 American Institutes for Research.
All rights reserved.
Functional Grammar Analysis—3
Activity 2: Scaffold Responses
Directions: Create emergent-level scaffolding (i.e., sentence frames and a word bank) for each
of your supplementary questions from Activity 1.
Word Bank
Sentence Frames
Copyright © 2015 American Institutes for Research.
All rights reserved.
Functional Grammar Analysis—4
Activity 3: Functional Grammar Analysis
Directions: Use the following sentence from The Voice That Challenged a $ation to fill in the
sentence elements in the first column. Then use your own words to complete the second column.
Share.
They had come on this chilly Sunday to hear one of the great voices of the time.
Sentence
Component
The Voice That Challenged a ation
Say It in Your Own Words
Who
What Happened
When
Why
What
Copyright © 2015 American Institutes for Research.
All rights reserved.
Functional Grammar Analysis—5
Activity 4: Writing Prompt
Directions: Select one of the following general writing prompts from the New Jersey
Department of Education.2 Identify aspects that might be challenging for ELLs in the table.
Rewrite the prompt for ELLs.
(1) Think what it would be like to live one day in the setting of your favorite book, or short story.
What would happen to you in this place? What would you do?
Write a story about what happens when you live one day in the setting of your favorite book, or
short story. Use your imagination along with your knowledge of history, science, current events,
or your own observation to develop your story.
(2) Your state is considering whether to charge a $2 fee for each person to enter and use parks
and community playgrounds. The money would be used to maintain and improve buildings,
fields, courts, and playground equipment. This proposal is controversial, and many citizens have
strong opinions about the idea.
You decide to write an editorial for the local newspaper expressing your opinion about whether
to charge a $2 fee for each person to enter and use parks and community playgrounds.
Write an editorial for the local newspaper expressing your opinion about whether to charge a $2
fee for each person to enter and use parks and community playgrounds. Be sure to include
reasons, facts, examples, and other evidence to support your position.
(3) Educational researchers claim that student learning will improve if all printed textbooks are
replaced with electronic textbooks, known as e-textbooks. Based on the researcher’s findings,
students in your school will be issued an e-textbook reader, which is a device that displays
electronic books.
Write an essay either supporting or opposing the claim that student learning will improve in your
school if all student textbooks are replaced with electronic reading books, known as e-readers.
Use your knowledge of books, history, science, current events, or your own experience or
observation to develop your essay. Be sure to include reasons, facts, examples, and other
evidence to support your position.
2
New Jersey Department of Education. (2014). $ew Jersey assessment of skills and knowledge, $J ASK 2014:
Parent, student, and teacher information guide.
Copyright © 2015 American Institutes for Research.
All rights reserved.
Functional Grammar Analysis—6
Prompt .umber:
Lexical Challenges:
Sentence-Level
Challenges:
Discourse-Level
Challenges:
Simplified Prompt:
Copyright © 2015 American Institutes for Research.
All rights reserved.
Functional Grammar Analysis—7
Activity 5: Preparing to Write and Writing
Directions: Brainstorm ideas for scaffolding the writing activity connected with the following
mainstream essay prompt. Develop a graphic organizer and identify how it will be aligned with a
paragraph frame.
Describe what happened on the ational Mall on Easter Sunday 1939.
Copyright © 2015 American Institutes for Research.
All rights reserved.
Functional Grammar Analysis—8