[scale=0.45]ALHAMBRAlogo.png Accurate merger fractions by PDF

Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis of
photometric close pairs
Carlos López San Juan
A. J. Cenarro, J. Varela, K. Viironen, A. Molino, N. Benítez,
& the ALHAMBRA collaboration
[ArXiv: 1409.1142]
Centro de Estudios de Física del Cosmos de Aragón
EGEE / 19th September 2014 / Bologna
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
Mergers and galaxy evolution fm with photometric redshifts
Mergers and galaxy evolution
Major mergers (1:1 – 1:4)?
Toomre 77; Naab+06; Rothberg+06ab,10; Hopkins+09
z=0
z=1
×2
z=2
×2
Major and minor mergers?
Trujillo+06,07; Buitrago+08; Naab+09, van Dokkum+10; Cassata+13
The knowledge of the merger fraction and its dependence on stellar
mass and colour is needed to constrain the merger track (Nipoti,
Naab, Eliche-Moral, Pawlik, Patton, Man, etc.)
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
Mergers and galaxy evolution fm with photometric redshifts
Mergers and galaxy evolution
Major mergers (1:1 – 1:4)?
Toomre 77; Naab+06; Rothberg+06ab,10; Hopkins+09
z=0
z=1
×2
z=2
×2
Major and minor mergers?
Trujillo+06,07; Buitrago+08; Naab+09, van Dokkum+10; Cassata+13
The knowledge of the merger fraction and its dependence on stellar
mass and colour is needed to constrain the merger track (Nipoti,
Naab, Eliche-Moral, Pawlik, Patton, Man, etc.)
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
Mergers and galaxy evolution fm with photometric redshifts
Mergers and galaxy evolution
Major mergers (1:1 – 1:4)?
Toomre 77; Naab+06; Rothberg+06ab,10; Hopkins+09
z=0
z=1
×2
z=2
×2
Major and minor mergers?
Trujillo+06,07; Buitrago+08; Naab+09, van Dokkum+10; Cassata+13
The knowledge of the merger fraction and its dependence on stellar
mass and colour is needed to constrain the merger track (Nipoti,
Naab, Eliche-Moral, Pawlik, Patton, Man, etc.)
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
Mergers and galaxy evolution fm with photometric redshifts
Close pairs in photometric samples
Two close galaxies in the sky plane,
rpmin ≤ rp ≤ rpmax , and in redshift space,
∆v ≤ 500 km s−1 (e.g., Patton+00).
fm = Np /N1
N1 : number of central galaxies,
Np : number of central galaxies with a
close companion.
With photometric redshifts we...
(i) apply a correction to avoid projection effects
(e.g., Rawat+08; Mármol-Queraltó+12; Xu+12; etc.),
(ii) assume a Gaussian probability distribution function (PDF) to
weight the close pairs (e.g., CLSJ+10).
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
Mergers and galaxy evolution fm with photometric redshifts
Close pairs in photometric samples
Two close galaxies in the sky plane,
rpmin ≤ rp ≤ rpmax , and in redshift space,
∆v ≤ 500 km s−1 (e.g., Patton+00).
fm = Np /N1
N1 : number of central galaxies,
Np : number of central galaxies with a
close companion.
With photometric redshifts we...
(i) apply a correction to avoid projection effects
(e.g., Rawat+08; Mármol-Queraltó+12; Xu+12; etc.),
(ii) assume a Gaussian probability distribution function (PDF) to
weight the close pairs (e.g., CLSJ+10).
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
Mergers and galaxy evolution fm with photometric redshifts
Close pairs in photometric samples
With photometric redshifts we...
(i) apply a correction to avoid projection effects
(e.g., Rawat+08; Mármol-Queraltó+12; Xu+12; etc.),
(ii) assume a Gaussian probability distribution function (PDF) to
weight the close pairs (e.g., CLSJ+10).
The above methodologies have several shortcomings:
The PDFs are usually non-Gaussian, and they assume either
Gaussian or flat distributions.
The luminosities and the stellar masses of the sources are also a
function of z, and they assume the values at the best
photometric redshift.
A red galaxy can have two co–existing solutions: either an old,
massive galaxy or a dusty, star-forming galaxy.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
Mergers and galaxy evolution fm with photometric redshifts
Close pairs in photometric samples
With photometric redshifts we...
(i) apply a correction to avoid projection effects
(e.g., Rawat+08; Mármol-Queraltó+12; Xu+12; etc.),
(ii) assume a Gaussian probability distribution function (PDF) to
weight the close pairs (e.g., CLSJ+10).
The above methodologies have several shortcomings:
The PDFs are usually non-Gaussian, and they assume either
Gaussian or flat distributions.
The luminosities and the stellar masses of the sources are also a
function of z, and they assume the values at the best
photometric redshift.
A red galaxy can have two co–existing solutions: either an old,
massive galaxy or a dusty, star-forming galaxy.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
Mergers and galaxy evolution fm with photometric redshifts
Close pairs in photometric samples
With photometric redshifts we...
(i) apply a correction to avoid projection effects
(e.g., Rawat+08; Mármol-Queraltó+12; Xu+12; etc.),
(ii) assume a Gaussian probability distribution function (PDF) to
weight the close pairs (e.g., CLSJ+10).
The above methodologies have several shortcomings:
The PDFs are usually non-Gaussian, and they assume either
Gaussian or flat distributions.
The luminosities and the stellar masses of the sources are also a
function of z, and they assume the values at the best
photometric redshift.
A red galaxy can have two co–existing solutions: either an old,
massive galaxy or a dusty, star-forming galaxy.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
Mergers and galaxy evolution fm with photometric redshifts
Close pairs in photometric samples
Our goal is to improve the estimation of the merger fraction with
photometric redshifts by using all the information encoded in the
probability distribution functions (PDFs) of ALHAMBRA.
The above methodologies have several shortcomings:
The PDFs are usually non-Gaussian, and they assume either
Gaussian or flat distributions.
The luminosities and the stellar masses of the sources are also a
function of z, and they assume the values at the best
photometric redshift.
A red galaxy can have two co–existing solutions: either an old,
massive galaxy or a dusty, star-forming galaxy.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
ALHAMBRA Filter set Area Photo-zs
The ALHAMBRA survey
Advanced, Large, Homogeneous Area, Medium–Band Redshift
Astronomical survey (Moles+08, alhambrasurvey.com)
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
ALHAMBRA Filter set Area Photo-zs
The ALHAMBRA survey
Advanced, Large, Homogeneous Area, Medium–Band Redshift
Astronomical survey (Moles+08, alhambrasurvey.com)
20 contiguous, non-overlapping medium-band (∼ 30 nm) filters in the
optical + 3 near-infrared filters (J, H, Ks ).
Limiting magnitude of ∼ 23.5 (AB 5σ, 300 aperture).
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
ALHAMBRA Filter set Area Photo-zs
The ALHAMBRA survey
Advanced, Large, Homogeneous Area, Medium–Band Redshift
Astronomical survey (Moles+08, alhambrasurvey.com)
Field
name
Overlapping
survey
area
(deg2 )
ALHAMBRA-2
ALHAMBRA-3
ALHAMBRA-4
ALHAMBRA-5
ALHAMBRA-6
ALHAMBRA-7
ALHAMBRA-8
DEEP2
SDSS
COSMOS
GOODS-N
AEGIS
ELAIS-N1
SDSS
0.377
0.404
0.203
0.216
0.400
0.406
0.375
Total
2.38
7 independent fields to defeat (and study!) the cosmic variance
(CLSJ+14a, Man’s talk) with a total high-quality area of 2.38 deg2 .
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
ALHAMBRA Filter set Area Photo-zs
The ALHAMBRA survey
Advanced, Large, Homogeneous Area, Medium–Band Redshift
Astronomical survey (Moles+08, alhambrasurvey.com)
# : 7144 galaxies
σz100 : 0.0134 | η1100 : 4.00 %
2.5
F814WAB < 24.5
2.0
zb
1.5
2000
1500
1.0
1000
500
0.5
0 0.2 0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2
0.00.0
∆z/1+z
0.5
1.0
1.5
zs
2.0
2.5
∆z/(1 + z) = 0.013 at I ≤ 24.5 (Molino+14).
The probability distribution function (PDF) of each galaxy.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
ALHAMBRA Filter set Area Photo-zs
The ALHAMBRA survey
Advanced, Large, Homogeneous Area, Medium–Band Redshift
Astronomical survey (Moles+08, alhambrasurvey.com)
1.0
2.5
PDF(z)
# : 7144 galaxies
σz100 : 0.0134 | η1100 : 4.00 %
F814WAB < 24.5
2.0
zb
1.5
2000
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
1500
1.0
0.0
1000
500
0.5
0 0.2 0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2
0.00.0
∆z/1+z
0.5
1.0
1.5
zs
2.0
2.5
0.2
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
1.0
Probability of a galaxy of being located
at redshift z
∆z/(1 + z) = 0.013 at I ≤ 24.5 (Molino+14).
The probability distribution function (PDF) of each galaxy.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
The PDF as a superior descriptor
15
1.0
PDF(z)
10
∆ δ (00 )
5
0
−5
0.6
0.4
0.2
−10
−15
0.8
0.0
−15
−10
−5
0
5
10
0.2
15
00
∆α ( )
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
1.0
Central galaxy: The Gaussian approximation is zp = 0.490 ± 0.018.
Nice job!!
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
The PDF as a superior descriptor
15
1.0
PDF(z)
10
∆ δ (00 )
5
0
−5
0.6
0.4
0.2
−10
−15
0.8
0.0
−15
−10
−5
0
5
10
0.2
15
00
∆α ( )
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
1.0
Central galaxy: The Gaussian approximation is zp = 0.490 ± 0.018.
Nice job!!
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
The PDF as a superior descriptor
15
1.0
PDF(z)
10
∆ δ (00 )
5
0
−5
0.6
0.4
0.2
−10
−15
0.8
0.0
−15
−10
−5
0
5
10
15
0.2
00
∆α ( )
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
Companion galaxy: The Gaussian approximation is
zp = 0.235 ± 0.188.
You know nothing!!
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
1.0
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
The PDF as a superior descriptor
15
1.0
PDF(z)
10
∆ δ (00 )
5
0
−5
0.6
0.4
0.2
−10
−15
0.8
0.0
−15
−10
−5
0
5
10
15
0.2
00
∆α ( )
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
Companion galaxy: The Gaussian approximation is
zp = 0.235 ± 0.188.
You know nothing!!
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
1.0
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
Close galaxies in redshift space: Z (z)
PDF(z)
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
1.0
Probability of being at the same redshift: Z (z) = PDF1 (z) × PDF2 (z).
However, this provides the wrong normalisation!
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
Close galaxies in redshift space: Z (z)
PDF(z)
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
1.0
Probability of being at the same redshift: Z (z) = PDF1 (z) × PDF2 (z).
However, this provides the wrong normalisation!
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
Close galaxies in redshift space: Z (z)
10
ΣPDF(z)
8
6
4
2
0
0.2
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
1.0
Probability of being at the same redshift: Z (z) = PDF1 (z) × PDF2 (z).
However, this provides the wrong normalisation!
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
Close galaxies in redshift space: Z (z)
ΣPDF(z)
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
1.0
2×PDF1 (z)×PDF2 (z)
PDF1 (z)+PDF2 (z) .
We normalise to the number ofR pairs (two galaxies) at each redshift.
In this case, Z dz = 0.58 pairs.
Probability of being at the same z: Z (z) =
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
The angular mask: Mθ (z)
15
10h−1 kpc ≤ rp ≤ 50h−1 kpc
10
20
15
0
θ (00 )
∆ δ (00 )
5
−5
5
−10
−15
10
0
−15
−10
−5
0
5
10
15
00
∆α ( )
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
In addition to Z (z), we deffine two masks.
The angular mask Mθ (z) = 1 where the system fulfills the rp
condition, and 0 otherwise.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
The pair selection mask: Mpair (z)
MB,1 ≤ −20.0 − 1.1z
MB,2 ≤ −18.5 − 1.1z
15
10
−23
−22
0
MB
∆ δ (00 )
5
−5
−20
−19
−10
−15
−21
−18
−15
−10
−5
0
5
10
15
∆ α (00 )
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
In addition to Z (z), we deffine two masks.
The pair selection mask Mpair (z) = 1 where the system fulfills the
selection and the luminosity ratio constrain, and 0 otherwise.
The pair probability function is PPF (z) = Z (z) × Mθ (z) × Mpair (z)
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
The pair selection mask: Mpair (z)
MB,1 ≤ −20.0 − 1.1z
MB,2 ≤ −18.5 − 1.1z
15
10
−23
−22
0
MB
∆ δ (00 )
5
−5
−20
−19
−10
−15
−21
−18
−15
−10
−5
0
5
10
15
∆ α (00 )
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
In addition to Z (z), we deffine two masks.
The pair selection mask Mpair (z) = 1 where the system fulfills the
selection and the luminosity ratio constrain, and 0 otherwise.
The pair probability function is PPF (z) = Z (z) × Mθ (z) × Mpair (z)
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
Robust estimation of fm in ALHAMBRA
Two close galaxies in the sky plane,
rpmin ≤ rp ≤ rpmax , and in redshift space,
PPF (z).
P R
PPFk dz
Np
,
fm = N = Pk R
PDF
1
i dz
i
N1 : number of central galaxies,
Np : number of close pairs.
7 ALHAMBRA fields ⇒
48 sub-fields (chips) ⇒
48 measurements of fm ⇒
fm distribution ⇒
ALHAMBRA merger
fraction
(CLSJ+14a)
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
PDF vs Gauss Estimation of the PPF Robust measurement of fm
Robust estimation of fm in ALHAMBRA
Two close galaxies in the sky plane,
rpmin ≤ rp ≤ rpmax , and in redshift space,
PPF (z).
P R
PPFk dz
Np
,
fm = N = Pk R
PDF
1
i dz
i
N1 : number of central galaxies,
Np : number of close pairs.
12
MB ≤ −20 − 1.1z
0.75 ≤ z < 0.9
σ = 0.38
σv = 0.29
10
8
N
7 ALHAMBRA fields ⇒
48 sub-fields (chips) ⇒
48 measurements of fm ⇒
fm distribution ⇒
ALHAMBRA merger
fraction
(CLSJ+14a)
6
4
2
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
fm
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
The merger fraction in MB samples
0.04
MB ≤ −20.0
Spectroscopy
SSRS2 (Patton+00)
MGC (CLSJ+10)
CNOC2 (Patton+02)
VVDS-Deep
DEEP2
fm
0.03
0.02
0.01
(Lin+04,08)
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
1.2
ALHAMBRA
Merger fraction of galaxies with MB ≤ −20.
Excellent agreement with spectroscopic surveys!
The merger fraction evolves as:
fm = (0.39 ± 0.07) × (1 + z)2.6±0.3 %
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
The merger fraction in MB samples
0.04
MB ≤ −20.0
fm ∝ (1 + z)2.6±0.3
fm
0.03
Spectroscopy
SSRS2 (Patton+00)
MGC (CLSJ+10)
CNOC2 (Patton+02)
VVDS-Deep
DEEP2
0.02
0.01
(Lin+04,08)
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
1.2
ALHAMBRA
Merger fraction of galaxies with MB ≤ −20.
Excellent agreement with spectroscopic surveys!
The merger fraction evolves as:
fm = (0.39 ± 0.07) × (1 + z)2.6±0.3 %
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
The merger fraction in MB samples
0.04
Spectroscopy
SSRS2 (Patton+00)
MGC (CLSJ+10)
CNOC2 (Patton+02)
VVDS-Deep
DEEP2
MB ≤ −19.5
fm
0.03
0.02
(Lin+04,08)
0.01
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
1.2
Spectroscopy +
photometry
GOODS-S (CLSJ+10)
ALHAMBRA
Merger fraction of galaxies with MB ≤ −19.5.
The merger fraction evolves as:
fm = (0.70 ± 0.09) × (1 + z)2.1±0.2 %
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
The merger fraction in MB samples
0.04
0.03
fm
Spectroscopy
SSRS2 (Patton+00)
MGC (CLSJ+10)
CNOC2 (Patton+02)
VVDS-Deep
DEEP2
MB ≤ −19.5
fm ∝ (1 + z)2.1±0.2
0.02
(Lin+04,08)
0.01
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
1.2
Spectroscopy +
photometry
GOODS-S (CLSJ+10)
ALHAMBRA
Merger fraction of galaxies with MB ≤ −19.5.
The merger fraction evolves as:
fm = (0.70 ± 0.09) × (1 + z)2.1±0.2 %
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
The merger fraction in MB samples
0.04
Spectroscopy
SSRS2 (Patton+00)
MGC (CLSJ+10)
CNOC2 (Patton+02)
VVDS-Deep
DEEP2
MB ≤ −19.0
fm
0.03
0.02
(Lin+04,08)
0.01
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
1.2
Spectroscopy +
photometry
GOODS-S (CLSJ+10)
ALHAMBRA
Merger fraction of galaxies with MB ≤ −19.0.
The merger fraction evolves as:
fm = (1.15 ± 0.10) × (1 + z)1.6±0.2 %
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
The merger fraction in MB samples
0.04
0.03
fm
Spectroscopy
SSRS2 (Patton+00)
MGC (CLSJ+10)
CNOC2 (Patton+02)
VVDS-Deep
DEEP2
MB ≤ −19.0
fm ∝ (1 + z)1.6±0.2
0.02
(Lin+04,08)
0.01
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
1.2
Spectroscopy +
photometry
GOODS-S (CLSJ+10)
ALHAMBRA
Merger fraction of galaxies with MB ≤ −19.0.
The merger fraction evolves as:
fm = (1.15 ± 0.10) × (1 + z)1.6±0.2 %
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
RMM [Gyr−1 ]
The major merger rate RMM
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.10
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
MB ≤ −20.0 − 1.1z
VVDS-Deep
(CLSJ+11)
MGC
(CLSJ+11)
ALHAMBRA
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
Major (∆MB < 1.5) merger rate of MB ≤ −20 − 1.1z galaxies.
−1
RMM = fMM TMM
Gyr−1
As previously, good agreement with the VVDS-Deep and MGC:
RMM = (0.029 ± 0.001) × (1 + z)1.7±0.4 Gyr−1
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
RMM [Gyr−1 ]
The major merger rate RMM
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.10
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
MB ≤ −20.0 − 1.1z
RMM ∝ (1 + z)1.7
VVDS-Deep
(CLSJ+11)
MGC
(CLSJ+11)
ALHAMBRA
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
Major (∆MB < 1.5) merger rate of MB ≤ −20 − 1.1z galaxies.
−1
RMM = fMM TMM
Gyr−1
As previously, good agreement with the VVDS-Deep and MGC:
RMM = (0.029 ± 0.001) × (1 + z)1.7±0.4 Gyr−1
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
Red and blue galaxies from the PDF
1.0
PDF
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
1.0
The PDF has extra information about the spectral type of the source.
The E/S0 templates define “red galaxies”, and the S/Starburst
templates define “blue galaxies”.
We can deal statistically with red and blue sub–samples.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
Red and blue galaxies from the PDF
1.0
PDF
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
1.0
The PDF has extra information about the spectral type of the source.
The E/S0 templates define “red galaxies”, and the S/Starburst
templates define “blue galaxies”.
We can deal statistically with red and blue sub–samples.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
Red and blue galaxies from the PDF
1.0
PDF
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
z
0.6
0.8
1.0
The PDF has extra information about the spectral type of the source.
The E/S0 templates define “red galaxies”, and the S/Starburst
templates define “blue galaxies”.
We can deal statistically with red and blue sub–samples.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
RMM [Gyr−1 ]
The major merger rate RMM vs colour
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.10
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.0
MB ≤ −20.0 − 1.1z
RMM ∝ (1 + z)0.8
ALHAMBRA
E/S0 templates
VVDS-Deep
NUV −r ≥ 4.25
(CLSJ+11)
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
MGC
u − r ≥ 2.1
The E/S0 templates define “red galaxies”, and the S/Starburst
templates define “blue galaxies”.
red
RMM
= (0.047 ± 0.008) × (1 + z)1.3±0.4 Gyr−1
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
RMM [Gyr−1 ]
The major merger rate RMM vs colour
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.10
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.0
MB ≤ −20.0 − 1.1z
RMM ∝ (1 + z)0.8
ALHAMBRA
E/S0 templates
VVDS-Deep
NUV −r ≥ 4.25
(CLSJ+11)
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
MGC
u − r ≥ 2.1
The E/S0 templates define “red galaxies”, and the S/Starburst
templates define “blue galaxies”.
red
RMM
= (0.047 ± 0.008) × (1 + z)1.3±0.4 Gyr−1
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
RMM [Gyr−1 ]
The major merger rate RMM vs colour
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.10
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.0
MB ≤ −20.0 − 1.1z
RMM ∝ (1 + z)1.3
ALHAMBRA
E/S0 templates
VVDS-Deep
NUV −r ≥ 4.25
(CLSJ+11)
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
MGC
u − r ≥ 2.1
The E/S0 templates define “red galaxies”, and the S/Starburst
templates define “blue galaxies”.
red
RMM
= (0.047 ± 0.008) × (1 + z)1.3±0.4 Gyr−1
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
RMM [Gyr−1 ]
The major merger rate RMM vs colour
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.10
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.0
MB ≤ −20.0 − 1.1z
ALHAMBRA
S/Starburst
templates
RMM ∝ (1 + z)2.2
VVDS-Deep
NUV −r < 4.25
(CLSJ+11)
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
MGC
u − r < 2.1
The E/S0 templates define “red galaxies”, and the S/Starburst
templates define “blue galaxies”.
blue
RMM
= (0.012 ± 0.003) × (1 + z)2.7±0.5 Gyr−1
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
RMM [Gyr−1 ]
The major merger rate RMM vs colour
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.10
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.0
MB ≤ −20.0 − 1.1z
ALHAMBRA
S/Starburst
templates
RMM ∝ (1 + z)2.2
VVDS-Deep
NUV −r < 4.25
(CLSJ+11)
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
MGC
u − r < 2.1
The E/S0 templates define “red galaxies”, and the S/Starburst
templates define “blue galaxies”.
blue
RMM
= (0.012 ± 0.003) × (1 + z)2.7±0.5 Gyr−1
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
fm vs MB
RMM vs z
RMM vs colour
RMM [Gyr−1 ]
The major merger rate RMM vs colour
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.10
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.0
MB ≤ −20.0 − 1.1z
ALHAMBRA
S/Starburst
templates
RMM ∝ (1 + z)2.7
VVDS-Deep
NUV −r < 4.25
(CLSJ+11)
0.2
0.4
0.6
z
0.8
1.0
MGC
u − r < 2.1
The E/S0 templates define “red galaxies”, and the S/Starburst
templates define “blue galaxies”.
blue
RMM
= (0.012 ± 0.003) × (1 + z)2.7±0.5 Gyr−1
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
J-PAS
Summary, conclusions, and future work
1
We have improved the methodology to compute the merger
fraction fm with photometric redshifts. The new method...
uses the full PDF information provided by BPZ.
applies consistent selections/conditions as a function of z.
deals statistically with “red” and “blue” templates.
2
We have applied the new method to the 48 ALHAMBRA
sub-fields to estimate fm .
3
The merger fractions and rates from ALHAMBRA are in excellent
agreement with those from spectroscopic surveys.
The next step is to include the stellar mass in the analysis.
We will apply this technique to estimate the merger fraction and the
density field in the J-PAS photometric survey.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
J-PAS
Summary, conclusions, and future work
1
We have improved the methodology to compute the merger
fraction fm with photometric redshifts. The new method...
uses the full PDF information provided by BPZ.
applies consistent selections/conditions as a function of z.
deals statistically with “red” and “blue” templates.
2
We have applied the new method to the 48 ALHAMBRA
sub-fields to estimate fm .
3
The merger fractions and rates from ALHAMBRA are in excellent
agreement with those from spectroscopic surveys.
The next step is to include the stellar mass in the analysis.
We will apply this technique to estimate the merger fraction and the
density field in the J-PAS photometric survey.
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
J-PAS
J-PAS: A next generation photometric survey
J-PAS : Javalambre - Physics of the accelerated universe
Astrophysical Survey (Benítez et al. 2014 [ArXiv:1403.5237])
1.2
Fλ(Arbitrary units)
0.4
Residuals
1.0
0.06
0.03
0.00
0.03
0.06
0.8
0.6
3000
M32 Spectrum
Best-fitting model
M32 synthetic photometry
4000
5000
6000
◦
λ(A)
7000
8000
9000
10000
J-PAS (j-pas.org) will map ∼8000 deg2 of the northern sky with
54 narrow-band filters (∼14 nm) + 2 medium-bands.
Photo–zs with ∆z/(1 + z) ∼ 0.3% (∼ 1000 km s−1 at z = 0.1)
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142
Introduction ALHAMBRA fm by PDF analysis Results Conclusions
J-PAS
Summary, conclusions, and future work
1
We have improved the methodology to compute the merger
fraction fm with photometric redshifts. The new method...
uses the full PDF information provided by BPZ.
applies consistent selections/conditions as a function of z.
deals statistically with “red” and “blue” templates.
2
We have applied the new method to the 48 ALHAMBRA
sub-fields to estimate fm .
3
The merger fractions and rates from ALHAMBRA are in excellent
agreement with those from spectroscopic surveys.
The next step is to include the stellar mass in the analysis.
We will apply this technique to estimate the merger fraction and the
density field in the J-PAS photometric survey.
Thanks for your attention!!
C. López-Sanjuan @ CEFCA @ EGEE2014 @ Bologna
Accurate merger fractions by PDF analysis; ArXiv: 1409.1142