IMPROVING COLLABORATION BY FEDERAL
AGENCIES:
AN ESSENTIAL PRIORITY FOR THE
NEXT ADMINISTRATION
!
by
Thomas H. Stanton
August 2008
!
One of a Series of Issue Papers on!
!
Presidential Management Capacity to Respond to 21st Century Challenges
Sponsored by NAPA’s Standing Panel on Executive Organization and
Management
!
!
!
This is one of a series of issue papers prepared under the auspices of The National Academy of Public
Administration’s Standing Panel on Executive Organization and Management. They are intended to inform
Presidential candidates and Congress about the management capacity of the Executive Office of the
President and the challenges facing it.
A list of the papers that have been completed as of this date can be found after this title page. The papers
represent the views of the author(s), not necessarily those of the Academy or any of its panels.
!
List of Issue Papers on
Presidential Management Capacity to Respond to 21st Century Challenges
"#$!%&'()*(+!,'($-!.(!/0$12&*3$!45+'(*6'&*.(!'()!7'('+$8$(&!2()$5&..9!'(!$::.5&!*(!;<<=!&.!
$0'8*($!&#$!*(>&*&2&*.('-!8'('+$8$(&!1'?'1*&@!.:!&#$!/0$12&*3$!4::*1$!.:!&#$!,5$>*)$(&A!!B.--.C*(+!
*>!'!-*>&!.:!*>>2$!?'?$5>!*>>2$)!'>!.:!D2+2>&!;<<EF!!!
!
Broad Governance Issues
!
x G,5*(1*?-$>H!I'-2$>H!'()!D>>28?&*.(>!J()$5-@*(+!KL..)!,2M-*1!7'('+$8$(&NO!!"#$%&'#()*+',-"#
#
x GL.3$5(*(+!C*&#!B.5$>*+#&F!!P(>&*&2&*.('-!Q#'(+$>!&.!/(#'(1$!B'1&RS'>$)!T$1*>*.(R7'9*(+!*(!
&#$!/0$12&*3$!4::*1$!.:!&#$!,5$>*)$(&HO!!"#$%&'#()*+',-"#
!
Institutional Management Capacity of the Executive Office of the President
!
x GD!7.)$5(*6$)!4::*1$!.:!/0$12&*3$!7'('+$8$(&F!!D(!4?&*.(!:.5!7'9*(+!&#$!7!*(!47S!'!
U$'-*&@HO!!!"#./01&2#3'-#!
!
x G"#$!,5$>*)$(&!72>&!T$3$-.?!'!%&5.(+!Q'?'1*&@!&.!7$$&!/0$12&*3$!45+'(*6'&*.(!
U$V2*5$8$(&>HO!!"#./01&2#3'-#)'4#5+6!+62#$),7+6#!
!
Management Tools Used by the Executive Office of the President
x
!
x
#
x
!
x
!
x
!
x
!
G%&5$(+&#$(*(+!&#$!L.3$5(8$(&N>!S2)+$&*(+!'()!B*>1'-!7'('+$8$(&!Q'?'1*&@HO!!"#89#:2+;+',#
<+4!=6'#)'4#>&0?07#@9#$%"A+#
GQ5*>*>!7'('+$8$(&O!!"#./01&2#3'-#
G"#$!,5$>*)$(&N>!P(&$5+.3$5(8$(&'-!7'('+$8$(&!D+$()'HO!!"#B6=A+#CA.%/+??#!
GL.3$5(8$(&!S@!Q.(&5'1&F!"#$!W#*&$!X.2>$!Y$$)>!Q'?'1*&@!&.!U$3*$C!'()!U$3*>$!&#$!Z$+'1@!
.:!;<&#!Q$(&25@!U$:.58HO!!"#.)'#@=22*)'!
GP8?5.3*(+!Q.--'M.5'&*.(!M@!B$)$5'-!D+$(1*$>F!D(!/>>$(&*'-!,5*.5*&@!:.5!&#$!Y$0&!
D)8*(*>&5'&*.(HO!!"#D&%*),#59#:2)'2%'!
G"#$!Z$+*>-'&*3$!Q-$'5'(1$!,5.1$>>HO!!"#B+6')64#C)620'!
;
Table of Contents
!
!
!
/0$12&*3$!%288'5@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA[!
P(&5.)21&*.(AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA\!
"#$!Y$$)!&.!%.-3$!,5.M-$8>!S$@.()!45+'(*6'&*.('-!S.2()'5*$>AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA=!
Q.--'M.5'&*.(!*(!&#$!B$)$5'-!D+$(1@!Q.(&$0& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA]!
Z'C>!&.!7'()'&$!P8?5.3$)!Q.--'M.5'&*.( AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA^!
D(!D+$()'!:.5!P8?5.3$)!Q.--'M.5'&*.(!D15.>>!45+'(*6'&*.('-!S.2()'5*$>AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA__!
Q#'(+*(+!45+'(*6'&*.('-!Q2-&25$>!&.!,5.8.&$!Q.--'M.5'&*.(AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA_[!
Q.(1-2>*.( AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA_=!
ADM.2&!&#$!D2&#.5AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA_]!
!
Appendices
!
D??$()*0!DF!!D15.(@8>!J>$)!*(!"#*>!U$?.5& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA_E!
D??$()*0!SF!!"#$!T*5$1&.5!.:!Y'&*.('-!P(&$--*+$(1$F!!/(#'(1$)!,$5>.(($-!7'('+$8$(& AAAA_^!
!
`
Executive Summary
P(!&.)'@N>!&$1#(.-.+@R)5*3$(!'()!1.8?-*1'&$)!$(3*5.(8$(&!*8?5.3$)!1.--'M.5'&*.(!.:!
:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!C*&#!.&#$5!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!#'>!M$1.8$!*8?$5'&*3$A!P(!8'(@!'5$'>H!>21#!'>!
15$'&*(+!*(&$5.?$5'M-$!>@>&$8>!:.5!?5.+5'8!)$-*3$5@H!1.--'M.5'&*.(!C*&#!>&'&$!'()!-.1'-!
+.3$5(8$(&>!'()!?5*3'&$!>$1&.5!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!.:&$(!1'(!15$'&$!'!5$>2-&!>2?$5*.5!&.!$'1#!
'+$(1@!.5!?5*3'&$!.5+'(*6'&*.(!&5@*(+!&.!+.!*&!'-.($A!!
!
P&!*>!&*8$!&.!$(#'(1$!&#$!12-&25$>!.:!:$)$5'-!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!&.!$8M5'1$!+5$'&$5!1.--'M.5'&*.(!
'()!:'1*-*&'&$!&#$!5*>$!.:!1.--'M.5'&*3$!-$')$5>!'()!8'('+$5>A!S2&!*(&$5.5+'(*6'&*.('-!
1.--'M.5'&*.(!82>&!M$!).($!C*&#.2&!C$'9$(*(+!.5!M-255*(+!'11.2(&'M*-*&@!.:!+.3$5(8$(&!
'+$(1*$>!&.!>?$()!?2M-*1!5$>.251$>!C*>$-@A!
!
%.8$!-$+*>-'&*.(!8'()'&$>!*(&$5.5+'(*6'&*.('-!1.--'M.5'&*.(A!"#$!L.-)C'&$5RY*1#.->!
T$?'5&8$(&!.:!T$:$(>$!U$.5+'(*6'&*.(!D1&!.:!_^E=!&5'(>:.58$)!&#$!a.*(&!Q#*$:>!.:!%&'::!
:5.8!'!C$'9!1..5)*('&*(+!M.)@!*(&.!'!>.251$!.:!*(:-2$(1$!&#'&!1.2-)!?5.8.&$!>$5*.2>!
*(&$5>$53*1$!1..?$5'&*.(A!"#$!T*5$1&.5!.:!Y'&*.('-!P(&$--*+$(1$!>*8*-'5-@!#'>!8'()'&$)!
*(&$5'+$(1@!>$53*1$!'>!'!5$V2*5$8$(&!:.5!?5.8.&*.(!&.!>$(*.5!-$3$->!.:!*(&$--*+$(1$!'+$(1*$>A!
b$&H!8'(@!+.3$5(8$(&C*)$!$::.5&>!'&!?5.8.&*(+!1.--'M.5'&*.(!#'3$!(.&!>211$$)$)!*(!&#$!
:'1$!.:!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!5$>*>&'(1$A!
!!
"#$!4::*1$!.:!7'('+$8$(&!'()!S2)+$&!c47Sd!*>!&#$!.(-@!'+$(1@!C*&#!1255$(&!1'?'1*&@!'()!
1-.2&!&.!:.>&$5!*8?5.3$)!1.--'M.5'&*.(A!".!?5.8.&$!'!12-&25$!.:!1.--'M.5'&*.(!M@!:$)$5'-!
'+$(1*$>H!47S!>#.2-)!$0?'()!'??-*1'&*.(!.:!&..->!>21#!'>!*(&$5'+$(1@!1.2(1*->!'()!'+$(1@!
?$5:.58'(1$!5'&*(+!>@>&$8>!&.!*(15$'>$!*(1$(&*3$>!:.5!:$)$5'-!8'('+$5>!&.!1.--'M.5'&$!C*&#!
&#.>$!.2&>*)$!&#$*5!'+$(1*$>N!M.2()'5*$>A!P()*3*)2'-!)$?'5&8$(&>!'()!'+$(1*$>!>#.2-)!').?&!
>@>&$8>!&#'&!5'&$!&#$!V2'-*&@!'()!$::$1&*3$($>>!.:!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(&.!&#$*5!>&5'&$+*1!'()!
?$5:.58'(1$!?-'(>!'()!*(&.!?$5:.58'(1$!$3'-2'&*.(>!.:!>$(*.5!$0$12&*3$>!'()!8'('+$5>A!
47S!C*--!($$)!&.!$0$51*>$!-$')$5>#*?!>@>&$8'&*1'--@!.3$5!8'(@!@$'5>!&.!#$-?!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!
*(&$5('-*6$!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(&.!&#$*5!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!3'-2$>!'()!12-&25$>A!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
[
IMPROVING COLLABORATION BY FEDERAL
AGENCIES: AN ESSENTIAL PRIORITY FOR THE
NEXT ADMINISTRATION
Introduction
!
Q.--'M.5'&*.(!'8.(+!+.3$5(8$(&!'+$(1*$>!'()!'15.>>!($&C.59>!*>!$>>$(&*'-!:.5!+.3$5(8$(&!
&.!M$!$::$1&*3$A!e'&5*('!C'>!.(-@!&#$!8.>&!5$1$(&!8'f.5!$0'8?-$!.:!'!?5.M-$8!&#'&!:'5!
$01$$)>!&#$!1'?'1*&@!.5!f25*>)*1&*.(!.:!'(@!>*(+-$!.5+'(*6'&*.(A!P(!.($!5$'-8!.:!+.3$5(8$(&!
':&$5!'(.&#$5H!>21#!'>!('&*.('-!>$125*&@H _ !#.8$-'()!>$125*&@H ; !?2M-*1!#$'-&#H ` !'()!)$-*3$5@!.:!
+.3$5(8$(&!M$($:*&>H!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!82>&!1.--'M.5'&$!C*&#!.&#$5>!&.!8$$&!&#$*5!
5$>?.(>*M*-*&*$>A!D>!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!)$3$-.?8$(&!$0?$5&!7*1#'$-!7'11.M@!1.(&$()>H!
&5'(>:.58'&*.(!.:!+.3$5(8$(&!M25$'215'1*$>!*(&.!1.--'M.5'&*3$!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!*>!*8?$5'&*3$!*:!
+.3$5(8$(&!*>!&.!9$$?!?'1$!C*&#!)$3$-.?8$(&>!*(!&#$!?5*3'&$!>$1&.5A [ !!
!
"$1#(.-.+@!8'9$>!1.--'M.5'&*.(!$'>*$5!&#'(!$3$5!M$:.5$A!"#$!$-$1&5.(*1!)$-*3$5@!.:!B..)!
%&'8?!M$($:*&>g5$V2*5*(+!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'8.(+!82-&*?-$!:$)$5'-!'()!>&'&$!'+$(1*$>!'()!:.5R
?5.:*&!'()!(.(?5.:*&!?5*3'&$!.5+'(*6'&*.(>g*>!'!+..)!$0'8?-$!.:!*(&$5.5+'(*6'&*.('-!
1.--'M.5'&*.(!&#'&!M$1'8$!?.>>*M-$!.(-@!M$1'2>$!.:!*8?5.3$)!&$1#(.-.+@A \ !!
!
W#*-$!&$1#(.-.+@!8')$!&#'&!$-$1&5.(*1!>@>&$8!:$'>*M-$!'&!5$'>.('M-$!1.>&H!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!
12-&25$!'->.!-*9$-@!?-'@$)!'(!*8?.5&'(&!5.-$A!Q.--'M.5'&*.(!M$&C$$(!&#$!B..)!'()!Y2&5*&*.(!
%$53*1$!cBY%d!.:!&#$!JA%A!T$?'5&8$(&!.:!D+5*12-&25$H!C#*1#!')8*(*>&$5>!B..)!%&'8?>H!'()!
&#$!T$?'5&8$(&!.:!X$'-&#!'()!X28'(!%$53*1$>H!C#*1#!')8*(*>&$5$)!&#$!:.58$5!DBTQ!cD*)!
&.!B'8*-*$>!C*&#!T$?$()$(&!Q#*-)5$(d!C$-:'5$!?5.+5'8H!#')!M$$(!($1$>>'5@!>*(1$!&#$!
*(1$?&*.(!.:!&#$!B..)!%&'8?!?5.+5'8H!>*(1$!DBTQ!$-*+*M*-*&@!1.(:$55$)!'2&.8'&*1!B..)!
%&'8?!$-*+*M*-*&@A = H ] !!D->.H!>&'&$>!?5.3*)$)!&#$!)$-*3$5@!.:!B..)!%&'8?>!&.!M$($:*1*'5*$>A!"#'&!
#*>&.5@!.:!($1$>>'5@!1.--'M.5'&*.(!-*9$-@!:'1*-*&'&$)!'!12-&25$!&#'&!8')$!BY%!?'5&*12-'5-@!.?$(!
_!%$$H!$A+AH!&#$!,5.f$1&!.(!Y'&*.('-!%$125*&@!U$:.58H!CCCA?(>5A.5+A!G425!1255$(&!('&*.('-!>$125*&@!>@>&$8H!'()!
&#$!8'(($5!*(!C#*1#!*&!*>!+.3$5($)!'()!:2()$)!M@!Q.(+5$>>H!).$>!(.&!?$58*&!&#$!&*8$-@H!$::$1&*3$!*(&$+5'&*.(!.:!
&#$! )*3$5>$! )$?'5&8$(&'-! $0?$5&*>$!'()! 1'?'M*-*&*$>! 5$V2*5$)! &.! ?5.&$1&!&#$!J(*&$)! %&'&$>H! *&>! *(&$5$>&>H! '()! *&>!
1*&*6$(>!*(!'(!*(15$'>*(+-@!1.8?-$0!'()!5'?*)-@!1#'(+*(+!C.5-)AO!
;!%$$H!$A+AH!"#.8'>!XA!%&'(&.(H!G7$$&*(+!&#$!Q#'--$(+$!.:!%$?&$8M$5!__HO!P(&5.)21&*.(!&.!"#.8'>!XA!%&'(&.(H!
$)AH!C++20'1#2&+#E&)??+'1+#%F#GHIIJ#B?=+760'2,#F%6#KFF+A20;+#@%;+6'*+'2H!7A/A!%#'5?$!,2M-*>#$5>H!;<<=A##!
`! %$$H! $A+AH! X.8$-'()! %$125*&@! Q.2(1*-H! L)20%')?# :26)2+1"# F%6# >)'4+*0A# 3'F?=+'M)# 3*7?+*+'2)20%'# >?)'J# N'+# O+)6#
:=**)6"H!a2-@!;<<]A!
[!,$5>.('-!1.882(*1'&*.(H!W'>#*(+&.(H!TQH!D2+2>&!^H!;<<]A!%$$!'->.H!7*1#'$-!7'11.M@H!D&+#P+)4+6,#Q+#L++4H!
X'53'5)!S2>*($>>!U$3*$C!,5$>>H!;<<]!c:.5&#1.8*(+dA!!
\!%$$H!$A+AH!"#.8'>!XA!%&'(&.(H!GP8?5.3*(+!B$)$5'-!U$-'&*.(>!C*&#!%&'&$>H!Z.1'-*&*$>H!'()!,5*3'&$!45+'(*6'&*.(>!
.(! 7'&&$5>! .:! X.8$-'()! %$125*&@F! "#$! %&'9$#.-)$5! Q.2(1*-! 7.)$-HO! E&)72+6! _`! *(! "#.8'>! XA! %&'(&.(H! $)AH!
C++20'1#2&+#E&)??+'1+#%F#GHIIJ#B?=+760'2,#F%6#KFF+A20;+#@%;+6'*+'2H!7A/A!%#'5?$!,2M-*>#$5>H!;<<=A!
=! S'5M'5'! %A! W'8>-$@H! :.58$5-@! T$?2&@! D>>*>&'(&! %$15$&'5@! '&! XX%A! ,$5>.('-! 1.882(*1'&*.(H! W'>#*(+&.(H!
TQH!D2+2>&!`H!;<<]A!
]!D!&'M-$!.:!'15.(@8>!2>$)!*(!&#*>!5$?.5&!*>!:.2()!*(!D??$()*0!DA
\
&.!?'5&*1*?'&*(+!C*&#!.&#$5!>&'9$#.-)$5>!&.!8.3$!B..)!%&'8?>!&.!'(!$-$1&5.(*1!)$-*3$5@!
>@>&$8A!
!
W#*-$!1.--'M.5'&*.(!C*&#!.&#$5!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!#'>!M$1.8$!M.&#!8.5$!($1$>>'5@!'()!$'>*$5H!
.5+'(*6'&*.('-!5$>*>&'(1$!&.!1.--'M.5'&*.(!5$8'*(>!'!8'f.5!?5.M-$8A!P&!*>!&*8$!(.C!&.!1#'(+$!
&#$!12-&25$>!.:!:$)$5'-!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!&.!$8M5'1$!+5$'&$5!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'()!&.!:'1*-*&'&$!&#$!5*>$!
.:!1.--'M.5'&*3$!-$')$5>!'()!8'('+$5>!&.!?.>*&*.(>!.:!'2&#.5*&@A!!
!
"#$!4::*1$!.:!7'('+$8$(&!'()!S2)+$&!c47Sd!C*--!M$!15*&*1'-!:.5!&#$!>211$>>!.:!'!($C!
')8*(*>&5'&*.(!*(!&#*>!$::.5&A!".!?5.8.&$!'!12-&25$!.:!1.--'M.5'&*.(!M@!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>H!
47S!>#.2-)!$0?'()!&#$!'??-*1'&*.(!.:!'3'*-'M-$!&..->H!>21#!'>!*(&$5'+$(1@!1.2(1*->!'()!
'+$(1@!?$5:.58'(1$!5'&*(+!>@>&$8>H!&.!*(15$'>$!*(1$(&*3$>!.:!:$)$5'-!8'('+$5>!&.!1.--'M.5'&$!
C*&#!&#.>$!.2&>*)$!.:!&#$*5!'+$(1*$>N!M.2()'5*$>A!P()*3*)2'-!)$?'5&8$(&>!'()!'+$(1*$>!>#.2-)!
').?&!>21#!5'&*(+!>@>&$8>!'>!?'5&!.:!&#$*5!)$?'5&8$(&R!.5!'+$(1@C*)$!>&5'&$+*1!'()!
?$5:.58'(1$!?-'(>!'()!>#.2-)!*(1.5?.5'&$!>21#!5'&*(+>!*(&.!&#$!?$5:.58'(1$!$3'-2'&*.(>!.:!
>$(*.5!$0$12&*3$>!'()!.&#$5!8'('+$5>A!W*&#!>2??.5&!:5.8!&#$!($0&!')8*(*>&5'&*.(H!47S!C*--!
($$)!&.!$0$51*>$!*&>!-$')$5>#*?!>@>&$8'&*1'--@!.3$5!8'(@!@$'5>!>.!&#'&!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!
*(&$5('-*6$!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(&.!&#$*5!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!3'-2$>!'()!12-&25$>A!!
!
The Need to Solve Problems Beyond Organizational Boundaries
!!
P(!8'(@!'5$'>!.:!+.3$5(8$(&'-!$()$'3.5H!&#$!(28M$5!.:!'1&.5>!($$)$)!&.!'1#*$3$!$::$1&*3$!
5$>2-&>!#'>!'-C'@>!M$$(!-'5+$A E !B$)$5'-!#*+#C'@!?5.+5'8>H!)$-*3$5@!.:!#.2>*(+!M$($:*&>H!
:$)$5'-!-.'(!+2'5'(&$$!?5.+5'8>H!'()!)$-*3$5@!.:!7$)*1'5$!'()!7$)*1'*)!M$($:*&>!'5$!.(-@!
>.8$!$0'8?-$>A!!
!
P(!5$1$(&!@$'5>!&#$!1.(&$0&!*(!C#*1#!+.3$5(8$(&!?5.+5'8>!.?$5'&$!#'>!M$1.8$!$3$(!8.5$!
1.8?-*1'&$)A!W#*-$!'+$(1*$>!#'3$!-.(+!.?$5'&$)!&#5.2+#!&#*5)!?'5&*$>H!'>!Z$>&$5!%'-'8.(!
?.*(&$)!.2&!*(!#*>!>$8*('-!'5&*1-$!8'(@!@$'5>!'+.H ^ !>&'::*(+!'()!M2)+$&!1.(>&5'*(&>!'()!
?5$>>25$>!:.5!.2&>.251*(+!#'3$!*(15$'>$)!&#*>!)$?$()$(1$A!Q.(>&'(&-@!$3.-3*(+!&$1#(.-.+*$>!
?5.)21$!82-&*?-$!$::$1&>H!*(1-2)*(+!:.51*(+!'(!2(M2()-*(+!.:!?5$3*.2>-@!1.8M*($)!+..)>!'()!
>$53*1$>H!'()!5$1.8M*(*(+!&#$8!*(!($C!C'@>A!"$1#(.-.+@!'->.!15$'&$>!($C!.??.5&2(*&*$>!:.5!
f.*(&!)$-*3$5@!.:!>$53*1$>H!>21#!'>!1.88.(!?.5&'->!.5!)'&'!>@>&$8>!&#'&!>2??.5&!82-&*?-$!
?5.+5'8>A!7.5$!?5.M-$8>!&#'(!$3$5!M$:.5$!#'3$!'1V2*5$)!+-.M'-!)*8$(>*.(>!&#'&!5$V2*5$!
1..?$5'&*.(!'15.>>!*(&$5('&*.('-!M.2()'5*$>A!!
!
,.-*1@8'9$5>!*(15$'>*(+-@!&'9$!'!+.3$5(8$(&C*)$!3*$C!.:!&#$!+..)>!'()!>$53*1$>!&#'&!
'+$(1*$>!>#.2-)!?5.3*)$A!"#$!T$M&!Q.--$1&*.(!P8?5.3$8$(&!D1&!.:!_^^=H!:.5!$0'8?-$H!
5$V2*5$>!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!&.!1..?$5'&$!&.!'>>25$!&#'&!:$)$5'-!)$M&>!'5$!5$?'*)!'()!&#'&!?$.?-$!
'()!M2>*($>>$>!C*&#!)$:'2-&$)!:$)$5'-!)$M&>!).!(.&!5$1$*3$!&'0!5$:2()>H!($C!:$)$5'-!-.'(>H!.5!
.&#$5!:$)$5'-!M$($:*&>A!B$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!82>&!M$!8.5$!(*8M-$!&#'(!$3$5!M$:.5$!'()!?5.M-$8>!
&#'&!&#$@!'&&'19!8'@!*(3.-3$!8.5$!'()!)*::$5$(&!'1&.5>A!!
!
E!%$$H!+$($5'--@H!Z$>&$5!7A!%'-'8.(H!G"#$!Y$C!L.3$5('(1$!'()!"..->!.:!,2M-*1!D1&*.(HO!P(&5.)21&*.(!&.!D%%?,#
%F#@%;+6'*+'2J#R#@=04+#2%#2&+#L+/#@%;+6')'A+H!Z$>&$5!7A!%'-'8.(H!/)*&.5H!40:.5)!J(*3$5>*&@!,5$>>H!;<<;A!
^!Z$>&$5!7A!%'-'8.(H!GU$&#*(9*(+!,2M-*1!7'('+$8$(&F!"#*5)!,'5&@!L.3$5(8$(&!'()!&#$!"..->!.:!L.3$5(8$(&!
D1&*.(HO!>=!?0A#>%?0A"H!3.-A!;^H!(.A!_H!>288$5!_^E_H!??A!;\\R;]\A
=
/0'8?-$>!'M.2()!.:!&#$!($$)!:.5!*8?5.3$)!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'15.>>!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!M.2()'5*$>A!
"#$!)$-*3$5@!.:!$8$5+$(1@!M$($:*&>!&.!)*>'>&$5!3*1&*8>!>#.2-)!M$!?.>>*M-$!$-$1&5.(*1'--@!.(1$!
'??-*1'(&!$-*+*M*-*&@!'()!'3'*-'M*-*&@!.:!:2()>!#'3$!M$$(!)$&$58*($)h!#.C$3$5H!$01$?&!:.5!
B..)!%&'8?>!'()!3'5*.2>!>&'&$!M$($:*&!?5.+5'8>H!&#$!1.2(&5@!>&*--!-'19>!'(!*(&$5.?$5'M-$!
('&*.('-!>@>&$8!:.5!)$-*3$5*(+!8.>&!M$($:*&>A!Q5$'&*(+!*(&$5.?$5'M-$!>@>&$8>!:.5!?5.+5'8!
)$-*3$5@!*>!'!8'f.5!1'&$+.5@!C#$5$!1.--'M.5'&*.(!1'(!15$'&$!'!5$>2-&!&#'&!*>!>2?$5*.5H!'()!
>.8$&*8$>!:'5!>2?$5*.5H!&.!$'1#!'+$(1@!.5!?5*3'&$!.5+'(*6'&*.(!&5@*(+!&.!+.!*&!'-.($A _< !!
!
J(&*-!5$1$(&-@H!&#$!B$)$5'-!X.2>*(+!D)8*(*>&5'&*.(!cBXDd!-.>&!8'59$&!>#'5$!&.!&#$!?5*3'&$!
>$1&.5H!*(!?'5&!M$1'2>$!.:!*&>!-'19!.:!&$1#(.-.+@!>@>&$8>H!1.8?'5$)!&.!')3'(1$>!*(!&#$!?5*3'&$!
>$1&.5H!&.!:'1*-*&'&$!8.5$!$::$1&*3$!2()$5C5*&*(+H!5*>9!8'('+$8$(&H!'()!-.'(!?5.1$>>*(+A __ !
W*&#!$('1&8$(&!.:!-$+*>-'&*.(!$0?'()*(+!&#$!5.-$!.:!BXD!*(!&#$!1255$(&!&5.2M-$)!#.2>*(+!
8'59$&H!&#*>!>#.5&1.8*(+!C*--!M$1.8$!$3$(!8.5$!>*+(*:*1'(&A!Q.--'M.5'&*.(!M$&C$$(!BXD!
'()!L*((*$!7'$H!&#$!+.3$5(8$(&!1.5?.5'&*.(!5$>?.(>*M-$!:.5!?5.3*)*(+!'!>$1.()'5@!8'59$5!
:.5!BXD!-.'(>H!1.2-)!#$-?!&.!5$?-*1'&$!?5*3'&$!>$1&.5!')3'(1$>!*(!2()$5C5*&*(+!'()!
?5.1$>>*(+!8.5&+'+$!-.'(>!$-$1&5.(*1'--@A!/(#'(1$)!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'8.(+!&#$!8'f.5!:$)$5'-!
#.2>*(+!?5.+5'8!'+$(1*$>!'->.!C.2-)!-$')!&.!*8?5.3$)!:*('(1*'-!5*>9!8'('+$8$(&A!!
!
Collaboration in the Federal Agency Context
#
P&!*>!2>$:2-!&.!)*>&*(+2*>##A%%640')20%'!:5.8!A%??)!%6)20%'#.:!82-&*?-$!.5+'(*6'&*.(>A _; !P(&$5'+$(1@!
1..5)*('&*.(!8*+#&!M$!)$:*($)!'>!'!>?$1*:*1!:.58!.:!1.--'M.5'&*.(!&#'&!'??-*$>!&.!?'5&*12-'5!
1'>$>!.5!.?$5'&*.(>A!S@!1.(&5'>&!&.!1.--'M.5'&*.(!C#$(!82-&*?-$!'+$(1*$>!8'@!?$51$*3$!
82&2'-!M$($:*&!*(!C.59*(+!&.+$&#$5H!1..5)*('&*.(!.:&$(!*>!8.5$!.:!'!&.?R).C(!$0$51*>$A!P&!
&'9$>!?-'1$!C#$(!'!-$')$5!C*&#!'2&#.5*&@!.3$5!82-&*?-$!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!)*5$1&>!&#$8!&.!
1.--'M.5'&$!&.!'1#*$3$!'!>?$1*:*$)!f.*(&!?25?.>$A!"#$!$::.5&!&.!*()21$!:$)$5'-!*(&$--*+$(1$!
'+$(1*$>!&.!>#'5$!*(:.58'&*.(!C*&#!.($!'(.&#$5!'()!C*&#!>&'&$!'()!-.1'-!+.3$5(8$(&>!*>!'(!
$0'8?-$!.:!'&&$8?&$)!1..5)*('&*.(A!D>!X'5.-)!%$*)8'(!?.*(&>!.2&!.(!&#$!M'>*>!.:!(28$5.2>!
$0'8?-$>H!1..5)*('&*.(!*>!(.&!$'>@!&.!'1#*$3$H!)$>?*&$!*&>!*8?.5&'(1$A _` !P()$$)H!*&!*>!V2*&$!
)*::*12-&!&.!?$5>2')$!*(&$--*+$(1$!'+$(1*$>!$3$(!&.!>#'5$!*(:.58'&*.(H!821#!-$>>!&.!1..5)*('&$!
f.*(&!'1&*.(H!C*&#!.&#$5!.5+'(*6'&*.(>A!!
!
W*&#!&#$!LD4H!&#*>!?'?$5!'11$?&>!/2+$($!S'5)'1#N>!)$:*(*&*.(!.:!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'>!G'(@!f.*(&!
'1&*3*&@!M@!&C.!.5!8.5$!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!&#'&!*>!*(&$()$)!&.!?5.)21$!8.5$!?2M-*1!3'-2$!&#'(!
_<!%$$H!$A+AH!"#.8'>!XA!%&'(&.(H!.+?0;+6"#%F#B+'+F02,#0'#)'#K*+61+'A"J#P+,,%',#F6%*#5=660A)'+#()260')H!PS7!Q$(&$5!:.5!
&#$!S2>*($>>!.:!L.3$5(8$(&H!a'(2'5@!;<<]A!
__!JA%A!L.3$5(8$(&!D11.2(&'M*-*&@!4::*1$S#8+4+6)?#5%=,0'1#R4*0'0,26)20%'J#.+A?0'+#0'#2&+#R1+'A"T,#C)6-+2#:&)6+#Q),#
R,,%A0)2+4#/02&#>6%4=A2#)'4#>6%A+,,#.+;+?%7*+'2,#%F#N2&+6#C%621)1+#C)6-+2#>)620A07)'2,H!LD4R<]R=[\H!a2($!;<<]h!'()!
8+4+6)?# 5%=,0'1# R4*0'0,26)20%'J# C%4+6'0M)20%'# >6%7%,)?,# Q%=?4# 5);+# >6%16)*# )'4# B=41+2# 3*7?0A)20%',# )'4# <+U=06+#
E%'20'=+4#3*76%;+*+'2,#0'#<0,-#C)')1+*+'2H!LD4R<]R]<EH!a2($!;<<]A!!
_;! D>! &#$! LD4! .M>$53$>H! &#$5$! '5$! (.! 1.88.(-@! '11$?&$)! )$:*(*&*.(>! .:! &#$>$! &$58>A! ! L.3$5(8$(&!
D11.2(&'M*-*&@! 4::*1$H! <+,=?2,VN60+'2+4# @%;+6'*+'2J# >6)A20A+,# 2&)2# A)'# &+?7# K'&)'A+# )'4# :=,2)0'# E%??)!%6)20%'# )*%'1#
8+4+6)?#R1+'A0+,H!LD4R<=R_\H!41&.M$5!;<<\H!?A!_A!
_`!X'5.-)!%$*)8'(H!GQ..5)*('&*.(F!"#$!%$'51#!:.5!&#$!,#*-.>.?#$5N>!%&.($HO!1#'?&$5!^!*(!>%?020A,S#>%,020%'S#)'4#
>%/+6H! :*:&#! $)*&*.(H! 40:.5)! J(*3$5>*&@! ,5$>>H! _^^EA! B.5! '(! $0'8?-$! .:! >211$>>:2-! 1..5)*('&*.(H! >$$H! TC*+#&!
P(9N>!)$>15*?&*.(!.:!&#$!$::$1&*3$!5$>?.(>$!&.!&#$!D-'>9'!$'5&#V2'9$!.:!!_^=[H!G7'('+*(+!Q#'(+$!&#'&!7'9$>!'!
T*::$5$(1$HO!!Q#'?&$5!]!*(!"#.8'>!XA!%&'(&.(H!$)AH!C++20'1#2&+#E&)??+'1+#%F#GHIIJ#B?=+760'2,#F%6#KFF+A20;+#@%;+6'*+'2H!
7A/A!%#'5?$!,2M-*>#$5>H!;<<=A
]
1.2-)!M$!?5.)21$)!C#$(!&#$!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!'1&!'-.($AO _[ !W#*-$!&#*>!?'?$5!5$1.88$()>!&#$!
'??-*1'&*.(!.:!&.?R).C(!'2&#.5*&@!&.!#$-?!15$'&$!*(1$(&*3$>!:.5!1.--'M.5'&*.(H!'+$(1*$>!.:&$(!
1'(!>$-$1&!&#$!'5$'>!C#$5$!&#$@!$0?$1&!&.!?5.)21$!&#$!+5$'&$>&!M$($:*&>A!"#*>!1.(&5'>&>!C*&#!
1..5)*('&*.(H!C#$5$!&#$!&.?R).C(!$0$51*>$!>?$1*:*$>!&#$!'5$'!C#$5$!1..5)*('&*.(!82>&!
.1125A!P&!1'(!M$!>$$(!&#'&!&#$!1.(1$?&>!.:!1..5)*('&*.(!'()!1.--'M.5'&*.(!1'(!.3$5-'?!*(!
>.8$!>*+(*:*1'(&!'??-*1'&*.(>A!!!
!
4($!$0'8?-$!.:!&#$!)*::$5$(1$!M$&C$$(!1..5)*('&*.(!'()!1.--'M.5'&*.(H!'>!&#$!&$58>!'5$!
2>$)!#$5$H!*>!&#$!$3.-2&*.(!.:!,5$>*)$(&N>!7'('+$8$(&!Q.2(1*-!c,7QdH!'(!47SR-$)!1.2(1*-!
1.8?.>$)!.:!&#$!>$1.()!5'(9*(+!.::*1*'-!'&!$'1#!$0$12&*3$!)$?'5&8$(&!'()!>.8$!8'f.5!
'+$(1*$>A!P(!&#$!_^^<>!&#$!1.2(1*-!C'>!'!8'f.5!>.251$!.:!1.--'M.5'&*3$!$::.5&>A!".?!?.-*&*1'-!
'??.*(&$$>H!+$($5'--@!5$>?.(>*M-$!:.5!8'('+*(+!&#$*5!)$?'5&8$(&>!.5!'+$(1*$>H!C.2-)!
$01#'(+$!*(:.58'&*.(!'()!C.59!&.+$&#$5!&.!>.-3$!1.88.(!?5.M-$8>A!D>!:.58$5!47S!
.::*1*'-!7'5+'5$&!b'.!#'>!C5*&&$(H!&#$!,7Q!>211$>>:2--@!').?&$)!'!G8$8M$5R.C($)H!
8$8M$5R.?$5'&$)O!12-&25$A _\ !!"#*>!1.(&5'>&>!C*&#!&#$!&.?R).C(!'??5.'1#!&.!1..5)*('&*.(H!
5'&#$5!&#'(!1.--'M.5'&*.(H!C#*1#!&$()>!&.!M$!?5'1&*1$)!*(!&#$!1255$(&!')8*(*>&5'&*.(A!"#2>H!
&#$!,7Q!&.)'@!*>!5$>?.(>*M-$!:.5!*8?-$8$(&'&*.(!.:!&#$!,5$>*)$(&N>!7'('+$8$(&!D+$()'!
c,7DdA _= !"#$!-'19!.:!$8?#'>*>!.(!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*>!$0?-'*($)!*(!+..)!?'5&H!>'@>!.($!:.58$5!
47S!.::*1*'-H!M@!&#$!:'1&!&#'&!&#$!,7D!8.>&-@!'))5$>>$>!1#5.(*1H!*(&$5('-!')8*(*>&5'&*3$!
8'('+$8$(&!*>>2$>H!>21#!'>!'11.2(&*(+!>@>&$8>H!C.59:.51$!?-'((*(+H!$&1A!"#2>H!&#$5$!*>!-*&&-$!
1'--!:.5!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(!&#$>$!'5$'>!'()!1.(>*)$5'M-$!5..8!:.5!'(!47SR-$)!'+$()'!M$1'2>$!
8.>&!$::.5&>!5$V2*5$!($C!>@>&$8>!'()!'))*&*.('-!5$>.251$>A _]!
!
S@!1.(&5'>&H!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*>!'!1..?$5'&*3$!$::.5&!M@!82-&*?-$!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!&.!C.59!&.+$&#$5!
&.!'1#*$3$!'!1.88.(!.Mf$1&*3$A!D>!X'5.-)!%$*)8'(!?.*(&>!.2&H!GD+$(1*$>!'5$!8.>&!-*9$-@!&.!
M$!C*--*(+!&.!1.--'M.5'&$!'()!($&C.59!C#$(!&#$@!'5$!'+5$$)!.(!1.88.(!.Mf$1&*3$>H!.?$5'&$!
2()$5!&#$!>'8$!-'C>!'()!5$+2-'&*.(>H!'()!).!(.&!1.8?$&$!:.5!>1'51$!5$>.251$>AO _E !
Q.--'M.5'&*.(!*>!&#$!>2Mf$1&!.:!&#*>!?'?$5A!D(!$0'8?-$!.:!1.--'M.5'&*.(!C.2-)!M$!&#$!
)$3$-.?8$(&!.:!*(&$5.?$5'M-$!>&'()'5)>!&#'&!'--.C!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!&.!?..-!&#$*5!'1&*3*&*$>!&.!
'1#*$3$!1.88.(!+.'->A!B$)$5'-!'()!>&'&$!'+$(1*$>H!(.(?5.:*&>H!'()!?5*3'&$!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!
)$3$-.?$)!*(&$5.?$5'M-$!>&'()'5)>H!+.3$5(*(+!15*&*1'-!:'1&.5>!>21#!'>!1'5)!:.58'&!'()!
1.(&$(&H!&.!?$58*&!&#$!$-$1&5.(*1!)$-*3$5@!.:!B..)!%&'8?>A!!!
!
D(.&#$5!+..)!$0'8?-$!*>!&#$!,7QN>!)$3$-.?8$(&!*(!;<<<!.:!B*5>&L.3A+.3H!'!1.88.(!
?.5&'-!c>$$!CCCAB*5>&L.3A+.3d!&#'&!2>$5>!.:!82-&*?-$!+.3$5(8$(&!?5.+5'8>!1'(!'11$>>!&.!
.M&'*(!*(:.58'&*.(!&#5.2+#!2>$!.:!'(!$::$1&*3$!>$'51#!$(+*($A!G"#$!,7Q!5$1.+(*6$)!&#$!
($$)!&.!&#*(9!)*::$5$(&-@!'M.2&!&#$!.??.5&2(*&*$>!'::.5)$)!M@!&$1#(.-.+@!'()!C'(&$)!&.!
8'9$!+.3$5(8$(&!>$53*1$>!'()!&5'(>'1&*.(>!'3'*-'M-$H!(.&!M@!&#$!&5')*&*.('-!>&.3$?*?$)!
'+$(1@!.5!)$?'5&8$(&H!M2&!M@!($$)g*(!'!:'>&H!5$-*'M-$!C'@AO _^!
_[! /2+$($! S'5)'1#H! @+220'1# R1+'A0+,# 2%# Q%6-# D%1+2&+6H! S5..9*(+>! P(>&*&2&*.(! ,5$>>H! _^^EH! ?A! Eh! LD4H! <+,=?2,V
N60+'2+4#@%;+6'*+'2J#>6)A20A+,#2&)2#A)'#&+?7#K'&)'A+#)'4#:=,2)0'#E%??)!%6)20%'#)*%'1#8+4+6)?#R1+'A0+,H!?A!=A!
_\!%$$H!$A+AH!7'5+'5$&!ZA!b'.H!D&+#>6+,04+'2T,#C)')1+*+'2#E%='A0?J#R'#3*7%62)'2#C)')1+*+'2#3''%;)20%'H!5$?.5&!&.!&#$!
,CQ!/().C8$(&!:.5!&#$!S2>*($>>!.:!L.3$5(8$(&H!T$1$8M$5!;<<<A!
_=!#&&?FiiCCCAC#*&$#.2>$A+.3i5$>2-&>i'+$()'i>1.5$1'5)A#&8-H!'11$>>$)!D2+2>&!]H!;<<]A!!
_]!,$5>.('-!1.882(*1'&*.(H!W'>#*(+&.(H!TQH!D2+2>&!_^H!;<<]A!
_E! X'5.-)! %$*)8'(H! :.5$C.5)! &.! "#.8'>! XA! %&'(&.(! '()! S$(f'8*(! L*(>M$5+H! $)>AH! C)-0'1# @%;+6'*+'2#
C)')1+)!?+H!a.#(>!X.?9*(>!J(*3$5>*&@!,5$>>H!;<<[H!?A!0A
_^!D&+#>6+,04+'2T,#C)')1+*+'2#E%='A0?J#R'#3*7%62)'2#C)')1+*+'2#3''%;)20%'H!?A!_;A!
E
!
D>!TC*+#&!P(9!#'>!C5*&&$(H!&#$!5$1.3$5@!$::.5&!:.5!&#$!D-'>9'!$'5&#V2'9$!.:!_^=[!?5.3*)$>!'!
>&5*9*(+!1.(&5'>&!&.!&#$!>-.C!'()!)*>f.*(&$)!?.>&Re'&5*('!5$1.3$5@!$::.5&!>.8$!:.5&@!@$'5>!
-'&$5A!"#$!D-'>9'!5$1.3$5@!5$-*$)!.(!-$')$5>#*?!5'&#$5!&#'(!>?$1*'-!-$+'-!.5!?5.1$)25'-!)$3*1$>A!
"#$!2>$!.:!1.--'M.5'&*3$!1.2(1*->H!&#'&!&#$8>$-3$>!#')!(.!*()$?$()$(&!'2&#.5*&@!M2&!C$5$!
1#'5+$)!C*&#!:'1*-*&'&*(+!1.--'M.5'&*3$!>.-2&*.(>H!1.(&5*M2&$)!&.!&#$!V2*19!)$1*>*.(R8'9*(+!
'()!5'?*)!'1&*.(>!&#'&!1#'5'1&$5*6$)!&#$!5$1.3$5@A ;<!
!
"#$!T$?'5&8$(&!.:!X.2>*(+!'()!J5M'(!T$3$-.?8$(&!cXJTd!#'>!M2*-&!'!>8'--!'()!$::$1&*3$!
1.--'M.5'&*3$!>@>&$8!1'--$)!QDPIU%H!&#$!Q5$)*&!D-$5&!P(&$5'1&*3$!I.*1$!U$>?.(>$!%@>&$8A!
QDPIU%!?5.3*)$>!'!8.)$-!.:!*(&$5.5+'(*6'&*.('-!1.--'M.5'&*.(!C*&#!?.&$(&*'-!'??-*1'&*.(!&.!
.&#$5!?'5&>!.:!+.3$5(8$(&!>21#!'>!#.8$-'()!>$125*&@!C'&1#!-*>&>A!XJT!)$3$-.?$)!QDPIU%!
*(!&#$!_^E<>!'>!'!)'&'M'>$!&#'&!BXD!-$()$5>!1.2-)!1#$19!&.!)$&$58*($!C#$&#$5!'!M.55.C$5!
#')!)$:'2-&$)!.(!'!?5$3*.2>!BXD!-.'(A!"#$!BXD!-$()$5!C.2-)!$(&$5!M'>*1!*)$(&*:@*(+!
*(:.58'&*.(!'()!5$1$*3$!(.&*:*1'&*.(!$*&#$5!&#'&!&#$5$!C'>!.5!C'>!(.&!'!8'&1#!C*&#!&#$!XJT!
)'&'M'>$!.:!)$:'2-&$)!M.55.C$5>A!P(!&#$!$'5-@!_^^<>H!C.59*(+!2()$5!&#$!'2>?*1$>!.:!&#$!
B$)$5'-!Q5$)*&!,.-*1@!W.59*(+!L5.2?H!'(!*(&$5'+$(1@!1.2(1*-!1#'*5$)!M@!&#$!47S!T$?2&@!
T*5$1&.5!:.5!7'('+$8$(&H!XJT!$0?'()$)!QDPIU%!&.!?$58*&!.&#$5!'+$(1*$>!&.!5$?.5&!
)$-*(V2$(&!(.(&'0!)$M&!'()H!2-&*8'&$-@H!&.!'11$>>!QDPIU%!&.!'>>25$!&#'&!&#$@!C$5$!(.&!
$0&$()*(+!15$)*&!&.!)$:'2-&$)!)$M&.5>!:5.8!.&#$5!?5.+5'8>A!"#*>!*(&$5'+$(1@!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*>!
$>>$(&*'-!&.!'>>25$!&#'&!)$:'2-&$)!)$M&.5>!:5.8!.($!:$)$5'-!?5.+5'8!).!(.&!5$1$*3$!:2()*(+!
:5.8!'!)*::$5$(&!:$)$5'-!'+$(1@!C*&#.2&!>$&&-*(+!&#$*5!.2&>&'()*(+!)$M&>!:*5>&A!XJT!5$?.5&>!
&#'&!QDPIU%!#'>!#$-?$)!XJT!'()!.&#$5!'+$(1*$>!&.!'3.*)!M*--*.(>!.:!).--'5>!*(!?.&$(&*'-!
-.>>$>!.(!-.'(>!&.!)$:'2-&$)!M.55.C$5>!C#.!>.2+#&!&.!.M&'*(!($C!:$)$5'-!15$)*&A!!
!
P(!*8?5.3*(+!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'8.(+!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!'()!C*&#!.&#$5!.5+'(*6'&*.(>H!&#$!
'11.2(&'M*-*&@!.:!'(@!($C!'55'(+$8$(&>!82>&!M$!1.(>*)$5$)A!P(&$5.5+'(*6'&*.('-!
1.--'M.5'&*.(!82>&!M$!).($!C*&#.2&!C$'9$(*(+!.5!M-255*(+!&#$!'11.2(&'M*-*&@!.:!+.3$5(8$(&!
'+$(1*$>!&.!>?$()!?2M-*1!5$>.251$>!C*>$-@!&.!1'55@!.2&!&#$*5!8*>>*.(>A!,5.M-$8>!15$'&$)!M@!
*(15$'>$)!*(&$5'+$(1@!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(!2()$5&'9*(+!:$)$5'-!?5.125$8$(&H!C#*1#!&#$!LD4!#'>!
?-'1$)!.(!*&>!#*+#R5*>9!-*>&H!>&'()!'>!C'5(*(+>!*(!&#*>!5$+'5)A!W#*-$!&#$!*)$'!.:!)$3$-.?*(+!
>?$1*'-*6$)!?5.125$8$(&!1$(&$5>!&.!>$53$!82-&*?-$!'+$(1*$>!*>!'&&5'1&*3$!*(!&#$!'M>&5'1&H!&#$!
1.(&5'1&*(+!'+$(1*$>!&..!.:&$(!:'*-$)!&.!8'*(&'*(!?5.?$5!'11.2(&'M*-*&@!.:!&#$!1.(&5'1&.5>!
&#'&!&#$@!#*5$)!&#*>!C'@A ;_ !!
#
Laws to Mandate Improved Collaboration
!
;<!TC*+#&!P(9H!G7'('+*(+!Q#'(+$!&#'&!7'9$>!'!T*::$5$(1$HO!1#'?&$5!]!*(!"#.8'>!XA!%&'(&.(H!$)AH!C++20'1#2&+#
E&)??+'1+#%F#GHIIJ#B?=+760'2,#F%6#KFF+A20;+#@%;+6'*+'2H!7A/A!%#'5?$!,2M-*>#$5>H!;<<=A!!
4(!&#$!V2$>&*.(!.:!)$:*(*&*.(H!P(9!C5*&$>H!GP(!8@!3*$CH!:5.8!'!-$+'-!>&'()?.*(&!j&#$!D-'>9'!5$1.3$5@!$::.5&k!C'>!
821#! 8.5$! 1.--'M.5'&*.(! &#'(! 1..5)*('&*.(H! @$&! *&! C'>! 3*$C$)! '()! ?$5:.58$)! 821#! 8.5$! -*9$! '! 1'>$! .:!
1..5)*('&*.(A!!"#*>!*>!M$1'2>$!.:!&#$!2(*V2$!.5+'(*6'&*.(!'()!&#$!2(?5$1$)$(&$)!8'('+$8$(&!>&5'&$+*$>!2>$)A!
"#$! 5$-*'(1$! .(! -$')$5>#*?! 5'&#$5! &#'(! >?$1*'-! -$+'-! .5! ?5.1$)25'-! )$3*1$>! 1.(&5*M2&$)! &.! &#$! V2*19! )$1*>*.(R
8'9*(+!'()!5'?*)!'1&*.(>!&#'&!1#'5'1&$5*6$)!&#$!5$1.3$5@lAj"#$>$!1.--'M.5'&*3$!>&5'&$+*$>k!1$5&'*(-@!C.59$)!*(!
'!3$5@!1#'--$(+*(+!>*&2'&*.(AO!,$5>.('-!1.882(*1'&*.(H!D2+2>&!]H!;<<]A!
;_!%$$H!$A+AH!"$>&*8.(@!.:!T'3*)!7A!W'-9$5H!Q.8?&5.--$5!L$($5'-!.:!&#$!J(*&$)!%&'&$>H!M$:.5$!&#$!Q.88*&&$$!
.(!X.8$-'()!%$125*&@!'()!L.3$5(8$(&'-!D::'*5>H!J(*&$)!%&'&$>!%$('&$H!a2-@!_]H!;<<]H!LD4R<]R_<^E"A
^
%.8$!-$+*>-'&*.(!#'>!>211$>>:2--@!8'()'&$)!*(&$5.5+'(*6'&*.('-!1.--'M.5'&*.(A!"#$!
L.-)C'&$5RY*1#.->!T$?'5&8$(&!.:!T$:$(>$!U$.5+'(*6'&*.(!D1&!.:!_^E=!&5'(>:.58$)!&#$!
a.*(&!Q#*$:>!.:!%&'::!caQ%d!:5.8!'!C$'9!1..5)*('&*(+!M.)@!*(&.!'!>.251$!.:!*(:-2$(1$!&#'&!
1.2-)!?5.8.&$!>$5*.2>!*(&$5>$53*1$!1..?$5'&*.(A!"#$!'1&!'11.8?-*>#$)!&#*>!M@!c_d!*(15$'>*(+!
&#$!aQ%!Q#'*58'(N>!'2&#.5*&@h!c;d!*8?5.3*(+!aQ%!>&'::!V2'-*&@!M@!5$V2*5*(+!f.*(&!>$53*1$!:.5!
?5.8.&*.(!&.!:-'+!.5!+$($5'-!.::*1$5!5'(9h!'()!c`d!+5'(&*(+!2(*:*$)!'()!>?$1*:*$)!1.8M'&'(&!
1.88'()$5>!cQPYQ>d!*(15$'>$)!'2&.(.8@!'()!'2&#.5*&@!.3$5!&#$*5!f.*(&!:*$-)!1.88'()>A!
4M>$53$5>!'&&5*M2&$!'!>*+(*:*1'(&!*(15$'>$!*(!J(*&$)!%&'&$>!8*-*&'5@!1'?'M*-*&*$>H!*(1-2)*(+!
1.8M*($)!>$53*1$!.?$5'&*.(>!*(!&#$!,$5>*'(!L2-:!W'5H!&.!&#$!_^E=!L.-)C'&$5RY*1#.->!D1&!
'()!&#$!5$:.58!.:!&#$!aQ%A!;; !!!
!
,25>2'(&!&.!&#$!8'()'&$!.:!%$1&*.(!_<__!.:!&#$!P(&$--*+$(1$!U$:.58!'()!"$55.5*>8!
,5$3$(&*.(!D1&!.:!;<<[H!&#$!T*5$1&.5!.:!Y'&*.('-!P(&$--*+$(1$H!C#.!*>!5$>?.(>*M-$!:.5!
?5.8.&*(+!1..?$5'&*.(!'8.(+!P(&$--*+$(1$!Q.882(*&@!cPQd!'+$(1*$>H!').?&$)!&#$!?$5>.(($-!
8.M*-*&@!5$V2*5$8$(&>!.:!&#$!aQ%A!4(!a2($!;=H!;<<]H!&#$!TYP!'((.2(1$)!&#'&!#$!C.2-)!
*8?-$8$(&!&#$!P(&$--*+$(1$!Q.882(*&@N>!Q*3*-*'(!a.*(&!T2&@!,5.+5'8F!!
!
a.*(&!PQ!)2&@!*>!'!1*3*-*'(!?$5>.(($-!5.&'&*.(!>@>&$8!>*8*-'5!&.!
f.*(&!)2&@!*(!&#$!8*-*&'5@A!"#$!*8?-$8$(&*(+!*(>&521&*.(>!5$V2*5$!
f.*(&!)2&@!'>!'!?5$5$V2*>*&$!:.5!?5.8.&*.(!&.!>$(*.5!1*3*-*'(!5'(9!
*(!.5)$5!&.!$(1.25'+$!'()!:'1*-*&'&$!'>>*+(8$(&>!'()!)$&'*->!.:!
?$5>.(($-!&.!('&*.('-!*(&$--*+$(1$!1$(&$5>H!'()!M$&C$$(!$-$8$(&>!
.:!&#$!PQA ;` !!
!!!!
"#$!&#$.5@!.:!*(15$'>$)!8.M*-*&@!*>!&#'&!*&!M.&#!:.>&$5>!'(!2()$5>&'()*(+!.:!&#$!?$5>?$1&*3$>!
.:!.&#$5!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!'()!'->.!15$'&$>!&#$!*(&$5?$5>.('-!5$-'&*.(>#*?>!&#'&!1'(!:'1*-*&'&$!8.5$!
$::$1&*3$!1.--'M.5'&*.(A!,5.3*>*.(>!.:!&#$!P(&$--*+$(1$!U$:.58!'()!"$55.5*>8!,5$3$(&*.(!D1&!
.:!;<<[!&.!?5.8.&$!*(&$5'+$(1@!8.M*-*&@!'5$!?5$>$(&$)!'>!D??$()*0!DA!!
!
W#*-$!M.&#!&#$!;<<[!'1&!'()!&#$!L.-)C'&$5RY*1#.->!D1&!C$5$!)*::*12-&!&.!$('1&H!>21#!
-$+*>-'&*.(!1'(!+5$'&-@!*8?5.3$!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'15.>>!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!M.2()'5*$>A!D(.&#$5!&@?$!
.:!-$+*>-'&*.(!&#'&!8'@!?5.8.&$!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'15.>>!'+$(1*$>!*>!'!-'C!&#'&!?$58*&>!.5!
8'()'&$>!?..-*(+!.:!M2)+$&!5$>.251$>A!"#$!LD4!(.&$>!.($!>21#!$0'8?-$H!C#$5$!'!;<<;!-'C!
5$V2*5$)!&#$!T$?'5&8$(&>!.:!T$:$(>$!cT4Td!'()!I$&$5'(>!D::'*5>!cIDd!&.!8'9$!'!
8*(*828!1.(&5*M2&*.(!.:!m!_\!8*--*.(!'((2'--@!:.5!:.25!@$'5>!&.!:2()!'!f.*(&!?5.+5'8!&.!
>#'5$!#$'-&#!5$>.251$>A ;[ !"#'&!$::.5&!1.(&*(2$>H!M2&!&#$!?5.1$>>!.:!1.(:.58*(+!T4T!'()!
ID!#$'-&#!>@>&$8>!>.!&#'&!>.-)*$5>!1'(!8'9$!'!>$'8-$>>!&5'(>*&*.(!:5.8!.($!>@>&$8!&.!&#$!
.&#$5H!1.(&*(2$>!&.!?5.+5$>>!.(-@!>-.C-@A ;\ !D!8.5$!1.8?5$#$(>*3$!-$+*>-'&*3$!'??5.'1#!*>!&#$!
$>&'M-*>#8$(&!.:!'!a.*(&!,-'((*(+!'()!T$3$-.?8$(&!4::*1$!&.!1..5)*('&$!'()!?-'(!:.5!'!
;;!D8@!SA!n$+'5&H!8?)/+4#!"#.+,01'J#D&+#K;%?=20%'#%F#2&+#E3RS#$E:S#)'4#L:EH!%&'(:.5)H!QDF!%&'(:.5)!J(*3$5>*&@!
,5$>>H!_^^^H!??A!_[<R_\_A!!
;`!4::*1$!.:!&#$!T*5$1&.5!.:!Y'&*.('-!P(&$--*+$(1$H!GT*5$1&.5!71Q.(($--!%*+(>!P(>&521&*.(>!&.!P8?-$8$(&!a.*(&!
T2&@HO!4TYP!Y$C>!U$-$'>$!Y.A!_]R<]H!a2($!;=H!;<<]A!!
;[!<+,=?2,VN60+'2+4#@%;+6'*+'2J#>6)A20A+,#2&)2#A)'#&+?7#K'&)'A+#)'4#:=,2)0'#E%??)!%6)20%'#)*%'1#8+4+6)?#R1+'A0+,H!?A!^A!"#$!
LD4! '->.! ?.*(&>! .2&! c'&! ?A! _<d! >2M>&'(&*'-! .M>&'1-$>H! *(1-2)*(+! )*3$5+$(&! >@>&$8>! '()! ?5.1$>>$>H! &.! $::$1&*3$!
#$'-&#!5$>.251$!>#'5*(+!M$&C$$(!&#$!&C.!)$?'5&8$(&>A!
;\!L.3$5(8$(&!D11.2(&'M*-*&@!4::*1$H!K?+A26%'0A#5+)?2&#<+A%64,J#WR#)'4#.N.#5);+#3'A6+),+4#D&+06#:&)60'1#NF#
5+)?2&##3'F%6*)20%'S#B=2#C%6+#Q%6-#<+*)0',H!LD4R<ER^\[H!a2-@!;<<EA
_<
&5'(>*&*.(!:5.8!&.)'@N>!'*5!&5'::*1!1.(&5.-!>@>&$8!&.!'!($0&!+$($5'&*.(!'*5!&5'(>?.5&'&*.(!
>@>&$8A!"#'&!-$+*>-'&*.(!*(1-2)$>!?5.3*>*.(>!:.5!*(&$5'+$(1@!?..-*(+!.:!5$>.251$>!*(!C'@>!&#'&!
'5$!>&*--!M$*(+!)$3$-.?$)A ;= !!!!!
!!
W#*-$!&#$5$!'5$!?.>*&*3$!$0'8?-$>H!8'(@!+.3$5(8$(&C*)$!$::.5&>!'&!?5.8.&*(+!1.--'M.5'&*.(!
#'3$!(.&!:'5$)!C$--!.3$5!&*8$A!"#$!%$(*.5!/0$12&*3$!%$53*1$!c%/%d!C'>!$0?$1&$)!&.!?$58*&!
'()!$(1.25'+$!)$3$-.?8$(&!.:!'!1')5$!.:!?5.:$>>*.('-!8'('+$5>!C#.!C.2-)!5.&'&$!'8.(+!
82-&*?-$!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>A!"#'&!C.2-)!:'1*-*&'&$!').?&*.(!.:!*8?5.3$)!?5'1&*1$>!:5.8!.&#$5!
'+$(1*$>!'()!'->.!C.2-)!1.(&5*M2&$!&.!'!M5.')$5!?$5>?$1&*3$!:.5!>$(*.5!:$)$5'-!8'('+$5>A!
X.C$3$5H!&#*>!)*)!(.&!#'??$(A!D!_^^^!>253$@!M@!&#$!4::*1$!.:!,$5>.(($-!7'('+$8$(&!*(!
1.(f2(1&*.(!C*&#!&#$!%$(*.5!/0$12&*3$!D>>.1*'&*.(!>#.C$)!&#'&!.3$5!^<!?$51$(&!.:!'--!%/%!
8$8M$5>!#')!(.&!8.3$)!M$&C$$(!'+$(1*$>!>*(1$!M$1.8*(+!>$(*.5!$0$12&*3$>A!"C.R&#*5)>!
#')!(.&!8.3$)!M$&C$$(!1.8?.($(&>!.:!'!>*(+-$!'+$(1@A ;] !!
!
,.-*1@8'9$5>!>.8$&*8$>!&5@!&.!2>$!5$.5+'(*6'&*.(!&.!?5.8.&$!*8?5.3$)!1.--'M.5'&*.(A!
U$.5+'(*6'&*.(!*>!'!1-28>@!&..-H!'&!M$>&H!:.5!&#*>!?25?.>$A!,5.M-$8>!.:!?..5!1.--'M.5'&*.(!
.:&$(!'::$1&!'+$(1*$>!C*&#*(!&#$!>'8$!$0$12&*3$!)$?'5&8$(&H!>21#!'>!&#$!T$?'5&8$(&!.:!
X.8$-'()!%$125*&@!cTX%dA!W#$(!#$!>&2)*$)!?5.M-$8>!.:!1.882(*1'&*.(>!'15.>>!&#$!
M.2()'5*$>!.:!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!C*&#*(!TX%H!7*1#'$-!7'11.M@!:.2()!&#'&H!&#$!G$'>@!?'5&!C'>!&.!
*(>&'--!1.882(*1'&*.(!&$1#(.-.+@A!"#$!#'5)!?'5&!C'>!+$&&*(+!?$.?-$!&.!1.882(*1'&$!*(!'!
&*8$-@!C'@AO ;E !7'11.M@!1.(&$()>!&#'&!$::$1&*3$!1.--'M.5'&*3$!-$')$5>#*?!'()!'!12-&25$!.:!
1.--'M.5'&*.(!'5$!:'5!8.5$!*8?.5&'(&!&#'(!8$5$!>&521&25'-!'??5.'1#$>!>21#!'>!5$.5+'(*6'&*.(A!
TX%!C.2-)!M$($:*&!:5.8!)$3$-.?*(+!'!12-&25$!&#'&!3'-2$>!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'()!:5.8!&5'*(*(+!
'()!+5.C*(+!-$')$5>!'()!8'('+$5>!M'>$)!.(!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'>!'!1.5$!3'-2$!'()!?$5:.58'(1$!
15*&$5*.(A!!
!
An Agenda for Improved Collaboration Across Organizational
Boundaries
!
X.C!1'(!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!+'*(!*(1$(&*3$>!&.!1.--'M.5'&$!C*&#!.&#$5!.5+'(*6'&*.(>o!7'(@!
M2)+$&!'()!?$5>.(($-!&..->!'-5$')@!$0*>&H!M2&!-$')$5>#*?!:5.8!&#$!&.?!.:!+.3$5(8$(&!*>!
($$)$)!&.!8'9$!&#$8!C.59A!
!
47S!1.2-)!15$'&$!'()!-$')!($C!*(&$5'+$(1@!1.2(1*->H!:.5!*(>&'(1$A!"#$>$!1.2-)!M$!>*8*-'5!&.!
&#$!B$)$5'-!Q5$)*&!,.-*1@!W.59*(+!L5.2?H!&.!?5.8.&$!1.--'M.5'&*3$!$::.5&>!&.!'))5$>>!
1.88.(!?5.M-$8>A!D:&$5!e'&5*('H!&#$5$!*>!'!1-$'5!($$)!:.5!*8?5.3$)!*(&$5'+$(1@!
1.--'M.5'&*.(!M.&#!&.!'))5$>>!&#$!1255$(&!5$1.(>&521&*.(!$::.5&!'()!&.!?-'(!:.5!'!:2&25$!
1'&'>&5.?#$A!%21#!1.2(1*->!'->.!8'@!($$)!&.!*(1-2)$!5$?5$>$(&'&*3$>!:5.8!>&'&$!'()!-.1'-!
+.3$5(8$(&>H!(.(?5.:*&>H!'()!:.5R?5.:*&!1.8?'(*$>A!4($!>21#!1.2(1*-!8*+#&!'))5$>>!&#$!
)$-*3$5@!.:!$8$5+$(1@!M$($:*&>!$-$1&5.(*1'--@A!"#*>!1.2(1*-!C.2-)!*(1-2)$!>$(*.5!8'('+$5>!
:5.8!B/7D!'()!L%D!'>!C$--!'>!5$?5$>$(&'&*3$>!:5.8!'+$(1*$>!&#'&!?5.3*)$!$8$5+$(1@!
;=!L.3$5(8$(&!D11.2(&'M*-*&@!4::*1$H!L+X2#@+'+6)20%'#R06#D6)',7%62)20%'#:",2+*J#>6%16+,,#)'4#E&)??+'1+,#R,,%A0)2+4#
/02&#.+;+?%7*+'2#%F#2&+#L)20%')?#R06,7)A+#:",2+*H!LD4R<]R;\H!Y.3$8M$5!;<<=A!!!
;]! 4::*1$! .:! ,$5>.(($-! 7'('+$8$(&H! G_^^^! %253$@! .:! &#$! %$(*.5! /0$12&*3$! %$53*1$HO! '3'*-'M-$! '&!
#&&?FiiCCCA.?8A+.3i>$>i>`<A'>?H!'11$>>$)!.(!D2+2>&!;H!;<<]A!
;E!7*1#'$-!7'11.M@H!G"#$!7'(@!Q2-&25$>!.:!L.3$5(8$(&HO!1#'?&$5!^!*(!"#.8'>!XA!%&'(&.(H!$)AH!C++20'1#2&+#
E&)??+'1+#%F#GHIIJ#B?=+760'2,#F%6#KFF+A20;+#@%;+6'*+'2H!7A/A!%#'5?$!,2M-*>#$5>H!;<<=A
__
M$($:*&>F!&#$!T$?'5&8$(&>!.:!Z'M.5!c2($8?-.@8$(&!M$($:*&>dH!X$'-&#!'()!X28'(!%$53*1$>!
c"$8?.5'5@!D>>*>&'(1$!:.5!Y$$)@!B'8*-*$>H!.5!"DYBH!M$($:*&>dH!D+5*12-&25$!cB..)!%&'8?>H!
'(!$0*>&*(+!$-$1&5.(*1!?5.+5'8H!'()!WPQH!M$($:*&>!:.5!W.8$(H!P(:'(&>!'()!Q#*-)5$(dH!'()!
.&#$5>A ;^ !!
!
"#$!1.2(1*->!1.2-)!M5*(+!&.+$&#$5!82-&*?-$!'+$(1*$>!&#'&!C.2-)!M$($:*&!:5.8!1.--'M.5'&*.(H!
>.8$&*8$>!'-.(+!C*&#!>&'&$H!-.1'-H!'()!?5*3'&$!?'5&($5>H!2()$5!&#$!'2>?*1$>!.:!'(!47S!&#'&!
1.2-)!$0$51*>$!?$5>2'>*.(!&.!:.>&$5!>21#!1.--'M.5'&*.(h!&#$!)5'CM'19!*>!&#'&!>21#!1.2(1*->!
5$V2*5$!1.(&*(2*(+!47S!-$')$5>#*?!&.!8'*(&'*(!8.8$(&28A!"#$!)$8*>$!.:!&#$!B$)$5'-!
Q5$)*&!,.-*1@!W.59*(+!L5.2?!>&'()>!'>!'!C'5(*(+F!'-&#.2+#!&#$!1.2(1*-!'1#*$3$)!>*+(*:*1'(&!
5$>2-&>H!*&!)*>'??$'5$)!'>!.&#$5!?5*.5*&*$>!'&&5'1&$)!47SN>!-$')$5>#*?A!Q.2(1*-!-$')$5>#*?!
?-'1$>!)$8'()>!.(!&*8$!'()!'&&$(&*.(!:5.8!47S!.::*1*'->!C#.!'5$!$::$1&*3$!1.--'M.5'&*3$!
-$')$5>A!".!M$!$::$1&*3$!'15.>>!82-&*?-$!1.2(1*->H!47S!C.2-)!($$)!&.!*(15$'>$!&#$!>&'::H!'()!
$>?$1*'--@!>$(*.5!47S!8'('+$5>!C#.!'5$!$::$1&*3$!1.--'M.5'&*3$!-$')$5>H!'3'*-'M-$!&.!&#$!
T$?2&@!T*5$1&.5!:.5!7'('+$8$(&A!"#$>$!?$.?-$!&#$(!1.2-)!$>&'M-*>#H!8'*(&'*(H!'()!-$')!c.5!
>2??.5&!&#$!-$')$5>#*?!.:d!&#$!1.2(1*->A!!
!
D(!'))*&*.('-!'??5.'1#!C.2-)!M$!:.5!47S!&.!5'&$!'+$(1*$>!?$5#'?>!'((2'--@H!.5!8'@M$!$3$(!
V2'5&$5-@H!'11.5)*(+!&.!&#$*5!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'15.>>!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!M.2()'5*$>A!%21#!'!5'&*(+!
8*+#&!M$!M'>$)!.(!15*&$5*'!>21#!'>!&#$!:.--.C*(+F!
!
_A &#$!$0&$(&!&#'&!&#$!'+$(1@!').?&>!?5.8*>*(+!?5'1&*1$>!:5.8!.&#$5!'+$(1*$>H!>&'&$!'()!
-.1'-!+.3$5(8$(&H!.5!&#$!?5*3'&$!>$1&.5!
;A &#$!$0&$(&!&#'&!&#$!'+$(1@!>#'5$>!?5.8*>*(+!?5'1&*1$>!'()!.&#$5!>2??.5&!c>21#!'>!
XJTN>!>#'5*(+!.:!QDPIU%d!C*&#!.&#$5!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!
`A &#$!$0&$(&!&#'&!&#$!'+$(1@!').?&>!'()!'??-*$>!$::$1&*3$!?$5:.58'(1$!8$'>25$>!:.5!
1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(!*&>!>&5'&$+*1!'()!?$5:.58'(1$!?-'(>!'()!*(!?$5:.58'(1$!15*&$5*'!:.5!
>$(*.5!$0$12&*3$>!'()!.&#$5!8'('+$5>!
[A &#$!5$>2-&>!.:!'(!'((2'-!`=<!)$+5$$!5$3*$C!.:!&#$!'+$(1@H!*(1-2)*(+!&#$!3*$C>!.:!.&#$5!
'+$(1*$>H!>&'&$!'()!-.1'-!+.3$5(8$(&>H!'()!?5*3'&$!.5+'(*6'&*.(>H!'>!&.!&#$!?$51$?&*.(!
&#'&!&#$!'+$(1@!1.--'M.5'&$>!C*--*(+-@!'()!2>$:2--@!!
!
".!'3.*)!+'8*(+!.:!&#$!>@>&$8H!47S!C*--!($$)!&.!>152&*(*6$!'+$(1@!1-'*8>!&.!'>>25$!&#'&!
1.--'M.5'&*.(!*>!&'9*(+!?-'1$!*(!#*+#R?5*.5*&@!'5$'>!&#'&!'1&2'--@!?5.)21$!8.5$!?2M-*1!3'-2$!
&#'(!C#$(!&#$!'+$(1@!'()!*&>!?'5&($5>!'1&!'-.($A!47S!$0'8*($5>!'->.!C*--!($$)!&.!$0$51*>$!
5$>&5'*(&!>.!&#'&!'+$(1*$>!&#'&!1.--'M.5'&$!).!(.&!:$'5!&#'&!47S!C*--!5$)21$!&#$*5!M2)+$&!
5$>.251$>!&.!5$:-$1&!?2&'&*3$!>'3*(+>A!!!!
!
D!5'&*(+!>@>&$8!>*8*-'5!&.!&#$!5'&*(+!>@>&$8!*8?-$8$(&$)!2()$5!&#$!,5$>*)$(&N>!7'('+$8$(&!
D+$()'H!1.2-)!?5.3*)$!&#$!3$#*1-$H!.5!'&!-$'>&!'!+..)!8.)$-H!:.5!5'&*(+!'+$(1*$>!'()!
5$?.5&*(+!5$>2-&>A `< !Q255$(&-@!'+$(1*$>!'5$!5'&$)!.(!:*3$!*()*1'&.5>F!#28'(!1'?*&'-H!
;^!"#$!,'59!Q*&@!Q$(&$5!:.5!,2M-*1!,.-*1@H!'!(.(?5.:*&!?.-*1@!1$(&$5!1.(>*>&*(+!.:!:.58$5!%&'&$!L.3$5(.5>!'()!
-$')$5>!*(!&#$!M2>*($>>H!'1')$8*1!'()!?#*-'(&#5.?*1!1.882(*&*$>H!#'>!&'9$(!&#$!-$')!*(!1'--*(+!:.5!*8?5.3$)!
1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(!)$-*3$5*(+!$8$5+$(1@!M$($:*&>A!%$$H!#&&?FiiCCCA?'591*&@1$(&$5A.5+iT*>'>&$5D>>*>&'(1$A'>?H!
'11$>>$)!D2+2>&!`H!;<<]A!
`<!"#*>!C'>!>2++$>&$)!M@!&#$!LD4!*(!<+,=?2,VN60+'2+4#@%;+6'*+'2J#>6)A20A+,#2&)2#A)'#&+?7#K'&)'A+#)'4#:=,2)0'#
E%??)!%6)20%'#)*%'1#8+4+6)?#R1+'A0+,H!LD4R<=R_\H!41&.M$5!;_H!;<<\A
_;
1.8?$&*&*3$!>.251*(+H!:*('(1*'-!?$5:.58'(1$H!$R+.3$5(8$(&H!'()!*(&$+5'&*.(!.:!M2)+$&!'()!
?$5:.58'(1$A!"#$>$!'5$!')8*(*>&5'&*3$!'5$'>!C#$5$!*()*3*)2'-!'+$(1@!'1&*.(H!5'&#$5!&#'(!
*(&$5'+$(1@!1.--'M.5'&*.(H!*>!.:&$(!1'--$)!:.5A `_ !P:!&#$!,7D!.5!>.8$&#*(+!-*9$!*&!*>!').?&$)!M@!
'!($C!')8*(*>&5'&*.(H!&#$(!*&!C.2-)!M$!#$-?:2-!&.!*(1-2)$!'!($C!5.M2>&!>$&!.:!15*&$5*'!:.5!
GQ.--'M.5'&*.(AO!!
!
".!#$-?!M2*-)!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(&.!$'1#!'+$(1@N>!12-&25$H!*&!C.2-)!M$!*8?.5&'(&!&.!M2*-)!'!>$&!.:!
8$'>25$>!:.5!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(&.!&#$!%&'()'5)!:.5!/0$12&*3$!/01$--$(1$!&#'&!*>!2>$)!&.!5'&$!
&#$!?$5:.58'(1$!.:!$'1#!'+$(1@N>!>$(*.5!$0$12&*3$>A!"#$!,5$>*)$(&N>!7'('+$8$(&!D+$()'!
2>$)!&#*>!'??5.'1#H!&.!?5.8.&$!*8?-$8$(&'&*.(!.:!&#$!,7D!M@!>$(*.5!$0$12&*3$>A `; !!"#$!
4::*1$!.:!,$5>.(($-!7'('+$8$(&H!M'19$)!2?!M@!47SH!C*--!($$)!&.!?-'@!'!8'f.5!5.-$!*(!
'>>25*(+!$::$1&*3$!*8?-$8$(&'&*.(!.:!1.--'M.5'&*3$!8$'>25$>!'??-*$)!&.!>$(*.5!$0$12&*3$>!'()!
.&#$5!:$)$5'-!8'('+$5>A!
!
D(.&#$5!*(&$5$>&*(+!*)$'!1.8$>!:5.8!7*1#'$-!7.55*>!.:!&#$!S25&.(!S-'&&!P(>&*&2&$!.:!
%@5'12>$!J(*3$5>*&@A `` !%*8*-'5!&.!>.8$!.&#$5!'1')$8*1>H!#$!M$-*$3$>!&#'&!&#$!,5.+5'8!
D>>$>>8$(&!U'&*(+!"..-!c,DU"dH!')8*(*>&$5$)!M@!47SH!8'(*:$>&>!>*+(*:*1'(&!>#.5&1.8*(+>A!
P(!?'5&*12-'5H!$3$(!&#.2+#!,DU"!*(!:'1&!#'>!-$)!&.!1#'(+$>!*(!8'('+$8$(&!'()!.?$5'&*.(!.:!
?5.+5'8>!5'&#$5!&#'(!*(!1#'(+$)!.5!5$)*5$1&$)!:2()*(+H!#$!*>!1.(1$5($)!&#'&!,DU"!8'@!
5$:-$1&!&#$!*(&$5'+$(1@!1.8?$&*&*.(!:.5!>1'51$!:$)$5'-!5$>.251$>!&#'&!*>!*(#$5$(&!*(!&#$!M2)+$&!
?5.1$>>A!W#@!(.&H!#$!>2++$>&>H!2>$!&#$!,DU"!'>!'!&..-!&.!$(1.25'+$!1.--'M.5'&*.(!M@!:$)$5'-!
'+$(1*$>!'15.>>!&#$*5!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!M.2()'5*$>o!!!
!
P(!1.(&5'>&!&.!&#$!,7DH!C#*1#!:.12>$>!-'5+$-@!.(!')8*(*>&5'&*3$!8'('+$8$(&!8'&&$5>H!,DU"!
'??-*$>!)*5$1&-@!&.!?5.+5'8>!'()!?5.+5'8!?$5:.58'(1$A!4($!,DU"!V2$>&*.(H!V2$>&*.(!`A\H!
).$>!'>9H!GT.$>!&#$!?5.+5'8!1.--'M.5'&$!'()!1..5)*('&$!$::$1&*3$-@!C*&#!5$-'&$)!?5.+5'8>oO!
X.C$3$5H!&#$!C'@!&#'&!,DU"!1255$(&-@!'))5$>>$>!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*>!V2*&$!-*8*&$)H!'()!&#2>!(.&!
'>!2>$:2-!'>!*&!1.2-)!M$!*:!1.--'M.5'&*.(!C$5$!+*3$(!'!#*+#$5!?5*.5*&@A!
!
"#$!,DU"!?5.1$>>!8'@!(.&!>253*3$!'!1#'(+$!.:!')8*(*>&5'&*.(H!'&!-$'>&!*(!*&>!1255$(&!:.58A!
Y.&!.(-@!#'3$!>.8$!'+$(1*$>!'()!'1')$8*1>!15*&*1*6$)!*&H!M2&!8'(@!*(!47S!'5$!1.(1$5($)!
'M.2&!&#$!$0&$(>*3$!>&'::!5$>.251$>!&#'&!'5$!5$V2*5$)!&.!')8*(*>&$5!&#$!,DU"!?5.1$>>H!
1.8?'5$)!&.!&#$!?$51$*3$)!M$($:*&>A!P:!,DU"!1'55*$>!.3$5!&.!'!($C!')8*(*>&5'&*.(!*(!>.8$!
:.58H!&#$(!*&!C.2-)!?5.3*)$!'(!$01$--$(&!3$#*1-$!:.5!5'&*(+!'+$(1*$>!.(!&#$*5!1.--'M.5'&*.(A!
U.M2>&!8$'>25$>!&#'&!5'&$!'+$(1*$>!.(!&#$*5!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(!*8?.5&'(&!'5$'>H!.3$5>$$(!M@!
47SH!1'(!*8?5.3$!:$)$5'-!'+$(1@!?5'1&*1$>!'()!.3$5!&*8$!1'(!#$-?!&.!*(>&*--!3'-2$>!'()!
12-&25$>!.:!1.--'M.5'&*.(A!!
!
"#$5$!*>!.($!-*9$-@!$01$?&*.(!&.!&#$!>?$1&528!.:!'+$(1*$>!&#'&!8*+#&!*8?5.3$!1.--'M.5'&*.(!
.(!&#$!M'>*>!.:!-$')$5>#*?!:5.8!47SA!"#$>$!'5$!&#$!('&*.('-!>$125*&@!'+$(1*$>A!47S!).$>!
(.&!'??$'5!&.!?-'@!($'5-@!'>!>*+(*:*1'(&!'!5.-$!C*&#!5$>?$1&!&.!&#$!('&*.('-!>$125*&@!'+$(1*$>!'>!
`_! P(! '))*&*.(H! &#$! ,7D! 1'-->! :.5! *(15$'>$)! 1..5)*('&*.(! .:! ID! '()! T$?'5&8$(&! .:! T$:$(>$! 8$)*1'-! 1'5$!
?5.+5'8>!'()!>@>&$8>H!'()!'!1..5)*('&$)!>#*:&!*(!.3$5>$'>!?5$>$(1$!.:!&#$!T$?'5&8$(&!.:!%&'&$!'()!.&#$5!JA%A!
'+$(1*$>A!
`;!4::*1$!.:!,$5>.(($-!7'('+$8$(&H!:2)'4)64#F%6#KX+A=20;+#KXA+??+'A+H!!4,7!B.58!_=\`H!B$M52'5@!;<<;A!
``! U$8'59>! .:! 7*1#'$-! 7.55*>H! 7'('+*(+! T*5$1&.5H! S25&.(! S-'&&! P(>&*&2&$H! %@5'12>$! J(*3$5>*&@H! '&! &#$! PS7!
P(&$5('&*.('-!%.1*'-!%$53*1$>!B.528H!a2($!\H!;<<]H!S'-&*8.5$H!7'5@-'()A!LD4!'->.!8'9$>!&#*>!5$1.88$()'&*.(!
*(H!<+,=?2,VN60+'2+4#@%;+6'*+'2J#>6)A20A+,#2&)2#A)'#&+?7#K'&)'A+#)'4#:=,2)0'#E%??)!%6)20%'#)*%'1#8+4+6)?#R1+'A0+,A
_`
*&!).$>!.(!&#$!).8$>&*1!>*)$!.:!+.3$5(8$(&A!P(!#$5!1'5$:2-!'('-@>*>!.:!&#$!$>&'M-*>#8$(&!'()!
$3.-2&*.(!.:!8'f.5!('&*.('-!>$125*&@!'+$(1*$>H!*(1-2)*(+!&#$!a.*(&!Q#*$:>!.:!%&'::H!Y'&*.('-!
%$125*&@!Q.2(1*-H!'()!Q$(&5'-!P(&$--*+$(1$!D+$(1@H!D8@!n$+'5&!).$>!(.&!5$:$5!$3$(!.(1$!&.!
47SA `[ !W#*-$!&#$!Y'&*.('-!%$125*&@!Q.2(1*-H!&#'(9>!&.!*&>!?.>*&*.(!*(!&#$!/0$12&*3$!4::*1$!
.:!&#$!,5$>*)$(&!c/4,d!8'@!#'3$!>.8$!'M*-*&@!&.!-$')!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'8.(+!&#$!('&*.('-!
>$125*&@!'+$(1*$>!'()!C*&#!.2&>*)$!.5+'(*6'&*.(>H!&#$!?.&$(&*'-!$::$1&*3$($>>!.:!>21#!
-$')$5>#*?!*>!(.&!'>!'??'5$(&!'>!:.5!47S!3*>RpR3*>!).8$>&*1!'+$(1*$>A `\ !!!
!
Changing Organizational Cultures to Promote Collaboration
!
"#$!&#$>*>!.:!&#*>!?'?$5!*>!&#'&!*(15$'>$)!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*>!'(!$>>$(&*'-!?'5&!.:!M2*-)*(+!8.5$!
1'?'M-$!+.3$5(8$(&!&.!5$>?.()!&.!'!?-$&#.5'!.:!1#'(+*(+!1*5128>&'(1$>!&#'&!5'*>$!?5.M-$8>!
&#'&!'!>*(+-$!:$)$5'-!'+$(1@!1'((.&!'))5$>>!M@!*&>$-:A!"#$5$!'5$!+..)!5$'>.(>!C#@!8'(@!
'+$(1*$>!($+-$1&!1.--'M.5'&*.(A!"#$!?5$>>25$!.:!1.8?$&*&*.(!:.5!f25*>)*1&*.(!'8.(+!
1.(+5$>>*.('-!1.88*&&$$>!'()!>2M1.88*&&$$>!'()!&#$*5!1.(>&*&2$(1*$>!*>!'!8'f.5!*(:-2$(1$!
.(!&#$!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!12-&25$!.:!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!&#'&!)$?$()!.(!&#$>$!1.88*&&$$>!'()!
1.(>&*&2$(1*$>!:.5!&#$*5!5$>.251$>A `= !D>!.($!$0?$5*$(1$)!.M>$53$5!(.&$>F!!
!
D+$(1*$>!#'3$!>?$1*:*1!-$+*>-'&*3$!8'()'&$>!C#*1#!'5$!?.-*1$)!M@!
?.C$5:2-!*(&$5$>&!+5.2?>!'()!.:&$(!3$5@!('55.C-@!:.12>$)!
1.(+5$>>*.('-!1.88*&&$$>!'()!>2M1.88*&&$$>A!P:!&#$@!M$-*$3$!&#'&!
*(!'&&$8?&*(+!>.8$!:.58!.:!1.--'M.5'&*.(H!&#$!'+$(1@!*>!
($+-$1&*(+!*&>!?5*8$!?25?.>$>H!&#$!'+$(1@!C*--!>..(!#$'5!'M.2&!*&!
*(!(.!2(1$5&'*(!&$58>H!.:&$(!*(!&#$!1.(&$0&!.:!&#5$'&>!&.!5$)21$!
5$>.251$>A `]!
!
D->.H!1.--'M.5'&*.(!.:&$(!5$V2*5$>!-.(+$5!&$58!'1&*3*&@H!*(1-2)*(+!)$3$-.?*(+!.:!5$-'&*.(>#*?>!
C*&#!?$.?-$!.2&>*)$!.:!.($N>!.C(!'+$(1@H!&#'(!8'@!M$!$'>*-@!?.>>*M-$!:.5!&#$!8'(@!:$)$5'-!
.::*1*'->!C#.!:*()!&#$*5!&*8$!1.(>28$)!M@!15*>$>!.5!&#$!?.>>*M*-*&@!.:!15*>*>A!P(!'))*&*.(H!
'+$(1@!')8*(*>&5'&*3$!>&.3$?*?$>!&#'&!>$?'5'&$!:*('(1*'-!.?$5'&*.(>H!*(:.58'&*.(!&$1#(.-.+@H!
#28'(!1'?*&'-H!'()!.&#$5!:2(1&*.(>!1'(!*8?$)$!&#$!'M*-*&@!.:!8'('+$5>!&.!1.--'M.5'&$!
$::$1&*3$-@!C*&#*(!&#$!>'8$!)$?'5&8$(&!.5!'+$(1@A `E !!
!
Z$+*>-'&*.(!'->.!?-'@>!'!5.-$!&.!&#$!$0&$(&!&#'&!*&!5$:-$1&>!*(&$(&!.:!.??.($(&>!.:!?'5&*12-'5!
+.3$5(8$(&'-!'1&*3*&*$>!&.!:5'+8$(&!'+$(1@!f25*>)*1&*.(!'()!+$($5'--@!?5$3$(&!$::$1&*3$!
*8?-$8$(&'&*.(A `^ !!%.8$!'+$(1*$>!#'3$!.?$5'&$)!'>!5*3'->!:.5!>.!-.(+!&#'&!*&!8'@!M$!)*::*12-&!
`[!8?)/+4#!"#.+,01'J#D&+#K;%?=20%'#%F#2&+#E3RS#$E:S#)'4#L:EH!P()$0A!
`\!a.#(!T$2&1#H!D5(.-)!e'(&$5!'()!S5$(&!%1.C15.:&!c;<<_d!#'3$!5$1.88$()$)!15$'&*.(!.:!'!T$?2&@!Y'&*.('-!
%$125*&@!D)3*>$5!C*&#!'2&#.5*&@!&.!)*5$1&!'+$(1@!*(3$>&8$(&!'()!?5.+5'8!?5*.5*&*$>!*(!*(&$5'+$(1@!'5$'>H!M'19$)!
M@!47S!$(:.51$8$(&A!!!
`=!P()$$)H!*&!#'>!M$$(!&#$!'2&#.5N>!$0?$5*$(1$!&#'&!1.(+5$>>*.('-!1.88*&&$$>!.:&$(!).!&#$*5!M$>&!C.59H!:5.8!'!
?2M-*1!?.-*1@!?$5>?$1&*3$H!'&!&#$!8'5+*(>!.:!&#$*5!f25*>)*1&*.('-!M.2()'5*$>!C*&#!.&#$5!1.88*&&$$>A!
`]! S$5('5)! XA! 7'5&*(H! :.58$5! T$?2&@! D>>.1*'&$! T*5$1&.5H! 47SA! ,$5>.('-! 1.882(*1'&*.(H! W'>#*(+&.(H! TQH!
D2+2>&!`H!;<<]A!
"#! S'5M'5'! %A! W'8>-$@H! G"$1#(.15'1*$>F! Q'(! "#$@! S$--! &#$! Q'&oO! 1#'?&$5! ^! *(! C)-0'1# @%;+6'*+'2# C)')1+)!?+J#
KX+A=20;+#N61)'0M)20%'#)'4#C)')1+*+'2#0'#2&+#YI,2#E+'2=6"H!a.#(>!X.?9*(>!J(*3$5>*&@!,5$>>H!;<<[A!
`^%$$H!$A+AH!"$55@!7A!7.$H!G"#$!,.-*&*1>!.:!S25$'215'&*1!%&521&25$HO!*(!a.#(!/A!Q#2MM!'()!,'2-!/A!,$&$5>.(H!
$)>AH!E)'#2&+#@%;+6'*+'2#@%;+6'Z!W'>#*(+&.(H!TQF!S5..9*(+>!P(>&*&2&*.(!,5$>>H!_^E^A
_[
&.!M5*(+!&#$8!&.!1.--'M.5'&$A!T*::*12-&*$>!'&!TX%!*(!&5@*(+!&.!*(&$+5'&$!12>&.8>!'()!
*88*+5'&*.(>!:2(1&*.(>!:.5!G.($!:'1$!'&!&#$!M.5)$5O!5$:-$1&!)$$?!12-&25'-!'()!?.-*1@!
)*::$5$(1$>!&#'&!1'(!&'9$!@$'5>!&.!.3$51.8$A!!!!!
!
B.5!')8*(*>&5'&*3$!.::*1*'->!C#.!>#'5$!'!1.88.(!12-&25$H!>21#!'>!1#*$:!:*('(1*'-!.::*1$5>H!
1#*$:!*(:.58'&*.(!.::*1$5>H!1#*$:!#28'(!1'?*&'-!.::*1$5>H!.5!*(>?$1&.5>!+$($5'-!.:!)*::$5$(&!
)$?'5&8$(&>!'()!'+$(1*$>H!1.--'M.5'&*.(!1'(!1.8$!('&25'--@A!P&!1'(!M$!8.5$!)*::*12-&H!'()!
>.8$&*8$>!821#!8.5$!)*::*12-&H!&.!.M&'*(!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'8.(+!?5.+5'8!8'('+$5>!:5.8!
)*::$5$(&!.5+'(*6'&*.(>A!"#'&!*>!&#$!M*+!1#'--$(+$A!
!
4(!&#$!.&#$5!#'()H!&#$5$!'5$!*(15$'>*(+!?5$>>25$>!:.5!*8?5.3$)!?5.+5'8!1.--'M.5'&*.(A!
/>?$1*'--@!C*&#!&#$!)$3$-.?8$(&!.:!'!('&*.('-!'()!+-.M'-!$1.(.8@H!8'(@!?5*3'&$!*(&$5$>&!
+5.2?>!#'3$!+'*($)!'(!*(15$'>$)!>&'9$!*(!1.--'M.5'&*.(!M@!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!'15.>>!
.5+'(*6'&*.('-!M.2()'5*$>A!B$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!:5$V2$(&-@!-'+!&#$!?5*3'&$!>$1&.5!*(!&#*>!5$>?$1&A!
"#$!$-$1&5.(*1!)$-*3$5@!.:!B..)!%&'8?>H!'()!1255$(&!$::.5&>!&.!$0?'()!$-$1&5.(*1!)$-*3$5@!.:!
.&#$5!:$)$5'-!'()!>&'&$!M$($:*&>H!#'3$!M$$(!)5*3$(!*(!?'5&!M@!&#$!25+*(+!.:!?5*3'&$!:*('(1*'-!
*(>&*&2&*.(>!&#'&!>$$9!&.!>$53$!'(!*(&$5.?$5'M-$!('&*.('-!8'59$&!5'&#$5!&#'(!'!:5'+8$(&$)!
1.(+$5*$>!.:!>8'--$5!?5.+5'88'&*1!'()!+$.+5'?#*1!f25*>)*1&*.(>A!!
!
B$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!'->.!8'@!-'+!>&'&$!'()!-.1'-!+.3$5(8$(&>H!C#*1#!#'3$!1.--'M.5'&$)!:.5!@$'5>A!
"#2>H!>&'&$>!5$>?.()$)!&.!e'&5*('!M@!*(3.9*(+!&#$!/8$5+$(1@!7'('+$8$(&!D>>*>&'(1$!
Q.8?'1&!c/7DQdH!'!82&2'-!'*)!'+5$$8$(&!&#'&!'--.C$)!&#$!'::$1&$)!>&'&$>!&.!5$V2$>&!
'>>*>&'(1$!:5.8!.&#$5!>&'&$>H!:.5!Y'&*.('-!L2'5)!5$>.251$>H!-'C!$(:.51$8$(&!?$5>.(($-H!
8$)*1'-!&$'8!>2??.5&H!>$'51#!'()!5$>12$!>$53*1$>H!'()!1.88.)*&*$>!>21#!'>!*1$!'()!C'&$5H!
'()!?5.3*)$!5$*8M25>$8$(&!.(1$!&#$!$8$5+$(1@!C'>!.3$5A!%.8$!-.1'-*&*$>!#'3$!M$+2(!&.!
1.?@!&#$!/7DQ!8.)$-H!C#*1#!'??-*$>!.(-@!&.!&#$!>&'&$>H!:.5!&#$*5!.C(!1.--'M.5'&*3$!
5$-'&*.(>A!!!
!
P(!>#.5&H!>.8$!?5$>>25$>!&#'&!?5$3*.2>-@!*()21$)!'+$(1*$>!&.!#.'5)!5$>.251$>!'()!>2??.5&!
&.)'@!'5$!+*3*(+!C'@!&.!'(!$(3*5.(8$(&!C#$5$!*(15$'>$)!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*>!.:&$(!C$-1.8$!*:!
(.&!5$V2*5$)A!J(:.5&2('&$-@H!'+$(1@!12-&25$>!8'@!(.&!#'3$!1#'(+$)!'??5.?5*'&$-@!&.!5$:-$1&!
&#$!.:&$(!1#'(+$)!1.(&$0&A!X.C!&#$(H!1'(!'+$(1@!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!12-&25$!M$!1#'(+$)!&.!
?5.8.&$!&#$!3'-2$!.:!1.--'M.5'&*.(o!
!
"#$!'??-*1'&*.(!M@!47S!.:!'!1.8M*('&*.(!.:!&..->g*(&$5'+$(1@!C.59*(+!+5.2?>!'()!
8.(*&.5*(+!'+$(1@!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'15.>>!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!M.2()'5*$>H!?5$:$5'M-@!-*(9$)!&.!
?$5:.58'(1$!+.'->!'()!.Mf$1&*3$>!:.5!$'1#!:$)$5'-!'+$(1@!'()!&.!?$5:.58'(1$!8$'>25$>!:.5!
>$(*.5!$0$12&*3$>!'()!8'('+$5>gC*--!M$!'(!*8?.5&'(&!M$+*((*(+A!D(!$>?$1*'--@!*8?.5&'(&!
&..-!C*--!M$!:.5!47S!&.!5$C'5)!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'()!5$1.+(*6$!8'('+$5>!'()!'+$(1*$>!&#'&!
1.--'M.5'&$!C$--A!"#$!47S!T$?2&@!T*5$1&.5!:.5!7'('+$8$(&!C*--!($$)!&.!?5$3$(&!
?5$8'&25$!M2)+$&!12&>!M$1'2>$!.:!>'3*(+>!'()!)$>*+('&$!'5$'>!C#$5$!5$3$(2$!>#'5*(+!'8.(+!
'+$(1*$>!1'(!M$!'!#*+#!?5*.5*&@A!!
!
a2>&!'>!*8?.5&'(&!C*--!M$!1'5$:2-!.3$5>*+#&!M@!47S!'()!4,7!.:!&#$!C'@!&#'&!'??-*1'&*.(!.:!
&#$>$!&..->!*8?5.3$>!&#$!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!12-&25$!'&!$'1#!'+$(1@!'()!?5.8.&$>!'!1.--'M.5'&*3$!
.2&-..9A!D>!TC*+#&!P(9!#'>!C5*&&$(F!
!
_\
P!5$+'5)!&#$!>&'&2&.5@!5$>&.5'&*.(!.:!>.8$!>.5&!.:!8'('+$8$(&!1'?'1*&@!*(!
&#$!/4,!c$*&#$5!*(!.5!.2&!.:!47Sd!'>!'!15*&*1'-!>&$?!&.C'5)!$::$1&*3$!'()!
>2>&'*($)!'&&$(&*.(!&.!*(&$5'+$(1@!'()!*(&$5+.3$5(8$(&'-!1..5)*('&*.(!'()!
1.--'M.5'&*.(A!!P!#'3$!M$$(!2('M-$!&.!&#*(9!.:!>.8$&#*(+!&#'&!1'(!5$?-'1$!
*&A!!4($!1'(!)$3$-.?!'--!>.5&>!.:!?.-*1*$>H!'()!*>>2$!'--!9*()>!.:!)*5$1&*3$>!
C*&#.2&!*&H!M2&!8'9*(+!&#$!)*3$5>$!+.3$5(8$(&'-!8'1#*($5@!:2(1&*.(!
$::$1&*3$-@!*>!'!)*::$5$(&!8'&&$5H!$>?$1*'--@!'>!&#$!(28M$5!.:!?.-*&*1'-!
'??.*(&$$>!*(15$'>$>A [< !!
!
P(!.&#$5!C.5)>H!C#*-$!'??-*1'&*.(!.:!&#$!5$1.88$()$)!&..->!M@!47S!1'(!#$-?!&.!*8?5.3$!
1.--'M.5'&*.(!M@!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>H!*&!*>!.(-@!C*&#!'!)$)*1'&$)!>&5'&$+@!.:!-$')$5>#*?!'()!
?5.8.&*(+!12-&25'-!1#'(+$!&#'&!47S!1'(!2>$!&#$!@$'5>!.:!&#$!($0&!')8*(*>&5'&*.(!$::$1&*3$-@!
&.!1#'(+$!&#$!:2()'8$(&'-!)@('8*1>!.:!*(&$5.5+'(*6'&*.('-!1.--'M.5'&*.(!M@!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!
'()!8'('+$5>A!!
!
%$3$5'-!:'1&.5>!1'(!C.59!&.+$&#$5!&.!?5.8.&$!'!12-&25$!.:!1.--'M.5'&*.(!'15.>>!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!
M.2()'5*$>F!
!
x '!($C!C'3$!.:!:$)$5'-!$8?-.@$$>H!>1#..-$)!*(!&#$!P(&$5($&!'+$!'()!8.5$!.?$(!&.!
1.--'M.5'&*.(!&#'(!8'(@!.:!&#$*5!?5$)$1$>>.5>H!1.8*(+!*(&.!+.3$5(8$(&!
x >$(*.5!$0$12&*3$>!C#.>$!#*5*(+H!?5.8.&*.(!'()!5$&$(&*.(!C.2-)!M$!M'>$)!*(!?'5&!.(!
8$'>25$>!.:!&#$*5!1.--'M.5'&*3$!>9*-->!cC#'&!7*1#'$-!7'11.M@!1'-->!G>.:&!>9*-->Od [_ !!
x &#$!?5'1&*1$!.:!'+$(1*$>H!C*&#!-$')$5>#*?!:5.8!47SH!&.!*(15$'>$!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(!
'5$'>!&#'&!?$51$?&*M-@!M$($:*&!&#$*5!*()*3*)2'-!8*>>*.(>!
!
Conclusion
!
P8?5.3$)!1.--'M.5'&*.(!.:!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>!C*&#!>&'&$!'()!-.1'-!+.3$5(8$(&>!'()!?5*3'&$!
>$1&.5!.5+'(*6'&*.(>!#'>!M$1.8$!*8?$5'&*3$A!!D+$(1*$>!&#'&!:'*-!&.!1.--'M.5'&$!8'@!-'19!
15*&*1'-!*(:.58'&*.(!&#'&!?'5&($5>!8'@!M$!'M-$!&.!?5.3*)$A!"#$>$!'+$(1*$>!5*>9!:*()*(+H!*(!
&.)'@N>!&$1#(.-.+@R)5*3$(!'()!1.8?-*1'&$)!$(3*5.(8$(&H!&#'&!&#$!C'@!&#'&!&#$@!?$5:.58!
&#$*5!8*>>*.(>!#'>!M$1.8$!.M>.-$&$A!
!
47S!>&'()>!'&!&#$!'?$0!.:!&#$!/0$12&*3$!S5'(1#A!P&!*>!&#$!.(-@!'+$(1@!&#'&!1255$(&-@!#'>!&#$!
1'?'1*&@!'()!1-.2&!&.!:.>&$5!*8?5.3$)!1.--'M.5'&*.(!M@!:$)$5'-!'+$(1*$>A!S.&#!&#5.2+#!'!
+.3$5(8$(&C*)$!5'&*(+!>@>&$8!'()!M@!$>&'M-*>#*(+!($C!1.2(1*->!&.!?5.8.&$!1.--'M.5'&*.(!*(!
15*&*1'-!'5$'>H!'>!C$--!'>!-$')$5>#*?!&#'&!$0?5$>>$>!*&>$-:!8.5$!+$($5'--@H!&#$!($0&!
')8*(*>&5'&*.(!>#.2-)!2>$!47S!&.!'>>25$!&#'&!+.3$5(8$(&!'+$(1*$>!1.--'M.5'&$!$::$1&*3$-@!
'15.>>!.5+'(*6'&*.('-!M.2()'5*$>A!!
!
!
q!q!q!!
!
[<!TC*+#&!P(9A!,$5>.('-!1.882(*1'&*.(H!W'>#*(+&.(H!TQH!D2+2>&![H!;<<]A!
[_!G"#$!7'(@!Q2-&25$>!.:!L.3$5(8$(&AO!!
_=
.About the Author
$%&'()!*+!,-(.-&.!*>!'!B$--.C!.:!&#$!Q$(&$5!:.5!&#$!%&2)@!.:!D8$5*1'(!L.3$5(8$(&!'&!
a.#(>!X.?9*(>!J(*3$5>*&@A!X$!*>!'!8$8M$5!.:!&#$!M.'5)!.:!)*5$1&.5>!.:!&#$!Y'&*.('-!
D1')$8@!.:!,2M-*1!D)8*(*>&5'&*.(!'()!'!:.58$5!8$8M$5!.:!&#$!:$)$5'-!%$(*.5!/0$12&*3$!
%$53*1$A!!X*>!?2M-*1'&*.(>!*(1-2)$!&C.!M..9>!.(!+.3$5(8$(&R>?.(>.5$)!$(&$5?5*>$>!cL%/>d!
'()!&C.!$)*&$)!M..9>!.(!:$)$5'-!.5+'(*6'&*.(!'()!8'('+$8$(&A!Q.(1$5(>!$0?5$>>$)!*(!D#
:2)2+#%F#<0,-!cX'5?$5Q.--*(>H!_^^_d!#$-?$)!-$')!&.!$('1&8$(&!.:!>$3$5'-!?*$1$>!.:!-$+*>-'&*.(!
'()!&#$!15$'&*.(!.:!'!($C!L%/!5$+2-'&.5A!75A!%&'(&.(N>!SADA!)$+5$$!*>!:5.8!&#$!J(*3$5>*&@!.:!
Q'-*:.5(*'!'&!T'3*>H!7ADA!:5.8!b'-$!J(*3$5>*&@H!'()!aATA!:5.8!&#$!X'53'5)!Z'C!%1#..-A!X$!
*>!:-2$(&!*(!L$58'(!'()!#'>!1.()21&$)!5$>$'51#!*(!>$3$5'-!1.2(&5*$>A!"#$!Y'&*.('-!
D>>.1*'&*.(!.:!Q.2(&*$>!'C'5)$)!#*8!*&>!T*>&*(+2*>#$)!%$53*1$!DC'5)!:.5!#*>!')3.1'1@!.(!
M$#'-:!.:!&#$!*(&$5+.3$5(8$(&'-!?'5&($5>#*?A!
Acknowledgements
!
"#*>!?'?$5!#'>!M$($:*&$)!:5.8!*(>*+#&>!1.(&5*M2&$)!M@!(28$5.2>!:5*$()>!'()!
1.--$'+2$>H!*(1-2)*(+!Q.5'!S$$M$H!U*19!Q*(V2$+5'('H!%&$3$(!Q.#$(H!7255'@!
Q.8'5.CH!L$.5+$!B5$)$5*19>.(H!L$55@!L*(+5*1#H!T'(!L2&&8'(H!TC*+#&!P(9H!
X$5M$5&!a'>?$5H!B5$)$5*19!e'*>$5H!D-!e-*8'(H!7*1#'$-!7'11.M@H!S$5('5)!7'5&*(H!
S521$!71T.C$--H!Q#5*>!7*#8H!e$(!U@)$5H!U.M$5&!%#$'H!7@5'!%#*?-$&&H!".8!
%&'19H!X'5.-)!%&$*(M$5+H!S$5(*1$!%&$*(#'5)&H!D()5$C!J>1#$5H!S'5M'5'!W'8>-$@H!
'()!U.M$5&!W.5-$@A!Y.($!.:!&#$8!1'(!.5!>#.2-)!M$!#$-)!5$>?.(>*M-$!:.5!&#*>!
?'?$5h!C#*-$!+5'&$:2-!:.5!&#$*5!1.--'M.5'&*.(H!&#$!'2&#.5!&'9$>!>.-$!5$>?.(>*M*-*&@!
:.5!&#$!:*('-!?5.)21&A!!
_]
Appendix A
Acronyms Used in This Report
DBTQ!!!
QDPIU%!
QPD! !
QPYQ! !
TX%! !
TYP! !
T4T! !
/7DQ!!
/4,! !
B/7D!!
BXD! !
BY%! !
LD4! !
L%D! !
XJT! !
PQ!
!
aQ%! !
Y%Q! !
47S! !
4,7! !
,DU"! !
,7D! !
,7Q! !
%/%! !
"DYB!!!
ID! !
WPQ! !
D>>*>&'(1$!&.!B'8*-*$>!C*&#!T$?$()$(&!Q#*-)5$(!
XJTN>!Q5$)*&!D-$5&!P(&$5'1&*3$!I.*1$!U$>?.(>$!%@>&$8A!!
Q$(&5'-!P(&$--*+$(1$!D+$(1@!
1.8M'&'(&!1.88'()$5!
T$?'5&8$(&!.:!X.8$-'()!%$125*&@!
T*5$1&.5!.:!Y'&*.('-!P(&$--*+$(1$!
T$?'5&8$(&!.:!T$:$(>$!!
/8$5+$(1@!7'('+$8$(&!D>>*>&'(1$!Q.8?'1&!!
/0$12&*3$!4::*1$!.:!&#$!,5$>*)$(&!!!
B$)$5'-!/8$5+$(1@!7'('+$8$(&!D+$(1@!!!
B$)$5'-!X.2>*(+!D)8*(*>&5'&*.(!!!
B..)!'()!Y2&5*&*.(!%$53*1$H!JA%A!T$?'5&8$(&!.:!D+5*12-&25$!!
L.3$5(8$(&!D11.2(&'M*-*&@!4::*1$!!!
L$($5'-!%$53*1$>!D)8*(*>&5'&*.(!!
T$?'5&8$(&!.:!X.2>*(+!'()!J5M'(!T$3$-.?8$(&!!!
P(&$--*+$(1$!Q.882(*&@!!!
a.*(&!Q#*$:>!.:!%&'::!!
Y'&*.('-!%$125*&@!Q.2(1*-!
4::*1$!.:!7'('+$8$(&!'()!S2)+$&!!!
4::*1$!.:!,$5>.(($-!7'('+$8$(&!
,5.+5'8!D>>$>>8$(&!U'&*(+!"..-!!
,5$>*)$(&N>!7'('+$8$(&!D+$()'!!!
,5$>*)$(&N>!7'('+$8$(&!Q.2(1*-!!
%$(*.5!/0$12&*3$!%$53*1$!!!
"$8?.5'5@!D>>*>&'(1$!:.5!Y$$)@!B'8*-*$>!
T$?'5&8$(&!.:!I$&$5'(>!D::'*5>!!!
%?$1*'-!%2??-$8$(&'-!Y2&5*&*.(!,5.+5'8!:.5!W.8$(H!P(:'(&>!'()!Q#*-)5$(!!
_E
Appendix B
The Director of National Intelligence – Enhanced Personnel
Management
[\#]9:9E#^#_\`aI#<+,7%',0!0?020+,#)'4#)=2&%6020+,#%F#2&+#.06+A2%6#%F#L)20%')?#3'2+??01+'A+!
!
/01!2.%(.345!647)&..40!'(.(84'4.-!!
!
/"1!!
!
/91!"#$!T*5$1&.5!.:!Y'&*.('-!P(&$--*+$(1$!>#'--!?5$>15*M$!8$1#'(*>8>!&.!:'1*-*&'&$!&#$!
5.&'&*.(!.:!?$5>.(($-!.:!&#$!*(&$--*+$(1$!1.882(*&@!&#5.2+#!3'5*.2>!$-$8$(&>!.:!&#$!
*(&$--*+$(1$!1.882(*&@!*(!&#$!1.25>$!.:!&#$*5!1'5$$5>!*(!.5)$5!&.!:'1*-*&'&$!&#$!C*)$>&!?.>>*M-$!
2()$5>&'()*(+!M@!>21#!?$5>.(($-!.:!&#$!3'5*$&@!.:!*(&$--*+$(1$!5$V2*5$8$(&>H!8$&#.)>H!2>$5>H!
'()!1'?'M*-*&*$>A!!
!
/:1!"#$!8$1#'(*>8>!?5$>15*M$)!2()$5!>2M?'5'+5'?#!cDd!8'@!*(1-2)$!&#$!:.--.C*(+F!!
/;1!"#$!$>&'M-*>#8$(&!.:!>?$1*'-!.112?'&*.('-!1'&$+.5*$>!*(3.-3*(+!>$53*1$H!.3$5!&#$!1.25>$!.:!
'!1'5$$5H!*(!8.5$!&#'(!.($!$-$8$(&!.:!&#$!*(&$--*+$(1$!1.882(*&@A!!
/;;1!"#$!?5.3*>*.(!.:!5$C'5)>!:.5!>$53*1$!*(!?.>*&*.(>!2()$5&'9*(+!'('-@>*>!'()!?-'((*(+!.:!
.?$5'&*.(>!*(3.-3*(+!&C.!.5!8.5$!$-$8$(&>!.:!&#$!*(&$--*+$(1$!1.882(*&@A!!
/;;;1!"#$!$>&'M-*>#8$(&!.:!5$V2*5$8$(&>!:.5!$)21'&*.(H!&5'*(*(+H!>$53*1$H!'()!$3'-2'&*.(!:.5!
>$53*1$!*(3.-3*(+!8.5$!&#'(!.($!$-$8$(&!.:!&#$!*(&$--*+$(1$!1.882(*&@A!!
!
/<1!P&!*>!&#$!>$(>$!.:!Q.(+5$>>!&#'&!&#$!8$1#'(*>8>!?5$>15*M$)!2()$5!&#*>!>2M>$1&*.(!>#.2-)H!
&.!&#$!$0&$(&!?5'1&*1'-H!>$$9!&.!)2?-*1'&$!:.5!1*3*-*'(!?$5>.(($-!C*&#*(!&#$!*(&$--*+$(1$!
1.882(*&@!&#$!f.*(&!.::*1$5!8'('+$8$(&!?.-*1*$>!$>&'M-*>#$)!M@!1#'?&$5!`E!.:!&*&-$!_<!'()!
&#$!.&#$5!'8$()8$(&>!8')$!M@!&*&-$!PI!.:!&#$!L.-)C'&$5RY*1#.->!T$?'5&8$(&!.:!T$:$(>$!
U$.5+'(*6'&*.(!D1&!.:!_^E=!c,2M-*1!Z'C!^^r[``dA!!
!
_^