Transition Authority A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Published by: ISBN: 978-9966-21-355-6 © Transition Authority & Electoral Institute for Sustainable Democracy in Africa (EISA), 2013 TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Acronyms ........................................................................................ viii Foreword ..................................................................................................... x Acknowledgement ..................................................................................... xii A. General Background ................................................................................... 1 B. Devolution ................................................................................................... 5 C. Enhancement of Democratic Culture and Accountability ............................................................................................. 7 D. Political Parties in governance ..................................................................... 8 E. Distinctiveness,interdependence and intergovernmental relationships .............................................................................................. 12 F. Public Finance Management ...................................................................... 14 G. The Structure of Government .................................................................... 19 H. The Mandate, role and function of County Government ............................ 22 I. Functions and roles of County Governments ............................................. 23 J. The County Executive ................................................................................. 24 Composition of a County Executive Election, Role and Function of Officers of a County Executive The County Governor The County Executive Committee County Public Service K. The County Assembly ................................................................................. 28 Composition of a County Assembly Election and Nomination of Members of a County Assembly Speaker of a County Assembly The Majority Leader and the Minority Leader of a County Assembly Mandate, Role and Function of a County Assembly iii Management and Administration of a County Assembly The County Assembly Service Board The Clerk and Staff of a County Assembly The Contact of a County Assembly with the National Parliament and County Executive L. Operations of A County Assembly .............................................................. 33 Environment in which a County Assembly Operate Segments/Seasons in the life of a County Assembly The Oath of Allegiance or Affirmation of Allegiance M. The Powers, Privileges and Immunities of A County Assembly ................... 39 Origin of Privilege What is Privilege? Immunity from Legal Proceedings – Freedom of Speech Committee of Privilege Evidence Privilege of Witnesses Sanctions Against False Evidence Courts not to exercise jurisdiction in respect of acts of the Hon. Speaker and Officers of a County Assembly Mechanisms for the Public to Access, Participate in and Oversight a County Assembly N. The Work and Proceedings of A County Assembly ...................................... 44 Work of a County Assembly Proceedings of a County Assembly Orders of the Day and Order of Proceedings Placement of Business on the Order Paper The Votes and Proceedings How a Matter gets on the Order Paper iv Modes of Decision Making Member not obliged to vote Status of the Division – no vote for the Hon. Speaker O. The Practice and Procedure ....................................................................... 52 Content of the Practice and Procedure of a County Assembly In the Chamber – Conduct of Members and the Business The Speaker entering and leaving the Chamber Members entering and leaving the Chamber Papers to be read in the Chamber Members not to read out Speeches or Personal Statements Maiden Speeches Members to be heard without Interruption Interrupting a Member speaking – to raise a Point of Order Manner of Speaking in a County Assembly Referring to occupants of the Chair Moderate Language - unparliamentary words Declaration of personal interest Relevance Decided matters may be rescinded Anticipation of matters likely to be debated Allegation and substantiations Quorum of a County Assembly P. How Resolutions are made – Motions ........................................................ 60 Substantive Motions Notice of a Motion When a Motion is in possession of a County Assembly Amendments to a Motion- Motion as amended Moving amendments to Bills and Motions How to second an amendment v Q. How a Law is made - Acts of County Assembly ......................................... 63 What is a Bill? The stages in the making of a Law Not more than one stage of a Bill may be dealt with at a Sitting Assent of the County Governor Custody of Acts of a County Assembly Adherence to the Fourth Schedule of CK 2010 R. Sittings, Adjournments and Adjournment motions ..................................... 65 Sittings Adjournments End of Normal Sitting Raising Definite, Urgent Matters of State/County Importance Dilatory Adjournment Motions Motions to curtail ongoing Business Leave of a County Assembly Limitation of Debate S. Committees of A County Assembly ........................................................... 69 Committees of the Whole County Assembly Select Committees Membership of Committees Procedure in Committees and Record of Work Public Access and Participation T. The Budget in The County Assembly ........................................................... 72 Role and function of the Cabinet Secretary for Finance Role and function of the Commission for Revenue Allocation Role and function of the National Parliament Role and function of the County Executive Committee How the estimates of the Annual Budget arrive in a County Assembly vi • Sequence of processing the Annual Budget • Role and Function of the Select Committees • Role and function of a County Assembly APPENDICES ............................................................................................. 78 Appendix A: Guide to establishment of County Public Service and Board Appendix B: Guide to establishment of County Assembly Service and Board Appendix C: Oaths of Office Appendix D: Distribution of Functions between National and County Governments Appendix E: List of Counties Appendix F: Bibliography vii LIST OF ACRONYMS CK 1963 CONSTITUTION OF KENYA, 1963 CK 2010 CONSTITUTION OF KENYA 2010 SIDA SWEDISH INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT AGENCY WFD WESTMINSTER FOUNDATION FOR DEMOCRACY EISA ELECTORAL INSTITUTE FOR SUSTAINABLE DEMOCRACY IN AFRICA THE CPST THE CENTRE FOR PARLIAMENTARY STUDIES AND TRAINING LEGCO LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL KADU KENYA AFRICAN DEMOCRATIC UNION KANU KENYA AFRICAN NATIONAL UNION APP AFRICAN PEOPLES PARTY KPU KENYA PEOPLES UNION FRG FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY UK UNITED KINGDOM OF GREAT BRITAIN AND NORTHERN IRELAND CGA COUNTY GOVERNMENTS ACT 2011 PFM PUBLIC FINANCE MANAGEMENT ACT 2012 SSMS SPECIAL SEAT MEMBERS IN THE COUNTY ASSEMBLIES MMGS MEMBERS OF MARGINALISED GROUPS IN THE COUNTY ASSEMBLIES CCA CLERK OF COUNTY ASSEMBLY CASB COUNTY ASSEMBLY SERVICE BOARD NALK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF LEGISLATURES OF KENYA ACAK ASSOCIATION OF COUNTY ASSEMBLIES IN KENYA ACLK ASSOCIATION OF CLERKS OF LEGISLATURES IN KENYA SCA SPEAKER OF COUNTY ASSEMBLY CECM COUNTY EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEMBER viii BPS BUDGET POLICY STATEMENT BROP BUDGET REVIEW OUTLOOK PAPER MT/DMS MEDIUM TERM DEBT MANAGEMENT STRATEGY FSP FISCAL STRATEGY PAPER C- BROP COUNTY BUDGET REVIEW AND OUTLOOK PAPER CEF COUNTY EMERGENCY FUND CPS COUNTY PUBLIC SERVICE CPSB COUNTY PUBLIC SERVICE BOARD ix FOREWORD A Guide to Mandates and Roles of County Governments in Kenya is a timely and welcome resource poised to spur and contribute to sound and proper implementation of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 (CK 2010). The publication is critical, given the near total transformation of the principles, processes and structures of government, which CK 2010 is set to usher in. The Constitution of Kenya, 2010, was adopted by sixty seven percent (67%) of Kenyans in a national referendum on August 05, 2010, thereafter, promulgated on August 27, 2010. Thus the CK2010 became the supreme basic law replacing the nearly fifty year old Constitution of Kenya, 1963 (CK1963). The latter was enacted by the British House of Commons and issued as the Kenya Independence Order – in – Council of 1963. The concepts and principles of democratic governance in CK 2010 expressly provide for an unfettered sovereignty of the people as the arch-stone of government. Hence, the unequivocal right of the people to participate in and oversight the government, traverses the entire Constitution. Embedded, therein and of no less significance, are the objects and principles of devolved government. Devolution is principally meant to take away and re-distribute/share out the power to plan, legislate, budget and make policies for governing from an erstwhile highly centralized national executive and legislature to fortyseven county executives and assemblies. The implementation of CK 2010 has been going on since its promulgation. The National Assembly has led the way, by enacting most of the legislation in the Fifth Schedule, especially, those that should be ready by the time the first general elections are held under CK 2010. It would help to remind readers, however, that not all legislation identified, under the Fifth Schedule, must be enacted prior to the first general elections in March,2013. Indeed, a cursory view reveals that, most of the identified legislations have an enactment timeframe of three or more years. Apart from the National Assembly, virtually all organs with responsibility to implement CK 2010 have played their part. On this score, I note with appreciation that, though the Transition Authority was only set up in June 2012, it hit the road running. Within a short time its input is being felt across Kenya. Nonetheless, it goes without saying that as the time scheduled for the first general elections under the CK 2010 draws near the value of the Guide needs no further emphasis. The Guide condenses and digests the mandates, roles and functions of both the County Executive x and County Assembly. In this way it is an easy reference manual as it precludes one from going through the more than six statutes, each of which has a little of what devolution is about. In the same breath it provides an immediate link for the users, into how the County Government transacts its mandate, roles and functions. The Guide has a sufficiently vast and rich content which is fairly easy to read .It is the work of an author of seasoned experience and practice on the mandate and operations of Parliaments. This Guide is a real relief to all who seek to comprehend devolution and the operations of County Governments in Kenya. HON. KENNETH MARENDE, EGH, ACIArb, M.P, SPEAKER, KENYA NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NAIROBI xi ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I find it a thrilling opportunity, to be able to put down a few words as an acknowledgement of the efforts made to produce this epoch setting publication- A Guide to Mandates and Procedures of County Governments in Kenya. The Transition Authority welcomes this publication which will act as a valuable guide for putting in place of the processes and structures necessary for the operationalisation of County Governments in Kenya. The Guide is a concise and handy manual which has meticulously put together the must know of the Mandate and Procedure of County Governments. The project to produce the Guide was initially conceived for the County Assembly. However, in the course of putting it together it became necessary to expand the scope to include the County Executive. At the same time it became necessary to add brief information on matters of general application in the devolved system of Government in Kenya. The Guide received a lot of support from many people. However it will not be possible to individually acknowledge, everyone. But, I wish to pay special tribute to: • The Hon. Speaker of the National Assembly, for ever present interest in the work of the Transition Authority. In the short time since our appointment he has been able to spare time to receive us and hold fruitful exchanges. Further, he has graciously agreed to provide the Foreword; • The Clerk of the National Assembly, who continues to work closely with the Transition Authority, by facilitating the staff of the Parliamentary Service Commission to participate in many of our activities; • My colleagues, the Members of the Transition Authority, who upon appointment and conclusion of formalities of assumption of office, hit the road running and are soaring higher everyday; • The Electoral Institute for Sustainable Democracy in Africa (EISA) together with their funding partners, the Government of Sweden, the Swedish International Development Agency (SIDA-Sweden) for supporting the development of this Guide. The views expressed in this Guide do not necessarily reflect those of our supporting partners. • The Westminster Foundation for Democracy (WFD) for the sustained interest and support to virtually all aspects of the work of the Transitional Authority; xii • The Consultant, Mr. Murumba Werunga, Emeritus Clerk of Parliament and former Head of The Centre for Parliamentary Studies and Training (The CPST), Kenya, for reviewing relevant literature and editing the Guide. • The secretarial staff and all the other contributors who may not be mentioned here, but whose input remains invaluable for the successful conclusion of this project. I commend the Guide to all persons interested and working for the establishment of the County Governments, as the standard and appropriate manual for the operationalisation of County Governments in Kenya. KINUTHIA WA MWANGI CHAIRPERSON TRANSITION AUTHORITY Nairobi xiii A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA A. GENERAL BACKGROUND 1. At the turn of the twentieth century before present Kenya was officially constituted into a colony and later a Colony and Protectorate of the British Crown, the British issued the Order – in – Council of 1906 that laid out its key structures of governance. The Order – in – Council of 1906 was in effect the first Constitution of Kenya, which had been amended ten times, by the time it was replaced in 1954 by the Lyttelton Constitution. The Lennox-Boyd Constitution came into effect in 1958. The Ian Macleod Constitution which came into effect in 1960 was the last of the Colonial Constitutions, drawing its roots from the Order – in – Council of 1906. 2. The 1906 Order – in – Council amongst others provided for an Executive Council and a Legislative Council; both evolved, respectively, to be the Executive and the Legislature of the National Government of Kenya. The Executive Council was staffed by non – elected Members till the dawn of Independence. On the other, the Legislative Council, begun as a wholly nominated body but progressively its portion of elected Members kept increasing till 1961 when it had a majority of elected indigenous members. However, till the first sitting of the Independence Parliament, on June 11, 1963, members of the unicameral Legco were nominated or elected on racial and not on political party basis. 3. The amendments to the 1906 Order – in – Council, progressively accommodated the demands for representation in governance by the key racial groupings. Its successor constitutions were either totally replaced or amended for similar reasons. For instance, the Lyttleton Constitution of 1954, whose main objective was to promote multi – racial government, was soon superseded by the demands for increased African representation, after the March, 1957 first election for Africans. In 1958, it was replaced by the LennoxBoyd Constitution, which increased the Elected African Representative Members from the first seven (7) in 1957 to fifteen (15). 4. The Constitution of Kenya, 1963, was issued in the Kenya Independence Order-in Council of 1963 being a negotiated armistice, between the departing colonial British government and the resilient African nationalists. By the time the Constitution of Kenya, 1963 (CK 1963), was replaced by the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 (CK 2010), it had been amended thirty – four times. 1 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 5. The Constitution of Kenya, 1963, amongst others, provided for:5.1 Unitary parliamentary system of government, with two levels – the National and quasi – federal devolved eight Regional Governments; 5.2 Bicameral National Parliament, comprising a Senate and a House of Representatives; and eight Unicameral Regional Assemblies; 5.3 A National Executive, comprising a non – Executive Governor – General; an Executive Prime Minister, a Council of Ministers all- drawn from the National Parliament; except the Governor – General; 5.4 A Regional Executive, comprising an Executive Chairperson, Regional Executive Committee-all drawn from the Regional Assembly; 5.5 The powers and authority to govern were heavily tilted in favour of the Executive, though, there were less clearly defined structures of division of labour and limited checks and balance vested in the National and Regional Legislatures; 5.6 The Government at both National and Regional levels embraced principles of competitive multi – partyism. 6. The Constitution of Kenya, 1963 was replaced by the Constitution of Kenya 2010; the latter was adopted by 67% at a national referendum on August 05, 2010 and then promulgated on August 27, 2010. 7. The thirty-four amendments to the CK1963, had substantially altered and obliterated, the governance principles, structures and the entire architecture of government, by for instance – 1.1 Retaining a Unitary Parliamentary System of Government with an Executive President and a Unicameral National Parliament, without, the quasi – federal devolved regional governments; 1.2 A Unicameral National Parliament, without reckonable powers to check and oversight governance; 1.3 The powers and authority to govern were virtually wholly vested in the single Executive President; 1.4 The status of political parties, oscillated between multi – partyism and mono – partyism [de jure and de facto multi - partyism - 1963 to 1982; de jure mono – partyism - 1982 to 1991; de jure multi – partyism – 1991 to 2012]. 8. The two hundred and sixty – five sections and six schedules enunciate a great philosophical, economical, social and structural paradigm shift of, the governance and 2 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA its architecture that, had served Kenya for nearly fifty years. The key benchmarks of the shift include:8.1 The explicit sovereignty of the people of Kenya, as the custodian of the authority and power to govern, including its apportionment to designated state organs, institutions and offices, who exercise the same on behalf of the people; 8.2 The affirmation of the supremacy of the Constitution and exhortation of all Kenyans to ensure its implementation and defence; 8.3 The clearer division of mandate, role, function to govern between the main stakeholders/ arms of the state and government, i.e. the Parliament, the Executive, the Judiciary, the ten Constitutional Commissions and two Independent Offices; 8.4 The devolution, distribution, openness and accountability in governance and service provision; upholding gender parity; inclusion of the erstwhile marginalized communities; 8.5 The creation of two levels of government – at National and County; and an increase in the number of Kenyans, designated to serve; thus making governance an all inclusive Kenyan process; 8.6 The clearer checks and balances, separation of powers and mandate between the three arms of government whereby, despite, there being no concurrent membership of persons serving in either, there will still be co-operation and inter-dependence 8.7 Specifying the entitlement of citizenship, its acquisition, revocation and dual citizenship; 8.8 Specifying the rights and freedoms of the people, including their application; 8.9 Specifying the requirements for the leadership and integrity including the national values and principles of governance; 8.10 The affirmation of the multiparty democratic status of Kenya; 8.11The creation of a National Government, comprising of an Executive and a bicameral National Parliament; 8.12 The creation of a County Government, comprising of an Executive and a unicameral County Assembly; 8.13 The provision of an elaborate process of amending of the Constitution, whereby, the amendment of certain provisions would require direct participation of the people at a referendum. 3 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 8.14 The requirement of the participation of the public at all sittings of the National Parliament and County Assemblies; including, those of the Constitutional Commissions. 4 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA B. DEVOLUTION 9. Chapter Eleven on Devolved Government re-crafts the vision of the nationalism movement as was enshrined in the Independence Constitution, 1963. This time round, the Constitution creates forty-seven Counties each with its own elected government. The County Government will have and exercise executive and legislative authority including the accompanying mandates and powers, to raise limited revenue, establish policies, plan, and budget and carry out the processes of governing. Additionally, the National Government is obligated to support the County Governments. Form of Devolved Government 10. The basic premise in the application of devolution is determining the extent to which the apportionment of the traditional power and authority of the state: - to tax, spend, account for governance, provide and deliver public services, control; distribute and redistribute resources, legislate, set public policy, define and enforce rights; and put in place and enforce a governing machinery; is reserved in the central/national state organs or dispersed across a range of devolved and decentralized entities of mini governments. The investiture or dispersal among the National and County Government is on the basis of the CK 2010 and the attendant Acts of Parliament. 11. The form of the Devolved Government in the CK 2010 is defined in Section 6 which postulates that though the two levels of government are distinct, nevertheless, they remain inter-dependent. Clarity of the extent and the apportionment of mandate, role, function and power in the devolved system are to be found in the provisions of Chapter Eleven, the Fourth Schedule and the Acts of Parliament that enable and give effect to constitutional provisions. Given that government in Kenya is unitary, the two levels are required to observe and adhere to, among other provisions CK2010, the following: (i) Section 10 - National Values and Principles of Governance (ii) Part 5 – Relationships between Governments 5 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA The Objects and Principles of Devolved Government 12. Devolved governance is achieved by the creation of County Governments and Decentralized Units and Structures. Underlying and embedded in the processes of devolution are the Objects and Principles of Devolved Government provided under Sections 174 and 175 of the CK 2OIO. 13. The Objects of Devolved Government include:(i) Promotion of democratic and accountable exercise of power; (ii) Fostering national unity through recognition of diversity; (iii) Giving powers of self – governance to the people and enhancing their participation in the exercise of the powers of the State and in making decisions affecting them; (iv) Recognition of the right of communities to manage their own affairs and to further their development; (v) Protection and promotion of the interests and rights of minorities and marginalized communities; (vi) Promotion of social and economic development and the provision of proximate, easily accessible services throughout Kenya; (vii) Ensuring equitable sharing of national and local resources throughout Kenya; (viii) Facilitation of the decentralization of State Organs, their functions and services, from the capital of Kenya; (ix) Enhancement of the checks and balances and the separation of powers among those exercising it. 14. The Principles of Devolved Government include:(i) democratic principles and separation of powers; (ii) reliable sources of revenue to be able to govern and deliver services effectively; (iii) that the membership of representative bodies should not comprise more than two thirds of one gender. 6 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA C. ENHANCEMENT OF DEMOCRATIC CULTURE AND ACCOUNTABILITY 15. Running through CK 2010 and effecting statutes are provisions for the public to participate in and engage in the work of both the National Parliament and the County Assemblies. Some of these provisions follow here-below. 16. The Objects and Principles of Devolved Government under Sections174 and 175 of CK 2010 stand for and expect a participatory system of government; for instance – Section174 (a) promotes democratic and accountable exercise of power; (b) gives powers of self – governance to the people and enhances their participation in the exercise of the powers of the State and in making decisions affecting them; Section175 County Governments are to be based on democratic principles and separation of powers. 17. The powers under Section 195 of CK 2010 for a County Assembly and the Select Committees to summon witnesses to appear and give evidence and produce documents, as is the case in virtually all democratic governments, it provides a converse, whereby, the public seek to present evidence on any matter being dealt with. Indeed, the common approach has invariably been that whenever a Select Committee is dealing with legislation, budgetary matters or carrying out an inquiry on any matter, it would always call for/ invite presentations from the public. 18. The requirement under Sections 217 (2) (d) and 221 (5) of CK 2010 for the Constitutional Commissions; and Section 196 (1) and (2) of CK 2010 for the County Assembly and its Select Committees to sit in public and also facilitate the participation and involvement of the public in all business, except, in the exceptional circumstances determined by the Hon. Speaker; these re – enforces statements in paragraphs 16 and 17 above. 19. The rights at the disposal of the public under Article 119 of the Constitution and Section 15 of the County Governments Act, 2012 to petition a County Assembly to consider 7 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA any matter within its authority and at the same time requiring a County Assembly to facilitate the presentation of such petition – give an unequivocal right for the public to both participate in and oversight the work of a County Assembly; 20. The provisions of Sections 27, 28 and 29 of the County Governments Act, 2012, provide elaborate processes through which the electorate of an Electoral Ward, oversight the performance of their Elected Members and could recall the Member before the expiry of the life of that County Assembly. Those provisions by extension provide continuous oversight over the entire County Assembly. Though it might take long to complete the recall proceedings, the codification of these provisions is a constant deterrent on any lax performance. D. POLITICAL PARTIES IN GOVERNANCE 21. At the core of democracy is the recognition of divergence of views and perceptions among the “demo”, i.e. the people, who, not – with – standing the divergence, must “cracia”, i.e. allow/ agree on how to be governed. The CK 2010 recognized this core principle of democracy and declared in Section 4 (2) that, “The Republic of Kenya shall be a multi – party democratic state…” Nonetheless, this declaration does not negate the efficacy of the provisions of Section 1 of CK 2010, which affirms that, “All sovereign power belongs to the people of Kenya and shall be exercised only in accordance with this constitution.” The next three sub sections, spell out how the “sovereign power” is to be exercised and delegated at the two levels of government. 22. In a multi – party democratic State, the political parties market their manifestos to the people, especially at elections. This process gives the people, the opportunity to compare and make their choice. 23. Political Parties have always been part of the formation of representative democratic governments. In Kenya, even prior to the Order – in – Council of 1906, some form of political party had instigated its issuance. The Order – in – Council was in response to a petition sent to the Secretary of the Colonies in London by a Colonist Association. The Colonist Association was a social welfare – cum political pressure group of immigrant European settlers, pressing for participation in the budding colonial government. The 8 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA foundation laid by the Colonist Association, was to be adopted by other races, right up to re – Independence. 24. Presently, governments in most democratic polities, are formed by and operationalize the manifesto of a political party, which the electorate preferred over the others at an election. The centrality of political parties to formation of democratic government, is endorsed, not only by their recognition but further, by the extensive elaboration which the constitution and enabling statutes devote to their formation, management, participation in general and other elections and the formation of government at the two levels. 25. In addition to provisions of Section 4, the CK 2010 provides for the role and function of political parties:25.1 Chapter Seven – Representation of the People – provides what is required of Political Parties as well as Section 92 of the Political Parties Act, 2012; (i) 25.2 Chapter Eight – The Legislature – elaborates the role and function of Political Parties in the formation of the National Legislature, its operation and management. The same is the case in Chapter Eleven – Devolved Government for the formation of the County Assemblies. (ii) 25.3 Chapter Nine – The Executive – gives further elaboration on the role and function of political parties. Indeed, the President and Deputy President are creations of the parties. 26. The role and function of political parties in governance, is exhaustively elaborated in the Elections Act, 2011 while, the Political Parties Act, 2011, dwells on the formation and management of Political Parties. Status of Political Parties 27. The status of political parties in most democracies oscillates between One Party and Multi – Parties. Kenya has experienced these two since Independence. 28. Kenya regained Independence on a Constitution that, provided for multi – parties. When the First Parliament, met on June 11, 1963, three political parties were 9 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA represented. These were the ruling party – Kenya African National Union (KANU), the Kenya African Democratic Union (KADU) and the African Peoples Party (APP). On the first anniversary of re – Independence on December 12, 1964, KADU and APP had voluntarily dissolved and merged with KANU. This produced a status referred to as de facto One Party, since the constitution had not been amended, to effect de jure One Party. 29. The de facto One Party status lasted till April 14, 1966, when another party, the Kenya Peoples Union (KPU), was formed. This party existed till October 1969, when it was proscribed. Thus, the de facto One Party state resumed. 30. The first general elections were held on January 06, 1970, under the de facto One Party status. 31. The de facto One Party status prevailed till June 09, 1982, when the CK 1963, was amended to create a de jure One Party status. This status prevailed till December 01, 1991, when the CK 1963, was amended to revert to de jure Multi – Party status. This status has been re – affirmed by CK 2010. Coalition of Political Parties 32. Coalition of political parties is a phenomenon that can exist in a multi – party democracy. Coalitions could be formed for various reasons, for instance: 32.1 Where there exists strong regional political parties, with none is capable of marshalling sufficient votes to attain the threshold to win a general election; 32.2 Where there exist, strong ethnically or ideologically based political parties, with none capable of marshalling sufficient votes to attain the threshold to win a general election; 32.3Where there exist, numerous tiny political parties fragmented on tiny regional, ethnic; fear of domination, often transient, so that none could stand a chance of ever winning a general election. 33. Coalition of political parties has been common in continental Europe – Federal Republic of Germany, Italy; in the Middle East – Israel, Lebanon; in Asia – India, Pakistan. The 10 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Federal Republic of Germany (FRG) has so far been the best practice, while both Italy and Israel are examples of the unpredictability of coalitions. The situation in Africa has yet to be tested! 34. Pursuant to provisions of the Political Parties Act, 2011, formation of coalitions among political parties are guided by Section 10, thus (i) Formed and concluded, either prior to or after the general elections; (ii) The coalition pacts are to be deposited with the Registrar of Political Parties; (iv) The coalition pacts apply to Members of the National and County Assemblies; (v) The matters core to the coalition and which the political parties are required to abide with are in the Third Schedule. The Political Parties in the Legislature 35. The status of Political Parties in the Legislature; at National and County levels; reflect the above description. 36. Thus, within the Legislature, the management of political parties, whether singly or as a coalition, have the following leadership structure: 36.1 The Leader of the Majority Party or Coalition of Parties constituting the Majority in Legislature – (i) Is usually a Member of the Legislature, designated by the body of the party or coalition, as stated in its constitution [CK 2010 91(1)(b)]; (ii) In some jurisdictions, the Members of the party or coalition in a Legislature, designate one of themselves to be their Leader; 36.2 The Leader of the Minority Party or Coalition of Parties leads the Party or coalition of Parties constituting the biggest single number of Members in the Legislature, next to the Majority Party. The process of designation of its leader, is as in (i) above; 36.3 Leaders of the Majority and Minority are often recognized in the national constitution and in the order of precedence of the Legislature, after the Hon. Speaker. In addition to their role and function as Leaders of their parties, 11 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA they also shoulder management and administrative responsibilities for the Legislature. The Standing Orders and the traditions, conventions and practice of Legislatures, give recognition to them and elaborate their role and function. 36.4 Leaders of other parties are given less prominent recognition and responsibilities by the procedure and practice. 36.5 In addition to the Leaders of Political Parties, the Majority and Minority Leaders, have each a Chief Whip. The smaller parties have their own whips. 36.6 Remuneration, office accommodation, staff and facilitation are usually accorded to the Leaders and the Whips of the Majority and Minority Parties. In some jurisdiction, there is a set criterion by which the Leaders and Whips of smaller parties receive remuneration and limited facilitation. E. DISTINCTIVENESS, INTERDEPENDENCE AND INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONSHIPS 37. The basis and framework for distinctiveness, interdependence and intergovernmental relationships are statutory and by best practice. The provisions of Sections 6(2) and 189 of the CK 2010 provide a lead in this regard. Whereas Section 6(2) lays emphasis on distinctiveness and interdependence, Section 189 demands closer liaison, consultation and exchange of information that is necessary for appropriate working of the structures of governance. The output of these two sections would appear to disallow subservience of one level of government to the other, a status that should be upheld in all statutes and regulations to be put in place for the operationalisation of devolution. Despite the distinct constitutional functioning of the two levels, their institutional arrangements, legal frameworks and practical operations are not based on absolute autonomy but rather on interdependence and co-operation. 38. The need for a framework to govern the intergovernmental relations is premised on the provisions of Sections 6(2), 187 and 189 of CK 2010. The framework has been consolidated in the Intergovernmental Relations Act, 2012, whose principles and objects include:(i) Consultation and co-operation between the National and County Governments; and among the County Governments. 12 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (ii) Establishment of institutional structures and mechanisms for intergovernmental relations. (iii) Giving effect to provisions of Sections 187 and 200 of the CK 2010, regarding the transfer of functions and powers by one level of government to the other; including the transfer of legislative powers from National to County level. (iv) Mechanisms to resolve intergovernmental disputes. (v) Recognition of the sovereignty of the people. (vi) Promotion of National Values and Principles of Governance provided for in Section 10 of the CK 2010. (vii)Promotion of accountability by the people in decision making and actions taken. (viii)Institutionalized protection of marginalized groups. (ix) Providing a forum for coordinating the policies on legislation and functions of the two levels of government. (x) Providing a forum for sharing and disclosing necessary data and information. 39. The Intergovernmental Relations Act,2012, establishes under Section 7 the following structures:39.1 A National and County Governments Coordinating Summit:(i) Comprise of the President, the Deputy President and the Governors of the forty-seven Counties; (ii) The function, regulation and reporting of the Summit; also referred to as the Apex Body, are provided for in Sections 8, 9, 10. (iii) The Summit and the Council under 39.2 below, are supported in their work by the Intergovernmental Relations Technical Committee (Sections 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, and18) 39.2 A Council of County Governors (Section 19) (i) Comprise all Governors of the forty-seven Counties (ii) The functions, regulation and reporting of the Council are in Sections 20, 21, 22 and 23. 39.3 The Intergovernmental Relations Act, 2012, also provides the principles and processes for the:- 13 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (i) Transfer and Delegation of Powers, Functions and Competencies. (ii) Dispute Resolution Mechanisms. (iii) A Schedule on the Conduct of Meetings. 39.4 Participation of the Public in work of the organs is as provided for in adherence to provisions of Section 118 of the 2010. Those provisions are replicated for in the work of both the Summit (Section 8(1)) and the Council(Section 20(9)) and in the entire County Government (Section 38(2) (b)). 40. In addition to the foregoing, there are Regulations and Rules made under the enabling /effecting Acts of Parliament that enhance intergovernmental relations, including, ensuring they operate on harmonized standards, for instance:(i) Section 205, Public Finance Management Act, 2012 (ii) Part VI, Public Finance Management Act, 2012 F. FINANCIAL AND BUDGETARY DOMAIN 41. The Constitution of Kenya 2010 confers responsibilities on a number of institutions that have a bearing on public finance management. This is further amplified by the Public Finance Management Act, 2012. The institutions involved in the public finance management and their respective roles and responsibilities are:(i) The National Treasury (ii) The County Treasury (iii) The Controller of Budget (iv) The Auditor General (v) The Commission on Revenue Allocation (vi) The Salaries and Remuneration Commission (vii)The Central Bank of Kenya (viii)National and County Executives (ix) Parliament and County Assemblies 42. The roles, functions, responsibilities in the financial and budgetary domain are fully realized by the input of the following stakeholders:- 14 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 43. The National and County Governments:- The Executive is the national agency responsible for the following: (i) Macro-economic policies and projections; (ii) Assessing and documenting macro and fiscal stability factors; (iii) Computing resource envelope based on macro-framework; (iv) Coordinating public expenditures consistent with resource envelope; (v) Guiding budget preparation, consistent with agreed policies/priorities; and (vi) Monitoring budget execution and taking necessary corrective action. (vii)Enactment of legislation and setting policies that give the power and authority to do the activities for governing, for instance:• Taxation and levies that constitute public revenue; • Entering into agreements for borrowing loans and getting grants; • Planning, starting from Decentralized Units to National Level on whose basis the annual and medium term budgets are made; • Distribution of financial, material and human resource; • Harmonisation and standardisation that apply across the Republic; • Establishment of fora and structures to guide, encourage co-operation, consultations, resolution of disagreements and disputes, facilitation of joint planning and support for each other; • Provide leadership for governance; • Provide and facilitate the participation of the public; • Provide for the establishment of independent constitutional commissions and offices that contribute to enhanced oversight and accountability. 44. The Independent Constitutional Commissions and Offices The Commissions and Offices oversight and ensure compliance with statute and accountability by all stakeholders, viz:a) Commission on Revenue Allocation 45. Established under Section 215 of CK 2012, the CRA operate and exercise authority under Section 216 of CK 2012 in addition to other provisions of the Public Finance Management, 2012. It is responsible for vertical and horizontal sharing of resources. Specifically, the functions of the CRA include: 15 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (i) Develop an equitable basis for allocation and the criteria which should be consistent with Section 203. The section specifies the vertical basis but not horizontal; promotes and gives effect to criteria of Section 203 (1) on equitable share; and advises and recommends on other public financial management matters to Counties. (ii) When appropriate define revenue sources for the County and National Governments; (iii) Recommends ways to encourage fiscal responsibility. (iv) Determine, publish and regularly review a policy setting out the criteria by which to identify marginalised areas under Section 204(2) b) Controller of Budget. 46. The functions of the Controller of Budget are both constitutional and executive at the two levels of government. The key function of the Controller of Budget is, authentication of public spending and ensuring that funds are withdrawn on and for approved purposes. 47. Pursuant to Section 228 of CK 2010 and the other provisions under the Public Finance Management Act, 2012 and the County Governments Act, 2012, the Controller of Budget has power to:(i) Approve release of funds from the Exchequer; oversee implementation of national and county budgets and authorize withdrawals from public funds; and ensures that, every withdrawal from any public fund is authorized by law; and monitor and prepare quarterly budget implementation and report on National and County Governments. (ii) Oversee the implementation of the budgets of the National and County Governments by authorising withdrawals from public funds under Sections 204,206 and 207 0f CK 2010. (iii) Approve withdrawals only on satisfaction that, they are authorised by the law. (iv) Report quarterly to National Parliament and County Assemblies on the implementation of the budgets of the National and County Governments. 16 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA c) Auditor- General 48. Pursuant to Section 229 of CK 2010 and provisions in other statutes, the mandate of the Auditor General is to audit and report on all accounts of public entities and all funds and commissions whose financing is met from public funds. All accounting officers of National and County entities are required to submit their financial reports and statements, three months after the end of each financial year to the Auditor General. The Auditor General is consequently required to audit financial statements and submit and report to Parliament and the County Assembly within six months after the end of each financial year on: (i) Accounts of Commissions and Independent Offices; (ii) The National Assembly the County Assemblies and the Senate. (iii) Accounts of political parties; and (iv) Public debt and accounts of any other entity requiring public audit 49. Parliament and County Assemblies are required to scrutinize the audit reports produced by the AG within three months of submission. Under Section 229, (6), the AG is required to perform audits on results and effectiveness of expenditure including that of political parties. The Salaries and Remuneration Commission 50. Pursuant to Section 230 of CK 2010, the Salaries and Remuneration Commission has functions that broadly cover payment of salaries and benefits within the Public Service. (i) Is responsible for harmonizing pay and benefits, (ii) Ensure harmonization of salaries/ benefits, by precluding, the basing of the amounts paid as salaries for state officers on political considerations, as that lacks credibility. (iii) To urgently review and harmonize pay and benefits and advise National and County Governments as necessary on fiscal sustainability of pay and benefits; ability to attract necessary skills to the sector; and sustain productivity, transparency and fairness; and apply these principles as a guide to future wage structure in public sector. 17 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA The Central Bank of Kenya 51. Pursuant to Section 231 of CK 2010 the Central Bank has the power to:(ii) To formulate and guide the monetary policy, promote price stability, issue and control currency circulation; regulate the financial sector; be a banker to Government, particularly, on matters of public debt. (iv) Formulate monetary policy; promote price stability, issue currency and other functions conferred by statute. The National and County Executives 52. The functions for the Executive arms of the Government, at both the National and County Levels (i) Ensure the various funds and bank accounts into which public funds are held and deposited are established and operated as required by statute and best practice. (ii) Budget and prepare annual and medium term estimates as required by statute and their processing through the Legislatures. (iii) Implement the plans, budgets and account to National Parliament and County Assemblies. The National Parliaments and County Assemblies, 53. The functions of the Legislatures at both the National and County Levels are as encapsulated under the Constitution and the Public Finance Management Act, 2012. Different roles are dealt with distinctly and require specific procedure for their transaction. At National level, the National Assembly is mandated as follows; (i) Section 218 provide for Annual Division and Allocation of Revenue in a matter of sharing out national revenue; (ii) Section 114 provides matters on Money Bills; (iii) Section 221 provides for Annual Estimates; while Section 222 provide for advance approval of expenditure; and Section 223 provides for Supplementary Appropriations and provisions of Section 220 provide for planning at County level 18 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 54.The Constitution of Kenya 2010 confer unlimited powers on the Parliament on the national purse which includes:(i) The power to authorize taxation, other charges and public borrowing; modify sharing of revenue base and collected revenues; (ii) Oversee budget implementation, hold the Executive to account on performance; conduct detailed scrutiny through Committees; and (iii) Monitor compliance and achievement of results. (iv)Ensure sustained oversight on the activities in the financial and budgetary domain. (v) Scrutinise and approve the separate annual and medium term budgets and estimates of the three arms of government and other entities spending public funds. (vi)Scrutinise the recommendations and determinations of independent constitutional Commissions on financial matters. The Public 55. Pursuant to Sections 118, 119 of CK 2010 and provisions in other statutes- County Governments Act, 2012, Intergovernmental Relations Act, 2012, Public Finance Management Act,2012, the public are :(i) Guaranteed constitutional and statutory rights to participate in all meetings of all State Organs. (ii) Guaranteed constitutional and statutory rights to petition, demand and access public information held by from all State Organs, Commissions and Offices. G. THE STRUCTURE OF GOVERNMENT 56. The Constitution of Kenya, 2010, provides a structure of government that differs in many aspects from virtually all governments since re - Independence. However, that, government will be understood upon implementation of the CK 2010 and appurtenant statutes. 19 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 57. The key aspects of the government in the CK 2010 include:(i) Unitary hybrid system, incorporating aspects of the Westminster (British) Parliamentary system and the USA Congressional Presidential system; (ii) Unitary hybrid system with devolved structure, sharing and distributing governance between one National Government and forty – seven County Governments. 58. The National Government comprises – 58.1 The National Executive, consisting, the President, who is its head; the Deputy President and a Cabinet of not less than fourteen and not more than twenty – two Secretaries; (i) only the President seeks election, while the Deputy President is a running mate of the President; (ii) none of them is either, concurrently a member of the National Parliament or sits and directly takes part in its proceedings; (iii) the President addresses Parliament on statutorily designated occasions; (iv) the President serves for only two five year terms; 58.2 The Cabinet Secretaries are nominated by the President and vetted by the National Parliament prior to appointment; (i) the Cabinet Secretaries appear before Select Committees of Parliament as required by statute and the Standing Orders of the National Parliament; (ii) the Public Service Commission procures the National Public Service. (iii) The Cabinet procures the services and facilities for the use by the Executive. 58.3 The Parliament – consisting, a Senate of sixty eight members and a National Assembly of three hundred and fifty members; (i) All members are either elected or nominated; (ii) None of the members is either concurrently a member of the National Executive or sits and directly takes part in the proceedings of the Executive; (iii) There is no limit on the terms of membership of Parliament; (iv) The Parliamentary Service Commission procures the human resource and the services and facilities for the use of Parliament. 59. The County Government comprise – 59.1 The County Executive, consisting, the County Governor, being its head, the 20 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Deputy Governor and a County Executive Committee whose number will be related to the portfolios necessary for each County Government: (i) only the County Governor seeks election, while the Deputy Governor is the running mate of the County Governor; (ii) none of them serves concurrently as a member of a County Assembly or sit and directly takes part in the proceedings of the County Assembly; (iii) The Governor addresses the County Assembly on statutorily designated occasions; (iv) there is a two five year terms limit on the tenure of the Governor; 59.2 The County Executive Committee Members are nominated by the Governor and vetted by the County Assembly prior to appointment; (i) the County Executive Members appear before Select Committees of the County Assembly as required by statute and or the Standing Orders; (ii) The County Service Board procures the County Public Service. (iii) The County Executive Committee manages and administers the operations of the County Public Service. 59.3 The County Assembly – the total membership of the forty – seven County Assemblies is set at one thousand ,four hundred and fifty members:(i) Individual County Assemblies, will have such number of elected Members depending on the number of the electoral wards delimited by the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) meanwhile, the Nominated Members will be in proportion to those elected. (ii) All Members are either elected or nominated; (iii) None of the Members serves concurrently as either a member of the County Executive or sits and takes part in the proceedings of the Executive. (iv) There is no limit on the tenure of members of the County Assembly. (v) The County Assembly Service Board procures the human resource, the services and facilities for the use of the County Assembly. 59.4 Decentralized Units – each County shall:(i) Be decentralized to further units, pursuant to the CK 2010, the Urban Areas and Cities Act, 2011 and the County legislation; (ii) Ensure that its functions and the provision of services by a County Government are decentralized to:(iii) The Urban Areas and Cities established according to the Urban Areas and Cities Act, 2011; 21 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (iv) The Sub – Counties equivalent to Constituencies for election to National Assembly established under Section 88 (4) (c) of CK 2010; (v) The Electoral Wards established under Section 88 (4) (c) of CK 2010; (vi) The number of Village Units determined by the County Assembly; 60. Additional Units to be determined by the County Government through an Act of the County Assembly. H.THE MANDATE, ROLE AND FUNCTION OF COUNTY GOVERNMENT 61. The Mandate, Role and Function, which County Governments have and execute are as specified and vested in them, by the CK 2010 and the various Acts of Parliament that effect and facilitate the implementation of the relevant provisions in the Constitution. 62. The Constitution of Kenya, 2010, amongst others, provide for the functions in:(i) Chapter Eleven – Sections 174 to 200. (ii) Fourth Schedule- Distribution of Functions between the National Government and the County Governments (Sections 185 (2), 186 (1) and 187 (2)). 63. The Acts of Parliament that facilitate the implementation of the provisions of the Constitution, include:(i) The Transition to Devolved Government Act, 2012; (ii) The Intergovernmental Relations Act, March 09, 2012; (iii) The County Governments Act, August, 2012; (iv) The Public Finance Management Act, August 27, 2012; (v) The Petitions to Parliament (Procedure) Act, August 31, 2012. (vi) The Urban Areas and Cities, Act, August 30, 2012. 22 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA I. FUNCTIONS AND POWERS OF NATIONAL AND COUNTY GOVERNMENT 64. The Functions and Powers of the National and County Governments are provided for in the Fourth Schedule of the Constitution. The exemptions include:(i) Functions or powers conferred by legislation on both levels, that would be dealt with under concurrent jurisdiction; (ii) Functions and powers that are not expressly conferred on the County Government would be presumed to belong to the National Government; (iii) However, the National Parliament may legislate on any matter meant to serve the whole country; (iv) Transfer of assigned functions and powers between the two levels is to be done by mutual agreement, though the constitutional responsibility for its performance would remain with the level to which it was originally assigned. Further, the resources necessary for the execution of the transferred functions or powers, would also have to be transferred to the level to which the function is transferred; (v) The Governments are to perform their functions and powers in a manner that respects the functional and institutional integrity of government. Thus, each Government is required to assist, support and consult and as appropriate implement the legislation of the other. (vi) The National Parliament shall enact legislation providing mechanisms for settling intergovernmental disputes, including through negotiation, mediation and arbitration. (vii)National Parliament enacts legislation that prevail upon County legislation whereby:(a) It would prevent unreasonable action by a County Government; (b) It would provide for matters that can only be effectively legislated at national level; (c) The matter requires uniformity across the nation based on uniform norms and standards or policies; (d) It is necessary for maintenance of national security, economic unity, protection of common market, promotion of economic activities nationally, promotion of equal opportunities, protection of the environment, et cetera. 23 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (viii)County Assemblies enacts legislation that prevails upon national legislation for matters where the circumstances in (vi) do not apply. 65. County Governments exercise constitutional authority, are corporate bodies with perpetual succession and have full powers necessary to discharge their due functions. To that end, County Governments would – (i) Enter into contracts; (ii) Acquire, purchase or lease land; or (iii) Delegate any of their functions to be performed by their staff, decentralized units or other entities. (iv) Borrow, lease and receive grants from development partners with the authority of the National Government. J. THE COUNTY EXECUTIVE Composition of a County Executive 66. The Executive of the County comprise – (i) The County Governor and the Deputy County Governor; (ii) The Members of the County Executive Committee; (iii) The Civil Service of the County Executive. Election, Role and Function of the officers of the County Executive 67. The officers of the County Executive are elected to office as follows:- The County Governor 67.1 Election of the Governor (i) The Governor of a County is directly elected by the registered voters of a County, at a general election of Members of Parliament, i.e. the second Tuesday in August every fifth year. The first general election under the CK 2010, are scheduled for March 04, 2013; (ii) Eligibility for election requires same qualifications as for election to a County Assembly; 24 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (iii) Each eligible candidate, is required to designate one person, who is as qualified as the candidate, to be a running mate for the position of a Deputy County Governor; (iv) The Governor and the Deputy Governor do not hold office for more than two terms of five years each; 67.2 Removal of the County Governor from office The County Governor shall be removed from office for:(i) Gross violation of the Constitution or other laws; (ii) Commission of a crime under national or international law; (iii) Abuse of office or gross misconduct; (iv) Physical or mental incapacity to perform the functions of the office of a County Governor. 67.3 Vacation of the office of a County Governor The office of a County Governor shall become vacant, if the holder:(i) Dies; (ii) Resigns in writing, addressed to the Speaker of the County Assembly; (iii) Ceases to be eligible to be elected, a County Governor, by ceasing to qualify for election to a County Assembly, under Section 180 (2) of the CK 2010; (iv) Convicted to serve a sentence of imprisonment for at least twelve months; (v) Removed from office as at sub-paragraph 66.2 above; 67.4 Filling a Vacation where the County Governor vacates office • Section 182 (2), (3),(4),(5) and (6) provide for the process to fill the office of a County Governor where the Governor causes the vacation of the office. 67.5Roles and Functions of a County Governor The roles of a County Governor include:(i) Being the chief executive of the County; (ii) Providing leadership to the County; (iii) Providing leadership to the County Executive Committee and administration on the basis of County policies and plans; (iv) Promoting democracy, good governance, unity and cohesion within the County; (v) Promoting competitiveness to make the County a preferred destination for investment, et cetera; 25 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (vi) Being accountable for the management and use of the resources of the County; (vii)Promoting and facilitating the participation of citizens in development of policies, plans and delivery of services in the County; (viii)Being the official spokesperson of the County. 67.6 The functions of a County Governor, include:(i) The exercise and execution of the authority and functions as provided in the constitution and statute; (ii) By mutual consultation, perform state functions within the County, on behalf of the President; (iii) Represent the County in national and international fora; (iv) Make appointments within the Executive with the approval of the County Assembly, i.e. to the County Executive Committee and the Chief Officers of the Civil/ Public Service of the County Government; (v) Allocate portfolios to Members of the County Executive Committee; (vi) Submit County plans, policies and budget to the County Assembly for consideration and approval; (vii)Consider, approve and assent to bills passed by the County Assembly; (viii)Submit to the County Assembly, an annual report on the implementation status of the policies and plans of the County and also an annual report on matters of public importance raised by the Citizens Forum and the response by the Executive; (ix) Deliver an Annual State of the County Address to the County Assembly; (x) Sign and cause the publication in the County Gazette of all Bills passed by the County Assembly, important formal decisions made by a County Governor or by the County Executive Committee. 67.7 The powers of a County Governor, include:(i) Dismissing members of the County Executive Committee, while taking into account the provisions of Section 40 of the County Governments Act, 2012; and any resolution of a County Assembly; (ii) Appointing Accounting Officers to departments, entities or decentralized units in a County Government; (iii) Having the powers necessary to execute the duties of the office of a County Governor; 26 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (iv) Assigning of duties and functions to the Deputy Governor, except the constitutional and statutory ones, which are vested in the Governor (Section 32 (4) of the County Governments Act, 2012). 67.8 Appointment of Members of a County Executive Committee (i) Members of a County Executive Committee are appointed by the County Governor, with the approval of a County Assembly; (ii) Members of a County Executive Committee may also be appointed under provisions of Section 42, of the County Governments Act, 2012. (iii) The appointment by a County Governor and the approval by a County Assembly of members of a County Executive Committee, take into account the provisions of Sections 10 and 179 (3) of the CK 2010 and Section 35 of the County Governments Act, 2012. 67.9 The County Executive Committee (i) The executive authority of a County vests in and is exercised by a County Executive Committee under Section 34 of the County Governments Act, 2012; (ii) the County Executive Committee shall – (a) prepare bills for consideration by a County Assembly; and implement Acts of the County Assembly ; and the national legislation to the appropriate extent; (b) manage and co – ordinate the functions of the County administration; including those in Sections 46 and 47 of the County Governments Act, 2012; (c) provide to the County Assembly, full and regular reports on matters relating to the County; (d) Submit/ present the budget of a County to the relevant Select Committee of a County Assembly; (i) The County Executive Committee executes the roles and functions, necessary for the effective and efficient operation of the Urban Areas and Cities, pursuant to provisions of Section 37 of the County Governments Act, 2012. (ii) The Members of the County Executive Committee are individually and collectively accountable to the County Governor in the performance of their roles and functions. (iii) The Members of the County Executive Committee, may be required to:- 27 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (a) Attend, appear or submit documents to Select Committees of a County Assembly; (b) Attend and appear to answer questions relating to their portfolios. 67.10 Removal from office of a member of a County Executive Committee Members of the County Executive Committee may be removed from office (i) By a County Governor, as provided for in Section 40 (1) of the County Government Act, 2012; (ii) By resolution of a County Assembly as provided for in Section 40 (2), (3), (4), (5) and (6) in the County Governments Act, 2012. County Public Service 68. The County Public Service is constituted by a County Executive as in Appendix A, with the approval of a County Assembly for the positions of a County Secretary, and Chief Officers (Sections 44, 45, 50, 51, 52, 53, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63 to 86, of the County Governments Act, 2012). K. THE COUNTY ASSEMBLY Composition of a County Assembly 69. Membership of a County Assembly is constituted according to provisions in Section 177 (a), (b), (c) and (d) of the CK 2010; and Section 7 (1) and (2) of the County Governments Act, 2012. Election and Nomination of Members of a County Assembly 70. A County Assembly is composed of both elected and nominated Members. The process for the election and nomination, including how the stakeholders participate are set out in CK 2010 and statutes – County Governments Act, 2012, Political Parties Act, 2010 and Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission Act, 2011. 28 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Elected Members of a County Assembly 71. The Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) set one thousand, four hundred and fifty members as the maximum number of elected Members for all forty – seven County Assemblies. The actual number of Elected Members for each County Assembly will be equal to the number of Electoral Wards, the IEBC delimits for each County. However, the minimum number of the Elected Members per County is set at fifteen. 72. The Elected Members of a County Assembly are either sponsored by registered political parties or independently sponsored. Each Elected Member represents a single Member Electoral Ward in a County. Nominated Members of a County Assembly 73. There are two categories of Nominated Members in a County Assembly, viz:73.1 Special Seat Members (SSMs) – these would be nominated by registered political parties after the declaration of results of Elected Members; (i) SSMs would be chosen from a list of aspirants nominated by each registered political party and deposited with the IEBC, prior to general election; (ii) The number of SSMs apportioned to each registered party would be proportionate to the number of Elected Members, it will have gained at the general election; (iii) The totality of SSMs for each County Assembly can only be known after the general election, since SSMs are meant to provide a gender balance in ensuring that, no more than two thirds of the membership of a County Assembly is of the same gender. 73.2 Members of Marginalised Groups (MMGs) – each County Assembly shall have six MMGs, nominated by registered political parties in proportion to the number of elected member seats each will have after declaration of results for the general elections. (i) The MMGs would be drawn from persons with disabilities, the youth and the marginalized groups; (ii) The nomination of MMGs is done in respect of the provisions of Section 7 (2) of the County Governments Act, 2012 29 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Speaker of a County Assembly 74. Each County Assembly shall have a Speaker of a County Assembly. The Speaker shall be elected by Members of a County Assembly from persons who are not its members. 75. The Speaker of a County Assembly shall preside at all sittings of the Assembly. There is no provision for the position of a Deputy Speaker, thus in the absence of the Speaker, or while a County Assembly is deliberating on matters directly affecting the Speaker, the Assembly, would elect one of its Members to preside. However, the Member so elected on the first of such occasions, shall preside at all subsequent occasions during the lifespan of that Assembly. The Majority Leader and the Minority Leader of a County Assembly 76. For the particulars of their role and function in a County Assembly refer to Part F, above. Tenure of a County Assembly 77. In accordance to provisions of Section 177 (4) of the CK 2010, the lifespan of a County Assembly, constituted at a general election is five years. The lifespan starts from the day the Members are sworn in. 78. The Clerk of a County Assembly shall swear in Members within fourteen days, after the declaration of final results of an election. Mandate, Role and Function of a County Assembly 79. A County Assembly exercise and execute the mandate, role and function by the sovereign power to participate in governance, delegated to them under Section 1(2), (3) and (4) of CK 2010. 80. The mandate, role and function of a County Assembly can be hardly spelt out or quantified. Such is the case, given that, legislatures, which include County Assemblies, 30 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA have come into existence by evolution. Thus, their status, mandate, role and function have also, with time, evolved to encompass far wider aspects than codified. 81. Nevertheless, on the basis of the current philosophies and practices of governance and from CK 2010 and pertinent statutes, these would ably be the mandate, role and function of the County Assemblies in Kenya viz:(i) They are the home of and executer of the legislative authority of a County by making and unmaking laws to facilitate the due execution of the powers and functions of a County Government under existing statute; (ii) They exercise oversight over all issues and matters of governance, especially, the operation of the County Executive Committee and all organs of the County Executive; (iii) They receive, deliberate on and approve:(a) All development plans, programmes, policies and budget of a County Government; as set out in Sections 207, 220 (2), 201 and 203 of CK 2010 and Part IV of the Public Finance Management Act, 2012; (b) After vetting all nominees for appointment as County Secretary and Chief Officers of the County Public Service; (c) The borrowing by a County Government in accordance with provisions of Section 212 of CK 2010. (d) Appointment of a Clerk of a County Assembly (CCA) on recommendation of the County Assembly Service Board (CASB). (iv) They represent the electorate of a County in the governance, including providing leadership in deliberation on all matters of concern and interest; (v) However, Members of a County Assembly, do not get directly involved in the Executive or functions of a County Government or in the delivery of services meant to be done by the County Public Service. Management and Administration of a County Assembly 82. The organs and structures for the management and administration of a County Assembly have been put in place by both statute and practice. Further, it is a common long established convention and tradition for the processes to involve and revolve around the key political offices/ leaders of a Legislature. Whereas such key political 31 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA officers/ leaders initially hold and occupy constitutional offices, the management and administrative chores are added by statute and practice. 83. Pursuant to the CK 2010, Statute, Standing Orders and the traditions and conventions, the key political offices/ leaders perform dual roles and functions, viz; 83.1The Roles and Functions by Practice (i) Enables a County Assembly to fulfill its constitutional, statutory and traditional mandate; (ii) Political offices/ leaders, include, the Speaker, the Majority Leader, the Minority Leader; which, are constitutional and statutory offices by Section 178 of the CK 2010 and Section of the County Governments Act, 2012; (iii) The other political offices/ leaders are the Chairpersons of the Select Committees of a County Assembly, who are a consequent of the provisions of Section 14 of the County Governments Act, 2012 and the Standing Orders. 83.2 The County Assembly Service Board (i) Is created by Section 12 of the County Governments Act, 2012, as a body corporate with perpetual succession and a common seal; (ii) The County Assembly Service Board comprise four members – the Speaker who is also the chair; the Majority and Minority Leaders and one non – member. (iii) The Secretary of the Service Board is the Clerk of the County Assembly; (iv) Section 12, in addition to providing for the membership of the Service Board, also details the responsibilities of the Board; (v) In a nutshell, the responsibilities of the Service Board are to ensure the County Assembly is availed with services, facilities, human and material resources for its proper operation/ functioning; et cetera. 83.3The Clerk and Staff of the County Assembly (i) The Clerk of a County Assembly is the Chief Procedural Advisor; the Chief Executive Officer; Authorized Officer; Accounting Officer and Secretary of the County Assembly Service Board; (ii) The Clerk and the Staff serve in the County Assembly Service which appoints them; they do not fall under the County Public Service Board. 32 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Contact of County Assembly with National Parliament and County Executive 84. Thus, a combination of the mandate, role and function carried out by the organs/ structures in paragraph 81 above ensure an all round, sound, proper, appropriate management and administration of a County Assembly. Needless to say, the organs/ structures keep continuous contact with their equivalents at the National Parliament and the County Executive. 85. Harmonization and standardization of norms and procedure is achieved through specific fora:(i) The National Association of Legislatures of Kenya (NALK); (ii) The Association of County Assemblies of Kenya (ACAK) (iii) The Association of Clerks of Legislatures of Kenya(ACLK) (iv) Intergovernmental fora. L. OPERATIONS OF COUNTY ASSEMBLIES 86. The Working Mechanisms, Processes and Tools of a County Assembly are meant to collectively enable a County Assembly effectively and efficiently fulfill its mandate, role and function. Every aspect touches the other; none could be applied and relied upon to deliver singly the work of a County Assembly. 87. As has been opined above in paragraphs 80 and 819 regarding the management and administration of a County Assembly, so it is with the working mechanisms, processes and tools. These too, are imbedded in tradition, practice and convention of legislatures as they have evolved through centuries. Often it may not be possible to appreciate, understand or even describe the genesis of some of the precepts/ principles underlying some of the conventions, practices and privileges. 88. Be that as it may, the sources of the working mechanism, processes and tools of legislatures, in this case, the County Assemblies, may be identified as:(i) The Constitution and Statutes; (ii) The Standing Orders; 33 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (ii) The practice, traditions and conventions; (iv) The decisions and considered rulings of the Speaker; (v) Incidents/ precedents of how a matter is dealt with in the course of proceedings; (vi) Political trends resulting in reform of the political system, constitution, statute, procedure; and (vii)The nature and type of the Speaker and the Members of a Legislature. 89. Information on the working mechanisms, processes and tools of a County Assembly will be availed in the following description of the structures, organs, components of the work, roles and functions. Environment in which A County Assembly would operate 90. The environment, in which a County Assembly would operate, is widely viewed as political. Yet imbedded within it are facets of technical knowledge encompassing, information on law, procedure, research briefings on the various items of the business dealt with, finance and budgeting, privilege, management and administrative aspects. An explanation on the following will put in proper perspective, how the foregoing are applied to enable a County Assembly execute its mandate, role and function:- A County Government 91. By the provisions of Section 1 (3) of the CK 2010, a County Assembly and a County Executive are State Organs which constitute a County Government under Section 176 (1) of the CK 2010. The County Government exercises powers and authority delegated by the sovereign; i.e. the people of Kenya. A County Assembly 92. A County Assembly is the forum through which the people, who own the sovereign power to govern, participate in the making of laws, formulation of policies for taxation, budgeting, establishment of County Public Service, et cetera. Through the same forum, the people maintain surveillance and oversight on how they are governed; while The County Executive gives an account of its operations in governing the County. 34 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Segments/Seasons in The Life of A County Assembly 93. A County Assembly has at least seven distinct Segments or Seasons, beginning when it first sits/ sworn in following a general election to the time it is dissolved upon expiration of its statutory term:93.1 A County Assembly • Is established in accordance with provisions of Sections 177 and 178 of CK 2010, 93.2 A Session of a County Assembly (i) The first sitting of the first session of a County Assembly after a general election shall be convened by the County Governor through a Notice in the Gazette. The Notice shall be issued within thirty days after declaration of the result of the general election. Further, it shall specify the place and date of the sitting. (ii) A Regular Session of a County Assembly is convened by the Hon. Speaker in each calendar year; commencing on the second Tuesday in February, or on a day/ date set by a resolution of the County Assembly; (iii) A Regular Session of a County Assembly is held for the duration already specified in its calendar; (iii) A Regular Session of a County Assembly is ended by an adjournment on the date specified in its calendar or dissolved upon expiry of its statutory term; (iv) In the fifth year of the life of a County Assembly, the dissolution would pave way for a general election. 93.3 A sitting of a County Assembly (i) Subject to a calendar of a County Assembly, each of the days therein on which a County Assembly meets as a Plenary, Committee of the Whole County Assembly or a Select Committee, is known as a sitting; (ii) Pursuant to provisions of Section 14 (1) (a) of the County Governments Act, 2012, the sittings are regulated by the Standing Orders; (iii) There are varied definitions of a sitting, depending on the nature of the business to be transacted at the sitting; (iv) The intervals between sets of sittings in a Session are known as Adjournments. 35 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 93.4 Prorogation of a County Assembly (i) A County Assembly may be prorogued pursuant to its calendar; (ii) In parliamentary parlance, prorogation signifies the cessation of the proceedings of one Session. (iii) Any business then pending before a County Assembly comes to an automatic halt and should there be a need to continue and conclude any of the halted business, the relevant Standing Orders would be applied. 93.5 Dissolution of a County Assembly (i) Subject to provisions of Section 177 (4) of CK 2010, a County Assembly stands automatically dissolved in the fifth year of its life, on the same day it first met after a general election; (ii) In parliamentary parlance, dissolution signifies the end of the life of one County Assembly 93.6 Adjournment of a County Assembly (i) An adjournment of a County Assembly is the interval/ an interruption of the sittings within a Session; in accordance with the Standing Orders; (ii) There are various forms of adjournment, depending on the causes or reasons, though predictability does emerge with practice. 93.7 Recess of a County Assembly (i) A recess is the period when a County Assembly is adjourned to a day which is not the next normal sitting day, including ,when it is adjourned at the end of a Session or prorogation; (ii) A recess at the end of a statutory life of a County Assembly may not be significant as it comes as a consequence of dissolution. The Oath of Allegiance or Affirmation of Allegiance 94. Pursuant to Section 74 of the CK 2010 and Section 9 (3) of the County Governments Act, 2012, every member of a County Assembly, cannot take his/her seat and participate in any business of a County Assembly, until he/she has subscribed to the Oath of Allegiance or Affirmation of Allegiance at a sitting of the Assembly. 95. A Judge administers the Oath of Allegiance or Affirmation to all Members assisted by the Clerk of a County Assembly. 36 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA The Oath at the first sitting of a County Assembly after a General Election 96. At the first sitting of a County Assembly following a general election, the procedure followed in administering the Oath or Affirmation of Allegiance to Members, is as follows:(i) Once all Members have taken their seats, the Clerk of a County Assembly:(a) Lays a complete list, as published in the Kenya Gazette by the IEBC of all Members Elected and Nominated on the Table of the County Assembly. (b) The names in the list are arranged alphabetically, starting with those of Elected Members. (c) Lays the Notice convening the session of the County Assembly, published by the County Governor in the Gazette. (ii) The Clerk of a County Assembly calls out the full names of each Member, who rises in her seat, proceeds to the Bar of the Assembly, where she bows to the Chair, then proceeds to the Table. (iii) The Clerk of a County Assembly, inquires from the Member, the religion he/ she belongs to and whether he/ she wishes to take an Oath or Affirm to an Allegiance; (iv) If the Member is a Christian or a Muslim, she would respectively be given a Bible or a Koran, which while lifting by her right hand and holding a Form containing the written Oath or Affirmation of Allegiance, will proceed to read out the text; (v) On conclusion, the Member shakes hands with the Judge, proceeds to the left side of the Table and signs the Oath of Allegiance Book, and then returns to her place, amidst congratulatory bench thumping by colleagues. (vi) The Member is at liberty to take the Oath or Affirmation of Allegiance in either of the official languages, used for communication in the proceedings of a County Assembly. The Oath on the other occasions, during the life of a County Assembly 97. On other occasions, the Administration of the Oath or Affirmation of Allegiance is performed by the Hon. Speaker as the first item of the proceedings at a sitting, soon after Prayers. On such occasions:- 37 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (i) The newly Elected or Nominated Member sits behind the Bar during Prayers; (ii) Immediately after Prayers, the Clerk of a County Assembly, reads out the first order of the day which is, the Administration of Oath, after which he reads out the full names of the new Member; (iii) The Hon. Speaker, the Members, the Clerks and the public rise and remain standing to the end of the Administration of Oath. (iv) The new Member rises, proceeds to the Bar and sandwiched between her two sponsoring Members, the three bow to the Chair, proceed to stand in front of the Mace, bow to the Chair once more; proceed to the space behind the Clerks’ seats and the Chair, bow again and remain standing facing the Hon. Speaker. (v) The senior of the two sponsoring Members, who is normally on the right of the new Member, introduces her to the Hon. Speaker; (vi) The Hon. Speaker then asks the new Member her religion and whether she would take an Oath or an Affirmation of Allegiance; (vii)Depending on the new Member’s reply, the Hon. Speaker is then handed the relevant material by the Clerk of the County Assembly which he proceeds to hand to the new Member; (viii)The Member taking either the Bible or the Koran in her right hand, raises it up and holds the Form containing the Oath or Affirmation of Allegiance in her left hand which she reads out aloud; (ix)The Member then returns the Bible/ Koran and the Oath/ Affirmation of Allegiance to the Hon. Speaker; (x)The Hon. Speaker shakes hands with the new Member, utters the special words of ‘welcome and best of luck”; (xii)Thereafter the new Member and her two sponsors proceed to the left of the Table where the new Member signs the Oath Book; (xiii)The trio then proceeds to the Bar, where they bow to the Chair before moving to their respective seats. 38 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA M. THE POWERS, PRIVILEGES AND IMMUNITIES OF A COUNTY ASSEMBLY ORIGIN OF PRIVILEGE Origin of Privilege 98. The Powers, Privileges and Immunities, often referred to as “Privilege”, which virtually, all legislatures enjoy and exercise in the performance of their mandates, roles and functions, have a long history. The genesis of Privilege stretches to over ten centuries in the evolution of the British Parliament at Westminster. The Privileges of the British Parliament were passed on to legislatures in virtually all British Colonies. Thus, Privilege has come to be by custom, tradition, convention, constitution and statute. 99. In Kenya, Privilege was first codified in an Act of the Legislative Council (Legco) in 1952. It is among the statutes which transited into re – Independence. Today it is entitled the National Assembly (Powers and Privileges) Act, Cap 6, Laws of Kenya. 100.Parliamentary Privilege is recognized and provided for by the CK 2010, for the National Parliament by Sections 117 and 125 and for the County Assemblies by Sections 195 and 196 (3). However, since Parliamentary Privilege, is nearly standard, Section 17 of the County Governments Act, 2012, acknowledge and affirm that status by stating, “The national law regulating the powers and privileges of Parliament shall, with the necessary modifications, apply to a County Assembly.” 101.Nevertheless and, so as to gain a proper perspective and appreciation of Parliamentary Privilege, a recourse to how it evolved at Westminster would be appropriate. Privilege and its content 102.The following lengthy quotation is from Parliamentary Practice, Twenty-Fourth Edition; whose original was authored by Sir Thomas Erskine May, former Clerk of the House of Commons, Westminster, U.K, in 1837. (i) Erskine May, the acknowledged authority on Parliamentary Practice, has defined Parliamentary Privilege as, the sum of the peculiar rights enjoyed by each House collectively as a constituent part of the High Court of 39 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Parliament, and by the Members of each House individually, without which they could not discharge their functions, and which exceed those possessed by other bodies or individuals. (ii)Thus, privilege, though part of the law of the land, is to a certain extent an exemption from the ordinary law. The distinctive mark of a privilege is its ancillary character, which puts Parliamentary Privilege in the context of the rights that, are “absolutely necessary for the due execution of its powers. (iii) Privilege is enjoyed by individual Members, because the House cannot perform its functions without unimpeded use of the services of its Members; and by each House for the protection of its Members and the vindication of its own authority and dignity. (iv)Indeed the origin of privilege was as the King’s peace (protection) enjoyed by his subjects, but in special measure by his servants (the staff of the royal courts, the Lords, et cetera. However, with time, new comers to the High Court of Parliament, the Commons, began to lay claim to privileges enjoyed by the Lords.” 103.The struggle by the House of Commons to gain some privilege from the Crown, the Courts and the Lords has been fierce and prolonged. To-day the U.K. House of Commons claims Parliamentary Privilege as customary rights. 104.By extension, these privileges were introduced to colonial legislatures. Hence, it is part of the great parliamentary tradition that at the commencement of a new Parliament, the Hon. Speaker reminds the Executive of the claim by the Legislature to its ancient rights and privileges. 105.By practice, Parliamentary Privilege which is the short form of all the Rights, Powers, Immunities and Privileges awarded to Parliament and the individual Members are now enjoyed by officers who serve in the Legislatures, witnesses appearing before the Legislatures and the Select Committees and persons involved in the printing and production of records of its proceedings and work. 106.The privileges awarded are double edged. They give all due protection and facilitate the operations of the House and Members in their individual capacity, but in the same vein they lay and make certain demands on them. 40 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA The Extent of Privilege - Examples 107.It is not intended to discuss the details of Privilege; however, the following are mentioned to give an indication of its extent. Immunities and Privileges 108.The object of these is, to ensure that Members of a County Assembly go about their business without impediment. Immunity from Legal Proceedings 109.No legal proceedings, whether criminal or civil can be instituted against any Member for words spoken before or written in report to a County Assembly or its Select Committee; or for any other matter in the course of a member executing her duties. This is per provisions of Section 16 of the County Governments Act, 2012. These provisions are often dubbed the “freedom of speech.” Freedom from arrest for Civil Debt 110.A Member may not be arrested for a civil debt during a Session, unless it is related to or has criminal intentions. Speakers Orders 111.The Hon. Speaker would from time to time issue Orders for the better carrying out of the purposes of privilege. Such orders cover matters like, the deduction/ recovery from earnings of Members in payment of refreshments or other facilities made available to them within the precincts of a County Assembly. The orders would normally be authenticated by the Clerk of a County Assembly and when exhibited in a conspicuous position within the precincts of a County Assembly, it is deemed to be sufficient notice to all concerned persons. 41 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Code of Conduct 112.These are directions issued from time to time by the Hon. Speaker to regulate the conduct of Members whilst in the precincts of a County Assembly other than the Chamber. Conduct in the Chamber is governed by the Standing Orders. Committee of Privilege 113.Comprise Members appointed by a County Assembly and chaired by the Hon. Speaker. This Committee inquires into reported complaints, breaches of privilege by any Member that is intended or likely to reflect adversely on the dignity or integrity of a County Assembly, et cetera. Reports of such inquiries and any recommendations are placed before a County Assembly for consideration. Power to Order Attendance and Giving of Evidence 114.The object of the powers and privileges in relation to gathering of evidence by a County Assembly and its Select Committees is to ease the processes and extend the privilege to persons co-operating in that regard. 115.In the course of its proceedings, a Select Committee has powers to order the attendance before it of any person it deems has evidence, papers, records or documents that would be useful to the Committee. In this regard, the Select Committee would invoke provisions of Section 125 of CK 2010. 116.The persons appearing before a County Assembly or any of its Select Committees to give any form of evidence could be examined under oath, as the County Assembly or Select Committee find appropriate. Privileges of Witnesses 117.All persons summoned to give any form of evidence before a County Assembly or a Select Committee, enjoy the same rights and privileges as before a Court of Law. Public officers could decline to give evidence, as provided for in Section 18 of the Official Secrets Act Cap 6, Laws of Kenya. 42 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Sanctions against False Evidence 118.Some of the provisions against breaches of the Law of Privilege include:(i) Witnesses who give false evidence before a County Assembly or any of its Select Committees would be guilty of an offence under Section 108 of the Penal Code, Cap 63, Laws of Kenya. (ii) Members are not supposed to receive reward for promotion or opposition to Bills, Motions et cetera. Any Member who in the course of his/ her duties receives or accepts either directly or indirectly any bribe, fee, compensation, gift or reward for the promotion or opposition to any Bill, Motion or any matter submitted for the consideration of a County Assembly or a Select Committee, shall be guilty of an offence and liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years or to a fine not exceeding ten thousand shillings, or to both; and every bribe, fee, compensation, gift or reward accepted or received by him/ her shall be forfeited. Protection of persons responsible for publications authorised by a County Assembly 119.All persons and organizations involved in the printing and publication of any reports, papers, minutes, votes and proceedings, the Hansard, enjoy immunity from any legal process as long as a certificate issued under the hand of the Hon. Speaker shall signify that such persons or their servants were acting under the authority of a County Assembly. Courts not to exercise jurisdiction in respect of acts of the Hon. Speaker and Officers of a County Assembly 120.The exercise of any power vested or conferred upon the Hon. Speaker or any officer of a County Assembly by the Law of Privilege is not subject to jurisdiction of any court. Officers of a County Assembly to have powers of Police Officer 121.Every officer of a County Assembly shall, while acting under the law of privilege and of the application of the provisions of the criminal law, have all the powers and enjoy all the privileges of a police officer. 43 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Further Reading on Privilege 122.The above summary is meant to guide hon. Members who are encouraged to read more closely so as to fathom their grasp of Parliamentary Privilege and application. It is recommended that, hon. Members read relevant material in the Twenty Fourth Edition of Parliamentary Practice by Sir Thomas Erskine May which is available in the Library of the National Parliament. Mechanisms for the Public to Access, Participate and Oversight a County Assembly 123.The mechanisms and processes by which the public have the right to access, participate and exercise oversight on the work of a County Assembly are by custom, tradition, practice and statute. Both the CK 2010 and the effecting Acts of Parliament, for instance the County Governments Act, 2012. provide specific rights and avenues for such engagement. The statutory provisions are specified in Part F. Enhancement of Democratic Culture and Accountability. N. THE WORK AND PROCEEDINGS OF A COUNTY ASSEMBLY Work of a County Assembly 124.The work transacted by a County Assembly is in the form of items emanating from and meant to enable a County Assembly fulfill its mandate, role and function. The work constitutes the agenda of a County Assembly, known as Orders of the Day, placed on an Order Paper for each sitting. The orders of the day are disposed of through a series of activities, according to procedure and practice as synchronized in clearly enforceable statements, known as Standing Orders. 125.The work of a County Assembly is provided for by custom, tradition, convention, practice and statute, as indeed, are its mandate, roles and functions. The quality and the quantity of the work often more or less depend on the state of democratic fervour 44 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA in the country, the calibre of the Members, not necessarily, in terms of academic achievement, but more in terms of political efficacy and acumen. Proceedings of a County Assembly 126.The proceedings of a County Assembly, on the other hand, is the sum of what happens in the Chamber of a County Assembly from the moment it is duly assembled, i.e. when the Hon. Speaker has taken the Chair of the County Assembly. The proceedings are a product of the words spoken and the decisions taken to transact the orders of the day and other pronouncements incidental thereto. The Hon. Speaker presides and guides the proceedings according to the totality of the practice and procedure of a County Assembly. 127.The orders of the day do not all constitute the work or the business of a County Assembly. However, the outcome of their transaction is the proceedings of a County Assembly, which is recorded in the verbatim format, commonly referred to as the Hansard. The Order Paper 128.The orders of the Day of the proceedings of a sitting of a County Assembly would be put on an Order Paper in the following format:- Prayer (i) Matters other than Business (a) Administration of Oath (b) Communication from the Chair (c) Message from the Senate (d) Presentation of Petitions (e) Papers to be Laid before a County Assembly (f) Notices of Motions (g) Statements (ii) Business to be transacted would be as set out on the Order Paper; here could be placed- 45 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (a) Bills at various stages of transaction – • First Reading; Second Reading; Committee of the Whole County Assembly; Third Reading. (b) Motions on various issues• Adoption of a report of a Select Committee; • Urging a County Assembly to establish an ad hoc Select Committee to investigate the increasing incidents of violence among sand harvesters in River Sabwani on the boundary of Trans- Nzoia and West Pokot Counties. 129.The proceedings arising out of the disposal of the orders of the day on the Order Paper as at paragraph 127 above could consist of business introduced by political parties and individual Members for decisions that would the fulfillment of a pledge in an election manifesto. At the same time, some could be for, new legislation to deal with an aspect of governance which a County Executive find necessary. Further clarification is in the following brief explanation on some of the orders of the day. Orders of the Day and Order of Proceedings 130.Paragraph 129 to 144 sheds light on the items in the Order Paper and also on the nature of the individual orders. 131.Some of the matters which are not placed in the Order Paper include: (i) Points of Order, (ii) Notices for Motions of Adjournment on urgent matters of National/ County importance; (iii) Dilatory Motions of adjournment of a County Assembly; (iv) Queries relating to lack of Quorum; (v) Dilatory Motions of adjournment of Debates, (vi) Motions which may be moved without notice. The Order Paper: Preparation and Publicisation 132.The Order Paper is a schedule showing the sequence of agenda items, called Orders of the Day, to be dealt with by a County Assembly at one sitting. It is prepared by the 46 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Clerk of a County Assembly under the direction of the Hon. Speaker on the authority of the Sessional Committee under the chairpersonship of the Majority Leader. The Clerk of a County Assembly also prepares and publicizes a Weekly Programme and Schedule of Sittings of Select Committees which is published on the website and distributed to departments of the County Executive. 133.The running sequence of the items on the Order Paper is split into two distinct parts:- Matters other than Business 134. Administration of Oath.This is to enable any newly elected or nominated Member to be sworn in or affirm to the Oath of Allegiance. Communication from the Chair 135. This is for the Hon. Speaker to convey any message e.g. Notification of Assent to Bills by H.E. the Governor. He may also give a Considered Ruling or some information to a County Assembly regarding additions, deferment of the Orders of the Day. Presentation of Petitions 136.This is an opportunity for Members to present any Petition from wananchi who could be their constituents or interest group, with a prayer for some action by a County Assembly to give relief on some matter or situation. Papers to be Laid before a County Assembly 137.This is an opportunity for some official documents, such as, reports of the accounts of some County Corporation or those of Select Committees of the County Assembly to be formally presented to the Assembly. Notices of Motions 138.This is an opportunity for a Member who has a Notice of a Motion she intends to move in the future to bring the terms of such a Motion to the attention of a County 47 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Assembly; Notices relate only to Substantive Motions, which will have been approved by the Hon. Speaker and balloted by the Sessional Committee. Placement of Business on the Order Paper 139.Business of a County Assembly comprises items introduced by the Government, Party and Individual Member; each of which cause their business to be placed on the Order Paper, subject to processing by the Select Committee 140.The Business is disposed of in the sequence in which it stands on the Order Paper, or in such other sequence as the Hon. Speaker may decide for the convenience of a County Assembly. 141.The Leader of the Majority Party shall place the business submitted by the County Executive Committee on the Order Paper in such sequence as the Standing Orders provide. However, on every Wednesday Morning on which a County Assembly sits, business other than Government business; except the business of the Financial Statement and the Annual Estimates; has precedence. 142.Occasionally, on some of the sittings on Wednesday Morning, when it is desired to have Government business dealt with, a procedural motion is moved as the first item of Business to exempt Government Business from the mandatory requirement of the Standing Order No. 34 which give precedence to Business other than Government Business on Wednesday Mornings. 142.Order Papers have a running index number for each sitting while pages have running numbers for each page as a record for proceedings in a Session. The Votes and Proceedings 143.The Votes and Proceedings is the precise summary of the proceedings of a County Assembly at each sitting, whose particulars are: (i) The summarized record of what was said, done or transacted at the Sitting. All proceedings, i.e. both matters constituting non- business and business are recorded in the order in which they were dealt with or occur. 48 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (ii) The sequence set out on the Order Paper is sometimes not strictly followed; though, whenever this happens, the alteration, is recorded too. (iii) The part of the proceedings not recorded in the Votes and Proceedings include: (a) Points of Order on matters of procedure; (b) The entry, withdrawal and departure of the Hon. Speaker from the Chamber; and any action, noise by strangers; (iv) The part of the proceedings that are recorded in the Votes and Proceedings, include, (a) Time a County Assembly assembled; (b) Prayer; (c) Administration of Oath, only if administered; (d) Communication from the Chair, only if given; (e) Petitions, only if any were presented; (f) Papers, only if any was laid on the Table; (g) Notices of Motions, only if any was given; (h) The rest will be a record of the business disposed of in the sequence it was transacted, whether it was adopted, negatived, deferred or dropped. (i) In the process of disposition of business, matters other than business, that arise are also recorded, plus a brief summary of any statements made; and (j) Results of a division by name; (k) Time of interruption of proceedings, the name of the Presiding Officer who actually adjourned the sitting and the date of reconvening, if known. How matters get on the Order Paper 144.The matters contained on the Order Paper at any sitting are split into those that are automatically included and those that are put by the initiative of a Member. 145.The matters that are automatically included in the Order Paper comprise: (i) Prayer; (ii) Administration of Oath; 49 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (iii) Communication from the Chair; (iv)The Official Opening of a County Assembly; (v) Petitions; (vi) Notices of Motions; (vii) Statements; and (viii) Messages from the Senate. 146.The matters whose inclusion arise from the initiative of a Member, comprise:(i) Substantive Motions for debate. (ii) Stages of a Bill; (iii) Substantive Motions for Adjournment of a County Assembly, usually specified; (iv) Notices of amendments intended to be moved to Bills during the Committee Stage; (v) The address of the County Governor on State of the County and on any other subject; et cetera. Modes of Decision Making 147.Pursuant to Section 20 of the County Governments Act, 2012 decisions of a County Assembly, are signified by voting. The voting is either by the counting of voices (oral) or by a physical count (division). Both modes of decision making apply to all matters of substantive nature on which the House is required to make a decision. However, there are some occasions on which divisions with specific majority votes are mandatory, for instance:• To overturn the veto of a County Governor upon declining to assent to a Bill passed by a County Assembly, under Section 24 (5) of the County Governments Act, 2012. Decision (Voting on Motions) 148.When the debate is concluded: (i) the Hon. Speaker puts the question and a vote is taken (ii) the question is to be put, in the following words: 50 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA “Will as many as are of that opinion say, “Aye”. “As many as are of a contrary opinion say, “Noe”. (iii) The Hon. Speaker must then collect the voices and decide whether the “Ayes” or “Noes” have it. He will then pause and if no one objects and cries “Division” he will say, “The Ayes have it.” and that is the decision of the County Assembly on the subject of that Motion. Claiming/Calling for vote by Division 149.A Division is taken if a Member claims and – (a) The Hon. Speaker considers there is reasonable doubt as to the outcome; or (b) Twenty percent or more further Members rise to support the Member claiming a Division and the question is not one of procedure; or (c) The constitution or statute requires the question to be carried by a certain majority. 150.When the Hon. Speaker directs a Division to be taken, the Division bell is rung for five minutes. Tellers for a Division 151.Two Tellers for the “Noes” and two Tellers for the “Ayes” are to be named by the Hon. Speaker in consultation with the two Chief Whips. 152.At the end of five minutes the Hon. Speaker orders the doors to be locked and the Bar drawn. No Member may thereafter enter the House. 153.The Hon. Speaker then announces the names of the Tellers and says; “Ayes” to the right and “Noes” to the left – proceed to a division. The doors to the lobbies shall be unlocked fifteen minutes thereafter. 154.The Clerks- at- the Table and the Tellers tick off the names of each Member as he files past. 51 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Member not obliged to Vote 155.No Member shall be obliged to vote in a Division, however those present but not voting shall record their names with the Clerk of the County Assembly at the Table. Fifteen minutes after the locking of the doors to the Lobbies, the County Assembly or the Committee of the Whole County Assembly shall be called to order and any Member who shall not have voted then shall forfeit her right to vote. The result of the division is announced by the Hon. Speaker. Status the Division- No vote for the Hon. Speaker 156.The Hon. Speaker has neither an original nor casting voting. Where the result is equal, the question is negatived (lost). 157.On all other occasions, when a County Assembly votes, decisions are carried by simple majority of the Members present and voting. O. THE PRATICE AND PROCEDURE Content of the Practice and Procedure of a County Assembly 158.The processes by which a County Assembly transacts its proceedings, Members relation to each other, the required etiquette the totality of what it applies in carrying out its mandate, role and functions may in one word be referred to as procedure. 159.The Procedure is wide and include: (i) The unwritten and un-codified working processes that have come into place by usage, tradition, convention, etiquette and the rulings of the Hon. Speaker, normally referred to as the Practice; (ii) The written or codified form, normally referred to as the procedure; (iii) The whole totality is known as Practice and Procedure; 52 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA IN THE CHAMBER – CONDUCT OF MEMBERS AND OF BUSINESS The Speaker, Entering and Leaving the Chamber 160.When the five minute bell rings, Members should proceed with dignity to the Chamber. On the Hon. Speaker being announced, Members should stop talking and make their way to their seats, where they should stand in silence. The Hon. Speaker will bow at the Bar and on arriving at the Table will face the County Assembly and read a Prayer. 161. The Hon. Speaker would then mount the dais, bow to Members on the right and then to those on the left. Members should turn slightly to the Hon. Speaker and return the bow. When the Hon. Speaker sits, Members sit. 162. At the conclusion of business, the Hon. Speaker would rise and bow to the right and the left .Members should also rise and return the bow of the Hon. Speaker. Members remain standing silently in their places until the procession leading the Speaker out is clear of the Chamber. Whenever the Speaker rises 163.When the Hon. Speaker, or the Chairperson of a Committee, rises to intervene in a debate, Members must be silent. Should a Member, at that time be speaking, or standing, she must resume her seat. It is out of order to interrupt the Hon. Speaker and any Member entering the Chamber at that time, must stand in a respectful manner at the Bar until the Hon. Speaker or the Chairperson of a Committee, has completed speaking. Catching the eye of the Speaker 164. A member may not speak in a debate until his name has been called out by the Hon. Speaker that, is until he has “caught the eye of the Hon. Speaker”. 165. Members should stand up and speak from their own places while addressing all their remarks to the Chair. 53 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Referring to the occupants of the Chair 166. The occupant of the Chair is addressed as the Hon. Speaker, or the Hon. Temporary Speaker, as the case may be, or in Committee as the Hon. Chairperson. A lady member who occupies the Chair is referred to as the Hon. Madam Speaker. Members entering and leaving the Chamber during a sitting 167. When the Members enter the Chamber during a Sitting, they should halt at the Bar and bow to the Chair. This is a customary practice by which every Member acknowledges with respect, the authority of the Chair. Similarly, Members wishing to leave the Chamber should bow to the Hon. Speaker on rising from their seats and proceed to the Bar of a County Assembly where they should again bow. Members passing from one side of a County Assembly to the other 168. A Member must not pass between the Chair and any Member who is speaking; to do this is violation of the etiquette of a County Assembly. A Member crossing the floor from one side of the Chamber to the other must pause and bow to the Chair. It is out of order to pass between the Chair and the Table, i.e. in front of the Hon. Speaker and behind the seats used by the Clerk of a County Assembly and the Clerks-at-the-Table. 168. Should Members on opposite sides of the House wish to consult, they should withdraw through the Main Entrance or proceed to the screen behind the Chair of the Hon. Speaker. Papers to be read inside the Chamber 169. Members must not read extraneous papers, such as newspapers, periodicals, et cetera; in the Chamber; unless they are to be quoted in the course of a debate. Members not to read out their speeches 170. It is out of order to read a speech. Exceptions to this rule would include; delivery of a Government Statement, opening a debate, as they are deemed, authoritative 54 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA pronouncements, figures or technicalities, which cannot be memorized easily or whenever the Hon. Speaker is satisfied that, the necessity for precision of the statement, justify its being read out. Further, Members can refer to notes or quote brief extracts from documents. 171. Exception to speaking more than once in a Debate Ideally a member is not allowed to speak more than once on each question in a debate. However, there is no restriction on the number of times she may speak to a Motion in a Committee of the Whole County Assembly, Points of Order, Statements and in any other proceedings which are not in the category of debate. Inadmissible Articles/Substances 172.Articles such as weapons, walking sticks, umbrellas, fly switches, desk top computers, lap tops et cetera, should not be brought into the Chamber. Dress Code 173.Members would be expected to attend sittings of a County Assembly dressed respectably, they may wear national costumes established by tradition, or by more recent custom, but not ostentatious headgear or others which would stir concern in the Chamber. Personal Statements 174. These provide a limited opportunity for a Member who has been criticized for his conduct or remarks, in the County Assembly, to justify his action and to apologize or remove any misunderstanding. Permission to make such a statement must be obtained from the Hon. Speaker, who will normally allow it prior to commencement of Business. This opportunity must not be used to respond to matters not emanating from the proceedings or related to activities of Members in a County Assembly. 55 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Maiden Speeches 175. Maiden Speeches are given high priority and are usually treated with special courtesy. The Member making a Maiden Speech, should be congratulated by the other Members speaking following her. Ideally, before delivering a Maiden Speech, the Member should announce vividly her name and the Electoral Ward she represents, if she is an Elected Member. Members to be heard without Interruption 176. A Member has a right to be heard without interruption, provided he is not out of order, irrelevant or repetitive; though inoffensive interjections which do not seriously interrupt his speech are not discouraged. While an occasional interjection may add spice to a debate, continuous interruptions cannot be tolerated and Members should desist from making them. Drawing attention to Breach of Order 177. Members may draw the attention of the Hon. Speaker to any breach of order. To do so a Member may interrupt a colleague who is speaking with the words, “On a point of order, Hon. Speaker…..”The Hon. Speaker will then give a brief ruling on the matter, or state that, he defers the ruling to another day. Interrupting a Member Speaking to offer Information 178. A Member who is speaking may permit interruption by another Member who wishes to elucidate a point. Such a Member will attempt to rise with the words, “Will, the Hon. Member permit me?”or “Would, the Hon. Member kindly give way?” or “On a point of information”. The Member, then speaking will usually resume his seat, while the interrupting Member asks for or gives explanation of a point , but if the hour is late, or if the Member then speaking suspects the other of merely trying to harass him, he may indicate that he is not prepared to give way. 56 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Interrupting a Member Speaking - Point of Order 179. A Member speaking may be interrupted at any time on a Point of Order. The words used are, “Hon. Speaker, on a Point of Order”. The member interrupting thus must be certain that, his point is a Point of Order and not a point of explanation or a point of argument. Points of Order may relate either to the propriety of what the Member then speaking has said, or to any other matter which is immediately relevant to the procedure (including a proposal to move the Closure of a Debate). Manner of speaking in a County Assembly 180. Erskine May, who is the authority on parliamentary procedure, states, “Good temper and moderation are the characteristics of parliamentary language. Parliamentary language is never more desirable than, when a Member is canvassing the opinions and conduct of his opponents in debate.” Reflections in a County Assembly during debate against the character and proceedings of the Assembly or its Members which tend to degrade the legislature are prohibited. Members referring to Colleagues 181. Members may not refer to colleagues by name, instead they should employ such appropriate description, as:distinguishing each Member by the office she holds; (i) by the Electoral Ward she represents or by some such designation as, “The hon. Member who just resumed her seat,” or “The hon. Member who has just spoken so eloquently,” (ii) a lady Member should be referred to as, ”The hon. and Gracious Lady, the Member for….”, (iii) a former member of the Armed Services as, “The hon. and Gallant member for….”, (iv) a Member having legal qualifications as, “The hon. and learned Member for….”, 57 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (v) Nominated Members may be referred to as, “The hon. Nominated Member who has just spoken,” or “The hon. Nominated Member Mr. X.” (in this case her name may be used). The art of Speaking 182. Members whose speeches are uninteresting, repetitive or irrelevant would soon find themselves speaking to empty benches, even if not called to order for repetition or irrelevance. When to speak in a Debate 183. No Member other than the proposer and the seconder may speak in a debate until the question has been proposed from the Chair. Moderate Language- Un parliamentary Words 184. Members are expected to observe moderation of language and avoid saying anything which might reflect on the motives, honesty or sincerity of another Member. Though there may be no exact definition of an un parliamentary expression, it has been held in most legislatures that, such references as “ignorant”, “wasting time”, “sit down”, “stooge”, “shut up”, “nonsense”, “lie”, “liar”, “stupid”, and many others fall in that category. 185. Cries of “shame”, particularly if voiced loudly, are considered to be a gross form of misconduct; however, cries of “hear hear”, in moderation, can be used, but when frequent and loud for the purpose of interrupting a speech, they are considered as un parliamentary. Such cries as “Questions”, “Order”, or “Division”, when used in moderation, would be permitted by the Hon. Speaker. Declaration of Personal Interest and Relevancy 186. A Member who wishes to speak on any matter in which he has a personal interest shall first declare that interest. 58 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 187. The subject matter of the Motion must be studied, to ensure that the speeches are relevant to that subject matter. Irrelevancy could cause the Hon. Speaker to discontinue the speech of a Member. Decided matters may be rescinded 188. When a matter has been decided by debate and resolution of a County Assembly, it cannot be discussed further in the course of any subsequent debate during the next six months. It may only be revisited on a motion to rescind the decision taken on it earlier. Anticipation of matters likely be debated 189. Matters which are to be the subject of a debate (whether on a Motion or in respect of a Bill) in the near future must not be referred to in a current debate, unless with the guidance of the Speaker. 190. Members must not repeat, in the course of any one debate, what they or other Members have already said. Allegations and Substantiation of Fact 191. Members should refrain from alleging specific matters of fact as being true, unless they are prepared to substantiate them by producing some kind of evidence which reasonably justifies such allegations, though not necessarily amounting to strict proof. Quorum of a County Assembly 192. A Member may rise at any time on a Point of Order and draw the attention of the Hon. Speaker to the fact that, a quorum is not present. A quorum of a County Assembly is one third of all its Members. 59 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA P. HOW RESOLUTIONS ARE MADE - MOTIONS Substantive Motions 193. A Substantive Motion is a self-contained proposal which upon debate and adoption would constitute a decision of the House. Notice of a Motion 194. All Substantive Motions are preceded by its sponsoring Member giving a Notice containing its purpose, objects and contents to the County Assembly. There are exceptions to this rule, for instance, Motions in the Committee of the whole County Assembly. 195. Before giving Notice of a Motion, a Member would deliver to the Clerk a copy of the proposed Motion in writing and signed by himself. The Clerk submits the same to the Hon. Speaker, who may admit it or direct that it be altered or that it is inadmissible. 196. When a Notice of Motion is approved by the Hon. Speaker, the Member gives notice by reading the text out at a sitting of the County Assembly when the Clerk calls out the order of the day, “Notice of Motion”. 197. Motions sponsored by the Majority Party, the Minority party or any other Party, shall have precedence over all other Motions on the days specified in the Standing Orders. Variation on this, may be made by the Sessional Committee in consultation with the sponsoring party. 198. Once a Notice of a Motion has been given, the Sessional Committee decides on the sitting at which it could be debated. Whereas a Notice of Motion could be withdrawn by the Member who gave the Notice; the same Notice could be given again either by the same or any other Member. The substance of a Motion should be prefaced with such words as: “That, in the opinion of this County Assembly….” 60 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA “That, this County Assembly approves….” “That, this County Assembly urges Government to….” “That, this County Assembly notes….” Etc. “That, this County Assembly calls upon the Senate/Government to….” 199. A Member who has a Motion standing in her name, may authorise in writing another Member to move that Motion in her stead. When a Member fails to move a Motion 200. If a Member is not present to move her Motion at the time when it appears on the Order Paper, such motion shall not appear again on the Order Paper during the same session except with the leave of the Hon. Speaker. Reserving the right to speak on a Motion 201. A Motion must be seconded. The Member seconding the Motion, could reserve her right to speak later in the debate, by rising in her place and bowing without speaking. When a Motion is in possession of a County Assembly 202. When a Motion has been moved and seconded, the Hon. Speaker will, propose the question by saying, “The question before the House is that….” ( reads out the Motion). Once the question has been proposed, the Motion is open to debate and deemed to be in the possession of a County Assembly; and cannot be withdrawn without the leave of the Assembly. Amendments to a Motion- Motion as amended 203. Amendments and amendments to amendments can be proposed in the course of the debate. However, only one question should be before the Assembly at one time. Therefore, the County Assembly has to dispose of amendments before resuming the debate on the original or amended Motion, as the case may be. 61 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 204. If the Motion is amended, the Hon. Speaker will propose the question in its new form before the debate continues. Any Member who has not spoken to the original Motion can take part in the debate on the Motion as amended, even though he has spoken to the amendment, unless the Hon. Speaker had ruled that, the motion and the amendment should be debated together. Right of a Mover to Reply 205. Before the debate is concluded, the Mover of the original Motion has the right to reply. Moving amendments to Bills and Motions 206. A proposal before the County Assembly may be agreed to or negatived as it stands, or it might be agreed to if it were altered in some way by means of an amendment. This procedure is applicable to Motions and Bills. Every amendment must be relevant to the question which it proposes to amend. An amendment may take one or other of the following forms:(i) leaving out certain words; (ii) adding or inserting certain words; or (iii) leaving out certain words and adding or inserting others. (iv) an amendment must be handed to the Clerk-at-the-Table in writing before it is moved. 207. An amendment to a Bill at Committee stage must be notified to the Clerk of a County Assembly in writing before the commencement of the sitting at which that Bill is to be considered, unless it is moved by the Member in charge of that Bill. An amendment to an amendment in Committee may, however, be moved on delivering it, in writing, to the Chairperson at that time. Amendment not to negate a Bill or a Motion 208. No amendment is permitted if it implies a direct negative of the original proposal, or elimination of its main purpose/ objective. The correct way to expressing a contrary opinion is by voting against the Motion. 62 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Time at which an amendment is to be moved 209. An amendment may be moved at any time after the original Motion has been proposed and before the final question has been put. Any amendment proposed in the County Assembly must be seconded unless it is an amendment in Committee of the Whole County Assembly. How to second an Amendment 210.Unlike the seconder of a Substantive Motion, the seconder of an amendment cannot second formally by bowing and thereby reserving her right to speak later. If she wishes to speak to the amendment, she must do so at the time she seconds the amendment. Q. HOW A LAW IS MADE - ACTS OF COUNTY ASSEMBLY What is a Bill? 211.A Bill is draft legislation for consideration by a County Assembly. Upon approval and assent to by the County Governor, it is called an Act of the County Assembly. 212.Each member receives copies of all Bills which are for introduction to the County Assembly. Stages in the making of a Law 213. Not more than one stage of a Bill may be taken at the same sitting without the leave of the House. A Bill passes through six stages. These are: (i) Drafting, Printing and Circulation- A time limit is set, prior to the next stage, to enable the public read and study it and prepare to participate. (ii) First Reading- to draw the attention of the Members and the public to the Bill. At this stage, the Bill may be referred to the relevant Sectoral Committee. (iii) Second Reading- the Mover introduces ,outlines its aims and objectives and all 63 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA details .Members discuss the Bill and the views of the Mover together with the report of the Sectoral Committee. At the end of the Second Reading, the only amendment that could be made, is to defer its Second Reading for six monthsliterary, “killing the bill” (iv) Committee of the Whole County Assembly as a Stage- the Bill is considered clause by clause. Members may propose amendments. (See paragraph 208 to 213 above). (v) Report Stage- the Committee informs the County Assembly sitting in Plenary of their consideration of the Bill. (vi) Third Reading- Members may again debate the principles of what is already in the Bill but further amendments should not be proposed, except to defer its Third Reading for six months, literary-“killing the Bill” Assent of the County Governor 214.When a Bill has passed its Third Reading in the County Assembly sitting in Plenary, it is sent by the Hon. Speaker to the Governor for assent. 215.Procedure to be followed where the Governor declines to assent to a Bill passed by a County Assembly are in Section 24 of the County Governments Act, 2012 and S.O.121. Custody of Acts of a County Assembly 216.All Bills enacted by a County Assembly and assented to by the Governor shall be in the custody of the Clerk of the County Assembly. Adherence to the Fourth Schedule of CK 2010 217.In executing the legislative power of the County, the County Assembly shall ensure that all Bills introduced adhere to the Fourth Schedule CK 2010. 64 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA R. SITTINGS AND ADJOURNMENTS AND ADJOURNMENT MOTIONS Sittings 218.The sittings of a County Assembly, pursuant to provisions of S.O.20 are held as follows:(i) Afternoon Sittings are held on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday, commencing at 2.30 p.m. and are interrupted at 6.30 p.m.; but they may on some days, by a resolution of a County Assembly, be extended for an agreed period; (ii) Morning Sittings are held on Wednesday commencing at 9.00 a.m. and are interrupted at 12.30 p.m. (iii) In the Committee of Supply, each of the allotted days must consist of three hours, either in the morning or afternoon. Sittings on the afternoon of an allotted day may continue up to 07.00 p.m. Adjournments 219.The normal interruption of proceedings of normal sittings would come at 12.30 p.m. and at 6.30 p.m. ,respectively, during Afternoon and Morning sittings. 220.The Adjournment of a County Assembly would also come about in the event of there being no Quorum under provisions of Standing Order 26. Such adjournment is normally without question put. Motions for the Adjournment 221.These Motions are split into Substantive and Dilatory (i) The Substantive Motions End of Normal Sitting The adjournment of a County Assembly under S.O. 24, to a day other than the 65 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Next Normal Sitting day or sine die is secured by a resolution of the Assembly. The resolution would normally be by a Motion contained in a Notice appended to the Order Paper for the Sitting at which such Adjournment is contemplated. To raise Definite Urgent Matters of the State /County Importance 222.The Adjournment secured pursuant to provisions of Standing Order No.23, would enable a Member, raise a matter considered Definite, Urgent and of State or County Importance. Motions seeking this kind of Adjournment are moved at any time and without notice. The sequence of events leading up to the moving of such motions is as follows:(i)The Member should hand a written notification of the matter she wishes to raise to the Hon. Speaker, at least two hours before the commencement of a Sitting at which she intends to raise the matter; (ii)The Hon. Speaker has the duty to decide whether he considers the matter to be one which falls within the phrase “a definite, urgent matter of State/ County importance” (iii)Should the Hon. Speaker decide in the affirmative he then accordingly informs the County Assembly; (iv)If not less than five other Members rise in their places in support, the Hon. Speaker shall then nominate a time on the same day at which such a Motion may be moved; (v)This form of motion is intended to facilitate the discussion of a particular subject, and only that subject may be discussed. The object is not literally to adjourn a County Assembly; but to set aside scheduled business to facilitate the deliberation, ventilation on that particular matter; (vi)At the conclusion of the debate, no question is put. (ii) Dilatory Adjournment Motions 223.These are motions made for the purpose of gaining time, postponing the decision on a question and may be a safe way to evade altogether having to make any decision at all. There are the following types:- 66 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Adjournment of a debate 224.These Motions can be moved by a Member at any time after a Question has been proposed, that she wishes to postpone to some future occasion the further discussion of the proposed question, by stating, if, in a County Assembly, “That, the debate be adjourned”; or if in the Committee of the whole County Assembly, “That, the Chairperson do report progress”. (i) The Hon. Speaker or the Chairperson has to decide whether such a Motion is not frivolous and an abuse of the proceedings of a County Assembly, if it is not, he will forthwith put the question; or if it is, he may decline to propose the question. (ii) The debate on any such Motion is confined to matters raised in the Motion; which if adopted the debate on the proposed question ceases forthwith. Adjournment of a County Assembly 225.These Motions can be moved, pursuant to provisions of S.O. 21 by any Member at any time in the course of proceedings. Motions in this regard include, those seeking the adjournment of the Assembly, to facilitate attendance by the Assembly to some urgent State/County matter within the Nation or the County. These Motions are moved without notice, and are concluded by putting of the question. (i) The Hon. Speaker has the task of deciding whether the Motion is frivolous, vexatious or an abuse of the proceedings of a County Assembly; if it is, he may decline to put the question; otherwise, he may forthwith put the question. (ii) The debate on such a Motion shall be confined to the matter of the Motion, which if adopted, the County Assembly adjourns immediately, otherwise deliberation on the proposed question resumes. (iii) A Member who has moved or seconded a negatived dilatory Motion may not subsequently move or second another such motion during the same debate. (iv) Even though a dilatory Motion may have been moved and negative, more such Motions may be moved by any other Member during the same debate. 67 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Motions to curtail ongoing Business 226.Motions under this form of procedure are also dilatory and are moved in the course of proceedings after a question has been proposed. These Motions may be moved at any time and comprise the following:(i) A Member may at any time seek to curtail the further discussion of a question to which the Mover has the right to reply, by moving a closure. The Member moving this kind of a Motion rises in her place on a point of order and states- “That, the Mover be called upon to reply”. (a) The Hon. Speaker has the duty to decide whether such a Motion is an abuse of the proceedings of the Assembly or an infringement of the rights of Members, if not, then the question shall be put forthwith and decided without debate; and if he thinks so, then the debate on the question then before the House shall resume. (b) If the Hon. Speaker puts the Question and it is decided in the affirmative, then the Mover shall reply immediately, if she does not wish to reply, the question of the main question shall be put. (ii) A Member may at any time seek to curtail the further discussion of a question to which the Mover has no right to reply, by moving a closure. The Member moving this kind of a Motion, rises in her place on a point of order, and states, “That, the question be now put”. • Such motions are dealt with in a manner similar to that above. Leave of the County Assembly 227.Wherever, the procedure or any, Standing Order, requires “the leave of the County Assembly”; it refers to a situation where there is no objection by any Member, either with the sympathy of the Hon. Speaker or, with the support of at least two other Members. Limitations of Debate 228.The House may impose a limit on the duration of a debate on any particular motion and also a limit on the amount of time set aside for each Member wishing to speak 68 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA to the debate. Both limitations could be imposed on the same Motion. There are limitations imposed on certain specific business, e.g. debates on both the Public and Private Bills; adoption of reports of Select Committees and of the Motions. Members should refer to the relevant Standing Order for details. S. THE COMMITTEES OF A COUNTY ASSEMBLY 229.The procedure of a County Assembly provide for the formation of two kinds of Committees; (i) Committees of the Whole County Assembly; and (ii) Select Committees which comprise Standing, Ad hoc and Sectoral Committees; Committees of the Whole County Assembly 230.There are three types of Committees of the Whole County Assembly. (i) Committee of the Whole County Assembly on Committee stage of a Bill 231.Once a Bill has gone through a Second Reading, it is automatically committed to the Committee of the Whole County Assembly. (ii) Committee of the Whole County Assembly on the Budget 232.Following the submission of annual or supplementary estimates of expenditure of a County Government before a County Assembly by the chairperson of the Budget and Appropriations Committee, the Committees of Ways and Means and of Supply deliberate on them in sequence. Both Committees are comprised of all Members of the Whole County Assembly. Committee of Ways and Means 233.Confines itself to deliberations on the processes suggested to raise funds to foot the budget for the next Fiscal Year. These deliberations are supposed to be disposed off during the allotted days. 69 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Committee of Supply 234.Confines its deliberations on the distribution of funds to be raised in the Committee of Ways and Means to the various departments of a County Executive, County Assembly and any County Corporations; this Committee does the distributions within the allotted days. Select Committees 235.A County Assembly can form Select Committees, split into:(i) Standing/Sessional Committees; (ii) Ad Hoc Committees; and (iii) Sectoral Committees. (iv) Select Committees, consist of a minimum of five and a maximum of eleven Members, Standing/Select Committees 236.The business executed by the Standing/Sessional Committees is either routine and/or in-house. The lifespan of the membership of these Committees coincides with that of a Session. The Committees falling under this category are:(i) Sessional Committee:- prepares and manages the programme of the business of a County Assembly on a weekly basis and its Annual Calendar; decides on all questions for changes in the Calendar and Order Paper; (ii) Budget and Appropriations Committee:- examines and deals with matters relating to finances and budgeting of a County Government. (iii) Public Accounts and Investments Committee:- examines reports by the Auditor-General on County Government expenditure, investments in County Corporations and Funds Accounts; (iv) Speaker’s Committee:- examines matters relating to the welfare of Members, staff and the management of a County Assembly; (v) Procedure and Rules Committee:- examines matters relating to and makes periodic reviews of the procedure and the Standing Orders as necessary; (vi)Powers and Privileges Committee:- deals with issues regarding privileges of a County Assembly, Members and the public. 70 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA Ad Hoc Committees 237.These are formed by a County Assembly as and whenever the need arises to investigate, study and make recommendations on certain specific matters and issues which need consideration and solution. Sectoral Committees 238.A County Assembly may form Sectoral Committees at the commencement of its life, to which their lifespan correspond. 239.Sectoral Committees investigate or inquire into the activities and administration of departments of the County Executive as constituted, subject to the Fourth Schedule of CK 2010; assigned to each. Out of such investigation, the committees could propose legislation; while dealing with Bills, in addition to dealing with the estimates of assigned departments; and vetting nominations for appointment as Secretary and Chief Officers of a County Government. 240.The Sectoral Committees include:(i) Sectoral Committee on Agriculture, Environment and Natural Resources; (ii) Sectoral Committee on Early Childhood Education and Vocational Training; (iii) Sectoral Committee on Transport and Public Works; (iv) Sectoral Committee on Planning, Trade, Tourism and Co-operatives; (v) Sectoral Committee on Children, Culture and Community Services; (vi) Sectoral Committee on Health Services Membership of Committees 241.All Committees of the Whole County Assembly, constitute all Members and assemble in the Chamber of a County Assembly. 242.Nominations to all Select Committees are made by the Sessional Committee, in consultation with the leadership of political parties with Members in the County Assembly, subject to approval by the County Assembly. In certain cases the composition 71 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA is made directly by the County Assembly, for instance, in case of the Sessional Committee and Ad hoc Committees. Procedure in Committees and Record of Work 243.The core of the procedure in Committees is in Standing Order No.118 which reads:“Save as and to the extent to which the chairperson may in his discretion otherwise direct, for the purpose of facilitating full consideration and discussion of the matter referred to a Select Committee, the procedure in a Select Committee (which refers to Standing, Sectoral and Ad hoc Committees) shall be as nearly as possible, the same as that in Committee of the Whole County Assembly”. 244.The procedure in the Committee of the Whole County Assembly, is a general relaxation of that in the Plenary of a County Assembly, in which for instance, a Member may speak severally on the same question (see paragraph 103). The proceedings enjoy the same privilege as those of the Plenary of a County Assembly. Public Access and Participation 245.Proceedings of Select Committee and witnesses who appear are held in public, except as provided for in Section 196 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010. T. THE BUDGET IN THE COUNTY ASSEMBLY Role and Function of the Cabinet Secretary for Finance 246.Pursuant to provisions of Section 218(1) of CK 2010, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance shall at least two months before the end of each Financial Year submit to the National Parliament:(i) A Bill by the name, Division of Revenue Bill, which shall have divided the revenue raised by the National Government among the National Level and County Level Governments as required under Sections 202(1) and 203 of CK 2010. 72 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (ii) A Bill, by the name, County Allocation Bill, which shall have divided among the Counties, the revenue allocated to the County Level of Government, as resolved under Section 217 of CK 2010. (iii) The share of the revenue of a County as authorised in the County Allocation Bill, shall be transferred to the County without undue delay. Role and Function of the Commission on Revenue Allocation 247.Pursuant to provisions of Section 216 of CK 2010, the Commission on Revenue Allocation shall:(i) Make recommendations of the basis and criteria for the equitable sharing of the revenue raised by the National Government, between the former and the County Governments and among the County Governments; (ii) Determine a policy setting out the criteria by which to identify the marginalised areas for the purposes of Section 204(2) of CK 2010 Role and Function of the National Parliament 248.Pursuant to provisions of Section 204 of CK 2010,enact the Equalization Fund, which is to be utilized by the National Government as provided for under this Section. 249.Pursuant to provisions of Section 217 the Senate and the National Assembly, adopts a resolution determining the basis for allocating among the Counties, the share of the national revenue that is annually allocated to them. 250.The resolution is initiated by the Senate, once every five years. However, it requires the concurrence of the National Assembly, subject to provisions of Section 217(5). Role and Function of the County Executive Committee 251.Pursuant to provisions of Section 224 of CK 2010, each County Government shall prepare its annual budget estimates and later an Appropriations Bill as provided for in the Public Finance Management Act, 2012. 73 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 252.The annual budget, estimates and the Appropriation Bill shall be prepared by a County Executive Committee and submitted by a County Executive Committee Member for Finance to a County Assembly for approval and enactment. How the Annual Budget and the Estimates arrive in a County Assembly 253.Pursuant to provisions of Section 128 of the Public Finance Management Act,2012 (PFA,2012), the budget process for a County is managed by a County Executive Committee Member (CECM) for Finance, including forwarding the annual budget and estimates of a County Government to a County Assembly. Sequence of Processing the Annual Budget 254.The Sequence/Processes of the transaction of the Budget of a County Assembly are:(i) County Development Plan- is prepared under Section 126 of CK 2010 and submitted to a County Assembly by the County Executive Member responsible for Planning, not later than September 01, in each year. (ii) County Budget Review and Outlook Paper (a) For each Financial Year, the County Budget Review and Outlook Paper is submitted by the County Treasury to the County Executive Committee by September 30, of the Financial Year; (b) The County Executive Committee approves the County Budget Review and Outlook Paper within fourteen days; (c) The County Budget Review and Outlook Paper is then submitted to a County Assembly (iii) The Circular Setting out Guidelines to be Followed by County Governments in the Budget Process (a) The County Executive Member for Finance issues the Circular not later than August 30, in each year; (b) The Circular shall specify, amongst others• A Schedule for preparation of the Budget, specifying key dates by which various processes are to be completed; • Key policy areas and issues to be taken into consideration; • The procedures to be followed by the public to participate and the format in which information and documents may be submitted. 74 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (iv)The Pronouncement of the Revenue Raising Measures of the County Government (a)The Pronouncement shall be made by the County Executive Member for Finance in each Financial Year; (b) The County Finance Bill, is submitted to a County Assembly on the date of the Pronouncement; (c) The County Finance Bill sets out the revenue measures together with a policy statement expounding on the same; (d) The County Finance Bill shall be approved not later than ninety days after a County Assembly passes the Appropriation Bill (v)The County Fiscal and Strategy Paper (a) The County Fiscal and Strategy Paper is prepared by the County Treasury and submitted to the County Executive Committee for its consideration and approval; (b) The approved Paper is then submitted to a County Assembly by February 28, of each year; (c) The Paper specifies amongst others, the broad strategic priorities and policy goals that would guide preparation of County budgets for the coming year and over the medium term; (d) The Paper, further ,includes- the financial outlook of the revenues, expenditures and borrowing of the County Government for the coming year and over the medium term; (e) The Paper is considered by the Committee on Budget and Appropriation which tables a report and recommendations before a County Assembly; (f) A County Assembly considers the Paper together with the report of the Budget and Appropriation Committee and adopts it within fourteen days; (g) The County Executive Committee Member for Finance considers recommendations of a County Assembly on the Paper when finalizing the Budget proposal for the year concerned. (vi) Statement of Debt Management Strategy (a) The Statement of Debt Management of a County Government over the medium term is submitted to a County Assembly by a County Executive Committee Member for Finance, on or before February 28, in each year; (b) The Statement sets out the actual and potential liabilities in respect of loans and plans to deal with the loans; 75 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (c) Further, the Statement would include information on• The total stock of debt as at the date of the Statement; • The sources of the loans; • The principal risk associated with those loans; (d) The Statement is considered by the Committee on Budget and Appropriation which would table a report and recommendations to the County Assembly (e) The report of the Committee would be considered by the County Assembly; once adopted, the views and recommendations of the Assembly would be forwarded to the County Executive Committee (vii) Submission of Annual Budget Estimates and Documents (a) The Annual Budget Estimates, Supporting Documents and any Bills required to implement the Budget for the forthcoming Fiscal Year for the County Executive and other entities; except the Finance Bill, should be submitted by the County Executive Committee Member for Finance by April 30, of the year; (b) The Annual Budget Estimates and any Accompanying Documents shall be prepared by and submitted to the County Assembly by the Clerk of the County Assembly by April 30, of the year; copies shall at the same, be submitted to the County Executive Committee Member for Finance (c) The Annual Budgets and Estimates of the County Governments and the County Assembly shall be referred to the Sectoral Committees; (viii) The Role and Function of Select Committees (a) The Sectoral Committees shall consider their sectoral budgets and estimates and report to the Budget and Appropriation Committee; (b)The Sectoral Committees shall require the respective County Executive Committee Members to appear to elucidate and respond to any queries; (c) The Budget and Appropriation Committee shall adopt the same procedure as the Sectoral Committees; as well as facilitating public participation; (ix)The Role and Function of a County Assembly (a) The Budget and Appropriation Committee shall table a report and recommendations on the two budgets and estimates to the Committee of Supply of the County Assembly; (b) The Budget and Appropriation Committee, as well as, the Committee of Supply, shall deliberate and if amendments are proposed, they should be 76 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA done in compliance with the provisions of Sections 131 of PFM 2012; and approve the Budgets and the Estimates by April 30, of the same year; (c) A County Assembly shall consider and approve with or without amendments the annual Budgets and Estimates of the County Government and the County Assembly by June 30. of the year; (x) The Appropriation Bill of the Year (a) The Appropriation Bill of the year, incorporating the two sets of Budgets and Estimates, shall be submitted to the County Assembly, soon after the County Assembly would have approved the Budgets and the Estimates; (b) The Appropriation Bill shall be submitted by the County Executive Committee Member for Finance and shall be enacted soon after by the County Assembly. (xi) Statutory Stages in County Government Budget Process The Statutory Stages in County Government Budget Process are set out in Section 125 of PFM; 2011. Comparative Summary of Processing Annual Budget at both levels of Government Cabinet • • Approves the Budget Policy Statement (BPS) and the Budget Review and Outlook Paper (BROP), and Medium Term Debt Management Strategy MT/DMS. Reviews the Annual Budget Estimates for the National Government (excluding Parliament and the Judiciary) before submission to Parliament for approval. County Executive Committee • • • Approves the Fiscal Strategy Paper (FSP) and the County Budget Review and Outlook Paper (C-BROP); Reviews and approves the Annual Budget Estimates for the County Government excluding the County Assembly before submission to the County Assembly for approval; Has powers to establish a County Emergency Fund (CEF) but with the approval of the County Assembly. 77 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA APPENDICES APPENDIX A GUIDE TO ESTABLISHMENT OF A COUNTY PUBLIC SERVICE INTRODUCTION 1. The Mandate (Functions, Roles, Powers and Activities) of County Governments are executed by two categories of personnel. The first category are the elected and nominated politicians– who primarily engage in the formulation of policy and its translation into legislation and programmes; and accounting for the work of various organs and structures of government. The second category is the apolitical (nonpoliticians, non-partisan) who are hired by the first category to turn the wheels of the working of governance. Both categories have and exercise their functions and powers; pursuant to various provisions of the Constitution of Kenya 2010, the enabling statutes and the regulations and rules, enacted under the ambit of the statutes. 2. The Guide has, though, without much detail highlighted the part played by the political (elected, nominated) personnel of the County Governments. The following is a brief view of the Establishment of the County Public Service. MANDATE AND POWER OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS 3. The mandate and powers to put in place a County Public Service (CPS) are vested in the County Government by Section 235 (1 and 2) of CK 2010, viz (i) The responsibility to constitute, the entire County Public Service, creation of specific structures, organs and offices; recruitment of personnel, their control, deployment and limitation; (ii) The establishment would, however, have to adhere to the uniform norms and standards to be established by legislation of the National Government; 78 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 4. The Establishment and the Activities of the County Public Service are further subject to: (i)National Values and Principles of Governance in Section 10 of CK 2010,which bind all State Organs, State Officers, public officers and all persons in their service to the public; (ii)Values and Principles of Public Service in Section 232 of CK 2010, which apply to public service in all State Organs at National and County levels; all State Corporations; (iii)The Objectives of the County Public Service in Sections 53 and 58 of the County Governments Act,2012 which require the County Public Service to: (a) Comply with and promote Values and Principles of Sections 10 and 232, above; (b) Organize the staffing and functions so as to ensure efficient, quality and delivery of productive services; (c) Provide for institutional systems and mechanisms for human resource utilization and development to enhance service delivery; (d) Provide for establishment of County Public Service Boards for each County (iv) Each County Government is to have its own County Public Service, to be headed by a County Secretary. 5. The processes for establishing or putting into effect the above, especially, the provisions of Section 235 of CK 2010, would be undertaken by the Cabinet Secretary with responsibility for Devolution/County Governance. The County Secretary would prepare a Sessional Paper conceptualizing and indicating the enabling legislation with its objects. The Sessional Paper and the enabling Legislation would in turn be discussed by and approved by the County Executive Committee, then submitted to the County Assembly for adoption and enactment. 6. The enabling legislation would be followed by Regulations to operationalize it. 79 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA ESTABLISHMENT OF COUNTY PUBLIC SERVICE BOARDS 7. Each County shall have and establish a County Public Service Board(CPSB), by provisions of Section 57 of the County Governments Act, 2012(CGA 2012). COMPOSITION OF COUNTY PUBLIC SERVICE BOARD 8. The composition of the County Public Service Board is under Section 58 of CGA which also specifies the process of its appointment, cessation of office, qualifications, removal from office, et cetera. FUNCTIONS AND POWERS OF A COUNTY SERVICE BOARD 9. The core functions and powers of a County Public Service Board are provided for under Section 59 of CGA, 2012. 10. The rest of the functions, powers, regulation of the individual activities; the control and facilitation of the County Public Service, including establishment and abolishment of public offices; appointment to public offices, deployment, discipline, establishment and maintenance of institutional memory; promotions, secondments, contracts, resignations/retirements and appeals; delegation of functions and powers to its staff and others – Sections 60 to 86 of CGA 2012. 11. The processes for the establishment of and the putting into effect of the above provisions would be taken by the County Executive Committee Member responsible for County Public Service affairs. The County Executive Committee Member would prepare a County Sessional Paper conceptualizing and indicating the enabling legislation with its objects. The Sessional Paper and the Legislation would in turn be submitted to the County Assembly for adoption and enactment; upon discussion and approval by the County Executive Committee. 12. Upon enactment of the enabling Legislation, the County Executive Committee Member, would then prepare and submit to the County Assembly the Regulations to operationalise the Legislation. 80 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 13.The establishment of both the County Public Service and the County Public Service Board, would greatly benefit from the establishment and operations of the equivalent for the National Government. 81 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA APPENDIX B GUIDE TO ESTABLISHMENT OF COUNTY ASSEMBLY SERVICE INTRODUCTION 1. The Mandate (Functions, Roles, Powers and Activities) of County Governments are executed by two categories of personnel. The first category are the elected and nominated politicians– who primarily engage in the formulation of policy and its translation into legislation and programmes; and accounting for the work of various organs and structures of government. The second category is the apolitical (nonpoliticians, non-partisan) who are hired by the first category to turn the wheels of the working of governance. Both categories have and exercise their functions and powers; pursuant to various provisions of the Constitution of Kenya 2010, the enabling statutes and the regulations and rules, enacted under the ambit of the statutes. 2. The Guide has, though, without much detail highlighted the part played by the political (elected, nominated) personnel of the County Governments. The following is a brief proposal on the Establishment of the County Assembly Service. MANDATE AND POWERS OF COUNTY ASSEMBLIES 3. The mandate and powers for the County Assemblies to put in place the County Assembly Service are often claimed on the basis of, history and tradition. Today it is claimed as being necessary in quest for democratic best practices of governance, within proper operation of the principles of separation of functions /powers among the three arms of Government. This principle has been ably incorporated in the Public Finance Management Act, 2012, whereby, there are three separate budgets, one each for the Executive, the Judiciary and the Legislature. The exercise of this principle vindicates the National Assembly for relentlessly struggling for the establishment of the Parliamentary Service Commission (PARLSCOM) in 1999. 82 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA ESTABLISHMENT OF A COUNTY ASSEMBLY SERVICE BOARD 4. Each County Assembly shall constitute a County Assembly Service Board, pursuant to provisions of Section 12 of CGA, 2012,whose particulars include:(i) Status of the County Assembly Service Board as a body corporate with perpetual succession and common zeal; (ii) Composed of five members, with the Clerk of the County Assembly as its Secretary; (iii) The processes of service, cessation of appointment; (iv) The functions, roles and powers - broadly to ensure the County Assembly is provided with services and facilities to enable it to function efficiently and effectively – budgeting, hiring personnel, promoting ideals of parliamentary democracy and ensuring the well being of hon. Members and staff. 5. The establishment of the County Assembly Service Board will require:(i) a Sessional Paper, to conceptualize and map out the objects and structures of the Board (ii) a County Assembly Legislation, containing virtually all in the Sessional Paper to give legal effect to the establishment; (ii) Regulations to address pertinent details in the operationalisation of the legislation and its objects. 6. To initiate and effect the above processes would be the Speaker’s Committee of the County Assembly; which will at the same time act in the interim as the Board. 7. The entire drive to establish the County Assembly Service Board, would greatly benefit from a close study of the establishment and operations of the Parliamentary Service Commission at National Parliament. 83 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA APPENDIX C COUNTY GOVERNMENTS OATHS OF OFFICE Oath of Office for Governor/ Deputy Governor “I ...................................., do swear/ solemnly affirm that I shall always truly and diligently serve the people and the Republic of Kenya in the office of Governor/ Deputy Governor of ………………………County; that I shall diligently discharge my duties and perform my functions in the said office, to the best of my judgment; (that (in the case of the Deputy Governor) I shall at all times, when so required, faithfully and truly give my counsel and advice to the Governor of the …………………. County); that I shall do justice to all. (So help me God) Oath of Office for Speaker/ Acting Speaker “I …………………………., having been elected as Speaker/ Acting Speaker of the County Assembly of ………………………………… County do swear/ solemnly affirm that I shall always truly and diligently serve the people and the Republic of Kenya in the office Speaker/ Acting Speaker of the County Assembly in …………………………… County; that I shall respect, uphold, preserve, protect and defend this Constitution of the Republic of Kenya; and that I shall do right to all manner of persons in accordance Constitution of Kenya and the laws and conventions of Parliament without fear or favour, affection or ill shall (So help me God) Oath of Office for County Assembly Clerk “I……………………………, do swear/ solemnly affirm that I shall always truly and diligently serve the people and the Republic of Kenya in the office of Clerk of the County Assembly in ……………………… County; that I shall diligently discharge my duties and perform my functions in the said office, to the best of my judgment; that I shall at all times, when so required, faithfully and truly give my counsel and advice to the Speaker of the County Assembly of ……………………….. County; that I shall do justice to all. (So help me God) Oath of Office for the County Executive Committee Member 84 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA “I ………………………….., do swear/ solemnly affirm that I shall always truly and diligently serve the people and the Republic of Kenya in the office the Executive Committee Member of …………………….. County; that I shall diligently discharge my duties and perform my functions in the said office, to the best of my judgment; that I shall at all times, when so required, faithfully and truly give my counsel and advice to the Governor of the …………………….. County; that I shall do justice to all. (So help me God) Oath of Office for County Assembly Members “I ……………………………, do swear/ solemnly affirm that I shall always truly and diligently serve the people and the Republic of Kenya in the office of County Assembly Committee Member of ……………………. County; that I shall diligently discharge my duties and perform my functions in the said office, to the best of my judgment; that I shall at all times, respect, uphold, preserve, protect and defend this Constitution of the Republic of Kenya; and that I shall do right to all manner of persons in accordance with the Constitution of Kenya and the laws and conventions of Parliament, that I shall do justice to all (So help me God).” 85 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA APPENDIX D FOURTH SCHEDULE (Articles 185(2), 186(1) and 187(2)) DISTRIBUTION OF FUNCTIONS BETWEEN THE NATIONAL AND THE COUNTY GOVERNMENTS Part 1- National Government 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Foreign Affairs, foreign policy and international trade. The use of international waters and water resources. Immigration and citizenship. The relationship between religion and state. Language policy and the promotion of official and local languages. National defence and the use of national defence services. Police services, including – (a) the setting of standards of recruitment, training of police and use of police services; (b) criminal law; and (c) correctional services 8. Courts 9. National economic policy and planning. 10. Monetary policy, currency, banking (including central banking), the incorporation and regulation of banking, insurance and financial corporations. 11. National statistics and data on population, the economy and society generally. 12. Intellectual property rights. 13. Labour standards. 14. Consumer protection, including standards for social security and professional pension plans. 15. Education policy, standards, curricula, examinations and the granting of university charters. 16. Universities, tertiary educational institutions and other institutions of research and higher learning and primary schools, special education, secondary schools and special 86 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA education institutions. 17. Promotion of sports and sports education. 18. Transport and communications, including, in particular – (a) road traffic; (b) the construction and operation of national trunk roads; (c) standards for the construction and maintenance of other roads by counties; (d) railways; (e) pipelines; (f) marine navigation; (g) civil aviation; (h) space travel; (i) postal services; (j) telecommunications; (k) radio and television broadcasting; 19. National public works. 20. Housing policy 21. General principles of land planning and the co-ordination of planning by the counties. 22. Protection of the environment and natural resources with a view t establishing a durable and sustainable system of development, in particular – (a) fishing, hunting and gathering; (b) protection of animals and wildlife; (c) water protection, securing sufficient residual water, hydraulic engineering and the safety of dams; and (d) energy policy; 23. National referral health facilities. 24. Disaster management. 25. Ancient and historical monuments of national importance. 26. National elections. 27. Heath policy. 28. Agricultural policy. 29. Veterinary policy. 30. Energy policy including electricity and gas regulation and energy regulation. 31. Capacity building and technical assistance to the counties. 32. Public investment. 33. National betting, casinos and other forms of gambling. 87 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 34. Tourism policy and development. Part 2 – County Governments The functions and powers of the county are – 1. Agriculture, including – (a) crop and animal husbandry; (b) livestock sale yards; (c) county abattoirs; (d) plant and animal disease control; (e) fisheries 2. County health services, including, in particular – (a) county health facilities and pharmacies; (b) ambulance services; (c) promotion of primary health care; (d) licensing and control of undertakings that sell food to the public; (e) veterinary services (excluding regulation of the profession); (f) cemeteries, funeral parlours and crematoria; and (g) refuse removal, refuse dumps and solid waste disposal; 3. Control of air pollution, noise pollution, other public nuisances and outdoor advertising. 4. Cultural activities, public entertainment and public amenities including – (a) betting, casinos and other forms of gambling; (b) racing; (c) liquor licensing; (d) cinemas; (e) video shows and hiring; (f) libraries; (g) museums; (h) sports and cultural activities and facilities; and (i) county parks, beaches and recreation facilities. 5. County transport, including – (a) county roads; (b) street lighting; (c) traffic and parking; 88 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA (d) public road transport; and (e) ferries and harbours, excluding the regulation of international and national shipping and matters related thereto. 6. Animal control and welfare, including(a) licensing of dogs (b) facilities for the accommodation, care and burial of animals. 7. Trade development and regulation, including – (a) markets; (b) trade licences(excluding regulation of professionals); (c) fair trading practices; (d) local tourism; and (e) cooperative societies. 8. County planning and development, including – (a) statistics (b) land survey and mapping; (c) boundaries and fencing; (d) housing; and (e) electricity and gas reticulation and energy regulation. 9. Pre-primary education, village polytechnics, homecraft centres and childcare facilities. 10. Implementation of specific national government policies on natural resources and environmental conservation, including(a) soil and water conservation; and (b) forestry. 11. County public works and services, including(a) storm water management systems in built-up areas; and (b) water and sanitation services. 12. Fire fighting services and disaster management. 13. Control of rugs and pornography. 14. Ensuring and coordinating the participation of communities and locations in governance at the local level and assisting communities and locations to develop the administrative capacity for the effective exercise of the functions and powers and participation in governance at the local level. 89 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA APPENDIX E FIRST SCHEDULE (Article 6(1)) COUNTIES 1. Mombasa 2. Kwale 3. Kilifi 4. Tana River 5. Lamu 6. Taita Taveta 7. Garissa 8. Wajir 9. Mandera 10. Marsabit 90 11. Isiolo 12. Meru 13. Tharaka –Nithi 14. Embu 15. Kitui 16. Machakos 17. Makueni 18. Nyandarua 19. Nyeri 20. Kirinyaga 21. Murang’a 22. Kiambu 23. Turkana 24. West Pokot 25. Samburu 26. Trans Nzoia 27. Uasin Gishu 28. Elgeyo/Marakwet 29. Nandi 30. Baringo 31. Laikipia 32. Nakuru 33. Narok 34. Kajiado 35. Kericho 36. Bomet 37. Kakamega 38. Vihiga 39. Bungoma 40. Busia 41. Siaya 42. Kisumu 43. Homa Bay 44. Migori 45. Kisii 46. Nyamira 47. Nairobi City A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA APPENDIX F: BIBLIOGRAPHY 1. The Constitution of Kenya, 1963 (Kenya Independence Order-in – Council) 2. The Constitution of Kenya, 2010 3. The County Governments Act, 2012 4. The Transition to Devolved Government Act,2012 5. The Petitions to Parliament (Procedure) Act,2012 6. The Inter-Governmental Relations Act,2012 7. The Public Finance Management Act, 2012 8. The Political Parties Act,2011 9. The Elections Act,2011 10. The Urban Areas and Cities Act,2011 11. The National Assembly (Powers and Privileges) Act, 2003 12. The National Assembly Standing Orders (Draft), 2012 13. The Model County Assembly Standing Orders (Draft One), 2012 14. The National Assembly Members Handbook(Eighth Edition), 2002 15. Parliament Buildings – A Historical Pictorial Guide, (Third Edition),1997 16. Parliamentary Practice in Kenya, H.B. Ndoria Gicheru,1976 17. Parliamentary Service Act, Act No. 20, 2000 18. A History of Constitution Making in Kenya by Media Development Association and Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, 2012 19. Handbook on Kenya’s Electoral Laws and System, by Ongoya Z. Elisha and Willis E. Otieno, 2012 20. A Handbook on Legislative Practice and Procedure of the National Assembly by the National Secretariat of Nigerian Legislatures, National Assembly, Abuja, Nigeria, 2004 21. The Bureau of Parliamentary Studies and Training, Lok Sabha, New Delhi. India 22. The CPA at 100 Years (Book published to commemorate One Hundred Years of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association) London , UK, 2012 23. Parliament of India, Edited by G.C. Malhotra, Secretary General, Lok Sabha, India, 2002 24. Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 2011 25. House of Commons Practice and Procedure, Canada, Second Edition,2009, by Audrey O’Brien and Mark Bosc 91 A GUIDE TO THE MANDATES AND PROCEDURES OF COUNTY GOVERNMENTS IN KENYA 26. Parliamentary Practice, Fourth Edition, 2004, Thomas Erskine May 27. Stormont, the House on the Hill (A History of the Precincts of the Parliament of Northern Ireland) by Jack Gallagher, 2008 28. The Scottish Parliament (several Pamphlets/ Booklets), 2012 • Discover the Scottish Parliament • Making the Scottish Parliament work for you • How the Scottish Parliament works 29. The National Assembly for Wales (several Pamphlets/Booklets), 2008 – • National Committee – Submitting a Petition • National Assembly, Explore the Senedd 30. Global Parliamentary Report – The Changing Nature of Parliamentary Representation, April, 2012 by the Inter-Parliamentary Union and the UNDP 31. Final Report on Devolved Government in Kenya, 2010; Office of the Deputy Prime Minister and Ministry of Local Government; Chairperson – Dr. Mutakha Kangu. 32. Sessional Paper on Devolved Government under the Constitution of Kenya, 2010; Office of the Deputy Prime Minister and Ministry of Local Government, 2010. 92 Transition Authority Transition Authority 5th Floor KICC Building P.O. Box 10736 - 00100 Nairobi, Kenya Tel: +254 - 0710 287 080 Email: [email protected] ISBN: 978-9966-21-355-6 This Publication is supported by The Swedish government,WFD & EISA
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz