ON T H E NATURE OF T H E EARTH'S CORE W. H. Ramsey" (Received 1949 June 5 ) t Suntnzary In a previous paper (M.N., 108,406,1948)the author has suggested that the density jump at the boundary of the Earth's core is duc to a phase transition under pressure, and not to the appearance of a new material such as iron. A metallic type of structure was proposed for the material in the core. In the present paper the transition to the metallic phase is explained in greater detail. Seismological data are used to prove that the core cannot be composed of either iron or an alloy of nickel and iron. I t is shown how the theory removes certain difficulties arising from the hypothesis of an iron core, and how it can account for features not hitherto explained. INTRODUCTION Seismological observations have revealed a discontinuous change in structure at approximately half-way to the centre of the Earth. It is currently assumed that this is the boundary of an iron or an iron-nickel core. No decisive evidence in support of this assumption has ever been advanced, but at m e time it seemed that this composition could account for certain unexplained phenomena. The mean density of the Earth, namely 5-52 g . / ~ m . ~is, considerably larger than would be expected from the materials found on or near the surface, even when adequate allowance is made for compression. It was therefore argued that the core had to be composed of a heavy material, and iron is the only abundant heavy element. It was also pointed out that a ferromagnetic core could account for terrestrial magnetism. Moreover, it has been held, especially by geochemists, that strong support for the hypothesis of an iron core is provided by iron meteorites. These arguments in support of an iron core have lost force as a result of recent experimental and theoretical investigations. Adams and Green (I) have found experimentally that the effect of pressure on the Curie temperatures of iron and iron-nickel alloys is too small to allow the ferromagnetisni to persist at the temperatures and pressures prevailing in the core ; Slater (2) has reached the same conclusion on theoretical grounds. The variation of the Earth's magnetic field with depth has recently been measured in mines by Runcorn (3) and by Hales and Gough (4), and the tentative results suggest that the magnetism originates, not in the core alone, but throughout the Earth. These workers emphasize that the evidence at the moment is not conclusive, but the experiments can in principle distinguish between magnetism originating in the core and distributed magnetism. Jeffreys (5,6) has pointed out that the hypothesis of an iron core is inconsistent with the observed mean densities of the terrestrial planets, if it is assumed that the chemical constitutions of these planets are similar to that of the Earth.1 T o account for the observed mean densities it must be assumed * On leave from the University of Manchester. t Original version received 1949 March 24. 3 This difficulty arises, not only with an iron core, but in any theory in which the Earth's core and mantle are assumed to be chemically distinct. 410 W. H . Ramsey that the smaller planets contain relatively less iron. As regards the evidence from meteorites, the iron variety is less common than was formerly supposed, the proportion of the stony to the iron variety being about thirty-five to one (7). T h e average iron content of all meteorites is about 25 per cent by weight, but the figure for the Earth must be in the neighbourhood of 40 per cent if the core is iron. The latter percentageis also much larger than would beexpected if the Earth were originally of solar composition. Thus at the present time no strong evidence can be advanced in favour of an iron core. I n recent publications (8, 9) the author has given an alternative explanation of the discontinuous jump in density at the boundary of the core. The suggestion is that the material of the core is chemically identical with that of the surrounding mantle, and that the jump in density is due to a phase transition under pressure. A metallic type of structure is proposed for the material in the core. I n one of the papers cited (8) it was shown that this theory can account for the observed mean densities of the terrestrial planets assuming identical chemical constitutions. A slight condensation of the heavier elements towards the centre of the Earth had to be assumed. This condensation is reasonable on a priori grounds and it is not in conflict with any geophysical observations ; indeed, there is some geophysical support for it. The present paper examines the transition to the metallic phase in greater detail, and it shows how the theory removes certain difficulties and how it accounts for features not hitherto explained. TRANSITION TO METALLIC PHASE Before proceeding to investigate the phase transition at the core boundary, a general explanation of the transition to a metallic phase will be given. As the material of the Earth is chemically complicated, the transition will first be described using helium, which is probably the simplest case, as an example. Consider the solid to be formed by arranging the atoms in a definite crystal structure. When the volume is very large the interactions between atoms are negligible, and the energy spectrum consists of the sharp lines characteristic of the isolated atoms. I n its normal state the helium atom has two IS electrons which form a closed shell. As the volume of the solid is decreased to its normal value, this electronic energy level is lowered slightly by the weak van der Waals attraction. The level is not appreciably broadened, as the normal helium atom is not degenerate (cf. reference (IO), p. 308). If the solid is compressed, the strongly repulsive interaction typical of closed shells comes into play, and the energy increases rapidly as the volume is diminished. It is also the completed shell in helium which makes electronic conduction impossible ; a net current, even in the presence of an electric field, would violate the Pauli principle (cf. Seitz (10)). I n the first excited state of the helium atom one of the electrons is raised to the 28 level. This state is degenerate, as the shells are incompletely filled. This energy level will therefore be split into a quasi-continuous band by the mutual interactions when the atoms combine to form a solid. Even if all a t o m in the solid are in this excited state the band will not be completely filled. The electrons of the band will therefore conduct electricity when a field is applied ; a net current can be established through electrons jumping to unoccupied levels in the band. For this reason the band is usually referred to as a conduction band. If all atoms are in the conducting state the solid will be metallic; this will be referred to as a metallic phase of helium. In forming the solid the conduction band is depressed On the Nature of the Earth’s Core 411 towards the ground state, as the metallic binding is much greater than that arising from van der Waals’ forces. Also, when the solid is compressed, the repulsion which eventually sets in will be less strong than that between the closed shells of the normal atoms. The result is that, when the solid has been sufficiently compressed, the conduction band crosses the ground state. The crossing of the levels is illustrated schematically in Fig. I. The total internal energy U per mole .EnergX Excited state Ground state Molar volume FIG.i.--Schenzatic representation of the electronic energy h e L . of the solid follows directly from a knowledge of the energy levels, and hence the Helmholtz free energy P at any fixed temperature T may be found: F= U - T S , (1) where S is the entropy per mole. The free energy F at a fixed temperature is shown schematically as a function of the volume in Fig. 2, the subscript I referring t o the normal solid and the subscript z to the metallic phase. The two phases can co-exist in equilibrium at pressure P and temperature T if their Gibbs free energies (thermodynamical potentials) are equal ; that is, if U, + PV1- TS1= U2 + PV2 - TS,, (2) where V,, V , are respectively the volumes occupied by one mole of the normal solid and the metallic phase at temperature T and pressure P. I n virtue of the thermodynamical relation (aF/aV),= - P, (3) the condition (2) for equilibrium is equivalent to drawing a common tangent TITa to the two curves of Fig. 2. The magnitude of the slope of this tangent is the critical pressure P. The normal phase of solid helium is stable only at pressures smaller than P, and the metallic phase is stable only at higher pressures. W. H . Ramsey 412 Hence, if helium is compressed, its density will increase abruptly at the critical pressure P. It is suggested that the abrupt jump in density at the boundary of the Earth's core is due to a phase transition of this type. Free energy fI \ I I I I I I I I 1 v2 v1 Molar volume FIG.z.-The transition to the metallic phase. The subscripts I and 2 refer to the normal and metallic phases respectively. The transition to the metallic phase has been explained using helium as an! example. The essential features of this explanation are quite general, and apply equally well to ionic crystals and to solids composed of saturated molecules such as hydrogen. At high pressures these solids are difficult to compress because of the strong repulsion between the closed shells or between the saturated molecules. The solid could collapse into a dense metallic state if these units were broken, but to break them would require a large energy, often in the neighbourhood of ten electron volts per molecule. Nevertheless, if the pressure is increased, a critical pressure will be reached at which the work done by the hydrostatic forces during the collapse to the metallic phase supplies just the energy required; this is the condition expressed by equation (2), which at the absolute zero of temperature is. u,- u, = P(v,- V2). (4) At higher pressures the solid will be metallic. This type of phase change is more drastic than the usual polymorphic transition in which the crystal structure alone is modified. In the latter type of transition the volume decreases by only a few per cent, but in a transition to a metallic phase a decrease of 50 per cent would not be surprising. The critical pressure for the transition to a metallic phase will usually be high on account of the large change in the internal energy. For example, consider a solid of density 5 g./cm.S and molecular weight 50; if ( U2-U,) is 10 e.V. per molecule, then the critical pressure would be one million atmospheres*, even if the metallic phase were infinitely dense. Such a * One atmosphere is approximately IOO dynes/cm.*. On the Nature of the Earth's Core 413 pressure has not yet been attained in the laboratory, but it does occur in the interior of the Earth (cj. Appendix). The conduction band shown in Fig. I, which gives rise to the metallic phase, exists in the normal solid as an excited state. Its height above the ground level may be measured directly by the absorption of ultra-violet light. Hilsch and Pohl (11) made a particularly careful examination of the alkali halide crystals by this method and they found that the excitation energy varied from about 5-5 e.V. for the iodides to 10.6 e.V. for sodium fluoride. The measurements on quartz ( S O , ) are of more immediate interest in the present paper as silicates are the most common materials in the Earth ; Gleason (12)has shown that the conduction band in quartz lies about 10.9 e.V. above the ground state. It will be noted that, as has been assumed earlier, the excitation energy for these solids is of the order of magnitude of 10e.V. Hydrogen is the only substance for which detailed calculations on the transition to a metallic phase have been made. Wigner and Huntington (13)were the first to examine the conditions under which metallic hydrogen should be stable, but recently more extensive calculations have been made by Kronig, de Boer and Korringa (14). In the metallic phase hydrogen was assumed to have a structure similar to that of the alkali metals. The latter authors found that the critical pressure for the transition is about 700,000 atmospheres, and at the critical pressure the densities of the normal solid and the metallic phase are respectively 0.4g./cm3 and 0.8 g , / ~ m . ~The . temperature was assumed to be absolute zero, but the authors estimate that the effect of temperatures up to a few thousand degrees Centigrade is unimportant. These calculations illustrate the large jump in density typical of this type of phase transition, and they confirm our conclusion that the critical pressure is of t h e order of magnitude of one million atmospheres. It is instructive to look at the metallic phase from the point of view of the periodic table. The alkaline earth atoms have the same valence structure as helium, namely two equivalent s electrons. But under normal conditions the alkaline earths are metallic and helium is non-metallic. The difference arises from the fact that the heavier elements have lower ionization and excitation energies as their valence electrons are in higher shells. The conduction band is therefore lower relative to the ground state, and overlapping occurs at normal lattice spacings. This accounts for the metallic properties of the heavier elements. There are many other examples of light non-metals and heavy metals having the same atomic structure, notably hydrogen and the alkali metals. The heavy metals throw some light on the metallic phases of the lighter elements in the same group. The atomic volumes of the elements in the first and second groups of the periodic table are shown in Table I. The atomic volume is the volume occupied by one gram-atom of the solid element. The elements are arranged in Table I in order of increasing atomic weight, and, with the exceptions of hydrogen and helium, the atomic volume increases uniformly with atomic TABLE I A~bma'cVolume in Cubic Centimetres Group I Group I1 Hydrogen I3 Helium Lithium 13-0 Beryllium Sodium 23 '7 Magnesium Potassium 45'4 Calcium Rubidium 55'8 Strontium Caesium 71.1 Barium 33 4'9 14.0 25 '9 34'5 36.6 414 W. H . Ramsey weight in each group. It is reasonable to assume that the anomalous behaviour of hydrogen and helium is due to their non-metallic structures and that it would disappear if the atomic volumes referring to the metallic phases were used. I t is therefore clear that metallic hydrogen at low pressures must be much denser than the ordinary solid ; actually the calculations of Wigner and Huntington (13) show that it is about seveli times as dense. From Table I one would expect metallic helium to be ten, or even twenty, times as dense as the normal phase. This is not surprising as the lattice spacing in solid helium is abnormally large, as the attraction between atoms arises only from the very weak van der Waals forces. It has been shown above that the critical pressure for a transition to a metallic phase will usually be of the order of magnitude of one million atmospheres. I n a few instances the critical pressure may, of course, be much smaller ; indeed, both metallic and non-metallic modifications of some elements exist under laboratory conditions. Grey tin is a non-metal and an electrical insulator ; its crystal structure is of the diamond type which is characteristic of the non-metals of the fourth group of the periodic table. On the other hand, the common white tin, which is about 25 per cent denser than the grey variety, is a typical metal. Arsenic also has metallic and non-metallic allotropes. Metallic arsenic has a density of 5-1g . / ~ m . ~ but , the non-metallic yellow form has a density of only 2-0g . / ~ m . ~ .Bridgman (15, 16) has prepared a black allotrope of phosphorus by exposing yellow phosphorus to a pressure of 12,000atmospheres at zoo deg.C. Black phosphorus, which is about 50 per cent denser than the yellow variety, appears to be stable at atmospheric pressure, as samples have remained unchanged for twenty years. Its electrical conductivity at atmospheric pressure is about 2 ohm-l cm.--l; this is greater than that of yellow phosphorus by a factor of ~ o l l , but it is still considerably smaller than that associated with metals. Its electrical behaviour approaches that of metals as the pressure is increased. At 20,ooo atmospheres the conductivity has increased to 300 ohm-l cm.-l, and at pressures above 12,000atmospheres the temperature coefficient of the resistance is positive. A second, and somewhat denser, form of black phosphorus has been discovered at higher pressures, but its electrical conductivity has not yet been measured. The important feature to note from these examples is that the metallic phase is considerably denser than the non-metallic allotrope. THEMATERIAL OF THE EARTH’S CORE Up to date it has not proved feasible to compute the cohesive energies of any but the simplest metals. The existing calculations deal mainly with the monovalent elements, and even these are not entirely satisfactory. One cannot therefore hope to give a detailed quantum mechanical treatment of the transition of the material of the Earth to a metallic phase, such as has been given by Wigner and Huntington (13) and by Kronig, de Boer and Korringa (14) for hydrogen. The decision as to the nature of the Earth’s core must therefore, for the present, rest on indirect and somewhat less conclusive evidence. It can nevertheless be stated that the conditions at the boundary of the core correspond to those expected at a transition to a metallic phase, and they are very difficult to explain on any other hypothesis. The pressure at the core boundary is 1-4million atmospheres and the jump in density is about50 per cent ; these figures are consistent with a transition to a metallic phase. Bremarkable feature of the core boundaryis itssharpness; On the Nature of the Earth’s Core 415 if the density increased continuously over a small region, as opposed to an abrupt jump, then the reflecting power of the boundary for seismic waves would be ihuch smaller than is observed (cf. Jdre ys (17)). A sharp boundary is difZcult,. if not impossible, to reconcile with a change in chemical composition. There is considerable uncertainty about the temperature at the boundary of the core, but the indications are that it isin theneighbourhood of 10,000deg. C. (cf. reference (IS)). Thus the temperature may well be above the critical temperature of iron,. which is estimated by Eucken (19)to be about goo0 deg. C. ; if this is so, a sharp boundary cannot be maintained by the usual agencies. Even if the critical temperature is not exceeded, it must be closely approached, and so the chemical separation will be less complete than under laboratory conditions. Gravity could not maintain a sharp boundary at 10,000deg. C. At 10,000deg. C. kT is about I e.V., k being Boltzmann’s constant; this energy is sufficient to interchange an iron atom at the boundary of the’core and a light atom 300 km. above the boundary. If gravity were the controlling factor, then the jump in density would not be sharp as indicated by seismology, but would be spread over at least 300 km. Moreover, if it were possible to explain so complete a chemical separation, then the elements in the core should be extremely rare in the mantle, in particular at the surface of the Earth. On the other hand, a discontinuous jump in density is inevitable on the hypothesis of a phase transition. Chemical homogeneity and uniform thermal conditions are ensured, as the core is both liquid and metallic. The sharpness of the boundary therefore lends support to the theory put forward in this paper. Nearly all our knowledge of the internal structure of the Earth is based on seismological observations ; this work has recently been reviewed by Jeffreys (17) and by Bullen (20). The velocity of elastic waves at all depths in the Earth can be derived directly from the measurements. This information by itself does not determine the internal density distribution. Bullen (zx)has estimated the density distribution on the assumption that, except at discontinuities such as the core boundary, the increase of density with depth is entirely due to adiabatic compression ; that is, that ’ dpldr =Kp(dP/dr), (5) where p, P and K are respectively the density, pressure and adiabatic compressibility at distance r from the centre of the Earth. The discontinuities at which equation (5) breaks down are the base of the crustal layers (depth 33 km.), the “ z o o discontinuity’’ (depth 400 km.), the boundary of the core (depth zgoo km.), and the boundary of the inner core (depth 5100 km.). At low pressures the coefficient of thermal expansion of rocks is about I O - ~per deg. C., and so a temperature change of a few hundred degrees would not appreciably alter the density. Bridgman (IS)has shown that the coefficient of thermal expansion decreases rapidly with pressure ; it is therefore probable that in the deep interior of the Earth the density is insensitive to temperature changes of a few thousand degrees Centigrade. Thus the variation of temperature within the Earth does not appreciably affect the estimated density distribution. Equation (5) therefore asserts that the chemical composition of the Earth does not change with depth, except possibly at the discontinuities. The “ zoo discontinuity ’’ has been explained satisfactorily by Bernal (22) as a transition to a crystal structure which is more stable at high pressures. In the present paper the core and 416 W. H . Ramsey the inner core are also explained as phase transitions. Thus, in the approximation in which equation (5) is valid, the Earth is of uniform chemical composition below the crustal layers. From its density and elastic constants at a depth of 40 km., this material has been identified as olivine, which is a mixture of go per cent magnesium orthosilicate MgaSiO, and 10 per cent iron orthosilicate Fe2Si0,(cj. Jeffreys (17)). While equation (5) may be a reasonable approximation, it would indeed be surprising it if were exactly true. One would expect the heavier elements to gravitate towards the centre of the Earth ; for example, the proportion of iron orthosilicate in olivine should increase with depth. The present author’s (8) calculations on the terrestrial planets suggest that this is so. The mean density of Mars, as computed from Bullen’s density distribution, is slightly, but definitely, too small. The only reasonable assumption which seems to be capable of removing this discrepancy is a condensation of the heavier elements towards the centre of the Earth. The extent of the central condensation required is that the mean atomic weight of the whole Earth should be 8 per cent greater than that immediately below the crustal layers. A central condensation of this magnitude removes an inconsistency in geophysical data. I n explaining the “ zoo discontinuity” as a change in crystal structure, Bernal (22) estimated that the jump in density should be g per cent. If equation (5) is assumed to be valid, seismological data indicate a density jump of 30 per cent. On the other hand, if central condensation of the heavier elements is allowed for in the manner indicated by the author’s calculations on the terrestrial planets, the density jump indicated by seismology is in good agreement with the calculated value. The most reasonable procedure is therefore to allow for central condensation in the manner indicated. Bullen’s (21) density distribution has accordingly been corrected for central condensation using equation (6) of the author’s previous paper (81, and details are given in the Appendix; these figures will be adopted in the present paper. The correction to Bullen’s densities is everywhere small, and it exceeds 6 per cent only in the inner core. The principal modification is in reducing the jumps in density at the discontinuities ; the density jump at the boundary of the core is reduced from 3.75 g . / ~ m .to~ 2-90 g.lcm.3. An arbitrariness remains in all estimates of the internal density distribution. The -total mass and moment of inertia of the Earth are not sufficient to determine all of the jumps in density. The density jump at the boundary of the inner core must be chosen arbitrarily, and that adopted by Bullen (21) and in the Appendix to the present paper is about 5 g . / ~ m . ~ .However, as the inner core occupies only I per cent of the total volume, this ambiguity does not appreciably affect the densities outside the inner core.” Let us for the moment entertain the possibility that the materials of the core .and mantle are chemically distinct. The information given in the Appendix is sufficient to estimate the density po which the material of the core would have at zero pressure. It would, of course, be wrong to make a linear extrapolation of the density to zero pressure, as it is known, both from Bridgman’s work (15,16) and from seismology, that the compressibility is much larger at lower pressures. It is found empirically that for the Earth the bulk modulus k,which is the reciprocal of the compressibility K , is a linear function t of the pressure P: k = K O + aP. (6) * Later in the paper it will be shown that the densityjump of 5 g./cm.Scannot be much in error. t Equation (6) ignores an anomaly just outside the inner core; this anomaly will be explained 3ater. On the Nature of the Earth’s Core 417 T h e validity of this relationship for the material of the core is illustrated by a -diagram on page 220 of Bullen’s book (20). The bulk modulus can always be expanded as a power series in the pressure ; since quadratic and higher powers are unimportant at the large pressures prevailing in the core, one would expect the linear approximation to be reliable at smaller pressures. This point has been examined more closely on the basis of the atomic theory of solids and details will be given elsewhere * ; it is found that the bulk modulus at low pressures will .always be less than predicted by the linear expression (6). This means that equation (6) will always lead to too large a value for po. By integrating equation (6) one obtains the following equation for po : (Po/P2)0L = ko/k,, (7) *here p2 (=8-92 g . / ~ m . ~and ) k, (=5*85 x 1 0 dynes/cm.2) ~ ~ are respectively the density and bulk modulus just inside the core boundary. I n order that equation (6) may correspond to the bulk moduli given in the Appendix, the adjustable constants must be chosen as follows : K,= 054 x lola dynes/cm.a, (8) lnserting these values in equation (7) it is found that po is 4-8g . j ~ m . ~ . In contrast with this figure, the densities of solid and liquid iron are 7-9 and As the density of solid nickel is 8.9 g . / ~ m . ~the , 6.9 g . / ~ m . ~respectively. , iron-nickel alloys are even denser than iron. The difference between po and the density of iron cannot be ascribed to uncertainties in the extrapolation. I n this connection it is the decrease in density when the pressure is released which is of ~ than pa, the density just inside the core importance ; po is 4.1 g . / ~ m .smaller . ~ than p2. Thus boundary, but the density of liquid iron is only 2.0 g . / ~ m less the method of extrapolation must introduce an error of a factor of two if the material of the core is iron ; this is certainly impossible. AnothS possibility is that the disagreement between po and the density of iron is a consequence of the special assumptions which were made in deriving the figures quoted in the Appendix. T h e procedure was arbitrary only in so far as the density jump at the boundary of the inner core and the central condensation of the heavy elements were concerned. The value of po is increased if the extent of the central condensation is diminished or if the jump in density at the boundary of the inner core is decreased. T h e most extreme assumptions which can be made are that there is no central condensation of the heavier elements and that the density is continuous across the boundary of the inner core. These assumptions lead to a density po of 6.4 g . / ~ m . and ~ , this is the largest value which can be derived from seismological data on any reasonable set of assumptions. Even this density is less than that of liquid iron. Moreover, this value of po is too large, as the bulk moduli at low pressures are less than those predicted by equation (6) ; it is estimated that the error which arises in this way is about 0.5 g . / ~ m . ~ .If the material of the core were to undergo a change in structure as the pressure is released, then this would further decrease the density at zero pressure. It therefore seems unreasonable to identify the material of the core with metallic iron or an iron-nickel alloy. Even if the Earth’s core and mantle are chemically distinct, the core may be composed of a material other than iron. The only elements which are cosmically abundant are hydrogen, helium, oxygen, silicon, magnesium and iron. All other a =3.82. * In a later issue of the Geophysical Supplement. 418 W. H . Ramsey elements are comparatively rare and need not concern us here. As gravity on1 the Earth is too small to retain hydrogen and helium, the core must be composed mainly of oxygen, silicon, magnesium and iron. Only a small number of very stable compounds can be formed from these elements. I n fact, only the oxides need be considered; the other compounds which are likely to occur, such as. silicates and orthosilicates, are little more than mixtures of the oxides. Magnesium. oxide MgO and silica SiO, have low densities and are the chief constituents of olivine, the material of the mantle. On the other hand, the oxides of iron have densities between 5 and 6 g./cm.S, and so they meet the requirements of the material of the core so far as density is concerned. There is, however, no mechanism to separate these compounds from the material of the mantle, as they mix freely with magnesium oxide and silica ; for example, dunite, which is composed mainly of olivine, contains the oxides of iron in appreciable quantities (cf. reference (23)). Thus it appears that there is no reasonable explanation of the density jump at the core boundary in terms of a change in chemical composition, This favours the view that the core discontinuity is due to a phase transition. As has been mentioned earlier, this view is also supported by the observed mean densities of the terrestrial planets (cf. reference (8)). I n the iron core theory geochemists attributed the formation of the core to the immiscibility of liquid iron and silicates ; they drew an analogy with the separation which takes place in an iron furnace. This view has recently been challenged b y Kuhn and Rittmann (24,25) who have shown that, even under the most favourable conditions, the time required for sbch a chemical separation is much larger than the age of the Earth. The argument of Kuhn and Rittmann is forceful, as it does. not depend critically on a particular theory of the origin of the Solar System. Irrespective of the origin of the Earth, one would expect that initially it was of approximately homogeneous composition ; the reasoning of Kuhn and Rittmann then shows that an iron core could not be formed. The argument is, of course, equally valid against any other type of chemical separation, and hence it supports the theory put forward in this paper. Having given this proof that the Earth‘s core is not iron, the authors cited proceed to develop a speculative theory of the Earth’s interior. The central idea of this theory is that, while the outer layers of the Earth have lost their light volatile constituents, the deep interior has remained of solar composition to this day. The authors claim to have shown that there would not be sufficient time for diffusion and convection to remove the hydrogen from the core. Their argument is based on a picture of the Earth’s formation, which is not necessarily correct; for example, their ideas on the solidification of the crust may be entirely wrong. Moreover, if the Earth were formed by the capture of material, either atoms or meteorites, then the problem of the escape of hydrogen would not arise. However, it is not necessary to criticize the theory in detail as it is untenable on general grounds. Since only the outer layers of the Earth are supposed to have lost hydrogen and helium, the overall chemical composition must still be approximately the same as that of the Sun and the major planets. Hoyle (26) has pointed out that this situation cannot be reconciled with the observed mean densities of the major planets. T h e Earth, in spite of a smaller central pressure, is about eight times as dense as Saturn. Moreover, the core of the Earth, which is supposed to be of solar composition, is largely responsible for the high mean density; this follows from the fact that the radius of gyration is less than that corresponding to uniform density. According to the calculations On the Nature of the Earth’s Cwe 419 of Kronig, de Boer and Korringa (14), the density of hydrogen at the pressures in the core is only about I g./cm.a. A density in the neighbourhood of 10g./cm.* is required to explain the mean density of the Earth. If it is assumed that hydrogen is mixed with iron, which would have a density of about 12 g./cm.a at theee pressures, then the content of hydrogen by weight cannot be more than 5 per cent. On the other hand, the hydrogen content of solar matter is at least 50 per cent by weight. Hence most, if not all, of the hydrogen must have escaped and 80 the basis of the theory of Kuhn and Rittmann is entirely wrong.+ Eucken (1% 27) has recently criticiaed the work of Kuhn and Rittmann referred to above ; some of his criticisms have been answered by Kuhn In his most recent publication (27) on this subject, Eucken endorses the argument of Kuhn (25) that an iron core could not have been formed in the Earth by the method usually supposed, that is, by means of the processes which dtect the separation in an iron furnace. Eucken (q) does not claim to have discovered a new mechanism by means of which an iron core could have been formed, though in his earlier paper (19)he did make a suggestion which was later criticized by Kuhn (28). On the whole, Eucken’s criticisms have been directed, not so much against Kuhn’s contention that an iron core could not have been formed, but against the theory of Kuhn and Rittmann that the Earth’s deep interior is essentially of solar cornpottition. Kuhn (28) claims to have answered some of Eucken’s objections to this theory, but others, based on density considerations and similar to those presented above, he has been unable to answer satisfactorily. (a). THEPHASETRANSITION AT THE COREBOUNDARY I t has been shown above that the existing explanations of the Earth’s core face serious, and apparently unanswerable, objections. This provides strong, but negative, support for the theory advanced in this paper. In the present section of the paper it will be assumed that the author’s theory is correct, and it will be shown that it has certain implications which can be put to an empirical test. In this way the tenability of the theory can be established on the basis of positive evidence. As has been mentioned before, the chemical composition immediately below the crustal layers is roughly go per cent magnesium orthosilicate (molecular weight 141)and 10per cent iron orthosilicate (molecular weight 204); the mean molecular weight is therefore 147. There will be relatively more iron orthodicate at the boundary of the core, and the previous calculations (8) suggest that the mean molecular weight is probably about 160; this figure will be adopted in the subsequent argument, but none of the conclusions is sensitive to it. The term mole will be used to denote 160g,of the material. An energy diagram similar to Fig. 2 can be constructed from seismological data. For each phase the variation of the free energy F with pressure is given hy the thermodynamical identity (aF/aP),=KPM/p, (9) where p is the density at pressure P and where M is one mole (160g.). Strictly speaking it is the isothermal compressibility K which appears in equation (9)and it is the adiabatic compressibility which is derived from the velocities of seismic waves; for a solid the dfierentx betweem these compressibilities is only of the 8 ”. ‘ F l a t h a d on this theory of Kubn dRimnmn hrve been mde by Rupert Wildt in recent “ Rcport on the Progccm of Astronomy M.N., x v , 84,1947. 0 33 W . H.Ramsey 420 order of magnitude of 0.1 per cent, and it is even less at very high pressures. The linear expression (6)for the bulk modulus k ( = ~ - is ~ )valid for both phases; for the metallic phase of the core the adjustable constants are given by equation (81, and for the phase in the mantle they are R, =2.07 x 1o12 dynes/cm.2, a = 3-68. (10) Equations (6)and (9)enable us to find the free energy F of each phase as a function of the density p. The free energies of the two phases are connected by the fact that the phases are in equilibrium at the boundary of the core. The condition for equilibrium is (11) - FI(P1)= P(v1- V2h where p1 and p2 are respectively the densities on the outside and the inside of the boundary, and where Vl and V2are the corresponding molar volumes ; as in the first section of the paper, Fl refers to the ordinary phase and F2 to the metallic phase. The pressure at the boundary of the core is 1-39x rolBdynes/cm.2, and p1 and p2 are respectively 6-02and 8.92 g . / ~ m (cf. . ~ Appendix). Hence the difference in the Helmholtz free energies is Fa(p2)- F,(pl) = IZOO kilojoules/mole, (14 which is approximately 12e.V. per molecule. The energy diagram constructed in this way is in appearance similar to Fig. 2 and need not be reproduced. In the subsequent argument the free energies Fl and F2 will be required at only three densities, namely the density just inside the core (8.92g:/cm.*), the density just outside the core (6.02g./cmP) and the density of the normal phase at zero pressure (3.6g./~m.~).The free energies at these densities are given in Table 11. All the figures refer, of course, to the chemical composition and temperature at the boundary of the core. F2(PZ) TABLE I1 Free Energies in Kilojoules per Mole Density (g./ana) Fl Fa 8.92 4200 1800 6-02 3 -6 600 I260 I 270 0 * 100 kilojoules per mole is approximately I e.V. per molecule. The height of an excitation band above the ground level is determined by the internal energies U, and U,,rather than by the free energies F, and Fp Unfortunately the former cannot be derived directly from seismological. data. In the notation of equation (I) the difference in the internal energies is (U2 - U,) = (84- F,) + L, (13) where L is the latent heat L = T(S2- Sd. (14) At a constant temperature the entropy of a solid or liquid is practically independent of the volume ; this is a consequence of the smallness of the coefficient of thermal expansion,which is usually of the order of magnitude of I O -per ~ degree Centigrade. Hence the latent heat L in equation (14)is independent of the molar volumes V , and V,, and it is equal to the heat absorbed during the transition to the metallic phase. If both phases were solid, L would be of the order of magnitude of one kilojoule per mole, and so could be neglected. Under these circumstances On the Nature of the Earth’s Core 421 the free energies listed in Table I1 would also be the internal energies. The core of the Earth is liquid in the sense that it does not transmit transverse elastic waves with periods of a few seconds. This does not necessarily imply that it is liquid from an atomic point of view ; but let us examine the consequences if it were. For an element the entropy of fusion is in the neighbourhood of k per atom, where k is Boltzmann’s constant. For a compound it is usually greater than, but still comparable with, R per molecule. There is considerable uncertainty about the temperature at the boundary of the Earth’s core, but let us assume that it is IO,OOO deg. C.* At this temperature an entropy increase of k per molecule corresponds to a latent heat of 80 kilojoules per mole. Thus, if the Earth’s core is a true liquid, the latent heat term in equation (13)would certainly have to be taken into account in a quantitative treatment, but it may be ignored for the purpose of making rough estimates. For the following discussion the latent heat L will be put equal to zero, so that there is no distinction between the free energy F and the internal energy U. When the density is 3.6 g . / ~ m .the ~ difference in the free energies is 1270 kilojoules per mole (cf. Table 11); this corresponds to approximately 1.3 e.V. per molecule. One would therefore expect the material of the Earth to have an ultra-violet absorption band at approximately 1000 A. I n view of the uncertainties in the calculations one cannot lay great stress on the figure of 13 e.V. for the excitation energy; this value may be in error by several electron volts. Nevertheless 13 e.V. is a reasonable excitation energy for a very stable molecule, and only very stable molecules will occur in the Earth. This shows that the pressure and density jump at the boundary of the Earth’s core are just what one would expect at a transition to a metallic phase. It has been assumed above that every molecule shares in the excitation, and yet the material at the core boundary contains two compounds in comparable proportions, namely magnesium and iron orthosilicates. An orthosilicate is, however, little more than a mixture of silica and the metallic oxide, and probably every orthosilicate has an excitation energy approximately the same as that of quartz, which is crystalline silica. Gleason (12)has shown that the conduction band in quartz lies about 10.9e.V. above the ground level ; this is not significantly different from the 13 e.V. mentioned above. The core discontinuity may therefore be tentatively attributed to the excitation of the molecule SO,. It will be seen from Table I1 that just outside the core boundary the excitation energy is about 7 e.V., and just inside the boundary it is 24 e.V. At a temperature of IO,OOO deg. C. kT is about I e.V. Both excitation energies are therefore large compared with RT,and so only a very small percentage of the molecules will be excited thermally. The sharpness of the transition will therefore not be impaired by the high temperature. On the high pressure side of the core boundary the excitation energy is about 24 kT, and so only one molecule in IO’O will he excited. Clearly the thermal excitation cannot modify any of the properties to a detectable extent. On the other hand, just outside thecore boundary the centre of the conduction band is only 7kT above the ground level. Moreover, at these high pressures the conduction band will be broad, and the bottom of the hand is probably only 4 or 5kT above the ground state. One would therefore c:;j>ect that the fraction 8 of the molecules which is excited by thermal agitation is ofthe order of magnitude of I per cent. This will modify the elastic constants * A survey of current views on the Earth‘s thermal hirtory her been given by Bullard (18). c, 33’ W. H. Ramsey 422 to an appreciable extent. The bulk modulus k, will be altered by an amount MI = (ki-kJ6, (15) where ki is the bulk modulus of the metallic phase when the density is 6.02 g./~m.~, It may easily be verified from equation (7) that k; is much smaller than k,, and so equation (1.5, becomes &/klw -6. (161 Thus, just outside the core boundary the bulk modulus should be too small, the anomaly being of the order of magnitude of I per cent. This anomaly will disappear exponentially with the distance from the core boundary, partly because the temperature decreases but mainly because the excitation energy increases, The rigidity will show a similar anomaly of approximately the same magnitude. This type of anomaly will occur at every transition to a metallic phase, provided that the temperature is sufficiently high. An important characteristic of the anomaly is that it is confined to the low pressure side of the transition. On the high pressure side the excitation energy is always very large; this is a direct consequenceof the small compressibility of the normal phase at high pressures and the large change in volume which is characteristic of this type of phase 6 . 4 1000 Fro. 3.-The 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 Depth (km.1 celocities of seismic waves as a function of depth (afterJeffreys (29)). These predictions receive remarkable confirmation from seismology. In Fig. 3 the velocities of seismic waves are shown as a function of depth; P refers. to the primary or longitudinal waves, and S to the secondary or transverse waves.. The velocities, rather than the elastic constants, are used as they are derived On the Nature of the Earth’s Core 423 directly from the observations; the velocities P and S are related to the bulk modulus k and the rigidity p by the equations The predicted anomalies can be seen in both velocities‘just outside the boundary of the core (depth 2900 km.). As is expected, both velocities are tob small, and the magnitude of the anomaly corresponds to 6 in equation (16) being between 3 and 4 per cent. As is also predicted, there is no irregularity just inside the boundary of the core. The existence of these anomalies is positive proof that the core is due to a transition to a metallic phase. A more extreme example of this type of anomaly occurs just outside the inner core (depth 5100km.). Jeffreys (29) has shown that the velocity must decrease with depth for some distance outside the inner core* and then increase abruptly at the boundary of the inner core, as shown in Fig. 3. No other hypothesis seems to be capable of explaining the observations. It will be noted that again there is no evidence of an irregularity on the high-pressure side of the boundary. The magnitude of this anomaly corresponds to about 15 per cent of the molecules being excited. These anomalies show that both the core and the inner core are due to phase transitions of the type described in the first section of this paper. The anomaliesjust outside the core have been known for many years and they have attracted the attentions of several geochemists. Following the analogy with an iron furnace, geochemists suspected ihat a layer of metallic sulphides should have collected at the surface of the iron core, and at one time they suggested that the anomalies were due to this layer. Such a chemical separation of the sulphides is, of course, impossible for the reasons given by Kuhn and Rittmann (24, 25). It is also at variance with seismic data, as there should be two reflections, one at the top of the layer and one at the bottom. It is also impossible to explain the anomaly as a mixing of the materials of the core and the mantle ; this would be in contradiction with the observed sharpness of the boundary. Though the anomalyjust outside the inner core has been known for several years, no explanation has been attempted. This is because the composition of the inner core has remained a problem. The only abundant heavy element is iron and it was thought to be the chief constituent of the cpre. The elements appreciably heavier than iron are less common by a factor of a thousand or more. The composition of the inner core and the anomaly just outside it are, of course, explained simultaneously by the theory put forward in this paper. As nothing is known about the density of the inner core a rough estimate will now be made. It has been shown earlier that just outside the inner core about 15 per cent of the molecules are excited, as compared with 3 or 4 per cent just outside the core. This difference is probably due to the higher temperature and to considerably broader energy bands. The difference in the free energies at the density just outside the boundary is therefore probably not much different from the corresponding figure for the core (cf. Table 11) ; assume that it is 500 kilojoules per mole. A table similar to Table I1 can be constructed by the same methods and so the jump in density can be found from equation (11). The density jump turns out to be 5 g . / ~ m . ~ .This figure is insensitive to the structure of the inner core ; it may be a liquid or it may be a solid which satisfies Poisson’s relation. This estimate is, of course, very rough * T h e linear nature of the decrease is not significant; it is a consequence of a special assumption made by J ~ (-1. F 424 W. H. Ramsey but it serves to show that the figure adopted in the Appendix cannot be wildly in error. THEORIGIN OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM The theory developed in this paper has an important bearing on cosmogonyWith the hypothesis of an iron core the terrestrial planets appear to have different chemical compositions. Jeffreys (6) has shown that it must be assumed that the smaller planets contain relatively less iron. The smaller planets could not have retained a relatively higher percentage of the lighter elements. Hence it must be assumed that the planets were originally of different chemical compositionsOn the other hand, there is too much order in the Solar System for the planets to be formed by a series of unrelated events. For example, the orbits of the planets and of their satellites are nearly in one plane, and they are described in the same sense. This difficulty is removed by the present theory. It has been shown in a previous paper (8) that on the basis of this theory the observed mean densities of the terrestrial planets are compatible witfi identical chemical constitutions. Another difficulty from the point of view of cosmogony is the chemical composition of the Earth. The olivine in the mantle of the Earth contains at least 8 per cent iron by weight. The mass of the core is about one-third of that of the whole Earth. Thus, on the iron core hypothesis, iron is the most abundant element in the Earth and it accounts for at least 40 per cent of the total mass. This is much larger than the average iron content of meteorites, and it is also much larger than would be expected if the Earth originated from solar matter. T h e composition of the inner core presents a further difficulty; the elements appreciably heavier than iron occur only in very small quantities. These difficulties are overcome by the theory developed in this paper. As the core and inner core are explained as phase transitions, the problem of finding heavier elements in large quantities does not arise. Let us make a rough estimate of the chemical composition of the Earth on the basis of this theory. We need concern ourselves only with oxygen, silicon, magnesium and iron ; the other elements account for only a few per cent of the total mass. As has been mentioned before, the material immediately below the crustal layers has been identified as olivine, which is a mixture of 90 per cent magnesium orthosilicate and 10 per cent iron orthosilicate. There is a condensation of the heavier elements towards the centre of the Earth, and the previous calculations (8) on the mean densities of the terrestrial planets show that the mean atomic weight of the whole Earth is about 8 per cent larger than that immediately below the crustal layers. For simplicity, let us assume that the central condensation is entirely due to the proportions of iron and magnesium orthosilicates changing with depth. The chemical composition of the Earth is then determined uniquely, and by mass it is 40 per cent Oxygen, 21 per cent iron, 21 per cent magnesium and 18 per cent silicon. This estimate is very rough, but it gives an idea of the relative importance of the four most common elements. The estimated composition of the Earth is not significantly different from the average composition of all meteorites (7,23), which is 32 per cent oxygen, 26 per cent iron, 17 per cent magnesium, 18 per cent silicon and 7 per cent of other elements. The relative abundances of the elements in the Sun’s atmosphere are rather uncertain (cf. reference (30)),but the compositions given above are consistent with the view that. both planets and meteorites originated from solar matter. This unification is essential in any theory of the origin of the Solar System. On the Nature of the Earth’s Core 425 CONCLUSION The theory developed in this paper can explain all of the changes in structure in the deep interior of the Earth. It has been shown in a previous paper (8) that it can also account for the mean densities of the terrestrial planets on the basis of identical chemical constitutions. No previous theory has had these merits. Moreover, so far as the author can foresee,no a priori objectionsto this theory can be raised. On theother hand, the objections to the iron-core theory and to the theory of Kuhn and Rittmann (24,25) seem to be unanswerable. The present theory of the Earth’s interior is the simplest which has been put forward. In it the Earth is of uniform chemical composition, apart from a slight condensation of the’heavier elements towards the centre. The other terrestrial planets and meteorites have the same chemical composition as the Earth, and this composition is consistent with solar origin. The present theory explains the anomalies just outside the core and inner core in a very natural way ; these anomalies have never before been explained satisfactorily. The sharpness of the core boundary is also support for the theory. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author would like to acknowledge the interesting discussions he has had with Professor L. Rosenfeld, Professor H. Frohlich and Dr Huang Kun, and he would like to express his appreciation for the interest which they have shown in this work. He would also like to thank Professor N. Bohr for the privilege of working in this famous Institute. Universitetets Institut for Teorefbk FysiR, Blegdamsvej, I 5, Ksbenhuvn, B : 1949March 22. References (I) L. H. Adams and J. W. Green, W .Mug., 12,361,1931. J. C. Slater, Phys. Rev., 58, 54, IW. (3) S.K. Runcorn, Nature, 161, 464,1948. (4)A. L.Hales and D. I. Gough, Nature, 160,746,1947. ( 5 ) Harold JeRreys, M.N., % 823, 1934. (6)Harold Jefh-eyg, M.N., Gcoghys. Suppl., 4, 62,1937. (7) Betio ahtenberg (Editor), ,The Intrmal Constitution of the EQtth, New Yo&, 1939, p. 113. (8) W. H. Ramsey, M.N., 108,406, 1948. (9)W.H.Ramsey, The Obsmutory, 69.6, 1949. (10)F. Seitz, The Modern Themy of Solids, New York, IW. (XI) R. Hilsch and R. W. Pohl,2 e i f s . f . Physik., 59,812,1930. (12)P. R. Gleason, Proc. Nut. Acud. Sci., Wash., 15, 551, 1929. (13) E. Wigner and H. B. Huntington, J. Chem. Phys., 3,764,1935. (14)R. Kronig, J. de Boer and J. Korringa, Physicu, 12,245, 1946. (IS) P.W. Bridgman, The Physics of High Pressures, London, 1930. (16) P. W. Bridgman, Rev. Mod. Phys., 18, I, 1946. (17) Harold Jeffrey, Rpts. 011 Progress in Physics, 10, 5 2 , 1945. (IS)E. C. Bullard, Nature, 156, 35, 1945. (19) A. Eucken, Nutunu., 32, 112, 1944. (20) K. E. Bullen,,An Introduction to the T h e q of Seismology, Cambridge, 1947(21) K. E. Bullen, Bull. Seism. SOC.A m . , 30, 235, 1940;32, 19,1942. (22) J. D.Bernal, The Observatory, 59, 268, 1936. (2) On the Nature of the Earth's Core 426 (23) Francis Birch, J. F. Schairer and H. Cecil Spicer (Editors), Handbook of Physical Constants, Geol. SOC.A m . , 1942. (24) W.Kuhn and A. Rittmann, Geol. Rundsclzau, 32, 215,1941. (25) W.Kuhn, Natum., 30, 689, 1942. (26) F. Hoyle, The Observatory, 69, 7, 1949. (27) A. Eucken, Natum., 33, 312, 1946. (28)W.Kuhn, Natum., 33, 311, 1946; Experimentia, 2, 391,1946. (w)Harold Jeffreys, M.N., Geophys. Suppl., 4, 594, 1939. (30) R. v. d. R. Woolley and C. W. Allen, M.N., 108, 292, 1948. APPENDIX Depth (km.) 33 I00 200 300 400 413 500 600 700 800 900 1000 I200 1400 1600 I 800 2000 2200 2400 2600 2800 2898 2898 3000 3200 3400 3600 3800 4000 4200 4400 4600 4800 4982 Density (s./cm.3) 3'29 3'39 3-50 3'59 3 -68 3-70 3-91 4.1 I 4'27 4'38 4-50 4-60 4'75 4'90 5-06 5 '20 5'36 5 '49 5 '63 5 -78 5-91 6.02 8.92 9-09 9'43 9'76 I0.06 0.03 I 1-25 0.065 I '40 0'100 I -56 0.137 0.141 0.174 0.214 0.256 0.299 0.344 0.389 0.482 0.578 0.676 0.78 0.88 0.99 1'74 I -76 1-39 1.39 I -48 I -66 I -84 2-18 2.56 2.87 3-1I 3-28 3'52 3 -84 4-18 4'55 4'93 5 '34 5-71 6.1I 6.53 6.80 6.92 5 '85 6.14 6.77 7'49 '1'10 1'21 1-33 2'02 6.22 10.35 2'20 10.63 10.89 I 1-14 11-38 11.61 11.8 2-37 2.54 2-71 2.86 3 '02 8-91 9*6 5121 12'0 5121 17'3 18.0 18.5 5700 6371 Internal Density Distribution, etc. Pressure Bulk Modulus (xolZdynes/cm.8) ( 1 0 'dynes/cm.z) ~ I *16 0.009 3-15 3'25 3 '25 3 '74 3 '95 10'2 10.9 11.5 12'2 12.9 11.3 Rigidity ( 1olZdyna/cm.*) 0.62 0.67 0.74 0.81 0.90 0.91 1-10 1'32 1.50 I -65 I '77 I -86 2'01 2'15 2-29 2-43 2-57 2-71 2-85 3-00 3-15 3-21
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz