Glen Eira Activity Centres Community Engagement Comments
Carnegie
Table of Contents
Question ....................................................................................................................Page number
What do you use Carnegie shopping strip for? ............................................................................ 3
Please list .........................................................................................................................................14
How do you travel to Carnegie shopping strip?..........................................................................16
What do you call Carnegie shopping strip? ................................................................................23
What do you love about Carnegie shopping strip ......................................................................32
What don’t you like/do you want to see changed? ....................................................................44
What makes Carnegie shopping strip unique and special? .....................................................68
Open Space .....................................................................................................................................78
Type of shops/retail outlets ............................................................................................................87
Community Services .......................................................................................................................98
Transport ....................................................................................................................................... 102
Private development .................................................................................................................... 109
What are three things that would make Carnegie shopping strip fantastic? ...................... 121
Name another shopping strip or centre in Melbourne you’d like it to become like and why?
......................................................................................................................................................... 135
What would you like Carnegie shopping strip to be like for future generations in 30 years
time? ............................................................................................................................................... 145
Any other comments?.................................................................................................................. 155
1
2
Date
What do you use Carnegie shopping strip for?
Nov 28 16 06:02:24 pm
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes
Other
Cafes, Weekly shop, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Weekly
shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Meeting
friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Weekly shop, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Retail outlets, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Retail outlets, Cafes, Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Weekly
Nov 29 16 06:29:16
Nov 29 16 09:48:36
Nov 29 16 02:02:14
Nov 29 16 05:17:36
am
am
pm
pm
Nov 29 16 06:57:25 pm
Nov 29 16 11:06:31 pm
Nov 30 16 05:37:26 am
Nov 30 16 08:09:13 am
Nov 30 16 09:25:28 am
Nov 30 16 01:37:26 pm
Nov 30 16 02:43:46 pm
Nov 30 16 04:37:55 pm
Nov 30 16 10:32:17 pm
Nov 30 16 10:49:43 pm
Nov 30 16 11:43:52 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 12:51:45 pm
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 06:16:34 pm
Dec 01 16 06:39:40 pm
Dec 01 16 07:43:36 pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46 pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 12:12:05 am
3
Dec 02 16 02:55:35
Dec 02 16 07:44:25
Dec 02 16 09:09:01
Dec 02 16 09:10:50
am
am
am
am
Dec 02 16 09:21:33 am
Dec 02 16 10:02:16 am
Dec 02 16 10:40:50 am
Dec 02 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 02 16 12:26:26 pm
Dec 02 16 12:38:18 pm
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 02:23:16 pm
Dec 02 16 03:25:11 pm
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
Dec 02 16 07:20:13 pm
Dec 02 16 07:23:41 pm
Dec 02 16 08:10:48 pm
Dec 02 16 09:39:36 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
Dec 03 16 12:07:43 pm
Dec 03 16 01:07:24 pm
Dec 03 16 01:11:04 pm
Dec 03 16 01:39:39 pm
Dec 03 16 01:48:27 pm
Dec 03 16 02:34:16 pm
Dec 03 16 04:42:15 pm
Dec 03 16 04:58:50 pm
Dec 03 16 05:25:18 pm
Dec 03 16 06:02:26 pm
Dec 03 16 06:31:54 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:38 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop, Library
Retail outlets, Cafes, Weekly shop, Library
Retail outlets, Cafes, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Library
Retail outlets, Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends
Retail outlets, Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Cafes, Bars, Weekly shop
Cafes, Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop, Library,
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Retail outlets, Cafes, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Other
Retail outlets, Cafes, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
4
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08 pm
Dec 04 16 03:50:48 pm
Dec 04 16 04:41:54 pm
Dec 04 16 05:19:29 pm
Dec 04 16 07:17:49 pm
Dec 05 16 11:47:03 am
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 05 16 06:44:44 pm
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 02:13:56 am
Dec 06 16 07:53:47 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 12:14:30 pm
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
Dec 06 16 01:44:42 pm
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 04:20:37 pm
Dec 06 16 05:13:56 pm
Dec 06 16 07:21:30
Dec 06 16 07:36:32
Dec 06 16 08:01:02
Dec 07 16 08:38:49
pm
pm
pm
am
Dec 07 16 01:30:53 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:25 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:55 pm
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 07 16 09:56:41 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 08:01:30 pm
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Weekly shop, Library
Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Retail outlets, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Weekly
shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Weekly
shop, Meeting friends
Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Cafes, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
5
Dec 09 16 03:15:33
Dec 09 16 03:31:00
Dec 09 16 04:02:32
Dec 09 16 04:02:34
Dec 09 16 04:48:02
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 04:57:31 pm
Dec 09 16 10:07:30 pm
Dec 10 16 10:04:18 am
Dec 10 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 10 16 01:15:25 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 09:29:29 am
Dec 11 16 01:55:48 pm
Dec 11 16 05:58:28
Dec 11 16 06:14:48
Dec 12 16 02:20:12
Dec 12 16 04:28:28
Dec 14 16 03:36:48
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 14 16 09:37:51 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07
Dec 15 16 08:59:06
Dec 16 16 12:06:19
Dec 16 16 02:04:25
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 16 16 02:07:53 pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Dec 17 16 09:00:42 am
Dec 17 16 09:36:01 am
Dec 17 16 10:26:51 am
Dec 17 16 02:40:19 pm
Dec 17 16 06:10:26 pm
Dec 18 16 01:09:39 pm
Dec 18 16 10:23:31 pm
Meeting friends
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop, Cafes,
Bars
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Cafes, Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop, Meeting
friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Weekly
shop, Meeting friends, Library
Cafes, Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop, Library
Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Retail outlets, Cafes, Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Library, Other
Retail outlets, Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Cafes, Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Library
Retail outlets, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
6
Dec 19 16 09:03:13 am
Dec 19 16 11:10:21 am
Dec 19 16 11:19:45 am
Dec 19 16 11:27:41 am
Dec 19 16 11:34:44 am
Dec 19 16 11:36:23 am
Dec 19 16 11:41:09 am
Dec 19 16 11:44:32 am
Dec 19 16 11:46:20 am
Dec 19 16 11:48:39 am
Dec 19 16 11:54:38 am
Dec 19 16 11:59:23 am
Dec 19 16 12:04:25 pm
Dec 19 16 12:07:06 pm
Dec 19 16 12:12:19 pm
Dec 19 16 12:22:42 pm
Dec 19 16 12:24:03 pm
Dec 19 16 12:31:26 pm
Dec 19 16 12:47:03 pm
Dec 19 16 12:48:52 pm
Dec 19 16 12:51:57 pm
Dec 19 16 12:53:50 pm
Dec 19 16 12:59:44 pm
Dec 19 16 01:02:27 pm
Dec 19 16 01:05:53 pm
Dec 19 16 01:09:43 pm
Dec 19 16 01:12:58 pm
Dec 19 16 01:15:09 pm
Dec 19 16 01:16:30 pm
Dec 19 16 01:19:29 pm
Dec 19 16 01:21:26 pm
Dec 19 16 01:24:13 pm
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Cafes, Bars, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Other
Cafes, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop, Other
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Cafes, Other
Cafes, Bars, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
7
Dec 19 16 01:34:02 pm
Dec 19 16 01:35:37 pm
Dec 19 16 01:36:53 pm
Dec 19 16 01:40:30 pm
Dec 19 16 01:43:34 pm
Dec 19 16 01:47:03 pm
Dec 19 16 01:49:12 pm
Dec 20 16 03:50:39 pm
Dec 20 16 08:58:27 pm
Dec 21 16 07:38:15 pm
Dec 21 16 11:20:20 pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44 am
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
Dec 22 16 08:48:44 pm
Dec 23 16 01:21:05 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 23 16 08:02:16 pm
Dec 23 16 10:35:02 pm
Dec 24 16 06:19:24 am
Dec 24 16 10:17:31 am
Dec 24 16 09:58:08 pm
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
Dec 25 16 06:15:10 pm
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 26 16 04:28:51 pm
Dec 26 16 07:01:09 pm
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 27 16 08:11:33 pm
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
shop
Cafes, Library, Other
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Other
Cafes, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Cafes, Library
Weekly shop, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Meeting friends, Library
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Library
Retail outlets
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Meeting
friends, Library
Retail outlets, Cafes, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
8
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 08:00:46 pm
Jan 01 17 10:43:11 pm
Jan 01 17 11:49:13 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15 am
Jan 03 17 05:38:54 pm
Jan 04 17 01:44:07 pm
Jan 04 17 04:19:58 pm
Jan 04 17 08:52:40 pm
Jan 04 17 11:40:31 pm
Jan 05 17 07:58:49 am
Jan 05 17 08:03:07 am
Jan 05 17 11:41:31 am
Jan 08 17 01:02:53 pm
Jan 08 17 02:41:07 pm
Jan 08 17 10:13:18 pm
Jan 09 17 01:40:52 pm
Jan 09 17 01:51:18 pm
Jan 11 17 03:11:49 pm
Jan 11 17 04:45:00 pm
Jan 12 17 06:39:14 pm
Jan 14 17 05:47:35 pm
Jan 14 17 06:04:44 pm
Jan 14 17 08:31:43 pm
Jan 16 17 01:33:04 am
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Library
Cafes, Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends
Retail outlets, Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Weekly
shop, Meeting friends
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Retail outlets, Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Meeting friends, Library, Other
9
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 19 17 04:19:18 pm
Jan 19 17 11:23:52 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
Jan 21 17 06:35:30 am
Jan 24 17 01:56:15 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 25 17 09:10:02 am
Jan 26 17 12:17:14 am
Jan 26 17 12:02:14 pm
Jan 26 17 02:41:34 pm
Jan 27 17 03:28:37 pm
Jan 28 17 09:10:58 am
Jan 28 17 11:13:55 am
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 12:52:06 pm
Feb 01 17 01:36:19 pm
Feb 01 17 08:58:54 pm
Feb 01 17 09:51:04 pm
Feb 01 17 10:59:14 pm
Feb 03 17 01:54:17 pm
Feb 03 17 10:13:18 pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 12:07:39 am
Feb 05 17 09:04:43 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Meeting
friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Meeting
friends
Cafes, Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Other
Retail outlets, Bars, Weekly shop, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items
Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop, Library,
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library, Bars
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Cafes, Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop, Library
10
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:06:15 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41
Feb 06 17 06:28:50
Feb 06 17 06:41:44
Feb 06 17 06:57:40
Feb 06 17 06:59:40
Feb 06 17 07:05:16
Feb 06 17 07:20:51
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:46:31 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35 pm
Feb 07 17 12:02:21 am
Feb 07 17 03:43:47 am
Feb 07 17 07:37:46 am
Feb 07 17 08:53:34 am
Feb 07 17 09:22:32 am
Feb 07 17 09:32:02
Feb 07 17 10:31:31
Feb 07 17 10:31:34
Feb 07 17 11:37:55
am
am
am
am
Feb 07 17 12:54:13 pm
Feb 07 17 12:55:13 pm
Feb 07 17 01:20:27 pm
Feb 07 17 01:29:06 pm
Feb 07 17 02:22:12 pm
Feb 07 17 02:48:16 pm
Retail outlets, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Library
Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop, Library
Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop, Meeting friends
Cafes, Other, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Other
Cafes, Bars
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Weekly
shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Retail outlets, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
11
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 08:42:27 pm
Feb 07 17 09:00:05
Feb 07 17 09:25:41
Feb 07 17 10:35:41
Feb 07 17 11:19:05
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 08 17 01:26:30 pm
Feb 08 17 02:03:01 pm
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 08 17 05:03:53 pm
Feb 08 17 05:49:41 pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08
Feb 08 17 10:49:39
Feb 09 17 12:04:18
Feb 10 17 09:31:59
pm
pm
pm
am
Feb 10 17 10:34:06 am
Feb 10 17 11:01:20 am
Feb 10 17 01:36:52 pm
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 10 17 02:38:19 pm
Feb 10 17 04:09:57 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
Feb 10 17 10:53:48 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Feb 11 17 06:53:53 pm
Feb 11 17 06:54:18 pm
Feb 11 17 07:58:24 pm
Feb 12 17 11:17:14 am
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes
Cafes, Other
Cafes, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop
Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Bars, Weekly
shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends, Library
Cafes, Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items
Retail outlets, Cafes, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Weekly shop
12
Feb 12 17 02:01:05 pm
Feb 12 17 05:59:20 pm
Feb 12 17 06:23:07 pm
Feb 12 17 07:02:25 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 12:46:35 pm
Feb 13 17 05:14:39 pm
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 12:50:53 pm
Feb 14 17 01:56:09 pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09 pm
Feb 15 17 12:08:50 am
Feb 15 17 10:19:11 am
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
Feb 16 17 03:39:55 pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:21:55 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53
Feb 17 17 12:21:13
Feb 18 17 01:52:15
Feb 18 17 08:13:09
pm
pm
am
am
Feb 18 17 11:51:03 am
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 08:36:02 am
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop
Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Weekly shop, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Library
Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Bars, Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Meeting friends
Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library
Cafes, Weekly shop, Meeting friends
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Cafes,
Weekly shop, Meeting friends, Library
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Meeting
friends, Library
Retail outlets, Cafes, Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Cafes, Weekly shop,
Library, Other
Daily needs - milk/newspapers/small shopping items, Retail outlets, Weekly
shop, Library
Other
13
Date
Please list
Nov 29 16 09:48:36 am
Nov 29 16 02:02:14 pm
Restaurants
Dinner
Takeaway dinner
Lunch
Supermarket
Fish shop
Restaurants
Restaurants
I work there
restaurants
I work there too
Restaurant
Restaurants
Medical centre and Pharmacy
Post office, $2 shops
Restaurant
Going out for dinner
Library playground
doctor, optician, chemist, hardware shop, op shops, newsagent when it
existed,
Hairdresser
Restaurants
To be honest it is not family friendly anymore. There are more restaurants
than ever. There used to be a great book shop, a great shoe shop and
newsagent. What happened to the Greek deli that was amazing? The only
time I now go down is for a quick bite to eat and that is just OK nothing to
write home about. Even our old Chemist has sold out and the one that is
there is very average. I never even vegie shop any more as the quality is
not great. The Super market I do use when I have to.
Dry cleaning and beauty treatments
restaurants
business ( I have a café)
restaurants
business
business
everything
restaurants, basically all shopping
Business
dinner, chicken shop in plaza, bakeries, banks, dry cleaning and pubs
fruit and veg shops, butcher and pharmacy
restaurants
restaurants
restaurants
everything
everything including butcher
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Nov 30 16 08:09:13 am
Nov 30 16 02:43:46 pm
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 09:09:01 am
Dec 03 16 12:07:43
Dec 03 16 06:31:54
Dec 04 16 02:47:08
Dec 04 16 07:17:49
Dec 05 16 11:47:03
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 07:36:32 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
Dec 19 16 11:36:23 am
Dec 19 16 11:54:38 am
Dec 19 16 11:59:23 am
Dec 19 16 12:04:25 pm
Dec 19 16 12:07:06 pm
Dec 19 16 12:12:19 pm
Dec 19 16 12:22:42 pm
Dec 19 16 12:31:26 pm
Dec 19 16 12:59:44 pm
Dec 19 16 01:02:27 pm
Dec 19 16 01:12:58 pm
Dec 19 16 01:15:09 pm
Dec 19 16 01:34:02 pm
Dec 19 16 01:35:37 pm
Dec 19 16 01:40:30 pm
14
Dec 19 16 01:47:03 pm
Dec 21 16 11:20:20 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 24 16 06:19:24 am
Dec 24 16 10:17:31 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Jan 05 17 07:58:49 am
Jan 12 17 06:39:14 pm
Jan 14 17 05:47:35 pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 24 17 01:56:15 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 25 17 09:10:02 am
Jan 27 17 03:28:37 pm
Jan 28 17 09:10:58 am
Jan 28 17 11:13:55 am
Feb 01 17 10:59:14 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14
Feb 06 17 06:11:41
Feb 06 17 08:44:55
Feb 06 17 09:41:45
am
pm
pm
pm
Feb 07 17 12:02:21
Feb 07 17 03:43:47
Feb 07 17 09:32:02
Feb 07 17 02:22:12
am
am
am
pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 10 17 10:34:06 am
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 12 17 05:59:20 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
school and kumon
Work
Gym
Restaurants and take away primarily.
Work
Dinner
Love the choice and quality of restaurants we have
Restaurants yummm
Haircuts
Hairdresser and banks
Restaurants
having a walk, people watching
restaurants
restaurants, doctor
Restuarants
Doctor
Physio
I work there too
Chemist for advice, medicine, blood pressure check.
Hairdresser, fruit and vegetables, Asian cooking ingredients, banking, post
office
gym hairdresser
Nothing. I sometimes go to Chemist Warehouse only
Walking with my dog,
Children's playground next to the library/ restaurants/ sitting on a seat and
watching the vibrant community/ op shops
Restaurants
Doctors, catch buses
business owner
NOW NO NEWSAGENCY......SO SAD & ANNOYING....... too many ASIAN
CAFES/Restaurants
Banking
Hairdresser
Clothing
Post Office
Banks and Post Office
Great food and lots of variety - eat in or take away. Great small businesses
- fruit shops, butcher, alcholol shop, delicattessen, cafes etc. Discount
chemist.
Park exercise live transport
Visiting doctor at the rear of Pharmacy.
I rarely visit there now, I do not like the totally Asian look, with the
celebration of Chinese New Year
going to the station to take the train
Enjoying the ambience and looking for new shops. Especially enjoy the op
shop.
Optician
Restaurants
Nothing. I do not use Carnegie Shopping precinct anymore because it is all
Asian Restaurants.
There are only a couple of Retail shops most of no interest to me.
15
2 Woolworths supermarkets and 2 Warehouse Chemists is rediculous, why
not a Coles for competition? one of the Warehouse Chemists opened up
right next door to a Pharmacy that has been there for 40 + years! Where is
the planning? Where is the Carnegie Traders Association? they should plan
to ensure their is a good variety and balance of shopping and restaurants in
Koornang Road to bring it back to a valuable part of Carnegie.
Date
How do you travel to Carnegie shopping strip?
Nov 28 16 06:02:24 pm
Nov 29 16 06:29:16 am
Nov 29 16 09:48:36 am
Nov 29 16 02:02:14 pm
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Nov 29 16 06:57:25 pm
Nov 29 16 11:06:31 pm
Nov 30 16 05:37:26 am
Nov 30 16 08:09:13 am
Nov 30 16 09:25:28 am
Nov 30 16 01:37:26 pm
Nov 30 16 02:43:46 pm
Nov 30 16 04:37:55 pm
Nov 30 16 10:32:17 pm
Nov 30 16 10:49:43 pm
Nov 30 16 11:43:52 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 12:51:45 pm
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 06:16:34 pm
Dec 01 16 06:39:40 pm
Dec 01 16 07:43:36 pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46 pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 12:12:05 am
Dec 02 16 02:55:35 am
Dec 02 16 07:44:25 am
Dec 02 16 09:09:01 am
Dec 02 16 09:10:50 am
Dec 02 16 09:21:33 am
Dec 02 16 10:02:16 am
Dec 02 16 10:40:50 am
Walk, Drive
Walk
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk
Walk
Drive
Walk, Drive
Ride, Drive
Drive
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive
16
Dec 02 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 02 16 12:26:26 pm
Dec 02 16 12:38:18 pm
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 02:23:16 pm
Dec 02 16 03:25:11 pm
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
Dec 02 16 07:20:13 pm
Dec 02 16 07:23:41 pm
Dec 02 16 08:10:48 pm
Dec 02 16 09:39:36 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
Dec 03 16 12:07:43 pm
Dec 03 16 01:07:24 pm
Dec 03 16 01:11:04 pm
Dec 03 16 01:39:39 pm
Dec 03 16 01:48:27 pm
Dec 03 16 02:34:16 pm
Dec 03 16 04:42:15 pm
Dec 03 16 04:58:50 pm
Dec 03 16 05:25:18 pm
Dec 03 16 06:02:26 pm
Dec 03 16 06:31:54 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:38 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08 pm
Dec 04 16 03:50:48 pm
Dec 04 16 04:41:54 pm
Dec 04 16 05:19:29 pm
Dec 04 16 07:17:49 pm
Dec 05 16 11:47:03 am
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 05 16 06:44:44 pm
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 02:13:56 am
Dec 06 16 07:53:47 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 12:14:30 pm
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
Dec 06 16 01:44:42 pm
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 04:20:37 pm
Dec 06 16 05:13:56 pm
Dec 06 16 07:21:30 pm
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk, Ride
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive, Catch public transport, Other
Walk
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Ride, Drive
Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk, Ride, Drive
Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk, Drive
17
Dec 06 16 07:36:32 pm
Dec 06 16 08:01:02 pm
Dec 07 16 08:38:49 am
Dec 07 16 01:30:53 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:25 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:55 pm
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 07 16 09:56:41 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 08:01:30 pm
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:34 pm
Dec 09 16 04:48:02 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 04:57:31 pm
Dec 09 16 10:07:30 pm
Dec 10 16 10:04:18 am
Dec 10 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 10 16 01:15:25 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 09:29:29 am
Dec 11 16 01:55:48 pm
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
Dec 11 16 06:14:48 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 12 16 04:28:28 pm
Dec 14 16 03:36:48 pm
Dec 14 16 09:37:51 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
Dec 15 16 08:59:06 pm
Dec 16 16 12:06:19 pm
Dec 16 16 02:04:25 pm
Dec 16 16 02:07:53 pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Dec 17 16 09:00:42 am
Dec 17 16 09:36:01 am
Dec 17 16 10:26:51 am
Dec 17 16 02:40:19 pm
Dec 17 16 06:10:26 pm
Dec 18 16 01:09:39 pm
Dec 18 16 10:23:31 pm
Dec 19 16 09:03:13 am
Dec 19 16 11:10:21 am
Walk, Drive
Drive
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive, Catch public transport
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk, Ride, Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Walk, Catch public transport
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Other
18
Dec 19 16 11:19:45 am
Dec 19 16 11:27:41 am
Dec 19 16 11:34:44 am
Dec 19 16 11:36:23 am
Dec 19 16 11:41:09 am
Dec 19 16 11:44:32 am
Dec 19 16 11:46:20 am
Dec 19 16 11:48:39 am
Dec 19 16 11:54:38 am
Dec 19 16 11:59:23 am
Dec 19 16 12:04:25 pm
Dec 19 16 12:07:06 pm
Dec 19 16 12:12:19 pm
Dec 19 16 12:22:42 pm
Dec 19 16 12:24:03 pm
Dec 19 16 12:26:59 pm
Dec 19 16 12:31:26 pm
Dec 19 16 12:37:53 pm
Dec 19 16 12:47:03 pm
Dec 19 16 12:48:52 pm
Dec 19 16 12:51:57 pm
Dec 19 16 12:53:50 pm
Dec 19 16 12:59:44 pm
Dec 19 16 01:02:27 pm
Dec 19 16 01:05:53 pm
Dec 19 16 01:09:43 pm
Dec 19 16 01:12:58 pm
Dec 19 16 01:15:09 pm
Dec 19 16 01:16:30 pm
Dec 19 16 01:19:29 pm
Dec 19 16 01:21:26 pm
Dec 19 16 01:24:13 pm
Dec 19 16 01:34:02 pm
Dec 19 16 01:35:37 pm
Dec 19 16 01:36:53 pm
Dec 19 16 01:40:30 pm
Dec 19 16 01:43:34 pm
Dec 19 16 01:47:03 pm
Dec 19 16 01:49:12 pm
Dec 20 16 03:50:39 pm
Dec 20 16 08:58:27 pm
Dec 21 16 07:38:15 pm
Dec 21 16 11:20:20 pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44 am
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
Dec 22 16 08:48:44 pm
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Walk
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Other
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
19
Dec 23 16 01:21:05 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 23 16 08:02:16 pm
Dec 23 16 10:35:02 pm
Dec 24 16 06:19:24 am
Dec 24 16 10:17:31 am
Dec 24 16 09:58:08 pm
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
Dec 25 16 06:15:10 pm
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 26 16 04:28:51 pm
Dec 26 16 07:01:09 pm
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 27 16 08:11:33 pm
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 08:00:46 pm
Jan 01 17 10:43:11 pm
Jan 01 17 11:49:13 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15 am
Jan 03 17 05:38:54 pm
Jan 04 17 01:44:07 pm
Jan 04 17 04:19:58 pm
Jan 04 17 08:52:40 pm
Jan 04 17 11:40:31 pm
Jan 05 17 07:58:49 am
Jan 05 17 08:03:07 am
Jan 05 17 11:41:31 am
Jan 08 17 01:02:53 pm
Jan 08 17 02:41:07 pm
Jan 08 17 10:13:18 pm
Jan 09 17 01:40:52 pm
Jan 09 17 01:51:18 pm
Jan 11 17 03:11:49 pm
Jan 11 17 04:45:00 pm
Jan 12 17 06:39:14 pm
Jan 13 17 12:06:37 pm
Jan 14 17 05:47:35 pm
Jan 14 17 06:04:44 pm
Jan 14 17 08:31:43 pm
Jan 16 17 01:33:04 am
Walk
Walk, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk, Ride
Walk
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk, Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive, Catch public transport
Drive
Walk, Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk
20
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 19 17 04:19:18 pm
Jan 19 17 11:23:52 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
Jan 21 17 06:35:30 am
Jan 24 17 01:56:15 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 25 17 09:10:02 am
Jan 26 17 12:17:14 am
Jan 26 17 12:02:14 pm
Jan 26 17 02:41:34 pm
Jan 27 17 03:28:37 pm
Jan 28 17 09:10:58 am
Jan 28 17 11:13:55 am
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 12:52:06 pm
Feb 01 17 01:36:19 pm
Feb 01 17 08:58:54 pm
Feb 01 17 09:51:04 pm
Feb 01 17 10:59:14 pm
Feb 03 17 01:54:17 pm
Feb 03 17 10:13:18 pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 12:07:39 am
Feb 05 17 09:04:43 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:06:15 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:28:50 pm
Feb 06 17 06:41:44 pm
Feb 06 17 06:57:40 pm
Feb 06 17 06:59:40 pm
Walk, Ride, Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk
Ride
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk
Walk
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Ride, Drive, Catch public transport
Drive
Ride, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk
21
Feb 06 17 07:05:16 pm
Feb 06 17 07:20:51 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:46:31 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35 pm
Feb 07 17 12:02:21 am
Feb 07 17 03:43:47 am
Feb 07 17 07:37:46 am
Feb 07 17 08:53:34 am
Feb 07 17 09:22:32 am
Feb 07 17 09:32:02 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:31 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:34 am
Feb 07 17 11:37:55 am
Feb 07 17 12:54:13 pm
Feb 07 17 12:55:13 pm
Feb 07 17 01:20:27 pm
Feb 07 17 01:29:06 pm
Feb 07 17 02:22:12 pm
Feb 07 17 02:48:16 pm
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 08:42:27 pm
Feb 07 17 09:00:05 pm
Feb 07 17 09:25:41 pm
Feb 07 17 10:35:41 pm
Feb 07 17 11:19:05 pm
Feb 08 17 01:26:30 pm
Feb 08 17 02:03:01 pm
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 08 17 05:03:53 pm
Feb 08 17 05:49:41 pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08 pm
Feb 08 17 10:49:39 pm
Feb 09 17 12:04:18 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
Feb 10 17 10:34:06 am
Feb 10 17 11:01:20 am
Feb 10 17 01:36:52 pm
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk
Walk
Drive
Walk
Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive, Catch public transport
Walk
Walk
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Catch public transport
Drive
Drive
Drive
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk
Walk, Drive
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
22
Feb 10 17 02:38:19 pm
Feb 10 17 04:09:57 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
Feb 10 17 10:53:48 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Feb 11 17 06:53:53 pm
Feb 11 17 06:54:18 pm
Feb 11 17 07:58:24 pm
Feb 12 17 11:17:14 am
Feb 12 17 02:01:05 pm
Feb 12 17 05:59:20 pm
Feb 12 17 06:23:07 pm
Feb 12 17 07:02:25 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 12:46:35 pm
Feb 13 17 05:14:39 pm
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 12:50:53 pm
Feb 14 17 01:56:09 pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09 pm
Feb 15 17 12:08:50 am
Feb 15 17 10:19:11 am
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
Feb 16 17 03:39:55 pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:21:55 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 17 17 12:21:13 pm
Feb 18 17 01:52:15 am
Feb 18 17 08:13:09 am
Feb 18 17 11:51:03 am
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 08:36:02 am
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
Drive
Walk
Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive, Catch public transport
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride
Walk, Ride, Drive
Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Ride
Walk, Drive
Walk, Ride, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk, Drive
Walk
Walk
Drive
Walk
Walk
Walk
Date
What do you call Carnegie shopping strip?
Nov 28 16 06:02:24 pm
Nov 29 16 06:29:16 am
Koornang rd
Carnegie shops or Koornang rd
23
Nov 29 16 09:48:36 am
Nov 29 16 02:02:14 pm
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Nov 29 16 06:57:25
Nov 29 16 11:06:31
Nov 30 16 05:37:26
Nov 30 16 08:09:13
Nov 30 16 09:25:28
Nov 30 16 01:37:26
Nov 30 16 02:43:46
pm
pm
am
am
am
pm
pm
Nov 30 16 04:37:55 pm
Nov 30 16 10:49:43 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 12:51:45 pm
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 06:16:34 pm
Dec 01 16 07:43:36 pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46 pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18
Dec 02 16 12:12:05
Dec 02 16 02:55:35
Dec 02 16 07:44:25
Dec 02 16 09:09:01
Dec 02 16 09:10:50
Dec 02 16 09:21:33
Dec 02 16 10:02:16
Dec 02 16 12:10:10
Dec 02 16 12:38:18
Dec 02 16 01:05:49
Dec 02 16 02:23:16
Dec 02 16 03:25:11
Dec 02 16 05:06:34
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Koornang Rd shops
Koornang rd
Koornang road
The shops
Koo-nang
Koornang Road shops
My local shops
Koornang
Koornang road
The Neeg
Koornang Road
The Negs
Carnegiwa
Carneggles
Carnegie (pronounced Car-Ne-Zsay)
Carnegistan
North or South Koregie (depending on the side of the tracks)
Downtown Rosstown
Big Trouble in Little Asia
Dumpling Central
Exportonia
The Neg or Koornang rd
Koornang road shops
local shopping
Koornang rd shops
Koornang Rd
A little bit dirty, needs a refresh and update.
It has what a family needs.
The Street
Koornang Road or Koornang Road shops
Koornang Road
Koornang Rd
The shops
I don't refer to the street - I go to work or to the shops or to the restaurant or
to the pub or the library or the dutchie
Carnegie shops
Crowded
Koornang Rd shops
Koornang Road
Koornang Road Shops
The Shops
Carnegie shops
the nang or the shops
Koornang Strip
carnegie shops
Koornang rd shops
Koornang road
Car-ne-jay
Carnegie Shops
24
Dec 02 16 07:20:13 pm
Dec 02 16 07:23:41 pm
Dec 02 16 08:10:48 pm
Dec 02 16 09:39:36 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
Dec 03 16 12:07:43 pm
Dec 03 16 01:07:24 pm
Dec 03 16 01:11:04 pm
Dec 03 16 01:39:39 pm
Dec 03 16 01:48:27 pm
Dec 03 16 02:34:16 pm
Dec 03 16 04:42:15 pm
Dec 03 16 04:58:50 pm
Dec 03 16 05:25:18 pm
Dec 03 16 06:02:26 pm
Dec 03 16 06:31:54 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:38 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08
Dec 04 16 03:50:48
Dec 04 16 04:41:54
Dec 04 16 05:19:29
Dec 04 16 07:17:49
Dec 05 16 11:47:03
Dec 05 16 05:44:03
Dec 05 16 06:44:44
Dec 06 16 12:05:57
Dec 06 16 02:13:56
Dec 06 16 07:53:47
Dec 06 16 08:40:08
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
pm
pm
am
am
am
am
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
Dec 06 16 01:44:42 pm
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 04:20:37 pm
Dec 06 16 07:21:30 pm
Dec 06 16 07:36:32 pm
Dec 06 16 08:01:02 pm
Dec 07 16 08:38:49 am
Dec 07 16 01:30:53 pm
Koornang rd
Koornang Rd
Carnegie shops
Carnegie shops
down Koornang Road
Koornang shops
Carnegie shops
Koornang rd
Koornang Road
Carnegie shops
Carnegie
i dont know
Koornang Rd
Koornang Road Shopping Strip
Koornang rd
Koornang Rd
Koornang Rd
Carnegie Village
Koornang Rd
Bedlam! Busier and busier with little parking, loss of diversity in shops in
recent years, more restaurants
Koornang Rd
my local shopping strip
Carnegie shops
Carnegie Shops
Koornang Road
Carnegie shops - it's not fancy but it cannot be misunderstood eh!
Koornang Rd Shops
Koornang Road Shopping Centre
Koornang road
Koornang Rd
The shops
Not very attractive quite dirty pavements a lack of green planting.
Many shops looks the same with similar food.
Just one straight line of shops with not much variety and very little interest.
Homeless sleeping outside of the chemist shop all day on the pavement.
I am a local resident and try to avoid shopping here for all of the above.
Terrible parking too.
The shops
koornang rd shops
Carnegie
Koornang Road / the shops / et al.
koornang road
Carnegie shops
Carnegie shops
Carnegie or Koornang Rd
The shops up the road
Koornang road shops
25
Dec 07 16 03:46:25
Dec 07 16 03:46:55
Dec 07 16 08:44:26
Dec 07 16 09:56:41
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46
Dec 08 16 11:25:22
Dec 08 16 08:01:30
Dec 08 16 11:58:15
Dec 09 16 03:15:33
Dec 09 16 03:31:00
Dec 09 16 04:02:32
Dec 09 16 04:02:34
Dec 09 16 04:48:02
Dec 09 16 04:55:51
Dec 09 16 04:57:31
Dec 09 16 10:07:30
Dec 10 16 12:10:10
am
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Koonang Road shopping strip
Carnegie
my local shops
A shambles at times, lacking parking from over development, bad planning
and short sightedness from Glen Eira council.
Surely our taxpayers money can do better than this.
And to add more insult to the local Carnegie residencs, the council sends
out ridiculous letters asking our opinion about the area after the council has
already made their decisions!!?.
If you are not going to listen to the local residents, or at least meet with the
ones that are directly affected, please do not waste our time and the paper
with such rubbish offers.
Or employ people who can actually get the job done and not just loaf along
in the government system
I live with my wife, two streets over. So we are close.
Carnegie
Koornang Road
Carnegie Village / Koornang Road Shops
Koornang Rd shops
Koornang Rd
Carnegie
carnegie
Carnegie Shopping Strip
The Main st
The carnegie shops/koornang road
Koornang
Koornang Road
The shops
Dec 10 16 01:15:25 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 09:29:29 am
Dec 11 16 01:55:48 pm
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
Dec 11 16 06:14:48 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 12 16 04:28:28 pm
Dec 14 16 09:37:51 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
Dec 15 16 08:59:06 pm
Dec 16 16 12:06:19 pm
Dec 16 16 02:04:25 pm
Dec 16 16 02:07:53 pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Main Street
Carnegie High Street
Our local village
Koornang Road
Downtown Carnegie
Cafe Strip
Home Office (work from local cafes with wifi)
Koornang Rd
Carnegie Shops
Koornang road
Carnegie shops.. or... Koornang rd
Koornang rd
NEGS
Koornang Road
Koornang Rd
Koornang
Koornang Rd
the local shops
Koornang
Shops
26
Dec 17 16 09:00:42
Dec 17 16 09:36:01
Dec 17 16 10:26:51
Dec 17 16 02:40:19
am
am
am
pm
Dec 17 16 06:10:26
Dec 18 16 01:09:39
Dec 18 16 10:23:31
Dec 19 16 09:03:13
Dec 19 16 11:10:21
Dec 19 16 11:19:45
Dec 19 16 11:27:41
Dec 19 16 11:34:44
Dec 19 16 11:36:23
Dec 19 16 11:41:09
Dec 19 16 11:44:32
Dec 19 16 11:46:20
Dec 19 16 11:48:39
Dec 19 16 11:54:38
Dec 19 16 11:59:23
Dec 19 16 12:04:25
Dec 19 16 12:07:06
Dec 19 16 12:12:19
Dec 19 16 12:22:42
Dec 19 16 12:24:03
Dec 19 16 12:26:59
Dec 19 16 12:37:53
Dec 19 16 12:47:03
Dec 19 16 12:51:57
Dec 19 16 12:53:50
Dec 19 16 12:59:44
Dec 19 16 01:02:27
Dec 19 16 01:05:53
Dec 19 16 01:09:43
Dec 19 16 01:12:58
Dec 19 16 01:15:09
Dec 19 16 01:16:30
Dec 19 16 01:19:29
Dec 19 16 01:21:26
Dec 19 16 01:24:13
Dec 19 16 01:34:02
Dec 19 16 01:35:37
Dec 19 16 01:36:53
Dec 19 16 01:40:30
Dec 19 16 01:43:34
Dec 19 16 01:47:03
Dec 19 16 01:49:12
pm
pm
pm
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Carnegie
Koonang Road shops or Carnegie shops
Koornang road shops, local shops, koornang road, Carnegie main street.
Up the street
The shops
Carnegie
Up the street
Koornang Rd
The street
Koornang
Koornang Road Shops
the shops
Koornang shops
Carnegie
carnegie
Koornang Road
Carnegie
shops
carnegie
Morton Ave
Koornang shops
Koornang
koornang
Koornang strip
Koornang Road
carnegie
Koornang shops
Koornang shops
Koornang road
Koornang road
Carnegie or Koornang Road
Koornang road
carnegie
just going shopping on the streets
Carnegie mall
koornang
dumpling buffet
carnegie
carnegie
carnegie
carnegie
carnegie
carnegie
carnegie
carnegie
carnegie
Carnegie shopping strip
carnegie
27
Dec 20 16 03:50:39 pm
Dec 20 16 08:58:27 pm
Dec 21 16 07:38:15 pm
Dec 21 16 11:20:20 pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44 am
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
Dec 22 16 08:48:44 pm
Dec 23 16 01:21:05 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 23 16 08:02:16 pm
Dec 23 16 10:35:02 pm
Dec 24 16 06:19:24 am
Dec 24 16 10:17:31 am
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
Dec 25 16 06:15:10 pm
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 26 16 07:01:09 pm
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 27 16 08:11:33 pm
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 11:49:13 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15 am
Jan 03 17 05:38:54 pm
Jan 04 17 01:44:07
Jan 04 17 04:19:58
Jan 04 17 08:52:40
Jan 04 17 11:40:31
Jan 05 17 07:58:49
Jan 05 17 08:03:07
Jan 05 17 11:41:31
Jan 08 17 01:02:53
Jan 08 17 02:41:07
Jan 08 17 10:13:18
Jan 09 17 01:40:52
Jan 09 17 01:51:18
Jan 11 17 03:11:49
Jan 12 17 06:39:14
Jan 14 17 05:47:35
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
am
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Koornang Shops
Main Street
Koornang road
Koornang road
Koornang Rd
Kunang Road
Koornang Rd
Down the street
Koornang Rd
koornang road
Koornang
Down the street
" Car neige"
Koornang Road shops / Koornang Road
Koornsng Rd Shops
The amazing place for food n coffee.
Koornang rd shops or carnegie shops
Carnegie shops
Carnegie shops
Koornang Road
Koornang road
Dandenong Rd down to just past Néerim Rd and businesses adjacent.
Koornang Rd shops
The shops
Carnegie shops/ koornang road shops
Carnegie
Koornang Rd
My local strip or Carnegie strip
Koornang Rd
The section of Koornang Rd from Neerim Rd to the railway line.
koornang rd (dandenong rd - physio/lizzy's) and 1 block deep on either side
(kokaribb/shepparson)
Koornang Rd shops
Carnegie Shops
Carnegie
The strip
The street
Carnegie
Koornang Rd?
Koornang Road.
koornang road
Koonang Road
Koornang Rd
Koornang rd
Koornang Road SC
Food street
Koornang Road
28
Jan 14 17 06:04:44 pm
Jan 14 17 08:31:43 pm
Jan 16 17 01:33:04 am
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 19 17 04:19:18 pm
Jan 19 17 11:23:52 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
Jan 21 17 06:35:30 am
Jan 24 17 01:56:15 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 25 17 09:10:02 am
Jan 26 17 12:17:14 am
Jan 26 17 12:02:14 pm
Jan 27 17 03:28:37 pm
Jan 28 17 09:10:58 am
Jan 28 17 11:13:55 am
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 12:52:06 pm
Feb 01 17 01:36:19 pm
Feb 01 17 08:58:54 pm
Feb 01 17 09:51:04 pm
Feb 01 17 10:59:14 pm
Feb 03 17 01:54:17 pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 12:07:39 am
Feb 05 17 09:04:43 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:06:15 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:28:50 pm
Feb 06 17 06:57:40 pm
Koornang Road shopping centre
Carnegie
Koornang Rd
Carnegie Main Street/Koornang Road
No particular name... just carnegie shops
Koornang Rd shopping
Carnegie
Carnegie Shops
the shops!
Carnegie shops
Koornang Road
Koornang road
Carnegie
My local Village.
Koornang Road
dand rd, shepparson, kokaribb, lizzy's chocs area
Carnegie shops or Koornang Rd shops
Koornang Road
Koornang Rd
The negz
Carnegie shops
Koornang Rd
Koornang Rd carnegie
the shops
Koornang road
Carnegie Shopping Strip
Carnegie
Koornang Rs
Koornang Rd
Down the street
The Carnegie shops
Used to be full of great cafes and resturants. Now it is full of international
pick and pack chemist.
Carnegie shops.
Koornang rd
Carnegie shops
Koornang Rd
either "Carnegie" or "Koornang Rd"
Koornang Road
Carnegie shops
Koornang Rd
The Neg
Down the road or Koornang Rd
Koornang Rd or Down the road
Smelly
Carnegie shops
Koornang Rd section between Princess Hwy and Neerim Rd
29
Feb 06 17 06:59:40 pm
Feb 06 17 07:05:16 pm
Feb 06 17 07:20:51 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:46:31 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35 pm
Feb 07 17 12:02:21 am
Feb 07 17 03:43:47 am
Feb 07 17 07:37:46 am
Feb 07 17 08:53:34 am
Feb 07 17 09:22:32 am
Feb 07 17 09:32:02 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:31 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:34 am
Feb 07 17 11:37:55 am
Feb 07 17 12:54:13 pm
Feb 07 17 12:55:13 pm
Feb 07 17 01:20:27
Feb 07 17 01:29:06
Feb 07 17 02:22:12
Feb 07 17 02:48:16
Feb 07 17 03:21:51
Feb 07 17 03:53:36
Feb 07 17 04:03:58
Feb 07 17 04:13:51
Feb 07 17 04:57:23
Feb 07 17 05:08:22
Feb 07 17 08:42:27
Feb 07 17 09:00:05
Feb 07 17 09:25:41
Feb 07 17 10:35:41
Feb 07 17 11:19:05
Feb 08 17 01:26:30
Feb 08 17 02:03:01
Feb 08 17 04:05:54
Feb 08 17 05:03:53
Feb 08 17 05:49:41
Feb 08 17 10:41:08
Feb 08 17 10:49:39
Feb 09 17 12:04:18
Feb 10 17 09:31:59
Feb 10 17 10:34:06
Feb 10 17 11:01:20
Feb 10 17 01:36:52
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
am
am
pm
Carnegie Shopping Hub
Koornang Rd Shops
Koornang Rd
Koornang Road
'town'
Carnegie
Koornang Road
the shops
Carnegie
Koornang Rd OR North Carnegie
Koornang Rd
Koornang Rd shops
Koornang Road Shops
koornang road
Koornang
Grocery Shopping
Koornang Road
Koornang Road
Koornang Road!
However I find that this area is very "asian"
Carnegie
Carnegie or Koornang Rd
KOORNANG ROAD
Koornang
Cos its along the strip of Koornang Road
Koornang Road
The road section from Dandenong Rd to Neerim Rd.
The Neg
Koornang Road
Koornang rd
Koornang Rd
Busy convenient food street
carnegie
Koornang Rd shops
Carnegie
koornang road shops
CARNEGIE
My local village to purchase from. NOT an Asian food strip
Koornang Rd
Carnegie shops
up the street
Koornang Road
Mainly café and chinese restaurant precinct now
Koonang Road shopping strip
shopping
the shops
koornang rd shops
30
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 10 17 02:38:19 pm
Feb 10 17 04:09:57 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
Feb 10 17 10:53:48 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Feb 11 17 06:53:53 pm
Feb 11 17 06:54:18
Feb 11 17 07:58:24
Feb 12 17 11:17:14
Feb 12 17 02:01:05
Feb 12 17 05:59:20
Feb 12 17 06:23:07
Feb 12 17 07:02:25
Feb 13 17 11:02:12
Feb 13 17 11:28:53
Feb 13 17 12:46:35
Feb 13 17 05:14:39
Feb 13 17 05:47:00
Feb 13 17 07:11:00
Feb 14 17 12:50:53
Feb 14 17 01:56:09
pm
pm
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09 pm
Feb 15 17 12:08:50 am
Feb 15 17 10:19:11 am
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
Feb 16 17 03:39:55 pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:21:55 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 17 17 12:21:13 pm
Feb 18 17 01:52:15 am
Feb 18 17 08:13:09 am
Feb 18 17 11:51:03 am
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 08:36:02 am
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
Feb 20 17 07:22:19 pm
Koornang Rd
main st
Carnegie shops
Negs
Koornang road
My local shops
The Koornang Street area
I tend to call it Koornang Rd, or I'm going up the street or shops
Koornang Rd
Carnegie High Street
Carnegie
The shops or Koornang Rd
Carnegie shopping area
Local shops, the high street, up the street,
I don't like any of it
Koornang road shops
Koornang Road.
we just call it Carnegie
"the shops"
Koornang Rd Shops
Carnegie
Variety of shops for essentials. Would like more bar style venues.
I call it "Koornang road" or "down the street"
I just refer to it as Koornang Road
Just Carnegie. Everyone we know understands what we mean when we
say to meet at Carnegie.
Koornang Road
Carnegie
Carnegie strip
Carnegie shops
Carnegie shops
Koornung Road shopping strip.
Little Asia town
The shops
Koornang Road Shops
Koornang Rd
Koornang road shops
Length of Kornang Rd
Koornang Road from Dandenong road until the block after Neerim Road
and the surrounding streets
Shopping strip
I just say that I am going "into Carnegie"
Carnegie
The shops.
Carnegie Shopping strip is known amoung residents who have been here
10+ years as - "The Asian Invasion strip"
Koornang Rd
31
Feb 20 17 07:35:25 pm
Koornang Rd
Date
What do you love about Carnegie shopping strip
Nov 28 16 06:02:24 pm
Nov 29 16 06:29:16 am
Close to home, range of shops, see local people from community
The community, shop owners knowing your name and order.Bumping into
friends in the street
Cheap restaurants. Great library for kids.
Restaurants
Asian supermarkets
Supermarkets
Lively
Variety of places to eat dinner
Hope lively it is now, lots more people
Later opening hours, restaurants
It's handy because I live so close. It's got a lot of shops that offer most of
our needs
It feels like my community
Variety in food
Low rise, diverse mix of restaurants, shops and small market stores
Food, Coffee,
Having a library as part of the shopping strip
I love how Glen Eira has responded to the shortage of car parking by
sending more parking inspectors to the area and clamping down on the
timed parking. I mean, loosening the restrictions in some areas so workers
have somewhere to park would have also made sense, but then, where's
the revenue in that? Great job guys. Keep it up!
It is a great community and lots of young families during the day. Then at
night it is a completely different feel.
Shopping locally rather than at Chadstone; diversity of restaurants & shops
Love that everything is in close proximity. Calm get the day to day things
done as well as the weekly supermarket shopping
Variety of food and cafes
with influx of students there is a great range of inexpensive eateries
Lots of food options and great hang out place to meet up with friends
restaurant variety (although too many Korean places currently) and mix of
shops
I live very close and it has some very good cafes and restaurants.
It is convenient to do shopping locally.
Independent stores
The variety
Great Food (restaurants that are not chains)
Everything I need (fruit and veg, deli, butcher, poultry, pharmacy, post
office) in one place
Clean and friendly and unique
Nov 29 16 09:48:36 am
Nov 29 16 02:02:14 pm
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Nov 29 16 06:57:25 pm
Nov 29 16 11:06:31
Nov 30 16 05:37:26
Nov 30 16 08:09:13
Nov 30 16 09:25:28
Nov 30 16 01:37:26
Nov 30 16 02:43:46
pm
am
am
am
pm
pm
Nov 30 16 04:37:55 pm
Nov 30 16 10:32:17 pm
Nov 30 16 10:49:43 pm
Nov 30 16 11:43:52 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 12:51:45 pm
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 06:16:34 pm
Dec 01 16 06:39:40
Dec 01 16 07:43:36
Dec 01 16 09:00:46
Dec 01 16 09:01:07
pm
pm
pm
pm
Proximity
It is close by, easy to find parking and friendly service.
Cafes, Sunny's fruit shop, Baker's Delight, Siam 1
32
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 12:12:05 am
Dec 02 16 02:55:35 am
Dec 02 16 07:44:25 am
Dec 02 16 09:09:01 am
Dec 02 16 09:10:50 am
Dec 02 16 09:21:33 am
Dec 02 16 10:02:16 am
Dec 02 16 10:40:50 am
Dec 02 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 02 16 12:26:26 pm
Dec 02 16 12:38:18 pm
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 02:23:16 pm
Dec 02 16 03:25:11 pm
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
Dec 02 16 07:20:13 pm
Dec 02 16 07:23:41 pm
Dec 02 16 08:10:48 pm
Dec 02 16 09:39:36
Dec 03 16 11:28:22
Dec 03 16 12:07:43
Dec 03 16 01:07:24
Dec 03 16 01:11:04
pm
am
pm
pm
pm
Dec 03 16 01:39:39 pm
Dec 03 16 01:48:27
Dec 03 16 02:34:16
Dec 03 16 04:42:15
Dec 03 16 04:58:50
Dec 03 16 05:25:18
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 03 16 06:02:26 pm
Dec 03 16 06:31:54 pm
easy access to supermarkets, butcher, chemist, some cute shops,
restaurants.
It's very convenient for a mum with kids at Carnegie PS.
The people in general are caring intelligent friendly and community minded.
In general the shopkeepers are friendly & helpful
The French Creperie
The deli
Space
Good restaurants, library and many supermarket options
The restaurants are good
The variety of Restaurants and Coffee Shops the Library
All the cafes
Lots of good restaurants, the library is wonderful, and Aldi
The variety of shops, restaurants and cafes and the friendly vibe.
Convenience and the variety of shops / businesses
Proximity, Convenience, Range of shopping options
lots of good laces to eat, close to home and public transport
Its close to home, see local people there & retailers get to know you
Everything except chinese courier shops and traffic.
That all practical shops are there but that there is also nice cafes. Great
with kids to be able to do shopping and let them have a play outside library
all in one outing.
I used to love the variety of eateries - whilst I LOVE Asian food we need
some more variety. I love there is still a butcher and fruit and veggie shop
and chicken shop and great bakery in Bakers Delight and that you can do
your weekly shop at Woolies without going over the railway line!
The local feel and choice
Restaurants
Close to home.
Variety of cafes
The range of shops and eating places
all the restaurants & the supermarkets at Carnegie Central
You can get most things there, feel like im supporting local
Variety of restaurants and presence of banks and post office
convenience, range of restaurants, Woolworths, Aldi, greengrocers, the
atmosphere, library
Cafes
Restaurants
Seeing other people we know in the community
Having all the convenience shopping we need
Cafes and restaurants
It is walking distance from my home
friendly people
Close to home, supermarket, library, cafes
It's close, it has fruit and veg grocers. It has bakeries. It has butchers. it has
banks, post office, chemists, $2 shops, hair dressers, lots of resturants and
pizza. Also it has Winedown.- great selection of wine and beer from
Australia and around the world.
Restaurants, library, fresh fruit markets
Cheap Asian eats
33
Dec 03 16 08:24:38 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08 pm
Dec 04 16 03:50:48
Dec 04 16 04:41:54
Dec 04 16 05:19:29
Dec 04 16 07:17:49
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 05 16 11:47:03 am
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 05 16 06:44:44 pm
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 02:13:56 am
Dec 06 16 07:53:47 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 12:14:30 pm
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
Dec 06 16 01:44:42 pm
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 04:20:37
Dec 06 16 05:13:56
Dec 06 16 07:21:30
Dec 06 16 07:36:32
Dec 06 16 08:01:02
Dec 07 16 08:38:49
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
Dec 07 16 01:30:53 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:25 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:55 pm
Easy to get to, not too busy, great library,
Fresh fruit and veg
1) The traditional butchers, grocers, bakeries and delis. Although we do
have the supermarket options for after hours, it's these local shops that give
Carnegie a real local, village feel. This is important for our community.
2) The multiculturalism and it's obvious influence on our food outlets and
diversity of backgrounds, people and languages you experience walking
down the street. This is at the heart of what makes out village unique and
special.
Local traditional retailers - butcher, small retailers, fruit&veg, library and
small cafes. Also love all major banks are available, Spotlight and Aldi
further up past the crossing and the general community feel - it's
multicultural and diverse age ranges too. Great having kinder and primary
schools close by too.
Local and convenient- not Chadstone!
The variety of restaurants and cafes, being able to buy fresh fruit and veg
and groceries from independent grocers.
usually can get all i want from rhere
Always bump into someone I know
Variety of shops
Community feel, meeting neighbours, good choice, it is so close to my
house, walking the dog.
Generally speaking it can support most life needs with easy access on foot.
Open, level space. Friendly. Nice shops.
nice atmosphere, varitey of coffee shops and resturants
Some decent food places
Great range of everything
Parking is easy, close to home, a variety of small shops near Woolworths
I think it looks tired and need of new paving and an uplift.
The wide variety of restaurants and the community atmosphere.
It has all our daily shopping needs in one area - easy to walk up and down.
Also the range of cuisines and great cafes
low key friendly
Variety, quality, choice
I like having a range of cafes and restaurants, access to banks, retail and
other services, I like the "anchors" of the library, hotel and Carnegie Central,
I like that it is pedestrian-friendly and inviting.
it's close to where I live
Wide variety of cafes and restaurants
Variety of cafes and traders
Good value for money and close to home
Lots of shops and people. Also the Asian flavour.
Almost everything I need for my regular shopping is close by in the one
shopping strip - supermarket, fruit & veggie shops, bank, post office,
newsagent etc.
It's got everything covered from banks to bakery to library to cafes to fresh
fruit/veges, restaurants and supermarkets. You name it and you'll most
likely find it here! It's easily accessible for anyone driving or walking. It's
spread out nicely.
The great range of food shops and restaurants
It seems safe, I like the cafes and some restaurants. The library is very
34
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 07 16 09:56:41 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46
Dec 08 16 11:25:22
Dec 08 16 08:01:30
Dec 08 16 11:58:15
am
am
pm
pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:34 pm
Dec 09 16 04:48:02 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 04:57:31 pm
Dec 09 16 10:07:30 pm
Dec 10 16 12:10:10 pm
good but I think the hours could be earlier on weekends.
proximity to home, mix of shops, friendliness
Library
This is a great addition to Carnegie.
Well done to Glen Eira for seeing this through
Well designed, well serviced and has public transport to any where.
Diversity of food outlets
The variety of good shops
It is a great shopping strip and it is in my neighbourhood - it is one of the
reasons I bought my apartment in this area. It is known for the great variety
of restaurants and cafes, which I have been enjoying exploring over the last
couple of months since I moved.
I don't it is second rate. Much prefer to go to Glenhuntly shops or Bay
street Brighton
All grocery needs are met and there are some great places to eat (brunch
and dinner)
The library is great and there are many lovely cafes and enough
hairdressing salons.
It is close to home
Community feel
Always see people you know
A pretty good and wide range of items/services/goods available
There is just about everything I could possibly need and a huge variety of
eateries
Amazing restaurants/Asian cuisine and cafes. We are spoilt for choice with
the amount of options for day and night activities.
Restaurants!!!
Wine down for the local service
Dec 10 16 01:15:25 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 09:29:29 am
Dec 11 16 01:55:48 pm
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
Dec 11 16 06:14:48 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 12 16 04:28:28 pm
Dec 14 16 03:36:48 pm
Dec 14 16 09:37:51 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
Post office
Love that it has most things you need; chemist, supermarket, bank, bakery
green grocery etc.
Cafe's great coffee and food
Great selection of eateries (Asian delights)
Great gift shops
Broad cross-section of shops for local needs (from Hardware to Post Office,
Banks, etc)
Places to eat and have coffee. Good banking facilities. Fresh fruit and veg.
shops.
Diverse
Almost everything available from pantry to services
I like the cafes and the library area and forecourt. I like the restaurants. I
like that it is sometimes alive in the evening with the restaurants...
Proximity to cafes, supermarket, chemist, all the essentials..
Large choice of resteraunts, Greengrccers & Butchers
The variety and diversity of cafes, restaurants and small retail outlets.
The convenience of nearby parking lots and street parking to reach all the
shops.
The food! I mostly come to the area to either do a grocery shop or eat out
for dinner.
The village feel and bumping into community freinds
35
Dec 15 16 08:59:06 pm
Dec 16 16 12:06:19 pm
Dec 16 16 02:04:25 pm
Dec 16 16 02:07:53
Dec 17 16 07:35:05
Dec 17 16 09:00:42
Dec 17 16 09:36:01
pm
am
am
am
Dec 17 16 10:26:51 am
Dec 17 16 02:40:19 pm
Dec 17 16 06:10:26 pm
Dec 18 16 01:09:39 pm
Dec 18 16 10:23:31 pm
Dec 19 16 09:03:13 am
Dec 19 16 11:10:21
Dec 19 16 11:19:45
Dec 19 16 11:27:41
Dec 19 16 11:36:23
Dec 19 16 11:41:09
Dec 19 16 11:44:32
Dec 19 16 11:46:20
Dec 19 16 11:48:39
Dec 19 16 11:54:38
Dec 19 16 11:59:23
Dec 19 16 12:04:25
Dec 19 16 12:07:06
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
pm
pm
The Multicultural food and people
lots of casual restaurants
mix of old style shops, diversity, local neighborhood flavour
I like the fresh food aspect- butcher, chicken shop, veggies etc with quirky
stores like 2 dollar shop, specialty cakes like Europa and then utilities like
banks and Post Office
Lots of shops and options for food
I feel safe there and not judged
Variety of shops and coffee shops
I love the selection of restaurants and shopping options in this compact
area. There is enormous variety of shops and parking options at the rear of
the shops or underground which enables me to be able to easily purchase
weekly shoping needs and load them into my vehicle. However, the library
area and open space is nice to walk through and feel a sense of
community. The whole area is now a concrete jungle, if the council could
undertake a lot more tree planting along Koonang Road, in the open space
area abutting the library and the surrounding streets this would make it
more appealing. Also support cycling and pedestrians with less car parking
on Koonang Road, more trees in these spaces and bike parking options. I
love the Mosics at Santucci cafe which are fun and makes the stripe more
vibrant so more community art would be great. Also some performance or
busking in the open space area. Or mini community local Australian/ Glen
Eira made markets
Range of restaurants and cafes, quality of stores, it has everything you
need there - doctors, dentist, post office, dry cleaner, gift shop, butcher,
bakery etc...
Underground parking at Carnegie Central - so great for all weather grocery
shopping w our baby
Great selection of take away
Laundromat
Library
Asian groceries
Location, all banks. Restaurant. Woolworths and Aldi pharmacy.
The awesome cafes
Local butchers, green grocers, restaurants, supermarkets, paharmacies,
library, kids play area.
Huff
Aldi
Trains for son
Library
everything there
everything there
variety of shops though still lacking
restaurants
people
all the shops
easy access
the look
easy access to the train, plenty of great restaurants, cafes and shops
community
food
food
36
Dec 19 16 12:12:19 pm
Dec 19 16 12:22:42 pm
Dec 19 16 12:24:03 pm
Dec 19 16 12:26:59 pm
Dec 19 16 12:37:53 pm
Dec 19 16 12:48:52 pm
Dec 19 16 12:51:57 pm
Dec 19 16 12:53:50 pm
Dec 19 16 12:59:44 pm
Dec 19 16 01:02:27 pm
Dec 19 16 01:05:53 pm
Dec 19 16 01:09:43 pm
Dec 19 16 01:12:58 pm
Dec 19 16 01:15:09 pm
Dec 19 16 01:16:30 pm
Dec 19 16 01:19:29 pm
Dec 19 16 01:21:26 pm
Dec 19 16 01:24:13 pm
Dec 19 16 01:34:02 pm
Dec 19 16 01:35:37 pm
Dec 19 16 01:36:53 pm
Dec 19 16 01:40:30 pm
Dec 19 16 01:43:34 pm
Dec 19 16 01:47:03 pm
Dec 19 16 01:49:12 pm
Dec 20 16 03:50:39 pm
Dec 20 16 08:58:27 pm
Dec 21 16 07:38:15 pm
Dec 21 16 11:20:20 pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44
Dec 22 16 02:22:40
Dec 22 16 08:48:44
Dec 23 16 01:21:05
Dec 23 16 01:44:26
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 23 16 08:02:16
Dec 23 16 10:35:02
Dec 24 16 06:19:24
Dec 24 16 10:17:31
pm
pm
am
am
Dec 24 16 09:58:08 pm
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
variety
everything
coffee shops and eating
walk and get everything (aldi, woollies and spotlight)
variety of shops
restaurants
vibrant
different types of shops but changing
all the eateries and good cake shop
prices, service and parking
I usually don't really buy clothes from here but they do have a variety of
clothes here.
good life style
the food the people the coffee
variety of cusines
coffee shops
everything
restaurants and coffee shops
everything
everything
variety
everything
parking good. lots of variety
warmth of community & tradies
accessibility
variety of shops
The restaurants, the wide footpaths, the hustle and bustle
Changing outlets, new trendy cafes.
All basic needs are provided for, butcher, pharmacy, bakery etc
Asian restaurants
Grill'd
I can do all my grocery shopping there, fruit, bakery, butcher, post office
and a few good gift shops. dinner is good as well
Its vibrantcy
Its proximity
Nothing anymore
Bakers Delight, Sunnys, Salvos, Red Cross
Variety of shops, open space, clean, good cafes, food options which deliver
near by
The variety. I can get everything I need.
Proximity, variety, locals
The restaurants.
It's walkable and has food from across the globe. Being able to see the sky
when standing on one side of the road and looking across the road to the
other side.
Convenient
I don't. I used to shop their and I went to the hairdress there for 30 years.
Now I come to Woolworths & spotlight on my way home from Chadstone.
Accessibility n great restaurant opening hours
37
Dec 25 16 06:15:10 pm
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 26 16 04:28:51 pm
Dec 26 16 07:01:09 pm
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 27 16 08:11:33 pm
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 08:00:46 pm
Jan 01 17 10:43:11 pm
Jan 01 17 11:49:13 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15 am
Jan 03 17 05:38:54 pm
I like that it has a good mix of food outlets. About 2-3 years ago it was
mostly asian restaurants, but now a few more western places have opened.
I think the asian restaurants are an important part of the area, but it is nice
to have a range of places to eat and drink, for breakfast, lunch and dinner.
Maybe even a small bar or two would be good for the area. I have certainly
eaten out at all times of the day since living in the area. However if im
looking for a place to get a coffee after 4pm or a drink anywhere else than
the Rosstown hotel, there are no options (unless going for a meal). So there
are still more opportunities. Maybe some weekend markets by the library
would be good.
Close to home.
Diversity & quality of food & cafe's
Community feel.
Bagels, Asian restaurants, supermarket are our regulars
It's close to home and coverd quite a few of our needs.
The food, the green grocer, the barber, post office and the supermarkets at
the back not taking centre stage. It is the perfect local.
Coffee shops
Library, best chocolate shop, great cheap restaurants, pub, Op shops,
cafes,
It has had a nice village feel but this is changing as smaller retailers like
butchers and newsagents get pushed out to make way for more asian
courier shops or restaurants
I love that I can walk to the shops and buy most of the things I need without
having to rely on a big supermarket chain. I love the cafes and the library. I
love the little play ground for the kids. I love the new crepe place. I love the
poultry shop and the butcher. I love the fruit shops.
Cafes, all you need in one strip, sense of community, I often meet
people/neighbours out shopping and stand and chat, cafes, multicultural
mix.
The Rosstown hotel, Siam 1 wine bar, and the few coffee shops. Far too
many dumpling places and vitamin wholesalers. No diversity whatsoever in
terms of personal shopping. Couldn't even buy a decent pair of socks or
stockings.
The cafes and restaurants. Supermarket, chemist and newsagency all
within easy access. Library too.
Got all door shopping needs, butcher, fruit and veg all within close proximity
to the supermarket
Walking distance to my house, plenty of variety, awesome library,
It is 5 minutes from where I live.
I loved the diversity of weekly shopping retailers (butchers, fruit and veg
shops, etc).
one stop shop after the cafe morning coffee. bakery, butcher, hairdresser,
deli, library, $2 shops, hardware, gifts, shoes, clothing, banks, post office
like the sitting areas and trees. open space.
mostly can find a park
interesting and vibrant, morning, noon and night
diversity in cafes and foods
can walk
38
Jan 04 17 01:44:07 pm
Jan 04 17 04:19:58 pm
Jan 04 17 08:52:40 pm
Jan 04 17 11:40:31 pm
Jan 05 17 07:58:49 am
Jan 05 17 08:03:07 am
Jan 05 17 11:41:31 am
Jan 08 17 01:02:53 pm
Jan 08 17 02:41:07 pm
Jan 09 17 01:40:52 pm
Jan 09 17 01:51:18 pm
Jan 11 17 03:11:49 pm
Jan 12 17 06:39:14 pm
Jan 14 17 05:47:35 pm
Jan 14 17 06:04:44 pm
Jan 14 17 08:31:43 pm
Jan 16 17 01:33:04 am
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
free parking
Food shops
Well, I used to love it, which is why I bought a house here. now it is very
different. I love the (now only) butchers shop, the green grocers shops, the
coffee places and the library, also the Op Shops. I also have my hair done
here. Now it is mainly Chinese restaurants and noisy young people and it
has lost the atmosphere I loved. The car parking is impossible.
The diversity of food, celebrates our Aussie culture so beautifully. Also the
library & the great events that get our on from time to time (eg Christmas
thing recently)
Cafes
The food
Restaurants and cafes
As well as grocery stores within walking distance
The diversity of cultures represented
Speciality food stores - green grocers, butchers, bakers; cafe life spilling
onto pavement; bustling and colourful; trees; library.
Food smells, activity everywhere
Mix of business
Bustling atmosphere
Good massage
Reasonably priced
Restaurants and cafes
One stop Shop
Close to home. Library in strip. Lots of shops.
Everything is in close walking distance.
lots of cafe and restaurant selections
Fresh food and deli, supermarkets, chemists, banks, cafes, restaurants,
library
There are a few good cafes, for example Huff, Figjam etc. unfortunately the
diversity of the shopping strip is dying, being taken over by horrendously
low-quality oriental cuisine shops.
Many things (i) easy proximity (walk) from home (ii) the library and
community services (iii) access to weekly food shopping outlets and local
doctor (GP) (iv) the cafes and the (slowly) increasing sophistication of the
food outlets (but also love the originals too).
I love that when we go there we always see someone we know or recognise
(in that you don't know someone but you are at the polite nod and smile
stage). Having been visiting and hanging out in the strip shops for the past
six years it has been nice getting to know people
We regularly use many retail/services outlets - optometry, clothing, salvos,
music school, doctors, pharmacies, butchers etc.
Jan 17 17 09:42:20
Jan 18 17 07:06:17
Jan 18 17 10:33:13
Jan 19 17 09:27:26
pm
am
pm
am
The "rock park" in front of the library continues to be a hit with my children 6
years on.
Great coffee shops and restaurants. Library.
Great food and decent prices close to home.
Within walking distance, and I can do my weekly shopping for fruit and veg'.
The range of products and services offered. I like that I can get anything I
may need from one of the shops there.
39
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 19 17 04:19:18 pm
Jan 19 17 11:23:52 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
Jan 21 17 06:35:30 am
Jan 24 17 01:56:15 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 25 17 09:10:02
Jan 26 17 12:17:14
Jan 27 17 03:28:37
Jan 28 17 09:10:58
Jan 28 17 11:13:55
Jan 28 17 04:02:36
am
am
pm
am
am
pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 12:52:06
Feb 01 17 01:36:19
Feb 01 17 08:58:54
Feb 01 17 09:51:04
Feb 01 17 10:59:14
Feb 03 17 01:54:17
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 03 17 10:13:18 pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 12:07:39 am
Feb 05 17 09:04:43 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Great variety of shops in a small area. Particularly for groceries and daily
needs. The library close to the shops is great. Very much a local community
hub including public transport.
vibrant atmosphere
Fruit & Vegie shops, cafes, banks, supermarket nearby, pharmacists, cheap
shops, hairdressers
That it has a reasonable range of businesses including banks, post office,
supermarket.. Business operators and staff are friendly and helpful. There
can be community stalls held there (unlike Chadstone) for kinders, schools.
It is convenient for me as I can walk there.
Local businesses. Convenient. Many different shops. Library.
I love the amount of restaurants on offer
walking space, diversity of shops, one stop, friendly, sit outside, open
spaces
it has most of the services including banks and post office, medical
services, a good variety of restaurants and cafes, food stores and a friendly
mix of residents and visitors.
convenience, cosmopolitan, superb library, thriving
the few non food stores left
The food
That it has everything I need all within 10 minutes walk from my home.
Close to home, friendly people, good food & coffee, great optometrists :)
I like it because it caters for everybody in the area. Compared to
Chadstone, it is safer to walk to it - This results in more independant kids,
elderly, and those who cannot afford a car using it. Also it is more
interesting as there are less regulations to make it boring like Chadstone.
The variety different industries present means I rarely go elsewhere.
Convenience, friendlness, livelyness, delicicious food that is affodable,
diversity, great haidresser
Variety
It's local, always busy which is a good sign that it is a great shopping centre.
The diversity of shops, the late night eating options plus meets daily needs
Local traders
The variety
I like the friendly feel of the shops south of the railway. I use the fruit and
vegetable shops, the small hardware shop, the cake shop/cafes. Also use
the supermarket. The section north of the railway is less pedestrian friendly
(particularly the corner of Arawatta St) and not my favourite. Carnegie
Central is not a good fit and has bought congestion to the area.
Not much at the moment. Having just moved to the area, there needs to be
a more eclectic mix of shops old and new.
Lots of variety of resturants and cafes.
1. finding a new ceramic mosaic from time to time on a wall somewherelove those (by Rita Santucci I think?)
2. quite good library
3. I love the times when the railway boomgates are down- the easiest and
safest way to cross Koornang road without being monstered by agressive
drivers.
restaurants, a couple of nice retail shops and cafes.
I know where what I need is
good personalised service from local shops
diversity of food shopping
sense of community
40
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:06:15 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41
Feb 06 17 06:28:50
Feb 06 17 06:41:44
Feb 06 17 06:57:40
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 06 17 06:59:40 pm
Feb 06 17 07:05:16 pm
Feb 06 17 07:20:51 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:46:31 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35 pm
Feb 07 17 12:02:21 am
Feb 07 17 03:43:47 am
Feb 07 17 07:37:46 am
Feb 07 17 08:53:34 am
Feb 07 17 09:22:32 am
Feb 07 17 09:32:02 am
That it is relatively close, walking distance
The diversity of shops
Sadly, Woolworths is the about the only thing I like about Koornang Rd
shops.
The Variety of shops that serve daily/weekly shopping needs.
Was disappointed to see the closure of a butcher, a delicatessan and the
newsagency in recent times as these are all part of the regular shopping
needs.
Cafes, particularly Huff Bagelry, also Bakers Delight, restaurants such as
Shyun.
Fresh fruit and veg shops and barry's butcher shop. The library, Shyun and
Aldi. Also the creperie
Fresh and cheap fruit and veg.
The library
The cafes
I try to avoid it at all times.
The variety of restaurants and eateries
All the great restaurants, fresh fruit shops, access to post office, chemist,
banks, etc.
Walking distance; wide variety of goods
It is near my house and has fruit, meat and supermarket all in close
proximity
Great restaurants, not overly crowded
The post office, the railway station, the shopping centre, the cafes, the fruit
and veg store, the hardware store, the library and community centre
the restaurants, Huff
Walking access, train, variety of stores and restaurants
Broad demographic of people- all ages, many ethnicities, many different
styles of people... so it has an accepting, easy going atmosphere. This also
brings a great range of different eateries from different nationalities,
excellent choice of ingredients for cooking and makes it feel very alive and
creative. I like the artistic elements of the mosaics and some of the shops. I
love the feel the shoppers and families bring- like you go to the shops to
socialise, slow down and feel happy- it is uplifting. I think a lot of people
walk to the shops rather than in many other shopping strips they drive and
are more in a hurry. In Koornang Rd you almost always see people
stopped and having conversations having bumped into each other- so often
this is older people setting this welcoming tone, so it is important this is
maintained and the area remains affordable for them. I love the range and
size of the street. Parking isn't too bad. The supermarket is also an asset
just behind. Competitive prices helps attract a good crowd and keeps you
happy to shop there.
everything, the atmosphere, it is more casual & welcoming compared to
many other areas. Everyone is laid back. There is a good mix of ethnic
backgrounds. There are no arseholes.
Atmosphere, range of quality cafes and restaurants.
Lots of people inc families with kids, lots of people walking their dogs.
The diversity of the shops
Dont really love it
The cafes, restaurants, multiculturalism and generally everything (apart
from the rubbish sometimes)
diversesity
41
Feb 07 17 10:31:31 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:34 am
Feb 07 17 11:37:55 am
Feb 07 17 12:54:13 pm
Feb 07 17 12:55:13 pm
Feb 07 17 01:20:27 pm
Feb 07 17 01:29:06 pm
Feb 07 17 02:22:12 pm
Feb 07 17 02:48:16 pm
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 08:42:27 pm
Feb 07 17 09:00:05 pm
Feb 07 17 09:25:41 pm
Feb 07 17 10:35:41 pm
Feb 07 17 11:19:05 pm
Feb 08 17 01:26:30 pm
Feb 08 17 02:03:01 pm
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 08 17 05:03:53 pm
Feb 08 17 05:49:41 pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08 pm
Feb 08 17 10:49:39 pm
Feb 09 17 12:04:18 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
Feb 10 17 10:34:06 am
Feb 10 17 11:01:20 am
Feb 10 17 01:36:52 pm
Diversity
Food
Close to where I live
Friendly and has all my weekly shopping needs
Compact and versatile
Nothing, I actually dislike it
Community, Bumping into friends, location.
Its close proximity and convenience
LIBRARY PROXIMITY
& WATER FOUNTAIN
SHE KNOWS & SERENDIPITY
FABULOUS NEW FRENCH CAFE
Good cafes, lots of amazing Asian food. Good vibes, friendly community
vibe.
Not a shopping Mall
Banks all in one area
Post Office
Cafes
Public transport
It's packed with cafes, restaurants and shops.
That everything isn't too spread out like other shopping strips. I also like
that the major banks are along the strip, as well as a Post Office, green
grocers and bakeries. And there's a great selection of restaurants to
choose from.
A good local shopping centre
Small businesses, amazing diverse food, diverse people, library, chemist,
shopping centre, playground, nearby parks, hairdressers.
Diversity of shops, community vibe, food and library
Convenient to go grocery shopping n nice food
the cafes restaurants and the whole feel about it. its busy..its vibrant..its
multicultural..
the restaurants,new french pancakes cafe, , Russian deli and Fruit shops
and Banks
Good mix of shops
variety of food & coffee/cafes, some places still offer reasonable prices, it is
unpretentious, the library & staff are great
COMPETITIVE FOOD SHOPPING AND THE LARGE RANGE OF EATING
ESTABLISHMENTS ALSO BANKS AND A/POST,
Chemist Bakery Butcher and supermarket. Don't let those go too.
Abundance of restaurants, it's got everything I need, easy to walk to
Family restaurants
one cafe, huff bagelry and Grill'd. the rest of the shops are rubbish
I enjoy the proximity and being able to get most of our needs
That the banks are still there
Can get daily tasks/shopping done and close to home
different restaurant
Variety of shops, cafes and restaurants. Great fruit and vegetable shops.
Proximity.
There are still lots of different shops. I can still do my weekly shopping
there. There are still green groceries, a bakery, chemists, wine outlet, a
hardware, butchers etc. Not too crowded with just cafes and restaurants.
The strip of shops is never too busy. I also like it that I can access the
42
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 10 17 02:38:19 pm
Feb 10 17 04:09:57
Feb 10 17 06:00:56
Feb 10 17 10:53:48
Feb 11 17 11:05:31
pm
pm
pm
am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24
Feb 11 17 06:53:53
Feb 11 17 06:54:18
Feb 11 17 07:58:24
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 12 17 11:17:14 am
Feb 12 17 02:01:05 pm
Feb 12 17 05:59:20 pm
Feb 12 17 06:23:07 pm
Feb 12 17 07:02:25 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 12:46:35 pm
Feb 13 17 05:14:39 pm
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 12:50:53 pm
Feb 14 17 01:56:09 pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09 pm
Feb 15 17 12:08:50 am
Feb 15 17 10:19:11 am
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
library easily.
It has local shops that I use - hairdresser, supermarkets, chemists, library,
fruit shops, ATMs. It's often bustling and lively.
resturants
Its variety in food has all major banks and a great placew to meet friends for
coffee.
I love the vast array of shops, health care and facilities.
variety of food outlets
People I know who own the shops
Proximity to my house. The cosmopolitan atmosphere. the variety of cafes.
Not only Asian but others such as Russian and French.
The restaurants, cafes and Convienience.
Close to home
It is full of life and activity and I love its many cafes/restaurants.
The sense of community that is mostly present amongst traders and
customers alike. The water refill station! The library.
Both supermarkets and markets close to each other, offer more choices to
shoppers
Proximity, take away dining options, huff bagelry, William Murray Tavern, a
good buzz.
Nothing
Great cafes, terrific library, handy range of shops, banks, post office etc
How everything I need , from groceries, cafes, dry cleaner and bank to post
office and hairdressers is there. All kinds of food from around the world too.
proximity
It is lively day and night with supermarkets/foodie shops open during the
day and many restaurants to choose from at night
Running into local people that I know
Things that we frequent such as Woolworths, the pharmacy and post office
are all in close vicinity to each other.
That locals are encouraged to shop there. Friendly staff at small shops.
I love that the shop keepers say hi and recognise locals when we walk into
a shop. I love the restaurants and the cafes that are just a couple of minutes
from my front door. I love the fresh fruit markets and the small businesses. I
love seeing the family run restaurants, and meeting the people who run
them. I love the William Murray! I love the library area, and the programs
they run and the resources they have to share. I love the op shops. I love
that I can just walk down there, get what I need and walk back home and
have run into my neighbours or my friends because everyone's doing the
same thing. I love that I can find a place to have a coffee, or a cake, or a
meal, or a drink. It's the best!
It's reasonably diverse. I love the Bagel Shop, the Japanese restaurant
Shyunn, and Gabrielles Pizza.
Convenience to our home; a wide enough selection of grocery outlets,
banks and a post office. Convenience to railway line and access into the
city for work.
The shops: vegetarian and fruits, butcher, supermarkets, Delicatessen
The cafe and restaurants
The postoffice
The banks
The real mix of retail outlets and the food
Cafes and restaurants. Good supermarkets. Proximity.
its got a relaxed community feel.
43
Feb 16 17 03:39:55 pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:21:55 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53
Feb 17 17 12:21:13
Feb 18 17 01:52:15
Feb 18 17 08:13:09
Feb 18 17 11:51:03
Feb 18 17 05:27:15
pm
pm
am
am
am
pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17
Feb 20 17 08:36:02
Feb 20 17 05:06:32
Feb 20 17 07:08:22
Feb 20 17 07:19:21
pm
am
pm
pm
pm
Feb 20 17 07:22:19 pm
Feb 20 17 07:29:49 pm
Feb 20 17 07:32:52 pm
Feb 20 17 07:35:25 pm
Feb 20 17 07:39:37 pm
Feb 20 17 07:43:00 pm
Convenience
The range of shops and the fact that most of my shopping needs are met in
this small area. I love the look of the strip with the old shop facades and
less high rise developments. The fact that you can just stroll along taking in
the atmosphere.
The proliferation of restaurants; the bustling feel of the precinct; the little bits
of art work dotted along the strip
Location to my house
It has a great mixture of eating out options.
Great restaurants and friendly feel
Has all you need re groceries. Friendly and clean.
Restaurants & super markets
small strip of shops each individualized with it's different character, the
chairs and relaxed atmosphere. The small cafes and retail shops and the
different variety of cuisines and small grocery shops (eg. Russian/ Asian
groceries)
Convenience from my home
I did love the diversity of the various shops but that has unfortunately
changed. I now only visit specific shops when I need to.
It has almost everything you need
everything about it I love. It's range of shops, it is safe and it's restaurants.
Nothing
Variety of shops, more density, supermarkets, train
Variety of shops
Very friendly
Variety of shops, cleaner
Variety of shops that are close to home
Diversity of shops and restaurants
Friendly shop keepers, nice people
Walkability, public transport accessibility, variety
Date
What don’t you like/do you want to see changed?
Nov 28 16 06:02:24 pm
More diverse restaurants - way over saturated with asian cuisine. Would be
fantastic to have middle eastern, modern Australian and italian dinner
restaurants. More major brand clothing retailers. More upmarket cafes ala
left field, mr brightside etc.
To many Asian stores . Too many restaurants ts that are all the same.
Stores with non English signs that are un inviting. There needs to be more
balance. Don't get me wrong I love the diversity of the Asian food choices
however there seems to bee many of the same and high turnover.
I think it's in desperate need of a pedestrian crossing near Nandos - people
are always crossing the road there anyway. Get rid of some tired looking
shops and add more cafes.
Not allowed to perform u-turn
Hard to park
More connected bike paths
More bike parking
Stop putting bike lanes alongside parked cars
Nov 29 16 06:29:16 am
Nov 29 16 09:48:36 am
Nov 29 16 02:02:14 pm
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
44
Nov 29 16 06:57:25 pm
Nov 29 16 11:06:31 pm
Nov 30 16 05:37:26 am
Nov 30 16 08:09:13 am
Nov 30 16 09:25:28 am
Nov 30 16 01:37:26 pm
Nov 30 16 02:43:46 pm
Nov 30 16 04:37:55 pm
Nov 30 16 10:32:17 pm
Nov 30 16 10:49:43 pm
Nov 30 16 11:43:52 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 12:51:45 pm
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 06:16:34 pm
More separated bike lanes
Close koornang road to cars regularly eg Saturdays this would Open the
road space to peds, cyclists and Street trading
I'd love to have more variety in the restaurants on offerGreek?
Spanish?
Parking can be difficult. Not enough variety of restaurants (too many
dumpling shops)
Lots of dodgy Asian stores. More modern cafes and please we need a great
florist in this area.
The large complex on the corner of Koornang and dandenong road is
embarassing. It's ugly - has no windows and is a complete eye sore
More sophisticated eating options, and a wine bar. Maybe tree line the
street to make it more visually appealing
Not enough variety of shops. A butcher is closing at Christmas time and
probably another Asian restaurant will open. Too many Asian restaurants,
need variety. Need a deli, seafood shop, more butchers for example. Need
more rubbish bins as they are always overflowing or otherwise emptied
more regularly. Footpaths need to be regularly cleaned as they have a dirty
look about them. Skyrail will be absolutely terrible for the shopping strip, it
should be UNDERGROUND. Vehicles should not do U-turns in Koornang
Road. Bring back the street festival when Koornang Road is closed to
vehicles.
I'd like to see less parking inspectors and more car parks.
Too many asian resurants and dumplings. More cafes and more parking.
A better playground at the library it is where all us mums meet for coffee
with the kids.
We love the Asian representation but want to retain the balance of cultural
mix. we have just lost the European deli & are losing Barry Gardner's
butchers at Xmas to be replaced by yet another Korean restaurant.
Shopkeepers report that high rents, pressure from supermarkets & keen
Asian businesses are changing the shape of Carnegie.
Please remove the fruit carts that are on the footpath outside the fruit shop
on the bakers delight side of Koornang road. This footpath is always busy
and people are practically falling over each other to get past the fruit shop.
Please look into this as it has been getting worse over the last year or so.
Too many of the same shops (dumplings even though I LOVE them) .
Missing a flower shop, book shop, deli, health food shop. Needs bigger
trees.
a paint job on the upper storeys on front of shops
It's hard to find a restaurant on the Carnegie shopping strip that is still open
at 9pm weekdays. I'd rather eat out locally after working late or sports
training but there is virtually impossible.
Trying to park at the Safeway (near Neerim Rd) to pick up groceries is
impossible after 6:30 - there needs to be some 30 min-1 hour car parking
spots as all the restaurant goers take the spots - I now go to Oakleigh
Centro if after 6:30 as it's easier to park.
Needs an update, more lighting, outside spaces, bars/cafes and less cheap
Asian shops/cafes/restaurants
There is lack of car park. Extremely busy shopping strip, even lack of
parking inside the shopping complex at the corner of Princes HWY.
Condition of road, lots of pot holes due to lack of maintenance, over
development, and removing the crossings.
Excessive amount of rubbish around the area where the shops are.
Duplicate stores (chemist warehouse)
45
Dec 01 16 06:39:40 pm
Dec 01 16 07:43:36 pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46 pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 12:12:05 am
Dec 02 16 02:55:35 am
Dec 02 16 07:44:25 am
Dec 02 16 09:09:01 am
Sad that the newsagent closed
Charity subscription hawkers. (Happy to donate, but they are intrusive)
So many Asian stores popping up that seem to be to ship herbal medicine
or baby formula overseas.. they look like mini warehouses.
although there is a bike lane and a 40km speed limit, cyclists persist in
riding on the footpath in the shopping centre and at speed, it is only a
matter of time before a toddler or old person is injured or killed. The council
needs to be pro-active in solving this danger by having a blitz by bylaw
officers. Current "no riding" signs are totally ineffective and should be
painted on the footpath which is where people look, not up in the air, as was
done years ago and also very effectively in Sydney Rd Coburg/Brunswick.
Too many cafes/restaurants particularly asian at expense of other cusines.
Lack of parking.
Overcrowded footpath with pedestrians, hordings, cafe seating
4 sets of traffic signals between dandenong and neerim roads
Carnegie central shopping centre has one car exit, potential death trap
Congestion caused by railway crossing.
No more dumplings! Plenty to choose from!
Too many restaurants of the same type , needs more diversity. No bars
other than the Rosstown, would be great to have a wine bar or a brewpub.
Too many outlets for shipping goods to China. No good deli anymore.
Basically a lack of planning for commercial spaces for a vibrant shopping
precinct. Too much space given to real estate agents. Too much residential
development happening nearby with not enough parking so that carparks
are always full and no new commercial space reserved in these new
developments for shops and restaurants. Carnegie is a great central
location for NE Glen Eira shopping and has advantages over both
Murrumbeena and Glen Huntly. I would like to see a diverse restaurant/bar
scene and some interesting shops. I would love to see a farmers/makers
market in the library precinct. If you make the Carnegie shops a destination
for locals, we will use it well.
I really dislike the "shops" that are really fronts for exporting Australian
goods to China. Koornang Rd will die as a shopping precinct if too many of
these "shops" -are allowed. They aren't of any value to the local shopper
and devalue the street as a whole in terms of making it an attractive
shopping destination
•The lack of restaurant cuisine variety: too much asian, not enough
european (greek, french, italian) or modern australian
•No style across the strip, no aesthetics: need serious streetscape
regulation!
•Red brick walls in the street are old fashion, need fresh design
•Many shops make the street look messy, some at both end of the strip
drag the entire style down: don't care about the shop front look and feel,
look like a ghetto area, items for sell are rubbish (mobile case/cover?
drugs?), or shops are empty ie. exporting/importing to china.
•Barister/solicitor Thomson & Thomson at corner neerim/koornang is
useless for the strip, council need to make the most of these great location
•Some asian shops on the strip and neerim road don't even bother signing
in English (how can this be allowed?)
Parking pointless. Too many Asian shipping co, that could be run from an
'industrial estate' rather than prime strip space
Some clothing and more upmarket home styling wares, a Coles instead of 2
x Woolworths, easy acces to shops for Mums with prams (no steps),
Proliferation of cheap shops, vitamin shops and multiple discount
pharmacies
Due to the growth of the area little consideration has been given for parking.
46
Dec 02 16 09:10:50 am
Dec 02 16 09:21:33 am
Dec 02 16 10:02:16
Dec 02 16 12:10:10
Dec 02 16 12:26:26
Dec 02 16 12:38:18
am
pm
pm
pm
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 02:23:16 pm
Dec 02 16 03:25:11 pm
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
Dec 02 16 07:20:13 pm
Dec 02 16 07:23:41 pm
Dec 02 16 08:10:48 pm
Dec 02 16 09:39:36 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
The congestion is pretty terrible. But hopefully that will be improved by the
removal of the level crossing!
Parking is a nightmare, especially after 6.00pm, if you want to quickly get
something at Woolworths, you can't unless you walk. It's sad there are now
so many shops that are no longer proper shops, just places packing up
vitamins to send to China.
The traffic from the boom gates!
Insufficient car parking spaces.
can't wait for boom gates to be removed from railway
potentially more variety in food stores, cafes that are open longer in the
afternoon - till 5/5:30
Too many asian restaurants & other, it needs variety-it's like being in
Springvale! It's too hard to get parking so it's quicker to walk.
Stop adding new chinese courier shops, they are a major problem, and if
they continue to take over, the shopping strip as we know will be destroyed.
Whilst I love Asian food and don't want to see it go, there are many of the
same cuisines that are over represented. Perhaps there could be more
variety in cuisines. Also I think we need a health food store (similar to
sunnybrook or Aunt Maggies). Perhaps also a book store.
In addition, parking is becoming challenging on the weekend due to the
increase in number of residents occupying the newly built apartments. This
could be addressed
PARKING - never used to have a problem getting a park now I struggle all
the time. Too many people living here due to over development is the
issue! Not so many Asian restaurants - love the food but want more
variety.
Get rid of the old shops that serve no purpose and get rid of the pedestrian
crossing. Everyone j walks as it is
Not enough parking
Too many restaurants of only Asian cuisine - need more diversity
Limit the number of ASIAN restaurants/ cafes.
A greater variety of shops.
THE NEWS AGENTS HAS CLOSED!!!!!.....a retrograde step in Carnegie
community.
Too many Asian restaurants
realign the traffic light sequence at Arawatta St
40km limit 24 hrs 7 days Koornag Rd between Dandenong Rd & Neerim Rd
Dec 03 16 12:07:43
Dec 03 16 01:07:24
Dec 03 16 01:11:04
Dec 03 16 01:39:39
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 03 16 01:48:27 pm
Dec 03 16 02:34:16 pm
a system to stop people dumping rubbish almost every night and especially
on weekends at the Salvos store cnr Koornang & Neerim - a disgrace
The retail shops are not for me so about half the shops i wouldnt use
Buildings are becoming tired with age
Will be good when the level crossing removal is finished!
Emergence of beggars on the street
Lack of variety in restaurants
Fresh food retailers getting priced out by rent rises
New developments being approved with shops presenting active street
frontages but then being used as international shipping/distribution. These
uses are not permitted within a Commercial 1 zone and should be
monitored.
Traffic too busy. Can't park very easily.
Perhaps shaded areas in new library frontage
Parking is hard
Lack of verity of restaurants
47
Dec 03 16 04:42:15 pm
Dec 03 16 04:58:50 pm
Dec 03 16 05:25:18 pm
Dec 03 16 06:02:26 pm
Dec 03 16 06:31:54 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:38 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Over crowded
Hard to walk into restaurant and get a table
Too many apartments
Homeless people on footpath
better public toilet access
Too many dumpling shops- loosing variety
I hate the way the government railroaded (ha ha) the rail above road in this
area when the Frankston line (after Caulfield) got the below road version.
Of course we all know why, the rich live around the North road underpass
etc.
Didn't expect anything else.
Too many apartments now, and parking is a nightmare. More trendy retail
shops like minta and co would be nice. A toy shop too.
Better pedestrian access, more interesting food outlets, decent cafes, better
parking
I'd like to see more variety in shopping. There's very little in good quality
clothing, homewares and books (especially books!). Great restaurant
options but would also like to see more cafes and coffee options. Parking is
a nightmare; trying to quickly
park and grab a takeaway or do some grocery shopping at the Woollies
after work is impossible.
1) In general, The lack of greenery. We would love to see positive ways of
introducing native trees and low lying native bushes to the precinct. We're
kind of tired of random planting ei. Library and Koornang Rd footpath trees,
and would love to see a clever, world class, approach to landscaping that
will benefit the community and introduce a presence of birds and wildlife
too. I hope the new level crossing area isn't a wasted opportunity in this
regard. One of the most inspiring things i've seen happen in Carnegie was
the recent community native planting effort on Woorayl St. However was
behind this should be consulted for a potential overhaul of the entire area.
How clever and cool would that be.
2) Less 'Daigou' shops. They are popping up everywhere and are the
antithesis of the Carnegie community spirit. No one know what they are or
do, they're not welcoming and they're ugly. Why can't they be encouraged
to lease warehouse space to pack their boxes for exporting purposes.
Sorry, i know that's a little blunt but I would have to say they're probably the
least inspiring thing to happen in Carnegie over the past few years. Can't
there be some sort of regulation that promotes shops opening that would
actually make our neigbourhood better? Every local i've spoken too seems
to agree.
Would like a fishmonger more small cafes and less Asian restaurants.
Seriously we have so many and I think it's going to one day just be
restaurants, which would be a shame.
Remove the Asian pop up shops as they look cheap and nasty plus I am
sure cafes and a fishmonger would thrive.
Would like the parking at Woolworths patrolled as now there are so many
new residents in apartment blocks, you can never get a car parking space.
I've seen cars parked there all day and I am sure the removal of the train
station car park hasn't helped this.
A new car park at Woolworths would be ideal - multi storey to give more
space for the growing number of residents.
48
With the removal of the train crossing a park would be great in that area.
Koornang park is great and just across the road from us, but somewhere for
the kids to go in the village would be great.
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08
Dec 04 16 03:50:48
Dec 04 16 04:41:54
Dec 04 16 05:19:29
Dec 05 16 11:47:03
Dec 05 16 05:44:03
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
pm
Dec 05 16 06:44:44 pm
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 02:13:56 am
Dec 06 16 07:53:47 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 12:14:30 pm
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
Dec 06 16 01:44:42 pm
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 04:20:37 pm
Dec 06 16 05:13:56 pm
Dec 06 16 07:21:30 pm
Dec 06 16 07:36:32 pm
Why don't we call is Carnegie village, to create a family friendly
atmosphere...
Lack of parking
Lack of diversity
Please actually police the no U turn signs!
I would love a bar!
cleaner street and paths less parking in main rd .
More retail shops, more cafés
Level crossing. Traffic problems. Dilapidated shops. Unkept shops.
The restaurants are a bit same as.....
Some shop fronts are quite run down. Some asphalt needs to be
resurfaced.
bins emptied more often, recycle bins needed, more high rise developement
on Koornang Road, more office space on Koornang Road
Too many "average quality" dumpling places and very mediocre food places
The traffic light sequence at Koornang/Rosstown and Koornang/Arawatta
needs to be changed for pedestarian movements. Often the vehicles are
stuck in congestion, waiting for the boom gates but pedestarians are forced
to wait. Long waits are causing people to jaywalk which makes it even more
dangerous.
The back of the restaurants on the library side carpark are unsightly and
smelly, the whole shops area could be more bike friendly
I would like to see the whole area re thought with a complete update of how
it look and what it offers to all.
I don't like people constantly double parking along the road while dropping
people off. It creates traffic hold ups.
Although it is great to have such a choice of restaurants - it would also be
good to have a variety other retailers - good quality homewares, book shops
etc. Also, a number of the shops take very little care in their presentation window designs etc. A good tidy up with attractive/appropriate signage
would be good. Public art is also needed in Koornang Road
too many asian cafes. not enough diversity.
I want to see restrictions on number of each type of cafe/restaurant.
I want to see much more italian/ greek influence.
better parking
The removal of the level crossing will be a big (positive) change for the
area. At present the traffic can be frustrating largely because of the pinch
point of the level crossing. Also the shopping strip seems divided by rail bring the northern and southern halves together is important for positioning
Koornang Road and surrounds as a genuine single, mid-size
retail/dining/commercial area of the South East. I would be happy to see the
shopping strip "spill over" properly into Neerim Road, the eastern end of
Rosstown Road, etc. In the longer run a tramline extension up Koornang
Road, to link Tram 67 with the Carnegie Rail Station would be good.
Asian food great, but too many Asian restaurant, too few of any other type
of restaurant.
More eateries and wider selection of cuisines and a seven eleven
Would like Cafe/restaurants to have trading hours
Too many Asian courier stores, would love to see a wine bar and more
49
Dec 06 16 08:01:02 pm
Dec 07 16 08:38:49 am
Dec 07 16 01:30:53 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:25 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:55 pm
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 07 16 09:56:41 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 08:01:30 pm
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
European restaurants
No metered/paid parking in the carparks behind the shops.
Needs much more parking, it is often very hard to park. Needs a multistorey car park - free for the first 2 hours of parking. Also needs a fresh fish
shop and a shop that sells refrigerated and frozen Kosher food. The
supermarket sells Kosher food on a regular shelf only.
The shops can be open until a little later in the evening maybe..
There are too many like type restaurants. Would like to see a few more
clothing outlets, no more $2 shops and a few different types of restaurants.
I think there are to many Asian restaurants I like them but I think there could
be more variety. Footpaths need to be improved quite dirty and needs a
upgrade. The back of the shops in front of the car park by the library are
dirty they need to be cleaner food scraps everywhere.
Love the mix of restaurants. I don't like the Asians shops that only advertise
in their Asian language. I enjoy eating at the Asian restaurants but am not
happy with the new shops ( selling mostly baby food!) that everything is in
Asian - how do I know what they sell- why would I support them if they don't
advertise in English as well - as they are living in an English country.
Parking.
Shop owners to take some pride in their shops and shop fronts.
Not plaster them with rubbishy posters and signage resembling a getto.
Tree planting, this can add greatly to the street scapes including the main
street.
It's not rocket science, choose the right plants(not natives)
I love the sky rail. I can not wait for it to be finished should take the pressure
off Koornang road so traffic can flow smoothly and with out interruption. The
sky rain will future proof the roads along the Cranbourne and Pakenham
train lines.
like the removal of railway crossover and skyrail concept to keep trains
moving until new system is ready. There would have been more disruptions
with an underground system plus it might flood as other areas do e.g.
Windsor Station.
More carparks
A ban on plastic bags! Encouraging shoppers and community members to
use reusable shopping bags.
I don't like all the restaurants. No parking any more. The strip lacks
atmosphere. Need more greenery. We have lost so many beautiful trees it
is a disgrace. The strip is old and tired. Needs a lot more diversity. Basic
shops again but not second rate cheap shops. Too many of them. Carnegie
on a whole is always dirty with garbage everywhere.
More greenery
Better retail
More cafes / bars
Greater variety of cuisine (Mexican would be good)
Green open space linked to outdoor dining areas
Lately I have fallen out of love with Carnegie.
The deli and the newsagency have left and the fruit and vegie shops are
average quality and one is not cheap. I used to go there and get everything
I needed for the week but now I have to go somewhere else for anything
from a newsagents and a deli and I tend to go elsewhere for fruit and
vegetables. The worst thing is the parking in the early to late evening. I
tend to go to the supermarket on my way home and by about 6.30-7 pm the
supermarket car parking is full and hardly any of the cars are moving. It's
getting very annoying not being able to access the local supermarket with
ease. I am a twenty minute walk away so sometimes I walk there. There
50
Dec 09 16 04:48:02 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 04:57:31 pm
Dec 09 16 10:07:30 pm
Dec 10 16 10:04:18 am
Dec 10 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 10 16 01:15:25 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 09:29:29 am
Dec 11 16 01:55:48 pm
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
Dec 11 16 06:14:48 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
are not many places to park a bike without feeling as though you are getting
in the way of the pedestrians.
More parking
Not enough variety in places to eat.
Too many dumpling and variants of Asian restaurants
More family friendly eateries
An icecream shop
More parking available
The level crossing removal will be brilliant. We're becoming more crowded
with so much development so perhaps more public transport connections to
take the pressure off parking
Level crossing to be removed asap.
Too much property development in the area. Big apartment blocks are eye
sores and ruin the classic look of the suburb. There are many streets in the
area now being taken over by apartment blocks.
Removal of level crossings to minimise traffic
Would like less duplication. We only need one 2 dollar shop. 1 fruit shop.
Less dumplings (though we love them)
I think there needs to be another decent butcher. I'd also like to see some of
the dodgy shops that seem like fronts for something else removed. Finally I'd love a wine bar or something... there are so many young families with
parents that go on date nights to the high street that are DESPERATE for
somewhere cool to go for a glass of wine!
More local art depicted on buildings, telegraph poles, more xmas
decorations and more festivity ... It's a community village and maintaining
that sense of vitality is important
There are too many restaurants of the same type. There is not enough
parking. We need more everyday shops to buy goods like clothes and other
household items. We are forced to go to Chadstone.
Not much greenery.
Very few trees.
Too many restaurants crowding out everyday shops
The whole street needs a refresh and is not clean, and tidy and beautiful
such as Centre rd Bentleigh. I think it lags behind. It needs more greenery.
There is one tree and there needs to be another tree on the opposite side of
the road matching it. The brickwork cemicircle times two needs an update,
maybe some more mosaics there and sitting areas improved.Many people
congregate in Carnegie shopping strip and there needs to be more seating
for them such as elderly and disabled. It looks tired and dishevelled as I
mentioned before compared to Bentleigh shopping strip. If it was refreshed,
more trees and more seating and levelled up to Centre rd Bentleigh then
that would be a great start. The arcades need looking at also. They are
dark and dingy. The childrens playground at the library is ugly. The treed
area, including the seating, however, has been completed very nicely. It
looks beautiful. If you followed this type of design throughout the strip, then
that would look fantastic. I really do think it looks a mess. I am so pleased
this strip is being examined as for a long time as a Carnegie resident, I have
been very disappointed in it. I would like to see a couple of bars to improve
the nightlife. Nothing major, or too late. The strip could accommodate some
later opening venues.
More diversity- no more dumpling places or shop fronts for selling
formula/vitamins overseas, way too many!
More parking required
51
Dec 12 16 04:28:28 pm
Dec 14 16 03:36:48 pm
Dec 14 16 09:37:51 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
Dec 15 16 08:59:06 pm
Dec 16 16 12:06:19 pm
Dec 16 16 02:04:25 pm
News agency and deli re opened
M
Nothing
Several road intersections on the strip have become very congested and I
have personally been a witness to a few near-misses in the last 6 months.
These intersections would certainly benefit from an upgrade after review by
professional urban planners, i.e. installation or upgrade of traffic lights. The
intersections are:
1) Morton Avenue & Koornang Road
2) Neerim Road & Koornang Road
Once the train line is removed I would love to see greater integration of the
northern side of the strip. Once the crossing is removed though I'd also be
worried about a increase in road traffic. I'd like to see this mitigated if it
becomes problematic.
Trees need to be retained. Updated community art projects would be nice.
A popular theme would be how the lxra came to town and ruined it.
The long wait for the level crossing
too many asia dispatch stores/powdered milk/vitamins giving no benefit to
the wider community and a poor visual
TOO MANY DUMPLING STORES!
Really - we need diversity not a plethora of single cheap cuisine stores. I
understand the increase of apartments means people want cheap takeaway
or on store food but surely not all the same.
Dec 16 16 02:07:53 pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Dec 17 16 09:00:42 am
Dec 17 16 09:36:01 am
Dec 17 16 10:26:51 am
Dec 17 16 02:40:19 pm
Dec 17 16 06:10:26 pm
Dec 18 16 01:09:39 pm
The parking at peak periods has become unworkable. Not enough space.
The design of the carpark near Safeway is bad. Too small turning circle.Bad
visibility out onto Kookarib Rd
I would like to see some wine bars/more cafes and more multicultural
restaurants not just of the Chinese variety
Uneven footpaths, some sandwich boards in the walkway, some pedestrian
congestion
Parking
Less $2 shops selling junk. More virbant and cultural appeal such as art
work or performances. More promotion of local Australian made goods or
products. Make the area more of an active transport zone. The last thing I
would want to see is multi storey car parks around Carnegie station which
would create even worse traffic. Make Koonang Road a destination to stop
or ride your bike or walk and less traffic. The station areas should promote
active transport not people driving and parking at or in the surrounding
streets so council need to implement permits to stop this happening or
some such strategy. I am concerned with the elevated train tracks will
enable drivers to cut through all the minor side streets to pass through our
neighbourhood, given the train track currently funnells cars through the level
crossing areas removing all the train lines will mean all the street could
become through areas if people have the opportunity to cross via parking
areas underneath the rail line to get to the streets on the other side. The
traffic situation will not be improved by moving the rail crossing but will open
up a whole new disaster for local residents all along the tracks
Fewer pop-up Chinese shipping/box shops - they look bad/unfinished.
Better parking south of the railway line
Better traffic flow
Parking facilities
More independent retail shops - bookstore / clothing / homewards. Less bad
52
Dec 18 16 10:23:31 pm
Dec 19 16 09:03:13 am
Dec 19 16 11:10:21 am
Dec 19 16 11:19:45 am
Dec 19 16 11:27:41 am
Dec 19 16 11:34:44 am
Dec 19 16 11:36:23 am
Dec 19 16 11:41:09 am
Dec 19 16 11:44:32 am
Dec 19 16 11:46:20 am
Dec 19 16 11:48:39 am
Dec 19 16 11:54:38 am
Dec 19 16 12:04:25 pm
Dec 19 16 12:07:06 pm
Dec 19 16 12:12:19 pm
Dec 19 16 12:22:42 pm
Dec 19 16 12:31:26 pm
Dec 19 16 12:37:53 pm
Dec 19 16 12:47:03 pm
Dec 19 16 12:48:52 pm
Dec 19 16 12:51:57 pm
Dec 19 16 12:53:50 pm
Dec 19 16 12:59:44 pm
Dec 19 16 01:02:27 pm
Dec 19 16 01:05:53 pm
Dec 19 16 01:09:43 pm
Dec 19 16 01:12:58 pm
Dec 19 16 01:15:09 pm
Dec 19 16 01:19:29 pm
Dec 19 16 01:21:26 pm
Dec 19 16 01:24:13 pm
Dec 19 16 01:34:02 pm
Dec 19 16 01:35:37 pm
Dec 19 16 01:36:53 pm
Dec 19 16 01:40:30 pm
Dec 19 16 01:43:34 pm
Dec 19 16 01:47:03 pm
Dec 19 16 01:49:12 pm
Dec 20 16 03:50:39 pm
Dec 20 16 08:58:27 pm
Dec 21 16 07:38:15 pm
food outlets that aren't thriving - I.e Pan Pan Chinese
No more residential development. Improved parking for supermarkets at
peak times. Rail line to go underground.
Library
Aldi
nothing
sitting/ play ground
less parking spots
N/A
N/A
N/A
nothing
N/A
cleaner public toilets
would like more car parks so people can park and enjoy the shops more
so many limited parking spots customers cant stay for long.
difficult for finding parking
accessibility
permit parking for residents
parking is a hassle for CX5. Level crossing disruptions
Parking ( to many limited spots making it hard for enjoying)
news agency is gone
nothing
traffic
too many food restaurants
not too many Asian restaurants
more parking
I think its good as it is
more kids activites
nothing. maybe ice cream and fresh fish
customers decreasing
N/A
N/A
not sure
skyrail
more car parks
2hour limitation parking so local flats don't use it
N/A
I am thankful for everything don't change
parking
More carparking! Stop the residents of the apartments at the corner of
kokaribb and neerim roads from parking their cars in the safeway carpark!
Too many Asian restaurants. Love Asian food but a bigger variety of places
to enjoy food/ drinks with different cuisine would mean we could go out
locally more often and not have to leave the area.
Ice cream shop
Wine bar
Steakhouse
53
Dec 21 16 11:20:20 pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44 am
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
Dec 22 16 08:48:44 pm
Dec 23 16 01:21:05 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 23 16 08:02:16
Dec 23 16 10:35:02
Dec 24 16 06:19:24
Dec 24 16 10:17:31
pm
pm
am
am
Dec 24 16 09:58:08 pm
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
Dec 25 16 06:15:10 pm
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 26 16 04:28:51 pm
Dec 26 16 07:01:09 pm
Diversity of places/shops to attend.
with the rapid growth in our suburb, there is a huge shortage in parking
places, which is rapidly becoming a major issue any time of day now
Repave the intire airea, with sandstone bricks.
Remove the doggy asfelt and red bricks. On the strip and a joining streets.
Mornington did this a few years back and it looks fantastic. Airy and bright.
Plant more trees on the strip and a joining streets
Restrict the amount of simular restaurants, add more galleries, retail out lets
and a bar or two.
Removed parking to have more space for outdoor seating and greenery.
More pedestrian friendly.
Greater variety in stores.
More options for bars with slightly better nightlife
Overkill of restaurants selling the same food
Too many packaging/postal places that exist purely for sending goods to
China. These DO NOT belong in a street such as Koornang Rd and do not
benefit the local community in any way. Also too many dumpling eateries.
more greenery/trees. Less traffic. Better lighting/safety around carparks and
laneways (e.g. the lane between koornang rd and woolworths carpark (near
chemist & slave 2 the bean), should have better lighting and CCTV so it's
safer to walk down at night alone.
A grass area.
It's all good
Level crossing removal will be good.
More trees, wider footpaths. Maybe some colored pavers to give it some
warmth. Avoid it becoming a traffic sewer once the level crossing is gone.
Traffic speed, too many crazy mind driver, u turn as well speed on the
road. We have many young kids around neighbourhood walk to school,
hope can keep them safe from road.
Better shops. Wow to a decent shoe shop, women's clothes & better
variety. Fruit shop I haven't visited butcher neither. Just so limited. Now
lincraft at a Chadstone may not even go to 'Plaza'.
Cycle Lane
Solar lights in streets
Tennis court refurbish
More events auch as weekend markets by the library, a few small bars so
we dont have to go elswhere for a drink, security cameras would be good
too.
Once level crossing is removed it would be good to make better use of area
between train line and dandenong rd. It is not as nice as the rest of the
area.
While space is limited, parking does need to be expanded. I sometimes
drive there rather than walk to save time but it can sometimes be longer
because you cant find a parking space. While the area under the skyrail
should be parkland, possibly another 50 parking spaces could be created
(in addition to a new train station car park).
Laneways connecting car parks to strip need 'beautifying'.
Cafe's open until 5:30.
Southside safeway car park needs better flow
Too many asian restaurants, whilst they are good and there are some other
options, there arent many nice dinner restaurants that are not asian.
Carnegie has lost its variety. So many stores have become dumpling ir
korean bbq places so there's very few take out options left. There's also
very few actual retail stores, food is the main focus. Also an increase in
drug addicts in the area makes it feel less safe.
54
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 27 16 08:11:33 pm
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
More outdoor eating , easier access to the car parks and we need a great
cake shop that is open until late for an after dinner coffee and cake.
Not enough food options, a lot of the same
Types of food
Lack of green space, trees and greenery. Like a bit more diversity in
restaurants and busineses.
I don't like the lack of retail diversity and the lack of parking. The over
development of nearby suburban house blocks into apartment towers
(some of which have zero street appeal and are cramped and shoddy) has
put undue pressure on the parking both during the day and at night.
I would also like to see an active campaign to attract more appealing
retailers - the quality and range of offerings is not widely appealing atm.
I would also like the overseas courier shops moved away from the main
shopping precinct as they are not doing anything for the local community
(plus often have no english signage).
There are a heck of a lot of dumpling places - we could do with some
variety. Really sad to see the Greek deli close this year and to loose yet
another butcher. Santucci being sold was a big loss - There is a lot of Rita
in the personality of our street.
The Christmas festival is a shadow of its former self. It used to bring people
out in droves... But now it is just some miserable parents trying to keep their
kids calm while they stand in massive cues for face painting / balloon
twisting. There wasn't even Christmas carols on the speakers in the weeks
before Christmas this year - it use to feel festive.
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 08:00:46 pm
Jan 01 17 10:43:11 pm
Jan 01 17 11:49:13 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15 am
Jan 03 17 05:38:54 pm
Jan 04 17 01:44:07 pm
Jan 04 17 04:19:58 pm
What ever happened to the brass band that did mother day / Father's Day
etc?
Too many asian restaurants - would like more of a mix!!
More diversity in terms of perhaps small clothing stores, shoe stores and a
general clean up. Stroll down the Main Street on a Sunday afternoon and
its filthy!
The streets vould be cleaner and some shops look poorly maintained.
Better lighting at night is needed.
Limited variety of shops - lots of chinese export shops, but no quality book
shop, homewares, florists, etc
There are too many dumplings restaurants. Want to see more bars, cafes
and other cuisines other than dumplings.
Could do with a little more variety of food, there are too many dumpling and
pizza eateries.
Would love some more retail shops.
And it would be awesome to have a couple of reataurants or bars that are
open later (somewhere to go for a drink with friends after dinner kind of
thing).
NO MORE DUMPLINGS! SIX DUMPLING PLACES IS ENOUGH
I don't like that my butcher just closed down.
How can we encourage people to shop locally such that other, similar,
retailers don't close down? Then we will have another Lygon St, with
nothing but restaurants.
there seem to be a few obscure shops opening and i am not even sure what
it is they sell... i'll go down tomorrow and see.
More parking
I don't like the overwhelming Chinese shops, would prefer a balance. The
culture has changed too far, too quickly. The shopping strip ad lane to the
Shepparson Street carpark are filthy, dumped rubbish of food wrappings
55
Jan 04 17 08:52:40 pm
Jan 04 17 11:40:31 pm
Jan 05 17 07:58:49 am
Jan 05 17 08:03:07 am
Jan 05 17 11:41:31 am
Jan 08 17 01:02:53 pm
Jan 08 17 02:41:07 pm
Jan 09 17 01:40:52 pm
Jan 09 17 01:51:18 pm
Jan 11 17 03:11:49 pm
Jan 11 17 04:45:00 pm
Jan 12 17 06:39:14 pm
Jan 14 17 05:47:35 pm
Jan 14 17 06:04:44 pm
Jan 14 17 08:31:43 pm
Jan 16 17 01:33:04 am
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
and coffee cups.. There seems insufficient cleaning, insufficient rubbish
bins and they need more frequent emptying to encourage people to use
them. The entrances to individual shops are dirty, people no longer seem
or sweep their entrances to make them attractive . The Traders should
step up here. Signs in shops only in Chinese… The variety of shops,
which make an area interesting has gone. Balance in all things is important.
The level crossing removed. Also a revamp of the benches along the road
&one trees/greenery.
Demolish skyrail when it's built
I would like there to be more options for a drink on a friday or saturday
night, a dive bar or a wine bar
Improved market for groceries delis and butchers, a mini market
overall aesthetic
Too many Asian restaurants and two-dollar shops. Not enough trees.
Closure of speciality food shops for yet more Asian restaurants (although
some are delicious!).
Lack of parking.
More (or one!) independent bars that serve craft beer. Better public play
space with more natural materials - the book worm playground is dated and
hot and not terribly engaging for families to meet at.
More diversity in restaurants and food outlets
Pie/bakery shop where you can get a quick sandwich
Bar for a drink
No more dumpling or korean restaurants, we have more than enough!
More name outlets like priceline...dont need 2 chemist warehouse.
No more cheap $2 stores.
More diversity in types of restaurants and shops.
The amount of rubbish and donated stuff that is piled outside of the Salvos
each night and more so every weekend, is a major eye-saw. I appreciate
that people want to pass on items they no longer need but the overflow
detracts from the area greatly and attracts rummagers. I also feel for the
poor staff who have to sort thru it all!
More car park please...
I don't like seeing a lot of homeless and junkies around felt insecure for my
family with kids
Too many dumpling/noodle/asian bbq restaurants. Not enough variety in
eateries. No nightlife or place to meet for coffee in evening. Needs traffic
lights at kokarrib and Neerim roads as so much more traffic now due to
apartments being built.
Dirty footpaths (pidgeon droppings, dog poo, spittle, paper rubbish),
homeless people lying in doorways or begging, touting outside restaurants,
smelly rubbish bins.
more parking
Glad the level crossing is going. Street looks hard
Less overseas shipping/packaging shops, less Chinese/Korean cuisine,
more diversity in terms of offerings - more cafes, clothes shops, gift shops
etc.
Perhaps an option of more parking - though where this would occur I am at
a loss. The increasing density around the transit corridor appears to have
done little to abate the growing traffic in the area That said, I am also a strong advocate of increasing the space put to Water
Sensitive Urban Design principles - i.e. lose one or two street car parks to
more vegetated biofilftration systems and street trees with permeable
pavement etc - this would also go a significant way to reducing some of the
56
pressures placed on the Elster Creek Catchment as we were recently
reminded.
With the train removal going ahead, there is a great opportunity to open this
land up to more green space that could be functional year-round with
minimal maintenance (in deed ZAM zero additional maintenance of wsud
features is fast catching on in many LG areas).
I think Leftfield has been able to demonstrate that Carnegie and the
surrounding area is capable of delivering sophisticated, up-market eateries i would like to see more of this included along the strip - and a wine bar...
ahh to have a sophisticated wine bar within walking distance...
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 19 17 04:19:18 pm
Jan 19 17 11:23:52 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
As for the appearance of the strip, this warrants a refresh - I liked the sense
of community connection that the tiled walls provided, something similar to
this would be nice - to improve the village atmsophere..?? some public art
by locals etc.
Too many junk shops. To many new cheap Chinese shops. We need some
greenery and art work... The area needs some beautifying.
More bicycle infrastructure. The cycle lane puts you in danger of being
footed and pedestrians don't see it because it's not a different colour. A few
more late night eateries. Accessible public toilets after 9pm.
Too many food venues, not enough parking, and with more units being built
it can only get worse. The area is starting too smell of rotten food. There
needs to be greater control regulation of waste removal.
Small business being forced to close - we've lost the deli, a couple of
butchers and the new smallgoods place, which is a shame as they
contribute to the variety of products on offer. Everything seems to get
replaced with dumpling restaurants. I like dumplings, but how many does
one street need?
Also the number of "cash only" restaurants - all the EFTPOS machines in
Carnegie must be broken!
More open space/plaza to have a rest. Rear of shops should be allowed to
be developed for more retail space. New train station should be integrated
with all the local bus stops: 623, 624, 626, 900, 969.
It's very dirty
Needs more trees or greenery
Too many restaurants the same
No newsagency at the moment
Not enough parking
The restaurants and cafes dominate with less of other more traditional
shops. I'd prefer more variety of shops so that the street looks open and
lively all day. At the moment, in the morning many businesses are closed.
I'd also like a requirement that all shops have their name in English as some
businesses only have a foreign language. Foreign languages are fine but
there should be English versions at all premises as well.
Finally, I'd like all premises to display street numbers.
The properties in the shopping strip are very expensive, so some shops are
closing because the rent is too high. I do like all the cafes that have been
established in Carnegie, making it an "Eat Street" for young people. I like
the 40 km hr limit on the road.
Car parking, particularly with the railway works going on - it has been a
problem with commuters cars in local streets, but now very difficult to park
to shop etc. Hopefully will improve when rail project is finished.
We have a large number of restaurants and food outlets (which is great) but
there needs to be more diversity- we have more than enough Asian style.
57
Jan 21 17 06:35:30 am
Jan 24 17 01:56:15 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 25 17 09:10:02
Jan 26 17 12:17:14
Jan 26 17 12:02:14
Jan 26 17 02:41:34
Jan 27 17 03:28:37
am
am
pm
pm
pm
Jan 28 17 09:10:58 am
Jan 28 17 11:13:55 am
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
There are an increasing number of "pop up" shops who pack boxes and
send them overseas, again, we have more than enough, don't need more.
Needs a good tidy up, not only by council, but also some of the traders and
other owner/tenants.
Shame the Newsagent has gone, but suspect there is a story behind that.
Too many stores opening selling the same thing. Appears to be a lot of
cheap shops with not much on offer, almost appears as a front and faux
retail outlet for something else. I would suggest limiting new stores on the
strip to those that are different to the stores already there. For instance
there is no need for more Korean restaurants or pizza places but a nice
trendy quiet bar is missing, burger places are lacking and so on
develop back of shops for eating, cafes, popups or small cafes in library
walk through to koornang
Parking for cars is becoming a problem as higher density living increases in
the area. There is a need for additional parking frequently throughout any
given week and this will probably increase when the railway crossing is
removed which is likely to attract more visitors to the area. Consideration
should be given to a multi level car park probably south of the library,
behind the shops on the eastern side of Koornang Rd.
beggars, charity muggers, lack of parking, level crossing
Less food places, need some thought aboit catering to local needs.
Not enough nightlife
a
Significantly improved on-road cycling conditions. Bike lane is currently in
door zone. Would like to see Glen Eira lead the way in reducing car use by
providing best-in-class cycling and pedestrian facilities.
Architecture/design solutions to improve street landscape – current bricks
are ugly. Better seating solutions for elderly. Removal of car spaces for
trees and pedestrian facilities. Solutions designed for people first, not cars.
Create a village feel – not a road with shops. Break the mould and create
something unique ownable to Carnegie and it's people.
Lack of Christmas tree at Christmas
I do not like the packaging / export shops that pose as "retail outlets" these
take the place of shops that would be useful for local consumers and make
the strip less useful overall. We need much better parking - many people
stopped shopping in carnegie years ago when it became increasingly hard
to access by car - this is due to traffic congestion and limited parking. I don't
like too many restaurants as it shifts the activity in the street to evening - we
need a balance of day and night businesses
Despite engineering efforts drivers still travel too fast along the road. I think
speed cameras should be introduced especially as the traffic will increase
with the rail overpass. I also think the speed limit should be reduced to
30km/h, as many other jurisdictions have this to be a good limit in such
areas (there is plenty of academic research and successful practices of
this). I also think this should be the permanent 24 hour speed limit as it
would be better for the night time economy - Something that should be
encouraged with the shifting demographics and work practices.
In do not like the asian pack and post shops - milk powder and vitamins rhey are not. inclusive to the community as a whole and take away space
that could be used by a business that serves the whole cumunnity better.
Also I do not like hearing from other businesses that they are having to pay
so much rent it makes me nervous thar we will loose more good
shops/restaurants.
58
Feb 01 17 01:36:19 pm
I do not like all the continuous development going on - the noise, the trucks,
and the constant dust is awful surely therecare enough flats now - please
stop.
I don't dislike all the cafes and eateries but would like to see an ICE
CREAM PARLOUR. Families would love it.
Now that Dairy Bell is no longer (and it was out of our municipality) the
closest is Elsternwick where there are two.
Would be great for the shopping strip.
Also, the newsagency has closed down. What a shame.
Feb 01 17 08:58:54 pm
Feb 01 17 09:51:04 pm
Feb 01 17 10:59:14 pm
Feb 03 17 01:54:17 pm
Feb 03 17 10:13:18 pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 12:07:39 am
Feb 05 17 09:04:43 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
A good, proper deli would be an asset.
The brick walls and run down look of the street scapeneed to be
modernised and fixed. Create an inviting space.
Too many Asian vitamin stores that have no signage in English. This
alienates the majority of people walking on the street.
Buskers at the library forecourt to make it 'happening'
An actual bar would be good!
SKYRAIL!
An ice cream shop!
The section between the railway and Dandenong Rd needs some work to
make it more pedestrian friendly and appealing to shoppers. It's not
appealing as it is.
Too many cheap Asian restaurants and shops geared at student
demographic. It needs a few more upmarket clothing / homewares stores, a
good continental deli, few more nicer restaurants, a good butcher. The two
that are there are closing down due to high rents which is a shame.
Less international pick and pack chemist. I count at least 5 stores when I
walk pass everyday. These stores are better suited for local community
stores.
Pedestrians and public transport users desperately need Vicroads to
change the timing on Koornang Rd lights once the level crossing no longer
provides safe passage. Currently commuters who need to cross to catch a
train need to wait for around 3-4 traffic cycles for a green light at Rosstown
Rd. Similarly, I have seen elderly people at the Arawatta street lights just
give up and run in front of traffic after waiting unbelievably long times for a
green signal. This will become a dangerous situation with our aging
population. Pedestrians should have FAIR treatment.
less fast food chain stores - ie. pizzas, more niche retail shops
It has too many restaurants now. There beginning to be a lack of essential
shops. Butchers deli green grocers. It's all Korean Indian and Chinese
restaurants dumpling shops and groceries. Hard to find parking for
shoppijpng as all spots are full for hours with restaurant goers. Killing the
goose that laid the golden egg
too many similar restaurants. Each week restaurants are replacing other
shops eg newsagent and butcher.
Too may restaurants will kill the retail strip
Hate the traffic, pissed off about the lousy traffic management, inadequate
and substandard parking especially on-street parking, all the towers and
other mult-unit development that are replacing Edwardian homes and
California Bungalows, inadequate drainage, loss over time of diversity of
shops and services to be replace by yet more food outlets, congested
59
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:06:15 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:28:50 pm
Feb 06 17 06:41:44 pm
Feb 06 17 06:57:40 pm
Feb 06 17 06:59:40 pm
Feb 06 17 07:05:16 pm
Feb 06 17 07:20:51 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:46:31 pm
footpaths were pedestrians have to squeeze past tables and chairs of street
traders, no green public open space worthy of the name, lack of trees
providing a canopy, unsignalized intersections where drivers routinely
perform illegal and/or dangerous maneuvers
More open space and better use of it around the library. Also more street
fairs and pop up events
There are far too many Asian export shipping shop fronts being opened up.
There is not a lot of diversity in what is on offer. There are eateries, mostly
same same asian, but apart from that, there isn't a lot of variety in the
shops. There are hardly any retail shops. I feel that the current strip caters
for either students or elderly people. The local butcher shops are rude and
have not kept up with the more modern thinking of offering more free range
products. Sadly, the newsagent closed which was one of the last bastions
of strip shopping. I hope that it won't be replaced by yet another shipping
shop.
I don't like to see the closure of shops that do provide for regular needs, eg
butcher, delicatessan, newsagency
Like to see more diversity in restaurants/cuisine. Less dumplings, more of
everything else.
We don't like the proliferation of Asian restaurants,particularly dumplings.
The lack of trees.
The lack of variety in retail.
People doing u-turns
The ugliness of new buildings and the rapid turnaround of shops.
Too many cheap shops, not enough quality shops
Too many cheap shops
Too many asian restaurants
Advertising in Chinese only
Trucks
Smoking
When I first move here over 10 years ago, it had far more quirky little retail
shops. These have now been replaced with Asian eating places. Gone are
the nice little shops. Not even a newsagent anymore.
More diverse stores e.g. only one pub in the town. More variety of
restaurants e.g. very Asian focused - would be nice to see different genres
extend pedestrian strip
Constantly waiting for the train is a pain which I know is in the process of
being changed. The lights to turn onto Koornang Road from Princess Hwy
are too short and often take 3-4 lights to turn in traffic.
I would love to see a great ice cream shop open up.
It would be nice to have a couple of nice clothing shops open up eg.
Witchery, Country Road.
The current relatively relaxing atmosphere should remain
Too many Chinese restaurants and hairdressers, not much variety
Pedestrian lights on corner of Rosstown rd and Koornang rd take far too
long. More retail stores
Please try to improve the postal shops with blind shop windows, and the
vitamin stores that aren't accessible to the broader community. I am glad
that chinese people are part of the local community, but these shopfronts
are an eyesore.
We need to have a plan for what we want the strip to be, once we know
then we should regulate to the extent we can the types of shops that can be
opened. There is a really weird mix of shops currently. There is an
opportunity to bring more people to the strip if it had a great variety of
eateries and lifting the quality of the outlets.
60
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35
Feb 07 17 12:02:21
Feb 07 17 03:43:47
Feb 07 17 07:37:46
pm
am
am
am
Feb 07 17 08:53:34
Feb 07 17 09:22:32
Feb 07 17 09:32:02
Feb 07 17 10:31:31
am
am
am
am
Feb 07 17 10:31:34
Feb 07 17 11:37:55
Feb 07 17 12:54:13
Feb 07 17 12:55:13
am
am
pm
pm
More green space, more trees.
I worry that it may become too gentrified and loose the broad multicultural
mix and older population and raise shopping prices. Also I don't want to
loose the relaxed, creative atmosphere as the artists are a big part of what
makes it interesting and cool.
nothing
Improved conditions and amenity for pedestrians.
Don't know
No more Asian restaurants as we have plenty. I would also like to see some
bars open up.
Cleaned up, is always dirty. More trendy shops and cafes.
I hate the rail crossing but that is being fixed up
more carparking
Clean up of all outdated shopfronts
Xmas tunnel of lights at Christmas.
I am very excited to see the Sky Rail Project in Carnegie Station.
All shops could have English writing to allow us to know what they sell!
Nothing
Dislikes
1. Concrete jungle - more trees needed
2. Lack of Parking fr the amount of people living and shopping in that area
3. Lack of variety - everything is asian food, groceries, vitamin shops
4. Dirty - I feel that this area is dirty and unsightly
Changes
1. Trees or gardens. I have recently moved from Stonnington and have
really noticed the difference. I understand there is a huge demographic
difference, but I don't believe this should dictate the environment
2. Bars? There is only one pub style venue. A nice wine bar or venue would
be good
3. Bakery or nice cafe
Feb 07 17 01:20:27 pm
Feb 07 17 01:29:06 pm
Feb 07 17 02:22:12 pm
Lack of parking, Too many stores that are no longer shops IE Courier
businesses that could be office based. To many cheap takeaway food
stores that look unclean. Loss of standard Shops like Butchers,
Newsagencys, delis Etc
More retail shops, less offices in the shopping centre.
*Too many ASIAN RESTAURANTS .... not enough choice
More AUSTRALIAN & EUROPEAN FOOD.....
*A NEW NEWSAGENCY - URGENT
*a beautiful library forecourt SPOILT by lack of shade in summer and rain
protection in wet weather
THE RUBBISH LEFT IN FORECOURT AFTER CHINESE NEW YEAR
CELEBRATIONS - disgusting .... people are sooooo lazy..... the littering
around our streets is abominable..... i live in adjoining street and am forever
picking up other people's rubbish ..... there needs to be another bin in the
forecourt;
*THE TERRIBLE ROAD SURFACE ON CORNER OF KOORNANG &
NEERIM ....VERY POOR MAINTENANCE
V DANGEROUS FOR THOSE OF US WITH MOBILITY
AIDS
MORE DISABLED PARKS NEEDED IN KOORNANG ROAD
61
******WHOEVER IS IN CHARGE OF THE CROSSINGS LIGHT CHANGE
SEQUENCES IS SOOOOOOO OUT OF TOUCH..... ridiculous how long we
have to wait AND IT USUALLY HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH RAILWAY....
it is prob computerised but it needs to be reassessed........
ALSO NEED A BETTER/MORE/CLEANER PUBLIC TOILET SYSTEM
AROUND THE AREA.... for use outside library hours....toilet near WW/SW
IS DISGUSTING AND DIFFICULT FOR DISABLED PEOPLE TO USE.....
put a new style one on the SHEPARSON road side......
I DISAGREE WITH COUNCILS POLICY REGARDING OPEN AREAS
BEING UNCOVERED...... come on this is AUSTRALIA .....there are plenty
of options for covers over playgrounds/forecourts that contain slats or other
options that can open/close at appropriate times.....& that can work in with
trees etc;
AS YOU ARE ALLOWING SONMUCH BUILDING/DEVELOPMENT IN THE
AREA YOU COULD AT LEAST BE SENSINLE ABOUT THE
VEGETATION/trees you plant.......NO EUROPEAN PLANTS......
AUSTRSLIAN NATIVES AND FRUIT TREES......we have discovered
OLIVE TREES GROW BEAUTIFULLY AROUND THIS AREA.... they are
sturdy, clean, and dense & provide good shade and could be harvested by
those of us that like olives.....
And more Jacarandas around the streets
Feb 07 17 02:48:16 pm
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
PLEASE DONT GIVE ANY MORE PERMITS FOR ASIAN FOOD
OUTLETS EXCEPT FOR A GOOD DEDICATED SUSHI OUTLET.....
I'd like to see more variations of cuisine (more japanese, mexican, african,
burgers) rather than 70% korean 30% chinese/malaysian.
Id like there to be more retail stores, (proper retail, not overseas shipping
fronts and stores that sell baby formula and vitamins - I have no issues with
this being a thing, but these are wasted shopfronts that add no character to
the strip at all)
More planter boxes, recycle bins, more regular empting of rubbish bins,
more variety of shops
Too many cafes/restaurants to the detriment of other shopping needs like
clothing & footwear.
No decent book/DVD/CD shop
With the growth of apartments in the area, parking is hopeless during
business hours.
The Woolworths supermarket in Kokkaribb should be demolished as there
is a good Woolworths cnr Koornang & Dandenong Rds and the site used for
parking.
1. Too many cheap restaurants. I believe they mainly cater for the local
student population and run on tight margins but they all contribute to create
a transient, fast and cheap food culture. Food is often of mediocre quality. I
know it's cheap but most customer are happy about it but won't improve the
overall dining experience.
2. The back lane of Koornang Road (Shepparson Avenue side) is a
disgrace. Smelly, dirty, shabby.
3. Not much variety of cuisines when it comes to restaurants. Perhaps, it is
little the Council can do but diversity is always welcomed.
4. We desperately need a bookshop on the Koornang Rd shopping street.
Plenty of restaurants, hair saloons and cafes but not one single bookshop...
62
5. Not enough good quality fashion shops.
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
6. Last but certainly not the least the Market Arcade, or whatever it is called
connecting Koornang Rd and the car park (Kokaribb Rd) is in desperate
need of beatification/renovation. It's shabby and uninviting. It's got so much
potential.
I'm sick of the rail works and contractors just standing around in groups
chatting between themselves all the time. I also don't like that the
newsagent went.
With so much traffic, it doesn't help when people are constantly double
parking making the problem worse. Maybe get rid of the on street parking
altogether and make the pedestrian footpath wider and more inviting. With
a pram it can be difficult to pass people walking the other way with
obstacles in the way (green grocer carts, cafe tables and chairs, etc.). And
with all the development going around, it would make sense that the
carpark next to Woolworths be multi-story.
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 08:42:27 pm
Feb 07 17 09:00:05 pm
Feb 07 17 09:25:41 pm
Feb 07 17 10:35:41 pm
Feb 07 17 11:19:05 pm
Feb 08 17 01:26:30 pm
Feb 08 17 02:03:01 pm
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 08 17 05:03:53 pm
Feb 08 17 05:49:41 pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08 pm
Feb 08 17 10:49:39 pm
It would also be nice to see some clothing retail shops (not everyone goes
to Chadstone all the time).
I want LESS bars and cafes ... it needs to be a shopping area not another
entertainment spot
More parks would be great. Spanish/mexican cafe. More children's facilities
(although the library already has some great activities and programs). More
small businesses.
Too may shops boxing baby formula and vitamins to be sent overseas. Of
no value to local community.
Too busy on traffic, even just cross the road, it takes like 5-10minso wait for
the traffic light and more variety on reataurant.
And lack of sport centre, no way to find a indoor place if want to play
badminton, squash or table tennis
happy with the shopping strip as is..
more street furniture, more bins, more activities
Concern that small traders will be driven out by increasing rents
can't think of anything at moment
HAPPY7 AS IS
More car parking that is monitored for time. To many appartments going in
with only one car space allocated so they fill up the streets and car parks.
More train parking. More shopping parking and more 30 min shopping
parking till 10pm so you can get food shopping done
Easier to drive through Koornang Rd
Don't like The limited car parking, the amount of 2 dollar shops and very
similar Asian restaurants, beggars and people stopping me trying to sell me
something or get me to donate, particularly around the library forecourt.
footpath are uneven and dangerous in places. more control over the shops
that are set up the last thing we need is another disgusting Asian restaurant
that no one eats at because the food is terrible. I understand that there is
nearly 70 restaurants on the strip but only 3 or 4 are decent and are popular
with the locals. More control over shops, the indian grocer that is next to my
building has no loading bay to receive deliveries so the trucks continually
block my drive way and there is not enough parking in the street for their
customers who also continually block our drive way to go to the store, it
should never have been able to open there!!
More variety of retailers. Although we love Asian food, it would be nice to
63
see some more variety.
Feb 09 17 12:04:18 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
Feb 10 17 10:34:06 am
Feb 10 17 11:01:20 am
Feb 10 17 01:36:52 pm
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 10 17 02:38:19 pm
Feb 10 17 04:09:57 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
Feb 10 17 10:53:48 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Also, it is a shame that some prime retail outlets act as distribution centres
for vitamins and formula exports to China. This detracts greatly from the
feel of the shopping strip.
no more high rise development at the expense of more shops going. Little
chance however.
Congestion has increased over the years and it is becoming difficult to find
a park. Just more people living in the area and more cars. Apartments are
going up but there doesn't seem to be enough "parking" for the residents
which then flow onto the street.
What would help is larger dedicated drop 5 mins parking drop off site near
the train station. If there is drop off area they are not clearly visible or used
for parking/bus stops. How do you drop off people/kids to catch the train
when there is NO safe parking area near the stations. The airport has a
designated drop off zone where people can drop off and leave why can't we
have one outside the stations?
don't let too many Chinese delivery shop open
Less junk shops. The arcade needs flashing up
I don't want to see more restaurants. I think that there are enough. If the
strip becomes inundated with restaurants and cafes then it will not be useful
for the residents of Carnegie. It is very difficult to find a park in the parking
areas during the weekend. So more parking is needed especially now that
Carnegie is growing so quickly. I don't bother to drive to shop on the
weekend. Fortunately I can walk from my house. The strip can look messy
and needs a regular clean - that is the footpaths- and some sort of upgrade.
Also the parking areas need to be regularly cleaned. Some of the backs of
the shops, especially near the library, are dirty and can be filled with boxes
etc and rubbish.
There are too many of the same type of shop - ie noodle/dumpling cafes.
We need variety so as to cater to many tastes. We need to maintain the
diversity that makes Carnegie a great place to live.
more car parking
That's easy more car places to park, even some with more time limits than
just 2 hours. I got held up at the hair dresses and came out 15 minutes past
the 2hours and was booked.
I love it all
With the extra people in the area, due to multi-story living, I am finding that
the pedestrian path (street) and curb-sides (road) needs to be cleaned more
thoroughly and more often during each day. I regularly see food items on
the footpath which is a safety hazard and it attracts flies and smells awful.
Don't like the traffic, the lack of the availability of car parking & the
congestion of the main street roads
I feel the streets could be cleaned up. The tiny lane leading to the car park
near the fruit shop is in need of a good clean up.
The library frontage is disappointing. Such a lot of money was spent for very
little results.
Needs to be people friendly with tables and chairs and more grass.
It looks unloved, I would like it dressed up a bit - more upmarket .... it would
be great to westernise it more ( not so Asian or so multicultural , (with the
greatest respect) more choice of retail, boutiques.... I hate the congestion
on the roads due to the trains, you can be at the lights trying to turn into
Koornang road from Dandenong Rd for 15 - 20 minutes at some times of
the day, which I'm sure you are aware of.
64
Feb 11 17 06:53:53 pm
Feb 11 17 06:54:18 pm
Feb 11 17 07:58:24 pm
Feb 12 17 11:17:14 am
Feb 12 17 02:01:05 pm
Feb 12 17 05:59:20 pm
Feb 12 17 06:23:07 pm
Feb 12 17 07:02:25 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 12:46:35 pm
Feb 13 17 05:14:39 pm
Lack of diversity in the restaurants and cafes. Too many Korean BBQ
restaurants and Asian restaurants. Given the shift of the demographic in the
area about time for more refined and upmarket cafes and restaurants like
Left Field
Too many apartment buildings being built changing the dynamic of the
community, adding to sound pollution, traffic fumes and parking issues.
Also every time an apartment building starts the land is completely cleared.
All vegetation is removed. Only a small amount of garden area is retained
and often that has very little vegetation meaning future problems with
drainage and possibility of flooding.
Impossible to regulate I know, but just far far too many of the same type of
restaurants, and shopfronts for freighting baby powder and vitamins
overseas.
Deep desire for more retail outlets - butchers, clothing, gifts, florist etc etc
1. 40km/h until 12am on Koornang Road is just too much. There is no one
on the street after 9:30pm! Many drivers ignore the speed limit as it is so
ridiculous to drive in such a slow speed on an empty street.
2. more parking is needed
3. However, parking should be banned on Koornang Road as vehicles
driving in and out really slows down traffic. It always takes more around 15
minutes, just to drive from Caltex to ALDI. It's just painful to make my way
through Koornang Road
Love the dumpling places and regularly patronise a couple of them but
there are too many. I don't like the proliferation of 'discount' shops and
shops that send stuff cheap to China, but I suppose there are lots of people
who use them. They just look trashy. I miss the bookshop and deli and I'm
very sorry to see Barry Gardiner butcher close down.
Have shops other than Asian selling goods as well as food
More parking is needed. A deli is needed. More recreational areas that are
'green'.
The congestion on Saturdays. I live in Morton Avenue and on Saturdays it
can take a good 15 minutes to get to princes highway.
1. The lack of car parking for train users is putting pressure on vehicular
access to businesses in the area. We must use this opportunity to provide
sufficient car parking for train users within a 5-7 min walking distance, as
the disappearance of railway crossings will also increase patronage.
2. The disappearance of what once was a wide variety of retail outlets to
become a monotonous eating alley with limited variety of food types. The
clothing and footwear shops, the deli, the newsagency, the hardware shop
and many others are all gone, replaced mainly by Asian food outlets.
The signage looks messy. I love the variety of cultures in Carnegie but there
are several shop fronts that don't put any effort into appealing signage. I
also believe that all shops should have signage in english (not only
chinese). There are many shops that have there shopfronts completey
covered with cheap paper with chinese writing. This does not help
integration and impacts the "community feel" to Carnegie. I love the variety
of Asian resaurants, Paradai Thai is one of our favourites but we need to
continue to add avariety. We were happy to see a French Creperie as a
newcomer to the area.
- Too many shops are closing that I use to do my business, such as the deli,
the butcher, the newsagent.
- Too many restaurants and not enough everyday shops.
- Encourage these types of businesses back so I am not forced to use the
big supermarkets.
There are too many Asian restaurants. While we understand there are
65
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 12:50:53 pm
Feb 14 17 01:56:09 pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09
Feb 15 17 12:08:50
Feb 15 17 10:19:11
Feb 15 17 07:38:33
Feb 16 17 03:39:55
pm
am
am
pm
pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:21:55 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 17 17 12:21:13 pm
Feb 18 17 01:52:15 am
many different Asian cultures in the area, we have stopped visiting the strip
for dining as there is too much of the same thing. We now travel out of the
area for dining options.
Sadly it is ridiculous rents that are driving some small operators out of
Koornang Road. Also, the spike in the amount of traffic is very concerning,
as is the amount of apartments that are not providing adequate parking to
protect the precinct. Developers should be forced to provide more before it
affects people coming to shop in Carnegie. It is now a challenge to get a
park at the two supermarkets - the smaller Woolworths has its car park filled
with tenants from the apartments facing Neerim Road (where Ray White
offices are) which means that parking for shoppers is almost halved.
I don't like it when I see small businesses leaving the area, or too many
franchises entering the area. I like the small village feel of our suburb. I
obviously wasn't keen on the rail works happening, it was quite dramatic
and worrying, and the noise from the works has kept me awake but i
understand changes are happening. I don't mind the apartments going up in
the area, but I want don't want to see too many apartments as it will cause
congestion in our small area. I would love more trees along the railway line
again, as it broke my heart when I saw so many taken down. People need
trees and seats to sit and enjoy nature. So more trees please. I would love
an ice cream or frozen yoghurt place in koornang road. That would pretty
much make Koornang road perfect.
I really really don't like the Chinese "chemist" shops. these are effectively
vitamin exporting fronts. They are completely signed in Chinese writing,
and all you can hear when you walk past, is the "screech" of packing tape
as boxes are packaged up. These shops do no belong on the main street they are NOT retail shops. We need more Cafe's with breakfast options as
well.
An improvement in the street cleanliness, particularly on weekends.
Improve quality of footpaths and more rubbish bins. Enforce no U-turn
regulation in Koornang Road as this does cause problems from time to
time.
I would like much more free car parking
The busy traffic
Limited diversity of shops.
too many flats, too many restaurants, not enough diversity
Bit ranshackled. Generally low rise older shops but without significant
heritage. Limited diversity
I don''t like the growing number of shop front packaging goods and sending
them overseas - they are not an attractive part of the shopping range - at
least 6 and counting.
I am very concerned about the older houses being demolished to make
way for apartment buildings. This is destroying the character of Carnegie
and removing the atmosphere that people come to enjoy. Adding more of
these high rise developments to the shopping strip will also destroy the
streetscape that is so attractive.
Also The graffiti is very dischordant with the strip and should be a major
concern for the council. I congratulate you on your efforts to remove it as
quickly as possible.
Carpark at rear of arcade repaired; arcade spruced up; extra trees along
the strip would enhance the streetscape
More bike stands. Keeping play area outside library maintained. Empty
rubbish bins more regularly
The area gets congested with traffic.
Nothing specific
66
Feb 18 17 08:13:09 am
Feb 18 17 11:51:03 am
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 08:36:02 am
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
Feb 20 17 07:08:22 pm
Feb 20 17 07:19:21 pm
Feb 20 17 07:22:19 pm
Feb 20 17 07:29:49 pm
Feb 20 17 07:32:52 pm
Feb 20 17 07:35:25 pm
Feb 20 17 07:39:37 pm
Feb 20 17 07:43:00 pm
Too many Asian restaurants. Not enough variety in food outlets. Seriously
how many dumpling places can you have in one street. Also signage on
stores. Can't read Asian. These new Asian "health" stores or the postage
places - too many.
Streetscape is looking very tired & cheap. Upgrade footpaths furniture trees
along Kornang Rd
More real greenery esp. outside the library (Less concrete, real grass and
shrubs trees, flowers) more greenery scattered down the strip. Need a
newsagent! (I DO NOT WANT TO SEE ANYMORE LARGE CONCRETE
DEVELOPMENTS GOING UP WHICH WILL COMPLETELY DESTROY
THE CHARACTER OF THE SHOPPING STRIP AND SUBURB)
Would like to see better quality restaurants
At one stage there was an equal mix between shops and eateries and with
different ethnicities. As each shop has closed it would appear that an eatery
has replaced it. Whilst this might not be a bad thing I am disappointed that
there appears to be too much of an Asian influence now along the whole
strip. It is like a second Box Hill with Peking ducks hanging up in windows. It
has lost the feel that Carnegie used to have.
We have enough Asian restaurants. I've lost count of how many dumplings
restaurants there are. We need more variety in the cuisine. Middle
Eastern/Turkish, Greek, Spanish, Mexican/South American, Eastern
European, African - so many cuisines and you keep approving permits for
Asian. It's becoming a joke.
Also, the fact we have 2 Woolworths - the old one should really become a
Coles. Once the railway crossing is removed, having one on each side will
become pointless
high rise storey apartments, destroying the strip with to many people and
the rise of the homeless beggar.
I would like to see a balance of Retail clothing Shops and Restaurants.
Lose one of the Woolworths supermarkets and replace it with a Coles
Supermarket.
An good quality House implement, furniture type shop.
Need better links between train and bus, more public spaces, better trees,
less bulk shops sending to China
More bike paths
Would like a newsagency
Don't like the 'packing' shops that send things overseas. Do not add any
value/contribute to the shopping strip
Parking can be difficult
Railway crossing - Koornang Rd
More multi-culturalism on Koornang Rd
More scootering and skate parks - child friendly
more greenery
Improved parking
Old shopfronts - need upgrading
Limited seating
North Rd speed limit - 40 too slow
Parks should have permanent table tennis tables like in Sydney (metal net
that doesn't need to be replaced)
More mix of shops (eg clothing)
More green space/ playgrounds - in Carnegie the only walkable outdoor
playground is Lyons Park
67
What makes Carnegie shopping strip unique and special?
Date
Nov 28 16 06:02:24
Nov 29 16 06:29:16
Nov 29 16 09:48:36
Nov 29 16 02:02:14
pm
am
am
pm
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Nov 29 16 06:57:25 pm
Nov 29 16 11:06:31 pm
Nov 30 16 05:37:26
Nov 30 16 08:09:13
Nov 30 16 09:25:28
Nov 30 16 01:37:26
am
am
am
pm
Nov 30 16 02:43:46 pm
Nov 30 16 04:37:55 pm
Nov 30 16 10:32:17 pm
Nov 30 16 10:49:43 pm
Nov 30 16 11:43:52 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 12:51:45 pm
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 06:16:34 pm
Dec 01 16 07:43:36 pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46 pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Local community feel
Unfortunately not much anymore.
Great cheap restaurants, catering to local uni students.
Restaurants
Library
Library play area
Everything you need in the one place
Village life, it's one of the most colourful/alive shopping strips in the suburbs
It's cheap but offers good quality food and shops. It's not pretentious
Restaurants. Good weekly food shop options that are local businesses grocer, butcher, bread. We miss the Carnegie deli.
Great restaurants
Restaurants, open spaces, low rise, fruit stores, cafes,
It's ours!
Has a library, can do most of your shopping there as there is a
supermarket.
There are some fantastic small businesses in Carnegie that are truly unique
to the area. The Little Shop (unique gifts), GD Foods (amazing smoked
goods), Carnegie Delicatessen, Barry Gardiner Butcher (a good old family
butchers) and a secondhand bookshop that has some rare and unique old
books. I hope that they are encouraged to stay and not pushed out by the
ever increasing export shops that send milk powder and vitamins to China.
The people
DIVERSITY!
The diversity of the shops. Although it could do with a few less dumpling
shops and an ice team shop would be a fantastic addition.
the food.
has a nice buzz, meet friends there for coffee and shops open a lot of the
time.
It has something for all age groups.
variety of shops, cafe's, etc
Not overdeveloped but that is changing
Lots of cheap eateries, small businesses and main supermarkets. A great
place to eat and do shopping.
Variety, independent locally run stores, diversity of culture, al fresco dining.
Small amount of chain stores.
Nothing unique or special
Lack of diversity in shops
Eateries are all same cusines
Area caters well to different cultures, types of family units and at this stages,
for most, is still affordable.
Dumplings!
It is a great location and central to several suburbs (including those on the
other side of the highway), especially with the Skyrail removing obstacles to
traffic flow.
The diversity of the suburb lends itself to a diverse shopping experience.
We have Greek, Italian, Indian, Korean, Japanese, Australian, Middle
Eastern residents, and we should reflect this! We have families and
68
Dec 01 16 11:26:22
Dec 02 16 12:05:18
Dec 02 16 12:12:05
Dec 02 16 02:55:35
Dec 02 16 07:44:25
Dec 02 16 09:09:01
Dec 02 16 09:10:50
Dec 02 16 09:21:33
Dec 02 16 10:02:16
Dec 02 16 10:40:50
Dec 02 16 12:10:10
pm
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
pm
Dec 02 16 12:38:18 pm
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 02:23:16 pm
Dec 02 16 03:25:11 pm
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
Dec 02 16 07:20:13
Dec 02 16 07:23:41
Dec 02 16 08:10:48
Dec 02 16 09:39:36
Dec 03 16 11:28:22
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
Dec 03 16 01:07:24 pm
Dec 03 16 01:11:04 pm
Dec 03 16 01:39:39 pm
Dec 03 16 01:48:27
Dec 03 16 02:34:16
Dec 03 16 04:42:15
Dec 03 16 04:58:50
Dec 03 16 05:25:18
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 03 16 06:02:26 pm
Dec 03 16 06:31:54 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:38 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
students, we should reflect this too!
Village feel, lots of people walk to the shops . Friendly people
the range of restaurants
It isn't chadstone.
Great Asian food, variety, not too upmarket and fussy.
It's not really a shopping strip so much as a dining precinct
The variety of great shops
The cafes
The restaurants and the library
It has everything you need, it's welcoming and vibrant.
The number and variety of good quality shops
The amazing range of eateries mixed in with commercial premises which
also include a Library, Post Office, Banks, a supermarket, newsagency,
pharmacies, butchers shops, fruiterers, bottle-shop, Railway & Bus station,
and a small hardware store..all close to two parking areas which cannot
cope with the demand
(Looks like we've lost our Newsagency and a delicatessen though!)
friendly welcoming atmosphere, still has small local feel
I wouldn't say unique nor special as it's all same same. The xmas street
festival is now appalling so people won't be interested
The variety of restaurants and shops, and the quality of the products.
The multi-cultural feel, both through the people that shop there and the
nature of the shops. It is also nice that it is not too polished or
gentrified...you feel like you can wander down in your pyjamas and it would
be ok!!
I guess the Asian restaurants. It used to have much more of a friendly
neighbourhood feel where we all knew each other but not anymore.
All the choice of restaurants
So many restaurants in a such a small area
The individual butcher shops and fresh fruit shops.
Cheap food, unique shops - not chains
ever growing number of diverse (culture) restaurants, all licensed and BYO
wine. we are the envy of the southeast
Vibrancy
multicultural feel, always lots of people there
The range of unique local stores and businesses creating an active and
vibrant environment.
Diversity of cafes and restaurants
Close to home
people
Large strip, 2 supermarkets and Aldi, library
For a little while longer it's still here.
Until the above road Rail comes into play and this area becomes a ghetto.
Everything you want for a daily shop is there - though it's missing a
target/Kmart/big w - if they had one in the spotlight centre that would make
the area complete
Great dumplings well priced
The Asian and Russian influence, fresh fruit and veg
The multiculturism and diversity. I mean there is no other place in Australia
that has as many Korean restaurants on one street! Not to mention the
clusters of other cuisines. Let's tell the rest of Melbourne about that! A good
69
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08 pm
Dec 04 16 03:50:48 pm
Dec 04 16 04:41:54 pm
Dec 04 16 05:19:29 pm
Dec 04 16 07:17:49 pm
Dec 05 16 11:47:03 am
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 05 16 06:44:44 pm
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 02:13:56
Dec 06 16 07:53:47
Dec 06 16 08:40:08
Dec 06 16 12:14:30
Dec 06 16 12:38:36
Dec 06 16 01:42:00
Dec 06 16 01:44:42
Dec 06 16 02:49:34
am
am
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 06 16 04:20:37
Dec 06 16 05:13:56
Dec 06 16 07:21:30
Dec 06 16 07:36:32
Dec 06 16 08:01:02
Dec 07 16 08:38:49
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
Dec 07 16 01:30:53 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:25 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:55 pm
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 07 16 09:56:41 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 08:01:30 pm
design and marketing team would have a field day with this.
One long strip which is generally has a relaxed feel. There are no pubs and
bars on the strip which I think makes it family friendly. Multicultural strip and
most likely not that many people think to come here, so it's full of familiar
people...
Its a busy strip with opportunity to be a vibrant local resource for residents
The variety and diversity
different nationalies and restauants known for.Little Korea.
So many dumplings!
Its just close by, has Aldi and Spotlight.
open area in Library forecourt, great restaurants
Bugger all probably. One of the multi story apartment developers produced
a fancy booklet which extolled '....the laneways of Carnegie....". As a sales
pitch that is about a dishonest as it gets.
The mixture of franchises, chain stores, and independents.
Asian influence and good coffee shops
A mix of food places and hairdressing service, groceries, and play area at
the library
Everyone is friendly and still has a community feel.
Great restaurants
Nothing much just busy and not special or differerent
The Rosstown Hotel
The range of cuisines available
multicultural uni precinct
mixture of shops, different cultures
There is a clustering of some restaurant types and cuisines - eg Korean
BBQ. It's also of a size big enough to be a destination in its own right. That
said, mostly I shop there because it is convenient to me, but it could
continue to carve out a niche and be a bigger draw for broader parts of
Melbourne.
Nothing
One of the best and longest shopping strips in Melbourne
Lots of different cuisines. It's a multicultural melting pot!
Offers something for everyone
Asians
Lots of very well patronised cafes and restaurants of many different
cuisines. Everything you need for regular weekly shopping is in the one
short strip.
It's just always buzzing with people.. it's got a mix of everything..
Easy access to all shops, although more parking will be required. You get
to know the shop owners
Good cafes and restaurants.
shops, variety, eateries - don't need to go to Chadstone Centre
It has a great variety of shops and plentiful supermarkets but i wouldn't say
it was unique or special.
A younger demographic has added to the Saturday morning Buzz
The places to eat, the individuality of the shops, the great public transport
access. It really is a wonderful shopping strip.
It survived the many Chadstone developments, unlike Highett that struggled
with Southland.
That there are minimal poor quality stores
70
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 04:57:31 pm
Dec 09 16 10:07:30 pm
Dec 10 16 10:04:18
Dec 10 16 12:10:10
Dec 10 16 01:15:25
Dec 10 16 03:53:39
am
pm
pm
pm
Dec 11 16 09:29:29
Dec 11 16 01:55:48
Dec 11 16 05:58:28
Dec 11 16 06:14:48
am
pm
pm
pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 12 16 04:28:28 pm
Dec 14 16 03:36:48 pm
Dec 14 16 09:37:51 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07
Dec 15 16 08:59:06
Dec 16 16 12:06:19
Dec 16 16 02:04:25
pm
pm
pm
pm
It has so much, is popular, and people are lovely - there are people from all
different backgrounds, and it is not hoity-toity!
There is nothing unique and special about Carnegie. It does not cater for all
ages and types of people. It is just a food strip.
I have lived here for 20 years and we bought into the suburb for the old
homes (one which we have done up) and the closeness to amenities. Sure
Chadstone is on the doorstep but how do old people get there when they
cannot walk properly. We still need our basic shops and with the
monstrosity of the skyrail (which we were never consulted about) our old
homes are being pulled down by the dozen to hide the ugly rail. Store
owners cannot keep afloat while this unwanted skyrail is being built
So as far as I am concerned Carnegie is now a suburb that a lot of people
do not want to live in anymore because of what is happening. Disgusting
I don't think there is anything unique about it
Not sure. It maybe needs some more public artwork in open spaces.
Seeing people you know
Shopkeepers knowing you
The variety
It's like a mini China Town in the suburbs. There is a lot of great quality food
in a small precinct.
It's a melting pot and it has fabulous cheap eating out options
All the Korean Restaurants
Great mix of coffee, bars, food variety and diversity of shops ... multicultural
mix of locals makes it warm and friendly and interesting ... attracts
interesting people .... arty
Good coffee shops
Diverse, friendly
Most of what I need is within a 5 minute walk from home
Cheaper restaurants opening late, the beautiful forecourt, perfect length of
Koornang Rd, not too long, not too short, so close to many forms of public
transport, affordable cuisine, multi denominational, lots of different cultural
cuisine, relaxed atmosphere, lots of students, not pretentious or
supersilious. It is just itself. But it could be so much more!
Very multicultural
Has all the basics
The variety and diversity of small shops
The food options all in one place, for a small area. Great integration of the
library and courtyard as well, right in the middle.
It's proximity to our home and its range of cheap eats.
Lots of great Asian food
casual restaurants
Mix of shops. Freshfood outlets as well as mix of restaurants and cafes.
Places to meet and sit, Library etc
Old school neighborhood feel- keep
Ihate the glitz of Chadstone so small is great
Dec 16 16 02:07:53 pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Dont wreck it with making it too glitzy and homgeneous like mall shopping
It's Asian food and restaurants
Culturally interesting,
Library in the heart
71
Dec 17 16 09:00:42 am
Dec 17 16 09:36:01 am
Dec 17 16 10:26:51 am
Dec 17 16 02:40:19 pm
Dec 17 16 06:10:26 pm
Dec 18 16 01:09:39 pm
Dec 18 16 10:23:31 pm
Dec 19 16 09:03:13 am
Dec 19 16 11:10:21 am
Dec 19 16 11:19:45 am
Dec 19 16 11:27:41 am
Dec 19 16 11:34:44 am
Dec 19 16 11:41:09 am
Dec 19 16 11:46:20 am
Dec 19 16 11:48:39 am
Dec 19 16 11:54:38 am
Dec 19 16 11:59:23 am
Dec 19 16 12:07:06 pm
Dec 19 16 12:12:19 pm
Dec 19 16 12:22:42 pm
Dec 19 16 12:24:03 pm
Dec 19 16 12:26:59 pm
Dec 19 16 12:37:53 pm
Dec 19 16 12:47:03 pm
Dec 19 16 12:51:57 pm
Dec 19 16 12:53:50 pm
Dec 19 16 12:59:44 pm
Dec 19 16 01:02:27 pm
Dec 19 16 01:05:53 pm
Dec 19 16 01:09:43 pm
Dec 19 16 01:12:58 pm
Dec 19 16 01:15:09 pm
Dec 19 16 01:16:30 pm
Dec 19 16 01:19:29 pm
Dec 19 16 01:21:26 pm
Dec 19 16 01:24:13 pm
Dec 19 16 01:43:34 pm
Dec 19 16 01:47:03 pm
Dec 19 16 01:49:12 pm
Dec 20 16 03:50:39 pm
Dec 20 16 08:58:27 pm
Dec 21 16 11:20:20 pm
Good coffee shops
The variety of shops, restaurants and feeling of relatively peaceful, safe and
friendly area. You meet locals down there whenever you go. However
now it feels less like this and more of a concrete jungle these days with all
the high rise and not doubt the horrendous appearance of a massive sky
rail dominating the horizon will destroy the peace and relaxed feel.
Lots of restaurants, lots of fresh produce shops, good public transport
access, positive community vibe, everything you need is in one place.
Eclectic, good supermarkets, good bakeries, library hub, busy but not
crowded
No need to travel anywhere else. Caters for all nationalities
Close knit community
Local traders create a community feel.
Not unique
people
good
diversity
variety of cafes and restaurants
shops
different shops
close to the train station
fun
cafes
events/ variety
diversity
people
diversity
diversity
diversity
peopl
variety of cultures
great places to eat
individual shops no "chain" stores
that its really close to my house
good culture
the people
new shops
the diversity
the mini street festivals
diversity
the history
shopping
accessibility/ comfort and friendly people everywhere
diversity
The restaurants.
Community environment, shop owners know you by name and build rapport
over time.
There is nothing unique about the strip. It's run down, has no foodie havens,
72
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44
Dec 22 16 02:22:40
Dec 22 16 08:48:44
Dec 23 16 01:21:05
am
pm
pm
pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 23 16 08:02:16
Dec 23 16 10:35:02
Dec 24 16 06:19:24
Dec 24 16 10:17:31
pm
pm
am
am
Dec 24 16 09:58:08 pm
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
Dec 25 16 06:15:10 pm
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 26 16 04:28:51 pm
Dec 26 16 07:01:09 pm
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 27 16 08:11:33 pm
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 08:00:46 pm
nothing new and exciting.
you can still find all shops for daily needs: grocery, fruit and veg, butcher,
bakery
Multiculturalism
Its known for its dumpling stores and thats about it
Access/ openess
Not much these days. It's becoming more homogeneous. It had way more
diversity in the 90's - Armenian, Japanese, Sri Lankan, Greek, Lebanese..
It is the only shopping strip that doesn't feel "mall" like in the south eastern
suburbs. There's not a presence of "big" brands taking up shop fronts - it's
mostly small businesses and daily use shops, rather than homemaker
centres and industrial shops like a lot of nearby shopping centres. It feels
more like fitzroy/brunswick than an outer suburb. It provides the amenities
of a small suburb, closeness to the train station/city, and you can live a
great lifestyle without having to drive to bigger shopping centres.
The Asian restaurants
Variety and library
The asian restaurants.
Variety of cafes and restaurants. A reflection of the community. That it is
LOCAL. That it is buzzing AND there still is the connection to the sky. And
that there is shelter all along the strip as well.
Friendly, variety foods
Very little. It is hard to park. There is very little other that food, cafes, $2
shops and a chemist.
Close to highway. Restaurant opening hours r good as well
It is a real mix of shops now. So many places to eat (though a few more non
food stores could be good). Choice of two supermarkets, all the services eg
dr, pharmacy and post office, that you could possibly need.
I think it is nice if the area can keep a mix of cheap, mid priced and more
expensive dining options so there is something for everyone. Unlike some
areas which are all expensive or uninspiring takeaway (depending on
location).
Variety of cuisines, esp Asian (variety important).
Proximity.
Variety of shops - can get most things we need
The number of decent shops that i would regularly visit is much higher
relative to other strips near by
Great $2 shops, the centre is slowly getting better and it's very easy to get
to.
It's multicultural mix creating suburban bliss. It is not pretentious, what you
see is what you get.
Good location
Dumpling heaven, great library with open space. Dutch club and Rosstown
best hotel, best chocolates in Melbourne at Lizzies.
Nothing makes it unique or special I'm afraid - it is sadly lacking these
qualities...
mostly family run businesses. Sad to see nandos, subway eye arrive a few
years back and worry that the street will just become like any other, any
where else.
Coffee shops great greengrocers and butchers and lots of food places.
Nothing apart from the numerous restaurants but there's not an enormous
choice.
The quality of the cafes and resautants i like.
73
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15 am
Jan 03 17 05:38:54 pm
Jan 04 17 01:44:07 pm
Jan 04 17 04:19:58 pm
Jan 04 17 08:52:40
Jan 04 17 11:40:31
Jan 05 17 07:58:49
Jan 05 17 08:03:07
Jan 05 17 11:41:31
Jan 08 17 01:02:53
pm
pm
am
am
am
pm
Jan 08 17 02:41:07 pm
Jan 09 17 01:40:52 pm
Jan 09 17 01:51:18 pm
Jan 11 17 03:11:49
Jan 12 17 06:39:14
Jan 14 17 05:47:35
Jan 14 17 06:04:44
Jan 16 17 01:33:04
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 19 17 04:19:18 pm
Jan 19 17 11:23:52 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
The Carnegie Library is fantastic and I like how the strip is quite long,
having the Woolies there too makes it great.
I like supporting local businesses, so I hope the strip can only improve (sad
to see some shop closures). Huff Bageley makes it pretty unique too!
That there still can be a strip with 57 restaurants so close to a huge place
like Chadstone close by. I have been going to one hairdresser there for 14
years.
The variety of cultures represented (Russian, Greek, Chinese, Korean, etc)
mix of shops, cultures, clients; free parking, easy access, wide footpath,
seating areas, fantastic community centre, good coffee
Variety in cafes/restaurants
The length and the history. The library and the play areas beside it. The
casual seating for pedestrians which isn't part of a cafe. There are some
good coffee shops. Europa shop is a welcome stand alone. Banks and
offices balanced with other outlets make it a busy hub.
The food & the diversity, one of the best places to eat in Melbs.
Amenity, which will diminish with skyrail
The variety of quality food
The variety
Again, the mix of cultures represented
Busy, bustling, vibrant, speciality food shops. Cultural diversity. Let the
Russian deli never close!
nothing in particular.
Good food - variety of different meal options.
Mix of restaurants.
Huffs
Poor parking and lack of diversity
This street have banks post restaurant cafe bakery all in one
Nothing really. It's pretty low key.
Friendly shop keepers, period architecture, easy access to the library.
Very Asian but a few cafes are not. Great range of services for its size banks, hairdressers, clothing alterations, phones, computer repairs,
lawyers, medical, dental, physiotherapist
Christmas celebrations
Well, I am not sure its unique - but it is special for my family as it is
proximate and services most of what we need :-)
Food!
Currently it is known for Asian food, it was well known for fresh produce
there were 4+ butchers ... do you know how many there are now? We
need more fresh food outlets.
That there is room for all - multiple grocers, multiple butchers, multiple op
shops, bakers, restaurants. I love that I can drop off my dry cleaning and
get a cake on the way home.
Great collection of grocery and food outlets in a small area, close to public
transport.
its not unique or special especially now the skyrail is going up. its a slum!
Choice of shops, cafes & other businesses. Refer to earlier answer.
It's unique feature is the large number of cafes and restaurants featuring
different styles of cuisine.
Local traders and businesses, makes a great contrast to Chadstone.
There are some little gems in the street; Bakers Delight, the hardware shop,
Gabriella Pizza, Santuchi and many more.
74
Jan 21 17 06:35:30 am
Jan 24 17 01:56:15 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 25 17 09:10:02
Jan 26 17 12:17:14
Jan 27 17 03:28:37
Jan 28 17 09:10:58
Jan 28 17 11:13:55
am
am
pm
am
am
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 12:52:06
Feb 01 17 08:58:54
Feb 01 17 09:51:04
Feb 01 17 10:59:14
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 03 17 01:54:17 pm
Feb 03 17 10:13:18 pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 12:07:39 am
Feb 05 17 09:04:43 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:06:15 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
The food you can get is not matched in to many other places
easy access
the variety of shops and mix of people. Also the access to the services
available in the area.
Number and diversity of restaurants,
Unique stores, personal service, library
The people and the unique eateries.
The variety of restaurants and eateries
The people of carnegie are unique and special
The people make the strip. I think the main st committee help a lot too ( I
am biased)
There is nothing that stands out, but there doesn't need to be. It is a place I
go to everyday and it works. I brush my teeth everyday too, but there isn't
anything unique and special about that, and it works.
Diversity, family friendly, mostly inderpendant businesses, convenient has
vitually everything you need in one shoppimg strip, affordable good quality.
Also I love the mosaics that you see in odd corners and on shops I believe
these unique art works create great character in the carnegie shopping
area.
Variety
The vibe during the day... lots going on.
Mostly small business. Not a lot of chain stores.
The variety of stores that are there. The great service. The huge array of
people that make the area multicultural
The variety of cafes and eateries give it a vibrancy and friendly feel. Also
provides for most daily needs. It's a pity the newsagent has recently closed,
as well as the deli which closed in 2016.
Not much at the moment: I find it bland cheap and boring, it has so much
potential to be unique and special
Diverse culture on the one shopping strip.
You can hear at least 5 different languages spoken in the street that I can
recognise. also, the unique ceramic murals in various locations.
diversity but not too big
Not much it is becoming generic el cheapo Springvale Clayton Chinese
Not much quality shopping
Diversity of food shops - eg deli, Russian deli, Asian food shops, green
grocers, butchers, etc
Is it unique and special? Maybe the relatively low-rise ambience of the
precinct up until 10 years ago. Now its a concrete jungle and rat-race where
car is king and pedestrians an afterthought.
The restaurants
I don't think the strip is unique at all unless you call having multiple asian
restaurants , special.
That it offers such a range of shops to provide for everyday needs, and that
it has a variety of reasonably priced restaurants and coffee shops
Good fresh produce, fruit, veg & meat, close to supermarket, friendly
retailers
Variety of fruit and veg.
Friendliness of people
Multicultural
Butchers and greengrocers,bakery,cafes etc
There is nothing unique or special anymore. Just ugly shops and smelly
cooking.
75
Feb 06 17 06:28:50
Feb 06 17 06:57:40
Feb 06 17 06:59:40
Feb 06 17 07:05:16
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 06 17 07:20:51 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:46:31 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35 pm
Feb 07 17 12:02:21 am
Feb 07 17 03:43:47 am
Feb 07 17 07:37:46
Feb 07 17 08:53:34
Feb 07 17 09:22:32
Feb 07 17 09:32:02
Feb 07 17 10:31:34
Feb 07 17 11:37:55
Feb 07 17 12:55:13
Feb 07 17 01:20:27
Feb 07 17 02:22:12
am
am
am
am
am
am
pm
pm
pm
Feb 07 17 02:48:16 pm
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 08:42:27
Feb 07 17 09:00:05
Feb 07 17 09:25:41
Feb 07 17 10:35:41
pm
pm
pm
pm
Small and close together
The lovely Asian, Korean, Thai restaurants. Great food variety.
Not too busy
Strip shopping locations are dwindling so it is nice to have the old style
shops, instead of bigger supermarkets/ shopping centres
Good place to hang out and eat food
The variety of asian tastes available.
Not much at the moment, there are a few gems but its hit and miss
Safe at night and walkability.
Multiculturalism, broad age groups visit, many of the shops have familiar
owners who have been there for years, interesting creative elements like
the designs of cafes, mosaics on the poles, quotes on blackboards, range
of people who shop there, unpretentious. I like the wide central entrance to
the library and playground.
it is definitely unique & special. Im not exactly sure why. The location, the
people, the feng shui, the mix of shops.
Diversity of cafes and restaurants - feels multicultural.
Ethnic mix, Indians, Chinese & other East Asian, Russian, Greek, Italian
and more
The diversity of the people and the shops.
Dont think it is special or unique
the feeling of community and its multicultural nature
so many hospitality offerings
Many cheap eats in this area
All the eateries
Nothing, I don't rate this area at all and only go here as it is close to home
Not much any more!!!
CLOSE TO WHERE I LIVE
CENTRAL
LIBRARY FABULOUS
PROXIMITY OF WW/SW SUPERMARKET
ONCE RAIL WORKS FINISHED CARNEGIE CENTRAL WILL BE More
ACCESSABLE
******NEED A COLES SUPERMARKET WITHIN WALKING DISTANCE
the quality of the food that already exists there is fantastic. The cafe's are
always great, very friendly shopkeepers and locals. Having the library there
is also handy.
Asian resturants
I don't think it is unique or special.
It is a handy strip for business with Post Office, banks & cafes in close
proximity.
It's vibrant and lively. Not too long, not too short. Not sure about being
unique and special. This is not Chapel Street.
Don't know about special but the number of dumpling restaurants certainly
makes it unique.
It used to be special..diverse set of shops not now..destroyed by the cafes
There is an amazing array of people and food. Good food is its specialty.
There are a lot of smaller businesses.
Asian restaurant hub
More different festival carnival to be hold or celebration activities
its vibrant..but relaxing at the same time
restaurants and cafes
76
Feb 07 17 11:19:05 pm
Feb 08 17 01:26:30 pm
Feb 08 17 02:03:01
Feb 08 17 04:05:54
Feb 08 17 05:03:53
Feb 08 17 10:41:08
Feb 08 17 10:49:39
Feb 09 17 12:04:18
Feb 10 17 09:31:59
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
Feb 10 17 10:34:06
Feb 10 17 11:01:20
Feb 10 17 01:36:52
Feb 10 17 02:00:18
Feb 10 17 02:20:59
Feb 10 17 02:38:19
am
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 10 17 04:09:57
Feb 10 17 06:00:56
Feb 11 17 11:05:31
Feb 11 17 06:45:24
pm
pm
am
pm
Feb 11 17 06:53:53 pm
Feb 11 17 06:54:18 pm
Feb 11 17 07:58:24 pm
Feb 12 17 11:17:14
Feb 12 17 02:01:05
Feb 12 17 05:59:20
Feb 12 17 07:02:25
Feb 13 17 11:02:12
am
pm
pm
pm
am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 12:46:35 pm
Feb 13 17 05:14:39 pm
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Mix of shops
not too busy compared to some areas, much prefer than large centres like
southland, can sit down near library & rest, can get in & out fast, variety of
shops from opp shops to expensive gift shop love them both! Can get
everything I need (except clothes)
THE RANGE OF FOOD AS I said before
Library mall and food shops close together
Asian restaurants and grocers, mix of people
nothing
The mix of local businesses - although this has diminished in recent years
Nothing
It use to have great selection of variety of fresh food outlets which were very
good quality. This over time has disappeared. I don' t believe that it as
unique or special now. Before it had both the food outlets and the cafes.
Now its just a place to go do shopping, grab a coffee and leave. It does
have some good cafes and restaurants so great for a coffee and lunch.
lots different varies of restaurant & shop
Good mixture of shops and restaurants. Need to retain the balance, though.
As stated before, the different types of shops available.
It's local and it has the shops and businesses I like to use
diverse
The strip has a great selection in places to eat, as well as having everything
else at hand such as banks, post office, hairdressers as well as grocery
shopping.
It is full of old and new shops but all have such great quality
It's Asian influence.
The abundance of cafes and the cosmopolitan feel.
It's convienience, however it would be much better and nicer to get away
from the Asian aspect, Carnegie has had and still experiencing growth and
change, the area is such a gem now with more Caucasian folk entering the
area. With all the new apartments, it's modernising the area so I feel the
shopping strip needs to compliment a new modern feel. Once the train line
is completed with recreational facilities, walkways etc, parklands will make
such a difference.
Unique - have such a saturation of dumpling restaurants and Korean
restaurants
It is multicultural.
Only really proximity to my home for me, no real attractions for the outside
visitor
Cafes
Variety and abundance of Asian eateries.
Nothing
In a short strip of road, we have everything.
Its location, far enough from Chadstone to be viable.
The very diverse local population living harmoniously with each other.
It has excellent transport options and a lot of variety. There is a buzz about
it with it being busy day and night.
The restaurants.
The lack of 'chain' stores.
The people, I love the mosaic decorations, and the newly renovated area in
front of the library is a great community hub.
It was accessibility and a good variety of neat and tidy shops, but now that
77
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 12:50:53 pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09 pm
Feb 15 17 12:08:50
Feb 15 17 10:19:11
Feb 15 17 07:38:33
Feb 16 17 03:39:55
Feb 16 17 04:06:54
am
am
pm
pm
pm
Feb 16 17 05:21:55 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 18 17 01:52:15 am
Feb 18 17 08:13:09 am
Feb 18 17 11:51:03 am
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04
Feb 19 17 04:52:17
Feb 20 17 08:36:02
Feb 20 17 05:06:32
pm
pm
am
pm
is diminishing and many store windows are full of ugly posters and some
shops are not maintained as well as they used to be.
I love the mosaics on the shopfronts, and the hidden artworks. I love the
multicultural feel of the street and the way we celebrate christmas, new
year, mother's day, father's day and so much more (thank you to the traders
who organise all that!). Friends and family are always so willing to come to
carnegie and it feels like we have everything we need right here. The place
is friendly, lovely and caring and has a real village feel to it with the diversity
of people and businesses.
I like the diversity. There are some really awesome noodle shops, great
Thai, Vietnamese, Korean, Italian, Japanese, Grilled etc. This is great.
Though we have probably reached saturation point when it comes to noodle
shops.
The mix of all the actual retails and cafe/restaurants.
Lot of emails are closing and are replaced by restaurants. It's not good. The
strip must keep a lot different retails. It's part of the place
Its vibrant
Restaurants
community spirit, not too upmarket
Convenience. Closest supermarket
The range of shops, the preservation of the older architectural style, the
friendly shop keepers, the longer trading hours, the great Salvos op shop.
It's cultural diversity
Great coffee shops.
Variety of cafes and restaurants and the mosaics
The cafes and people friendly.
Buzz from so many busy cafes
The small individualized shops and laneways giving Carnegie character,
vibrancy and life, the attempt at greenery, the pigeons and other birds/
animals, the chairs to sit and rest, the different cultural shops selling
different groceries and cafes conveniently close.
Nothing now apart from the long standing service traders.
Great vibe, busy but not crazy
It's variety, safety and places to eat.
Unfortunately nothing
Open Space
Date
Nov 28 16 06:02:24
Nov 29 16 06:29:16
Nov 29 16 09:48:36
Nov 29 16 02:02:14
Nov 29 16 05:17:36
pm
am
am
pm
pm
Nov 29 16 11:06:31
Nov 30 16 05:37:26
Nov 30 16 08:09:13
Nov 30 16 01:37:26
Nov 30 16 02:43:46
pm
am
am
pm
pm
Park and play areas for children
More Parking
Open space in front of the library is good!
More outdoor dining
Close road to cars
More bike parking in the open, safer for women
Garden and plants
An outdoor sitting area
Keep open spaces and maintain library
New seats in the main street. More trees
Car parks? Oh, wait. Activated car parks.
78
Nov 30 16 04:37:55 pm
Nov 30 16 10:49:43 pm
Nov 30 16 11:43:52 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 07:43:36 pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46 pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 12:12:05
Dec 02 16 02:55:35
Dec 02 16 07:44:25
Dec 02 16 09:21:33
am
am
am
am
Dec 02 16 10:02:16
Dec 02 16 12:10:10
Dec 02 16 12:26:26
Dec 02 16 12:38:18
Dec 02 16 03:25:11
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 02 16 07:20:13 pm
Dec 02 16 09:39:36 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
Dec 03 16 01:07:24 pm
Dec 03 16 01:39:39 pm
Dec 03 16 01:48:27 pm
Dec 03 16 02:34:16 pm
Dec 03 16 04:42:15 pm
Dec 03 16 04:58:50 pm
Dec 03 16 06:02:26 pm
Dec 03 16 06:31:54 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:38 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Better playground at the library with a fence along Jersey parade so the
little kids don't run onto the road.
Please help the poor man you sleeps outside the front of the chemist
everyday. Also please look at removing the people collecting for different
organizations they just spoil the whole vibe of the area.
Nice trees, perhaps at the expense of a car park or two along the length.
could do with more
area near Library is fine
More parkland....gathering spots in the town centre
Wide open space with grass or trees for families to spend time in.
Car park for all to use when they are shopping or visiting this area.
Clean and safe environment.
Well maintained roads.
Dead space outside library
Fine.
A wider variety of restaurants, bar.
A better playground near the library.
Urban parks for example the parklets of San Francisco
http://pavementtoparks.org/parklets/
Better designed carparks.
Grass - bike path and perhaps community vegetable garden
Style guide for shops to meet (signage)
Make it pedestrian only (no cars), like in Oakleigh
A clear central area with real gravity (not a heartless corridor)
Very little.
Yep. Placee for kids to run around
Hoping this will be improved by the freed land beneath the sky rail
The only open space leading to the library has recently been upgraded and
is very nice, but it is small and the only open space apart from carparks
a monthly market in the library forecourt
I don't see open space a big issue when I'm either shopping or dining out
more greenery is always good
It would be great to have a little more open space or a children's play area
in addition to the one by the library
More on footpath dining
Greenery, more plants
need an anti graffiti program when skyrail goes up
Buildings are age weary and need rejuvenation
Not necessary in the strip itself other than some improved landscaping.
Area in front of library would be better with shade
Do not any more open space
bicycle trial
Sky rail should make it one long strip. Variety shrinking though, only one
butcher soon, delis closed
More greenery where kids can play
Library is nice but lacks greenery and shade. Nowhere to sit to hide from
midday sun
Yes - would like to see more of this
more of it! it's a tight space so a well thought out and educated approach to
design is paramount. we need a visionary team to consult with the right
79
designers so that Carnegie doesn't eat itself which we've seen happen all
around Melbourne. This is the time to put some smart processes into place.
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08 pm
Dec 04 16 04:41:54 pm
Dec 05 16 11:47:03 am
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 05 16 06:44:44 pm
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 02:13:56 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 05:13:56
Dec 06 16 07:21:30
Dec 06 16 07:36:32
Dec 07 16 08:38:49
Dec 07 16 01:30:53
Dec 07 16 03:46:25
pm
pm
pm
am
pm
pm
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 07 16 09:56:41
Dec 08 16 11:15:46
Dec 08 16 11:25:22
Dec 08 16 11:58:15
pm
am
am
pm
Encourage more legal grafitti murals and street art. It's a real positive thing
for a neighbourhood to encourage. And it represents our youth too.
A park in the village would be great!
very little open space and nothing green- the old 'safe' park was replaced by
a hot small space.
Is ok.
Need more shade
Put the two large car parks underground and cover with REAL parks with
REAL grass unlike the Library forecourt. The immediate area surrounding
the shopping strip has much less greenery - both grass ans trees - due to
apartments replacing detached houses.
Taking away some of the public seats/tables and replacing them with food
outlet seating was bad. The associated Skyrail open space will help but
such amenities need to be spread about to make the centre people and
child friendly.
Nice open space.
Could have more variety of resturants
More open space would be ideal especially between the shops
Transforming the laneway connecting Woolworths and Koornang Rd
opposite the library into a green laneway with benches and bushes.
More planning more painting .
A modern look on a very tired shopping strip with some awnings falling off .
A no parking in the street would help.
Alley ways too are very tired and collect a heap of rubbish on a windy day.
Public art
more trees
cobbled pavementor unique pavement tyles\artisitc creative style and look
as the mosaic works started.
a fountain in the library open space area
Strong links between the shopping strip and the new linear park under the
elevated rail has a high potential. Otherwise the library forecourt is good other similar outdoor spaces should be considered as the strip expands.
More trees
More parks with great play equipment for kids
See below.
Playground for kids
Some of the cafes /restaurants can have more outdoor seating.
A better welcoming area at the back of the shopping centre, out near
Woolworths. That area looks very dowdy and dirty.
more seats near the library forecourt for adults to sit down when children
playing!!
A Bunnings!!
Nothing I can add
Where do you get it?
More shelter in the current open space?
Community garden
Community composting facility - where those of us who live in apartments
can bring out compost to contribute to the garden and reduce waste.
Arts! of all types!
80
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:34 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 04:57:31 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
Dec 11 16 06:14:48 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 14 16 03:36:48 pm
Dec 14 16 09:37:51 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07
Dec 15 16 08:59:06
Dec 16 16 12:06:19
Dec 16 16 02:04:25
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Dec 17 16 09:36:01 am
Dec 17 16 10:26:51 am
What open space?
More open space would encourage the village atmosphere, especially if
accessible from outdoor dining areas of cafes
It would also make the strip seem less dirty
A space where people can park their bikes, access via a pathway around
the back of the shops. Seating and a water station and a bike assist
station.
Room at the station for bike parking.
Water feature and herbs growing in an open space for people to use. Herbs
can be planted in lots of spaces for people to use.
More variety of clothing shops for men and women.
European cafes, far to many
Asian, as much as I dearly love Asian cooking
good how it is
Adequate. Maybe some grassed areas somewhere
Great opportunity to utilise local artists to beautify the main shopping strip
(e.g. in past there were totems painted on the telegraph poles). This is
indicative of the artistic, diverse and youthful vibrancy of the suburb and
creates a warm invite to locals, depicting the culture of Carnegie with its
ethic mix and cultural diversity, with artistic expression embedded within its
cafe culture
There's only the library forecourt which seems a bit wasted. A decent cafe
with outdoor seating not clogging the pavement.
Can only hope something decent is planned for under the railway when it's
completed.
seating greenery, possibly lighting, better parking,
Upgrade play area outside library- child friendly, interactive, play equipment
The little lane ways could be improved with more street lighting to make it
safer to use at night. People often use these lane ways to get to the big
parking lots (e.g. Woolworth's car park off Kokaribb Road and Carnegie
Library car park off Shepparson Road).
With the removal of the train line, this could enable more open space below
the elevated station. I would love to see some new space used as maybe
for a weekend/fortnightly market.
More greenery
Dog free park
its ok
Library mall doesn't have enough seats
Internet is great there
Safer places to tie up dogs that are not so close to the road
Modern feel
More open space do not fill in the area around the station with high rise car
parks or the traffic issues will only be multiplied not improved post the
crossing removal. So more trees a bus zone to improve pick up and drop off
of passengers. Most of the time cars use this spot and it adds to the traffic
issues
More landscaping and trees to reduce the noise soften the area and
respond to climate change issue of providing shade on days when heat is
extreme all the concrete and bitumen make it even hotter. With all the
development there have been many trees removed and not new trees
planted to soften the impact. Please ensure future developments have to
have set back and plant trees
More greenery, flowers, grass.
81
Dec 17 16 02:40:19 pm
Dec 17 16 06:10:26
Dec 18 16 01:09:39
Dec 18 16 10:23:31
Dec 19 16 09:03:13
Dec 19 16 11:10:21
Dec 19 16 11:19:45
Dec 19 16 11:41:09
Dec 19 16 11:44:32
Dec 19 16 11:46:20
Dec 19 16 11:54:38
Dec 19 16 12:07:06
Dec 19 16 12:12:19
Dec 19 16 12:24:03
Dec 19 16 12:31:26
Dec 19 16 12:47:03
Dec 19 16 01:09:43
Dec 20 16 03:50:39
Dec 21 16 07:38:15
pm
pm
pm
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 21 16 11:20:20 pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
Dec 22 16 08:48:44 pm
Dec 23 16 01:21:05 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 23 16 08:02:16
Dec 23 16 10:35:02
Dec 24 16 10:17:31
Dec 24 16 09:58:08
Dec 25 16 12:28:25
Dec 25 16 10:47:31
pm
pm
am
pm
am
am
Dec 25 16 06:15:10
Dec 25 16 06:48:49
Dec 26 16 07:01:09
Dec 27 16 09:45:59
Dec 29 16 09:36:45
Dec 30 16 01:24:59
pm
pm
pm
am
am
am
More gardens and places to sit outside
Covered places for shade or rain protection
Enough
More plants and congregation places
more spaces for kids and families. Trees, 'green areas'.
A nice big park for kids
Grass and good sitting areas.
trees and gardens
trees
vegie gardens
Play ground
more open space near the shop
parking
wine bar/ more cafes
parking
parking
build more family friendly open spaces as families are increasing in the area
more car spaces
More alfresco eating spaces.
Wine bar
Desert bar
Steakhouse
Fine
more outdoor sitting areas to enjoy food from the local restaurants. Reduce
traffic through the main street. Reduce the speed limit permanently
More pedestrian friendly
More greenery: grass, trees, etc
More and nicer open spaces
There is no open space that is user friendly. Only the area in the hot sun
near the library
We're losing open space fast and casting whatever open space we do have
into shadow thanks to greedy developers.
Better bike paths around carnegie would be amazing. More green on the
streets, eg more trees, and grass around the station/footpaths (but not that
terrible grass on residential streets, more local plants and mini gardens, not
just trees and tanbark)
Yes need this
Yes, that would be great
More green
Parking spots
Green
Yes
We need more parks
Parking, sports and recreation facilities, bbq and picnic facilities.
Pretty good
The open space near the library is wonderful.
More outdoor stace for cafes, to make it more dog friendly.
Trees, greenery, (we need lots) bit difficult but good outdoor eating.
Improve playground area and seating outside library (would be nice to have
a green, shady spot for reading)
82
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 08:00:46 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15
Jan 02 17 10:48:36
Jan 03 17 11:58:15
Jan 04 17 01:44:07
Jan 04 17 04:19:58
Jan 04 17 08:52:40
Jan 04 17 11:40:31
Jan 05 17 11:41:31
Jan 08 17 01:02:53
pm
pm
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
pm
Jan 08 17 02:41:07 pm
Jan 09 17 01:40:52 pm
Jan 09 17 01:51:18
Jan 11 17 03:11:49
Jan 12 17 06:39:14
Jan 14 17 05:47:35
Jan 16 17 01:33:04
Jan 16 17 05:02:49
Jan 17 17 02:01:54
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
am
pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 19 17 11:23:52 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
It's okay - this is a shopping space, the little play ground out side the library
is perfectly adequate.
More green space.
Open space around skyrail would be great as long as it is maintained
properly.
More trees and gardens are needed. I really like the mosaic so more things
like that I would like.
Some more trees or greenery along the strip.
Can walk to a park in about 15 minutes or 30 to Caulfield Park.
I like the chairs areas in the strip.
More plants/ trees
Well, that space in front of the library looks better.
Trees
Ok
N/A
Trees should arch over the whole strip from the railway to Neerim Road.
More tables and chairs on footpaths. Grass and trees where railway line
was (once it's elevated).
Sure, more is always good.
More natural spaces that are safe for children to play. The bookworm
playground is dated and hot and doesn't provide a nice environment to meet
up with friends.
Communal seating with trees
More but limited choice,
More outdoor restaurant seatings
Koornang rd is very busy flow through road. No place for open space.
The streetscape is harsh and uninviting.
Needs way more greenery! It's such a concrete jungle these days.
Definitely more of this required - the forecourt in front of the library is great but too much asphalt and not enough 'green' (i.e. consider the vegetated
biofiltration systems... :-)).
I think in the wake of the skyrail - it would be good to see more natural
green spaces for connectivity across the rail line and for asethetics,
recreation and general amenity.
Our library forecourt is hot, barren and ugly. We need GREENERY. The
one piece of art was removed.
Greenery
Outdoor seating
More tree's would be great, if not possible flower's or annuals.
The quadrangle outside the library/worm park has recently been upgraded
and is very good. Please turn the power back on though! The worms used
to have glowing eyes, and the robots would speak, it used to be a lot more
interactive.
More small plaza areas with shade. Improve rear of shops to open up for
retail services.
some stylish & clean seating areas with greenery
Many suggestions about what should happen re gardens, bike path etc
under the new railway line have been put in to the Level Crossing
Authority's. This will be an asset to Carnegie shopping Centre if done
properly. There will also need to be some parking for people catching the
train at Carnegie station.
The refurbished space by the library is good.
83
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 26 17 12:17:14 am
Jan 27 17 03:28:37 pm
Jan 28 17 11:13:55 am
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 12:52:06 pm
Feb 01 17 08:58:54 pm
Feb 01 17 09:51:04 pm
Feb 01 17 10:59:14 pm
Feb 03 17 01:54:17 pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 12:07:39 am
Feb 05 17 09:04:43 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:28:50 pm
ok with the development of the area in front of the library but might be good
with the creation of some open space near the redeveloped railway station.
Shady trees in the walkway to library.
Park.
Significantly improved on-road cycling conditions. Bike lane is currently in
door zone. Would like to see Glen Eira lead the way in reducing car use by
providing best-in-class cycling and pedestrian facilities. More greenery.
Architecture/design solutions to improve street landscape – current bricks
are ugly. Better seating solutions for elderly. Removal of car spaces for
trees and pedestrian facilities. Solutions designed for people first, not cars.
Create a village feel – not a road with shops. Break the mould and create
something unique ownable to Carnegie and it's people.
Yes - more open space is always good for mental & physical health
There is too much surface car parks that could be used as parks instead.
These spaces should be used to ensure there is more open space available
for future population growth. The council should not invest in car parking.
Car parking is not a public good as only people with cars can use it - let the
market provide for car parking or charge market rates for its use.
Green well kept spaces are always brilliant also interractive green spaces
like st kildas community garden in the old bowling green are fabulous.
Lawns greenery
Get ride of the brick walls and create more spaces like the library forecourt
Cafe infront of library
Certainly need more of this
The library forecourt is central and provides a hub that is probably
adequate.
Handmade markets from local guests.
more plants would be nice- drought tolerant obviously but more green would
help as Carnegie is just not that attractive really.
area around library and improvement but need more no traffic, gathering
area.
Great precinct around library. Focal point well thought out.
yes. The forecourt redevelopment is boring with limited planting, grey
looking and uncomfortable seating. Provide seating with backs so people
can sit comfortably and watch the world go by.
We used to have public park where my daughters played. It got bulldozed,
asphalted and concreted over, and not replaced. Yes open space is
missing, in the very area that Council is targetting for uncontrolled and
unregulated higher density development.
A space for community gardens
The play area next to the library is outdated. There is hardly any open
space and the small amount near the library doesn't offer a lot of shade.
Possibly to have some open space to run a farmer's market/street stalls
occasionally
Create a bus depot/interchange -so that it's easier to find the relevant buses
and stops
More parking for disabled -in proximity to the shops
More space and more trees. Restriction of trucks
Not enough trees
Too many cars
More shade and green space needed
Reduce the smell of the food somehow.
Only one open space. Very narrow strip, difficult to walk through when busy.
84
Feb 06 17 06:57:40 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35 pm
Feb 07 17 12:02:21 am
Feb 07 17 03:43:47 am
Feb 07 17 08:53:34 am
Feb 07 17 09:32:02 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:34 am
Feb 07 17 11:37:55
Feb 07 17 12:54:13
Feb 07 17 12:55:13
Feb 07 17 01:20:27
am
pm
pm
pm
Feb 07 17 02:22:12 pm
Feb 07 17 02:48:16 pm
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 09:00:05 pm
Feb 07 17 09:25:41 pm
Feb 07 17 10:35:41 pm
Feb 07 17 11:19:05 pm
Feb 08 17 01:26:30 pm
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 08 17 05:49:41 pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08 pm
Feb 08 17 10:49:39 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
Impossible to park on strip
The oval / kids playground is quite close so I'm happy with access to this.
There could be more open space. Most of it is taken up with a play park.
What about other users?
Green space and trees
Im happy with it as is
More trees, better materials/finishes along the street.
Gardens and trees with seats and play areas with shade
Trees, park area, benches to sit on
more car parking
I don't really notice the infrastructure in Carnegie, maybe because they are
very outdated? The benches along the main road (Koornang Raod) are a
little bit old. It would be nice if those benches are modern designed.
Also, the traffic lights could be well-designed in terms of waiting time? I feel
like pedestrians have to wait for ages for the green light.
Variety of restaurants not just Asian
Removal of railway crossings underground. Futile hope I fear !
Gardens, Trees on footpaths etc
Parking
Cleanliness
NEW STYLE PUBLIC TOILET ON SHEPARSON ROAD SIDE
FLEXIBLE
FLEXIBLE COVERS FOR PUBLIC OPEN AREAS
CROSSING LIGHT SEQUENCES CHANGED
MORE LITTER BINS
HARSHER CONSEQUENCES FOR LITTERERS
FIX ROAD SURFACE AT KOORNANG/NEERIM
More grass? Some shelters, park areas (not just the concrete part between
the library and Koornang, although that play equipment is cool)
yes
With the growth of apartments in Neerim Rd it is probably too late to think
about open space, unless the Woolworths supermarket in Kokkaribb is
demolished and used for a park & car parking.
Less parking bays but larger footpath along Koornang Rd?
Wider pedestrian footpaths. More shelter between the main strip and the
library.
almost zero open space in Carnegie and with the HUGE overdevelopment
of apartments allowed by council and VCAT this is getting worse ... not one
square cm of new open space anywhere
Another open space with seating would be great.
Park
ok
open space needs morework - too boring
Cleaner footpaths
a bit of a grassed area to sit & rest,play or eat
basketbalk and netball rings
Streetscape Vegetation and better/prettier lighting.
there is very little, only the small part near the library.
parking is becoming very limited
More of it only really at the library.
85
Feb 10 17 10:34:06 am
Feb 10 17 01:36:52 pm
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 10 17 02:38:19 pm
Feb 10 17 04:09:57 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Feb 11 17 06:53:53 pm
Feb 11 17 06:54:18 pm
Feb 11 17 07:58:24 pm
Feb 12 17 02:01:05 pm
Feb 12 17 05:59:20 pm
Feb 12 17 06:23:07 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 12:46:35 pm
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Exercise Park far away, need more trees plant around
Yes probably more sitting areas especially with shade. So more trees and
greenery.
I think the amount of open space outside the library is adequate
more car parks
Again I would have to say more parking spaces along more extended times
during the day.
Yes, some park land would be nice, but given how busy it is it would be
hard to see happening
More seating for the elderly to rest as they walk along the strip.
More open park spaces created due to all the multi-dwellings. We will have
young families moving in and we need more parks created in the streets
next to the Koornang strip so families can take their offspring out of the
small apartments without having to use a car to get to the park.
More grassed areas. More trees and proper landscaping.
More love and tidied up, modernised, some parts look terribly run down and
dirty.
Skate park
Parks for children
Definitely lacking in the immediate area. Very little in the way of large trees.
No street trees in Neerim Road on the north side from Toolambool Rd to
Koornang Road. Because of this there is no shade on that side of the road
in summer or protection from rain in winter. Also trees are needed to
reduce car and truck fume and noise pollution which is becoming
unbearable for anyone with respiratory problems.
The redevelopment of the library forecourt was a great start, but I feel more
could be done here - still fairly sparse / harsh.
The outdoor eating areas at cafes etc give the strip a great vibe. The open
space near the library looks really good now. I look forward to more open
space when skyrail is finished. Needs lots more trees and greenery
generally.
Enable residents to contact the Traders Association.
Diversity of cultures including European cultures to be represented in the
shopping strip
Definitely need more outdoor recreational space that is not concreted.
Grass, trees etc.
There is a need for green open spaces - with trees, real grass, sitting
benches and space for kids to run. They do not need to be large in area, but
there should be several, on each side at an each end of the shopping strip
New outdoor activities for young people, ie a skate park, a basketball court.
It is importnat to keep children active. It would be nice if they could meet up
with friends locally and enjoy some "free" physical activity. This is even
more importnat now that children are living more in twonhouses and units
and don't have a back yard.
Big trees, grassy areas, shady areas
Less posters and ugly street signage - particularly that above the verandah
line. A fair and consistent variety of shops. No more Asian restaurants and
"cheap" shops - there are enough to service the area. Tougher parking
restrictions and developers being made to provide more parking. New
stations should also have increased parking, but our understanding is that
this is not the current plan.
I don't know where, perhaps near the skyrail we could have some more
green spaces. How cool would it be to have locals using the park area not
just as a walk through but as a place to meet and sit and enjoy the
weekend. Picnic tables or chairs would be great, as would things like built in
86
Feb 14 17 12:50:53
Feb 14 17 03:19:09
Feb 15 17 12:08:50
Feb 15 17 10:19:11
Feb 15 17 07:38:33
Feb 16 17 03:39:55
pm
pm
am
am
pm
pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:21:55 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 17 17 12:21:13 pm
Feb 18 17 01:52:15 am
Feb 18 17 08:13:09 am
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29
Feb 19 17 03:22:04
Feb 20 17 05:06:32
Feb 20 17 07:29:49
Feb 20 17 07:39:37
Feb 20 17 07:43:00
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
ping pong tables, so people can just bring along a bats and a ball. The most
important thing is that the open park space feels safe and secure, so
lighting and safe paths would be essential.
More trees. Greenery always improves any outdoor area.
car park
Yes it very stark needs a softer edge and more common spaces
Not a major priority for me.
more trees
Ensure Skyrail ugly imposition does not split the strip and demise the village
feel. Develop open spaces that are functional and popular
More if possible.
The walkway opposite the library open space could be developed/enhance
with seating & Trees to make it a more welcoming place of gathering
Get rid of Asian restaurants. Add more bike stands.
Get rid of Asian express post shops
The area outside the library suffices but some green space close to the strip
that you could take food to would be good.
Trees!
The playground at the library should get a revamp.
More real greenery and shrubs and trees, less fake grass and concrete
around the library (Children will fall on fake grass as much as real grass and
it will hurt just as much)
Yes, more open space will be nice
Adequate
No comment
Need to make sure parks have good facilities
Need a toilet in the Garden Ave Park in Glen Huntly
Bike paths, outdoor green areas
Date
Type of shops/retail outlets
Nov 28 16 06:02:24 pm
Bookstore
Major clothing brand stores
Frozen yoghurt
Non-asian dinner restaurants
Newsagent, delis, cafes, butchers, fruit & veg, gift, clothes.
More cafes!
Less Chinese vitamin exporters. Huge shame the 'little gift shop' was lost
b/c couldn't compete re rent with vitamin exporters. They're a drain on
community life and add nothing.
Enough dumpling shops.
Love love love the local woolies
Different types of food
-Greek
-Spanish
-Kebab shop
Deli. Local bar, not just restaurants and the pub... something in between
A great florist more new cafes
Avoid big commercial stores taking over
Wine bar, Farmers Market?
Nov 29 16 06:29:16 am
Nov 29 16 09:48:36 am
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Nov 29 16 06:57:25 pm
Nov 29 16 11:06:31
Nov 30 16 05:37:26
Nov 30 16 08:09:13
Nov 30 16 09:25:28
pm
am
am
am
87
Nov 30 16 01:37:26 pm
Nov 30 16 02:43:46 pm
Nov 30 16 04:37:55 pm
Nov 30 16 10:32:17 pm
Nov 30 16 11:43:52 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 12:51:45 pm
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 06:16:34
Dec 01 16 06:39:40
Dec 01 16 07:43:36
Dec 01 16 09:00:46
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 12:12:05 am
Dec 02 16 02:55:35 am
Dec 02 16 07:44:25 am
Dec 02 16 09:21:33 am
Dec 02 16 10:02:16 am
Dec 02 16 10:40:50 am
Dec 02 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 02 16 12:38:18 pm
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 02:23:16 pm
Dec 02 16 03:25:11 pm
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
Dec 02 16 07:23:41 pm
Deli, variety of restaurants, seafood shop, butcher
Import shops, to balance the number of export shops. More dumpling shops
and maybe more Korean food. There just isn't enough.
More clothing stores and restaurants that don't sell Asian food.
Retain diversity in shops - not just Asian restaurants!
deli, bookshop
fashion shops
Target, Kmart or Big W would be very welcome and appreciated. That's the
type of store that makes Carnegie shopping strip incomplete (as opposed to
Bentleigh which has a small Target store in addition to supermarkets).
another Korean restaurant (joke!)
Less asian, more fashion and Mediterranean flovours
We have almost every shop, one needs to do shopping. More fresh food
markets to create competition.
Deli
more non Asian cafes and less backyard food exporters
Diversity of shopping
Food shops out number other, perhaps that is why most go to Chadstone of
their 'other than food' shopping.
Need a deli back
Always going to be tricky with Chadstone up the road. But would encourage
diversity especially in the dining outlets. We know people will come to a
good café/restaurant -- look at the success of Left Field, in the middle of
suburban Carnegie.
Clothes butchers delis toy shops homewares camping goods
More great cafes (like in Oakleigh)
More european / modern australian restaurants
French bakery (eg. Noisette, Laurent or Philippa's..)
European cheese shop
Italian Ice Cream shop
italian/Greek.
More clothing and homewares, shoes, funky cafes like Left Field. Maybe a
wine bar or too?
Need to encourage variety - we have enough dumplings and discount
pharmacies now
Dominated by restaurants, but that's fine because Chadstone Shopping
Centre is so close.
nursery/garden shop, book shop, ice cream shop
Less chains, and more small businesses make it more homely
There isn't a menswear shop, but I doubt this could compete against
Chadstone
ice-cream shop
bendigo bank atm
Need more variety in shops-don't know who gives authorisation for the
shops but seriously, enough of the same & mix it up. We have a great
community who I feel are thinking the same!
Variety of shops are what a lot of the people wants.
Mostly mentioned in prior comments but would also be great to have a deli the deli recently shut down and this was a real loss to carnegie. Perhaps
also a high end bakery
More variety in terms of restaurants.
More cafe/brunch type outlets
Too many 'daigou' shops popping up
88
Dec 02 16 08:10:48 pm
Dec 02 16 09:39:36 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
Dec 03 16 12:07:43 pm
Dec 03 16 01:07:24 pm
Dec 03 16 01:11:04 pm
Dec 03 16 01:39:39 pm
Dec 03 16 05:25:18 pm
Dec 03 16 06:02:26 pm
Dec 03 16 06:31:54 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:38 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08
Dec 04 16 04:41:54
Dec 04 16 05:19:29
Dec 05 16 05:44:03
Dec 06 16 12:05:57
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
Dec 06 16 02:13:56 am
Dec 06 16 07:53:47 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
Dec 06 16 01:44:42 pm
Coles - too many Woolworths in the area
Newsagent.
Florist
Shoe shops
need a Greek restaurant and another fish and chip shop
don't need large or specialty retail outlets that are already at Chadstone
Quality fresh fish shop; improved kids clothing shop; toy shop
News-agency has closed and we need one
Variety of restaurants.
Loss of fresh food is concerning - previously there were 3 butchers and 3
delis, soon there is to only be one of each.
A good quality Mexican Restuarant / take away.
Actually, something other than Asian would would be nice.
Nice trendy boutiques selling homes wares and toys andclothes
Decent cafes, more varietal food options, very one dimensional at the
moment.
As mentioned good quality homewares, clothing and books
- More food, let's make this like no other strip in Melbourne. It's already
almost there!
- Less Asian vitamin packaging places.
- Say no to unhealthy fast food giants and convenience stores.
Fishmonger
Local IGA
More cafes please - make it a place to come for coffee and spend time with
the kids
Loss of diversity- too many restaurants and bulk vitamin/baby milk exporters
Another deli closed recently
Is ok
Retail shops, like clothes for twenty-thirty year olds
Shops could be cleaner/less dilapidated.
Good selections.
Better mix of retail and food places, offering more variety and quality food
other than dumplings. Adding dessert or gelati place, toy shop is idea for
younger families. Target or job hifi would be great!
Real estate agents don't have to be on the main road.
More late trading restaurants that aren't Asian cuisines.
Shopping wise, it's pretty bad so anything is probably better.
Small bars
There are so many food shops who look the same.
carnegie need to attract a different type of shopper from other areas and
shops with a better standard and variety of goods.
Better quality clothes,more types and standards of foods.
Good quality homewares
Bookshop
Newsagency (the one has just closed)
Good quality giftware shop
an artisan bakery. with great sourdough bread..maybe wood fired oven etc.
more great italian restaurants
a good greek cafe
maybe a spanish tapas bar?
a great organic grocer/ with some beautiful local artisan products.
fresh fish
bookshop
89
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 05:13:56 pm
Dec 06 16 07:21:30 pm
Dec 06 16 07:36:32 pm
Dec 07 16 08:38:49 am
Dec 07 16 01:30:53 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:25 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:55 pm
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46
Dec 08 16 11:25:22
Dec 08 16 08:01:30
Dec 08 16 11:58:15
am
am
pm
pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:34
Dec 09 16 04:48:02
Dec 09 16 04:55:51
Dec 09 16 04:57:31
Dec 09 16 10:07:30
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 10 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 10 16 01:15:25 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 09:29:29 am
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
While I love the cafe and low-cost restaurants in Koornang Road, I think
there is a gap in both the higher-end restaurants and small bars. There is
the pub, the Dutch Club and the new bar near the station, but a couple
more might be good. I wouldn't expect it to be a 24 hour street, but perhaps
with a bit more opportunity for pre- or post- dinner drinks.
Seven Eleven and a wider variety of cuisines
A couple of bars would be great
Wine bar
European restaurants
Fresh fish shop
No comments
I understand the newsagent is going, I think this is a necessity in a shopping
centre as well a butchers. Perhaps a new dress shop.
Refer to Q6
Advertisements in English and Asian for those new shops that only have
Asian writing on display!
Nothing I can add
More ethnically diverse food options
Cafes open after 5pm
Eco shops, bulk goods stores (where you can buy grains, flours, legumes,
nuts & fruit in bulk and use your own containers), fair trade shops, anything
ethically/sustainably based.
Live music venues and cafes that are open later.
See previously
Newsagents
Bookstores
Clothing stores (decent)
Deli's
Shoe stores (family orientated)
Homewares
Homewares stores would be great, little boutiques too
Good delicatessen
News agents
High quality fruit and veg shop
Coles needed
Large bottle store
More variants on types of cuisine
Happy
Bars/pubs. The neighbourhood is quite gentrified, with a great deal of young
professionals living in the area. We need somewhere to go at night time to
have a few drinks. A beer garden would be amazing.
Fish shop
Health food shop (like sunnybrook)
Wine bar
Dessert bar
Book store
Bars
The mix of eateries is improving with the French Crepery the Italian
restaurant and others balancing the broad mix of Asian eateries
Men's clothing, women's. a good florist, toy shop, newsagent.
The newsagent closing was a shock.
The discount shops and Woolworths provide a very limited range of cards,
everyday stationery.
90
Dec 11 16 06:14:48 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 14 16 09:37:51 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
Dec 15 16 08:59:06 pm
Dec 16 16 12:06:19 pm
Dec 16 16 02:04:25 pm
Dec 16 16 02:07:53
Dec 17 16 07:35:05
Dec 17 16 09:00:42
Dec 17 16 09:36:01
pm
am
am
am
Dec 17 16 10:26:51 am
Dec 17 16 06:10:26 pm
Dec 18 16 01:09:39 pm
Dec 18 16 10:23:31 pm
Dec 19 16 09:03:13 am
Dec 19 16 11:19:45 am
Dec 19 16 11:41:09 am
Dec 19 16 11:44:32 am
Dec 19 16 11:46:20 am
Dec 19 16 11:54:38 am
Dec 19 16 12:12:19 pm
Dec 19 16 12:31:26 pm
Dec 19 16 12:59:44 pm
Dec 19 16 01:12:58 pm
Dec 20 16 08:58:27 pm
Dec 21 16 07:38:15 pm
Dec 21 16 11:20:20 pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44 am
bars, hot bread shops including hot pastries
More shops catering for local families (they seem to be increasingly catering
for the international/student population)
More variety required
I like the independent nature of many of the retail shops, but that also
means for some people less familiarity with the store and their wears.
Perhaps more inviting shop fronts.
A cool cafe come bar. A modern deli. An organic wine bar.
Clothing stores
more 'modern australian' cuisine type places - restaurant/bar types.
more fashion and homeware retail shops ideally
i was sad to see the deli go. I want shops with fresh or pantry items not
more cafes or takeaway places
I love the 2 dollar shops and manchester/clothes shop and op shop
Diversity is the key
More breakfast spots and bars.
Needs more diversity and healthier restaurant options
Independent fashion shops with local makers
Less $2 junk shops. Encourage retailers to improve the appeal of the
shops such as what Santucci has done with the mosics. You could employ
local artists/ schools to do this as part of your community grants
Homewares store needed. More night life and recreational places - eg
cocktail bar, beer garden, lawn bowls.
No
Homewares / books and less trashy options
Keep local traders.
Restaurants and cafes
Target or kmart
health food
Australian butcher
organic stores
massage
cafe
gift shops and clothing stores
clothes shops and cafes
a little more variety in restaurants
different food, frozen yoghurt and fresh fish
Different cuisines
Clothes shops, women's fashion
Boutique designer shops
Clothes shops
Book shop
There is little diversity. It is crying out for a couple of trendy bars and cafes.
make sure that existing shops, eg fruit&veg, butchers, bakery, can keep
existing. very sad to see the newsagent go.
Fashion mail and female
Gift
Selection of bars
Gallery
Craft shops
There are two many Asian resterants, need more selection in regards
resterants
91
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
Dec 22 16 08:48:44
Dec 23 16 01:21:05
Dec 23 16 01:44:26
Dec 23 16 08:02:16
Dec 23 16 10:35:02
Dec 25 16 12:28:25
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
Dec 25 16 06:15:10 pm
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 26 16 04:28:51 pm
Dec 26 16 07:01:09 pm
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 27 16 08:11:33 pm
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 08:00:46 pm
Jan 01 17 10:43:11 pm
Jan 01 17 11:49:13 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15 am
Jan 04 17 01:44:07 pm
More variety of restaurants
Less freight forwarders
More bars
Overkill of the same type of restaurants, so little retail left
Book shop, health food shop, another Italian place in addition to Basilico.
A health food cafe would be nice.
A good baby shop. A cocktail bar would be great.
Italian restaurants
Shoes, what about a Zierra ( mature ladies) even school shoes cannot be
purchased. Clothes there is not a Blue Illusion, Fella Hamilton, Country Rd,
nothing, nothing nothing.
More restaurants can be added as it will then become more graceful n
famous
There are no retail stores aimed at men.
Keep a diverse mix of food, bars and retail, from cheap to more expensive
and everything from asian to aussie to european so that the area never gets
boring for its inhabitants (with more and more people moving within walking
distance) and people in surrounding suburbs
In danger of losing variety, eg loss of news agency, maybe too many of
same kind of food
Nice mid price range restaurants that are not Asian, better quality fruit and
veg shop
More actual retail shops are needed with longer trading hours. Less of the
'same' types of restaurants.
A cake shop & cafe that is open late for after dinner post restaurant
gatherings.
Need a more diverse range of shops
Book shop,
Clothing
Gift/Homewares
Country Target
Healthfood
Newsagent
Butcher
Other food - frozen yoghurt, greek,
Butcher. Deli. Fish monger. Health foods.
Less asian restaurants.
Need more shoe and clothing stores to encourage people to shop locally
and not rely on chadstone.
A cinema would be amazing. Also more good cafes and retail stores like
Witchery would be good.
Book shops
Other types of restaurants except pizza and dumplings
Salad bar, juice shop, seafood shop
A nice bar or two (not big loud venues, just somewhere like Elwood), where
you can meet friends for a drink after work or dinner.
Some more retail shops (no more $2 stores), shops that make the area
appealing.
Unique eating places (but no more dumplings or pizza places please!)
Coles instead of a 2nd Woolworths would be awesome!
Too many restaurants of the one type (dumplings). One failing business
even changed to a dumpling place that no one goes to.
More butchers, please!
More homeware/ variety shops
92
Jan 04 17 04:19:58
Jan 04 17 08:52:40
Jan 04 17 11:40:31
Jan 05 17 07:58:49
Jan 05 17 08:03:07
Jan 05 17 11:41:31
pm
pm
pm
am
am
am
Jan 08 17 01:02:53 pm
Jan 08 17 02:41:07 pm
Jan 08 17 10:13:18 pm
Jan 09 17 01:40:52 pm
Jan 09 17 01:51:18
Jan 11 17 03:11:49
Jan 11 17 04:45:00
Jan 12 17 06:39:14
Jan 14 17 05:47:35
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Jan 14 17 08:31:43 pm
Jan 16 17 01:33:04 am
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
More variety.
The cute shop (sadly closed down)
Excellent
Another pub
Grocers butchers and deli
It appears to be a very food-centric strip of shops which is fine; if anything
I'd like to see more food options like decent delicatessens, etc.
Less Asian restaurants; more speciality food stores (not chains). Higher-end
shops, including clothing; remove junky two dollar shops. More diversity of
nightlife - especially a few more bars would be wonderful.
We're slowly loosing some shops, like butchers, bakers.
Would love to see a bar that serves craft beer mixed with family friendly
dining.
A gelato cart/shopfront.
Later night coffee spot.
Coffee shop like Starbucks
Greater diversity of shops away fro Asian Dumpling restaurants.
Too many asian restaurants and asian vitamin shipping outlets
More breakfast brunch dinner service
No more of those Chinese mail order shops. They do not add anything to
the street life of the strip. More variation in restaurants.
more carparking
Newsagency closed. A loss.
Less shipping shops (are they even legal?) and less of the same-same
Korean/Chinese dumpling shops.
Love to see:
a wine bar in the strip (so one doesn't have to go to the Rosstown for a
drink).
other new restaurants/cafes like Leftfield (fewer chains).
Kids suggested an ice-cream shop.
Need fewer of:
massage joints (seriously since when did the world need so many they are
everywhere).
We're missing a newsagent! E could do with a few more real retail stores...
Clothing, housewares, gifts etc. We seem to be going backwards.... Less
diversity and more and more Asian vitamin and baby milk stores. Enough
already.
Gelato
Later hours
One or two more licensed venues like The William Murray :)
Rooftop areas
Fresh food.
We need a newsagent (another casualty, recently closed), and why are
there so many of the "ship overseas" outlets? They are popping up
everywhere and give off an odd vibe (closed doors, all signs in Chinese,
people emptying shelves of products so they can ship overseas at a profit
and deprive local shoppers from items they may need). It feels like we lose
a bit of community character every time a new one appears (last count was
6 that I noticed just on Koornang Road or immediate surrounds!)
Encourage diversity for food outlets.
more differing restaurant cuisines
93
Jan 19 17 04:19:18 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
Jan 21 17 06:35:30 am
Jan 24 17 01:56:15 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41
Jan 26 17 12:17:14
Jan 26 17 12:02:14
Jan 26 17 02:41:34
Jan 27 17 03:28:37
Jan 28 17 09:10:58
Jan 28 17 11:13:55
pm
am
pm
pm
pm
am
am
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 12:52:06 pm
Feb 01 17 01:36:19 pm
Feb 01 17 08:58:54 pm
Feb 01 17 09:51:04 pm
Feb 01 17 10:59:14 pm
Feb 03 17 01:54:17 pm
Feb 03 17 10:13:18 pm
newsagency
less cheap shops
The restaurants and cafes dominate with less of other more traditional
shops. I'd prefer more variety of shops so that the street looks open and
lively all day. At the moment, in the morning many businesses are closed.
Need to encourage diversity, see previous comments re Asian style
restaurants and "pop up" shops.
Over the years we have had many come and go, some are missed, some
not. The council probably doesn't have much control over what businesses
come to the area, but they need to be careful of all the planning applications
that want dispensations to the local rules, eg dispensation for parking which
needs to be maintained.
Bar (quiet, small, boutique)
Burger joint
Clothing retail
not too many of the same type of shops.. a few more cultures.. liked the
french and italian cafe opening,
ok
Newsagency, bookstore, men's clothing.
Bars, clubs
a
Better quality bakeries
Newsagents
A good mix is needed.
Clothing, pet shop, book shop, newsagent, florist, lolly shop, health food
shop, - we have none of these. We have too many of other types of shop
It is good. I do not think the council should prescribe the types of shops etc.
They will evolve with the needs and preferences of the population. However
I think the council should ensure small properties cannot be joined into
larger ones. It means there is opportunity for smaller business to gain a foot
in the street, and if a business goes broke, there is not a large frontage of
inactivity that can affect the surrounding business.
No to food chains, no to pack and post, yes to inderpendant operators, yes
to great food, yes to affordable and creative shops, yes to beauty service
shops
Newsagent !!!
as said before
ice cream parlour
newsagent
proper deli
A bar
Less Asian language vitamin stores
Ice cream shop
An ice cream shop.
A newsagent
I don't like big supermarkets and am sad that the variety of retail shops has
diminished over the years. The closure of the deli is a loss as well as the
news agent and McKees furniture. Over the years the strip has lost variety
and is becoming less useful for locals. Cafes and restaurants are good but
we need the other as well.
Modern clothing and homeware stores
Funky cafes
Continental deli
Butcher
94
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 09:04:43 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:06:15 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:28:50 pm
Feb 06 17 06:41:44 pm
Feb 06 17 06:57:40 pm
Feb 06 17 06:59:40 pm
Feb 06 17 07:05:16 pm
Feb 06 17 07:20:51 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:46:31 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35 pm
Feb 07 17 03:43:47 am
Feb 07 17 07:37:46 am
Feb 07 17 08:53:34 am
Feb 07 17 09:22:32 am
Feb 07 17 09:32:02 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:34 am
Feb 07 17 11:37:55 am
Coles supermarket!!
Clothing, shoes, handmade goods.
niche retail stores with quality stock - clothing, homewares, giftware
Too many Dirty looking cheap Asian eats. Too many dumpling shops.
Decreasing real food shops i.e. Butchers about to close poor quality fruit
and veg. Everything cheap chinses not fresh.
encourage shops that increase the fresh food diversity rather than more
restaurants. Restaurants are only open certain hours and the place
sometimes seems dead now.
Diversity of shops is disappearing, mostly replaced with yet more food
outlets. Commerical activity is creeping further out from the spine at the
expense of residential amenity.
A book shop
Can we please limit the amount of asian restaurants and shipping fronts
and have some more retail. More clothing stores and a shoe store that isn't
for grandmas. Without more retail, people are forced to go to Chadstone
and not shop locally.
Keep the essentials for everyday shopping. Chadstone isn't far away for
clothing etc.
Any chance of a "boutique" cinema?
Classier shops. No more $2 shops
More quality and less cheap shops.
Less Asian and more diversity in restaurants
Better quality of retail and more variety of restaurants
A bar
A bookshop
Bring back some retail shopping and reduce number of restaurants.
More diverse restaurants (not all Asian). More quality shops for clothes and
gifts (mostly dollar stores or charity shops)
A few clothing stores eg. Witchery, Country Road, Kookai.
I would love a mexican food place and an ice cream shop to open up.
No more Chinese restaurants
More non-food shops i.e retail outlets
improve the shop fronts of the closed shops, and improve the vitamin shops
and postal outlets sending packages to China.
newsagency, wine bar, whiskey bar, book shop with cafe, more diverse mix
of cuisines in the restaurants
More bars.
I think it would be good to have more upstairs venues, like cafes, backing
onto the carpark.
A small cinema.
Im happy with it as is
Video shop, newsagent
No more asian restaurants. More clothing retailers and lounge bars.
Trendy shops, better cafes, nicer, cleaner shops, not only restuarants
no newsagency any more
anonother major super market
Carnegie is known for the cheap eats and everyone love them. But it would
be so nice to have more retail outlets. Cloths, furniture, etc.
I go to Chadstone for the variety
95
Feb 07 17 12:54:13 pm
Feb 07 17 12:55:13 pm
Feb 07 17 01:20:27 pm
Feb 07 17 01:29:06 pm
Feb 07 17 02:22:12 pm
Feb 07 17 02:48:16 pm
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 08:42:27 pm
Feb 07 17 09:00:05 pm
Feb 07 17 09:25:41
Feb 07 17 10:35:41
Feb 07 17 11:19:05
Feb 08 17 01:26:30
Feb 08 17 04:05:54
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 08 17 05:03:53 pm
Feb 08 17 05:49:41 pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08 pm
Feb 08 17 10:49:39 pm
Feb 09 17 12:04:18 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
OK
Italian, Greek anything other then Vietnamense, Thai and asian
A bigger and cleaner supermarket, or the development of Carnegie Central
Newsagency
Butchers
Vairety of Resturants.
Clothing shops, Butcher shop,
NEWSAGENCY
COLES
AUSTRALIAN/EUROPEAN FOOD OUTLETS /no more Asian ones
WITH ALL THE FOOD OUTLETS I CANT BELUEVE THERE IS NO
ICECREAM etc .........
******A GOURMET ICE-CREAM OUTLET
AND
******A SOFT SERVE YOGHURT OUTLET
A SECOND OP SHOP - not SALVOS
more retail, a newsagency? a deli (not just the russian deli, a proper big
deli)
more variety like Deli more restruants other than asian
Need clothing shops, footwear, a nursery or flower shop, a decent
bookshop (with DVD's CD/s), video hire shop.
Newsagency if the current one is closing down.
1. Bookshop (please!!)
2. Fashion shops (good quality, attractive--They can still compete with
Chaddy)
3. More variety of restaurants.
4. Enough hair saloons. Far too many.
More retail outlets and less dumpling restaurants. Less cramped cafes.
The impact of huge numbers of single bed apartments is changing the
shopping centre... service shops have been replaced by more and more
fast food and cafes outlets.
An art shop would be good.
Florist would be good and a couple of bars.
The carparks are vey ugly, where the backs of the shops are.
More clothing stores
More variety on restaurant to and less private courier shop. It's a bit too
much in Carnegie now.
cothes and morev ariety
Not too many restaurants
clothing shops are not really there but I do not see that as a problem
Less Asian, massage and Chinese parcel and packaging shops, less
restaurants that only open at night. More food diversity
Clothing stores
Priceline
Greek restaurant
High end gift and home ware shops and fashion
less terrible Asian restaurants that no one goes to, need more decent cafes
and speciality stores like deli's, butchers, bakeries etc.
clothing and/or boutiques
Newsagency.
More variety would be good but do understand why - its so hard for
business to compete with Chadstone. Shame that the deli's and butchers
have closed down and just replaced with restaurants.
96
Feb 10 17 10:34:06 am
Feb 10 17 01:36:52 pm
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 10 17 02:38:19 pm
Feb 10 17 04:09:57 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
Feb 10 17 10:53:48 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Feb 11 17 06:53:53 pm
2 Woolworth? too many Chinese delivery shop.
Just keep the range as it is. More variety of shops to purchase every day
food items could mean that prices are competitive and that is good for the
shoppers.
Not enough diversity. Not enough 'speciality' shops such as delicatessen,
gourmet bakeries, cake shops, homewares shops, . No vegetarian cafes!
retail clothes
Another newsagent would complete the strip
More health care
More boutique stores, we have enough cafes and restaurants
Cafes
Jewelry stores. Ladies fashion of a better quality that is available.
More choice and variety, more westernised get away from being so Asian
influenced and cheep and cheerful . Classier, as an example Bentleigh's
shopping strip is fantastic, such a choice and variety,. So is Elwood and
Elsternwick are there 3 Woolworths in less than 5 minutes from each
other? Perhaps a Coles as an example, no more Asian grocers, anymore it
will look like Clayton or Springvale.
More after hours entertainment options - bars and wine bars.
Get rid of all of the crappy $2 stores and discount stores.
Feb 11 17 06:54:18 pm
Feb 11 17 07:58:24 pm
Feb 12 17 02:01:05 pm
Feb 12 17 05:59:20 pm
Feb 12 17 06:23:07 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 12:46:35 pm
Feb 13 17 05:14:39 pm
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 12:50:53 pm
Feb 14 17 01:56:09 pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09 pm
Feb 15 17 10:19:11 am
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
Feb 16 17 03:39:55 pm
The community is crying out for more quality, high class eating
establishments. For example, Left Field cafe is packed from morning to
evening every day because there's nothing else like it in the area
Middle Eastern foods and good health food, vegetarian/vegan shops.
Per previous comments - fewer restaurants, or at least more diversity in
cuisine, more retail outlets
Needs a (European style) deli. Desperately need to replace the newsagent.
It is my dream for Carnegie to have a spanish tapas bar. A nice place to
drink where there are no pokies. And a bookshop!
We need a variety of shops, not just food shops and not just Asian shops.
No Massage outlets of the rub and tug type
A deli is needed to replace the recently closed one. More clothing shops
too.
A good deli, a newsagency and a hardware outlet are sorely missed.
Continue to have a variety of food shops (not all Asian).
Encourage more clothing stores, boutiques.
Deli, newsagent, independent bakery, organic vegetable store.
These 'freight' shops do not service the entire community - they specifically
service Asian clientele and most of them refuse to serve anyone from other
cultures.
As above.
The shops and restaurants are FANTASTIC. The only addition I would
suggest is a frozen yoghurt or ice cream place....
More cafe's offering great breakfast. Split Milk is fantastic.
Better mix of types of food outlets. An Italian or greek delicatessen/small
goods.
Fish shop, one more butcher, florist
Supercheap Auto/Autobarn type outlet
newsagent needed, more deli, more diverse food places there are a lot of
dumpling places, clothes shops,
Greater diversity. Fewer/none distribution shops rather retail shops
97
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 17 17 12:21:13 pm
Feb 18 17 01:52:15 am
Feb 18 17 08:13:09 am
Feb 18 17 11:51:03 am
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 08:36:02 am
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
Increase the range, restrict the number of those packing goods for
oversease from the immediate strip.
Put heritage overlays on older buildings.
Pet shop
Toy shop
Newsagents
It was a shame to see the deli go. It's great to have local places to do your
food shopping at so you don't have to go to the supermarkets for
everything. A nice bar or similar would also be good.
More variety in food outlets - too many Asian outlets
The 90% dominance of Asian shops is good but has created a lack of
variety.
Need a news agency, milk bar, deli
Better quality cafes and restaurants for breakfast, lunch and dinner or just
coffee
Less of an Asian influence and more individual traders like the clothes
shops that used to be there.
More diverse cuisines other than Asian
Coles supermarket
Kmart
perhaps a k-mart or big W
Dress shops, Home shops, Close on of the Warehouse Sales and
Woolworths supermarkets. Jewellers, Susan, Target type shops to provide
a more balances variety of shopping for residents.
Date
Community Services
Nov 29 16 09:48:36 am
Nov 30 16 02:43:46 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46 pm
Improve public toilet near Woolworths.
Translation services maybe?
fine
fine
No comments
Library, youth centre and community hall to hold events for all.
I think our local Carnegie library, although relatively newish, is no longer big
enough. Computers are always in demand and entire families migrate in the
foyer.
A farmers market.
... I don't know - how is disability access ? Are there plenty of seats for the
elderly ?
Would love easier access to the Post Office. Library is great.
I'm not aware of any community services apart from the library
Parking in Neerim Road is nigh on impossible due to the closure of the
Station Car Parks. This is further affected by the changed demographic
caused by the influx of so many new appartment complexes.
need a bigger post office with more people working in it
Library is fantastic - perhaps some green space to lay down and play with
the kids would have been good
Good library
Not sure
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 07:44:25 am
Dec 02 16 09:21:33 am
Dec 02 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08 pm
98
Dec 05 16 11:47:03 am
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 07:21:30 pm
Dec 06 16 07:36:32 pm
Dec 07 16 08:38:49 am
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 04:57:31 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 14 16 03:36:48
Dec 14 16 09:37:51
Dec 16 16 02:04:25
Dec 17 16 09:00:42
Dec 17 16 09:36:01
Dec 17 16 02:40:19
pm
pm
pm
am
am
pm
Dec 17 16 06:10:26
Dec 19 16 12:12:19
Dec 19 16 12:37:53
Dec 20 16 08:58:27
Dec 21 16 11:20:20
Dec 22 16 08:48:44
Dec 23 16 01:44:26
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Have a Council service desk service in the Library for set times each week.
Great library.
Promote education classes or use the library more for different health
activities
I think it is quite well covered. The library is a great point for Council
engagement.
A local community childcare would be great
The area outside the library is great but it needs some grass it's so stark
and boring. Would be a nice outdoor eating area if it had some life.
Soup kitchen and other support for homeless people
Christmas Festival in Carnegie has been a non event the last couple of
years. Can't we close the street for community fun?
Nothing I can add
Public lectures of interest at Library
Community Health
Community garden
Community composting facility - where those of us who live in apartments
can bring out compost to contribute to the garden and reduce waste.
The toy library was good when my child was little.
Why don't we fix our pool up?
Perhaps better services for the elderly, especially enabling continued
connection with the community
The library is doing very well.
Public toilets. the one at the car park next to Woolworths is not at all user
friendly. Could it be revamped to make it more modern, with more than one
toilet and could it be camouflaged with some greenery so that it doesn't
stand out.
good how it is
Can't comment.
Renewal of the artisanal and art oriented talent expressed in images and
other artifacts/artworks commissioned within the precinct
Library is fantastic!
Maternal child health services are amazing
Police station
Nothing of mind.
Library and Post Office is great. Banks great.
Medicare office
Yes it is good to have a shop front option for people
It would be great if there was a Maternal and Child Health Centre in the
library complex
No
good not excellent
more centres for older generation to do activities when they come out
Youth services/ club
Almost overflowing between the parks, library, pool etc.
Ok.
A gathering area/theatre/arts centre could be a nice addition to be used for
local plays/bands or student work. E.g. like Chapel off chapel.
There is only the library. Wow . What about a learning hub. Toy library.
Gym, sports complex with a pool. Smaller than GESAC. YMCA STYLE.
Good
99
Dec 26 16 04:28:51 pm
Dec 26 16 07:01:09 pm
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 04 17 04:19:58
Jan 04 17 11:40:31
Jan 05 17 11:41:31
Jan 08 17 01:02:53
pm
pm
am
pm
Jan 11 17 03:11:49 pm
Jan 12 17 06:39:14 pm
Jan 14 17 06:04:44 pm
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 20 17 12:03:42
Jan 24 17 02:58:41
Jan 26 17 12:17:14
Jan 27 17 03:28:37
Jan 28 17 11:13:55
pm
pm
am
pm
am
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 09:04:43 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
The library is great, no complaints
The library is great
The 67 tram should be relocated to Koornang Road and Nerrim Rd to link it
to The shopping area.
Good
Library/ community centre us great.
Not sure.
Playgroup for small children and their parents.
Murrumbeena police station "in name only" I was told. I don't know where
the closest fire station is. Chemmart and bulk billing doctors on main street.
Not sure, the library is a special one. Parking is a disaster.
Ok
N/A
Library is wonderful. That's plenty for this little strip, except that railway
station could be community information hub.
Additional Wine bar / Hotel
Playground need an improvement with a better facility
The library gets very noisy because loud conversation is tolerated. Even the
so called "quiet study area" is not insulated from the noise.
RECYCLING BINS NEEDED URGENTLY.
There are no medical clinics, dentists, Medibank, Centrelink or Bupa offices.
Bicycle infrastructure
Events
Youth Group, Choir group for all ages., walking group. Advertise and create
a united community by these groups. English conversation groups. Outdoor
Movies for all ages ne'er the library.
The library is excellent
Council should have a more comprehensive presence in the Carnegie
Library. Information and access to council services should be facilitated in
the Community Centre. the Community Centre should be more visible and
provide services, not just rooms for rent.
The Community Services at the library are great.
ok
Love the library, need a park
Water fountains, more toilet facilities. Bicycle lock-up/parking.
The library is great
I believe there is still a playgroup there?
Is there enough for elderly & youth ? Am not sure
As with Melbourne generally there is an increase in people without secure
permanent accommodation, and this is occurring in Carnegie as well. I think
the best community service a council can provide is to do its most to
increase the supply of affordable permanent dwellings for the economically
marginal. Zoning around the main street should not prohibit small
apartments and any excess council land should be developed for 100%
affordable housing.
Handmade classes.
some community events in community open space.
Well equiped
more council services available locally. Better integration of library and
shopping strip.
Library is valuable. Its probably the only community service I use in
Carnegie. Are there others?
100
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:28:50 pm
Feb 06 17 06:57:40 pm
Feb 06 17 07:20:51 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55
Feb 06 17 11:26:35
Feb 07 17 03:43:47
Feb 07 17 09:32:02
Feb 07 17 10:31:34
pm
pm
am
am
am
Feb 07 17 11:37:55
Feb 07 17 12:54:13
Feb 07 17 01:20:27
Feb 07 17 02:22:12
am
pm
pm
pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 09:00:05 pm
Feb 08 17 02:03:01 pm
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 12 17 05:59:20 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
More community art opportunities
Perhaps a shop front for Council/Community Services -though this could be
more prominent at the library
More education for recycling and non smoking
Ban on plastic bags in supermarkets and shops!
Better education for recycling and stop smoking
More seats for the elderly
Are great
Happy with all the local community services / factilities. Perhaps renewing
some of the old buildings / footpaths would be nice.
Better christmas street fair since its gone progressively worse over the last
few years.
City of Glen Eira shop would be good.
Im happy with it as is
Don't know
more car parking
Community services are really good and I enjoy events hosted in Carnegie
such as the Chinese New Year event.
Seniors activities
Adequate
Street Fair
A FINANCIAL WELFARE OUTLET FOR APPLICATION AT HARD
TIMES.....Brotherhood of St Lawrence/Vinnies or ???????
COLES OR WOOLWORTHS PETROL OUTLET ..... current one sooooo
expensive and no competition
SUGGESTION BOX AT LIBRARY FOR COUNCIL ....... checked daily......
not everyone has internet
Medicare/Medibank Office.
A meeting hub like the Bank of Bendigo Meeting Hub on 438 Neerim Rd,
Murrumbeena?
Newsagent
The Library ..apart for being an ugly blot is adequate... but the child play
area is vastly inferior to the area it replaced at the time of Library's building.
Programs and activities for children and families. A gymbaroo would be
great.
Indoor sports center
RANGE OF MEDICAL SERVICES IN A MEDICAL CENTRE
More train parking
what community services, there are none.
The library precedent could seems to be used for this.
Adequate
none
Front of library more welcoming. Coffee stand near by. more colour. Art
displays from local school. Pleasant soothing music.
Citizens
No suggestions here. I think that it is a good idea to have medical clinics
and other health facilities located on Koornang Rd, but South of the
shopping precinct, as they are more accessible by car than if they were
within the shopping strip.
Library is excellent. Train is great - when it is operating out of Carnegie!
Council needs to respond to the need for more general hard rubbish
collections - ie. people who rent the many, many apartments simply leave
101
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
items on the nature strip when they move out - they do not bother calling for
a hard rubbish collection, so the Council should do general pick ups.
The library is a fantastic community space and the whole forecourt out the
front is fantastic. The programs they have running are also fantastic.
Medicare office
more parks for families
Generally more in the surrounding areas than in shopping strip. Maybe an
arts/theatre venue/hall such as restoring Carnegie Hall. Another council
venue in addition to library would be good.
Bike park racks
More car parking
It would be better to keep community services away from the main traffic of
Koornang Road.
could promote more arts entertainment community gatherings
Adequate
More childcare facilities
No comment
Date
Transport
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Nov 29 16 11:06:31 pm
Better facilities for bikes
Parking can be difficult. This has gotten worse with the recent growth in
apartment developments.
Rail underground. Enforcing car parking strictions
Maybe remove the level crossing. Perhaps lift it over the road, or under, I'm
not fussed. I'm sure whichever it is you won't get any complaints.
fine
car parking spots
More parking
direct connection of Carnegie train line to Glen Waverley line perhaps with a
bus?
Inadequate due to increase in population and proximity of Carnegie to CBD.
Traffic is shocking
Pretty good already
Carnegie ha excellent public transport
Increased bike parking would be brilliant.
Parking for visitors.
Sky Rail, - looking forward to the homeless people sleeping under it and the
grafitti and the muggings and attacks. Well done Dan Andrews, you will
finish off what the council started with all the rampant overdevelopment and
turn Carnegie into a slum.
Transport is fine, but the new rail proposals will noit allow direct access to
Richmond sporting complexes viua South Yarra.
smart bus signs for 623/626 stops - as the 623 always runs late it would be
good to know how far away it is
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09 pm
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
Feb 16 17 03:39:55 pm
Feb 16 17 05:21:55 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 17 17 12:21:13 pm
Nov 30 16 01:37:26 pm
Nov 30 16 02:43:46 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46
Dec 01 16 09:01:07
Dec 01 16 09:12:23
Dec 01 16 11:26:22
Dec 02 16 07:44:25
Dec 02 16 09:09:01
Dec 02 16 09:21:33
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
am
am
Dec 02 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 02 16 12:38:18 pm
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 02:23:16 pm
Level crossing removal by skyrail creates more problems than it solves
comparing to under ground station.
102
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
Dec 02 16 07:20:13 pm
Dec 02 16 07:23:41 pm
Dec 03 16 01:39:39 pm
Dec 03 16 06:02:26
Dec 03 16 08:24:38
Dec 04 16 08:37:17
Dec 04 16 10:13:11
pm
pm
am
am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08 pm
Dec 04 16 05:19:29 pm
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 02:13:56 am
Dec 06 16 07:53:47 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 07:21:30 pm
Dec 06 16 07:36:32 pm
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Not enough parking but no idea where you could get more from????
Fix the level crossing
Tram 67 should go into the centre, not end in a random spot on Koornang
Rd
Sky rail and the subsequent development around the station precinct will be
fantastic for Carnegie.
Not enough free parking.
More parking
All good...looking forward to 2018 with the removal, of the crossings!
Public transport is good and will be better after grade separation- totally
congested at the moment
Not sure
Level crossing removal. Better tram stops so pedestrians aren't departing
into traffic. Faster trams. Better ability for cars to overtake trams.
Transport is very good; accessible by car, bus, train and walking of you live
nearby.
More frequent bus service would be great.
Consider removing the street parking in front of The Rosstown and
Carnegie Central. There's ample 2hr free parking in the basement of
Carnegie Central. These very few cars cause congestion on Koornang Rd
and will continue even with the level crossing removed.
More parking.
Improve buses schedule pick up areas
Tram extension from the end of Truganini Road to the Carnegie Station.
Keeps the buses out and gives it the urban feel it deserves.
Also I'd be happy to pay for a car park in a multi-level building given the
challenges in getting one of the free ones on the street or behind the shops.
I think the car parks behind the shops could be better used. Given the high
value of the land now, building a multilevel carpark and developing the atgrade carparks is likely feasible.
Carnegie train station car parks were being taken mostly by people who live
in the high rise residential development next door which meant there were
less parks available for commuters. You would have to get to the station by
7.15am at the latest in order to secure a park
People doing u- turns!!!
Parking - sky rail has made parking harder but council has no alternative for
us residents - east Malvern is not Carnegie. I have to drive over rail
crossing to get there and I'm stuck at the rail gates so it is not worth it!
Parking - all these new too high developments are going up but council has
not done any extension to parking lots either side of Koornang Rd.
Why???? It is becoming a constant nightmare to park so supporting our
local shops has decreased.
The completion of sky rail.
More parking
Let's see what happens when the level crossing is removed!
What a joke! at the moment with the mess with the trains I am constantly
late for work.
Offering us fruit at the station is not going to make people change their
minds. We loved our old station and what is happening at the moment is
just unbelievable.
Transport is already great
103
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 04:57:31 pm
Dec 09 16 10:07:30 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
Dec 16 16 02:04:25 pm
Dec 16 16 02:07:53 pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Dec 17 16 09:00:42 am
Dec 17 16 09:36:01 am
Dec 17 16 02:40:19 pm
Dec 17 16 06:10:26 pm
Dec 18 16 01:09:39 pm
Dec 18 16 10:23:31 pm
Dec 19 16 11:27:41 am
Dec 19 16 11:46:20 am
Dec 19 16 12:12:19 pm
Dec 19 16 12:22:42 pm
Dec 19 16 12:26:59 pm
Dec 19 16 12:31:26 pm
Dec 19 16 12:47:03 pm
Dec 19 16 01:12:58 pm
Put some thought and planning into better walking pathways leading to the
Carnegie hub. The walking paths need to be away from the main roads or
protected with some hedges to block off some of the noise. Include going
past some interesting sites, places of interest, artwork, mosaic work,
seating, garden boxes.
good. although can not wait for the removal of the level crossing. The
traffic is horrendous at the moment and I avoid the area due to this.
Excellent
More parking. The car parks are always full from 6pm.
Transport is excellent - Let's hope the skyrail project enables local
expression of beautification of the inevidable concrete associated with the
project
The 67 and 3 tram routes should be linked from Truganini Rd along
Koornang Rd to Waverley Rd.
More Parking
The street scape could do without the oversized DustBuster style station.
Rail under road would be great!
Buses and trains wonderful. Dedicated taxi rank would be good.
Railway - needs improvement - but this is already happening
Better bus terminal at the train stations and another better stop in the
middle of the shops.
Bike parking
Traffic is a huge issue in the precint so traffic calming methods such as
more trees and some fun art work in place of some car parking. Promoting
active transport by providing more bike parking and bike events to
encourage locals to walk or ride rather than drive. Work with all the great
small business bike shops up on Dandenong Road to promote this locally.
Less parking around train stations will promote this opportunity rather than
multi-storey car parks. Work with businesses to promote workplaces that
support workers to ride such as showers, and lockers to enable them to
want to ride and somewhere safe to park their bike.
The street parking up on the corner of Woorayll Road and Koonang Road is
a nightmare as you cannot easily turn into this street given cars are allowed
to park too close to the corner which makes entry and exiting of the street
very challenging. Given we live down the other end of Woorayll Road I
often find people double park while they are waiting to pick someone up at
the station. It would be great to have a transit space for this and less longer
term parking as this makes driving down the street very challenging.
Parking south of the railway line is terrible
Good
Overhead train will be great
Rail line to go underground. Improve parking. Improve traffic flow to reduce
congestion.
good
less cars
good not excellent
N/A
good
transport hard for customers
change in the infrastructure not good to full heritage (old flats uniqueness
gone)
skyrail
104
Dec 19 16 01:19:29
Dec 19 16 01:35:37
Dec 19 16 01:49:12
Dec 20 16 08:58:27
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 21 16 07:38:15 pm
Dec 21 16 11:20:20 pm
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
Dec 22 16 08:48:44 pm
Dec 23 16 01:21:05 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 24 16 10:17:31 am
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 26 16 04:28:51 pm
Dec 26 16 07:01:09 pm
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 11:49:13 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15
Jan 04 17 04:19:58
Jan 04 17 11:40:31
Jan 05 17 11:41:31
am
pm
pm
am
Jan 08 17 01:02:53 pm
Jan 11 17 03:11:49
Jan 14 17 05:47:35
Jan 14 17 08:31:43
Jan 16 17 05:02:49
pm
pm
pm
am
parking
car parking
parking
Remove train crossing
No parking on Main Street, still one lane but allow traffic to flow easier
The train station is an absolute mess.
Its a bit stupid to have the tram ending so far away from the train line.
Greater connectivity would be good.
Less parking on the actual shopping strip - should be taken by the carparks
back a few streets.
Ok, disappointed council does not support those impacted by sky rail..but
has let the government control the structure
Bike paths. The tram number 67 route could be extended from Truganini Rd
up to Carnegie train station/the shopping strip. This would create great
alternative transport from the city, or down to cafes and shops further down
Koornang rd, neerim rd and glen eira rd.
Make it largely pedestrianised. A mall where people can walk with cars
around the periphery. Again ... Trying to prevent it becoming a traffic sewer.
Bus is very limited. I am on Frankston line as well as within working
distance to Elsternwick on Sandringham line. I am unable to use as I
require disability access re Parking.
Cycle lane
Good
more parking, less traffic. The rail crossing removal is very welcomed
Very good as is.
The 67 tram should be relocated to Koornang Road and Nerrim Rd to link it
to The shopping area.
Good
Bus Train & Tram are all available
Will be great when skyrail is completed.
There's plenty of buses.
Transport from Carnegie to Camberwell junction
Transport in Carnegie is awesome
Two tram lines (3 & 67) at either end, train line, multiple bus lines plus 15
minutes walk to Caulfield Train Station I would say there was not much
wrong with it.
Parking is a real problem with this strip.
Is well services.
Excellent
It would be nice if the train and bus services were actually synced everytime I get off at Carnegie station the wait for a bus traveling towards
North Rd is so long I just end up walking home...
Buses seem ok, but better routes needed, and station needs to work better
as a transport hub and community information centre.
Scrap the tragic Skyrail project .
Ask me again after the new station a d elevated railway has been built.
better cycle lanes
Everything is great transport-wise.
105
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
i think the area is serviced well with trains and buses and a short walk to a
tram - a benefit to being slightly closer to the city (and chadstone).
Jan 17 17 09:42:20
Jan 18 17 07:06:17
Jan 18 17 10:33:13
Jan 19 17 09:27:26
Excellent facilities!!
Bicycle infrastructure
Difficulty to moment now that Sky rail is going ahead.
Don't even get me started on sky rail and the debacle that has been. We
begrudgingly accept that it's going ahead despite local community
protestations and can only hope that the supposed open space underneath
won't turn into a poorly maintained ghetto of drugs and homelessness and
graffiti.
Integrate bus and train stops into a transport hub.
no skyrail
At the supermarket there is no room at the front of the shop for people to
leave their shopping jeep while they are choosing their purchases.
pm
am
pm
am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 19 17 11:23:52 pm
Some of the shops do not have good access for people on mobility scooters
or wheel chairs. This is unfortunate as the flat terrain makes Carnegie a
suitable area for travelling using these items.
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 25 17 09:10:02 am
Jan 26 17 12:17:14 am
Jan 27 17 03:28:37 pm
Jan 28 17 11:13:55 am
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 08:58:54 pm
Feb 03 17 01:54:17 pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
The right hand turn arrow from Dandenong Road to Koornang Road is
dangerous as cars can be waiting there for ages as the road is blocked.
Hopefully the grade separation will improve that.
Thank goodness the level crossing is going. Pity there was not more proper
discussion about Sky Rail, it may well be the best option, but there should
have been more consultation with locals.
Busses are plentiful, hopefully they will be integrated with the rebuilt station
area.
Tram at Truggannini Road is good, a little remote from the shopping centre,
but still an asset to the area.
ok
more parking with level crossing removal
fantastic publuc transporr
On road cycling lane is outdated and extremely dangerous. Major
improvements needed. Less parking (loading only).
Public transport is excellent
Walking: It is healthy, cheap, and all the population can do it. Yet the are
poor footpaths and crossing all around the shopping area. One shit example
is the red light arrangement just north of the railway crossing. The signalling
is totally retarded people have to wait forever for cars that don't exist, and
there is only one crossing point across the main street where there should
be two - one on either side of the side street. This is a shopping street for
people. People not in cars exchanging money and goods and services is
the primary economic activity so why would you discourage people not in
cars??
Safer
will be good once sky rail is done
Secure bicycle parking can be a problem in some areas.
Need more car spaces, our visitors struggle to find parking spots when
joining us for lunch and dinner.
Well serviced. Except over crowded parking from restaurants can't get into
supermarket car park at night to shop it's full
Extend the 67 tram to Koornang Rd. Better than where the line ends now.
106
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:28:50 pm
Feb 06 17 06:41:44 pm
Feb 06 17 06:57:40 pm
Feb 06 17 07:20:51 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35
Feb 07 17 03:43:47
Feb 07 17 09:32:02
Feb 07 17 10:31:34
pm
am
am
am
Feb 07 17 11:37:55 am
Feb 07 17 12:54:13 pm
Feb 07 17 02:22:12 pm
Bus drivers need better road awareness when driving down Koornang Rd.
Bus service is poor and infrequent. Not good enough for those wishing to
head cross-city. Skyrail is a blight. Traffic is dangerous and chaotic along
Koornang Rd, often takes me 10 min to move 400m, and worst case I've
had to give up after 30 min.
Better bus services
Free flowing traffic. More bike racks ..especially near the Aldi Centre.
See above for suggestions for a bus interchange near the station and more
disabled parking in the street itself
More restrictions on cars.
Too many trucks and traffic
More shoppers parking at Woollies. Gotta pick your time or walk to do
some shopping as people at the restaurants park in the Woollies car park.
Current train closures are inconvenient
Increase parking area for new development. More msrked pedestrian
crossing
Having he train there and tram nearby is fantastic. The level crossing is a
big pain, however, I am aware of plans to remove this.
More frequent buses (624,623,626,etc.)
It's great! Keep the speed limit at 40km per hour.
Put car parking underground and re-develop council carpark into open
space.
Im happy with it as is
The buses and trains are very good for me
ok
Well the Sky Rail Project is in progress and we are looking forward to
seeing it.
OK for me as is
No need for public transport, parking facilities improveded
While rail works being done ...... buses should leave closer to station ....
from DANDENONG ROAD TOO FAR FOR DISABLED AND FAMILIES
WITH KIDS ETC ....... not Morton Road of course .....other side of station
MACHINERY AND TRAFFIC FOR BUILDING SITES ......: should only enter
streets via NEERIM ..... RIDICULOUS HAVING SUCH TRAFFIC GOING
AROUND MORTON/SHEPARSON/JERSEY..... such a stupid
idea......should enter the area via Grange/Koornang then go RIGHT
AROUND SHOPPING CENTRE TO NEERIM AND UP THT WAY
Feb 07 17 02:48:16 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 09:00:05 pm
Driving down Sheparson/Belsize/Elliott/Tranmere to Neerim......parking in
Neerim is too close to corners especially if trucks/4WD etc are there.....
drivers entering Neerim just cannot see.....one needs to be in the middle of
the road to see traffic ..... VERY DANGEROUS......SO MUCH TRAFFIC ......
Cannot wait for the skyrail, Koornang Rd is a nightmare.
Level crossing should have gone underground as houses currently backing
onto railway line will be sold for more apartments.
Improved cycling lane on Koornang Rd?
hahaha what a laugh... one word .. SKYRAIL... hahah ... council is an active
participant in this vile vandalism of our suburb... unforgivable
Level crossings removal.
Hopefully trains regarding level crossing could be improved, less
congested, improve safety.
Buses to chadstone can be more frequent on weekend.
107
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
Feb 10 17 10:34:06 am
Feb 10 17 01:36:52 pm
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
Feb 10 17 10:53:48 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:53:53
Feb 12 17 02:01:05
Feb 12 17 05:59:20
Feb 12 17 06:23:07
Feb 13 17 11:02:12
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 12:50:53 pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09
Feb 15 17 10:19:11
Feb 15 17 07:38:33
Feb 16 17 03:39:55
pm
am
pm
pm
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Traffic lights behind Safeway and from library side street turning right into
Neerim Rd
other than buses there are none.
Better and safe drop off zones around the train station. In particular when
trying to drop off and pick up kids /people that catch a train into the city for
an event.
not enough parking space or need bike lane?
Parking areas need to be enlarged.
Adequate
good
Much more free parking for shoppers and commuters! I want to see under
ground car-park for all train commuters so that it will free up the streets
close to the station. Right now it is very dangerous in streets like
Toolambool road to enter and exit your home. There must be enough carparking to cater for for the future i.e. all the new residents expected with
ALL the new building permits issued for multi-story dwellings. We need to
have excessive car-parking for all the stations including Murrumbeena and
Hughesdale.
People not following road tules and doing "U" turns in the street. The road
congestion in the main road & surrounding streets.
Places to park your bike needed
Happy with public transport. More parking areas with time limit greater than
it is. At the moment only 2 hours near library. If you attend workshops which
I often do there is not enough time and it can become stressful watching
the time and having to repark so you do not get a parking ticket.
NO SKYRAIL
Looking forward the the station being finished and a new bus interchange.
Transport is ok
More car parking.
WE NEED MORE CAR PARKING FOR CURRENT AND FUTURE TRAIN
USERS, but not right next to the station, as this area would be better used
for community purposes. A 5-7 mins walking distance form car spaces to
the station would be OK
Is already good however more bus services in peak times, especially
between 7.30 and 8.30 am, would make it easier for my children to get to
school.
ie. Buses 624 and 623 travelling towards Caulfield.
Traffic is horrendous!!!!!
Well hopefully congestion will ease around the railway line once all the
works are complete and all the trucks will disappear.
There needs to be traffic lights at the intersection of Kokaribb and Neerim
Roads. This intersection is manic, and needs some control.
perfect
No issues
3 train lines
Better parking arrangements. Minimise impact of parking on surrounding
areas. Improved but chargeable parking.
Removing some of the parking in Koornang Road to visual appeal, improve
safety, widen footpaths for pedestrians and wider outdoor sitting
Where do I start? Skyrail has demolished our beautiful old heritage station
and stripped us of our community woodland garden!
When our station isn't closed the train is easily accessible and frequent as
108
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
are busses
Adequate
Disappointed with Skyrail. Would rather Rail Under Road.
Date
Private development
Nov 29 16 06:29:16
Nov 29 16 02:02:14
Nov 29 16 05:17:36
Nov 29 16 11:06:31
Nov 30 16 08:09:13
am
pm
pm
pm
am
Nov 30 16 09:25:28 am
Nov 30 16 01:37:26 pm
Nov 30 16 02:43:46 pm
Nov 30 16 10:49:43 pm
Nov 30 16 11:43:52 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46 pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 02:55:35 am
Dec 02 16 07:44:25 am
Dec 02 16 09:09:01 am
Dec 02 16 09:21:33 am
Less is more.
Too many new apartment blocks
More medium density please.
STOP with the apartments. Local infrastructure is struggling to cope.
avoid any further development that looks like the complex on the corner of
Koornang and dandenong roads
Too many apartments is making congestion
Already ruin due to large development approvals
More. We need more apartments. Each with 0.8 car spaces allocated to
them, should be plenty.
No more thanks. Enough overgrown buildings near Koornang road
keeping high -rise to the main roads so that the smaller streets maintain a
dignity
less high rises
No comments
Too many development projects are allowed at the same time on Neerim
Rd Carnegie. I wonder when all occupied, how we are going to cope with
the traffic?
Stop the development of high density apartments.
Way too many changes of premises.
You need to ensure that the largescale residential developments include
suitable commercial space. For example, the two big apartment complexes
next to the railway station have no commercial space at all, what a waste!
The ground floor of the building on the corner of Kokoribb and Neerim is
wasted on a Real Estate Agency -- perhaps there needs to be some
incentive to put restaurant space into buildings.
The number of hi rise developments in carnegie is crazy and at odds with
council policy - council considers amenity and neighbourhood character vcat just dismisses that and passes most of the applications - result is a
concrete jungle - not good
Protect great retail shops at ground level - not another realestate agents,
sollicitor office or charity shop
No more apartments needed. I hope parking doesn't get affected otherwise
I wont come as mucb
Should be obliged to provide adequate parking. No more parking
exemptions!
Way too much. koornang road was not designed for so many local
residents.
Carnegie used to have a friendly village atmosphere, it's completely gone
now. At least we won't get skin cancer, as we are always in the shade from
the rampant overdevelopment and hideous apartment blocks that quickly
look become rundown and even cheaper and nastier in appearance.
109
Dec 02 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 02 16 12:38:18 pm
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 02:23:16 pm
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
Dec 02 16 08:10:48 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
Dec 03 16 01:39:39 pm
Dec 03 16 01:48:27 pm
Dec 03 16 02:34:16 pm
Dec 03 16 05:25:18 pm
Dec 03 16 06:02:26 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08 pm
Dec 04 16 03:50:48 pm
Dec 04 16 05:19:29 pm
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 05 16 06:44:44 pm
Dec 06 16 02:13:56 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
The "flavour" of traditional Carnegie is being ruined by the many high-rise
appartment complexes.
less high density housing, the apartments are ruining the character of our
neighbourhood
Too much development-it is spoiling our community-enough is enough.
Parking is limited because of it
Too many apartments, affordable houses are what the community actually
need.
Needs to STOP - too many people as it is not enough infrastructure to
support the over development
NO MORE APARTMENT BLOCKS!!!!
keep the apartments coming if necessary but only on main roads, not side
streets
Continue to allow greater density of residential and commercial
development within the activity centre. This can only increase the vibrancy
of the strip.
Too many apartments nearby, adding to congestion on Koornang Rd.
Too many apartment & large townhouses
Loosing too many period houses
No more bloody high rise apartments.
I know that's not going to happen, It's all part of the plan to turn Carnegie
into a Ghetto.
Too congested
I'm not against development, just against crap development. We understand
the need to grow, but we need to trust the local government is doing
everything in it's power to grow in a positive way. Tougher rules to make it
harder for dodgy developers is a must. We want to be a suburb that
promotes good, sustainable and an altruistic approach to design and
development.
Do we really want to encourage more apartment blocks? How will our
infrastructure cope?
Apartment development is excessive in height and lacks quality. The uglyproblem ridden development at the corner of Koornang and Arawatta is
typical of developer making a quick dollar and leaving problems- owners
unable to obtain recompense for faulty building and community left with an
eyesore, rubbish on the street constantly. Developers need to build
apartments for real families (2-3 bedrooms with reasonable size). The focus
on students will leave Carnegie as a slum of the future
Not sure
less high rise apartments Carnegie is lossing its character it a shame
More new shops will improve the area. Perhaps large appartments will bring
more wealth to the area
All for development with appropriate height restrictions.
needs more developement of shops to multistorey buildings to take
pressure off surrounding streets
Developments should have sufficient visitor parking or cars will overflow
onto already limited street parking.
We have been swamped by apartments with very little community
consulting.
What's next more of the same?
you are currently ruining the place by letting bland new housing take over
from the lovely older style.
Dec 06 16 01:44:42 pm
110
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 07 16 01:30:53 pm
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 04:57:31 pm
Dec 09 16 10:07:30 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 09:29:29 am
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
Dec 16 16 02:04:25 pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Dec 17 16 09:36:01 am
I'm supportive of both apartments in the central core and, if workable, mixed
use and office space. I don't think Council's restriction of mixed-use zone
heights to seven storeys was necessary, especially given three ten-plus
storey buildings are approved. Perhaps a 12 to 15 storey cap would be
more appropriate.
There is too much concrete coming up in very little space
well we have far too much now - council has wrecked surrounds of Neerim
Rd Carnegie and it doesn't look like stopping.
How many apartment buildings can be built at the same time in a street and
the next street. Constant trucks and road stoppages and 7am works started
- trucks/tradies arrive from 6.15am and sit/stand around talking or listening
to music.
To relax your policy of numerous storey block of units but that's around the
shopping strip not in it.
Apartment developments should be allowed to be higher around station and
shops - lost opportunity with recent developments.
Limit new developments/extensions to 3-5 stories.
Limit investment of large multinational organisations, limit investment by
monopolies/duopolies.
Stop the hi-rises it is not what we want in this area. Families still want a
backyard for their children. Our end of Neerim rd has been decimated!
When are you going to wake up and save our heritage. I cannot put it more
strongly.
This needs to be more considered, particularly in regards to how it benefits
the community. There are too many apartments going up which impacts
road congestion and car parking as well as general amenity. A lot of
developments are cheap and ugly (Neerim Rd / Kokaribb Rd corner is a
great example).
Too many high rise apartments. Residents from these apartments tend to
park on the side streets instead of in their allocated parking spots. This
makes the side streets cluttered and dangerous.
Perhaps too much.
Less!!!
Ensure that appartments meet minimum size standards for rooms and build
quality. Most appear quite good but a couple look like they will be hovels
with a decade.
Too may apartments
The old Carnegie Theatre seems to be vacant. Any plans for that? Hope it's
not more shoddy student flats. A boutique cinema complex maybe, like the
new Lido in Hawthorn?
No more development!!!! The suburb is being destroyed!!!
There's currently enough apartment blocks on the agenda. Probably too
many actually.
Whilst I recognise the need for modernisation there should be some
overarching management of the overall aesthetics of the suburb. Somme of
the buildings are UGLY!
The character of the neighborhood is being sacrificed for wholesale
development and Nerrim Rd is in danger of becoming a wind tunnel!
Without additional parking the oversupply of apaprtments will mean
Carnegie shops are in constant gridlock.
More private courtyard seating areas in their design
There is too much development, it is all one bedroom or two bedroom and it
is fenceline to fenceline. All this has resulted in ugly high rise with no
111
Dec 17 16 06:10:26
Dec 18 16 10:23:31
Dec 19 16 11:27:41
Dec 19 16 12:12:19
Dec 19 16 12:26:59
Dec 19 16 12:31:26
Dec 21 16 11:20:20
Dec 22 16 12:00:50
pm
pm
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
Dec 22 16 08:48:44 pm
Dec 23 16 01:21:05 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 24 16 10:17:31 am
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
Dec 25 16 06:15:10 pm
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 26 16 04:28:51 pm
Dec 26 16 07:01:09 pm
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 10:43:11 pm
Jan 01 17 11:49:13 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
planting of trees or any opportunity to soften the impact of these building.
Ensure that developers do following through with landscaping plans and be
fined if they do not. So often these are required by council to help provide
privacy for the affected residents but these plantings do not happen are so
poorly down the trees fail to survive or mature
Too much
No more residential development, the infrastructure cannot support it.
shopping centre with lots of car parks
places that can fit prams in them
too much new developments
level crossing good idea
Love the idea of bringing more people into the area.
not sure what you mean, but overdevelopment is a major issue and will
destroy the feel
Greater density near the station and shopping strip is ok for a few streets
but it needs to be appropriately designed. Both in external size and form as
well as internal fit-out. There isn't a need for heaps of tiny 1 bedroom
apartments. More 2-3 bedroom places with adequate facilities.
Disappointed council has not supported residents, in what is an
overdevelopment of the area.
No apartments built directly on Koornang rd. More private parking should be
provided by developers so that apartment parking doesn't spill onto the
street.
Should have side setbacks and height limits that still allow views of the sky's
when standing on Koornanga road in front of a property on the opposite
side, the sky should still be visible within the limits of that property, likely
making that height is concentrated away from the shopping strip and side
setbacks that still allow views of the sky (without using an adjoining property
to facilitate that view). I'd love there to be 50% views left, but maybe 33%
will have to do. And views should not require raising of the head, but should
be within normal field of vision.
Yes to better community co-operative like Sandy Beach also affordable
housing in property development.
Too many apartments in Carnegie.
Seems like this suburb might get highly dense in 3-4 yrs
Not too many more appartments
Drowning in high rise. Real danger of losing community as more and more
short term residents move in who don't form connection s
It's getting very busy and parking is becoming difficult, probably because
there are more people in the area.
Less, it is starting to get overdeveloped and the buildings should be small
with no more than 12 units per building.
Art house cinema. Music venues including bars and cafes.
Less high rise development. Area us turning into a carpark!!
What would that be?
Fever high ride buildings - given that there are lots more people but no extra
parking, driving around is becoming extremely hard. If we are to keep this
pace of development, much more infrastructure is needed
Nothing higher than 4 stories an main roads
That is to be expected due to the amount of people living in the area and
how close it is to a major university.
112
Jan 04 17 04:19:58 pm
Jan 04 17 11:40:31
Jan 05 17 11:41:31
Jan 08 17 01:02:53
Jan 08 17 02:41:07
Jan 11 17 03:11:49
Jan 14 17 05:47:35
Jan 16 17 01:33:04
pm
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 26 17 12:17:14 am
Jan 28 17 11:13:55 am
Too many high rise flaw. Kills the greens spaces and forces people onto
the streets.
Stop overdevelopment
I am mindful of the availability of parking
OK if in keeping with historic feel of area.
Should be controlled appropriately.
Already overdeveloped and Carnegie is becoming an urban slum.
Too many large apartment blocks.
There's a lot nearby. Could make things worse or may drive things better.
Hard to know.
Less 4-storey high developments everywhere in Carnegie. What happened
to my beautiful suburb?
If sections are redeveloped, I think there is a need to ensure that the bottom
level is dedicated to retail space to improve the walkability and open up the
area (i.e. it is a shame the apartments built near the train station didn't have
this - this would have greatly increased the buzz and activity near the
station.
All up, while I am for development this needs to be kept in check, i think the
current density around the shopping area is sufficient - neerim road is only
going to become more crazy busy with traffic
TOO MUCH HAPPENING. How many apartment buildings can we support!
There will be no parking at the supermarkets or surrounding streets. We're
going to become a low facility housing development.
Developments which match the local style/blend in
Enough 1 and 2 bedroom. With no parking, you are creating a disaster in
waiting, you will find overcrowded units that will become a community
problem.
STOP WITH ALL THE APARTMENTS. If you're going to approve them at
least make them fit with the current community character! We are losing so
many nice older houses for yet more cheap and nasty tiny polystyrenewalled shoeboxes. Letting us down!!
Use the developer levy to provide LOCAL open space to compensate for
high density development. Large developments must provide better design
to allow for more greenery and open space.
too many units going up & too high rise in places
Greedy Developers are unfortunately taking over. There are way too many
Appartments in Neerim Road and other closer areas, they are destroying
our village with extra traffic and parking. It is also annoying when
developers are allowed to close off roads and footpaths whilst they are
building, because I guess they are greedy for profit and want to build on
every spare inch (centimetre) they can make a buck from and don't give a
damn about the locals and their amenity and enjoyment of the local area.
Development is inevitable, we must move on, but the Deovelopers have got
away with too much. I appreciate that the Council regularly gets taken to
VCAT so the Developer gets Coucil regulations overturned - don't give in to
them, we will all regret many of these developments in the future.
They also need to adhere to permits for hoardings etc, they get away with
too much and leave them up much longer than originally permitted.
ok
ugly
Too much too much.
This is out of control and is having too much impact on our streetscape and
the people who live here - this may change carnegie significantly and I fear
113
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 01:36:19 pm
Feb 01 17 08:58:54 pm
Feb 01 17 09:51:04 pm
Feb 03 17 01:54:17 pm
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:41:44 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35 pm
Feb 07 17 03:43:47 am
Feb 07 17 07:37:46 am
Feb 07 17 09:22:32 am
it won't be for the better
Minimum or no side setbacks should be encouraged in the vicinity of the
main street to develop new commercial areas. The laneways should remain
intact and developed further in new commercial areas. They minimise
pedestrian-car conflict on the main street. Shop top housing should be
allowed and encouraged.
Please stop
NO MORE APARTMENT BLOCKS
Nothing too high. 2 storeys is awesome
Walk through arcades a little shabby
I don't want to see the strip become a canyon of high rise units, as has
happened elsewhere.
Crazy overcrowding of shopping precinct. Slums of the not too distant
future.
Better quality apartment design. The blank grey high apartment walls are
overbearing around Koornang Rd. More family friendly apartments
incorporating garden space into the developments. If we are going to have
apartments (which seems inevitable) they have to be much better than what
we are currently getting. these will be slums in 20-30 years because of
poor design and quality.
Oh wow. Yes there is a lot of ugly poorly designed modern development
occuring, with moonscaping and inadequate landscape, essentially covering
their entire block, with substandard and dangerous accesways to their
basement carparks, waivers for inadequate visitor parking, reliance on onstreet parking.
No problems with development but you need to make sure that all the
applications asking for reduced parking are denied. There isn't enough
parking as it is and since that monstrosity was built backing on to the
Kokaribb Rd Woolies, you can't get a park at the best of times.
Just slow down on the development of flats/apartments, especially in
residential streets.
Be aware that there is a need for family living with schools and child care
centres in the neighbourhood.
And older people are not necessarily looking for high rise living.
More control over the rapid increase of very ugly high-rise buildings i.e. the
corner of Neerim rd -Ray White.
More stepped back development with more green spaces per building.
Stop ugly high-rise development such as the ray white on Neerim Rd
Buildings should be stepped back and have green spaces around them.
Too much heat from concrete
Stop developing. In 10-20 years, the way it's going there will be no more of
the beautiful houses that were here. It will be all units. Sad
Limit new development
There is a hell of a lot of development in the area. I live on the corner of
Jersey Pde and Belsize Avenue and there are a lot happening in both
streets. It is a serious inconvenience.
Make new developments contribute to new open space
Im happy with it as is
Don't turn all the old houses into blocks of units please, as they have no
trees or front gardens.
Would like to keep the Koornang Road shopping strip to no more than 2
stories.
Care is needed with the private development to ensure the character is not
lost
114
Feb 07 17 09:32:02 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:34 am
Feb 07 17 12:54:13 pm
Feb 07 17 01:20:27 pm
Feb 07 17 01:29:06 pm
Feb 07 17 02:22:12 pm
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 11:19:05 pm
Feb 08 17 01:26:30 pm
Feb 08 17 02:03:01 pm
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 08 17 05:03:53 pm
Feb 08 17 05:49:41 pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08 pm
Feb 08 17 10:49:39 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
Feb 10 17 10:34:06 am
Feb 10 17 11:01:20 am
Feb 10 17 01:36:52 pm
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
only near trainline
There are too many apartments however the traffic infrastructure is not
catching up with the needs of the increased population.
Buildings no higher then four stories
To be kept inline with the area and infrustructures to be update to
accomodate the increase of people and traffic.
Less or prefer no 3-4 storey apartment buildings
DEVELOPERS HAVE NO CARE FOR LOCALS......Nature strips are ruined
especially prior to building starting during advertising stage..... no servicing
of nature strips.....Fences around properties often left dangerously
unsafe......WORK STARTS TOO EARLY 0600 hours often and at
weekends..... we are bombarded by rail works and developers in Jersey
Parade.......
IN DAYLIGHT SAVING HOURS they could start later as they could work in
early evening at least up to 1800-1900 hours INSTEAD THEY FINISH AT
1500-1600 why??????
Higher development of current shops to take pressure off surrounding
residential streets, ie increase number of storeys of shops along Koornang
Road. More office space.
Too many apartments already
A beautification plan for all private developments is needed.
Since the introduction of the new residential zones Carnegie has been
destroyed.. a blitz of over sized inadequately built .. poorly designed
unsustainable apartment blocks have been dumped on residents. I am sure
the rate revenue looks good.. and I am just enjoying the car clogged streets
Keep large apartments and businesses to a minimum.
Limit apartments
has had enough development re flats & should stop!!! Now!!!
HIGHER RISE DEVELOPMENTS
Less appartments approved as streets schools and parking cannot cope
Stop developments and new apartment buildings!!
Let restaurants have more outdoor seating. This would encourage more
alfresco dining.
Stop allowing developers to knock down houses and build apartments.
More townhouses and houses. between the railway crossing removal and
all the apartment development we can barely move around.
There is just too much development occurring in Carnegie. There are far
too many apartments. Building size should be limited to 3 storeys and 4
storeys closest to train and shopping strip and 3 stores elsewhere where
apartments are being built.
Improve of the style and quality of development. Could some of the
developments not offer open spaces / more greenery? Rather than just a
concrete jungle.
too many new apartment building now. should be some for like town
house?
Too many apartment blocks changing the landscape
No more private development around the shopping strip. The area is getting
too congested with all the development of apartments.
Not really much room for any new developments
to much
Be strict with all regulations for new multilevel dwellings. Do not relax the
laws at all ESPECIALLY with requests for parking reductions.
115
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Feb 11 17 06:53:53 pm
Feb 11 17 06:54:18 pm
Feb 12 17 02:01:05 pm
Feb 12 17 05:59:20 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 05:14:39 pm
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 12:50:53 pm
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
Feb 16 17 03:39:55 pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 17 17 12:21:13 pm
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Too many units going up. Washing on balconies and cluttershould be
banned as in hotel resorts.
Feels as though we are in Hong Kong
Limit unreasonable development as we don't need it turning into a rental
transient suburb.
No more apartment complexes. The area has become overdeveloped and
losing its character.
Not enough public parking available around Koornang Rd anymore.
Very little in the way of town houses with gardens being built. Too many
apartment buildings. Families need space for children.
A small cinema? With the same boutique feel of the Classic in Elsternwick.
The increased dense residential developments mean traffic and parking in
the evening is difficult, as is dumped rubbish, trollies etc.
Limit multi story apartment buildings around the strip
Council should limit the height of any developments to 5 storeys to ensure
that no apartment is level with or higher than Skyrail.
Council must also stop its foolish practice of allowing car parking
dispensations to developers of apartment blocks. These dispensation
always end up ripping off the community of public car parking. Private
vehicles are here to stay, and students do own and drive cars too. In the
unlikely event, unused car spaces within buildings can always be
successfully converted by tenants into storage spaces on a temporary
basis.
Limit over developement in small residentail streets. If it is not called a
"road" then it is too small for 3 and 4 storey developements.
There are too many apartment blocks which is over populating the area
Crazy amount of multi storey development is ruining our suburb. Cheap
buildings with limited parking will destroy the streets and any future success
of the area. It will eventually lower the value of the area as the quality of
buildings is very average.
I don't know how apartment development will be contained, as it seems like
so many are going up all the time. The beauty of carnegie is still in its leafy
streets where kids still play cricket in the street and neighbours talk to each
other. We don't want to lose that feeling. Also, just make sure there are
enough car parks for all the apartments because otherwise street parking
will become difficult.
Stop the apartments. There are so many many apartments going up on
Neerim road, that I am very worried about the congestion - for parking and
public transport. It doesn't seem like the infrastructure of Carnegie is
growing at the same rate as apartment developments.
no more flats!! non - green rubbish flats built - how many are 3 bedroom??
the one on Neerim / Belsize is empty?? too many are just 1/2 bedroom &
there's not enough parking.
Intensity of development should be at its core rather than at fringes into low
rise residential areas
No more multi storey apartment buidings.
Preserve the older architecture style homes that give Carnegie its
character.Put heritage overlays on older buildings.
No more massive developments...
I have no issue with development and the apartments/units being built but
the area is becoming congested so it needs to be planned properly with lots
of parking, more public transport services and the like.
Don't allow too much development esp. multilevel development to intrude
116
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 08:36:02 am
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
Feb 20 17 07:29:49 pm
Date
Nov 29 16 06:29:16 am
Nov 29 16 09:48:36 am
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Nov 30 16 02:43:46 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
Dec 03 16 01:11:04 pm
Dec 03 16 02:34:16 pm
Dec 03 16 06:31:54 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 07:17:49 pm
on the surrounds, esp. when we have beautiful old character houses, which
tie in with the surrounds, disappearing. These new developments not only
overcrowd the area, but strip the area of any character. In compensating for
the trees we are loosing with the new station planting more trees on nature
strips, more tree lined streets
Less multistorey apartment buildings
No high rise developments
Too much High Rise development in suburban streets has ruined Carnegie.
They would have been better restricted to the Dandenong Road.
High volume of over development. Need to keep it in check to maintain the
community feel of the area.
Survey Response Carnegie
Other
With the over development and increase of people, there needs to be more
parking. There also needs to be more monitoring of illegal parking. Double
parking in main streets near the station and shops is extremely frustrating to
the locals doing the right thing.
Need way more parking!! Pedestrian crossing near Nandos.
Car parking is a bloody nightmare. Double edged sword, I love the liveliness
of koornang but am annoyed when I can't Park to grocery shop b/c too
many punters at the restaurants.
Better access and parking for bikes would help this
Perhaps a council that can actually make a significant difference to any of
the above. Last I checked Glen Eira can't and don't have any say on what
retail / shops are in the strip.
some days a clean up of lanes would be nice
more car parking and short duration spots for quick turn around shopping pick up food orders, milk and grocery shopping, etc
No comments
Traffic conditions along Koornang Rd, Neerim Rd and Murrumbeena Rd
should reflect the real conditions of over development. Perhaps the traffic
should be one way on one road and more restrict conditions same as the
Glen Waverley shopping strip.
Carnegie could take advantage of the current interest in beer to have a
brewpub or even an urban winery. Would certainly draw people to the area.
My husband will travel to find a brewpub like Bad Shepherd in Cheltenham
or Two Brothers in Moorabbin.
Car parking - we need ease of parking. Consider developing the car park
near the library Make that multi storey
we need permit parking restrictions on both sides of Chestnut St Carnegie
now.
Even greater diversity of restaurants
Due to so many apartments being built Carnegie is loosing that unique
feeling of a close community.
The planning in the area is a significant issue. There have been so many
flats/new dwellings erected but zero assessment on impact to the shopping
precinct or parking. Council should be ashamed about the changing
character of the neighbourhood. Cheaply constructed dwellings replacing
weatherboard Edwardians and California bungalows. Disgraceful!!
Swimming pool open all year round...
I would like to the keep the community feel. Glen Eira news paper stand
117
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 07:36:32 pm
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 10:07:30 pm
Dec 11 16 01:55:48 pm
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
Dec 11 16 06:14:48
Dec 12 16 04:28:28
Dec 15 16 12:59:07
Dec 15 16 08:59:06
Dec 16 16 12:06:19
Dec 17 16 07:35:05
Dec 17 16 09:00:42
Dec 17 16 09:36:01
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
am
am
and notice board. Courts for tennis, basket ball. Grass and Nature.
The strip could use a bit of 'jazzing up' perhaps with some re-paints and
plants along the road.
Higher Maintenance of the buildings or smaller streets to avoid the feel of
"old and dirty"
Thank you.
An increased pride of some of the retailers to tidy up their shops/better
presentation/appropriate (professional looking) signage. In particular at
night when there are so many people wandering the shopping strip after
dinner, attractive window displays would certainly improve the look and also
hopefully provide interest for people to visit not only for dinner but make use
of the other retailers
Better bike linkages along the entire Koornang Road strip.
I'm not sure who owns the car park out the back street with the old
Woolworths supermarket but it is an absolute disgrace - needs a big tidy up
an enclosed off dog leash are where we can take dogs and train them
without opportunities for them to run out of park and onto road please
Nothing I can add
CCTV everywhere around shops and parking areas
Bike racks
Water fountains
More seating
Activities to get community members engaging with one another.
All spaces, transport, retail stores and cafes/restaurants to be accessible for
people with disabilities.
The amount of garbage left lying around is just revolting. Can you not learn
from other councils that do not have this problem. I go to Brighton and do
not see piles of rubbish left for weeks and weeks. The system of ringing in
to get your garbage picked up is not working. Most people just dump it and
leave it. In fact we have a woman in our street that regularly puts her
rubbish (she is a hoarder) on other people's nature strips as she does it so
often that she has had warnings. It goes on deaf ears. The same out of
back of the shops it is filthy!
Greater heritage preservation. Gary Peer offices on Koornang are used to
have beautiful lead light windows which were ripped out to modernise the
office. Lovely old homes ripped down for non-descript apartments. Things
like that are preventable. Carnegie will look very bland and ugly if heritage
is not maintained.
Beer garden.
Trees, Greenery
More trees. Upgrade Koornang Rd street furniture. This year's Christmas
decorations have hit a new low.
greenery , cleanliness, seating lighting , refer to previous answers
Nothing
Save our beautiful mature Gum trees on the north and south of the station.
Drone racing area
better parking once the train line goes in
Better Christmas decorations
Farmers markets
The councils street planting are an opportunity to improve the appearance
of the area but I do not support the coucnils policy of planting indigenous
trees as this results in ugly slow growing non shaddy trees.
Select trees such as we see in Stonnington or Boroondara which greatly
118
Dec 17 16 02:40:19 pm
Dec 18 16 01:09:39 pm
Dec 19 16 11:54:38 am
Dec 20 16 03:50:39 pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44 am
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Jan 01 17 10:43:11 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 03 17 05:38:54 pm
Jan 04 17 11:40:31 pm
Jan 08 17 01:02:53 pm
Jan 14 17 06:04:44 pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 04:19:18 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
Jan 21 17 06:35:30 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
add to the beauty of their suburbs
People collecting for charities are pushy and intrusive meaning you can't
relax near the library if they are there
Need parenting rooms for nappy changes and feeding
Less apartment blocks - stop overdeveloping
allow people to do more on the outside of the shop so its more attractive
More carparking. Carnegie has become a 'destination' for people from other
suburbs. Whilst this is great, carparking has become difficult.
parking arrangements - there is not enough.
the speed limit on Koornang road needs to be reduced to 30km/hr,
permanently, any time of day. To have illuminated signs displaying '60' is a
joke and very dangerous. it does not fit with the current volume of traffic,
pedestrian and cars.
Change the dodgy asfelt and red brick pavement on the strip and
sourounding streets. It makes the place cheap and dismal. Pave it with
sandstone brick, they did this in mornington it makes a huge difference the
the look and feel of the street.
More parking should be provided near the station so that it doesn't spill onto
nearby streets (e.g. down Blackwood St).
Gym, strength training, dance therapy as well as dance classes..
Nice street landscaping and artwork. And TREES
Like Creperie, Lizzy's, JJs, Huff, Chemist Warehouse (although it is very
cramped on southern side of railway). Aldo's Butchery was good too...
Streets and car parks could be much, much cleaner!
Would really love the strip to get a tiny make over so it looks fresh and less
outdated. The cheap stores bring down the look, so it would be great to get
some new modern small shops or cafes/restaurants.
keeping the facades and buildings well maintained. Clean footpaths and
sitting areas. Pavement life.
No skyrail
Please preserve the historic feel of this strip - that's a key reason it works.
The encroachment of huge lumps of modern apartments isn't great.
Regular gutter and footpath cleaning, cleaning of rubbish bins would
eliminate bad smells and grubby appearance.
Something that we could really use is access to a walking/ bike trail. Too
many large roads around us to make walking and bike riding safe. PLEASE
MAKE AN EXTENDED WALKING/BIKE TRAIL UNDER THE SKYRAIL .
Please please please. With lots of greenery.
community gardens, match schools with aged care facilities to help create
community.
Some restaurants other than dumpling places would be nice!!
Take ownership of the management of the land freed up by the LXRA to
make it a high quality public space for a range of community uses.
I'd also like a requirement that all shops have their name in English as some
businesses only have a foreign language. Foreign languages are fine but
there should be English versions at all premises as well.
Finally, I'd like all premises to display street numbers.
Glen Eira council overall does a pretty good job, can't please all the people
all the time, but thanks for trying.
More trees and flower beds
Killing the goose that laid the golden egg with overcrowding
overdevelopment and poor quality. Will soon look like China town spingvale
with little or no monitoring of developments
More graffiti type art work. Include young people and draw young people
119
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 07:20:51 pm
Feb 06 17 08:46:31 pm
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
Feb 07 17 12:02:21 am
Feb 07 17 03:43:47 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:34 am
Feb 07 17 02:22:12 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
into the space. Skate park nearby would be great - maybe under sky rail.
use green space to encourage community and interaction. this is important
when we have more people living in apartments. Social connection is a
huge indicator of wellbeing and increased longevity.
I haven't seen a "vision" for how Carnegie will function in 10, 20, 30 years
from now with all the development. It appears to be a recipe for disaster
since traffic will only get worse, and people don''t have open space in safe
convenient walking distance, and only 1- and 2-bedroom apartments are
being built, all targeted at a narrow segment of the population.
Smoking ban in street.
More design elements such as Rita's mosaics
Discourage smoking
Discourage advertising in Chinese only
More rest areas and seating
Carnegie has lost itself. Was once a lovely place to live, now I tend to stay
at home and go else where to do my shopping. No heart anymore.
Please reopen Carnegie Theatre, its a great shame to see it closed and
unused.
clean up the alley ways and carpark rubbish tips
Make sure there are plenty of seats.
The area in front of the library which leads to Koornang rd could be
improved; invite artists to create things here. Allow musicians to perform
there. Have a Hawker's Stall night market there in summer, or even in the
Library car park.
More ways for people to cross the street - make the "fake" crossing a real
crossing, remove ugly brick barriers. Make the place feel like people are
prioritised instead of cars.
Don't know
All in all, I really love Carnegie and hope our town can become an area
people love to visit not only for the cheap eats but for leisure, shopping, and
more
THE PROXIMITY TO THE LIBRARY/STATION/WW IS BENEFICIAL TO
ME WITH A DISABILITY BUT THERE IS SO MUCH IMPROVEMENT
Need to determine why many shops in the strip do not last.
Carnegie was a quiet efficient middle suburb... well serviced by public
transport and with an excellent shopping centre... it is hollow leftover now
as house after house is knocked over and shop after shop becomes a
cafe... it is unliveable and ugly
Do not replace small businesses with large retail chains. Do not get rid of
the large number of cafes, restaurants and small food stores. Another
delicatessen would be great.
Shops must display English. Some are showing Chinese writing only. Not
ok!!
more car parking
Priority needs to be the cleanliness of the environment to create a good
atmosphere. Ensure paths are hosed down and cleaned on a regular basis.
Trees to beautify the landscape.
Keep the roads clean, the nature strips mowed, the kerbs maintained free of
weeds. Show Carnegie some love, care more about the astetic facade of
the suburb.
Thank you!
Thanks for this opportunity to have a say. I just hope that this is not another
window-dressing exercise as we experienced with Sky Rail.
What is happening next to Carnegie Pool? I thought they were putting in
new multi use courts? It just looks like a car park.
120
Feb 14 17 03:19:09 pm
Feb 15 17 10:19:11 am
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29 pm
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
What are three things that would make Carnegie
shopping strip fantastic?
Date
Nov 28 16 06:02:24 pm
Nov 29 16 06:29:16 am
Nov 29 16 09:48:36 am
Nov 29 16 02:02:14 pm
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Nov 29 16 06:57:25 pm
Nov 29 16 11:06:31 pm
Nov 30 16 05:37:26
Nov 30 16 09:25:28
Nov 30 16 01:37:26
Nov 30 16 02:43:46
Car park, car park, car park
No particular issues
knocking down Carnegie & Murrumbeena stations was criminal vandalism.
protect our lovely suburb.
Just to add emphasis - Put heritage overlays on older buildings, do not
allow old buildings and houses to be demolished and replaced with
inappropriate buildings. - Carnegie's future is in your hands - please protect
the village character.
Stop appartments!!
To many renters that do not care for our community
Not allowing charities to hound passers by into signing up to monthly
donations
please allow the Pigeons and other animals to stay, it adds character and
some people especially the children enjoy the animals
Koornang road gets very busy, difficult to drive through
Improved safety at night
Overall, I feel that the heart has been ripped out of Carnegie to cater for
students and overseas developers at the expense of Carnegie's long term
residents who have been enjoying a quiet family community suburb.
am
am
pm
pm
Nov 30 16 04:37:55 pm
Nov 30 16 10:32:17 pm
Nov 30 16 10:49:43 pm
More non asian dinner restaurants
Bookshop
Major clothing and footwear store
Parking
Less food outlets of the same kind
More variety of shops
Cooler shops - cafes and boutiques. More parking.
Outdoor dining
More parking
Better traffic flow
Closed to cars permanently.
Later trading hours
More bike infrastructure on road and parking
More variety in food offerings.
Wine bar
Some plants, better parking (more short term) more retail options not just
restaurants
Trendy cafes, more parking
More sophisticated eats and drinks, improve aesthetic
Variety of shops, needs to be cleaned up, rail underground
More diversity of outlets / restaurants, more available car parking and no
parking on the main strip. That would make Carnegie great again.
If it was cleaner and the rubbish bins were emptied more often.
Another European-style deli
Quality cafes (Santucci's has gone)
Retaining local butchers
More retail clothing/ gift shops
More pathway room in front of shops
Remove the terrible smell when you walk thru the car park to woolwortgs
121
Nov 30 16 11:43:52 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 12:51:45 pm
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 07:43:36 pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46 pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 12:12:05 am
Dec 02 16 02:55:35 am
Dec 02 16 07:44:25 am
Dec 02 16 09:09:01 am
Dec 02 16 09:10:50 am
Dec 02 16 09:21:33 am
Dec 02 16 10:02:16 am
Dec 02 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 02 16 12:38:18 pm
near the charity bins. The smell from the supermarket is atrocious
Near, variety, safe
a bit more open space which I hope will be provided when overhead lines
are finished
1. A discount department store (such as Big W, Kmart or Target)
2. The addition of a Coles supermarket would give consumers more options
for groceries.
3. More food options.
more car parking spots
less high rises overlooking it
gelati shop
1. Small bars/cafes
2. More outside dining
3. More events
More car park
Open space for all
Changed traffic conditions to ease the congestion along the roads.
Bars
Facelift shop fronts
Greater diversity of eateries
Get rid of cheap junk $2 type shops
Get rid of popup shops exporting goods overseas
More parking, more diversity of shops and....can't think of a third.
Less dumplings
Less high rise apartments
Less real estate agents
More commercial space in new developments, particularly aimed at
restaurants.
More diversity in restaurants.
A farmers market
Better parking
Better mix of shops
No level crossing
Design identity for the strip
Pedestrian street
European eateries (restaurants, French bakery, cheese shop, deli)
Space & time to park
Community vibe.
Green space.
Funky cafes, clothing, kids spaces.
Increased focus on pedestrian traffic - discourage cars through Koornang
Road
Increased focus on keeping the area clean and attractive
Increased use of library forecourt for public events
Temporary closing the road to create a night food market
More parking, get rid of that horrible little Woolworths, with its nasty staff
and turn it into a park. Sunlight would be nice, but too late for that as it is all
overshadowed by highrise apartment blocks
less traffic on the roads, more events/activities (like a market), continued
vibrancy
Better parking, some similar eateries could be replaced by more shops. A
Koornang Road Pedestrian Mall would be great if there was a bypass route
for motor traffic
larger variety in cafes/restaurants
122
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 02:23:16 pm
Dec 02 16 03:25:11 pm
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
Dec 02 16 07:20:13 pm
Dec 02 16 07:23:41 pm
Dec 02 16 08:10:48 pm
Dec 02 16 09:39:36 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
cafe's open slightly longer in afternnon
more trees seating areas
Variety with the shops, more community things on & a local bar that trades
after 12 midnight!
Variety of people, yummy and good quality foods, and good variety of super
markets.
- Good health food shop
- Deli
- Fish shop
More restaurant variety eg A great Italian restaurant
A bar
More parking
Remove level crossing
More open space
More bins for waste
more cafes
Fewer Asian restaurants
Increased car parking spaces
coffee shops open at night, a bar ( not hotel with pokies) trees
better paving, especially at intersection of Koornang & Arawatta
better lighting all down Koornang Rd (Dandenong Rd to Neerim)
Dec 03 16 12:07:43 pm
Dec 03 16 01:07:24 pm
Dec 03 16 01:11:04 pm
Dec 03 16 01:39:39 pm
Dec 03 16 01:48:27 pm
Dec 03 16 02:34:16 pm
Dec 03 16 04:42:15 pm
Dec 03 16 04:58:50 pm
Dec 03 16 05:25:18 pm
Dec 03 16 06:02:26 pm
Dec 03 16 06:31:54 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:38 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
getting rid of that level crossing
Fresh fish shop, another amazing cake shop, better charcoal chicken shop
More public seating
No all-day parking in adjacent streets
buskers
even more diversity of restaurants (not just Asian)
More restaurants/bars
More people walking to the strip.
Level crossing removal
Making it into a mall with no cars.
Less over crowding
More parking
More verity of restaurants
have easy acess or better public toilet in Spotlight centre.
Railway gone, national chains, variety in food
-Rail below Road.
-A descent Saturday Christmas Street festival. Honestly I don't know why
you even bother over the last couple of years.
A cool little wine/beer bar.
More parking. Outdoor eating. Small park
Remove cheap two dollar shops, improved parking, greater food options
and/or bars
More clothing stores
A great bookshop (even second hand books!)
Frozen yoghurt/bubble tea or ice cream
Different types of restaurants
More flora and fauna.
Less Diagou stores.
Another bar or two.
More cafes, less Asian restaurants and more variety
More traditional retailers - butcher, fishmonger, bakeries
123
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08 pm
Dec 04 16 03:50:48 pm
Dec 04 16 04:41:54 pm
Dec 04 16 05:19:29 pm
Dec 04 16 07:17:49 pm
Dec 05 16 11:47:03 am
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 05 16 06:44:44 pm
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 02:13:56 am
Dec 06 16 07:53:47 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 12:14:30 pm
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
Dec 06 16 01:44:42 pm
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 05:13:56 pm
Dec 06 16 07:21:30 pm
More clothing or design stores
3-4 level height restriction
Improved diversity
A decent bar
Less car traffic
There seems to be a high turnover with some of the restaurants, but that's
ok
easy parking and HOME MADE cake shop
Shady area to eat take away food...library courtyard is too sunny. Some
more retail shops. More interesting shops
Cleaner/more upkeep on shops. Traffic issues solved. A market.
Outdoor eating, fairy lights in trees, shops that transition from indoor to
outdoor Market stall area. Heaps of parking
Ban smoking outside restaurants.
Force Woolworths to transfer one of its sites to Coles.
As mentioned previously, put the large car parks underground and cover
with parks. This would remove vast asphalt heat sinks as well as provide
much needed open space in a city with so little. People would be drawn to
it.
- Having the level crossing removal finished, with that area kept free of
rubbish/graffiti
- More assortment of stores; general retail, clothing
- Some of the laneways (ie Carnegie Arcade) and car parks need to be
fixed up
Flower boxes, recycle bins
More variety of stores, open space, better public transport but less traffic on
the main street
General cleanup on the streets, modify Koornang Rd with the previously
mentioned issues and removing the level crossing.
Small bars, an upgrade of the footpath pavement, more carparks
More greener environment
Cleaner areas to sit
Removal of terrible smells outside food shop in alley way by the chemist
this is ghastly.
Less people asking for money in the street for campaign
A brighter more modern appearance it's very drab and old fachioned
Get shop keepers to do more about the appearance of their shop.
Completely non smoking, more parking, train line fixed.
Improved window displays
Public art
Greater variety of general retailers
more trees
beautiful paving
a fountain in the open space near library.
greater diversity - not so many restaurants
- Keep increasing its size - out and up - make it a destination in itself
- Some interesting other entertainment draws, for example the Elsternwick
core is anchored by the cinema (it needn't be a cinema for Carnegie).
- Better access via public transport and carparking improvements.
It already is very good
A couple of bars
Less $2 shops
More quality retailers or restaurants/cafes similar to Left Field that has
recently opened up in the area
124
Dec 06 16 07:36:32 pm
Dec 07 16 08:38:49 am
Dec 07 16 01:30:53 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:25 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:55 pm
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 07 16 09:56:41 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 10:07:30 pm
Dec 10 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 10 16 01:15:25 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 09:29:29 am
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
Grassed area in front of library.
Or a monthly market in this area that can spill into the foyer of the library.
Some young vibrant artwork on bland walls.
More parking
More parking
More parking
Wider shopping street, ample outdoor seating
Street needs to look a bit more trendy, although not too much. A french
bakery, see if the chocolate shop will move into the main area, Attract
more healthy storeowners.
Cleaner
More variety of restaurants (not just asain)
Better footpaths
more parking, cleanliness
Get rid of Sky Rail!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The variety of shops, the public transport links and its safe and secure, no
one seems to hang around without a purpose.
Trees?
CCTV (safety)?
Parking (but where?)
New station and landscaping
- buying from local shops and producers, rather than big franchise /
duopolies.
- buying items without unwanted extras, ie. less/no plastic bags/packaging
- ending the day with a nice meal / coffee and listening to some great music!
More Green good looking spaces
More diversity in shops
Being able to park without driving around for ages
Better retail
More variety in restaurants (no more dumplings venues are needed)
Green space including safe places to chain bikes while you shop
More open spaces along the shops where people sit and talk and meet
each other.
Public artwork
A bike parking centre with facilities to increase the comfort level for cyclists.
variant in cuisine available
icrcream shop
less traffic
The crossin removed faster.
A beer garden.
Kmart.
Great food
Amazing library
Friendly business owners
Some more "cool" retail shops. (aka mint & co)
One or two more cafes
Bring back another deli - we miss the carnegie deli
More visual expressions of the cultural diversity. As mentioned employing
local artists, including indigenous artists to aid the artification and
beautification of our gorgeous urban village. This will compliment the cafe
culture and young innovative vibrancy of the diverse population of Carnegie
and invite others to visit and spend as it will speak to the cool culture of
inner-middle suburban Melbournians
Florist, clothing stores, more fresh food eg a deli.
Didn't I suggest this previously?
125
Dec 11 16 06:14:48 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 12 16 04:28:28 pm
Dec 14 16 03:36:48 pm
Dec 14 16 09:37:51 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
Dec 15 16 08:59:06 pm
Dec 16 16 12:06:19 pm
Dec 16 16 02:04:25 pm
Dec 16 16 02:07:53 pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Dec 17 16 09:00:42 am
Dec 17 16 09:36:01 am
Dec 17 16 10:26:51 am
Dec 17 16 02:40:19 pm
Dec 17 16 06:10:26 pm
Dec 18 16 01:09:39 pm
Dec 18 16 10:23:31 pm
Dec 19 16 09:03:13 am
Dec 19 16 11:27:41 am
Dec 19 16 11:54:38 am
clean, update with regard to furnishings, greenery, movement, less
congestion with regards to traffic, having an inviting atmosphere to bring
people to and stay.
1.More diversity in the kind of shops and restaurants
2. Less shops selling formula
3. Deli and news agency back. A florist too!
Already is fantastic
1) Improved traffic management around congested intersections
2) Sufficient free parking in walking distance to the shops
3) More street lighting
More pedestrian space.
More public art
A performance venue (already in Library?)
Rail under road.
Rail under road.
Rail under road
Markets
Free wifi
More parking
- a "target urban' or cotton on or similar big store
- a large restaurant/bar with modern cuisine
- more kids activities around the library open area
Better parking
More connection between the two ends- either side of the railway line (more
park, meeting and open space under SkyRail with some
artspace/performance space
Diversity of shops- keep fresh food and utilities dont just have one sort of
restaurant
- more good coffee shops
- known retail stores
- cool wine bar/s
Health food shop (not the only milk and vitamins type)
Bus stop
Cycling hub (tools, drink fountain etc) near the pathway that is separated
cycle and walking
More parking at peak times
More independent design shops
No boom gates
promotion of active transport
more art and cultural vibrancy such as appearance of shops and local
events that reflect the diversity of the area
more landscaping and height limits
Cocktail bars, dessert place, open later at night.
Garden space
Parenting room
More parking (undercover would be a bonus)
More parking. More parking, more parking
Lessshop wastage, more plants and greenery, different types of shops
Improved traffic flow and reduced congestion.
rail line to go underground.
No more residential development.
Park
Kmart
news agency
more car park
126
Dec 19 16 12:12:19
Dec 19 16 12:22:42
Dec 19 16 12:31:26
Dec 19 16 12:47:03
Dec 19 16 12:59:44
Dec 19 16 01:09:43
Dec 19 16 01:12:58
Dec 19 16 01:16:30
Dec 19 16 01:19:29
Dec 19 16 01:40:30
Dec 19 16 01:49:12
Dec 20 16 03:50:39
Dec 20 16 08:58:27
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 21 16 11:20:20 pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44 am
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
Dec 22 16 08:48:44 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 23 16 08:02:16 pm
Dec 23 16 10:35:02 pm
Dec 24 16 06:19:24 am
Dec 24 16 10:17:31 am
Dec 24 16 09:58:08 pm
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
Dec 25 16 06:15:10 pm
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 26 16 04:28:51 pm
wine bar/ cafes/ more access to public toilets
diversity, fresh produce etc
more open free spaces for parking
less noise
more outdoor eating. Fresh signage (fresh paint)
good dinner area
better parking, different shops
increased security
sustainable garden at forecourt
clear good/ any loo signs near library and where to go if library closed!
maintain the heritage
More alfresco dining areas.
Better parking facilities.
Better public toilets/ baby change options
A trendy bar/restaurant
Inspired cafes
More space to eat at restaurants outdoors and heating along the street front
where restaurants have public dining
rail under road - Skyrail is a disaster. With Koornang road underground,
you can transform the shopping strip to a pedestrian mall. This will open up
opportunities for retailers, bring in more variety, allow for cafes and
restaurant to expand their outdoor seating areas. NOT having more
Chinese/Asian export businesses open up would also be fantastic.
More verify of restaurants and shops
Remove the asfelt and red brick pavement.
Plant more trees
More open space - maybe even like Oakleigh in being a mall
More greenery
More on street eating - cafes, restaurants, bars
Greater variety of shops.
Improved access.
Better open space.
Bike paths, trams going up to Carnegie station, an arts centre/theatre to
have local events like plays and bands play.
Open space, more night drinking spots,
Sky rail
Sky rail
Sky rail
It is fantastic
More green, nicer ground to walk on, pedestrianised and maintaining sky
views.
Festive, mini playground,
Community Food Garden, gazebo with parkland or greenery, a gym, pool
small hydro pool.
Restaurant
Coffee shops
Bakery
Weekly markets, small bars, more coffee shops/cafes.
Longer opening hours for cafes.
Asian restaurant with English signage (some feel unwelcoming to
westerners - don't know if that's intended but that is the effect)
1. More Non Asian restaurants
2. No rail crossing
127
Dec 26 16 07:01:09 pm
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 27 16 08:11:33 pm
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 08:00:46 pm
Jan 01 17 10:43:11 pm
Jan 01 17 11:49:13 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15 am
Jan 03 17 05:38:54 pm
Jan 04 17 01:44:07 pm
Jan 04 17 04:19:58 pm
Jan 04 17 08:52:40 pm
Jan 04 17 11:40:31 pm
Jan 05 17 07:58:49 am
Jan 05 17 08:03:07 am
Jan 05 17 11:41:31 am
3. More parking
Longer trading hours
A better variety of shops
More shops on the Dandenong rd side of the railway tracks
A cake shop
Easier access to the car parks
More outdoor cafe seating
Better food options, better parking, cleaner arcade area between street and
car park near Woolworths
Greenery
Art house cinema
Bookshop
Some attractive street plantings and updated bins/chairs - give it more of a
village feel
Better parking (ie. more of it)
Increased retail offerings - greater diversity as per previous answers
More of Rita's art work
A deli
Another butcher
More diversity in eating places, keeping it cleaner and less high rise
development in the surrounding area.
Diversity of dining and more retail outlets rather than vitamin wholesalers.
Easy access to most things in the same area....
More chain retail stores eg nine west, a couple of great winebars with a
beer garden.
More greenery (some nice trees or colour), a revamp so it's a little more
modern, couple of new restaurants or bars.
Less shops of the same type (dumplings), actual shops that sold stuff other
than food (there used to be more back in 2000/2001), more small business
encouraged such as the William Murray Tavern.
1. Holding on to a few essential retailers
2. Better parking facilities
3. That's all I've got - I really love the strip already!
extend it along koornang road with more diversity of outlets... and neerim
road.
i do love the Carnegie North centre also... i've not mentioned that and i am
there most days
the carnegie woolworths (the old one) becoming coles
More atmosphere and night life - cool cocktail bar
I wish I knew. It is good anyway but could be better somehow. Maybe
some plaques acknowledging who and what the original shops were and
some glazed pictures of the hops and various local historic features Railway Station, Memorial Hall, Cattle auction yard, Carnegie cinema and
mansions up to the railway line.
Nothing, it is already.
Not building skyrail
Shops open longer
More cafes
A new dive bar
An independent gourmet burger place
A wine bar
Restaurants cafes and atmosphere
- A cohesive, functional and contemporary aesthetic to the strip
- Better lighting of the linkage between Koornang Rd and the eastern
128
Jan 08 17 01:02:53 pm
Jan 08 17 02:41:07 pm
Jan 08 17 10:13:18 pm
Jan 09 17 01:40:52 pm
Jan 09 17 01:51:18 pm
Jan 11 17 03:11:49 pm
Jan 11 17 04:45:00 pm
Jan 12 17 06:39:14 pm
Jan 14 17 05:47:35 pm
Jan 14 17 06:04:44 pm
Jan 14 17 08:31:43 pm
Jan 16 17 01:33:04 am
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 19 17 04:19:18 pm
carpark (adjacent to Nandos) as it feels dodgy at night.
- Some work on the eastern carpark as it seems tired and shabby
More trees, more speciality high-end food shops and less Asian
restaurants.
1. A mall without cars between Neerim Rd & Rosstown Rd.
2. Trees through same section.
3. Market areas - perhaps on weekends in car parks.
No parking on the street/no through road. More natural space to meet with
friends. Coffee bar or later night options.
Filtered water fountains
Casual bar/cafe
Greenery to sit away from cars
More diverse range of shops.
Wine bar / meeting place in central Koornang Road.
Scrap the Skyrail project that is a local disaster and will be an eyesore.
Better parking, more diverse retailers (not just eateries) and a more
attractive streetscape/less rubbish
More car park
More variety in restaurants. A newsagent. Nightlife.
Clean toilet block. One which is scrubbed clean not just hosed out.
Sign board with local map and information.
More trees or shrubs.
working the way it is in my opinion.
love the Carnegie festival and open area in front of the Library for open
shows
Decent men's clothing shop. Kitchenware shop.
Recycle bins, more greenery, less international shipping outlet shops.
Reinvigorated asethetics (i.e. improved upkeep/maintenance, improved
green space/street trees - think WSUD).
more open space for activity (thinking this fits under the train line)
Wine Bar (yes I like my wine).
Some high class retail stores. Some green areas (including in front of the
library)
Access to walks and riding paths.
Rooftop bar/cafe
Better bicycle infrastructure
More of it! (Bring more down to the North road end near Left Field!)
1) Area's to meet and share food and drink.
2) Free Yoga and Thi Chi classes Sunday AM.
3) Free movies or motivational Speakers each month.
Some night time entertainment - a bar or two (not just restaurants and the
Rosstown!!)
Support local business so these long-standing establishments (newsagent,
deli, butcher) don't have to close down
The regular street parties are excellent and should continue
The people
The diversity of food outlets
Convenient pedestrian access to services
differing shops & cuisines
more parking
a total clean up & replacement of paving & seating
Somewhere for community groups to set up a stall or table, probably at the
Koornang Rd end of the library entry. Community groups should be able to
conduct sausage sizzles and similar, like at Bunnings
129
Jan 19 17 11:23:52 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
Jan 21 17 06:35:30 am
Jan 24 17 01:56:15 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 25 17 09:10:02
Jan 26 17 12:17:14
Jan 26 17 12:02:14
Jan 27 17 03:28:37
am
am
pm
pm
Jan 28 17 09:10:58 am
Jan 28 17 11:13:55 am
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 08:58:54 pm
Feb 01 17 09:51:04 pm
Feb 01 17 10:59:14 pm
Feb 03 17 01:54:17 pm
Removal of the rail crossing
Mens and womens clothing shops
1. Completion of the grade separation project including new station at the
level crossing.
2..Establishment of a fantastic fun restaurant that would attract families who
are visiting the new Lego world at Chadstone.
3. I am very pleased that the Carnegie Traders Associataion are having a
Chinese New Year celebration this year.
Tidy up by council, owners, tenants and developers.
New station precinct and removal of the level crossing will be a big
improvement, provided it is done properly.
A greater diversity of shops/businesses.
Better shop front design, flower beds and trees
more nationalities shops, keep it an affordable shopping experience.. love
$2 shops surving
Cultural events, easier access to the area with ample parking and
movement of vehicles, ongoing variety of shops and cafes/restaurants.
level crossing removal, easier parking, less traffic
Control rent rise by greedy landlords so good business dont leave.
Bars, clubs, park
Safe on-road cycling conditions.
People-centric, village streetscape.
More ped crossings.
Close proximity of everything
Choice of shops
Ease of access
Get rid of the railway line
Improve the parking
Get rid of the "shops" that are really export businesses
1.Traffic: 30km/h 24/7 speed limit enforced with speed cameras. In order to
increase safety, make the street more relaxing and enjoyable for its users
and increase the permeability across the street which increase economic
activity for business.
2. Car parking: No minimum car parking requirements for private
developments. No more council subsidized car parking. Car parking is not a
public good and cars are not economic activity, they are just are means of
getting somewhere and a very expensive one. I am a local business owner
and 95% of my customers arrive by walking, cycling or public transport yet
so much public money is spent on car infrastructure. Why?
3. Develop cycling infrastructure. People in the area actually enjoy cycling,
but it is to dangerous or inconvenient. The Victorian standards for cycling
infrastructure are not adequate and reflect in the low cycling rates. The
council should look overseas, especially The Netherlands where they have
made all the mistakes and have very good infrastructure and high cycling
rates. There is no need to reinvent the wheel.
Stop all development, stop pack and post shops, keep rent reasonable for
inderpendant non chain operators
A bar
More cafes
More shops that aren't vitamin or hair dressers
Streetscaping. Paved footpath. No skyrail
No train crossing. Big trees. A grassy park
1. More variety in the type of retail outlets.
2. More greenery.
3. Less traffic.
130
Feb 03 17 10:13:18 pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 12:07:39 am
Feb 05 17 09:04:43 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Better shops and restaurants and cafes
More local stores.
1. A facelift: replace all the poor street trees that have died over the years?
give the library forecourt some shade?
2. friendlier people: (a big ask) not a bad neighbourhood, but not a great
atmosphere either.
3. ???
movie theatre
Less dumplings more quality shops not everything needs to be $2
1. Redevelop the Woolworths and carpark with increased car parking, well
designed apartments and green space as well as new supermarket and
even a fresh food market. This carpark is a wasted opportunity, too small
for current demand and ugly.
2. Better integrate the library and services with the rest of the strip
3. Encourage a diversity of businesses to prevent Koornang Rd becoming a
restaurant strip.
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:06:15 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:28:50 pm
Feb 06 17 06:57:40 pm
Feb 06 17 07:05:16 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:46:31 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
If really really brave, banning of cars from Koornang Rd. Street trees.
Bolder setbacks of 3rd and higher levels of multiunit development to restore
a more pedestrian-friendly scale
1. more free events and a night time economy
2. Gigs, festivals and events
3. A regular market that supports local producers
Better range of shops.
A wine style bar.
More footpath seating for cafes etc
Maintaining the shops that meet everyday needs
Space for a farmers market/street stalls on an occasional basis
A cinema
A Sussan, Witchery or Country Road
Fewer dumpling restaurants
Shade from trees
Better variety of shops and restaurants
Smoking ban
More variety of shops and retail
More shade
Less traffic
Reduce number to of restaurants.
All shops to display English as well as characters.
Reduce the smell.
Restaurants
Close by
Value for money
A few nice clothing stores.
A nice ice cream shop during summer.
Fixing up some of the old footpaths, etc.
More restaurant variety
Cleaner car parks
Increased diversity of cafes and shops
more diverse mix of eateries
a bar
getting rid of the crappy mixed business shops
More open space and trees
131
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35
Feb 07 17 12:02:21
Feb 07 17 03:43:47
Feb 07 17 07:37:46
pm
am
am
am
Feb 07 17 08:53:34 am
Feb 07 17 09:22:32 am
Feb 07 17 09:32:02 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:34 am
Feb 07 17 11:37:55
Feb 07 17 12:54:13
Feb 07 17 12:55:13
Feb 07 17 01:20:27
am
pm
pm
pm
Feb 07 17 02:22:12 pm
To not change the feel of it too much.
For it to be known as a creative, innovative place.
For it not to become like Ackland St with chain stores and overpriced poor
quality shops.
If it wasnt changed at all. If large scale developments can be avoided.
Easier for people to walk around, a beautiful-looking street, lots of trees.
Lounge bars. More clothing retailers. More trees and perhaps a pedestrian
strip (no car access from the railway line to Nerrim Road
New footbaths and benches to sit on and trees
-revamped new pavements
-probably a cleaner strip
-a first class newsagency
more car parking
more ca parking
more car parking
-Cheap eats
-Modern designed infrastructures
-Well designed shop fronts
I think it is fantastic
See previous questions
Bars and cafes
Clean up/ Update of Public spaces
Variety In Stores
More parking availability
MAKE THE ROADWAY DOWN THE MIDDLE (KOORNANG) A MALL
CREATE A CIRCULAR ROUTE AROUND SHOPPING CENTRE SO AS
TO CREATE MALL
YOU HAVE SO MUCH DEVELOPING GOING ON YOU COILD AT LEAST
PUT A MULTI-STORY CAR PARK IN
PARK.... you have high multi-Story residences flanking both car parking
venues ..... think of the public...... how many extra people will you have in
the area when ALL THE DEVELOPMENTS ARE FINISHED...... I have
counted 18 developments approved/finished/ongoing in the immediate
vicinity...... the money you must be making soooooo much money from
these developments
Feb 07 17 02:48:16 pm
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
DISABLED PEOPLE OFTEN NEED MORE THAN TWO HOURS AT
CARNEGIE CENTRAL ..... better parking option for disabled
Some parks somewhere, more parking (finding a spot on Koornang Rd is
about 5% success rate)
More variety of shops, recycle bins, empty rubbish bins more regularly
Underground railway crossing.
More decent shops, eg, clothing & shoes.
Outdoor cafes
1. Pedestrian footpath on both sides of Koornang Rd to be redone and
possibly made larger. There would be less parking space but there is plenty
of parking in the nearby parking lots. One of parking lot can be transformed
in a multi-level one.
2. Good public art is missing. I personally like mosaics. One local example
is available here: http://www.mosaicrepublic.com.au/windsor
132
3. The Market Arcade must be redone. It will transform the Carnegie
shopping strip experience.
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 08:42:27 pm
Feb 07 17 09:00:05 pm
Feb 08 17 01:26:30 pm
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 08 17 05:03:53 pm
Feb 08 17 05:49:41 pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08 pm
Feb 08 17 10:49:39 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
Feb 10 17 01:36:52 pm
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 10 17 02:38:19 pm
Feb 10 17 04:09:57 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
(4). Well, this is a fantasy more than anything else but I would like to see
the section between Neerim and Rosstown Roads close to traffic. I am not
sure if this is an option but in an ideal world that would be fantastic!
1. Get rid of on street parking (and make the pedestrian footpath wider) and
make the car park next to Woolworth multi-level.
2. A better variety of shops.
3. Security cameras and better lighting at night.
shops
trees
demolition of Skyrail
Japanese and Spanish restaurant or cafe, more facilities for children and
families (including cafe's with a play area space for children), art store
More little evening spots like bars
A good deli
More clothing stores
Improve traffic congestion, easy to take public transport to other surburbs.
a recessed grass area
no begging eg at supermarket entry
fewer people approaching me on street to sell/raise money
Long term thinking about design. Control over what shops and how many
of type allowed . More parking !!
Boom gates gone
Quicker to drive through
More shops
1. More outdoor dining areas
2. Streetscape vegetation including better/prettier lighting
3. More car parking
new footpaths, better shops (get rid of the terrible Asian restaurants) and
tighter regulations on shops and where they can open
some of the cafes with dining on the footpath
Improvement around the design around the train station streets and linkage
to the shopping strip. needs to more inviting. Not sure if sky rail will
improve or make look worst. Need to ensure that the area is safe and
inviting. Design and maintenance is important. A little more greenery
around the area.
Cleanliness
Seating under shade
No more cafes and restaurants
A speciality delicatessen, more non-Asian cafes and restaurants and more
shops that are not just selling food.
more carparking
better traffic flow
clean the st
Maybe another shoe shop and definitely a news agency.
1. Movie cinema
2. community Garden
3. more community events
(1) Loads of parking
(2) More variety of shops
(3) Council encouragement to renovate the 1st floors of existing shops to
create office space to attract small to medium businesses to come to
Carnegie.
133
Feb 10 17 10:53:48 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Feb 11 17 06:53:53 pm
Feb 11 17 06:54:18
Feb 12 17 11:17:14
Feb 12 17 02:01:05
Feb 12 17 06:23:07
pm
am
pm
pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 12:46:35 pm
Cafes, more places for children, places to park your bike
Lots more green space.
Closing down Koornang Road to traffic.
Clean and tidy environment.
Not so Asian influenced, adding variety, make it look loved and well kept.
We need to be proud of our strip not embarrassed to suggest to guests to
go there.
More upmarket cafes and restaurants.
No more Asian restaurants
Live music venues - jazz, acoustic guitar
Longer hours for the post office please. Open on weekends!
A Spanish tapas bar, a cinema, specialty shops.
A deli
More parking
More green recreational areas
- the establishment of something resembling a European city square in the
direct vicinity of the train station and shops.
- more public car parking for train users
- a few small treed green open spaces on all sides of the strip for people
and families to have lunch, relax, and for kids to run.
It needs to look tidier. Compare it to our wealthier neighbours like Church
street, Brighton. Carnegie could be even better if it looked cleaner and
people cared about presentation. We choose to live in Carnegie (and not
Brighton) because we love the cultural diversity but its disappointing that
more effort is not put into presentation.
Upgraded streetscape (removal of current ugly brick features).
Organic foods shops such as bread/meat/vegies
Feb 13 17 05:14:39 pm
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 12:50:53 pm
Feb 14 17 01:56:09 pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09 pm
Feb 15 17 12:08:50 am
Feb 15 17 10:19:11 am
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
Feb 16 17 03:39:55 pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Artisan food choices
More dining variety
Better parking options
Replace 'freight' stores with more unique retail business
1. Less traffic/more parking
2. Less junk style shops with ugly posters covering windows
3. A wider variety of food style restaurants - no more Asian please
* some more park space and trees
* built-in ping pong tables!
* frozen yoghurt/ice cream place
- more cafes
- more trees
- a few more retail stores that include homewares and clothing
Improve quality of footpaths, general cleanliness and lighting.
1) The end of traffic jam on Koornang Rd,
2) Addition of 500 car places
3) Animation one Sunday a month with closure of Koornang Rd for the day
The variety of restaurants
Already pretty good
bring back our cute station, more green area's/trees, more community
activities
No skyrail, connection to surrounding area, lively and coherent feeling and
atmosphere
1. Remove the graffiti quickly.
2. Restore the old facades on the existing buildings - many are in need of a
134
Feb 16 17 05:21:55 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 18 17 01:52:15 am
Feb 18 17 08:13:09 am
Feb 18 17 11:51:03 am
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 08:36:02 am
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
facelift and a coat of paint.
3. Increase the range of shops - there are probably enough eateries now.
A greener aspect
Removal of car parking on the north side of the railway line; this adds
enormously to the congestion
On a similar note, the timing of the lights just north of the train line could be
way more sensible
More car parking.
Less appartments
Playground area updated
More art (public, street, whichever), more greenery and more events
More trees
Food variety
1. Effective seamless integration of the streetscape under the rail crossing
with the rest of the Kornang Rd streetscape.
2. Selective removal of some on street parking to allow for widener footpath,
bigger area of outdoor dinning with larger trees.
3. Creating a vision that is unique to Carnegie building upon the existing
strengths.
More real greenery, green spaces, flower boxes with flowers
Keeping small individualized shopfronts and laneways with more variety of
different shops and small boutiques that aren't chain organisations
reducing development
Quality of restaurants and cafes, safety and less congestion (traffic),
available quality local butcher/fishmonger
A good newsagent.
A Coles supermarket (behind the strip) replacing the Woolworths that is
there.
It still has a vibrant feel about it which is good, so can't think of a third thing.
Less Asian restaurants
Coles supermarket
The completion of the sky rail, All the retail space staying utilised and to
keep the library.
Less Asian Restaurants, more European restaurants
More traditional shopping.
Rail under Road instead of Skyrail.
Date
Name another shopping strip or centre in Melbourne
you’d like it to become like and why?
Nov 28 16 06:02:24 pm
Church st Brighton - has all major clothing brands, bookshop and kids
toyshops plus a range of restaurants
None we should be unique.
Surf pde broadbeach qld
Can't think of Melbourne option
Acland St, St Kilda
Pedestrianised, few cars,
Glenferrie Road Food offerings have more variety but I'd hate to make it as
pretentious
Church street BRIGHTON.
High st has a great mix of restaurants cafes and shops
None
Nov 29 16 06:29:16 am
Nov 29 16 02:02:14 pm
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Nov 29 16 06:57:25 pm
Nov 29 16 11:06:31 pm
Nov 30 16 05:37:26 am
Nov 30 16 08:09:13 am
135
Nov 30 16 09:25:28
Nov 30 16 01:37:26
Nov 30 16 02:43:46
Nov 30 16 04:37:55
am
pm
pm
pm
Nov 30 16 10:49:43 pm
Nov 30 16 11:43:52 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 12:51:45 pm
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 06:16:34 pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46 pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 02:55:35 am
Dec 02 16 07:44:25 am
Dec 02 16 09:09:01 am
Dec 02 16 09:21:33 am
Dec 02 16 10:40:50 am
Dec 02 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 02:23:16 pm
Dec 02 16 03:25:11 pm
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
Dec 02 16 07:20:13 pm
Dec 02 16 08:10:48 pm
Dec 02 16 09:39:36 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
Swan St Richmond - better variety, more bars and eats - trees
Camberwell, variety of shops, fresh market and rail underground
Yarraville. If you don't know why, get there and check it out.
Bay st Brighton it is much cleaner with better shops. Koornang road is
becoming like Box Hill
Not sure
Bay street port melb. It's prettier. :)
camberwell
Although we have more food options in Carnegie which is really great, the
shopping strip on Centre rd in Bentleigh offers more competitive retail
stores which makes the shopping experience more complete. With a
discount department store (Target) as well as supermarkets on the same
shopping strip, shopping for residents of Bentleigh is a lot more convenient
because they have access to such stores in the vicinity.
Glenhuntly Rd, Elsternwick - variety of shops
Oakleigh Eaton Mall: fantastic atmosphere, great food, family friendly and it
is the heart of the city
Kingsway in Glen Waverley, has limited parking and well monitored.
Malvern Shopping Centre is the same.
Love Carnegie because it is unique :)
Puckle Street, Moonee Ponds because it has more and different shops, a
variety of food places and the road is not used to get to a major road. There
are other roads, nearby that more cross traffic more efficiently.
Hampton St. a wide variety of shops and restaurants there
I'd like to see it more like Windsor or perhaps Balaclava (which is a bit more
limited for various reasons), a diverse destination for dining and shopping,
that retains its appeal to locals.
Oh goodness the situation with the boom gates is so bad at carnegie I can
never leave - how do I get to experience other shopping strips?
Richmond or Carlton (variety of eateries, style, vibrant, colourful)
Ormond Rd, Elwood. Variety of shops that suit my and familys interest, not
to crowded, aesthetically pleasing
Camberwell Junction has a diverse range of shops and food outlets
None it should be its own centre.
Look Carnegie, is pretty high up there as far as shopping strips go , but
there still could be improvements
carnegie has its own uniqueness
Centre Road Bentleigh, High St Ashburton
High street malvern or Glenferrie Rd hawthorn
No, Carnegie is great for its own good. Copying another strip does nothing.
When I consider all the lovely shopping strips I know such as Rathdowne st
in Carlton or Ormond rd in Elwood, my next thought is that even though
they are great, they lack the grittiness of Carnegie which is what gives it
appeal. So the answer is none
Hampton Street - great clothes shops there and restaurant choices - but no
space in our strip for that and that's ok
Acland st. Because it's vibrant and fresh
Centre Rd Bentleigh.....a greater range of shops.
Far greater parking facilities
Ormond rd elsterwick.
Glenferrie Rd, Malvern
it's very cool over there
136
Dec 03 16 12:07:43 pm
Dec 03 16 01:07:24 pm
Dec 03 16 01:11:04
Dec 03 16 01:39:39
Dec 03 16 02:34:16
Dec 03 16 04:58:50
Dec 03 16 05:25:18
Dec 03 16 06:02:26
Dec 03 16 08:24:38
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08 pm
Dec 04 16 04:41:54 pm
Dec 04 16 05:19:29 pm
Dec 04 16 07:17:49 pm
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 02:13:56 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 12:14:30 pm
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Glenferrie rd malvern - feels nicer
Acland Street, St Kilda which looks less dilapidated, is lighter and brighter,
has a holiday ambience and a variety of street entertainment
Oakleigh with the outdoor cafes and malls
It is unique and doesn't have to be the same as anything.
Any small strip that has better parking and a larger verity of shops
It doesn't need to be like others
Why can't Koornang be it's own thing?
Bridport st in Albert park. Peaceful.
Malvern end of Glenferrie Rd. Has such a great mix of stores. Different
food, books, retail etc
Rathdown St Village Carlton. Yarraville Village.
- It's simply greener. An enthusiastic planting approach decades ago is now
evident and being enjoyed by future generations.
- They respect the heritage of Carlton, architecturally and culturally. If
developers and Asian Vitamin stores were allowed to do what they wanted,
Rathdown Street wouldn't be what it is today. We have something special
happening right now in Carnegie, let encourage it, not let it slip away.
- They encourage a quality of life and focus on the neighbourhood and
village lifestyle, hence a lack of corporate take over.
Yarraville - their pop up park became a permanent space and it means the
kids have a safe place to play
Love the village atmosphere- people know one another and talk
It feels secluded and private - Carnegie used to feel like that and now it
doesn't because of all the apartments and associated traffic
Chapel st- more fashion, more bars
Acland street, has something for everyone although it's missing all the
Asian restaurants
Main street Mornington. It is more. Beautiful, cleaner, has ample parking
and less traffic issues even though it attracts large numbers of tourists.
I was very impressed by the forecourt area outside Eastlands shopping
centre. Opposite Ringwood station. There are quaint little eateries. Fed
square has a great forecourt with large TV for events.
Church St, Brighton
- Great shops/cafes
- Close to transport
- Close to parks
- Very clean/well-maintained
Centre road bentleigh for its variety of stores, quality of food offering and
the feel that it is more accessibility.
Shouldn't have to look like something else. It should have it's own
character.
Malvern or Toorak
It has much more of an International appeal
Centre Road in Bentleigh. Better selection of retail stores (clothing, Target,
book store).
Glenferrie Road Malvern has a great variety of retail and restaurants so it
would be good to have the range of shops and most a very well presented
(however I still think Carnegie is unique and feels far more relaxed than
Malvern so I wouldn't want to lose this aspect)
bay st brighton. a bit quirky.
Let it be itself, but with some good ideas from elsewhere. Integrate with the
station (eg Armadale), consider extending the strip along Neerim Road,
other spur roads and further south along Koornang Road to bring a greater
137
Dec 06 16 07:21:30 pm
Dec 06 16 07:36:32
Dec 06 16 08:01:02
Dec 07 16 01:30:53
Dec 07 16 03:46:25
Dec 07 16 03:46:55
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 07 16 09:56:41 pm
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 04:57:31 pm
Dec 09 16 10:07:30 pm
Dec 10 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 10 16 01:15:25 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 09:29:29 am
Dec 11 16 01:55:48 pm
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
Dec 11 16 06:14:48 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 12 16 04:28:28 pm
Dec 14 16 09:37:51 pm
critical mass (eg Glenferrie Road south of High Street), an entertainment
anchor tenant and links to open space (eg Elsternwick).
I don't think I need to become like any other strip in Melbourne. It's beauty is
that it's unique...
Crows nest in Sydney. Fantastic vibe with a real family feel.
Let it stay unique.
It's hard to compare. I like the feel it has now
Kensington.
Cleanliness of Glenferrie road, Malvern
Variety of Balaclava shopping strip
Armadale, Camberwell, etc
The residents appear to respect their strip, the street planting and road
rules(no U turn in main street!!!)
The shop owners keep their shop fronts clean, even when the shops close it
doesn't take on a filthy look as Carnegie's can at times.
Carnegie shopping strip is unique and special.
Murrumbeena needs more improvements than Carnegie which may occur
after skyrail and new station and more high rise apartments.
High Street, Westgarth/Northcote - because of shops like Terra Madre,
venues like Bar 303 and Open Studio, and the Westgarth cinema.
Bay Steet Brighton
Glenferrie rd Malvern
Mailing Rd Canterbury
Parts of Lygon St, Brunswick St too. These areas have a great mix of quirky
and quality retail, cafes and bars
Mailing Road Canterbury.
Better quality shops and more variety in the retail section. Mailing Road is
not just a lot of places to eat Asian style food.
Oakleigh, great atmosphere
I don't think it needs to become like another shopping strip
Chapel Street, to some extents. A few bars would be nice. More retail isn't
necessary, it is an extremely successful food strip, with essential retail
stores such as Chemist Warehouse/Aldi etc.
Camberwell
Hampton Street
I think already we have been voted number 1 shopping strip in City of Port
Philip. While some others have been good in the past, many suffer from
gentrification, whereas Carnegie is unique in having a large university
international student population, which keeps a vibrant young population,
making it a university suburb and university shopping strip, melded with a
mixed local population. This ensures it remains vital and youthful.
Ashburton and Bentleigh. Both have more variety of shops and both have
better parking facilities.
Brighton.. For large trees and Greenery
Church St, Brighton. I know, different demographic. And Koornang Rd is
narrow. It's open, wide pavements good for cafes. Great variety of traders.
Also entertainment venues.
centre rd bentleigh clean and easy to get to...and drive through
Mount Martha village- quality shops and cafes, friendly, village feel
Hawkesburn village- quality shops and variety
No other
Camberwell, for the size, variety and vibrancy. They have a cinema. I would
love to see a cinema in Carnegie, but it would be near impossible to
compete with Chadstone, except as a niche theatre, think Nova, Lido,
138
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
Dec 16 16 12:06:19 pm
Dec 16 16 02:07:53 pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Dec 17 16 09:00:42 am
Dec 17 16 09:36:01 am
Dec 17 16 10:26:51 am
Dec 17 16 02:40:19
Dec 17 16 06:10:26
Dec 18 16 01:09:39
Dec 18 16 10:23:31
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 19 16 09:03:13 am
Dec 19 16 12:04:25
Dec 19 16 12:12:19
Dec 19 16 12:26:59
Dec 19 16 12:31:26
Dec 19 16 12:47:03
Dec 19 16 01:09:43
Dec 19 16 01:12:58
Dec 19 16 01:21:26
Dec 19 16 01:35:37
Dec 19 16 01:49:12
Dec 20 16 08:58:27
Dec 21 16 07:38:15
Dec 21 16 11:20:20
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44 am
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
Dec 22 16 08:48:44 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 23 16 10:35:02 pm
Place, etc.
Glen Eira Rd Rippon Lea
Stylish options, lovely sense of community, great example of multicultural
harmony
glenhuntly rd, elsternwick - more variety
Chapel Street. A better selection of cafes and shops. But please no
nightclubs - just some cool bars.
Elsternwick for its diversity especially food-wise
High st Northcote - good variety of shops, coffee shops and restaurants
Mailing street in Canterbury it has a lovely relaxed feel which draws people
to want to go there. The have a mix of parking with great landscaping to
soften and enhance the appearance. The heritage appeal of the buildings
is a drawcard for me as this is different which makes it an appealing
destination. Koonang Road is currently just lots of ugly buildings just like so
many shopping strips but by adding mosics or adopting a theme it would be
more of a destination that would spark peoples interest
Brunswick Street: mix of culture, nightlife, shopping, community, food, art.
Something for any occasion and buzzing at any time of day.
Oakleigh - car free strip of shops and lots of parking
It's unique the way it is
Ripponlea - great mix of shops / retail
Bentleigh east. Train underground. Great mix of retailers. No residential
developement.
Camberwell Burke rd
Has shopping for shoes and clothes and market
bentleigh
glen ferrie road
Bentleigh
springvale
elwood and st kilda
flinders lane
Bentleigh, fitzroy
st kilda
bentleigh
not sure lived in Carnegie for 15 years
Glenferrie Rd, Malvern. Great mix of shops/ restaurants/ services.
Bridge road in richmond
Chapel St Windsor/Prarahn markets. The area is always bustling and there
are hundreds of interesting places to eat and meet people. The area itself
attracts attention as opposed to a single restaurant.
See previous question - a pedestrian mall with plenty of outdoor eating
places and a variety of shops.
Morington, Its not in the center of Melbourne but it looks great.
Eaton Mall - Oakleigh
Acland St - St Kilda
More pedestrian friendly with more on street space.
There are many other town squares in over seas locations that could be
used for inspiration
Nothing to compare. It should set a standard.
Acland st - it has a very social and vibrant atmosphere, but is safe and
clean, and has a very distinct feel to it.
Chaddy is very clean
139
Dec 24 16 09:58:08 pm
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
Dec 25 16 06:15:10 pm
Dec 25 16 06:48:49
Dec 26 16 04:28:51
Dec 26 16 07:01:09
Dec 27 16 09:45:59
Dec 27 16 08:11:33
Dec 29 16 09:36:45
pm
pm
pm
am
pm
am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 11:49:13 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15 am
Jan 03 17 05:38:54 pm
Jan 04 17 01:44:07 pm
Jan 04 17 04:19:58 pm
Jan 04 17 08:52:40 pm
Jan 04 17 11:40:31 pm
Jan 05 17 08:03:07 am
Chadstone, all in one spot
Glenferrie RD Malvern. Great book shops, clothes, still a viable shoe shop,
Malvern Central within radius. Harold Holt pool within driving distance.
Optus, Telstra stores. So much more.......
South Ybarra, chapel strip
Great atmosphere n so many things to do
Carslile st balaclava,
They have a good mix of shops, food, supermarkets/fruit and vege, gyms,
medical etc as well as a few small bars with live music etc.
Uniqueness has its own virtue. As long it's quality.
More restaurants like on Glenferrie Rd
Oakleigh
It is already second to none.
Glen ferrie road
Glenferrie Rd Hawthorn
Great shops with diversity. Book shops, clothing,
Attractive decorations in street.
Arthouse cinema
Good bars, pubs,
Cheap restaurants as well as up market.
The esplanade in Elwood, The concourse in Beaumaris and even Centre
Rd in Bentleigh have a better feel and greater sense of community, as the
traders all have a sense of pride and purpose. I think the "cheap" shops
bring a cheap feel unfortunately.
Carnegie is not a cheap area to live - it has quite good schools and is close
to the beach and the pools and Chaddy and the city. However it has been
thrown to the wolves by council in allowing all the rapid changes to housing
development. Many high-rise blocks will not look very nice in a few years
time and that detracts greatly from the appeal of the area - which does have
good bones.
Bentleigh is more diverse and more range of shops, better landscaping of
the street.
Glenferrie road, glenhuntly road elsternwick,
Church st Brighton, cause it has a great vibe with great retail stores and
great restaurants
Elwood. There are more places to visit for a nice dinner or drinks with
friends.
Why would you want to do that? If you wanted it to be another place you
would go to that place. It used to be a lot more Korean. If anything I would
want it more like Box Hill.
I don't really shop anywhere else, sorry.
Elsternwick - there is something for everyone. Love the gift stores, classic
cinema, restaurants, cafes, op shops, a bit different retro styles and retail,
clean... and no tram in carnegie strip, which is good.. feels less hectic
Chapel street because it's viberant and stuff is always happening
A bit difficult as each place has it's own mix. However the culture/social mix
we have now hasn't grown but has been imposed very rapidly. So many
people no longer shop here but drive to North Road, Malvern, Elsternwick
etc. More variety.
None, it is good as is. Keep it accessible for all and local!
Glenferrie road minus the elevated rail. Cafes and food options
Malvern road Hawksburn, it has boutiques, general grocery shopping of
high quality, such as Peter Bouchier butcher and Toscanas fruit and veg
store. As well as a variety of cafes and restaurants
140
Jan 05 17 11:41:31 am
Jan 08 17 01:02:53 pm
Jan 08 17 02:41:07 pm
Jan 09 17 01:40:52 pm
Jan 09 17 01:51:18 pm
Jan 11 17 03:11:49 pm
Jan 11 17 04:45:00
Jan 12 17 06:39:14
Jan 13 17 12:06:37
Jan 14 17 05:47:35
pm
pm
pm
pm
Jan 14 17 06:04:44 pm
Jan 16 17 01:33:04 am
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53
Jan 19 17 04:19:18
Jan 19 17 11:23:52
Jan 20 17 12:03:42
Jan 24 17 01:56:15
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 26 17 12:17:14 am
Jan 26 17 12:02:14 pm
Jan 27 17 03:28:37 pm
Jan 28 17 09:10:58 am
Tough one - the shopping strip is almost too short to support a good mix of
cafe, food and retails stores.
High Street, Armadale - every shop is a pleasure to see; every shop makes
you want to spend money; and it's relaxing and invigorating to visit. Even
the little clipped trees are pleasant. (Wish there was more cultural diversity,
though!).
Maling Rd, Canterbury. Trees, village feel, slow pace.
Ackland street in St Kilda as it is vibrant and traffic is slower.
Mailing rd, canterbury
Unique feel from designed features.
Mix of specialty shops
Good quality food
Burke rd, camberwell
Brand name shops
Glenhuntly Road, Elsternwick with greater range of shops and underground
rail.
Toorak Rd, SY
Oakleigh - walking street with full of food places
Bentleigh as it has a few larger stores with small fronts and a subtle under
road train line and station. Also lots of smaller businesses that are not just
Asian noodle or hairdressers.
Oakleigh. It has a relaxing, village atmosphere.
No. Just get this one a bit more appealing. I like it.
High St, Northcote. A perfect example of diversity, coolness, lots of cafes
and food etc.
Why does it have to be 'like another spot in Melbourne"?? This seems
absurd - build on the strengths that is currently has and work to make the
place attractive, accessible and useful for more residents.
Church rd. Brighton. The shops are lovely, the footpaths are pleasant and
green and it's a pleasure to walk around there.
Fitzroy--- not totally like it but more vibrant and beautiful
Bay Street Brighton
Oakleigh's lovely wide piazza with all the outdoor seating for restaurants is
lovely
Acland st St Kilda - for the gardens and parks around the shopping strip.
Springvale Shopping Centre - for the pedestrian malls
Victoria Ave Albert Park or Glenferrie Road Hawthorn for class & diversity
Not sure
Glenferrie Road Malvern - much wider range of shops,.
None come to mind, keep it uniquely Carnegie.
oakleigh.. great walking, people watching, european feel could blend with
the asian feel
Glenferrie Rd, Malvern. It has a good mix of shops, services restaurants
and cafes.
elsternwick, glenferrie rd.
Mornington. Heaps of life during day and night. High quality cafes and
restaurants and numerous bars for evening outings.
Albert park shopping strip.
Designed for the people. Large sidewalks, trees, open village feel.
Encourages long stays and allows people to connect.
Chapel St South Yarra. It's a like being in a shopping centre.
141
Jan 28 17 11:13:55 am
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 08:58:54
Feb 01 17 09:51:04
Feb 03 17 01:54:17
Feb 03 17 10:13:18
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 05 17 12:07:39 am
Feb 05 17 09:04:43 am
Feb 05 17 04:10:15 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:06:15 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:28:50
Feb 06 17 06:41:44
Feb 06 17 06:57:40
Feb 06 17 07:20:51
Feb 06 17 08:44:55
Feb 06 17 08:46:31
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35
Feb 07 17 12:02:21
Feb 07 17 03:43:47
Feb 07 17 07:37:46
pm
am
am
am
High street Ashburton because it has an excellent range of useful shops
I think Koornang is almost perfect - I like aspects of other places but prefer
Koornang
Glen ferry Rd - ppl go there for its vibrancy
Happy the way it is
Maling Rd Canterbury. It has appeal and is friendly.
Glen Huntly Rd Elsternwick
Glenferrie Rd Hawthorn
Variety of nice shops and restraints
Gertrude Street, Fitzroy.
none that are a valid comparison- even though there are places with much
more variety (bookshops and clothes would be great) Carnegie has the
advantage of being so compact and easy to cover the whole strip quickly.
it rates pretty well when compared to other shopping strips in Melbourne.
Elsternwick more cosmopolitan better mix of shops bookstores clothes
coffee etc not just cheap Asian eats.
Glenferrie Rd Malvern has a great diversity of shops and is always busy
during the day, though lacks open space and has some other issues.
Glen Huntly has trams and soon to have public open space, and generally a
more human scale building envelope.
Sydney Road, there's lots going on and its racially inclusive
Carlisle Street East St Kilda. This has a great range of shops and seems to
keep up with the moving demographic. It has the right amount of
hairdressers, chemist, supermarkets, fruit and veg as well as a good
selection of eateries and clothing stores.
Carnegie is quite unique and I'm not sure I can nominate another strip
shopping centre that would bring in the diverse cultural needs that this area
calls for.
Glenferrie Rd Malvern, because it has good bookstores, clothing shops,
cafes.
Church St Brighton because of trees.
Glenferrie Rd for quality of shops
Brunswick St Fitzroy for buzz
Church St Brighton for shade
Brunswick St for buzz
Glenferrie for retail
Mailing Rd Canterbury.
Really nice atmosphere, lovely shop people, quirkly little shops. Just nice.
South Melbourne for the diversity, markets and pubs
Bourke street
I like that Carnegie is unique so not really.
Greville st in prahran, feels modern but enclosed and uncrowded
Acland St
Glenferrie Rd, Malvern
Clarendon St, South Melbourne
Would prefer it to keep its own identity
I love Oakleigh because it retains an authentic, democratic, unique feel to it.
Also I love Collingwood/ Brunswick/ Fitzroy for their creativity and blend of
sophistication while being equally comfortable with grunge.
Theres no where like Carnegie.
Lygon Street for the way it feels - trees, street life, easy to walk around.
It's the best
Elwood, Yarraville
142
Feb 07 17 08:53:34 am
Feb 07 17 09:22:32 am
Feb 07 17 09:32:02 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:31 am
Feb 07 17 10:31:34 am
Feb 07 17 11:37:55 am
Feb 07 17 12:54:13 pm
Feb 07 17 12:55:13 pm
Feb 07 17 01:20:27 pm
Feb 07 17 02:22:12 pm
Feb 07 17 02:48:16 pm
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 09:00:05 pm
Feb 07 17 10:35:41 pm
Feb 08 17 01:26:30 pm
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 08 17 05:49:41 pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08 pm
Feb 08 17 10:49:39 pm
Feb 09 17 12:04:18 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
Feb 10 17 11:01:20 am
Feb 10 17 01:36:52 pm
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Gertrude Street Fitzroy
This shopping strip is unique and we don't need it to become like any other
church st brighton as plenty of car parking
Small version of Chapel St
Malvern - it is a nice area that people can go for food, drinks, sweets, and
shopping (the Malvern Central Shopping Centre is great).
Brunswick st, a little hipper and more variety in food
Chadstone
Glenferrie Road, Malvern or Glenferrie Road, Hawthorn
Both these are busy areas yet always feel clean and have huge variety of
retailers and food
None, Lets be unique.
Sorry don't know other centres much
Centre Rd in Bentleigh has a lot better Retail options, however I prefer how
close Koornang Rd feels. Centre Rd is a bit more hectic and spread out,
which means I don't ever want to park at one end and walk - this is why I
prefer Koornang Currently.
I like the rotunder on Centre Rd and the area where they have events and
bands playing.
Brunswick street
Glenferrie Road, Malvern
Has everything that Carnegie has without the railway crossing.
Ambience is more "upmarket"
Appears cleaner.
Glenferrie Rd, Malvern. Because it offers the right balance of cafes,
restaurants and shops in general. They all tend to be of high quality and
well maintained. It invites you to go back and back again. Shabby shops are
just off-putting.
Bentleigh (Cantre Road) - the whole strip seems cleaner, and has much
better and well known shops (Target, Susan, Priceline, etc.) It has great
Japanese restaurants for sushi on the go and a lot more parking options.
look at Brighton ..trees... street furniture.. pedestrianisation ...
Carnegie is unique - there is no other street I can think of that has the
diversity in people and food as well as the relaxed welcoming feeling
Glen Waverley
glenferrie rd. more choices
Degraves St city LOL
it is interesting , varied ( but tooooo busy)
Hampton GlenferrievRd or Brighton has the variety mix right.
Church st Brighton.
It has a great community feel and is a very pleasing st to walk down
therefore encourages shoppers to use it. Also has a great mix of very good
businesses.
centre road bentleigh
Centre Road Bentleigh as there is a greater variety of businesses, and the
place has a nice feel about it
Bentleigh or even Elsternwick with more variety. Not everyone wants to go
to Chadstone
Brighton - church street.
No
unsure
Hampton street - variety, bustling and speciality shops
143
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 10 17 02:38:19 pm
Feb 10 17 04:09:57 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Feb 11 17 06:53:53 pm
Feb 11 17 06:54:18 pm
Feb 12 17 02:01:05 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 12:46:35 pm
Feb 13 17 05:14:39 pm
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 12:50:53 pm
Feb 14 17 01:56:09 pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09 pm
Feb 15 17 12:08:50 am
Feb 15 17 10:19:11 am
elwood has a village atmostphere
Maybe Mordialloc as again there is plenty of parking spaces with extended
parking times during the day.
South Yarra
Chapel street - variety of food outlets (by this I mean type of cuisines) and
variety of retail shops. We have lost many retail shops due to Chadstone,
however new shops that open lately always seems to be some type of
"discounted" retail outlet, giving the district a feel of being in the lower socioeconomic area, which it isn't if we take a look at the average council rates :)
We love Chadstone.
All the beautiful coloured trees and plants and the cleanliness of the place.
Elwood, Bentleigh, Bay st Port Melb, Church st Brighton
High St Armadale - diversification of quality bars, restaurants, cafes,
clothing stores, lifestyle stores. Provides a more complete shopping
experience. Need to leave Carnegie if you want shopping diversity at the
moment.
I'd like it to retain its essential multi cultural feeling but with more variety.
Not quite so many Asian restaurants. Middle Eastern, Russian, Greek,
Italian, Mexican, Aboriginal and African. Maybe Chapel Street has the most
variety. Parking is crucial.
Ripponlea or Brighton for the village feel.
- Fed Square: a very successful public open space next to a main station
with easy access to green spaces.
- Glenferrie Rd Malvern and Burke St Camberwell for the variety of
shopping outlets
- Maling St (Hartwell I think) for its nice small treed parc which could be
reproduced at various locations at the back of the shopping strip
Church street Brighton for aesethic reasons but also Oakleigh because of
its pdestrian areas and European feel. If we could somehow encourage less
traffic up/down Koornang Rd (direct more up Grange once the Sky rail is
finished).
Queen Victoria Market
Obviously, not that big, but it has good grocery shopping choices for people
who want to avoid supermarkets and support local food artisans and
healthy, fresh, organic groceries!
Whitehorse Road, Balwyn
It is more inclusive for everyone in the community
Carlisle Street - great variety of shops, bars and restaurants
I think Koornang road is the best. Elsternwick is pretty cool because they
have a cinema too! Imagine! We would never have to go to chadstone for
anything if we had a cinema. Movies in the park? Twilight movies? Do any
other suburbs do that?
A cross between South Yarra and Brunswick. It's important to keep the
diversity, and a bit of the "grunge" - but we need a few more options other
than restaurants.
Koornang Road is already well rated but we can try to be as:
- Elsternwick / GlenHuntly rd
- Bentleigh / Center rd
We have enough restaurant but need to had shops, car parking and open
space. With the sky rail we should be even better
Bay Street Brighton and Canterbury
No knowledge
144
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
Feb 16 17 03:39:55 pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:21:55 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 17 17 12:21:13 pm
Feb 18 17 01:52:15 am
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 08:36:02 am
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
Kensington, personal and has community spirit
Should have its own style/atmosphere
But like:
Oakleigh: functionality with personality, and destinations
Glenferrie Road, Malvern: great diversity
Smith street Fitzroy minus the graffiti.
I want it to remain its unique self
Glenferrie rd. variety of food shops, clothing, book shops and restaurants.
(Not all cheap Asian shops)
Glenferrie Road in Hawthorn - it's got a lot more atmosphere than Carnegie
and a mix of upmarket, mid-market and cheap options.
I like that it has some unique features but am quite fond of Brunswick St
when I travel further
Mailing Road - full of character and heritage reflecting the suburb (not big
large same looking development, which echos a packed city) flowers and
trees and real greenery soften the area and there is a vast array of shops
selling different boutique wares. Green spaces and parks close by give it a
family friendly vibe
Smith street for the food, grocery shopping
Bentleigh. This seems to have a good balance between retail outlets,
eateries and op-shops.
Centre Road, Bentleigh
Expands out a bit plus has much more variety of shops & restaurants
none Carnegie is unique.
Bentleigh East as it has a great variety of all types of shopping plus
Restaurants and Cafe's. This is now my preferred shopping precinct.
Date
What would you like Carnegie shopping strip to be like
for future generations in 30 years time?
Nov 28 16 06:02:24 pm
Nov 29 16 06:29:16 am
Upmarket, sustainable, safe, charismatic
More inviting than it is now.
A safe environment
Clean
Friendly
Great atmosphere, lively, the place to be
A relief from the urban sprawl
Somewhere local to meet, eat and breathe
The local shops
Cleaned up not so many Asian shops
Nearly the same as it is now with minimal movements upward (keep it low
rise and feeling like a community shopping strip)
Clean, Sophisticated options that's not over developed
Improvements as mentioned previously
Safe, clean and inviting to everyone who wants to visit.
Less Asian shops
Diverse & offering an alternative to going to Chadstone - shop local!
Mainly the same
Leafy and acessible
Nov 29 16 02:02:14 pm
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Nov 29 16 11:06:31 pm
Nov 30 16 05:37:26 am
Nov 30 16 08:09:13 am
Nov 30 16 09:25:28
Nov 30 16 01:37:26
Nov 30 16 02:43:46
Nov 30 16 04:37:55
Nov 30 16 10:32:17
Nov 30 16 10:49:43
Nov 30 16 11:43:52
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
145
Dec 01 16 11:47:50
Dec 01 16 12:51:45
Dec 01 16 01:15:20
Dec 01 16 01:38:06
Dec 01 16 02:34:30
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 01 16 09:00:46 pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 12:12:05 am
Dec 02 16 02:55:35 am
Dec 02 16 07:44:25 am
Dec 02 16 09:09:01 am
Dec 02 16 10:02:16 am
Dec 02 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 02 16 12:38:18 pm
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 02:23:16 pm
Dec 02 16 03:25:11 pm
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
Dec 02 16 07:20:13 pm
Dec 02 16 08:10:48 pm
Dec 02 16 09:39:36 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
Dec 03 16 01:07:24
Dec 03 16 01:11:04
Dec 03 16 01:39:39
Dec 03 16 01:48:27
Dec 03 16 02:34:16
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 03 16 04:42:15 pm
Dec 03 16 04:58:50 pm
Dec 03 16 05:25:18 pm
Dec 03 16 06:31:54 pm
clean & tidy
Similar to what it is now but with more retail outlets.
restaurant and local grocery hub
No comments
I hope to see this shopping strip to provide necessary space and shops for
families and all to enjoy. Clean and safe, inviting and prosperous for all to
have.
More on from a small, quaint shopping strip to one that supports the
growing surrounding population better.
A good mix of cafes, butchers, fruit shops
I would like to see that it is still a place for locals and visitors alike.
A mix of shops - not derelict , not all restaurants, certainly not all export to
China shops
Stylish destination, international, family friendly, vibrant
A place where the hustle and bustle goes away for a while.
Cafes and restaurants, some that stand the test of time, kids spaces.
Things for kids to do so they don't just turn to technology.
A place where people can meet each other and relax at any time of the day.
I'd like it to be clean, with more grass. A safe place to walk and cycle
A small business and shopping hub outside the CBD.
Similar to now, making sure it maintains its community feeling.
I can't give a realistic answer to that question
i don't want the area overdeveloped i would want it to remain a friendly local
shopping area perhaps with more open space for people to meet up sit and
enjoy out the out doors as well as the cafes and restaurants
Community focussed, less development & less Asian shops!
Continous improvements and expand along koornang road.
As it is...with the suggestions made previously. I think open outdoor space
will be a necessary addition in such a highly populated area
still have the essentials like butcher, fruit and veg, chicken shop, bakery
Safe and clean
A small shopping strip with many fresh fruit/ butcher shops, and places to
buy daily essentials eg milk, newspapers( if still around) and cafes to enjoy
a coffee and a catch up with friends.
Also a library .
Unique shops with character as a contrast to chadstone with shops you can
find in any big shopping cente
modern, clean & freshly painted, with proper paving and road surfaces - not
run down, dilapidated and abandoned
I hope it will retain its village atmosphere
Less through traffic - perhaps a shopping mall with outdoor restaurants
Serving the same role for the local community it does now.
No more congested than it is today.
More verity of shops
Better parking
More of a community
more different shops and more police to feel safe.
Not just one long dumpling shop. Bring back fresh food and more
gifts/clothing
You actually believe any of us will be around in 30 years?
Cool thriving less focused on thrift shops great outdoor spaces and
servicing families well
146
Dec 03 16 08:24:38 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 02:47:08 pm
Dec 04 16 03:50:48 pm
Dec 04 16 04:41:54 pm
Dec 04 16 05:19:29 pm
Dec 04 16 07:17:49 pm
Dec 05 16 11:47:03 am
Dec 05 16 05:44:03 pm
Dec 05 16 06:44:44 pm
Dec 06 16 02:13:56 am
Dec 06 16 07:53:47 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 12:14:30 pm
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
Dec 06 16 01:44:42 pm
Dec 06 16 02:49:34 pm
Dec 06 16 07:21:30 pm
Dec 06 16 07:36:32 pm
Dec 07 16 08:38:49 am
Dec 07 16 03:46:25
Dec 07 16 03:46:55
Dec 07 16 08:44:26
Dec 07 16 09:56:41
pm
pm
pm
pm
Green, open, uniquely Carnegie
I think i've touched on this with previous answers. (Greener. Still
multicultural. And local shops that are run by the community for the
community.)
A village - keep it unique and keep it multicultural
Not sure
Similar to what it is now, maybe with a bar or two
have mORE freindly parks and sporting clubs to join
Friendly and vibrant
Beautiful. Welcoming. Open.
A great social community hub.
See above!
Maintained in good condition and keeping with the times
Bay st Brighton
A lively, environmentally-friendly, congestion-free, great transport service
and infrastructure, safe and desirable.
Not too overcrowded
Modern clean bright clean designs with changing plans for the environment
and users
Clean, a large variety of shops, family friendly
Clean, activated, lots of public art.
That the open space planned for the sky rail project is successful and
provides a range of opportunities for community events and attractive to
visit.
multi cultural.
not lopsided asian!!!!
equal cafe choices chiinese/korean/italian/greek.
a few indian..and others.
quirky and fun..treed..beautifully paved with quiet reflection areas. great
artisan food stores.
inviting for all kinds of people, not too much focus on Korean/Asian
A genuine destination for people beyond Carnegie, while still being a local
focal point. Carnegie is getting denser; I would expect the strip to grow
along with the increasing population and cater to the need for the increasing
number of apartment dwellers to "get out" on a regular basis.
To continue to celebrate the multiculturalism of the people who live in the
area
Hopefully maintain it's cafe and restaurant culture. Love the new
hairdressers & nail place in the area. I hope the Asian courier stores don't
keep multiplying and that Asian writing on stores is supported with English
as well.
The same balance between facilities (banks, post office, library, hardware
store, greengrocers etc), cafes/restaurants and gift shops as it is now. Not
to degenerate into a strip of all cheapie shops or adult shops and
entertainment or something like that. It is currently suitable for all ages and
backgrounds and should stay that way.
Not sure as it would need to be changed as times change.
same as Q9
friendly, safe & clean
Well the way it is going with the open slather development fueled by Glen
Eira Council
I don't think it will be a place to be.
We certainly won't be in the area for much longer.
147
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 08:01:30 pm
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 09 16 04:57:31 pm
Dec 09 16 10:07:30 pm
Dec 10 16 10:04:18 am
Dec 10 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 10 16 01:15:25 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 09:29:29 am
Dec 11 16 05:58:28 pm
Dec 11 16 06:14:48 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 12 16 04:28:28 pm
Dec 14 16 03:36:48 pm
Dec 14 16 09:37:51 pm
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
To upgrade individual properties, to keep the population in the general area
sustainable and to keep it safe and secure.
Not just be full of cafes but retain a diverse shopping experience. More
high rise around station and shops.
Still lots of fruit and veg shops and Asian groceries. Less traffic
A place where everyone feels included and welcome. A place where people
with disabilities can easily access all commercial and community spaces
and facilities. A place where people come to socialise and connect. A place
where the environment is cared for through the commitment of visitors,
community members, council, store holders and business owners.
A lot better than it is now.
My gosh it is 2016 and we have lost all our basic amenities.
The last good thing that happened was when the new library was built and
since then it has gone down hill fast. You are turning Carnegie into a hi-rise
concrete jungle and cutting every old growth tree in sight. We loved the old
fashioned quaintness of the suburb with its lazy feel. Well forget about that
you are demolishing every old home and heritage building you can get your
hands on and it seems every park you want to turn into a car park. Progress
is not always progress.
Lastly what has happened to decent Christmas decorations they too have
deteriorated over the years to a few piddly stars.
Clean, green, happy place to dine, shop and hang out with friends and
family.
Full of greenery and a place where most people walk to.
nil
Probably a tram going through it
Clean, still safe, a bustling day and night life, celebrating food/coffee/drinks.
Similar to now but naturally evolving
I'd like it continue with the great mixture of cultures. To be a place with a
great mixture of retail and restaurants for families.
It is critical that Monash university remains close by and sufficent rental
appartnments to attract tertiary international students who study in the CBD.
This maintains our broad asian restaurants and ensures that the suburb
remains vibrant. It is critical that it doesn't become completely Asian, as we
need to ensure cafes are maintained as this brings traffic during the day.
More expressions of art with constant renewal are key to attract an
innovative and interesting educated inner-city mindset to the suburb, that it
currently attracts.
It should have more variety in businesses
Retain the variety of shops and services, despite the proximity to
Chadstone. The small Woolworths should have the car park underground or
above the building and open plaza/cafes/ greenery at ground level.
Gee well accessable, fun, entertaining, affordable, ATTRACTIVE, green
and beautiful. I would like to see a water feature somewhere. Carnegie,
Koornang rd is already on the map. But it needs to be developed into the
NOW It is old and decayed.
To have more of a community feel and inclusive of all cultures
The same with no Sky Rail which would degrade its appearance
Similar to the way it is now (variety of small shops and restaurants plus
community spaces) but with the improvements suggested previously around
traffic management and safety.
Greener!
I hope they're not embarrassed by skyrail
148
Dec 15 16 08:59:06 pm
Dec 16 16 12:06:19 pm
Dec 16 16 02:04:25 pm
Multicultural
Friendly
-bigger - it should continue furtehr down over neerim rd and the retail
stretch onto side streets
-more parking somehow
- more retail
a place for all ages
a safe inclusive
Dec 16 16 02:07:53 pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Dec 17 16 09:00:42 am
Dec 17 16 09:36:01 am
Dec 17 16 10:26:51 am
Dec 17 16 02:40:19 pm
Dec 17 16 06:10:26
Dec 18 16 01:09:39
Dec 18 16 10:23:31
Dec 19 16 11:27:41
Dec 19 16 11:41:09
Dec 19 16 12:04:25
Dec 19 16 12:12:19
Dec 19 16 12:22:42
Dec 19 16 12:26:59
Dec 19 16 12:31:26
pm
pm
pm
am
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 19 16 12:37:53 pm
Dec 19 16 12:47:03 pm
Dec 19 16 01:09:43
Dec 19 16 01:12:58
Dec 19 16 01:40:30
Dec 19 16 01:49:12
Dec 20 16 03:50:39
Dec 20 16 08:58:27
Dec 21 16 11:20:20
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44 am
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
a place with a feel of community
A place to go and meet people at awesome food spots and bars whilst
doing a little shoppig
A taste of the world, a place to learn things about different cultures
Like High St Northcote
Retaining 2 storey buildings with mature trees to make it shady, funky
artworks and opportunity to sit in a pleasant environment with fun cultural
events and activities for the community which would entice others to want to
travel to our precinct by train or active transport. Not cars.
Rail under the road. No domination of multi storey high rises such as is
happening in Box Hill which is a dirty windy place as a result
A better version of what it is today - everything you need in one place,
accessible at any time and something for everyone. More variety.
A local hub w lots of restaurants, cafes and fresh produce plus community
services
N/a
Perfect mix of food and retail and green space
Sustainable, clean, safe, open, welcoming.
keep the heritage shops
bustling
keep its originality
parking and accessibility. different range of food places
don't change it
keep it as it is
Not to loose its character but encourage more small businesses to come in
the area
don't change the heritage
like how they have changed library front court. more friendly for residents.
build more areas were residents can relax.
more food joints
same
similar
maintain the history for future generations
Lots of local businesses
Easy to access and supports the needs of the community.
The street should be a playground both for families but also for working
professionals and students. Presently there is very little to entertain
millenials
To still have butchers, fruit and veg, bakery, banks, newsagent. all the daily
essentials
Freash open aired and vibrent
A place that the whole family could come and feel happy and safe. Could
149
Dec 22 16 08:48:44 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 23 16 10:35:02 pm
Dec 24 16 10:17:31 am
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 10:47:31 am
Dec 25 16 06:15:10 pm
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 27 16 09:45:59 am
Dec 27 16 08:11:33 pm
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
Dec 30 16 11:59:56 pm
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 08:00:46 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15 am
Jan 03 17 05:38:54 pm
Jan 04 17 01:44:07 pm
Jan 04 17 04:19:58 pm
Jan 04 17 08:52:40 pm
Jan 04 17 11:40:31 pm
Jan 05 17 07:58:49 am
Jan 05 17 08:03:07 am
Jan 05 17 11:41:31 am
come and eat and spend the evening together with friends
A user friendly, open space with variety, access and improved footpath
access.
Easily accessible from the city, full of independent retailers, nice cafes, local
entertainment, and a very artistic space.
Clean and safe
Fully pedestrianised, a walkable mall with trees in the middle, meeting
places, a piazza and entertainment (theatre). Our current way of life and
thinking assumes the car we'll always be there. It will not, and we should
start planning for that eventually (peak oil).
Organic food stores, child minding facility run by council. Adult drop in
centre.
Community Food Garden
Like south yarra
A place that people of all ages would be happy to go to for one reason or
another but that everyone feels safe , despite things like small bars/tappas
bars etc
The same mix of old and young.
The mix of cultures is great. Want to keep that but with poorly designed
high rise that may all disappear
Car free.
A monorail to Chadstone
Full of different types of food and retail shops
A hub to meet and enjoy eating, listening to music and appreciating
attractive surroundings. I would like somehow more quiet.
A real sense of community - an attractive and inviting precinct to go to relax
or get shopping/run errands.
Butchers / grocers / deli / fish monger plus speciality shops and cafes
during the day. Restaraunts by night.
Much the same as long as the sense of community remains in the area but
unfortunately because of the developments it has changed and will continue
to change and not for the betterment of the area.
A shopping strip where you can eat and drink at night and also a shopping
centre for all ages offering a variety of shops to keep people coming and not
having to travel to chadstone.
Great food places, a cinema and retail clothes stores.
I would hope the strip still exists and people suppprt their local retailers.
I hope it's not too crowded with huge apartment buildings.
Lots of green and colour would be great!
Not torn down and replaced by more roads at least. Who knows what it will
be like then?
I would like it to be still providing locals with the opportunity to buy their
groceries locally (although I'm not sure how many people will actually be
cooking their own meals in 30 years!)
well maintained, more dwellings, even more diversity
A one stop strip
Reflecting the needs of the people of all ages, not imposing on them..
Yes, 100%.
Minus the skyrail
Similar with a few more pubs
A place to spend your weekend
A buzzing hive of activity, particularly at night. This should be possible with
the number of apartments going up adjacent the railway station.
150
Jan 08 17 01:02:53 pm
Jan 08 17 02:41:07 pm
Jan 09 17 01:40:52 pm
Jan 09 17 01:51:18 pm
Jan 11 17 03:11:49 pm
Jan 11 17 04:45:00 pm
Jan 12 17 06:39:14 pm
Jan 14 17 05:47:35 pm
Jan 14 17 06:04:44 pm
Jan 16 17 01:33:04 am
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17 am
Jan 18 17 10:33:13 pm
Jan 19 17 09:27:26 am
Jan 19 17 10:23:05 am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 19 17 04:19:18 pm
Jan 19 17 11:23:52 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
Jan 24 17 01:56:15 pm
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 26 17 12:17:14
Jan 27 17 03:28:37
Jan 28 17 09:10:58
Jan 28 17 11:13:55
am
pm
am
am
Trees, green, vibrant, diverse, upmarket, inviting, full of enticing shops
including speciality food suppliers and quality delicatessens; even a local
cinema would be wonderful.
Retain village feel, trees get bigger, open spaces as peripheral properties
are bought up.
A nice place to meet with friends. A destination rather than a thoroughfare.
Full service day to day living
Not an urban slum choked by traffic congestion and overshadowed by an
ugly elevated rail line.
An attractive, safe, peaceful but vibrant place to hang out or meet others for
a coffee or a meal - where you can also get your basic daily needs.
Clean and tidy as it is now
Varied with both services and retail. Less traffic.
It needs provision for lower-rent premises so that there can be a greater
diversity of retail shops. There needs to be a community meeting place
other than the library. The old shop fronts look ver attractive and should be
retained.
Still doing what it does now - providing value and variety and a good range
of services.
Green, eco-friendly area with lots of community offerings.
In 30 years time - activated, beautiful/green, accessible and functional. I
would imagine that Koornang road stopped at neerim road and the rest was
for foot (push bike) traffic only and that there are vibrant, bustling
restaurants and public art and activities.
It must supply all the community needs.... If all the new apartments are
inhabited, without pleasant open spaces and all needed facilities it will
become an ugly slum.
Gorgeous, interesting, easily accessible to non-cars, useful for my every
day life and casual places to go at night.
Safe, Hip, a place to meet with friends in the open air. And a place to shop
for fruit and veg, if possible a farmers market each week.
Similar to what it is now - lots of small businesses offering a wide range of
products, services and food
A real community centre with a range of services, retail and public for the
local residents.
without a skyrail & plenty of trees & greenery.
See my earlier comments
To be like an urban village. Shops and cafes would be on the ground floor
of three or four story buildings with apartments above. Residents may not
need cars as they will be close to shops and public transport. While cafes
would continue, shops should concentrate of supply of fresh food, so that
people have options other than going to the major supermarkets. Examples
hot bread shop, fruit and vegetable, chicken, meat fish etc.
A vibrant local centre tat is used and appreciated by all concerned.
kept tidy, diverse, bit of paint and signage above shops repaired, love old
facades well looked after
I'd like it to keep the mix of shops, services and restaurants and be
accessible to everyone with a friendly village atmosphere.
community focused
A unique destination designed around people of al ages.
Clean, accessible, affordable
Unique attractive and useful with a variety of quality businesses and plenty
of parking -
151
Jan 28 17 04:02:36 pm
Jan 29 17 09:26:45 am
Feb 01 17 01:36:19 pm
Feb 01 17 08:58:54
Feb 01 17 09:51:04
Feb 03 17 10:13:18
Feb 04 17 01:30:30
Feb 05 17 12:07:39
Feb 05 17 09:04:43
Feb 05 17 04:10:15
pm
pm
pm
pm
am
am
pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 01:12:32 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:06:15 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:28:50 pm
Feb 06 17 06:41:44 pm
Feb 06 17 06:57:40 pm
Feb 06 17 08:44:55 pm
Feb 06 17 08:46:31 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
A place to go for everyday activities. You can walk, catch public transport
and ride a bike there. Inclusive for all age groups, economic wealth and
social backgrounds.
Safe, healthy, interesting and affordable
I've been a resident for 18 years and it was pretty quiet and a bit run down
when I first came here.
It has improved 100+% and I would love to see it remain a vibrant place for
people/families to shop, meet for a coffee, have dinner.
A place where people can go that meets all their needs.
Similar to today's - not overrun by development or apartments
Maintain community feel and small shops.
Better than now!
Still diverse in cuisine, a few more variety local hand made stores.
not too different....
hard question to answer
It will be closed or a slum by then as everyone one will more out due to
unpleasant congestion to many small flats being build with no amenity or
space around them. Not suitable for families. Who will live there when the
students go and the uni is sold off for more flats.
a community of different ages and ethnicities enjoying and using the space.
Not people hidden away in little dog boxes with no social connection.
Pedestrian friendly, with no cars, safe to ride bicycles around, places to
park bikes without competing with commercial hoarding pressed against
them, buildings that don't tower over people, trees, greenery, a better
balance/diversity of goods and services [ie not just food]
Friendly, affordable and a great place to scoialise
A place where you truly "shop local" and not have to go to Chadstone.
Perhaps a younger person might be better able to think that far ahead. I
don't think I can answer this one
Less cars, more bikes, less traffic
Classy shops, clean streets
Safe and clean.
Healthy with variety.
No rubbish or smoking
Have a vibrant buzz
More local and handmade goods
Safe clean and healthy
Buzzing
Who knows. The changes over the past 5 or 6 years have been majorly
disappointing.
Bigger with more bars and social events
A friendly place where people go to shop, dine and enjoy their spare time. I
love that there aren't any nightclubs or roudy pubs nearby and the streets
are quiet after 10pm
Reenergised like Acland St, St Kilda.
It won't compete with the big retail centres like Chadstone so it needs to find
its niche. A place with charm and character with boutique retail and a good
selection of quality dining option both during the day and at night with some
bars and pubs (without pokies)
More open space and trees
A welcoming place for all ages, races and types of people. I hope there is a
great range of venues, but that the small shops don't get pushed out by high
152
Feb 06 17 11:26:35 pm
Feb 07 17 12:02:21
Feb 07 17 07:37:46
Feb 07 17 09:22:32
Feb 07 17 09:32:02
Feb 07 17 10:31:34
am
am
am
am
am
Feb 07 17 11:37:55
Feb 07 17 12:54:13
Feb 07 17 12:55:13
Feb 07 17 01:20:27
Feb 07 17 02:22:12
am
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 05:08:22 pm
Feb 07 17 08:42:27 pm
Feb 07 17 09:25:41 pm
Feb 07 17 10:35:41 pm
Feb 07 17 11:19:05 pm
Feb 08 17 01:26:30 pm
Feb 08 17 04:05:54 pm
Feb 08 17 05:03:53 pm
Feb 08 17 05:49:41 pm
Feb 08 17 10:49:39 pm
Feb 09 17 12:04:18 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
Feb 10 17 01:36:52 pm
Feb 10 17 02:00:18 pm
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
rents or big competitors. I hope it retains it's character and doesn't get
snobby.
To be honest, if it can stay as it is now that would be great! If it can
somehow deal with the inevitable rise in population but still keep its
atmosphere & not become over developed.
Full of life, beauty, a place that feels like a town centre.
A pedestrian only area.
Upgraded but not unlike today
a destination strip
It is hard to predict what is going to be happen in 30 years but it would be
nice to see the traffic infrastructure to be re-designed to meet the needs for
increasing population.
More of the same
Same as it is now
As per previous question
Fun, Community, Historic.
AFTER THE RAIL IS FINISHED DO THE REDEVELOPMENT INCLUDING
THE SHOPPING STRIP..... Make a plan from Dandenong Road to Neerim
including Carnegie Central with a Mall down the centre underneath the
SkyRail
a pedestrian mall
Less cars.
Woolworths in Kokkaribb demolished and used as a green area with some
car parking.
Long term shops, seems to be a high turnover.
Too many eating places to the detriment of other shops, ie clothing
No cars allowed on the Rosstown and Neerim Rds section of Koornang Rd.
High quality shops. High quality development.
Safe and clean.
Koornang road closed between Neerim and Dandenong ... vastly more
trees for shade.... and a diverse range of shops
Similar with better transport and more facilities and parks for children
Maintain it's history. Family orientated, diverse collection of shops and
restaurants. More walking zones, less car. A community hub accessible and
welcoming to all people from different cultures and those with disabilities.
same as is
more variety
Still a mix. Not too many vacancies.
clean streets & shopfronts, competitively priced, variety of food outlets of
different ethnic origins
Variety cater for everyone's basic needs and tastes safe and ability to get
ther quickly to shop (parking)
the same
A pleasant place to shop at with a good mix of successful businesses.
A great place for community shopping and gathering
Will be all eateries if at all.
Trendy New York style living. Safe, inviting with lots to do.
Much the same with upgrades of footpaths, greenery and cleanliness
Local for local people . Keeping a large variety of everyday businesses
such as banks, post office, library and a large variety of shops and cafes
catering to many different needs.
a destination
153
Feb 10 17 02:38:19 pm
Feb 10 17 04:09:57 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
Feb 10 17 10:53:48 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Feb 11 17 06:53:53
Feb 11 17 06:54:18
Feb 12 17 05:59:20
Feb 12 17 07:02:25
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 12:46:35 pm
Feb 13 17 05:14:39 pm
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Feb 13 17 07:11:00 pm
Feb 14 17 12:50:53 pm
Feb 14 17 03:19:09 pm
Feb 15 17 12:08:50 am
Feb 15 17 10:19:11 am
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
Feb 16 17 03:39:55 pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:21:55 pm
I think Versatile, always moving with the times as well as celebrating events
in the calendar each up coming year. EG Chinese lunar week.
Easy, busy, fun and vibrant
Lots of small-medium businesses to open up in the area, to be more multicultural, not just Asian cuisines and more boutique stores that people from
around the city come to for shopping.
A pleasant local meeting place and a safe environment for all. More lighting
especially of trees as in St Kilda Road.
I feel it needs to reflect the growth in the area and the convienient location
being only 11 kms to the CBD, such a gem and oppportunity for further
growth
Brighton - more of a local, community feel with a quality retail experience.
All the things I've already mentioned.
No idea
More trees? I think this should be a key consideration when designing the
new post-sky rail open spaces.
A place where people can source most of their domestic requirements and
meet others in a variety of contexts.
A place where people can sit under trees and where kids can run and play
A place where buildings are in a human scale, not exceeding 5-6 storeys in
height
Maintain a family community feel. I am concerned that with all the
appartments being built that we are encouraging short term rentals for
students and couples and pushing families out. We need to keep and gain
as much green space as possible, encourage people to walk and ride to
shops and amenties and hence limit traffic congestion.
A place to purchase local groceries where individuals are directly supported
to grow and produce healthy sustainable food.
Accessible, clean, balanced, interesting, eclectic, catering for all
demographics, cultures and tastes. Do not give in to cheap options with a
short term aspect - plan for the future.
I would like it still to have a community feel and people who recognise each
other down the street. I would like festivals to happen and people to be
welcoming of people from all cultures and backgrounds. I would like the
koornang road shopping strip to be the place where you can go to try out all
kinds of different foods and meet great people.
I really don't know ..... I know what I don't want it to be - gridlocked by
apartment complexes and full of chinese vitamin dispensing shop fronts
Nice walking (car free zone) area were we can do shopping, take coffee, go
to restaurants in very good atmosphere. I see the Shopping Strip very easily
accessible by car with a lot of small car park all around. A place were
community meet.
More pedestrian friendly
Good community based strip
not looking like Hong Kong with skyscraper flats
Lively community village atmosphere with a cosmopolitan atmosphere with
great diversity
Diversity is both in terms of cultures but mix of experiences (retail, banks,
post office, dining, services)
Cleaned up and with no more high rise developments
A green, eco-friendly environment where power is sourced from renewable
energy and smart design is incorporated into the area
154
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 17 17 12:21:13 pm
Feb 18 17 01:52:15 am
Feb 18 17 08:13:09 am
Feb 18 17 11:51:03 am
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 08:36:02 am
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
Modern, trendy, clean and green. No cheap Asian shops and express post
shops exporting our Australia baby formula
Much the same.
A pleasant environment to be in with choice maintained
Similar but not as tired looking.
To be a place where future generations can be reminded and exposed to
culture, heritage and character that are being lost in so many areas as
developments lead to uniform shopping strips
Great food hub
Who knows ????
What will anything be like in 30 years time. Will we even shop ???
A hub that has everything needed with little need to visit shopping centres
I would like it to be safe, accessible and still have variety
I wont be here in 30 years time. This question is a bit silly as no matter
what we say now, future governments will have other ideas over this time.
Date
Any other comments?
Nov 29 16 06:29:16 am
Nov 29 16 05:17:36 pm
Just a hope that our voice will be heard as it has not been in recent years.
More community engagement like this please. I've seen koornang change
over 20 years, lots of good has happened but some mistakes were
foreseeable.
Councillors need to engage with the local community
no
more car parking - if you didn't get that message already
Nope
After living here for only 2 months, I can see Carnegie area now is going
through a rejuvenation process. Development of new apartments is ok but
over development is not. I am worried that when all these apartments are
built and occupied, there won't be enough road to cope with the load of cars
using this area.
I appreciate the opportunity I have been give to voice my concern. I would
like to see Carnegie area, clean, safe, vibrant and prosperous. Lets hope
our local council will put in place measures that will ensure all that. All the
best. Ziguras
No more high rise apartments !
Its convenience. I can get most of the day to day items that I need there
easily.
No - I love carnegie
Pls Remove all these loud store signs (aldi, spotlight..) and create style
regulation for shops.
A skatepark under the skyrail would be great as well as Tennis courts
Protective bike lanes
Nov 30 16 01:37:26 pm
Dec 01 16 11:47:50 am
Dec 01 16 01:15:20 pm
Dec 01 16 01:38:06 pm
Dec 01 16 02:34:30 pm
Dec 01 16 09:01:07 pm
Dec 01 16 09:12:23 pm
Dec 01 16 11:26:22 pm
Dec 02 16 12:05:18 am
Dec 02 16 09:21:33 am
Dec 02 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 02 16 01:05:49 pm
Dec 02 16 05:06:34 pm
No
No further comments
Thanks for the opportunity to give feedback.
Listen to the feedback from all but more importantly, action it!
Stop the over development of Carnegie so there aren't any more people
trying to use already stretched resources like parking in the strip.
155
Dec 02 16 09:39:36 pm
Dec 03 16 11:28:22 am
Dec 03 16 02:34:16 pm
Dec 03 16 05:25:18 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:38 pm
Dec 03 16 08:24:48 pm
Dec 04 16 08:37:17 am
Dec 04 16 10:13:11 am
Dec 04 16 05:19:29 pm
Dec 05 16 11:47:03 am
Dec 05 16 06:44:44 pm
Dec 06 16 12:05:57 am
Dec 06 16 08:40:08 am
Dec 06 16 12:14:30 pm
Dec 06 16 12:38:36 pm
Dec 06 16 01:42:00 pm
Dec 07 16 08:38:49 am
Dec 07 16 01:30:53 pm
Dec 07 16 03:46:25 pm
Dec 07 16 08:44:26 pm
Dec 07 16 09:56:41 pm
Range of food from malaysia china France Korea Italy etc
keep an eye out for an put a lid on chuggers and beggars on Koornang Rd
out front of the Library
Carnegie has lost the village feel that it had 20 years ago. It is also loosing
too much of its history and period buildings. It is becoming a concrete jungle
and I am afraid that it will become a place that more homeless people will
come to and more graffiti vandals will appear.
What's the point. you will do what you do.
It's a pity that the strip seems to end at Neerim Rd. It would be nice if there
were more retail options further up Koornang Rd towards Left Field cafe
Sad to see Carnegie Deli close.
Happy to see William Murray open it's hours as a bar.
Happy to see The Rosstown redesign its space to be more welcoming to
families and the community. I didnt go there for 10 years. But have have 5
times in the last year for family lunches.
Carnegie Central needs some serious love. The content is fine, but who is
managing this space? Paint the walls, put some plants in there, do
something!
Great communication about the crossings - only wish we didn't have to
house all the equipment at our station, and Murrumbeena. There are so
many trucks moving up and down our road - I worry about the kids
No
Please do not plant high allergen trees such as plane trees. They cause
terrible problems for 25% of the population. I would love to see native
plants, a native plant/bush food shop.
A market day once a month would be awesome. There is a lack of parking.
There is a severe lack of entertainment. Cafes which serve wine /cheese
and open late would be a welcome addition. Shop fronts are currently
crowded, ugly, and unkept. Stronger council guidelines may ve needed to
make the area more aesthetic/less dilapidated. Some historic arrtactions
could improve the area.
No.
no
For a shopping centre, Malvern central also has great feel about it, being
family friendly although the shops inclined to be on the higher end.
No thank you
It would be great if there was a post box close to the Woolworths on the
corner of Princess Hwy.
Many thanks for the opportunity to comment
nope.
It's a great strip that suit my family's needs very well. With a few tweaks it
could be even better.
To make the area friendly and make it so visitors and residents will
patronise it - it has to be clean and the station will need alot of attention
against graffitti
apartment developments and those house sold off but not demolished or
demolished - who is making sure that nature strips are mowed or trees
aren't overhanging - weeds galore. Is council doing anything to keep on top
of these beginning development to look after their residents or just happy
with their extra $$ received.
Get rid of sky rail and stand up for the residents that are affected
Try and sort the parking out.
Stop fining people for ridiculous parking situations that the council has
156
Dec 08 16 11:15:46 am
Dec 08 16 11:25:22 am
Dec 08 16 08:01:30 pm
Dec 08 16 11:58:15 pm
Dec 09 16 03:15:33 pm
Dec 09 16 03:31:00 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:32 pm
Dec 09 16 04:02:34 pm
Dec 09 16 04:55:51 pm
Dec 10 16 12:10:10 pm
Dec 10 16 03:53:39 pm
Dec 11 16 06:14:48 pm
Dec 12 16 02:20:12 pm
Dec 12 16 04:28:28 pm
Dec 14 16 03:36:48 pm
actually put in place(of course this is done to fine people, a pathetic money
grab)
No I have nothing to add.
Carnegie Central should have had some extra floors for residential
apartments (at least 4-5) as perfectly located for this, but was not allowed!
Wasted opportunity to build for the future!
Please consider the environment in your plans. There is a lot of work to be
done to try to prevent damage and waste, and it can start with small,
everyday actions - we can engage with the whole community to do this.
What a great opportunity!!
Do you really want to get me started. Its a bit late to put a survey out when
a lot of the damage has been done.
I am an Interior Designer and you can merge old and new and create
something beautiful but sadly your mindsets seem to be "lets remove any
trace of the old" and build big ugly not thought out hi rises. Let me tell you
these building will not stand the test of time like the beautiful Federation,
Victorian, Californian Bungalows and Italianate s of our past. Our suburb
will be the slums of tomorrow unless you wake up to yourselves
Is there any way of making Koornang Rd look cleaner?
Better Christmas decorations would be good too
Please do something about the parking in the evenings at the supermarket.
Yes, if this brochure I received in my mail box is the only result of the letter
that I sent to the Mayor then I am deeply disappointed as I am concerned
about the current distress caused by the railway developments. Wat it is like
coming home finding three B-doubles parked in the street blocking off
driveways, over half. Trucks, up and down the street, cars using the street
as a shortcut to jump the queue waiting to turn into Dandenong, trucks up
and down the streets constantly, and at least one truck that decided to turn
by using our driveway, and squashing the nature strip, and further
damaging the kerb and possibly damage to the storm drain which was
directly under where the tires went.
no
It's a great strip but need some better variety.
I've lived here since 1986 and Carnegie has never been more vibrant and a
better place to live than it is now. It has evolved from a suburb that looked
tired, where you couldn't buy a decent coffee for love nor money, to a
diverse, vibrant, community, underpinned by constant vibrancy from our
international student guests, many who gain residency and stay on.
Booran rd park is being developed into a monster of a park with lots of
twenty first century ideas. Lets take some of these ideas and transfer them
on to Koornang rd. So much effort and design into one park and that is fine.
But the shopping strip which everybody uses so much more, every day,
over and over, constantly, needs some of this 21st century DESIGN which
is being used for this park. Thank you for offering the public to give their
feedback.
Over development has ruined the suburb! Amenities, services and shops
need to be improved for the increasing population. Local families need to be
looked after not just the international investors and student population
No
Carnegie has become very popular because of its variety of restaurants and
local retailers. However, there has also been a negative impact on residents
around the area (i.e. reduced off street parking, traffic congestion, noise
from patrons at night etc.) and improvements to fix these issues should be a
priority.
157
Dec 15 16 12:59:07 pm
Dec 16 16 12:06:19 pm
Dec 17 16 07:35:05 am
Dec 17 16 09:36:01 am
Dec 18 16 10:23:31 pm
Dec 19 16 01:36:53 pm
Dec 22 16 12:00:50 am
Dec 22 16 11:52:44 am
Dec 22 16 02:22:40 pm
Dec 22 16 08:48:44 pm
Dec 23 16 01:21:05 pm
Dec 23 16 01:44:26 pm
Dec 23 16 10:35:02 pm
Dec 24 16 06:19:24 am
Dec 25 16 12:28:25 am
Dec 25 16 06:48:49 pm
Dec 29 16 09:36:45 am
Dec 30 16 01:24:59 am
Dec 30 16 04:13:09 pm
Our strip would be much better for a rail under road solution
the council should not allow any more non-fitted out tenancies to dispatch
vitamins and formula, they are eyesores
Thankyou
The sky rail will have a huge impact on the pease of the area so trying to
reduce noise will be important.
Council consider the potential for local streets to be filled with travellers
using our area as car park for the train rather than a destination to come
and enjoy.
Raising train tracks will create the opportunity for people to use all our
currently quiet minor streets as cut throughs which will destroy our local
peace and amenity
If you are going to ask for the feedback, please listen and act upon it. The
residents of Carnegie are clearly sick of the over development (too many
large scale developments). Protect the character of the area and stop
permtting short sighted, poorly constructed 4 storey developments that are
detracting from the character of the area, and are not sustainable due to
insufficient infrastructure. Don't be so short sighted, think long term and
make decisions accordingly.
feedback the survey has too many questions
Limit the speed limit for cars/trucks. Limit the volume of traffic, reduce the
use of Koornang Rd for trucks - at >60km/hr, it is a disaster waiting to
happen. Close the road, make it a pedestrian mall, and with the road
underground, you don't need to build a Skyrail. Make better choices for
vegetation - trees: introduce a variety, and consider the local vegetation.
One more time change the pavment to a qulity fish
Less car dependency and more pedestrian friendly - this has been shown to
revitalise shopping strips and squares all over the world.
I hope this is not just a waste of time that is dictated by money and
developers, but benefits the community. After 25 years I have lived here,
Carnegie is changing for the worse over the past few years.
Slow down the current rampant development and dissuade people from
driving by means of parking restrictions. Cars are already spilling over from
all the high rise developments.
No more chain stores!
It's great :)
Some shops need facelifts but it's come a long way in a short amount of
time
It is such a shame that Carnegie looks and feels neglected.
Generally we are happy with the way Carnegie has developed since we
moved here 20-odd years ago - the updating of shops and restaurants; the
establishment of a cafe culture. But we are worried about the rapid
inappropriate development that will almost certainly create a transient
population with no stake in Carnegie's 'well-being'
Carnegie is a great place and council needs to be mindful that although
higher density inevitable and can even be positive there must be thought
into open spaces and trees and greenery.
It needs help - it needs a big overhaul and hopefully it can be better than
ever.
(Forgot to add - the PO is good too btw - but we need more posting boxes
as they are 1km+ apart and all on the western side of Koornang Rd).
No more chain stores. No more dumplings. More things to bring people to
the street by day - the balance is shifting towards a night time street.
Maybe the council rules could be adjusted to allow for a sharing of the
street trading space - day venues could use night venues footpath space
158
Dec 31 16 09:49:09 am
Jan 01 17 08:00:46 pm
Jan 02 17 06:41:15 pm
Jan 02 17 10:48:36 pm
Jan 03 17 11:58:15 am
Jan 04 17 04:19:58 pm
Jan 04 17 08:52:40 pm
Jan 04 17 11:40:31 pm
Jan 08 17 01:02:53 pm
Jan 09 17 01:40:52 pm
Jan 11 17 03:11:49 pm
Jan 11 17 04:45:00 pm
Jan 14 17 05:47:35 pm
Jan 14 17 06:04:44 pm
Jan 16 17 05:02:49 am
Jan 17 17 02:01:54 pm
Jan 17 17 09:42:20 pm
Jan 18 17 07:06:17
Jan 18 17 10:33:13
Jan 19 17 09:27:26
Jan 19 17 10:23:05
am
pm
am
am
Jan 19 17 02:54:53 pm
Jan 19 17 04:19:18 pm
Jan 19 17 11:23:52 pm
Jan 20 17 12:03:42 pm
Jan 24 17 01:56:15 pm
during the day and at night vice versa?
Keep the Art Deco facades.
No I'm repeating myself already!
Streets could be greener and cleaner. Particularly the station.underpass
which often smells.
Maybe a mural or mosaic completed by the local primary school students to
put some colour in the forecourt in front of library (next to Grilld). Also some
artwork in the pavement (again, local schools or artists with mosaic etc).
No
No, thanks.
Wish I had more positive things to build on, but I still like having it nearby.
Maybe more traffic police to supervise the appalling non use of indicators,
causing frequent road rage at the Neerim Road, Koornang Road centre,
when you get behind a car and after the lights change they use their
indicator. Is this a sociality of the area, it happens all the time and
everybody complains about it.
Please do not ruin it as stonnington did to Greville St (ugly & ill thought-out
with a massive reduction in parking)
No skyrail. Killed the suburb
Wish the strip could be closed more than once a year for community
festivals. Wish development was better controlled to fit historic ambience of
area. Wish we could maintain and extend our diversity. Wish for more trees!
We are very fortunate to have the variety of eating spaces within walking
distance to home.
City of Glen Eira Council's consultation and planning has been disgraceful
in recent years and many long term residents of Carnegie are now moving
out.
Another Koornang Rd fair or something similar would be good for locals
Don't make the place too fancy or expensive for locals.
the commercial rubbish bins at the rear of shops really stink because they
do not get cleaned. There needs to be a requirement for keeping them
clean. To prevent germs and smells.
Please focus on eco-friendly developments and recycling opportunities.
thank you for the opportunity to comment, i just hope someone is indeed
reading this...
Please add a walking trail, some greenery/beauty, and limit the number of
cheap Asian outlet stores.
Overall I like it!
Don't follow other councils. Think community.
Thank you for asking for my opinion!
The population growth is putting stress on the local environment. There
must be compensation for loss of vegetation and open space. There is a
real risk of the neighbourhood around the shopping strip becoming an
unwelcoming concrete jungle. People like to shop in Carnegie because of
the convenience and small size and ease of getting around.
who is paying for the upkeep of the skyrail surrounding areas for the next 20
years
No
Continuation of the bus routes ( 625/6, 623,624 through the shopping
centre) would be beneficial.
Lived in the Carnegie for nearly 40 years (at a couple of different places).
love the area, wouldn't live anywhere else..
thank you
159
Jan 24 17 02:58:41 pm
Jan 26 17 12:17:14 am
Feb 03 17 10:13:18 pm
Feb 04 17 01:30:30 pm
Feb 06 17 11:50:14 am
Feb 06 17 12:46:33 pm
Feb 06 17 02:26:13 pm
Feb 06 17 03:52:10 pm
Feb 06 17 05:06:15 pm
Feb 06 17 05:43:58 pm
Feb 06 17 05:53:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:11:41 pm
Feb 06 17 06:57:40 pm
Feb 06 17 07:20:51 pm
Feb 06 17 08:47:30 pm
Feb 06 17 09:41:45 pm
Feb 06 17 11:26:35 pm
Feb 07 17 12:02:21
Feb 07 17 09:32:02
Feb 07 17 11:37:55
Feb 07 17 12:54:13
Feb 07 17 02:22:12
am
am
am
pm
pm
Feb 07 17 03:21:51 pm
Feb 07 17 03:53:36 pm
no.
nah
Carnegie Central also needs an uplift
Carnegie strip lacks a lot of Australian goods eg. Clothing.
good initiative. Council - please follow through on this process and
implement ideas to improve community wellbeing.
Planning Scheme is ancient, woefully out of date, and has been abused to
impose inappropriate development upon the residents while not managing
the amenity impacts. Council doesn't have a vision for the area, but is
determined not to allow the public to have any meaningful influence over
future development.
So many of the shops along Koornang road look cheap and tired. It would
be nice to see some shops/frontage try to evolve and change this
perception rather then leave windows looking like something from 4
decades ago.. Take the key cutting place in the arcade for example.
Everything about that place screams.. don't come in as i cant be bothered
making my business look welcoming to you.
All done
I have nothing against dumplings or Asian restaurants, in fact I love
Chinese, Korean, Japanese and Thai. I just think there doesn't need to be
any more dumpling restaurants.
Encourage diversity
Discourage shops advertising in Chinese
Better lighting at night especially after nee rim rd as the shopping a street is
extending
No
Perhaps with renewed footpaths it would be nice to have a few plants /
trees lining the streets and maybe a funky statue or two.
please please open carnegie theatre
More open space and trees
Maybe once a month the road could be blocked off to cars between Neerim
and the traffic lights south of the railway crossing, with cars being diverted
behind the supermarket. The shopping strip could become a mall with
tables and chairs for all the cafes, or Hawker's market, or other activities.
Above all it needs to stay feeling like a local shopping centre as an
alternative to Chadstone, where locals greet each other and enjoy shopping
or eating.
Dont change Carnegie- it is perfect as it is! Just because you are a council,
doesnt mean you have to change everything. If its not broken, dont fix it!
Concentrate on improving other shopping strips that lack character &
amenity, like Glenhuntly! Or Gardenvale.
Great that you're getting ideas from people.
desperately need more car parking
No I love it here
No
PLEASE DONT MAKE IT SEEM YOU ARE WANTING PUBLIC
FEEDBACK AND THEN
IGNORE IT ALL .......make it a COMMUNITY HUB FOR EVERYONE ......
rich and poor ........:
no
Convenient public transport.
Most banks represented.
Food availability
160
Feb 07 17 04:03:58 pm
Feb 07 17 04:13:51 pm
Feb 07 17 04:57:23 pm
Feb 07 17 09:25:41
Feb 08 17 01:26:30
Feb 08 17 02:03:01
Feb 08 17 04:05:54
Feb 08 17 05:49:41
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Feb 08 17 10:41:08 pm
Feb 09 17 12:04:18 pm
Feb 10 17 09:31:59 am
Feb 10 17 02:20:59 pm
Feb 10 17 06:00:56 pm
Feb 10 17 10:53:48 pm
Feb 11 17 11:05:31 am
Feb 11 17 06:45:24 pm
Feb 11 17 06:54:18 pm
Feb 13 17 11:02:12 am
Feb 13 17 11:28:53 am
Feb 13 17 12:46:35 pm
Feb 13 17 05:47:00 pm
Thank you for taking this initiative. It's an exciting time for Carnegie. I think
Carnegie needs a character. less suburbia, more cosmopolitan. A bold
vision and forward thinking are badly needed.
Planning has failed Carnegie... a victim of the ResGrowthZones and a rush
of speculative devt foisted on residents without any consultation...
no
Good work to survey community members!
IT'S COMPACTNESS
Don't wait 5. Years like train survey to do something
Too many very low end businesses do not encourage shopping. Need to
encourage very good operators that take pride in running successful
businesses. This will help make Carnegie shops more pleasant for
shopping.
stop so much apartment development, control shops relating to customer
parking and stock delivery.
I have lived in Carnegie and do not like the way it is headed. The high rise
apartment blocks on all corners, the shops closing ,and Asian eateries
opening everywhere, parking is a problem even at 9.30 am, the overall
ambience of the community is changing. We will not be here in 3 years time
.
Opportunity to make "good" a very disappointing decision by the state
government to do the sky rail in our community.
please put more car parks in both sides of koornang rd sky rail
Widen the footpath, by removing the street carparking, this will allow the
traffic to run smother through the strip. It goes without saying that we
should have carparking in excess.
Please stop congesting our shopping strip with over land of residential
apartments. Bringing a "rushed" type of person through the streets
Love the area. However priority should be given to a healthy clean
environment.
No thanks
The nature strip beside Woolworths in Kokaribb Road is not maintained by
either Woolworths or the Council. It is a disgrace. The synthetic grass
outside Woolworths and the plantings are much better that what is currently
there.
The paperbark trees common in the streets of Carnegie are awful. Any cars
parking under them get very dirty. They are trees for the country not for
streets. Constantly falling branches and bark create a messy environment.
The trees planted outside Woolworths are far better for the future. Shade
trees in the car parks would be wonderful.
I wish that Council takes the lead on development and focuses on the
common good. Please do not allow private developers to hijack the project
and wreck the place as they do everywhere else.
Please encorage variety. As said previously we love our Asian restaurnants
but we would like to see a variety of stores and restaurants. I would like all
shops advertising only in Chinese to have complosory signage in english.
There are many shop fronts where as a non chinese person I have no idea
what business thay are in. This creates segregation not integration.
Support sustainable living!!
Manage the developers before these places destroy Carnegie. Of course
there should be apartments, but the atmosphere of the area is being
gradually diiminished. We watched it flourish since we moved here 20
years ago, but the last couple of years has seen the area be consumed by
161
Feb 15 17 12:08:50 am
Feb 15 17 10:19:11 am
Feb 15 17 07:38:33 pm
Feb 16 17 03:39:55 pm
Feb 16 17 04:06:54 pm
Feb 16 17 05:34:53 pm
Feb 18 17 01:52:15 am
Feb 18 17 05:27:15 pm
Feb 19 17 02:38:29 pm
Feb 19 17 03:22:04 pm
Feb 19 17 04:52:17 pm
Feb 20 17 08:36:02 am
Feb 20 17 05:06:32 pm
development, parking issues, traffic congestion and buildings that are given
approval without much consideration for the future or the local overlay.
Nome
No
look after long term businesses
Utilise mainly because of convenience and needs to more destinations to
draw me in more
We love Carnegie shopping strip and don't want to see the charm slowly
destroyed by a modern facelift. It is great that you are doing this survey areas can be changed so quickly and good careful planning is important. I
am hoping the other residents are in accord with our views too.
Keep streets and bins clean. More bike stands. lolliepop person needed on
intersection Nerrim and kornang roads, to keep school kids safe
I have answered for Carnegie as I prefer it, Glenhuntly is closer, but though
there are some good places there it is, on the whole, comparatively dingy
with a lack of the environment and vibrancy that makes Koornang Rd so
good. I would love to see it improved too
Modernising Carnegie shopping strip may take away from the character and
accessibility, which make it special and popular. Unlike Chadstone it is
relaxed, selling different things, not another shopping area filled with chain
shops.
Birds add to the area
None
I think Council must think carefully as to what type of businesses will be
allowed in the future. Carnegie cannot be one whole strip of restaurants and
cafes. It needs diversity as it used to have, to encourage people to visit at
all times.
none
I would like to see a more balanced planning agenda from the Carnegie
Traders Association. I think they are the ones who control the type of
shops that come into this area.
162